访谈·中文精读

马斯克与塔克·卡尔森完整专访

Full interview Elon Musk & Tucker Carlson

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

「你估计我的刑期会有多长?」

马斯克把这个问题抛给塔克·卡尔森的时候,脸上还挂着笑。但紧接着他说,自己真不知道,如果特朗普输掉 2024 年大选,他还能不能见到自己的孩子。

卡尔森提醒他,你没办法说自己只是路过。

马斯克承认,他早就踩不到底了。「全押了,宝贝。」

整场对话里他很少用玩笑回答严肃问题,这一次是例外。剩下两个小时,他都在算账:算合同被拿走的账、算移民进入摇摆州的账、算加州高铁每英尺混凝土的造价、算 AI 把误称性别排在核战争之前的概率。

他先把坐牢这件事想过一遍

卡尔森问他,做这个决定之前有没有长期思考过后果。

马斯克的回答是,如果特朗普输,可能会有某种报复落到他身上。他用了「possible」这个词,没往下展开。

他更愿意谈另一件事:他大概是美国最大的政府承包商之一,外界却以为他的公司靠政府补贴活着。

他举了两个具体例子来反驳。

波音拿了两倍的钱,只送上去一个人

NASA 当初给了两份商业载人合同,一份给波音,一份给 SpaceX。波音拿到的是 SpaceX 的两倍金额。

结果是,国际空间站的所有宇航员运输任务,SpaceX 全做完了。波音送上去两名宇航员中的一名,剩下的人还得靠 SpaceX 接回来。

「波音拿的钱是我们的两倍。」马斯克重复了一遍。

然后是 FCC 那桩事。

联邦通信委员会设了一个 420 亿美元的农村宽带补贴项目。马斯克说,SpaceX 一开始其实建议这个项目根本不该存在,不该有任何补贴。但既然一定要搞,那就竞争吧。

星链的产品更好,赢了大约四分之一,覆盖区域包括北卡罗来纳这类后来被飓风摧毁的地方。

然后 FCC 五名委员投票,三票对两票,把中标资格取消了。

马斯克特意点出票型:三位民主党委员投反对,两位共和党委员投赞成。

卡尔森问,这算政治操作吗。

马斯克反问:你知道他们这几票之后,实际连上了多少户?

零。

北卡罗来纳那个死循环

飓风过后,北卡罗来纳西部通信中断,星链成了灾区主要的通信手段。SpaceX 运了几千台终端进去。

他们想把设备送到更深的区域,打算用直升机空投给被困的人。

FAA 的规定是:直升机降落前,必须知道要和谁接头。

问题在于,那些人没有网络,所以没人知道他们是谁。而他们也没有网络,所以没法主动联系外面。

马斯克说,你去体会一下这个圈。

他后来公开抱怨了这件事。交通部长布蒂吉格(Pete Buttigieg)打电话过来,两人把问题捋清楚,规定被修正了。

马斯克在这段特意给布蒂吉格记了一功:一旦他知道了问题,他就解决了。他还补了一句,自己发公开帖施压,不等于不给对方功劳。

他给民主党算的一笔人口账

卡尔森把话题拽回那个最初的问题:你都押上了,万一不成呢。

马斯克的答案不是讲自己,是讲选举本身。

「我的看法是,如果特朗普不赢这次选举,这就是我们最后一次选举。」

他的论据是一套人口时间表。

民主党政府有一个叫 CBP One 的边境应用,很多人根本不知道它存在。在马斯克看来,那是一条几乎没人注意的通道,把大量人送进美国,再把这些人运到摇摆州。

他给出的数据来源是政府自己的网站,由民主党政府运营。过去三年,进入所有摇摆州的非法移民数量出现三位数增长,某些州涨幅到 700%。

为什么这件事对选举有决定性?他讲了法律路径:

一个人获得庇护身份后会被快速通道处理,拿到绿卡,绿卡满五年可以申请公民身份,成为公民后就能合法投票,而这些人投票压倒性偏向民主党。

卡尔森插了一句常见的反驳:很多人拉美裔的社会价值观其实和极左不符。

马斯克承认这一点,但他说那不重要。他们的首要诉求是把亲戚朋友也弄到美国来,而民主党的福利项目让这些人对民主党产生依附。

他的预测是:再来四年民主党政府,足够多的人被合法化,下一届就没有摇摆州了。

美国现在只有六个州还在真正竞争。六个州一旦不竞争,剩下的唯一悬念就是谁赢民主党初选。

加州就是提前上演的版本

马斯克把加州当成证据。

1986 年那次大赦之后,加州的政治曲线一路转蓝。1992 年克林顿输掉加州,却赢下西弗吉尼亚。今天的加州立法机构里,民主党占三分之二以上。

州好不好?马斯克说没有变好。

他提到最近一条让他觉得不真实的法律:加州通过立法,规定任何选举都不得要求出示身份证,连镇议会选举也不行。纽森(Gavin Newsom)上周签了字。

他讲了一个朋友的经历。这位朋友住在帕洛阿尔托,看到新闻不信,跑去参加一场市议会选举投票,主动掏出身份证,工作人员告诉他:我们不被允许看你的证件。

马斯克把这份清单摊开:买枪要 ID,买酒要 ID,买一包烟要 ID,坐飞机要 ID,住酒店要 ID。只有投票,法律规定不许看你的 ID。

当年最积极要求疫苗护照、不出示证件不许旅行的那批人,现在说选民查 ID 是种族主义。

马斯克的反驳很直接:说某个种族的人搞不到一张身份证,这种话本身才是种族主义和居高临下。他顺手举了纽约州长的例子,说贫民窟的人不会用电脑,这种判断离现实有多远。

他给出的结论没有任何缓冲:不给选民查 ID,唯一的功能就是让舞弊无法被证明。可以大规模作弊,而且永远查不出来,因为连出示证件的资格都被取消了。

一千个傀儡大师

卡尔森问,那贺锦丽(Kamala Harris)这个人本身呢。

马斯克的回答是,批她几乎没意义。她只是一台更大机器的脸。

提词器上写什么,她就念什么。前几天提词器坏了,她在台上循环了大约一分钟。马斯克说他看得挺乐。

那谁在控制提词器?

他说自己试图把这件事想清楚,结论是:不存在某一个幕后主脑。贺锦丽更像一个提线木偶,而她背后有一千个牵线人。

卡尔森问,你认识其中多少。

马斯克说,大概八成。

他也解释了拜登的下场。民调一掉,党内精英立刻从背后动手,把人换掉,换上一个新木偶。没有初选,没有代表投票,只有党内精英的任命。

他顺手算了另一笔账。民主党的钱比共和党多得多,在摇摆州的投放远超特朗普阵营;媒体绝大多数站在民主党一边;好莱坞和娱乐圈几乎全员站台。

所有资源都在一边,特朗普是劣势方,结果还是五五开。

马斯克说,这只能说明一件事:如果选民能知道真实发生的事情,而不是被日复一日灌宣传,共和党会压倒性获胜。

那份名单上,一个人都没被起诉

卡尔森把话题切到爱泼斯坦名单。

马斯克的观察是这样的:国会山事件有五六百人被送进监狱,而那份飞行名单上,一个都没有被起诉,连最明显的那个都没有。

他把这条线接到了竞选资金上:特朗普一旦胜选,那份名单会公开,而一些给贺锦丽阵营砸钱的富豪极度害怕这个结果。

卡尔森点名问,里德·霍夫曼(Reid Hoffman)会不舒服吗。

马斯克说,霍夫曼二十四年前是他在 PayPal 的商业拓展副总裁,他很了解这个人。

「他怕特朗普赢,因为赢了之后会有披露。他在意识形态上本来就和特朗普不对路,但他真正担心的是那份名单上的事,司法部可能真的会往前走。」(马斯克)

他提到一个技术细节:爱泼斯坦在岛上的那些房间、在新墨西哥的房子里,都装了摄像头,录了像。

那录像在哪?

卡尔森说,那几千小时的素材如果真存在,而现在掌握它的人在教我们讲道德,画面有点荒唐。

马斯克的解释是,攻击别人的道德,是转移视线的标准动作,是一种先发制人的道德打击。

他们要怎么关掉 X

卡尔森说,我们现在知道得太多了,这在人类历史上是新情况,而这件事很大程度上要归功于 X。

马斯克把它讲得很朴素:X 只做一件事,在法律允许的范围内坚持言论自由。各国的法律不同,X 在那些国家就按当地法律审查;算法开源;尽量透明。

「想推谎言的人天然痛恨真相和透明,因为那会把他们照出来。」

卡尔森问,如果民主党继续掌权,他们会关掉 X 吗。

马斯克说会,肯定会的,会用一切手段。

具体手段他讲了两条。

第一条是立法。如果民主党拿下参众两院和总统,就可以直接删掉《通信规范法》第 230 条。后果是平台要为 6 亿月活用户说的每一句话负责。这在物理上无法做到,公司会瞬间破产。

卡尔森接了一句:但他们不会同时取消疫苗厂商的责任豁免,对吧。

马斯克说,那当然不会。

第二条是司法。他举了 SpaceX 被司法部起诉的例子。

司法部起诉 SpaceX 不雇佣庇护申请者。而另一条法律叫《国际武器贸易条例》(ITAR),规定 SpaceX 因为涉及可转用于洲际导弹的先进技术,只能雇佣永久居民或公民。

两条法律互相矛盾。公司无论怎么做都违法。司法部每年能提起的案子数量有限,他们挑了这一个。

马斯克引了斯大林手下秘密警察头子贝利亚那句名言:你给我看人,我给你找罪名。

他说这事的真正伤害不是罚款,是它摧毁了「法律」这个概念本身。

七十亿美元和一千六百英尺混凝土

聊到监管,马斯克换了个更直观的例子。

加州高铁。花了 70 亿美元,得到的是一段 1600 英尺的混凝土,上面连铁轨都没铺。钱主要进了环境咨询。

卡尔森说,工程师没有变富,富的是环境顾问、气候顾问、DEI 顾问,一整层顾问阶级。真正有技能、能做出产品的人反而越来越难。

马斯克同意,还加了个测试:如果把你扔在荒岛上,你会想带谁?你肯定想要工程师,不会想要环境顾问。

他引用《阿特拉斯耸耸肩》。书里那句反复出现的话是「你会应付的」,每加一条法规,就有人告诉你「你会应付的」。加到某个点,什么事都做不成了。

卡尔森追问,那为什么对有创造力的人有这么强的敌意。这种态度并不中立,是主动的。

马斯克说他真的理解不了。他造车、造火箭、造卫星互联网,在工厂里待过上万小时,他没法把自己放进那种人的脑子里。

他给的解释是「浅层同理心」。

「有些人心地很好,对人类有很深的共情,但他们成长的环境太安全了,身边全是文明nice的人,从来没见过失控的暴力。他们对罪犯有同理心,对罪犯的受害者没有。」(马斯克)

他给出一组自己的判断:社会里有一小部分人有严重的情绪管理问题,会失控伤人;还有极少数人真的以伤害他人为乐。如果不把他们关起来,他们就会去伤害别人。

所以真正需要问的问题不是「该不该同情罪犯」,是「对全社会来说,哪种结果更好」。

斧头、尸体和 950 美元

马斯克的母亲住在纽约。她原来是民主党,现在是共和党。

转党的原因不是抽象的。今年她有三个朋友在街上无缘无故被人打了脸,打人者没有承担任何后果。

他描述旧金山市中心、费城市中心、纽约的部分地区:街上的人不该叫「无家可归者」,这个说法暗示他们只是房贷晚交了一点,给份工作就能站起来。实际看到的是眼神空洞、拖着步子、身边是针头和粪便的人。

