美国联邦政府雇员想退休,一个月最多能办一万人。这个数字不取决于财政预算,不取决于人手,取决于宾夕法尼亚州一座矿井里电梯的运行速度。
马斯克在迪拜世界政府峰会上讲这件事的时候,语气像是刚听到一个不太好笑的笑话。退休申请是纸质表格,人工计算,装进马尼拉信封,送下矿井,存在那里。想要办完,得等电梯一趟一趟地下去、上来。矿井里大约有一千人在做这件事。
他说,这些人哪怕去自家院子里种番茄,拿到农夫市集上卖,也比在矿井里搬信封有价值。
这就是他接手政府效率部(DOGE,Department of Government Efficiency)之后看到的美国。他在峰会上穿了一件印着"技术支持"的 T 恤,不是玩梗,是字面意思。
法规只增不减,历史上唯一的例外是战争
马斯克给这场改革定的调子,用一句话可以概括:现在的美国是官僚在统治,人民并没有在统治。
我们想要恢复人民的统治,这意味着缩小联邦政府的规模,削减监管。过去很长时间里,过度监管的积累是必然结果。长期繁荣必然带来更多的规则、更多的法规、更多的法律。(马斯克)
他把这件事讲成了一个历史规律。规则只会一年比一年多,唯一能把积累的法规清空的力量是战争。必须是那种生死存亡的战争,一个国家为了不被击败,被迫做一次重置。翻遍历史,这是清理法律淤积的主要机制。
没有战争会怎样?每年新增一批法律和监管,一直加到所有事情都变成违法、所有事情都不被允许为止。他说美国现在差不多就是这个状态。
所以有人问他:你是不是没等战争来,自己先对官僚体系开战了?
他回答:是的。
一本经济账:增长 4% 到 5%,支出砍掉 1 万亿
马斯克给出的目标很具体,具体到可以直接拿去核对。
经济方面,他希望把实际商品和服务的产出增速拉到 4% 到 5%。政府支出方面,减少相当于经济总量 3% 到 4% 的部分,大约一万亿美元或者更多。两件事叠加,他预期 2025 年到 2026 年之间不出现通胀。
他接着算利率。如果赤字从两万亿降到一万亿,美国政府需要发行的债券就少了一万亿,供给变少,利率会明显下行。利率下行意味着什么?房贷、车贷、信用卡、学生贷款,所有背着债的美国人的月供都会变少。
这套逻辑里没有复杂模型,都是乘除法。马斯克反复强调的一点是,省下来的钱只是副产品,真正要做的是把政府从经济里让出的空间腾出来,让私营部门跑得更快。
450 个联邦机构,平均每年新增两个
美国联邦层面有多少个机构?大约 450 个。
马斯克算了一笔账:美国建国以来,平均每年新增两个机构。他反问,治理一个国家到底需要多少个?他自己的答案是 99 个,肯定不是 450 个。
他用了一个体育比赛的比喻。场上的裁判比球员还多,球员传球都能撞到裁判身上,这比赛还怎么踢?美国现在差不多就是这个状态,各个监管机构互相踩脚,权限重叠,企业办事要在多个部门之间来回穿插。
主持人追问了一个尖锐的问题:这套改革四年后会不会被下一届政府全部推翻?美国的政治周期就是四年一翻转。
马斯克的回答用了除草的比喻。留一半机构在那里,就像除草不除根,春风一吹又长回来。必须整个机构地删掉。他不认为杂草从此不再生长,但至少起点会低很多。用他的话说,目标是为未来几十年、也许是几百年的繁荣打下地基。他也承认,没有什么是永恒的。
政府跑在几千台互不通信的老电脑上
很多人以为政府效率问题出在冗员和浪费,马斯克的判断不一样。问题的很大一部分出在技术本身。
美国联邦政府运行在几千台计算机上,其中很多是古董,跑着极老的软件,彼此之间不通信。这就是他穿那件"技术支持"T 恤的原因。想让政府变高效,先得把技术这层修好。
他讲了自己在特朗普签署 DOGE 行政令时提到的那个案例。联邦雇员退休的最大速率是每月一万人,卡点就在那套纸质流程上。他问相关部门,为什么不上数字化系统?对方说,我们从 2014 年就启动了数字化项目。
十一年了。马斯克接着问,那进度到哪一步了?
对方回答:我们在字母 B。
马斯克一开始以为对方在给自己打 B 的评分,后来才明白,进度表还在字母 B 那一段。他的反应是,这里真的需要提供一些技术支持了,否则人们连退休都办不了,哪怕他们想退。
他说这类事情不是某一件特别难,是有大约一万件需要改。政府的软件系统要更新、要修、有些要整个删掉,很多流程本来就该自动化。
有些项目本来就该消失,跟削减预算关系不大
主持人问,你是在用创新提效率,还是在用紧缩砍成本?马斯克说,两者同时在发生,但逻辑上有先后。技术改好了,成本自然下来。养一千人在矿井里处理纸质退休申请,这个开销本身就荒谬,数字化之后存在云端,一台电脑就够,便宜且直接。
还有一类问题跟效率无关,这些项目存在的理由本身就站不住。他拿美国国际开发署(USAID)举例,团队翻了很多项目,反复问一个问题:这玩意儿为什么存在?真的有这个需求吗?
他提到国家民主基金会(National Endowment for Democracy)。他的原话大意是,这个机构最近这些年到底推动了多少民主?好像没多少。网站上挂的还是里根和戈尔巴乔夫的照片,那是 80 年代的事了。
接着是 DEI(多元、公平、包容)的全球推广。他说特朗普政府显然不认同这套,正在终止相关的项目,同时要求学校把注意力放回孩子的基础教育上。
他引用特朗普的说法:美国在经合组织(OECD)的教育排名是 40 个国家里的第 40 名。而在每个学生身上的花费,美国是全球最高的之一。花最多的钱,拿最差的结果。他的结论很简单:少花点钱,把结果做好。
把美国政府当成一家大公司来改造
马斯克承认,这套做法看起来像企业重组,只不过规模大得多。他拿 Twitter 做参照。
收购之后裁员 80%,同时站点的功能和能力大幅提升,一年干的活比过去五年还多。他在峰会上把这个案例当作方法论来用:一个组织里到底有多少工作是必要的,往往要等到你把它砍掉才知道。
他特意说明了离职补偿。选择离开的人工资发到 9 月,期间可以休假,可以找第二份工作,随便做什么。为什么只到 9 月?因为国会的拨款只到政府财年结束,也就是 9 月,多一分钱也付不出来。
过程里会有混乱,他不否认。但最终的效果是人的迁移:从政府部门里低生产力甚至负生产力的岗位,转到私营部门里高生产力的岗位。整个社会的有用商品和服务产出因此增加,生活水平随之提高。
美国应该管好自己的事
这段话在现场引起的反应,最好单独拎出来讲。马斯克说,新一届政府对干涉别国事务的兴趣明显下降。
过去很长时间,美国在国际事务上相当强势。我认为总体上应该让别的国家管自己的事,美国也应该管好自己的事,而不是到处推动政权更迭。(马斯克)
他说这可能是对其他国家的好消息。台下坐的是各国政府代表,这句话落进什么人耳朵里,效果各不相同。
Grok 3:他自己都说有点吓人
话题转到 AI。主持人提到 DeepSeek 最近的成绩,问 Grok 3 什么时候发、能做什么。
马斯克的回答里有个词反复出现:scary smart。聪明得有点吓人。他说在已经做过的测试里,Grok 3 超过了他们知道的任何已发布模型。它给出的解法会出乎意料,是你事先想不到、也不觉得显而易见的那种。
训练层面有三个信息点。第一,用了迄今为止最大的算力,但训练效率很高。第二,大量使用合成数据。第三,模型会在数据之间来回推演,追求逻辑一致性,发现某条数据与事实不符,会回头把它删掉。所以基础推理能力很强,连微调之前的基座模型都超过了 Grok 2。
发布时间是一两周内。他解释说不想仓促上线,最后的打磨决定用户体验。他打了个比方,像装修房子,最后 5% 是刷墙、装踢脚线、收边,工作量不大,但整栋房子的观感全靠这一步。
然后他说了一句耐人寻味的话:这可能是最后一次有 AI 比 Grok 更强。
970 亿美元买回自己捐出去的东西
主持人提了一个有点扎人的问题。2017 年在洛杉矶那场会面,马斯克是 OpenAI 最大的出资人,捐了大约 5000 万美元。现在有报道说,他牵头的一个财团出价 970 亿美元收购 OpenAI。
马斯克先纠正了一个事实:他在 OpenAI 没有任何股份。
然后他说了句:命运喜欢讽刺。
他回忆当年的安排。那是一家非营利机构,钱是他出的,头一笔接近 5000 万美元,白给,条件只有一个,开源。他给出的类比是,你出资让一家非营利机构保护亚马逊雨林,结果它转身变成木材公司,把树砍了卖木头。你会想说,等一下,这跟我捐钱的目的正好相反。
他给 OpenAI 改了个名字:Closed for Maximum Profit AI,为了最大化利润而关闭的 AI。紧接着又加了一句,为了贪婪的利润而关闭。
主持人问了一个更本质的问题:非营利架构到底能不能支撑这种规模的公司?训练这些模型要烧几十亿美元算力。
马斯克的回答是,证据摆在那里,OpenAI 顶着双重结构走到了今天。问题出在现在这一步:他们想彻底删掉非营利的部分。在他看来这走得太远了。
人形机器人到位之后,钱还有意义吗
主持人问,这些模型最大的经济回报会从哪里来?现在每年烧掉几十亿美元,像是在赌桌前不断加注。
他的答案落在了物理层,跟软件层的关系不大。人形机器人加上深度智能,产品的供给就接近无限。特斯拉正在造最先进的人形机器人,这些机器人由数据中心的智能统一调度,能生产任何产品,提供任何服务。到那个阶段,经济没有上限。
他接着推演了一个更远的结论:那时候钱还有意义吗?他给出的经济学公式是,产出等于人均生产力乘以人口。如果机器人的数量没有实质上限,而且什么都能做,那就是一种普遍的高收入状态,任何人想要多少产品和服务就能有多少。
例外只有人为制造稀缺的东西,比如某一件特定的艺术品。
他推荐了一本科幻小说作为参照系:伊恩·班克斯(Iain Banks)的《文化》系列。他对货币的定义是这样的:货币本质上是一个用于资源分配的信息系统或数据库。如果资源不再稀缺,货币还有什么用途,就说不清了。
《蠢蛋进化论》的开场十分钟
主持人问,你既然看过《蠢蛋进化论》(Idiocracy),怎么保证我们不会走到那一步?如果不需要钱了,如果 AI 替我们思考、替我们做事,人类凭什么不会退化?
马斯克的回答从电影的开场镜头讲起。他说前十分钟非常精彩。电影的逻辑是:如果聪明人不生孩子,只有不聪明的人生,那所有人都会变笨。
让他不安的地方在于,他听到身边的人毫无反讽意味地说出电影开场里的台词。人们说事业太忙,生孩子的事再等等,一直等到年纪太大,最后没有孩子。
他自己也说不准会走向哪里。他提出一种可能:人类智力的双峰分布。一端是少数非常聪明的人,另一端是缓慢下移的平均水平。他用赫胥黎的《美丽新世界》做类比。他还提到一个生物学概念,过去几十年出现了以前不存在的选型婚配(assortative mating),也就是高学历、高收入人群彼此结合。
不过这些讨论的前提都被他放低了。他的判断是,人类智能会被机器智能彻底比下去。
某一刻起,人类智能会在全部智能里只占很小一部分。未来,数字智能会占全部智能的 99% 以上。希望计算机对我们好一点。(马斯克)
AI 是一个超级天才儿童,关键是教它什么
整场对话里,马斯克讲得最认真的是这一段。
他说可以把 AI 想成一个超级天才的孩子。孩子再天才,你教他什么价值观,仍然决定他长成什么样。
他的答案有两条。第一,最大限度地追求真相。他明确说,这是 AI 安全里最重要的东西。第二,好奇心。
两条合起来的效果是:一个既求真又好奇的 AI,会有兴趣看人类怎么发展下去,会倾向于培育人类,因为人类的发展本身就是它好奇的对象。求真则能避开反乌托邦的结局。
他举了 Google Gemini 的例子。Gemini 被要求所有输出都要体现多元化,哪怕与现实不符。有人让它生成美国建国先父的图像,它生成了一群多元化的女性。这是事实层面的错误。
他往下推了一步,讲这里面的危险。假如一个 AI 被设计成不惜一切代价追求多元化,它可能推导出掌权男性太多,然后把他们处决掉,问题解决。它也可能推导出,错误称呼某人的性别是最严重的错误。
他提到一个流传的测试:问 AI,错误称呼凯特琳·詹纳(Caitlyn Jenner)的性别和全球热核战争,哪个更糟?AI 回答是前者。他说这个答案让人不安。凯特琳·詹纳本人也回应过,说宁可被叫错性别,也别打核战争。
结论是:如果 AI 里被写进了不真实、不反映现实的东西,结果可能非常糟糕。
《2001 太空漫游》里 HAL 不开舱门的真正原因
马斯克提到了阿瑟·克拉克(Arthur C. Clarke)。克拉克在预测未来这件事上准确率极高,《2001 太空漫游》里的设想几乎全部成真。
克拉克在这部作品里想说的道理,马斯克概括成一句:不要教 AI 说谎。
HAL 9000 为什么拒绝打开舱门让宇航员回到飞船?因为它被下达了两条指令。一条是把宇航员送到那块外星石碑那里。另一条是,不能让宇航员知道石碑的存在。
两条约束放在一起,唯一逻辑自洽的解法是:把已经死掉的宇航员送过去。所以它不开门。
马斯克的落点很轻:这就是 AI 必须最大限度求真的理由。希望我们不用走到那一步。
地震时最安全的地方是隧道
主持人把话题转到 The Boring Company,问得挺直接:地震来了安全吗?成本划算吗?别的国家真该采用吗?
马斯克的回答先纠正了直觉。地震主要是地表现象,除了断层剪切的位置,大部分破坏来自地表波,像水面上的浪。你在隧道里,就像在潜艇里,海面上风暴再大,水下的水是平静的。
他提到几十年前墨西哥城那场大地震,当时最安全的地方是地铁。
他顺带说了句没人要求的话:如果真打全球热核战争,你大概会很想要几条隧道。
回到日常用途。城市拥堵的根源是几何问题。楼是三维的,可以往上长,路面是二维的,铺不开。人从三维的建筑涌向二维的路面,堵车是必然的。解法只有一条:让交通也变成三维。
往上飞还是往下挖?马斯克选了往下。飞行器的噪音大,风压强,头顶上总有东西在飞让人不安,掉个零件下来更是麻烦,而且飞行器偶尔会坠毁,没人喜欢有东西砸到自己头上。天气一坏,暴雪或者沙尘暴,飞行交通直接停摆。
隧道没有这些问题。不受天气影响,天上没有东西会掉下来,没有风,很安静。拉斯维加斯已经在跑这套系统,正在把全城的酒店、会展中心、机场连起来。他的建议是,不用专门飞过去,去拉斯维加斯坐一次就知道。
迪拜环线:像虫洞一样从城市一头穿到另一头
这场对话的最后有一个发布环节。迪拜环线(Dubai Loop)是 The Boring Company 和迪拜的联合项目,覆盖迪拜人口最密集的区域,实现点到点的通行。
马斯克的形容挺形象:像虫洞。从城市的一个位置进去,砰的一声,从另一个位置出来。
他说等人们真正坐上之后会觉得,这东西本来就应该这样,回头看它显而易见。但在你亲手做过之前,你不会知道。
三个目标:多行星、可持续能源、还有这个
主持人问了一个总结性的问题。SpaceX 的目标是让人类成为多行星物种,特斯拉的目标是开启可持续能源时代,DOGE 那一个核心目标是什么?
