2024年11月,乔·罗根(Joe Rogan)在自己的播客里见到马斯克,开口第一句话是"谢谢你买下推特"。
紧接着补了一句:我不是夸张,你真的改变了历史的方向。我们本来在往一条全面审查、全面控制叙事的路上走。
马斯克的回答没有客套。他讲了一个很少被提起的私人原因。
收购之前,他是整个平台上互动量最高的账号。粉丝数比不过奥巴马这类账号,互动数排第一。系统里任何一处改动,他都能第一时间感觉到。
"我就像,这里有点不对劲。我越来越不安。"(马斯克)
这个说法听上去不像商业决策的依据,却解释了后面所有的事。一个重度用户对产品变化的敏感,最后变成了一笔440亿美元的收购。
封掉在任总统那天,他发的是"请不要暴乱"
罗根把2021年1月的那次封号称为分水岭。
马斯克说他看到的内容让他无法理解。特朗普账号被移除之前发的最后几条内容,大意是让大家保持冷静,不要打砸,不要破坏财产。
"你会想,这有什么问题?然后有人说,这是狗哨,他其实在说反话。"(马斯克)
罗根的反应更直接。你一边说他煽动了暴力,一边又说让他呼吁冷静是在说反话,这两件事没法同时成立。如果支持者真的听他的,让他喊停不就完了?
马斯克给出的方案更干脆:把账号还给他,让他自己发他认为该发的东西。结果他连"请大家冷静"都发不出来。
罗根把逻辑摊得更开。指控一个人煽动暴力,前提是他有号召力。承认他有号召力,却不让这个号召力去灭火,说不通。
他接着提到另一个层面。当时人群里确实有混进去的挑衅者在鼓动别人做违法的事。这套操作从1999年西雅图那场WTO抗议起就是公开的,算不上什么新鲜手段。
混在人群里的挑衅者,1999年就用过
罗根讲了一段1999年西雅图世贸组织部长级会议的抗议。
他说当时有人被派进人群,开始砸东西、点火。一场和平抗议在几十分钟内变成暴力事件,警察随即进场,一切被关闭。现场被划成"禁抗议区",你连车上贴一张画了红杠的WTO贴纸都不行。
第一修正案的集会权,在一次被制造出来的暴力之后消失了。
马斯克接回主线。他觉得美国正处在一个岔路口,而他收购推特的原因是,如果他不做,就没人会做。
440亿美元买下的,是一桩没人愿意接的生意
罗根问他,为什么是没人会做。
马斯克的回答很直白:这买卖不赚钱。价格明显偏高,长期看能给投资人一个交代,但他自己的原话是,这可不是一种轻松的谋生方式。
他还顺口提了一句,自己本来想戴一顶拿石油行业开玩笑的帽子来。
收购完成之后,真正的压力来自另一头。一批左翼非政府组织协调了一场广告主抵制,直到这次对话时还在持续。
罗根在这里替他说了一句:外界流传的说法是"马斯克不会做生意,推特买来时值440亿,现在少了400%",这套算法忽略了抵制本身,也忽略了一个更基本的事实,这家公司买来的时候就不值440亿。
组织抵制的机构,名字一个比一个正义
马斯克给了一个识别这类机构的方法:先看名字。
名字越像奥威尔小说里的部门,做的事情越相反。"反数字仇恨中心"(Center for Countering Digital Hate)在他嘴里是一家彻头彻尾的骗子公司,干的是审查的活,名字却顶着"仇恨"两个字。
这些机构不直接删帖。它们去找广告主,施压,让钱撤走。
马斯克给了两种前景。特朗普赢,抵制会大部分解除;哈里斯赢,抵制会加强,然后X会被想办法关掉。
罗根追问,真能关掉吗,路径是什么。
马斯克的答案只有一个词:司法部。
他们手里有整套现成的词,仇恨言论、虚假信息、错误信息。至于谁在真正传播错误信息,对起诉这件事没有影响。联邦司法部可以提起大规模诉讼,传票、律师团、几年时间的消耗,本身就是惩罚。
司法部起诉SpaceX:先锁定人,再去找罪
他举的例子是SpaceX。
司法部起诉这家公司,理由是它不雇用寻求庇护者(asylum seekers)。听起来像是一桩歧视案。
马斯克解释了两条法律怎么把人夹在中间。
SpaceX做的是航天运载技术,属于美国国际武器贸易条例(ITAR)管制下最严格的一类。这类技术如果落到朝鲜或者伊朗手里,可以拿来把核弹打到美国。按照ITAR,SpaceX不能雇用任何非美国永久居民,因为立法的前提假设是,这些人早晚要回国,会把火箭技术带回去。
与此同时,另一条法律说,歧视寻求庇护者是违法的。
两条法律同时成立,结果是这家公司雇用也违法,不雇用也违法。
司法部每年能打的大官司数量有限,它把其中一场用在SpaceX身上。
罗根的反应是:你看着机械臂接住助推火箭那一段,再想想司法部对这家公司发起集体诉讼,这两件事放在一起有多荒诞。几十年后的人回头看这段历史,大概会觉得难以理解。
马斯克引用了一句苏联时期的说法。贝利亚(Lavrentiy Beria)讲过,你给我一个人,我给你找出一条罪。先决定谁是目标,罪状之后再说。
他们指控特朗普要干的事,正是自己在干的
罗根点出这里的对称性。把司法部武器化,正是民主党和媒体反复说特朗普上台后会做的事。
马斯克的回应是,他们是公开在做,没有遮掩。
接着他把话题转到一个更日常的现象:同一批被反复推送的假消息。
他的态度是,政客夸大、说错话、偶尔不老实,这属于政治的一部分,可以理解。当同一批被彻底证伪的说法被有组织地反复推送,性质就变了。尤其是当你还自称是好人那一方、诚实那一方。
罗根补了一刀:连以事实核查著称的自由派网站都判定那些说法是假的,比如"非常好的人"(fine people)那一段。而奥巴马最近还在台上原样引用它。
