股东会·中文精读

2024 年度股东大会 | Tesla

2024 Annual Shareholder Meeting | Tesla

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2024年6月13日,特斯拉年度股东大会在德州奥斯汀的超级工厂举行。当天最抓眼球的新闻是两件事:股东重新批准了马斯克2018年那份价值560亿美元的薪酬方案,同时同意把公司注册地从特拉华州迁到德州。

但如果你只记住这两条,会错过这场发布会真正重要的部分。马斯克在演讲里说了一句话,被掌声盖过去了。

我们不只是翻开特斯拉新的一章,我们是在开始一本新书。(马斯克)

这句话不只是修辞。接下来的一个多小时里,他把特斯拉的未来押在了两个东西上:自动驾驶和人形机器人。按他自己的说法,仅自动驾驶就能让公司市值涨十倍以上,Optimus 单独对应的则是 25 万亿美元的市场。

数字大得离谱。马斯克这次给的是一套能拆开算的账,空话的成分不多。下面按他讲的顺序,把这场股东大会里有信息量的东西捋一遍。

投票结果:两件被媒体放大的事,和一件容易被忽略的事

先交代投票。这次股东大会一共 12 项表决,5 项特斯拉提案,7 项股东提案。

5 项特斯拉提案全部通过:选举 James Murdoch 和 Kimbal Musk 为二级董事;高管薪酬咨询性投票通过;从特拉华州迁册德州通过;重新批准 2018 年那份 100% 基于业绩的股票期权奖励;续聘普华永道为 2024 财年独立审计师。

7 项股东提案全部未获通过,投票结果与董事会建议一致。第 6 项(把董事任期缩短到一年)和第 7 项(简单多数投票条款)的提案人是两位长期批评特斯拉治理结构的个人股东,他们各拿到 3 分钟发言时间,讲得相当尖锐。James McRitchie 说“马斯克溢价正在被侵蚀,特斯拉是马斯克的流动性存钱罐”,John Chevedden 说“特斯拉股东权利评分只有 10 分,10 分是最差”。这些话没改变投票结果,但值得记下来,因为它们代表了一部分机构股东的长期立场。

被媒体放大的两件事,是 560 亿薪酬方案和迁册德州。这两件事在会前被讨论得足够多,这里不展开。容易被忽略的,是马斯克演讲开头对公司定位的重新定义。他说,如果谁还把特斯拉当成一家汽车公司来估值,那就用错了框架。

如果你把特斯拉当成一家汽车公司,那这个框架就错了。如果有人不相信特斯拉能解决自动驾驶,那他不应该投资这家公司。(马斯克)

这句话是整场演讲的题眼。后面所有的估值推算,都建立在这个前提上。

自动驾驶:马斯克把公司估值押在这上面

马斯克讲自动驾驶,重点全放在一条曲线上。

他给了一个非常具体的观察方法:不要看官方宣传,你自己去记录,每次 FSD 新版本推送之后,开多少英里才需要接管一次。这个数字如果随每个版本大幅提升,曲线就是指数级的。

随着每个版本的推送,你会看到很大的改进,看起来就是一条指数曲线。很明显,它会一直走到比人类驾驶安全得多的程度。(马斯克)

他提到一个细节:FSD 12.4 版本终于取消了方向盘扭矩提醒。这个提醒此前让很多车主抓狂,开车时得时不时晃一下方向盘证明自己还在。取消它,是体验层面的实质进步。

他对版本编号的处理也值得一说。别看 12.3、12.4、12.5 这些数字,直接忽略前面的“12”,把它当成第 3 版、第 4 版、第 5 版来理解。每两个版本之间,改进幅度少则翻倍,多则五到十倍。12.4 相对 12.3 是完完全全不同的版本,12.5 相对 12.4 也是。

这里有一个反直觉的地方值得说清楚。系统还不够好的时候,判断哪个版本更好很容易,接管次数说明一切。可当系统好到几千英里才需要接管一次,判断就变难了。因为测试本身成了瓶颈,训练和数据都已经不再是瓶颈。

马斯克原话是,眼下卡住进展的是“搞清楚哪个 AI 模型更好”这件事,算力和数据都已经不缺。专业测试驾驶员开了一整周,一次接管都没有,一周的高光时刻就是终于出现一次接管。这听起来像凡尔赛,但它揭示了一个真实问题:模型之间没有完全确定性,新模型可能消除了一个问题,又制造了另一个问题。

特斯拉的解法有三条。一是仿真。二是影子模式:把新模型推送到几百万辆车上,在后台运行,不接管车辆,只记录“如果这个模型来开,它会怎么做”,然后和人类实际驾驶做对比,算出误差差。三是把车派到几千个已知的困难路口去实测。马斯克特意提了“Chuck 的左转”,那是加州一个出了名的复杂路口,已经成了 FSD 测试的固定考场。

他还给了一个关于安全的数据对比。根据 2023 年的数据,开启驾驶辅助功能的特斯拉车辆,每 564 万英里发生一次事故。美国车队的平均水平是每 67 万英里一次。差了八倍多。

问答环节有人问,自动驾驶真正上路之后,难免会有严重事故,公司怎么面对。马斯克的回答是把问题拉回到统计上:美国每年大约 3.5 万到 4 万人死于交通事故,平均每 8000 万英里死一个人。真正要回答的问题是,我们有没有让这个数字变小。只要在变小,方向就是对的。

车队经济学:一半像 Uber,一半像 Airbnb

自动驾驶怎么赚钱,马斯克这次讲得比以前具体。

他的比喻是 Uber 加 Airbnb。一部分车由特斯拉自己拥有,像 Uber 那样运营。更大一部分来自车主,像 Airbnb 那样,车主可以随时把车加入或移出车队。

你点一下特斯拉 App,车就加入车队,你不在的时候它帮你赚钱。想要回来,点一下,车就开回来了。(马斯克)

他给了一个相当具体的承诺:车主通过车队赚到的钱,会远超这辆车的月供。特斯拉从中抽成,但大部分收入归车主。

这套模式有一个被忽略的连带效应:碳排放。现在一辆私家车一周大概只用 10 个小时,每天一个半小时。加入自动驾驶车队之后,同一辆车一周能用 50 到 55 个小时,使用率提高五倍。制造一辆车需要的资源不变,它的使用强度却翻了五倍,单位行驶里程对应的制造碳排放会大幅下降。这一点在环保叙事里很少被提,但对特斯拉的可持续能源使命来说,是实打实的增量。

估值上,马斯克直接引用了方舟投资(ARK Invest)的分析,说那是他看到的最准确的自动驾驶潜力测算。ARK 的预测是,仅凭车辆自动驾驶,特斯拉市值能到 5 到 7 万亿美元。马斯克说他同意这个判断,并且认为公司价值能涨十倍以上。

问答环节有人追问时间点,他的回答是 2029 年,五年之内。

Optimus:他给出的数字是 25 万亿美元

如果说自动驾驶是主菜,Optimus 就是马斯克眼里更大的那道。

他先讲了一个比例:人形机器人和人类的比例,至少是二比一,全球总量可能到 100 亿台、200 亿台甚至 300 亿台。然后他算了一笔账。

假设最终全球人形机器人年产量是 10 亿台。特斯拉拿到 10% 的份额,也就是一年 1 亿台。作为参照,全球汽车行业一年大约生产 1 亿辆。在极高产量下,单台 Optimus 的制造成本大约 1 万美元,因为它比车小,用料比车少。售价假设 2 万美元,那么特斯拉一年能赚大约 1 万亿美元利润。给 20 到 25 倍市盈率,对应 20 万亿美元市值。

如果市盈率是 20 到 25 倍,那光 Optimus 就是 20 万亿美元市值,自动驾驶再加 5 到 10 万亿。特斯拉达到今天全球最有价值公司十倍的估值,是在可能性范围之内的。(马斯克)

这段推算的关键假设有两个:一是人形机器人市场真有这么大,二是特斯拉能守住 10% 的份额。第一个假设没人能验证,第二个假设马斯克给了一套论据。

他的论据是供应链。做 Optimus 的过程中,特斯拉发现市面上根本没有现成的供应链。电机有,但人形机器人需要的那种电机、传感器、减速器,没有。所以特斯拉从第一性原理出发,把电机、减速器、传感器、电力电子、通信系统全部从零设计了一遍。

他展示了一只手:当前版本 11 个自由度,下一代 22 个自由度,能弹钢琴。

他的判断是,这种从零设计的工程量,对创业公司来说几乎不可能复制。而特斯拉有世界级的电气工程、机械工程、电力电子能力,还有现成的 AI 推理芯片和现实世界 AI 软件,再加上规模化制造能力。这四样凑齐,才有资格把成本压到 1 万到 2 万美元。

原型好做,量产难做。相对而言原型简单,生产困难。(马斯克)

进度上,他给了几个时间点。弗里蒙特工厂已经有两台 Optimus 在干活,任务是从产线末端取电芯放进运输箱。帕洛阿尔托办公室也有几台在走动。今年年底或明年初完成一次大的硬件改版,明年进入限量生产,先在自家工厂用。他预测明年特斯拉工厂里会有超过一千台,可能几千台 Optimus 在工作。2026 年,机器人会泛化到可以执行没专门训练过的任务。

他还提到安全。人形机器人必须对人类友好,这一点他反复强调,用了一个半开玩笑的说法:“我们得确保不会出现终结者场景。”

现有业务:那些被大叙事盖住的硬进展

发布会前一个小时,马斯克讲了不少现有业务的具体数字。这些内容在自动驾驶和 Optimus 的光环下容易被忽略,对判断公司基本面却更直接。

整车。Model Y 是 2023 年全球最畅销车型,按销量算。2024 年还会继续是第一。特斯拉累计生产突破 600 万辆,年底车队规模超过 700 万辆。弗里蒙特工厂是北美产量最高的汽车工厂,超过了当年丰田和通用合资时的 NUMMI 纪录。

Cybertruck。周产量创下 1300 辆的纪录。技术上几个点:48 伏低压系统(业界普遍还在用 12 伏)、800 伏驱动系统、世界上最大的压铸件、防弹车身。马斯克给了一个很具体的性能对比:能拖动 F350 柴油卡车,拖着保时捷 911 还能在四分之一英里加速上跑赢保时捷 911。

他判断一个产品酷不酷的标准很有意思:拿给小孩看。五六岁甚至三岁的孩子,没有滤镜,问他们喜欢哪辆车,答案都是 Cybertruck。

Model 3 升级版。总拥有成本算下来每月大约 216 美元,和同级别燃油车比,接近 200 美元出头。Performance 版本比保时捷 911 还快。

Tesla Semi。目前是低产量生产。马斯克说上周他刚刚批准了量产计划。他的论点是,商用车主极其客观,只看数字:同样一趟运输,电动半挂比柴油半挂便宜还是贵。答案是便宜得多,所以这是笔不需要犹豫的账。

超级充电网络。今年会部署比整个行业加起来还多的超充桩,下半年投入约 5 亿美元。之前有传言说特斯拉要收缩超充团队,马斯克的回应是“超充已死的传言被严重夸大了”。同时开放给其他品牌,提供适配器,因为建围墙不利于电动车整体增长。

4680 电池。所有 Cybertruck 都用 4680。马斯克承认这是块硬骨头,原话是“需要大量脑损伤才能把电芯制造做好”。但他说年底能看到成本打平的路径,目前 4680 成本比供应商高,可供应商一年前的价格比现在高得多。电池行业像 DRAM,供需一波动,价格就剧烈起伏。

储能。今年储能部署同比增长 200% 到 300%。Powerwall 3 被马斯克称为“个人层面的游戏规则改变者”,他的经验是任何技术迭代到第三代才真正进入甜点区。Megapack 的下一代(Megapack 3)还有几年,方向是把变电站的功能逐步吸收进去,最终做到高压线直接插进 Megapack 就能用。

服务业务。开始盈利了。马斯克说这在汽车行业不算小事。

AI 基础设施:芯片、算力和一个 AWS 式的机会

这场演讲里技术密度最高的部分,是马斯克讲 AI 硬件。

他说特斯拉是世界现实世界 AI 的领导者,处理视频、基于视频做决策这件事上,谷歌、OpenAI 都差得远。这话有没有水分另说,他给的支撑是芯片。

特斯拉从零设计 AI 推理芯片。车上现在跑的 Hardware 3 是几年前的设计,过去一年生产的车用 Hardware 4。Hardware 5 刚完成设计,现在改名叫 AI5。

