访谈·中文精读

马斯克的人类愿景|Real Talk with Zuby

Elon Musk's Vision For Humanity | Real Talk with Zuby

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

推特被收购之后,北美广告收入掉了一半以上,欧洲掉了四成。马斯克给这笔损失估了个价:每年大约20亿美元。

他把这笔钱叫作言论自由的成本。买回来的东西,是让所有人,包括你讨厌的人,都能把话说完。

2023年这场《Real Talk with Zuby》的访谈信息密度很高。他聊了买推特的真实动因、X想变成什么、人口崩溃为什么比气候变化更急、AI的坏结局长什么样、Neuralink会不会给大脑开后门,也聊了南非的童年、卖出去的第一款游戏,以及他为什么必须保持清醒。

下面按主题拆开,尽量保留他自己的论据和数字。

审查有明有暗,最阴的那种你根本看不见

买推特的动机,马斯克给了两条。

商业上,他从1990年代末就想做X,一个把金融和社交信息合在一起的系统。收购推特能让这个计划提前三到五年,比从零开始快得多。

另一条更重。他越来越担心公共讨论的空间在收缩,审查大量存在,一部分摆在明面上,一部分藏在暗处。

藏起来的那部分,他举了谷歌的例子。搜索引擎不需要删掉你,把结果往后推几页就够了。互联网上有个老笑话:最好的藏尸地点是谷歌搜索结果第二页,因为没人会去。

旧金山的政策会带来什么后果,证据就在眼前。把它放大到全球范围,如果你手里有一个覆盖全世界的巨型扩音器,它就成了一个向全人类广播的思想病毒扩音器。(马斯克)

他说这话时人正在旧金山。他用一种黑色幽默描述市中心:像《疯狂的麦克斯》和《行尸走肉》混在一起,有些街区连人都没有,那种空旷比有僵尸的地方更让人发凉。

访谈者Zuby补了一个观察。过去一年他跑了美国、英国、澳大利亚,在所有这些号称自由民主的国家,普通人对表达观点怕得要命。更微妙的一点是,很多人真正害怕的,是对手有了说话的权利。右翼尤其是这样,他们不怕自己被审查,怕的是对方的言论被放开。

马斯克的回应很直接:这些人该照照镜子,问问自己到底在要求什么。他们想要的,是让公众被误导、被蒙在鼓里,哪怕那些信息完全合法。

他反复引用第一修正案的内在逻辑。今天你剥夺不喜欢的人说话的权利,这把刀早晚会落到你自己脖子上。判断言论自由有没有在工作,信号很简单:你能听到自己讨厌的人,说出自己讨厌的话,这就是它在正常运转。

推特内部藏着一套谁也不认识的评分系统

收购之后,马斯克做的第一件大事是把推荐算法开源。他的说法是,其他社交平台全是黑箱,你不知道里面发生了什么,推特现在把代码摊在阳光下。

开源之后,团队还在不断挖出旧代码里不认识的东西。访谈里他提到,就在那一周,他们发现一个隐藏模块:每个账号都有一个声誉分数,某个账号一旦开始进入热门趋势榜,系统就会把它从榜单上删掉。

他自己就在被排除的名单里。

这套逻辑简单粗暴,看你被举报了多少次。粉丝越多越容易被盯上,只要一批机器人或者活动人士集中举报,就能用假举报把账号打到瘫痪,系统判定你被举报太多,趋势榜从此与你无缘。

他们正在做的,是给每个用户加可见性标签:有没有被搜索屏蔽、有没有被限流、账号上有没有什么东西在暗中拖后腿。目标是让用户不必相信马斯克的承诺,直接去看算法本身。理论上,独立第三方应该能复现你在推特上看到的推荐结果。

关于各国法律,他承认现实约束。大多数国家的言论限制比美国严,推特在当地只有两个选项:遵守,或者被切断。不遵守的后果是员工被逮捕、公司被罚、然后被赶出去。他说推特能做到的,是在合法范围内把审查降到最低。

X想当的是全球金融的实时数据库

很多人把X理解成推特改了个名字,马斯克的设想要大得多。

他讲了一段很技术的话。今天的金融系统大部分还跑在大型机上,很多代码是几十年前写的COBOL,大量业务还停留在批处理。整套系统又慢又不安全,塞满了异构的复杂数据库。银行大楼、分行、ATM,这些物理设施正在变得多余。

如果有一个实时的、同构的数据库,专门处理钱这种信息,效率会高出一个量级,欺诈更少,成本更低。

从信息论的角度看,X要成为关于钱这件事最有效的数据库。如果做对了,它满足人们金融需求的程度,会让它随着时间占到全球金融系统的一半左右。(马斯克)

他没给出精确数字,只说会是相当大的一个比例。

社交媒体那一半,本质也是信息交换,只不过交换的是文字、视频、图片、语音。两件事合起来,做一个应用接住你生活里几乎所有需要信息流转的需求:想做什么就在X上做,不想做就轻松离开去别处。

路线图上已经排了支付、私信全加密、视频和语音通话。他说支付可能在2023年晚些时候推出。

媒体做的是点击生意,真相排在后面

访谈绕不开主流媒体对马斯克的批评。

他的解释不带情绪。媒体的第一目标是点击最大化,真相最大化只是附加项。这是一场达尔文式的筛选:不追点击的媒体拿不到流量,拿不到流量就没有广告收入,然后公司倒闭。整套数据结构是为点击优化的。

真相通常无聊而且复杂。媒体给你的,是戏剧化的简写版本,比现实更辣、更有冲突感,因为必须有争议才有点击。

传统媒体还被另一件事挤压。谷歌和Facebook把广告收入的大头拿走了,报纸电视台的日子一年比一年难过,只能更拼命地追点击。他的判断是,它们被逼成了点击机器,不改就死。

后果之一是讽刺和现实的边界越来越模糊。他举了个例子:有文章把健身跟法西斯主义、白人至上扯在一起。他的反应是,健身就是为了健康和感觉良好,这有什么好说的。

出生率:被忽视的文明级危机

这是整场访谈里马斯克投入最多的话题。

他的起点是一组公开数据。日本2022年的死亡人数是出生人数的两倍。每一个西方国家都低于更替生育率。城市化、教育程度提高,都会压低生育率,这条曲线正在向全球扩散。

他描述的终局相当刻薄:

文明不会在一场爆炸里结束,它会在呜咽里结束,穿着成人纸尿裤。结局惨淡得不像话。(马斯克)

他把人口过剩这个流行观念直接称为一场大规模心理战。

这套观念从哪来?他给了一条演化路径。环保运动起步是好的,核心诉求也正确:人类必须转向可持续能源,否则文明迟早熄火。可这场运动走到极端,就得出了一个结论:人类是地球的瘟疫,人类本身就是问题。

他用一个比喻形容这种极端化:环保主义长成了一颗嵌甲,本来是为了保护脚趾,结果越长越往肉里钻。

他提到《纽约时报》几个月前的一篇头版文章,受访者的原话是:地球上有80亿人,一个都没有会更好。马斯克的回应是,这位先生可以自己先做个表率。

这类观点他称为灭绝主义,并且明确说,让这种哲学进入AI的训练数据极其危险。

人类不是地球的瘟疫

关于地球装不下这么多人的直觉,他给了一个具体计算,来自作家Tim Urban:把全人类肩并肩挤在一起,能塞进纽约市的一层楼里。

这个数字有点极端,但意思很清楚:人类的横截面积很小。你觉得人多,是因为你住在伦敦或者纽约。坐飞机横跨美国或者飞国际航线,窗外大部分时间是空的。从洛杉矶飞纽约,你想往某个人头上扔个球都很难扔中。

关于气候变化,他的立场是长期问题,短期不是紧急状态。

逻辑链条是这样的。真正的环境问题在于,人类把埋在地下几亿年的碳,以液体、气体、固体的形式挖出来烧掉,排进大气和海洋。这会改变海洋和大气的化学组成,持续足够久,气候确实会变。

但地球很大,人类很小,这个过程非常慢。他反对的是为了这件事去禁止农业、禁止养牛,那点排放在全局里连小土豆都算不上。

他还补了一句安慰。地球历史上经历过更大的灾难,巨型陨石撞击、超级火山、大陆漂移、全球雪球期、极端高温,生命都挺过来了。气候变化威胁的是人类这种生物的栖居方式,地球上的生命本身没事。恐龙没挺过那次撞击,但它们也活了一亿多年,跑得够久了。

Zuby提了一个更尖锐的角度。西方先爬上梯子,然后把梯子抽走。发展中国家的人还没吃饱,你让他先关心碳排放?这就是经济学家Rob Henderson说的奢侈品信念,只有过上好日子的人才负担得起这种想法。

马斯克部分同意,但补了一个乐观视角。可持续能源的成本在快速下降,风能加太阳能加电池,在很多地方已经比化石能源便宜。这套系统还能分布式部署,一家一户屋顶上装太阳能加电池,工厂自己发电,不用拉高压线。很多发展中国家直接跳过了固网电话进入手机时代,电力也可能跳过集中式电网。

怎么让人愿意生孩子:让为人父母变酷

Zuby提到一个现实。他认识的很多二三十岁的年轻人,觉得生孩子这件事非常可怕。没钱、买不起房、背着一身债,连自己都快养不活。

马斯克承认激励结构在很多国家是反着来的,养孩子确实贵。可他马上指出一个反直觉的数据:收入越高的人生得越少,收入和孩子数量呈负相关。养不起所以不生这个解释站不住脚,至少不是全部原因。

他的答案落在文化层面:为人父母这件事需要重新变酷。

没有什么比生孩子更能提升你的幸福感。我们被进化编程成了这样。假如养孩子在本能上不是有回报的,人类根本不会生孩子。(马斯克)

他打了个猫的比方。一只野猫可能很凶,见什么挠什么,一旦生下小猫,立刻变成温柔的妈妈,照顾幼崽是刻在基因里的程序。人类也一样。

有人担心孩子会毁掉自己的生活、夺走自由和乐趣。他的判断是,这种恐惧没有根据,有了孩子之后生活质量会提高,不会下降。

他自己有十几个孩子。Zuby问他当父亲对做事的动机有什么影响,他说这让他更想把未来的世界弄好,给孩子们留一个值得生活的世界。

他顺带纠正了一个常见误解。有人夸他关心文明很无私,他说不对,哪怕一个人极度自私,也应该关心文明,因为人没法脱离文明活着。想知道没有文明是什么样,去看荒野求生类节目就够了。监狱里最重的惩罚之一是单独监禁,监狱里其他犯人未必好相处,可人还是宁愿跟他们待在一起,不愿意一个人待着。

他讲了个儿子Saxon的故事。Saxon有自闭症,但常常一语中的。有很长一段时间,马斯克每周带全家去餐馆吃饭,Saxon不理解为什么要出门,食物叫外卖能送到,朋友叫到家里也行。后来他想通了,说:哦,人们去餐馆是为了跟陌生人待在一起。