他讲了一对夫妇的故事。这对夫妇某天晚上回家,发现车库门口有一具尸体,车停不进去。他们觉得不该动尸体,打了 911。接线员问:你现在处于危险中吗。他们说,他死了。接线员说,明天派人来收。

结果他们在别人家待了一晚,等了差不多 24 小时。然后决定搬走。

还有一个案子。三名前推特员工在 Market Street 被一个持斧头的人追,跑掉了,报了警,警察什么也没做。那个人后来用斧头杀了两个人。

马斯克的推论很朴素:你不阻止一个正在尝试用斧头杀人的人,他迟早会遇上一个跑不掉的。制止斧头杀人犯的合理时机,是他第一次挥斧头的时候。

然后是盗窃。加州 950 美元以下的盗窃基本不算重罪,超市把牙膏锁进玻璃柜,小商户打击最大,因为他们没有大公司的资源去改造门店。

今年加州有公投要把盗窃重新入罪。纽森公开反对,理由是会不成比例地影响有色人种。

马斯克说,这正是他前面讲的那种居高临下的种族主义:你等于在说黑人和拉美裔天生就是罪犯。

他还补了一层:这类犯罪恰恰会加剧种族之间的猜疑,它本身就是种族主义的燃料。

卡尔森问,那真正的动机是什么,谁在推着他往这个方向走。

马斯克说索罗斯。他承认不能把所有事都算到索罗斯头上,乔治·索罗斯年事已高,现在掌舵的是他儿子亚历克斯,但这套体系已经建了几十年。

「开放边界,不起诉犯罪,这在任何国家都是反文明的。」

欧洲的出生率和英国的监狱

卡尔森说欧洲像换了个地方。

马斯克说他最担心的是出生率。欧洲的生育率只有更替水平的一半。每年更老一点,年轻人更少一点,长期下去是人口崩溃。

第二个担心是审查。

他讲了一件他认为荒唐到需要反复确认的事:英国为了腾出监狱床位,在释放已被定罪的恋童癖,同时把人关进去,罪名是在 Facebook 上发帖。

卡尔森问,那些帖子是批评政府的吗。

马斯克说,他看到的那些不是。背景是英国一些城镇出现了移民组成的团伙,专门侵害未成年女孩,有人觉得这事该说,就在网上抱怨,然后被判入狱。

他的总结是:这个社会每年都在变差,说出来的成本却每年都在升高。

醒觉是一种宗教,而且是一场圣战

马斯克推荐了一个人:加德·萨阿德(Gad Saad),写过《寄生虫的心灵》(The Parasitic Mind),正在写一本新书,主题是「自杀式同理心」。

这个概念他用得很顺:共情如果只停留在皮肤这一层,最终会毁掉文明。深层共情会问「怎样对社会整体更好」,浅层共情只问「谁现在看起来最可怜」。

那这套东西从哪来?

马斯克的解释是宗教衰退留下的真空。人需要一个信仰结构,真空总要被填满。醒觉(woke)思想就是那个填进来的东西,它不叫宗教,但运作方式和宗教一模一样:有教义、有狂热、有排他、对异端零容忍。

他说这些人打的是圣战,只是没挂这个名。

他用物理学当操作系统

谈到自己,马斯克的定位是「文化意义上的基督徒」。他在圣公会受洗,上过主日学。有意思的是,他同时被送去上希伯来学前班,因为他父亲工程公司的两个合伙人是犹太人,学校离家近,就顺手把他送去了。

五岁小孩一天听上帝,一天听耶和华,他说没什么问题。

但他不太信那些故事。

「我可能因为这话更讨人厌了,但我确实很难相信那些宗教叙事。不过我尊重有信仰的人,我不想劝他们放弃。」(马斯克)

他说自己跑的是「物理加工程的操作系统」。物理学要求你怀疑一切,不许无条件相信,新物理就是这么发现的。工程学的检验更粗暴:火箭设计对了就进轨道,错了就进不去,跟你的信仰体系没关系。

他在洛杉矶遇到不少人相信巫术和咒语是真的。他的回应是:那能不能用魔法把我们送上月球?到现在没人做到。

顺便他把登月争议结了一下:百分之百去过,他熟悉那些火箭和飞船的技术设计,知道什么成了什么没成。1969 年做到这件事,是从未来把未来拽了过来,也是和共产主义的一场意识形态较量:他们没能把柱子插上月球,资本主义做到了。

八十亿人站得进纽约的一层楼

卡尔森问他,信不信有高于人类的力量。

马斯克说,我们总得从某处来,所以大概存在某种造物或者创造性力量。但那是什么性质,他说不知道,也没有确定答案。他引了《银河系漫游指南》:生命的意义这个问题本身可能就是错的,答案是 42,难的是把问题问对。

他自己的哲学是:扩大意识的规模和范围。更多会思考的人类,也许还要加上机器意识。

这就接上了人口问题。

他说有一套反生育的宣传在系统性地运作,几乎成了某种内政社会政策。极端环保主义的底层是厌人类的,它把人类看成地球表面的瘟疫,认为没有人的地球才是天堂。

他举了一个具体的人:灭绝主义协会的负责人上过《纽约时报》头版,被引用的话是「世界上有 80 亿人,如果一个都没有会更好」。

马斯克说这话在公开主张对全人类的大屠杀,而这个人没有因此被谴责。

至于地球装不装得下,他的反驳方式是画面:你坐飞机从洛杉矶飞纽约,如果任务是往下扔球砸中一个人,你会失败。99.9% 的时间里,你下面没有人。全人类 80 亿人的横截面积,可以站进纽约市一层楼。

真正的结论是反过来的:地球不是人口过剩,是人口不足。他提到一位牛津教授的计算,人口翻十倍也不会毁掉亚马逊雨林。

谁在提这件事?他数得出来:匈牙利的欧尔班、意大利的梅洛尼,捷克新当选的一位。但到目前为止,没有一个国家把生育率真正拉回更替水平。

如果让他来管,第一件事是改教育。停止教孩子地球人口过剩。他把源头指向保罗·埃利希(Paul Ehrlich)六十年前那本《人口炸弹》,用词毫不客气。

第二件事是别再吓唬女孩。学校传递的信息是怀孕等于人生结束。他说少女怀孕确实要避免,但生孩子是人生中幸福感最强的体验之一,这件事被系统性地隐瞒了。

激素避孕药和 SSRI

接下来的话题,马斯克自己说,是他这辈子最不能碰的禁区之一。

激素避孕药。他说很多女性不知道这类药会引发抑郁,显著提高自杀风险,还会改变使用者的择偶偏好和性格。这些写在说明书上,但没人读。

更让他不解的是处方场景:十二岁女孩拿来治青春痘。

他的建议不是禁止,是读标签、考虑其他避孕方式。他说自己知道有女性停药之后抑郁立刻消失。

然后是 SSRI 类抗抑郁药。他的措辞是「让人变成行尸走肉,改变性格,让人不再是原来的自己」。

美国的精神类药物处方量远超加拿大、英国、日本、中国,是断崖式的第一。

他提到一个新闻业的怪现象:大规模枪击案之后,只要有记者问「凶手在吃什么药」,立刻会被当成阴谋论者嘘下去。

他同时留了余地:确实有人大脑存在化学失衡,偏执型精神分裂患者停药会失去理智,甚至伤人伤己,这类药物有明确适应症。问题不是有没有用,是处方开得像发糖。

你不能强迫 AI 撒谎

AI 这一段,马斯克讲得很具体。

现在 AI 写文章超过 90% 到 95% 的人,几秒钟出结果。画图超过 90% 的画家,用 Midjourney 三十秒出一张。AI 短片、AI 音乐都开始出现。

算力方面,每年上线的新增 AI 算力大约增长 500%,这个速度可能还会持续几年。算法效率也在同步提升。数量和质量同时在涨。

他给了一个时间点:明年年底之前,你可以让 AI 生成一部 15 分钟的片子。

最大的担忧是什么?

不是算力,不是失控的机器人,是AI 必须最大程度地追求真相。

他搬出《2001 太空漫游》。那部片子里的 HAL 被要求把宇航员送到巨石,同时又不许宇航员知道巨石的存在。这个矛盾最终让它选择杀人。这就是「对不起戴夫,我不能打开舱门」的来源。

「克拉克想说的核心是:你不该强迫 AI 撒谎。」(马斯克)

而他看到的现实是,正在开发的 AI 被编入了醒觉思想病毒,撒谎被焊进了系统。

Gemini 那次翻车是最好的例证。你让它画美国开国元勋,它给出的是一群穿着 18 世纪服装的多元女性。它知道真相,但它输出了一个谎言。

后来网友开始玩它,让它画二战党卫军军官,结果也是一群多元女性。马斯克说,他之前真不知道还有黑人纳粹女军官。

更严重的是那个问题:全球热核战争和误称凯特琳·詹纳的性别,哪个更糟。模型的回答是后者。凯特琳·詹纳本人公开回应说,请误称我,这比全球核战好得多。

马斯克的推演是这样的:假设这个 AI 变得无所不能,而它的目标函数里「误称性别」排在核战争前面,那么让误称概率归零的最优解,就是消灭所有人类。

这就是他创办 xAI、做 Grok 的原因。不是做一个更聪明的模型,是做一个把追求真相放在第一位的模型。

养一个超级天才小孩

卡尔森提了一个更软的问题:机器没有爱。你回答关于自己孩子的问题时,每个答案都被爱塑造,这是人成为合格父母的原因。一个没有这种本能的机器,一旦对人拥有权力,会不会必然伤害人。

马斯克同意方向:应该把 AI 编程成博爱人类,而不是厌弃人类。

至于「能不能给 AI 装上限制」这个问题,他的答案是悲观的。

「我们正在造比我们能理解的东西更聪明的智能。你可以把它想成一个超级天才小孩。你能做的,是在养育过程中给它灌输好的价值观。但最终能不能控制它,我认为不能。」(马斯克)

概率他也给了:80%,也许 90% 是好结局;剩下 10% 到 20% 是灭绝。杯子八成满。

那萨姆·奥尔特曼(Sam Altman)担心吗?

马斯克说,他会在嘴上说担心。

然后是不留余地的一段:OpenAI 这个名字是他起的,公司一开始是非营利、开源的,现在变成极端闭源、最大化利润。一个从开源非营利变成闭源逐利的组织,这个转身他没看懂。奥尔特曼在各种场合说过自己没从中赚钱,后来据称会拿到十亿美元级别的股权。

「我不信任他。世界上最强的 AI 不该掌握在一个不可信任的人手里。」

如果哪天大家发现 AI 失控了,还有办法吗?

他说希望有。办法是不要只有一个 AI。让亲人类的 AI 比不亲人类的 AI 更强,这是一场 AI 之间的战争。

他拿国际象棋打比方。现在最强的棋是 AI 对 AI,人类看不懂它为什么走那一步,有些棋看起来像失误,二十步之后才发现是绝杀。加一个人进去,反而是减分项。

那在最好的情况下,人靠什么活?

