美国建不成高铁。
原因不在技术,也不在钱。马斯克的说法很直白:在美国修高铁,从头到尾都是违法的。
这就是我们修不了高铁的原因。它在法律上被堵死了,六个方向全封住。(马斯克)
这句话听着像玩笑。但它背后站着一套完整的思路,来源是威尔·杜兰特和阿里尔·杜兰特(Will and Ariel Durant)夫妇写的那本薄书,《历史的教训》(The Lessons of History)。全书不到一百页,把文明怎么兴起、怎么烂掉,压缩成了一份提纲。
马斯克在 Lex Fridman 的播客里聊了很久这本书。他把书里的线索一条条捡起来,摆在自己熟悉的领域上:出生率、罗马、韩国、法规堆积,还有他愿意去华盛顿干的那份活儿。
历史有潮流,但风暴里要挑最好的船长
关于历史怎么被推动,学界有一场吵了几百年的架:历史是被那些底层的、巨大的潮流决定的,还是被某个站在船头的人决定的?
马斯克说,这问题本身问错了。
两种说法都对。确实有潮流,但谁当船长也很重要。所以这是个假的二分法。(马斯克)
潮流是真实存在的,而且大部分由技术驱动。他举的例子是古腾堡印刷机。书籍因为印刷术变得便宜、变得随处可见,这件事跟哪个国王在位没关系,它自己就掀翻了一整套秩序。宗教改革、识字率、科学革命,都挂在这条线上。
但潮流不解释一切。马斯克补了一句:到了风暴天,你会想要一个尽可能好的船长。
这句话把政治人物的作用说清楚了。他们没有能力凭空造出一条潮流,也没有能力取消一条潮流。他们能做的是在潮流拍过来的时候,把船开成什么样。风平浪静的年头,船长的水平差别不大;一旦进入颠簸水域,一个人的判断会放大成几代人的命运。
Lex 问他,政治家和政府到底有多大能力把人类带向好的方向。马斯克没有给一个百分比,他用船长的比喻回答了:权力的大小,取决于当时的海况。
文明只有 5500 年,是地球寿命的百万分之一
聊文明兴衰,先要给它定一个起点。马斯克的观点是:文明的起点是文字的发明。
没有文字,知识只能靠口耳相传,一代人死掉,积累就断一次。有了文字,前人的经验才能变成后人的起点。所以在他看来,文字比城市、比青铜器、比任何一件文物都更能标记那条线。
这条线划在约 5500 年前,发明者是苏美尔人。
苏美尔人已经不在了,但他们的"第一次"能列出一长串。杜兰特在书里几乎是用展示的方式在写这一段:你想看"第一"?好,全是他们的。马斯克的原话是,这些古代苏美尔人"真的很能打"。
有意思的是紧挨着的另一边。古埃及人就在隔壁,地理上不算远,却完全独立地发展出了另一套文字系统,象形文字。楔形文字和象形文字是两套毫不相干的东西。而且两套系统各自的演化路径都能看得清楚:楔形文字一开始非常简单,是图画式的记号,越往后越抽象、越复杂,到晚期已经精致到让人咋舌。
然后马斯克把时间尺度拉到另一个量级。
地球的年龄是 45 亿年。文明 5500 年。
算一下:5500 除以 45 亿,大约是八十一万分之一,也就是说,文明大约只占了地球存在时间的百万分之一。
文明只存在了地球寿命的百万分之一。一闪而过。(马斯克)
他说这话的时候,语气是轻的。但那个比例放在那儿,很多争论的分量会变。我们习惯把帝国的兴衰当成天大的事,因为在我们这个物种的记忆里,那确实是大事件。放到行星尺度,那只是一层薄薄的火光。
Lex 接了一句:所以现在还是极早期的极早期。马斯克同意:非常早期。
我们手里只有不到 1% 的历史
接着马斯克说了一件容易被忽略的事:历史上被写下来的东西,能留到今天的,大概不到 1%。
原因很物理。要想让文字穿过几千年,你必须把它刻进石头,或者压进泥板。写在纸莎草上的东西基本上都烂掉了,除非它恰好被封在金字塔深处,躲过了湿气。这种运气属于极少数。