马斯克的反应是,他们已经完全不在乎了,就这么平铺直叙地说。
"利兹·切尼应该被枪毙",这句话是怎么长出来的
具体例子是利兹·切尼(Liz Cheney)。
那几天马斯克收到大量信息,说特朗普要求处决利兹·切尼。他的原话是这纯属捏造。
特朗普的原意是:如果利兹·切尼真的要去前线打仗,她大概会重新考虑一下自己有多好战。
马斯克把这个逻辑摊开讲。在华盛顿吃精致晚餐的人,和在前线战壕里被屠杀的人,承受的代价完全不对等。发动战争的人不承担风险,承担风险的是别人。这种安排冷酷,缺乏同理心。
特朗普说的就是这一点:让她自己去前线,她的好战程度会下降。
然后这句话被加工成"他要把她送上行刑队",传统媒体大规模跟进。
罗根提到卡玛拉竞选团队的另一个操作。特朗普谈的是保护女性免受从边境偷渡进来的危险人物伤害,原话里有"不管女性喜不喜欢"这样的表述。竞选团队截取半句,把它包装成"他要剥夺女性的选择权",然后铺进每一支广告、每一场演讲、每一次新闻报道。
半句话,脱离语境,重复一万遍。
每小时150万播放,就是不 trending
罗根讲了自己那期特朗普采访在YouTube上的遭遇。播放量一度冲到每小时140万到150万,视频不上 trending 榜。
马斯克说这件事没有任何解释得通的理由。一个已知频道,不是昨天刚注册的,不做诈骗币生意,内容体量是当年最大的采访之一,然后你找不到它。
YouTube对外说他们做了一些处理,但不说做了什么。
好在同一份内容也发在了X上。仅罗根和马斯克两个账号加起来,播放量7000万。
罗根说了一句判断:如果没有你,他们现在应该已经彻底控制住社交媒体了。
他的推论是,疫情期间被封掉的不只是阴谋论者,还有大量提出不同意见的科学家、医生、流行病学家。这些人在一个被统一审查的环境里,没有出口。
马斯克补了一个旁证。扎克伯格后来公开谈要采取更接近自由意志主义的立场,这个转变是对X抬高水位线的反应。只要有一家公司愿意让争议留在平台上,其他平台的审查就会变得刺眼。这个效应不需要监管推动,只需要一个不配合的样本。
社区笔记:开源到任何人都能复现
罗根说他现在对付假消息的固定动作是:直接给原始素材。
有人说特朗普讲过某个骇人听闻的句子,他不辩论,发一个链接,让对方看完整视频。不要采信他的转述,也不要采信任何人的转述。看那个人实际说了什么,实际做了什么,看现场的真实录像。
马斯克补了另一层工具:社区笔记(Community Notes)。
它的机制是众包核查,重点落在透明上。所有软件开源,所有数据开源,任何一条已经发布的笔记,第三方都可以独立复现它的生成过程。
马斯克说他经常被要求删笔记,多数来自左边,偶尔来自右边。他的回答是,连自己账号下面的笔记他都不删。
他给出的理由是结构性的:整个系统全公开,他真动手删,会像在安静房间里敲了一下锣,藏不住。这事跟自律无关,跟系统的可见性有关。
罗根把这称为对抗错误信息最好的机制。马斯克的表述更简洁:对抗错误信息的办法是更好的信息。实时核查,几百万人在下面争论这条到底对不对,比任何编辑部的判断都更接近事实。
他甚至说,很多情况下连社区笔记都不需要。在回复区放上证据,说明这条为什么错,就够了。
第一修正案是障碍,这话是谁说的
罗根提到一批公开表态。卡坦吉·布朗·杰克逊(Ketanji Brown Jackson)、约翰·克里(John Kerry)、希拉里·克林顿,都在不同场合说过类似的话:第一修正案成了打击虚假信息的障碍。
马斯克的意思是,这条修正案为什么被写进去,历史原因很清楚。制定宪法的那批人来自这样的国家,说错话会被枪毙或者关进监狱。
罗根接着讲第二修正案。他在洛杉矶跟人争论过很多次。他的问法是:你能不能保证美国政府永远不会变成暴政?对方答不上来。那枪就得留着。
他承认这话在枪击案频发的语境里听起来刺耳,逻辑本身却有独立性。暴政在历史上真实发生过,现在也在别的地方发生,而且从很轻微的地方开始。
英国因为一条帖子把人关进监狱
马斯克提到英国的数字。因为社交媒体发帖被判刑的人,量级在几千。
这些案子的性质值得看清楚。帖子跟实际暴力之间没有明确关联,判决依据是"鼓励暴力"这个判断本身。
罗根追问:有没有人真的因为看了某条帖子去做了某件事?没有。
与此同时英国监狱系统爆满,为了腾出空间,实际在提前释放已经定罪的恋童癖者。另一边,有人因为发了一条Facebook帖子被关进去。
马斯克用了"疯狂"这个词,并说这一切还是左派在推动。
"普通人太蠢,会被骗"这个论证站不住
支持审查的常见论证是这样的:普通人没有能力分辨真假,会相信错误信息,然后有人会死,世界会被搞坏。
马斯克的回击是一句反问:你说这是错误信息,说明你认为自己比所有读到它的人都聪明。这个前提本身就悬空。
他补充了平台的实际运行方式。一条帖子发出来,下面立刻会有回复、有纠错、有反驳。真正缺乏纠错机制的是传统广播媒体,它们说错话是单向的,没有对应的反驳通道。
罗根接过话:那些广播媒体天天说错话,观众没有地方当场反驳。
没有人为俄罗斯门道过歉
马斯克举了两个例子。
一个是瑞秋·玛多(Rachel Maddow)在疫情期间的说法:打了疫苗就不会感染新冠,病毒到你这里就停了。这句话在当时没有证据支撑,属于纯宣传。她没有为此道歉,节目照常播。
另一个是俄罗斯门(Russiagate)。三年时间里,大量报道称特朗普被普京控制,说他被拿捏了。核心证据是斯蒂尔档案(Steele dossier),这份档案由珀金斯·科伊(Perkins Coie)律所的一名律师编造,费用由克林顿竞选团队支付。
