2024 年 3 月,Don Lemon(唐·莱蒙)在特斯拉的奥斯汀总部坐下来,对面是马斯克。这场访谈录完没几天,X 取消了他的内容合作协议。一年后,莱蒙把这段对话剪成十集重新播出,开场白是这么说的:它不只是一次让人挑眉的对话,它还预告了此后定义马斯克轨迹的许多争论。
这话不算夸张。回看这一小时,马斯克后来反复使用的论据几乎全部摆在了桌上:X 是世界第一新闻来源、左右标签已经失效、旧推特是极左的工具、员工的政治捐款 99% 给了民主党。每一个说法都能在他此后两年里的发言中找到回声。
真正有信息量的地方,是他怎么把一堆旧材料组织成一套自洽的逻辑,以及有哪几个问题他一直没接。
莱蒙做这场访谈的动机,本身就带着火药
莱蒙在重播的开场里交代得很直白。2023 年下半年,X 平台上的极右声音和阴谋论者越来越占主导。马斯克公开承诺把 X 做成言论自由的空间,实际呈现出来的声音谱系却很窄,窄到不能代表完整的光谱。
马斯克本人在 X 上公开点名批评过他。莱蒙的反应是注册账号、加入平台,用一个相对平衡的声音去占一块地方。
然后事情出现了转折。马斯克在夏天主动联系他,说希望 Don Lemon 这样的人、以及其他偏左的声音来到平台上,会得到全力支持。原话是“数字城市广场属于所有人”。
莱蒙用这句话当第一个问题的引子,问马斯克:你说的“属于所有人”具体指什么?
“X 已经是世界第一新闻来源”,这是他的地基
马斯克的回答没有绕弯。他认为 X 已经是全球第一新闻来源,理由是实时事件没有第二个平台能接近。
人们了解任何一类新闻、尤其是突发事件的第一入口,就是 X 平台。就实时新闻而言,没有谁接近。(马斯克)
这个判断有事实成分。俄乌冲突、中东局势、美国大选的现场画面,很多时候确实是先在 X 上跑起来的。传统媒体的流程是记者赶到、编辑、审稿、发布,X 的流程是任何一个拿着手机的人按下发送键。速度上的差距不是一点半点。
接下来他讲的是扩展方向。X 不再只做短文本,而是把信息的所有形态都装进来:长文帖子可以写成一篇完整文章,理论上可以发一整本书;视频最长支持 4 小时,够放一部电影加半场讨论;文字、图片、长短视频,什么形式都能承载。
他嘴里的 X 更像一个容器,产品这个词已经装不下他的描述。用他的原话说,他们希望任何形式的信息都能在这个平台上找到位置。
他想要的观点多样性,具体到人名就是卡尔森加一个左派
回到“数字城市广场”这个概念,马斯克给的落地方式是靠人。
我们要确保有各种各样的观点。比如我们有塔克·卡尔森,大多数人会把他看作右派,他在右派里是相当有分量的名字。我们也想要左派里有分量的名字,再加上中间派,让用户听到不同的意见,自己做判断。(马斯克)
这套思路的隐含前提是:观点的平衡可以通过引入代表性人物来实现。平台负责提供场地和话筒,用户负责判断。
问题在于,话筒的大小并不平均。算法决定谁能被看见,而算法是他改的。这一点访谈里没有被追问。
“我以为你偏左”,这句话把话题引到了标签本身
莱蒙听到“左派”两个字,立刻反问:你说要请左派,你不是觉得我属于左派吧?
