2016 年 10 月 28 日,洛杉矶环球影城的一条布景街道上,马斯克上台先解释了一件事:这次他没穿那件毛绒外套。
然后他把这场发布会的大部分时间,用来讲一块瓦片。
产品叫太阳能屋顶(Solar Roof)。台下的人第一眼看到的,是几栋普通得不能再普通的加州住宅,屋顶铺着黑色、灰色、板岩色的瓦。马斯克说,这些瓦全都能发电。
他给出的条件摆在一起是这样的:比普通屋顶好看、比普通屋顶结实、比普通屋顶隔热好、比普通屋顶寿命长,而且装完之后的总花费,低于「普通屋顶的安装费加上同等电量的电费」。
如果这些条件同时成立,你为什么要选别的?(马斯克)
这句话是整场发布会的支点。它听上去像一句营销口号,其实是个很硬的工程约束:只要有一项不成立,整个逻辑就塌了。
他先讲了一段电动车的历史,因为太阳能正在重演
发布会开场,马斯克没有立刻讲屋顶。他先讲电动车。
十几年前的电动车长什么样,很多人还记得:外形奇怪、续航很短、性能差,开起来像一台高尔夫球车。消费者不是不环保,是不愿意为了环保买一台自己不想开的车。马斯克说,这个局面直到 Roadster 和 Model S 出现才被打破,电动车先是变成一台好车,然后才变成一台值得买的车。
太阳能行业当时的状态,和当年的电动车几乎一模一样。
屋顶上的太阳能板是后来加装的,凸出来一块,管线露在外面,颜色和屋顶对不上,看着像给房子打了个补丁。装它的理由只有一个:省电费。为了省钱,忍受一块丑东西在头顶上待二十五年。
马斯克的判断很直接:太阳能需要的是一次同样的转变,从「忍受」变成「想要」。
我们需要让太阳能板变得像今天的电动车一样有吸引力。(马斯克)
注意他用的词是「有吸引力」,不是「更便宜」。便宜解决的是犹豫,吸引力解决的是主动。这两个词的差别,决定了后面所有产品设计的取向。
那条竖着往上爬的曲线
讲完审美,马斯克放了一张图。
NASA 的二氧化碳浓度曲线,横轴是时间,纵轴是浓度,几十年来一路往上,末端几乎是垂直线。他说,全球变暖已经是一个严重危机,我们需要尽一切可能,加速向可持续能源的转型。
这张图在气候领域的发布会上出现过无数次,多数时候是作为背景板。这次它承担的功能不太一样:它要说明「加速」这两个字有多紧迫,从而解释 Tesla 为什么要做一件看起来和汽车无关的事。
因为屋顶属于建筑行业,电池属于电力行业,车属于交通行业。三件事在传统产业划分里毫无关系。
Tesla 的使命从来不是造车
马斯克在这里说了一段容易被忽略的话。
人们习惯把 Tesla 当成一家电动车公司。但 Tesla 真正的目的,是加速可持续能源的到来。当年之所以从车做起,是因为别的地方没有缺口。
世界上并不缺汽车公司,好的汽油车公司有很多,缺的是好的电动车,这才是当时真正需要的东西。(马斯克)
这段话解释了 Tesla 后来的产品线为什么长成那个样子。车是切入点,不是终点。
他把解决方案拆成三块,说得很干脆:
- 一块足够好看的太阳能屋顶,负责发电
- 一组电池,负责把白天存的电留到晚上用
- 一台电动车,负责把交通环节的石油消费换成电
这三块拼起来,才是一个家庭能源的完整闭环。少任何一块,闭环就断了。
太阳晚上不发光,所以电池是必需品
马斯克用了一个很朴素的解释。
太阳能屋顶在白天发电,可家里的用电高峰偏偏在傍晚。太阳落山那会儿,屋顶的输出往下掉,人回到家,灯开了,饭做了,空调开了,用电曲线往上冲。这两条曲线的交叉点,就是整个能源转型最难处理的地方。
他的说法是,我们现在正处在从白天过渡到夜晚的那个黄昏时刻,房子从「屋顶供电」切换到「电池供电」。
电池的作用就是把时间错开:白天把电存进去,晚上拿出来用。技术上讲,这就是个搬运工。
道理其实不复杂,你只需要一个电池。(马斯克)
但这句话成立的前提是成本。当时的家用储能还很贵,装一套下去,回本周期长得吓人。这场发布会同时更新的 Powerwall(家用储能墙)和 Powerpack(商用储能柜),正是冲着成本去的。
Powerwall 2 和 Powerpack 2 的数字
第二代 Powerwall 相比第一代,能量翻了一倍,功率翻了一倍还多。
具体规格:14 千瓦时储能容量,7 千瓦功率输出。马斯克把这个数字翻译成了生活场景:一栋四居室的房子,冰箱、插座、照明每天都能靠它供电;如果屋顶装了太阳能,这套系统可以无限期地供下去。
商用侧是 Powerpack 2,同样把能量翻倍,200 千瓦时容量,50 千瓦功率输出,而且可以按需扩展到任意规模。
接着他报了两个项目。
一个是和南加州爱迪生公司(Southern California Edison)合作的电站级储能项目,规模 80 兆瓦时,当时正在建设,是当时全世界最大的公用事业电池安装项目。
另一个是当年早些时候在夏威夷考艾岛(Kauai)落地的项目,52 兆瓦时。
两个数字放在一起能看出节奏:从几十兆瓦时起步,几年之内要往吉瓦时走。马斯克说,这类项目接下来会越来越多地出现在新闻里。
太阳能不是公用事业的敌人,这个误会需要澄清
发布会有个容易被跳过的段落,讲的是定位问题。
外界常常把屋顶太阳能理解成电力公司的对手:用户自己发电,从电网买电变少,公用事业的生意被抢走。马斯克专门回应了这一点。
有时候太阳能屋顶被摆成公用事业的竞争对手,但我们实际上既需要公用事业电力继续增长,也需要本地发电。(马斯克)
他给的理由是需求端的结构性变化。当交通、供暖和其他环节都从烧油烧气改成用电,全社会需要的电量大约会变成现在的三倍。他给的拆分是:三分之一来自交通,三分之一来自供暖,剩下的三分之一来自其他用途。
总需求涨三倍,这意味着即便家家户户都装了屋顶,电网也不可能被架空。他把未来的结构预测成一个比例:大约三分之一来自本地发电,大约三分之二来自公用事业规模的电站。
这个判断对后来几年的能源讨论很有参考价值。屋顶太阳能和集中式电站的关系,从那时起就不是替代,是分工。分布式解决的是自发自用和供电韧性,集中式解决的是规模经济。
四块瓦片,一块一块看
产品发布的部分,马斯克用了四栋房子做演示,每栋对应一种瓦型。
第一栋是纹理玻璃瓦(textured glass tile)。他让人把镜头推近,透过玻璃能看见底下的太阳能电池片。这种设计的思路是把电池藏在纹理后面,远看是一片有质感的瓦,近看才有隐约的网格。
第二栋是法国板岩风格(French slate)。马斯克特意强调,板岩是常规屋顶里最难仿的一种,因为它的表面不规则,颜色深浅有变化,一块一块都有细微差别。能把板岩做出来,基本等于把最难的一关过了。
第三栋是现代风格的平滑玻璃瓦(smooth glass tile)。这一种的视觉效果变化最剧烈,前后对比照片放出来,观众的反应是房子整个换了风格。
第四栋用的是托斯卡纳玻璃瓦(Tuscan glass),也是价格最高的一种。做法是把深色和浅色的瓦交错铺,深色的那些里面带太阳能电池。远看是地中海风格的深浅拼色,实际上是电池片在特定位置上的排布。
水转印:让每块瓦都不一样
