2022 年,金融时报问马斯克,你打算让特朗普回到 Twitter 吗。他的回答是:当初永久封禁特朗普,是个错误。
理由值得细看。封掉一个人,不等于让他闭嘴。特朗普去了 Truth Social,还带走了一大块右翼听众。声音没有消失,只是从一座所有人能同时看见的广场,搬进了回声更响的小房间。马斯克的原话是,这“最终可能比只有一个让所有人辩论的论坛更糟”。
这场访谈里让人反复回味的判断不止这一句。从 Twitter 该长什么样,到火星时间表,到自动驾驶为什么值得挨官司,再到为什么他认为“诱导需求”这个词蠢得离谱。下面按话题拆开讲。
“最不坏的公共广场”,以及它为什么不够好
马斯克给 Twitter 的定位是:目前最好、或者说最不坏的公共广场,一个让国内外交换想法的论坛。但他说,它本可以在这件事上做得好得多。
怎么算好得多,他列了几条。
第一条是清理虚假影响力。机器人、诈骗、垃圾信息,一个实体操控十万个账号,都是在制造假声量。他说 Twitter 在这件事上必须做得好得多。
第二条是建立信任。他的方案简单到有点粗暴:把算法开源,直接扔到 GitHub 上,问一句“有人想改吗,请便”。
你真正想要的是透明度,用透明度来建立信任。(马斯克)
第三条是透明的人工干预。任何针对推文或账号的调整,都应该被明示:推特的人对你的账号或这条推文做了什么,写清楚。用户不该坐在那里猜,为什么这条没人看,那条突然火了。他承认现在的机制“太随机”。
一座总部在旧金山的广场,天然带着左倾
他直接说,Twitter 目前有很强的左倾,原因是它base在旧金山。
他不认为那里的人存心要左倾。很多人只是觉得自己的立场挺温和。但环境本身极左,站在这个环境里看,温和就成了偏移。
后果是,这座广场在美国其他地区、以及世界其他地方,都不容易建立起信任。一个公共广场要成立,必须不偏不倚。
我说过,一场胜利的标志是,最右的 10% 和最左的 10% 同样愤怒。这不会让你收获掌声,你只是在把愤怒调平。(马斯克)
订单排到一年后,他担心的不是需求
有人问,你在 Twitter 上做那些会得罪人的事,会不会波及特斯拉。
他的回答是,他确信能卖掉所有造出来的车。目前下订单的等待时间长得离谱。问题不在需求,在产能。
他讲得更具体:就算没有供应链问题,特斯拉的需求也早就超过产能,现在超得离谱。公司可能限制、甚至停止接受某段时间之后的订单,因为有些交付时间已经排到了一年后。
客户的不满在于拿不到车,而不是想不想买。我基本不考虑怎么刺激需求,我大量考虑的是产能、工程和供应链。(马斯克)
被问到 Twitter 这笔交易有多确定,他把话说得很克制。股东投票还没举行,Twitter 连用于投票的委托声明都还没提交,中间还有待解决的问题。所以“这还不是一桩已完成的交易”。最顺利的情况下,也要两三个月。
至于拿个人资产去为这笔交易融资、万一失败会不会连累特斯拉和 SpaceX,他没给保证,只说事情还没到那一步。
永久封禁:罕见、有例外,但不能成为常规武器
关于特朗普,马斯克把它拆成一个更普遍的问题:Twitter 该不该有永久封禁。
他的立场是,永久封禁该极其罕见,只用于那些根本没有合法性的账号,比如机器人、垃圾信息、诈骗。他和杰克·多尔西(Jack Dorsey)聊过,两人看法一致。
具体到特朗普,他说当初的封禁不对,是个错误。因为这一举动疏远了这个国家的一大部分人,而且最终并没有让特朗普失去声音。他去了 Truth Social,右翼的一大块也跟着过去了。
主持人追问:就算他在国会大厦事件里鼓动了人群,有人还带着绞索,你依然认为移除他是错的?