事情查清之后,没有人道歉。希拉里照常出现在媒体上,很多人依然相信那套说法。
马斯克的落点是:这一整套运行方式没有追责环节,所以它能一直运行下去。
左派还是原来那个左派吗
两个人都说自己曾经属于左派。罗根说他这辈子一直是,马斯克说他三年前还是。
马斯克对左派的理解曾经是:追求自由,扩大个人自由,对人友善,有同理心,同时坚持个人自由和择优的社会。
他看到的变化是,现在的左派要压缩个人自由,言论自由首当其冲,同时用基于种族和性别的偏好取代择优。
罗根的表述更朴素。如果你不想让人讨论某些议题,你就没在执行人民的意志。你想让人闭嘴,只可能是因为你打算做一些别人不同意的事。这就是全部动机,没有别的解释。
马斯克补了一句:人们还在把特朗普叫法西斯,整套逻辑是反过来的,像穿过了镜子。
麦迪逊广场花园那场"纳粹集会"
例子是特朗普在麦迪逊广场花园(Madison Square Garden)的那场集会。
媒体的定性是"纳粹集会"。马斯克列了现场的事实:观众席里有以色列国旗,演讲者中大约四分之一是犹太人,各个种族、肤色、信仰的人都在场。他问,这里面哪一部分像纳粹集会。
MSNBC 的做法更直接。它播放1930年代纳粹集会的影像,和这场集会并排对比。
被忽略的事实是,麦迪逊广场花园办过几十场政治集会。吉米·卡特在那里演讲过,克林顿夫妇也在那里演讲过,民主党历届总统候选人几乎都在那里办过活动。
罗根把这类操作的受害对象点清楚了:不常上社交媒体、没时间逐条核实、只看传统媒体的人。这批人看到的世界,和X上的人看到的世界,是两套完全不同的东西。前者给结论,后者给过程。
推特文件:一个两周后自动清空的入口
罗根把推特文件(Twitter Files)称为这个信息时代最重要的材料之一,因为它第一次让外界看清政府对社交平台的日常干预是什么样。
马斯克的补充是,推特在这件事上态度积极。政府提出删帖要求,他们不但照做,还向政府报销工时费,金额以百万美元计。当时公司被一批立场鲜明的活动人士掌控,配合起来毫无阻力。
同样的操作也发生在Facebook身上。塔克·卡尔森(Tucker Carlson)节目的部分内容被限流,浏览量被压掉大约一半。这些被压的内容里,有事实层面的信息。
让他意外的地方在于记录本身的状
0:00Thank you so much for buying Twitter. You're welcome. Thank you so much. I'm not exaggerating when I think you changed the course of history. I really do. I really think you made a fork in the road. We were headed down a path of censorship and of control of narratives that is unprecedented.
0:20Forget about what they were able to do back when they had newspapers and the media under control. What they were doing with social media by suppressing information. and when you had a combined government effort, like what they were doing with the laptop story. We have 51 former intelligence agents saying this is Russian disinformation, take it offline.
0:41And Twitter complied. If you didn't buy that, we wouldn't have known that. We had no idea. Exactly. The reason I bought it was because I'm in a pretty attuned since I was like the most interacted with a user on Twitter before the acquisition. So before the acquisition, I had more interactions then there's some accounts like Obama and whatever had higher follow accounts, but I had the most
1:01number of interactions of any account in the system. So I was very attuned to if they saw change, if they change the system, I can tell immediately. And I'm like, I'm like, something weird is going on here. You know, I just got increasingly uneasy. And obviously, when they deplatformed
