播客·中文精读

马斯克 | All-In Summit 2024

Elon Musk | All-In Summit 2024

B 站版本为网友搬运,时间点可能差几秒
中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

访谈开场,主持人问最近怎么样。马斯克说,很少有哪一周是闲的。

主持人说,整个世界都这样,一周比一周离谱。

马斯克说,这肯定是个模拟,我们早就达成共识了。

主持人接了一句:如果这是某个外星人拍的 Netflix 剧集,收视率应该不错。马斯克说,是啊,收视率很高。

寒暄结束,话题转到言论自由。这场仗打了两年,主持人问他打得怎么样。

马斯克先报了个价。

自由的代价不便宜,大概 440 亿美元,正负十亿,取个整数。(马斯克)

那是他 2022 年买下推特的价钱。

自由的标价,正负十亿

马斯克说,全世界正在出现一股压制言论自由的怪异潮流,这件事应该让人非常不安。

他抛出一个问题:为什么美国宪法第一修正案被排在第一条,优先级那么高?

答案是,当年很多人从"说真话就会被关进监狱或者被杀掉"的地方来到美国。他们的诉求很朴素:我们不希望这里也变成那样。而今天,世界上仍然有大量地方,你批评政府就会被抓起来或者被杀掉。

让人意外的是,这股风潮已经刮到了西方。马斯克举了英国的例子:青少年因为发了表情包被判入狱,有人因为在社交媒体上写了几句晦涩的评论就进了监狱,连"认真的玩梗"都算不上。

法国那边,Telegram 创始人帕维尔·杜罗夫(Pavel Durov)被逮捕。

巴西那边,是一位被马斯克戏称为"伏地魔"的法官。

巴西这件事对他影响最直接。他花了不少篇幅解释 X 到底在争什么,同时反复强调希望这件事被正确框定,别被简化为"某个亿万富翁在无理取闹"。

X 的处境是这样:公司认为自己被要求去做违反巴西法律的事,而且被要求对此保持沉默。马斯克说得很直白,一家美国公司不能把自己的法律和价值观强加给别的国家,那样走不远。但如果一个国家的法律是某种样子,我们却被要求去违反它、还不许声张,那就不行。

他给出的判断标准听起来像是公司内部的行为准则:X 做的任何一件事,都应该能摊在阳光下解释,不能让人觉得不光彩、干错了事。

目前 X 正在和巴西司法当局沟通,想把事情弄清楚。如果确实是被要求违法,那巴西司法系统自己也不该接受;如果是 X 搞错了,也希望对方明确指出错在哪里。

主持人作为朋友表达了担忧:哪天醒来发现马斯克在某个国家被逮捕,自己还得去保释他。马斯克说这不是玩笑。过去是拜登说"得查查那家伙",现在变成了字面意义上的呼吁。《卫报》在三周内发了三篇文章,要求把他关进监狱。

马斯克反问了一句:卫报到底在守护什么?

他给的解释是这样的:如果有人试图向世界推销一个错误的前提,而这个前提只要经过公开对话就会被推翻,那这个人一定会反对公开对话。他不喜欢真相,所以想把它压下去。

逻辑链条被摆得很清楚:你买下了一个公共论坛,你让人们在上面表达,所以你应该被关进监狱。他承认自己看不懂这个逻辑。

那 X 的边界到底在哪?马斯克的回答比外界想象的保守。

如果某个内容在美国违法,在欧洲违法,在巴西违法,那就下架,或者封号。X 不是来制定法律的。反过来,如果言论本身不违法,平台凭什么插进去当审查员?这条路的尽头是谁来决定什么能说、什么不能说?

他给了一句总结:如果某个国家的人民想要不一样的法律,他们应该去改法律。在那之前,我们在每个司法辖区遵守当地法律。就这么简单,不复杂。

觉得 X 没守法,可以起诉。欧洲一些国家不让传播纳粹宣传,有历史敏感性,这类内容上传就删除。有些东西明显违法,不需要等诉讼,读一遍法条就知道。

他打了个比方:如果有人正在偷东西,你不需要翻法律书确认"这算不算偷"。

现场主持人在这一点上和他有分歧,认为总要有人来判断。马斯克的回答大致是,判断权应该留在立法者手里,而不是留给一家公司的内容审核团队。

联邦政府缺一个垃圾回收机制

话题转到政府效率。JD 万斯(JD Vance)当天早上刚来过这个舞台。X 上有一张图,把马斯克、小罗伯特·肯尼迪、特朗普和万斯画成了复仇者联盟。还有一张更出名的,马斯克站在一张桌子后面,桌上写着 DOGE,政府效率部(Department of Government Efficiency)。

马斯克承认那张图是他自己用 Grok 的图像生成器做的,然后发在了自己的账号上。

DOGE 具体怎么做?他的开场白是:难度极大。

上一次有人认真削减政府规模、清理荒谬法规,是里根在 1980 年代初。到今天已经过去四十年。

这四十年里发生了什么?法规和法条每年都在累积,一层一层往上加,最终的结果是所有事情都变成非法。他拿加州高铁举例:花了 70 亿美元,建出一段 600 英尺的路基,里面还没铺轨道。

你的税金就是这么花掉的。600 英尺混凝土,花了 70 亿美元,我们到底在干什么。(马斯克)

他顺手自嘲了一下:我承认自己在时间表上有时过于乐观,不乐观的人不会去做我正在做的事。但按现在的趋势,加州高铁可能要到下个世纪才能修完。到那时候大概已经有瞬移技术了。

他把美国的处境比作格列佛:被几百万根小绳子绑在地上。单看每一根绳子都不算太糟,但绳子有几百万根,最后你什么都干不成。这笔成本最终落在消费者和普通人头上,只是他们看不见。

然后是那个 EPA 的故事。

SpaceX 被美国环保署罚了 14 万美元,理由是"把饮用水倒在了地上"。地点是星基地(Starbase),位于热带雷暴区,水天天从天上下来,基地旁边就是海洋,有时候雨大到把路淹了。

那些水是用来在发射时给发射台降温的。EPA 自己也承认没有造成任何实际损害。马斯克说,那我们为什么要交这 14 万?对方的回答是:因为你们没有许可证。

他追问,往地上倒零损害的淡水还需要许可证?我们不知道有这回事。

更狠的在后头。EPA 随后表示,如果不交这 14 万美元,就不再处理星舰后续的发射申请。

他们就是勒索我们。行吧,我们交了 14 万。但这样下去我们永远到不了火星。(马斯克)

他说最让人困惑的地方在于,这种做法和美国自身的利益是相反的。火箭确实会制造噪音,但社会总要在"偶尔有点吵"和"巨大的进步"之间做取舍。问题是什么时候开始,我们连这种取舍都做不了了。

加州和德州的对比最能说明问题。特斯拉的德州超级工厂,从动工到完工用了 14 个月。上海的超级工厂用了 11 个月,而且体量是五角大楼的三倍。加州呢?光是监管审批走流程就要两年。

主持人替监管派说了句话:总要有些制衡,你不能假设所有企业都是好人。

马斯克的方案很具体:把要废除的规则一条条公开列出来,如果公众对某条规则反应强烈、希望保留,那就保留。而且,如果删掉之后发现是条好规则,随时可以加回去。

问题出在不对称上。加规则的流程非常顺畅,删规则的流程根本不存在。政府缺一套垃圾回收机制。

利息支出已经超过国防预算

除了法规,马斯克认为还有一件更要命的事:美国正在以极快的速度走向破产,而所有人都在装作没看见。

他的比喻是泰坦尼克号下沉之前,乘客忙着把银器塞进自己口袋。

数字是这样的。国防部加上情报部门,一年一万亿美元。而国债的利息支出刚刚超过国防部预算,同样是一年一万亿美元以上,而且还在涨。

净新增债务的速度是每三个月一万亿美元。这个间隔会缩短,很快变成每两个月,然后每个月。等到那时候,政府唯一能付得起的东西就是利息。

这就像一个人刷爆了信用卡,只是规模放大了无数倍。这个结局不会好看。(马斯克)

主持人提了一个他常听到的反驳,并说自己不同意:联邦、州、地方三级政府支出加起来占 GDP 的 40% 到 50%,接近一半的经济由政府采购支撑;近一半美国人直接或间接依赖政府支票,要么是政府雇员,要么是承包商。砍得太快、太狠,会带来明显的经济收缩、失业和衰退。这个平衡怎么把握?

