马斯克给火星文明划了一条线。这条线跟人数无关,跟房价无关,跟火星上有没有咖啡馆也无关。
他说,真正的门槛只有一条:如果地球的飞船从此不再来了,火星上的人还能不能活下去。
真正的门槛在于,火星上有没有足够的资源,让那里的人在来自地球的飞船停止抵达之后依然能活下去。(马斯克)
这句话听着平淡,实际非常狠。它把"殖民火星"从浪漫叙事变成了供应链问题。
他接着打了个比方:你在一艘远洋船上,什么都带齐了,唯独缺维生素 C。船不会立刻沉,人会慢慢死于坏血病。大航海时代真发生过这种事,船员一上岸牙齿就掉光。火星的处境一模一样。你可能只差一样东西,某一种矿物,某一条生产线,某一台坏了就再也造不出来的机床。差一样,整个文明就撑不住。
所以说火星能不能活,得把清单从头到尾核一遍,核到每一样都能在火星本地闭环生产。这件事没有捷径,只能一项一项啃。
清单上缺一项,前面九十九项都白干
这份清单长什么样,其实不难想。
氧气可以靠电解水,水可以从冰里取,这两项已经有方案。推进剂甲烷可以就地合成。建材可以烧结火星土壤。麻烦的是后面那些:芯片、轴承、密封圈、光学器件、精密阀门。这些东西依赖极长的产业链,一条链上几十道工序,每一道工序又要一整套设备和耗材。
马斯克没有展开讲细节,但他的判断标准已经把难度说清了。自给自足这件事的危险在于,它有一票否决的性质。你可以把九十九项都解决了,只要第一百项解不了,前面那些在关键时刻都不作数。
这也是他反复强调"要很长时间"的原因。技术难度不在某一个点上,在整条链的深度。越往深处,越是那种"看起来不起眼但地球只有两家厂能做"的东西。
地球断供的方式有很多种,战争只是其中一种
飞船为什么会停止抵达?马斯克列了几种可能。
第三次世界大战是一种。地球文明缓慢衰退是另一种。他把这两种放在一起讲,因为它们指向同一个结论:地球这边出问题,火星那边就得靠自己。
他引了一句现成的话,来自诗人艾略特:世界收场的时候,听到的是一声呜咽,并不轰烈。马斯克自己的表述更直白,文明终结有两套剧本。一套是一声巨响,小行星撞击、核战争这类瞬间事件。另一套是漫长的、几乎察觉不到的衰落,几代人过去,发射能力一点点退化,最后没人记得怎么造火箭。
后一种剧本读起来更让人不舒服。人类史上这种案例不少,某项工艺失传,某种材料断代,几百年后连考古学家都只能猜。发射能力比这些复杂得多,它需要制造、运输、燃料、人才、供应链、政策和钱同时在场。任何一个环节长期松掉,整件事就慢慢停了。
罗根在旁边补了一句:还有自然灾害。马斯克接得很快,小行星撞击归到巨响那一类。然后他把话题拐到恐龙身上,这一段是整场对话里最有画面感的部分。
杀死恐龙的是一串事件
很多人脑子里的版本是:一颗小行星砸在尤卡坦半岛,尘埃遮天,恐龙全灭。马斯克的说法更细。他说恐龙遇到的是连续发生的好几件事。单独拿出其中任何一件,恐龙可能都能扛过去。三件事叠在一起,恐龙没了。
罗根在这时插了句感慨,说鳄鱼居然还活着,这事挺神奇。马斯克的回答很具体:鳄鱼吃腐肉,爱吃到什么程度呢,灾难现场到处都是死掉的动物,在鳄鱼眼里那是自助餐。所以它们留下来了。
他把幸存名单列了一遍:鳄鱼、昆虫、蘑菇、鼩鼱。
鼩鼱这个词值得停一下。人类的祖先曾经是类似鼩鼱的小型哺乳动物,在恐龙脚边钻洞、夜间活动、吃虫子。马斯克顺着这个说:所以外面那些啮齿类动物都有希望,只要坚持写作业,总有一天能上火星。这句是玩笑,玩笑里藏着真实的时间尺度:从鼩鼱到马斯克,中间隔了上亿年。
二叠纪那次,活下来的物种大多"不像人"
话题从恐龙转到地球史上最惨的一次灭绝。马斯克说,二叠纪大灭绝是真的难熬,超过 90% 的物种消失了。