性能对比:Hardware 4 的摄像头分辨率比 Hardware 3 高四到五倍,整体能力强三到八倍。AI5 比 Hardware 4 强十倍,按马斯克的说法,是英伟达 B200 级别的计算能力,大约 18 个月后推出。功耗上,Hardware 3 和 4 只有几百瓦,AI5 能到 700 到 800 瓦,还会根据场景复杂度动态调整。

然后他抛出一个很少有人算过的账。特斯拉车队未来会超过 1 亿辆。如果每辆车有 1 千瓦的高效推理算力,加起来就是 100 吉瓦的分布式算力。一辆车一周跑自动驾驶大概 50 到 60 小时,剩下 100 多小时是停着的。这 100 多小时里,100 吉瓦的算力闲着。

亚马逊一开始只是网上卖书,后来有了 AWS,AWS 变得比亚马逊其他所有业务加起来还值钱。特斯拉这里也有类似的机会。(马斯克)

这段内容容易被忽略,想象空间却可能最大。它把特斯拉从一家卖车的公司,重新定义成一个拥有分布式算力网络的公司。当然,这只是设想,没有任何实施时间表。

训练侧,他说特斯拉已经不再受算力限制。现在真正的瓶颈是测试,前面讲过。今年晚些时候会启用一个专门训练 Hardware 4 的数据中心,位置在超级工厂南侧。

问答里的真话:那些没被剪辑进新闻的段落

问答环节持续了将近一小时,马斯克回答得比演讲部分更放松,也更有信息量。挑几段值得记的。

关于 560 亿薪酬。有人恭喜他拿到这笔钱,他的回应是:这是特斯拉股票,必须持有五年,不能套现走人,他也不想走。

关于人身安全。一位股东说很担心他的安全。马斯克说,过去大约七个月里,有两个“想杀人的人”来试图杀他,还牵涉其他人。他现在不随便签名了,因为签名可能让人凑近了开枪。他提到约翰·列侬,唱着“大家能不能好好相处”,然后被自己的粉丝枪杀。这段讲得很轻,内容却不轻。

关于特朗普。有人问特朗普为什么突然说自己是特斯拉粉丝。马斯克说他也不完全清楚,但特朗普会无缘无故给他打电话,打电话时人很好。他猜的原因是特朗普很多朋友现在开特斯拉,特朗普本人也是 Cybertruck 的粉丝。

关于 FSD 转移和推荐计划。有车主问 FSD 能不能长期支持转移。马斯克说技术上复杂,会给销售流程增加负担,而且公司得确认收入。他答应“再给一个季度”。推荐计划也是,下个季度重新评估。他给了一个更根本的判断:真正卡住需求的是价格。如果 Model Y 卖不到 2 万美元,能卖 500 万辆。问题是造不出那么便宜的车,让车更便宜才是关键。

关于 Cybertruck 国际化。今年只在北美卖。明年可能拿到其他市场的认证。马斯克说 Cybertruck 是按北美法规设计的,如果一开始就兼容所有国际法规,会逼出很多约束,把产品做差。所以要专门做中国版、欧洲版。他反复强调从原型到量产的难度是一百倍,从量产再把成本降 20%,比从原型到量产还难。

关于 Foundation 系列。很快会结束,非 Foundation 版本下个季度推出。

关于家用 HVAC。有人问特斯拉做不做家用空调系统。马斯克说没有在做,但列进了“比现在做的事更有用”的清单里。他想要一个高效、安静、带 HEPA 滤网、能控制湿度的家用 HVAC,把车上的经验搬过去,也许还能和 Powerwall 结合。不在高优先级,值得做。

关于没有马斯克的特斯拉。有人问如果他被车撞了(不是 FSD 开的车),特斯拉还有没有未来。马斯克的回答很坦诚:特斯拉没有他也有好未来,他的作用是加速器。技术行业里,领先还是不领先,差别巨大。创新本身固然重要,真正起决定作用的却是创新的速率,能不能用一年做完别人两三年的事。如果做不到,估值和产品就归别人。

关于锂精炼。有人问锂精炼产能够不够。马斯克说,算上中国是够的。如果地缘政治上出问题,锂会短缺。中国在精炼上非常强。特斯拉自己建精炼厂,是为了搞清楚整个流程,万一最坏情况发生,公司还能运转。

把这场股东大会拆完之后,剩下什么

整场发布会信息量很大,逻辑线索其实很清晰。

马斯克在做的,是把特斯拉的估值锚点从“卖多少辆车”换成“卖多少算力和智能”。车是载体,自动驾驶把载体变成能持续产生现金流的资产,Optimus 把同一套 AI 能力装进一个更大的市场。芯片、算力、车队规模、制造能力,这四样是支撑这个转换的基础设施。

他自己也承认,这套叙事里有很多“如果”。如果自动驾驶真能做到无人监督,如果人形机器人市场真有 10 亿台级别,如果特斯拉能守住份额,如果成本真能压到 1 万到 2 万美元。每一个“如果”都不小。

但他给了一个可以验证的观察指标,这个指标比任何估值模型都实用:每次 FSD 新版本推送后,你自己记录多少英里接管一次,然后看这条曲线。如果它是指数级的,那前面那些“如果”就值得认真对待。如果不是,那 25 万亿美元就只是发布会上的一个数字。

这场股东大会的价值,最终落在它给出的一个判断框架上。判断特斯拉,可以把问题换一换:它的车队一周能跑多少小时?它的推理算力有多少瓦?它的机器人一年能造多少台?这些是马斯克押注的变量,也是下一轮估值分歧真正会爆发的地方。

  • 如果你是特斯拉车主,从下一个 FSD 版本开始,记录每次接管之间的里程数。这个数字比任何评测都直接,连续记录三个版本,你会得到自己的曲线。
  • 如果你在关注特斯拉股票,把观察重点从季度交付量挪到三个指标上:FSD 每次版本迭代的干预里程提升幅度、储能部署的同比增速、Optimus 在工厂的实际部署数量。前两个是当下,第三个是未来。
  • 如果你是从业者,马斯克讲芯片和算力的那段值得反复看。他把“车队闲置算力”类比成 AWS,这个思路可以迁移到任何有大规模分布式硬件资产的行业:设备闲着的那些小时,是不是也能变成一门生意。
  • 如果你关心 AI 产品,记住他对瓶颈的判断:训练和数据都已经不缺,测试和评估才是。模型越好,越难判断哪个模型更好,评估体系本身会变成核心竞争力。
  • 如果你想验证他的说法,别听发布会,去开一次 FSD 12.4。方向盘提醒取消之后,体验的门槛降了一大截,自己开一段,比看一百页 PPT 都管用。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

3:08welcome to Texas [Applause] Home the home of [Applause] Tesla my name is Brandon arhart I'm the general counsel and corporate secretary and this meet this meeting is going to be in two parts first we're going to cover the 12 items that stockholders have been asked to vote on as well as any other matters that have been properly presented second our founder and CEO Elon Musk will provide a

3:50[Applause] presentation during the course of the following session we may discuss our business Outlook and make other forward-looking statements such statements are predictions based on current expectations actual events or results could materially differ due to a number of risks and uncertainties including those disclosed in our most recent 10K or 10q as filed with the SEC such forward-looking statements represent our views as of today should not be relied on Hereafter and we disclaim any obligation to update them after today at this time I'd like to thank thank members of the Tesla team and the board that are here in attendance a representative from Price

4:36Waterhouse Coopers Tesla's independent auditor is also present but before we begin I'd like to introduce you to our board chair Robin danol who would like to say a few words [Applause] thanks Brandon and hello everyone as chair of Tesla's board I am honored to welcome you all to our home Texas for

5:10our annual for our annual 2024 annual shareholder meeting and when I say I'm honored to welcome you our shareholders I truly am no other company in the world has such a diverse engaged and supportive set of shareholders as Tesla no other shareholder base understand its com company like you do nor is as committed to Tesla's mission to accelerate the world's transition to sustainable energy like you are it is a

5:44shareholder base whose interests the board are proud to represent it is also a shareholder base that understands that in order to accelerate the world's transition to sustainable energy and a sustainable energy economy Tesla needs to develop the most revolutionary Technologies not only in Autos but in energy and artificial intelligence as well our achievements this past year are steps towards fulfilling our mission some highlights include the mo y becoming the best selling vehicle in the world in 2023 [Applause]

6:29beginning deliveries of the much anticipated cyber truck proving that the muscle and utility of a pickup truck can be electric and cool and our energy storage deployments reaching an all-time high in 2023 with the deployment Trend continuing in 2024 by using our products Tesla customers avoided releasing over 20 million metric tons of greenhouse gas emissions in 2023 that is the equivalent of 51 billion miles driven by Ice Vehicles an increase of about 18 billion avoided ice miles since 2022 but to continue the exponential growth in greenhouse gas gas emission avoidance we not only have to get our products into as many customers hands as possible but we also need to increase

7:28the utilization of our products and to help further with that goal we released FSD supervised demonstrating that our approach to autonomy is scalable and that accomplishments in artificial intelligence along with leveraging our existing production lines to get our next Generation products to Market faster are essential to achieving our mission we have made and plan to make further investments in hardware and software ecosystem to further Advance our path to autonomy and set a course to realization of Robo taxes but sustainability is not just a about avoiding emissions it needs to take into account the whole life cycle from the manufacturing of the products

8:21to the products end of life that is why we Source responsibly we design our manufacturing processes to use less water per vehicle than the industry average and for the third year in a row we power our supercharger network with 100% Renewables energy and we are also working to build a battery material recycling ecosystem both internally and with others to ensure that we are moving towards a truly circular economy for energy storage in 2023 alone we supported the recovery of enough battery materials to build 43,000 new reel rear rear wheeel drive model wise that result is the epitome of a sustainable economy while sustainability is our mission we also

9:20have the goal of safety our cars are engineered to be some of the the safest in the world and we take real World data from our Fleet and our ability to push over theair updates to optimize safety for all our vehicle models our attention to the to autonomy also plays a role in our goal of safety based on 2023 data

9:45Tesla vehicles with driver assist Technologies engaged have only a one vehicle accident per 5.64 million miles driven compared to the US I think worth [Applause] cing compared to the US vehicle Fleet of one accident per 670,000 miles driven so not only are you protecting the environment but by driving a Tesla you're also protecting yourself and those who ride with you with another year of progress in furthering our mission under our belt I want to take this moment to thank our phenomenal Tesla employees whose creativity hard work and dedication are the source of our success as yes huge

10:43thanks and as most as most are also shareholders alongside each and every one of you I hope each employee takes pride in in the role that you have played in Tesla's accomplishments I am proud of you and the board and I appreciate you tremendously finally I want to remind our shareholders that your board is listening and we are here to represent your interests you are [Applause] yes you are the owners of the company and your voices your perspectives and your input are critical to us as a board and to the director of the company my fellow directors and I serve as your fiduciaries and oversee Tesla's Mission purpose and strategy with those responsibilities in mind we continuously

11:42set the highest standards for ethical Behavior corporate citizenship and corporate governance you don't see the day-to-day work of the directors but I can assure you this is a highly engaged board and I would like to thank my fellow directors for their dedication whether it be inside the boardroom meeting with our shareholders or working closely with our team members throughout the company Tesla is unique thank

12:14you thank you Tesla is unique in how active and large our retail shareholder base is and we hope you here in this room and our shareholders joining us virtually today continue to take advantage of our shareholder platform to enhance your engagement with Tesla I want to give a special shout out to our small But Mighty IR team and legal team and everyone involved in running this year's proxy campaign both inside and outside of [Applause]

12:56Tesla there is still much to do do but it has galvanized us around strong the strong belief that the right things are always worth fighting for thank you and now I'll hand it back thank you now I'm going to hand it back to Brandon thank you thank you Robin so I will now call the meeting to order the time is now 3:40 p.m. Central and I declare that the polls are now open we have already received over the past few weeks voting proxies from our stockholders however if you wish to vote your shares at this time you may do so through the virtual meeting portal or if you want to vote in person ballots and ballot boxes are available at the front Tesla's board of directors has appointed