他的回答是,错的推文该删、该隐藏,临时封禁也合适,但不该永久封禁。永久封禁从根子上破坏的是 Twitter 作为城市广场的可信度:如果每个人都能发声这件事不成立,广场就不成立了。
他用词很重:这在道德上是个坏决定,而且愚蠢到极点。
还有一层他没绕开。特朗普公开说过不会回 Twitter,只留在 Truth Social。马斯克说,这正是他想讲而没讲清楚的点:把特朗普从 Twitter 上封掉,并没有终结他的声音,反而在右翼内部放大了它。这就是为什么他判断这个决定“道德上错、而且蠢得直接”。
当然他也补了一句:他现在还没拥有 Twitter,所以这不是一件“一定会发生”的事。如果交易完成,他的处理方式是撤销永久封禁,但保留另一套工具:删帖、限流、临时禁言,都在选项里。
2000 万辆是算出来的,不是喊出来的
2030 年做到年产 2000 万辆,这个数字常被引用。马斯克在访谈里反复强调一件事:这是愿望,不是承诺,更不是“死在这座山头上”的誓言。
数字的来路他说得很清楚。全球大约有 20 亿辆轿车和卡车。要在可持续能源和电动化上真正留下痕迹,每年至少得替换掉 1% 的车队。1% 乘以 20 亿,就是 2000 万辆。
他顺带提了一个参照:特斯拉的年增速比地球历史上任何大型制成品都快,上一个最快的纪录是福特 T 型车。如果这个增速能维持,2000 万辆是能到的。
但他也说,走到今天这一步有多难,走到 2000 万辆就有多难,大概是一比一。这件事可能成,也可能不成。判断依据他也给了:看接下来发布的产品,自己评估这个目标现不现实。
锂不缺,缺的是把矿石变成电池级材料的设备
被问到最大的不确定性,他先点了原材料。锂的供给可能在三年左右出现紧张,正极材料也有压力。正极有两条主线,镍和磷酸铁锂。
然后他讲了一段“冷知识”。地球质量的 32% 是铁,30% 是氧。所以铁根本不缺。磷酸盐稍微麻烦一点,但也算常见。锂同样到处都是,不是什么稀有元素。
真正卡住的是设备。把铁和磷变成电池级磷酸铁,把镍变成电池级镍,采矿、尤其精炼的产能,归根到底是设备。他认为最大的单点约束,就是那套把矿石转化成电池级材料的装备。
他还顺带纠正了一下外界对这个目标的误读:别把 2000 万辆当成某种宏大承诺,好像特斯拉要为此殉道。它就是个 aspiration(愿望)。公司的目标只有一个,加速可持续能源的到来。多造车、多造储能电池,都是为了这件事。
可持续能源的三根柱子,和一根必须补上的短板
他把可持续能源的未来拆成三块:电动交通、固定式电池包,以及太阳能、风能、地热、水电这类可持续发电。
风能和太阳能有个天生的毛病:间歇性。太阳不照的时候得有东西把电存下来,这就是固定式电池包的位置。
至于特斯拉的目标算不算达成,他的回答分两半。让整个汽车行业转向电动化,这部分做到了,而且这本来就是目标的一部分。起步的时候,传统车企在这个方向上什么都没做,长时间里干脆否认电动车的概念,直到特斯拉开始抢走市场份额,他们才改了主意。
更大的目标没有完成。所以他还会留在特斯拉,“只要我还能有用”。
火星:3 到 5 年送星舰,本十年内送人
他描述自己做选择的标准,是尽量挑那组最可能让未来变好的行动,同时尽量别“用善意铺成通往地狱的路”。
按这个标准,特斯拉是加速可持续能源,SpaceX 是把生命延伸到地球之外,让人类成为多行星物种,星链则是给世界上网络服务最差的人群补上连接。
火星的时间表,他给得不硬:星舰大概 3 到 5 年能以粗糙的方式抵达火星。如果这一步成了,本十年结束前有可能送载人任务上去。
中国长期占 25% 到 30%,短期内不再建新厂
中国市场的重要性,他给了一个长期比例:大约 25% 到 30%,其余世界占四分之三。
有人追问,中国封了 Twitter,你买下 Twitter 之后,会不会有风险,比如中国拿这个来干扰特斯拉在中国的运营。他的回答很直接:没有看到任何这方面的迹象。
上海工厂的规则问题,他讲了一段往事。中国政府多次邀请他去建厂。他的条件是,不会做一家本地持股 51% 的合资厂。如果规则愿意改,而且不只为他一家改,为所有人改,那就往前走。后来规则改了,这件事到目前为止很成功,政府也很满意。
近期没有在中国再建新厂的计划。上海会扩产,但产能的重心放在刚完成的两座新厂:柏林和得州奥斯汀。
上海封控那段时间,他说和中国政府有过沟通,封控在快速解除,未来几周不会是大问题。
他过去对封锁的不满,有个具体指向。加州阿拉米达县,北美其他所有汽车工厂都获准复工,只有特斯拉不行。他说这没有依据,是随意的、不公平的,原因是特斯拉恰好位于那个县。他对自己工厂的防疫做法有信心,觉得比谁都做得好。
自动驾驶:从局部最大值里爬出来了
他承认自己过去对自动驾驶的预测有落空的时候。这件事有很多“假黎明”,你以为快到了,进度却开始走平。先是线性,然后看起来像对数曲线,逐渐变缓,因为你困在一个自己没意识到的局部最大值里。
现在他认为已经不在那个坑里了。当然他也说自己可能判断错,但按他最好的估计,今年能到比人类驾驶更安全的水平。
我们不只是要做到人类的安全水平,而是远远超过。最终按受伤概率衡量,大概会比人类安全 10 倍。(马斯克)
怎么验证?他建议去看 beta 项目的实测,或者看参与者拍的视频,看进度曲线有多陡。
被救下的人不知道自己被救过,死去的人家属会起诉你
有人把问题问得很直接:那些在事故中死去的人,算不算通向更高安全水平的代价。
他先纠正一个前提。特斯拉从来没有说过 Autopilot 不需要注意力。这一点被反复强调到令人厌烦,不确认需要监督,你连开都开不了。所以“先承诺车能自己开、后来没做到”这个说法,他说完全不是事实。
然后是他从一开始就知道的事:被 Autopilot 或自动驾驶救下的人,不会知道自己被救过。他们不知道自己本来会撞车,本来会撞到行人或骑车的人。
全球每年大约有 100 万人死于交通事故,重伤的也许有 1000 万。哪怕救下其中 90%,剩下 10% 里死去的人,家属照样会起诉。
我相信善的现实胜过善的表象。对那些宁愿要善的表象、不要善的现实的人,我完全不屑。(马斯克)
他的结论是:如果相信受伤概率真的在下降,那就做正确的事,然后等着被起诉。
滑板车很危险,专利全部免费,大众做得最好
更小、更便宜的车,市场会往哪走。他提了一句:滑板车非常危险,不建议任何人骑。滑板车和汽车之间如果发生争执,输的永远是滑板车。
关于向其他车厂授权平台,他提到特斯拉几年前就把专利全部开源了,谁都能免费用。他们申请专利,只是为了防止别人用专利雷区挡住电动车的路。后来他想明白了,特斯拉不会真的去起诉用自己专利的人。
