发布会·中文精读

马斯克在IAC 2016公布SpaceX火星星际运输系统架构

Elon Musk Unveils SpaceX's Mars Interplanetary Transport System Arcihtecture At IAC 2016

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2016年9月27日,墨西哥瓜达拉哈拉,第67届国际宇航大会(IAC)。马斯克走上台,先给出一个数字:去火星的票价,要压到20万美元左右,大致相当于当时美国一套房子的中位价。

这句话的分量在后面才显出来。按传统思路送一个人上火星,乐观估计要100亿美元。两个数字之间差5万倍。

马斯克说他想干成的事很朴素:让火星看起来是可能的,让它看起来是我们这代人有生之年能干成的事,而且任何一个真想清楚的人,只要愿意,真的能去。

历史只有两条路:留在地球等,或者成为多行星物种

马斯克把人类的走向拆成两条岔路。

一条是永远待在地球上,然后等到某次灭绝事件。他说自己没有末日预言,也不认为明天就会出事,但历史规律摆在那儿,早晚会有一次。

另一条是成为航天文明、成为多行星物种。

现场鼓掌了。马斯克停了一下,说:对,这就是我们要的。

他把目标说得很清楚。火星上要建的是一座能自己活下去的城市,一座不靠地球补给也能运转、最终能算得上“一个星球”的城市,插旗子的前哨站远远不够。

太阳系里没有第二个选项

为什么是火星,而不是别的地方?马斯克先放了一张按真实比例画的太阳系图。地球是从左边数第三块小石头,火星是第四块。太阳和木星大得离谱,海王星、土星、天王星依次排开,最右边是冥王星和它那群小伙伴。

在这个尺度上,选项其实很少。

金星不行。超高压、高温、硫酸澡堂,马斯克顺口加了一句:金星一点都不像那位女神。水星太靠近太阳。木星和土星的卫星可以去,但太远,路上太费劲。月球当然可以去,他也没意见,可是月球比行星小得多,没有大气,资源不如火星,一个昼夜28天。火星一天是24.5小时。

火星和地球的相似程度超出很多人的印象。现在学界认为早期火星很像地球,如果把火星重新加温,又会重新拥有浓厚的大气和液态海洋。火星离太阳大约是地球的1.5倍,阳光还够用,偏冷,但可以加热。大气以二氧化碳为主,掺了氮、氩和少量其他元素,这意味着压缩一下火星大气就能种植物。氮对植物至关重要,火星上有。

重力是地球的37%。马斯克说这会挺好玩,你扛得动重东西,蹦蹦跳跳,能玩出很多花样。

“我们只需要改最后一行数字:现在地球上有70亿人,火星上有0个。”

5万倍的价差,得靠四件事补齐

马斯克画了一个维恩图。一个圈是“想去火星的人”,一个圈是“付得起钱的人”。在2016年,这两个圈连碰都碰不到。

现实是,你花无限多的钱也去不了火星。按传统方式估算,比如走阿波罗计划那种思路,乐观成本是每人100亿美元。阿波罗计划按今天的美元算花了1000到2000亿,把12个人送上月球表面。马斯克说那是人类最伟大的成就之一,但那张船票实在太贵了,贵到两个圈只能勉强相切。

他要做的是把这两个圈拉到一起。如果去火星的成本能降到美国中位数房价,大约20万美元,那么建成自持文明的概率就非常高,几乎必然会发生。当然,想去的人不会太多,地球上只有一小部分人愿意去,但只要有足够多的人想去、又付得起,这事就能成。还可以拉赞助。最终会到这么一天:任何人只要把这当成目标,慢慢攒钱,总能攒够一张去火星的票。火星会长期缺人,工作不会缺。

要补上的是5个数量级,也就是降5万倍。马斯克自己的说法是“大约4.5个数量级”。

他把这4.5个数量级拆成四块:完全可复用(贡献2到2.5个数量级)、轨道加注(半个数量级)、火星就地生产推进剂(半个数量级)、选对推进剂。他说这四条不只对SpaceX成立,任何人设计火星运输系统,都得把这四条解决掉,否则每吨成本降不下来。

一张机票的类比:43美元和50万美元

马斯克用飞机解释复用与一次性使用的差距。

一架9000万美元的飞机,如果只用一次就报废,每张票得付50万美元。同样的飞机反复飞,你今天买一张西南航空从洛杉矶到拉斯维加斯的票,含税43美元。这是4个数量级的差距。任何交通工具都一样,汽车、自行车、马,只要是一次性的,没人用得起。

飞船的情况没这么夸张,因为地火转移窗口每26个月才有一次。飞船两年才能用一次,按30年寿命算,顶多飞12到15次。助推器和加油船不一样,它们可以高频使用。

所以整个设计思路倒过来了:飞船进轨道时油箱几乎是空的,把储箱做得特别大,然后用助推器和加油船反复往上加注,把飞船去火星时的载荷能力拉到最大。

轨道加注不做,成本直接翻5倍。加注还带来两个额外好处:飞行器可以造小一点,开发成本降下来;整个系统对性能不达标有容错,哪一环推力差一点,多跑一两趟加油就能补回来。

火星生产推进剂不做,成本同样翻5倍。而且不返航的话,火星上会堆满飞船坟场,越堆越多,不知道怎么处理。火星恰好适合干这件事:二氧化碳大气,土壤里有水冰,CO2 加 H2O 能造出甲烷(CH4)和氧气(O2)。

三种推进剂,最后选了甲烷

煤油让飞行器体积小,可火箭级煤油是高度精炼的航空燃料,很贵,复用潜力低,火星上没有石油,造不出来。

液氢比冲高,可它接近绝对零度,保温代价大得惊人,火星上制氢和储存的能耗极高。

甲烷几乎在所有维度上胜出。火星上补给一次推进剂,大概要占掉全星球50%到60%的能源,这个比例甲烷能扛住。

马斯克承认,他们一开始也觉得氢更合理,后来把整套系统放在一起算,结论是全甲烷系统(技术上叫深冷甲烷)每吨往返火星的成本最优。

“我们一开始以为氢会说得通,最后发现,优化‘每吨货物送到火星再运回来’的成本,全甲烷系统是明显的赢家。”(马斯克)

四件套:助推器、飞船、加油船、推进剂工厂

现场放了一段动画。马斯克特意强调,仿真直接用SpaceX工程部门的CAD模型跑出来,最终造出来的东西会和它几乎一模一样。

流程是这样:助推器扛着飞船起飞,把飞船送进轨道,然后自己返回。整个过程大约20分钟。回来之后马上加注、再起飞,这回扛的是加油船。

加油船和飞船长得几乎一样,区别只是把加压货舱和非加压货舱换成推进剂储箱。共用一套设计,开发成本能省一大截,这笔钱不会小。

加油船要上去3到5次,才能把飞船的箱子加满。等火星窗口打开,船队出发。

未来会有上千艘飞船在轨道上等着。马斯克说这场景像《太空堡垒卡拉狄加》,他还补了一句“那部剧不错”。两年时间足够慢慢往轨道上攒船,助推器和加油船在这两年里高频次往返,把复用次数吃满。飞船复用次数少,所以每一次都要尽量装满。

13000吨推力,42台发动机,一只碳纤维大桶

这个飞行器非常大。马斯克说,长期看未来的船会比这还大,这一版相对算小的。

尺寸有个下限。加压舱要装100人左右,还要带行李,带非加压货物,从炼铁厂到披萨店,什么都要带。要撑起一座自持城市,门槛大概是100万人。每26个月一个窗口,一船100人,那就是1万次飞行。所以他认为每船100人是最低数量级,最终会扩到200人以上,把每人的成本压下去。攒到1000艘船要花不少时间,从第一艘船抵达火星算起,大概要20到50次地火交会,也就是40到100年,才能有一座真正自持的火星城市。

箭体主要是先进碳纤维。硬骨头在深冷:既要液密又要气密,还要在反复加压和极低温下不开裂。碳纤维遇到液氧和液态甲烷容易开裂、渗漏。直到最近,技术才勉强做到不用在内壁加金属内衬,加了内衬就增加重量和复杂度。氧气增压尤其难。

整套系统用自生增压:发动机热交换器把甲烷和氧气气化,再回灌到各自的储箱里。控制推力器也用气态甲烷和氧气。整支火箭只需要两种工质。猎鹰9号要氦气增压、氮气做姿控,加上两种推进剂,一共四种,算上点火液是五种。

运力对比:可抛弃模式550吨,复用模式300吨。土星五号是135吨。马斯克说,大部分火箭包括SpaceX自己在飞的,运力那条白条只占箭体尺寸的一小块。这套星际运输系统第一次让性能条超过了火箭本身的物理尺寸。

起飞推力13000吨。马斯克说发射的时候大地都在震,动静相当 tectonic。它塞得进39A发射台,因为当年NASA为土星五号把这座台建得够大。未来可能在得州南海岸再加一个发射场。

猛禽、栅格舵,和7台能摆动的发动机

开发从两块最难啃的部位开始:猛禽发动机(Raptor)和碳纤维储箱。

猛禽是全人类燃烧室压力最高的火箭发动机,可能也是推重比最高的。它用全流量分级燃烧,把给定推进剂能榨出的动量榨到理论极限。液氧和甲烷被冷却到接近凝固点,密度提高10%到12%,这个数字对火箭性能的影响是决定性的,顺带还消除了涡轮泵气蚀的风险,高压力泵送也变得容易。