马斯克的回答很坦白,坦白到有点出人意料。他说自己确实以为莱蒙偏左,但紧接着补了一句:如今左右是什么,他自己也说不太清,因为议题已经高度两极化。他的判断是莱蒙更接近中左。
莱蒙不接受这个位置。他说自己独立思考,按议题投票,不按政党投票。
马斯克对这套说法表示认同,并且给出了一个更完整的表述:有一整套议题被相当随意地塞进左或右的口袋里,而大多数公民其实是左边同意一些、右边同意一些。
这段对话只有两三分钟,但它给整场访谈定了一个基调。在马斯克的框架里,左右标签属于过时的分类法,真正有意义的分类是允许说话和不允许说话。
这个框架很好用。它可以把所有关于内容质量的质疑,都转换成关于表达权利的争论。你问平台上是不是阴谋论太多,他回答的是过去右派被压得更狠。两个问题相关,但不在同一个层面上。
X 永远叫 X,这件事他一点没犹豫
访谈里有一段轻松的插曲。莱蒙问,我们还要叫它“前身为推特的 X”叫多久。马斯克说,顶多一年,一年后没人会再这么叫。
莱蒙追问,有没有考虑过改回推特。
马斯克的回答是没有,从来没有考虑过,从一开始就是 X。连收购用的公司主体名字本来就叫 X。
这件事外界讨论了两年,各种分析说改名字伤了品牌、丢了辨识度、白白扔掉了十几年的品牌资产。马斯克的态度等于告诉所有人:改名从一开始就跟营销无关,是早就拍板的事。
他自己列的成绩单:功能、算法、使用量
莱蒙问他管这么大一个平台感觉如何,马斯克的回答是“到目前为止还不错”,然后开始报数。
使用量创了纪录。功能上增加了一大批:从只能发短文本加一张图,扩展到长文、长视频、音视频通话(私信不再只能打字)、算法改进、系统速度提升。他把这些统称为“更快更好”,并说这些变化反映在了使用量上。
这段回答有个特点:全是能力和功能,没有一条是关于内容生态的。平台能做什么,和平台上发生了什么,属于两个层面的事。马斯克在前一个层面答得很足,在后一个层面留了空白。
莱蒙把问题摆上桌:平台正在变成 MAGA 的回音室
访谈进行到这里,莱蒙开始加压。
他的说法是:你说过要所有观点,但平台现在的走向是接过了部分保守派媒体的位置,越来越右,有时候甚至滑进阴谋论。他提到最近有一篇文章,把马斯克、特朗普和 X 并列为 MAGA 运动里最重要的三个标志。
马斯克的第一反应是否认,而且是否认文章本身。
这种胡说八道的文章每天都在被写出来,我肯定不会同意那一篇,它属于胡说八道那一类。(马斯克)
然后他给出了自己的版本:旧推特本质上是极左的工具,原因很大程度在于它位于旧金山和伯克利,它想把那一带的政治教条投射到全世界。
莱蒙确认了一遍:你认为它是极左?马斯克回答:是的。
他还提到自己一度因为铺天盖地的仇恨推文离开过平台,那些攻击大量来自右翼阴谋论者。马斯克接过话,说自己被骂过的名字也有上千种。
10 倍和 99%,他给出的两个数字
这是他在这场访谈里最硬的一段论证,值得逐条拆开看。
第一组:旧推特对右派账号的封禁和压制,次数是左派的 10 倍。而且即便封禁了左派账号,原因也多半是左派内部的互相攻击。
第二组:推特员工的政治捐款,99% 流向民主党。
推特的人,他们的政治捐款 99% 给了民主党。字面意义上的 99%。这显然是一个极度左倾的群体,他们用钱表达了立场。(马斯克)
莱蒙在这里抓住了要害。他连着问了几遍,你讲的是运营平台的人、拥有平台的人,而我问的是使用平台的人。
你说的是运营平台的人,我说的是使用平台的人,这是两件事。(莱蒙)
马斯克的回应是把问题推开:这跟他们对不对没关系,我只是在回答你那个“旧推特是否左倾”的疑问。
这段交锋值得停一下。莱蒙问的是结果,平台上的内容生态是否失衡。马斯克答的是原因,运营团队的政治倾向。用团队的构成去解释平台的性质,逻辑上说得通,但它绕开了对结果本身的检验:如果现在的结果确实在往一个方向偏,那这个偏移是谁造成的?这个问题在访谈里没有答案。
换个角度想会更清楚。一家餐厅的厨师全是素食主义者,这能说明餐厅的菜偏素,不能证明菜好吃。马斯克拿出证据支撑的是厨师成分,莱蒙质疑的是菜品口味。双方各自成立,只是站在不同的位置喊话。
搬家、广告商,和一句“宁可正确”
访谈之外,主持人补了几段背景。
马斯克此前公开说过不会把公司搬离加州,最后还是搬了,搬到了德州的巴斯特罗普(Bastrop),连奥斯汀都不是。这个细节有意思。他挑地方的依据,看起来偏重更低的监管密度和更少的舆论摩擦,城市资源反倒排在后面。
企业支持这块,主持人提到马斯克的立场是:宁可自己是对的,也不愿意依赖广告商。
这句话听着像骨气,翻译成商业语言其实是另一回事。X 的收入结构里广告占大头,公开跟广告主叫板的代价是实打实的收入下滑,这一点后来在估值上体现得很清楚。他愿意付这个代价,说明 X 在他眼里的价值,赚钱这件事大概排在很后面。
那价值在哪儿?看看下一集的预告就懂了。下一段访谈从一场看似平常的早餐会讲起:在朋友家里,他和特朗普吃了顿早饭。主持人说,那顿饭为马斯克此后进入华盛顿权力中心铺了路。
把这条线接上,X 的定位就清楚了。生意这层解释太薄,工具这个词更贴。
这场访谈真正的分歧在哪
回头看,双方其实没有在任何一个事实上正面冲突。10 倍、99%、4 小时视频、世界第一新闻来源,莱蒙一个都没有否认。他质疑的是这些事实拼出来的结论。
马斯克的推理链是这样的:旧推特由一群 99% 捐给民主党的人运营,所以它左倾;它压制右派 10 倍于压制左派,所以它不公平;我买下它、开放发言权限,所以现在的 X 更公平。
这条链的每一环单独看都站得住,整条链通向的结论未必成立。公平可以按程序定义(谁都能说话),也可以按结果定义(各种声音实际获得的传播量相当)。马斯克拿出证据支撑的是前者,莱蒙追问的始终是后者。
这也是为什么这场访谈在一年后还有重播价值。它把一个此后反复出现的争论固定成了文本:一个平台的所有者认为,只要不封号,广场就是开放的;一个记者认为,广场上谁被听见、谁被淹没,同样重要。
两种说法都有道理。区别在于,谁手里握着算法的开关。
顺带说一句,这场访谈本身的结局也提供了注脚。对话播出后没几天,X 取消了与莱蒙的内容合作协议。一个刚刚在镜头前说“数字城市广场属于所有人”的人,转头撤掉了对方在广场上的摊位。这个动作本身,比访谈里任何一句话都更有说服力。
落到你自己身上,有几件事可以立刻用起来
- 判断一个平台的政治倾向时,把“员工怎么想”和“用户看到什么”分开。前者用捐款、招聘、办公地点就能查,后者要看推荐流、封禁记录、流量分发。拿前者的证据去证明后者的结论,中间缺了最关键的一环。
- 遇到“某某平台偏左”或“某某平台偏右”的说法,先要一个可验证的指标:封禁比例、账号触达量、热门话题构成。指标和结论对得上再接受,对不上就先搁着。马斯克给的 10 倍和 99% 都是真数据,可它们回答的是另一个问题。
- 读这类长访谈时,留意提问者有没有把同一个问题问第二遍。莱蒙问了三遍“我说的是用户”,这三遍就是整场对话真正的裂缝所在。被绕开的追问,往往比被回答的部分更有信息量。
- 看一个平台的走向,功能清单比口水战靠谱。支持 4 小时视频、支持整本书的长文、把私信变成音视频通话,这些改动说明它在往“全能内容容器”走,短消息广场那条路已经走远了。产品动作透露的战略,比创始人发的推文准。
- 如果你在做内容或品牌,别把分发全押在一个平台上。一个决策者的一条指令就能改变你账号的命运,莱蒙的内容合作协议就是这么没的。至少留两条独立的触达渠道,邮件列表、私域、自建站点都算。
- 评价一个公共人物的表态,把“我看到的”和“我推断的”拆开记。马斯克在这场访谈里说的大部分属于前者,做结论时用的是后者。这个习惯对你自己写东西、做判断一样适用。
0:00hello everyone welcome to this very special anniversary edition of the Don Lemon show we're going to start this with my very first interview that kicked off the show okay so today we're going to revisit the what I believe is the most controversial impression interviews in recent memory U my conversation with Elon Musk a year ago I sat down with him at Tesla's massive Headquarters in Austin Texas and what followed was a conversation that not only raised eyebrows but foreshadowed many of the debates and the decisions that would come to Define musks trajectory now he was very candid about his views on Free Speech content moderation race and diversity and in the years since that