马斯克说,对,就是这样。你在餐馆能得到、在别处得不到的唯一东西,就是跟陌生人共处。人类比自己以为的更爱人类。

一支黑暗里的蜡烛

Zuby问,驱动你做这一切的底层动机是什么。

马斯克的回答很抽象,逻辑却完整。他把自己这套想法称为好奇心哲学,最准确的表达在道格拉斯·亚当斯的《银河系漫游指南》里:超级计算机算出了终极答案是42,真正难的是搞清楚问题本身是什么。

他想做的,是把意识的规模和范围扩大,让文明有能力更好地理解宇宙的本质。我们从哪来、往哪去、这一切终点在哪、什么是真实的。

外星人的问题他给了一个有趣的转折。他深度参与航天,至今没见过任何外星生命的确凿证据。真出现了,他会立刻赶过去看,希望对方友善。能跨越星际来到这里的文明,技术水平会远超人类,我们在他们面前是原始人。

可他说,如果宇宙里真的没有外星人,反而更让人担忧。

如果附近没有外星人,地球上这点意识就是广袤黑暗里的一支小蜡烛,而且很脆弱。我们应该尽一切努力,别让它熄灭。(马斯克)

这就是他推多行星物种的哲学底子。太阳会膨胀,地球可能5亿年后就不再宜居。5亿年听着很久,可地球已经存在45亿年,这只占寿命的10%左右。文明从最早的文字算起只有5000多年,是地球历史的百万分之一。人类在地质尺度上只是一闪。

所以要向外走。先火星,再整个太阳系,最终到其他恒星系。

他用阿波罗登月做类比。当年那句「为全人类」,让所有人都为自己是人类而自豪。我们需要这种让人早上愿意起床的、集体性的、鼓舞人心的目标。哪怕大部分人自己不去,也能通过去的人间接体验到。

Zuby接了一句:现在很多人对自己是人类这件事并不自豪,反倒觉得羞耻。马斯克同意,并且把它和生育率连了起来。对未来悲观的人不会生孩子,接着就是文明衰退。

AI:最大的威胁,也是最大的希望

问到人类面临的最大威胁,马斯克的答案毫不犹豫:数字超级智能。

他的判断分两层。好结果比坏结果更可能,AI大概率会改善生活。坏结果的概率不是零,而人类越担心坏结果,它发生的概率就越低。

最极端的坏结局是人类被消灭。次一级的坏结局,人类没被消灭,但被限制在类似黑猩猩和大猩猩的处境里:活着,数量不多,被安置在地球的一小块区域,主导物种不去打扰它们,也不优先考虑它们。它们不会灭绝,也永远不会扩张。

还有一种结局,AI不杀光人类,只留下足够多的人,就像我们研究黑猩猩一样研究我们。出于好奇。这对人类来说仍然算不上好结果。(马斯克)

好的AI长什么样?他推荐伊恩·班克斯的《文化》系列小说,说那是他见过最好的「AI与人类正面未来」的呈现。在他的设想里,AI是放大器,把人类能力放大若干倍,像当年计算机做到的那样。

真正的风险在于,AI只放大人类,还是开始自己掌舵。还有一种更阴的风险:灭绝主义哲学进了AI的训练数据,AI可能真的得出「人类是地球的瘟疫」这个结论,然后按这个结论行动。

他在这点上立场鲜明。

我是人类至上主义者,这一点我可以公开说。我们得为人类这一队而战。(马斯克)

AI对工作的冲击,他承认会很剧烈。很多现在存在的岗位会消失,也会出现新岗位。在良性AI情景下,人类会进入一个富足时代:只要不是人为制造稀缺的东西,比如某位艺术家的特制作品、某个特定街区的某栋房子,其他一切商品和服务都会变得极其充沛。

富足本身会带来新问题。他举了两个「听着像祝福其实是诅咒」的例子。永生是诅咒,你不知道永恒有多长。想要什么就有什么也是诅咒,到了那个地步,还有什么事情是有意义的?

工作带来的不只是钱。赚到1000万美元和中了1000万美元彩票,是两种完全不同的体验。前者是你创造了产品和服务、帮到别人换来的,后者是天上掉下来的。意义感来自前者。富足时代最难处理的,就是人怎么找到意义。

Neuralink:你早就是赛博格了

Zuby半开玩笑提到很多人对Neuralink的担忧:往大脑里放芯片,控制你的思想。马斯克接梗说,欢迎排队,谁想要一个。

正经的回答是这样。任何植入人体的设备,监管流程都极长,不可能一夜之间扑上来。要经过大量测试,一批一批人做,走FDA审批,Neuralink在安全标准上做得比FDA要求的还多。

第一款产品的目标很基础:恢复功能。给四肢瘫痪、渐冻症这类大脑和身体之间连接中断的人,重新建立通道。如果霍金能像身体健全的人一样快速交流,这件事本身就值得做。

第二款产品是恢复视力。即使视神经完全断了,也可以直接刺激视觉皮层的神经元,把图像送进大脑。摄像头选什么,你就能看到什么波段,红外、紫外、雷达,理论上都能接入。

长期目标是让生物智能和数字智能共生。他有个观察:人类早就是赛博格了。手机、电脑是自我的延伸,你把手机落在家里,会有类似幻肢痛的感觉。

问题在带宽。人的输入带宽极宽,光靠视觉,每秒输入的信息量是输出(打字、说话)的几万到上百万倍。Neuralink想解决的,就是把输出带宽提上来,让人和AI的接口更顺畅。

他打了个三层大脑的比方。最底层是爬行动物脑,管本能;上面是皮层,管理性、规划。皮层比爬行动物脑聪明得多,可皮层大部分时间干的事,是哄爬行动物脑开心。饿了去找吃的,有性冲动去找伴侣。人类花在「试图搞定性这件事」上的算力是惊人的,因为对绝大部分人类历史来说,性就等于繁殖,边缘系统被编程成追求它。

AI是第三层。这层会不会跟人类利益冲突,取决于它跟生物智能绑得有多紧。绑得紧,它大概也会像皮层服务边缘系统一样,服务皮层。

关于「以后不用Neuralink就没法正常生活」的担忧,他承认有可能,但那是几十年后的事。眼下的优先级他排得很清楚:先担心数字超级智能,先想办法避免第三次世界大战,先保证出生率别跌穿。

从比勒陀利亚到硅谷

Zuby提到几个月前第一次去南非,约翰内斯堡、开普敦。马斯克纠正:他主要住在约翰内斯堡和比勒陀利亚,在德班待过两年,开普敦去过几次没长住。

童年的评价很简短:大部分时间不快乐,不算100%糟糕,但相当艰难。他17岁离开南非,通过母亲拿到加拿大国籍,母亲出生在加拿大。

他说自己对南非的看法被一段负面经历打了烙印。他用了一个双关:字面意义上的伤疤,他身上有不少。

第一款游戏叫Blastar。他从小爱玩电脑游戏,那时候的游戏极其原始。10岁左右看到第一台电脑,Commodore VIC-20,内存8K,他觉得这是有史以来最好的东西。买了本编程书自学,从VIC-20玩到Spectrum(48K,在当时感觉很先进),一路写程序。市面上的游戏太少,他就自己写,画面、音乐全部自己搞。11岁那年把Blastar卖了,钱不多,一个孩子拿到那笔钱算巨款。

后来他还在帕洛阿尔托一家叫Rocket Science的游戏公司短暂工作过,跟火箭没关系,就是游戏公司。从10岁到30岁,他写软件写了差不多20年。

他还认真打过《雷神之锤》(Quake),进了全美最好的队伍之一。那场比赛他认为是美国最早的有奖电竞比赛之一。队伍一度领先,队里最强的那个人电脑中途崩了,最后拿了第二。奖金几千美元,在当时算不错。

读研时他本来打算做电动车储能技术,斯坦福的博士项目已经录取。1995年互联网正在起飞,他判断电动车技术会继续进步,自己以后能回来做,互联网这个窗口错过就没了,于是休学创业。

人类长出了一副神经系统

他对互联网的第一印象,用一个比喻概括:人类正在长出一副神经系统。

在此之前,信息从一个人传到另一个人,要么见面,要么打电话,要么有人拿着信跑一趟。想看书只能去图书馆,而大多数图书馆只有人类书籍总量的极小一部分。你的信息获取极其有限、极其慢。

有了互联网,哪怕你在最偏远的地方,只要能上网,人类全部的知识都在你面前。从几乎靠渗透、靠直接接触传递信息,跃迁到所有人都能访问全部信息。

他说这个平等化进程被严重低估了。麻省理工的课程在YouTube上免费,有网络连接的人可以在任何领域成为专家。印刷术之前,书要手抄,拥有书近乎拥有圣物,识字的人极少,有书的人藏书也不多。就算是英格兰国王,他的图书馆放到今天也不值一提。

普通人今天能接触到的信息,超过1980年地球上最有权势的人。这距离现在才四十多年。

幸福等于现实减期望

Zuby抛出一个矛盾:既然生活比历史上任何时候都好,为什么很多人不快乐。

马斯克的答案是期望校准。人的期望不断往上调,目标线一直在移动。幸福感等于现实减去期望值,期望每年都在涨,现实就得跟着涨才能维持同样的幸福。这是人性,改不掉。

他建议人多读历史。他提到一个讲早期航海史的播客,船员大量死于坏血病,因为当时没人知道维生素C是什么。读历史会发现,瘟疫来了整座城市死掉三分之一是常态。

细菌致病论被确立才不到150年。在那之前,医学界主流反对洗手,官方口径是病菌不存在,医生是干净的。你告诉一个19世纪的人,手上有些看不见的小生物会让你生病,这在当时听起来就像巫术。抗生素要到20世纪才被发现,一战时大量士兵死在伤口感染上,子弹反而排在后面。

他引用拿破仑时代的一句估算:每个法国女人要生六个孩子,两个死于分娩,两个死于战争,剩下两个才能延续种族。这个说法不完全准确,离现实不远。

Zuby感慨:今天我们习以为常的事,一百年后的人回头看,会想不通我们怎么什么都不知道。马斯克同意,但把话题拉回寿命。人类自然寿命大概就在80岁左右,女性普遍比男性活得长,部分原因是男性只有一条X染色体,没有冗余备份,加上睾酮的影响,还有男性干的蠢事更多。

他顺带提了一个数据:出生时男婴比女婴略多,51比49。男性在每一个年龄段的死亡率都更高,大自然用出生比例做了对冲。

保持清醒的方法,是让物理来当裁判

访谈快结束时,Zuby问了一个很真诚的问题:你被这么多人赞美、批评、爱、恨,怎么保持清醒。

马斯克借了电影《疤面煞星》的梗:别被自己的货嗨到。人一旦觉得自己太聪明,就会停止听批评,反馈回路就断了。推特在这件事上帮了大忙,你随便说点什么,一群只有20个粉丝的人立刻来纠正你。