1:16to setting president, you know, not deplatform Trump, that was just insane, you know, and the things he was posting, like he was posting things that he was posting good things, he was saying, like, hey, do not riot, don't do any destruction or property, you know, please stay calm.
1:33That's the kind of stuff you're supposed to. Yeah. And you're like, what's wrong with that? That's, and then some people said, oh, that's like some sort of dog whistling. He means the opposite. I'm like, okay, so we'll give you Trump's account. Now you post what you think you should post because you can post nothing.
1:47You can ask people to calm down. Like what? It was insane. Like it didn't make any sense. Well, it's completely illogical. and you say it's dog whistling to tell his followers to not be violent. That's crazy. That's crazy. That's crazy. Don't you think they will listen to him? Yeah.
2:02Isn't that the whole point they listened to him and created violence in the first place? That's what you think. That's what you're accusing him of. Right. And then there's the fact that we know that there was agents in the crowd that were ancient provocateurs that were encouraging people to do illegal.
2:16Yes. We know that for a fact. This is not that there was always the big Alex Jones type Tin foil hat conspiracy theory, because Alex proposed that back at the World Trade Organization protests, I believe we're in Seattle in the 90s. And they sent in, Agent Profocatur started smashing things, lighting things on fire.
2:36Now all of a sudden, a peaceful protest is no longer peaceful. They move in the cops. They shut everything down. They had it set up where it was a no protest zone, where you couldn't even have a pin that had the WTO with a red line through it. They wouldn't let you go in through to go to work.
2:50So you couldn't prote, you couldn't exercise your first amendment right. You couldn't even have a peaceful protest, a fucking sticker on your car. You couldn't have that. It's crazy. It is crazy. I think we're very much in a folk in the road in Destiny. And I mean, the reason I, you know, the Twitter acquisition was like, if I don't do this, I think we're screwed.