然后他补了一个常被忽略的细节:90% 这个数字还没说完整个故事。因为剩下那部分物种里,很大比例是真菌、海绵这类东西。
他在这里连着问了几个问题,语气是开玩笑的,逻辑却很干净:
- 你是海绵吗?那你大概没事。
- 你是蘑菇吗?你喜欢待在黑暗里,靠腐烂的动植物残骸过活?那也没事。
- 你是人类?那你完蛋了。
这段对话的锋利之处在于它换了个视角。人类习惯把自己当成地球的主人,把所有灭绝事件读成"生命的灾难"。可对那些靠腐败有机物为生的物种来说,大灭绝是一次盛宴。生态位空了,尸体遍地,它们反而繁荣。
地球历史上不止一次灭绝,是很多次。马斯克提到地球曾经整个冻成雪球,也曾经热到难以想象,大陆一直在漂移,超级火山喷发过不止一轮。这些都有地质记录支撑。
所以"人类会不会被灭绝"这个问题,地质史已经给过答案:可能性一直存在,只是时间没到。真正没答案的是另一件事,人类能不能在那之前把自己复制一份出去。
费米悖论:外星人在哪
罗根把话题拉回"大过滤器"这个词,请马斯克解释。
马斯克的起点是费米悖论。这个问题问出来只有一句:外星人在哪?
宇宙的年龄和尺度都摆在那里。银河系有一千多亿颗恒星,可观测宇宙里的星系数量以千亿计,行星数量比恒星还多。按概率算,文明不该只有我们一家。可我们什么都没听到,什么都没看到。
马斯克说,这件事只有两种可能,而且两种都同样吓人。
第一种,宇宙里有很多文明,我们只是还没碰上。这种情况下,别的文明看我们,大概跟看虫害差不多。他用了《星河战队》(Starship Troopers)的梗:某个高等文明路过太阳系,看了一眼说,这颗星球以前挺干净的,现在长了一堆虫子,去熏一下。就像我们处理白蚁一样,不打招呼,不讲道理,直接喷药。
第二种,宇宙里一个文明都没有。那我们得问:为什么没有?是不是所有文明在走到星际阶段之前,都会被某种东西干掉?
这就是大过滤器。这个概念最早由经济学家罗宾·汉森(Robin Hanson)在 1996 年提出,指的是生命从最原始的状态走到星际文明之间,横着一道或者几道极难跨过的坎。人类现在站在坎的哪一侧,没人知道。可能我们已经过了最难的关,也可能最难的那关还在前面。
这两种可能哪边更让人难受,其实不好说。第一种意味着人类的地位很尴尬,我们在这个宇宙里既不被需要,也不被尊重。第二种意味着宇宙给所有文明设了一个绝望的天花板,谁也别想过去。
马斯克把火星自给自足直接放进了这个框架。他的意思很清楚:在地球之外建立一个能独立存活的文明,是人类绕过这道坎的方式。哪怕地球这边彻底完蛋,物种还能续上。
他对"外星人"这件事的关注度是零
罗根问他,你经常想外星人这件事吗。
马斯克的回答很干脆:零,完全不。
这个答案跟他在前面聊星际殖民的热情形成了奇怪的落差。罗根也追问了一句,你都在想行星际旅行了,居然不想外星人?马斯克说,如果他们真出现了,那挺好,我会第一时间知道。
他在这里讲了一个判断标准,值得单独拎出来。
如果有人跟我说,你看这个外星人目击事件。我的回答是:这证据的质量,至少得比 7-Eleven 便利店或者 ATM 机的监控画面强吧。(马斯克)
他的理由很实在:今天造假太容易。一张模糊的照片,一段抖动的视频,成本几乎为零。举证责任在目击者那边。
他说,如果真看到证据,他会是第一个跳起来喊"有外星人"的人。在那之前,这件事不值得花时间。
他还补了一句更扎心的观察:有些人研究外星人研究了一辈子,拿出来的东西,除了一堆好听的故事,几乎没有别的。
什么样的证据才能让他改口
罗根试着找了个反例:考古学家满世界挖,万一挖出点什么呢?