马斯克说这个二选一是假的。没人说要让政府支出归零,问题是支出的水平对不对。

他补充了一个容易被忽略的点:同一个人,放在效率低的组织里和效率高的组织里,对经济的净贡献完全不同。不是人的问题,是操作系统的问题。

建墙拦人的那个制度,是坏制度

他给了两组对照。

朝鲜和韩国。朝鲜是 100% 政府,韩国大概 40%,而韩国的生活水平至少是朝鲜的十倍。

东德和西德。那条线只是地图上随手画的一道,结果西德长出了宝马、保时捷、奥迪、奔驰,东德人能买到的车只有特拉贝特(Trabant),马斯克的形容是"带个壳的割草机",极不安全。想买车得等二十年,孩子一怀上就得去登记排队,最后大概只有四分之一的人能拿到。

他特意强调,西德当年也不算资本主义天堂,社会主义成分相当重,政府占比可能有一半。同样一批人,两套操作系统,生活水平差出五到十倍,质量上更是天壤之别。

然后他给出了全场最锋利的一句判断标准。

怎么判断哪种制度更好?看哪个制度需要建墙把人民关在里面。需要建墙的那个,就是坏制度。(马斯克)

他补了个反例。从古巴往外跑的船很多,同时古巴岸边也停着不少空船,任何人都能划走。但没有人捡那些船去古巴。

有条没人要的船,我可以划去古巴,那边搞共产主义,太棒了。(马斯克)

所谓的过渡期问题,他也有具体设想。他不会主张把政府雇员明天就扫地出门、让人还不上房贷。合理的做法是给一到两年缓冲,期间照常发钱,让他们有时间去私营部门找工作,而他们最终会找到。东德并入西德之后,当地生活水平是大幅上升的。

主持人追问,四年时间能把政府规模砍到什么程度,给个大概区间。

马斯克先开了个玩笑:你是想让我在被暗杀之前就把数字说出来吗。

然后他半认真地提到,今年针对前政府雇员的死亡威胁数量是个很吓人的数字,自己不一定能活到那一天。他还调侃说邮局得留着,因为英文里"going postal"是持枪扫射的意思。

玩笑归玩笑,他的答案是:每年砍掉低个位数百分比,连着砍四年,是可以接受的节奏。如果这个机会不抓住,四年过去什么都没发生,那只能说明特朗普对这件事并不认真。而他自己的判断是,特朗普在这件事上很认真。

他的收尾是一句正面的话:如果真能清掉那些毫无意义的法规,把人从政府部门转移到私营部门,美国会迎来一轮巨大的繁荣,会有一个黄金时代。

造火箭比搬文件快,这不应该可能

访谈当晚有一场发射。马斯克说如果天气配合,他结束后就要飞去卡纳维拉尔角。

那是北极星黎明任务(Polaris Dawn),私人出资,金主是贾里德·艾萨克曼(Jared Isaacman)。这次飞行要完成人类第一次商业太空行走,轨道高度也是阿波罗计划之后人类离地球最远的一次。

主持人说,假设这次成功了,接下来呢。

马斯克先说了句心里话:如果把所有能许的愿攒成一个,他会许宇航安全。太空是危险的。然后才是答案:下一次星舰试飞。

星舰已经准备好飞了,卡在监管审批上。

造一枚巨型火箭的速度,比文件从一张桌子挪到另一张桌子还快。这不应该可能。(马斯克)

他提起动画电影《疯狂动物城》里车管所那只树懒。有意思的是,一年后他去车管所换驾照,柜台那位工作人员在自己的工位里贴了一张那只树懒的图片。马斯克说,这人手速飞快,自我认知相当清醒。

他由此引申出对政府的整体判断:政府对很多人来说,最直接的接触就是车管所。记住一点,政府就是放大版的车管所。

星舰已经取得的进展包括:两次达到轨道速度,助推器和飞船都在水面上完成软着陆,其中一次飞船有一半的襟翼被烧掉了。视频在 X 上可以看,画面相当震撼。

马斯克讲了一个判断项目的框架,听起来像废话,其实很有用。他说任何项目都可以画一个圈,然后问一句:成功在不在这个圈里?

很多项目的成功根本不在可能结果的集合里,从一开始就注定失败。星舰是第一个把"完全可复用"放进可能性集合的火箭设计,而且每一次发射都在证明这件事,剩下的只是时间问题。

他解释了为什么可复用是绕不过去的坎:让生命成为多行星物种,需要的根本性突破只有一个,快速、可靠、可复用的火箭。没有这个,其他都是空谈。

火星时间表他也确认了:两年内发射无人星舰去火星,四年内载人,前提是进展顺利。如果监管能提速,可以快很多。他强调这跟安全性无关,只是把已经确认安全的事情的审批流程,做得和造火箭一样快。

为什么要去火星?他给的答案和工程无关。

他说人需要让人心动的东西,需要抬头看未来的时候觉得未来会比过去好,需要有盼头。孩子是很好的检验标准:如果能对孩子说,你可以成为火星上的宇航员,你也许有一天能飞出太阳系,我们可以把《星际舰队学院》变成真的,那是一个让人兴奋的未来。

生活不能只是一件接一件地解决悲惨问题,总得有些值得期待的东西。(马斯克)

骑兵队长总得会骑马

主持人问,波音到底怎么了,星际客机(Starliner)把人送上去却接不回来。

马斯克的回答切入角度是商业模式。波音跟政府做的生意太多了,公司效率已经被"阻抗匹配"到政府那一档,离政府只差一到两档。而 SpaceX 的收入大部分来自商业客户,所以没有这个问题。

然后他谈到了人。

波音上一任 CEO 是会计学位,从来不去工厂,也不了解飞机是怎么飞的。

你要是负责造飞机、造飞船送人上轨道,那飞机怎么飞、飞船怎么上天,不能对你是完全神秘的东西。(马斯克)

他补充说,这不是说财务背景的人不能当 CEO。管可口可乐、管咨询公司,营销和财务出身完全合理,因为那些生意不依赖工程技术。但造飞机的公司不一样。

你要是骑兵队长,总得会骑马吧。(马斯克)

骑兵队长从马上摔下来,这事本身就够让人不安了。他说波音新任 CEO 至少会出现在工厂里,这是好迹象。

八成的富足,两成的别的东西

话题转到 AI。彼得·蒂尔(Peter Thiel)当天早些时候说过,到目前为止真正从 AI 上赚到钱的只有卖芯片的英伟达。

马斯克同意这个观察的一半:AI 领域的支出确实跑在收入前面,这一点毫无疑问。

但他强调另一半:AI 的改进速度是他见过的所有技术里最快的,而且快得多。图灵测试曾经是件大事,现在随便一个开源模型跑在树莓派上,大概都能通过。

他对好结局的描述是这样的:极度繁荣,一个富足时代。商品和服务不再短缺,每个人都能得到自己想要的东西,除了那些被人为定义为稀缺的东西,比如某些特定艺术品。有了 AI 加上机器人,商品和服务的成本会一路趋近于零。他说不是真的零,但趋势就是零。

这个未来的概率,他给的是 80%。

往好的方面想,只有 20% 的概率是毁灭。(马斯克)

那 20% 长什么样?他的回答是:说实话我也不知道。而且他承认,为了睡个好觉,他必须对 AI 刻意悬置一部分怀疑。

但他认为更可能发生的实际问题,其实是另一个。

当 AI 什么都能做、而且做得比人更好,人怎么找到意义。他提到自己认识越来越多退休的人,看起来过得挺享受。所以也许不至于爆发意义危机,也许会有。他把这称作更大的挑战。