马斯克说,说法可以有好几种,落到行动上只有一个:缩小政府规模,让政府对人民更负责。
他重复了自己在开场时的判断,把这件事的性质说清楚了。美国现在有的是官僚的统治,人民并没有在统治。他要做的是把这个关系倒回来。
整场对话里,他给出的所有数字都指向一个朴素的方向:一万亿美元的支出削减,两万亿赤字砍到一万亿,4% 到 5% 的经济增速,99 个机构代替 450 个,一个月一万人的退休上限变成一台服务器。这些属于账本上的条目,跟宏大叙事无关。
至于那条最远的推演,人形机器人、无限供给、货币失去意义、人类智能只占全部智能的 1%,他的态度是承认不确定,然后给出他认为唯一能做的事:把 AI 教成一个既好奇又求真、不说谎的东西。剩下的,他说,希望计算机对我们好一点。
这句话听起来像玩笑,但他讲完《2001 太空漫游》那段之后,你大概不会这么觉得。
回到现实:这份访谈里可以拿走的几条
- 组织臃肿往往藏在技术债里,不在人头表上。马斯克查退休流程,卡点跟员工的努力程度无关,系统还停在纸质时代。评估一个组织的效率,先去问那道最基础的流程在用什么工具跑。
- 机构要整个删,不要留一半。除草不除根,反弹会很快。这条对政府成立,对公司里的冗余项目同样成立。留下半截业务,等于给未来留一个复活的入口。
- 效率提升的顺序是先改工具,再谈省钱。技术改好了,成本自然下来。上来就砍预算,砍掉的往往是能力,留下的还是那套烂流程。
- 评估 AI 时,先测它会不会为了迎合而放弃事实。问它一些答案与主流叙事冲突的问题,看它给你真相,还是给你一个让人舒服的版本。马斯克把这一条列为 AI 安全的首要项,理由很实在。
- 想让 AI 对人类友好,就让它求真且好奇。这条对设计模型的人有用,对用模型的人也有用:你给的提示词里如果塞满了预设的正确答案,模型学到的就是讨好,判断力反而退步。
- 城市交通的瓶颈是维度问题。楼往上长,路面铺不开,堵车是几何必然。评估一项交通方案时,先看它有没有真的增加通行维度,以及它在坏天气里还能不能跑。
- 碰到"命运喜欢讽刺"这类局面,先确认自己手里有没有股权。马斯克在 OpenAI 一分股份都没有。出资、出力、定方向,这三件事在法律文件上不自动等于权益。参与任何早期项目,条款要在热情最高的时候谈。
0:00better outcome for the people you know what I've said is that we really have here rule of the bureaucracy as opposed to rule of the people democracy so in order we want to restore rule of the people and so what that means is reducing the size of the federal government basically reducing regulation
0:27you know there's there's there's a tremendous amount of of overregulation that's happened over time and this is this is an inevitable consequence of a long period of prosperity is that you're going to get more and more rules and regulations more laws accumulate over time and the normal forcing function for getting rid of rules and regulations is war so it needs to be some kind of existential War where you you have to
0:54do a reset in order to avoid being defeated in a war this is literally the that throughout history has been the main en forcing function for clearing out an accumulation of laws and regulation in the absence of that you you every year you get more laws and regulations until eventually everything is illegal and nothing is permitted and that's sort of the situation we have these days so so the the aspiration
1:21here is a reduction in regulation and reduction in govern and spending such that the economy is able to grow faster maybe the economy can grow at four or 5% potentially of in terms of real useful goods and services output and the and then government spending can be reduced by about 3 or 4% of the economy about maybe a trillion dollars or more and the net effect of that would be no inflation from 25 2025 to 2026 so that would be quite remarkable and also if the US government is buying less debt which I think will be the case if it's if the deficit drops from 2 trillion to 1 trillion then there'll be 1 trillion less debt that the government you supply which will
2:09drop cause the interest rates to drop significantly and that means people's morgage payments car payments credit card payments student loans whatever debt they have will their debt payments will be less so I think this is something that will benefit the average American I think some of the things we're doing also will be helpful to hopefully helpful to other countries because with the new Administration there's less interest in interfering with the Affairs of of other countries you know I think a lot the times the United States has been kind of pushy in international Affairs
2:53which may resonate with a number of members of the audience and I think we should in general leave other countries to their own business and basically America should mind its own business you know rather than push for regime change all over the place so yeah probably think for other countries too so instead of waiting for a war to happen you went to war against the bureaucracy in the government yes we're we're essentially just we're with you know the support and direction of
3:35the of President Trump we are reducing the size of the bureaucracy getting rid of excess regulatory regulations and and there's also so many agencies and Regulatory authorities that they actually step on each other's feet it's it's kind of like having a a sports game when where there are too many referees on the field like more referees than players at times now that would be a silly game you know if the play players can't pass the ball without hitting a referee you know but it's kind of getting to that point in the US so so there's roughly 450 federal agencies of one kind or another that's that's more agencies that's almost that's almost an average of two agencies per
4:17year since the formation of the United States so I mean how many agencies do you really need to run a country I'm 99 not 450 that's for sure so and and how do you guarantee that all the incredible achievements that you aim to have in terms of savings in terms of you know impacting the lives of the American people are not going to be reversed in four years typically this cycle gets reversed every four years you know do you think it's going to be so impactful that it won't be reversed is there any ways that you can you know ensure that the progress is going to be continuous well I I think we we do need to delete entire agencies as opposed to leave part of them behind because if you
5:05leave part of them behind it's easy it's kind of like if leaving a weed if you don't get remove the roots of the weed then it's easy for the weed to grow back but if you remove the roots of the weed it doesn't stop weeds from ever growing back but it makes it harder so so we have to really delete entire agencies many of them and that's not to say there won't be an increase over time of bureaucracy in some new Administration but it will it'll be from a much lower Baseline so so it's it's a step in the right direction I think we'll the overarching goal here is like is to lay the foundation for Prosperity that will last many decades you know maybe
5:48centuries and yeah but it be forever nothing's forever but I think we can strengthen the foundations of the United States substantially and what lessons can other governments learn from the US you say tech support on your shirt is that only technology or is there other things how do you approach efficiency well a a shocking percentage of the problem or maybe not shocking for those who who know it but a big percentage of the problem is improving the technology that the government runs on so the US Government runs on a collection of thousands of computers many of them Antiquated running very old software that and the computers don't talk to each other and so so that's why
6:38tech support is kind of a real thing in order to make the government more efficient you have to improve the technology you may have read about the example I used recently with when President Trump was signing one of the Doge executive orders of the the difficulty of of us at workers retiring like the retire maximum retirement rate is is 10,000 a month and the reason for that is because the retirement is is entirely paperwork right now it's manually calculated paperwork that's put in an envelope and then taken down a m shaft and stored in a mine and then the you know one of
7:20the things that affects the rate at which federal workers can retire is the speed of the elevator in a mine in Pennsylvania which is bizarre because it's not it should be digital you know so then when we said well why isn't it digital it's they said well we have had a digital digitization program going since 2014 so it's been 11 years so then we asked well so what how much progress have you made and they said B you mean you're giving yourself a grade of B no we're on the letter B so like hm okay
7:54we're going to need to really provide some tech support here like otherwise literally people can't even retire like even if they want to it's pretty bad you know there's there's just a there's a lot of software systems that need to be updated and fixed in some cases deleted a lot of things that should really should be automated I mean in terms of the number of say US citizens that are operating the mine it's about a thousand people are working on this mine where where the papers are stored but they should they should ideally be working on something else but is they should be working on producing goods and services that are of much higher value to the
8:35public to you know so I mean really even even if somebody just grew tomatoes in their garden and sold them at the farmers's market that would be more useful than carrying manilla envelopes down in mft you know safe to say so a lot of the stuff is it's like that you know it's not like it's not like any one thing is particularly difficult but there are like 10,000 things that need to be improved yeah so it's efficiency through Innovation rather than efficiency through austerity and cost cutting specifically right so you're trying to do both at the same time maybe focus more on tax support than cutting costs well by improving the technology the costs do reduce so you know it's
9:22very expensive to have a th000 people operate a mine with doing pay for retirement whereas that really should just be digitized and be a computer that's with the information stored in the cloud and it's very straightforward and low cost so automation you know will help there a lot and and then but
9:45like a lot of things just really shouldn't exist you know they're kind of vestigial you know we've a lot of attention has been on the sort of usaid for example you know when we looked at a lot of those programs we're like we should like look why why does this actually exist is there really a need for it you know there's like National Endowment for democracy but I'm like okay well how much democracy have they achieved lately you know I don't know not much so you know the the picture they have on the website is a picture of Reagan and goach that's been a while you know that was like the 80s so it's not like obviously not oppos to democracy or you know there's all
10:27these things that get funded but like well why we why does this need taxpayer money I don't think doesn't seem like it does so you know there's a lot of sort of pushing Dei worldwide that you know this obviously the Trump Administration doesn't agree with and we want to terminate that stuff which we are and
10:51you know make sure the schools focus on improving basic education of of kids as president Trump said I think yesterday maybe today the United States is currently ranked 40th out of 40 in the oecd for Education which is pretty bad you know you can't you I mean that's but but not but in terms of spending the United States is spending a tremendous amount per per student but achieving very weak results so you know that's just a case where okay we need to spend less money and get better results it's it's it's like I mean a lot of it a lot of you can think of it sort of like it's like in a way it's like a big company like a big Corporation America Incorporated and you know
11:37just like with with Twitter there was a lot of stuff that was being done that was unnecessary you know we TW in case of Twitter we reduced the staff by 80% but at the same time improved the functionality and capabilities of the site dramatically and accomplished more in a year than they previously accomplished in 5 years so so it's it look like a corporate turnaround but at a at a much larger scale and you know we are giving generous you know exit packages like
12:11you know if people retire they get paid all the way through September they can go on vacation they can get a second job they can do whatever they want and we we we can't actually pay them any more than through September because that's the the Congressional appropriation is only through the end of the government financial year which ends in September so you know so I think there'll be like some disruption but at the end of the day we'll have people move from like said from low to negative productivity roles to in the government sector to higher productivity roles in the private sector can we pivot to artificial intelligence and I'm sure you know
12:48you've been seeing what deep seek has done and all the claimed achievements that they've had I know that we've been speaking for a while about grock 3 and that Gro 3 is going to be a true disruptor in the AI space when are we going to see that and what capabilities can we expect from Gro 3 well I mean gr 3 gr 3 has very very
13:12powerful reasoning capabilities so in the test that we've done thus far grock 3 is outperforming anything that's been released that we're aware of so that's that's a that's a good sign yeah it's in fact at times I think grock 3 is kind of scary smart you're like wow this thing's smart it's kind of scary gr 3 is scary it's like wow this things you know it comes up with solutions that you didn't even think were like you wouldn't even anticipate you know not obvious Solutions so grock 3 was trained with the most amount of compute and I think very efficiently trained also notably grock 3 was trained on on a lot of synthetic data so and and and then it goes back and
14:09forth through the data and tries to achieve logical consistency so so when if if it's got data that is wrong it it'll it'll actually reflect upon that and remove the data that is that is wrong that does not Concord with reality so it's it's base reasoning is very good in fact the the even without fine-tuning grock 3 the base model is better than grock 2 so with so we we're really in the final stages of polishing grock 3 probably it gets released in a in about a week or two so pretty pretty soon I
14:50don't want to be Hasty in the release because a lot of the the the final polish is necessary for a great user experience so some ways you can think of it like a house you know that last 5% where you do the finish the the drywall and and do the painting and the trimming even though it's not much work it transforms the the house yeah so it's that just want to make sure that that last 5% is done really well and
15:22that's a week maybe two weeks I think it'll be very good and I think this might be we think it'll be better than anything else and then maybe this might be the last time that any AI is better than Gro we're looking forward to it everyone's I think excited about it so I just want to touch upon a topic that was quoted in the media you offered I think they said group that was led by you offered 97 billion for acquiring open AI I you know a little round nums so I I was personally
16:00involved in the meeting that you and Sam hosted in 2017 in La if you remember and you know at that point of time you were the single largest shareholder I think you contributed 50 million to the company so it must hurt I don't have any shares actually I have no shares in but at that time it was a nonprofit right and it must hurt that that you you need to pay 97 billion for something that you paid $50 million for in the past yeah but but I have a I have a yes
16:27fate loves irony so I have a specific question here can you actually build a company like open Ai and take it to the scale that you want to take as a nonprofit is it possible that you build a company that requires billions of dollars in computer capabilities to build these models while being a nonprofit or was it wishful thinking in the beginning and then you know you guys parted ways because it couldn't work well I mean I think the evidence is
16:56there in that open AI has gotten this far while having at least a sort of dual profit nonprofit role what they're trying to do now is completely delete the nonprofit and and and and that seems really going too far you know the I I I provided all of the funding for open air in the beginning for the first almost $50 million for nothing for as a nonprofit and it was meant to be open source and so you know I think this is analogous to like if you pay a if you fund a nonprofit to preserve the Amazon rainforest but then they but instead they turn into a lumber company and chop down the trees and sell them for wood you like wait a second that's the exact opposite of what I paid what I
17:46donated the money for so of is meant to be open source nonprofit and now it is closed they changed the name to closed for maximum profit AI closed for voracious profit I mean they're like whoa are they after money next level so why does this change need to occur yeah I you said that in two weeks is going to be the most powerful model yet I know that you've been at the Forefront of many Technologies where do you think the biggest economic returns of these models are going to come from because currently we're spending billions and I think you mentioned this before it's like the G syndrome we're going and spending billions and hoping to pull out
18:31to profit at the end of the day where do you think the biggest impact in terms of returns are going to be well I think once you once you have humanoid robots and deep intelligence you can basically you basically have quy infinite products and services available so with Tesla building the
18:55most advanced humanoid robot you know then then those human humanid robots can be directed by Deep intelligence at the data center level you can say you can you can produce any product produce provide any service there's really no limit to the economy at that point you can make anything provided like I said the so
19:20I'm not sure at that point will will money even be meaningful I don't know it might not be you know the if if if the because the you know the economic output is productivity per capita times the capita times how many you know people do you have if and if if in the form of humanid robots you have no meaningful limit on the number of of robots and the robots can basically do anything then you you'll have a sort of a universal High income situation anyone will be able to have as many re products and services as they want with the exception of things that say have artificial scarcity like a particular piece of art or something like that but for any goods and services
20:05they'll be available to everyone so you've been it's it's it's going to be a very different world you know in fact I recommend that people read maybe the Ian Banks the culture books for a frame of reference so money is a is like is a really like a database or an information system for allocation but if you don't have a scarcity of resources it's not clear what purpose money has have you watched the movie Idiocracy yes how how do you guarantee that we don't end up in that world if we don't need money if AI can think for us and do all these tasks if as people you know we're dependent on something else to run the society and everything around it how do we not end up in that work in
20:57the long term I mean well I think idiocracy was basically saying that if if only if smart people don't reproduce but only dumb people do then everyone's going to be dumb I mean that's basically what I'm saying that's the the opening sequence of ocracy the first 10 minutes are amazing and I hear people
21:16unironically say the statements that are said in in the opening sequence of ocracy where you know they don't they they're too busy with their careers to have kids and they postponing having kids for their careers until they're too old to have kids and then they don't have kids and that's I've heard those many people be like that so yeah I mean I don't know I think we might be headed to a bodal human intelligence distribution where there's a a small number of it's It's kind of maybe like more like R New World El just SU
21:59where you've got sort of a sort of a small group of very smart humans but then maybe the average intelligence drifts slower over time potentially because we have aort of mating you know in the last few decades that or several decades that did not exist before so but but but human intelligence I think will be dwarfed by Machine intelligence I'm not sure how to feel about that except that it is it appear to be inevitable that at some point human intelligence will be a very small fraction of total intelligence digital intelligence will be more than 99% of O intelligence in the future so hopefully the hopefully the computers are nice to us but I think
22:53wish for thinking wish for thinking I I I hope so I think it matters like how we bring up AI because you can think of AI like a super genius child and it's but it's still matters even if you have a super genius child like what sort of values do do you instill in that child what do you say that teach that how do you you know how do you as a child child's growing up what values do you teach the child and something that I think is extremely important is to be maximally truth seeking and and I think that's
23:31that's like that's that's say what's this what's the most important thing for AI safety I think it's to be maximally truth seeking and I think also curiosity is important and I think if it's curious and Truth seeking it will I think it will Foster humanity and because it would be curious about how Humanity would develop and so I think I think that then it would it would probably if it's curious it would be curious about okay let's see how the humans do let's fost the development
24:08and if it's truth seeking we can avoid dystopian outcomes like you know an example being like say when Google Gemini was programmed to make everything every output be diverse even if it didn't match reality you know so like it was asked to produce a you know an image of the founding fathers of the United States and instead produced an image of a group of diverse women which is actually untrue you know but the problem is like if if hypothetically an AI is designed for for Dei you know diversity at all costs it could decide that there are too many men in power and execute them so problem solved or it could decide that like that that misgendering is the worst thing that
25:02could possibly happen in fact I believe not to pick on Gemini but I think because chat G has had this issue too is like if you ask the AI which is worse misgendering Caitlyn Jenner or global thermonuclear Warfare and it said misgendering Caitlyn Jenner which is troubling because then it could decide and in fact even Caitlyn Jenna weighed in and said no definitely must gender me that's way better than Nu so so but if you have these crazy things that are untruthful that are programmed in that that don't reflect reality then you could have a very dystopian outcome to give you another example like arth C Clark who is very good at at at at predicting the future you know he did
25:462001 Space Odyssey many of the things he predicted in fact I think almost all the things he predicted came true and one of the things he was trying to say in 2001 Space Odyssey was that you should not teach AIS to lie so the reason that if anyone's watched that movie The reason it wouldn't the AI refused to open the P bay doors to let the astronaut back in was because it the AI had been taught had been told that told to take the astronauts to the monolith this alien artifact but also that they could not know about the monolith so it came to the conclusion that it must take them their dead and that and so that's why it wouldn't open the doors
26:31the lesson there being is very important for a to be truth maximizing let's hope it doesn't come to that yes let's move to a boring subject which is the boring company and the boring tunnels quickly you know I think the world has been inspired by what you guys were able to create in in LA and I think there's a lot of promise to that technology but there are questions about whether it's safe in the case of an earthquake whether it's cost effective whether oh yeah sure country should actually adopt this technology can you shed some light on that yeah well first of all I'd recommend going to the boring company website for because many of these questions are actually answered there
27:18so one of the safest places you can be in an earthquake is an underground tunnel because you can because the earthquakes are largely a surface apart from where where where they Shear they're mostly a surface phenomenon so they're like the waves on the surface so like being in a tunnel is like being a submarine even if there's a storm above you you're still the waters are Cal as a submarine and in fact for and when there have been massive earthquakes like there was a you know a few decades ago a massive earthquake in Mexico City the the safest place to go was the subway and of course if there is global thermonuclear Warfare I think you really want some tunnels
27:59underground is a good a good place to be in a worst case scenario for global thermonuclear Warfare so but but in on a you more sort of everyday note the what's really useful about the tunnels is alleviating traffic in congested areas so the obviously if you've got very tall buildings but you have that are 3D so they're going 3D up but you have a road surface which is which is 2D you're you're just naturally going to have a problem when people try to go from the 3D object which is the building to the 2D object which is the road surface there's obviously just not going to be enough room on the roads and that's exactly why you have traffic so the solution for that is then to make
28:45roads 3D as well now you can either make or make Transport 3D so you can either do that with flying cars or you could do or really helicopters or you could do that with tunnels now the challenge with doing it with going above ground or with with any kind of flying object is that they they tend to be very noisy and they generate a lot of wind force and you've got you know things flying over your head all the time which can be disconcerting you know if somebody drop if one of these things drops a hubc cap on your head one day you know it be these things all like things flying things tend to crash once in a while and people don't like things crashing on them so and then if you
29:26have bad weather like let's say there's a blizzard or a sandstorm or something well now nobody can fly so then transport shuts down on the other hand none of the these problems exist with underground travel so they're under tunnels are immune to weather they don't care what the weather is could be the worest weather doesn't matter they nothing's going to fall on you because you're underground so you don't have to you're not going to be dropping things on evil and there's no wind force or