他认为传统车企自己能解决电动化,这在今天不是根本性的难题。真正值得授权的是特斯拉的 Autopilot 全自动驾驶,那能救很多命。不过他说还得再证明自己一年左右,之后也许会有车厂来谈授权,他们非常开放。
被问到哪家电动车公司最让人印象深刻,他点了大众。大众不是初创公司,但从电动车的角度看,某种程度上可以当成初创公司来看。中国会跑出一批很强的公司,那里有大量聪明、拼命的人,而且信奉制造业。他用了句话形容:他们不只燃烧午夜 12 点的油,他们会燃烧凌晨 3 点的油,干脆不离开工厂。而在美国,人们想的是怎么完全不去上班。
隧道被低估了,“诱导需求”是他听过最蠢的说法之一
他认为隧道被严重低估。有人拿纽约的罗伯特·摩西举例:修了一堆高速公路,本想解决拥堵,结果只是带来更多拥堵。隧道怎么避免同一个结局,而且还更贵。
他对“诱导需求”这个概念的评价很不客气。
如果多修路只会增加车流,那我们把路拆了,车流是不是就减少了?真拆了,你看会不会有人上街。(马斯克)
他给的真正解释是维度错配。大城市里,人住在三维的高楼里,进出却要挤在一张二维的路网上,而且大家的出发和到达时间还差不多。这就是交通的配方。
解法是把路网也变成三维。往上或者往下都行,层数按需要加到把车流压到可以忽略为止。拉斯维加斯已经有了概念验证,一条从会展中心通往 strip 的隧道,接下来会连到所有酒店和机场。他说最初在克拉克县和拉斯维加斯市投票时只是险胜,等议员们亲自坐过一次,扩张到全城的方案是全票通过。
至于 VTOL,也就是垂直起降飞行器,他不看好。他刻意不叫它们“飞行汽车”,因为大多数根本不在路上跑。
问题一是噪音和下洗气流。一架小无人机放大到那种体量,起降时能制造多大的动静和气浪。满城飞起来,像一窝超级吵的巨型蜜蜂。
问题二是天气。大风、大雪、雨夹雪,飞不了就是全城停摆。
问题三是头顶安全。有人没好好保养他的飞行器,掉个轮子下来砸到你头上,这画面大多数人不会觉得舒服。再加上陌生人整天在你家后院上空盯着看。
这些是他认为 VTOL 成不了的原因。
特斯拉没有债务,现金很多,收购车厂“极不可能”
被问到有没有什么让他担心特斯拉的未来,他的回答是:特斯拉没有债务,现金很多。上海疫情限制是短期波折,未来的前景极其光明,会产出巨额自由现金流。
会不会拿现金去买另一家车厂,无论老牌还是新公司。他说极不可能。
买矿业公司呢。他说不排除。不是为了买矿而买矿,是为了解决加速能源转型路上的限制。如果那是唯一的路,就会去做。采矿、精炼,或者直接买下一家矿业公司,只要他们相信自己能显著改变那家公司的轨迹。
关于会不会把所有业务装进一个控股集团,他说看不到太多好处,股东结构不同,目标也不同。但有些人才是跨公司共享的,比如先进材料团队,很多人愿意加入的条件是同时做火箭和汽车。这两块不竞争,属于不同的竞争区间。对真正顶尖的工程师来说,钱不是问题,问题是项目够不够有意思。
把这场访谈从头到尾串起来,有一条主线:他反复在区分“表象”和“现实”。Twitter 要的不是看起来中立,是两端都真的能说话。Autopilot 要的不是看起来安全,是受伤概率真的下降。隧道要的不是看起来像在解决拥堵,是维度真的匹配上了。这个标准不讨喜,但它至少在逻辑上是自洽的。
下面这些判断,可以直接搬到自己的决策里用。
- 判断一个平台、一家媒体、一个社区是否中立,别听它自述,看两端反应。只有一端在骂,说明天平是歪的;两端同样愤怒,才叫平衡。
- 想封掉一个刺头之前,先算一笔账:封了之后他会去哪里,那边的声量会不会更大。封堵往往不解决问题,只是把问题挪到一个你看不见的地方继续发酵。
- 听一个目标时,分清 aspiration(愿望)和 promise(承诺)。愿望可以公开谈、可以失败;承诺要兑现。马斯克自己把 2000 万辆归到前一类,别人转述时常常归到后一类。
- 评估一个宏大目标,先找分母。20 亿辆车、每年换 1%、等于 2000 万辆,三个数字摆出来,目标立刻从口号变成算术题。
- 遇到供给瓶颈,先分清是元素稀缺还是加工设备稀缺。铁、锂、磷都不稀缺,卡住的是把矿石变成电池级材料的产线。绝大多数“资源不够”的焦虑,最后都落在加工能力上。
- 做长期技术预测时,留意进度曲线是不是在变平。线性增长突然看起来像对数曲线,往往意味着你困在一个没意识到的局部最大值里,而不是遇到了暂时困难。
- 如果你在做的事会让一部分人受益、另一部分人受损,提前接受一个事实:受益的人往往不知道自己受益了,受损的人一定会来找你。要不要做,取决于你信不信那个概率在真的下降。
- 判断一个基础设施方案值不值,先看它有没有匹配城市的维度。三维的建筑配二维的路网,拥堵是算术结果,不是管理问题。往上叠或者往下挖,都是把维度补齐。
- 评估 VTOL、飞行汽车这类新出行方案,别只看技术能不能飞。噪音、天气、坠落风险、隐私,四个约束任何一个过不了,规模化就无从谈起。
0:03Let me ask you to put your product development hat on. And if you pair Twitter all the way back, what is it, and what do you think it can be in 10 years' time? Well, what I've said is that I think Twitter is currently the best or, looked at another way, the least bad public square.
0:33A forum for the exchange of ideas nationally and internationally. But I think it could be a lot better at that. In order to be better at that, it needs to really get rid of the bots, and the scams, and spammers, and basically anyone trying to create sort of fake influence on the site by whereas one person or one entity operating a hundred thousand accounts.
1:04Or obviously scammers are not good. And Twitter really needs to do a much better job at that. It also needs to build trust, more trust with users. I think the way to do that is by open sourcing the algorithm so everyone can see how the algorithm works and can suggest improvements and changes.