3:09Is the issue. Well, if you didn't do it, no one else was gonna do it because it wasn't a financial winner. But it's kind of a crazy move. It's a crazy move. I mean, the thing was way overpriced. And long term, I think we ultimately make it a win for investors. But boy, this is a hard way to make a living.
3:25Well, there's also a concerted effort to suppress it. There's a concerted effort to the advertisers. Well, we had a, I still have a massive advertiser boycott that was organized by a bunch of left-wing NGOs. And I should have brought my, I have a hat, make oil well fiction again.
3:43I've seen that hat. Yeah, I should have brought, I was gonna wear my, I should have brought my make oil fiction again. but yeah, I mean, it's just totally, totally nuts. If you didn't do it, no one would have. And here's the hilarious narrative that I keep hearing from idiots. Elon's a bad businessman.
3:59Twitter is worth 400% less than when he bought it. No, it wasn't worth that in the first place. It wasn't worth that in the first place. It wasn't worth $44 billion wrong. And also, you're not taking into account the advertiser boycott. Exactly. That's total. Yeah, exactly. So there are these organizations, like you can tell this, They're like, when they have an Orwellian name.
4:20So like the Center for Countering Digital Hate is a total scam organization, because they're like the Ministry of Truth type of thing in Orwell. They're a censorship organization and they pushed the advertisers to boycott. So we still have, some of the boycott is starting to lift
4:39and I think if Trump wins, we'll see probably most of the boycott lift, But if Kamala wins, we'll see that boycott gets stronger. And they'll freaking shut down. There's no way that the sort of Kamala public regime would allow X to exist. You really think that they'll be able to shut it down though?
4:55Is there a pathway to that? Yes. What would they do? Well, I mean, they can just stick the DOJ on, you know, and say, they've had this whole thing about hate speech, misinformation, whatever, except the other one is pushing the misinformation. That doesn't stop them from filing massive lawsuits and using the DOJ.
5:13I mean, the DOJ is attacking SpaceX, for example, for not hiring asylum seekers, even though it is legal for SpaceX to hire anyone who is not a permanent resident of the US. So we're down if we do and down if we don't. Just an example of what DOJ can do. So it's illegal to hire someone who's not an American citizen.
5:33SpaceX is considered an advanced weapons technology. So it's covered by international traffic and arms regulations because we make rocket technology that can be used against the United States. Skiv North Korea or Iran got SpaceX rocket technology. They could use that to launch Nuke set America.
5:48Right. That would be bad. Yeah. That'd be really bad. That'd be really bad. So since we are in the most extreme category of weapons technology at SpaceX, under US-ITAR law, it is illegal for us to hire anyone who's not a permanent resident. Because the presumption is that if they're not a permanent resident, they're going to return to their home country and take the rocket technology with them.
6:10So it's illegal for us to hire anyone who's not a part of it. They can have a green card or be a citizen. They just have to be a permanent resident of the United States. Then there's another law that says, if you discriminate against asylum seekers, that's also, you're also breaking the law.
6:27So the DOJ can only do a small number of big lawsuits every year, launched a giant lawsuit against SpaceX, saying that SpaceX discriminated against asylum seekers. And we're like, bet it's illegal for us to hire anyone who's not a permanent resident. So we're in this one of the, oh, well, the, oh, well situation is getting insane.
6:46You're damned if you do and you're damned if you don't. So you're damned. Can you imagine history looking back at when you watch the robot arms catch the rocket and you realize this is like one of the greatest accomplishments in the history of aerospace. Like it is one of the most wildest accomplishments.
7:05When you watch that thing come and you see all this people Cheering and it catches it perfectly like holy Imagine how history is gonna look back at the DOJ going after that company. Yeah, how insane it is big lawsuit with an army of lawyers This was not like some minor thing, but doesn't even make any sense How could it even get brought to court if it's illegal? That's exactly so that's what I mean like basically if the government wants to go after you
7:30They'll just find a reason you know just like that famous quote from Baria. They had a Stalin's secret police and he's like, you've tortured a truly evil human being. Like this guy, Baria, one of his famous quotes was, show me the man and I'll show you the crime. They decide that you're the target and then they figure out the crime afterwards.
7:49That's the issue. They decided SpaceX was the target. They just figured out the crime afterwards. Which is so crazy because that's exactly what they're saying Trump is going to do if he gets into office. They're doing all the things that they accuse Trump of doing. Yeah, openly.