马斯克接得很快。他说,如果在一座金字塔正中间挖出一个一英寸见方的钛立方体,那外星人这事就算定了。因为那个年代做不出这种东西,钛的冶炼和加工需要一整套工业能力,连计算机都不需要出场,光有这台机器本身就是证据。
然后他自己把这条路堵死了:迄今为止,所有考古发现都跟当时的技术水平吻合。没有一件东西是那个时代造不出来的。挖出来的每一件器物,都能对应上当时的工具、工艺和材料。
这个标准很严格,也很公平。它要的证据其实特别简单:一件当时的文明绝无可能制造的东西。找不到,就等于没有证据。
Tic Tac 事件:整段对话里唯一让他认真听的案例
罗根抛出了一个具体案例,2004 年圣地亚哥外海的那次目击,代号"Tic Tac"(嘀嗒糖),因为飞行器外形像一颗白色的薄荷糖。
当事人是海军战斗机飞行员大卫·弗拉沃(David Fravor)中校。罗根提到莱克斯·弗里德曼(Lex Fridman)做过一期很长的访谈,他自己也采访过弗拉沃。
这段描述的细节密度很高,值得原样保留:
- 雷达追踪到一个目标,从六万英尺以上的高度下降到接近海平面,用时不到一秒。
- 外形像一颗嘀嗒糖,没有任何可见的推进装置,没有尾焰,没有机翼。
- 它锁定了战斗机的雷达,同时主动干扰了己方的追踪系统。
- 随后它出现在战斗机预定汇合的坐标点上,那个点距离原位置几十英里,用时几秒钟。
参与这件事的不止一个人。马斯克说,在那片海域执行任务的海军人员说他们遇到过好几次,谁也不知道那是什么,也不知道该怎么办。
罗根补充了后续:2017 年《纽约时报》发过一篇报道,把这件事和另外几起类似事件放在一起讲。后来国会通过了相关条款,塞进 COVID 救济法案里,要求情报机构在 180 天内把所有掌握的信息交出来。罗根的评价很直白:连政客都想搞清楚这堆东西到底是什么。
马斯克听完这些,反应很有意思。他没有否认,也没有顺着往下猜。他说的是:如果真有外星人,我应该会知道。罗根追问,你确定他们会告诉你?马斯克说,我大概是会被第一批通知的人之一。
这个回答算不上自信,更像一种基于位置的判断。他造火箭、发卫星、跟军方和 NASA 打交道,如果天上真有什么被确认的东西,信息流经他的概率不低。
但他也没把话说死。他说,如果这些飞行器真是外星文明,那它们的行为相当克制。一个能瞬间跨越星际的文明,真想公开露面,方式简单得很,降落在时代广场中心,走下舷梯,挥挥手就行。或者在洛杉矶市中心上空悬停十分钟。所有人都会信。它们没这么做,说明它们要么不存在,要么在刻意保持低调。
这里有一层逻辑值得留意。目击事件越多,越无法解释,反而越说明这个文明在隐藏。一个刻意隐藏的文明,你永远不会拿到它愿意让你拿到的证据。所以这条线追下去没有终点,它天然是个陷阱。
一百万年,够殖民整个银河系
话题绕回宏观尺度。马斯克给了一个时间估算。
假设没有新物理,飞船的速度上限就是亚光速,那么一百万年之内,殖民整个银河系完全做得到,顺手还能摸到几个邻近星系。
路径他也说了:先在火星建基地,把火星当成跳板,从一个恒星系统跳到下一个,一处一处铺开。以几千年的周期往外推,整片星系就铺满了。
一百万年听起来漫长。放在宇宙尺度上,这是一瞬间。银河系的年龄超过一百亿年,如果别的文明比我们早出现哪怕一千万年,按这个速度,它们早该铺满我们能看见的每一个角落。我们抬头看天,什么都没看到。
这个反差,就是费米悖论让人后背发凉的地方。宇宙给了那么长的时间,那么大的空间,那么多次机会,结果一片安静。
为什么必须走:物种保险
罗根问,这件事是不是必须做。
马斯克的回答里没有多少浪漫色彩。他说,如果人类文明想长期存活,这是必须的。地球上的物种太脆弱,扛不住自然灾害,也扛不住自己犯的错。所以从物种的角度看,我们得离开。
他特意强调了"物种"这个词。他关心的东西很具体:一条延续几亿年的族谱能不能继续往下写。某一代人过得好不好,有没有荣耀感,不在他的计算里。这个视角有点冷,也很诚实。
回过头看这整段对话,逻辑是闭合的:
- 地球历史上灭绝事件出现过很多次,不是一两次,是很多次。
- 每一次都有大量物种消失,活下来的是那些碰巧占据了对的生态位的物种。
- 人类没有理由认为自己一定留在名单上。
- 唯一能改变这个概率的办法,是在地球之外建立一个能自持的文明。
- 这个文明的最低标准,是地球断供之后还能活。
- 所以火星计划真正要解决的是闭环。抵达火星只是第一步。
这条推理链没有一处依赖情绪。它不需要你相信人类伟大,也不需要你觉得星空浪漫。它只需要你承认一件事:地球会出事,这属于时间问题。
而马斯克给出的数字也很清醒。他说建设一个真正的火星文明要花很长时间,几十年不够,几百年也未必够。他自己承认这件事的难度。在他看来,难度不构成不做的理由,只构成早点开始的理由。
如果只记住一件事
整段对话里,最容易被误读的是"火星殖民"这个词。它听起来像开拓、像冒险、像人类精神的延伸。马斯克本人谈这件事的时候,用的词更像工程师:冗余、备份、故障隔离、单点失效。
他脑子里那幅图,大概是一台跑了四十五亿年的机器,只有一份拷贝,从来没做过完整备份。硬盘上任何一处坏道,都是永久损失。