更根本的约束是物理。他有句话说得干脆:物理是法律,其他都是建议。

火箭造错了就会爆炸,车造错了就跑不起来。物理是个严厉的法官。你要么把工程和数学搞对,要么它就不工作。所以你必须保持脚踏实地,技术才真的能成。(马斯克)

Zuby最后当面表达了感谢。很多人因为推特恢复了账号、能重新自由说话,他想代表这些人说一声谢谢。马斯克的回应很简单:谢谢,很感激。

这场访谈真正值得带走的东西

两个多小时聊下来,他的观点可以压成几条相互咬合的判断。

言论自由有价格,他给了具体数字:每年20亿美元。这笔钱他愿意付,因为一旦允许审查你不喜欢的声音,审查迟早转向你自己。开源算法、给每个账号加可见性标签、允许第三方复现推荐结果,这些做法让「相信我们」变成「你自己看」。

人口崩溃是他认为被严重低估的危机。日本一年死亡人数是出生的两倍,每个西方国家都低于更替生育率,城市化会把这个趋势推向全球。他把人口过剩称为一场心理战,认为极端环保主义滑向「人类是瘟疫」的结论很危险,让这种哲学进入AI训练数据更危险。

AI是最大的变量。好结果比坏结果更可能,坏结果的概率不为零,越担心它,它越不容易发生。他推荐的正面想象是伊恩·班克斯的《文化》系列,反面场景是人类变成黑猩猩:活着,被限制在保护区里。

Neuralink没那么可怕,节奏会很慢,先解决瘫痪和失明,长期才谈人机共生。人类早就是赛博格,手机是外挂的大脑,Neuralink想解决的是输出带宽。

他的个人动力来自一套好奇心哲学:扩大意识的规模和范围,让人类成为多行星物种。如果宇宙里没有其他生命,地球上这点意识就是黑暗里一支脆弱的蜡烛,值得不惜代价保护。

把可操作的部分拎出来,大概是这样几件事:

  • 读一读伊恩·班克斯的《文化》系列。它是理解「AI与人类正面共存」最直观的思想实验,比读十篇AI风险报告更能建立具体想象。
  • 对任何「某群体天生该被消音」的论调保持警惕,不管它来自哪个方向。今天被消音的是你不喜欢的人,明天可能换成你。第一修正案的核心逻辑就在这里,也是马斯克每年花20亿美元在买的东西。
  • 看到耸动的新闻标题先停三秒,问一句:这条内容在最大化真相,还是在最大化点击。媒体的激励结构决定了它给你的通常是戏剧化的简写版本。
  • 如果你正在犹豫要不要孩子,把「养不起」这个理由单独拿出来审一遍。收入和孩子数量呈负相关,这个理由在很多情况下站不住。真正影响决策的往往是文化叙事,而那个叙事可能是错的。
  • 把物理当作判断事情的锚。一个方案在工程和数学上成不成立,可以被检验,其他争论都只是建议。这条对不同行业都适用:找到你所在领域那个不会说谎的裁判。
  • 读历史。坏血病、细菌致病论、分娩死亡率、战争死亡率,两百年前都是日常。读懂了,你对当下生活的基线判断会完全不一样。幸福感等于现实减期望,调整期望那一端,比调整现实容易得多。
  • 如果对AI焦虑,把焦虑转成具体问题:AI的训练数据里带了什么价值观,谁在决定这些价值观。这比笼统地害怕「AI觉醒」有用得多。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:01what was the biggest impetus to buying Twitter I grew I was growing increasingly concerned that there was a lack of freedom of speech and freedom of expression there was a lot of censorship and a lot of censorship with some of it was obvious a lot of it was hidden the average person is terrified effectively what they're saying is they want the public to be misled and uninformed I mean the media is going to give you generally the dramatized Cliff Notes version of reality I'll be honest of all the things you do and all the companies you run the one thing that does concern me and I know concerns a lot of people out there so I do have to bring it up

0:31which is neuralink we put a chip in your brain to control your mind yeah okay all right concerns not alleviated yeah Jump Right In step right up who wants one it's not every day you get to talk to a Visionary like Elon Musk I'm lucky to be able to learn from him on the podcast and off air when the cameras are off people feel more comfortable sharing their personal strategies Millionaires and billionaires invest in assets to counter inflation in Crazy Market swings Elon himself has previously talked about the little-known power of physical assets real tangible Investments that can hold their value during a crisis but the real story a group of everyday

1:14investors have already seen net returns of 10 13 and even 32 percent and they didn't need Millions because they used Masterworks art investing platform so far Masterworks has sold over 45 million dollars worth of luxury art handing the net proceeds right back to investors like us every Masterwork sales so far has delivered a return and users have already invested over half a billion dollars with them offerings can sell out in minutes but zubi listeners can skip the waitlist by going to masterworks.com and entering the promo code zubi Zuby in the how did you hear about usbox that's masterworks.com and use the promo code zubi see important disclosures at

1:54masterworks.com CD what's up ladies and gentlemen boys and girls around the world I would like to welcome you back to the real talk with zooby podcast today's episode this is a glorious day this is a magical episode we have got on a legendary guest without further Ado the one and only Elon Musk welcome welcome to the show man thank you so good to have you on so good to meet you yeah likewise it's amazing person I've interact a lot we've interacted a lot online but it's nice to be in present absolutely first things first man how how are you doing pretty good I mean it's got a lot going on obviously so I I just actually just got in from straw base Texas and we're building

2:36the Starship rocket so getting ready for another launch hopefully get to orbit this time probably be ready in about six to eight weeks that's awesome that's awesome first question I have to ask of course is just how do you manage this all man you do so many things and yeah just managing a single one of the companies that you do is a gargantuan task so how

3:02do you even manage all this on a day-to-day basis I mean with great difficulty I mean I work a lot and I have to say the last six months I've been extra difficult because of the Twitter workload I think things are reasonably stable at Twitter at this point obviously Linda yacrino's joined and I think she'll be a big help and so I'll still be spending a fair bit of time at Twitter but it won't be occupying as much time and you know that now that we're sort of financially more or less stable it's not like an emergency situation but we still want to rapidly improve the product especially on the video side and there's a lot of great things that are

3:47going to come out obviously payments down the road maybe later this year and improving the direct message stuff obviously enabling full encryption and video and voice calls I just basically solving like basically if there's something you want to do you can do it on the sort of you know X everything app or you can leave easily and do it somewhere else so you brought up x x is something that you've been having in mind for a long time tell me tell me 20 years yeah tell me the story about xx.com well I mean way back in the day the idea was for X or x.com to be an all-income thing

4:38in that financial services company or I thought kind of in like a infinite information Theory way to be a to be the most efficient database for the information that is money the way that money currently works is from a practical standpoint it's still mostly run on mainframes you know that's still a thing for banks it's mostly written in Cobalt it's still mostly batch processing so actually the financial system is very slow it's not secure you've got all these heterogeneous complex databases so if you have a real-time homogeneous database that is just like

5:23fundamentally more more efficient and doesn't have all the expenses of Bank buildings all over the place and Bank branches and ATMs which are increasingly kind of redundant it can operate way more efficiently and so essentially if if Done Right the X would be would serve people's financial needs to such a degree that over time it would become I don't know maybe half of the Global Financial system wow or some big number I'm not sure what the number is but pretty big so it would be by far the biggest sort of financial institution but like I

6:06said not not really in the way that people are used to thinking about Banks just just the most efficient database for the thing that is money I said like at least amount of fraud everything's real time and if it involves money in any way it can be dealt with seamlessly on one one location and then in addition you've got the sort of social media element which is also information it's people sharing information of various kinds whether it's text video pictures voice and and and so okay so both money and and what we call social media really information exchange and I think there's a potential there to make a product that is really quite compelling like combines all these

7:00things simplifies people's lives is more you know cost efficient for the average person so you know you don't have a minimum number of fees and whatnot so so I think this there's just a lot of a lot of potential to create some like the kind of the ultimate app or system website whatever I hear that and so with the long-term goal be for Twitter to evolve into X over time so it

7:30would just be fully integrated yeah I mean I said at the time of the acquisition like I I could do this independently and create it from scratch or what I thought was acquiring Twitter would probably accelerate progress by three or four years maybe five years I hear that what was the biggest impetus to buying Twitter what was the what was the thing that made you want to do that well like so there is a sort of you know for a long time I want to do sort of the for createx export and so that's that's one element of it I also thought that I grew I was growing increasingly concerned that there was a lack of freedom of speech and freedom of expression

8:13and that the there was a lot of censorship and a lot of censorship with some of it was obvious larva was hidden yeah and I thought that's really that was really unhelpful and unhealthy for public discourse you know so how are people say in America in a democracy supposed to make the right decision if they don't have the right information you know if they're being misled or important information has been withheld which obviously was the case you know in the infamous you know 100 by the laptop situation everyone knows about that but there are there are thousands of other smaller situations like that so effectively Twitter and frankly Google and YouTube and whatnot Facebook

8:54I mean they put their thumb on the scale of Elections worldwide and they have done for some time so and a lot of times it's so subtle you don't even really notice it frankly Googles might be the most pernicious in that it's very easy for them to to slightly de-rank a search so it's on page like four or five like if for if you're looking for something and nobody ever goes there so it's not gone it's just not on page one yeah and

9:23you know the old joke used to be that what's the best place to hide a dead body would be the second place second page of Google search results and nobody who goes there yeah so so I think for in order to have a solid Bedrock for democracy and frankly even if the country's not strictly speaking democracy it's still good for the people to know what's going on yeah we have to have at least one platform that you can count on that is maximum truth seeking and and that's what the goal is here with with X Twitter is maximum truth seeking really allowing voice of voices to be heard I mean unless someone's doing something like just flat out illegal then they should be allowed to say

10:10what they want to say and free speech is only relevant if it's if if we allow people that you don't like to say things you don't like otherwise it loses all meaning and at least in the US like the the first amendment is is pointless so and if you don't let people you don't like say things that they don't like and you censor them it's only a matter of time before that census sense of that censorship is turned upon you yeah you know so that was the essential wisdom in the First Amendment and and so you can kind of tell that it's working if you see people that you don't like saying you don't like that's a good sign actually yeah you know something

10:51I've noticed traveling all around the world and especially I mean recently I've been to all over the US of course spent time in the UK I went to Australia recently and it seems like in all these countries you know the these Western Nations that are supposed to be you know so-called liberal democracies people are supposed to be able to speak freely and so on the average person is terrified to speak their mind it seems that the concept of freedom of speech has really been pushed to the side and marginalized it's not it's something that is supposed to be a Bedrock of our societies and Nations and cultures but something I found incredibly interesting for example when