8:03Openly. Yeah. I mean, the sheer number of hoaxes that the Democratic Party is pushing over and over again. And they, and look, I understand like politicians are gonna exaggerate, they're gonna misspeak, and they'll tell occasional, you know, untruths, whatever. That's how it is in politics.
8:22But when you have deliberate, concerted, repeated pushing of hoaxes, you're like, wait a second, come on, man, this is too far. And you're supposed to be the good guys. You're supposed to, and you claim to be the good guys? I'm like, exactly. You're supposed to be the progressives.
8:37Yes, the Dems are like, oh, we're the good guys, we're the honest people. No, no, hang on, you can't claim to be the good guys. You can't claim to be the honest people. If you're deliberately pushing hoaxes that have been debunked thoroughly. Yeah, well, not just like even snopes, which is a liberal thing says as bogus.
8:53Yeah. Like the fine people hoax. Obama just said that on stage. Obama just said that, I was like, what the flunk? He doesn't give a, he doesn't give a, they're just, they're just flat out law flat out law. I love the other one where Kamala's campaign used what Trump was saying about protecting women and from illegal immigrants.
9:11Thank you. Remember that? Yeah. What he was saying is the women like it or not, I'm going to do it. Yeah. When he was saying that they were trying to say that he was taking away women's right to choose whether women like it or not. That's not what he was saying. Absolutely. He was literally talking about protecting them from dangerous people that are sneaking in through the border.
9:29Yes, exactly. They'll take like, not even a full sentence, like a half a sentence from the border. And then they'll push it on every ad, every speaking event, every media. And it gets repeated on the news. This is what's crazy. They'll talk about it on these new shows. It's quote, new shows.
9:46Yeah, exactly. I mean, a recent one that came up, a lot of people reached out to me, was like, oh, Trump says he wants to execute Liz Cheney. I'm like, that is utter. What's not what he said at all? It's not what he said at all. What he's saying is that, look, if Liz Cheney actually had to fight at the front lines, should think twice about going to war.
10:06Exactly. It's easy to go to war. It's easy to be a warmonger. If you don't have to risk dying at the front lines. If other, it basically gets fucked up. If people are having fancy dinners in Washington, DC, while people are being slaughtered and trenches, it's like you're not feeling the pain.
10:23Exactly. You're not taking the risk, it's someone else dying. Exactly. That's cruel and lacking in empathy. And all Trump was saying was that Liz Cheney would be much less of a warmonger because she's a huge warmonger, slightly her dad, if she actually had to go to the front lines and fight herself.
10:39And meanwhile, they're saying that he's saying she should be shot. Yes, which is a total lie. And I had tons of people calling me this weekend saying, oh, Trump says he's gonna put Liz Cheney in a firing squad. Like, that is an outrageous lie. And the legacy media ran with that lie, big time.
10:55Yeah, it's crazy. It's just wild to see. And if it wasn't for Twitter, I don't think we would know about all this stuff. I think it would be very difficult for you. I think YouTube throttled. They did something weird. They won't say what they did, but they did something weird with the Trump interview that I did.
11:10Well, you couldn't find it. It doesn't make sense. It made no sense. I mean, it was like the biggest interview on Earth. Yeah. And you can't find it. Yeah. Not only that, it was like trending. Bull. It wasn't trending. It wasn't trending. Wasn't trending. Like there's just no excuse for that, man.
11:25No excuse. There's no excuse. It was getting a million views, what was it? 1.4 an hour at one point, Tom? 1.5 an hour. Yeah. And it wasn't trending. Yeah. And it's like your channel is a known channel. It's not like it was started yesterday. It's like, this is a high trust, yours is a high trust channel.
11:44It's like you're not trying to sell your scam crypto coins. So. Well, thank God, we put it on X as well. Yeah, yeah. Because I think just with your account and my account alone, It's 70 million views. Well, it's like you can't hide things anymore because of you. And if it wasn't for you, I think they would have had total control of social media by now.
12:01They would have thrown the ban so many accounts during the pandemic, so many dissenting scientists and doctors and physicians. They banned so many conspiracy theorists, so many people that colored outside the lines. They would have done that everywhere. And it probably would have, I think even at what's going on at Facebook, they're being more lenient.