板岩效果是怎么做出来的,马斯克讲了个细节。
用的是水转印工艺(hydrographic printing)。每一块瓦的表面花纹都是单独印上去的,生产过程本身就带随机性,所以出现了他在台上说的那个说法:一块瓦就是一片雪花。
没有两块屋顶会是一样的。你随便挑两栋房子,它们的屋顶看起来就是不同的,因为它们真的不同。(马斯克)
这个细节解决的是屋顶行业一个长期存在的观感问题。常规屋顶的瓦是批量生产的标准件,铺满一整面屋顶之后,重复的纹理反而暴露了它是工业品。手工板岩之所以贵,就贵在那个「不一样」。
用印刷的方式把「不一样」量产出来,成本结构和观感就同时成立了。
街上看不透明,太阳看透明
托斯卡纳那栋房子上,马斯克还讲了一个光学方案。
瓦片表面覆了一层带微管的薄膜(microtubules film),视角改变时,它会从透明变成不透明。
从街上往上看,太阳的角度很高,薄膜是透明的,你能看到底下的电池片。从路人的角度平视,角度变得很浅,薄膜变成不透明,看到的就是一块完整的、有颜色的瓦。
这个方案的目的不在发电效率,在观感。它让「屋顶上有太阳能电池」这件事,只在需要的时候才被看见。
拿重物砸给你看
外观讲完,马斯克转向耐用性。
玻璃瓦的优势是材料本身。玻璃比传统的水泥瓦、陶瓦更硬,也更耐候。现场放了一段对比视频:同一个重物,分别砸在常规屋顶瓦和玻璃瓦上。
结果不用猜。常规瓦碎了,玻璃瓦扛住了。
这一步在整个论证里位置很重要。它堵住了一个必然会被问到的质疑:玻璃会不会很脆,冰雹来了怎么办,屋顶上走人怎么办。马斯克的回答方式是把实验拍下来,直接放给观众看。
美国每年四到五百万个新屋顶,全球是这个数字的二十倍
最后是市场规模。
马斯克给的数据是:美国每年更换的新屋顶大约四到五百万个,全球范围内这个数字要乘以二十,也就是八千万到一亿个。
这个数字解释了为什么太阳能屋顶和传统太阳能板是两个不同的市场。已经装好屋顶的房子,加装太阳能板是合理选择;正在新建或者正在翻修屋顶的房子,直接铺太阳能瓦才是合理选择,因为屋顶本身的钱反正要花。
他的推演很朴素:随着人们陆续更换屋顶,整个社区会一个一个变成太阳能屋顶。等到某一天,邻居之间互相看,会觉得不装才是奇怪的选择。
时间长了,每一栋房子都会变成太阳能房子。而且这个过程会让整个社区变好看。(马斯克)
他要的是一种炫耀感
发布会结尾,马斯克说了这场演讲里最不像工程师的一句话。
他说,如果太阳能做得足够好,你会想把它装在房子最显眼的位置,而不是藏在背面。你会把邻居叫过来,指着屋顶说,看看这个。
这听起来有点疯,但我们需要的就是这个。人们真的很在乎自己的房子,他们爱自己的房子,他们希望房子变得更好。(马斯克)
这段话点出了一件事:能源产品的普及速度,取决于它能不能被炫耀。
屋顶是房子里最难改动、也最显眼的部件。一块装上去要被看二十五年的东西,用户对它的美观要求,从来没有被行业认真对待过。行业默认用户只算经济账,于是二十年里给出的方案都是「加了块板子」。
马斯克把这个顺序倒过来了。先做成一块好瓦,再让它发电。发电能力藏在外观后面,不抢戏。
发布会最后一句是:这就是我们前进的方向,这就是我们想要的未来。
这场发布会真正的赌注
事后回看,这场发布会押注的东西比产品本身更值得琢磨。
它赌的是「屋顶 + 电池 + 车」这个组合会在同一个用户身上发生,赌的是三块业务能互相导流,赌的是用户愿意为美观多付一点、然后在电费上省回来。
这也是 Tesla 当时正在收购 SolarCity 的背景。一家做车的公司、一家做光伏的公司、一条做电池的产品线,要在同一套家庭能源方案里合并。发布会选在这个节点,本身就是一次表态。
风险也很明显。屋顶是本地生意,靠的是大量持证安装商,靠的是一户一户上门丈量。汽车可以集中生产、集中交付,屋顶不行。这套产品最后卖得好不好,取决于安装网络能不能跟上,而不取决于瓦片本身好不好看。
马斯克在台上没有回避这个难度,他只是把顺序摆出来了:先把产品做到让人想要,剩下的才有的谈。
产品不好,渠道再强也卖不动。这个顺序反了二十年,他想把它正过来。
- 评估屋顶光伏方案时,把「屋顶翻新成本 + 25 年电费」合成一个总数字再横向比较,只比每瓦单价会漏掉最贵的那一项
- 看任何储能产品,先确认它的功率和容量配比是否匹配你的负载曲线,容量大而功率小的产品带不动空调和电炉
- 判断一家能源公司的长期战略,看它的产品线能不能拼成闭环,只能单卖硬件的公司很难在价格战里活下来
- 关注交通和供暖电动化对电网的用电量影响,三倍需求是规划储能和充电设施时的基准假设,而不是极端情形
- 做产品定义时,把「用户会不会主动展示它」当成一个真实指标,美观是可量化的采用率变量,不是附加项
- 如果你想验证一个新兴硬件品类,去看它的安装环节能不能规模化,交付重人力是这类产品最常见的死因
- 观察供应链,玻璃瓦这类产品降价靠的是产线上量,盯住产能爬坡的节点,比盯住发布会上的定价更有效
0:04yeah no fuzzy jacket this time so the other side of bags talking about the booze no doing this which is as made the thread reaching record co2 levels and global warming is becoming a serious where is a serious crisis and we need to do something about that and the but just like with electric cars where the electric cars originally would they didn't look good they hadn't arranged they didn't have good performance and they're like a golf cart and support had a real hard time buying electric cars and I think you know something similar
0:46needs to happen to solely really need to make solar panels as appealing as as look for cars have become and the your piercing things that has you see around you all so louses if you know that did you notice totally thought that by teach them but the goal is to make have electric solar
