All-In 峰会的开场有点特别。主持人挨个念马斯克的头衔:SpaceX 创始人、首席执行官兼总工程师,特斯拉首席执行官、产品架构师兼董事长,X 的所有者、董事长兼首席技术官,无聊公司的创始人,Neuralink 和 OpenAI 的联合创始人,马斯克基金会的会长。念完他问了一句,我漏了什么吗?
镜头切过去,马斯克出现在屏幕上。主持人问他人在哪里,他说在飞机上,用的是星链。
主持人愣了一下:这是全世界唯一一台装在飞机上的星链终端吧?马斯克说,目前就这一台,不过已经有一批客机在装,以后会很多。他补了一句:机上星链的延迟低于 20 毫秒,比不少人家里的宽带还好。
这场对话的其余部分,就在这样一条链路上完成。一个已经在万米高空提供宽带的人,接下来要谈的是星舰、乌克兰战场、广告商抵制、台湾,以及比核武器更危险的数字超级智能。
星舰第二次发射,卡在一张纸上
主持人提到上半年那次发射,画面确实壮观。马斯克说,第二艘星舰已经在星舰基地(Starbase)完成堆叠,上周刚收尾,FAA 要求的整改也做完了,现在只等发射许可。
真正卡住第二次飞行的,只剩下监管审批。(马斯克)
这次飞行多了一个新东西:热分离(hot staging)。
传统的一二级分离,是助推器先熄火,飞船再点火,中间有一段双方都不出力的空窗期。火箭在这个窗口里白白掉速度。热分离反过来,助推器的发动机还在猛推,飞船的发动机已经点火,两股推力叠在一起完成分离。马斯克说,这是火箭入轨效率最高的分离方式,但上次没敢试,这次要试。
风险也在这里。他给的概率是:超过 50% 能完成级间分离,接近 50% 能入轨。他停顿了一下,改口说,如果热分离顺利,入轨概率大概在 30% 以上。而在上一次发射之前,他说的是低于 50%。
主持人问他,这个难度放在他整个职业生涯里算什么水平。马斯克的回答是尺寸和复用两个维度。
星舰比土星五号(Saturn V)大两倍多,推力大约是土星五号的三倍。土星五号是一次性的,用完就扔。星舰的设计目标是完全、快速可复用:助推器和飞船都要飞回发射场,被发射塔上的巨型机械臂夹住。马斯克管那对机械臂叫机械哥斯拉(Mechazilla)。
他描述的画面很具体:一枚几十层楼高的火箭从空中落下来,被两根机械臂接住,放回发射架,加注燃料准备下一次。目标是做到飞机级别的飞行频率。当然,它比 747 或者 A380 大得多。
那个半夜打来的电话
主持人把话题转到乌克兰。过去一周,马斯克因为"关掉克里米亚附近的星链"被骂得很凶。
他先纠正了一个理解偏差。星链从战争开始几天内就在乌克兰运行,乌克兰官员多次公开说星链对乌克兰的存续起到了关键作用。这些表态在 X 上都还查得到,只是媒体报道时经常省略。
然后他说克里米亚周边区域当时为什么是关闭的。
原因跟战争立场无关。美国对俄罗斯的制裁覆盖克里米亚,任何公司未经美国政府明确批准,不能向受制裁地区提供通信服务。SpaceX 没有拿到这份批准。
乌克兰方面也没有提前通知。半夜来的紧急电话,要求立刻打开覆盖。马斯克说他一开始没听懂,问对方说的是哪个区域,对方说克里米亚附近。
弄明白之后他发现,这是一次针对塞瓦斯托波尔(Sevastopol)俄罗斯舰队的突袭。对方要求星链提供的,是一场重大战争行动的通信保障。
他在这里讲了一段关于珍珠港的类比。日本当年那次偷袭,战术上赢了,战略上输得彻底。它激怒了美国公众,把一整个国家拖进复仇。马斯克认为,对塞瓦斯托波尔舰队的突袭不会让俄罗斯认输,只会让俄罗斯暴怒,然后导致冲突大规模升级。
主持人追问:如果当时是拜登总统直接下令,你会打开吗?
我不是拜登总统最大的粉丝。但如果我收到一份总统指令,要求打开,我会照做。我尊重总统这个职位,总统是这个国家的首席执行官,不管我喜不喜欢这个人。(马斯克)
他说这样的指令从来没有来过。
节目里还提到几天前 CNN 的一场采访。主持人杰克·塔珀(Jake Tapper)追着国务卿布林肯(Antony Blinken),用一连串诱导性问题攻击马斯克。布林肯没有接招,反而替 SpaceX 说了话。马斯克对这一点表示了认可。
然后是钱的部分。
支持乌克兰的支出,SpaceX 自己算过一笔账,大约 1 亿美元。这 1 亿还不包括另一项成本:整个星链星座面临的风险。
俄罗斯希望这套系统彻底消失。控制中心可能被网络攻击,卫星可能被指令变轨坠毁,也可能遭遇反卫星武器。整个星链系统的价值接近 100 亿美元。马斯克说,这部分风险没有任何人补偿。
对比很刺眼。美国为乌克兰拨出的资金总额在 800 亿到 1000 亿美元之间。其他所有向乌克兰提供支持的公司都拿到了钱。
我们做的是最有价值的那件事,拿到的钱却最少。尽管这样,我们还是乐意继续做下去。(马斯克)
把公共广场从左边挪回中间
主持人问他,拜登政府是不是在针对你。
马斯克说他不确定整个政府的态度,但政府内部确实有一些利益集团,不希望他好过。他话锋一转,提到一个更大的问题:政府的武器化(weaponization of government),以及检察官自由裁量权被滥用。
他的逻辑是这样的:法律面前人人平等,这句话没人反对。但真正决定结果的是,你选择去追诉谁。如果被追诉的是看起来微不足道的案子,而被放过的是一堆严重犯罪,独立选民会自己得出结论。
主持人问,收购 X 之后情况有变化吗?