1:27I would literally just put the Twitter algorithm on GitHub and say like, hey, anyone want to suggest changes to this? Please go ahead. And just you really want transparency to build trust. And then any sort of adjustments to tweets or any human intervention with any account on Twitter
1:51should be highlighted as a Twitter person took the following action with your account or with this tweet so that you're not sort of sitting there in the dark wondering, why did this tweet not get any attention? Or why did this one get a lot of attention? It's far too random. And then I think Twitter needs to be much more even-handed.
2:13It currently has a strong left bias because it's based in San Francisco. I don't think the people there necessarily intend, or at least have some of them don't intend, to have a left bias. It's just from their perspective, it seems moderate. But they're just coming at it from an environment
2:34that is very far left. So but then this fails to build trust in the rest of the United States and also perhaps in other parts of the world because Twitter needs to be even-handed and be... I think I said publicly, a victory would be that the most far right 10 per cent and the most far left 10 per cent are equally upset.
3:03I don't think this is a situation where you're going to get necessarily a lot of praise. You're just going to balance the anger. So how do you, because people will automatically associate you with Tesla and you with Twitter. Is there any risk in your mind that the actions that you're going to take at Twitter, which you've admitted freely will upset some people, potentially lead to a commercial impact on Tesla?
3:33I'm confident that we will be able to sell all the cars we can make. I mean, currently, the lead time for ordering a Tesla is ridiculously low. Our issue is not demand. It is production. But that's at the moment because of the global supply chains and the chip shortages. That's less around electric car demand, which we are expecting to go absolutely through the roof.
4:00And you obviously have very ambitious targets for that at Tesla. Yeah, I mean, even before there was the supply chain issues, Tesla demand exceeded production. So now, it's demand is exceeding production to a ridiculous degree. We're actually probably going to limit or just stop taking orders for anything beyond a certain period of time.
4:30Because some of the timing is a year away. So anyway, the frustration that we're seeing from customers is being unable to get them a car, not are they willing or interested in buying a car. So basically, I think zero about demand generation and a lot about production, and engineering, and supply chain.