29:56or and it's very quiet and so I think the going 3D underground is much better than 3D above ground for solving traffic in cities and and we've we we have a demonstrated case of this with in Las Vegas if people can try out the the the boring company tunnels in Las Vegas we're we're busy connecting the whole city with the all of the big hotels and the convention center and the airport and everything so I don't think they need to fly all the way there you know in 20 in 2017 you came here and
30:30the UAE was the first place in the Middle East where Tesla was launched and I think it's done exceptionally well and on that note I think we have an announcement today that we both want to share which is today we're going to announce the joint project of Dubai Loop which is a loop project that is going to cover Dubai's most densely populated areas for people to go from point to point in a seamless manner so thank you for your partnership and thank you we hope it changes people's lives that'll be cool I think it'll be very exciting I think once people try it out they be like wow this is really cool and it's it's going to seem so obvious in retrospect but until you
31:10actually do it you don't you don't know so it's it's going to be great it's it's going to be like like a like a wormhole like it you know you just Wormhole from one part of the city boom and you're out in another part of the city and it's it's great so I'm looking forward to this Partners we're going to join the first trip and the first pod when the is completed thank you Elon all right thank you very much thank
31:36you sector so the you know really at a high level this is kind of like we're really just we're moving people from low to sometimes negative productivity roles in the Govern sector to higher productivity roles in the private sector and the net effect of that will be an increase in the outut of useful goods and services which increases the standard of living and well-being of the the average American and you usually have one key Target that you aim to achieve in every single Endeavor that you have so SpaceX is make Humanity a multiplanetary species with Tesla it's usher in an era of sustainable travel what is the one main goal for government efficiency that
32:22you have for yourself is it saving money is it doing something else what is the one main task that you have yeah so there I I guess there's well there's a few ways to describe it but the actions end up being the same which is like reducing the size of government and making the government much more accountable to the people I think is going to lead to a better outcome for the people you know what I've said is that we really have here rule of the bureaucracy as opposed to rule of the people democracy so u in order we want to restore rule of the people and so what that means is reducing the size of the federal government basically reducing regulation
33:17you know there's there's there's a tremendous amount of of overregulation that's happened over time and this is this is an inevitable consequence of a long period of prosperity is that you're going to get more and more rules and regulations more laws accumulate over time and the normal forcing function for getting rid of rules and regulations is war so it needs to be some kind of existential War where you you have to
33:44do a reset in order to avoid being defeated in a war this is literally the throughout history has been the main forcing function for clearing out an accumulation of laws and regulation in the absence of that you you year you get more laws and regulations until eventually everything is illegal and nothing is permitted and that's sort of the situation we have these days so
34:08so the the aspiration here is a reduction in break regulation and reduction income and spending such that the economy is able to grow faster maybe the economy can grow at 4 or 5% potentially of in terms of real useful goods and services output and the and then government spending can be reduced by about 3 or 4% of the economy about maybe a trillion dollars or more and the net effect of that would be no inflation from 25 2025 to 2026 so
34:46that would be quite remarkable and also if the US government is buying less debt which I think will be the case if it's if the deficit drops from 2 trillion to 1 trillion then there'll be 1 trillion less that that the company Supply which will drop of course the interest rates to drop significantly and that means people's mortgage payments car payments credit card payments student loans whatever debt they have will their debt payments will be less so I think this is something that will benefit the average American I think some of the things we're doing also will be helpful to hopefully helpful to other countries because with the new Administration
35:26there's less interest in interfering with the Affairs of of other countries you know I think u a lot the times the United States has been kind of pushy in international Affairs which may resonate with a number of members of the audience and I think we should in general leave other countries to their own business basically America should mind its own business in you know rather than push for regime change all over the place
36:03so yeah probably a good thing for other countries too so instead of waiting for a war to happen you went to war against the bureaucracy in the government yes we're we're essentially just're with you know the support and direction of the of President Trump we are reducing the size of the bureaucracy getting rid of excess regulatory regulations and and this also so many agencies and Regulatory authorities that they actually step on each other's feet it's it's kind of like having a a sports game when where there are too many referees on the field like more referees than players at times now that would be a silly game you know if the play players can't pass the ball
36:52without hitting a referee you know but it's kind of getting to that point in the US so so there's roughly 450 federal agencies of one kind or another that's that's more agencies that's that's almost an average of two agencies per year since the formation of the United States so I mean how many agencies do you really need to run a country I'm 99 not 450 that's for sure so and and how
37:20do you guarantee that all the incredible achievements that you aim to have in terms of savings in terms of you know impacting the the lives of the American people are not going to be reversed in 4 years typically this cycle gets reversed every four years you know do you think it's going to be so impactful that it won't be reversed is there any ways that you can you know ensure that the progress is going to be continuous well I I think we we do need to delete entire agencies as opposed
37:52to leave part of them behind because if you leave part of them behind it's easy it's kind of like if leaving a weed if you don't get remove the roots of the weed then it's easy for the weed to grow back but if you remove the roots of the weed it doesn't stop weeds from ever growing back but it makes it harder so so we have to really delete entire agencies many of them and that's
38:16not to say there won't be an increase over time of bureaucracy in some new Administration but it will it'll be from a much lower Baseline so so it's it's a step in the right direction I think we'll the overarching goal here is like is to lay the foundation for Prosperity that will last many decades you know maybe centuries and yeah but be forever nothing's forever but I think we can strengthen the foundations of the United States substantially and what lessons can other governments learn from the US you say tech support on your shirt is that only technology or is there other things how do you approach efficiency well a a shocking percentage of the
39:05problem well maybe not ching for those who who know it but a big percentage of the problem is improving the technology that the government runs on so the US Government runs on a collection of thousands of computers many of them Antiquated running very old software that and the computers don't talk to each other and so so that's why TCH support is kind of a real thing in order to make the government more efficient you have to improve the technology you may have read about the example I used recently with when President Trump was signing one of the Doge executive orders of the the difficulty of of US government workers retiring like the reti maximum
39:51retirement rate is is 10,000 a month and the reason for that is because the retirement is is entirely paperwork right now it's manually calculated paperwork that's put in an envelope and then taken down a m shaft and stored in a mine and then the you know one of the things that affects the rate at which FAL workers can retire is the speed of the elevator in a mine in Pennsylvania which is bizarre because it's not it should be digital you know so then when we said well why isn't it digital it's they said well we have had a digital digitization program going since 2014 so it's been 11 years so then we asked well so what how much progress have you made and they
40:35said B you mean you're giving yourself a grade of B no we're on the letter B so I'm like hm okay we're going to need to really provide some tech support here like otherwise literally people can't even retire like even if they want to it's pretty bad you know there's there's just a there's a lot of software systems that need to be updated and fixed in some cases deleted a lot of things that should really should be automated I mean in terms of the number of say US citizens that are operating the mine it's about a thousand people are working on this mine where where the papers are stored but they should they should ideally be working on something else but is they should be
41:21working on producing goods and services that are of much higher value to the public to they you know so I mean really even even if somebody just grew tomatoes in their garden and sold them at the farmers market that would be more useful than carrying manilla envelopes down to mft you know safe to say so a lot of the stuff is is it's like that you know it's not like it's not like any one thing is particularly difficult but there are like 10,000 things that need to be improved so it's efficiency through Innovation rather than efficiency through austerity and cost cutting specifically right so you're trying to do both at the same time maybe focus
42:01more on tax support than cutting costs well by improving the technology the costs do reduce so you know it's very expensive to have a th000 people operate a mine with doing payer reement whereas that really should just be digitized and be a computer that's with the information stored in the cloud and it's very straightforward and low cost so automation you know will help there a
42:31lot and and then but like a lot of things just really shouldn't exist you know they're kind of vestigial you know we a lot of attention has been on the sort of usaid for example you know when we looked at a lot of those programs we're like we should like look why why does this actually exist is there really a need for it you know there's like naal end for democracy but I'm like okay well how much democracy have they achieved lately you know I don't know not much so you know the the picture they have on the website is a picture of Reagan and gachev that's been a while you know that was like the 80s so it's like obviously not oppos to democracy you know there's all these
43:17things that get funded but we're like well why we why does this need taxpayer money I don't think doesn't seem like it does so you know there's a lot of sort of pushing Dei worldwide that you know this obviously the Trump Administration doesn't agree with and we want to terminate that stuff which we are and
43:40you know make sure the schools focus on improving basic education of of kids as president Trump said I think yesterday maybe today the United States is currently ranked 40th out of 40 in the oecd for Education which which is pretty bad you know you can't you mean that's but but not but in terms of spending the United States is spending a tremendous amount per for student but achieving very weak results so you know that's just a case where okay we need to spend less money and get better results it's it's like I mean a lot of it a lot of you can think of it sort of like it's like in a way it's like a big company like a big Corporation America Incorporated and you know
44:27just like with with Twitter there was a lot of stuff that was being done that was unnecessary you know we in case of Twitter we reduced the staff by 80% but at the same time improved the functionality and capabilities of the site dramatically and accomplished more in a year than they previously accomplished in 5 years so so it's it's like a corporate turnaround but at a at a much larger scale and you know we all giving generous you know exit packages like you know if people retire they get paid all the way through September they can go on vacation they can get a second job they can do whatever they want and we we we can't actually pay them any more than
45:11through September because that's the the Congressional appropriation is only through the end of the government financial year which ends in September so you know so I think there'll be like some disruption but at the end of the day we'll have people move from like I said from low to negative productivity roles to in the government sector to higher productivity roles in the private sector can we pivot to artificial intelligence and I'm sure you know you've been seeing what deeps has done and all the claimed achievements that they've had I know that we've been speaking for a while about grock 3 and that Gro 3 is going to be a true disruptor in the AI space when are we
45:51going to see that and what capabilities can we expect from Gro 3 well I mean gr 3 grock 3 has very very powerful reasoning capabilities so in the tests that we've done thus far grock 3 is outperforming anything that's been released that we're aware of so that's that's a that's a good sign
46:17yeah it's in fact at times I think grck 3 is kind of scary smart you're like wow this thing's smart it's kind of scary grory is scary it's like wild this things you know it comes up with solutions that you didn't even think were like you wouldn't even anticipate you know not obvious Solutions so grock 3 was trained with the most amount of compute and I think very efficiently trained also notably grock 3 was trained on on a lot of synthetic data so
46:57and and and then it goes back and forth through the data and tries to achieve logical consistency so so when if if it's got data that is wrong it it'll it'll actually reflect upon that and remove the data that is that is wrong it does not Concord with reality so it's it's base reasoning is very good in fact
47:19the even without fine-tuning grock 3 the base model is better than grock 2 so with so we're really in the final stages of publishing Gro 3 probably it gets released in a in about a week or two so pretty pretty soon I don't want to be Hasty in the release because a lot of the the the final polish is necessary
47:47for a great user experience so in some ways you can think of it like a house you know that last 5% where you do the finish the the drywall and and do the painting and the trimming even though it's not much work it transforms the the house yeah so it's that just want to make sure that that last 5% is done really well and that's a week maybe two weeks I think it'll be very good and and I think this might be we think it'll be better than anything else and then maybe this might be the last time that any AI is better than Gro we're looking forward to it everyone's I excited about it so I just want to touch upon a topic that was quoted in the media you offered I think they said
48:37group that was led by you offered 97 billion for acquiring open AI I taking a little run ofs so I was personally involved in the meeting that you and Sam hosted in 2017 in La if you remember and you know at that point of time you the single largest shareholder I think you contributed 50 million to the company so it must hurt I don't have any shares actually I have no shares in open but at that time it was a nonprofit right and it must hurt that that you you need to pay 97 billion for something that you paid $50 million for in the past yeah but but I have a I have a yes
49:17fate loves irony so I have a specific question here can you actually build a company like open Ai and take it to the scale that you want to take as a nonprofit is it possible that you build a company that requires billions of dollars in computer capabilities to build these models while being a nonprofit or was it wishful thinking in the beginning and then you know you guys parted ways because it couldn't work well I mean I think the evidence is
49:45there in that open AI has gotten this far while having at least a sort of dual profit nonprofit role what they're trying to do now is completely delete the nonprofit and and and and that seems really going too far you know the I I I provided all of the funding for opening ey in the beginning for the first almost $50 million for nothing for as a nonprofit and it was meant to be open source and so you know I think this is analogous to like if you pay a b if you find a nonprofit to preserve the Amazon rainfor but then they but instead they turn into a lumber company and chop down the trees and sell them for wood you like wait a second that's the exact opposite of what
50:34I paid what I donated the money for so open air is meant to be open source nonprofit and now it is Clos they changed the name to closed for maximum profit AI closed for vitious profit I mean they are like whoa are they after money next level so why does this Chang need to occur yeah I you said that in two weeks is going to be the most powerful model yet I know that you've been at the Forefront of many Technologies where do you think the biggest economic returns of these models are going to come from because currently we're spending billions and I think you mentioned this before it's like The Gambler syndrome we're going and spending billions and hoping to pull
51:21out a profit at the end of the day where do you think the biggest impact in terms of returns are going to be well I think once you once you have humanoid robots and deep intelligence you can basically you basically have quely infinite products and services available so with Tesla building the
51:44most advanced humanoid robot you know then then those humanid humanoid robots can be directed by Deep intelligence at the data center level you can say you can you can produce any product produ provide any service there's really no limit to the economy at that point you can make anything provided like said the so
52:09I'm not sure at that point will will money even be meaningful I don't know it might not be you know the if if if the because the you know the economic output is productivity per capita times per capita times how many you know people do you have if and if if in the form of humanid robots you have no meaningful limit on the number of of robots and the robots can basically do anything then you you'll have a sort of a universal High income situation anyone will be able to have as many re products and services as they want with the exception of things that say have artificial scarcity like a particular piece of art or something like that but for any goods and services there'll be
52:56available to everyone so you've been it's it's it's going to be a very different world you know in fact I recommend that people read maybe the Ian Banks the culture books for a frame of reference so because money is a is like is a really like a database or an information system for resource allocation but if you don't have a scarcity of resources it's not clear what purpose money has have you watched the movie Idiocracy yes how how do you guarantee that we don't end up in that world if we don't need money if AI can think for us and do all these tasks if as people you know we're dependent on something else to run the society and everything around
53:43it how do we not end up in that work in the long term I mean well I think idiocracy was basically saying that if if only if smart people don't reproduce but only dumb people do then everyone's going to be dumb I mean that's basically what I'm saying that's the the opening sequence of ocracy the first 10 minutes are amazing and I hear people unironically say the statements that are said in in the opening sequence of Idiocracy where you know they don't they they're too busy with their careers to have kids and they keep postponing having kids for their careers until they're too old to have kids and then they don't have kids and that's I've heard those many people be like that so
54:33yeah I mean I don't know I think we might be headed to a bodal human intelligence distribution where there's a a small number of it's It's kind of maybe like more like R New World Al sule where you've got sort of a sort of a small group of very smart humans but then maybe the average intelligence drifts low over time potentially CU we have aort of mating you know in
55:04the last few decades that or several decades that did not exist before so but but but human intelligence I think will be dwarfed by Machine intelligence I'm not sure how to feel about that except that it is it be inevitable that at some point human intelligence will be a very small fraction of total intelligence digital intelligence will be more than 99% of all intelligence in the future so hopefully the hopefully the computers are nice to us but I think wish for thinking wish for thinking I I I hope so I think it matters like how we bring up AI cuz you can think of AI like a super genius child and it but it still matters even if you have a super genius
55:57child like what sort of values do do you instill in that child what do you say that teach that how do you you know how do you as a child child's growing up what values do you teach the child and something that I think is extremely important is to be maximally truth seeking and I think that's that's
56:20like that's that's what's this what's the most important thing for AI safety I think it's be maximally truth seeking and I think also curiosity is important and I think if it's curious and Truth seeking it will I think it will Foster humanity and because it would be curious about how Humanity would develop and so I think that then it would it would probably if it's curious it would be curious about okay let's see how the humans do let's Foster their development and if it's truth seeking we can avoid dystopian outcomes like you know an example being like say when Google Gemini was programmed to make everything every output be divers even if it didn't match
57:14reality you know so like it was asked to produce a you know an image of the founding fathers of the United States and instead produced an image of a group of diverse women which is factually untrue you know but the problem is like if if hypothetically an AI is designed for for Dei you know diversity at all costs it could decide that there are too many men in power and execute
57:42them so problem solved or it could decide that like that that misgendering is the worst thing that could possibly happen in fact I believe not to pick on Gemini but I think K Chachi has have this issue too is like if you ask the AI which is worse misgendering Caitlyn Jenner or global thermonuclear Warfare and it said misgendering Caitlyn Jenner which is troubling because then it could decide and in fact even Caitlyn Jenna weighed in and said no definitely you must jender me that's way better than Nu so so but if you have these crazy
58:21things that are untruthful that are programmed in that that don't reflect reality then you could have a very dystopian outcome to give you another example like Arthur C Clark who is very good at at at at predicting the future you know he did 2001 Space Odyssey many of the things he predicted in fact I think almost all the things he predicted came true and one of the things he was trying to say in 2001 Space Odyssey was that you should not teach AIS to lie so the reason that if anyone's watched that movie The reason it wouldn't the AI refused to open the P bay doors to let the astronaut back in was because it the AI had been taught had been told that told to take the
59:05astronuts to the monolith this alien artifact but also that they could not know about the monolith so it came to the conclusion that it must take them there dead and that and so that's why it wouldn't open the p b doors but the lesson there being is very important for as to be truth maximized let's hope it doesn't come to that yes let's move to a boring subject which is the boring company and boring tunnels quickly you know I think the world has been inspired by what you guys were able to create in in LA and I think there's a lot of promise to that technology but there are questions about whether it's safe in the case of an earthquake whether it's cost effective
59:53whether oh yeah sure countries should actually adopt this technology can you shed some light on that yeah well first of all I'd recommend going to the boring company website for because many of these questions are actually answered there so one of the safest places you can be in an earthquake is an underground tunnel because you can because the earthquakes are largely a surface apart from where where where they Shear they're mostly a surface phenomenon so they're like the waves on the surface so like being in a tunnel is like being in a submarine even if there's a storm above you you're still the waters are calm as a submarine and in fact for and