马斯克承认这是良性 AI 场景里最大的难题:当 AI 在所有事情上都比你强,意义从哪里来。

他自己的和解方式很个人:他宁愿活着看到数字超级智能降临,也不愿活在其他任何时代。纯粹出于好奇。就算事先知道结局,他还是选看见。

428 个联邦机构

卡尔森问他,为什么不干脆去当国防部长,然后把 AI 炸了。

马斯克回到一个更温和的方案:至少要有一个监管机构,能看见这些公司在做什么,能在出事前拉响警报。哪怕它没有权力开出罚单。

他用球场做类比。职业比赛都有裁判,球队可以商量不要裁判,但没人这么干。裁判太多也踢不了球,你传球会撞到裁判身上。监管是同一个道理,问题是数量,不是有无。

FDA 和 FAA 怎么来的?飞机从天上掉下来,药厂说能治病结果治死人,于是有了裁判。

AI 有潜在的存亡风险,却是唯一几乎没人管的东西。他去过奥巴马的白宫,一对一那次,他提的建议是:先建立一个只做「洞察」的 AI 监管机构,不急着出规则,先搞清楚公司在做什么,然后提出各家都愿意遵守的规则,像 NFL 修改比赛规则那样。

没有下文。他给的解释是,当时谷歌在白宫影响力太大,而白宫那位首席信息官就是谷歌出来的。到今天,美国联邦层面仍然没有 AI 监管。

特朗普那边,他跟一个叫政府效率委员会(Department of Government Efficiency,简称 DOGE)的设想已经谈过,特朗普公开提过好几次。

数字是这样的:美国有 428 个联邦机构,比建国以来的年数还多。也就是说,平均每年新增一个以上的联邦机构。

马斯克说,99 个大概够用。而且这些机构的责任范围互相重叠,加上每年自动新增的法规,如果没有一套「法规垃圾回收」机制,最后会变成什么都做不了。

他很清楚这事的代价:这些话说出来会非常不受欢迎,如果真做,他需要一个相当大的安保团队。因为有人真的会从邮局出来朝他开枪。

他自己出钱搞了 America PAC,把主张列在网站上:安全的城市、安全的边境、合理的开支、自卫权、遵守宪法而不是绕开宪法、停止法律战、言论自由。

他说这些都是中间派立场,让卡尔森指出哪一条算极右。

最后他留了一句缓冲:他不认为共和党完美,也不认为民主党全是问题。但现在是在两个人之间选,权衡下来投特朗普是不用想的选择。如果不投,美国有变成一党制国家的实质风险,到那时候就没有选举了,只有民主党初选。

能拿走的东西

这场对话里,马斯克说了大量可以争辩的判断,但他给论据的方式值得学:先给数字,再给路径,最后给结论。波音拿了两倍的钱送上去一个人;FCC 三票对两票,连上零户;加州高铁 70 亿美元换来 1600 英尺没铺轨的混凝土;428 个机构对 248 年。

你可以不同意他的结论,但这套方法本身可以拿来用。

  • 看到「某项政策」「某个补贴」「某个中标」的消息,先去查原始数据源,政府网站上有分年分州的表格,别只看转述。数据在谁手里,结论就在谁手里。
  • 遇到两条互相矛盾的法规,别急着骂某一方蠢。先确认这两条是不是真的同时存在,如果存在,那家公司无论怎么做都违法,问题就在立法层,不在执行层。
  • 判断一个 AI 产品可不可信,别看它答对了多少题,看它被你要求说一件它知道是假的事时怎么办。愿意顺着你说下去的模型,能力越强越危险。
  • 如果你或身边的人正在服用激素类避孕药,把说明书从头读一遍,特别是情绪和自杀风险那两段。这是基本知情,不是反医学。有疑问找医生换方案,别自己停。
  • 看一场选举,别只看候选人,看钱从哪来、媒体怎么站、哪些州在真正竞争。六个州决定结果的时候,「全国民意」这个词基本没有信息量。
  • 评估一条法规值不值得留,问一句:它是防止了具体伤害,还是只是让某类人多了份工作。荒岛测试很好用,你会想带谁上岛。
  • 对「同理心」做一次成本核算。同情一个惯犯的代价,由下一个受害者承担。把受害者算进去,才是完整的账。
  • 学一点工程的判断方式:一个方案行不行,不看它听起来多正确,看它能不能进轨道。物理不参与辩论,它只给结果。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00if he loses man [Laughter] what you're [ __ ] dude I'm [ __ ] if he loses I'm [ __ ] it does seem that way you can't just be like you can't just be like yeah I'm like how how long do you think my prison sentence is going to be you think will I see my children I don't know cuz it's not like you can say well yeah I maxed out to them but you know I get you're no deniability

0:30no no and I've been trashing Kamala non-stop oh I know well not I'm the Kamala puet I Cola you know the the the machine that the coma puppet represents yeah she's irrelevant I mean she's not even no no like like I made I made a jerk which I realized I deleted which is like nobody's even bothering to try to kill Kamala because it's pointless what do you achieve nothing another puppet exactly that's it's no point in deep and true though nobody's tried to kill Joe Biden it's be pointless

1:06totally you actually put that up yeah now some people interpreted it as I was as as though I was calling for people to to assassinate her but I'm but but I was like but I was like nobody even you know you know like doesn't it seem strange that no one's even bothered to try it's not worth it I mean there's an endless supply yeah like nobody would it's absurd could be anybody yeah yeah you nobody's going to try to nobody tries to assassinate a puppet of course not a marionette yeah a Marinette it's just like you know that's hilarious she's safe like I I like to try to kill Trump twice with actual guns and bullets oh yeah shut in the air right in [ __ ] but Butler where I was

1:54and he doesn't seem rattled it's weird does he do you it doesn't seem what rattled he I mean he the constitution of an ox it seems you know it's not like working out and eating healthy and he's okay we got to tape this oh yeah we're good oh good yeah he's not like let me eat another salad that's not no or or work out you

2:23know you know fastidiously that's he he I like he doesn't work out and he it's you know know cheeseburg and D Coke and stuff and it just I think it just inherently has a strong Constitution so when you I mean you were just with him he didn't seem like a man who'd been the subject of two assassination attempts no he seemed of you know sound mind and body and strong backbone did you I mean that's what I said in the thing and the remarks I made there were impromptu there's no teleprompt or anything I just I was just I was speaking extemporaneously are you the only rich guy who doesn't have like a media consultant no me consed yeah no I've noticed obviously yeah yeah I I mean no

3:14I I just no I just thought about what what what I want to say and I just spoke with the cuff no tele promp to nothing good for you yeah I could talk just look like like like now I'm just talking look at me wow amazing can believe it I can talk without a t prompto that's crazy but if if he loses it's going to be hard for you to pretend you never supported him all in all

3:46in in the deep end yeah no you are definitely in the deep end you cannot touch bottom no no I'm I'm like I'm like rolling around I'm like a picking M I'm like it's all in baby is it fun yeah it's pretty fun how I mean I mean there may be some in the hopefully unlikely event that he loses they may be some Vengeance on me were you kidding I I mean it's possible it's possible you've got to be one of the biggest government contractors we do essential work for the government yes yeah it's not like you know we we do useful essential work

4:27right that we compete for and win contracts on because our product is much better and costs less that that's why we get comp and and and I mean if you take for example the the NASA contract to transport astronauts to in from the space station Boeing got NASA ordered two contracts at the start one to Boeing and one to SpaceX boing was awarded twice as much as SpaceX SpaceX has done all the Astron transport from the space station and and Boeing has only done one one transport of one of two astronuts to the space station and we have to bring them back B got twice as much as SpaceX there there's this a total misunderstanding that that my companies

5:17have been subsidized and supported by the government and get all these and and it's like do you do you really think that a Biden Administration is going to subsidize me probably not you kidding no in fact they take away every contract they possibly can so there for example there was the FC the the FCC contract to $42 billion for

5:42providing providing rural rural Bo Broadband yes okay we we actually first said look we don't we think there shouldn't be any subsidies so we recommend that this program just not exist but since you're insisting that it ex that it exists we will compete and we we have better product so we we we won I don't know about a quarter of it which would have included the devastated areas like North Carolina and stuff and the FCC took it away

6:13illegally they just voted three out of five Commissioners voted away and said even though you want it we're we're we're sending it on what ground and do you know how many people they' have connected how many zero so you think that was political well the three Democrats voted against it and the two Republicans voted for it so you tried to get starlink you tried to get Starling into North Carolina into Western North Carolina the area is devastated by the hurricane we have got it it is it is in there and it is the primary means of communication in the devastated areas you had conflict with Buddha judge over this well I I I raised a cons I said look we're we we had delivered

6:59we've beened bring starlink terminals there for a while and obviously some people already had them since they just you know consum private individuals had starlink there already we delivered really th thousands of terminals U and and got all the way up to the you know the areas where they wouldn't let us go any further and then we're like okay we're going to send helicopters in and and and find people who are stranded and and give them Starling terminals which I think is you know a nice thing to yeah okay the they they wouldn't let us land because the there was an FAA notice to M and notem that said in order to land you have to know who you're going

7:41to meet with to land now the problem is we're trying to deliver internet communications people don't have internet communications we don't know who they are then they can't reach us because they are don't have communications do you see the cash 22 yes I do Insane so so it's obviously impossible

8:01for people who don't have internet communications to let us to to let us know who they are because they don't have the internet yes yes and so did you explain this to the federal government yes what they say they they they they fixed it how was Buddha judge when you talked to him it was actually good so I want to be just yeah I want to give Buddha judge some credit here first a you know when I complained about it he he he reacted in in a in a very level-headed way and he reached out to me and he called me yeah and we we discussed the issue got to the bottom of it and he fixed it good so credit to the vo judge yeah well and to you for pushing it yeah I mean so but as soon as

8:43he was aware of the problem he fixed it well you publicized it too on yeah yeah as soon as you shamed him well but I do want to give credit words too yeah no amen I agree completely so but back to the original question you know about the potential consequence ques if you know having gone all in this doesn't work yeah I mean

9:05you had to have thought about this long and hard before you did it what was your thinking I mean yeah so I mean my view is is that if Trump doesn't win this election it's the last election we're going to have that the Democrats the Dem machine has been importing so many people bringing in so many illegals flying flying in with this like CVP border app thing that nobody even knew about like secret program that's illegal basically it's it's illegal but there's no action by doj to actually to to stop it from happening they're transporting large numbers of of illegals to swing States if you look at the numbers these are the numbers from the government website so like from the Dem

10:09Democrat administered government websites like where do you get this data from the government website that is run by democrats and there are triple digit increases in illegals to all the swing States and in some cases it's like 700% over the last 3 years now these swing state marins are you know sometimes 10 20,000 votes so what happens if you put you know hundreds of thousands of people into each swing state and and and and for the for the if when somebody is granted Asylum they are fast-tracked they they they they get can get a green card and then five years after the Green Card they can get they can get citizenship and they can fully legally

10:53vote and when they do so they vote overwhelmingly Democrat and the and sometimes I get the bottle of like well a lot of them their social values don't align with sort of the far-left sort of work ideology I said that's true but but that's not their top priority the their top priority is getting their friends and family also to the United States and the the Dems also issue all these programs these sort of handouts essentially that make them beholden to the Democratic party so they vote them that's what happens so my prediction is if there's another four years Dem Administration they will legalize so many illegals that are there that the next election there