马斯克说有一些。
他描述 X 的目标:做一个平整的公共广场,服务这个国家中间的 80%。他给出的理由是,此前所有社交媒体都严重偏左,推特尤其偏左。平台对共和党候选人、共和党议题、右翼声音的压制比例,至少是对左翼声音压制的 10 倍。
所以他要做的是往中间移。
如果你站在左边,一切看起来都在往右移。实际发生的事情只有一件,往中间移。(马斯克)
一个群聊不需要一支军队
主持人提到,他们俩当时就在现场,看着马斯克拿到推特大楼的钥匙,那是十个月前的事。
马斯克的评价很直接:接手时这不是一家运转良好的公司。
十个月后,他认为有几件事可以说。广告收入最近出现了明显回升,如果这个趋势能延续,公司在广告这块的财务状况会不错。功能交付速度方面,他估计过去一年交付的新功能,比推特过去五年加起来还多。
做到这些用的人,是原来公司的 15% 到 20%。
他给了一个类比:X 这个东西,跟一个群聊有多大区别?本质就是一个大规模群聊。维护一个群聊,不需要一支军队。
说到军队,他拿特斯拉做了对照。特斯拉整个自动驾驶 AI 软件团队是 200 人。推特在做的事情,复杂度远低于自动驾驶,但当时的人数是前者的十倍以上。
他承认还有别的事需要人:广告销售、网络运营。但团队的规模跟业务体量应该匹配。
衡量平台健康度,他挑了一个指标:iOS 上报的屏幕使用时长。理由是移动设备上报的屏幕时间最难作弊,比任何日活、月活都实在。他说这个数字目前很好。
主持人问他,现在回头看这笔收购感觉如何。马斯克的回答是,公司刚刚转过一个弯,他对前景谨慎乐观。
创作者的三条收入线,和一套要开源的算法
话题转到创作者经济。主持人问为什么做收入分成,以及想把这块做成什么样。
马斯克的起点很朴素:一个创作者要靠内容吃饭,就得有一份公平、有竞争力的报酬。不管是写作、图片还是视频。
这块没有发明新东西。YouTube 怎么跟创作者分广告收入,X 就怎么做。除此之外还有直接订阅:读者可以按月订阅某个账号,账号主可以发音频、视频、长文或者纯文字。订阅费本身也是一条收入线。
目标是让 X 成为创作者最好的落脚点。有值得看的内容,你会想把它放在这里。
接下来他讲了一段关于算法的话,信息量很大。
X 的推荐算法已经开源了大部分,很快会全部开源。剩下的部分迟迟没放出来,理由有点尴尬:代码写得太难看,得先清理一下再公开。
为什么要开源?为了透明,也为了信任。马斯克说,理想状态是任何人都能拿着公开的算法,独立复现一条帖子为什么会爆。你能提前知道会发生什么,事后也能解释为什么。
然后是优化目标。X 优化的指标是用户在平台上的停留时间。这带来一个自然的推论:让人停留更久的内容,优先级会高于让人快速划走的内容。长视频、长文、原生上传的内容,天然占优。
如果你在帖子里放一个站外链接,用户点出去,在站内停留的时间几乎为零。系统会认为这条内容没有增加用户时间,于是它的曝光会被压低。它不会被删除,只是拿不到那么多注意力。
他给优化目标加了一个限定词:不后悔的用户时间(unregretted user minutes)。
他说很多人跟他讲过,自己在 TikTok 上花了很多时间,然后感到后悔。X 想做到的是,你花了很多时间,学到东西、被娱乐到,事后不觉得亏。
如果成功,你会想在这个平台上多待一会儿,待完之后你不会后悔。(马斯克)
六十个百分点的广告跌幅
主持人问起反诽谤联盟(ADL)那件事,问是不是准备起诉。
马斯克说要看情况。
他先讲事实:ADL 发起了一场抵制,他们不叫抵制,叫"暂停投放"。但这个暂停是没有期限的。结果是美国广告收入出现断崖式下跌,跌幅 60%。亚洲区的广告基本没有变化。
他提到,公司反复提交了系统分析报告,包括第三方独立分析。这些分析显示,平台上有害内容的浏览量在下降。掌握全部数据的第三方给出的结论是,仇恨言论变少了。
马斯克认为,问题从来不在仇恨言论,也不在反犹主义。问题在于,ADL 和一批类似组织已经变成了激进组织,行动远远超出它们声称的使命,也超出了捐款人对它们的预期。
他举了一个例子。ADL 当年在推动特朗普被封号这件事上起了关键作用。后来 X 恢复了特朗普的账号,ADL 立刻表示,仅仅恢复账号这一动作本身就构成仇恨言论。马斯克的反驳是:他还没说任何话,一个字都还没发,哪来的新增仇恨内容?