要让那个富足的未来落地,需要两个东西:自动驾驶汽车,和通用人形机器人。

他的推理是:一旦有了通用人形机器人和自动驾驶车辆,你就能造任何东西。经济规模没有真正的上限。地球上物质的量当然有上限,但经济学上,经济等于人均生产力乘以人数。人形机器人的数量没有上限,而且它们能非常聪明地工作,那经济就没有有意义的上限了。

特斯拉要解的是另一个问题

访谈提到 xAI 刚点亮的 Colossus 集群,目前是最强大的超级计算机,任何类型里都算最强。

马斯克顺势讲了特斯拉的 AI 和大型语言模型之间的差别。

语言模型的上下文在变长,但特斯拉的问题在另一个量级。车上有七个摄像头,一分钟多路高清视频就是几个 GB,折算成 token 是几十亿的规模。

所以核心工作在压缩。空间上要压缩像素,时间上也要压缩,把海量输入压成真正重要的那部分,然后把推理跑在一台几百瓦功耗的小计算机上。

这台推理计算机是特斯拉自己设计的。马斯克说,市面上能买到的任何供应商产品,都不如它。特斯拉的芯片团队非常强,强到连以太网传输层都自己重新设计了一套,因为现成的以太网不够用。

训练侧是 Dojo。Dojo 一代已经跑起来,Dojo 二代预计明年年底量产,性能大致相当于 B200 级别的训练系统。

但马斯克给了一个很清醒的预期管理:一项技术通常要经过三次大迭代才会变得优秀。Dojo 现在只到第二次,第三次大概要到 2026 年底。所以 Dojo 到底有多好,现在下结论还早。它未来有可能作为服务对外提供,但那时才谈得上。

史上最大的机会,大概一万美元

Optimus 项目的进展,马斯克说已经在工厂里做轻量测试,并且真的有用。

成本怎么算?他给了一条通用规律:任何东西在足够大的产量下,成本都会渐近于它的材料成本。芯片是例外,因为要付专利授权费和晶圆厂折旧,但纯粹的材料成本很低。

Optimus 比车小得多,也轻得多。按他的估算,需要至少三代产品迭代,然后把产量拉到年产百万台以上,那时候的材料加工人成本大概是 1 万美元出头。

可以把它想成,Optimus 会比一辆小型车还便宜。(马斯克)

一辆小型车大概 2 万到 2.5 万美元。时间表是五年,也许六年,做到年产百万台。到那个价位,地球上每个人都买得起。

三十年后机器人和人类的数量比例?他的回答毫不犹豫:机器人会远远超过人类。至少二比一,可能三比一。

理由很朴素:谁不想要一个机器人伙伴?它可以帮你遛狗、割草、看孩子、教孩子。还可以送一大批去火星干活,把火星改造成能住人的星球。他说火星现在本来就是个机器人星球,上面全是探测器和机器人直升机。

有用的通用人形机器人,是史上最大的机会。(马斯克)

有意思的是设计机器人的副产品:他们在这个过程中越来越理解人类为什么长成这样。

为什么是五根手指,为什么小指比食指短,为什么是对掌拇指。还有一个很多人不知道的事实:驱动手指的主要肌肉其实长在前臂,手指本身靠肌腱拉动,握力的大部分来自前臂。

当前这代 Optimus 的手把执行器装在手掌里,只有 11 个自由度,力量也不够,因为执行器必须塞进手里。下一代的手已经把执行器移到前臂,用线缆驱动手指,和人类一样,自由度提到 22 个。他们的判断是,这足以完成人类能做的几乎任何事。

马斯克在这里贡献了全场最好笑的一个比喻。

我们人类就是通用机器人,只不过是用肉做的。我现在正在操作我的肉体外壳。(马斯克)

主持人补了一句,如果把 Grok 装进机器人,它就有性格了,能处理语音、视频、图像。这个组合显然是特斯拉和 xAI 之间的天然接口。

那一周,他们想掏出一只小公鸡

访谈最后聊到了 2021 年那期《周六夜现场》(SNL)。主持人说马斯克有很好的幽默感,马斯克说这不是真的。

他回忆说,那一周前两天相当恐怖,因为什么都不好笑。

问题出在工作方式上。SNL 的常规流程是演员拿到写好的本子,照着演。马斯克和他带去的两个朋友以为可以自己出点子,冲进 Zoom 会议就开始讲。对面一片沉默。沉默持续了很久,最后他朋友迈克说了一个词: crickets,意思是冷场到只剩虫叫。对面连哼都没哼一声。

那个没通过审查的冷开场,他详细讲了。

设定是这样的:所有人都好奇 SNL 到底是不是真直播,有没有五秒延迟以防走光。马斯克上台说,今晚我们就来验证。方法是,他要把手伸进裤子,掏出一只小公鸡。

如果你们看到了我的小公鸡,说明直播是真的。如果没看到,那这么多年都是骗人的。(马斯克)

然后凯特·麦克金农(Kate McKinnon)走出来,说埃隆,我猜你的会比这个大。两人开始一来一回地讨论这只小公鸡,还问对方要不要摸一下。马斯克说,光听音频版本其实效果就挺好。

这个本子被否掉的理由是:那天是母亲节,台下坐着一堆妈妈。

另一个他很想做的段子是"教父"版。模仿《教父》开场那场戏,把"你在这一天来找我,向我要私钥"改成黑手党式的质问:你甚至不肯叫我一声 Doge 教父。他说这个段子需要西装、需要音乐、需要气氛,潜力很大。

台里说法律和责任上有顾虑。马斯克转头去骗主持人科林,说埃隆给康卡斯特打了电话,报价被接受了,我们刚买下 NBC,所以没问题了。科林愣了几秒,问他是不是认真的。马斯克说是真的,我们现在拥有 NBC 了。科林说,那情况确实不太一样了。

他还爆了一个细节:现场有提词卡,上面写好该说什么,他基本不照着念,直接即兴发挥。制作团队完全没预料到这一点,因为节目是直播的。

那一周后来成了马斯克自己评价最高的一段时光。主持人说,看到他能在火箭发射和各种麻烦之间,有一周纯粹地大笑、放松,很难得。

全场在"再来一次 SNL"的欢呼中结束。

几个可以立刻用起来的判断

这场访谈信息量很大,但真正能带走的东西不多,下面这几条是其中比较硬的。

  • 用"成功在不在可能结果的集合里"筛项目。马斯克这个框架听起来像废话,威力在于它能一秒淘汰掉大量注定失败的计划。开会时问一句:我们讨论的这条路,成功到底在不在可能性里?如果不在,别优化执行,先改设计。
  • 判断一个制度、一家公司、一个社区好不好,看它需不需要建墙拦人。需要设门槛阻止成员离开的组织,无论口号多漂亮,效率一定有问题。反过来,成员可以随时走却选择留下,这才是真实信号。
  • 给每条规则配一个回收日期。加规则容易,删规则没流程,这是所有组织的通病。下次要新增一条流程时,顺手写上它解决什么问题、什么时候复审。没有退出机制的规则,最终会累积成绑住自己的那几百万根绳子。
  • 压缩是 AI 工程的核心动作,先想清楚哪些信息真的重要。特斯拉车上七个摄像头一分钟就是几个 GB,做法是先压缩再推理,而不是堆算力硬扛。做自己的产品时也一样,输入越贵,越要先问:这些数据里,真正影响决策的是哪几个像素。
  • 对新技术的前三代保持耐心,对第四代保持贪婪。Dojo 要到第三代才可能优秀,Optimus 要三代产品迭代才谈得上量产。看到第一代产品拉胯就下结论,和看到第一代就 all in,是同一种错误。
  • 盯住 AI 的支出收入剪刀差,别只看估值。连马斯克都承认支出跑在收入前面。这个缺口最终要靠真实的应用收入来填,填不上的那部分,会在某个时点以很快的速度重新定价。