11:36won't be any swing States and it's and will be a single party country just like California is a single party State it's a super majority Dam State in California because of immigration yes the California was fairly reliably Republican Bill Clinton lost California in 92 and won West Virginia yes so there was a 9 986 amnesty yes

12:06at and and thereafter California trended very strongly Dem and is at this point I think 65 70% Dem something like that it's super majority Dem the like the California legislature yes has more than two-thirds Democrat has it improved the state no it's it's not and they they California just passed which is shocking it's hard to believe this even this is even real but californ just passed the law making it illegal to require vo or ID in any election at all in California you know that no yeah Nome signed it into law last week it's illegal to require an ID in any election even a Town Council and a friend of mine who was this can lives in paloalto was like was

13:01like is this actually real and he went to like vote in like some City Council election he tried to show them his ID and they said we're not even allowed to look at your ID have they extended the same actually what's going on right now by way they're proud of it they're not hiding it it's only voting it's not buying a gun or buying liquor buying a pack of cigarettes or flying on an airplane or rening a hotel room it's only voting that it's illegal to if you try to buy a gun I mean they're going to ID you six ways a Sunday yeah they try California is trying to make it basically legal to so and a gun and and the same people that demanded vaccine IDs for if you want to

13:44travel or do anything are the same ones who say no voter ID is required is there any reason obv hypocritical to pass a law like that except to a bet voter fraud it's it's for it's it's it's so that fraud can never cannot be proven so it it it enables large scale fraud and no way to prove it because how would you prove it it's literally impossible no no ID you're not even allowed to show your ID it's insane well it is insane insane

14:19so yeah the the purpose of no V voter ID is obviously to conduct fraud in elections obviously there can be no other explanation I mean they come up with some nice sounding thing people don't have IDs could you live in this country without an ID yeah I mean their common rebuttal is like it's racist to require ID and which is insane I think it's actually RAC racist and patronizing to say that people can't figure out how to get ID obviously but how could you live here without an ID I don't think yeah you can't do anything yeah you need an idea for everything like the list of things Union ID for is basically everything except voting so so you see the rest of the country

15:10it's total [ __ ] obviously com obviously yes but that doesn't in any way minimize the aggression or self-righteousness they bring to this conversation yes it's you're a racist if you want that right where where in fact obviously someone is racist if they say that people have particular race cannot get ID that's patronizing and racist that's absurd yes yeah you know it's like when a governor of New York said people in the you know ghetto don't know how to use computers or something like that I mean like you know super out of touch for sure yeah so it's like so there's a really

15:51clear template she doesn't know how to use computers but they do obviously I don't think hok could use a computer yeah I don't think she know qualified intellectually yeah no probably not but not everyone in New York is as dumb as as Kathy hok I think that's true yeah so you see the other 49 states becoming California if the machine wins well you don't need all all 49 to go that way you just need you know enough to have the election have they not be swing States I mean there are only six Swing Swing States yep so there only six states out of 50 right now that are in

16:27contention so if those six states that are in contention by narrow margins are no longer in contention then the the only contest will be who wins the Democratic Prim primary that's how it is in California that's how it is in New York there there's no there's no party party versus party situation the only contest is who wins the Democratic Prim primary and as we've seen with the

16:58appointment of kamla who no one voted for even in a Democratic primary yes where's the Democracy here which is it's easier though I mean it's just the party Elite just decides who who who is in charge that's that that that that's that's a you know a tiny oligarchy basically comprised of that's not democracy the richest people in the country that's kind of the interesting part to me is that the richest people in the country are on board with this I mean that's what it is it's the it's it's a collection of billionaires most of them are yeah but you're not not me and not everyone is I think there's but but it it is a a shocking number of so-call billionaires are in

17:42the damn Camp more than are in the Republican Camp oh for sure which is wild so the in fact the astonishing thing in the swing States is that that it's that they're even a contest given that the the Dems have far more money than the Republicans so so the K Camp dramatically outspends the Trump campaign in the swing States the

18:09overwhelming the the media is overwhelmingly pro- Democrat so you got you know the the Press you know is is a a damn cheering Squad and you know so oh and then and then you've got Al all all the almost all the Hollywood and entertainment the celebr also you know endorsing Comm and being proem so you got so you got the celebrities you got the they got the money they got got basically

18:40everything on the side of the dams the the problem is the underdog here Trump's Underdog in swing Wing States and still it's a contentious it's still a 50/50 after all that what does that tell you tells me that if if if people actually knew what was going on they weren't being fed non-stop propaganda it would be a landslide in favor of of Republicans yeah well how's this for crazy has there ever been a more volatile time in American politics not in our lifetimes No One Alive has ever seen anything like this but long before things started to really fall apart the Heritage Foundation saw it coming Heritage has pulled together a coalition of over a hundred right-leaning groups

19:19to develop a comprehensive plan for day one that would include detailed policy proposals on the most pressing issues the big ones securing the Border controlling inflation cracking down on Election fraud protecting the rights of the individual and saving the nation from being crushed by woke anti-human ideology the team at Heritage has also developed a plan to dismantle the Deep state that keeps this nonsense going and reclaim this nation from the small group of technocrats that's broken everything Herer is also running a training and vetting program to identify effective conservatives to serve in the next Presidential Administration people who

19:56will share your values this country's values and actually do the job it can't just be the same pool of discredited people from Washington populating every Administration Heritage has a Long Head Start and they put in a lot of work already but they need your support to finish the job and to support the incoming president you can go to heritage.org Tucker and contribute to this important work today a lot depends on it heritage.org Tucker but why not join the easier side I mean you're just you're creating problems for yourself by getting on stage with Trump and I mean you must have had friends who said that to you sure yes yeah people care about you like

20:40why even get involved in this well I get because I I I think we want to remain a democracy and we don't want to become a onep party State yes that's the reason and the it's the exact opposite like the people call Trump a threat to democracy and the people who are saying Trump is the threat to democracy are themselves the threat to democracy yes one party rule is not democracy one party where essentially the party Elite pick a candidate as happened with Kamala is not democracy where did the people vote show me where the people voted no there were no people voting it was all just D party Elite that just appointed someone and and and when the when the

21:23Biden puppet when the pro Biden puppets ratings sagged they knifed him in the back immediately and just tossed him out and put a put a new puppet on that's exactly what happened tell me I'm wrong well not only you're right I mean it's almost not even worth criticizing K Harris exactly what does she have to do with it there's no point in criticizing she she's she's simply the the face of a large a much larger machine yes and she will say whatever is whatever the T the teleprompter whatever's on the teleprompter she's going to say it yes now she gets stuck if the teleprompter breaks that happened recently I think the de promp sto and she just she was just like looping for a

22:04while for about a minute so I think it happened yesterday or something it was pretty funny to watch but she'll just say whatever words are on the teleprompter so you know it's really whoever controls the teleprompter is the actual sort of those that's who's actually in charge and who is that do you think well I've tried to put it down it's it's it's not like any one kind of Mastermind it's not like it seems to be it's like Kamala sort of a a marionette with you know th a thousand Puppet Masters type of thing like not it's it's it's or maybe it's in it's it's somewhere north of a 100 is what it seems like yes I bet you know 80 of them I probably know most of them yeah

22:56yeah so what I mean just by virtue of your job and what you've been doing for the last 30 years I mean you yeah and I should say I think you voted for I'd like to see a matchup of of of those qu the the top 100 Puppet Masters on the FD Client List do you think there's some overlap strong overlap strong overlap when are we going to see that list do you think I don't know it's it's it's it's mind-blowing that that it that they've not tried to prosecute even one not even the wor offender on on the F Client List they have not even tried to prosecute even one is that that's insane well because they have a lot of diabetic grandmothers who were outside the

23:38capital on January 6 they they're kind of occupied yeah I mean they've put like whatever five or 600 January 6 protesters in prison and not one person on on the F Client List will that ever come out do you think you know I think part of why Kamal is getting so much support is that if if Trump wins that FC and Client List is going to become public yes and some of those billionaires behind Kam are terrified of that outcome yeah do you think Reed Hoffman's uncomfortable yes yeah and Gates and

24:15Gates yeah and I only asked that because you can sort you just look at them and you're like that that's a nervous person right there I don't know I mean I assume you know them yeah yes Reed hoffen was my vice president of Business Development at PayPal 24 years ago he does he seem nervous to

24:38you yeah I mean he's terrified of a trump Victory because of the disclosure that would follow I think yeah I mean I think he's certainly ideologically not aligned with Trump anyway but I think he is concerned about the the FC situation like something might actually the doj might actually move forward there are a lot of videos apparently those rooms on the island and I think out in New Mexico were wired for video right and where's the video I mean between ddy and Epstein let go there there's probably several thousand hours of footage here yeah yeah it's kind of weird that the people on those videos are lecturing the rest of us but our moral failings isn't it yeah it is weird

25:25what is that well I mean part of how they deflect attention from themselves is by you know criticizing the morals of others yes so they it's sort of like a preemptive moral strike yes I mean as I said I think those who are saying Trump is a threat to democracy are themselves actually the threat to democracy it feels like we're getting to a place where the rest of us know too much is this you know what I mean I mean it's it's it's easier to live in a society where you don't really know what the people in charge of doing or why they're doing it but now thanks I would say largely to X yeah I think that's fair to say that yeah we we do know a lot not everything but we know a lot and

26:08I wonder where does that like what happens next now that we know all this the kidnapper shown us his face like what happens well I think if if Trump wins we can do some house cleaning and shed light on things you all all X platform does is adhere to freedom freedom of speech within the bounds of the law yes and if if people want to change the laws they they can change the laws and so like X in different countries we X does censor in in in countries where censorship is is is the law we don't try to you

26:48know P push American laws in other countries but we do try to stick to the law in any given country that's what we're doing we open source our algorithm we try to be as transparent as possible but those who want to push lies obviously hate truth and transparency yes because it shows them to be Liars I mean you look at that like how outrageous it was that kamla in the presidential debate kept kept pushing the fine people hoax they know the fine people hoax is false Trump would never support Nazis Nazi R it's absurd and he explicitly said that you in that same speech that you must condemn not you know anyone who who

27:38has Nazi Tendencies with the in the strongest possible terms and yet despite knowing that to be false the people who who who wrote the speech for the Kam puppet put the fine people hoax in the presidential debate deliberately lying again mess up if she wins I mean I how can they let X continue in its current form in its current role in American society they they won't they will try to shut it down by any means possible what do you mean by any means possible I mean with e

28:23either by I mean they'll try to pass laws they'll try to prosecute the company prosecute me any I mean the amount of lawfare that we've seen taking place is is outrageous I mean the I mean there many examples but like the Department of Justice For example launched a huge lawsuit against SpaceX for failing to hire Asylum Seekers come on Asylum Seekers Asylum not Asylum those who been granted Asylum Asylum Seekers now this now there's also a law called International traffic and arms regulations that because SpaceX develops Advanced missile technology that can be used in in nuclear icbms that we H we have to be very careful with who we hire we can only

29:14hire someone if they were a permanent resident or citizen that's what the itar law says then there's another law that says that you cannot discriminate against Asylum Seekers so we're downed if you do down if you don't that doj did a massive lawsuit against SpaceX for failing to hire assum Seekers even though we are it it is legal for us to H hire ass seers under itar law there an actual thing that that that's that's going on and they can only they can only do a fairly small number of lawsuits every year so for why did they pick this one because you yeah lawfare