他还补了一句:特朗普的女婿是犹太人,孙辈是犹太人,他本人出席过犹太婚礼,说这个人反犹很难成立。
颠倒的世界
主持人数了一下马斯克最近挨骂最多的两个立场:第一,捍卫言论自由;第二,主张和平。
他们说,今天《纽约客》有一篇文章把马斯克称作超级反派,理由正是他在倡导和平、在保护第一修正案。
马斯克接话:现在已经分不清什么是真实报道,什么是讽刺 parody。有篇稿子读下来,你会以为它是洋葱新闻或者巴比伦蜜蜂(Babylon Bee)发的。超级反派通常都是主张和平的,这本来该是个笑话。
节目里还聊到一段没上 SNL 的段子,叫"觉醒版詹姆斯·邦德"(woke James Bond)。他们写完之后,《卫报》爆出消息,说新的邦德小说和短篇故事太"觉醒",情节跟他们两年前写的恶搞几乎一模一样。
马斯克顺手调侃了一句阴谋论:那些没有成真的阴谋论清单已经短得可怜,人类需要再生产一些新的素材。
台湾,和一个被反复提起的夏威夷
主持人提到当天请了格雷厄姆·艾利森(Graham Allison)、雷·达里奥(Ray Dalio)等人,聊了一天美中关系。他们问马斯克,作为在中国有深度供应链和客户关系的企业家,怎么在当下的氛围里做决策。
马斯克先划清界限。SpaceX 和星链在中国没有任何业务,中国的规则也不允许。星链在中国是禁用的。特斯拉在四个整车工厂里,有一个在上海,中国市场很重要。
但他强调,他的绝大部分商业利益在中国之外。
他说自己对中国算了解。去过很多次,多年来跟各个层级的高层领导见过面,特斯拉在中国本土也做得相当成功。
然后他给出了他认为的核心问题:台湾。
中国的政策,半个世纪以来,甚至更长时间以来,一直是让台湾回归。马斯克用一个类比来解释这个立场:从中国的角度看,台湾的地位类似夏威夷,是一块本来属于自己、却因为外部力量而被人为分割出去的土地。
那个外部力量,他点名了:美国太平洋舰队。它挡住了任何形式的统一行动。
他接着讲了军力对比。中国的军事实力在逐年增长,美国的军力基本是静止的。从战略上看,防守台湾并不容易,因为它离中国海岸太近。
他的推论是:在不远的将来,中国在该区域的军力会远远超过美国在该区域的军力。如果按中国政策字面上的意思理解,当外交途径走不通时,就会有一个武力方案。这个方案他们说了很多年。
所以他认为,美中双方都在为一场潜在的摊牌做准备,地点是南海。他看到的具体表现是技术出口管制:英伟达的 H100 芯片不能卖到中国,先进造船设备也不能。他预计中国会出台对等反制,接下来几年会看到一轮一轮互相加码的制裁。
最后落到一个问题:统一最终走外交路径,还是非外交路径。他没有给答案,只说中国已经讲清楚,无论如何会有一个结果。
「物种叛徒」这个词
主持人把话题拉回 AI,问他怎么看当年参与创办 OpenAI 这件事,后悔的部分和收获的部分分别是什么,以及他在 X 上做 AI 的目标。
马斯克从最大的那句开始:数字超级智能可能是人类创造过的最重要的技术,它比核武器更危险。
创办 OpenAI 的动机是打破单极格局。当时的情况是,谷歌通过旗下的 DeepMind 掌握了 AI 领域压倒性的人才、算力和资源。而谷歌的走向,某种程度上取决于拉里·佩奇(Larry Page)、谢尔盖·布林(Sergey Brin)和埃里克·施密特(Eric Schmidt)这几个人的想法,因为他们通过超级投票权控制着 Alphabet,两票就能定事。
转折点是一次对话。马斯克说,佩奇在谈话中称他为"物种叛徒"(species traitor),理由是他站在人类这一边。
我问,那你站哪一边?(马斯克)
他的判断是:把数字超级智能的全部未来,交给一个认为"亲人类"等于背叛的人,这件事让他不舒服。
OpenAI 最初是非营利、开源的。马斯克对现状的评价是,它现在应该改名叫"为了最大利润而闭源 AI"(Closed for Maximum Profit AI)。他提到有消息说 OpenAI 打算筹集 1000 亿美元,用来买海量算力,去造一个数字上帝。他顺手开了个玩笑:听说所有参数权重都存在一个 CSV 文件里,那这位数字上帝本质上是个逗号分隔的表格。
然后是微软。OpenAI 的服务器跑在微软的 Azure 数据中心,微软能接触到全部源代码,能接触到 GPT-4 以及后续版本的全部权重。马斯克的判断是,最终微软对这套东西的控制力超过 OpenAI 本身。OpenAI 依赖微软,这一点 OpenAI 自己未必完全意识到。就算微软违约,官司也要打上好几年。
所以局面演变成谷歌和微软之间的竞赛。谷歌这边,他担心的是对 AI 安全不够上心,而且有理由这么担心。微软那边,是一家以盈利为目标的企业。他不否认微软很出色,但要说微软在道德决策上有漂亮的记录,很难讲得出口。
结论是:需要第三家公司参与竞争。
四百万辆车上的推理算力
这第三家,是 xAI 加上特斯拉。
马斯克在这里说了一句他认为被市场低估的话:特斯拉在真实世界 AI 上是领先的。不是实验室里的基准测试,是在物理世界里理解路况、做出反应的那种 AI。
主持人问他,特斯拉开放过专利,X 开源了算法,那会不会把 Dojo 或者全自动驾驶(FSD)也开放成平台让别人用。
他的回答分两层。
软件可以开源。硬件不行。开源一份芯片设计图纸,不等于别人马上就能造出这颗芯片。能用这些芯片的,只有那些愿意砸几十亿美元建计算设施的人。
他顺便抛了一个少有人提的数字:车上的推理计算机,整体算力远超 Dojo。目前路上大约有 400 万辆车装着高速 AI 推理计算机。这是一张已经铺开的分布式算力网络。
他还提到 Optimus 人形机器人,认为这件事非常有意思。
关于治理结构,他讲了一段挺坦诚的话。特斯拉没有超级投票权,如果有一天他疯了,股东可以把他投票赶走。他手里的票数有一些影响力,但不足以在胡来的时候保住位置。他认为这个安排是好的。
最后一块拼图是三十万行代码
访谈快结束时,主持人说他自己在试用 FSD 测试版,有些路段的表现相当惊人。他问马斯克,距离那个"ChatGPT 时刻"还有多远。
马斯克的判断是:已经很近了。近到即使车里没有人监督、没有人接管,FSD 完成一段安全行程的概率也高于人类自己开。
他给的证据是里程数据。目前 FSD 测试版状态下行驶的里程,安全性已经高于不开 FSD 的里程。
然后是趋势对比。把今天的版本跟半年前、一年前、一年半前分别摆在一起看,提升幅度非常大。
最后一块拼图在控制环节。车辆的控制部分目前由大约 30 万行 C++ 代码写成,要把这块也换成神经网络。整条链路变成"光子进,控制出",从摄像头输入直接到转向刹车输出,中间全部由神经网络完成。
他说,这一步做完,全自动驾驶显著优于人类驾驶员这件事就基本成立了。
整场对话到这里结束。主持人道了句"飞得安全",马斯克下线,画面切回掌声。
回头看这两个小时,有几件事是能直接拿来用的。
- 判断一家公司的技术密度,看它用了多少人做出多少东西。推特用 15% 到 20% 的人交付了比过去五年更多的功能,特斯拉自动驾驶软件团队只有 200 人。人多的团队未必在做难的事,可能只是在维护一个本该很简单的系统。
- 做内容要看清平台的优化目标。X 优化的指标是站内停留时长,原生上传的长内容天然占优,链到站外的帖子会被系统性降权。所有平台的推荐逻辑最后都会落到某个可量化的指标上,找到那个指标,比研究算法细节更有用。
- 把"事后不后悔"当成筛选内容的标准。刷完之后是否觉得亏,比刷了多久更能说明问题。这条标准对创作者同样成立,做让人事后不后悔的内容,是长期唯一划得来的做法。
- 技术出口管制会持续加码,做供应链的人要提前算好两套账。芯片、造船设备、AI 算力,管制清单只会变长。依赖单一来源的关键环节,值得现在就做一次替代方案的压力测试。
- 评估一项 AI 能力,要区分"演示"和"里程"。马斯克判断 FSD 靠的是行驶里程上的安全数据,不是几段惊艳的视频。看任何 AI 产品,先问它在真实场景里跑了多少量、出错的代价由谁承担。
- 硬件开源意义有限,软件开源才是杠杆。开放芯片图纸没人能立刻造出来,开放算法和代码却能立刻被验证。想建立信任,先开放别人能拿来复现的那部分。
0:00[Applause] okay wait I'll just I'll just read off all of your companies Elon I know them but I'm just going to read them to make sure I don't miss one because there's so many now founder CEO chief engineer of SpaceX CEO product architect and chairman of Tesla owner chairman CTO of x x.com founder of boring company co-founder of neurolink and open Ai and president of the mus Foundation did I get everything let your Winner's
0:43ride and we open source it to the fans and they've just gone crazy [Music] with where are you me it is coming it's kind of absurd where are you at Star base I'm in FL currently so this is this is a starlink and Flake connection are you kidding me that that's oh yeah that works pretty well huh I think there's only one wait I think it's one of of how stalling Works in an airplane at altitude there's only one of those in existence right it's on your plane that's it 101 there are a number of airliners that have stalling and there will be a lot more in the future Starling connection when you're assuming it's working properly is you would even be able to tell you you're on the ground
1:36or in the air because unlike Jo satellit the latency is you know really be less than 20 millisecs so it's a in fact for a lot I think for some people the Sonic connection on the plane will be better than their connection at their house that would be pretty great H how is the Starship doing it was incredible to see the first launch but I understand you're closing in on the second I know you've been working really hard on that and the team's working hard on it when do you think you're going to get the next one up and what are the chances it makes it to orbit well we have the second one stacked at Star base so it's ready to go and we finished that up in the last
2:24week we believe we've we've completed the rain I had an requested by the FAA so we should get our license hopefully soon but really the only thing holding back second plan of Starship at this point is Right fire approval wow what's your expectation or your hope in terms of the probability that it gets to orbit it's just a question of timing yeah how long it does take to get the approval paperwork whatnot so that's really up to the FAA at this point yeah but but what about making it to orbit do you think oh we are doing a new staging technique called hot staging where you light the up the upstage engines or the ship engines while the boost stage is still firing and this is the
3:17kind of the most efficient way to do is stage separation of rocket going orbit but we did not try that on the last mission and and we're trying on this Mission we think it will be overall better but I think this I think probably have a I hope well over 50% chance of getting to Stage separation and maybe at close to 50% chance of getting to Orit if the hot staging the new separation method is it works so I'd say maybe it's like a you know above i' say probably above 30% chance of getting toor with the sign whereas previously I said below 50 is this in terms of complexity how complex is this of a problem compared to the other problems you've worked on in your