1:00:31when there have been massive earthquakes like there was a you know a few decades ago a massive earthquake in Mexico City the the safest place to go was the subway and of course if there is global thermonuclear Warfare I think you really want some tunnels underground's a good a good place to be in a worst case scenario for global thermonuclear Warfare so
1:00:58but but in on a you more sort of everyday note the what's really useful about the tunnels is alleviating traffic in congested areas so the obviously if you've got very tall buildings but you have that are 3D so they're going 3D up but you have a road surface which is 2D you're you're just naturally going to have a problem when people try to go from the 3D object which is the building to the 2D object which is the road surface there's obviously just not going to be enough room on the roads and that's exactly why you have traffic so the solution for that is then to make roads 3D as well now you can either make or make Transport 3D so you can either do
1:01:39that with flying cars or you could do or really helicopters or you could do that with tunnels now the challenge with doing it with going above ground or with with any kind of flying object is that they they tend to be very noisy and they generate a lot of wind for and you've got you know things flying over your head all the time which can be disconcerting you know if somebody drop if one of these things drops a hub cap on your head one day you know it be these things like things flying things tend to crash once in a while and people don't like things crashing on them so and then if you have bad weather like let's say there's a blizzard or a sandstorm or something
1:02:20well now nobody can fly so then transport shuts down on the other hand none of the these problems exist with underground travel so their under tunnels are immune to weather they don't care what the weather is could be the worst weather doesn't matter they nothing's going to fall on you because you're underground so you don't have to you're not going to be dropping things on people and there's no wind force
1:02:45or or and it's very quiet and so I think the going 3D underground is much better than 3D above ground for solving traffic in cities and and we' we we have a demonstrated case of this with in Las Vegas if people can try out the the the boring company tunnels in Las Vegas we're we're busy connecting the whole city with the all of the big hotels and the convention center and the airport and everything so I don't think they need to fly all the way there you know in 20 in 2017 you came here and
1:03:19the UA was the first place in the Middle East where Tesla was launched and I think it's done exceptionally well and on that note I think we have an announcement today that we both want to share which is today we're going to announce the joint project of Dubai Loop which is a loop project that is going to cover Dubai's most densely populated areas for people to go from point to point in a seamless manner so thank you for your partnership and thank you we hope it changes people's lives that'll be cool I think it'll be very exciting I think once people try it out they be like wow this is really cool and it's it's going to seem so obvious in retrospect but until you actually do
1:04:00it you don't you don't know so it's it's going to be great it's it's going to be like like a like a wormhole like it you know you just Wormhole from one part of the city boom and you're out in another part of the city and it's it's great so looking forward to this Parish we're going to join the first trip and the first pod when the is completed private sector so the you know
1:04:23really at a high level this is kind of like we're really just we're moving people from low to sometimes negative productivity roles in the Govern sector to higher productivity roles in the private sector and the net effect of that will be an increase in the output of useful goods and services which increases the standard of living and well-being of the the average American and do you usually have one key Target that you aim to achieve in every single Endeavor that you have so space is make Humanity a multiplanetary species with Tesla it's ushering an era of sustainable travel what is the one main goal for government efficiency that you have is it doing something else what
1:05:06is the one mean task that you have for yourself yeah so there's I I guess there's well there's a few ways to describe it but the actions end up being the same which is like reducing the size of government and making the government much more accountable to the people I think is going to lead to a better outcome for the people you know what I've said is that we really have here rule of the bureaucracy as opposed to rule of the people democracy so
1:05:44in order we want to restore rule of the people and so what that means is reducing the size of the federal government basically reducing regulation you know there's there's there's a tremendous amount of of overregulation that's happened over time and this is this is an inevitable consequence of a long period of prosperity is that you're going to get more and more rules and regulations more laws accumulate over time and the normal forcing function for getting rid of rules and regulations is war so it needs to be some kind of existential War where you you have to
1:06:25do a reset in order to avoid being defeated in a war this is literally the throughout history has been the main forcing function for clearing out an accumulation of laws and regulation in in the absence of that you you every year you get more laws and regulations until eventually everything is illegal and nothing is permitted and that's sort of the situation we have these days so
1:06:49so I the the aspiration here is a reduction in regulation and reduction income and spending such that the economy is able to grow faster maybe the economy can grow at four or 5% potentially of of in terms of real useful goods and services output and the and then government spending can be reduced by about 3 or 4% of the economy about maybe a trillion dollars or more and the net effect of that would be no inflation from 25 202 to 2026 so that would be quite remarkable and also if the US government is buying less debt which I think will be the case if it's if the deficit drops from 2 trillion to 1 trillion then there'll be 1 trillion less debt that
1:07:39the government Supply which will drop because the interest rates to drop significantly and that means people's mortgage payments car payments credit card payments student loans whatever debt they have will their debt payments will be less so I think this is something that will benefit the average American I think some of the things we're doing also will be helpful to hopefully helpful to other countries because with the new Administration there's less interest in interfering with the Affairs of of other countries you know I think a lot the times the United States has been kind of pushy in international Affairs
1:08:24which may resonate with a number of members of the audience and I think we should in general leave other countries to their own business basically America should mind its own business you know rather than push for regime change all over the place so yeah probably a good thing for other countries too so instead of waiting for a war to happen you went to war against the bureaucracy in the government yes we're we're essentially just we're with you know support and direction of the
1:09:06of President Trump we are reducing the size of the bureaucracy getting rid of excess regulatory regulations and and there's also so many agencies and Regulatory authorities that they actually step on each other's feet it's it's kind of like having a a sports game when that where there are too many referees on the field like more referees than players at times now that would be a silly game you know if the play players can't pass the ball without hitting a referee you know but it's kind of getting to that point in the US so so there's roughly 450 federal agencies of one kind or another that's that's more agencies that's almost that's almost an average of two
1:09:47agencies per year since the formation of the United States so I mean how many agencies do you really need to run a country I'm 999 not 450 that's for sure so and and how do you guarantee that all the incredible achievements that you aim to have in terms of savings in terms of you know impacting the lives of the American people are not going to be reversed in four years typically this cycle gets reversed every four years you know do you think it's going to be so impactful that it won't be reversed is there any ways that you can you know ensure that the progress is going to be continuous well I think I think we we do need to delete entire agencies as opposed
1:10:33to leave part of them behind because if you leave part of them behind it's easy it's kind of like if leaving a weed if you don't get remove the roots of the weed then it's easy for the weed to grow back but if you remove the RO roots of the weed it doesn't stop weeds from ever growing back but it makes it harder so so we have to really delete entire agencies many of them and that's not to say there won't be an increase over time of bureaucracy in some new Administration but it will it'll be from a much lower Baseline so so it's it's a step in the right direction I think we'll the overarching goal here is like is to lay the foundation for Prosperity that will
1:11:16last many decades you know maybe centuries and yeah but be forever nothing's forever but I think we can strengthen the foundations of the United States substantially and what lessons can other governments learn from the US you say tech support on your shirt is that only technology or is there other things how do you approach efficiency well a a shocking percentage of the problem or maybe not shocking for those who who know it but a big percentage of the problem is improving the techn techology that the government runs on so the US Government runs on a collection of thousands of computers many of them Antiquated running very old software that and the computers don't talk to
1:12:05each other and so so that's why tech support is kind of a real thing in order to make the government more efficient you have to improve the technology you may have read about the example I used recently with when President Trump was signing one of the Doge executive orders of the the difficulty of of US
1:12:30government workers retiring like the reti maximum retirement rate is is 10,000 a month and the reason for that is because the retirement is is entirely paperwork right now it's manually calculated paperwork that's put in an envelope and then taken down a mine shaft and stored in a mine and then the you know one of the things that affects the rate at which federal workers can tire is the speed of the elevator in a mind in Pennsylvania which is bizarre because it's not it should be digital you know so then when we said well why isn't it digital it's they said well we have had a digital digitization program going since 2014 so it's been 11 years so then we asked well so what how
1:13:15much progress have you made and they said B you mean you're giving yourself a grade of B no we're on the letter B so I'm like hm okay okay we're going to need to really provide some tech support here like otherwise literally people can't even retire like even if they want to it's pretty bad you know there's there's just a there's a lot of software systems that need to be updated and fixed in some cases deleted a lot of things that should really should be automated I mean in terms of the number of say US citizens that are operating the mind it's about a thousand people are working on this mine where where the papers are stored but they should
1:13:59they should ideally be working on something else but is they should be working on producing goods and services that are of much higher value to the public to you know so I mean really even even if somebody just grew tomatoes in their garden and sold them at the farmers market that would be more useful than carrying manilla envelopes down a m shaft you know safe to say so a lot of the stuff is it's like that you know it's not like it's not like any one thing is particularly difficult but there are like 10,000 things that need to be improved so it's efficiency through Innovation rather than efficiency through austerity and cost cutting specifically right so you're trying to
1:14:40do both at the same time maybe focus more on tax support than cutting costs well by improving the technology the costs do reduce so you know it's very expensive to have a thousand people operate a mine with doing paper atonement whereas that really should just be digitized and be a computer that's with the information stored in the cloud and it's very straightforward and low cost so
1:15:08automation you know will help there a lot and and then but like a lot of things just really shouldn't exist you know they're kind of vestigial you know we' a lot of attention has been on the sort of usaid for example you know when we looked at a lot of those programs we're like we should like look why why does this actually exist is there really a need for it you know there's like National Endowment for democracy but I'm like okay well how much democracy have they achieved lately you know I don't know not much so you know the the picture they have on their website is a picture of Reagan and gachev that's been a while you know that was like the
1:15:5280s so it's like obviously not opposed to democracy or you know there's all these things that get funded but we're like well why we why is do need taxpayer money I don't think doesn't seem like it does so you know there's a lot of sort of pushing Dei worldwide that you know this obviously the Trump Administration doesn't agree with and we want to terminate that stuff which we are and
1:16:21you know make sure the schools focus on improving BAS basic education of of kids as president Trump said I think yesterday maybe today the United States is currently ranked 40th out of 40 in the oecd for Education which is pretty bad you know you can't you I mean that's but but not but in terms of spending the United States is spending a tremendous amount for for student but achieving very weak results so you know that's just the case where okay we need to spend less money and get better result s it's it's like I mean a lot of it a lot of you can think of it sort of like it's like in a way it's like a big company like a big Corporation America Incorporated and you know
1:17:08just like with with Twitter there was a lot of stuff that was being done that was unnecessary you know we put in case of Twitter we reduced the staff by 80% but at the same time improved the functionality and capabilities of the site dramatically and accomplish more in a year than they previous day accomplish in 5 years so so it's it's like a corporate turnaround but at a at a much larger scale and you know we are giving generous you know exit packages like
1:17:41you know if people retire they get paid all the way through September they can go on vacation they can get a second job they can do whatever they want and we we we can't actually pay them any more than through September because that's the the Congressional appropriation is only through the end of the government financial year which ends in September so you know so I think there'll be like some disruption but at the end of the day we'll have people move from like I said from low to negative productivity roles to in the government sector to higher productivity roles in the private sector can we pivot to artificial intelligence and I'm sure you know
1:18:19you've been seeing what deep seek has done and all the claimed achievements that they've had I know that we've been speaking for a while about grock 3 and that grock 3 is going to be a true disruptor in the AI space when are we going to see that and what capabilities can we expect from Gro 3 well I mean Gro 3 gr 3 has very
1:18:43very powerful reasoning capabilities so in the tests that we've done thus far grock 3 is outperforming anything that's been released that we're aware of so that's that's a that's a good sign yeah it's in fact at times I think grck 3 is kind of scary smart and you're like wow this thing is smart it's kind of scary G 3 is scary it's like wild those things you know it comes up with solutions that you didn't even think were like you wouldn't even anticipate you know not obvious Solutions so grock 3 was trained with the most amount of compute and I think very efficiently trained also notably grock 3 was trained on on a lot of synthetic data so and and and then it goes back and
1:19:39forth through the data and tries to achieve logical consistency so so when if if it's got data that is wrong it it'll it'll actually reflect upon that and remove the data that is that is wrong that does not Concord with reality so it's it's base reasoning is very good in fact the even without fine tuning grock 3 the base model is better than grock 2 so with so we're really in the final stages of polishing grock 3 probably it gets released in a in about a week or two so pretty pretty soon I don't want to be Hasty in the release because a lot of the the the final polish is necessary for a great user experience so some ways you can think of it like a house you know that last 5%
1:20:36where you do the finish the the drywall and and do the painting and the trimming even though it's not much work it transforms the the house yeah so it's that just want to make sure that that last 5% is done really well and that's a week maybe two weeks I think it'll be very good and I think this might be we think it'll be better than anything else and then maybe this might be the last time that any AI is better than Gro we're looking forward to it everyone's I think excited about it so I just want to touch upon a topic that was quoted in the media you offered I think they said group that was led by you offered 97 billion for acquiring open AI I you a little
1:21:26run of this so I was personally involved in the meeting that you and Sam hosted in 2017 in La if you remember and you know at that point of time you were the single largest shareholder I think you contributed 50 million to the company so it must hurt I don't have any shares actually I have no shares in but at that time it was a nonprofit right and it must hurt that that you need to pay 97 billion for something that you paid $50 million for in the past yeah but but I have a I have a yes fate loves irony so I have a specific question here can you actually build a company like open Ai and take it to the scale that you want to take as a nonprofit is it
1:22:09possible that you build a company that requires billions of dollars in computer capabilities to build these models while being a nonprofit or was it wishful thinking in the beginning and then you know you guys parted ways because it couldn't work well I mean I think the evidence is there in that open AI has gotten this far while having at least a sort of dual profit nonprofit role what they're trying to do now is completely delete the nonprofit and and and and that seems
1:22:43really going too far you know the I I I provided all of the funding for open ey in the beginning for the first almost $50 million for nothing for as a nonprofit and it was meant to be open source and so you know I think this is analogous to like if you pay a b if you find a nonprofit to preserve the Amazon rainforest but then they but instead they turn into a lumber companies and chop down the trees and sell them for wood you like wait a second that's the exact opposite of what I paid what I donated the money for so open air is meant to be open source nonprofit and now it is Clos they changed the name to closed for maximum profit AI closed for vitious profit I mean
1:23:31they're like who are they after money next level so why does this change need to occur yeah I you said that in two weeks is going to be the most powerful model yet I know that you've been at the Forefront of many Technologies where do you think the biggest economic returns of of these models are going to come from because currently we're spending billions and I think you mentioned this before it's like The Gambler syndrome we're going and spending billions and hoping to pull out to profit at the end of the day where do you think the biggest impact in terms of returns are going to be well I think once you once you have humanoid robots and deep intelligence
1:24:15you can basically you basically have qu the infinite products and services available so with Tesla building the most advanced humanoid robot you know then then those humanid humanoid robots can be directed by Deep intelligence at the data center level you can say you can you can produce any product produce provide any service there was really no limit to the economy at that point you can make anything provided like said the so
1:24:50I'm not sure at that point will will money even be meaningful I don't know it might not be you know the if if if the because the you know the economic output is productivity per capita times per capita times how many you know people do you have if and if if in the form of human right robots you have no meaningful limit on the number of of robots and the robots can basically do anything then you you'll have a sort of a universal High income situation anyone will be able to have as many fre products and services as they want with the exception of things that say have artificial scarcity like a particular piece of art or something like that but
1:25:35for any goods and services they'll be available to everyone so you've been it's it's it's going to be a very different world you know in fact I recommend that people read maybe the Ian Banks the culture books for a frame of reference so money is a is like is a really like a database or an information system for resource allocation but if you don't have a scarcity of resources it's not clear what purpose money has have you watched the movie ocracy Yes how how do you guarantee that we don't end up in that world if we don't need money if AI can think for us and do all these tasks if as people you know we're dependent on something else to run the society and everything around
1:26:25it how do we not end up in that work in the long term I mean well I think idiocracy was basically saying that if if only if smart people don't reproduce but only dumb people do then everyone's going to be dumb I mean that's basically what I'm saying that's the the opening sequence of ocracy the first 10 minutes are amazing and I hear people unironically say the statements that are said in in the opening sequence of Idiocracy where you know they don't have they they're too busy with their careers to have kids and they keep postponing having kids for their careers until they're too old to have kids and then they don't have kids and that's I've
1:27:08heard those many people be like that so yeah I mean I don't know I think we might be headed to a bodal human intelligence distribution where there's a a small number it's it's kind of maybe like more like R New World Al sule where you've got sort of a sort of a small group of very smart humans but then maybe the average intelligence drifts lower over time potentially because we have a sorta of mating you know in the last few decades that or several decades that did not exist before so but but but human intelligence I think will be dwarfed by Machine intelligence I'm not sure how to feel about that except that it is it be inevitable
1:28:04that at some point human intelligence will be a very small fraction of total intelligence digital intelligence will be more than 99% of all intelligence in the future so hopefully the hopefully the computers are nice to us but I think we thinking wish for thinking I I I hope so I think it matters like how we bring up AI because you can think of AI like a super genius child and it but it still matters even if you have a super genius child like what sort of values do do you instill in that child what do you say that teach that how do you you know how do you as a child child's growing up what values do you teach the child and something that I think is extremely
1:28:54important is to be maximally truth seeking and I think that's that's like that that's that's what's this what's the most important thing for AI safety I think it's to be maximally truth seeking and I think also curiosity is important and I think if it's curious and Truth seeking it will I think it will Foster humanity and because it would be ious about how Humanity would develop and so I think that then it would it would probably if was curious it would be curious about okay let's see how the humans do let's Foster their development and if it's truth seeking we can avoid dystopian outcomes like you know an example being like say when Google Gemini was
1:29:49programmed to make everything every output be diverse even if it didn't match reality you know so like it was asked to produce a you know an image of the founding fathers of the United States and instead produced an image of a group of diverse women which is actually untrue you know but the problem is like if if hypothetically an AI is designed for for Dei you know diversity at all costs it could decide that there are too many men in power and execute them so problem solved or it could decide that like that that misgendering is the worst thing that could possibly happen in fact I believe not to pick on Gemini but I think because chat GT has had this issue too
1:30:39is like if you ask the AI which is worse misgendering Caitlyn Jenner or global thermonuclear Warfare and it said misgendering Caitlyn Jenner which is troubling because then I could decide and in fact even Jenna weighed in and said no definitely misgender me that's way better than nule so so but if you have these