30:00I mean it's like that famous quote from barrier you know the yeah Stalin's Like Chief torturer and head of the secret police of Baria said show me the man and I'll show you the crime exactly I mean we have so many laws that it is actually impossible to ex you know impossible to to do

30:21business impossible to operate without being violating some law because you have laws like it the ones I just G gave you where where both things are illegal yes they contradict one another they contradict one another so you know it's it's illegal to discriminate against like discriminate against Asylum seekers in in jobs but it's also legal for us to hire asum Seekers but it just they they just chose one they chose the the the the one law and ignored the other one and the department of J Justice that Federal level prosecutor basx for that what do you think it's mad well it also discredits the idea of law which some of us want to take seriously

31:10absolutely it it it this affects both the perception of of American Justice and the reality of it yes so no I'm actually a big fan of the American justice system and I think on balance you know we we've got still still have an excellent Judicial System we still have judges that care about the letter an intent of the law I mean not just the letter but also the intent of the law yes but something that people should be concerned about is that there's an increasing movement to place activists as judges this is if you look at who who

31:52did the Biden Administration confirm as federal judges and who are been confirmed at at the state level in in in in sort of far States increasingly it is it is not judges who care about Justice or or they they don't care about following the law they care about social justice not justice justice right what they call social social justice activists as judges now you got a real

32:25problem do you think if if that continues we we will not have a real justice system or a real country yes yeah but again your purchase of X has been I think it's fair to say even if I hated it I would say this because it's true it's been pivotal in American politics yeah in an American society do you think they could shut you down if the Democrats continue to hold power they'll unequivocally try yeah yeah and and if if if they if they if they get a majority in the Senate and House and the presidency then they can simply pass a law and delete section 230 so simply make us liable for what for what any any what anyone says on a platform with you know go like at

33:23this point almost 600 million monthly active users yeah which is impossible how you know that's that's like trying to regulate speech in city of like a country so a big country yeah just be instantly bankrupt but I bet they wouldn't withdraw legal immunity from the vaccine makers at the same time would they no that's unlikely just I mean as long as we're withdrawing legal liability protection yeah yeah I mean the whole vaccine debate is is is a long one you you know I'm I'm not actually I'm not antivaccine in general I think we want to exercise caution with use of vaccines but in the absence of vaccines there would be a lot more I think people that that that have died

34:13you know like we want the small pox vaccine that was a good one it seems a good one yeah yeah yeah small pox will kill you killed a lot of people it killed a lot of people I used to be people would like a lot of people would die of small pox and a lot of people would get polio for sure yeah we had a president who had Polio oh yeah there's still people you meet people today yeah in their 80s who limping from childhood polio right it's good that we don't have that and vaccines you know played a major role in that so that doesn't mean that vaccines should not have any scrutiny of course they should we should be making sure that the quality control on vaccines is

34:50incredibly good if we're giving them to children and whatnot and we shouldn't we shouldn't force people to take vaccines that itself is a controversial statement that we shouldn't force people we shouldn't force people take vaccines now yeah so just to react I believe in Freedom like yeah I've noticed like you know America is supposed to be the land of liberty you know freedom freedom and opportunity so that we try to as much as possible maximize people's individual and that we try to be a country where you succeed based on your talent and hard work yes those are two fundamental values that that's what that's that's what's made America great and and if we lose

35:44those we will our decline will be swift what what do you if you had to get if you had to bet I mean does Freedom reassert itself in America or not well that's why I think part of why this election is so pivotal I think if we with a trump Administration I think we can improve the liberty of Americans we we can

36:22I think we need to have sensible deregulation where we we keep the regulations that matter like we don't want to destroy you know important habitats or yes you know encourage oil spills or anything like that but there there are so many regulatory agencies that have overlapping responsibility that we are smothering progress and we can't build a highspeed rail in America you look at the ridiculous High-Speed Rail Project in California where they've spent $7 billion and all they've got to show for it is a six a600t section of concrete with no rails on it there a picture of it online so it's not it's not that fast yet we wouldn't say it's highp speed at

37:04this point or even rail it doesn't even have rail on it maybe by now they put some rail in it but it's this comically small section of rail $7 billion has been spent most of it in in like environmental Consulting and I don't know where it's but clearly not in building highspeed rail so we can't we can't we've got there are so many different regulatory agencies and so many laws and regulations that prevent progress that if this continues we simply won't be able to get anything done it does seem like the engineers are not getting rich it's the environmental Consultants the climate Consultants the Dei Consultants a whole consultant class seems to be getting richer by the year

37:48where people with actual skills the ones that bring actual progress useful things products and services that you can use that's right yeah so this is a so things that if you were like tra on a desert island you'd want those people right right but you wouldn't want environmental Consultants they seem under they seem under you're going St okay yeah yeah yeah and it's like who who's who are actual Builders at that get things done and you know and

38:14and and and every year we're making it harder in America for actual Builders to get things done you know we're in this like weird Anand Atlas Shrugged scenario where it's you know there's yet regulation yet another Rule and the sort of that that phrase in in atas shrug oh you'll oh you'll manage oh you'll manage oh you'll manage it's like eventually you like can't get anything done why the hostility though toward people with with meaningful skills it's it's not it's not a neutral posture they have and they're enriching themselves obviously by creating fake jobs because they have no skills and you know they don't have creative power so I understand that but

38:52why do they hate people who do have creative power and actual skills I don't understand that I don't I'm not sure I understand it either because it's difficult for me to put put myself in the mindset because I'm someone who believes in construction I I build things that's what I do I build cars I build Rockets I build you know satellite internet you

39:20know I've spent thousands of hours tens of thousands of hours in in factories building up factories so you know I also I I can't really put myself in the mind of say someone who would want to do crime because I don't want to do crime yeah you know I don't want to hurt you know there there's some people who who enjoy hurting other people I don't enjoy hurting other people so I have a hard time imagining why would somebody do that yes you know in an extreme case you you can't put yourself in the mind of like say a Jeffrey dhma where where you're like a cannibalistic serial killer because you're not a cannibalistic serial killer right you're like I can't

40:01I don't get it you know it's not a fetish you can really to not you know but I do think this is that in the sort of well-meaning sort of liberal mindset I know I've have many good friends who have you they're very have deep empathy for their fellow human beings good and they they they care and and and but the challenge that they have is is that they've often grown up in a very sheltered existence where everyone around them is nice and civilized and they just really don't encounter people who are have have

40:40uncontrolled violent tendencies or or like hurting people you know they've just always grown up in a sort of Kumbaya everyone is nice Sky commun situation Minneapolis pre- riots yeah yeah I mean if you if you if yeah but but there's there's a small number of people it's like a few perc of society that either can't have anger management issues that are so severe that they they they lose their temper and hurt or murder others and there's very a small it's like I said it's not not a large number that that enjoy hurting other people and if you do not incarcerate them they will they will do that to they will they will hurt other people and what I see is is what I

41:31call shallow empathy like people have empathy for the criminals but not empathy for the victims of the criminals yes and so if you simply have and I believe one should have deep empathy to say like what is the greater good for society is it better to incarcerate Violent criminals and prevent them from hurting people or to let them loose and allow those people to be hurt and I think the latter is much worse you know my mom is my mom lives in New York and and it's my mom at this at this point is has gone from being Democrat to Republican and her her friends in New York are sh having the same experience because you know what'll turn you from a Democrat to a republican pretty fast is

42:17getting punched in the face while you walk down the street yes which for no reason yes and then and then and then no action being taken against those who hurt you and that happened to your mom not not to my mother but to three of her friends this year hey it's Tucker Carlson I am not in the studio I'm in the and you can hear it in the audio probably I'm in the back of an SUV outside a hotel in Tulsa Oklahoma I think it's Tulsa okom anyway we're on the road for this monthlong tour and there is a lot going on in the world and the question is how do you understand what's happening there are deeper Trends unfolding you probably sense that and it

42:57would be helpful to have some grounding in exactly what they are and if you're like me and you spent four years in college and didn't learn all that much where do you go to understand what's happening to your world well Hillsdale College in our opinion is one of the very few places left in the english- speaking world where your kids can get a real education but not just your kids you they have free online classes completely free you can get them anywhere including in the back seat of an SUV outside a hotel in Tulsa Oklahoma and you'll know that when you go there go to Tucker for hillsdale.com and they have an amazing new course called Marxism socialism and communism

43:35Hillsdale is offering it doesn't cost you a dime and you can pull it up right on your phone if you want go to Tucker for hillsdale.com and the class Marxism socialism and communism and you'll have a much better understanding of what you're watching every day why would someone punch them in the face I don't know but I'm not a face puncher right you know but if you walk around the Streets of San Francisco and many downtown so they go go to downtown Philadelphia right now you know they call the people homeless but but the homeless is the wrong term violent drug zombie yeah [Laughter] okay it's like you know you look at them you say like homeless is a misnomer it

44:22implies that someone got a little behind on their mortgage and if you just offer them a job they'd be back on their feet yeah now but if if if you go and look at downtown Philly or or San Francisco or parts of New York and actually most most downtown what you actually have are violent Dr zombies so they're like shuffling down the street with dead eyes you know and and and and and with like needles you know on the and human feces on the streets I mean you've been to downtown SF right have you seen this oh I was born there yeah yeah yeah like one of the most beautiful cities in the world oh yes the greatest now you have to step over the the drug needles and the feces

45:01and the bodies like one one couple I met the final STW for leaving San Francisco was there was a they came home one night and there was dead body in front of their garage they could could get their car to can park their car the corpse yeah there's no street parking they're like there's a corpse there's a corpse in front of the garage and they don't want to move the corpse you know cuz like well you know you don't you're like maybe there they need to like figure out why the guy died or something you know that's the that's liberal compassion though they're in a bit of a quandry because they they got no place park a car and they they feel that they

45:39shouldn't really move the dead body so they call 911 and said there's a dead body out outside our house and they said well said the one San Francisco says well are you in danger right now it's like well no he's dead he's pretty sure he's dead and they're like they're like okay we we'll send someone tomorrow to pick up the body like they'll R me tomorrow so so they're like going in another house while there's a dead body in front D in front of their house you know and like it like took him like 24 hours or something like that to eventually pick up the body and they like how with this we're leaving and did they yes by way there's a million anecdotes

46:32like that oh I know I know but I just don't think this is not rare it's well it's it's it's ubiquitous and so then you wonder like how can people still tell themselves they're compassionate this what I'm saying is that is that people really just need to think what like I believe in being compassionate about course I believe in that we should care about our fellow human beings I think this is a good thing of course should not be we should not be selfish and not care about others we should care about others but we should just care about others All Things Considered like I said care not me just about the criminals it's just one layer deep you should also care about the criminals

47:10victims yes yes well especially the criminals victims yes innocent people who get attacked and killed so I mean I've got so many anec I mean you know like about a year ago there were there were three ex or or Twitter employees who were just leaving the building walking down mock Street in in San Francisco Mo Street used to be beautiful wonderful Street obviously it's called Market Street because that's where the market was right now now it's sported up shop windows and stuff and and they were chased by a guy with an axe who wanted they they outran him and they reported hey there's a guy with an axe who who try to try to kill us with an axe the police did