真空版猛禽的比冲是382秒。马斯克说这个数字对整个任务至关重要,他们有信心达到,误差在几秒之内,最终可能略微超出。

助推器本质上是放大的猎鹰9号。栅格舵、底部并联大量发动机,这些都能看到影子。主要区别是主结构用先进碳纤维,铝锂合金不再用了,同时改用自生增压,氦气和氮气全部去掉。

42台猛禽并排。马斯克说发动机数量多是好事:猎鹰9号用9台,猎鹰重型27台,明年年初首飞,大规模并联发动机这件事SpaceX有相当多经验。数量多也带来冗余,坏几台照样完成任务。

助推器的任务是把飞船加速到约85000公里每小时。马斯克强调轨道动力学看的是速度,高度没那么重要。助推器就是掷标枪的人,负责把飞船这支标枪甩出去。到了低重力天体,比如火星、木星的卫星、将来也许金星,只需要飞船,助推器留在家里。月球、火星、冥王星都不需要助推器,助推器只服务于深重力井。

返回和着陆用的推进剂压到了起飞总量的7%,继续优化可能到6%。着陆精度越来越高,马斯克说如果看过猎鹰9号的回收视频,会发现落点一次比一次靠近靶心。加上姿控推力器之后,助推器可以直接落回发射架。箭体底部的对中结构负责吃掉微小的位置偏差。只有中心7台发动机会摆动,其余全部固定,这样发动机可以排到最密,摆动的空间也留给了最需要的地方。

飞船内部:加压舱、货舱、液氧箱

从上往下看。最上面是加压乘员舱,下面是非加压货舱,货物按极高密度扁平打包。再往下是液氧箱,然后是燃料箱,发动机直接装在底部的推力锥上。

液氧箱是整艘船最难的一块。推进剂温度最低;箱体本身构成机身结构,要承受上升的推力载荷和再入的气动载荷;还得对气态氧不渗透、不与氧发生反应。现代火箭都是这么设计的,飞机也一样,机翼本身就是油箱,只不过装的是航空煤油。正因为难,SpaceX从这里开始动手。

底部6台真空版高效发动机装在周边,不摆动。3台海平面版可以摆动,负责转向。在太空里也可以靠外侧发动机的差动推力做转向。

火星载荷最多450吨,具体看加注几次。目标每船至少100人。

80天到火星,30天是远期目标

行程时间取决于挑哪个窗口。上一个窗口,以每秒6公里的出发速度,单程可以压到80天。远期他估计能到30天。对比一下大航海时代,横渡大洋动辄半年以上,这么看还算好接受。

到达火星时的热防护至关重要。龙飞船一直在迭代PICA(酚醛浸渍碳烧蚀材料),现在到第三代,抗烧蚀能力越来越强,需要修补的地方越来越少。马斯克把热盾比作巨型刹车片,比的就是谁更耐磨,谁的翻修成本更低,最终目标是多次飞行完全不翻修。

乘员舱内部做了漫游动画:零重力游戏、到处漂浮、看电影、听讲座、客舱、餐厅。马斯克说得很直白,这趟旅程得好玩、不能憋屈,才能把维恩图里“想去”那个圈扩大。

火星上的推进剂工厂

火星大气主要是CO2,水冰几乎到处都是,CO2 加水就能用萨巴蒂尔反应造出甲烷和氧气。能源是这里的瓶颈,方案是铺一大片太阳能板。马斯克说,有了能源就有了水,火星的冰储量是巨大的。

票价14万美元一吨,最终可能低于10万

按这套架构算,当前送到火星表面的成本大约是每吨14万美元。一个人加上行李、食物消耗、生命维持,算下来票价最终可能低于10万美元,架构优化到位的话甚至能到10万以下。首批航班肯定贵,这套架构的价值在于它允许成本一路往下走。

钱从哪来:卫星、空间站、Kickstarter,还有他自己的资产

马斯克放了一张半开玩笑的融资幻灯片:钢铁侠内裤、发射卫星、给空间站送货、Kickstarter众筹,“然后盈利”。

正经的部分是:靠大量发射卫星、给NASA跑空间站货运来回产生还算不错的净现金流。私营部门里有不少人对出资建火星基地有兴趣,政府部门将来大概也会参与。最终这会变成巨大的公私合作项目。马斯克说美国当年就是这么建立起来的,世界上很多国家也是。

他顺带讲了一句自己的事:他个人积累资产的主要目的就是给这件事筹钱,没有别的动机,只是想为“让生命成为多行星”做出最大贡献。

2002年:一块地毯和一辆面包车

幻灯片切到2002年。当时的SpaceX就是一块地毯加一辆墨西哥流浪乐队的面包车,全部家当。画面里马斯克在跳舞,他说自己是“跳舞机器”,还说他喜欢用墨西哥流浪乐队开场。

那时候他觉得自己成功率大概10%,能把火箭送入轨道就不错了,根本谈不上认真考虑火星。但他判断,如果没有人带着强烈的意识形态动机闯进航天领域,人类成为航天文明的轨迹就断了。1969年上了月球,航天飞机能到低轨,航天飞机退役之后,趋势线一路朝零走。

他说很多人没意识到一件事:技术不会自动进步。只有大量顶尖工程人才持续往一个问题里砸,它才会进步。历史上有不少文明到达过某个技术水平,后来又跌回去,隔了几千年才恢复。

猎鹰1号是他们能想到的最小的有用轨道火箭,半吨运力。四年时间里自研了主机、上面级发动机、箭体、整流罩和发射系统。2006年第一次发射,飞了60秒就失败了。同一年,火箭刚炸完,NASA给了第一份合同。马斯克说他是NASA最大的粉丝,感谢那些敢下注的人。

2008年第四次发射成功。他说钱只够三次发射,前三次全炸了,最后是勉强凑出第四次。年底NASA给了第一份大额商业补给合同。

猎鹰9号第一版,10吨运力,是猎鹰1号的20倍,设计上就为龙飞船留了位置。2010年首次空间站任务,2012年完成货运往返,2013年开始垂直起降试验。2014年,轨道级助推器第一次在海上软着陆,落了7秒,然后倒了,炸了。马斯克的原话是“落了7秒,挺好”。

2015年12月,助推器返回卡纳维拉尔着陆。马斯克说那是他人生最好的时刻之一。那次着陆几乎不需要翻修就能复飞,如果一切顺利,几个月后会复飞其中一枚。

2016年实现海上平台着陆。这一步对高轨同步任务很关键,SpaceX大约60%的任务是商业GEO,速度太高,推进剂不够返航,只能落在海上。

4年造第一艘,10年是乐观估计

时间表故意说得模糊。预算很紧,能推进多少推进多少。争取4年左右完成第一艘开发版飞船,开始亚轨道试飞。这艘船其实有能力入轨,只要把货砍到很少;加油船形态肯定能入轨,只是回不来。

马斯克顺带提了一个想法:地球上的超高速点对点运输。纽约到东京25分钟,横跨大西洋10分钟,大部分时间花在去坐船的路上。前提是找得到不扰民的地方降落,比如离岸二三十英里的海上平台。火箭很吵,这是硬约束。他强调不指望这个赚钱。

助推器部分相对简单,就是放大猎鹰9号,看不到什么硬障碍。

全部拼起来真正跑通,顺利的话十年左右。他紧跟着补了一句:别把十年当承诺,风险巨大,花钱很多,很可能失败,但会尽最大努力。

从今往后,每个火星窗口都要发东西。龙2是推进着陆器,计划两年后去火星,2020年再发一次。他希望形成稳定节奏,像火车准点发车,每个窗口至少有一艘龙飞船去火星,最终换成大飞船。想搭载荷的人可以指望至少2到3吨有效载荷落到火星表面。

龙2设计成推进着陆器是有讲究的。靠降落伞,只能去有大气的地方;靠机翼,只能去有跑道的地方,而大部分地方没跑道。推进着陆在任何地方都能用。理论上,龙飞船能在太阳系任何固体或液体表面着陆。

猛禽首次全系统点火赶在大会前完成。马斯克感谢团队七天连轴转,说猛禽比梅林难得多,全流量分级燃烧、压力高得多,第一次点火没炸让他有点意外。他还提到燃烧产物里能看到纳米钻石形成。

猛禽推力是梅林的3倍,体积却差不多,因为工作压力是3倍。这意味着梅林的生产工艺可以大量沿用。梅林现在年产接近300台,所以整套系统51台发动机(助推器42台加飞船9台)完全在产能范围内,成本也不会失控。

第一个碳纤维储箱也在会前造出来了。尺寸很大,深冷推进剂初测结果相当不错,没有出现泄漏或大问题。储箱内部完全光滑,碳纤维铺层反光,看起来像切面很多的宝石。

超越火星:一路跳岛到冥王星

马斯克解释为什么管它叫“系统”。他平时不喜欢“系统”这个词,因为什么都叫系统,连你家狗都是系统。这套东西确实不止一个飞行器:助推器、飞船、加油船、推进剂工厂,四样齐了,就能靠跳岛去太阳系任何地方。

在小行星带或者木星某颗卫星上建一个推进剂补给站,火星到木星就没问题。土卫六(泰坦)再建一个,更远的冥王星再建一个,整个太阳系就打通了。可以去柯伊伯带,可以去奥尔特云。星际旅行他不推荐用这套,但只要有加油站,太阳系全域可达。他还说,去木卫二(欧罗巴)的任务特别值得做。

问答环节:辐射、厕所、签证

39A发射台能发猎鹰重型,也能发这套星际运输系统,两套都兼容。厂房可能在墨西哥湾沿岸几个州,路易斯安那是候选之一,最后在发射场做总装。飞行器太大,公路运不了,只能在发射场旁边造。