4:03career well so I mean making a rocket that is more the twice the size of the SAT 5 you know it's a in fact with an extra of the rocket it'll have roughly three times the thrust of a Saturn 5 Moon rocket whever it's signed to be fully rapidly reusable whereas the you know the SAT was completely Expendable and with baline we we still expand the upper stage but we we bring back the boo stage as people have probably seen the The Rocker liing videos and we are also able to recover the varant with the with falc but these things do land toly out to sea so it takes a while to bring them back to board and get them ready for figh G the the thing that you know so so this's a
4:53scale of Starship but then also the fact that it is designed for full and R re usability so both the booster and the ship come back launch site they get caught by these giant meaz arms youve see in congress's Godzilla it's basically bad catches this giant rocket out of you know B air and puts it back on the launch stand and gets ready for launch so it will be capable of you know basically aircraft level flight rates but but it's much bigger than say a 747 or 8380 you want can we talk about
5:31the events of was it last weekend the whole Ukraine Starling thing can you give us like a the Tik Tok of like what's going on and like how you're being forced to decide but like what is it like in that decision room if there was one or wherever you were where you're trying to figure out am I keeping this on do I turn it off what is going on people must have been bombarding you whatever you can share about what that was like how you made the decision yeah I I so I was actually mistaken a
6:04little bit in understanding the situation you know obviously we St sex have provided starlink connectivity for you know to Ukraine really since the beginning of the war really within a I think a few days of the war starting and as the Ukrainian Governor said the S was instrumental in the FS of Ukraine so you know they've said that really many times although the media forgets to mention that so and in fact they've said it on Twitter you X only know on his Twitter it's going to take a while to get that right yeah take a little time
6:52[Laughter] so you know you don't have to you don't have to take my words for it you just read what what they put you know so so son has been incredibly helpful to the Ukraine war eff we' have gone out of pocket very significantly to help them and at at the time this happened the region around Crimea was actually turned off now the reason it was turned off was actually originally was because United States had sanctions against Russia and we're not allowed to actually and that includes Crimea and the sanctions and we're not allowed to actually turn on connectivity to sanction the country without explicit government approval we did not have from the US government so
7:48so so basically the you know Ukraine didn't they didn't give us any any advanced warning or heads up or anything we just got the the sort of urgent calls from the Ukrainian government saying that we needed to turn on primier it's like in the middle of the night basically and we're like what are you talking about you know you which's it four you know and then you know we basically figured out that this was kind of like a bhit type attack on Sasol on the Russian
8:26fet Sasol so they're really asking us for to to really for actually take part in a major act War and you know well we so certainly have huge EMP support for the Ukrainian government the Ukrainian government is not in charge us people or companies that's not how it works and and Elon if if I could just but I should say that you know although I'm not President Biden's biggest fan if if I had received a Presidential Directive to turn it on I would have done so because I do regard the president as the chief executive officer of the country whether I want that post to the president or not I S respect the office and so if if you know if we gotten if I gotten a request from the
9:18president type of thing from the American president to be clear then I I I would have turned it on you know so but no such requests came through that that's a really that's a really interesting point and you're I mean the what jamas is referring to is you're now being attacked I saw there was a you know there was Jake Tapper the other day on CNN interviewing our secretary state was just he was all lathered up basically attacking you for this David David I mean to his credit secetary Lincoln was actually quite supportive despite the Absurd you know accusations and leading questions of the Jake taper at CN yeah he didn't take the bait credit to sery Lincoln in
10:05this regard for not you know taking the bait at all yeah well I to me this is an example of no good deed goes unpunished because if you had never given I hope I hope some good deeds back go unpunished I mean if you if you had never given Starling that you know but yeah I mean my point is just if if you had never given Starling to the Ukrainian government for free voluntarily you just volunteered it then no one be attacking you right now for not turning it on so they could do their attack on Crea yeah also one other thing I'll note is that your reason for not turning it on which is you don't be part of what could be a major escalation was exactly was exactly the reason that
10:53Biden Administration did not give attam attam missiles to Ukraine at that point in the War now they may be changing their minds but they were very worried about an attack the administration was an attack on Crea triggering some huge escalation of this war so not only did you not receive a directive from President Biden your thinking was very much in line with theirs at the time and and you're being attacked for that now there there's something you mentioned which is that you did this at a lot of economic cost to SpaceX can you just can you just talk about that for a second because I'm not sure people understand who's paying for what right now and who hasn't been paid and you
11:35know Etc there is well as you say like a lot of people are contributed to the effort staring is the fundamental communication backbone of the Ukrainian government and and essential services like First Responders and that kind of thing and you know is is used we we hope peacefully relatively peacefully on the warfront it is the only thing that works on the warfront everything else is been jamed by the Russians so it the only thing that works not not one of the [Applause]