而刻石头很费时间。所以能刻上去的内容,本身就经过了筛选:帝王的功业、神庙的账目、祭祀的规矩。普通人的日常、失败者的辩解、中间过程的犹豫,几乎全部消失。
这个事实有实际后果。我们拿着这 1% 去推断规律,很容易把幸存者偏差当成历史法则。杜兰特夫妇做的事情,是在这残存的样本里做横向比较,把不同文明放在一起看,找那些反复出现的模式。
即便样本这么少,模式还是明显得刺眼。一个文明接一个文明地兴起,又一个接一个地倒下。马斯克说,考古记录显示出来的东西,用"疯狂"来形容不算过分。
人性没有升级过
Lex 提到书里的另一个判断:我们总觉得自己和古人不一样,但人性似乎一直没变。
马斯克同意:人性的基本盘,几千年来差不多是同一套。
这意味着什么?同样的坑会被反复踩,哪怕手里的工具已经换了好几代。技术会升级,人的嫉妒、恐惧、贪婪、对地位的渴望、对陌生人的警惕,几乎没有版本迭代。
顺着这个思路,文明就更像有机体了。马斯克用的类比是从受精卵开始的:受精卵、胎儿、婴儿、幼儿、少年,最后衰老、死亡。
文明会走完一个生命周期。没有任何文明能永远存在。(马斯克)
所以帝国的兴衰不是异常事件,是常态。真正值得问的问题,不在于会不会衰落,而在于能不能把衰落往后推,或者推得更缓一些。
Lex 把问题抛给了当下:美国这个帝国,要做成什么样,才能在接下来的一百年里继续繁荣,而不是塌掉?
历史书里最常被跳过的那一行
马斯克的回答,先给了一个提醒:这件事在历史书里经常被跳过,但杜兰特写了。
出生率。
而且这里有一个反直觉的地方:一个文明赢了太久,出生率就会往下掉。掉起来可以很快。
这件事今天正在全球发生。韩国是最低的那一个,总和生育率在 0.7 到 0.8 之间,常年是全球最低。马斯克说的数字是 0.8 左右。
然后他做了一个推算:如果生育率不继续往下掉,就停在现在这个水平,韩国会失去大约 60% 的人口。
这个数是怎么来的?人口更替需要的水平是 2.1,也就是平均每个女性生育 2.1 个孩子,人口规模才能持平。0.8 大约只有它的三分之一多一点。每一代人过去,人口规模大约乘 0.38,也就是少掉六成左右。这不是某一个灾难预测,只是把一个数字按算术推下去。
更麻烦的是,韩国的这个数字每年还在往下走。而且这已经很难说是韩国独有的现象。
我不是要单独点韩国的名。这件事正在全世界发生。任何一个文明,一旦到达某个繁荣水平,出生率就会掉下来。(马斯克)
这句话里的因果关系值得停一下。繁荣是成功的结果,然后它反过来关掉了让繁荣得以继续的那个开关。马斯克没有解释心理机制,他只说了这个现象在数据上有多稳定。
罗马不是被打败的,是没人再生罗马人
这不是新问题。马斯克把时间拨回两千年前。
凯撒在公元前 50 年左右就注意到了罗马的生育率问题,试图推动立法,给愿意生第三个孩子的罗马公民一些实际好处。马斯克自己也不确定这次尝试有没有成功。
后来奥古斯都做到了。他是独裁者,元老院基本只是摆设,所以他推得动。给生三胎的罗马公民减税,这类激励确实是落地了。
结果是失败。
罗马还遭遇了别的东西,一连串疟疾流行,还有瘟疫。但马斯克强调:这些罗马以前也扛过。真正致命的是另一件事,出生率低于死亡率。
罗马亡于罗马人不再生产罗马人。这才是根本问题。(马斯克)
这句话短得像个口号,但它把一整段复杂叙事压缩成了一个比率。帝国的边界、军团的战力、税收的规模、道路和引水渠的维护,全部依赖人口。当分母开始缩小,其他所有变量都只是延缓,没有一个是解药。
Lex 追问:真就这么简单?