在火星上建第二份拷贝,成本高得离谱,时间长到看不见尽头。可一旦建起来,物种的存续概率就从"全有或者全无",变成了"还有一条路"。
这就是他那句话的全部含义:门槛在"地球沉默之后那边还有没有人能回话",跟"有多少人住在火星"关系不大。
- 判断任何火星计划的时间表,把注意力从发射次数和火箭回收上移开,去看"本地闭环生产"推进到了哪一步。氧气、水、推进剂、建材、备件,一样一样数,看哪一样还要从地球运。
- 看到 UFO 或 UAP 的新闻,先问三个问题:原始传感器数据在哪?记录设备的分辨率是多少?有没有独立的第二套探测系统交叉验证?三样都缺,就当故事听。
- 遇到"某地挖出超越时代工艺的器物"这类说法,直接去查主流考古学界的回应。绝大多数情况下,答案都是当时的工艺水平完全做得到。
- 关注二叠纪、白垩纪这些灭绝事件的科普材料,比关注任何末日预言都有用。你会得到一个具体的、可比较的时间尺度感,而这正是判断"该不该备份"的唯一依据。
- 读马斯克这类访谈,把他讲的每句话拆成两半:哪一半是工程判断,哪一半是价值判断。前者可以查证,后者得你自己决定要不要接受。
- 如果你对星际殖民感兴趣,从读地球的灭绝史开始,先搞清楚为什么走,再研究怎么走。
- 遇到"要多久"这类问题,先问清楚问的是哪件事。抵达火星大概按年算,闭环自给按几十年算,形成一个真正能独立存活的文明按世纪算。三个时间尺度混在一起谈,讨论必然失焦。
0:00The Girogan experience. How much time before there's regular travel back and forth to Mars? Roughly. Like a real civilization on Mars. Well, I think it's going to take a while to build a real civilization. The real threshold that really matters is, for getting past the Great Filter,
0:32filter is do we have enough resources on Mars such that if the if the spaceships from Earth stop coming to survive, yeah. So I can only be just missing one little thing you'd be like, you're on a long sea voyage and the only thing you're missing is vitamin T. It's a lot good. It's not only a matter of time, you
0:57know, yeah, and then it's gonna be curtains. So you got to have all the things necessary to sustain civilization on Mars. And the reason that the shift from a stopcoming could be World War III or could be due to a slow decline of civilization. So civilization here on Earth could end with a bang or a wimper.
1:20Or natural disasters. Yeah, asteroid impacts. Yeah, that would be the bang category. But it could be like a whole series of things. Like, so what killed the dinosaurs? Well, it wasn't just one thing. It was like a whole bunch of things happened in a row. And while they could have taken any one of those things,
1:41they had like three things happen. And no dinosaurs. Which is kind of amazing that crocodiles are still here. Yeah. Those fuckers. Well, crocodiles live on a decayed meat. They love rotten meat. And so in any kind of disaster situation, there's a lot of dead creatures. And the crocodiles love it.