辐射没有想象中可怕。会有风险,癌症概率略微上升,但不致命。遇到太阳风暴,把火箭尾部朝向太阳,让乘客聚在水墙周围,水就是最好的屏蔽层。到了火星,星球本身挡掉一半辐射,还有薄薄一层大气。长期可以造人工磁场偏转高能粒子。马斯克说辐射经常被拿出来说事,实际没那么严重。

水不用愁。火星水多得很,水冰储量巨大。瓶颈在能源。有能源就有水。方案是海量太阳能板,可能还有地热,如果公众接受,也许上核能。

第一批去的人会非常危险,死亡率很高,绕不过去。他说不会送孩子去,标准很简单:你准备好死了吗?准备好了,你就是候选人。他在意的有两件事:尽快建成自持文明,把人类整体的生存风险降下来;以及这件事带来的冒险感。地球在很长时间里都会是好地方,不需要所有人搬走。人每天醒来需要为未来兴奋,需要被激励,需要想活下去。

返回选项必须留。知道能回来,愿意去的人会多得多,哪怕绝大多数人最终一次都没回来。当年去北美殖民地的英国人大部分再没回过欧洲,但心里知道能回,这一点在心理上完全不同。何况飞船本来就要返航,跳上去就行,返程免费。

普通人能不能去?能。训练几天就够,想多练也可以。

SpaceX雇不了外国人,卡在ITAR(国际武器贸易条例)。火箭技术被归类为先进武器技术,普通工作签证不够,需要国防部长或国务卿特批。马斯克说,SpaceX没有选择余地,法律不允许就是不允许。特斯拉没有这个限制,工程团队25%到30%来自美国以外。他直说这个政策对美国不明智,全世界有那么多有才华的人,公司想招却招不了。

资源投入现在很小,不到公司总量的5%,几千万美元级别。等猎鹰9号最终版和龙2开发完、两级复用跑顺,一年半到两年内,大部分工程团队会转到星际运输系统,届时每年投入大概2到3亿美元。整个项目在产生正现金流之前,累计投入大约100亿美元。

名字。第一艘去火星的船,马斯克想叫“黄金之心”(Heart of Gold),出自《银河系漫游指南》,靠无限非概率驱动。“我们的船也极其不可能。”缩写不太好听,他自己也承认了。

加注流程取决于加注速度。如果能快速加注,人上去,几周内加满就走。如果船要提前一年在轨等着,就不能让人待在里面,得等加满之后再发一艘载人船上去对接转移。货运和载人分开,这也是设计里预留的弹性。

NASA该不该支持这套方案?马斯克说多路径并进是好事,不建议取消任何星际探索的尝试,多几口锅在火上烧更好。他来IAC讲架构,就是希望鼓励全世界的公司和组织做类似的事,或者提出更好的架构,互相竞争,或者合作。多几家公司做星际飞船,未来变好的概率就更高。

他会不会是第一个上火星的人?不会。第一次任务死亡概率太高,他得先安排好继任计划,确保公司使命能延续下去。他最怕的就是公司被只想最大化利润的投资人接管,然后火星计划被丢在一边。他想看着孩子长大。

这套方案真正的门槛在哪

把整场演讲拆开看,硬骨头有三块:碳纤维深冷储箱、猛禽的全流量分级燃烧、以及轨道上的大规模低温推进剂转移。这三样都没有先例,SpaceX在2016年只是刚点火成功一台发动机、刚做出一个储箱。

第四块是火星上的能源,他在问答里一句带过。要在火星表面年产上千吨甲烷和氧气,太阳能板的面积是天文数字。这块如果解决不好,返程票就无从谈起,整套复用逻辑也跟着断了。

还有一块他没怎么讲:人。100个人在直径十几米的舱里待80天,加上后续几百上千人的长期定居,生命维持、医疗、心理、社会治理,这些在2016年的演讲里基本是空白。他自己也说,SpaceX负责修铁路,铁路修通之后的事,留给想去的人。

整套方案的姿态很清楚:先把最难最贵的运输环节解决掉,把票价打到20万美元,剩下的交给创业者和后来者。他用联合太平洋铁路做类比。当年修铁路的时候很多人说这是傻主意,加州根本没几个人住。铁路修通之后,加州成了全球科技和娱乐的中心,成了美国人口最多的州。没有那条铁路,后面的一切都不会发生。

  • 判断一个火星或深空项目靠不靠谱,先问它有没有回答那四个问题:完全复用、轨道加注、就地生产推进剂、推进剂选择。四条缺一条,成本就翻几倍。
  • 看航天公司的技术进展,别只看渲染图,看两样硬件:发动机有没有全系统点火,储箱有没有做过低温加压测试。这两件最难,也最不会说谎。
  • 做硬科技创业的,可以借这套思路自查一遍:把目标成本拆成几个数量级,再逐条找出每个数量级由哪个技术环节贡献。哪个环节没解决,整个成本模型就塌了。
  • 关注可复用进展,重点看复用次数和翻修工时。这两项决定票价曲线,比单次发射成功更能说明问题。
  • 对火星移民感兴趣,先记住每26个月一次的地火窗口。行业真正的节奏卡在这个时间表上,跟新闻热点关系不大。
  • 做内容或教育的,马斯克在会上反复讲的一件事值得记下来:公众的想象力和意愿,本身就是这套系统的一部分。维恩图里“想去”那个圈,是可以被扩大的。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00[Music] good afternoon ladies and gentlemen I am johal I am president of Kes the French space agency and the president elect of the International astronautical Federation and it is my pleasure to welcome you here at the 67th International astronautical Congress Elon Musk is founder CEO and lead designer of space sex Elon founded SpaceX in 2002 with the goal of Revolution space technology and ultimately enabling humans to become a multiplanetary spaces and that the plan is going to lay out for us today SpaceX has had a number of First including as the first private company to deliver cargo to and from the International Space Station and the first entity to land an orbital class

0:58booster back on land and run ships out at Sea please join me in welcoming Elon

1:15Musk nice having you all right so thanks thank you very much for having me look forward to talking about the SpaceX Mars architecture and what I really want to try to achieve here is to make Mars seem possible make it seem as though it's something that we can do in our lifetimes and that you can go and and is there really a way that that anyone could go if they wanted to I think that's that's really the important thing so I mean first of all why go anywhere right the I I think there really two fundamental paths history is going to bate along two directions one one one path is we stay on Earth forever and then there will be some eventual Extinction event I I don't have an

2:11immediate Doomsday Prophecy but there's it's eventually history suggests that will'll be some some Doom event the alternative is to become a space spring civilization and a multi-planet species which I hope you would agree that is the right way to go yes [Applause] that's what we want

2:45yeah so how do we figure out how to how to take you to Ms and and create a a self- sustaining city a city that is not merely an outpost but could become a planet in its own right and PR thus we could become a truly multiplet species U there you know sometimes people wonder well what about other places in the solar system why why Mars well just so sort of put things into perspective this is this is what this is an actual scale of what the solar system looks like so we're we're currently in the the third Little Rock from the left that's Earth yeah

3:29exactly the and and our goal is to go to the fourth Rock on the left that's Mars but you can get a sense for the real scale of the Soul system how big the sun is and Jupiter Neptune Saturn Uranus and then the little guys on on the right are Pluto and friends this this sort of helps see it not not quite to scale but it gives you a better sense for for where things are so our options for for going to for for becoming a multiplet species within our solar system are are limited we have in terms of nearby options we've got Venus but Venus is a high

4:16pressure super high pressure hot Acid Bath so that that would be a tricky one Venus is not at all like the goddess this is not in no way similar to to to the actual goddess so really difficult to make things work on Venus Mercury is also way too close to the Sun we could go potentially on the mar one of the on one of the moons of Jupiter or Saturn but those are quite far out much further from the Sun a lot harder to get to it really leaves us with one option if we want to become a multi-planet civilization and that's that's Mars we could conceivably go to our moon and I certainly have nothing against going to the moon but I think it's it's challenging to create a

5:03become multiplanetary on the moon because it's it's much smaller than than a planet it doesn't have any atmosphere it it's not as resourcer as Mars it's got a 28 day day whereas the Mars day is 24 and 1 half hours and in general Mars is is far better suited to ultimately scale up to be a self-sustaining civilization so just to give some comparison between the the two

5:34planets that they're actually Fair they're remarkably close in a lot of ways in in fact we now believe that that early Mars was a lot like Earth and in fact if we could War Mars up we would once again have a thick thick atmosphere and liquid oceans so but where things all right now moth is Mars is about half a gain as far from the Sun as as Earth so still decent sunlight it it's a little cold

6:05but we can warm it up it has a very helpful atmosphere which in the case of Ms being primarily CO2 with some nitrogen and argon and a few other Trace elements means that we can grow plants on Mars just by compressing the atmosphere and and it has nitrogen too which is also very important for for growing plants it would be quite fun to be on Ms because you'd have gravity which is about 37 37% out of Earth so

6:36you'd be able to lift heavy things and bound around and like have a lot of fun and the day is remarkably close to that of of Earth and so we just need to change that bottom row because currently we have 7 billion people on Earth and zero on Mars so there there's been a lot of great work by NASA and and other organizations in early exploration of Mars and understanding U what what Mars is like where could we land what's the composition of of the of the atmosphere where where is there water order ice I should say and and so we need to go from these early exploration missions to actually building a city the the issue that we have today is that if you look at a vend diagram we