最后一条不属于操作层面,但可能是这场访谈里最值得记住的一句。

马斯克说,人需要一些让心脏动一下的东西。孩子问起未来的时候,你得能说出点让他眼睛发亮的事。这个标准对公司、对家庭、对个人都成立。如果一件事只剩下解决问题,没有人会为它长期投入。

YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00[Applause] the greatest entrepreneur this generation Elon Musk hey guys grab my stuff sit there I'm going to yep I'm going to take this all right do this thanks for taking the time how how you doing brother you keep him busy yeah I mean it's rarely a slow week I mean in the world as well yeah I mean any given week I me it just seems like the things getting nuttier it it it's definitely a simulation we've agreed on this at this point I mean well look if if we are in some alien Netflix series I think the ratings are high yes ratings are High

1:00how are the the the freedom of speech Wars going this is a you've been you've been at War for two years now yes the price of freedom of speech is not cheap is it I think it's like 44 billion something like that just numbers give her give or take a billion yeah round numbers yeah yeah it's

1:24it's it's pretty nutty there there is like this weird movement to quell's Free Speech kind of around the world and and this is something we should be very concerned about you know you have to ask like why was the first amendment like a high priority was like number one One is because people came from countries where if you spoke freely you would be imprisoned or killed and they were like well we would like to not have that here because that was

1:58terrible and actually you know there's a lot of places in the world right now if you if you're critical of the government you get imprisoned or killed right yeah we'd like to not have that are you concerned to that I mean I supect this is a receptive audience to that message [Applause]

2:23you I I think we always thought that the West Was the exception to that that we knew there were authoritarian places around the world but we thought that in the west we'd have freedom of speech and we've seen like you said it seems like a global movement in brit you've got teenagers being put in prison for memes opposing it's like you like to you like to Facebook post throw him in the prison yeah people have got an actual you know prison for for like like obscure comments on social media not even [ __ ] posting yet like not even yeah it's crazy P got thrown in prison recently I'm like that was pretty about I was like what is the massive crime that

3:07right pav in France and then of course we got Brazil with judge Voldemort that that one seems like the one that impacts you the most can you what's the latest on that well we I guess we're we are trying to figure out is there some reasonable solution in Brazil the you know the concern I mean I want to just make sure that this is framed correctly and you know funny memes aside I the the the nature of the concern was that least at at excorp we had the perception that we were being asked to do things that violated Brazilian law so obviously we cannot as an American company impose American laws and values on on other countries that you

4:04know we wouldn't get very far if we did that but but we do you know think that if if a country's law laws are a particular way and we're being asked to what we we think we think we're being asked to break them then and and be silent about it then obviously that is no good so so I just want to be clear thetime sometimes comes across as elon's trying to just be a crazy whatever billionaire and demand outrageous things from other countries and you know well that is

4:42true in addition there are other things that that I think are you know valid which is like we we we obviously can't you know I think any given thing that we do at excorp we've got to be able to explain in the light of day and and not feel that it was dishonorable or you know we we we did the wrong thing you know so we don't we that that that that was the that that's the nature of the concern so we actually are in sort of discussions with the you know judicial authorities in in Brazil to try to you know run this to ground like

5:30what What's actually going on like if if we're being asked to break the law Brazilian law then that's that that obviously should not be should not sit well with the Brazilian Judiciary and if we're not and we're mistaken we'd like to understand how we are mistaken I think that's a that's a pretty reasonable position I'm a bit concerned as your friend that you're going to go to one of these countries and I'm going to wake up one day and you're going to get arrested and like I'm going to have to to go bail you out or something like this is feels very acute like yes I mean it's not a joke now like they're literally saying like you know it's not just Biden saying like

6:09we have to look into that guy now it's become quite literal like this I who was the guy who just wrote the was it the guardian piece about like oh yeah yeah there have been three articles and I think in the past three weeks Robert Reich but it wasn't just him it was like three different articles three different articles it doesn't that's a trend that calling for me to be imprisoned right in the in the guardian you know guardian of what what are they Pro exactly guardian of I don't know authoritarianism yeah guardian of yeah yeah censorship censorship but but the premise here is that you bought this thing this online Forum this communication platform and you're

6:54allowing people to use it to express themselves therefore you have to be jailed I don't understand the logic here right there's what do you think they're actually afraid of at this point what's the motivation here I mean I think the if somebody's a if somebody's sort of trying to push a false premise on the world then and then that that and that premise can be undermined with public dialogue then they will be opposed to public Dialogue on that premise because they wish that false premise to Prevail right so that's I think you know the the issue there is if they don't like the truth you know then we want to suppress it so now the you know the the sort of the

7:41what what we're trying to do with excorp is I distinguish that from my son who's also called X yes you have you have parental goals everything's just called X basically it's very difficult disambiguation the sun yeah everything so what what we're trying to do is simply adhere to the you know the the

8:08laws in a in a country so so if something is illegal in the United States or if it's illegal in you know Europe or Brazil or or wherever it might be then then we will take it down or we'll suspend the account because we we're not you know there to make the laws we but but if speech is not legal

8:30then then what are we doing okay now we're injecting ourselves in as as a sensor and and where does it stop and who decides so and where where does that path lead I think it leads to a bad place so if the people if in a country want the laws to be different they should make the laws different but otherwise we're going to obey the law in each jurisdiction right and some of these Europe that's it it's it's not more complicated there we're not we're not trying to FL out the law we going to be clear about that but we're we're trying to adhere to the law and if the laws change we will change and if if the laws don't change we we won't we're just literally trying to adhere to the law

9:12it's pretty pretty straightforward there are some very straightforward if somebody doesn't thinks we're not adhering to the law well they can file a lawsuit Bingo also very straightforward I mean there are European countries that don't want people to promote Nazi propaganda yes they have some sensitivity to it well it's it is illegal and it is illegal in those countries if somebody puts that up you take it down yes but they typically file something and say take this down no in some cases it is just obviously illegal like you don't need to file a lawsuit for you know if something is just you know unequivocally illegal we can literally read the law this

9:48violates the law you know anyone anyone can see that like you know you don't need like if if somebody is stealing you don't need let me check the law on that okay oh no they're they're stealing Frisco let's talk so we had we had JD Vance here this morning he did a great job and you know one of the things is there's this image on X of like basically like you Bobby Trump and JD are like the Avengers I guess and then there's another meme where you're in front of a desk where it says d g the department of governmental efficiency yes yes I posted that one tell us about I I made it using grock the gro image generator

10:31and I posted it tell us about it to my profile seek for efficiency how how do you do it well I mean I I think with great difficulty but you know look it's been a long time since there was a serious effort to reduce the size of government and to remove absurd regulations yeah and you know the last time there was a really concered effort on that front was Reagan in the early ' 80s so we're 40 years away from a a a a serious effort to

11:10remove you know not regulations that don't serve the greater good and and reduce the size of government and I think it's just if we don't do that then what's what what's happening is that we get regulations and laws accumulating every year until eventually everything's illegal and that's why we can't get major infrastructure projects done in the United States like if you look at the absurdity of the California highs speed rail I think they theyve spent $7 billion and have A600 put segment that doesn't actually have rail in it I mean your tax dollars at work I mean yeah what are we doing that's an expense of 600 feet of concrete you know and and I mean I think it's like if

11:54you know I realize sometimes I'm perhaps a little optimistic with schedules but you know I mean I wouldn't be doing the things I'm doing if I was you know not an an optimist so but but but but at the current Trend you know California High Street rail might finish sometime next Century maybe probably not we're just we'll have teleportation by that time so yeah exactly AI do everything at that point so so so so I think you really think of you know the the United States and many countries it's it's arguably worse than the EU as being like galiva tied down by a million little strings and like any one given regulation is not is not that bad but you've got a million of them and or