马斯克的回答是:在根本层面上,是的。
如果一个文明连自己的人数都维持不住,它就会消失。这是小学算术。(马斯克)
繁荣本身会关掉生育的开关
杜兰特夫妇翻了一个又一个文明的账本,看到的曲线高度一致:文明处在压力下的时候,出生率高;一旦外部敌人消失,或者进入一段长时间的繁荣,出生率必然下降。
马斯克说得很明确:他不认为存在例外。
这个机制有它别扭的地方。压力是一种不舒服的东西,人类花了整部文明史在摆脱它。摆脱成功之后,那种"必须把孩子生下来"的紧迫感也跟着消失了。生存的账从"多生孩子才能有劳动力、有养老、有兵源",变成了"多生孩子会稀释每个孩子的资源"。
于是人口这个变量开始往反方向走,而且是慢慢地、几乎不被察觉地走。没有任何一天你会看到崩塌,只是每一年的数字都低一点。
马斯克给出的底线很朴素:没有人类,就没有人类。
这话听起来像废话,但它确实是所有其他讨论的前提。在这个前提之上,才轮到第二层的东西:自由,让人能自由地去建造。
他也顺手划了另一条线:别打大仗。如果真的发生全球热核战争,那就没什么可讨论的了,大家在放射性废墟里一起完蛋。
性和孩子,被拆开的两件事
话题在这里拐了个弯。Lex 顺着"生物计算机"的说法调侃:也许这台机器分配给性的算力是合理的,甚至应该再加点。
马斯克的回应很干脆:亨乐式的性,无关紧要。
它不产生孩子。真正重要的是杜兰特说清楚的那件事。(马斯克)
这句话可以从机制上理解。生物层面,性这套系统的设计里本来就装着两个东西:一个驱动,一个结果。快感负责驱动,繁殖是结果。现代生活把这两者几乎完全解绑了:避孕手段、城市化、受教育年限延长、养育成本上升,驱动的那一半照常运转,结果的那一半被关掉了。
当一座城市里有一个亿的人都在这套新配置下生活,个体的选择完全合理,加总起来却是一个文明级别的转向。
这里没有谁做错了什么。每一个具体的人都在做对自己最划算的决定。问题在于,这些决定没有人在总量上负责。
一百万个绳结,和一亿根细线
文明的第二个慢性病,马斯克讲得更细:法律和法规会不断累积。
任何文明跑得够久,规则就会越堆越高。每一条新规出台时通常都有理由,为了应对某个具体问题。问题解决之后,规则不会自动消失。它就留在那里,成为后来者的成本。
如果没有某种强制机制把这些堆积清理掉,最终什么都做不了。历史上最常见的那个强制机制,是战争。战争会把一整套旧规则推倒,因为活下来比守规矩更要紧。这显然不是个好办法。
马斯克给了两个比喻。
一个是动脉硬化。血管不会某天突然堵死,是常年一点点沉积,最后血流过不去。
另一个他更喜欢:你像格列佛一样,被一百万根细线绑在地上。没有哪一根线是致命的,随便扯断哪一根都不解决问题。问题在于有百万根。
所以他说,社会需要一套针对法律和法规的"垃圾回收"(garbage collection)。
这个说法对写代码的人是秒懂的。程序跑久了,内存里会积攒大量已经不再使用的对象,如果没有人定期清理,可用内存越来越少,程序迟早卡住。现代语言大多自带垃圾回收器,自动做这件事。
法律系统没有垃圾回收器。它的规则只增不减,因为删除一条规则的收益是分散的,成本是集中的;保留一条规则的收益是集中的,成本是分散的。这套激励结构决定了堆积是默认结果。
高铁的例子就是结论。不是工程师不行,不是预算不够,是这条线要穿过的每一道审批、每一份环境评估、每一个土地征用环节,都有一票否决权。所有环节都对,加起来就是造不出来。
他真想去华盛顿干这件事
聊到这里,马斯克主动说了一件他此前在公开场合提过的事。
我和特朗普讨论过设立一个政府效率委员会的想法。我愿意成为这个委员会的一部分。(马斯克)
Lex 问:这有多难?