7:33the there's there's there's no intersection of sets of people who want to go and can afford to go in fact right now you cannot go to Mars for infinite money using traditional methods you know if if taking sort of a pol style approach the an optimistic cost number would be about $10 billion a person so for for example the Apollo program the cost estimates are somewhere between 100 to20 billion dollar in current current year dollars and we sent 12 people to the service of moon which was an incredible thing and I think probably the one of the greatest achievements of of humanity but but that's that a a steep price to pay for a ticket that's why these circles only

8:23just barely touch so you can't create a self-sustaining civilization if the ticket price is $10 billion a person what we need is a closer is to move those circles together and if we can get a the cost of moving to Mars to be roughly equivalent to a median house price in in the US which is around

8:47$200,000 then I think the probability of establishing a self-sustaining civilization is very high I think it I think it would almost certainly occur not not everyone would want to go in fact I think a relatively small number of people from Earth would want to go but enough would want to go and who could afford the trip that it would happen and you people can get sponsorship and and I think it gets to the point where where almost anyone if they saved up and and this was their goal they could ultimately save up enough money to to buy a ticket and move to Mars and Mars would have Labor shortage for a long time so a jobs would not be in short supplyer so it is a bit tricky

9:29because we have to figure out how to improve the cost of trips to M by 5 million per. so this is this is not easy and I mean it's and it sounds like virally impossible but I I think I think there are ways to do it this this translates to an improvement of approximately four and a half orders of

9:52magnitude these are the key elements that are needed in order to achieve the 4 and a half order of Bank Improvement most of the the Improvement would come from Full reusability somewhere between 2 and 2 and a half orders of magnitude and then the other two orders magnitude would come from refilling in orbit propellent production on Mars and choosing the right propellent so I'm going to go into detail on all those Flor reusability is is is really the the super hard one it's it's it's very difficult to achieve reusability for for even an orbital system and that challenge becomes even substantially greater for a system that has to go to another

10:39planet but as an example of the difference between reusability and expendability in aircraft and this you could actually use any form of Transport you could say a car bicycle horse if there was single use almost no one would use them it' be too expensive but with with with frequent flights you can take something like that an aircraft that cost $90 million and if it were single use you'd have to pay half a million doar per flight but you can actually buy a ticket on Southwest right now from LA to Vegas for $43 including taxes so that's I mean

11:19that's a massive Improvement right there it's it's it's showing a four order of magnitude Improvement now this is harder the reusability doesn't apply quite as much to Mars because the number of times you can reuse the the spaceship is it the spaceship part of the system is left less often because the Earth Mars revu only occurs every every 26 months so you get to use the spaceship part roughly every two years now you get to use the the booster and the tanker as frequently as you'd like and so it makes that's why it really makes a lot of sense to to load the spaceship into orbit with essentially tanks dry and have it have really quite big tanks that

12:00you then use the booster and tanker to refill while it's in orbit and maximize the the pad of of the the spaceships that when it goes to Mars you you really have a very large payload capability so said refilling an orbit is is one of the Essential Elements of this without refilling in orbit you you would have a half water of magnitude impact roughly on on the cost by half of magnitude I think audience mostly knows but what that means is each order of magnitude is a factor of 10 so not not refilling in orbit would mean a 500% roughly increase in the cost per ticket it it also allows us to build a smaller vehicle and lower the development cost although this vehicle

12:55is quite big but it would be much harder to build something that's 5 to 10 times the size and it also reduces the sensitivity of performance characteristics of the of the booster rocket and tanker so if there's a shortfall in the performance of of any of the elements you can actually make up it by having one or two extra refilling trips to the spaceship so this is it's very important for reducing the susceptibility of the system to a performance shortfall

13:32and then producing propellant on on Mars is actually you also very obviously important again if if we didn't do this it would have at least a half order of magnitude increase in the in the cost of a trip so 500% increase in the cost of the trip and it would be pretty absurd to try to build a city on on Mars if if your spaceships just kept staying on Mars and not going back to Earth you have this like massive grave graveyard of ships you have to like do something with them so it really wouldn't make sense to to to leave your spaces shifts on Mars you really want to build a propellent plant on Mars and send the shift back so and M happens to work out well

14:17for that because it has a CO2 atmosphere it's got water ice in the soil and with H2O and CO2 you can produce CH4 methane and oxygen O2 so picking the right propellant is also important that sort of think of this as maybe this there's three main choices they have the they have their merits but kerosene or rocket propellant grade kerosene which is also what Jets use Rockets use a very expensive form a highly refined form of of jet fuel essentially which is a form of kerosene the it helps keep the vehicle size small but because it's it's a very specialized form of jet fuel it's it's quite expensive the reusability potential is lower very difficult to

15:09make this on Mars because there's no oil so really quite difficult to make the propellant on Mars and and then propell and transfor is is is pretty good but not not great hydrogen although it has a high specific impulse is is very expensive incred difficult to to keep from boiling off because liquid hydrogen is very close to absolute zero as as a liquid so the insulation required is is tremendous and the

15:43the cost of U the energy cost on Ms of producing and storing hydrogen is very high so when we looked at the overall system optimization it was clear to us that that methane actually was the the clear winner so it would require maybe anywhere from you know 50 to 60% of the energy on Ms to re to refill propellent using the propellent depot and and just the the technical challenges are a lot easier so so we think we think methane is actually better on just really almost across the board and and we started off initially thinking that hydrogen would make sense but ultim came to conclusion that the the best way to optimize the cost per unit Mass to Mars and back

16:31is is to use an all methane system or or technically deep cryome meths so those are the four the four elements that need to be achieved so so whatever Arch whatever system is designed whether by SpaceX or or or anyone we think these are the four features that need to be addressed in order for the system to to Really achieve a a low cost per cost per ton to the surface of

17:03Mars and this is this is a simulation of the overall system [Music]

21:39so so what you saw there is is really quite close to what we will actually build it will look almost exactly what you saw like what you saw so this is not not not an artist impression these the simulation was actually made from the SpaceX engineering CAD models so this is not you know it's not just well this is what it might look like this is what we plan to try to make it look

22:06like so in the video you you you got a sense for what the system AR architecture looks like the the rocket booster in the spaceship take off loads the the spaceship into orbit the rocket booster then comes back it comes back quite quickly within about 20 minutes and so it can actually launch the the the the tanker version of the spacecraft which is essentially the same as the as the spaceship but filling up the the unpressurized and pressurized cargo areas with propellant tanks so they look almost identical so this this also helps lower the the development cost which obviously will not be small and and then the propellant tanker goes up and it'll go

22:49actually up it'll go up multiple times so anywhere from three to five times to fill the tanks of the of the spaceship in orbit and then once the the spaceship is the tanks are full the cargo has been transferred and we reach the Mars R timing which as mentioned is roughly every 26 months that's when the ship would depart now over time there would be many spaceships you'd ultimately have I think upwards of a thousand or more spaceships waiting in orbit and so that the Mars Colonial Fleet would depart on mass they're kind of like battle Galactica you've seen that thing that's good good show so bit like that but it actually makes sense to to load the spaces shifts

23:35into orbit because you've got two years to do so and then make frequent use of the booster and the tanker so get get really heavy reuse out of those and then with the with the spaceship you get less reuse because you have to say well how long is it going to last well maybe 30 years so that might be 12 to maybe 15

23:55flights of the spaceship at most so you really want to maximize the cargo of the spaceship and and and use the booster and the the tanko a l so any the ship goes to Mars gets gets replenished and then returns to earth so I'll go into some of the details of the vehicle design and performance and I'm I'm going to gloss over or Le I'll I'll only talk a little about the the technical details in the actual presentation and then I'll leave the the detailed technical questions to the to the Q&A that follows this is to give you a sense of

24:51size it's quite big and the funny thing is I think in in the long term the strips will be even bigger than this I I think this will represent this will be relatively small compared to the Mars interplanetary shifts of the of the future but it kind of needs to be about the size because if if in order to to fit 100 people or there abouts in the pressurized section plus carry the luggage and all of the unpressurized cost Chago to build propellant plants and build everything from Iron foundaries to pizza joints

25:36so you name it in the we need to carry a lot lot of cargo so it it really needs to be roughly on this on the sorder of magnitude because if we say like the the say AUM threshold for self- sustaining city of mars or civilization would be a million people well and you can only go every two years if you if you you know if you have 100 people per ship that's 10,000 trips so I think at least 100 people per trip is is the right order of magnitude and I think we actually may end up expanding the the the crew section and U and ultimately taking more like 200 or more people per flight in order to reduce the cost per person so but it's you know 10,000 flights is is a lot of

26:23flights so you really want ultimately I think on the order of ships it will take a while to build up to a th000 ships and so I think if you say when when would we reach that million person threshold from the point at which the first ship goes to Mars it's probably somewhere between 20 to 50

26:48total Mars rendus so it's it's it's probably somewhere between you know maybe 40 to 100 years to achieve a a fully self-sustaining civilization on Mars so that's the sort of cross-section of the ship and you know in some ways it's not that complicated really the it's made primarily of an advanced carbon fiber the carbon fiber part is tricky when dealing with deep cryogens and and trying to achieve

27:27both liquid and gas in permeability and have and not have gaps occur due to cracking or pressurization that would make the C by The Leaky so this is this is a fairly significant technical challenge to make deeply cryogenic tanks out of carbon fiber and it's only recently that the that we think that the Caron F technology has gotten to the point where where we can actually do this without having to to create a liner on the in some sort of metal liner or other liner on the inside of the the tanks which would add mass and complexity so particularly tricky for the hot gasas oxygen pressurization so this this is designed to be autogenously pressurized which means that the the