5:01I have two more questions on Twitter, if I may, before we turn for the rest of the session to Tesla. How confident are you the deal will happen? And is there a risk, this is all one question, and is there a risk? Because you're putting a lot of your personal stake up for this to fund it.
5:19Is there a risk that if it all goes south, you're imperilling your stake in Tesla, potentially hurting Tesla financially and maybe even SpaceX if it all goes to pot? That's the technical term. Yeah, sure. So I mean, I think there's still a lot of things that need to get done before this deal concludes.
5:42Obviously, there's not yet even been a shareholder vote. And Twitter has not yet filed the proxy for a shareholder vote. So there are still some outstanding questions that need to be resolved. And so it is certainly not a done deal. And just objectively, it's not yet a deal. The best case scenario is that this would be I think perhaps done in two or three months.
6:19Yeah. And the final question, and this is really the toupe'd elephant in the room, are you planning to let Donald Trump back on? Well, I think there's a general question of, should Twitter have permanent bans? And I've talked with Jack Dorsey about this and he and I are of the same mind, which is that permanent bans should be extremely rare and really
6:54reserved for people where they're trying to, for accounts that are bots, or spam, scam accounts, where there's just no legitimacy to the account at all. I do think that it was not correct to ban Donald Trump. I think that was a mistake. Because it alienated a large part of the country and did not
7:25ultimately result in Donald Trump not having a voice. He is now going to be on Truth Social as well a large part of sort of the right in the United States. And so I think this could end up being frankly worse than having a single forum where everyone can debate. So I guess the answer is that I would
7:51reverse the permanent ban. Obviously, I don't own Twitter yet. So this is not like a thing that will definitely happen. Because what if I don't own Twitter? But my opinion, and Jack Dorsey, I want to be clear shares this opinion, is that we should not have permanent bans. Now that doesn't mean that somebody gets to say whatever they want to say.
8:10If they say something that is illegal, or otherwise just destructive to the world, then there should be perhaps a timeout, a temporary suspension, or that particular tweet should be made invisible, or have very limited traction. But I think permabans just fundamentally undermine trust in Twitter as a town square where everyone
8:46can voice their opinion. I think it was a morally bad decision, to be clear, and foolish in the extreme. Even after he egged on the crowd who went to the US Capitol, some of them carrying nooses. You still think it was a mistake to remove him? I think that if there are tweets that are wrong, and bad,
9:18those should be either deleted or made invisible. And a suspension, a temporary suspension, is appropriate. But not a permanent ban. So if the deal completes, he might potentially come back on but with the understanding that if he does something similar again, he'll be back in the sin pin?
9:43He has publicly stated that he will not be coming back to Twitter and that he will only be on Truth Social. And this is the point that I'm trying to make, which is perhaps not getting across, is that banning Trump from Twitter didn't end Trump's voice. It will amplify it among the right.
10:05And this is why it is morally wrong and flat out stupid. OK, thank you. Let's turn to Tesla again. I'd like to ask you about your ambitions for the future. You've said you want the company to be able to make 20 million cars a year by 2030, which would make it the same size as Toyota and Volkswagen combined today.
10:32Give us a sense, what does the business look like by 2030 to make 20 million cars? Plants, footprints, models. Yes, well this is not a forum for announcing new products, new Tesla products. The 20 million by 2030 is an aspiration, not a promise. And the reason for aiming for something like that is there are approximately two billion cars and trucks in the world.
11:06And for us to really make a dent in sustainable energy and electrification, I think we need to replace at least one per cent of the fleet per year to really be meaningful. And that's where the 20 million units comes from is, let's try to replace one per cent of the global fleet of two billion cars and trucks per year.
11:32And that's our aspiration. It's not a promise. It's an aspiration. I think we've got a good chance of getting there. And people will see based on the products that we unveil, will be able to judge for themselves whether that goal is realistic or not. We have an incredible team at Tesla.
11:54And executing very well. And our annual growth rates are faster than any large manufactured product in the history of earth. I think the next fastest was the growth of the Model T. And we're faster than the Model T. So if that growth rate continues, then obviously, we will reach about 20 million vehicles a year.
12:16But we may stumble and not reach that goal. And I'd say roughly, it's roughly equally difficult to have gotten to this point as will be to get to 20 million. And what's the biggest uncertainty with getting to 2030? Is it manufacturing ramping? Is it the raw materials? Is it something else?
12:53There are some raw material constraints that we see coming in lithium production probably in about three years and in cathode production. The cathode, the two main cathode choices are nickel and iron phosphate. Obviously, iron is extremely plentiful. But Earth is 32 per cent iron by composition.
13:20So a little bit of trivia, if someone says, what is Earth made of, the single biggest element that Earth is made of is iron. The second biggest element that Earth is made of is oxygen, which is about 30 per cent of Earth mass. So clearly, iron is not in short supply. The phosphate is slightly more of a challenge, but still quite common.