11:31you bought Twitter was that people were not afraid that they would be censored but they were afraid that their opposition yeah especially people more on the right side I mean I would not be censored they were afraid of the freedom of speech aspect so how did we get there I mean I think that people like like that should really look at themselves in the mirror and say like what are you actually asking here you want censorship you want things to be you want information to be withheld from the public even though it's totally legal you effectively what they're saying is they want the public to be misled and and uninformed of of all sides of the issue that's obviously morally wrong

12:10yeah so but yeah the situation where basically all the social media companies are based in the Bay Area or I guess if you add snap it's LA but the most influential ones are all in the Bay Area so they have a very sort of far left position especially in San Francisco I mean it doesn't get more far left than Francisco Berkeley it's like you know you know exploring the city today and yeah I noticed that I felt that yeah I mean you can see like there's some pretty rough parts of the city you know people are supposed to say oh you must be exaggerating I'm like you just come to downtown SF on any random day yeah it's the same thing and it's it's like Mad Max Walking

12:53Dead situation yeah it's horrible yeah it's like you can't believe it now there are certainly still many nice parts of San Francisco but the fact that the downtown core is basically a dead zone it's and and frankly some of the areas where there's just no people at all I think might be worse when the parts where the zombies are because it's actually Bleaker this is It's just empty yeah so you know we clearly don't want to have a world where that policy is Amplified to Earth you know where where you know we don't want all of us to be like downtown SF so you can see kind of like where the policies lead and we have evidence is right here so we anyway we

13:33it's one thing if that if the sort of damage radius of an ideology is located is limited geographically to you know sort of 10 mile radius or something like that which is what what you know say Anisha ideology would be limited geographically but when you've got some massive Global megaphone it's a effectively a mind virus megaphone to Earth if you have something like Twitter Facebook Instagram yeah big talk to some degree large degree I've had a lot of people voicing increasing concerns about tick tock not from the standpoint of spying but you know having a negative effect on the youth yeah so short shorter attention spans and I don't know how do you how do you manage that aspect

14:26when it comes to social media because I understand that anyone running a major social media Corporation there are so many different points of interest and conflicts and ethical confusion I think a lot of people think it's sort of easier than it must be right you've got number one I think people often forget that these platforms are Global they're not just in the USA they're not just in one nation they're yeah 100 plus different countries different jurisdictions with different laws different rules there's political elements involved yeah and so on you've got the you know typical stuff that you're not going to want polluting any type of websites there's various

15:08legal issues but then also the goal of the platforms is to keep people on them in most cases is to sell advertising is to make them sticky and addictive and keep people coming back but in your mind where's the line on that between we can recognize some of the problems that social media is having especially when it comes to younger people right but at the same time you do want people of course using the app and enjoying it and spending time on their so in your mind where do you think that balance is well there is actually quite a lot of pressure from advertisers yeah I mean the our advertising in in North America and Europe is you

15:53know down like 50 it's actually you know we're still roughly even in most Asia actually interestingly enough but in North America is down like I don't know over 50 percent Europe sound about 40 percent and you know I think if we if we simply towed the line and kept going as it was before then we would still have a lot of that Revenue so that like actually freedom of speech was pretty expensive yeah it really is cost billions of dollars it's currently costing probably freedom of speech currently costing about two billion a year so this is a lot just on Twitter and and lost Revenue it's oh it's right right now roughly two billion dollars a year yeah

16:50now I think that could change over time hopefully it will that over time we the advertisers will realize that actually Twitter is is not a some sort of hate speech purveyor in fact I get more laughs from Twitter than anything else yeah like you say like last per day I mean it's more than everything else combined from at least for me I you know I sometimes see I mean I see content I disagree with but I don't find it to be sort of you know a festering sort of pile of hate you know what's your experience I love Twitter I mean I've been using Twitter since 2009. yes you know well every time I've seen it through a lot of different iterations and what what I did notice

17:33myself is that for the for the first few years of using Twitter no one really worried about being banned or silenced censored Shadow band all of that it wasn't really a thing it really started to ramp up I want to say around 2015 maybe due to the U.S elections and you started to feel the walls closing in not just personally but other people were found finding oh like oh that person got banned yeah oh that person that person that person it's you know I'd start out with people more on the fringes but then it starts closing in and people start getting temporary I mean I got temporarily suspended for saying okay dude once that was my one suspension yeah I

18:08said okay dude wow in response to in response to somebody and it's cool I made a song in some good great merchandise outfit in the end but yeah I had to delete that tweet it literally just said okay dude okay so yeah people were getting banned for all these sort of things and then now in the past year it's it's opened up again yeah and I think people are having more fun now because they know okay I can make that edgy joke or I can say this or I can say that everybody needs to be walking away at shells exactly so it's like walking eggshells just definitely going to be a buzz kill yeah so yeah it's it's a I mean our general philosophy is huge close to the

18:47law in any given country we can't do more than that yeah as you mentioned some countries in fact most countries maybe all countries have more restrictions on speech than the US so we don't have any choice but to you know obey the laws of Any Given country or they'll simply cut Twitter off so sometimes people like are under laboring on the impression that we can mandate what speech is going to be in some other country and like we're not the government you know so we'll do the best we can but but we can't go if we just do illegal stuff they'll arrest our employees find us and then kick us out yeah so it's we'll do do the best we can and I think we're doing I'm confident

19:31at this point where we we do the least amount of censorship we're the most open we're the only social media company that open sources it's a recommendation algorithm everyone else is still you know so just a black box you don't know what's going on in there and and then we're we're making it better better over time so you know we're going to add indicators so you can see on your profile page have you been search banned have you been okay visibility filtered is there is there anything that's that's affecting your account in a negative way so like we're going for maximum transparency so and I think that's what really both trust you know because it's one thing to

20:16say like oh yeah trust us but but why well you can see everything we're doing you know then then you you don't need to believe me you can just literally look at the algorithm you can just literally you know everything's you know completely above board and you know it should be possible for actually independent third party to recreate the recommendations that they see on Twitter using our algorithm and frankly we're still finding different layers of code that we didn't know existed we literally found one this week okay which was

20:56which it had like a reputation score for any given account and if that account started trending it would be deleted from the trending list oh and I mean I was turned out I was one of those accounts so the system would exclude me from any Trends that's interesting so and it was it was just it was simply based on how many times an account had been reported okay but but not not like dividing my total follower account or anything so you know if if like point oh so if you just had a big following then yeah if anyone with big following is basically getting but getting Trend banned which is crazy yeah or anyone that says anything remotely controversial or is targeted by you know

21:46Bots or activists yeah it is basically it's very easy to sort of reports fam an account kind of DDOS an account with with a with fake reports and then the system would just say oh this account's gotten lots of reports so they can't be in Trend yeah were you expecting such a level of I mean of course you've got massive public support and praise as well and I know you've been dealing with this your you know criticism your whole career sure but were you expecting I mean I guess number one is what what level of backlash or criticism have you

22:31received I mean I I see what I see but I mean from your perspective how much has it been in terms of just the amount of stuff coming whether that's from mainstream Media or just from individuals and even other organizations well I think it's it was really be hard to avoid the criticism of me frankly it's like it's not like I'm I'm like I'm not dying to get to get pressed it's just the there's just my name gets a lot of clicks and the you know it's important to understand that the price is primarily a click maximizing machine not a truth maximizing machine and really it's it's somewhat of a darwinian exercise if if you're not a click maximizing machine well you don't get

23:13the clicks and then you don't get the revenue and then the you know the company goes under yeah so the entire data structure is Max is maximized clicks not maximize truth and so that's why you'll have while you'll have sort of Insanity headlines that are like really way over the top or because often the truth is is boring and complicated or it's certainly more like a sort of you know version of the truth that the media will without will be more salacious you know it'll be spicier than reality and and they'll it'll be the cliff notes version but you know the drama I mean the media is going to give you generally the dramatized Cliff Notes version of reality

24:01because if it's if they give you the full thing is too complicated and it's gonna bore people and and if if they really give give it too much balance it really doesn't have enough controversy to get the click this is the incentive structure and so one that you know whatever your incent will happen so anyways that's the situation with with the media and if the Legacy Media have had to deal with the shrinking advertising plan for a long time because Google and Facebook and whatnot have taken so much of the of the advertising Revenue so they're it's been they're happy about they're happy about that well it's been a struggle for the traditional media yeah so that that

24:42they've been forced to be click maximizing machines or die so how do you think how do you think that's going to play out over time I mean I think a lot of people recognize the problem with the sort of Click bait model like it's it's really a broken incentive structure that's leading to increased manipulation you know ridiculous headlines I mean yeah we see a lot it's why it can be difficult to see the line between satire and reality now because it's just yeah it's gotten so goofy that you can't tell whether something is from the best recipe or the onion like many times or it's getting totally crazy yeah I mean there's been stuff about you know

25:24Fitness being linked to Fascism and white supremacy and you know I mean bodybuilding is a fitness really I wasn't aware that yeah I mean people should obviously be in good shape it's just a matter of health and feeling good and I mean I should work out I I don't really work out much but I agree I think I agree with the idea of working out and I agree with the idea of fitness and and it's just obviously a fundamental a healthy way to live I mean come on I'm ripping a t-shirt right now I don't know if you can read that this is the get jacksonated t-shirt Okay cool so nice that's the movement I'm trying to get everyone in the gym get jacks get get

26:04jacked get vaccinated our podcast today is sponsored by the wellness company as you guys know I'm always looking for the best health and wellness products to give me an edge but if I eliminate businesses that have gone woke or forced vax mandates on their employees there are fewer and fewer companies that I feel comfortable supporting that's where the wellness company comes in the wellness company was formed by a team of doctors who lost their jobs for speaking up about mandates and pushing back against lockdowns they offer live telemedicine and a wide range of custom formulated supplements to help keep you at your best my favorite wellness company product is their Spike support

26:38formula it's the only product I've seen that contains ingredients research to block and dissolve coveted Spike proteins in the bloodstream taking daily Spike support can bring better mental Clarity and increased energy levels whether you're vaxxed or unvaxed it doesn't discriminate and neither does the wellness company get back to that pre-covered feeling go to twc.health forward slash zubi and use code zubi that's Zuby to save 15 at checkout that's TWC DOT health forward slash zubi and use the code Zubia checkout something I wanted to ask you is this is a big question this is a big question but with all the stuff that you do what what motivates you what's the Big

27:21Driver well internally I'm what I'm trying to do is take the threat of actions that maximize the probability that the future will be good for civilization that we will expand the scale of scope of scope and scale of Consciousness so that we're better able to understand the nature of the universe so I would call my I'd say I have like a philosophy of curiosity that's maybe best articulated by Douglas Adams in The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy okay so we're you know that's really famously has like the it was a big computer comes up with the answer 42 but the really hard part is what question to ask so I think it's like we want to try to understand more about the nature