1:15roofs that look better than normal roof Claire electricity at last longer a better insulation and actually have a cost an installed cost that is less than a normal roof plus the cost of electricity so why would you buy anything else so let's get into going to get into the details here so obviously sort of the chart they're probably familiar with with that trial decay from from NASA about how we're vertical climb on co2 levels and we need to do
1:52everything we possibly can to accelerate the transition to sustainable energy so so the goal of Tessa Tessa importance think Tesla as the electric car company but but really a bit all purpose of Tesla was to accelerate the event of sustainable energy it sounds like it's not like there was a shortage of car companies in the world the plenty of good gasoline car companies but they weren't good electric cars that's that's really what was needed so the only three parts to the solution and so we go to
2:28what is the future that we want it consists of a really appealing solar roof and then combine that with with storage and with little cars so it's the thing it's a others three-part solution yeah chief a solution is assuring that complicated now you need battery packs because the Sun does not shine at night and the point that worked right now is a factor of the transition which are transitioning from day to tonight it's dusk and so what's happening is that the
3:10houses are transitioning from the roof generating power to the battery pack this with the powerwall producing power so during the day you fill up the battery and then at night and that's been doing you use the battery and straightforward really it's like not that complicated you just need a both/and but if you have a great solar
3:39roof and you have a battery pack your house and an electric car that's the way that scales worldwide that you can you can solve the whole energy equation look at so yeah obviously looks like you so it's a look like Jeff just the power 12 but this is a big step above the powerful one and it has twice as much energy and more than twice as much power so it's a 14-14 fill at our energy storage seven collect our backrub and just put that in basic terms we can take a four-bedroom house and you can have you can get empowered the refrig the sockets and lights every day and if you have solar on your on your own your house you can power it indefinitely so
4:36that's just with one and and then on the utility side we've got the power back to which similarly doubles the energy so it's a turn turn kill at our capability 50 kilowatt power output and this current scale to unlimited size so it's a in fact we've recently announced the the biggest utility battery installation