13:48So I do not see any fundamental scaling constraints. And lithium is also quite common. So lithium is practically everywhere. So this is not a question of a shortage of as though it's some rare element. It's really just that the lithium mining, and especially the refining capacity, and that of taking iron and phosphorus
14:13and turning it into battery grade iron phosphate, or nickel and turning it into battery grade nickel is, it's really the equipment. I think the single biggest constraint would be the equipment necessary to convert the ore into battery grade materials. Yes. I think you're sort of putting too much emphasis on those 20 million vehicles by 2030 as though this is some grand promise, some hill upon which we will die.
14:42It is simply an aspiration. And we may achieve it. We may not. Our goal is to accelerate the advent of sustainable energy. And so that's why we want to make a lot of cars, and also a lot of stationary battery packs. Because the three pillars of a sustainable energy future are electric transport, stationary battery packs,
15:08and solar and wind, and geothermal, and hydro, basically sustainable energy sources. But solar and wind particularly are intermittent. And so you need stationary battery packs to store the energy when the sun doesn't shine. Do you think Tesla has succeeded in its goal then? Or do you think there's still much more to do?
15:33I think we've not succeeded in the goal. If you consider the goal to be getting the automotive industry to move strongly towards electric vehicles, I think that part of the goal we have succeeded in. And that was explicitly part of our goal is to get the industry moving towards electric vehicles.
15:52Because they were doing nothing in that direction when we started. And for the longest time, they were dismissing the concept of electric vehicles. And then Tesla started taking market share away from them. And that changed their mind. How long do you think you're likely to stay at Tesla?
16:16As long as I can be useful. And what else is there in terms of potential future projects that piques your interest? You're obviously going to be quite involved in Twitter if the deal goes through. But you've got Tesla, you've got SpaceX, you've got Boring, you've got Neuralink. As you're looking around thinking you potentially have capacity, what else is there in terms of the kind of, I don't know, betterment of the human condition or improving Earth that you feel you might want to turn your attention to in the future?
16:49Well, I'm trying to take the set of actions that I think most likely make the future good and hopefully not pave the road to hell with good intentions. So I think Tesla is about accelerating sustainable energy. Because we're obviously a sustainable energy future on Earth for us to be good.
17:09Then SpaceX is about extending life beyond Earth so that we may become a multi-planetary species and with Starlink, providing internet coverage to the least served in the world. What do you think the next goals are then for SpaceX? And do you have a date in mind for when you think they will get to Mars?
17:38I think we should be able to maybe I don't know, get Starship to Mars on crude in three to five years. And then I think if that's successful, then we may be able to send a crewed mission to Mars before the end of the decade. Can I bring us down to Earth gently and ask you about China in relation to Tesla?
18:09Where do you... Sure. How important is the market for you? Do you think China contributes most of your growth in the future? No, I think China is obviously, a very significant market, that it's probably 25 per cent to 30 per cent of our market long-term. The rest of the world is probably 3/4 of it.
18:36Do you see, I promised I didn't have any more Twitter questions. But this is sort of a Twitter question. Do you see any risk at all that China uses your ownership of Twitter potentially to interfere or block Tesla's operations in the country? Because obviously China has banned Twitter.
18:56I've seen no indication to that effect. OK. How close would you say you are personally to the Chinese government? Because when you set up the factory in Shanghai, the rules were rewritten around joint ventures to allow you to do that. Well, yeah. I was certainly asked many times by the government of China
19:20to do a factory in China. I said, well, we're not going to do one which is 51 per cent locally-owned. And so if they're willing to change the rules, not just for us, but for everyone, then we would move forward. And so they did. And I think it's been very successful so far. And the government's very happy about it.
19:41And so I don't know. Things are proceeding fairly well. How many other plants are you expecting to open in China in the near future? Well, we're not expecting to open any additional plants in China in the near future. We will be expanding our Shanghai factory. But our focus on production is going to be on the two new factories that we've recently completed in Berlin and in Austin, Texas.
20:14How hard is it as a problem to solve? Because you've made predictions in the past about autonomy and some of those haven't come to fruition at the same time. Has your understanding of the problem of autonomy changed over the last few years? Well, yes. I'd say that self-driving is one of those things where there are
20:39a lot of false dawns or where you think you're getting there, but then you end up asymptoting, your progress is initially linear, and then looks logarithmic, and sort of tapers off because you're in a local maximum that you did not realise you were in. And at this point, I think we are no longer trapped in a local maximum.
21:05And obviously, I could be wrong. But I think we are actually quite close to achieving self-driving at a safety level that is better than human. And it appears, my best guess, is that we will get there this year. But we're really not far from it. And like I said, the best way to assess this is to be in our beta programme, or look at the videos of those who are in the beta programme, and look at the progress that has
21:42occurred. And if the progress is dramatic. And I'm confident we will not merely get to the safety level of a human, we'll get far in excess of the safety level of a human. So I think ultimately, probably a factor of 10 safer than a human as measured by the probability of injury.