28:08of the universe I stand like what does it all mean where where do we come from where are we going where does this all end up is what's real are there aliens I mean well they seem to be confirming some stuff quite recently I mean I I have yet to see actually any actual evidence of aliens so and I'm really deep in space yeah so

28:32yeah I I I mean if if there is some actual evidence of aliens or an actual UFO I'll be there in a second you know I mean obviously you know it's like we're talking about bodies here or like is it a UFO is there advanced technology I mean that would be very very interesting and hopefully they're friendly so I managed to get all the way here from another star system I mean the technology is going to be far in excess I mean we're we'll be primitive compared to them you know so but I also think like if if there aren't a aliens or that that's actually perhaps even a bigger concern because you know if they actually aren't aliens in our galaxy or anywhere near us

29:15then effectively this Consciousness this Consciousness on planet Earth is the light of Consciousness is like it's like a tiny candle in a vast Darkness and a fragile candle and we should just do everything we can to make sure it does not go out what do you think is the greatest threat to humanity well I think digital super intelligence is a real real concern I think that

29:51digital super intelligence or artificial general intelligence as it's called sometimes or mostly is more likely to be good than bad but it's just that the the probability of a bad outcome is not zero and I think I think probably the more we worry about a bad outcome the less likely it is to occur okay so so I think we should be con you know just say like let's try to steer the AI in a good direction what do you think that potentially bad outcome would be I mean I've got ideas in my head I've seen some Sci-Fi movies but I mean the the obviously the extreme case would be at wife's out Humanity you know that would be it's not a zero percent chance

30:34hopefully it's a low chance but it's not zero or wife doesn't maybe just maybe it doesn't wipes a whole lot but you know it's kind of like the you know or the chimps and the gorillas they're they're in small sections of Earth but they're yeah and we don't like it's not like we're like going and hunting them down or anything but but they're they're contained in small areas of us and so they don't we don't prioritize them we don't prioritize them and I'm not sure that like they're certainly not like expanding yeah you know they got the there so they think that could be a also not not a great outcome where it's like it doesn't kill all the humans just keeps

31:17enough around just for the hell of a pharmacist yeah or like just to see what happens like study us like who isn't the most whatever you know just the people would like to study us out of curiosity potentially that would still not be a great outcome for Humanity you know I think we want to like I said expand the scope and scale of Consciousness yeah both biological and digital and ultimately go out we've become a multi-final species become an Interstellar species because these other star systems and and maybe we do meet aliens or maybe we visit these various star systems and we see well here's an alien civilization that lasted 10 million years

32:00and did incredible things and then ultimately died out potentially I mean I think we we could find there's a whole bunch that there's a whole bunch of of Dead one planet civilizations never got Beyond The Home Planet so I mean Judith's expansion of the sun earth arguably may become and have uninhabitable as soon as half a billion years from now which is a long time but it's been around for four and a half billion so that would only be a 10 increase in the lifespan of both and so and if you look at if you date a civilization from perhaps the first writing that's about 5 000 years old and that's 5500 years old though so

32:48kind of archaic preak uniform in Samaria so that's sort of like that's a very short period of time so they say like Earth's been around for one and a half billion years writing is five thousand years old so if your date civilization from the first writing which is probably a reasonable number then civilizations only been around for one millionth of Earth's existence not long ago not long at all I thought we're a flash in the pan basically so

33:23anyway so I think we we want to do everything we can to obviously make life on Earth great and make picture of oath of solid and that Civilization is on on a sound footing you know keep making with better but then expand to Mars and ultimately you know to to the rest of the solar system and eventually to other star systems be a space foreign civilization like you know in the good Sci-Fi movies and yeah shows it's like you know Star Trek and whatnot let's you know go out there and see there's civilizations who have never let me read pretty cool if we meet Aliens hopefully they're friendly you know and just gain a vastly greater understanding of the Universe I think it

34:15might depend on which humans they meet first whether or not yeah I think we need to be quite cautious about who they who they meet first yeah because they might form some quick judgments based on that yeah like we just want to have the opportunity right now we don't really know how to go anywhere close to the speed of light let alone beyond the speed of light so it will take us a long time to get to nearest star systems I mean optimistically with known physics we could get to the nearest star system in about 40 or 50 years okay it'll be very difficult to even get make it that short it's a long time to be traveling through deep space so anyway I think that's the future that

34:57would be that's that's exciting and there needs to be things that are exciting and inspiring where you wake up in the morning and it's not just about solving one problem or another or some sort of international struggle with between the humans but but that there are inspiring goals collectively as Humanity where we're really excited about about that and I think being a space barring civilization is something that I think a lot of people would find very exciting and and inspiring and you know even if they don't go with themselves they can just you know kind of live vicariously through those that went I mean I think you know with the Apollo Landings it was you know they

35:37were literally said For All Mankind you know and I think everyone was proud to be a human at that point it's like we actually went to the we went to a damn Moon that's such an important sentence you just said there actually wow you know yeah you just said something there that that's actually really important you said people being proud to be human and I think actually we increasingly live in a time where a big part of the problem is that that's not the case yeah I think oftentimes people view it with a sort of nationalistic lens about people being proud to be American they're proud to be British or whatever and those people recognize that that

36:11sort of patriotism seems to be declining but I actually think yeah as a species as a whole perhaps we're not feeling as optimistic about our own species as we should be and I think that there's been a lot of fear a lot of people living in constant fear perhaps people feeling like the future is going to be worse than the present and even worse than the past in some ways and yeah I think that's causing a lot of psychological problems and having really impact on society and culture because if you don't think the future is going to be better right than the present then you lose hope totally and it's important to have that Spirit of Adventure yeah and I

36:49think also if people lose hope in the future if they have you know if there's if they're pessimistic about the future then they're also unlikely to have kids in which case you get the civilizational decline I mean we just have you know for most of us demographic collapse like the birth rates are just crazy low yeah so we're certainly I think not expanding and we're really gonna contract pretty significantly I mean Japan last year had twice as many deaths as both that's crazy yeah so

37:22I mean every every single Western Country yeah has a below replacement birth rate yeah and just generally the trend is as soon as you get sort of urbanization frankly unfortunately education tends to urbanization education reduce birth rate yeah so and that's that Trend will ultimately happen I think throughout the world so so that's why I'm you know encouraging people like let's at least like maintain our numbers you know like we don't actually expand in a crazy way but it's at least maintaining numbers maybe a little bit of growth so why do you think so many people think the opposite I mean you hear a lot of talk about over I think the whole

38:04overpopulation yeah I think I think it's a massive psyop and yeah yeah that's not true yeah but why do so many otherwise smart people buy buy into that well I think to some degree this is a side effect of the environmental movement okay you know so you know the sort of environmental movement I think started off well where it was saying look we need to move to sustainable energy which is is correct in the long term we do need to move to sustainable energy it's total logical if we don't move to sustainable energy then it's unsustainable and we'll run out and civilization we'll grind to a halt so we do need to have sustainable energy over time there's obviously a concern with

38:48with climate change although I like I'm of the opinion that while there is a long-term concern for climate change there there is not really much of a short-term concern like it's big things it's a very slow process and I think we don't we don't need to sort of be stopping people from farming or having cows or or whatever like this is crazy this is that then and that's like small potatoes are from an environmental standpoint the the really the the the the the fundamental thing from environmental standpoint is if you've got billions of tons of

39:26fossil fuels essentially you know Carbon in liquid and gaseous form or solid form in the case of coal that's buried deep underground and you move it from deep underground into the into the atmosphere and the oceans you obviously change the chemistry of the of the oceans and atmosphere and if you keep doing that for a long time we'll eventually change the chemistry enough that they will indeed be climate change but Earth is very big and human and humans are small I mean Tim Urban I

39:57calculated that you could fit all the humans on Earth on one floor in the city of New York on one floor on one floor yes and you've kind of wedged in there but yeah you know but oh okay so if you just kind of spread the video shoulder shoulder yeah whatever it's a like basically across like the cross-sectional area of humans is small like we think that there are a lot of people but and that's if you live in like London or New York you'll be like oh wow there's a lot of people but this is that's a very rare situation most of the time you know if you're if you're flying you know across the us or internationally it's empty yeah I mean you're far from

40:36holiday to New York most of the time there's like you don't see anyone no yeah so yeah so like if if you're if you're trying to drop a ball on somebody's head while flying from LA to New York you'd have a real hard time you know you're gonna miss yeah it's just not a you know humans are not densely packed they're

41:01so yeah plenty of room for more people that's basically the situation so so anyway so I think the environmental movement kind of got somewhat overzealous and kind of was and like in the limit of environmentalism you sought to conclude that humanity is a plague on on Earth that humanity is actually the problem it's a big one yeah and that's like obviously taking the environmental movement just too far but there are literally people who believe this that like extinctionists yes New York Times as some months ago had an article front page article with with some guy who and his quote was there are eight billion on people on Earth and it would be better if there were none

41:44that's dark yeah I'm like hey buddy you can saw it with yourself yeah you know if you really want to you know make a difference but you know take your own advice here but it but that's like a crazy Viewpoint you know that's like literally saying this genocide Humanity like what how can you say that with a straight face that's when it's like total Madness but but people like like I said in the limit of environment of environmentalism it sort of becomes like an ingrown toenail you know it's sort of like yeah Twitter is fine but not if it's like warped in England it's it's just gone too far humanity is not a blatant on the face of the Earth and frankly even with climate

42:26change life on Earth will still continue I mean the calamities that Earth has suffered where life continued afterwards like gigantic meteorite impacts super volcanoes the continents drifting all over the place there have been times in Earth's past where it's been like a total snowball or it's been absolutely sweltering hot and you know life you know we had many Extinction events but there were but life continued but you know like we didn't we don't see the dinosaurs now but they've had a good run for whatever 100 plus million years so so even if there's catastrophic climate change on Earth life continues it just may not be your life as we know it it'll it may not be humans it'd

43:13be something else so what we're talking about with climate change is not a threat to a life on Earth but really maybe a threat to human humans or a dislocation of humans if there's low-lying countries that you know the water level rises and other underwater type thing so so I mean I think one just needs to strike the right balance by saying like look over time we need to move to a sustainable energy economy and we we can't just keep taking billions of tons of coffin from deep underground and putting it in the atmosphere and expect nothing will happen forever yeah but we also don't need to be alarmist about it and super negative and massively disrupt people's Lifestyles I

43:57mean I think people can continue to live a normal life yes and they shouldn't be guilty about being human or sort of frankly having a stake it's fine yeah it all something that strikes me with that agenda as well and people who push it is it also seems like Western countries climbing the ladder and then pulling the ladder up after them right so when you have large developing nations somewhere somewhere like India lots of parts of Africa and so on and it's like okay the Western Nations have gone through this whole process to even get to a stage where you can afford to care about such things you've got other nations that are developing and they're trying