5:08in the world which is going to be with psychiatry Edison it's going next site and so with an 80 megawatt hour battery installation that's being broke right now so and then when I was born earlier this year which is 430 in Hawaii during 52 megawatt hours when you see a lot more of these announced over time and I think I think it's point to a ship or people appreciate that the solution is both a local power generation and utility power generation it's not one or the other sometimes this was the sunroof yes position as a competitor to two utilities but we're actually going to need a utility power to increase and we're going to need local power generation because if you transition old
6:01energy to to electric that they're roughly triples the amount of electricity that's needed so and about a third for transport about a third floor heating about a third for will require use of electricity so the future is bright for Israelis and full for local power generation I'd expect it to be roughly a third local power generation roughly two-thirds are utility so it's a very severe by future full for utilities and Photoshop
6:35so let's look at take a look at some of these works well as initially what we're looking for here is how do we have a sunroof that is better than the normal way and that looks better last longer has better insulating effect and where the cost of roof plus electricity is less than that of memory now this is this is sort of the integrator future we've got a electric car a power wall
7:06and silicon a sunroof and the key is that it needs to be beautiful affordable and seamlessly integrated and I mean if all those things are true why would you go any other direction so yeah so we
7:31show you this is the before shot of that house there so that's what I looked like before now that's also yeah we've got some close-up shots let me confer if you look if you look carefully you can actually see those the solar cells behind the glass I'll actually pick up I so you can show you what I mean this is a textured glass
8:18tile if you look carefully you can see the syllabus all cells that see that so that more functionality stick take a look at the next house like so that house is also solar and that's a sort of a salad bit of a French slate which is one of the hardest things to do this it's considered one of the best groups you can possibly do as a convention roof so well if it can we make a French slate
9:01roof that's so low that looks as good or better than with conventional first lately and we were able to do that as well and less time with hydrographic printing so each tile is unique so that it's the production process itself makes each tile as special unique is with special snowflake tile the the nice
9:27thing is like no two roofs will be the same so it's not just cookie cutter you can take any two roofs like that and they will look different because they are different this is the sweat the French like hydrographic looks like let's see that