12:47Millions actually and and and then eventually you just can't get anything done and and this is a this is a massive tax on the on the consumer on the people it's just they don't they don't realize that there's this this massive tax in the form of irrational regulations I'm going I'll give you a recent example that that you know is is just insane is that like SpaceX was fined by the EPA $140,000 for they claimed dumping portable water on the ground drinking water so and we're like this is that star base and and we're like it's we're in a TR tropical thunderstorm region that stuff comes from the Sky all the time and and there was no actual harm done you

13:34know it was just water to cool the the the Launchpad during liftoff and there's zero harm done like and they're like they agree yes there's zero harm done we're like okay so there's no harm done and you want us to pay $140,000 fine it's like yes because you didn't have a pmit okay we didn't know there was a ponent needed for zero har fresh water being on the ground in a place that where fresh water full from the sky all the time got it next to the ocean next to the ocean cuz there's a little bit of water there too yeah I mean sometimes it rain so much the the roads are flooded so we're like you know how does this make any sense yeah and and then they're like then then they

14:16were like well we're not going to process any more of your any more of your applications for launch for Starship launch unless you pay this $140,000 they just ransomed us and we're like okay so we paid $140,000 but it was a it's like this is no good I mean at this rate we're never going to get to Mars I mean that's the that's the confounding part here yeah is we're acting against our own self-interest you know when you look at we do have to make putting aside fresh water but hey you know there the rocket makes a lot of noise so I'm I'm certain there's some complaints about noise once in a while but sometimes you want to have a party or you want to make

14:53progress and there's a little bit of noise therefore you know we we trade off a little bit of noise for massive progress or even fun so like when did we stop being able to make those tradeoffs but talk about the difference between California and Texas where you and I now reside Texas you were able to build the gigafactory I remember when you got the plot of land and then it seemed like it was less than two years when you had the party to open it yeah from start of construction to completion was 14 months 14 14 months

15:30is there anywhere on the planet that would go faster is like China faster than that China was 11 months got it so Texas China 11 and 14 months California how many months and just to give you a sense of size the Tesla gigafactory in China is three times the size of the Pentagon which was the biggest building in America no there are bigger buildings but the pentagon's pretty big one yeah where it was the biggest in units in units of Pentagon it's like three okay three pentagons and counting yeah got it in 14 months the

16:04just the just the regulatory approvals in California would have taken two years yeah so that's that's the issue where where do you think the regulation helps like for the people that will say we need some checks and balances we can't have some because for every good actor like you there'll be a bad actor so where is that line then yeah I mean I have a sort of you know in in sort of doing Su sensible deregulation and reduction in the size of government the is is just like be very public about it and say like which of these rules do you if the public is really excited about a rule and wants to keep it we'll just keep it and and here the thing about the rules

16:44if if like if the rule is you know turns out to be a bad we'll just put it right back okay and then you know problem solved it's like it's easy to add rules but we don't actually have a process for getting rid of them that's the issue there's no garbage collection rul when we were watching you work

17:05David and I and Antonio in that first month at Twitter which was all hands on deck and you were doing zerob based budgeting you really quickly got the cost under control and then miraculously everybody said this site will go down and you added 50 more features so maybe explain because this is the first time yeah there like so many articles like the that this this Twitter is Dead Forever there's no way it could possibly even continue at all it was almost like the Press wasting for you let's write theit here has the orbituary they were all saying their goodbyes on Twitter remember that yeah yeah yeah they were all leaving and saying their goodbyes cuz the site was

17:43going to melt down and totally fail and and all the journalists left yeah and which is if you ever want to like hang out with a bunch of Hall monitors oh my God threads is amazing every time I go over there and post they're like they they're really triggered but yeah I mean if you like being condemned repeatedly then you know for reasons that make no sense then threads is the way to go yeah it's really it's it's the most miserable place on Earth if Disney's the happiest this is the anti- Disney but if we were to go into government you went into the Department of Education or Pi pick the department you've worked with a lot of them actually sure you can't go in there

18:21in zero based budget okay we get it but if you could just pair two three four 5% of those organizations what kind of impact would that have yeah I mean I think we'd need to do more than that I think ideally but compounding every year 2 3% a year I mean it would be better than what's happening now yeah I look I think we we you

18:49know if if Trump wins and obviously I suspect there are people with mixed feelings about whether that should happen but but if but we do have an opportunity to do kind of a once- in a-lifetime deregulation and reduction in the size of government because because the other thing besides the regulations America is also going bankrupt extremely quickly and and nobody seems everyone seems to be sort of whistling past the graveyard on this one but they're all they're all grabbing the silverware everyone's stuff in their pockets and the silverware before this the Titanic SS like well you know the the defense department by budget is a very big budget okay it's a

19:31trillion dollars a year DOD Intel it's Trill a trillion dollars and interest payments on the national debt just exceeded the defense department budget they're over a trillion dollar a year just in interest and Rising we're we're adding a trillion dollars to the net to our debt which our you know kids and grandkids are going to have to pay somehow you know every every three months and then soon it's going to be every two months and then every month and then the only thing we'll be able to pay his interest yeah and and if if this it's just you know it's just like a person at scale that has racked up too much credit card debt and this this is not this is not have a a

20:23good ending so we have to reduce the spending let me ask one question cuz I've brought this up a lot and the counterargument I hear which I disagree with but the counter argument I hear from a lot of politicians is if we reduce spending because right now if you add up federal state and local government spending it's between 40 and 50% of GDP so nearly half

20:45of our economy is supported by government spending and nearly half of people in the United States are dependent directly or indirectly on government checks and either through contractors that that the government pays or their employed by government entity so if you go in and you take to harden acts too fast you will have significant contraction job loss and recession what's The Balancing Act Elon just thinking realistically because I'm 100% on board with you the steps the next set of steps however assume Trump wins and you become the the chief doe

21:23dog like G how how like yeah and I think the challenge is how quickly can we yeah how quickly can we go in how quickly can things change and without without I want that on my business card yeah without all the L without all the contraction and job yeah so so I guess how do you really address it when so much of the economy and so many people's jobs and livelihoods are dependent on government spending well I mean I I do think it's it's it's sort of you know it's it's false dichotomy it's not like no government spending is going to happen you really have to say like is it the right level and just remember that that you know any any given person if they are doing things in

22:13a less efficient organization versus more efficient organization their contribution to the economy their net output of goods and services will reduce I mean you've got a couple of clear examples between East Germany and West Germany North Korea and South Korea I mean North Korea they're starving South Korea it's like amazing it's the future the compounding effect of productivity gains yeah yeah it's night and day yeah and so in the north North Korea you've got 100% government and in South Korea you've got probably I don't know 40% government it's not zero yeah U and yet you've got a standard of living that is probably 10 times higher in South Korea at least at

22:50least exactly and then East and West Germany in West Germany you had just thinking in terms of cars I mean you had BMW Porsche Audi Mercedes and and East Germany which is a random line on a map you you the the car only car you could get was a a trabant which is basically a lawn mower with a shell on it and it was extremely unsafe and you there's a 20-year wait so you like you know put your kid on the list as soon as they're conceived they're conceived and and even then only I think you know quarter of people maybe got got this lousy car and

23:33the same so so that's just an interesting example of like basically the same people different operating system and and it's not like West Germany was some you know you know a capitalist Heaven it was it's quite socialist actually so so when you look you know probably it was half half government in West Germany and 100% government in East Germany and again gain sort of a five to like it call at least a 5 to 10x standard of living difference and even qualitatively vastly better and and it's obviously you know sometimes people have these amazingly in this modern era this debate as to which system is better well I'll tell you which system is better the one that

24:15doesn't need to build the world to keep people in okay that's that's how you can tell okay it's a dead giveaway spoiler alert dead giveaway they climbing the wall to get out you have to build a barrier to keep people in that is the bad system there wasn't West West berin that built the wall okay they were like to you know anyone who wants to flee West berin go ahead speaking of walls so it you know and and and and if you look at sort of the flux of boats from Cuba there's a large number of boats from Cuba and there's a bunch of free boats that you anyone can take to to to Cuba

