在德克萨斯州博卡奇卡,有一座 120 米高的塔,塔顶伸出两条巨大的机械臂。它要接住的东西,是一枚从天上掉下来、重达 250 吨、下落速度还超过音速一半的助推器。
马斯克自己说起这件事的时候,语气里带着一种“我知道这听起来有多疯”的坦然。
这玩意儿确实挺疯狂的。一座定制的塔,带着两条手臂,设计目的是接住人类有史以来制造的最大、最重的飞行物,把它从空中夹下来。(马斯克)
2022 年春天,Everyday Astronaut 的 Tim Dodd 爬上星舰(Starship)发射塔,跟马斯克聊了这一段。这座塔在 SpaceX 内部被叫作“Stage Zero”,零级。火箭还没点火,零级就已经决定了后面所有事情能不能成立。
那两条机械臂,本来只是用来吊火箭的
很多人已经忘了,这两条“筷子”最初的设计目的跟接火箭没关系,它俩是干吊装和堆叠的活。
风大的时候起重机能力会打折,物理限制摆在那儿。马斯克当时的想法很干脆:把助推器的着陆腿删掉。
有人跟我说,助推器的腿会很重。我说,那就删掉腿,删掉。那用什么?用塔上的手臂就行了。(马斯克)
在场的人以为他在开玩笑。马斯克说,那就认真搞吧。现在回头看,这件事已经变得“很正常”了,大家都觉得似乎可行。
他自己给出的总结是:“在 SpaceX,我们擅长把不可能变成延期。”
这句话值得单独拎出来。它背后藏着一套工程方法论:先设一个看起来荒谬的目标,承认它大概率会晚,但不承认它不该做。
接住一个 250 吨的坠落物,过程比想象中慢
助推器直径 9 米,不算边条翼,大约 30 英尺。着陆时的重量在 250 吨左右,马斯克希望随着迭代能压到 200 吨以下。
这里有个容易被忽略的细节:干重其实是个浮动概念。火箭落地那一刻,贮箱里还残留着好几吨气体,光是那个体积里一个大气压质量的空气就有好几吨。所以“多重”这个问题,得看你说的是哪个瞬间。
真正的着陆序列是这样展开的。
助推器以超过音速一半的速度下坠,也就是大约 0.5 马赫。这时候它离地面只有几百米。它必须在极短的距离内把速度降到零,同时修正横向误差。
发动机会在 0.5 马赫左右点火,但那时它离地面只有几百米。它得飞快地把自己刹住,然后修正掉任何偏差。落地时的 XY 误差,必须在那一刻消掉,速度降到基本为零,然后落进两条手臂之间。(马斯克)
手臂张得很宽,等助推器进来,再合拢,贴住箭体侧面。助推器继续往下走,箭体上那几个几乎看不清的吊挂凸耳会碰到手臂上表面,然后停住。
马斯克补了一句:“希望它不会剪切、不会皱掉。”
Tim Dodd 说他真心希望助推器别撞到塔,尤其别撞到那个发射环,那东西制造难度极高。
马斯克的回应带着典型的 SpaceX 腔调:
我们还没找到它不工作的理由。成功是可能的结果之一。概率不确定,但大于零。(马斯克)
有件事和直觉相反:如果一切顺利,整个过程看起来会相当慢。
助推器长度大约 70 米。假设下降速度是每秒 2 到 3 米,最后需要穿过手臂的那段距离有 20 米左右,那就是十秒钟。观众会盯着屏幕想:怎么还没结束。
手臂合拢的时机也很讲究。它要在最后阶段才收紧,合拢后要贴在甲烷贮箱那一段,也就是火箭上部大约三分之一的光滑区域。贴得太用力会把箭体压瘪。
我们有一大堆失败的方式。(马斯克)
还有一处细节:边条翼必须朝向塔的反方向,否则会卡到手臂。助推器不仅要落进两条手臂之间,还得转对角度。
120 米,圣安东尼奥以南最高的建筑
Tim Dodd 站在塔顶说,这东西远看很大,站到下面看更大,大气里的雾霾让它往远处淡下去,反而更显得不真实。
马斯克提到,有人告诉他这是圣安东尼奥以南最高的建筑。此前这一带的最高点是南帕诸岛(South Padre)的一家酒店。这座塔比它高出一大截。
马斯克还给了一个非常直观的参照:120 米版本的星舰,尺寸差不多等于旁边那艘叫 Sapphire 的游轮。
人们想知道那是什么感觉,就去坐一次 Sapphire 号,然后知道这枚火箭有多大。想想都觉得离谱。(马斯克)
站在塔顶往下看,助推器在厂房旁边小得像玩具,人更是小到几乎看不见。Tim Dodd 说,如果没亲眼见过,很难相信这一切在一年前还完全不存在。
星舰必须先入轨,其他一切才有意义
Tim Dodd 问起人类着陆系统(Human Landing System)的进展,马斯克的回答把优先级摆得很清楚。
设计层面做了很多,电脑里都跑过。硬件也有一些。重心落在入轨上。
因为人类着陆系统没有入轨就无从谈起,这是显然的。(马斯克)
更硬的约束来自星链。星舰是唯一能运载星链 2(Starlink II)卫星的载具。
第一颗星链 2 卫星已经造出来了,就在基地里,7 米长,大约 1.25 吨。猎鹰 9 号(Falcon 9)无论是整流罩容积还是运力,都装不下它。
马斯克说得很直接:就算把星链 2 缩小,猎鹰 9 号的总上行质量也远远不够。
性能提升的幅度接近一个数量级。单颗星链 2 卫星能处理的有效数据量,比星链 1 强近十倍。用户终端走的是另一条升级路线,可以同时兼容两代卫星。
衡量航天的指标不是发射次数,重点在每年送上轨道的有效质量
访谈里有一段马斯克对行业指标的批评,值得单独拎出来说。
很多人讨论航天时喜欢比“每年发射多少次”。马斯克认为这个指标没有意义。
真正重要的是你每年把多少有效载荷送入轨道。否则就像拿一艘小舢板去跟超级油轮比,说它们是一回事。(马斯克)