2:06So that's why they're around. The crocodiles and bugs and mushrooms. And shrews. Shrews, yeah. Which is why we're here. Yeah, exactly. Oh, great, great, great, great, great. Grandparents were shrews. What a strange thing to come from. So there's hope for all you rodents out there.
2:26Yeah. one day you can go to Mars. Just keep doing your homework. Absolutely. So so there'll be the you say the great filter. What did you mean by that? well, so there's something called like the Fermi Paradox of like where are the aliens? Yeah. So where are the aliens? and I think it was call
2:53that's saying that said, like, there either are a lot of aliens or none. And the, either they're equally terrifying. If there are a lot of aliens, well, I mean, the invasion ship slash, you know, bug infestation, just, you know, like, the Starship, tuber style? Well, yeah, it's like an anion civilization.
3:25Might just view us as like a bug infestation. Right. It's like, hey, we left that planet. It was fine. Now it's got a bunch of bugs. Just go fumigate it, you know? Like, we fumigate a house. That's certainly possible. And then, but if there are no aliens, well, could it be that all civilizations are just destroyed before they become interstellar?
3:45You know, so. And I want to be clear, like, to the best of my knowledge, there is no evidence for alien life on Earth. There's no evidence for alien life. There's no direct evidence for alien life. No, and if somebody says, oh, what about this alien for sighting or whatever? I'm like, listen, it's got to be at least as good as a 7-Eleven or ATM cam.
4:14OK? It's like if somebody's got at least like an iPhone one level camera like something, you know The problem with that is it's just too easy to fake things today, too Yeah, sure I look I've at least try hard and they're in faking are you familiar with Commander David Frabors account of the tic-tac UFO that he encountered off of the coast of San Diego go. Lex, you know, Lex, Lex Friedman. Yeah. Lex Friedman interviewed him on his podcast
4:44and I interviewed him as well. And if you ever get a chance to listen to Lex's conversation with him, it's really excellent. But this guy is a naval fighter pilot and talked about this thing that they tracked on radar that went from more than 60,000 feet above sea level to one foot and less than a second, shaped like a tic tac, no visible sign of propulsion,
5:06locked radar, actively jammed their tracking systems, and then went to their predetermined point that the fighter jet was supposed to scramble to, went to it 30 miles away in a couple of seconds. They have no idea how it did it, they don't know what it is. These guys that were working for the Navy,
5:29off the coast said they encountered them several times, they didn't know what they were, they didn't know what to do. to have just different photos or something. They do they have video of it. Okay. They have video of it. They have there's you ever see the New York Times article that came out in 2017 about this stuff?
5:46No. Yeah, there was a New York Times article in 2017 that was detailing this and there's a couple of there's a couple other different sightings that were very similar. They were trying to figure out what these things were and why and it was also in the COVID relief package that the CIA was supposed
6:03to release, yeah, the politicians are trying to figure out what all this shit is. And so they try to get them to release all the information they have within 180 days. Honestly, I think I would know if they're aliens. I would hope so. That's why I'm asking you. No, I be jumping on that.
6:21You should watch that conversation with Lex. Like, here's the thing. Do you think that they would want us to know? Or do you think they would just be observing and making sure we don't blow ourselves up? Would be a few of the real civilizations. I don't know man, they're real civilizations.
6:37They sure are subtle. I mean if they wanted us to know obviously they could just show up and walk down Main Street. You know, okay I'm an alien, check me out. He has my spaceship, I just land in the middle of Times Square. I'll be like, okay. Or hover over downtown LA. Yeah. Yeah.
6:55We were like, okay we believe you. So whatever they are very subtle very subtle the aliens How often do you think about it? I'm zero zero even though you're thinking about interplanetary travel you don't really think about aliens No, I mean if they show up. I'm like great. Okay. No, this isn't your information, but we
7:19What an interesting way of putting it. This is new information. Listen your information like where are you guys up till now? So anyway, listen, I'm, if I see some evidence for aliens, I'll be like, I'll be the first to be like, ah, aliens, you know. Right, then you'll investigate, but until then you think it's kind of a waste of time.