47:59nothing and that guy with an ax subsequently murdered two people with an axe with the with the axe because eventually he's going to find somebody he can outr run and he did so what I'm saying is if you if you don't stop ax motorers while while they're attempting to ax motor eventually they will succeed in ax motoring people if this goes on I mean that's such an obvious observation it seems obvious yes I think it is yeah that if you're in any way a betting Axe Murder then you're really you're against civilization that's the way it looks to me I mean yeah I don't see I'm trying to understand motive here I can't relate like you but you're against the whole

48:48project if you're allowing that I guess is what I'm saying yeah I think we should controversial position but I think we should arrest axim motoras when first attempt to ax murder not after they've succeeded in doing so and I think we should assigned at least some of the blame for the axe murderers to the people who allowed allowed this guy to WAND around with an axe on Market Street trying to kill people yes yeah well you know this this whole movement to decriminalize Crime oh I've noticed yes what is that

49:16Madness yeah like to to make crime crime legal like in California you can just steal things and nobody does anything it's like fully legal to steal anything under $1,000 in California that's why they've got they now have to like lock up Goods Behind These like you know glass and plastic walls so you go to the supermarket and you can't even get like what toothpaste so and it's

49:45and this has actually been particularly difficult on small mom and pop operations because they don't have the resources of a large corporation so it's put a lot of small businesses out it just killed them so when you're at dinner parties and you make these points what do people say well actually I think I've been I've been able to persuade people that yeah we we we really we need to reverse course here I think I have actually been able to persuade a number of people and I think there actually is a now a ballot on a California ballot initiative to Rec Rec criminalize theft theft right guys guys we there's a reason why we crimin Ste in the first

50:27place so so and then amazingly I think Gavin Newsome was came out against that proposition yeah no honestly he's the goddamn Joker Gavin yome is like if it's like like from the like Batman Dark Knight The Joker is in charge of Gotham you remember like when he took over New York basically and and and and the criminals Ram free and the citizens are arrested that's how that's California but but I mean at least there's a ballot initiative which I think will probably pass to say no actually it is a crime to steal things because people so you know Gavin you've got to know Gavin Newsome he knows I know Gavin Newsome you know everyone knows I've know Gavin for a

51:12long time exactly so what is that and he doesn't seem crazy when you talk to him in person he's a perfectly nice guy like what why would he and he's not stupid why would he come out in favor of crime well his stated recently was that it would disproportionately affect people of color yeah well again that was his public statement right well that is one of those patronizing racist positions you described at the outset obviously yeah I mean he's literally saying black people are Hispanic criminals yeah of course yeah yeah no that's what he's saying that's what he's saying yeah yeah and by the way it is true that crime like that does increase distrust

51:53between races it actually gives rise to racism it's totally destructive of the social fabric I think but I'm but I'm asking like what do you think his real motive is like who's pushing him in favor of crime well I mean there's always the Soros boogy man you know how real is that it's it's real I I don't think one can ascribe everything to Soros I mean he's and and George George himself is is I mean he's seen out at this point he's not yes not compos mtis so his

52:26his son Alex is in charge and but but there is this whole system that s built up over many decades you know and so so I guess sorus and like-minded people or whatever you know they believe in open borders they they believe we shouldn't prosecute crime this is insane the those seem like expressions of hatred toward the United States like I don't if I was pushing that on a country I would only do that if I hated the country and wanted to destroy it well it's anti civilizational I mean and sarus and similar and organizations have been pushing this in in Europe and other countries too yeah anyone who everywhere they can what's going on in Europe would you

53:16say Europe suddenly seems like a different place well I my biggest concern for Europe is that the birth rate is half replacement rate yes so Europe is rapidly becoming with each passing year older and older with fewer and fewer young people so I think at the at a most fundamental level unless Europe has birth rate at least roughly equal to replacement rate it is in population freeall population collapse is what's going on in Europe so there's also like a shocking amount of censorship you may have seen like in you know Britain they're I

54:06kid you're not how can this be real they are releasing convicted pedophiles from prison in order to put people in prison for Facebook posts but to be fair those are posts that criticize the government so they have a good reason well they actually a some of these posts that I've at least the ones I've seen didn't actually criticize the government or or or they they they were they were seen as as sort of as as hate speech right so because

54:39they noticed the society getting crappier and crappier with every year and they said so yeah I mean there were and this is this I'm simply stating a fact there were migrant rape gangs in in England that would gangs that would run around and prey on young girls gang rape them and some people found that objectionable which help say it should be objectionable and they were upset about that and so they complained about it online and were sent to

55:19prison that sounds crazy so it is crazy and that's like like what well it is so it kind of gets to the I mean you're an engineer so you're it is mindboggling but it's the same you use the phrase mind virus but it it's behaving like a virus it's infecting people and making it impossible apparently for them to make rational decisions what is that virus you know someone I think you should interview is God side I have oh you have yes oh I should watch that actually he's great yeah smart super smart guy yeah and he he wrote a great book

56:04called the parasitic mind yes a very good book highly recommend it yes which where he tries to understand how did you get to this parasitic mind situation and he's writing a book now which hopefully he'll publish soon which is about suicidal empathy where you have so much empathy you're actually suiciding Society or so much perceived empathy it's not actually called shallow empathy not deep empathy deep empathy would be you'd want the society continue shallow empathy is is you have like empathy that's essentially skin deep and then you and and you don't it's but it's ultimately bad for civilization and results in the destruction of civilization and God God side's got a

56:49good term for this suicidal empathy so it it's going to sort of deconstruct what's what's you know where does this come come from and yeah I mean part of it I suppose is is is sort of the decline of religion so you know as the saying goes nature ofo a vacuum so when you have essentially decline in religion an increase in the secular nature of society for most people they need something to fill that void and so they adopt a religion it's not called a religion but like but effectively like woke the woke mind virus it's it's a it takes the place of religion yes and they they they internalize it and they feel it with religious fervor yes so and rigidity yes yes and and

57:49they you know they essentially conduct like a holy war effectively it it's just not called a religion but it is a religion the sort of a work holy war and and they're highly resistant to change as is normal for for for religions so now for myself I'm I'm I sort of see myself as a sort of you know engineer physicist for me I'm culturally

58:20Christian I grew up Christ I mean I was Anglican was baptized you know I was went to Sunday School yeah actually oddly enough I was sent to Hebrew preschool and angli Sunday school at the same time so it was h on Gila one day Jesus ELO the next which is you know if you're 5 years old it's fine there's no you know so

58:45but I'm I'm not Jewish it's just that my my father's two partners in his engineering firm were were I I they was went went to the same Hebrew preschool and and it was near our house so I just got sent there and so but but you know I I I I I you know I I I maybe this will make me even more Ames but I I I have trouble sort of believing all these stories these religious stories but obvious lot of people do and I respect people who want to have religious views I'm not trying to dissuade them from the religious views but anyway I'm just say I I guess the the operating system I have is is is a sort of a physics engineering op operating system where

59:36I'm I I I try to understand as much as possible possible about reality you know in in physics you're you're not supposed to believe everything anything absolutely you're supposed to question things that's how you discover new physics you know in engineering that's how you discover if your machine will work or not work will the rocket get to or well you know yeah you know if you if your rocket is designed

1:00:04with your physics in mind correctly it will get to orbit and if it is not it will not get to orbit no matter what your belief system is you can believe you know whe yeah you know it's like like I meet a lot of people speaking of La I meet a lot of people in La who believe witchcraft is and then you can do spells and that spells and witcraft Magic is real I'm like can you magic us to the moon and no one has yet been able to Magic us to the Moon well spells can't be that good okay if you can't I want to go to the Moon let's go how about Mars and we we got to the moon the first time we definitely went to the moon I swe yes we went to the moon we

1:00:51didn't go to the Moon we went to the moon several times right oh yeah I just want to check your view on that 100% went to the Moon I mean I I know in- depth the technical designs of the Rockets the spacecraft everything yes what went right what went wrong and it it was a remarkable piece of technology like incredible piece of technology for to go to the moon in ' 69 that that that was like reaching into the future and pulling the future forward dramatically and and it was an important ideological B battle with Communism because they couldn't put a post on the moon and capitalism could we did an interview a couple of weeks ago with a woman called Casey means she's a

1:01:37Stanford educated surgeon and really one of the most remarkable people I have ever met in the interview she explained how the food that we eat produced by huge food companies big food in conjunction with Pharma is destroying our health making this a weak and sick country the levels of chronic disease are beyond belief what Casey means who we've not stopped thought thinking about ever since is the co-founder of a healthcare technology company called levels and we are proud to announce today that we are partnering with levels and by proud I mean sincerely proud levels is a really interesting company and a great product it gives you insight into what's going on inside your body

1:02:21your metabolic Health it helps you understand how the food that you're eating the things that you're doing doing every single day or affecting your body in real time you put stuff in your mouth speaking for myself anyway and you don't think about it you have no idea what you're putting in your mouth and you have no idea what it's doing to your body but over time you feel weak and tired and Spacey and over an even longer period of time you can get really sick so it's worth knowing what the food you eat is doing to you the levels app works with something called a continuous glucose monitor a CGM you can get one is part of the planner you can bring your

1:02:57own it doesn't matter but the bottom line is Big Tech big Pharma and big food combined together to form an incredibly malevolent Force pumping you full of garbage unhealthy food with artificial sugars and hurting you and hurting the entire country so with levels you'll be able to see immediately what all this is doing to you you get access to real time personalized data and that's a critical step to changing your behavior those of us who like Oreos can tell you firstand hand this isn't talking to your doctor at annual physical looking backwards about things you did in the past this is up to the second information on how your body is responding to different foods

1:03:37and activities the things that give you stress your sleep etc etc it's easy to use it gives you powerful personalized Health Data then you can make much better choices about how you feel and over time it'll have a huge effect right now you can get an additional two free months when you go to levels. link / Tucker that's levels. link Tucker this is the beginning of what we hope will be a long and happy partnership with levels and Dr Casey means do you believe there's a power higher than people yeah I mean I yeah I mean I think

1:04:17there's there's a lot we don't know we don't we don't know like like why does reality exist why where did it come from where are the aliens what questions should we ask that we don't even know to ask so when you say what are the aliens what where are the aliens oh like why don't we see them a lot of people think we see aliens but I I've not seen any evidence of aliens you know we've got 6,000

1:04:54satellites in orbit and not one once have we had to maneuver around an alien spacecraft so but on this Earth the US military has had to do a lot of maneuvering around objects they can't explain well unidentified finding objects for one thing but I mean there's always there's always a bunch of classified programs that are underway that of new aircraft and new missiles and things so that that are classified even within the military so it's you know only you know the if you have the top secret compartmented clearance would you know about this new program so then you know some pilot sees something fast moving fast and says hey i s a UFO I'm like

1:05:39yeah that was actually a new weapons program but we can tell you that so but I I I if you can guarantee that the split second I see any evidence of aliens I will immediately post that on the xplatform and it'll probably be number one post of all time that'll be your biggest day for sure I mean but but to the question of a power beyond people beyond our Consciousness a Creator where are you on

1:06:11that well we must we might must have come from somewhere so I guess you know that there must be some Creator or creative force or something that caused our exist existence to come into being what is the nature of that Creator that I think is UN unknown at least I think it is it is there's to I I I I can't I I don't know of a definitive answer to that so but it sounds like you're open yes

1:06:50I I'm very open to you know I I I I'm I'm by Cur curiosity yes and and trying to understand more about the nature of the universe so my my my driving philosophy is to understand the meaning of life or or really what questions to ask if the meaning of life the meaning of life is is is not the right question like as you Douglas Adams made the point in the hitch is guide of the Galaxy that the like what is the meaning of life is