12:10things you know but but I think you have to sort of think of say the you know you know taking the actual example of Paul har and say like well how did that work out for Japan it didn't work out well at all right because it was a a tactical victory a strategic defeat it enraged the American public who sort of naturally wanted Vengeance for for the Z you know the Zach and I think that that you know while I don't think it's on the same scale that there was certainly that potential of sort of a many P Hava with results in a mass escalation of hostilities but not
12:54this would this would not this would not defeat Russia it would enrage Russia do you Don do you donate the network or do they pay you for it sorry yeah so I'm actually not sure what the final accounting is at this point but I I I think at one point at one point you calculated our sort of cost of supporting things that roughly $100 million now the $100 million does not count the mass of risk to the entire Starling constellation because Russia would like to have the entire thing deleted so you know nobody's compensating us for that and so if we were to get
13:36say our control center were take down and Cyber attack they you know they command satellites to the over and destroy the entire system or use anti satellite weapons so you know the these are this is a pretty significant risk for which we have not received any compensation and obviously would be catastrophic to the entire stalling system which is you know approaching $10 billion Elon do you think the current government Administration saying hey 10 mil million and then actually I say one of the BR meing things was as you as you've seen there's there's a very large amount of money that's been appropriated for Ukraine you know I'm not sure what the the total is at this point but
14:27must be 100 close billion or somewhere between 80 and 100 billion you know now all of the you know other sort of providers us providers of support to Ukraine are being paid so then why should SpaceX be excluded that doesn't make sense we we're doing one of the most valuable things and yet are getting the least money this iser but you know despite that we're still happy to keep keep going and
15:00Elon does the Biden Administration have it out for you and why H what have gave you that idea [Laughter] yeah but let me ask you own and control I don't if the whole Administration has it out me I think there probably aspects of the administration that are not or or you know as aspects of you know interests aligned with with with with resent Biden who probably do not wish
15:33good things for me I don't know you know really what their issue is but there does seem to be a significant increase in the weaponization of government and I say really sort of misuse of prosecutorial discretion in a many many areas where and I think this is this is really a dangerous thing for you know for I don't
16:05know for that to be potis and politics with with with government agencies it's it's just really and then I think from you know from from say you know Democratic party standpoint or or say B Biden Administration standpoint I think this is this the danger here is that if there's significant must use prosecutorial discretion let's say one says okay everyone's equal under the law yes but who are you who are you choosing to pursue and if if you if you're pursuing what what appeared to Independent voters to be trivial cases while ignoring serious
16:49crimes it's hard to imagine that a lot of independent voters that's going to win over thoughtful independent voters did this did things change when you bought X yeah I think that they did change somewhat you know I I'll go with the with with the sort of you know the xplatform is really to be a Level Playing Field a public square that is supportive of you know most of the country let's say that the middle 80% or something like that now that's not been the case really for all social media that all social media have been really very very left leading far left leading and really Twitter was far left leading you know the the suspensions of of s Republican candidates or interests or
17:44voices was was really at least 10 times the rate of of suppression of left left bring voices on you know on all Twitter so so what what I'm trying to do is move it to the middle which from standpoint of say the left appears it is moving to the right Everything's Relative if you're standing on the left but it's not it's simply moving to the middle that's all in an attempt to actually represent the whole country and and not just here half the country or even maybe less than half the country so that's it really so I think there's like there's really to be alarmed about here it's you know it's just that it's intended to be a Town Square inclusive of the whole country
18:36and else you know and and the world that's all it it's been I guess you took over X Twitter on Halloween weekend if I remember correctly when you got to the building you got the keys and David and I were lucky to be there with you when you got the keys and we got to check things out this is 10 months into a turnaround and it wasn't a high functioning organization I think when you took it over where is the company at now and are you pleased with I guess the progress because it looks like new features are getting launched the product velocity is great obviously advertising's been challenging but it feels like there's some green shoots so so how do you feel about the purchase
19:21now yeah well I should say we recently seen a significant increase in advertising which is great so that's a you know if that Trend continues I think the company will be in in very good Financial shape on the advertising front so that in terms of positive developments that that seems to be one of them and from a feature
19:45standpoint I think those who are look using the system I think we' I think we might have delivered more new features you know in the last I know a year than in the last you know all tter did in 5 years you know there there really feature the feature development pace is very rapid and this is being done with really about 15% of the original company
20:12maybe a little more 15 20% so it's it's really you know efficient you know at the end of the day you have to say you know how complicated is a system like the X Twitter platform you know how different is it from a group chat frankly it's like a group chat at scale so he I don't think you need an army
20:37to maintain a group chat yeah yeah I mean it's it's not the self-driving platform and it had maybe 10 times as many people working on it as the self-driving platform at Tesla which seems crazy the entire self-driving AI software team is 200 people and the what they're doing is much more complex than Twitter or you know much a lot more so you now there's other things that obviously need to be done like advertising sales OB network operations and how can you talk to it's really not it's not a it's not a huge I don't like I said don't even know me for for for what we're here and I think you know the people that that are still the company are obviously being