卫星星座这个行业,核心指标是“有效质量流量”。一年发射 60 次小火箭,和一年发射 6 次星舰,完全不在一个量级。
星舰必须成功,商业上的理由也压在这里:星链 2 上不去,星链就卡在地面上。
完全复用是通往火星的唯一钥匙,地球是最难的那颗星球
站在塔顶,Tim Dodd 问了一个很直白的问题:你内心深处真的相信,这是人类成为多行星物种的起点吗?
我相信这件事第一次成为可能。让生命成为多行星物种,关键是完全可复用的火箭。就这一个关键。(马斯克)
紧接着,马斯克给出了一段技术密度很高的判断。
完全复用在地球上“刚刚好可能”。火星反而容易得多,重力只有地球的 37% 到 38%,大气密度只有 1%。
在地球上实现完全复用,考虑到地球重力场的强度和大气密度,是极其困难的。火星上相对容易。地球上只是勉强可能。(马斯克)
他特意澄清了一个常见的误解:过去的火箭工程师并非没想到复用。他们天天坐飞机,当然知道飞机能重复使用。
复用这件事在他们脑子里出现过,他们完全清楚。只是技术问题极其困难,他们认为不可能,或者成功概率太低,不值得做。(马斯克)
这段话解释了为什么“可复用”在航天领域被当作笑话讲了几十年。所有人都算过,算完觉得不划算,于是就不再算了。
太阳终将蒸发海洋,这是多行星的最终理由
Tim Dodd 提到马斯克此前说过的一个类似诺亚方舟的比喻:如果你真的在乎生命,就得有第二个栖息地。
马斯克的回答把时间尺度拉到了几十亿年。
如果你真的往长远看,终有一天会出现某种灾难,哪怕不是人类造成的,也会摧毁地球上所有生命。太阳最终会膨胀,蒸发掉海洋,地球会变得像金星一样热,热到任何生命都无法存在。也许还有一些化能细菌能活,但最终它们也会死。(马斯克)
结论落在这里:延长我们已知生命的唯一方式,是成为多行星物种,最终成为多恒星物种。不做这件事,地球上的生命终将消失。
所以那些真正在乎地球生命的人,应该非常在乎让生命成为多行星、最终多恒星的。(马斯克)
彗星撞木星,撞出一个地球大小的坑
很多人有一种印象,觉得 SpaceX 是在逃离地球、逃避地球上的问题。马斯克用预算数据回应:NASA 的预算只占联邦预算的 0.3%。
他顺带说了一个事实:地球目前没有任何拦截小行星的能力。有了星舰之后,才有了一点可能。
但他认为真正的危险不在小行星,在彗星。
彗星才是真正的危险,因为外太阳系里有几十亿甚至上万亿个天体,其中一些是长周期彗星。大家最熟悉的是哈雷彗星,它大约每个世纪回来不到一次。所以很可能有很多长周期彗星,我们根本不知道它们存在。(马斯克)
他举的例子是苏梅克-列维 9 号(Shoemaker-Levy 9)。那颗彗星撞上木星时,在木星上撞出了一个地球大小的洞。
如果那玩意儿撞的是我们,游戏结束,全都没了。(马斯克)
经济不是零和游戏,资本配置是一份工作
Tim Dodd 提出了另一个常见质疑:花一亿美元造火箭,这一亿美元就“进了太空”。
他的反驳是:钱没有离开经济,它进了供应链,进了技术积累。NASA 在 60 和 70 年代做的事,塑造了今天的社会。
马斯克把这个话题接了过去,讲得更系统。
经济总体上是正和游戏,是一个不断做大的饼。今天的人均经济产出远高于过去,饼的增长速度远超人口增长。
如果一个人对经济有隐含的零和假设,那他想往上走,唯一的办法就是从别人那里拿。但显然今天的经济总量远大于过去。(马斯克)
他的判断很明确:创造财富、创造好的产品和服务,应该被赞赏,因为这实质性地提高了生活水平。
随后是一段关于消费和资本配置的区分,讲得很马斯克。
人们有时候把消费和财富混为一谈,但它们显然不是一回事。资本配置是一份工作,消费是乐趣。我不觉得有多少人愿意干沃伦·巴菲特那份工作,读那些极其枯燥的公司年报,抠会计细节,然后决定要不要投可口可乐还是百事。我不想要那份工作。(马斯克)
他用的类比很朴素:电、自来水、空调,一开始都只有极少数人能用,后来成了全世界的标准配置。航空旅行曾经昂贵、危险、只有少数人负担得起,现在是日常。等离子电视曾经贵得离谱,现在在沃尔玛花五百美元就能买到一台画质惊人的。
进步是巨大的。(马斯克)
三年前的 Starbase,只有一堆土和三个推进剂罐
访谈里有一段轻松的对比。
Tim Dodd 第一次来这里是 2019 年 3 月,差不多整整三年前。那时候只有一个小跳跳(Starhopper),刚开始做初步的静态点火测试。
马斯克补充说,当时的推进剂区就是三个小罐子,一个土堆,一个帐篷,仅此而已。
现在整个基地的推进剂储存系统,是为完整版星舰准备的,马斯克说这部分投入了相当大的精力。
Tim Dodd 问起一个实际问题:如果要中止测试,或者做第一次静态点火,回收需要多久?得把推进剂排回贮罐。
马斯克的回答很坦诚:一开始会非常颠簸。
猎鹰 9 号早期,我们有过十几次中止发射。有段时间我基本就住在卡纳维拉尔角,就为了让那枚该死的火箭起飞,让九台发动机同时启动、离地。然后是一次又一次发射中止。(马斯克)
他提到那段时间带着孩子去迪士尼,去了很多次哈利波特园区。Tim Dodd 说希望星舰的过程能好一些。
大概率不会。这类工程的真实样子,从来都是十几次中止堆出来的那一次成功。
这期访谈真正的信息量在哪
很多人看这类视频,看的是奇观:塔有多高,机械臂有多大,风景有多壮观。这些都是真的,也确实好看。
马斯克在这次爬塔过程里给出的,其实是几条判断。