0:38interview musk has become one of the most powerful and polarizing figures on the planet from his controversial political statements to his growing influence over global discourse it's clear that musk's role in shaping our world has only intensified so this interview is going to be broken up into 10 pieces you can watch them at the top of every every hour today and then they'll live on on YouTube so we're going to look back at that conversation that sparked a global debate and it reshaped the way we view technology in media in our first segment we're going to dive into why I conducted this interview in the first place because of the growing dominance of far-right
1:14voices and conspiracy theorist on the xplatform now musk had promised to create a space for Free Speech but the platform was becoming increasingly hijacked by Voices that didn't represent the full spectrum of perspectives and I was cted public public by musk on Twitter and as a result I decided to join the platform to bring a more balanced voice to the conversation little did I know that following our interview that musk would cancel our content deal an unexpected move that ignited Global controversy set off headlines all over the world here's the interview listen we are here as part of a launch of a news interview show that is going to be on x.com it's coming
1:56as a media industry as you know is going through a whole lot of changes X is Al been affected by that where do you see xcom's role in the future of news and journalism Elon well I I think the I see the the X as it's it's already the number one source of news in the world so it is number one U the number one way that people actually are informed about any kind of news meaning realtime events is on the xplatform forly Twitter there's there's nothing even close for real-time news so we also want to expand upon that and we we have done so with long form content so instead of just doing what us to call tweets you can now do long form posts you can post an entire essay in
2:42fact you can now put an entire book post an entire book to the platform you can do long form video content so you can do up to 4-Hour video segments we really want news in whatever form it is or information I should say in whatever form it is to be available on our platform whether it's short long text pictures video whatever the case may be yeah and some of the stuff that we do long from video interview shows what have you you you reached out over the summer and you said it would be great to have MTO Don Lemon others on the left put on this platform you'll receive full support the digital Town Square is for all what do you mean by that I just mean that
3:27we want to make sure that there are a wide variety of viewpoints that it's you know we obviously have for example tuck cson who most people will view as being on the right and you know that's that's a quite quite a prominent name on the right we want to have prominent names on the left as well to provide different views of points of view as well as Centrist just basically a wide range of viewpoints on the platform so users can hear different opinions you they can hear you know is what's your point of view what's tu's point of view and make and you know and people can make their own decision about what they what they believe you didn't mean that I'm on the
4:08left did you think that I thought you were on the left but I don't know I'm used to well let's just say I don't know what the left is or the right is frankly these days because things can be quite polarized but you seem my impression was that you you're you're be more likely to be described as on the left than the right my my sense is you're sort of Center left I don't know you tell me well well did you ever watch me on CNN or did you watch I saw I saw SE yeah not I I've saw segments yeah but