21:35very productive in creating and deling new features and you know we keep seeing sort of RedBoard usage and the the know the most prous number is really the is user seconds as reported by the mobile device especially iOS the the iOS what iOS reports as the screen time is the is the least gameful metric and and those numbers are exem are very good so you know I think I'm course justly optimistic about where things are headed and I I feel like the company's turned just you know just recently turned turn a corner tell us about you know said at least moderate prosperity and and hopefully significant tell us about the success of sharing Revenue why did
22:26you do it and then just the the vision you have for just the Creator economy and what you want that to evolve into and build into yeah I mean it sounds to reason that if if you're a Creator and you need to need to make a Livy for what you're doing so there's got to be you know Fair compensation competitive compensation for a Creator whether they're doing you know WR their writing or pictures video whatever the case may be and so we're and we're so we're not really in you know inventing anything new here we're just you know as YouTube does with creators they will do rev show with advertising and so we're doing rev show with advertising we're also to have enabled direct
23:17subscription to accounts where whatever somebody you know you could be doing audio video long form text anything and you can subscribe to someone and that's you know OB that's way for a subscriber to make a living as as well you know for a Creator to make a living so the intent is for the ACT platform to be the best home for creators where if you've got interesting content then you you want to put it on a platform and you know there's a lot of questions about like sort of the algorithm and whatnot I I should mention like the the algorithm is I think almost all of it is open sourced and and we will I think quite soon have the entire open source the only reason I it really
24:01hasn't been done entirely open source yet is because we're somewhat embarrassed with the code and need to just clean it up before putting something extremely embarrassing out there but the point is that like we want transparency boths trust and if you've got if you if you can recreate the results on the xform of how viral a post is going to be independently using the you know the the public algorithm you know the H algorithm that that's really where we want to get to so you you kind of you kind of know what to expect and and why something happened now now I should say the we are we are trying to optimize for user time on the
24:50platform what this naturally means is that posting content that someone looks at longer is going to get higher priority than content that is short just because the system is trying to Max it's it's aspiring to maximize you unreg user remittance is what I call it so like basically how do we if we're succeeding you want to spend more time on the platform and you want to and after having spent that time you don't want to regret it I mean speaking of Tik Tok you know that's I've had a lot of people tell me they spend a lot of time on Tik Tok and they regret it we don't want to be we want it to be that you spend a lot of time on the xplatform and you learned a lot you
25:43you're entertained and you don't regret it so when you're optimizing for you know user minutes and like I said aspirationally under regretted use minutes if you the more content that you post on the system the more reach that thing will get because the system is saying oh those user is spending more time in the platform because they're they're you know seeing say your podcast or reading a long
26:11form article or watching some video that's going to get a lot more time than say if you if you link to a video elsewhere or you link to an article elsewhere that that that's just that that that that means you'll you will be on that post for a very short period of time and so the the system will be like okay that did not increase user time so it will it won't be excluded it it will get less attention that than actually posting content natively on the system do you want to talk about the ADL and you sort of where what the status of that is whether you're pursuing a lawsuit or not or where that stands I think we'll have to see about that I mean
26:58yeah I mean the fact of matter is that ad did initiate a boycott they don't call it a boycott they call it a pause but you know po that is never ending isot so and and and we just we saw a massive drop in us advertising we saw basically no change in advertising in Asia but domestically with ADL is strong we saw 60% drop in advertising so you
27:29know that's pretty intense and and this is despite you know showing repeated analyses of the system including third party analysis of the system which actually showed that the number of views of hateful content declined so you know the third parties who have all the data analyz and said actually there's less safe speech the issue I think with the ADL is not a question of hate speech it's not a question of any semitism obviously it's that the ad and a lot of other organizations have become activist organizations which are acting far beyond their stated mandate or their original mandate and and I think far beyond what donors to those organizations think they are
28:22doing you know one of the things that the a was extremely opposed to and in fact was instrumental in in happening was there the ad was instrumental in getting Donald Trump the platformed and then when we we you know we restored the account they they made it super clear that they regarded simply restoring his account on you know Twitter now that that that constituted hateful speech like he hasn't even said anything you know he has to at least say something or post something for there to be incremental painful painful content this is absurd and what's this got to do with anti-Semitism like you know Donald Trump's son-in-law is Jewish his Jewish
29:09gr I'm pretty sure he's not anti-semitic okay you know he's at the wedding so this this so so the problem is that a lot of these organizations like said they've really been captured by the W agenda and they're they're pushing you know serious of beliefs and values that I think are often contrary to their what what they're done as belief and that's that's what we have in the situation well yeah I I'll note that the the two positions that you've taken that have brought the most heat on you number one defending Free Speech number two advocating peace and how dare