马斯克的回答没有绕弯:抗体反应会非常强烈。
然后他补了那句更有画面感的话:
到那个点上,你是在攻击矩阵。矩阵会反击。(马斯克)
"矩阵"这个词容易被理解成某个秘密组织。但放在这个语境里,它指的是另一回事:一整套靠现有规则运转的部门和流程。每一条法规背后都站着一个机构、一份预算、一群人的职业身份、一批依赖它生存的承包商。你要删掉的不是一行字,是某个人的整个世界。
所以清理法规的阻力从来不是"大家没想到",恰恰相反,是太多人想到了,并且每一个都有正当理由说明自己那条不能动。一百万个正当理由加在一起,就是一百万个绳结。
把这几条线摆在一起看
这场对话里马斯克讲的东西,其实可以列成一张很短的清单。
- 技术潮流推动历史。印刷机是模板,它不服从任何统治者。
- 但领导力在动荡期会放大。海况越差,船长的水平越重要。
- 文明有生命周期,没有例外。兴衰是常态,不是意外。
- 人口是底线条件。低于更替水平并且持续,结局在算术上已经写好。
- 法规会累积,需要定期清理,否则系统会因为自身重量而停摆。
- 别打核战争。这一条不满足,前面所有讨论都不成立。
这六条有一个共同点:它们都可以翻译成工程语言。输入、约束、熵增、维护周期。在他的模型里,文明是一个需要主动维护的系统,默认状态是衰减。没人维护的秩序不会保持原样,它会变慢、变重、变脆。
这也解释了他为什么反复强调"造东西"这件事。在他的判断里,一个社会能不能持续造出物理世界里真实存在的东西,是它是否还活着的体温计。法规堆积到造不出高铁,那不是某个项目的失败,是体温计给出的读数。
至于那 5500 年和 45 亿年的比例,它不是用来让人丧气的。马斯克更像是把它当成一个提醒:我们才刚起步,很多东西还没有定型,所以现在做的选择,权重比在一个成熟文明里要大得多。窗口还开着,但开的时间不会太长。
这套看法对普通人有用的部分
马斯克和 Lex 的这场聊天,信息密度不低,但它对日常生活的实用价值需要自己翻译一下。上面那些判断落到个人层面,能变成几个具体动作。
- 去读杜兰特夫妇的《历史的教训》。原书不到一百页,一个下午能读完,它把五千年文明史压成了一份提纲。读完再看新闻,很多事件的位置会自动变化。
- 记住 2.1 这个数字。它是人口更替线。以后看到任何地区的总和生育率,先跟 2.1 比一下,你就能大致推出二三十年后那里的学校、房子和养老金会是什么形状。这类判断不需要模型,只要会除法。
- 下次路过一个修了十年还没修完的工程,去查一下它需要过多少道审批。数出来的数字,就是那根绑住格列佛的细线的直径,也是你理解这类事情为什么总是慢的入口。
- 给自己所在的行业做一次"法规负债"盘点。列出那些因为历史原因存在、今天已经没有实际作用、但还在持续消耗人力的流程和审批。你会发现清单比你以为的长,然后挑一条尝试推掉它,亲身体验一下抗体反应有多强。
- 判断一项技术会不会真的改变世界,别只看它本身有多酷,看它有没有大幅降低信息或能量的成本。印刷机降低的是复制文字的成本,这条线索比任何一次政权更替都长。
- 把时间尺度往上调一档。文明 5500 年,地球 45 亿年。这个比例不解决任何具体问题,但它能让一部分焦虑失去分量,也能让另一部分事情显得更值得做。
0:02and we've gotta live within our means. - Do you think politicians, in general, politicians, governments, how much power do you think they have to steer humanity towards good? - I mean, there's a sort of age-old debate in history, like, is history determined by these fundamental tides?