4:38CNN is generally considered left yeah why do you say that why do I say CNN is generally considered left I think if if you look at any sort of media survey of what is on the left or right I think they would say like for example Fox is on the right and CNN is on the left yeah so that's what you think am I missing something here okay are you missing something I don't know I I think that would you would when I read that I said like many of my critics or detractors they never really watched me on CNN they just saw the clips of me either on social media or maybe on Fox news or conservative media where it's sort of a where I become a character or a
5:22caricature of what I actually am and it's taken out of context sure well how would you describe yourself I would describe myself as someone who is I I I am independent in my thinking and I vote for People based on the issues and how I feel about it not necessarily because of political leaning of some sort well I agree with that approach I think that's generally how how people should you know take things which is I mean there there are a whole sort of set of issues which are sort of somewhat arbitrarily bucketed into right or left but I think most I think most citizens would think that they would agree with some things on the left but not everything or agree on some things
6:02on the right but not everything so you know that's that's what I think most people feel I guess how much longer maybe maybe the answer is forever how much longer are we going to have to call it the formally known as Twitter I mean even Prince went back to prince instead of is it always going to be X it's definitely always going to be X but we've been say everyone says X formerly known as Twitter how long is that going to happen not not probably a year from now people won't bother yeah did you ever consider going back to Twitter because I know you've gotten you never considered that not at all it was always going to be X it always going to be X so
6:43acquisition company was literally called X yeah so X is going through some changes is said a lot of of media companies are going through some changes it's it you're in charge of an incredible platform Elon how do you feel that's going I think it's going pretty well so far we're seeing record usage we've added a tremendous amount of functionality I mentioned the that you know it used to be that you can only do short you know text and maybe a a picture or something like that short video but now you can do long form text long form video We've added audio video calling so you can not not just do text DMS you can do audio video calling we've improved the
7:23algorithm I think significantly and made the system faster and better and that's reflected in The increased usage so let's talk about that because you said you wanted all points of view right it's it's a digital Town Square for all it's the the the platform has kind of picked up where conservative media some conservative media is left off that moving to the right increasingly becoming part of a conservative dialogue sometimes even conspiracy theories right there was an article recently written about you saying that you Donald Trump and X were the most important people
7:56or places or whatever icons when it comes comes to the Maga movement do you agree with that how do you feel about that well I mean there are nonsense articles written all the time and I certainly wouldn't agree with that one I put in the nonsense category so the the the objective fact of the matter in my opinion was that old Twitter was fundamentally a a tool of the the far-left As and that was really I think a lot of it was due to being located in San Francisco brookley and so it wanted to essentially project the SF bookly political Dogma