28:15fuel and the oxygen we gasify them through heat exchanges in the engine and use that to pressurize the tanks so we'll gasify the methane and use that to pressurize the fuel tank gasify the oxygen use that to pressurize the oxygen tank and this Compares this is a much simpler system than what we have with with Falcon 9 where we use helium for pressurization and we use nitrogen for gas thrusters in this case we would aogen autogenously pressurize and then use gasius methane and U oxygen for

28:52the control thrusters so really only you only need two ingredients for this as opposed to four in the case of Falcon line and actually five if you consider the ignition liquid so we we use a sort of complicated liquid to ignite the engines that that isn't isn't very useable in this case we would use Spock

29:23ignition so this give you a sense of vehicles by performance sort of current and historic you can actually read that but in expandable mode the the the vehicle approach that we're proposing would do about 550 tons and about 300 tons in reusable mode that compares to S 5 Max capability of of 135

29:47tons but I think this this really gives a better sense for things the the white bars show the performance of the vehicle like in there was the payload to orbit of the vehicle so you can see essentially what what it represents is what's the size efficiency of of the of the vehicle and most Rockets including ours our ours that are currently flying the the performance bar is only a small percentage of the actual size of the rocket but with the intering system with which will initially be used for Mars we've been able to

30:31we believe massively improve the design performance so it's the first time a Rocket's sort of performance bar will actually exceed the physical size of the rocket this gives you a more direct sort of comparison this is the thrust level is is quite enormous we're talking about lift off thrust of 13,000 tons supp be quite quite tectonic when it takes off but it does it does fit on pad 39a which NASA's been

31:13kind of to allow us to use where because they somewhat oversized the pad in doing Saturn 5 and and as a result we can actually do a much larger vehicle on that same Launchpad and then in the future we expect to add additional launch locations probably probably adding one on the south coast of Texas but this gives you a sense of the the relative capability if if you can read those

31:43but these vehicles have very different purposes the this this is really intended to carry huge numbers of people ultimately millions of tons of caro to Mars so you really need something quite large in order to do that so talk about some of the key elements of the inter interplanetary spaceship and rocket booster we we decided to start off the development with what we think are probably the two most difficult elements of the of the design one is the the Raptor engine and this is going to be the the highest chamber pressure engine of any any kind of rolt and probably the highest thrust to weight

32:32it's a it's a full flow stage combustion engine which maximizes the theoretical momentum that you can get out of a given Source Fu an oxidizer we we subcool the oxygen or methane to densify it so compared to when it when propounds normally use their used close to their boiling point in in most rockets and in our case we we actually loaded the propellant close to the freezing point and that can result in a density Improvement of up to around 10 to 12% which makes an enormous difference in the in the actual results of the rocket it it also makes the it gets rid of any cavitation risk for the turbo pumps and it makes it easier to feed a high pressure turbo pump if you

33:18have very cold propellant really one of the keys here though is the the a vacuum version of rapture having a 382 second ISP th this is really quite critical to to the whole m mission and we're confident we can get to to that number or at least within a few seconds of that number ultimately maybe exceeding it

33:49slightly so the rocket the rocket booster in many ways is is really a scaled up version of the falcon9 booster you'll see a lot of similarities such as the grid fins obviously clustering a lot of engines at the base and the big difference really being that the the primary structure is an advanced form of carbon fiber as opposed to aluminum lithium and that we use autogenous pressurization and and we get rid of the the helium and the the nitrogen so this uses 42 Raptor engines

34:26there a lot of engines but we use nine on a falcon 9 and with Falcon heavy which should launch early next year there's there's 27 engines on the base so we've got pretty good experience with having a large number of engines it also gives us redundancy so that if some of the engines fail you can still continue the mission and be fine but the main job of this of the booster is to accelerate the spaceship to around 85,000 km an hour

35:00and for for those that are less familiar with orbital Dynamics really it's it's all about velocity and and not about height so really that's the job of the the booster the booster is like the javelin thrower sort of it's got to toss that Javelin which is the the spaceship and in the case of other planets

35:21though which have which have a gravity well which is not as deep so Mars moons of Jupiter perceivably one day maybe even Venus the well Venus will be a little trickier but for for most of the solar system you only need the spaceship so you don't you don't need the booster if you have a lower gravity well so no booster is needed on the moon or Mars or any of the moons of Jupiter or Pluto you just need the spaceship the booster is just there for heavy gravity Wells

35:58and then we we've also been able to optimize the propellant needed for Boost back and Landing to get it down to about 7% of the LIF off propellent load we think with some optimization maybe we can get it down to about 6% and we've also are now getting quite comfortable with the accuracy of the landing if you've been watching the The falcon9 Landings you'll see that they're getting increasing increasingly closer to to the bullseye and we think particularly with with the addition of additional with addition of some thrusters some maneuvering thrusters we can actually put the booster right back on the launch stand and then those those spins at the base are essentially

36:36centering features to take out any minor U position mismatch at the L side so it looks like at the base so we think we only need to gimbal or steer the the center cluster of engines so there's seven engines in the center cluster those would be the ones that that move for steering the rocket and the other ones would be fixed in possession which gives us the the best concentration of of we can max out the number of engines because we don't have to leave any room for gambling or moving the engines and and like I said this is all designed so that you could actually lose multiple engines even at lift door for anywhere in flights and continue the mission safely

37:29so the for the spaceship itself in the top we have the the the pressurized compartment I'll show you a fly through of that in a moment then beneath that is the is where we would have the unpressurized cargo which would be really flat packed in a very dense format and and then below that is the liquid oxygen tank the liquid oxygen tank is probably the hardest piece of this whole vehicle cuz it it's got to handle propellant at the coldest level and it and the tanks themselves actually form the for form the airframe so the the airframe structure and the tank structure are combined as it is in in in all modern rockets and in aircraft for example the the wing is

38:15really a fuel tank in in Wing shape so the it has to take the the the the thrust loads of ascent the loads of of re-entry and and then it has to be impermeable to gasius oxygen which is which is tricky and non-reactive to gases oxygen so so that's the that's the hardest piece of of the the spaceship itself which is actually why we started on that element as well and I'll show you some pictures of that later so and then below the oxygen tank is the the fuel tank and then the engines are mounted directly to the the the thrust cone on the base and then there there are there are six of the vacuum the high efficiency see vacuum engines around the perimeter and

39:00those are those those don't gimble and and then there are three of the sea level versions of the engine which do gimble and provide the steering although we can do some some amount of steering if you're in Space by with differential thrust on the outside engines the net effect is a Caro

39:19to Mars of of up to 450 tons depending upon how many refills you do with the the tanker and the goal is at least 100 passengers per ship although I think ultimately we'll probably see that number grow to 200 or more this this chart's a little difficult to interpret at first but I kind of we decided to put it there for people who want to watch the video afterwards and and sort of take a Clos look and analyze some of the numbers

39:51the the column on the left is probably what's most relevant and that's that gives you the trip time so depending upon which Earth Mars rendevu you're aiming for the trip time at 6 K kilm per second departure of last year can be as low as 80 Days and then over time I think we obviously improve that and ultimately I suspect you you'd see Mars transit times of as little as 30 days in in the more distant future so it's it's fairly manageable considering the trips that that people used to do in the old days that routinely take sailing voyages that would be 6 months or

40:36more so on arrival the the heat shield technology is is extremely important we've been refining the the heat shield technology using our Dragon spacecraft and we now have we're now at version three of P which is phenolic impregnated carbon blader and it's getting more and more abust with each new version with with l ablation more resistance less need for ref forment the heat shield is basically a giant brake pad so it's like how good can you make that brake pad against extreme rear entry conditions and minimize the the the cost of refurbishment and and make it so that you could have many flights with no referment at

41:19all this is a flly through of the the crew compartment for just want to give you a sense of what it would feel like to actually be in the spaceship I mean in order to make it appealing and and increase that portion of the vend diagram where people who actually want to go it's got to be really fun and exciting and it can't feel cramped or or boring so

42:20the the crew the crew compartment or the ENT compartment is setups that you can do zerog g games you can float around there'll be like movies lecture polls you cabins a restaurant it'll be like really fun to go you're going to have a great time so the the propellant plant on Mars again this is one of those slides that I won't go into in in detail here but people can think about offline the the key point being that the ingredients are there on Mars to create a propelled plant with relative ease because the atmosphere is primarily CO2 and there's water ice almost everywhere you've got the the CO2 plus H2O to make methane CH4 and oxygen O2

43:11using the S reaction the the trickiest thing really is the the energy source which we think we can do with a large field of of of solar panels so then to give you essential cost really really the key is is making this affordable to almost anyone who wants to go and we think based on this architecture this architecture assuming optimization over time like the very first flights wouldn't be would be fairly expensive but the architecture allows for a cost per ticket of less than $200,000 maybe as less maybe as little as $100,000 over time depending upon how much mass oppos and take so we're right now estimating about $140,000 per ton to the SS of Mars so if a person plus

44:06the luggage is less than that taking into account food consumption and life support then we we think that the the cost of of moving to Ms ultimately could drop below $100,000 so funding these are we thought about funding sources and so we've got steel Underpants launch satellites send carget space station Kickstarter of course followed by profit so the obviously it's going to be a challenge to to fund this this whole Endeavor we do expect to

44:49generate pretty decent net net cash flow from launching lots of satell lights and servicing the space station for NASA transferring kogo to and from space station and and then I know that there's there's a lot of people in the private sector who are interested in helping fund a base on Mars and then perhaps there'll be interest on on the government sector side to also do that ultimately this is going to be u a huge public private partnership and I I think that's that's that's how the United States was established and many other countries around the world is a public private partnership so I think that's probably what what occurs and right now we're just trying to make as