0:25Or is it determined by the captain of the ship? Both really. I mean, there are tides, but it also matters who's captain of the ship. So it's a false dichotomy essentially. I mean, there are certainly tides, the tides of history. There are real tides of history. And these tides are often technologically-driven.
0:50If you say like the Gutenberg press, the widespread availability of books as a result of a printing press, that was a massive tide of history, and independent of any ruler. But in stormy times, you want the best possible captain of the ship. - Well, first of all, thank you for recommending Will and Ariel Durant's work.
1:17I've read the short one for now. - Oh, "The Lessons of History." - Lessons of History. And so one of the lessons, one of the things they highlight is the importance of technology. Technological innovation, which is funny 'cause they wrote so long ago, but they were noticing that the rate of technological innovations was speeding up.
1:40Yeah, I would love to see what they think about now. But yeah, to me, the question is how much government, how much politicians get in the way of technological innovation and building versus like help it and which politicians, which kind of policies help technological innovation?
1:58'Cause that seems to be, if you look at human history, that's an important component of empires rising and succeeding. - Yeah. Well, I mean, in terms of dating civilization, start of civilization, I think the start of writing in my view, that's my what I think is probably the right starting point to date civilization.
2:21And from that standpoint, civilization has been around for about 5,500 years when writing was invented by the ancient Sumerians who are gone now. But the ancient Sumerians, in terms of getting a lot of firsts, those ancient Sumerians really have a long list of firsts. It's pretty wild.
2:42In fact, Durant goes through the list of like, you wanna see first? We'll show you firsts. The Sumerians were just ass kickers. And then the Egyptians were right next door, relatively speaking. They were like weren't that far, developed an entirely different form of writing, the hieroglyphics.
3:02Cuneiform and hieroglyphic's totally different. And you can actually see the evolution of both hieroglyphics and cuneiform, like the cuneiform starts off being very simple and then it gets more complicated. And then towards the end, it's like, wow, okay. They really get very sophisticated with the cuneiform.
3:16So I think civilization is about 5,000 years old. And earth is, if physics is correct, four and a half million years old. So civilization has been around for 1000000th of earth's existence, flash in the pan. - Yeah, these are the early, early days. - Very early. - We make it very dramatic because there's been rises and falls of empires.
3:42- Many, so many rises and falls of empires. So many. - And there'll be many more. - Yeah, exactly. I mean, only a tiny fraction, probably less than 1% of what was ever written in history is available to us now. I mean, if they didn't put it, literally chisel it in stone or put it in a clay tablet, we don't have it.
4:03I mean, there's some small amount of like papyrus scrolls that were recovered that are thousands of years old, because they were deep inside a pyramid and weren't affected by moisture. But other than that, it's really gotta be in a clay tablet or chiseled. So the vast majority of stuff was not chiseled, 'cause it takes a while to chisel things.
4:27So that's why we've put tiny, tiny fraction of the information from history. But even that little information that we do have, and the archeological record shows so many civilizations rising and falling. It's wild. - We tend to think that we're somehow different from those people.
4:43One of the other things they do highlight is that human nature seems to be the same. It just persists. - Yeah. I mean, the basics of human nature are more or less the same. - Yeah, so we get ourselves in trouble in the same kinds of ways, I think, even with the advanced technology.
4:59- Yeah, I mean, you do tend to see the same patterns, similar patterns for civilizations where they go through a life cycle, like an organism, sort of just like a human is sort of a zygote, fetus, baby, toddler, teenager, and eventually gets old and dies. The civilizations go through a life cycle.