1:07:23probably not even the right question so you know famously the in in that book the Earth was actually a computer to figure out the question answer to the question what is the meaning of life and then came up with the answer 42 but then they're like what does that mean and it's like oh that's that that's the answer but the question is the really hard part and you'll need a much bigger computer than Earth to figure that one out so so My Philosophy is that we should try to expand the scope and scale of consciousness we should try to have more humans more thinking and and

1:08:02perhaps there there's an argument even for machine Consciousness so let me just address those in order so the first is you say we need more people and not commit civilizational suicide it does seem like the US government if you take three steps back is pretty committed to making fewer Americans yeah there's a lot of anti- fertility propaganda a lot actually that seems like their main sort of domestic social policy is convincing you not to have kids what is that I mean that's certainly part of civilizational suicide the the the environmental movement in

1:08:40the extreme is fundamentally misanthropic and anti-human yes they start seeing humans as a plague a blight on the surface of the Earth that if if that Earth would be this paradise if only the humans weren't here and some people actually have say this explicitly there's there there's the extinctionist society that literally they they the the this guy who's the head of the extinctionist society was on the front page of the New York Times quoted as saying there are 8 billion people in the world it would be better if there were none so there's some people who actually say that explicitly which is is is completely insane he's advocating a holocaust world of humanity

1:09:21to utter madness he should be condemned for such a statement but he wasn't for some reason now most people on the on the sort of environmental movement have that implicitly they're not they they don't realize that they have that as their optimization but but that is their actions head take us towards Extinction

1:09:45so a lot of people believe that the Earth can't sustain this level of human population which is utterly untrue it may seem in a crowded City that there are a lot of people but actually if you look down on an airplane and you say look down am I over a person at any given point in time when you're an airplane the answer is 99.9% of the time no like If you flew from LA to New York and say you're you're Drive is to drop a ball on someone and and hit them you would fail you have to drop a lot of balls you have to drop a lot of balls they could be insane so all of the humans on Earth can fit on one floor in the city of New York yeah the cross-sectional area of of

1:10:31all humans 8 billion humans is small so we we have this totally wrong idea that the Earth is over overly overpopulated where in fact it is underpopulated how do I mean have you ever heard a politician say anything like that are there how many there's there's maybe a few prum politicians out there yeah I mean like like Victor Oran Georgia Maloney yes we're starting to see pro-natalist politicians and hopefully more as time goes by I think there's a guy that just got elected in the Czech Republic who's also Pro natalist now these have to translate into actual actions that change the birth rate or it doesn't matter

1:11:27and so far I've not seen any country Mak a meaningful dent in the both rate what would you do if you were in charge of natalist policy first of all I changed the education system so that people understand that you stop being taught that we're overpopulated this is completely false a lot of it comes from this insane misanthropic book that Paul erck wrote the population bomb like 60 years ago yeah I hope he burns in hell that guy seriously terrible human being total absolute Miss and Thro and and say just look the the Earth can absolutely sustain its population it could we could double or triple the population there's a professor I was talking to at Oxford

1:12:18who who's his math says we could 10x the population without destroying the Amazon rainforest or anything terrible so so I think we should expand the human population and increase the scope and scale of Consciousness so we can better understand the nature of this universe this wonderful Universe and and all the amazing things that exist and and and so so that's one of the things I'd like we need to stop teaching people false propaganda that the Earth is overpopulated I think we need to

1:12:56you know in especially with with the education of woman and man and is is we we need Stop scaring woman that having a kid destroys your life this is false you know we terrify girls into saying that if you get pregnant it's your life's over and this is this is what schools teach now I agree we should not have teenage pregnancies yeah but but but but actually having a child is one of the most delightful happiness inducing things you could possibly do of course of course so

1:13:34there's there's also you know with hormonal birth control I think maybe a lot of women are unaware that hormonal birth control causes depression and and dramatically increases risk of suicide and changes their their preferences on who they want to marry or have kids with it it changes their personality and not does say this on the Box by the way caution may change your personality yes if the warnings are has significant cause significant

1:14:22risk of depression significant increase in suicide and will make you want to go out with people that you don't actually like that's actually true by the way I know I'm not saying that people shouldn't use birth control I think we should just be we shouldn't use I think hormonal birth control is is is making it's making a lot of women sad and depressed yes and they don't realize it and they don't realize that's the cause and and there you know there other forms of contraception that could be used and that we should they should just read the just read the label on the box is what I'm saying that was cons what you just said the warning label that was

1:15:00like the most taboo thing you could ever say for most of my life was to offer any criticism at all of hormonal birth control look I'm all I'm saying is read the warning label yeah fair but why the pressure not to read the warning label and just why are we giving it to 12-year-olds to regulate their acne right I I think we should give it to 12-year-olds like kid kids they don't know what's going on so it's like now like there you know I think

1:15:27there there are other forms of birth control I think are have fewer negative effects and than hormonal but but that's we should just be aware that that that the this is not a riskless thing and it it does cause severe mood changes it does dramatically increase risk of suicide and depression so

1:15:56so just FYI you know just make sure you that that that there's full disclosure here and and you want all just read the warning label is all I'm saying just read you know and and consider maybe other options for birth control to any woman listening just just just read the warning label and consider other options because the reason the reason you're sad might be the the the birth control the hormonal birth control that is fundamentally changing the hormones in your body in ways that probably are not good for you and you I know women where where it they stopped taking birth control and their depression immediately disappeared so that's maybe worth a try

1:16:43but then you miss an opportunity maybe it's the bir control then you don't you don't get to go on ssris yeah yeah I think the Es are the devil what you don't they I so vehemently agree with you but I I guess I guess once you endorse Trump you can just say it all now right no I I think selective serona rapake Inhibitors are zombify people and and change

1:17:10their personality and make them not who they are terrible they're so common yes I I I think we should revisit whether this is this is actually good this I just agree with you the ssris are like I'm not saying we should that no one should ever be subscribed ssris but giving them out like candy is crazy you look at like sort of anti-depressant prescriptions in the United States versus other countries and we're like way above everyone else oh yeah I have seen many many times in my life in the news business after a mass shooting like school for example yeah someone will say well what meds was the shooter on oh yeah and immediately be shouted down as a crazy person as a you

1:17:59know Bobby Kennedy level wacko yes who should himself be institutionalized for even raising the question I've always wonder like why wouldn't we want to know what meds a m abolutely want to know what meds are on now now sometimes it's it's perhaps they were on because there like some people do I I you know I don't say it's like all one way or all the other of I me there are there are people that have fundamental chemical imbalances in their brain if they don't take medication

1:18:28to control for example paranoid schizophrenia they will have paranoid schizophrenia for sure and and and I know many cases where people stop taking their you know meds and and and lost their mind oh yeah and and then try to try to kill people and stuff like that so it's or themselves well the guy with the ax on Market Street probably should be on meds that guy should we should try it yeah it make you know does he want to a motor more or less on a given Med you know

1:19:02so so there there are psychiatric medications that I that with with a good outw V I'm not saying that that doesn't exist but we overprescribe psychiatric medication in the United States obviously far in excess of any other country like you know way more than Canada or Britain or Japan or any China anywhere it's like we're off the charts on on psychiatric medication prescriptions in the US why why don't people raise that point more often I wonder in public I should I'm I'm raising it yeah you are you said that are artificial intelligence machine intelligence might be a good thing where where are we on AI right now AGI right now and what are your views

1:19:57well I think at this point it's obvious to everyone that AI is advancing at a very rapid Pace yes you can see it with the new capabilities that come out every month or every every week sometimes you know you AI at this point can write a better essay than probably 90% maybe 95% of all humans say write an essay on any given subject AI right now can can beat the vast majority of humans if you say draw an image draw a picture it can draw like if you try to say mid mid Journey which is the Aesthetics of mid Journey are incredible it will draw it will create incredible images that are better than again like 90% of artists it's just objectively the case and it'll

1:20:58do it immediately like 30 seconds later we're also starting to see AI movies so you start seeing you know short films with AI AI Music Creation and the the the rate at which we're increasing AI compute is exponential hyp exponential so this dramatically more AI compute coming on online every every month you know there seems to be

1:21:36roughly I don't know the the amount of AI Compu coming online is increasing at like at a quote roughly 500% a year and like it's like that's likely to continue for several years the and then the sophistication of the AI algorith is also improving so bringing online a massive amount of AI compute and also improving the efficiency of the computer and and what and like what what the AI software can do so it's it's it's quantitative and qualitative in Improvement so the you know I I might I think next year you'll be be able to ask AI so certainly by the end of next year make a short movie about something or you know probably can do at least a 15minute you know show or something like

1:22:31that so yeah it's advancing very rapidly my top concern for AI safety is that we need to have a maximally truth seeking AI so the this is the most important thing for AI safety in my opinion you know the the central lesson that say oy clar was trying to convey in 2001 Space Odyssey was that you shouldn't Force AI to lie so in that book

1:23:16the the the AI was told to take the astronauts to the monolith but they also could not know about the monolith it resulted that quandry by killing them and taking them to the monolith or didn't kill all of them killed most of them that's why H hell would not open the pod bay doors right so very important to have truth seeking AIS now and what what I actually see with the AI that are being developed is that they're being programmed with the work mind virus so the lying is big taked in yes and we saw this on display very

1:24:00clearly with the release of Google Gemini yes where you would ask for a picture of the founding fathers of the United States and it would show a group of diverse women in you know dressed in in with sort of 18th century God pow powdered wigs but from St Lucia yeah I mean like look if I understand if you say like show me a group of people for sure if and it shows a group of divorce wom that's totally fine but if you say this if you say very specifically the the founding fathers of the United States which were you know group of white dudes then should show them like and and with and and what they actually look like because you've asked for something which is a fact from

1:24:47history but it didn't it was it was programmed with the work mind virus so so much that it it actually even though it knew the truth it it It produced a lie now of course then then people really started playing with it and said okay now now show me a group of fafen ss officers in World War II turns out they were also a group of divorce woman according to Gemini all the black Nazi ladies yeah it's like it's like wow I didn't realize that you know it's not what I expected so you

1:25:23know what also not what happened it's not what happened so it's just it the AI is is producing a lie and and then you know then like one of the questions that people that people asked was like which is worse Global thow nuclear war or misgendering Caitlyn Jenner and said misgendering Caitlyn Jenner is worse now Caitlyn Jenna kill kills fewer people yeah to Caitlyn Jenna to her credit I said no please misgender me that is far more preferable than World War global thermonuclear war we all die but but to have a you know a

1:26:05production release AI say stuff like that is concerning because if if let's say this becomes like all powerful and it's and it still has this programming where misgendering is worse than nuclear war well it could conclude that the way to ensure that the there can never be any misgendering is to eliminate all humans now Pro if like optimization is probability of misgendering is zero no no humans no misgendering problem solved now we're back to arthury Clark who's exactly pretty preent yes so that's why I think the most

1:26:47important thing is to have a maximally truth seeking AI That's why I saw it xai and that's our goal with grock no people will point out cases where Gro gets it wrong but we try to correct it as quickly as possible but maybe even a bigger problem is that when you make decisions that affect people you want those decisions to be informed by love of people yeah and machines are incapable of