45:39much progress as we can with the resources that that we have available and just sort of keep keep moving both forward and hopefully I I think as we as we show that this is possible that this dream is real not just a dream it can it something that can be made real I think the support will snowball over time and I should say also the the main reason I'm personally accumulating assets is in order to fund this so I I really don't have any other motivation for personally accumulating assets except to be able to make the the biggest contribution I can to making life multiplanetary

46:26[Applause] timelines not the best at this sort of thing but just to show you where we started off in 2002 SpaceX basically consisted of carpet and a mariachi van that that was it that's that's that's all of SpaceX in 2002 as you can see I'm a dancing machine and yeah I believe in

47:12kicking off sreat events with marians I really like marians but but that that that was what we started off with in 2002 and really I mean I thought we had maybe a 10% chance of of of doing anything of even getting a rocket to orbit let alone getting beyond that and and and taking Mars seriously but but I came conclusion that if if if there were if there wasn't some new entrance into into the space Arena W with a strong ideological motivation then it it didn't seem like we were on a trajectory to ever be a space bring civilization and and be out there Among the Stars because you know in ' 69 we were able to go to the moon and the space shuttle could get to

48:00lowth orbit and then obviously the space shuttle got retired but but that trend line is down down to zero so I think what a lot of people don't appreciate is that technology does not automatically improve it it it only improves if if a lot of really strong engineering Talent is applied to the problem that it improves and there are many examples in history where civilizations have reached a certain technology level and then have fallen well below that and and and then recovered only Millennia

48:37later so we go from 2002 where we basically were clueless and then and develop with Falcon 1 the smallest useful orbital rocket that we could think of which would deliver half a turnon to orbit and then four years later we developed the and built the first the first vehicle so we developed the main engine the upper stage engine the the air frames the Fairing and and the the launch system and had our first attempted launch in 2006 which failed so that that lasted about 60 seconds unfortunately but but 2006

49:20four years after starting is also when we we actually got our first NASA contract and I just want to say I'm incredibly grateful to NASA for supporting SpaceX you know despite the fact that our rocket crashed it was awesome I'm NASA's biggest fan so you know thank thank you very much to the people that had the faith to do that thank [Applause]

49:52you so then 2006 followed by a lot of grief and then finally the fourth launch of Falcon 1 worked in 2008 and we were really down to our last pannies in fact I only thought I had enough money for three launches and first three bloody failed and but we're able to scrape together enough to just barely make it and do a fourth launch and that thank thank goodness that fourth launch succeeded in 2008

50:24that was a lot of pain and and then also at the end of 2008 is when when NASA awarded us the first sign the first major operational contract which was for resupplying Caro to the space station and bringing Caro back then a couple years later we did the first launch of Falcon 9 version one and that had about a 10 ton to Orit capability so it was about 20 times the capability of Falcon 1 and also was assigned to to to carry our Dragon spacecraft then 20 2010 is our first

51:03mission to the space station so we were able to finish development of dragon and dock with the space station in 2010 so sorry 20 sorry 2010 is Expendable Expendable drag Expendable Dragon 2012 is when we delivered and returned Caro from the space station 2013 is when we first started doing a vertical take off and Landing tests and then 2014 is when were able to have the first orbital booster do a soft Landing in the ocean The Landing was soft it fell over and exploded but Landing for 7 Seconds it was good and we also improved the

51:49capability of the vehicle from 10 tons to about 13 tons too and then 2015 last year in December that was definitely one of the best moments of my life when the rocket booster came back and landed at Cape canaval so that was really [Applause] yeah so I think I think that that really showed that we could bring an or class booster back from a very high velocity all the way to the launch site and landed safely and and

52:37and with with almost no refurbishment required for reflight and if if things go well we we're hoping to refly one of landed boosters in in a few months so yeah and then 2016 we also demonstrate landing on on a ship the landing on the ship is important for the very high velocity geosynchronous missions and that's that's important for usability of of Falcon 9 because about roughly a quarter of

53:07our missions are are sort of servicing the space station and then there's a few other low orb missions but most of our missions probably you know 60% of our missions are commercial geom missions so U we've got to do these high velocity missions that really need to land on a ship out to sea they don't have enough propellants on board to boost back to the the launch site so looking into the future next steps we were kind of intentionally a bit fuzzy about this timeline but the we're going we're going to try to make as much progress as we can obviously it's with a very constrained budget but we're going to try to make as much progress as we can

53:55on the the elements of the interplanetary transport rooster and spaceship and and hopefully we'll be able to do to complete the first development spaceship in maybe about 4 years and start doing subal flights with with that in fact actually has enough capability that you could maybe even go to orbit if you limit the amount of cargo with the spaceship but well you have to really have to really STP it down but in in in tanker form it can definitely get to orbit can't get back we can get to overit it actually starts thinking like maybe there is some market for really fast transport of stuff around the world provided we can land somewhere where noise is not a super big deal Rockets

54:51are very noisy but we we could transport cargo to anywhere on Earth in 45 minutes at at the longest so most places on Earth would be maybe 20 25 minutes so you know maybe if we had a floating platform out off the coast of you know say off the coast of New York say 20 30 miles out you could go from you know New York to Tokyo in I

55:24don't know 25 minutes across the Atlantic in 10 minutes as really most of your time we be getting to the ship and then there be real quick after that so some intriguing possibilities there although we're not we're not counting on that and then and then development of the booster we actually think the booster part is is relatively straightforward because we've it it's it amounts to a scaling up of the Falcon 9 booster so there's we don't see a lot of sort of showstoppers there yeah so so then but then trying to put it all together and and and and make this actually work for M if if things go super well it might be kind of in the 10-year time frame but

56:14there's there's I don't want to say that's when when it will occur it's like there's a huge amount of risk it's going to cost a lot good chance we don't succeed but going to do our best and and try to make as much progress as as possible yeah and and we're going to try to send something to MOS on every MOS R vi from here on out so Dragon 2 which is a propulsive Lander we plan to send to Mars in in a couple years and and then do probably another dragon mission in 2020 in fact we want to establish steady Cadence that there's always a flight leaving like there a train leaving the station with every Mo Ru we will be trans we will be sending a dragon at least a

57:06dragon to Mars and ultimately the Big Spaceship so if there people that are interested in putting payloads on on Dragon you know you can count on a ship that's going to transport something on the order of of at least two or three tons of useful payload to the surface of Mars [Applause]

57:35yes that's that's part of the reason why we designed Dragon 2 to be a propulsive Lander is as a propulsive Lander you can you can go anywhere in the solar system so you could go to the Moon you could go to well anywhere really whereas say if something relies on parachutes or wings then you can pretty much only well if it's if it's it's Wings you can pretty much only land on Earth because you need a Runway most places don't have a Runway and then any place doesn't have a dense atmosphere you can't use parachutes so but propulsive works anywhere so so Dragon should be capable of landing on any solid or liquid surface in the in the solar

58:20system and then I I was really excited to see that the team managed to do the all up Rapture engine firing in advance of this conference the I just want to say thanks to to the rafter team for really working seven days a week to try to get this done in advance of of the presentation because I I really wanted to show that we've made some Hardware progress in this direction and and the Raptor is a really tricky engine it's a lot trickier than than Mullen because it's a full flow stage combustion much higher pressure and I'm kind of amazed it didn't blow up on the first firing but fortunately it it was it was

59:16good it's kind of interesting to see the mock diamonds forming yeah

59:33so the part and part the reason for making the engine sort of small like Raptor although it has three times the thrust of a Mullen is actually only about the same size as a Mullen engine because it has three times the operating pressure and that means we can use a lot of the production techniques that we've honed with Mullen we're currently producing Merin engines at almost 300 per year so we understand how to make rocket engines in volume U so even though the the M vehicle uses 42 on the base and nine on the upper stage so we 51 engines to to make that's well within our production capabilities for Mullen and this is a similarly similarly sized engine to Mullen except

1:00:19for the expansion ratio so we feel really comfortable about being able to make this engine in volume at at a price that doesn't doesn't break our budget and then we also wanted to make progress on the param structure so as I mentioned this this is really a very difficult thing to make is is to make something out of carbon fiber even though carbon fiber has Incredible strength to weight when when you want want to then put super cold

1:00:55liquid o and liquid methane par particular liquid oxygen in in the tank is subject to to cracking and leaking and it's a it's a very difficult thing to make just the sheer scale of it is is also challenging because you you've got a layup the carbon fiber in exactly the right way on a huge mold and you've got to cure that mold at temperature and and then

1:01:20it's it's and then it's just really hard to make large large carbon fiber stru structures that that can do all of those things and carry incredible loads so so that's that's the other thing we wanted to focus on was the Raptor and then building the first development tank for the Mars

1:01:42spaceship so yeah this this this is this is really the htest part of the of the spaceship the other pieces are we we have a pretty good handle on but this was the the trickiest one so we wanted to tackle it first you get a size for how big the tank is it's really really quite big also big congratulations to the team that worked on that they also were working seven days a week to try to get this done in advance of the IAC and

1:02:13so that we managed to build the first tank and the initial tests with cryogenic propellent actually look quite quite positive we have not seen any leaks or or major issues this is what the the tank looks like on the inside so you can get get a real sense for how much just how big this this tank is the it's actually completely smooth on the inside but the way that the carbon 5 applies lay up and reflect the light makes it look look