12:21You know, here Zuckerberg talking about taking a more libertarian stance. That's entirely reaction to the way Twitter has kind of moved the watermark. Exactly. As soon as any company steps out of line and is willing to actually have the truth of debated on their platform, it forces the other platforms to allow things to be
12:39more truthful to not censor because their censorship becomes glaringly obvious. Yes. Yes. And you know, the best thing I found for as a rebuttal, like if somebody, if there's a hoax, it's just go to the source material. You know, if somebody thinks, you know, Trump said that we should put those chain in a firing squad, I'm like, let me send you a link to X so you can watch his video.
13:04That's the best way. Yes. Don't take my opinion for it. Don't take anyone's opinion for it. Go to the source material. And community notes. Yes, and community notes is awesome. Community notes is the best. It's awesome. It's incredible. Yeah. Because everybody gets checked. Yes, including me.
13:17Yeah. And with community notes, the, all the software is open source and all the data is open source. So you can recreate any given note independently. That's amazing. Yeah. That's how it should be. It's a total absolute transparency in every way. You know, sometimes I get asked, oh, y'all can you remove a note?
13:35You know, mostly by the left, but sometimes by the right, I'm like, I'm like, I don't even remove notes on my own count. Nothing. And by the way, everything is totally open. So if I did that, it would stick out like a sore thumb immediately. Like it's not going to be subtle. That is the best counter to misinformation.
13:51Yes, absolutely. Let everybody look at it and say, okay, here's what the actual facts say. Yes, exactly. The counter to misinformation is better information. Not just that, but having it checked in real time by the community. So you have millions of people that can go over it and debate whether or not this is true or that's true.
14:09Yes, and like I said, the best way to understand the truth of things is don't take anyone's opinion for it. Look at the source material. So look at what someone actually said. Look at what someone actually did. Look at the real videos of the situation. And then you can actually, you'll know what's real.
14:24Especially on the Democrat side, they've been repeatedly saying that the First Amendment is an obstacle. And they're claiming, oh, the First Amendment is enabling disinformation, misinformation. And I'm like, yo, there's a reason for the First Amendment. Freedom of speech, the reason they found out the country put the Freedom of Speech there is because they came from countries, where if you spoke your mind, you would get shot or imprisoned.
14:48That's why the First Amendment exists. And the Second Amendment is there to stop the attorney of government. The Second Amendment, the right to be our arms, is there to protect freedom of speech. You know, and I've had these debates, especially with people in LA, because they're like, one, take your one's guns away.
15:02And I'm like, yo, can you guarantee me that the government, that we will never have a tyrannical government in the United States? Can you make that guarantee? But like, well, nobody can make that guarantee. I'm like, then we need to keep our guns. Because that's what's gonna stop it.
15:17That sounds crazy for people to hear because they think about gun violence and gun problems and gun this and gun that, but that's the reality of the world that we live in is that tyranny is possible and it exists other places and it's slowly existing. It's slowly rearing its head in the UK.
15:34You're saying, I think the number of people that have been arrested for just social media posts is bananas, it's in the thousands. Yes, several thousand people have been given prison sentences those in the UK for social media posts that where there was no explicit link to actual violence,
15:53but they just said it encouraged violence. Like, well, did anyone actually do anything as a result of that? Media posts will know. But they're just and and then they have a prison overcrowding situation in the UK so that quite literally releasing convicted pedophiles and putting people in jail for Facebook posts,
16:11does an actual thing happening in Britain? Like it's you're like, it's all wild. The helicopter is going on. And what's insane to me is that it's all being encouraged by the left. Katainge, Brown Jackson, John Kerry, Hilary. John Kerry was one of the people who said that on camera, like a few weeks ago, saying
16:30that the first amendment is an obstacle to fighting misinformation. Yeah. That's crazy. That's such a crazy thing to say when you have a solution in community notes. You have a solution in something that could clear everything up any confusion within a day or two. And even without a community note, you can reply to a post with evidence that shows that
16:49the post is wrong. You don't even need community notes. I mean, community is helpful because it sticks to the original note. Yes. But in the replies, you can say, here's why you're wrong, here are the reasons, and here's the evidence. But the argument is that people are too unsophisticated, that they're not going to research these
17:03things. They're going to be a victim of misinformation. So they're going to read something that's incorrect. They're going to run with it. People are going to die. People are going to ruin the world. because people believed in misinformation. It's a stupid argument. It's a stupid argument.