24:58there's like hey wow an abandoned boat I could use this boat to go to Cuba where they have communism awesome Yes and and and yet nobody nobody picks up those boats and and does it amazing so given this a lot of thought yeah wait so your point is jobs will be created if we cut government spending in half jobs will be created fast enough to make up for right just to count yes obviously you know I'm not suggesting that that people you know have like immediately tfed you know tossed out with with with no severance and and you know can't now can't pay their mortgage they need to see some reasonable offramp where yeah yeah so reasonable offramp where

25:37you know they're still you know earning they're still receiving money but have like I don't know a year or two to to f to find jobs in the private sector which they will find and then they will be in a different operating system again you can see the difference East Germany was incorporated into West Germany living standards in East Germany Rose dramatically so in four years if you could shrink the side size of the government with Trump what would be a good Target just in terms of like ballpark I mean are you trying to get me assassinated before this even happens no no pick AO number I mean you know there's that old phrase go postal I mean it's like they might yeah on me so we'll

26:16keep the post office I I'm going to need a all the security details guys yes I mean this year a number of disg granted workers for former government employees is you know quite a scary number I mean I might not make it you know I was saying low low digits every year for four years would be palatable yeah and I like your idea the thing is that if if it's not done like if you have a once once in a lifetime or once in a generation opportunity and you don't take Serious action and and then you have four years to get it done and then and if it doesn't get done then how serious is Trump about this like you've talked to him about it yeah yeah I think he is

26:56very serious about it got it and no I I think actually the reality is that if we get rid of nonsense regulations and shift people from the government sector to the private sector we will have immense Prosperity and and I think we will have a golden age in this country and it'll be fantastic can we can we talk about

27:20SP you have a bunch of critical Milestones coming up yeah in fact there's an important a very exciting launch that is may be happening tonight so if if that the weather is is holding up then I'm going to leave here head to Cape canaval for the the the PO stor Mission which is a private Mission so funded by Derek DED isman and he's awesome guy and and there this will be the first time the first private first first commercial space walk and and'll be at at the highest altitude since Apollo so it's the furthest from Earth that anyone's gone

28:04yeah and you what comes after that let's assume that's successful and I sure hope so man no pressure yeah we you know Absolut you know Astron prior astral safety is man if I had like all all all the wishes I could save up that would be the one to to put on so you know space is dangerous so

28:34the the yeah the next Milestone after that would be the next flight of Starship which you know Starship is next five Starship is ready to fly we are waiting for regulatory approval you know yeah it it it it really should not be possible to both a giant rocket faster than the paper can move from one desk to [Applause]

29:09another that stamp was really hard approved yeah you ever see that movie zootopia you ever see that movie zootopia there's like a sloth in for the approval yeah accidentally tell a joke and and I was like oh no this is good here we go going to take a long time sorry sorry but yeah zootopia you know you know the funny thing is like so I went to the DMV about I don't know a year later after zootopia and to get my whatever license renewal and the guy in in an exercise of incredible self- awareness had the sloth from zootopia in his in his cube in in in his Cube and he was actually Swift yeah with the with the Mandate beat the sloth yeah yeah no personal agency

29:59personal agency no I mean some people like think the you know the government is more confident than it than it is I'm not saying that there aren't confident people in the government they're just in an operating system that is inefficient once you move them to a more efficient operating system they their output is dramatically greater as we've seen examp you know when East Germany was reintegrated to into with West Germany and and and the same people were vastly more prosperous with a basically half capitalist operating system so but I mean for a lot of people their like the maybe most direct experience with the government is the DMV and and then

30:46the important thing to remember is the the government is the DMV at scale right that's the government got the mental picture how much do you want to scale it yeah yeah sorry can you go back to chat's question on Star so you you announced just the other day Starship going to Mars in two years and by the way huh yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah and then four years for a crude aspirational launch in the next window and how much is the government involved I'm not saying like say you watch by these not you know but these but it based on our current progress where with with Starship We were able to successfully reach oval of velocity twice we were able to achieve soft

31:33Landings of the the booster and the ship in water and that's despite the ship having you know half its flaps cooked off you can see the video on the X platform it's quite exciting so you know we we we think we'll be able to have to launch reliably and repeatedly and quite quickly and the the the

31:57fundamental Holy Grail breakthrough for rocketry for to what the fundamental breakthrough that is needed for life to become multiplanetary is a rapidly reusable reliable rocket R for the pirate somehow throw a pirate in there the so with Starship is the first rocket design where success is one of the possible out with full reusability so you know for any given project you have to say this is the circle to write diagram has a circle and is Success the success dot in the circle is is success in the set of possible outcomes that's you know sounds pretty obvious but there are often projects where that that is success is not in the set of possible

32:52outcomes and so so Starship not only is fully full reusability in the set of possible outcomes it it is being proven with each launch and and and I'm confident it will succeed it's simply a matter of time and you know if if we can get some improvement in the speed of Regulation we we could actually move a lot faster so that would that would be very

33:20helpful and and in fact if if this if not if something isn't done about reducing regul and and sort of speeding up approvals and to be clear I'm not talking about anything unsafe it's simply the processing of the safe thing can be done at a as as fast as the rocket is built not slower then then then we could become a space buring civilization and a multiplet species ultimate and be out there among the stars in the future and

33:53there's you know it's it's just very like it's incredibly important that we have things that that we find inspiring that you look to the Future and say the future is going to be better than the past things to look forward to and like like kids are a good a good way to assess this like what a kids fired up about and if you can say

34:17you know you you could you know you could be an Astron on Mars you you could maybe one day go beyond the solar system we could make Star Trek Starfleet Academy real that is an exciting future that is inspiring you know just I mean you need things that move your heart right yeah [ __ ] yeah [ __ ] yeah let's do it I

34:47mean it like like life can't just be about soling one miserable problem after another there's got to be things that you look forward to as well yeah and and do do you think you might have to move it to a different jurisdiction and to move faster I've always wondered if like it's rocket technology is considered an advanced weapons technology so we can't just go do it you know in another country yes in it yeah interesting and if we don't do it other countries could do it I mean they're so far behind us but theoretically there's a national security you know justification here if if somebody can put their thinking caps on like do we want to have this

35:24technology that you're building the team's working so hard on stolen by other countries and then you know maybe they don't have as much red tape I I wish people were trying to steal it so that no no one's trying to steal it it's just too this just it's too crazy basically and that's for you yeah it's way too crazy El what do you think is going on that led to

35:52boing building the St line the way that they did they were able to get it up but not complete but can't complete they can't finish can't finish and you're going to have to go up and finish well I mean I think Boeing is a company that is you they actually do so much business with the government they have sort of impedance matched to the government so they're they're like basically one notch away from the government maybe two they're not far from the government from an efficiency standpoint because they derive so much of the revenue from the government and a lot of people think well SpaceX is super dependent on the government and actually no most of our revenue is

36:36commercial so and and and and there's been I think at least up until perhaps recently because they have a new CEO who actually shows up in the factory yeah and the the the CEO before that I think had a degree in accounting and and never went to the factory and didn't know how airplanes flew so I think if you are in charge of a company that makes airplanes fly and a spacecraft go to Orit you need to know it can't be a total mystery as to how they work yeah so you know I'm like sure if somebody's like running cocoa Pepsi and and they're like great at marketing or whatever that's that's fine because you know it's it's not a sort of Technology dependent

37:32business you know or if they're running a you know financial consulting and their degrees in accounting that makes sense but I think you know if you if you're the Cavalry Captain you should know how to ride a horse pretty basic yeah yeah great it's like it's disconcerting if the Cavalry Captain just falls off the horse you know he's scar team I'm sorry I'm scared of hces gets on backwards I'm like oops sh shifting gears to AI Peter was here earlier and he was talking about how so far the only company to really make money off AI is NVIDIA with the chips do you have a sense yet of where you think the big applications will be from AI is it going to be an