第一,指标的选取决定了行业的方向。用发射次数衡量航天,会得到一个好看的假象。用每年送入轨道的有效质量衡量,才看得见真正的差距。这套思路换个行业照样管用:指标选错,人就会去优化错的东西。
第二,很多“不可能”的真实含义是“概率太低,所以没人做”。火箭复用这件事,所有工程师都想过,算完都放弃了。这类问题有个特点:难度不会随时间下降,收益会随规模上升。等规模到了,重算一遍,结论可能就翻过来了。
第三,工程上的疯狂目标和执行上的“会延期”可以共存。“把不可能变成延期”这句话,是这套方法论最精炼的表达。它承认现实,但不放弃目标。
第四,长期理由和短期理由要分开讲。星舰的短期理由是星链 2 上不去,商业模型就断了。长期理由是太阳终将膨胀。两个理由都成立,搅在一起说就失真了。用长期愿景掩盖短期的工程问题,是骗自己。用短期问题否定长期愿景,是骗别人。
如果你想真正理解这套系统,可以做这几件事
- 下次看到“某国一年发射多少次”的新闻,换成“全年送入轨道的有效载荷质量”再算一遍,看看排名会不会变。
- 遇到一个被反复说“不可能”的技术方向,先问一句:物理上不可能,还是算下来不划算?这两种“不可能”的寿命完全不同。
- 关注星舰第一次助推器回收尝试时,别只看成功或失败。看它有没有修正横向误差,看手臂合拢的时机,看箭体有没有被压瘪。这些细节才决定第二次能不能成。
- 把“把不可能变成延期”这句话抄下来。它适合放在任何一个你正在做的、被人说疯了的事情旁边。
- 如果有人用“这钱不如用来解决地球上的问题”来质疑航天投入,可以告诉他两个数字:NASA 占联邦预算 0.3%,以及苏梅克-列维 9 号在木星上撞出的那个地球大小的洞。
0:00Hi, it's me, Tim Dodd, the Everyday Astronaut. Welcome to Starbase, Texas. Today, I'm going to be taking you up SpaceX's launch tower, otherwise known as Stage Zero with Elon Musk. We'll get the ultimate view of Starbase and learn more about just how exactly SpaceX plans to catch the world's largest flying object with giant robotic chopsticks. This is part two of our
0:21Spring 2022 Starbase Tour with Elon. In the first part, we got up close and personal with the high bay and starship prototypes and in the next part we'll get really in-depth with Raptor 2 and Merlin rocket engines so stay tuned and if you happen to find this video valuable consider dropping a super thanks as a tip below here on YouTube or become a channel member or patreon supporter for early access and
0:45to show your support that being said let's get up in there I feel like you always talk about you know how you just want to build an
1:05exciting future a world where people get excited about stuff wake up and want to do cool things and yeah I gotta tell you standing right here man that's that's pretty hard to not get excited about this yeah I mean this is pretty crazy I mean there's a custom built tower with arms that'll that are designed to
1:28catch the the largest and heaviest flying object ever made and pluck it out out of the air. I mean, that's a theory anyway. So. I think it's funny. People actually forget now that they're actually meant to lift and stack the rocket. The crane sets its bad wind capability. But one time the booster legs were going to weigh a lot.