13:54Tony cardo a representative of the cardo group to serve as the inspector of election in addition in addition broadridge Financial Services has certified that starting on April 29th 20124 the proxy materials or notice of internet availability for proxy materials were mailed or provided to all Tesla stockholders of record on April 15

14:192024 we have a majority of the outstanding sharff represented at the meeting so I declare that there's a quorum present and then we may proceed with the meeting the items are on the agenda are as follows there are five Tesla proposals the election of two class two directors James Murdoch and Kimble musk to serve for a term of three years until their respective successors are duly elected and qualified to approve executive compensation on a non-advisory basis to approve the redomestication of Tesla from Delaware to Texas via conversion

15:03to ratify the 100% performance-based stock option award to Elon Musk that was previously approved by stockholders in

15:222018 to ratify the appointment of price Waterhouse Cooper's LP as Tesla's independent registered public accounting term for the fiscal year 2024 Tesla's board has recommended that our stockholders vote for each of the two director nominees and for each of the four other Tesla proposals we have also received seven stockholder proposals that are described in the proxy statement I would like to remind our stockholders that Tesla's board has prepared a statement in opposition to these proposals which also appear in our proxy statement so let's turn to those seven stockholder proposals the first one is an advisory vote regarding reduction of director terms to one year our board

16:04has recommended that our stockholders vote against this as explained in the proxy this proxy this stockholder proposal was proposed by Mr James MCR who has prepared a pre-recorded message thank you we presented a similar proposal in 20121 55% supported it even though the board put up a competing proposal accountability every other year instead of every year neither received the required 67% of shares owned 90% of the

16:38S&P 500 have a Declassified board most institutional shareholders will again support our proposal join them the recent Delaware Court case identified three legal deficiencies at Tesla directors were not independent the facts of the pay plan presented to investors were misleading and the board failed to negotiate properly a major part of the Cur is declassifying the board so shareholders can hold directors accountable or submit their own nominations Matt moscardi of free float calls proposal number six the most important vote today since it may enable investors to change the board bringing new skills and professionalism John chetan's simple majority vote is the

17:27other crucial vote another important endorser is n minnow co-founder of companies including proxy advisor ISS the musk premium is already eroding Tesla is musk's liquid piggy bank since it's publicly traded his other companies are not either he sticks around long enough to use our shareholder Capital to fund his other Ventures or he shifts his attention sooner if we reject his his pay package and turn off the money tap bite the bullet prepare for a future that doesn't depend on a superhero dictatorship we need to transition from a board dominated by friends and family to one of expert independent directors in engineering software and other relevant Fields musk is a genius I'm

18:21saddened to see him Focus his attention elsewhere but it is happening don't let him siphon off more from Tesla we need to transition to a more democratic Tesla that can attract customers employees and shareholders seeking a better world ahead again vote for number six and seven declassify the board for accountability lower the voting threshold for more flexibility vote now before the polls are closed your vote can make a significant difference in our future thank you right thank you thank you Mr MCR as a reminder the board's response was contained in our proxy statement the second stockholder proposal is an advisory vote regarding simple majority

19:11Provisions in our governing documents our board has recommended against and are set for for the reasons in the proxy this stockholder proposal is proposed by Mr John Chetan who is on the line to present this Pro proposal Mr chedin I would like to invite you to speak you will have three minutes three

19:32minutes hello this is John Chetan proposal seven simple majority vote chal's requested the board of directors take the necessary steps so that each voting requirement in the charter and bylaws that calls for a greater than civil majority vote be replaced by a requirement for a majority of the votes cast for and against such proposals or a simple majority this includes making the necessary changes in plain English this proposal seven is the exact same concept that the Tesla board of directors supported at the 2022 Tesla annual meeting the 2022 Tesla board of directors proposal then won 98% support from the Tesla shers who voted and the board of directors version of this

20:18proposal would have been adopted earlier if the board of directors had only made a slight effort to encourage more Tesla shers to vote for their proposal this simple majority vote standard proposal will help improve Tesla's shareholder rights Tesla now scores a dismal 10 in shareholder rights with 10 being the worst possible score the Tesla board of directors supported this proposal Concept in 2022 and should do so today sh the rights and a simple majority vote standard are all the more important when Tesla has a CEO Elon Musk

20:56who is threatening to give less attention to to Tesla and threatening to withhold advanced technology from Tesla unless it gets a56 billion paycheck never before have shers been under such duress when asked to prove an outrageous 56 billion CEO paycheck plus there's no promise with the 56 billion paycheck that Mr mus will devote any minimum percentage of his time to Tesla or pursue any minimum amount of advanced technology at Tres Russ Gerber of the investment firm Gerber Kawasaki said I believe the Tesla board of directors is the most conflicted least independent and most incapable boorder of directors in the history of business please vote Yes

21:44simple majority vote proposal seven thank thank you Mr chedin as a reminder our our the board's response is set forth in the proxy our third stockholder proposal is an advisory vote regarding annual reporting on anti-harassment and discrimination efforts our board has recommended against for the reasons set forth in the proxy this stockholder proposal is proposed by the New York State Common retirement fund as the lead filer which has requested the Dr Kristen Hall as represented for Neo impact Capital as co- filer for this proposal present this proposal Dr Hall I would like to invite you to speak you have three minutes thank you hello I'm Dr Kristen Hull of Nia impact

22:31Capital I'm here on behalf of lead filer New York State Controller Thomas D POI Trustee of New York State retirement fund owner of Tesla shares valued at over 650 million as of March of this year and I'm here as a co- filer of proposal 8 the fund is a significant long-term owner of Tesla and has an explicit focus on investing in climate Solutions Long View large Cap Fund through its trusty Amalgamated Bank ap7 and our Juna join us in filing this resolution our firm name Nia means intention and purpose we invest only in those companies we see building toward a better world a sustainable and inclusive future as the founder of Nia I had been proud in our early ownership of Tesla I

23:23saw the potential and the need for innovation in the automotive and the clean energy Market space however when looking under the frunk we find failures in workplace management one of the most important components of any business employees need to be hired trained motivated and engaged to do high quality work and we need those employees to be able to contribute to their top ability to do so they must feel both physically and emotionally safe at work investors are requesting the report outlined in proposal 8 because workplace abuse harassment and discrimination have no place at Tesla they can result in substantial costs including employee turnover increased

24:13absenteeism and reduce productivity as well as legal costs all of which can INF fact shareholders investments in the company they may also lead to difficulties in recruiting high quality employees something that Tesla needs to remain Innovative and at the Forefront of a quickly moving technological landscape we have expressed concerns about Tesla's workplace for years and year after year more harassment and discrimination allegations have emerged with few visible improvements in Tesla's people management policies or practices to assuage our concerns lawsuits and class actions before Tesla now involve thousands of employees with allegations including repeated use

25:00of racial epithets by managers and employees segregation and discrimination against non-white employees in job assignments pay and promotion and retaliation when employees report their experiences these concerns are why I now formally move proposal 8 requesting that Tesla's board commission an independent report on the effectiveness of the company's efforts to provide prevent harassment and discrimination within this revolutionary and Innovative workspace thank you great thank you Dr Hull the board's responses set forth in the proxy materials let's turn to the fourth stockholder proposal which is an advisory vote regarding the adoption of freedom of Association and collective

25:49bargaining policy our board has recommended against for the reasons set forth in the proxy this stockholder proposal was proposed by S so Investment Group whose representative tazel Patel has prepared a pre-recorded message hello I'm tasel Patel the executive director of the S so Investment Group and I hereby move proposal 9 a shareholder proposal requesting that Tesla board of directors adopt and disclose a non-interference and collective bargaining policy that upholds International labor right standards in its operations this resolution was submitted with other co- filers and we are concerned that Tesla's existing policy fails to clearly explain

26:32how conflicts between International and local labor law will be resolved and because of clear indications that Tesla is not adhering to its current policy despite the operational legal human Capital Management and reputational risks involved we recognize that Tesla revised its Global human rights policy in April 2023 to explicitly refer to the rights of workers to free association and collective bargaining but these revisions were fatally compromised the statement committing to respect these rights includes the qualifier in conformance with local law rather than referencing the often higher international human rights standards suggesting that Tesla respects these

27:11rights only as explicitly required by local laws numerous signs suggest that Tesla is not respecting its workers fundamental rights in Sweden Tesla has faced months long strikes and boycotts over what has been characterized as a refusal to bargain moreover as part of its reporting on this situation Reuters wrote that Tesla has a policy of not signing Collective agreements which if true would directly contravene the company's current policy in Germany Tesla faces allegations of refusal to bargain and poor working conditions in the United States Tesla has had adverse Decisions by the full National Labor Relations Board and the US fifth Circuit

27:51Court of Appeals over labor rights violations just last month the nlrb issued a complaint alleging that restrictions in Tesla's workplace technology policy served to unlawfully discourage employees from joining unions or acting concertedly it is also relevant for shareholders to consider the broader human Capital Management risks Tesla faces including reports of higher health and safety violations and injury rates than peers and numerous lawsuits alleging of hostile work environments freedom of Association and collective bargaining are considered enabling rights meaning that they imp EMP power workers to effectively advocate for additional labor rights including the

28:32right to a safe and healthy workplace free from discrimination the adoption of a comprehensive labor rights policy that clearly articulates a commitment to non-interference goodfaith collective bargaining and adherence to higher International standards would help Tesla better mitigate these human Capital Management risks as well as operational and reputational risks like we are seeing in Sweden therefore we urge you to vote for item thank you thank you Miss Patel the board's response is set forth in the proxy the fifth stockholder proposal is an advisory vote regarding reporting on effects and risks associated with electromagnetic radiation and wireless

29:13Technologies our board has recommended against for the reasons set forth in the proxy this stockholder proposal is proposed by lendr P purcel whose representative Dr deah Davis has prepared a pre-recorded message I am Deborah Davis founder of Environmental Health Trust I speaking with you today on behalf of shareholder lendry purcel regarding her proposal seeking an annual report on the risks for magnetic fields and wireless radiation in their products I'm also speaking on behalf of millions of young children infants and toddlers and pregnant women who are more vulnerable to wireless radiation according to the American Academy of Pediatrics I'm the

29:56founding director of the board on Environmental Studies in toxicology from the National Academy of Sciences and I've published more than 220 scientific articles on environmental health and have concluded along with hundreds of other experts that current exposures to non-ionizing electromagnetic fields called EMF constitute a serious and unrecognized public health risk Tesla vehicles operate with the 1200 pound battery that emits magnetic fields and also uses wireless equipment such as Wi-Fi and radar are emitting Wireless radiation Tesla should provide transparent information on measured exposures and efforts to reduce them the World Health Organization has concluded

30:38that both low levels of EMF and microwave or cellular radiation are quote possible carcinogens the same category as some pesticides and gasoline the companies that provide secondary insurance like Lloyds of London and swiss 3 have long considered electromagnetic fields to be uninsurable comp able to as bestus due to potential health and environmental damages Tesla shareholders have a right to know how the company ensures itself against such risks the fact that current levels may be legal does not mean they are safe in fact us regulations were set more than a quarter century ago it has been three years since the US Circuit Court of Appeals for the District of Colombia

31:21determined that the FCC had been quote arbitrary and capricious in its failure to consider all of the science and refusal to update Wireless limits Tesla has failed to inform consumers about the measured levels of magnetic fields and wireless radiation with within the automobile or their other products infants and toddlers by law are strapped into seats to protect them during crashes but they have no projection from EMF that can go more deeply into their thinner skulls to mitigate risks for Tesla the company could Shield its vehicles and ensure Wireless antennas could be easily turned off hardware and softare W changes can lower exposures generally Tesla has developed extremely

32:02rigorous compliance and Hazard screenings Beyond regulatory requirements for certain toxic chemicals investors can encourage the company to take a similar leadership role regarding reducing EMF it's time for the company to unambiguously compete on safety regarding Wireless radiation and non-ionizing radiation emitted by its products thank you thank you Dr Davis the board's response is set forth in the proxy let's move on to the sixth stockholder proposal which is an advisory vote regarding adopting targets and Reporting on metrics to assess the feasibility of integrating sustainability metrics into senior executive compensation plans our board