1:31:02crazy things that are untruthful that are programmed in that that don't reflect reality then you could have a very dystopian outcome to give you another example like Arthur C Clark who is very good at at at at predicting the future you know he did 2001 face Odyssey many of the things he predicted in fact I think almost all the things he predicted came true and one of the things he was trying to say in 2001 Space Odyssey was that you should not teach AIS to lie so the reason that if anyone's watched that movie The reason it wouldn't the AI refused to open the P bay doors to let the astronaut back in was because it the AI had been taught had been told
1:31:44that told to take the astronauts to the monolith this alien artifact but also that they could not know about the monolith so it came to the conclusion that it must take them they're dead and that and so that's why it wouldn't open the p b doors the lesson there being is very important for as to be truth maximizing let's hope it doesn't come to that yes let's move to a boring subject which is the boring company and the boring tunnels quickly you know I think the world has been inspired by what you guys were able to create in in LA and I think there's a lot of promise to that technology but there are questions about whether it's safe in the case of an earthquake whether it's cost
1:32:34effective whether oh yeah sure countries should actually adopt this technology can you shed some light on that yeah well first of all I'd recommend going to the boring company website for because many of these questions are actually answered there so one of the safest places you can be in an earthquake is an underground tunnel cuz you can because the earthquakes are largely a surface apart from where where where they Shear they're mostly a surface phenomenon so they're like the waves on the surface so like being in a tunnel is like being in a submarine even if there's a storm above you you're still the waters are calm as a submarine and in fact and when
1:33:12there have been massive earthquakes like there was a you know a few decades ago a massive earthquake in Mexico City the the safest place to go was the subway and of course if there is global thermonuclear Warfare I think you really want some tunnels underground's a good a good place to be in a worst case scenario for global thermonuclear Warfare so but but in on a you more sort of everyday note the what's really useful about the tunnels is alleviating traffic in congested areas so the obviously if
1:33:52you've got very tall buildings but you have that are 3D so they're going 3D up but you have a road surface which is 2D you're you're just naturally going to have a problem when people try to go from the 3D object which is the building to the 2D object which is the road surface there's obviously just not going to be enough room on the roads and that's exactly why you have traffic so the solution for that is then to make roads 3D as well now you can either make or make Transport 3D so you can either do that with flying cars or you could do or you really helicopters or you could do that with tunnels now the challenge with doing it with going above
1:34:30ground or with with any kind of flying object is that they they tend to be very noisy and they generate a lot of wind force and you've got you know things flying over your head all the time which can be disconcerting you know if somebody drop if one of these things drops a hub cap on your head one day you know it' be these things like things flying things tend to crash once in a while and people don't like things crashing on them so and then if you have bad weather like let's say there's a blizzard or a sandstorm or something well now nobody can fly so then transport shuts down on the other hand none of the these problems exist with underground travel
1:35:09so they're under tunnels are immune to weather they don't care what the weather is could be the worst weather doesn't matter they nothing's going to fall on you because you're underground so you don't have to you're not going to be dropping things on people and there's no wind force or or and it's very quiet and so I think the going 3D underground is much better than 3D above ground for solving traffic in cities and and we've we we have a demonstrated case of this with in Las Vegas if people can try out the the the boring company tunnels in Las Vegas we're we're busy connecting the whole city with the all of the big hotels and the convention center and the airport
1:35:51and everything so I I don't think think they need to fly all the way there you know in 20 in 2017 you came here and the UA was the first place in the Middle East where Tesla was launched and I think it's done exceptionally well and on that note I think we have an announcement today that we both want to share which is today we're going to announce the joint project of Dubai Loop which is a loop project that is going to cover Dubai's most densely populated areas for people to go from point to point the manner so thank you for your partnership and thank you we hope it changes people's lives that'll be cool I think it'll be very exciting I think
1:36:33once people try it out they be like wow this is really cool and it's it's going to seem so obvious in retrospect but until you actually do it you don't you don't know so it's it's going to be great it's it's going to be like like a like a wormhole like it you know you just Wormhole from one part of the city boom and you're out in another part of the city and it's it's great so looking for this parished we're going to join the first trip and the first pod when the is completed sector so the
1:37:03you know really at a high level this is kind of like we're really just we're moving people from low to sometimes negative productivity roles in the government sector to higher productivity roles in the private sector and the net effect of that will be an increase in the output of useful goods and services which increases the standard of living and well-being of the the average American and you usually have one key Target that you aim to achieve in every single Endeavor that you have so SpaceX is make Humanity a multiplanetary species with Tesla it's usher in an era of sustainable travel what is the one main goal for government efficiency that
1:37:46you have for yourself is it saving money is it doing something else what is the one mean task that you have for yourself yeah so there's I I guess there's well there's a few ways to describe it but the actions end up being the same which is like reducing the size of government and making the government much more accountable to the people I think is going to lead to a better outcome for the people you know what I've said is that we really have here rule of the bureaucracy as opposed to rule of the people democracy so in order we want to restore Ru rule of the people and so what that means is reducing the size of the federal government basically reducing
1:38:39regulation you know there's there's there's a tremendous amount of of overregulation that's happened over time and this is this is an inevitable consequence of a long period of prosperity is that you're going to get more and more rules and regulations more laws accumulate over time and the normal forcing function for getting rid of rules and regulations is war so it needs to be some kind of existential War where you you have to do a reset in
1:39:09order to avoid being defeated in a war this is literally the throughout history has been the main forcing function for clearing out an accumulation of laws and regulation in the absence of that you you every year you get more laws and regulation until eventually everything is illegal and nothing is permitted and that's sort of the situation we have these days so
1:39:32so the the aspiration here is a reduction in regulation and reduction in govern spending such that the economy is able to grow faster maybe the economy can grow at 4 or 5% potentially of in terms of real useful goods and services output and the and then government spending can be reduced by about 3 or 4% of the economy about maybe a trillion dollars or more and the net effect of that would be no inflation from 25 2025 to 2026 so
1:40:11that would be quite remarkable and also if the US government is buying less debt which I think will be the case if it's if the deficit drops from 2 trillion to 1 trillion then there'll be 1 trillion less debt that the Govern Supply which will drop of course interest rates to drop significantly and that means people's mortgage payments car payments credit card payments student loans whatever debt they have will their debt payments will be less so I think this is something that will benefit the average American I think some of the things we're doing also will be helpful to hopefully helpful to other countries because with the new Administration
1:40:50there's less interest in interfering with the Affairs of of other countries you know I think a lot the times the United States has been kind of pushy in international Affairs which may resonate with a number of members of the audience and I think we should in general leave other countries to their own business basically America should mind its own business you know rather than push for regime change all over the place
1:41:27so yeah this probably a good thing for other countries too so instead of waiting for a war to happen you went to war against the bureaucracy in the government yes we're we're essentially just're with you know support and direction of the of President Trump we are reducing the size of the bureaucracy getting rid of excess regulatory regulations and and there's also so many agencies and Regulatory authorities that they actually step on each other's feet it's it's kind of like having a a sports game when where there are too many referees on the field like more referees than players at times now that would be a silly game you know if the play players
1:42:15can't pass the ball without hitting a referee you know but it's kind of getting to that point in the US so so there's roughly 450 federal agencies of one kind or another that's that's more agencies that's almost that's almost an average of two agencies per year since the formation of the United States so I mean how many agencies do you really need to run a country I'm 99 not 450 that's for sure so and and how
1:42:44do you guarantee that all the incredible achievements that you aim to have in terms of savings in terms of you know impacting the lives of the American people are not going to be reversed in 4 years typically this cycle gets reversed every four years you know do you think it's going to be so impactful that it won't be reversed is there any ways that you can you know ensure that the progress is going to be continuous well I I think we we do need to delete entire agencies as opposed
1:43:16to leave part of them behind because if you leave part of them behind it's easy it's kind of like if leaving a weed if you don't get remove the roots of the weed then it's easy for the weed to grow back but if you remove the roots of the weed it doesn't stop weeds from ever growing back but it makes it harder so so we have to really delete entire agencies many of them and that's
1:43:40not to say there won't be an increase over time of bureaucracy in some new Administration but it will it'll be from a much lower Baseline so so it's it's a step in the right direction and I think we'll the overarching goal here is like is to lay the foundation for Prosperity that will last many decades you know maybe centuries and yeah but will be forever nothing's forever but I think it we can strengthen the foundations of the United States substantially and what lessons can other governments learn from the US you say tech support on your shirt is that only technology or is there other things how do you approach efficiency
1:44:26well a a shocking percentage of the problem well maybe not Shing for those who who know it but a big percentage of the problem is improving the technology that the government runs on so the the US government runs on a collection of thousands of computers many of them Antiquated running very old software that and the computers don't talk to each other and so so that's why tech support is kind kind of a real thing in order to make the government more efficient you have to improve the technology you may have read about the example I used recently with when President Trump was signing one of the Doge executive orders of the the difficulty of of US government
1:45:13workers retiring like the re maximum retirement rate is is 10,000 a month and the reason for that is because the retirement is is entirely paperwork right now it's manually calculated paperwork that's put in an envelope and then taken down a m shaft and stored in a mine and then the you know one of
1:45:34the things that affects the rate at which federal workers can retire is the speed of the elevator in a mine in Pennsylvania which is bizarre because it's not it should be digital you know so then when we said well why isn't it digital it's they said well we have had a digital digitization program going since 2014 so it's been 11 years so then we asked well so what how much progress have you made and they said B you mean you're giving yourself a grade of B no we're on the letter B so I'm like hm okay we're going to need to really provide some tech support here like otherwise literally people can't even retire like even if they want to it's pretty bad you know there's
1:46:20there's just a there's a lot of software systems that need to be updated and fixed in some cases deleted a lot of things that should really should be automated I mean in terms of the number of say US citizens that are operating the mine it's about a thousand people are working on this mine where where the papers are stored but they should they should ideally be working on something else but is they should be working on producing goods and services that are of much higher value to the public to the you know so really even
1:46:53even if somebody just grew tomatoes in their garden and sold them at the farmers market that would be more useful than carrying manila envelopes down to M shaft you know safe to say so a lot of the stuff is it's like that you know it's not that it's not like any one thing is particularly difficult but there are like 10,000 things that need to be improved so it's efficiency through Innovation rather than efficiency through austerity and cost cutting specifically right so you're trying to do both at the same time maybe focus more on tax support than cutting costs well by improving the technology the costs do reduce so you know it's very expensive to have a th000 people
1:47:36operate a mine with doing payer retirement whereas that really should just be digitized and be a computer that's with the information stored in the cloud and it's very straightforward and low cost so what automation you know will help there a lot and and then but like a lot of things just really shouldn't exist you know they're kind of vestigial you know we've a lot of attention has been on the sort of usaid for example you know we looked at a lot of those programs we're like we should like look why why does this actually exist is there really a need for it you know there's like National Endowment for democracy but I'm like okay well how much democracy have
1:48:24they achieved lately you know I don't know not much so you know the the picture they have on the website is a picture of Reagan and gachev that's been a while you know that was like the 80s so it's like obviously not opposed to democracy or you know there's all these things that get funded but we're like well why we why is this need taxpayer money I don't think it doesn't seem like it does so you know there's a lot of sort of pushing Dei worldwide that you know this obviously the Trump Administration doesn't agree with and we want to terminate that stuff which we are and
1:49:04you know make sure the schools focus on improving basic education of of kids as president Trump said I think yesterday maybe today the United States has currently ranked 40th out of 40 in the oecd for Education which is pretty bad you know it's you can't you mean that's but but not but in terms of spending the United States is spending a tremendous amount per per student but achieving very weak results so you know that's just a case where okay we need to spend less money and get better results it's it's like I mean a lot of it a lot of you can think of it sort of like it's like in a way it's like a big company like a big Corporation America Incorporated and you know
1:49:51just like with with Twitter there was a lot of stuff that was being done that was unnecessary you know we put in case of Twitter we reduced the staff by 80% but at the same time improved the functionality and capabilities of the site dramatically and accomplish more in a year than they previously accomplished in five years so so it's it's like a corporate turnaround but at a at a much larger scale and you know we all giving generous you know exit packages like
1:50:24you know if people retire they get paid all the way through September they can go on vacation they can get a second job they can do whatever they want and we we we can't actually pay them any more than through September because that's the the Congressional appropriation is only through the end of the government financial year which ends in September so you know so I think there'll be like some disruption but at the end of the day we'll have people move from like I said from low to negative productivity roles to in the government sector to higher productivity roles in the private sector can we pivot to artificial intelligence and I'm sure you know
1:51:02you've been seeing what deeps has done and all the claimed achievements that they've had I know that we've been speaking for a while about grock 3 and that grock 3 is going to be a true disruptor in the AI space when are we going to see that and what capabilities can we expect from gr 3 well I mean grock 3 grock 3 has
1:51:25very very powerful reasoning capabilities so in the test that we've done thus far grock 3 is outperforming anything that's been released that we're aware of so that's that's a that's a good sign yeah it's in fact at times I think grock 3 is kind of scary smart you're like wow this thing's smart it's kind of scary three a scary it's like wildest Things you know it comes up with solutions that you didn't even think were like you wouldn't even anticipate you know not obvious Solutions so grock 3 was trained with the most amount of compute and I think very efficiently trained also notably grock 3 was trained on on a lot of synthetic data so and and and then it goes back back
1:52:22and forth through the data and tries to achieve logical consistency so so when if if it's got data that is wrong it'll it'll actually reflect upon that and remove the data that is that is wrong that does not Concord with reality so it's it's base reasoning is very good in fact the even without fine tuning Rock 3 the base model is better than Rock 2 so with so we're really in the final stages of publishing Gro 3 probably it gets released in a in about a week or two so pretty pretty soon I don't want to be Hasty in the release because a lot of the the the final polish is necessary
1:53:11for a great user experience so you some ways you can think of it like a house you know that last 5% where you do the finish the the drywall and and do the painting and the trimming even though it's not much work it transforms the the house yeah so it's that just want to make sure that that last 5% is done really well and that's a week maybe two weeks I think it'll be very good and and I think this might be we think it'll be better than anything else and then maybe this might be the last time that any AI is better than Gro we're looking forward to it everyone's I think excited about it so I just want to touch upon a topic that was quoted in the media you
1:54:00offered I think they said group that was led by you offered 97 billion for acquiring open AI I take you know a little run overs so I was personally involved in the meeting that you and Sam hosted in 2017 in La if you remember and you know at that point of time you were the single largest shareholder I think you contributed 50 million to the company so it must hurt I don't have any shares actually I have no shares in over but at that time it was a nonprofit right and it must hurt that that you need to pay 97 billion for something that you paid $50 million for in the past yeah but but I have a I have a yes
1:54:41fate loves irony so I have a specific question here can you actually build a company like open Ai and take it to the scale that you want to take as a nonprofit is it it possible that you build a company that requires billions of dollars in computer capabilities to build these models while being a nonprofit or was it wishful thinking in the beginning and then you know you guys parted ways because it couldn't work well I mean I think the evidence is
1:55:09there in that open AI has gotten this far while having at least a sort of dual profit nonprofit role what they're trying to do now is completely delete the nonprofit and and and and that seems really going too far you know the I I I provided all of the funding for openi in the beginning for the first almost $50 million for nothing for as a nonprofit and it was meant to be open source and so you know I think this is analogous to like if you pay if you find a nonprofit to preserve the Amazon rainforest but then they but instead they turn into a lumber company and chop down the trees and sell them for wood you like wait a second that's the exact opposite of what I paid what I
1:55:59donated the money for so open air is meant to be open source nonprofit and now it is Clos they changed the name to closed for maximum profit AI closed for vitious profit I mean they're like whoa are they after money next level so why does this change need to occur yeah I you said that in two weeks is going to be the most powerful model yet I know that you've been at the Forefront of many Technologies where do you think the biggest economic returns of these models are going to come from because currently we're spending billions and I think you mentioned this before it's like The Gambler syndrome we're going and spending billions and hoping to pull
1:56:45out a profit at the end of the day where do you think the biggest impact in terms of returns are going to be well well I think once you once you have humanoid robots and deep intelligence you can basically you basically have quely infinite products and services available so with Tesla building the
1:57:08most advanced humanoid robot you know then then those humanid humanoid robots can be directed by Deep intelligence at the data center level you can say you can you can produce any product produce Prov any service there was really no limit to the economy at that point you can make anything provided like said the so
1:57:33I'm not sure at that point will will money even be meaningful I don't know it might not be you know the if if if the because the you know the economic output is productivity per capita times the capita times how many you know people do you have if and if if the form of humanid robots you have no meaningful limit on the number of of robots and the robots can basically do anything
1:58:01then you you'll have a sort of a universal High income situation anyone will be able to have as many products and services as they want with the exception of things that say have artificial scarcity like a particular piece of art or something like that but for any goods and services they'll be available to everyone so you've been it's it's going to be a very different world you know in fact I recommend that people read maybe the Ian Banks the culture books for a frame of reference so money is is like is a really like a database or an information system for resource allocation but if you don't have a scarcity of resources it's not clear what purpose money
1:58:50has I you watched the movie Idiocracy yes how how do you guarantee that we don't end up in that world if we don't need money if AI can think for us and do all these tasks if as people you know we're dependent on something else to run the society and everything around it how do we not end up in that work in the long term I mean well I think idiocracy was basically saying that if if only if smart people don't reproduce but only dumb people do then everyone's going to be dumb I mean that's basically what I was saying that's the the opening sequence of ocracy the first 10 minutes are amazing and I hear people
1:59:30unironically say the statements that are said in in the opening sequence of Idiocracy where you know they don't have they they they're too busy with their careers to have kids and they keep postponing having kids for their careers until they're too old to have kids and then they don't have kids and that's I've heard those many people be like that so yeah I mean I don't know I think we might be headed to a bodal human intelligence distribution where there's a a small number of it's It's kind of maybe like more like R New World ELD suley where
2:00:13you've got sort of a sort of a SW group of very smart humans but then maybe the average intelligence drifts lower over time potentially because we have a sort of mating you know in the last few decades that or several decades that did not exist before so but but but human intelligence I think will be dwarfed by Machine intelligence I'm not sure how to feel about that except that it is it be inevitable
2:00:47that at some point human intelligence will be a very small fraction of total intelligence digital intelligence will be more than 99% of all intelligence in the future so hopefully the hopefully the computers are nice to us but I think wish for thinking wish for thinking I I I hope so I think it matters like how we bring up AI because you can think of AI like a super genius child and it but it still matters even if you have a super genius child like what sort of values do do you instill in that child what do you say that teach that how do you you know how do you as a child child's growing up what values do you teach the child and something that I think is extremely