29:50you how dare you how dare you and there's there's an article like the opposite world or something yeah we're living in upside down World there there's an article in today's New Yorker calling you a super villain because you're advocating peace and protecting the first amendment I mean it's like completely upside down do you want people to eat their vegetables you at this point you literally cannot tell actual press from parody no like if that was a bon be or onion no literally you're doing a you're doing and and change the banner to you know Babylon b or whatever onion or something like that par some parody thing and be like oh that's a good joke
30:36you know yeah super bones normally advocate for peace that's you know of course we want to get rid of all the nuclear weapons hey hold that's what the funniest the funniest skit that didn't make it on SNL that we were worksh Shing was probably woke James Bond and we wanted to do like
31:03this woke James Bond and Eli will tell you some of the jokes it was pretty hilarious but then we were just talking about a story that broke in the guardian about the new James Bond novel and short story is to woke and it's literally the parody we did two years ago Elon speaking of Peace we
31:24had we had a grais reality also like the you know the you know conspiracy theories that that that haven't come true list is you know quite short sees that turn out quite short and we really need more conspiracies generated because we're running out of to find the [Laughter] truth okay check off is accurate so
31:55I don't know who's the you know responsible these conspiracy theories but but you know we just need some more material paging Alex Jones Elon we had Graham Alison here today I know you talked about his book we had Ray Doo here we had Ro kna and we talked a lot about China the US relationship with China you are you have several businesses that have deep supplier and customer relation ships in China given what's going on and clearly the tenor has changed the the mood has changed with respect to US policy towards China what it's like in DC what it's like in Silicon Valley and how everyone talks about the relationship with China today it's pretty crazy how quick things have
32:34changed as a business leader with all these business relationships with China how do you make decisions and and how things are changing and how do you think about where this is headed sure well I mean let's just clarify here you know SpaceX has no SpaceX of Starling have no in China whatsoever they're not they're not allowed you know SpaceX does launch China satellites and starlink is abandon in China so to be clear SpaceX starlink zero business in China in the case
33:11of of Tesla one of our of our four vehicle factories one is in China so you know it's a it's a significant car market but it is you know so what I'm trying to say is like the by far the bulk of of my business interests if if I I would peing MTI which I Aspire not to be are Outsider China let's just be clear about that then with respect to now that said I think I understand China well I've been there many times I've met with the senior leadership at many levels of China for for many years and so I I think I've got a pretty good understanding at least as an outsider of ch so and and Tesla has been very successful domestically in China so you know the fundamental thing here
34:07is is really Taiwan the China has well really since for like half a century or so maybe longer at this point longer at this point their policy has been to to s reunite Taiwan with China from this standpoint you know it may be just analogous to like Hawaii or or something like that like an integral part of China that is arbitrarily not part of China
34:38mostly because of the US stop has us Pacific Fleet has stopped any any sort of reunification effort force so now really things getting to the point increasingly year-over year where China's military strength is increasing and ours is more or less static and strategically you know you can imagine trying to defend Taiwan is not not easy because it's it's very close to the coast of China so there will come a point if you know Pro probably not not too distant future where China's military strength in that region far ex exceeds US military strength in that region and if one is to take China's policy literally and probably one should then there will be some
35:36forceful for forceful beuse for you know to incorporate Taiwan into China this is what they've said that if if there is not a diplomatic solution there will be a solution by force let me if I can and so really what's going on here you've seen you know this in in many areas and I think this Tempo is going to increase is that you know both China and the US are preparing for a
36:10potential Showdown you know in the South China CA so that's why you're seeing increasing restrictions on export of us technology to China but such as the the Nvidia you know the Nvidia h100s being and you not allow to ship to China and I think there'll be more and more you you also not not allow to ship Advanced ship making equipment to China so and I suspect you know you know China is going to respond with some reciprocal sanctions and you'll I think you'll see this kind of a TI T reciprocal sanctions increasing in the next next few years so I think quite a very hot
36:52temperature and then we'll see this is there going to be a a diplomatic solution to re reunification or a non- diplomatic solution you but has made it clear that there will one way or another be a solution from their standpoint Yeah you mentioned Nvidia so let me just talk about Ai and bring it back to that for a second can you tell us your regrets but also the
37:24positives of the experience you had with open Ai and then what your goals are with X well the AI discussion is is certainly a long one or could be a long one you know digital super intelligence that might be the most significant technology that Humanity ever creates and and it has the potential to be more dangerous than and nuclear weapons so
38:06you know in the case of creating opening eye it was to have there not be a unipolar world where Google with its subsidary deat mine you know would control an overwhelming amount of AI talent and compute and and resources which then is somewhat dependent on basically how how Larry paage U and serge BR and