38:20enabling self-driving is it going to be enabling robots is it transforming Industries I mean it's still I think early in terms of where the big business impact is going to be do you have a sense yet I I mean I think I think they that they the spending on AI probably runs ahead of I mean does run ahead of the revenue right now that's there's no question about that but the rate of improvement of AI is faster than any technology I've ever seen by far and and and it

39:05it's I mean like the for example the touring test used to be a thing now you know your basic open source random llm writing on a freaking Raspberry Pi probably could you know beat the touring test so there's I I I think actually like like the the good future of AI is one of immense Prosperity where there is an age of abundance no

39:40shortage of goods and services everyone can have whatever they want unless except for things we artificially Define to be scarce like some special artwork but but anything that is a manufactured good or provided Service will I think with the Adent of AI plus robotics that the cost of goods and services will be will Trend to zero like I'm not saying it be actually zero but it'll be it every everyone will be able to have anything they want that that's the good future of course and you know in my view that's probably 80% likely so look on the bright side only 20% 20% probability of annihilation nothing is is the 20% like what does that look like I don't know man I mean

40:35frankly I do have to go engage in some degree of of deliberate suspension of disbelief with respect to AI in order to sleep well and even then because I I I I think the actual issue the the most likely issue is like well how do we find meaning in a world where AI can do everything we can do a bit better that that is that is perhaps the bigger challenge although you know at this point I know more and more people who are retired and they seem to enjoy that life so but I think that that may be maybe there'll be some crisis of meaning like because the computer can do everything you can do but better so maybe that'll be a challenge but but really you

41:21know you need you need the sort of end factors you need the the autonomous cars and you need the sort of humanoid robots or your general purpose robots but once you have general purpose humanoid robots and autonomous vehicles you really you you you can build anything and and and this I think that there's no actual limit to the size of the economy I mean there obviously you know the mass of Earth you know like that one limit but the you

41:57know the economy is is really just the average productivity per person times number of people that's the economy and if you if you've got humanoid robots that can do you know where there's no real limit on the number of humanoid robots and and they they can operate very intelligently then then there's no actual limit to the economy in there's no meaningful limit to the economy you guys just turned on Colossus which is like the largest private cluster I guess of gpus anywhere is that it's it's the it's the most powerful supercomputer of any kind which sort of speaks to what David said and kind of what Peter said which is a lot of the kind of economic

42:41value so far of ai ai is entirely gone to Nvidia but there are people with Alternatives and you're actually one with an alternative now you have a very specific case because Dojo is really about images and large images huge video yeah I mean the the the Tesla problem is different from the you know the sort of llm problem the nature of the intelligence actually is actually and and the what what matters in the AI is is different to to the point you just made which is that in the in tales's case the context length is very long so we've got gigabytes of context G context Windows yeah yeah you've got you know sort of we just bringing it up kind of billions of tokens of context NY

43:27amount of context because you've got seven seven cameras and if if you've got several you know let's say you've got a minute of several high high def cameras then that's gigabytes so you need to compress so the Tesla problem is you got to compress a gigantic context into the the pixels that are that actually matter and you know and and and condense that over a time so you've got in both the time Dimension the space Dimension you've got to compress the pixels u in space and the pixels over in time and and and then and then have that inference done on a tiny computer relatively speaking a small you know a few hundred watt it's a Tesla designed AI inference computer which

44:17is by still the best there isn't a better thing we could buy from suppliers so the Tesla designed AI inference computer that's in the cars is better than anything we could buy from any supplier just by the way that's kind of a by way the the Tesla ai ai CHP team is extremely good you guys in the design there is a technical paper and there was a deck that somebody on your team from Tesla published and it was stunning to me you designed your own transport control like layer over ethernet you're like ah ethernet's not good enough for us you have this TT Coe or something and you're like oh we're just going to reinvent ethernet and like string these

44:51chips it's pretty incredible stuff that's happening over there yeah no the team the the Tesla chip design team is extremely extremely good so but is there a world where for example other people over time that need you know some sort of like video use case or image use case theoretically you know you'd say oh why not you know I have some extra Cycles over here so which should kind of make you a competitor of Nvidia it's not intentionally per se but yeah I mean the you know this training and inference and we we do have you know two those two projects at T we've got Dojo which is the the training computer and then you know our inference chip which is in

45:37every every car inference computer so and Dojo we've only had Dojo one Dojo 2 is you know should be we should have Dojo 2 in volume towards the end of next year and and that that that will be we think sort of comparable to the sort of a b200 typ type system a training system and you know so

46:05there's I guess there's some potential for for that to be used as a service and but like you Dojo is is just kind of like I mean we're I guess I guess I have like some improved confidence in Dojo but I think we won't really know how good Dojo is until probably version three like usually takes three major iterations on a technology for it to be to be excellent and we'll only have the second major iteration next year

46:42the third iteration I don't know maybe late you know 26 or something like that how's the how's the Optimus project going I remember when we talked last and you said this publicly that it's in doing some light testing inside the factory so it's actually being useful what's the build of materials and when you know for something like that at scale so when you start making it like you're making the model three now and there's a million of them coming off the factory line what would the would they cost 20 30 $40,000 you think yeah I mean what I mean I've discovered really that you know anything made in sufficient volume will ASM totically approach the cost of

47:21its of its materials so now there's there's I should say the there's some some things are constrained by the cost of intellectual property and like paying for patents and stuff so a lot of you know what what's in a a chip is like paying paying royalties and depreciation of the chip faab so but the actual modal cost of the chips is very low so so so Optimus it obviously is

47:48humanoid robot it it is it weighs much less than it's much smaller than a car so the you could expect that in high volume and and i' said you also probably need three three production versions of Optimus so you need to refine the design three at least three major times and and then you need scale production to sort of the million unit plus per year level and I think at that point the cost

48:20the the you know the labor materials on Optimus is probably not much more than 10,000 yeah and that's a decade long journey maybe basically think of it like Optimus will cost less than a a small car right so at at scale volume with three major iterations of technology and and so if a small car you know costs $225,000 you know it's it's probably like I don't know $220,000 for for an Optimus for a humanoid robot that can be your your body like a combination of R2D2 and c3p a bit better I mean you know that's I honestly I think people are going to get really attached to their humanoid robot because I mean like you look at sort of watch Star Wars and it's like R2D2 and see3 I

49:08love those guys you know they're awesome and their personality and and I mean and all all R2 could do is just beef at you could couldn't speak English c3p to translate the beeps you know so you're in year two of that if you did two or three years per iteration or something it's a decade long journey for this to hit some sort of scale I I would say m major iterations are less than two years so okay it's probably on the order of five five years yeah maybe six to get to a million units a year and at that price point everybody can afford one on planet Earth I mean it's going to be that one: one two: one what do you think ultimately if we're sitting here in 30 years the number of

49:57robotss on the planet versus Humans yeah I think the number of robots will vastly exceed the number of humans vastly yeah vastly exceed I mean you have to say like who who would not want their robot buddy everyone wants a robot buddy you know this is like it especially if it can you know you know it can take care of your your take your dog for a walk it could you know mo mow the lawn it could watch your kids it could you know like it could it could teach your kids it could it could we could also send it to Mars we could send a lot of robots to Mars to do the work needed to yeah make it a colonized planet for you Mars is already the robot Planet there's

50:39like a whole bunch of you know robots like Rovers and Rob helicopter yes only robots so yeah the no I I think the the sort of useful humanoid robot opportunity is the single biggest opportunity ever because if you assume like that I mean the I think the ratio of humanoid robots to humans is going to be at least 2 to one maybe 3 to one because everybody every everybody will want one and then there'll be a bunch of robots that you don't see that are making goods and services and you think it's a general one generalized robot that then learns how to do different tasks or yeah hey I mean we are a generalized yeah we're a generalized robot we're just made of meat you know