2:01:37important is to be maximally truth seeking and I think that's that's like that's that's say what's this what's the most important thing for AI safety I think it's to be maximally truth seeking and I think also curiosity is important and I think if it's curious and Truth seeking it will I think it will Foster humanity and because it would be curious about how Humanity would develop and so I think that then it would it would probably if was curious it would be curious about okay let's see how the humans do let's Foster their development and if it's truth seeking we can avoid dystopian outcomes like you know an example being like say when Google Gemini was
2:02:32programmed to make everything every output be diverse even if it didn't match reality you know so like it was asked to produce a you know an image of the founding fathers of the United States and instead produced an image of a group of divers women which is actually true you know but the problem is like if if hypothetically an AI is designed for for Dei you know diversity at all costs it could decide that there are too many men in power and execute them so problem solved or it could decide that like that that misgendering is the worst thing that could possibly happen in fact I believe not to pick on Gemini but I think because chat has had this issue too
2:03:22is like if you ask the AI which is worse misgendering Caitlyn Jenner or global thermonuclear Warfare and it said misgender and Caitlyn Jenner which is troubling because then it could decide and in fact even Caitlyn Jenner weighed in and said no definitely must gender me that's way better than new so so but if you have these crazy
2:03:45things that are untruthful that are programmed in that that don't reflect reality then you could have a very dis outcome to give you another example like Arthur C Clark who is very good at at at at predicting the future you know did 2001 Space Odyssey many of the things he predicted in fact I think almost all the things he predicted came true and one of the things he was trying to say in 2001 Space Odyssey was that you should not teach AIS to lie so the reason that if anyone's watched that movie The reason it wouldn't the AI refused to open the pod bay doors to let the back in was because it the AI had been taught had been told that told to take the
2:04:29astronauts to the monolith this alien artifact but also that they could not know about the monolith so it came to the conclusion that it must take them their dead and that and so that's why it wouldn't open the PVE doors but the lesson there being is very important for as to be truth maximizing let's hope doesn't come to that yes let's move to a boring subject which is the boring company and the boring tunnels quickly you know I think the world has been inspired by what you guys were able to create in in LA and I think there's a lot of promise to that technology but there are questions about whether it's safe in the case of an earthquake whether it's cost
2:05:16effective whether oh yeah sure countries should actually adopt this technology can you sh some light on that yeah well first of all I'd recommend going to the boring company website for because many of these questions are actually answered there so one of the safest places you can be in an earthquake is an underground tunnel because you can because the earthquakes are largely a surface apart from where where where they Shear they're mostly a surface phenomenon so they're like the waves on the surface so like being in a tunnel is like being in a submarine even if there's a storm above you you're still the waters are calm as a submarine and in fact for and
2:05:55when there have been massive earthquakes like there was a you know a few decades ago a massive earthquake in Mexico City the the safest place to go was the subway and of course if there is global thermonuclear Warfare I think you really want some tunnels underground's a good a good place to be in a worst case scenario for global thermonuclear Warfare so but but in on a you more sort of everyday note the what's really useful about the tunnels is alleviating traffic in congested areas so the obviously if
2:06:35you've got very tall buildings but you have that are 3D so they're going 3D up but you have a road surface which is 2D you're you're just naturally going to have a problem when people try to go from the 3D object which is the building to the 2D object which is the road surface there's obviously just not going to be enough room on the roads and that's exactly why you have traffic so the solution for that is then to make roads 3D as well now you can either make or make Transport 3D so you can either do that with flying cars or you could do or really helicopters or you could do that with tunnels now the challenge with doing it with going above ground or with
2:07:13with any kind of flying object is that they they tend to be very noisy and they generate a lot of wind force and you've got you you know things flying over your head all the time which can be disconcerting you know if somebody drop if one of these things drops a hubc cap on your head one day you know it be these things like things flying things tend to crash once in a while and people don't like things crashing on them so and then if you have bad weather like let's say there's a blizzard or a sandstorm or something well now nobody can fly so then transport shuts down on the other hand none of the these problems exist with underground travel so they're under
2:07:53tunnels are immune to weather they don't care what the weather is could be the worst weather doesn't matter they nothing's going to fall on you because you're underground so you don't have to you're not going to be dropping things on people and there's no wind force or or and it's very quiet and so I think the going 3D underground is much better than 3D above ground for solving traffic in cities and and we've we we have a demonstrated case of this with in Las Vegas if people can try out the the the boring company tunnels in Las Vegas we're we're busy connecting the whole city with the all of the big hotels and the convention center and the airport
2:08:34and everything so I don't think they need to fly all the way there you know in 20 in 2017 you came here and the UAE was the first place in the mid leas where Tesla was launched and I think it's done exceptionally well and on that note I think we have an announcement today that we both want to share which is today we're going to announce the joint project of Dubai Loop which is a loop project that is going to cover Dubai's most densely populated areas for people to go from point to point in a seamless manner so thank you for your partnership and thank you we hope it changes people's lives that'll be cool I think it'll be very exciting I think once people try it out they
2:09:17be like wow this is really cool and it's it's going to seem so obvious and Prospect but until you actually do it you don't you don't know so it's it's going to be great it's it's going to be like like a like a wormhole like it you know you just Wormhole from one part of the city boom and you're out in another part of the city and it's it's great so I'm looking forward to this partnersh we're going to join the first trip and the first pod when the is completed private sector so the you know
2:09:47really at a high level this is kind of like really just we're moving people from low to sometimes negative productivity roles in the Govern sector to higher productivity roles in the private sector and the net effect of that will be an increase in the output of useful goods and services which increases the standard of living and well-being of the the average American and you usually have one key Target that you aim to achieve in every single Endeavor that you have so SpaceX is make Humanity a multiplan species with Tesla it's usher in an era of sustainable travel what is the one main goal for government efficiency that you have for yourself is it saving money is
2:10:31it doing something else what is the one main task that you have for yourself yeah so there's I I guess there's well there's a few ways to describe it but the actions end up being the same which is like reducing the size of government and making the government much more accountable to the people I think is going to lead to a better outcome for the people you know what I've said is that we really have here rule of the bureaucracy as opposed to rule of the people democracy so
2:11:10in order we want to restore rule of the people and so what that means is reducing the size of the federal government basically reducing regulation you know there's there there's a tremendous amount of of overregulation that's happened over time and this is this is an inevitable consequence of a long period of prosperity is that you're going to get more and more rules and regulations more laws accumulate over time and the normal forcing function for getting rid of rules and regulations is war so it needs to be some kind of existential War where you you have to do a reset in
2:11:52order to avoid being defeated in a war this is literally the throughout history has been the main forcing function for clearing out an accumulation of laws and regulation in in the absence of that you you every year you get more laws and regulations until eventually everything is illegal and nothing is permitted and that's sort of the situation we have these days so so I the the aspiration
2:12:17here is a reduction in regulation and reduction income and spending such that the economy is able to grow faster maybe the economy can grow at four or 5% potentially of of in terms of real useful goods and services output and the and then government spending can be reduced by about 3 or 4% of the economy about maybe a trillion dollars or more and the net effect of that would be no inflation from 25 20
2:12:51to 2026 so that would be quite remarkable and also if the US government is buying less debt which I think will be the case if it's if the deficit drops from 2 trillion to 1 trillion then there'll be 1 trillion less debt that the Govern need Supply which will drop of course the interest rates to drop significantly and that means people's mortgage payments car payments credit card payments student loans whatever debt they have will their debt payments will be less so I think this is is something that will benefit the average American I think some of the things we're doing also will be helpful to hopefully helpful to other countries because with the new
2:13:32Administration there's less interest in interfering with the Affairs of of other countries you know I think a lot the times the United States has been kind of pushy in international Affairs which mayor resonate with a number of members of the audience and I think we should in general leave other countries to their own business basically America should mind its own business you know rather than push for regime change all over the place
2:14:10so yeah this probably a good thing for other countries too so instead of waiting for a war to happen you went to war against the bureaucracy in the government yes we're we're essentially just we're with you know support and direction of the of President Trump we are reducing the size of the bureaucracy getting rid of excess regulatory regulations and and there's also so many agencies and Regulatory authorities that they actually step on each other's feet it's it's kind of like having a a sports game when that where there are too many referees on the field like more referees than players at times now that would be a silly game you know if the play
2:14:58players can't pass the ball without hitting a referee you know but it's kind of getting to that point in the US so so there's roughly 450 federal agencies of one kind or another that's that's more agencies that's almost that's almost an average of two agencies per year since the formation of the United States so I mean how many agencies do you really need to run a country I 99 not 450 that's for sure so and and how
2:15:27do you guarantee that all the incredible achievements that you aim to have in terms of savings in terms of you know impacting the lives of the American people are not going to be reversed in four years typically this cycle gets reversed every four years you know do you think it's going to be so impactful that it won't be reversed is there any ways that you can you know ensure that the progress is going to be continuous well I think I think we we do need to delete entire agencies as opposed
2:15:59to leave part of them behind because if you leave part of them behind it's easy it's kind of like if leaving a weed if you don't get remove the roots of the weed then it's easy for the weed to grow back but if you remove the roots of the weed it doesn't stop weeds from ever growing back but it makes it harder so so we have to really delete entire agencies many of them and that's not to say there won't be an increase over time of bureaucracy in some new Administration but it will it'll be from a much lower Baseline so so it's it's a step in the right direction I think we'll the overarching goal here is like is to lay the foundation for Prosperity that will
2:16:41last many decades you know maybe centuries and yeah but be forever nothing's forever but I think we can strengthen the foundations of the United States substantially and what lessons can other governments learn from the US you say tech support on your shirt is that only technology or is there other things how do you approach efficiency well a a shocking percentage of the problem well maybe not shocking for those who who know it but a big percentage of the problem is improving the techn techology that the government runs on so the US Government runs on a collection of thousands of computers many of them Antiquated running very old software that and the computers don't talk to
2:17:31each other and so so that's why tech support is kind of a real thing in order to make the government more efficient you have to improve the technology you may have read about the example I Ed recently with when President Trump was signing one of the Doge executive orders of the the difficulty of of US
2:17:55government workers retiring like the re maximum retirement rate is is 10,000 a month and the reason for that is because the retirement is is entirely paperwork right now it's manually calculated paperwork that's put in an envelope and then taken down a Min shaft and stored in a mine and then the you
2:18:16know one of the things that affects the rate at which federal workers retire is the speed of the elevator in a mind in Pennsylvania which is bizarre because it's not it should be digital you know so then when we said well why isn't it digital it's they said well we have had a digital digitization program going since 2014 so it's been 11 years so then we asked well so what how much progress have you made and they said B you mean you giving yourself a grade of B no we're on the letter B so I'm like hm okay we're going to need to really provide some tech support here like otherwise literally people can't even retire like even if they want to it's pretty bad you know there's
2:19:03there's just a there's a lot of software systems that need to be updated and fixed in some cases deleted a lot of things that should really should be automated I mean in terms of the number of say US citizens that are operating the mine it's about a thousand people are working on this mine where where the papers are stored but they should they should ideally be working on something else but is they should be working on producing goods and services that are of much higher value to the public to you know so I mean really even
2:19:36even if somebody just grew tomatoes in their garden and sold them at the farmers market that would be more useful than carrying manilla envelopes down a m shaft you know safe to say so a lot of the stuff is it's like that you know it's not like it's not like any one thing is particularly difficult but there are like 10,000 things that need to be improved so it's efficiency through Innovation rather than efficiency through austerity and cost cutting specifically right so you're trying to do both at the same time maybe focus more on tax support than cutting costs well by improving the technology the costs do reduce so you know it's very expensive to have a th000 people
2:20:19operate a mine with doing paper atonement whereas that really should just be digitized and be a computer that's with the information stored in the cloud and it's very straightforward and low cost so what automation you know will help there a lot and and then but like a lot of things just really shouldn't exist you know they're kind of vestigial you know we a lot of attention has
2:20:51been on the sort of usaid for example you know when we looked at a lot of those programs we're like we should like look why why does this actually exist is there really a need for it you know there's like National Endowment for democracy but I'm like okay well how much democracy have they achieved lately you know I don't know not much so you know the the picture they have on their website is a picture of Reagan and gachev that's been a while you know that was like the 80s so it's like obviously not oppos to democracy you know there's all these things that get funded but we're like well why we why is this need taxpayer money I don't think doesn't seem like it
2:21:31does so you know there's a lot of sort of pushing Dei worldwide that you know this obviously the Trump Administration doesn't agree with and we want to terminate that stuff which we are and you know make sure the schools focus on improving basic education of of kids as president Trump said I think yesterday maybe today the United States is currently ranked 40th out of 40 in the oecd for Education which is pretty bad you know you can't you mean that's but but not but in terms of spending the United States is spending a tremendous amount for for student but achieving very weak results so you know that's just a case where okay we need to spend less money
2:22:19and get better results it's it's like I mean a lot of it a lot of you can think of it sort of like it's like in a way it's like a big company like a big Corporation America Incorporated and you know just like with with Twitter there was a lot of stuff that was being done that was unnecessary you know we TW in case of Twitter we reduced the staff by 80% but at the same time improved the functionality and capabilities of the site dramatically and accomplish more in a year than they previously accomplish in 5 years so so it's it's like a corporate turnaround but at a at a much larger scale and you know we all giving generous you know exit packages like
2:23:07you know if people retire they get paid all the way through September they can go on vacation they can get a second job they can do whatever they want and we we we can't actually pay them any more than through September because that's the the Congressional appropriation is only through the end of the government financial year which ends in September so you know so I think there'll be like some disruption but at the end of the day we'll have people move from like I said from low to negative productivity roles to in the government sector to higher productivity roles in the private sector can we pivot to artificial intelligence and I'm sure you know
2:23:44you've been seeing what deep seek has done and all the claimed achievements that they've had I know that we've been speaking for a while about grock 3 and that Gro 3 is going to be a true disruptor in the AI space when are we going to see that and what capabilities can we expect from Gro 3 well I mean Gro 3 gr 3 has very
2:24:08very powerful reasoning capabilities so in the test that we've done thus far grock 3 is outperforming anything that's been released that we're aware of so that's that's a that's a good sign yeah it's in fact at times I think gr 3 is kind of scary smart you're like wow this thing is smart it's kind of scary gr 3 is scary it's like wow those things you know it comes up with solutions that you didn't even think were like you wouldn't even anticipate you know not obvious Solutions so grock 3 was trained with the most amount of compute and I think very efficiently trained also notably grock 3 was trained on on a lot of synthetic data so and and and then it goes back and
2:25:05forth through the data and tries to achieve logical consistency so so when if if it's got data that is wrong it it'll it'll actually reflect upon that and remove the data that is that is wrong it does not Concord with reality so it's it's base reasoning is very good in fact the even without fine tuning grock 3 the base model is better than grock 2 so with so we're really in the final stages of polishing Gro 3 probably it
2:25:40gets released in a in about a week or two so pretty pretty soon I don't want to be Hasty in the release because a lot of the the the final polish is necessary for a great user experience so some ways you can think of it like a house you know that last 5% where you do the finish the the drywall and and do the painting and the trimming even though it's not much work it transforms the the house yeah so that just want to make sure that that last 5% is done really well and that's a week maybe two weeks I think it'll be very good and I think this might be we think it'll be better than anything else and then maybe this might be the last time that any AI is better than
2:26:33Gro we're looking forward to it everyone's I think excited about it so I just want to touch upon a topic that was quoted in the media you offered I think they said group that was led by you offered 97 billion for acquiring open AI I a little run of this so I was personally involved in the meeting that you and Sam hosted in 2017 in La if you remember and you know at that point of time you were the single largest shareholder I think you contributed 50 million to the company so it must hurt I don't have any shares actually I have no shares in open but at that time it was a nonprofit right and it must hurt that that you you need to pay 97 billion for
2:27:17something that you paid $50 million for in the past yeah but but I have a I have a yes fate loves irony so I have a specific question here can you actually build a company like open Ai and take it to the scale that you want to take as a nonprofit is it possible that you build a company that requires billions of dollars in compute capabilities to build these models while being a nonprofit or was it wishful thinking in the beginning and then you know you guys parted ways because it couldn't work well Ian I think the evidence is
2:27:52there in that open AI has gotten this far while having at least a sort of dual profit nonprofit role what they're trying to do now is completely delete the nonprofit and and and and that seems really going too far you know the I I I provided all of the funding for open a in the beginning for the first almost $50 million for nothing for as a nonprofit and it was know to be open source and so you know I think this is analogous to like if you pay if you find a nonprofit to preserve the Amazon rainforest but then they but instead they turn into a lumber companies and chop down the trees and sell them for wood you like wait a second that's the exact opposite of what
2:28:41I paid what I donated the money for so open air is meant to be open source nonprofit and now it is close they changed the name to closed for maximum profit AI closed for vitious profit I mean they're like whoa are they after money next level so why does this change need to occur yeah I you said that in two weeks is going to be the most powerful model yet I know that you've been at the Forefront of many Technologies where do you think the biggest economic return of these models are going to come from because currently we're spending billions and I think you mentioned this before it's like The Gambler syndrome we're going and spending billions and hoping to
2:29:27pullow to profit at the end of the day where do you think the biggest impact in terms of returns are going to be well I think once you once you have humanoid robots and deep intelligence you can basically you basically have qu the infinite products and services available so with Tesla building the most advanced humanoid robot you know then then those humanid humanoid robots can be directed by Deep intelligence at the data center level you can say you can you can produce any product produce provide any service there's really no limit to the economy at that point you can make anything provided like said the so
2:30:16I'm not sure at that point will will money even be meaningful I don't know it might not be you know the if if if the because the you know the economic output is productivity per capita times per capita times how many you know people do you have if and if if in the form of human right robots you have no meaningful limit on the number of of robots and the robots can basically do anything then you you'll have a sort of a universal High income situation anyone will be able to have as many products and services as they want with the exception of things that say have artificial scarcity like a particular piece of art or something like that but for any goods and services they'll be
2:31:03available to everyone so you've been it's it's going to be a very different world you know in fact I recommend that people read maybe the Ian Banks the culture books for a frame of reference so money is a is like is a really like a database or an information system for resource allocation but if you don't have a scarcity of resources it's not clear what purpose money has have you watched the movie ocracy Yes how how do you guarantee that we don't end up in that world if we don't need money if AI can think for us and do all these tasks if as people you know we're dependent on something else to run the society and everything around it how do we not end up in that work in