1:02:50faceted so then what about Beyond Ms so as we thought about the system and the reason we call it a system because generally I don't like calling things systems because everything's a system including your dog the is that is that it's actually more than a vehicle there's there's obviously the rocket booster the spaceship the tanker and the propellent plant the

1:03:17the Institute propellent production if you have all of those four elements you you can actually go anywhere in the solar system by by by Planet hopping or or Moon hopping so by establishing a propellent Depot on in the asteroid belt or on one of the moons of Jupiter you can go to you can make flights from Mars to Jupiter no problem in fact even from even without a propellent Depo at Mars you can you can do a flyby of of Jupiter

1:03:50without a propellent Depot so but but by establishing a propellent Depot let's say you know en slatus Oro or any of there few few options and then doing another one on Titan jup Saturn's moon and then perhaps another one further out on Pluto or elsewhere in the solar system this system really gives gives you freedom to go anywhere you want ones in the greater solar system so you can actually travel out to the Caper Bel to the Earth Cloud I wouldn't recommend this for Interstellar Journeys but

1:04:37this this this basic system provided we have filling stations along the way is means full access to the entire greater solar system

1:05:01really great to do a mission to Europa particularly all right so any questions that I can answer [Applause]

1:05:26hello yeah D St I can't see a thing by the way so anyway I'll just add I want try to look at you I'll just hear the dis voice okay Derek stos of nasaspaceflight.com okay can you talk a little bit about from the video it looks like launch complex 39a is going to be initial launch site can you talk about some of the initial test flights modifications to the pad and where the booster and spacecraft may be built sorry I think you may need to speak a little bit louder sure the video showed launching from launch complex 39 can you talk a little bit about initial test flights booster construction site and where the spacecraft may be built as it seems to

1:06:07be too large to transport by Road or any other terrestrial transport yeah so we are expecting to do the initial flights from 39a so we're set we're planning to set up 39a such that it can launch either Falcon heavy or the interplanetary system the it's it's quite a big launch site so I think we we we can do that in terms of construction of the the ship and booster you're right it is quite big not something you can really transport on the roads so the I I think we would probably look at construction of the the booster and

1:06:54the spacecraft at some of the gulf Gulf States we're actually looking at Mud Louisiana as one of the possibilities and but but I I think we would end up constructing the booster and spacecraft in in probably multiple States and and then perhaps doing final assembly at the launch site thank

1:07:23you right here hi hi alen right here in front of you I'll jump okay great it's very nice to meet you my name is Aldo and 3 weeks ago I was at Bernie man in the Nevada desert great and it felt like I was in Mars it was a dusty storm and it was really cold at night and there was no water but there was one problem at Bernie man with a population of only 75,000 there was a lot of

1:07:56and there was no water to take it into the rivers which is kind of what we do today in our current sanitation system so I was like is this what Mars going to be like just a Dusty waterless storm so I was like Hey Ellen are you working on a sustainable sanitation are we going to have toilet in Mars that doesn't use water today on Earth there's three billion people that don't have a toilet actually have to say we have to keep it the no essays only questions all right so are you working on the toilet for Mars yeah I think MZ actually has

1:08:36a huge amount of water and water ice so I don't think we'll really suffer a water shortage in MZ the main thing about moss is actually going to be energy if you have energy there's plenty of water because there there's massive amounts of Ice so it's really just about getting huge numbers of solar panels out there and potentially doing geothermal energy and you

1:09:00know ultimately I think assuming the public is receptive you know there might be nuclear I think certainly if you build nuclear on MOS as to whether you transport nuclear to M would be you kind of up the public to decide all right next question I'm George lordos from mitsdm and MIT gsli Elon the first humans on Mars will in the history books as we all know who should these men and women be maybe children too who should these people be carrying the light of humanity to Mars for all of us thank you well I I think the first Journeys Tom Mars are going to be really very dangerous the risk of ferality will be High there's just no way around it so I would not

1:09:49justest have a sending children or it would be basically are you prepared to die then that's okay okay then then you know you're candidate for going but but really this is this is less about like you know who goes there first or it's the thing that really matters is making a a self- sustaining civilization on laws as fast as possible it this is different from Apollo this is you know

1:10:22this is really about minimizing existential risk and and and having a tremendous sense of adventure I mean the thing that MOS really represents I mean there's the whole life insurance and protecting life and ensuring that the land of Consciousness is not extinguished which I think is incredibly important you know backing up the biosphere and to be clear this is not about everyone moving to Mars it's about becoming multiplanetary I think Earth will be a good place for a long time but but but it's just it's the probable lifespan of human civilization will be much greater if we're a multiplet species now that's the defensive argument but the the arent I actually

1:11:05find most compelling is that it is that it would be an incredible Adventure I think it would be the most inspiring thing that I could possibly imagine and life needs to be more than just solving problems every day you need to wake up and be excited about the future and be inspired and want to live

1:11:28thank you thank very much hey hey Elon dick rocket newspace Global you're the best everybody get up for Elon please this guy inspires the out of us come on I've got a gift for you it's a comic book called the future of fusion it's about the first man on Mars looks like you I can't get past El Chapo's militia though so I don't know should I just throw this onto the stage sorry my question is can I give you this gift sure if you had yeah the future of Fusion thank you sir all right thank you hi Elon Lauren grush from The Verge

1:12:02you talk about how the Mars colonization architecture is meant to serve as a backup plan and there's somebody mics here yeah if you can see me okay the Mars architecture is supposed to serve as a backup plan for Humanity but you didn't touch much on how you will keep humans safe on the way over there from either deep space radiation or how they will live on the planet can you give give us some insight into the life support systems habitats stuff like that sure I mean the my

1:12:33view on the radiation thing is that there's certainly some risk of radiation but it's not it's not it's not deadly there will be some slight increased risk of of of cancer but it's it's I think relatively minor you need to have some shielding particularly if there's a solar flare or or sort of a big so any kind of sort of solar storm you want to basically point the rocket at the at the Sun and and maximize your shielding effect you know point the rear of the rocket at the Sun so you maximize your shielding effect and and have the passengers cluster around the column of water but I think the radiation risk there is is relatively small once you're

1:13:15on mass obviously you you cut your radiation in half just because you've got the planet shielding you and then there's at least some atmosphere and I think then when point you can construct over time is an artificial magnetic field to deflect high energy particles so I actually the radiation thing is is is it's often brought up but I think it's not not too big of a deal the and then there's

1:13:41what happens once once people are there I mean the goal of SpaceX is really to build the transport system it's like building the Union Pacific Railroad and and and once once that transport system is built then there's a tremendous opportunity for anyone who wants to go to Mars and create something new or build the the foundations of a new planet so it's like who wants to sort of be you know among the founding members of of a new planet and and like I said build everything from Iron refineries to so the first pizza joint you know we one them all and then things on Mars that no people can't even imagine today that might be unique or would be unique to to Mars and

1:14:32but but that that's that's really where a tremendous amount of Entrepreneurship and talent would flourish just just as happened in California when the Union Pacific Railroad was completed and and when they were building the Union Pacific a lot of people said well that's a super dumb idea because there's no you know there's hardly anybody lives in California but now today we've got sort of the at least the you know us epicenter of Technology development and entertainment and and it's the biggest state in in the nation so but you need that transport link if you can't get there and none of those opportunities exist so so our goal is just to make sure you can get there you

1:15:16thank you you want back okay hi my name isia I would like to ask you the following thing I'm Russian and a lot of people here are from many different countries you're going interplanetary but you're not going International when are you going to higher people from other countries than the

1:15:42US yeah so I think people are a bit confused about this unfortunately this is not up to us so the the US government regulations well they make getting a job in us hard as it is just getting a job Visa hard as it is but if you're working on Rocket technology that's considered an advanced weapons technology so even a normal work visa isn't sufficient unless you get a special permission from the secretary of defense or the or the Secretary of State so I want to be clear this is not some out of some desire of SpaceX to just hire people with with green card it's it's because we're not allowed to do anything else and I I mean I I think this is not a wise thing for this

1:16:33is not a wise policy for you know for the us because there's so many talented people all around the world that we would love to have work at our company but unless unless they can somehow get a green card we can't we're just we're legally prevented from from hiring anyone but for example this is not the case at Tesla Tesla we're about about a quarter of our engineering team is from outside the US and maybe even 30% because we

1:17:05don't have the itar Restriction so I really wish we could do more just hands are tied thank you cool hey Elon so can't wait for the SpaceX in probability Drive looking forward to that but you often talk about wanting to inspire masses and kind of push technology forward for conquest and I'm developing a series with funnier die which is like the top online comedy site found by Will barel and it's about questions not essays yeah yeah quick question so it's about you sending someone to Mars but kind of like that first monkey that got shot into space they're never coming back it's going to be a one-way trip so not necessarily well maybe so you mathematically determine the world's

1:17:48most Expendable human being to make the journey and that's Michael Sarah so wanted to see if this is like a project that you might have any interest in supporting funni your die just drove 31 million views to a like Hillary Clinton's Z Ghan video a few days ago want to see if might be able to talk about it after I I think I think it's pretty important to give people the option of returning like the the number of people who will be willing to move to MZ is much greater if they know that they have the option of returning even if they never actually return I mean most of the people that went to the origal English colonies in North America they never returned to

1:18:27Europe even once but but some did and just knowing that if you don't like it there that you can come back I think makes a big difference in people's willingness to to go there in the first place and in any case we need the spaceship back so it's it's coming you can jump on board or not it's cool you get you get a free return trip if you want