17:16Because it's an argument that they're too dumb to know what's right or wrong. If you know, because you're saying it's misinformation, why do you think that you're smarter than everybody who reads that? Exactly. And obviously anyone on the X system knows that things are posted and then there are replies and there are bottles and it's immediately corrected.
17:33But where are the corrections for the legacy media? Right. When some broadcast media, they say false things all the time, things all the time, but it's a one way street. There's no rebuttal. There's no counter. Right. Right. Who's apologized for being incorrect about what did Rachel Mato ever apologize for
17:52telling everybody that if you get the COVID vaccine, you're never going to get COVID. It won't that virus stops with you. Never. Never. It's just it was not true at the time. There was no evidence to support it at the time. It's pure propaganda. And she said it, the Russia gate hoax. The
18:06for three years, they said that he was Putin's toy. And that Putin had him compromised the steel dossier. Steel dossier was completely fabricated by lawyer Perkins Koi, who was paid by the Clinton campaign. Literally. Crazy. And still people think the Russia hoax is real. And there's no repercussions.
18:23Yes. No one had to apologize. Hillary couldn't have ever came out and apologized for that. And people still listened to her. The whole thing is crazy. And it's all coming from the left, which growing up as a person who was in the left my whole life, it doesn't make any sense. Same, I was on the left until three years ago.
18:38It's not the left anymore. It's not the left anymore. It's just, I think we obviously want, I believe we want freedom. We want to maximize post-posomal liberty. I think we want to be kind to people. We want to have empathy. And but it's very important to have personal freedom and a merit-based society.
18:54And the left is wants to oppress your freedoms, especially freedom of speech. And they want to have a non-barret-based society, with race-based and sex-based preferences. as well as I can. No, we just want people to succeed based on their skills and their hard work. And if they don't want people to express themselves about particular issues, then they're not doing the will of the people.
19:16And if they're trying to suppress people's ability to communicate, they're only doing that because they wanna do things that people don't want them to do. And they wanna silence opposition. That's all it is. And the fact that people can't see that and they wanna call Trump a fascist, it's the whole thing is through the looking glass.
19:33I mean, it's one hoax after another that they're portraying as Trump. I'm trying to call the rally at Madison Square Gardens like a Nazi rally. I'm like, yo, there was like literally an Israeli flag in the audience. I think a quarter of the speakers were Jewish. There was like, there were people of every race, color, creed, religion at that rally.
19:49Tell me what about that is Nazi? And yet it was portrayed as a Nazi rally. Well, MSNBC, they literally showed video of the Nazi rally from the 1930s and then compared it to the Trump rally. Now ignoring the fact that Jimmy Carter spoke there. There have been dozens of political rallies at Madison Square Gardens.
20:07Dozens on the Democrat side. People on X will like, and here's exactly, here's Jimmy Carter, and here's both Clinton. And here's, wait a second. Actually, it looks like every presidential candidate has done a, on the Democrat side, has done a rally at Madison Square Gardens. Are they not these two?
20:23But what they're doing is they're praying on low information voters who aren't engaged actively on social media who don't have the time to look through everything. Exactly. Yeah. If people are just on looking at legacy mainstream media, then they have a totally different worldview than if they're on X and seeing the actual flow of argument and the actual evidence.
20:44Well, what was the pushback? What happened when you guys released the Twitter files? Because I think the Twitter files is probably one of the most important things in this age of information for understanding the influence that government has on social media and on discourse because when when we found out that that was the case that the government was actually
21:02Asking Twitter to remove posts that were factual all the time. They did the same thing to Facebook They had them throttle pieces of one of Tucker Carlson's show. They suppressed the views by 50 percent. Yeah of factual information Yeah, no, there was there was massive government interference in Twitter, but but Twitter welcomed it. It doesn't point at all
21:20All Twitter was controlled by far left activists. They welcomed the government interference. They got paid by the government for it. That's crazy. They got paid for their time, correct? Yeah, they got paid millions of dollars for suppressing information. So it's like Bill and Tom.
21:37And a bunch of it was like, I had this sort of magic portal into the Twitter system. And all of the communication in this portal was auto-deleted after two weeks, which breaks federal foil lawyers. So we didn't know what was said because it was all deleted after two weeks. That's insane. Yeah. That's so crazy. It's so crazy that people thought that was okay.
21:58It's not super not okay. No, it's super not okay. It's unconstitutional. And no one would want that. No one would want the government to have that kind of access. Exactly.
资源与出处
- 视频原始视频文件
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版