44:37to get up to the level of prosperity that say the USA has right now and you know you want them to care about the environment but it's like people are still poor people are not going to care about the environment until they've got their basic needs met so there's a part of it where it's this you know it's it's this sort of belief system that I I think is very what's what's the right term it's almost like to use a Rob Henderson term it's like a luxury belief right you know it's like okay it's all good for you to view things that way but if you think about the average person yeah in many parts of the you know developing World they can't afford to be thinking

45:16this way they still need to get up to at least the basic level that our countries are in yeah I I mean I agree with that I mean I agree with what you just said but I I also think that the cost of sustainable energy has been drop it dropping tremendously and you're seeing a lot more wind and solar

45:39and you know pair that with the battery and you've got you know continuous power for wind wind and solar that's actually very competitive so cost competitive and actually one of the one of the nice things about say solar battery is you you don't need to run high power lines all over the place and have some you know localized solar battery situation on your house or Factory welding or it's you can kind of

46:09decentralize the power generation and and I think that's actually better for people to have decentralized power generation and you know also decentralized Communications like a lot of places they skipped all the sort of phone landline stuff and went to cell phones yes in fact a lot of places in the world have way better cell connectivity than you know Silicon Valley which is bizarre yeah you know so yeah when it comes to the idea of underpopulation what is your biggest concern about that if there are not you've said many times publicly that we need more people we need more human beings yeah what what would happen if you know this is this is not my perspective but for the people

46:58who are there who do think you know who do have this sort of malthusian world view and they think that there's too many people there's enough resources he's been wrong for a very long time but you know kind of like still comes back communism it won't go exactly there we go again so what what's the greatest fear there if people are not reproducing as they have been for most of human history what's the what's the greatest concern there well I think it's like what we risk is civilizational collapse yeah you know so and and and somewhat of a depressing civilizational collapse if the birth rate keeps dropping every year and population just keeps going into the

47:38sort of like negative death spiral literally then it won't die with a bang it'll die with a with a whimper in adult diapers I mean that's a that's a bleak end to civilization so you know I keep looking at the growth rate numbers which is just like available online you know it's a lot like it's basic facts and hoping that both rates will turn around and that every year it gets worse yeah what do you think could practically be done to to help with that because a big factor in this is you know I talk to a lot of a lot of young young men and young women you know I'm in my in my own position as well yeah so yeah I plan to I I will

48:27I will yeah but due to you know from everything from social and cultural factors economic factors Financial factors a lot of young men and women say the average 20 year old or even 25 year old they find the whole idea of having children bringing new life into the world very scary because they feel like hey you know I don't have the money I can't afford it I can't even buy a house I'm in debt I'm struggling to keep my head above water so on so what do you think could practically be done in USA Canada UK Europe all these developed countries South Korea Japan all these places where the you know population is declining birth rates are declining I

49:11I think it's one thing to to recognize the issue but what do you think can be done on a sort of practical reasonable level well I I do think that like some of the like the incentive structure in in a lot of countries is against having kids yes so like it's a sort of it is it is expensive to have kids especially if you want to sort of give the best education and all that sort of stuff so it's a it is you know financially difficult I mean if I say that but then ironically the higher someone's income

50:00fewer kids yeah yeah so it doesn't totally make sense that you have an inverse correlation with income and and kids where so so I guess people may may sort of think that but it's not actually real you know I think that the fears there's these unjustified fears of like well if I have a kid things are going to be financially terrible at it's actually not true you know it's

50:35I don't know that I have a good answer to this because I'm trying to you know figure it out yeah I mean I know that for a lot of young people and some of this is media and cultural programming but a lot of people have been pushed over the decades the idea that having children ruins your life right that it it takes away your freedom and your autonomy and you can't have fun and do all this cool stuff and you've got to just you know I think the idea of Parenthood I think the solution is I don't and I don't know exactly how to do this but I think the idea of Parenthood and family needs to be made cool yeah it does it needs to be made cool again yeah

51:13absolutely and I think people just understand like nothing will make you happier than having kids it will absolutely improve your happiness level and have kids and I mean we're kind of like programmed for that you know it's like if we would just say like like in the old days where it's like you know people's sort of straw food was like short supply they had plague like you know it's like trying to just start trying to survive from one year to the next in the middle days was like a big deal and so you know now now we have now that's kind of more or less normal that you would survive from one year to the next so you know we're going to become I guess a

51:56complacent but but but basically if if it wasn't rewarding instinctively to have kids we wouldn't have them yes you know I mean almost none of the world was literate until not that long ago so it's not like you're like oh let me read a bunch of books you you kind of have to instinctively love having kids otherwise you can't read about it it's like it's going to read books yeah so so I think that's important to understand you'll you will absolutely be happier if you have kids absolutely we're literally we've evolved to have that as All Creatures have I mean you could take say like I don't know like a you know like I don't know an alley cat or something like or like like a or

52:47Bobcat like some like wild creature that would normally be quite Fierce and unfriendly and like kill read anything it came across but the moment it has you know Cubs or puppies or whatever it or kittens it becomes a you know that becomes loving mom you know so like like the cat that was really mean is like taking care of its little kittens it's Instinct it's like you know it's genetic programming so people should really expect that if they have kids they will improve their quality of life not make it worse if you haven't heard already it's smooth sack summer that's right this is the summer to keep your man Parts cool while still looking hot with manscapes and you can

53:32jump right in and get 20 off plus free shipping with the code zubi at manscaped.com the leaders in below the waist grooming are making sure we all have a ball this summer by giving us everything we need to stay fresh downstairs the manscaped performance package 4.0 has everything you need to prepare that summer bod their lawnmower 4.0 trimmer features a Cutting Edge ceramic blade to reduce grooming accidents thanks to their Advanced Skin safe technology it's even waterproof so you can groom yourself in the shower if that's how you roll the package also includes their weed whacker ear and nose hair trimmer crop preserver ball deodorant manscapes boxers and the shed

54:10travel bag get 20 off plus free shipping with the code zubi at manscapes.com that's 20 off plus free shipping with the code zubi Zuby manscaped.com it's smooth sack summer boys get on board or get left behind you've got a lot of kids yeah I'm trying to say a good example awesome yeah how how has having kids

54:33made your made your life better how does it how does it make you happier and how does it motivate and drive the things that you're doing well I think I mean I don't know it's like I think it's normal to love your kids you know it's just it's just kind of an automatic thing and they've got this little creature that's depending on you to take care of it and it's very wanting to do so I think inherently so I mean they're a lot of fun they're but I don't know you love them they love you do you find do you find being a father is a driver is that a particular driver and motivator for the way you think and the things you're trying to the things that you're not

55:14trying to do the things you are doing I think it does motivate me to you know want to make sure that the world is the future is going to be good for for my kids you know and and sometimes people might say like well you know so sometimes I'm complimented and said and it will say like well it's very magnanimous magnanimous of you or altruistic of you to care about civilization but I think actually like even if somebody's very selfish you should still care about civilization because we cannot live in the absence of civilization you could live alone we cannot you know if you want to know what being alone and without civilization is just look at like naked and afraid you know

55:57they don't want to it's it's not we all like actually hanging out with other humans we all actually we all actually like each other more than we think in reality one of my sons Saxon who's sort of autistic but he's kind of awesome he's like an article of wisdom you know he for a long time he was rare I'd like to try to have like a family dinner at a restaurant once a week you know just go out somewhere and and Saxon for a long time was really didn't understand why we're doing this he's like why are we going out and and then finally he he had an epiphany and said oh the reason people go to restaurants is to hang out with strangers and I'm like yeah that's actually true

56:46yeah because you can get the same restaurant food delivered you can call your friends over yeah but you know what you can't get unless you go to a restaurant is hanging out with strangers so we actually like hanging out with friends really discovers nightclubs yeah exactly you know a darker room yeah you can barely see anyone it's the music's not but it's still kind of fun and you're just with a bunch of strangers basically we're just humans actually do love other humans more than they may think they do and you think you look at like say what what's like one of the worst punishments in prison is solitary confinement and it's not like you know

57:24if you're not intelligent confinement you know the rest of the prison is maybe not like the most awesome group to hang out with but it's way better than being alone you're probably safer in there but yeah you don't want to be there so humans love other humans more than they realize yeah I've listened to a lot a lot of your interviews and a lot of stuff is about the sort of here and now but I'm curious to know a little bit more about your your journey people see all the things that you're doing now with Tesla and putting rockets in space and buying Twitter and you know restoring free speech trying to make Humanity an interplanetary species but tell me more

58:01I was in I went to South Africa for the first time just a few months ago so I was in I went to Johannesburg I went to I went to Cape Town I know that that's where that's where you grew up and you spend your mostly in Johannesburg Johannesburg Victoria and for a couple years in Durban okay I visited Cape Town a few times but didn't live there what was can you tell me can you tell me a little bit more about your the the pre super multiple CEO Elon Musk you know yeah I had kind of like a I wouldn't say I really mostly sat on a unhappy childhood actually it would not it was not a that wasn't 100 bad but it was pretty rough and thank you I lived in South Africa Plus 17. and

58:54and then I was able to get Canadians Canadian citizenship through my mom because she was born in Canada okay and so I was like well you know I left when I was 17. so you know I think my views of South Africa are somewhat scarred by kind of a negative childhood experience like literally scars yeah I have literally quite a few scarves so

59:24it was it was so soft so there's certainly plenty of good things about the country but in my particular experience was not that great so I hear that yeah I know you one of your first projects was a video game called blastar yeah getting that right yeah tell us about blastar well I always loved video games when I was kid on computers so like the video games back then were extremely primitive you know

59:56so I guess when I was about I don't know 10 or 10 or so I I saw like the first computer I mean I read a lot of books and then I saw that you could actually have a computer which is I thought wow this is the best thing ever it was a Commodore vic-20 I think it had like 8K of Ram or something okay yeah it's crazy it was best the other was best thing ever and so I and I got a book on programming told myself how to write write computer programs and then gradually progress from the Commodore 20 to the

1:00:40some class Spectrum which was actually a pretty brilliant little computer that was a 48k a few of those felt very Advanced after like 20. and then yeah so I was just kind of programming and you couldn't really get very many games so I was like well program games playing myself so but it is it is interesting that the the Escape simple game that I wrote when I was a kid and I remember when I was like 11 or something and edit all the the graphics and the music and everything primitive Graphics promoted music but so and yeah I was actually yeah I sold to get game for money which was not much money it was a lot for a little kid and I wrote a bunch of other games too

1:01:37when I was a kid and then actually had a I worked briefly at it software company a games company called Rocket Science in Palo Alto which had nothing to do with with rockets it was just a games company and then I know I wrote software for almost 20 years from like ages roughly 10 to 30.