22:02Given where you're trying to get to with this, the factor above human driving, the potential lives that could be saved with that, I need to ask you about some of the accidents and fatalities that have happened with vehicles previously. The people who died, do you consider that that was a price worth paying to get to the level
22:25where we want to be to save more human lives in the future? Well, it is important to note that, and we have never said ever that the Tesla autopilot does not require attention. We have always made that extremely clear repeatedly. You can't even turn it on without acknowledging that it requires supervision.
22:50We remind you of that every time you turn it on to ad nauseum. So this was not a case of setting expectations that the car can simply drive itself in the past and then not meeting those expectations. That is completely untrue. Now it is also the case however, and I knew this would be true from the beginning, that people don't, the people whose lives
23:22are saved with autopilot or autonomy don't know that their lives were saved. And so if you are going to say deaths, annual automotive deaths every year is around a million people per year die from automotive accidents, maybe 10 million per year are severely injured. And so with autonomy, the cars driving,
23:51it's assisted driving right now. But it will be fully autonomous in the future. Like I said, those who didn't realise they would have crashed, or hit a pedestrian, or cyclist, they don't know that. But, so basically, even if you let's say save 90 per cent of the people that would otherwise have died, the remaining 10 per cent who did die will still sue you.
24:20Now but I think it is, in the grand scheme of things, what is the morally right decision? And I am a strong believer in the enduring, the reality of good over the perception of good. And I have utter contempt for those who simply who prefer the perception of good over the reality of it.
24:42And so we're just going to take the heat. But if we believe that the probability of injury is reduced, and we are very confident of that, and but we also know that we're going to be sued despite doing the right thing, we will do the right thing and get sued. What is Tesla's approach to smaller and more affordable end of the market?
25:09You're going to go smaller than the Model 3. But could you get into a scooter, micromobility, something else? Scooters are very dangerous. I would not recommend anyone drive a scooter. If there was ever an argument between a scooter and a car, the scooter will lose. Would you ever consider licencing your platform to other OEMs?
25:31Presumably, that would help switch the industry towards electric mobility in your opinion. Well, we've already open-sourced all our patents. Anyone can use our patents for free. So great. We only patent things in order to prevent others from creating this minefield of patents that inhibit progress
25:53with electric vehicles. But several years ago, I came to the conclusion, we're never going to really prosecute anyone for using our patents. So let's just say you can use any Tesla patents for free. So I think hopefully, that's helpful to others. But I think the regular car industry, the traditional carmakers will solve electrification.
26:19It's not fundamentally difficult at this point to make electric cars. The thing that I think they may be interested in licencing is Tesla autopilot full self-driving. And I think that would save a lot of lives. But I think we still have where we have to prove ourselves for, I don't know, maybe another year or so.
26:45And then, perhaps there will be some other carmakers who may wish to licence Tesla autopilot. And we'd be very open to that. Thank you. Of all the other EV start-ups, which one has impressed you the most?
27:12Well, I think the company making the most progress besides Tesla is actually VW, which is not a start-up, but could be viewed in some ways as a start-up from an electric vehicle standpoint. So VW is doing the most on the electric vehicle front. I think there will be some very strong companies coming out of China.
27:36There's just a lot of super talented, hardworking people in China that are, we strongly believe in manufacturing. And they won't just be burning the midnight oil. They'll be burning the 3:00 AM oil. So they won't even leave the factory type of thing. Whereas in America, people are trying to avoid going to work at all.
28:01You've been critical of lockdowns in the past, particularly when it happened in the US. Shanghai is currently locked down. Most of the western world is able to carry on functioning at the moment because of vaccines. But China is going towards a zero-Covid approach. What do you make of the Chinese government's actions?
28:23Well, I've had some conversations with the Chinese government in recent days. And it's clear that the lockdowns are being lifted rapidly. So I would not expect this to be a significant issue in the coming weeks. In the past, where I was sort of upset with lockdowns is where those lockdowns differentially affected Tesla but not others.
28:52So in the case of California and the Bay Area counties specifically, every other car factory in North America was allowed to start, but not Tesla, even though there was no basis for that. It was simply because we were located in Alameda County in California. And but they had no rationale.
29:11It was arbitrary, and unfair, and that's the reason for why we're quite upset about kind of Tesla being singled out as the only car company in America that wasn't allowed to start even though I think our healthcare practises are probably better than anyone else. Do you think you'll ever wrap all your various operations, Tesla, SpaceX, et cetera, under one
29:38umbrella group? Or do you want to keep them separate for the time being? I think there's sort of separate objectives with different shareholder bases. And I think, I don't see a tonne of merit in combining them. At times, there are people where we have some very talented people who actually are willing to join, but they want to do things both at SpaceX and Tesla.
30:12So for example, we've got one of the best advanced materials teams in the world. It might be the best, but it's certainly one of the best. And a lot of people in that team were willing to join, but only if they could work on both rockets and cars. And so it was like, great. Let's do that.