1:18:55hi Elon Cameron ashgar here from the outer space education Alliance over the years we've watched an admiration as you've drawn up great blueprints of how we are going to get to Mars I'm just curious about what type of initiatives you have in mind for answering the question of why and increasing public interest and actually Desiring to do such a thing that's so vast and complex no exactly that's that's why I really want I start off the The Talk by saying what really matters is intersection of sets intersection of sets of people that want to go and can't afford to go so anything that can be done to increase the desire of people to go I think is a good thing and

1:19:39there's I mean there's been a lot of Mars shows Mars you know movies and and there's some TV shows that I know that are getting written and you you really want to create the the dream of M in people's minds and have it be like you know it's the new frontier and it's and make it as exciting and fun and desirable as possible so I think this is where this is where the entertainment industry can play a huge role and just make in just just imagine you know putting putting that dream in people's heads showing them what it can be like and and I think this is really something that appeals to anybody with with an exploratory Spirit if if if you if you're an

1:20:29Explorer if if you want to be on the frontier and and push the envelope and and you know be where things are super exciting even if it's dangerous that's I mean that's really who we're appealing to here and but I think anything that anyone here could do in that direction would would would be great getting people excited excited about going getting the public behind this and and and and the truth is like right now on Earth you can basically go anywhere in 24 hours I mean anywhere go you can get you can go you can fly over the Antarctic pole and parachute out 24 hours from now if you want you can get you can get get parachuted to

1:21:19the top of Mount Everest from the right plane and that you can go to the bottom of the ocean Earth Earth from a physical standpoint you can go anywhere anywhere so there is no real physical Frontier on Earth anymore but space is is that Frontier and so I think it's going to appeal to anyone with that with that exploratory spirit thank you very much hey hello I'm Laura back here

1:21:56man it's really hard to figure out where the dis Voice is coming from like I was I wanted to ask you like for some normal people like me what would it take physically do you need some requirements or something to get Mars sorry I I can't hear you yeah like if normal people want to travel to Mars do we need some specific requirements or do normal people can go there no I mean we're trying to make it such that anyone can go yeah but you know do we need like a

1:22:32lot of training or something special nope maybe a few days of training yeah also I mean TR more if you want I wanted to ask you in in behalf of all the ladies can I go upstairs and give you a kiss a good luck kiss [Applause] sounds sounds sounds great I don't have him here but I appreciate thank you appreciate the thought hi Jeff house space news over on your right question on resources how much resources are you putting into this development right now in terms of funding employees and so on and how do you expect that to change as the development of the booster and spaceship ramp up well right now the resources that have been put into the interplanetary transport system are are

1:23:24pretty low I mean certainly well under 5% of the company and maybe we're spending a few tens of millions of dollars on it right now so it's it's relatively small and but then as as we finish development of the sort of the the final version of Falcon 9 which should be sometime next year and dragon 2

1:23:54and and and and get the reusability of the Boost stage and reusability of Dragon 2 sorted out then we we'll gradually apply more more resources to the interplanetary system and so hopefully over time we'll be able to have most of our engineering team well we will perhaps within a year and a half to two years we should have most of SpaceX engineering working on the interplanetary system system and hopefully be able to spend maybe more in the order of of a couple hundred million do a year maybe $300 million a year on on the system still not a lot relative to the overall thing and you know in order to make this whole thing work and work reliably before it starts

1:24:44generating maybe some kind of positive cash flow is I mean it's probably an investment on the order of $10 billion so it's you know a lot of money to get there hi Elon my name is Zach I'm a space Enthusiast and a local idiot for Rooster Teeth and I was just wondering you know can you talk a little bit about the future of humans in space and are you going to go to Mars cuz I I would hate to put in all this work and then not go yeah I would definitely I would definitely like to go to orbit and maybe visit the space station station and then ultimately go to Mars you I got to make sure that if something goes wrong in the flight and you know I die then you know that

1:25:40there's a good succession plan and that the mission of the company continues and and that it doesn't somehow get taken over by investors who just want to you know maximize the the profit of the company and not go to Mars that would be my biggest fear in that situation thank you so

1:26:03much hi Mr musk this is Nancy wolson with Autos space education Alliance and I know you've been talking about a getting to Mars can you can you see me here I can yes okay I see I can see your arms hey right here okay so and I know we need to get first to Mars but I have a question in the back of your head have you been thinking about Interstellar travel Interstellar yes I mean I think if we were to do Interstellar travel the best way to do it would would be with kind of an antimatter Drive that would give you the best obviously Mass efficiency it's difficult to be antimatter

1:26:50so I you know but even in the best cas case scenario that's really quite a long journey even to get to proximus Andor I think the key thing is to establish a a base on on Mars and as soon as there's a base on Mars then there's a a very powerful forcing function for improving space transport technology I mean right now there there just isn't that forcing function because all we do is is is very local stuff in in Earth orbits so as soon as we've got a base on on

1:27:28Mars we can see even a base on the moon but but certainly based on laws that creates a very powerful forcing function for making space technology better and better every year and and and that's ultimately what will lead us to Interstellar travel I think trying to do Interstellar travel right off the bat is would be very tricky

1:27:50you know sort of like if you're if you're developing aircraft you really want to First do the right flyer and then maybe get to a DC3 and then a 707 and a and then a you know 747 but but trying to build the 747 right off the bat would be a toll order so yeah I agree but you agree that it's something that we need to start talking about oh yeah I think it's definitely worth talking about I mean I think the the technical solution like I said is is is I think optimally antimatter I see yes okay thank you for coming to the iic 2016 by the way right thanks thanks for having [Music] me I was curious to know if you ever considered the idea of using a cycler

1:28:43and a semic cycler to go to Mars on a routine basis and if yes why didn't you eventually go for it yeah I think the I know when we do the TR trying to figure out the best cost per unit Mass to the surface of Mars the I mean you could do a cycl but I would our calculations at least show that it's just better to go directly there and and not have a cycler the transit time actually matters quite a lot for reuse for reuse of the space spaceship so if you can if you can reuse that spaceship very frequently then your cost per T to

1:29:32Mars drops drops a lot so now we could be wrong about that and it could turn out in the future that having a cycler is is a good way to go but I would consider that to be in the realm of potential future optimization along with having a prop propellent Depot on the moon that that might make sense but I say put that in the the category of future optimization thank you hello Elon Tim DOD here the everyday astronaut with space flight now and now in the animation you showed the passengers loading up onto MCT and or sorry the interplanetary IP yeah and then going into orbit we're thinking about names I I mean it's it's it's the names thing is really really hard think I think like

1:30:18maybe for for the the name of the first ship that goes to Mars not the name of the whole sort of the ship line or whatever necessarily but the first ship that goes to Mars like my current favorite is is Heart of Gold from the hit is Guide to the Galaxy so I think I probably we'll name the first ship that goes to Mars hard of gold and I like the fact that it's that it's driven by infinite improbability because I think our ship is also extremely improbable so

1:30:55so I like the infinite probability Drive the the acronym is not the best you know but you show it going into orbit with the 100 passengers and then refueling it three to five times and then doing your Mars injection right is this the plan or is it to have a fully fueled you know IP or MCT or whatever and then put passengers on board or can you tell me a little bit about that process yeah so the it it really

1:31:24kind of depends on how quickly we do the a propellent replenishment and how many missions are pure cargo versus have people on board if we can do the the the refueling very quickly then we can send people up there and maybe complete the refueling process in a few weeks if but if if we're loading spacecraft into orbit with crew compartment say year in advance you wouldn't want people on board then so what we would do is probably just launch a one of the just do a mission

1:32:04which all it does is transfer people so it would it would wait until the spacecraft is fully fueled then launch another spacecraft which docks and transfers people from the empty one which with tanks empty to one with tanks full yep that makes sense thank you all right hello IND my name is Alonso I think what you presented today is just incredible what I want to change a little bit topic I have a startup to make electric public transport buses to to convert it space space questions only sorry oh sorry the thing is I just have my prod outside it would be awesome if you could go out and see it it's a 30 ton electric box yeah great space questions this is a the IAC so we're

1:32:50space questions only my name St to of s space intelligence okay and and looks like we just have time for a few more questions so maybe we take two or three more questions and then my question was is with respect to NASA and its own Mars plan do you think they should back your plan and use SLS for just the Luna missions instead and also do you intend to be the first man on Mars I think it's good for there to be multiple paths to to Mars so you

1:33:22know I wouldn't suggest any anything you know any attempt at interplanetary Travel be be canceled I I think it's good to have multiple irons in the fire and and in fact like a big part of me coming here today was to really try to encourage the International Community to to to to to think about building architectures like this I I think it's actually much better for the world if there are multiple companies or organizations building interplanetary spacecraft you know the more the better anything I think that improves the probability that the future is good and and so so and multiple companies doing it I think would be would be would be great so I wanted to come and

1:34:16describe the architecture in actually in the hopes that this would encourage companies and organizations around the world to perhaps do something like this or maybe they've got a better architecture that's why I wanted to do at at the IC was to really encourage really encourage people to compete with spaceex or potentially team up or just just get get the community in general to think about going to Mars and taking Mars seriously but but you could use more funding from n of course so sorry I can't hear you you could use some more funding from and also will you be the first man on Mars I I don't think so maybe

1:35:00but I I I'm not really sure I have to I don't know the pros and cons to that because like I said I if if I I would definitely need to have a very good succession plan because the probability of death is quite high on the first mission so and I'd like to see my kids grow up and everything so some pros and cons there than I'm sorry we're out of time and have to make way for a new session so this is going to be our last question sorry yeah have to make room for a new session sorry guys thank you thank you for coming thank you for listening question

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份