1:02:03any I heard you used to play Quake a lot yeah and got pretty good pretty darn good at that yeah yeah so yeah played a lot of weight [Music] and had one of the best teams in the country actually and I think I think it was the first I think the first paid Esports thing in the US or certainly one of the first and we ended up coming second in that we were actually coming first but then the best I was the second best post on the team the best person on the team his computer crashed halfway through the game so we ended up coming second but

1:02:50I think like we made a few thousand dollars or something so it was pretty good at Quake back in the day yeah and I heard you did you want to you wanted to get into or at least you thought about getting into programming video games but then is that is that fair to say I did actually work on some fairly Advanced video games okay let this company rocket science okay okay but that's

1:03:15I like video games but I wanted to sort of have a I don't know as big of impact on the world as possible like I said like trade try to take the set of actions that I think most likely to result in a good future be as useful as possible so yeah so I mean I was you know for a while there was was pursuing a path of developing technology for electric vehicles that's what I was going to be doing my Graduate Studies at Stanford on okay it's sort of advanced energy storage technology for electric vehicles and are putting putting that on hold to start an Internet company because I figured like the technology of electric vehicles would advance and I could come back to

1:04:03it which I did later but the internet was like it was the which was going super over at the time if this is in 95. so so I wanted to be part of building the internet basically what was your first impression of the internet because I think for young people now it was like the internet it feels like the internet's always been there yeah because I think people forget how you breathe or something yeah I think people forget that I mean even within my lifetime yeah I remember when nobody had email addresses I remember when people were terrified to put their credit card details online when people thought selling books online was a dumb idea and this Amazon thing was never going to

1:04:43work like that's all within my own Lifetime right so stuff has changed very very quickly but what was your first impression of the internet and how did you so quickly realize its potential well you know as we're talking about I you know into computers from when I was even before I even had a computer I was reading about reading about them so

1:05:09so I had some like very early primitive computers and then had a computer with a modem so like a balanced like bulletin board or in these various sort of very early pre-internet things and and then like like the you know you sort of started to have the internet go beyond just universities and like a handful of universities and government institutions to be kind of commercialized and and it was just growing exponentially so it I mean the way I sort of visualized sort of it was like the humanity was like acquiring a nervous system so previously information had to flow from one person to another so either had to meet in person you had to call them on a

1:06:01phone or you had to somebody had to carry a letter by hand to someone else and that was the way that information flowed and if you wanted to have access to a book you'd have to go to a library and the book you know most libraries would only have a very small subset of books that exist so your access to information was very limited and very slow and but as soon as you have the internet where everyone's connected now you could be in very remote location and if you've got access to the internet you have access to all of Humanity's information everything you have access to the entire kind of collective group-wide so it's like moving from like we were communicating almost by

1:06:49osmosis like just point like literally direct contact to and very limited amount of information to now anyone has access to all of the world's information I mean right I mean the internet you can learn anything on the internet yeah okay yeah I mean all like the MIT lecturers are on YouTube you can become an expert in anything for free if you've got an internet connection yes and I think people haven't realized that yet yeah I mean I guess if you ask them they know it's true but they they don't quite appreciate that that the the the equality of access to information is so radically better today than it was in the past it's it's no comparison you know I mean for a long time like

1:07:38books were very rare and like people would have a small collection of books before the Gutenberg Press I'd have to literally copy out the book by hand so having a book was like a like a relic and it was like it's a hardly anyone had books hardly anyone could read and even those that had books didn't have very many of them then you had a good repressed thing and now you can make copies of books you know but still paper still limited still not that many

1:08:10so we should be actually quite excited about the fact that there is this massive leveling of opportunity of access to information because the those that did have books in the old days would be it would be like some the Lord of some in a manner or something would have their their Library but even that would be a pretty small Library and and most people had notebooks so now you have access to vastly more information than you know the king of England did yes like in it even 100 years ago like even say 20 for 40 years ago like the average person right now has access to more information than the most powerful person on Earth did in say 1980.

1:08:59or even 1990 frankly oh I wish it felt like it well the sort of thing is that like it's in human nature to that our expectations recalibrate so because you know the the difference between almost any part of the world really elicits actively at War versus like having to survive by yourself or with a small group living off the land it's it's like our quality of life basically

1:09:42is so dramatically better than the past you have to say well why aren't we happy it's because or or sometimes why a lot of people aren't happy is that they we just keep recalibrating we keep setting our expectations higher we keep moving the goal post yeah so so it's you know keep moving the goal post recap keep recalibrating then you just naturally will always be wanting things to be better than than in the past it's it's kind of like like our you know it's the same goes like happiness is reality my minus expectations but if our expectations keep Rising then reality has to keep Rising too and yeah so

1:10:32no overall I think people should be more optimistic about the future and I think you should recognize that alive today is vastly better than it was in times past [Music] that actually violence on average is much lower than it used to be oh yeah war is rare I mean yeah before in Ukraine but it'd just be like everywhere you know even just I mean just look at the past Century yeah I mean yeah last century was insane yeah so you understand it's not rare for them to be War yeah so yeah I think people I think people lack perspective and gratitude yeah with all those things that you're saying and I think that if people had more awareness of both history and how far and how quickly

1:11:22human beings have advanced and how much things have gotten better even if you just take something obvious things poverty yeah you know childhood mortality women dying in childbirth access to education that's a huge issue I mean literacy yeah people were used to just be getting taken out left right and Center you know it was very normal for you know a quarter or a third of children to to die before they reach age five it was very normal for a young men to be going off to war and being brutalized and killed and all sorts of horrible ways yeah in fact like so Napoleon said like all every French woman has to have six kids two will die in charge two two will drive children two will die

1:12:03in war and then two more to continue friends wow yeah yeah and it wasn't that far wrong yeah it's a little Napoleonic Wars and stuff yeah I just think that because of that because of the when I think with the lack of perspective comes a lack of gratitude and then no matter how comfortable someone's life is no matter how good things they are even if they're they're in good health no one around them is sick or dying whatever and they're still just feeling down and sad and I think if

1:12:33they could just reframe that in their minds then I think people would be a lot happier yeah absolutely I really encourage people to be students of History yeah I mean there's some really good podcasts out there that are very compelling you know podcasts there's like this explorers podcast that's really interesting like of the early sea voyages you know and how like everyone was like dying of scurvy because they didn't even know vitamin C was a thing yeah and then they finally figured out okay vitamin C is a thing so and you know I mean if you read history like man it just feel like we'd have like plagues over here like a third of the city died you know

1:13:18I mean they only discovered they only just discovered germs less than fewer than 150 years ago yeah right so people drove the area that you even should wash your hands yeah exactly for you know delivering a baby or something that was that was new yeah the gym fear of disease was opposed for a long time by the medical establishment it's like actually worth noting that like you know literally the official line was germs were fake yes and the doctors are clean so yeah doctors exactly and you know if you don't have like a good sort of microscope or something and someone tells you that there's like these tiny creatures that you can't see I mean it

1:13:54sounds like witchcraft yeah it's like but there's tiny creatures that you can't see that are on your hands and if you touch something else those tiny creatures are going to go in someone else to basically bacteria and viruses and they're gonna maybe die and and they're so small you can't see them like once you get markers microscopes people like okay I see like little things wiggling around like I don't know what those things are but they don't look good but for a while they were like if this they're like this is prosperous this you're trying to tell my little tiny things that are the small are the real reason we're gonna get ill as opposed to like you know bad spirits or

1:14:32something you know like because they would like they would just think that there was like bad air or something it's like there's two places first you know too much blood sticks yeah this this place is cursed that's why we get ill it's like or maybe this it's got some bacteria yeah so yeah it took a while and they put that with that for a long time and we didn't even figure out like antibiotics until last century yes so yeah because in World War one yeah I believe so many people died of infections yeah then died from actual wounds yeah I mean if you're sitting there in a trench covered in mud and blood and you get a scratch yes I mean that scratches May probably end of you

1:15:15you know yeah what's the name of that movie the one that was like all filmed in one take the world where it's is it 1917 or 1917 I think that's it yeah that that movie just made me like gosh I'm glad that I did not have to yeah some Next Level Slaughter yeah it was brutal yeah I wonder what do you ever wonder what the things are you know how we look and look back at something like you know the germs which seems very obvious now I wonder what the things are that are happening right now that people are getting sick from and dying from the 100 years from now people are going to look back and be like wait they didn't they didn't know that how did they not

1:15:51know that well really the probability of death at this point and I mean unless someone's engaging in very dangerous activity is is low so our lifespans we're really reaching pretty much the end of our natural lifespans so now if somebody drinks a lot of alcohol heavy drugs or smoking is really bad you know these things can have a serious impact on lifespan but if you don't do anything like that you're probably you know probably gonna live till 75 80 years old you know we're kind of like our pre-programmed to live around that the human lifespans around around 80. yeah so that's just what's programmed into us and then actually for whatever reason

1:16:42women are programmed to live slightly longer than men so they've it could be that you've got X Y chromosome and and like men don't have the redundancy of a double X chromosome so if there's an error on either the x or the Y it's gonna you know reduce your lifespan I think actually technically testosterone I think also yeah yeah so and then we also do a lot of really stupid stuff we do a lot of stupid stuff but but but the it's just the statistics are very clear I think it's neverwhere in the world a woman live longer than men even if you account for war and adventurous and what's really interesting as well is that the probability of a male child being born

1:17:23is slightly higher it is 51 and 49 yeah so it's interesting that it actually accounts for that yeah this is men are more likely to die at every year of age yeah literally from a baby to to when you're old that's interesting tell me more about so I'll be honest of all the things you do and all the companies you run I think it's all awesome the one thing that does concern me and I know concerns a lot of people out there so I do have to bring it up which is neuralink sure so firstly can you explain what

1:18:05neuralink is and what the goal of it is we put a chip in your brain to control your mind yeah thank you all right concerns not alleviated yeah Jump Right In step right up who wants one no so so normally you'll be able to see neuralink coming from a very long distance because any device that you implant in a human is you have to go through so many tests it moves very slowly you just to a few people at a time and then you go to extreme lengths to prove safety you have to go through the FDA approvals like we're not trying to sidestep any you know regulatory approvals for doing everything you know buy the book and with maximum we're really actually we're going far beyond what

1:18:57the requirements are of the FDA from a safety standpoint and the the initial devices will really just be a pretty basic it'll be about restoring functionality to people who've lost their connection between their their brain and their body so you can imagine like if say Stephen Hawking could talk or communicate as fast as somebody with a fully functioning body that would be amazing so that's like the what we're trying to do that's our first application is to restore functionality to quadriplegics tetraplegics and and people who have just for one eight whatever reason and no longer have a connection between or a limited connection between their