1:51The one just said, you know, delete the legs, delete. We're like, well, what's the, you just use arms. And then set it again. I mean, go a while. You're serious. OK, we better get on this. And now it's normal. We think it seems plausible. It seems plausible. Yeah. I mean, it's a little super crazy.
2:10But the more you talk about it, I mean, I think, you know, at SpaceX, we specialize in converting things from impossible to late. Yeah. So, but it's pretty nutty because you're going to have this gigantic, you know, booster coming back. And I mean that's nine meters in diameter not counting the chines or roughly 30 feet in diameter.
2:41And it'll weigh about 250 tons. Just put on the heavy side, we'll make that lighter of a time. Wait is that two, fifteen hours every single time? This is way heavier than I think we can get the... Well, there's the weight at different points. So it's like, say like, when the landing tanks are full versus
3:11weight when the landing tanks are empty. So how much alleys mass do you have? And there's a ton of- Dry weight is kind of floating. You know, there's dry weight is kind of a relative when it's actually in the air. Yeah. I mean, there's several tons of air mass in the vehicle. Just you just say, like, what's the mass of one atmosphere
3:30in that volume with several tons. So anyway, I think we'll be able to get the mass well under 200 tons over time. It's still pretty heavy. So you've got like a cool couple hundred tons of plummeting at, let's see, I think out the velocity at which we start up the engines is more than half the speed of sound.
4:04So this thing is still coming in really fast. Yeah. Pretty much down in a downward direction. So then the light the engines, like I said, are on Mach 0.5, give or take. But it's only several hundred meters in the air. So it's got to slow itself down very fast, then correct any error.
4:31So whatever the XY-era is, when the engines land, it's gonna take out that XY-era and then drop the velocity to basically zero, come in between the arms. The arms will be wide and as is coming in, the arms will close, go flush against the side of the vehicle and the vehicle will be descending through the arms.