32:46has recommended against for the reason set forth in the proxy this stockholder proposal is proposed by tulip Sher Securities limited whose rep representative constant rickets has prepared a pre-recorded message good afternoon fellow shareholders thank you for your time I'm constant rickets and today I'm speaking on behalf of tulip share in support of proposal 11 urging Tesla to integrate sustainability metrics including diversity among senior Executives into executive compensation plans this proposal calls for robust quantitative targets and transparent reporting to both resolve executive pay plan controversies and ensure our company's long-term stability and success

33:35diversity and Independence in leadership are essential for Innovation and enhanced decision-making while sustainability metrics in executive compensation reflect alignment with regulatory pressures investor expectations and responsible business practices despite 75% of S&P 500 companies incorporating syst sustainability metrics into executive pay plans Tesla fails to do so this is especially concerning given our mission to accelerate the world's transition to renewable energy the recent ruling that voided our CEO's 56 billion pay package highlighted the need for fair and negotiated compensation plans that serve stockholders best interest Tesla's proxy statement does

34:24not offer substantive evidence of how the voided 2018 award harm stockholder democracy or how its ratification will cure prior deficiencies and lead to a different outcome likewise the opposition to this proposal fails to show any evidence of an existing performance-based component integrated into the executive pay structure that respects established human rights due diligence processes and principles instead it cites its human rights policy that is wholly unrelated to executive compensation and doubles down on the argument that the currently contested executive pay structure is the only means of motivation to achieve our company's Mission this commitment to the

35:06status quo essentially dismisses the ongoing controversies that Tesla must face and overcome including softening sales advaning competition split focus in leadership a 30% drop in stock price reduced market cap Mass layoffs human rights violations and ongoing legal challenges Tesla's executives absolutely should be duly compensated for Innovative and successful business however stockholder democracy allows us to oose demands like 25% control of the company and the largest pay package in corporate American history via further share issuance we also have the right to vote for our leadership's compensation to be commensurate with financial and sustainability performance this does not

35:52mean we do not respect our leadership's time energy and contributions quite the contrary as it is our duty as stockholders to ensure long-term viability and success for our company thank you Miss rickets the board's response is set forth in the proxy let's move on to the seventh stockholder proposal which is an advisory vote regarding committing to a moratorium on sourcing minerals from Deep Sea mining our board is recommended against for the reason set forth in the proxy this proposal is proposed by as you so whose representative Elizabeth Le has also recorded a pre-recorded

36:32message good afternoon chairman members of the board my name is Elizabeth Levy representing as youo speaking on proposal number 12 we know more about the surface of Mars than we do about the bottom of the ocean even so a new industry is moving forward to exploit the deep sea we believe this industry poses risks to Tesla now and into the future deep sea mining is the process of dredging the ocean floor to extract battery related minerals it will indiscriminately destroy habitats and obliterate life in its path seabed mining could release carbon stores and toxic sediment plumes poisoning marine food chains and disrupting sea life breeding and migration the deep sea is complex and

37:24abundant with life its ecosystems are slow growing and Fragile with little to no ability to recover from outside disturbance plans are moving forward to launch the process for commercial scale deep sea mining with or without regulation Tesla's membership in the oecd and Irma mining protocols does not resolve this issue as neither currently applies to mining in the deep sea over 800 Marine Science and policy experts 25 countries 72 indigenous groups and 48 companies are calling for a ban moratorium or precautionary pause on deep sea mining this includes Tesla's competitors BMW Renault rivan Volkswagen

38:11and Volvo even General Motors has stated it does not plan to use deep sea mine minerals our company's public stance on deep sea mining matters Tesla is the face of the EV transition and its ambiguous position on deep mining could drive investment in this controversial industry conversely a clear stance restricting Tesla's use of deep sea minerals can drive innovation in battery mineral Tech Recycling and circularity with these Technologies even the most ambitious future evu scenarios could be met without harming the deep sea Tesla's failure to take a stand on deep sea mining combined with the fact that a former Tesla board director is now serving as a board member and

38:59special advisor to the CEO of the metals company the very company leading the charge on deep sea mining raises concerns such a relationship appears to imply that Tesla supports the metals company in its deepsea mining activities committing to a moratorium will clarify expectations and reduce reputational harm to the company assuring customers and investors that Tesla will indeed wait until science shows deep sea mining will not cause significant or irreparable damage thank you thank you Miss Levy the board's response is set forth in the proxy please note that now is the final opportunity to submit any votes in order for them to be counted I declare that the polls are now

39:49closed [Applause] based on the proxies that we have received and the votes submitted at this meeting I'd like to announce the results on a preliminary basis with respect to the seven stockholder proposals our stockholders have approved the recommendations of the Tesla board on all of them except for proposal six regarding director terms and proposal seven regarding simple majority voting now moving on to the five Tesla proposals first our stockholders have approved the election of our two Class 2 directors James Murdoch and Kimbell musk to serve for a term of three years until their respective successors are duly elected and [Applause] qualified second our stockholders have

40:51approved executive compensation on a non-binding advisory basis third our stockholders have approved the ratification of appointment of price Waterhouse Cooper's Lop as Tesla's independent registered public accounting firm for the 2024 fiscal [Applause] year fourth our stockholders have approved the redomestication of Tesla from Delaware to Texas

41:36Fifth and finally our stockholders have approved the ratification of the 100% performance-based stock option award to Elon Musk that was approved by stockholders in 2018

42:00[Applause] the meeting is now closed and with that Tesla shareholders let's welcome Elon [Applause] [Music] Musk the goal is to give people hope that there is a path to a fully sustainable global economy that we are on that path that we are accelerating that path and that so long as we don't get complacent about it it will happen Le were really the beginning of the end of the Tesla bubble I actually think the company could go bust Tesla's model Y is the world's best selling car beating out Toyota's R 4 and its Corolla models regarding FSD version 12 it's profound the rate of improvement is rapid it might be the biggest asset value appreciation in history when you

43:17can do unsuit biased full self driving I mean that just sounds like a story stock autonomous taxi I mean can you really balance want your checkbook with you know sort of Pie in the Sky predictions like that if you ask the wrong question the right answer is [Music] impossible my prediction is that a majority of Tesla's long-term value will be Optimist and that prediction I'm very confident [Music] of it's very rare a product comes along that is seemingly impossible that experts said would never be made and this is one of those times finally the future will look like the future people say like why' you make it bulletproof I'm like why not energy storage deployments the mega

44:06pack in particular reach an all-time high in q1 leading to record profitability for the energy business this is the machine that builds the machine and the factory is the product and this building is the most advanced car factory that Earth has ever [Applause] seen if you value Tesla as an auto company this is the wrong framework if somebody doesn't believe T is going to solve autonomy I think they should not be an investor in the company but we will and we are

44:38[Music] [Applause] [Music] hey guys welcome welcome to the Tesla shareholder meeting and I I just want to start off by saying Hot D I love you [Applause] guys yeah I we have the most awesome shareholder base I mean it's just incredible any public company it's incredible wow so and you know

45:43we've we've got a a great sort of shareholder meeting here to recap the achievements of the the company and and and tell you about where we're going and it's I think it's incredible I think we're not just opening a new chapter for Tesla we're we're starting a new book [Applause]

46:08okay so th those of you whove been following Tesla closely understand like you get it you know and so so like the important thing is you get it I mean it's so the yeah where where things are going I think is just going to be absolutely mind-blowing you know we're we're obviously making great progress in solving the sustainable energy problem you know with electric vehicles with stationary storage with solar and and then terms I think in terms of the the value of the company autonomy is just such a mind-blowing thing that that like I said you guys understand but I think most of the world does not yet understand so and you know in

47:05talking to a lot of the sort of big institutional investors they're often in like New York and they don't drive cars so I'll be like U have you driven our car or have you have you tried self-driving you know the the version 12.3 and they're like oh no okay well you should try it that would be a good thing to do and and if you just plot the points on the curve of how well autonomy is progressing and just believe the curve it's headed towards a

47:42unsupervised full self-driving very quickly at an exponential Pace if you just if you just yeah it's it's I mean yeah [Applause] so it's it's it's it's really as simple as that and in fact i' I'd invite you to just do it personally just say okay with each release how many miles do you drive before you have to intervene it's it's not it's like literally that that simple and with each release you'll see it there there's a big Improvement big Improvement and it looks like an exponential so and it's very clear that that will actually go to the point where it is actually far safer than a person driving the car so and and I have some insight into you

48:33know the next releases because we we've we've got basically for every release that's on the road we we kind of see what the Next Generation releases and a little bit about the release after that so we have some insight into where it's going and it's really amazing no question whatsoever that will far exceed human safety yeah no question

48:56[Applause] so and I think you know I have I have mentioned this but like sometimes it's it's like helpful to sort of reiterate and connect some of the dots because so sometimes people wonder well how do you go from this big Fleet to actually monetizing the fleet in an autonomous situation and it's it's actually a combination of like it's like Airbnb and Uber to some degree so like there'll be some cars that Tesla owns itself it's kind of like an Uber fashion but then for the fleet that is owned by our customers it will be like an Airbnb thing you can add or subtract your car to the fleet whenever you want so you can say like I'm going away for a week

49:47at just one tap on your Tesla app your car gets added to the fleet and it just makes money for you while you're gone yeah so you can say you can add it to the fleet for a few hours for a few days for a few weeks whenever you want it back you can say come back and car will come right back and I'm highly confident

50:14that it will far exceed the value of like the revenue made by the the owner of the car will far exceed the actual monthly payment and then Tes will obviously take a REV share on that but most of the money will go to the owner of the car and it's this is actually going to work this is what will happen so you I mean I mark my words this is this is simply a matter of time now admittedly I'm a little optimistic sometimes you know I'm I you know so I don't have complete lack of self-awareness but if I wasn't optimistic this wouldn't exist this Factory wouldn't exist you know so [Music]

51:01so you know that's my my brother who's awesome he's here got just got reelected well sorry those things so like a little anecdote like when we were kids in school my my brother would tell me the the wrong time for the bus so that I wouldn't miss the bus and then I'd be upset with him like why did you tell me the bus was going to come earlier than it was and and he's like well cuz otherwise you'd be late for the bus this is an actual thing that that would happen so I'm I I guess I've been sort of pathologically optimistic from you know from birth but but that's the reason we're this is all this stuff is happening anyway it's like I got to be somewhat pathologically

51:47optimistic but I do deliver in the end that's the important thing [Applause] [Music] [Applause] so yeah and it's it's really just going to be something else I've mentioned this before but like the for Aran bestest I'd recommend reading the Aran bestest analysis that's the most accurate there may be you know more accurate ones but the most accurate sort of analysis of the potential of autonomy the most accurate that that I'm aware of is is Kathy Wood's AR invest so and if I recall correctly

52:30they they predicted somewhere over a $5 trillion valuation for Tesla just based on vehicle autonomy not counting Optimus [Applause] yeah yeah I agree with that so so I I think I think just based on vehicle autonomy we can we can 10x more than 10x the value of the company I believe that's what will happen hey no it's just what what do you know it's it's it's 4:20 p.m. just noticed that so you

53:18[Laughter] know so so I think that's actually I I think that's that's pretty accurate but there's there's it actually gets way crazier when you think about the the Optimus robot which is really a humanoid robot that is intended to you know be able to do anything you want it to do to be you know it's

53:52your you know your companion it can be at your house it can sort of babysit at your kids it could teach them be a teacher it it you know it can do Factory stuff like I I think that the ultimate ratio of you say how many super useful humanoid helper Droids do you want like who doesn't want a C3PO you know

54:20you know but a C3PO plus R2-D2 plus you know Plus+ pretty awesome I think I think everyone in the world is going to want one like literally everyone and and then there will be obviously robots in Industry making stuff and so I mean I I think the ratio of humanoid robots to humans will probably be at least two to one something like that one: one for sure so which means like somewhere on the order of 10 billion humanoid robots maybe maybe 20 or 30 and so then it's like okay well let's say you know you you kind of make let's say the build rate is I I think the build rate will be probably something ultimately like a billion a year humanoid robots like

55:13actually and if Tesla just has a 10% share of that and it might be a lot more than 10% and there's you know we make like 100 million Optimus units a year just I mean for reference the Auto industry is roughly 100 million vehicles per year so that you know sort of similar bup at least within an order of magnitude and I like I think we could make one for a cost of maybe at at at really high scale of about $10,000 it's it's it's smaller it's be less expensive than a car so and I think if you sold it for sell for $20,000 or something this is at Large Scale volume Tesla would basically make about a trillion dollars of profit a year from that so [Applause]