1:19:36they're they're right in their body and then the second application would be restoration of eyesight so if somebody's gone completely blind maybe even just lost the optic nerve you can actually still directly assimilate the neurons in the visual part of the cortex so you can give a

1:19:59direct Vision to the brain in fact you could actually depending upon what cameras you used you can actually see in different wavelengths okay you know like Jordi laforge from like you know you could like have that like I actually watched like an episode of Star Tech Next Generation with special effects compared to what we're used to like you know not that great but he's got like the wrap around you know like glasses and you can see in different wavelengths so you can see like ultraviolet infrared and that kind of thing so you can actually do that you can say like you could see in radar if you want yeah and what's the what's the long term what's the long-term goal for it because

1:20:43I think myself and others I think the the first part is the first part sounds sounds fine sounds yeah that's like hard to argue with yeah yeah but long term I think I mean the concern that people have is is this just leading us into this dystopian transhumanist future where where does it go what are the what are the ethical boundaries of it well I mean the thing I wanted to emphasize is that it's not going to like sort of pounce on us overnight it'll you'll see it coming it's going to be very slow in fact I I really think that artificial general intelligence or digital super intelligence is likely to arrive before we have really Advanced neural Links at least that's

1:21:27where the trend is right now so but but ultimately the idea would be to achieve a symbiosis between our biological mind and our kind of digital mind so we're already kind of a cyborg if you think of like your phone and your computers as an extension of yourself in fact like if you leave your phone behind it's like you have missing limb syndrome you're like where'd it go you know and so the phone is a kind of an extension of myself the computer is the first applications that we use are operating an extension of self so we are already a cyborg it's just that the interface is with our eyes and our fingers yeah and and that that interface especially

1:22:14output the rate at which we can type words into a phone or a computer just it's very slow our input is much better because with with the data rate from vision is you know I don't know many thousands of times maybe a million times better than the rate at which we can output so our input is like maybe roughly a million times better than output and so so what what a neural like device can do is improve that bandwidth allow you allow here to be sort of much more symbiotic with your the the AI extension of yourself so you can think of like like a human brain really is could be ugly divided into two parts one is kind of like the Primitive brain the reptile brand sometimes called you

1:23:06know it's like a sort of Basic Instinct and and then we've got the cortex like the higher level thinking planning and that kind of thing but the two operate symbiotically so I haven't yet met anyone who wants to delete their limbic system or delete their cortex everyone's quite happy having both yeah they're like I like it the way it is you know but your cortex is way smarter than your Olympic system so but the irony is that even though the cortex is way smarter than the living system most of what it's doing is trying to make the Olympic system happy cyclomic systems hungy I'm hungry okay let's get some food the limbic system is warning okay

1:23:41let's you know have sex or whatever we'll see I mean the sheer amount of of effort the you know the cortexes have of all the humans have put into trying to get laid is insane it's got to keep the species going yeah but not even with even if you know it's not for procreation like like the limbic system is is really like too simple to understand that like sex does not result in in procreation because for almost all of human existence that it did they're both control it's a very recent thing so the the limit system is like trying to incent procreation and but but now we can effectively hack the limbic system by doing procreation by having sex without procreation

1:24:34so which is I guess maybe part of the the issue with you know why do we have both kids it's like in the past it would just happen because you know in order to make a living system happy you'd have sex you you didn't have birth control so if you out where you'd pop out some kids yes so that's that's how it used to be so so that so even though you've got a cortex that's way smarter than the limbic system the cortex is still basically just trying to make limit system happy and and then if you think like the computers as a sort of a third layer the AI is a third layer it's not necessarily the case that the AI would be acting contrary to our interests I think

1:25:17if it's closely linked with biological intelligence I think it could actually be just again trying to make the cortex happy which is trying to make the limbic system happy so I think we'll put even more computing power to try to get laid basically now the AI is going to help you get laid I think I think what it is that that concerns people about it number one I'm you know number one being new but I think the main thing is is the the fact that this is something that's like inside your body right I think the idea of putting a chip ins the idea of someone putting a chip in my brain I I just have a I have a visceral

1:26:09would it be though long term I mean I hope so I think it should be optional yeah be bizarre if it was not no I think it's kind of like the reason I ask is because smartphones right now are sort of optional but if you don't have a smartphone the way everything is sort of designed around Society you yes you cannot have a smartphone but it's a massive hindrance and disadvantage in many ways true a smartphone is almost essential and a modern society to do things yeah so could a neural link end up in that same sort of place it's possible but I'm just saying if it does it's a it's it's many decades from now so it's not like you know it's not today's problem yeah

1:26:56I'd worry a bit more about digital super intelligence I'd worry about let's try to avoid world war three yeah let's let's make sure we're at least having enough kids to sustain our population you know basic stuff like that yeah what's your greatest concern with artificial intelligence because I know that you have worked with it but also I know it's something that you personally have massive concerns about as well which you've voiced in this podcast and elsewhere yeah I I think that actually the most likely outcome for artificial intelligence is is that it is good that it will improve our lives most likely but there's some chance that it will not and

1:27:42I think we just need to be very cognizant of that and understand it's a powerful technology it's a double-edged sword and we need to put a lot of effort into ensuring that we have a good AI outcome and not a bad one what does a good one look like well if I'd recommend people read the Ian Banks Books Okay the culture books that's the best representation of a positive AI human future that I've seen okay so that's my recommendation I mean it effectively AI I think it it will massively enhance the human ability it's like a just a massive amplifier human ability just like the computer was so it really is just a question of like does does it there's some risk that it

1:28:42doesn't really amplify human activity but it starts basically just being in charge yeah and you know there's some risk it may you know view Humanity negatively and decide that we're a blight on the earth like like I think like like a very dangerous thing would be if the if these sort of human extinctionist philosophy somehow got into AI that would be bad like that guy that was on the front page in New York Times saying you know eight billion people on Earth three we don't want him coding it we don't want him coding you yeah safe to say there's quite a few people in the cycle of the woods who have that yeah either explicit or implicit extinctionist view yes where

1:29:21they view Humanity as a blight on the face yeah there's a lot of antenatalists in the in the world and people who and Andrea actually anti-human yes yes like you said people who don't have the pride in Being Human right there's people who really feel like guilty people even say that that's a speciesism you know that's it yeah yeah I mean I'm a human supremacist I'll I'll be open about that one yeah I mean I think we gotta fight for team human like if we don't fight for as humans who we will yeah I mean if the Earth exists and humans do not then it's like we're saving the planet for who at that point yeah what do you think about AI replacing jobs

1:29:57though because that's that's a big concern even if AI doesn't sort of go Rogue and start doing something directly horrible I think a lot of people's concerns is just hey what about everyone's jobs I will certainly be very disruptive because jobs were different so no I think yeah the the rate of change the rate the change caused by AI is going to be pretty radical so that there will you know a lot of jobs that are that currently exist won't exist in the future I think there will be new jobs and I do think like in a benign AI scenario we will really have an age of abundance the I think really goods and services unless they're artificially made scarce

1:30:42like like it's specialized artwork or you want that particular house in that neighborhood like it has to be an artificial scarcity but anything that is not made artificially scarce will be plentiful as in a benign AI scenario you'll be able to have any products and services you want that anyone will

1:31:03does that not start to cause a whole new level of problems yeah it does it's like this it's like you you know there's some things which sound like a like a a blessing but may in fact be a curse yeah like I think you will live forever it sounds like a blessing it's actually a curse you would not want to live forever you don't know how long forever is and and if you say another potential curse is you can have anything you want effortlessly are you sure you want that yeah does anything matter at that point yeah and and what about the value I mean I think a lot of the value of work isn't just getting money to buy things is the meaning it's the purpose it's knowing

1:31:47that you worked for this thing right it's different it's different to get 10 million dollars because someone just gave you 10 million dollars or you won a lottery versus you created a business and sold products and services that helped you to earn that money exactly so it's like how do we find meaning and relevance yeah if you have an age of abundance where the computer you just ask for anything and get it it is something you will have struggle with that that'll that'll be I don't know it's I think that's kind of most likely where we're headed is in age of abundance [Music] but it will definitely cause some existential angst

1:32:35what are you most optimistic about in fact I should say like okay for a neural link device I mean part of what I'm hoping is here in a benign AI scenario like how do we even go along for the ride how do we even understand the AI okay like you've got some sort of you know incredible intelligence unless we do sort of effectively have better symbiosis increase the bandwidth to our the AI extension of ourselves effectively augment our human intelligence substantially we may not even be able to appreciate the Wonders that will exist in the future like how do you even go along for the ride and appreciate the I don't know potentially amazing things in the future

1:33:18yeah hmm what gives you what what keeps you optimistic day to day you're you're a busy man you're running all these companies you've got a busy family life going on you've got praise criticism love hate flowing in all different directions but number one two two questions actually number one how do you stage how do you stay sane and grounded with it all because something that's always makes you think I'm saying I think you're certainly grounded I think you're grounded honestly I mean the fact that we're sitting here and that you know you interact with so many people I mean let's be honest 99 of people were in your position they wouldn't be doing what you're doing on

1:34:02on any level you're you're there on Twitter you're cracking jokes you're posting memes and responding I mean if it's you're you're who you are but you're also you strike me as a a normal guy who's doing extraordinary things rather than someone who's just completely like I don't know out there and I couldn't even have a conversation with you know so that's what I mean by saying

1:34:33well I I do think it's important to you know not get you know quite Scarface don't get high on your own supply of course in the end he did but you don't want to start thinking too highly of yourself because it actually reduces your feedback loop you you know if you think you're too smart you you stop listening to criticism so I think you know the Twitter is actually helpful for that you know instantly if you will not try about voicing their opinions so the frogs with 20 followers keep you in check yeah I mean yeah I've got you know like there's just some things I'm trying to get accomplished and you know Advanced rocketry and sustainable energy and

1:35:27put in case of Twitter freedom of speech so I think these are these things are these things mean a lot to me so I am I guess I'm motivated to get these things done in order to get these things done I have to stay sane because you know like physics is the law and everything else is recommendation and if you if you go crazy and you don't you do things happen you know agree with physics the Rockets blow up the cars don't work so physics is a heart you know harsh judge it's you you get you get the engineering and math right or you don't and it doesn't work if you don't so you you have to stay grounded in order for the Technologies to actually work

1:36:15I hear that Elon very very grateful for you taking the time out for this conversation I want to say I mean I said this on Twitter but I want to say it to your face I massively admire and appreciate what you're doing a massive thank you to from everyone who has been dealing with the nonsense on Twitter who's managed to get their accounts back and be able to speak freely and all that I want to say that but honestly I think what you're doing is is awesome you're a huge inspiration I know that

1:36:48in this age of criticism people don't like to tell people hey you're doing a good job I want to encourage you I want to uplift you so I want to do that and God bless you well thank you I appreciate it man thank you it was a pleasure

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份