4:56And those tiny little, you can barely see them, little mobs. Those kind of lifting lugs will touch the top of the arms and then it will hopefully not share often and crumple. Joe, is there anything you want to add there? I don't know if you could add that, but I was just describing the landing sequence. I was accurate.
5:19I really hope it doesn't hit the tower. Yeah, exactly. And especially not that launch ring, which is really difficult to make. The load shrink is very complicated. We have not found a reason yet why it will not work. Yes, success is one of the possible outcomes. The probability is uncertain, but it is above zero.
5:44So the arms are off to the side. So in theory, the bush is going to come back and then with engine start up, it'll translate over, slow down and translate over and get in between the arms. Arms need to close, not, and when they close, they need to close in such a way that they don't crush the rocket as well.
6:07We're scored all the way up the whole thing. Just, yeah, there's a lot of ways for us to fail. How quickly like, is it gonna close like almost at the last second? Like, or it will be mostly closed and there's a small tolerance there and it skirts the whole thing by, you know. It's intended to close on the methane tank so just smooth upper section about the top third of the rocket and then you can keep translating down and touch on those dogs that stick out of the rocket.
6:35Yeah. I mean, if things are going right, it will actually look like the rocket is descending between the arms for quite a while. You know, because the length of the thing It's like basically around 70 meters. So, if you've got a descent rate of, I don't know, let's say two or three meters per second, and you have 20 meters or something like that,
7:04it's okay, you're waiting for like 10 seconds. So we'll actually be like, actually this has taken a while. And now you gotta clear those chines too. You can't have it be so close down on the... The chimes will be blocked kind of away from the tower, so they won't be increasing. Oh, got the opposite way from the clamps.
7:27Got it. Yeah, that makes sense. That's cool. But you still need to get the rocket has to still fit in between these arms. So, it's still gotta come in. And it's just center up and this arms will slew in. Yeah. To meet it wherever it is. So if it's off to one side, it's gonna hit one of the arms, which will be quite bad.
7:54Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Well, cook the arm or, you know, bunch of bad things can happen. It's just insane though. I mean, it's, it's, it looks big from far away, but it looks even bigger when you're underneath it and you start to see almost the, the atmospheric distortion and the haze, make it fade into the distance there.
8:21Yeah, I'm told this is the tallest thing south of San Antonio. Yeah, because I think the other tallest was on South Padre. They have that the hotel was the other tallest thing in the whole area here. So yeah. And that's quite a bit taller. Actually, booster and rocket are almost identical.
8:40There are at least the 120 meter version was like exactly the size of the sapphire over there. people need to know what that feels like just go up in the sapphire and know that's how big this rocket is which is insane to think about. Obviously you're not too worried about like the human landing system right now compared to just getting things into orbit but how is that has any of that stuff solidified yet? Like the
9:06any of the human landing system? Well I mean there's a lot of sort of design because they're done on the computer level. But there's some hardware, but our focus is getting to orbit. If we can... Because human landing won't work without getting to orbit, obviously. Yeah, we need Starship to get to orbit because it's also got to...
9:27It's the only thing that can carry the Starlink II satellites. So we've already produced the first... And we have onsite the first Starlink II satellite. And it's seven meters long. And Falcon has neither the volume nor the mass to overcapability required for Starlink II. So even if we shrunk the Starlink II satellite down, the total up mass of Falcon is not nearly enough to do Starlink II.
9:54How heavy does one version two weigh? Well, it's about one and a quarter tons. There's so wide- electrically huge that. Yeah. But if you just say like, like this, there's a lot of people talk a lot about how many launches per year there are to orbit, but this is not really what matters.
10:14I think what really matters is what's the total useful payload tour per year. Cause otherwise you could say, if this were ocean ships, you'd be like comparing a dinghy to a super tanker. And it's like they're not the same. Yeah. So, for satellite constellation, the thing that really matters is what is your total mass flux,
10:40useful mass flux to orbit. Yeah. Yeah, so, you know, mass to orbit. Yeah, so we need Starship to work and to fly frequently or stalling to be stuck on the ground. So that's your big motivator at this point is like get these things going. And so they'll, I assume because they're bigger, they'll, well, they'll have to be fewer of those
11:00to service the same amount of like area, like is it gonna be, is version two gonna be in a higher orbit, servicing more people like with per satellite, or is it just bigger so it has higher capacity, more bandwidth, more like all of that, I guess, compared to version one. The Starlight two satellites are almost in order of magnitude more capable than Starlight one.