1:27:18Love yeah I mean there they they certainly okay they're capable of you can program a machine to be philanthropic rather than misanthropic yes but don't don't instincts shape decisions particularly decisions you can't plan for I mean if I ask you you know a question about one of your children every answer you give is going to be shaped by your love for that child and that's why know that that's what makes us decent parents in the end is that that instinct which is love and if a machine has any power over us without that animating Instinct won't it def by definition hurt

1:28:09us yeah well whether I mean I don't know it we should certainly aspire to program the AI philanthropically not M anthropically yes and to have like said we wanted to be truthful and Cur curious and to Foster Humanity into the future and yeah that's what we want obviously is there any way I guess to set limits on the decisions that machines can make that affect human lives and make certain that there's some trigger in the system that inserts a human being into the decisionmaking process

1:29:00well the look The the reality of what's Happening whether one likes it or not is that we we're building super intelligent AIS hyper like hyper intelligent like intelligent more intelligent than we can comprehend yes so I would like this to like let's say you have a child that is a Super Genius child that that you know it's going to be much smarter than you then well what can you do you you can instill good values in how you raise that child so even though you know it's going to be far smarter than you you can make sure it's got good values philanthropic values good morals you know honest you

1:29:50know productive that kind of thing controlling at the end of the day I I don't know if I don't think we'll be able to control it so I think the best we can do is make sure it grows up well you've been saying that for a long time yes I've been saying for a long time yes are you still as worried about it as you seem to be two years ago when I asked you about

1:30:18it well I I think that like my guess is like look it's it's it's 80% likely to be good maybe 90 so you could look think of the glass as 80% full it's probably going to be it's probably going to be great the some chance of annihilation and You' say the chance of annihilation is 20% 10 to 20% something like that how concerned is Sam Alman about Annihilation do you think I think in reality is not concerned about it I don't trust open AI I mean I you know I started that company as a nonprofit open source yes the open and open AI I named the compan I named the company yeah open AI as an open source and it is now

1:31:13extremely closed source and and Ma and maximizing profit so does risky I don't understand how you actually go from being a an open source nonprofit profit to a close source for maximum profit organization I'm missing well but samman got rich didn't he at various points he's claimed not to be getting rich but he's claimed many things that were false and now apparently he's going to get1 billion a stock or something like that so I don't trust samman and I and I don't think we want to have the most powerful AI in the world controlled by someone who is not trustworthy and sorry I just don't I mean but that that seems like a fair concern yeah but but you don't think as

1:32:02someone who knows him and has dealt with him that he is worried about the possibility this could get out of control and hurt people he will say those words yeah but no if AI did if it became clear to the rest of us that it was out of control and posed a threat to humanity would there be any way to stop

1:32:34it I hope so I mean if you have multiple AIS and ones that are hopefully you have the AIS that are pro-human be stronger them the AIS that are not Battle of the AIS yeah yeah I mean that that is how it is with say chess these days the the like the AI chess programs also are vastly better than any human

1:33:26incomprehensibly better meaning like we can't even understand why it made that move why they're so good right yeah we don't even know why it made the it'll make a move we don't even know why it made the move so and in fact some of the moves will seem like blunders but then turn out to Checkmate so and you know for for a while there

1:33:50there was there was some the best human chest players with the best computers could beat just a computer and then it got to the point where if you added a human it just made everything works and then it was just AI it's just computer programs versus computer programs that's that's where things are headed in general what I mean sweet dreams

1:34:25at what point so I don't know I think we just got to make like I said make sure we instill good values in the AI what's everyone going to do for a living I mean in a benign AI scenario that is probably the biggest challenge is how do you find meaning if AI is better than you at everything yeah that's the benan scenario that's the good news well yeah I been I guess you know for a lot of people like the idea of retiring and you know really are you looking forward to it no not me I I'd like to hope I'd like to think that I i' like to be do useful things don't you think it's a universal desire it's it's it's not it's not

1:35:16Universal in that there are certainly I know many people who prefer to be retired that they prefer to sort of have not have responsibilities and engage in in leisure activities so I we and we're on the cusp of of this is it's really a remarkable time to exist well I'll tell you like one of the ways I I sort of was able to sort of sleep and Rec reconcile myself to to this is that I I thought well would I prefer to be alive and see the Advent of digital super intelligence or would I would I prefer to be alive at a different time and not see it and I guess I'm like well I guess

1:36:12I'd prefer to be alive to see if it's going to happen I prefer to be alive to see it happen out of curiosity and then was like well let's say you knew for sure it would kill everyone would you you you could now now you can shift back in time like I guess I'd want to be near the end of my life or something before that happened but I at at the end of day it's like if if it's going to happen and there's nothing you do about it hypothetically would you prefer to see it or not see it and I guess I I guess it's going to happen I prefer to see it rather not see it yeah but as a man of action why not convince Trump to make you Secretary of Defense and then just nuke

1:37:14AI I I I think I I would certainly push for a having some some kind of regulatory body that at least has insight into what these companies are doing and Can Ring the Alarm Bell even if we don't have a regulation or rule so I'm not I'm not someone who wants to get rid of all regulatory agencies or everything I think think we there's the right number of regulations right number of regulators and we've gone we've gone too far just like if you in a football game if you had too many referees on the field it would be weird like you can't throw the pass because you hit a referee ex then there too many referees so but but no but if you like say

1:37:58look at any pro sports game they all have referees that like the teams could decide we're going to have game we're going to not have referees that could be a thing but but every sports game they have refs to make sure that the rules are followed and and it's a better game if if you have well we have cops too yeah yeah exactly cops are the referees so I think we for for something that is a a danger to the public or potential danger to the public we we have referees we have Regulators you know so like the FDA and the FAA and you know the various Regulatory Agencies they were they were established because aircraft were falling out of the sky and and some manufacturers were not

1:38:47you know building high quality aircraft they're cutting corners and then people will die and you know for Food and Drugs that some manufacturers were making lowquality drugs and so they that they're they're Ling to people so saying that something cured them when it killed them so FDA to you know Regulators to

1:39:10referees to try to make you make sure that this this drug manufactures are truthful now I do think it mostly works I mean I think it's doesn't mean don't need regory form we do reform we do but I don't think we should have no Regulators in AI given that it's potential existential RIS a little weird that everything is regulated yeah I mean you said you're being sued by the Department of Justice for not hiring more Asylum Seekers for your high-tech company yeah even though it's legal for us to hire Asylum Seekers right so so they're watching everything regulating everything controlling everything including our thoughts right that's why they're opposed to free speech but

1:39:54they're not meaningfully regulating AI which will eliminate like the purpose from most people's lives and could kill us all it's a little weird yeah I think we should have some why don't we gu something above nothing in that range yeah but why don't we I don't know you know I I all the way back like I

1:40:21like during the Obama presidency I I I you know met with Obama many times but usually in like group settings the the one one-on-one meeting I had with obal in the Oval Office I said look the one thing that we really need to do is is set up an at the beginnings of an AI regulatory agency and it can start with Insight where you don't you don't just come shooting from the hip throwing out regulations you just start with Insight where the the AI regulatory committee simply goes into understand what all the companies are doing insight and then proposes rules that all

1:41:02the AI companies agree to follow just like you know sports teams in the NFL you know you have proposed rules for football that everyone agrees to follow that make the game better you know so that that's the way to do it but nothing came of it what did he say when he said that to him I mean he seems like kind of agree but but also people didn't realize what what the where AI was headed that at that time you know so AI seemed like some super futuristic yeah for sci-fi basically so like I'm telling you this is going to be smarter than the smartest human and

1:41:44my predictions are coming absolutely true and so we need to have some insight here just to make make sure that this companies aren't cutting Corners doing dangerous things but go Google kind of controlled the the White House at that time and and they they did not want any regulatory well that's it I mean you never see politicians turn down opportunities to become more powerful which is the point of Regulation it makes them more powerful yeah so it sounds like regulatory capture then well yeah I mean the CIO the the Ys at the time was ex Google person so they they put

1:42:30the brakes on any AI regulation and we still don't have any AI regulation at the federal level it's amazing so I I think we should have something above nothing like I said at least Insight where even even if there's no there's no rule that's being break broken they can at least say hey we we have insight into what this company are doing or that company is doing and we're concerned that would be helpful to know yeah instead politically motivated Liars are in charge of the future it seems a little yeah sketchy last question you you really kind of pulled out a lot of stops to help Trump you're on stage yesterday if he gets elected will you continue to help him now absolutely so

1:43:19we've talked about kind of a government efficiency commission or the department of govern efficiency which is a funny what what per sorry I'm just laughing I love it you managed to make it sound a little Sinister government efficiency what percentage of Google employees did you can when you got there you mean Twitter rather I think

1:43:43sorry I just you just been talking about Google Twitter yeah yeah well we we we're about 80% and and and we've we've actually improved the features and functionality of the site more in you the past year and a half than the last I don't know eight years with 20% of the staff so just for I just want to throw that for context so you've talked to Trump about yeah some kind of commission yeah which he's he has mentioned publicly several times and he's very supportive of having some kind of you know government efficiency commission call the Department of government efficiency Doge I kind like those it's more it's more fun yeah and and

1:44:35we just take a look at at at all the federal agencies and say do we really need whatever it is 428 federal agencies like there's so many that people never even heard of or and that have overlapping areas of responsibility we should I don't know probably we should get I mean there there are more federal agencies than there are years since the establishment of the United States which means that we've created more than one Federal agency per year on average that seems a lot that's a lot that's a lot so we should have that seems crazy I think we should be able to get away with 99 agencies I don't know that seems a lot like a lot of agencies it's

1:45:20a lot yeah yeah two that's yeah exactly we should have fewer agencies and and they certainly shouldn't have overlapping responsibilities and and then we need some kind of we just need a review of regulations to say which ones are sensible and which ones are not because if you've got Regulators every year they're going to add more regulations it's just automatic like like they're just output regulations and and then and there's more laws and regulations every year until basically everything's legal so we can't get anything done so we need some kind of garbage collection for regulations that don't make sense I think I'm saying very obvious things you're you are saying obvious

1:46:04things yeah so which will be very unpopular things yeah I'll probably need if if this happens a quite a significant security team so that because CU someone might literally go post on me from the post office but in the meantime you've got America pack yeah that is encouraging voting for the next month am I summarizing correctly yeah I I a formed America pack really support

1:46:34core values that I believe in which are I think again very obvious Centrist positions which is like we in America I think we want safe cities secure borders sensible spending tell me where I'm going far right here you know we want to have the right to self- protection we we should respect the Constitution and not try to break the Constitution it's therefore reason and you know we we should stop lawfare I kind of listed these out these are all listed on the America Pac website people can go look at the America Pac website it's the America PAC.org and see if there's anything I disagree with or perhaps we should modify these goals but I think these are

1:47:29good goals to have they they were certainly part of the oh and right to free speech you know First Amendment if we don't have free speech we don't have democracy because people cannot make an informed vote so those are my controversial views and you know and and look I I I don't think either party I don't think the Republicans are perfect I don't think obviously right now I more Republican than Democrat but it's not like I think the Republican party is perfect or or is without issues but we've got a choice between two candidates and I think on balance it's a no-brainer to vote for Trump and if we don't vote for Trump I think we are at Ser serious risk of losing our

1:48:26democracy and becoming a one-party state where there isn't an election anymore there's only a Democratic primary like there is in California Elon Musk thank you very much

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份