10:03and then the third house is really transformative just believe it or not that's what it looked like before so we changed the roof one is like whoa you put that roof on we're going to change the house too so that that you know that tile is is more of a modern work
10:45if we can really see as the angle changes that you can see the solar cells so here we put a film with microtubules on it so that as as the angle changes it goes from transparent to opaque so from the vantage point of the street or anyone near the house it looks completely opaque but from the Sun it's to Tucson it's transparent and then
11:29probably the most price of one is that the testin testin glass so this is also solar panels but we put two versions of the testing Ross approach all of the dark tiles have solar panels so we interleave a dark and light and then the dark ones are the ones with solar panels
12:06then you can see that the transparency changes quite a bit so as you're from the sun's matters point which tends to be high angle you can see that the soul of the solar cells but as you change the angle to shallow angle it relates to ISIL vote RG color
12:37so that so many other advantages of glass is that we can actually make it a lot a lot tougher and lasted longer than a conventional roof so we're just as a demonstration video sure what happens if you drop a drop the big weight on a conventional roof tile and one of our glass tiles
13:02so so the solar point just want to look better last longer provide better insulation and cost less All Things Considered than a conventional roof and that the solar shears walking for the current solar systems because then if you're building a new house or you're redoing a roof then this is the way to go but if you're if you have a new roof then you obviously want to put solar panels on that roof so there's there's two very distinct markets and it is about at four to five million new roofs in the US over here and I think 20 times that number worldwide so the convention over time as people replace their roofs will soar roofs that the whole neighborhood whatever everyone would
13:57have solar like why wouldn't buy wing to you overtime every every house would become a solar house and it's it's a neighborhood where the aesthetics actually get better so where you look around your neighborhood and that's what you want to have happen so the key is really to make to make solar something desirable where if you install a solely from your house I mean really private you want you want to put it on the most prominent part of the house you want to call your neighbors over and say check up check out the sweet worth like you're crazy here often a little
14:39bit but that's that's the cuter people people really care about the homes they love their homes and they really want they want food to be better and I think taking this approach it can be so that's the best that's where we're headed and our PP that's the future we want
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版