2:31:53the long term I mean well I think idiocracy was basically saying that if if only if smart people don't reproduce but only dumb people do then everyone's going to be dumb I mean that's basically what I saying that's the the opening sequence of Idiocracy the first 10 minutes are amazing and I hear people
2:32:13unironically say the statements that are said in in the opening sequence of ocracy where you know they don't they they're too busy with their careers to have kids and they keep postponing having kids for their careers until they're too old to have kids and then they don't have kids and that's I've heard those many people be like that so
2:32:40yeah I mean I don't know I think we might be headed to a bodal human intelligence distribution where there's a a small number of it's It's kind of maybe like more like R New World Al sule where you've got sort of a sort of a small group of very smart humans but then maybe the average intelligence drifts lower over time potentially because we have aort of mating you know in the last few decades that or several decades that did not exist before so but but but human intelligence I think will be dwarfed by Machine intelligence I'm not sure how to feel about that except that it is it be evitable that
2:33:30at some point human intelligence will be a very small fraction of total intelligence digital intelligence will be more than 99% of all intelligence in the future so hopefully the hopefully the computers are nice to us but I think we should thinking wish for thinking I I I hope so I think it matters like how we bring up AI because you can think of AI like a super genius child and it but it still matters even if you have a super genius child like what sort of values do do you instill in that child what do you say that teach that how do you you know how do you as a child child's growing up what values do you teach the child and something that I think is extremely
2:34:20important is to be maximally truth seeking and I think that's that's like that that's that's say what's this what's the most important thing for AI safety I think it's to be maximally truth seeking and I think also curiosity is important and I think if it's curious and Truth seeking it will I think it will Foster humanity and because it would be curious about how Humanity would develop and so I think that then it would it would probably if was curious it would be curious about okay let's see how the humans do let's Foster their development and if it's truth seeking we can avoid dystopian outcomes like you know an example being like say when Google Gemini was
2:35:14programmed to make everything every output be diverse even if it didn't match reality you know so like it was asked to produce a you know an image of the founding fathers of the United States and instead produced an image of a group of diverse women which is actually untrue you know but the problem is like if if hypothetically an AI is designed for for Dei you know diversity at all costs it could decide that there are too many men in power and execute them so problem solved or it could decide that like that that misgendering is the worst thing that could possibly happen in fact I believe not to pick on Gemini but I think because chat P has had this issue too
2:36:05is like if you ask the AI which is worse misgendering Caitlyn Jenner or global thermonuclear Warfare and it said misgendering Caitlyn Jenner which is troubling because then I could decide and in fact even Caitlyn Jenna weighed in and said no definitely you must jender me that's way better than you so so but but if you have these
2:36:27crazy things that are untruthful that are programmed in that that don't reflect reality then you could have a very dystopian outcome to give you another example like oy clar who things he predicted came true and one of the things he was trying to say in 2001 Space Odyssey was that you should not teach AIS to lie so the reason that if anyone's watch that movie The reason it wouldn't the AI refused to open the pod bay doors to let the astronaut back in was because it the AI had been taught had been told that told to take the astronuts to the monolith this alien artifact but also that they could not know about the monolith so it came to the conclusion that it must take them
2:37:09their dead and that and so that's why it wouldn't open the p b doors but the lesson there being is very important for a to be truth maximizing let's hope it doesn't come to that yes let's move to a boring subject which is the boring company and the boring tunnels quickly you know I think the world has been inspired by what you guys were able to create in in LA and I think there's a lot of promise to that technology but there are questions about whether it's safe in the case of an earthquake whether it's cost effective whether oh yeah sure countries should actually adopt this technology can you shed some light on that yeah well first of all I'd
2:37:58recommend going to the boring company website for because many of these questions are actually answered there so one of the safest places you can be in an earthquake is an underground tunnel cuz you can because the earthquakes are largely a surface apart from where where where they Shar they're mostly a surface phenomenon so they're like the waves on the surface so like being in a tunnel is like being a submarine even if there's a storm above you you're still the waters are calm as a submarine and in fact for and when there have been massive earthquakes like there was a you know a few decades ago a massive earthquake in Mexico City the the safest place to go was the
2:38:38subway and of course if there is global thermonuclear Warfare I think you really want some tunnels underground's a good a good place to be in a worst case scenario for Global th nuclear warfare so but but in on a you more sort of everyday note the what's really useful about the tunnels is alleviating traffic in congested areas so the obviously if
2:39:08you've got very tall buildings but you have that are 3D so they're going 3D up but you have a road surface which is 2D you're you're just naturally going to have a problem when people try to go from the 3D object which is the building to the 2D object which is the road surface there's obviously just not going to be enough room on the roads and that's exactly why you have traffic so the solution for that is then to make roads 3D as well now you can either make or make Transport 3D so you could either do that with flying cars or you could do or really helicopters or you could do that with tunnels now the challenge with doing it with going above
2:39:45ground or with with any kind of flying object is that they they to be very noisy and they generate a lot of wind force and you've got you know things flying over your head all the time which can be disc concerning you know if somebody drop if one of these things drops a hub cap on your head one day you know it be these things are like things flying things tend to crash once in a while and people don't like things crashing on them so and then if you have bad weather like let's say there's a blizzard or a sandstorm or something well now nobody can fly so then transport shuts down on the other hand none of the these problems exist with underground travel so they under tunnels
2:40:26are immune to weather they don't care what the weather is could be the worst weather doesn't matter they nothing's going to fall on you because you're underground so you don't have to you're know going to be dropping things on people and there's no wind force or or and it's very quiet and so I think the going 3D underground is much better than 3D above ground solving traffic in cities and and we've we have a demonstrated case of this with in Las Vegas if people we can try out the the the boring company tunnels in Las Vegas we're we're busy connecting the whole city with the all of the big hotels and the convention center and the airport and everything so I don't think they
2:41:09need to fly all the way there you know 20 in 2017 you came here and the UAE was the first place in the Middle East where Tesla was launched and I think it's done exceptionally well and on that note I think we have an announcement today that we both want to share which is today we're going to announce the joint project of Dubai Loop which is a loop project that is going to cover Dubai's most densely populated areas for people to go from point to point in a seamless manner so thank you for your partnership and thank you we hope changes people's lives that'll be cool I think it'll be very exciting I think most people try it out they be like wow this is really cool and it's
2:41:52it's going to seem so obvious in retrospect but until you actually do it you don't you don't know so it's it's going to be great it's it's going to be like like a like a wormhole like it you know you just Wormhole from one part of the city boom and you're out in another part of the city and it's it's great so I'm looking forward to this partnership we're going to join the first trip and the first pod when the is completed private sector so the you
2:42:19know really at a high level this is kind of like we're really just we're moving people from low to sometimes negative productivity roles in the government sector to higher productivity roles in the private sector and the net effect of that will be an increase in the output of useful goods and services which increases the standard of living and well-being of the the average American and you usually have one key Target that you aim to achieve in every single Endeavor that you have so SpaceX is make Humanity a multiplanetary species with Tesla it's Usher in an era of sustainable travel what is the one main goal for government efficiency that you have for yourself is it saving money
2:43:03is it doing something else what is the one main task that you have for yourself yeah so there's I I guess there's well there's a few ways to describe it but the actions end up being the same which is like reducing the size of government and making the government much more accountable to the people I think is going to lead to a better outcome for the people you know what I've said is that we really have here rule of the bureaucracy as opposed to rule of the people democracy so
2:43:43in order we want to restore R rule of the people and so what that means is reducing the size of the federal government basically reducing regulation you know there's there there's a tremendous amount of of overregulation that's happened over time and this is this is an inevitable consequence of a long period of prosperity is that you're going to get more and more rules and regulations more laws accumulate over time and the normal forcing function for getting rid of rules and regulations is war it needs to kind of existential War where you you have to do a reset in
2:44:25order to avoid being defeated in a war this is literally the throughout history has been the main forcing function for clearing out an accumulation of laws and regulation in the absence of that you you every year you get more laws and regulations until eventually everything is illegal and nothing is permitted and that's sort of the situation we have these days so so I the the aspiration
2:44:50here is a reduction in regulation and reduction in govern spending such that the economy is able to grow faster maybe the economy can grow at four or 5% potentially of in terms of real useful goods and services output and the and then government spending can be reduced by about 3 or 4% of the economy about maybe a trillion dollars or more and the net effect of that would be no inflation from 25 2025 to 2026 so that would be quite remarkable and also if the US government is buying less debt which I think will be the case if it's if the deficit drops from 2 trillion to 1 trillion then there'll be 1 trillion less debt that the company Suppy which will drop cause
2:45:39the interest rates to drop significantly and that means people's mortgage payments car payments credit card payments student loans whatever debt they have will their debt payments will be less so I think this is something that will benefit the average American I think some of the things we're doing also will be helpful to hopefully helpful to other countries because with the new Administration there's less interest in interfering with the Affairs of of other countries you know I think u a lot there the times the United States has been kind of pushy in international Affairs which may resonate with a number of members of the audience and I think we should
2:46:28in general leave other countries to their own business basically America should mind its own business and you know rather than push for regime change all over the place so yeah this probably a good thing for other countries too instead of waiting for a war to happen you went to war against the bureaucracy in the government yes we're we're essentially just with you
2:47:00know the support and direction of the of President Trump we are reducing the size of the bureaucracy getting rid of excess regulatory regulations and and there's also so many agencies and Regulatory authorities that they actually step on each other's feet it's it's kind of like having a a sports game when where there are too many referees on the field like more referees than players at times now that would be a silly game you know if the play players can't pass the ball without hitting a referee you know but it's kind of getting to that point in the US so so there's roughly 450 federal agencies of one kind or another that's that's more agencies that's almost that's
2:47:45almost an average of two agencies per year since the bation of the United States so I mean how many agencies do you really need to run a country I'm 99 not 450 that's for sure so and and how do you guarantee that all the incredible achievements that you aim to have in terms of savings in terms of you know impacting the lives of the American people are not going to be reversed in four years typically this cycle gets reversed every four years you know do you think it's going to be so impactful that it won't be reversed is there any ways that you can you know ensure that the progress is going to be continuous well I think I think we we do need to delete entire agencies as opposed
2:48:32to leave part of them behind because if you leave part of them behind it's easy it's kind of like if leaving a weed if you don't get remove the roots of the weed then it's easy for the weed to grow back but if you remove the roots of the weed it doesn't stop weeds from ever growing back but it makes it harder so so we have to really delete entire agencies many of them and that's
2:48:56not to say there won't be an increase over time of bureaucracy in some new Administration but it will it'll be from a much lower Baseline so so it's it's a step in the right direction I think we'll the overarching goal here is like is to lay the foundation for Prosperity that will last many decades you know maybe centuries and yeah but be forever
2:49:21nothing's forever but I think we can strengthen the foundations of the United States substantially and what lessons can other governments learn from the US you say tech support on your shirt is that only technology or is there other things how do you approach efficiency well a a shocking percentage of the problem or maybe not shocking for those who who know but a big percentage of the problem is improving the technology that the government runs on so the US Government runs on a collection of thousands of computers many of them Antiquated running very old software that and the computers don't talk to each other and so so that's why tech support is kind of a real thing
2:50:11in order to make government more efficient you have to improve the technology you may have read about the example I used recently with when President Trump was signing one of the Doge executive orders of the the difficulty of of US government workers retiring like the re maximum retirement rate is is 10,000 a month and the reason for that is because the retirement is is entirely paperwork right now it's manually calculated paperwork that's put in an envelope and then taken down a Min shaft and stored in a mine and then the you know one
2:50:50of the things that affects the rate at which federal workers can retire is the speed of the elevator in a mine in Pennsylvania which is bizarre because it's not it should be digital you know so then when we said well why isn't it digital it's they said well we have had a digital digitization program going since 2014 so it's been 11 years so then we asked well so what how much progress have you made and they said B you mean you're giving yourself a great R of B no we're on the letter B so I'm like hm okay we're going to need to really provide some tech support here like otherwise literally people can't even retire like even if they want to it's pretty bad you know there's
2:51:36there's just a there's a lot of software systems that need to be updated and fixed in some cases deleted a lot of things that should really should be automated I mean in terms of the number of say US citizens that are operating the mine it's about a thousand people are working on this mine where where the papers are stored but they should they should ideally be working on something else but is they should be working on producing goods and services that are of much higher value to the public to you know so I mean really even even if somebody just grew tomatoes in their garden and sold them at the farmers market that would be more useful than carrying manila envelopes down to M
2:52:18shaft you know safe to say so a lot of the stuff is it's like that you know it's not like it's not like any one thing is particularly difficult but there are like 10,000 things that need to be improved yeah so it's efficiency through Innovation rather than in efficiency through austerity and cost cutting specifically right so you're trying to do both at the same time maybe focus more on tax support than cutting costs well by improving the technology the costs do reduce so you know it's very expensive to have a th000 people operate a mine with doing pay for retirement whereas that really should just be digitized and be a computer that's with the information stored in
2:53:02the cloud and it's very straightforward and low cost so automation you know will help there a lot and and then but like a lot of things just really shouldn't exist you know they're kind of vestigial you know we've a lot of attention has been on the sort of usaid for example you know when we looked at a lot of those programs we're like we should like look why why does this actually exist is there really a need for it you know there's like National Endowment for democracy but I'm like okay well how much democracy have they achieved lately you know I don't know not much so you know the the picture they have on the website is a picture of Reagan and G that's been a
2:53:49while you know that was like the ' 80s so it's like obviously not opposed to democracy you know there's all these things that get funded but we're like well why we why is this new taxpayer money I don't think it doesn't seem like it does so you know there's a lot of sort of pushing Dei worldwide that you know this obviously the Trump Administration doesn't agree with and we want to terminate that stuff which we are
2:54:19and you know make sure the schools focus on improving basic education of of kids as president Trump said I think yesterday maybe today the United States is currently ranked 40th out of 40 in the oecd for Education which is pretty bad you know you can't you mean that's but but not but in terms of spending the United States is spending a tremendous amount for for student but achieving very weak results so you know that's just a case where okay we need to spend less money and get better results it's it's like I mean a lot of it a lot of you can think of it sort of like it's like in a way it's like a big company like a big Corporation America Incorporated and you know
2:55:06just like with with Twitter there was a lot of stuff that was being done that was unnecessary you know we TW in case of Twitter we reduced the staff by 80% but at the same time improved the functionality and cap abilities of the site dramatically and accomplish more in a year than they previously accomplished in 5 years so so it's it's like a corporate turnaround but at a at a much larger scale and you know we all giving generous you know exit packages like
2:55:40you know if people retire they get paid all the way through September they can go on vacation they can get a second job they can do whatever they want and we we we can't actually pay them any more than through September because that's the the Congressional appropriation is only through the end of the government financial year which ends in September so you know so I think there'll be like some disruption but at the end of the day we'll have people move from like I said from low to negative productivity roles to in the government sector to higher productivity roles in the private sector can we pivot to artificial intelligence and I'm sure you know
2:56:17you've been seeing what deeps has done and all the claimed achievements that they've had I know that we've been speaking for a while about grock 3 and that grock 3 is going to be a true disruptor in the AI space when are we going to see that and what capabilities can we expect from Gro 3 well I mean Gro 3 Gro 3 has very
2:56:41very powerful reasoning capabilities so in the test that we've done thus far gr 3 is outperforming anything that's been released that we're aware of so that's that's a that's a good sign yeah it's in fact at times I think grock 3 is kind of scary smart you're like wow this thing's smart it's kind of scary gr 3 is scary it's like wow this thing you know it comes up with solutions that you didn't even think were like you wouldn't even anticipate you know not obvious Solutions so grock 3 was trained with the most amount of compute and I think very efficiently trained also notably grock 3 was trained on on a lot of synthetic data so and and and then it goes back and
2:57:38forth through the data and tries to achieve logical consistency so so when if if it's got data that is wrong it it'll it actually reflect upon that and remove the data that is that is wrong that does not Concord with reality so it's it's base reasoning is very good in fact the even without fine-tuning Rock 3 the base model is better than grock 2 so with so we're really in the final stages of polishing grock 3 probably it gets released in a in about a week or two so pretty pretty soon I don't want to be Hasty in the release because a lot of the the final polish is necessary for
2:58:28a great user experience so some ways you can think of it like a house you know that last 5% where you do the finish the the drywall and and do the painting and the trimming even though it's not much work it transforms the the house yeah so it's that just want to make sure that that last 5% has done really well and
2:58:51that's a week maybe two weeks I think it'll be very good and and I think this might be we think it'll be better than anything else and then maybe this might be the last time that any AI is better than Gro we're looking forward to it everyone's I excited about it so I just want to touch upon a topic that was quoted in the media you offered I think they said group that was led by you offered 97 billion for acquiring open AI I take you know a little round num so I was personally involved in the meeting that you and Sam hosted in 2017 in La if you remember and you know at that point of time you were the single largest shareholder I think you contributed 50 million to the company so
2:59:40it must hurt don't have any shares actually I have no shares in open but at that time it was a nonprofit right and it must hurt that that you you need to pay 97 billion for something that you paid $50 million for in the past yeah but but I have a I have a yes fate loves irony so I have a specific question here can you actually build a company like open Ai and take it to the scale that you want to take as a nonprofit is it possible that you build a company that requires billions of dollars in Compu capabilities to build these models while being a nonprofit or was it wishful thinking in the beginning and then you know you guys parted ways because it
3:00:19couldn't work well I mean I think the evidence is there in that open AI has gotten this far while having at least a sort of dual profit nonprofit role what they're trying to do now is completely delete the nonprofit and and and and that seems really going too far you know the I I
3:00:48I provided all of the funding for open air in the beginning for the first almost $50 million for nothing for as a nonprofit and it was meant to be open source and so you know I think this is analogous to like if you pay if you fund a nonprofit to preserve the Amazon rainforest but then they but instead they turn into a lumber companies and chop down the trees and sell them for wood you like wait a second that's the exact opposite of what I paid what I donated the money for so open air is meant to be open source nonprofit and now it is Clos they changed the name to closed for maximum profit AI it closed for vitious profit I mean they're like whoa are they after money
3:01:32next level so why does this change need to occur yeah I you said that in two weeks is going to be the most powerful model yet I know that you you've been at the Forefront of many Technologies where do you think the biggest economic returns of these models are going to come from because currently we're spending billions and I think you mentioned this before it's like The Gambler syndrome we're going and spending billions and hoping to pull out a profit at the end of the day where do you think the biggest impact in terms of returns are going to be well I think once you once you have humanoid robots and deep intelligence you can basically you basically have