30:35And so we can sort of share some of the ideas between rockets and cars, which are obviously not competitive. They're different competitive segments. So if you say like, if somebody is a really incredible technologist, innovator, engineer, they want to work on interesting things.
30:55So the more interesting, sure. Money is, they could get money from, anyone would hire them for a lot of money. So then it's not a money thing. It's really just, how interesting are the projects? And so there are just a few cases where we can recruit some of the smartest engineers, scientists,
31:21technologists in the world. But they want to work on both rockets and cars. And there's a few cases like that. What do you think is the next big innovation in personal transportation? Well, I think tunnels are underrated. Underappreciated. Tunnels will never let you down. Or will they?
31:44No, but here's the question on tunnels. So if you look at, say, for instance, Robert Moses in New York built loads of highways. They were supposed to solve congestion. And all they did was led to more congestion. How do you avoid tunnels doing exactly the same, but just being very expensive in the process?
32:04I have to say this notion of induced demand is one of the single dumbest notions I have ever heard in my entire life. If adding roads just increases traffic, why don't we delete them and decrease traffic? And I think you'd have an uproar if you did that. The real problem is that we have not, if you take, say congested cities, which really almost all large cities are congested, you have a fundamental dimensional problem.
32:34You have, say, these tall buildings, or multi-level buildings, where you've got people living in 3D. And then you want to take them in and out of those buildings on a 2D road network. How would you possibly expect that to work? So and especially if they weren't all arrive and depart at roughly the same time.
32:58This is just a recipe for traffic, obviously. So now if you go 3D, which you go 3D up, or you go 3D down, now you have you're matching the dimensionality of the buildings. The buildings are 3D. And if the road network, or you could potentially have flying cars, is 3D, then you will completely alleviate the traffic problem.
33:20So think of tunnels not as a single layer of tunnels, but as many layers as you want, as whatever layer count is necessary to drop traffic to negligible levels. I think it's so obvious this will work. It boggles my mind that people wouldn't think it would work. And we've already, we have a proof of concept of this in Las Vegas with a tunnel going from the convention centre to the strip.
33:48And that will soon be connecting all of the hotels and the airport in Las Vegas. And people will just try it out for themselves. It's working really well already in Vegas. And there was some scepticism among the county and the city as to whether it would be effective. And I think the test tunnel just barely succeeded in a vote
34:14with the local government in Clark County and Las Vegas. But once they saw the initial test tunnel and rode in it themselves, we got a unanimous vote in favour of expanding it to the whole city. So that should tell you something. Could you ever potentially go in the other direction three dimensionally and look at VTOLs and potentially flying vehicles?
34:42Well, I like the idea of VTOLs. But we already have VTOLs in the form of a helicopter. So but the problem with going 3D in the air is that you now have things that make a lot of noise that, and the wind force that they generate when taking off or landing is very high. I mean, if you just say like, look at a little drone.
35:13And say, now imagine if that thing was big. What a racket it would make. And how much wind force would it generate? And now they're going all over the place like a giant beehive of super noisy bees. I don't think this is what people want. In most of cities, helicopters are actually banned except for emergency purposes because of this reason.
35:37So then there's also the weather dependency. So if there are high winds, or heavy snow, rain, sleet, now you can't fly. So now you're shut down and can't go anywhere. Then there's the probability of something falling on your head is much higher if there are all these VTOLs flying all over the city.
36:06I mean, I think people's comfort level would be quite reduced should someone have perhaps not properly serviced their flying car and drops a wheel on your head. That I think would be discomforting to most people. And also, having them fly over your backyard, and having strangers stare at you all day is probably also just comforting.
36:30So I think these are all reasons why I have I think VTOLs will not succeed. I deliberately avoided calling them flying cars because most of them don't drive on the road. Is there something going on that makes you worry about the future of Tesla? Or do you think the company is now completely secure?
36:50No. I think the future of Tesla is extremely strong. So Tesla has no debt. It has a lot of cash. And there's a sort of a short-term hiccup with the Covid restrictions in Shanghai. But to the best of my knowledge, the future of Tesla is incredibly bright. And I think we will throw off a tremendous amount of free cash
37:24flow. Do you think with your cash and obviously your market cap at the moment you would ever consider buying another carmaker, whether an established OEM, or a new business? Well, I think it's highly unlikely. No. You've obviously done a number of mining deals trying to secure raw materials.
37:44Do you think you could ever go a step further and actually buy a mining company in the future? It's not out of the question. We will address whatever the limitations are on accelerating the world's transition to sustainable energy. It's not that we wish to buy mining companies. But if that's the only way to accelerate the transition,
38:12then we will do that. But there are no arbitrary limitations on what's needed to accelerate sustainable energy. We'll just tackle whatever set of things are needed to accelerate sustainable energy. And doing mining, and refining, or buying a mining company, provided, we think we can do, we can change that mining company's trajectory significantly are possibilities.
38:40Thank you so much for giving us so much of your time. Ladies and gentlemen, please show your appreciation for Elon Musk. Thank you.
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版