11:21Bandwidth wise or total like throughput? I just think it would like, how many useful bits of data can each satellite do? The Starlink 2 in terms of useful bits of data is almost in order of magnitude better than the Starlink 1.
11:42Wow. Are those different user terminals too compared to... The user terminals are on a separate upgrade path. Okay. Yeah. Although user terminals will work with... user terminals will work with a Starlink 1 or a Starlink 2 satellites, but the Starlink 2's are just much more capable.
12:00Yeah. Is it possible to go up in the tower and he's in runner? I don't know. Can we go up in the tower? Is the elevator working? As long as the generator is on. Yeah, I can fire it up. Okay. I mean, just might not be a bad place to watch a sunset at this point. Yeah.
13:05for the initiative. Yep, sorry. I'll let you all go into it. Should I go up? Up for you? Yeah. Oh, I guess so. We'll get stuck with the CUNY on and then keep it in. Yeah, then continue up. The 50 and then... Yeah. Nice tower. Yeah. I'm gonna pass it apart. This view is gonna be insane.
13:50I can already see it. He has a little sneak beats through the... Dang!
14:20Wow. This is epic. This is so epic. We're not even at the top. I don't know if it's worth it. He's worth it. He's worth it. He's wearing a key arm this. Oh, look. I think it's top that man. I think it's top that man better. Look how beefy all this stuff is, though. Yeah, I mean this is insane custom designed gigantic hardware.
14:48It's hard to believe this is real. It genuinely is. Gee he's. That's... Yes. It's quite the beard. It's beautiful. Yeah, it's beautiful. Look at the top of the booster even right now. And we are in the sky.
15:31We can't even see South Padre. Oh wow. Yeah, really hazy. Oh, should we go up? Yeah. Ha ha ha. It's even better when there's a vehicle on the off-mount. Oh, I know. I know. I can't imagine. I'm close and personal. Seriously. I'm going to come back. Oh, yeah. I missed the one. I came out here I think the day after you guys stacked.
16:01Well, I guess I came out for the last event. But I think he stacked on like the forged card. I don't know something. I don't know what day That's right Yeah Emergency skate platter thing
16:41I maybe want to do that once It probably took like an hour I feel like you're kinda excited. Really getting up here though. The craziest thing to me is that none of this was here a year ago. That's just hard to fathom. It's like, especially if you were out here three years ago, and saw quite literally nothing but a feel that a little RGB-2 can.
17:14You know? Wow, look at that. I mean, it's far down there. If this isn't surreal, I don't know what is. Yeah, totally. It's insane. I mean, the ship looks small from here. The ship looks tiny from here. Well, you can, people are like tiny. It's like, whoa. How tall is this again at this point?
18:01There are a hundred words we've metered the top. OK. What about it? What, 38, busy? Oh my god. And look at how hazy even the production site is right now. Yeah. Yeah. But this is not a good place to give a fair of heights, that's for sure. You better go get over them real quick.
18:35Yeah. We should get like a hang glatter and jump over something. That's weird. It's so rides as a zip line over to the high bay. You could probably zip line pretty far. Yeah. I can't believe how small the boosters look from here even. Yeah. It just looks like so fake right now. This is insane.
19:41Just we how does that feel whoa Where to go oh my god You see the ocean out there We really like out on the yeah on the night the Gulf I guess insane It is gorgeous I think this is the time to be Philosophical almost it's just so inspiring out here, you know, it's I mean, in your heart of hearts, like in the very depths of your soul, do you really believe this is like the start of making humans multi-planetary?