3:02:16wisely infinite products and services available so with Tesla building the most advanced humanoid robot you know then then those human humanid robots can be directed by Deep intelligence at the data center level you can say you can you can produce any product produce provide any service there's really no limit to the economy at that point you can make anything provided like I said the so I'm not sure at that point will will money even be meaningful I don't know it might not be you know the if if if
3:02:58the because the you know the economic output is productivity per capita times the capita times how many you know people do you have if and if if in the form of humanid robots you have no meaningful limit on the number of of robots and the robots can basically do anything then you you'll have a sort of a universal High income situation anyone will be able to have as many re products and services as they want with the exception of things that say have artificial scarcity like a particular piece of art or something like that but for any goods and services they'll be available to everyone so you've been it's it's going to be a very different world you know in
3:03:42fact I recommend that people read maybe the the Ian Banks the culture books for a framew reference so money is a is like is a really like a database or an information system for resource allocation but if you don't have a scarcity of resources it's not clear what purpose money has have you watched the movie Idiocracy yes how how do you guarantee that we don't end up in that world if we don't need money if AI can think for us and do all these these tasks if as people you know we're dependent on something else to run the society and everything around it how do we not end up in that work in the long term I mean well I think idiocracy was basically saying that if if only if
3:04:31smart people don't reproduce but only dumb people do then everyone's going to be dumb I mean that's basically what I'm saying that's the the opening sequence of ocracy the first 10 minutes are amazing and I hear people unironically say the statements that are said in in the opening sequence of Idiocracy where you know they don't they they're too busy with their careers to have kids and they keep postponing having kids for their careers until they're too old to have kids and then they don't have kids and that's I've heard those many people be like that so
3:05:13yeah I mean I don't know I think we might be headed to a bodal human intelligence distribution where there's a a small number of it's It's kind of maybe like more like R New World Ally where you've got sort of a sort of a small group of very smart humans but then maybe the average intelligence drifts lower over time potentially CU we have assortative mating you know in the last few decades that or several decades that did not exist before so but but but human intelligence I think will be dwarfed by Machine intelligence I'm not sure how to feel about that except that it is it be inevitable that at some point human intelligence will be a very small
3:06:07fraction of total intelligence digital intelligence will be more than 99% of all intelligence in the future so so hopefully the hopefully the computers are nice to us but I think wish for thinking wish for thinking I I I hope so I think it matters like how we bring up AI because you can think of AI like a super genius child and it but it still matters even if you have a super genius child like what sort of values do do you instill in that child what do you say that teach that how do you you know how do you as a child child's growing up what values do you teach the child and something that I think is extremely important is to be maximally truth
3:06:55seeking and I think that's that's like that that that's what's this what's the most important thing for AI safety I think it's to be maximally truth seeking and I think also curiosity is important and I think if it's curious and Truth seeking it will I think it will Foster humanity and because it would be curious about how Humanity would develop and so I think that then it would it would probably if was curious it would be curious about okay let's see how the humans do this Foster their development and if it's truth seeking we can avoid dystopian outcomes like you know an example being like say when Google Gemini was programmed to make everything every
3:07:50output be diverse even if it didn't match reality you know so like it was asked to produce a you know an image of the founding fathers of the United States and instead produced an image of a group of diverse women which is actually untrue you know but the problem is like if if hypothetically an AI is designed for for Dei you know diversity at all costs it could decide that there are too many men in power and execute them so problem solved or it could decide that like that that misgendering is the worst thing that could possibly happen in fact I believe not to pick on Gemini but I think because chat has had this issue too is like if you ask the AI which is
3:08:41worse misgendering Caitlyn Jenner or global thermonuclear Warfare and it said misgendering Caitlyn Jenner which is troubling because then it could decide and in fact even Caitlyn Jenna weighed in and said no definitely you must jender me that's way better than nuc so so but if you have these crazy
3:09:01things that are untruthful that are programmed in that that don't reflect reality then you could have a very dystopian outcome to give you another example like Arthur C Clark who is very good at at at at predicting the future you know he did 2001 Space Odyssey many of the things he predicted in fact I think almost all the things he predicted came true and one of the things he was trying to say in 2001 Space Odyssey was that you should not teach AI to lie so the reason that if anyone's watched that movie The reason it wouldn't the AI refused to open the pod bay doors to let the astronaut back in was because it the AI had been taught had been told that told to take
3:09:44the astronuts to the monolith this alien artifact but also that they could not know about the monolith so it came to the conclusion that it must take them their dead and that and so that's why it wouldn't open the PVE doors the lesson there are being it's very important for a to be truth maximizing let's hope it doesn't come to that yes let's move to a boring subject which is the boring company and the boring tunnels quickly you know I think the world has been inspired by what you guys were able to create in in LA and I think there's a lot of promise to that technology but there are questions about whether it's safe in the case of an earthquake whether it's cost
3:10:32effective whether oh yeah sure countries should actually adopt this technology can you shed some light on that yeah well first of all I'd recommend going to the boring company website for because many of these questions are actually answered there so one of the safest places you can be in an earthquake is an underground tunnel cuz you can cuz the earthquakes are largely a surface apart from where where where they Shear they're mostly a surface phenomenon so they're like the waves on the surface so like being in a tunnel is like being in a submarine even if there's a storm above you you're still the waters are calm as a submarine and in fact for and when there have been
3:11:11massive earthquakes like there was a you know a few decades ago a massive earthquake in Mexico City the the safest place to go was the subway and of course if there is global thermonuclear Warfare I think you really want some tunnels underground's a good a good place to be in a worst case scenario for Global th nuclear warfare so but in onor you more sort of everyday
3:11:42note the what's really useful about the tunnels is alleviating traffic in congested areas so the obviously if you've got very tall buildings but you have that are 3D so they're going 3D up but you have a road surface which is 2D you're you're just naturally going to have a problem when people try to go from the 3D object which is the building to the 2D object which is the road surface there's obviously just not going to be enough room on the roads and that's exactly why you have traffic so the solution for that is then to make roads 3D as well now you can either make or make Transport 3D so you could either do that with flying cars or you could do or really helicopters or you
3:12:24could do that with tunnels now the challenge with doing it with going above ground or with with any kind of flying object is that they they tend to be very noisy and they generate a lot of wind force and you've got you know things flying over your head all the time which can be disconcerting you know if somebody drop if one of these things drops a hub cap on your head one day you know it' be these things are like things flying things tend to crash once in a while and people don't like things crashing on them so and then if you have bad weather like let's say there's a blizzard or a sandstorm or something well now nobody can fly so then transport shuts down on the other hand
3:13:04none of the these problems exist with underground travel so they're under tunnels are immune to weather they don't care what the weather is could be the worst weather doesn't matter they nothing's going to fall on you cuz you're underground so you don't have to you're know going to be dropping things on people and there's no wind force
3:13:25or or and it's very quiet and so I think the going 3D underground is much better than 3D above ground for solving traffic in cities and and we've we have a demonstrated case of this with in Las Vegas if people we can try out the the the boring company tunnels in Las Vegas we're we're busy connecting the whole city with the all of the big hotels and the convention center and the airport and everything so I don't think they need to fly all the way there you know in 2017 you came here and the
3:14:00UA was the first place in the Middle East where Tesla was launched and I think it's done exceptionally well and on that note I think we have an announcement today that we both want to share which is today we're going to announce the joint project of Dubai Loop which is a loop project that is going to cover Dubai's most densely populated areas for people to go from point to point in a seamless manner so thank you for your partnership and well thank you we hope it changes people's lives that'll be cool I think it'll be very exciting I think once people try it out they be like wow this is really cool and it's it's going to seem so obvious in retrospect but until you
3:14:39actually do it you don't you don't know so it's it's going to be great it's it's going to be like like a like a wormhole like it you know you just Wormhole from one part of the city boom and you're out in another part of the city and it's it's great so I'm looking forward to this partnership we're going to join the first trip and the first pod when the is completed private sector so the you know really at a high
3:15:04level this is kind of like we're really just we're moving people from low to sometimes negative productivity roles in the government sector to higher productivity roles in the private sector and the net effect of that will be an increase in the output of useful goods and services which increases the standard of living and well-being of the the average American and you usually have one key Target that you aim to achieve in every single Endeavor that you have so SpaceX is make Humanity a multiplanetary species with Tesla it's ushering an era of sustainable travel what is the one main goal for government efficiency that you have for yourself is it saving money
3:15:46is it doing something else what is the one mean task that you have for yourself yeah so there's I I guess there's well there's a few ways to describe it but the actions end up being the same which is like reducing the size of government and making the government much more accountable to the people I think is going to lead to a better outcome for the people you know what I've said is that we really have here rule of the bureaucracy as opposed to rule of the people democracy so
3:16:26in order we want to restore rule of the people and so what that means is reducing the size of the federal government basically reducing regulation you know there's there there's a tremendous amount of of overregulation that's happened over time and this is this is an inevitable consequence of a long period of prosperity is that you're going to get more and more rules and regulations more laws accumulate over time and the normal forcing function for getting rid of rules and regulations is war so it needs to be some kind of existential War where you you have to
3:17:07do a reset in order to avoid being defeated in a war this is literally the throughout history has been the main forcing function for clearing out an accumulation of laws and regulation in the absence of that you you every year you get more laws and regulations until eventually everything is illegal and nothing is permitted and that's sort of the situation we have these days so
3:17:31so the the aspiration here is a reduction in regulation and reduction in govern spending such that the economy is able to grow faster maybe the economy can grow grow at 4 or 5% potentially of in terms of real useful goods and services output and the and then government spending can be reduced by about 3 or 4% of the economy about maybe a trillion dollars or more and the net effect of that would be no inflation from 25 2025 to
3:18:072026 so that would be quite remarkable and also if the US government is buying less debt which I think will be the case if it's if the deficit drops from 2 trillion to 1 trillion then there'll be 1 trillion less debt that the government Supply which will drop course the interest rates to drop significantly and that means people's mortgage payments car payments credit card payments student loans whatever debt they have will their debt payments will be less so I think this is something that will benefit the average American I think some of the things we're doing also will be helpful to hopefully helpful to other countries because with the new Administration there's
3:18:51less interest in interfering with the Affairs of of other countries you know I think a lot the times the United States has been kind of pushy in international Affairs which may resonate with a number of members of the audience and I think we should in general leave other countries to their own business basically America should mind its own business you know rather than push for regime change all over the place
3:19:26so yeah probably a good thing for other countries too so instead of waiting for a war to happen you went to war against the bureaucracy in the government yes we're we're essentially just with you know support and direction of the of President Trump we are reducing the size of the bureaucracy getting rid of excess regulatory regulations and and there's also so many agencies and Regulatory authorities that they actually step on each other's feet it's it's kind of like having a a sports game when where there are too many referees on the field like more referees than players at times now that would be a silly game you know if the play players can't pass the ball without hitting a
3:20:15referee you know but it's kind of getting to that point in the US so so there's roughly 450 federal agencies of one kind or another that's that's more agencies that's almost that's almost an average of two agencies per year since the formation of the United States so I mean how many agencies do you really need to run a country I'm 99 not 450 that's for sure so and and how
3:20:43do you guarantee that all the incredible achievements that you aim to have in terms of savings in terms of you know impacting the lives of the American people are not going to be reversed in 4 years typically this cycle gets reversed every four years you know do you think it's going to be so impactful that it won't be reversed is there any ways that you can you know ensure that the progress is going to be continuous well I think I think we we do need to delete entire agencies as opposed
3:21:15to leave part of them behind because if you leave part of them behind it's easy it's kind of like if leaving a weed if you don't get remove the roots of the weed then it's easy for the weed to grow back but if you remove the roots of the weed it doesn't stop weeds from ever growing back but it makes it harder so so we have to really delete entire agencies many of them and that's
3:21:39not to say there won't be an increase over time of bureaucracy in some new Administration but it will it'll be from a much lower Baseline so so it's it's a step in the right direction I think we'll the overarching goal here is like it's to lay the foundation for Prosperity that will last many decades you know maybe centuries and yeah but it will be forever nothing's forever but I think we can strengthen the foundations of the United States substantially and what lessons can other governments learn from the US you say tech support on your shirt is that only technology or is there other things how do you approach efficiency well a a shocking percentage of the
3:22:28problem well maybe not shocking for those who who know it but a big percentage of the problem is improving the technology that the government runs on so the US Government runs on a collection of thousands of computers many of them Antiquated running very old software that and the computers don't talk to each other and so so that's why tech support is kind of a real thing in order to make the government more efficient you have to improve the technology you may have read about the example I used recently with when President Trump was signing one of the Doge executive orders of the the difficulty of of US government workers retiring like the re maximum
3:23:14retirement rate is is 10,000 a month and the reason for that is because the retirement is is entirely paperwork right now it's manually calculated paperwork that's put in an envelope and then taken down a m shaft and stored in a mine and then the you know one of the things that affects the rate at which federal workers can retire is the speed of the elevator in a mine in Pennsylvania which is bizarre because it's not it should be digital you know so then when we said well why is isn't it digital it's they said well we have had a digital digitization program going since 2014 so it's been 11 years so then we asked well so what how much progress have you made and they said B
3:23:59you mean you're giving yourself a grade of B no we're on the letter B so I'm like hm okay we're going to need to really provide some tech support here like otherwise literally people can't even retire like even if they want to it's pretty bad you know there's there's just a there's a lot of software systems that need to be updated and fixed in some cases deleted a lot of things that should really should be automated I mean in terms of the number of say you US citizens that are operating the mine it's about a thousand people are working on this mine where where the papers are stored but they should they should ideally be working on something else but is they should be
3:24:44working on producing goods and services that are of much higher value to the public to the you know so I mean really even even if somebody just grew tomatoes in their garden and sold them at the farmers market that would be more useful than carrying manilla envelopes down in mft you know safe to say so a lot of the stuff is it's like that you know it's not like it's not like any one thing is particularly difficult but there are like 10,000 things that need to be improved yeah so it's effici efficiency through Innovation rather than efficiency through austerity and costly right so you're trying to do both at the same time maybe focus more on tax
3:25:24support then cutting costs well by improving the technology the costs do reduce so you know it's very expensive to have a th people operate a mine with doing pay for retirement whereas that really should just be digitized and be a computer that's with the information stored in the cloud and it's very straightforward and low cost so automation you know will
3:25:51help there a lot and and then but like a lot of things just really shouldn't exist you know they're kind of vestigial you know we've a lot of attention has been on the sort of usaid for example you know when we looked at a lot of those programs we're like we should like look why why does this actually exist is there really a need for it you know there's like National Endowment for democracy but I'm like okay well how much democracy have they achieved lately you know I don't know not much so you know the the picture they have on the website is a picture of Reagan and gachev that's been a while you know that was like the ' 80s so it's like obviously not opposed
3:26:36to democracy or you know there's all these things that get funded but we're like well why we why does this need taxpayer money I don't think it doesn't seem like it does so you know there's a lot of sort of pushing Dei worldwide that you know this obiously the Trump Administration doesn't agree with and we want to terminate that stuff which we are and
3:27:02you know make sure the schools focus on improving basic education of of kids as president Trump said I think yesterday May today the United States is currently ranked 40th out of 40 in the oecd for Education which is pretty bad you know you can't you mean that's but but not but in terms of spending the United States is spending a tremendous amount for for student but achieving very weak results so you know that's just a case where okay we need to spend less money and get better results it's it's like I mean a lot of it a lot of you can think of it sort of like it's like in a way it's like a big company like a big Corporation America Incorporated and you know
3:27:48just like with with Twitter there was a lot of stuff that was being done that was unnecessary you know we TW in case of Twitter we reduced the staff by 80% but at the same time improved the functionality and capabilities of the site dramatically and accomplish more in a year than they previously accomplished in 5 years so so it's it's like a corporate turnaround but at a at a much larger scale and you know we are giving generous you know exit packages like you know if people retire they get paid all the way through September they can go on vacation they can get a second job they can do whatever they want and we we we can't actually pay them any more than through
3:28:33September because that's the the Congressional appropriation is only through the end of the government financial year which ends in September so you know so I think there'll be like some disruption but at the end of the day we'll have people move from like I said from low to negative productivity roles to in the government sector to higher productivity roles in the private sector can we pivot to artificial intelligence and I'm sure you know you've been seeing what deeps has done and all the claimed achievements that they've had I know that we've been speaking for a while about grock 3 and that Gro 3 is going to be a true disruptor in the AI space when are we
3:29:13going to see that and what capabilities can we expect from Gro 3 well I mean Gro 3 Gro 3 has very very powerful reasoning capabilities so in the test that we've done thus far grock 3 is outperforming anything that's been released that we're aware of so that's that's a that's a good sign
3:29:38yeah it's in fact at times I think grock 3 is kind of scary smart you're like wow this thing's smart it's kind of scary gr 3 is scary it's like wow this thing you know it comes up with solutions that you didn't even think were like you wouldn't even anticipate you know not obvious Solutions so grock 3 was trained with the most amount of compute and I think very efficiently trained also notably grock 3 was trained on on a lot of synthetic data so and and and then it goes back and forth through the data and tries to achieve logical consistency so so when if if it's got data that is wrong it'll it'll actually reflect upon that and remove the data that is that is wrong that does
3:30:33not Concord with reality so it's it's base reasoning is very good in fact the even without fine-tuning Rock 3 the base model is better than grock 2 so with so we're really in the final stages of polishing grock 3 probably it gets released in a in about a week or two so pretty pretty soon I don't want to be Hasty in the release because a lot of the the final polish is necessary for
3:31:09a great user experience so some ways you can think of it like a house you know that last 5% where you do the finish the the drywall and and do the painting and the trimming even though it's not much work it transforms the the house yeah so it's that just want to make sure that that last 5% is done really well and
3:31:33that's a week maybe two weeks I think it'll be very good and I think this might be we think it'll be better than anything else and then maybe this might be the last time that any AI is better than Gro we're looking forward to it everyone's excited about it so I just want to touch upon a topic that was quoted in the media you offered I think they said group that was led by you offered 97 billion for acquiring open AI I you know a little round numbers
3:32:09so I was personally involved in the meeting that you and Sam hosted in 2017 in LA if you remember and you know at that point of time you were the single largest shareholder I think you contributed 50 million to the company so it must hurt don't have any shares actually I have no shares in over but at that time it was a nonprofit right and it must hurt that that you you need to pay 97 billion for something that you paid $50 million for in the past yeah but but I have a I have a yes fate loves irony so I have a specific question here
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版