56:11yeah if the price Tings multiple is say I know 20 or 25 something like that that would mean a 20 trillion market cap from Optimus Alone and and probably 5 to 10 from autonomous vehicles so like I think it's actually conceivable it's with within the realm of possibility for Tesla to achieve a valuation 10 times that of the most valuable company today

56:49so so when I say this is like we're starting a new book I mean it's going to be the best book Next Level next next next next level oh now we need to make sure these robots are nice to us and you know that's very important yeah so so anyway that so with that let me get into the presentation blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah [Laughter]

57:26oh man I I I think it might be worth us just putting a word limit on future shareholder Tesla [Laughter] proposals it's like it's like like you you can't have like a novel length you know it's CCT like you can't have a whole novel as a Tesla present Tesla proposal so you know as you can see our impact is accelerating you know we're we're starting to make a real noticeable then in C emissions so we're we're really you know making a lot of progress towards achieving our goal of sustainability and one of the the effects of autonomy is actually is going to be an even greater effect on carbon emissions because I I I suspect that we'll go from Passenger cars having

58:18about 10 hours of usage per week about an hour and a half per day to probably a third of the hours in the week maybe 50 55 hours which means the same car will will be used five times more often so so you need a certain amount of resources to make the car but it'll have five times the usage in my opinion I think that's quite likely which will be an even more dramatic impact on carbon emissions so you know we we care a lot about sustainable manufacturing our factories are beautiful like you walk around the factory it's it's it's actually you know contrary to these like what you reading the Press it's like a good vibe in the factory like people are

59:02smiling and happy it's like it's [Laughter] nice [Applause] so so yeah so I mean we do care we actually do care a lot at Tesla about doing the right thing and we you know we're not going to be perfect but we do care a lot about doing the right thing so our vehicles are water efficient energy efficient you know we try whenever possible to use Renewables for powering the factory and you know do do our best to do the right thing our batteries are lasting a lot longer I got too many things in my hand anyway the batteries are last lasting a lot longer which is which is good safety is is is good in the

1:00:01factory we're improving the affordability of EVS you know model Y is comparable to BMW X3 but its actual cost of ownership on a monthly basis is much lower we were number one in EVS globally last year so yeah [Applause] [Music] [Applause] so yeah so let's see and congrats to the Tesla team on making six million Vehicles all time [Applause] [Music] [Applause] so so I mean the Tesla Fleet is really becoming very substantial I mean it's going to be 7 million Vehicles by the end of this year over 7 million Vehicles so [Applause] we had and our our Factory in Fremont is currently the highest volume Auto auto Factory in North America so and and we broke the prior production record

1:01:09from when it was numi so it's it's actually pretty wild there's a we have a giant car factory in the San Francisco Bay Area it's it's like it's not exactly the cheapest place to have a car factory it's like that in the Swiss elves or something you know but but we we still managed to make you know great cars at high volume and that's a testament to the the great team we've got in Fremont so congrats to the Premont [Music] [Applause]

1:01:43team and you a lot of people were saying the Cyber truck is like fake it's never going to come out you know and now we're shipping a lot of cyber trucks we we had a weekly record of 1300 [Applause] so and you know I think with a cyber truck it it really is something special like you know people sometimes have like different opinions on the Cyber truck but if you really want to know if there's a if something is is cool if it's if it's a great product like show it to a kid okay like no filter okay the kids got like no filter like a 5-year-old six-year-old something like that and or even three-year-old and say which car do you like [Laughter] cybertruck so it's like that's how

1:02:43you know and it's finally something that it it just looks like the future it's and it drives so well it you know it's comfortable it's it's just a fantastic product I think it's I think it's our best product and it's a lot of innovation it's got a 48 volt low voltage system finally instead of 12 volts 800 volt drivetrain the world's biggest castings you know it's bulletproof all the cool things can you know outpull a F350 Diesel which is a very impressive truck and it can you know it it can do a quarter mile faster than a Porsche 911 while towing a Porsche 911 so that's insane so

1:03:42[Applause] yeah and if you think if you think about it like how how often do companies make products that move your heart that are really special it's it's so rare and I think this is one of them so [Applause] yeah and we launched the upgraded three which is actually a fantastic car I recommend trying it out it's it's really a great car and it's only $216

1:04:20after gas savings like total cost of ownership it's basically $200 and something dollars when compared to a gasoline car similar gasoline car so it's it's really a a great deal and a fun car and the performance model 3 Performance is well it's like you know fast than Porsche 911 it's

1:04:44just a great great car so yeah so [Applause] yeah yeah and of course mon became the best selling vehicle globally and this this is something that we predicted so you know I think I said in like 2022 it would mod Y would be the biggest car in the world by Dollar volume sales and then 2023 it would be the biggest in unit volume and it was

1:05:22and again this year it will be the bestselling car on so [Applause] yeah and we we got the the Tesla semi you know we're we're in low volume production of the Tesla semi and just last week I I approved the plans for volume production of the Tesla semi [Applause] so we're going to make a lot of semi trcks so we're going to start off with yeah it's it's it's something I think it'll actually move the needle financially it's not like a it's not a small small thing and the thing about like a commercial vehicles is that companies that use them are super objective it's not like it's actually I mean obviously we're going to make it have cool style and be an awesome car

1:06:29but for commercial vehicles the companies that make the the buying decisions they they just look at and say like what are the numbers like is this cost less to transport or cost more to transport than than say a diesel truck and the thing is that the economics are much better than than a diesel truck it's kind of basically no-brainer if if you're a Transport company don't use an electric that t Electric semi you're just losing money why would you do that do you not like money okay but if you do like money

1:07:01then I recommend using the Tesla semi and so so I think this is this is really going to actually sell at a scale that people will be surprised at and and will actually move the needle financially and do a lot of good and also for for CO2 and and and sustainability because semis are driven all the time actually even at at much smaller numbers they have a very big effect on total carbon emissions

1:07:39solved so obviously we've got some new new products that we're working on under the covers and I think these These are I think these going to be pretty special so you know some of them I I think people at maybe at first may think oh it's not going to be that amazing but just wait it will be [Applause]

1:08:19so so our supercharge network is continuing to grow you you know rumors of the death of the supercharg are greatly exaggerated we we are in fact continuing to grow the supercharge Network significantly in fact this year I think we will put more deploy more supercharges this year that are actually working than the rest of Industry combined just FY

1:08:52so now now we are going to be more careful about about like you know the capital efficiency of where we deploy supercharges but for sure any place that has congestion any sort of missing parts of the map that we're missing we're going to put the supercharges there so even for the remainder of the year we we expect to spend about half a billion dollars on on supercharge of deployment so it's it's very significant it' be a well spent half a billion so this is a you know

1:09:24it's it's a lot so and we we're this is actually not showing a bunch of new markets that will be opening up later this year and next so we're obviously we want Tesla to be worldwide and there's still a lot of countries that we you know have zero to very few Teslas and we obviously we want Tesla everywhere so there are a lot of new markets that we're going to open up later this year or

1:09:51next we're also opening the supercharge of supercharges to other companies with the that that's the adapter to the old some somewhat clunky connector but our goal is to be helpful to other car companies so any other car companies that are going electric we do want we do want to be helpful to them with our supercharg Network so we're providing them with adapters and enabling them to have access to the Tesla supercharging network because we think it's better to do that that then to create a world Garden that inhibits EV

1:10:33[Applause] growth oops there was a bit of latency here and we're also innovating a lot in battery production with the 4680 that's built right here and it is it's a hard problem you know like there there are entire companies that just make battery cells that's all they do and but we're making good progress like all the Cyber trucks that you see use the Tesla 4680 cell and that we have a clear path

1:11:07to the 4680 being we think probably the most competitive cell from its from a manufacturing efficiency standpoint and so it's it's but it is it is a hard problem I have to say there's there's quite a lot of brain damage required to be good at cell manufacturing it's like a brain damage High but I think it does it does give Tesla resilience in the face of if

1:11:38there are changes in the I don't know geopolitical situation somehow but it like it's good to have some Independence in cell manufacturing so yeah and we're making stady progress and we also have have the the cathode Refinery which you can see behind the the the main Factory so you can sort of see it in the picture there that's the cathode Refinery and then we've got the lithium Refinery in South Texas and so we're just making sure we've kind of got the pieces of the puzzle and the I mean if you were to look at sort of a video of how Tesla does say cathode and and lithium refining and how the rest of Industry does it it's night and day I mean you can sort of eat off

1:12:24the floor in the in the Tesla Refinery and I would not recommend doing so in the others so you know it's it's really it's it's we're definitely going very very vertical here but I think that this is a it's a wise investment that will that will pay off more than people realize so

1:12:49[Applause] I don't think this thing's working so this year we're also on track to complete a massive number of energy deployments so that is a gigantic increase in in deployment capability so like we're really see we seem to be tracking to sort of a two to 300% year-over-year growth and in energy storage deployment and stationary pack so it's giant and the the

1:13:34limiting factor really is being able to build more Mega packs and build more power walls so we're ramping up production of the power wall 3 which is really a game Cher for at at the personal level the power wall 3 it usually takes about three iterations of of Any Given technology to to Really for for to be something where it's like okay now we're really hitting the sweet spot so power wall 3 is like an epic product the mega pack is also U

1:14:06even it's I'd call it sort of iteration two of mega pack is is also an epic product with with the MEAP Pack 3 which is I don't know probably a couple years away we'll we'll start actually absorbing more and more of the substation of the of the of the sort of Power Electronics so CU I sort of think you want to get to the point with the mega pack where you can literally just take the high voltage power lines and plug them in just there's no Sub Station we just just plug them in just drop them down and drop it down and plug it in that that's and now now it works which is like mindblowing for the utility industry by the way like they're like what yeah you just plug the wires in and

1:14:53it'll work for for for very high voltage so that that I think is is actually going to be major so this is anyway so yeah this is this is great excellent work by the energy storage [Applause] team services and other are also looking good so we're actually now making money on the services and other stuff so this is a kind of a big deal

1:15:31great yeah so see yeah and Tesla is obviously way more than a car company we you know we we do a lot of software at Tesla you know about I don't know roughly half the or a very huge percentage of of the engineering we do is actually software engineering so Tesla's I'd say as much as software company is it it's a hardware company this is a very big deal because car companies are not software companies normally so this this matters a lot so things like our aut aut software for energy storage all the software that controls the cars the mega packs power walls of the solar

1:16:14the obviously for AI and and full self-driving or big deal Insurance service and collision the Tes also writes a lot of software internally that that helps that like we call like the Tesla operating system internally that is Head and Shoulders above what any other company has I think probably better than any Fortune 500 company the Tesla internal software is is just way better so it's yeah it's just a far more than what people normally think of as a car company and Tesla is also the world the leader in real world AI so there's

1:16:59really this is a big deal like Tesla is ah head of of Google matter you know opening eye anyone on real world software actually look taking in video and making decisions based on video no one can no one is even close and it's getting better I say with each passing month if not each passing week so [Applause]

1:17:39yeah and and it's it's it's also worth noting that Tesla is actually pretty good at chip design so the the AI inference chip that's that was designed by Tesla that's in cars we had sort of our Hardware 3 AI and cars made in you know over the past year have the hardware 4 we've just completed design on Hardware 5 which we're now calling ai5 because it it's it's really is

1:18:09it's it's there's still actually is not a a chip from Nvidia or from and I have a lot of respect for NVIDIA from any company that we would prefer to put in our car that is better than what we have in the car so so we we we started from scratch in chip design just as we started from scratch in AI software and have the best real world AI software and the and the best AI inference chip in the world from nothing so this is you know a big

1:18:50[Applause] deal and the the capability of the of the chips in the car is is dramatic like I mean right now all the cars are actually training like we we have Hardware 4 run Hardware 3 in EM emulation mode so we'll continue to make significant progress in Hardware 3 but later this year we'll actually bate continue working on Hardware 3 so so on train training on Hardware 3 but but then do separate training on Hardware 4 that'll be the the sort of training cluster that we're building at the south side of the gigafactory and that'll be dedicated Hardware 4 video and inference and you know so the the hardware 4 has cameras that have about four or five times better