20:25I believe we have a... I think for the first time it is possible, that it's possible outcome to make life multi-planetary. The key to making life multi-planetary is a fully reusable rocket. That's the key. So, full and rapid reusability, like an aircraft. So it's just very hard to achieve full reusability given the strength of Earth's gravity field
20:57and the density of the atmosphere. Full reusability is like relatively easy on Mars, which has around 37-38% of Earth's gravity and about 1% atmospheric density, but it's just barely possible to achieve reusability on Earth. Like, it's not as though, you know, all the rocket engineers in the past, it's not as
21:25though the reusability never occurred to them. They're well aware of aircraft and other things. It's just that it's an incredibly difficult technical problem and they just thought it was impossible or the probability of success was so low that it was not worth doing. So I feel like, yeah, I feel like you almost had a bit of a Noah's arc esque, you know,
21:56if you're to get biblical aspect of the, at the last talk was saying how, you know, if you care about life, then, and the true continuation of life on earth and continuation of life is a consciousness, then you have to have a sustained planet, you know, another sustained playing it often. Exactly. I mean, I think, you know, if you think really long term, then
22:20you realize that eventually there will be some national disaster, even if it is not made by humans, that destroys all life on Earth. So eventually the Sun will expand and evaporate the oceans and and when we'll be like Venus you know just so hot that no life can really exist or maybe some chemotropic bacteria but eventually
22:45even they will they will die. So the only way to prolong life as we know it is for us to become multi-planetary and ultimately multi-stellar and if we do not do that, or life on Earth will die. So those who care about life on Earth should really care a lot about life becoming multi-planetary and ultimately multi-seller.
23:12When I think there's a lot of people get attached to this idea that for some reason, you know, SpaceX or other aerospace companies are trying to escape Earth and escape Earth's problems. And I think you put it into a really good perspective that, you know, currently specifically
23:27like NASA's budgets, you know, 0.3% of the federal budget. And then a let alone, you know, the entire cost of and how much we're investing so far in making, you know, getting humans off of Earth and protecting our planet even with asteroid defense and stuff is still relatively small.
23:46I think people don't understand that. Yes, Earth does not currently have any ability to stop asteroids. Now with Starship, that we then have some ability to stop an asteroid. Actually, technically, a comet would be the real danger because there are billions, if not more than billions, maybe trillions of objects that are in the outer solar system,
24:14some of them with their very long period comets. An example that most people are probably aware of is Haley's comet. So, I think it's the exact periodicity, but it's slightly under one's per century that Halley's Comet comes by. So there's, there are probably many objects, many comets that have very long periods that we are on, simply don't know exist.
24:42And for example, the comet Shumae Gilevi, when that hit Jupiter, it made a hole in Jupiter the size of Earth. So if that did hit us the game over everything's dead. So, anyways, there's always some risk of such a thing occurring and the probable lifespan of life is just much greater if we're a multi-planets and ultimately multi-cell
25:18or civilization. Well I think people also don't tend to realize that it's not a zero-sum game that if we're working on rockets and space flight and aerospace technology and all of these things, life support for these things, it's not just that you, you know, this company spent $100 million on a rocket and that $100 million went into space. It's that that $100 million went into the economy, you
25:41know, invested in our own technology, our terrestrial technology, you know, look at all the spin-offs of NASA and what you know what NASA had done in the 60s and 70s to create the society that we live in today, you know, I mean, I think people are shortsighted sometimes on the implications
25:58that you don't immediately see, those things that you don't immediately grasp because they're just kind of unknowns at this point. I mean, in general, the economy is very much a positive sum game, a kind of a growing-the-pie situation. When people examine their understanding beliefs of the economy, if they have an implicit assumption that the economy is zero sum, then
26:34the only way for one person to get ahead is by taking things from another. But obviously the economy today is much, much greater than it was in the past. And we have the economic output per person is massively greater than the past. And so obviously what has happened is that the pie has grown and has grown much faster
27:01than the population has grown. So essentially, if one creates wealth, or creates great products and services, that is something
27:19that should be applauded. That is effectively increased the standard of living of the country and perhaps of the world. And sometimes people will conflate or, you know, essentially think of consumption and wealth is the same thing, but they're obviously not the same thing. So, you know, this is a sort of long argument of
27:53sort of capital allocation is a job. Consumption is fun, but capital allocation job. So anyway, I don't think a ton of people want to say Warren Buffett's job, which is to read through very tedious annual reports of companies, including the minutia of the accounting and decide whether to invest in co-corpepsi. Like I
28:21don't want that job. So I think aerospace in general kind of still follows the same like you know back in the day at one point no one had electricity running water air conditioning all of moderns life conveniences but of course at first it started off as something that only a few people could get and now it's you know pretty common standard of living across the world and yeah you know you got to start somewhere same with air travel you know yeah exactly travel used to be accessible to almost know very few people was insanely expensive and dangerous and now it is commonplace to fly somewhere. And TV's used to be rare and expensive
29:03and then you know big glass screen plasma's used to be extremely expensive and now you can buy you know good Walmart and buy an amazing glass screen plasma for 500 bucks. It's amazing. Yeah. It really is. Yeah. I don't want to add the conversation on Walmart plasma at the same time.