8:32worldwide you think it was far left yes I do I I used to get I actually got off the platform because I would get so much hate tweets when it it was called in so much hate tweets and and just Guff from right-wing conspiracy theorists being called everything from you know to Sure you know the people will do I've been called every name times a thousand yeah so you you still you believe that it was left and I think yes do you agree that it much so do you do you agree that it's right now and that even it's moved into sort of magal land conspiracy theory I certainly don't think it's right the the old school Twitter suspended and suppressed accounts that You' call on the right 10
9:21times more than they did An accounts on the left and even when they did suspend even when they did suspend an account on the left it was because of arguments between two people in the left the political donations of old Twitter were 99% Democrat does that sound left righted left wiing or rightwing to you the Twitter donations yes you know when they look at donations by from a company if a company donates n literally 99% of all donations are to Democrats does that strike Who as a left leaning or a right leaning you mean the company donated I understand what you're saying people at the company but the people not the not the company the people at the company indiv individuals
9:58at the their donations were 99% to Democrats what about the people using the platform though that's what I'm talking about no I'm talking you're questioning whether was old Twitter left leaning and you seem that that seemed like a dubious thing to you and what I'm trying to tell you is that Twitter employees people at Twitter their political donations work 99% literally 99% to Democrats that's obviously an extremely left leaning group
10:30they speak they're speaking with their money in doing so but does that mean that the they were doing something wrong on the platform maybe they were running it in a way that was people appreciated and that was actually truthful no it's got nothing to do with with with whether they're doing something wrong or not we're just trying to you're you're wondering you seem skeptical that it was left leading I'm like yo 99% of the donations of people at Twitter were to the Democrats okay so that suggests obviously they're they're very left Le well I'm so you're talking about the people who ran the platform and the owners of the platform I understand owners people who work there I'm well
11:06people who work there I'm talking about people using the platform musk has taken X in a direction that he believes Champions Free Speech though there are critics who argue it has become an echo chamber for the right and the far right now despite saying that he wouldn't move the company to Texas he ultimately did not to Austin though but to bastra and when it comes to corporate support musk insists that he'd rather be right than relying on advert iers in part two of our conversation we're going to pick up with a seemingly unremarkable breakfast meeting with Donald Trump at a friend's house a meeting that set the stage for musk's rise to one of the most powerful
11:40positions in Washington Working alongside the president stay with us thanks everyone for watching your support means the world to us so make sure you hit the like button and you subscribe to our channel to make sure that you never ever miss a video we're live every day 10: a.m. eastern time we drop even more content at 2: p.m.
11:59Eastern and 5:00 p.m. Eastern and if you want more Don Lemon show content we'd love for you to become a member of the lemon Community where you will receive access to special Community posts you'll get exclusive content and members only live shows so head over to our Channel page or click the join button on this video again thank you for watching we appreciate your love and your support and we will see you next time
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版