1:19:44resolution and depending on how you count the the sort of harder four it's it's about anywhere from three to eight times better than Hardware 3 so but but everything you're seeing thus far is just Hardware 3 and we still have a long way to go before we get we reach the limits of Hardware 3 so Hardware 3 I think we'll we'll still we'll do amazing things but but Hardware 4 I think we'll probably do about five times better then

1:20:12Hardware five which comes out in about 18 months or so is 10 times more capable than Hardware full it it's like a a s if you know Nvidia Hardware it's it's sort of a a b200 class computer so you know that's like this so what we'll just progressively do is improve how many nines of reliability the car gets and I and then of course that will go into Optimus as well so the same chip will go into you know HRA 4 will go into optim is is an Optimus

1:20:55Hardware ai5 which we're calling switching from Hardware 5 to ai5 will be an Optimus and in all cars in about 18 months and it's really just a a staggering amount of compute and it's very it's very power efficient compute so it's it's got to be because if you're in a mobile application like a humanoid robot or a car you you can't just be socking down 10 kilowatts you know like you can in a data center so you've got to be very power efficient so the

1:21:26you know sort of Hardware three and four are only a few hundred Watts yeah yeah this is hard now Hardware 5 we will be able to go probably up to about 7 or 800 watts it but it will it'll power fluctuate contingent upon the complexity of the scene that it is that it is in so if it is in a you know parking lot station areas like you know comp you know don't have to think very much just like a person like if you're in a complicated traffic scenario you've got to think a lot more than if you're just cruising along you know on an empty road but something that I think is potentially interesting down the road is like at some point the Tesla Fleet I

1:22:17think will probably be you know over 100 million vehicles and if each vehicle has a kilowatt of efficient inference compute I think there's a there I think there's an sort of an Amazon web services AWS type opportunity because if you got 100 million vehicles with a kilowatt of efficient inference compute you've got 100 gaw of compute like 100 gaws of compute is a lot and it's distributed all over the world so even so when the car is not in autonomous mode which I think probably is you know in doing robot taxi work maybe 50 60 hours a week but about 100 hours a week it's it's not it's probably stationary so so there's 100 hours of 100 gws of inference compute

1:23:12which I think we should use why not you know when when when people looked at Amazon were started out I say as an online book seller and it's you know has grown to be like this incredible place where you can buy anything and and then they and then Amazon web services like well they got all these computers that only really see Peak usage sometimes but what are they going to do when it's not Peak usage and sometimes Amazon servers are down like 10% so that's when they said well let's do Amazon web services and then Amazon web services became more valuable than the entire rest of Amazon and you know I think there's there's some kind of opportunity there that's

1:24:03pretty significant for for Tesla down the road you know again that's really nobody's really factoring that in but I think that that actually will be quite significant we also are no longer compute constrained for training so I check in with the team is like is there anything we could do to improve the pace of progress with respect to training and inference and currently that is not the limiting factor in fact the limiting factor right now is that the the the amount of miles between interventions is so long that it takes quite a while to figure out which version is better than the other version because none of them are requiring any interventions so it's like you know if

1:24:51you start getting to like thousands of miles between interventions or you 10,000 miles to get an intervention then like well the average person only drives about 10,000 miles in a year and if it's in a an urban environment and the average speed is 20 M hour I mean so our professional test drivers get pretty bored frankly you know they they're like okay I drove all week and there was no intervention like like the highlight of the week would be like yes an intervention finally it's like getting to that point so so this is where actually having a a giant Fleet is extremely important because we can deploy a new FSD model and run it in Shadow mode and

1:25:34see what see how well it performs Rel you know compare how the human drives the car versus the the new self-driving build and and then Analyze That Delta in Shadow mode like the shadow knows or doesn't know as the case may be and and then be able to assess by getting billions of Miles very quickly with the giant Fleet like that basically that that data engine is incredibly helpful like actually it's not possible to solve the self-driving problem without having millions of vehicles on the road so so that's actually the is like figuring out clever ways to test which H how good the next build FSD build is is is actually the limiting factor right now and then of course like

1:26:27I said we are building another training data center right here which will be dedicated to Hardware 4 training so we we'll we'll bate Hardware 3 and Hardware 4 training later this year we'll we'll keep improving Hardware 3 but we we're going to uncor the full capability of Hardware 4 as well so yeah

1:26:53[Applause] and I think I think most people here have tried out version 12 would it say like UNS sort of unsupervised full self driving full self driving would be version 12 so we we are actually just keeping the version arbitrarily at 12 and then like calling it 12.4 12.3 12.4 12.5 but it's actually

1:27:20really like version 13 version 14 but interesting this is an arbitrary designation so 12.4 is actually like a whole different version than than 12.3 and 12.5 is a whole different version 12.4 so you'll see really giant improvements I think sometimes factor of 10 improvements between successive versions

1:27:54and then as I mentioned the way it'll work for the existing Fleet is you'll be able to add or subtract your car to the fleet as as you'd like and and there will also be Tesla owned cars so it'll be a combination of like uber plus Airbnb but it'll be pretty wild that the that there'll be a software update and then the whole the whole Fleet suddenly becomes accessible it's like suddenly you've got I 7 million 10 million cars that can ultimately tens of millions of cars that can do autonomous driving and instead of being used 10 hours a week can be used 50 or 60 hours a

1:28:40[Applause] week so it's it's pretty wild to just you know be in palto with a bunch of cubes and then a humanoid robot just walk past we've made a massive amount of progress with Optimus in a short period of time from someone pretending to be a robot dancing in a suit to a pretty

1:29:08Hodge pody robot to a robot that is actually doing useful tasks in the factory today so we have two Optimus robots in our Fremont Factory that are doing basically this task which is taking cells off the end of the line and placing them in a shipping container and yeah we actually have quite a few of these cruising around our offices in in paloalto so there's and and I think we've got kind of like one major Hardware revision which should be done by end of this year or early next before and and then we'll move into a limited production next year of Optimus limited production for use in our factories where we'll test out the product kind of you

1:29:58know you know as I said sort of eat our own dog food or whatever the electronic equivalent all that is so but I I think like next year I my prediction is next year we'll have over over a thousand maybe a few thousand Optimus robots working at Tesla [Applause] and and and things are going to scale up very rapidly from there

1:30:33so we'll iron out the bugs it'll like the degree of autonomy will be radically better you'll just literally be able to talk to it and say please do this task or I'm going to show you something now do that the thing that I'm showing you and you know get to the point where it can watch a video of something like a person and and then learn just by looking at that video and and do that task so yeah

1:31:04so really it's going to be quite something and and I'm confident of the prediction that there will be more like the ratio of humanoid robust to humans will be greater than one: one so that they'll be you know more than 10 billion humanid robots in the world probably 20 or more and

1:31:31tells is going to be by far the leader in that you're seeing a lot of robot startups and but I think it's actually very challenging to to do Optimus as a robot startup because what we found to make Optimus work we've had to design EV design from first principles from scratch every part of the robot so the motors the gearbox the sensors the Power Electronics the communication system everything had to be done from scratch we we found that there's basically nothing there's no supply chain so even though there are many electric motors made in the world there's no supply chain for the types of motors and sensors and gearboxes that are needed for a humanoid

1:32:20robot and I mean what you seeing here is our current generation hand and arm but our next which has 11 degrees of freedom our next Generation has 22 degrees of freedom it will be able to play the piano so it's it's really like wow now of course like I said we need to make sure we don't have the terminat scenario that's very important so

1:32:47know say safety of the humanoid robot will be very important but because it requires so much groundup design designing every motor gearbox sensor Power Electronics from scratch it's it's very hard for a startup to if not impossible for a startup to replicate that but at Tesla we have the world's best electrical engineering I think we've got the world's best mechanical engineering for for gearboxes and and and for you electric motors Power Electronics so you know we have the resources to do that it it applies quite well and then you also have to have the the brain you need the you need the the the you need a power efficient inference computer which we've got

1:33:31for the car and we'll be using an Optimus you need AI real you need to be the best in real world Ai and Tesla is the best in real world AI so you need all of these you need a very strong hand of cards in order to make a compelling a robot and then you also need to be very good at scale manufacturing so in order to have the robot not cost like hundreds of thousands of dollars in order to make it cost like you know 10 or $20,000 you actually need to design for manufacturing and be very good at manufacturing and what in my experience prototypes are are easy compared to volume manufacturing prototypes are easy production is hard relatively speaking so Tesla has the

1:34:17production capability it has the engineering capability and it has the AI hardware and software capability and even the most optimistic estimates that I've seen for for Optimus the Optimus Optimist I think under undercount the magnitude of of what this what will be able to do you know as I said at the beginning of the of the presentation I you know I agree with the aren best analysis that autonomous

1:34:57transport is called sort of a 5 to7 trillion dollar market cap situation Optimus I think is is a a 25 literally $25 trillion market cap situation [Applause] so now I don't want to I don't want to tralize tralize what's necessary to get there I mean it's an immense amount of work that is required to get there like super difficult U but we are moving

1:35:29very fast down that road and we're going to make it happen so thank [Applause] you I guess with that we can go to Q&A sorry yeah oh I guess we've got mics lined up [Laughter] dive for the mic hey Elon last year I thanked you for making the world a better place for my son to live in and I wasn't clear in particular I was referring to what you've done for the First Amendment and our rights thank you [Applause] history will not forget it and the sacrifices you made and the risks you took will pay off and have paid off thank you yeah well I very much appreciate that you know I think it's you have to say like why was it why was the first amendment so important is because you

1:36:44know people came here from places where if they spoke their mind they'd be put in prison or killed or just shut out from society ostracized as so freedom of speech is absolutely fundamental to a good future and yeah that's the reason for you know acquiring Twitter and and try to you just making it a free speech platform and I I think it's

1:37:08it was like I think very important to just the future of civilization so thank [Applause] you hey Elon my name's Ronnie I'm on your right side how's it going hey I work for Tesla sales in Orland Park Illinois and I was always wondering do you think Tesla could ever move forward towards bundling software as like a package to you know possibly increase take rate for FSD you know maybe bundle it with premium connectivity and future soft for options I think we we definitely want to encourage people to try FSD and

1:38:01one of the things I sort of I think probably makes sense is that when we have a significant Improvement every time we have a significant Improvement in FSD give people you know give all customers a like a twoe free trial so like hey we've made a an improvement to FSD you know try it for another two weeks you know with with with 12.4 we finally get rid of the steering wheel nag which I know was driving people crazy yeah like like like thank heaven for small mercies so you know even

1:38:35just something like that not having the steer steering wheel nag and obviously having a far lower intervention count like or far more miles between interventions so I think we'll you know I think keep sort of offering people free trials of of FSD every time we make a significant Improvement thank

1:38:57[Applause] you oh sorry yeah it's when you hear the loud of the speakers you're like ears don't work you know good afternoon yeah two questions actually first after $ 56 billion you can afford to probably take your kids to Disneyland now is that where you're going well I I mean by the way it is worth emphasizing that is Tesla stock that I have to own for five years so you know like it's there like it's not possible to like it's not actually cash and I can't cut and run nor would I want to but and I've actually been

1:39:40to Disney Disneyland Disney World many times with kids it's a little tough for me to go these days without crosing a Ruckus you know maybe I should just like wear a Mickey Mouse outfit just go and you know pretend I'm like one of the so as we as we work on autonomy and we're getting to that threshold where things are getting to a seriously advanced level eventually there are going to be some harsh consequences it's part of breaking through right and I'm just curious where your mind is at on that and have you thought about you know some of those early consequences that were unfortunately going to have to have in order to have a better safer future I'm just wondering you mean like

1:40:29scary robots or what no no in Auto in Auto in the cars with full self- driving and okay like we've seen some companies that there's been some unfortunate mishaps and they just straight up like close shop and you know that's not the plan but those are real consequences of of developing this technology and I'm just wondering where your mind is at on that yeah well we are we do try to be very careful with the deployment of FSD

1:41:00and you know we do have a a lot of cars so what like like inevitably when there are a lot of cars and you've got you know billions of miles you do have the low of Lodge numbers where okay there's a small chance of something bad happening but when you look at the sort of safety per mile because we got a lot of miles it's very clear that the safety per mile is better than human driving so so when when we you know