29:26Yeah. So, hell of a lot of progress. I mean, again, not to bring up the past, but three years
29:38ago, I think the first time I ever came out here was March 2019. So, almost exactly three years ago. And all you had was a little hoppy. He had just made it out here. I was starting to do some of the initial static firing. That was three years ago. The hopper is sold. It's there. Looking over us all. The grandfather. We all need.
30:01Yeah. But even, I mean, even the tank farm was like three tanks of those smaller, you know, for the first tassel. It was so tiny and there was literally just a dirt mound and three tanks. And now, you know, it's, and there was a tent out there and that was about it. Yeah, the propellant storage for the whole vehicle was actually that was a really that was quite difficult
30:27put a lot of effort into that propellant storage. How? Okay, so if you have to scrub if you're trying to do like your the first static fires and stuff, how long does it take to recycle? Because you're probably how's it what's that look like? because you have to drain the propellants back into the tanks and say at the comm
31:08Yeah, but I mean obviously the first the first booster static fires will be probably Yeah, no, I mean it's gonna be very bumpy at first. I mean for Falcon 9 in the beginning We have we'd have like a dozen Recycles like we're scrub the launch like a dozen times. Yeah I mean as a while there for a while there I was living out at the Cape basically just
31:30working on getting the damn rocket to take to you know getting all nine engines to start and take off and and we just have one launch board after another. So, I brought the kids with me and I went to Disney with a lot in Harry Potter land. I think you can probably get out of here.
31:56Hopefully that will be as good. Thanks again to Elon for all of your generous time
32:13and thanks to Ryan Schielinski with Causic Perspective for helping to capture and share this conversation. And I have a huge thank you to my Patreon supporters for helping make this and everything we do at Everyday Astronaut possible. If you want to help support us, head on over to patreon.com slash Everyday Astronaut.
32:27And while you're online, be sure and check out our awesome merch store for shirts like this, the RD-171 shirt, and lots of other cool, nerdy, rocket stuff at everydayastronaut.com slash shop. Thanks everybody, that's gonna do it for me. I'm Tim Dodd, the Everyday Astronaut. Bringing space down to Earth for Everyday People.
我认为,你知道,在SpaceX,我们擅长把不可能变成“迟到”。
I think, you know, at SpaceX, we specialize in converting things from impossible to late.
是的,成功是可能的结果之一。概率不确定,但高于零。
Yes, success is one of the possible outcomes. The probability is uncertain, but it is above zero.
所以,对于卫星星座来说,真正重要的是你送往轨道的总质量通量,也就是有用的质量通量。
So, for satellite constellation, the thing that really matters is what is your total mass flux, useful mass flux to orbit.
就有效数据比特而言,Starlink 2 几乎比 Starlink 1 好一个数量级。
The Starlink 2 in terms of useful bits of data is almost in order of magnitude better than the Starlink 1.
我认为,这是第一次,让生命成为多行星物种是可能的,是一个可能的结果。
I think for the first time it is possible, that it's possible outcome to make life multi-planetary.
让生命成为多行星物种的关键,是完全可重复使用的火箭。这就是关键。所以,要像飞机一样实现完整且快速的重复使用。
The key to making life multi-planetary is a fully reusable rocket. That's the key. So, full and rapid reusability, like an aircraft.
所以,延长我们所知生命的唯一方式,就是让我们成为多行星物种,并最终成为多恒星物种;如果我们不这么做,地球上的生命就会消亡。
So the only way to prolong life as we know it is for us to become multi-planetary and ultimately multi-stellar and if we do not do that, or life on Earth will die.
所以本质上,如果一个人创造财富,或创造伟大的产品和服务,那是应该受到称赞的。那实际上提高了这个国家、也许还有全世界的生活水平。
So essentially, if one creates wealth, or creates great products and services, that is something that should be applauded. That is effectively increased the standard of living of the country and perhaps of the world.
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 视频原始视频文件
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版