51:28we're a meat General meat yeah I mean operating my meat puppet you know so yeah we are actually and by the way it turns out like as we're designing Optimus we sort of learn more and more about why humans are shaped the way they're shaped and you know and why we have five fingers and why your little finger is smaller than you know your index finger you know you know obviously why you have opposable thumbs but also why for example your the muscles the major muscles that operate your hand are actually in your forearm and and your fingers are primarily operated like your the muscles that actuate your fingers are located the vast majority of the of your finger strength is

52:17actually coming from your forearm and your fingers are being operated by tendons little strings that that's and so the current current version of the Optimus hand has the actuators in the hand and has only 11 degrees of freedom so it can't it's not as doesn't have all the degrees of freedom of human hand which has depending on how you count it roughly 25 degrees of freedom and

52:44and and and and it's also like not strong enough in certain ways because the actuators have to fit in the hand so the Next Generation Optimus hand which we have in Prototype form the the actuators have moved to the forearm just like a human and they operate the the fingers through cables just like a human hand and and then the next Generation had has 22 degrees of freedom which we think is enough to do almost anything that a human can do and presumably I think it was written that X and Tesla may work together and you know provide services but my immedate thought went to oh if you just provide a grock to the robot then the robot has a personality and can process

53:32oh yeah voice and video and images and all of that stuff as the as we wrap here U I think you know everybody talks about all the projects you're working on but people don't know you have a great sense of humor that's not true oh you do you do people don't see it but I would say one of I know for me the funniest week of my life or one of the funniest was when you did SNL and we got and you you I got to tag along maybe you saw it maybe behind the

54:02scenes like some of your funniest Recollections of that chaotic insane week when we laughed for 12 hours a day it was a little terrorizing on the first couple of days but yeah I was I was bit worried the beginning there because frankly nothing was funny day one was rough rough yeah so I mean

54:27it's like a rule but can't you guys just say it just say the stuff that got on the cutting some the funniest skits were the ones that didn't let you do that's what I'm saying can you just say there were a couple of funny ones yeah that they didn't let you you can say it so that he doesn't get I mean how much time do we have here well we should just give one or two because it was in your mind which one do we regret most not getting on air you really want to hear that I I mean I mean it was a little I see it was a little funny okay here we go all right here we go

55:06guys all right so one of the things that I think everyone's been sort of wondering this whole time is is Saturday night Saturday Night Live actually live like live live live live or do they have like a delay or like just in case you know there's a wardrobe malfunction or something like that is it like a you knowu 5sec delay what's really going on but there's a there's a way to test this right we came out the way there's a way to test this which is we don't tell them what's going on as I I W on and says this is the script I throw it on the ground we're going to find out tonight right now it's Saturday if sat night life is actually live and the way that we're going to do

55:56this is I'm going to take my [ __ ] [Applause] out this is the greatest pitch ever and and if if if if you see my [ __ ] you know it's true and if you don't it's been a lie it's been a lie all these years all these years now this is we're going to bust them right now and this we're pitching this yeah yeah so ping this on Zoom yeah ping this on zoom on like a Monday after like yeah we're like kind of hung over from the weekend and like Ping thisi and and and it's h it's you know Jason's on and Mike and you yeah and Mike you know got like you know who my friends who I think are sort of you know quite funny you know Jason's quite funny I think like like

56:51Jason's the closest thing to Cartman that exists in the real in real life we have a joke that he's Butters and I'm Cartman yeah so and then my friend Mike's Prett funny too so so we we come in like like just like guns blazing guns blazing with with like ideas and we didn't realize like actually you know that's not how it works and and and that that it's normally like actors and and they just get told what to do and like oh right well you mean we can't just like do funny things that we thought of what there watching this and on the zoom they're a gas pitch yeah it's silence like so I'm like and I'm like and I was like is this thing working is this are we muted is is

57:36our mic on they're like we hear you yeah and then and then after a long silence like Mike's Mike just says the word crickets crickets and they're not laughing they're going to not even going to chugle like what's going on and then Elon explains the punchline yes which is exactly so there's more to it okay yes

57:58that's just the beginning so Elon says so so then I'm so I'm like so so so so I said like I'm I'm I'm going to I'm going to reach [Laughter] down into my pet into my pants and and I stick my hand on my pants and I'm going and I'm and I'm going to pull my co and I tell this to the audience and the audience is going to be like go right and and and and and then and

58:24and then and then and then I pull out a a a baby rooster you know yes and it's like okay this is kind of PG you know it's like that not that bad it's like it's this is my tiny [ __ ] and and and it's like what do you think and so then and do you think it's an ice coock I mean I like it I pitch I'm like and then Kate McKennon walks out yeah exactly and I'm like oh no but you haven't heard half of it Kate mcken comes out yeah and she says Elon expected you would have a bigger [ __ ] yeah I like I I don't mean to disappoint you Kate but yeah but I I I hope you like it anyway but Kate's got to come out with with with her cat okay right so and Kate

59:16says you see where you can see where this is going and I say nice wow that's that's a that's a that's a nice [ __ ] you've got there Kate wow that's amazing it looks a little wet was it raining outside and then do you mind if I stroke your [ __ ] is that cool it's like oh no Elon actually can I hold your [ __ ] of course of course Kate you definely hold my [ __ ] and and then you know we exchang and I think just the audio version of this is pretty good right and and and you know so

59:54it's like wow you I really like stroking your [ __ ] and I was like I and then you say I'm really enjoying strug at your [ __ ] yes of course and yeah so you know they're looking at us like oh my god what have we done inviting these lunatics on the program yeah they said they said like well it is it is Mother's

1:00:23Day it's Mother's Day we might not want to go with this one the mom's in the audience and I'm like well that's a good point well fair fair it might be a bit uncomfortable for all the moms in the audience maybe I don't know I don't know maybe they'll dig it maybe they like it so yeah that was that's the that's the that's the

1:00:44that's the cold open that didn't make it we didn't get that on the air but we did fight for Doge yes and we got Doge on the air Ian there's a bunch of things that I said that were just not on the script like they have these like Q cards for what you're supposed to say and I just didn't say it I just went off off the rails yeah they didn't see that coming yeah it's live well it's

1:01:09live and so the Elon wanted to do Doge this is the other one and he wanted to do Doge on late night and he says Hey Jake Al can you make sure oh yeah so I want yeah I wanted to do the Doge father like you sort of redo the you know that scene from the the to Godfather I mean you kind of need the music to cue things

1:01:31up you bring me on my daughter's wedding listen you ask for Doge yeah you got R and I give you Bitcoin but you want do exactly you really got to set the mood you have to have tuxedo andice you got to have like Mar you come to me on this day of my Do's wedding and you ask me for your private

1:02:02keys are you even a friend you'll call me the Dodge father so b b know so that has potential they had great potential so they come to me and I'm I'm talking to Colin and Jo who's got a great sense of humor and he's amazing he loves Elon and he's like we can't do it because of the law and stuff like that and the law and liability so I said it's okay Elon called Comcast and he put in

1:02:33an offer and they just accepted it we just bought NBC so it's fine yeah and Colin Joe looks at me I sold this so good and he's like you're you're serious I'm like yep we own NBC now yeah and he's like okay well that kind of changes things doesn't it I'm like absolutely where're a go on on Doge yeah and then he's like you're [ __ ] with me and I'm I'm [ __ ] with you or are we or are we it was the greatest week of and that

1:03:07like is like two of 10 stories yeah we got yeah we got we'll save the other eight yeah but it was and I was just so happy for you to see you have a great week of just joy and fun and letting go cuz you were launching Rockets you're dealing with so much [ __ ] in your life to have those moments yeah to share them and just laugh it was just so great and more of those moments I think we got to we got to get you back on SNL who wants them back on SNL one more time all right ladies and gentlemen our bestie Elon Musk [Applause] [Laughter] [Applause]

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份