38:33Eric believe things should go because they they between three of them or two out of three have control over alphabet because they've got super voting rights and you know I was quite based on some conversations I had with lar paig where you know you call me a species for being pro humanity and so I'm like what side of you on there you know
39:02you know I think and so so I felt like uncomfortable having the entire future of digital super intelligence be in the hands of someone who equ a species for being pro Humanity you know how can it not be so that's opening eye was originally created as an open source nonprofit and now is a close to be it should be renamed closed for Max no profit AI
39:32it is it is closed and they are aiming to I think make try to make a100 billion I think according to S get $100 billion from somewhere for some vast amount of compute to create digital god apparently all the waste are stored in a common separated value file by the way so our dig God will be a CSV file how do we import it file import see what happens
40:06so so anyway so so now opening is also very closely line with Microsoft you know Microsoft is really you the open servers are running on in Azure and Microsoft data centers you know so really what you have is I think at the end of day Microsoft having more control than open AI they have access to all the source code they have access to all the weights of the you know gb4 and future versions so they have all rights to this to to thing it's not at any point really they could cut off open AI I don't think open AI quite realizes that the dependence on on Microsoft and even if Microsoft does break some contract they'll just be tied up in litigation for you know for years
40:54so really you've got a contest between kind of like Google and Microsoft Google as mentioned I'm concerned about you know sorry not not caring enough about AI safety and good reason and then Microsoft just is is a I think you know a profit seeking organization and I you know I think such is great but I I can't say like you know that it would difficult to to say that that m has a has an amazing track record and moral decision- making so
41:38diplomatic anyway so so so was like okay look let's just so I think let's try to create a third company that is competitive I I I do think Tesla is underated from an AI standpoint in terms of real world AI Tesla has the best real world AI so you know hopefully between xai and Tesla there's kind of a third Contender or would you look you've done you open source your patents at Tesla you are very Pro open source your source code at X would you ever considering releasing dojo and FSD more as a platform substrate for everybody else or that's sort of off the table right now well I don't know if that's you know in the case of say Dojo or our inference
42:31Hardware that's in the car our inference inference computer which is actually a lot lot more comp than Dojo by the way you know we've got I know somewhere in the order of 4 million cars that have highp speeded Ai and Par computers in them like open sourcing chip designs doesn't mean you you suddenly get that thing yeah you know so
43:00you can open open source the software but I think chip designs it's only ones that could actually use those chips or really kind of yeah would be some someone that's willing to spend many billions of dollars on on a computer development so anyway I think I think in the case of you know don't saying Optimus is really interesting any I think just in general Tesla is one of the most leading AI companies and in some respects the leading AI company when it comes to real real world AI understanding the real world and and actually reacting to that with self-driving and so and I think that will become part of the the solution for AGI or general super intelligence so
43:58in the case of Tesla I think we've got a sort of a good governance structure in that there's no super voting rights or anything like that so if I'm you know go crazy the CH of Tesla can vote me out you know I have enough vote to be you know I think moderately influential but not enough to stay in even if I'm doing crazy stuff so I think that's actually good
44:25great I was told we have to wrap him at oh okay just on FSD before we wrap I'll let you go we were talking earlier this year and you said hey maybe chat GPT 4.0 like moment for self-driving was coming and I've I've been playing with the beta and yeah how how close does it feel to you because it it some of the rides it's been doing for me are pretty darn impressive the latest beta is pretty incredible yeah it's pretty pretty neat I you know I used to love it on the highways and on the streets I'd be like okay but now I'm using it increasingly on the streets so where do you how do you feel about it right now and I I guess you made a lot of predictions on it over the years but
45:11it it does feel like it's getting pretty close yeah I think it's I think it's very close to you know being in a situation where even if there's no human oversight or intervention that the probability of a safe journey is is higher with FSD and no supervision like even if you're seep of the car than if the person is driving we're very close to that you know those that have the FSD beta which really anyone could get at this point so the the the miles we see driven under the FSD beta currently are much safer than the miles that are driven without it so that's you know that's that's already very good milestone but you know you can just see that it's getting better and better like
46:03if you see if you compare the you know FS beta today versus 6 months ago versus you know a year ago versus 18 months ago it's really the Improvement is dramatic and we've got the final piece of the puzzle which is to have the control part of the car transition from about 300,000 lines of C++ code to also neural network so the you know the whole system will be neural net in your network phons into controls out and
46:38and that that that's kind of the final piece of the puzzle for fullop driving being significantly better than human W awesome thanks for taking the time buddy fly safe and I'll see you shortly ladies and gentlemen Elon mus thanks bud [Applause] [Music] and instead we open sources to the fans and they've just G [Music]
47:14crazy Bes myg taking [Music] driveway oh man we should all just get a room just have one big huge orgy cuz they're all useless it's like this like sexual tension that they just need to release [Music] Som we need to get [Music] merch I'm going all [Music]
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版