1:41:26we can show that to regulators and obviously make our case to the public and say like actually you know human driving is not perfect you know there's there's a per person killed roughly every 80 million miles so like I think like 35 40,000 people are killed every year in the US from auto accidents what matters is like are we making that number smaller and as long as we're making that that number smaller we're doing the right thing thank you

1:41:55hey Elon this is Bash I have one question sure so we know that we know that we love you all we love from our bottom of the heart we love you so much Elon my question is my question is like we all know Tesla will be the most valuable company in the world one day yeah we just want to know if you have any prediction when and what is the infection Point what when when we can say this is the inspection point is is it solving the FSD or is it like Optimus on ground will be the point from your you know perspective well as I mentioned before I think it's worth looking at the you know the arch

1:42:40invest analysis I think that is the most accurate analysis their prediction is I think 5 to7 trillion by 2029 market cap so more than 10 times what things are today in 5 years I think that is accurate thank you thank you all right hey Elon hey hey huge fan and I think history will show that you've had a profound impact on Humanity so I think that's just given and just couple of questions I guess I fixed my Tesla addiction by putting cars on turo and I found that about half my rers is the first time they're driving a Tesla and then the other half really want to buy one after they've tried it out so I guess a couple questions when could we expect maybe the referral program to

1:43:31come back if it would come back and could we also get a passenger van like a 12 passenger van sometime soonish I'll add that to my list so the yeah so the referral program like yeah I think we'll we'll we'll reexamine the referral program probably next quarter and like it is very

1:44:08important to sort of look at the what is the fully considered cost of a Tesla so with the referral program it effectively increases the price of the car so you know is the price increase what what is better for the End customer is a slight price increase because of the referral Pro program or or not but I

1:44:28we examine that I think in you know next quarter and and see if see if it makes sense I think some kind of referral program does make sense and you know but I think for a lot of people like by far like by far the biggest thing we see is that people just can't afford the car that's the biggest thing like that's the limiter on demand you can imagine in the limit if there was say you know an 18 like if if

1:44:57model y cost like less than $20,000 it sell like probably 5 million units like it would be insane so now that's not feasible you know today but I think working on figuring out ways to make more affordable Vehicles is really the the game changer like for for most people it is really not a question of of whether they want a Tesla they do want a Tesla they simply do not have enough money to afford one so we have to make it affordable that's That's essential thank you hey I just want to introduce myself my name is Hamza first off thank you for introducing me to hrebec he and I are now like close thanks to you and I moved to Austin thanks to you so my

1:45:43question is basically for FSD transfer I think that should be something that should be ongoing I think not only on the benefit of you for getting more people on the fleet and getting you know statistics and info but also as Tesla owners it makes us want to get the next model and transfer over you know for instance the thing that's been holding me back is wanting to wait for the fstd transfer again so is there a reason why you haven't implemented that for like ongoing time it it is pretty complex for us to to do this it's sort of adds a fa bit of complexity to the the sales process

1:46:21but yeah and it is tough because we got to own Revenue somehow so you know transfer is is is tough but we sorry one more quarter okay one more quarter all right you got it one more quarter all right so yeah all right oh Elon thank you for hosting us if you can see me I'm trembling uncontrollably it really look up to you shareholder consumer you know tripled my humble tiny little portion of of your shares the last two days just being engaged knowing we coming here and appreciate you hosting a Shar holders and it just means so much to us you're welcome you're an absolute Idol this question comes because I care about you as a human being but in the context of being

1:47:32a shareholder unlocking these values of Optimus we need you and just with all the global uncertainty you're so high-profile just want to make sure you're doing everything to take care of yourself safety and health for the future of the company I say that cuz I care about you as a person but since this is a shareholder meaning and the spirit of shareholder value well thank you I appreciate the kind sentiment yeah I I think I I probably need to like work out and you know and and like not get not get assassinated or something you know I I mean it it is getting a little crazy these days you know like to First approximation the prob that that a homicidal maniac will try to kill you is

1:48:26proportionate to how many homicidal Maniacs hear your name okay so they hear my name a lot I'm like okay I'm on the list you know so yeah so we actually did have two homicidal Maniacs in the last roughly seven months come to aspirationally try to kill me and a bunch of other people so it's not just me and and there wasn't like like an actual issue that they articulated they were just you know in the homicidal maniac career so

1:49:01and so I do need to be kind of careful it it is which is not great because like forces me to be a bit more sort of standoffish you know and you know like so now like I've like stopped signing things cuz just you know something CU like that would be a sure way to like homicidal Mania Go San fris ass something and then shoot him type of thing so then I you know I have to be like more stand offish and stuff which I prefer not to be but it seems wise like think of like John Lennon who was like singing about like hey can't we all just be nice to each other and then he got shot you know by one of his fans like okay this we'll try to avoid that so anyway I appreciate the kind

1:49:48sentiments I will endeavor to stay alive and keep and yeah so all right hi Elon I was reading an article the other day is Tesla still have somewhere in the product timeline a home interact system in the works a home interact system we do not have a home trct system that I'm aware of no no we do not one HVAC system oh HVAC oh h back yeah yeah sure yeah in the list of things that would be like more useful than like it would be nice to do would be a great HVAC system that is very power efficient you know has like a bulin he a filter and like take a lot of things that we've learned in the car and apply that to home hbac because I'm I I actually maybe there

1:50:47is a great home HVAC system out there but I don't I haven't found it which is pry pretty wild and and just building in the filtration system and you know being able to sort of maybe also control humidity somewhat and like I said be super efficient and quiet which are all things that we we do in the car that would be a pretty sweet thing to do you know maybe we can combine that with the power wall or something on the list of things to do that is not super high but I it would be it would be cool to do do that one day hi this is s I just want to thank you for making the Cyber truck and you're welcome yeah kids love it really my four and sixy old they love it

1:51:36exactly that's what I saying kids it's like amazing it's like I went to Disney last week nobody looks at Disney everybody looks at Cyber yeah there's a funny story if if you may allow so we were preparing my daughter we went to Destin and then from there we were driving to Disney and then we were preparing my daughter to she's 4 years to just get used to the lines and you know you have to have a lot of patient to get in the line and she's like Dada why don't we just say we'll show you our saber truck and then we'll cut the lines I mean she got used to it because we were driving superchargers and then everybody was coming over taking pictures sure it's a funny story you

1:52:18know yeah yeah and then I have a request would you allow six year-old to tour the factory maybe someday in the future right now it's C at 12 years okay even though we have referral rewards it's CED 12 years would you allow the kids to tour the factory maybe they can see the robots sure sure if you make an event or something like that yeah maybe we could have like a always like worried about kids safety and stuff you know in case kid like goes running off into like the robot sell or something but but yeah we we could I think lower this maybe have like a more limited to her that's you know enables younger kids to go sure we'll do that all right

1:53:01see that okay Donald Trump has been a big critic of electric vehicles but last week he surprised Us by saying he's a big fan of Tesla and a big fan of [Applause] you what did you tell him well you know I can be persuasive [Music] so yeah actually I I don't exactly know why he this good question I mean you know I have had some conversations with him and he does he does call me out of the blue for no reason I don't know why but he does and it's and it's like he's very nice when he calls and you know and I was like you know you know electric cars I think are pretty good for the future America's the leader in electric cars you know you know by America and stuff and oh and I

1:54:04think he actually a lot of his friends now have Teslas and they they will love it and he's a huge fan of the Cyber truck so I think those may be contributing factors you [Applause] know hey Elon on your right sorry yeah my name's Keanu longtime fan of your like brand and company and everything I'm wondering when you take the driver out of the seat for the driverless car how do you plan to handle interventions which I'm sure will happen at some rate even if they're rare yeah so there's I mean clearly we want to make sure that if if there's no driver in the car the probability of of a severe intervention is extremely low you know you know we we want to make

1:54:51sure like the the car is extremely cautious around vulnerable Road users like cyclists or pedestrians so really we'd want the the probability of of a of of hurting as a pedestrian or cyclist to be incredibly low like way lower than someone driving a car now then there there are interventions that happen where the car is simply like I don't know get stuck down a one-way Street where with a like crazy construction situation that but in which case it'll it'll basically phone home and say help I need I'm stuck and then I think we can probably solve a lot of these things just by you know remoting into the car and and kind of like steering it like a

1:55:39giant RC car that's that's what I'm guessing that's what what I think we'll do than hey Elon on more be from Kazakhstan thanks for installing superchargers I just want to acknowledge Tesla Boomer mama and soya Meritt for all the efforts they to organize the yeah there's a Afterparty to celebrate at luster Pearl East if you guys want to come and celebrate all the efforts for the community congratul ulations Elon thank you

1:56:27y thanks for hosting today Elon it's about four years since you did battery day and and grew out those very ambitious targets of getting to a ter hour of batteries and earlier in your presentation you alluded to the great difficulty of scaling up this new technology I think as shareholders we're most interested can you tell us a little bit more because in terms of affordability which you also mentioned does this huge burden these 46 80s get manufacturing credits and also on the consumer side get large credits as well if you could scale that so that we could produce full level of cyber trucks and also start to put them back in the Y and the three potentially it would

1:57:08greatly improve affordability and be great in terms of scale sure the so achieving affordability is actually at this point more about the rest of the car than it is actually about the battery pack so the the price per kilowatt hour of cells from suppliers has dropped dramatically so there there was a massive Spike for a few years in the cost of of lithium ion cells from suppliers because every car manufacturer put in gigantic orders for battery packs like giant giant orders so the price of like of lithium and like all the raw materials and the the battery cells went went crazy it doubled like the price

1:57:58of cells doubled price of lithium I think went up at almost like like five fivefold or like 500% like went up crazy numbers so since then the demand like suppliers battery cell suppliers have increased their supply and the orders from other car manufacturers have declined so I mean it is worth noting that it's it's like it's tough sledding out there for EVS you know GM announced I think a 50% reduction in recently and in their EVS Ford announced reductions I think almost every manufacturer has announced reductions in their electric vehicle plans now Tesla we're going to increase but it but it is not an easy Market and but to to to get the

1:58:49the cost of car down it's it's really the the pack is a piece of the puzzle but it's it's really everything else too so I I I really would describe like like making a car more affordable it's like Game of Thrones but pennies game of pennies so there's C to First approximation 10,000 unique items in a car and if each each one costs five bucks or you then you've got a $50,000 car so to actually get the cost of car down you've got to chisel away pennies and to to get the 10,000 items to be you know $3 instead of $5 that's kind of what it amounts to

1:59:32now with respect to our own cell production we do see a path to cost par by the end of this year a very difficult path to cost parity currently our 468 are cost more than our suppliers now they cost more than the suppliers today but they cost less left in the suppliers a year ago so you know like there's a bit of a feast famine thing with with battery cell Supply it's kind of like for Dram chips you know like the dram industry goes from like you know over Supply to under Supply the price of dram changes like crazy it's kind of like that for sales so but we expect to achieve

2:00:16cost cost prity with even the the much lower Supply or sell price today by the end of the year hi Mr musk I've been a long-term investor since 2012 great wow and I voted for your compensation package in 2018 again this year and shout out to Tesla Boomer Mama Alexandra you I had a privilege to talk to you in 2013 briefly and you spoke about the truck which became to cybertruck you're a man of your reward I have friends all over the world in Asia Canada and Europe and I I know that cybertruck's been on tour how's been the the reception for the Cyber truck and when will it be or is it possible to sell when when will it be sold internationally yeah

2:01:11so I think Pro you know we might be able to certify it for other markets sometime next year but like for for sure this year it's just North America we did design the car to North American requirements because if you start going with the superet of all International requirements it forces a lot of constraints on the on on Cyber Tru that would make the product frankly worse so I think we we'll we'll need to make a special version that is for example a China compliant or Europe compliant and but but really doesn't make sense to add that complexity until we've achieved a higher volume production on the Cyber truck there's still a lot of work to do on cost down for the

2:02:03Cyber truck you know I generally say like the the level of difficulty going from say prototype you go from prototype to production it's a 100 times harder to go from from the you know from prototype to production is 100 times harder and then once you reach production to improve the price by 20%

2:02:24like or the cost of goods by 20% is harder than reaching production in the first place like it's Mega pain it's like you know and to be frank it's not the funnest job in the world you know like chiseling pennies is not it's like washing the dishes frankly you know like wash a lot of dishes here I could super fun to make prototypes that's really fun and it's it's kind of cool to get it's it's pretty cool to get the production going then the cost grind is a grind that is like you know it's hard