7:40Yeah. Yeah. It definitely seems like a waste of time. If nothing's happened so far, you think about all the people that have been researching aliens for their whole life and they have very little to show for it. Well, you know, there's other than cool stories. Yeah, I mean we have archaeologists going all over the world looking at things
8:01You know with us this the people like if we were to find something like let's say like a cube of titanium Just like a one inch cube of titanium see in the middle of the permit. I feel like aliens for sure There's no way they could have made a titanium back then. No, there's no way. They that's hard
8:19That's all one little didn't even need a computer like a computer would be like hey, well computers because they didn't have computers back then, so it must be aliens. But even just some advanced metallurgy, anything. Like, we can say anything like that. Right, nothing like that that we could point to that we can't do.
8:40Everything that we found archeologically is consistent with the time, the technology they had at that time. Archeologically, yes. So you're just talking about old stuff. Yeah, just throughout history, it's not like, like, like, a alien's visitor, there'd be something buried somewhere, I think.
8:59We haven't seen anything. So anyway, maybe they were aliens, but they're very subtle. If they're just very, they're being pretty shy. So far as we can tell, there's none. So Nor are we seeing signals from any other solar system or anything like that. So now, and the things that on a galactic timescale,
9:25even with sub-light travel, you could absolutely colonize the whole galaxy, even some of the neighboring galaxies. So if you gave, if you said a million years with current, with, and say there's no new physics, could you colonize the galaxy in a million years? Absolutely, the entire galaxy.
9:44So you would start with Mars, build bases on Mars, and use Mars to jump off to all these other planets, set up places there and over thousands of years easily. Yeah, kind of like, you know, from one solar system to the next and yeah. That, it seems like that's imperative. Like that has to happen if the human civilization is going to survive.
10:05Because our planet is just, we're too subject to natural disasters and our own folly and if the species is going to survive, we kind of have to escape. It's mostly about the species. I mean, there have been some real doozies of like, you know, massive meteors and super volcanoes and continents and we were all over the place and Earth's been a snowball and
10:27super hot. But if you read like the geological history of Earth, it's like very long and complicated. So and then there have been so many extinction events, not like just a few. Yeah, I mean the the Permian extinction event that was a real rough one where it's like well over 90% of
10:49all species died out and I didn't tell the whole story because a huge chunk of the remaining species were fungi and You know like sponges and stuff like that, you know, but like if you if are you are you a sponge? You probably don't okay. They're still around Are you a mushroom? Do you like being in the dark and feasting on dead, dead, dead,
11:15plant and animal matter? Okay. But if you're like a human, you're screwed. Catch new episodes of the Joe Rogan Experience for free only on Spotify. Watch back catalog JRE videos on Spotify, including clips, easily, seamlessly switch between video and audio experience. On Spotify, you can listen to the JRE in the background while using other apps
11:39and can download episodes to save on data costs all for free. Spotify is absolutely free. You don't have to have a premium account to watch new JRE episodes. You just need to search for the JRE on your Spotify app. Go to Spotify Now to get this full episode of the Joe Rogan experience.
所以你必须拥有在火星上维持文明所需的一切。
So you got to have all the things necessary to sustain civilization on Mars.
所以地球上的文明可能轰然终结,也可能悄然消亡。
So civilization here on Earth could end with a bang or a wimper.
那么,但如果没有外星人,会不会所有文明都在成为星际文明之前就被毁灭了?
And then, but if there are no aliens, well, could it be that all civilizations are just destroyed before they become interstellar?
我是说,如果他们想让我们知道,显然他们可以直接出现,走在主街上。
I mean if they wanted us to know obviously they could just show up and walk down Main Street.
我们考古发现的一切都与那个时代、他们当时拥有的技术相符。
Everything that we found archeologically is consistent with the time, the technology they had at that time.
所以如果你说,用当前(技术),假设没有新物理学,你能在一百万年内殖民银河系吗?绝对可以,整个银河系。
So if you gave, if you said a million years with current, with, and say there's no new physics, could you colonize the galaxy in a million years? Absolutely, the entire galaxy.
因为我们的星球,我们太容易受到自然灾害和我们自身愚蠢的影响,如果物种要生存下去,我们某种程度上必须逃离。
Because our planet is just, we're too subject to natural disasters and our own folly and if the species is going to survive, we kind of have to escape.
所以,然后有过非常多的灭绝事件,不是只有几次。
So and then there have been so many extinction events, not like just a few.
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 视频原始视频文件
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版