5:29No civilization will last forever. - What do you think it takes for the American empire to not collapse in the near term future in the next 100 years to continue flourishing? - Well, the single biggest thing that is often actually not mentioned in history books, but Durant does mention it is the birthright.
5:59So like a perhaps to some, like counterintuitive thing happens when civilizations are winning for too long. The birth rate declines. It can often decline quite rapidly. We're seeing that throughout the world today. Currently, South Korea is like, I think maybe the lowest fertility rate, but there are many others that are close to it.
6:29It's like 0.8, I think. If the birth rate doesn't decline further, South Korea will lose roughly 60% of its population. But every year, that birth rate is dropping. And this is true through most of the world. I don't mean to single out South Korea. It's been happening throughout the world.
6:49So as soon as any given civilization reaches a level of prosperity, the birth rate drops. And now you can go and look at the same thing happening in ancient Rome. So Julius Caesar took note of this, I think, around 50-ish BC and tried to pass, I don't know if he was successful, tried to pass a law to give an incentive for any Roman citizen that would have a third child.
7:20And I think Augustus was able to, well, he was the dictator so. (laughs) The Senate was just for show. I think he did pass a tax incentive for Roman citizens to have a third child. But those efforts were unsuccessful. Rome fell because the Romans stopped making Romans. That's actually the fundamental issue.
7:48And there were other things there. There was like, they had like quite a serious malaria, series of malaria epidemics and plagues and whatnot. But they had those before. It's just that the birth rate was fallower than the death rate. - It really is that simple? - Well, I'm saying that's- - More people is required.
8:09- That's at a fundamental level. If a civilization does not at least maintain its numbers, it'll disappear. - So perhaps the amount of compute that the biological computer allocates to sex is justified. In fact, we should probably increase it. - Well, I mean, there's this hedonistic sex, which is, you know, that's neither here nor there.
8:33- Yeah, it's not productive. - It doesn't produce kids. Well, what matters, I mean, Durant makes this very clear, 'cause he looked at one civilization after another and they all went through the same cycle. When the civilization was under stress, the birth rate was high. But as soon as there were no external enemies or they had a extended period of prosperity, the birth rate inevitably dropped every time.
9:00I don't believe there's a single exception. - So that's like the foundation of it. You need to have people. - Yeah. I mean, at base level. No humans, no humanity. - And then there's other things like human freedoms and just giving people the freedom to build stuff. - Yeah, absolutely.
9:24But at a basic level, if you do not at least maintain your numbers, if you're below replacement rate, and that trend continues, you will eventually disappear. This is elementary. Now then obviously, also wanna try to avoid like massive wars. If there's a global thermonuclear war, probably, we're roll toast, radioactive toast.
9:55So we wanna try to avoid those things. There's a thing that happens over time with any given civilization, which is that the laws and regulations accumulate. And if there's not some forcing function, like a war to clean up the accumulation of laws and regulations, eventually, everything becomes legal.
10:21And that's like the hardening of the arteries, or a way to think of it is like being tied down by a million little strings, like Gulliver. You can't move. And it's not like any one of those strings is the issue. You got a million of 'em. So there has to be a sort of a garbage collection
10:43for laws and regulations so that you don't keep accumulating laws and regulations to the point where you can't do anything. This is why we can't build a high-speed rail in America. It's illegal. That's the issue. It's illegal six ways to Sunday to build high-speed rail in America.
11:04- I wish you could just like, for a week, go into Washington and like be the head of the committee for making, what is it? For the garbage collection, making government smaller, like removing stuff. - I have discussed with Trump the idea of a government deficiency commission. - Nice, yeah.
11:22- And I would be willing to be part of that commission. - I wonder how hard that is. - The antibody reaction would be very strong. - [Lex] Yeah. - So you really have to, you're attacking the matrix at that point. Matrix will fight back.
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版