2:02:58work you know there's some reward to it like there's sort of a reward to washing the dishes I guess you have clean dishes but it's that is that is is a tough so that's real hard work I just had to say that it there's been a really big reception like have friends that you know messaged me and said they love the Cyber Truck design and it's it's definitely a head turner so oh yeah I I I think from a demand standpoint we would have plenty of demand in other parts of the world for cyber truck no question like wherever it goes anywhere in the world it's a gets a massive crowd so so it's not a demand thing it's it's really we've got to reach volume production go through the

2:03:45cost grind I can't I it difficult for me to overstate the difficulty in the cost grind it's really intense and then we've got to recertify the car which includes making some design changes for to meet to be compliant in other markets all right good afternoon Elon I like your shoes I don't know if everybody else can see them C out there cyber truck yeah

2:04:15my question was in regards to the foundation series do you guys have a certain number that you are planning on making or a timeline of when the non-foundation series are going to come out yeah we'll start making the we'll we'll we'll end the foundation series actually pretty soon and the non Foundation series sometime next

2:04:38[Applause] quarter hi Elon thank you for delivering shareholder value and congrats on your pay package and I'm Michael I ask a lot of questions on the quarterly investor and I wanted to ask you can you give me a little bit more color on the neural net scaling laws that you're seeing as you're training FSD like how much data how much more inference compute how much more training compute do you need for each successive nine in reliability of the full self-driving software and how much data are you currently collecting thank you yeah that's a great question I mean that's something that we go through really every week at at Tesla I spent a lot of time with the the

2:05:24Tesla AI team and you I think probably like you know like a huge portion of I mean it's it's it's it's really like a big part of my job is is like okay we need we need to get the car to drive itself you know and yeah you need to solve things on a on a chip level for inference for training for software there's also massive data data storage challenges because you got pedabytes of video coming in

2:06:01and you know even for for say for a big Nvidia cluster it's actually really hard to make a big Nvidia cluster actually work in training it doesn't just open the box and plug it in it's not like that at all it's like massive effort required to get a big training cluster to to operate with to operate at all and then operate operate with high up time

2:06:29so I mean with respect to like the various versions that we're seeing like you go from version 123 well like if you just ignore the 12 and and think of it like three four five six that's actually the way to think about it ignore the 12 part and and just call it like version three version four version five that's version six that that's how to think about it between each one there's anywhere from I don't know a minimum of a doubling of improvement to in some cases I think a five to tenfold Improvement you know especially as we eliminate sort of say I think we're close to eliminating almost all static object

2:07:18collisions so you know like curves and medians and like we're pretty close to to having it to have almost zero static object collisions so once you get to zero static OB that now you have a gigantic Improvement in miles between intervention then you get into classes of dynamic objects that are you know different classes and different things can get obviously very complicated if you've got a complex intersection with traffic lights all over the place and like somebody bumped the one traffic light now's pointing in the wrong direction or the traffic light's broken and and there's someone who is not obeying the traffic laws because they're just running a red

2:08:06or they got confused about traffic light so you get into these very complex situations that are much harder to solve so but but and then like as I was saying earlier it actually gets as as the system gets better it get it it gets harder to figure out which which which AI model is better like like because now you know like okay it's thousands of miles between intervention how do we as quickly as

2:08:47possible figure out which AI model is better and when when you make make these different AI models they're they're obviously not like super deterministic so you could have something a new model that does that eliminates one problem but creates another problem so so so what so we're trying to

2:09:10solve this by a combination of simulation uploading models having them run in Shadow mode so it's actually kind of helpful that not everyone has full self driving because we can see we can write it in Shadow mode and see what would the what would this new model have done compared to what the user did so since we've got you know millions of cars that we can do this with that gives us a Delta between what the AI model predicted would do and and the user would do and if you kind of sum up the errors between them you can see oh there there was a bigger error stack from this model versus that model when you uploaded them into each upload them into

2:09:51100,000 cars but that's that's that's the the biggest limiter right now it's it's not training it's not it's not data it's actually testing the AI models and then figuring out clever ways to figure out if a new model is better or not like we know like there are sort of particular intersections that are difficult and so we if we just like like all the models will be great at like driving on a on a on a wellp painted road with no intersection they will be great at that but but will they be great at the complicate so so we've identified several thousand intersections in the United States where we'll we'll actually take the new model and try the car in

2:10:38those those very difficult intersection like you know a sort of for the famous like Chuck's left turn [Applause] yeah so if you imagine Chuck's left tone hey Chuck I wonder what the neighbors think but there there's there's many such complicated traffic situations in the country so we we've identified several thousand which should we then send cars to those locations to compare the models and and then as as I mentioned there's we we have yet to uncor any of the ability of Hardware 4 which we'll do later this year so I I I think

2:11:31the you know the exponential rate of improvement of miles between intervention will continue and will accelerate yeah so hey Elon I was wondering if as you you you've called a a Tesla basically a robot with wheels and so I'm wondering kind of as that as as that logic transfers over to Optimus what kind of will Tesla use any large language models on top of the current Tesla Tesla robox capabilities and also if so will Optimus have any kind of personality and would would that be something that the end user might be able to have control over yes to all of those questions

2:12:22yes to all so like we're headed for a wild future I mean wild wild wild you know cars will all drive themselves people will have super helpful humanoid help robots and yeah you'll be able to customize the personality customize the voice and and really kind of the robot will kind of get to know you as well and know your preferences you won't even have to say things because it'll just kind of understand you I I think it we'll get to this point where it's like it'll be odd not to have a robot buddy like you know sort of not not to have your C3PO and you know

2:13:09R2D2 so yeah yeah hi Ellen Max here huge fun thank you for hosting us I wanted to ask you How do you how much integration work do you think will be needed to deploy Optimus into different types of factories Industries like unique technicians or just have them go watch and like how do you foresee that well if I think if you fast forward a few years it really will be quite a generalized robot like say two years from now like like next year it'll like this year it's still quite specific you you know tasks specific training so to do a particular task we we have to kind of do Fair B training to to to solve that

2:14:01task but over time I think you sort of accumulate these kind of training Primitives where like calling like walking for example is a training primitive picking something identifying an object and and grabbing it is would be a primitive and these Primitives are then generalized to to anything so you could say pick up a cup pick up a shirt fold the shirt these these things will generalize I think quite quickly so I I

2:14:38expect probably not next year but like in 2026 it's it's really the kind of thing where you you could tell it to do kind of a wide range of tasks a wide range of tasks including tasks where has not specifically done that exact thing before probably in I'm guessing 2026 true and do you foresee a cheaper version where tasks don't require like walking for example or so you the the hardware will become a lot simpler or cheaper well we're going to focus on making just a fantastic humanoid robot at scale and and really

2:15:26achieving scale economies and building that humanoid robot the you know at at very high volume if you're really good at manufacturing you can get the the cost of almost anything down to its constituent elements essentially the the the weight and if you just look at the the weight of the raw materials times the value of those raw materials excluding circuit boards you you really can say like if if it weighs less it's going to cost less and but but but what I'm saying is that it's it's better for us to achieve very high volume with Optimus than to have a wide range of robots that have lower volume yeah right hi there

2:16:18okay one of the best things about the re certifying of your compensation package was listening to all the positive feedback of current inmer employees to what you have contributed to Tesla in the unfortunate event that you're hit by a car not full self-driving can you take a few minutes or a few seconds and brag them on your board and the rest of your leadership to assure us that even without you Tesla has an incredible future at $30 trillion

2:16:56well I think Tesla has a good future without me I I I think I I'm a helpful accelerant to that future [Applause] and for for for technology it matters if you're ahead or or not ahead aot a lot so the the rate of like what matters is not Innovation but the rate of innovation you know can you do in one year what other companies do in two years or three years so like probably my you know biggest most helpful thing is is innovation accelerant and you know because given enough time the the various startups that are doing humanoid robots will eventually succeed one of them will and so

2:17:48what really matters is can we be much faster than everyone else can our product be done a few years ahead before theirs and be better because if that's not the case then then you know you they will achieve the valuation and not not Tesla they will make the valuable product not Tesla so you know that's that's where I I think I'm probably most useful is that is accelerating the pace of technology and innovation and getting to scale yeah that's that's that's it mostly but I I am very much hardened by and appreciate the support of current for tells employees tells the board and and all you guys for helping out you know my Haw goes out of

2:18:45you hi you Jessica or my name is Jessica and I have lived full-time RV for about 3 years in South Texas and I just wanted to thank you for your Starship or for the Starship program and everything you're doing there in addition to Tesla do you work at SpaceX or something no okay okay but you living in RV in South Texas yeah okay hi and in my

2:19:13RV park they don't allow car camping for Teslas or electric vehicles at all if you're not pulling a trailer and I feel that there's a huge opportunity there but also for Just For example people who are coming into town for Starship launches in Tesla's if they could park somewhere overnight in trickle charge okay and U maybe have access to you know bathroom facility or just something simple like that okay just something I wanted to just put forward I I know that a lot of people come into the park and are disappointed they can't stay so okay got it just just a thought all right I'll I'll inquire to see if there's like maybe some place that would allow people

2:20:02to stay in their cars which in in a Tesla you really can often stay quite comfortably in a car and yeah and and charge all right thanks all right I I think so this this this will have to be the the last question I think or maybe last two yeah all right so last two questions you and two guys heyan my name is stepen I'm truly thankful for all you've done for Humanity and watching your companies and what you've done has been the most exciting hope inspiring movie that there's ever been so thank you so much and thank you yeah thank you and my question today is about lithium refining in the past you stated that would be a limiting factor in the future

2:20:43and I know Tesla has built the refinery in Texas I was just kind of curious your current opinion about the refiner do you think there's enough capacity coming online or will Tesla need to expand past Texas in that regard there's there's enough lithium refining if you count China if you if there should if there's a geopolitical challenge on that front then there may be a shortage of lithium but China is very good at at refining so but I I think just Tesla being

2:21:19figuring out lithium finding understanding what it takes and then you know once we understand how it works then we can scale it up from there and that like it's I think it's pretty important to you know be careful with geopolitical risk and just make sure that if in a worst case situation that Tesla is okay all right thank you last this is the last question hi Lan thank you congratulations for yet another big win I'm nikel I'm based out of Silicon Valley and as you mentioned on FST awareness and giving people rights because most people unless they really experience it they don't quite know how safe it is becoming and how convenient it is becoming so I

2:22:07built tesmi company it's a platform for Tesla owners to offer learning experiences FSD and we would love to explore how we can help scale with your support and guidance and we'd love to have a follow-up conversation to discuss more details with you how we can work together thank you I I have a suggest okay sure okay sure sure sure sure you really

2:22:35want to ask a question followup please I'm not I'm not sure how to answer that question exactly but I mean we are we are focused on improving FSD for sure and I think the adoption will be widespread like when it is really working insanely well and it's and it's driving like a f- star Uber driver I think adoption will be will be very very quick all right I have a really good suggestion okay what's the suggestion sure I Shar this suggestion with one of your FST team but I don't know whether it reached you or not basically as FST keep on improving we are not quite sure at what rate you will be improving the mar of lines so and and so lot ofip remains as to when you can

2:23:25exactly operate the robot taxi so it occurred to me that in between supervised FSD and robot taxi there is something intermediate stage that's commercializable which is what I would call a robot rental car okay the idea is that you would people would go to your platform to order a rental car and you will deliver that overnight to the front of the driveway and and then so so the only time that the the that that car will be driving without a person is at night with nobody and you can take as long as you want and you drop in the front of the car and after that it's supervised so that will get you to a a commercialization much sooner much more guaranteed so that's my suggest all

2:24:10right well I appreciate the thought I I I I think like I said it's the progress in FSD will be you know really amazing you'll see with each success ESS of version like I said the best way to think of FSD ignore the 12 just think of the the point number we're going from from version 3 to four to 5 to six and and you'll see just radical improvements with each successive version you know and and I mean if current current Trend continues it's going to be like you you you'll really find that you don't intervene in the course of a year type of thing so even even in complex situations anyway with that thank you very much for your support

2:24:57so so thanks guys all right [Applause] [Music]

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份