2023 年 6 月的巴黎,VivaTech 会场挤满了人。主持人莫里斯·莱维(Maurice Lévy)开场就把马斯克的头衔念了一遍:PayPal、Tesla、SpaceX、OpenAI 的缔造者,永远逆流而上,而且几乎每次都被证明是对的。
然后他话锋一转:现在桌上摆着一个 440 亿美元重的问题,Twitter 你还对吗?
马斯克自己先把刀递了过来。
很贵。如果我真那么聪明,为什么会花这么多钱买 Twitter?(马斯克)
暖场还有个小插曲。主持人提前放风,说马斯克想用法语演讲,马斯克一脸“我的天”,全场笑翻。接着主持人问:有人说你是 evil genius(邪恶天才),你到底是哪一种?马斯克说,仔细看他头上能看到天使的光环,还有翅膀,只是比较小,不太容易看见。
一个多小时的对话,从火箭、电动车、AI 监管,一路聊到广告、乌克兰和脑机接口。马斯克说的很多话并不新鲜,但连起来听,能看到一套相当一致的世界观:他做的每一件事,都能追溯到十几岁时想明白的一个问题。
全球 20 亿辆车,电动车连 1% 都不到
主持人问他,你到底为什么这么执着于开新公司、做新东西?
马斯克先甩了个包袱:晶体冰毒。如果你觉得红牛能给你翅膀,那这个更猛。说完赶紧补一句,开玩笑,记录在案。
正经回答只有一句:核心使命还差得远。
电动车的数字他张口就来。全球路上大约有 20 亿辆汽车和卡车,其中电动车不到 2000 万辆。渗透率连 1% 都不到。可持续能源发电同样,离目标还很远。Tesla 做了很多,但前面的路更长。
SpaceX 的目标更夸张:让生命成为多行星物种,把生命延伸到地球之外。
为什么这件事重要?马斯克给了两个理由,一个防御性的,一个激励性的。
先说服性的。
银河系里可能只有我们这一支蜡烛
他说常有人问他见没见过 UFO、外星人。答案是一个都没有。
他的推论很直接:如果存在,到这个时候他应该已经见过了。所以很可能,至少在这个银河系里,只有我们这一份意识。
他用了蜡烛的比喻。意识之光就像茫茫黑暗里的一支小蜡烛。如果真是这样,我们就应该尽一切努力,别让这支蜡烛熄灭。
这句话背后是一整套行动逻辑。要确保地球本身是安全的,文明是可持续的,所以要做电动车、做储能。同时要把生命延伸到太阳系的其他行星,最终延伸到其他恒星系统。
第二个理由是激励。
马斯克说,生活不能只是解决一个接一个的问题。人需要被激励,需要早上醒来时觉得活着是件让人兴奋的事。
他拿阿波罗登月举例。1969 年宇航员登上月球,当时的说法是“为全人类”。如果问地球上任何一个人,人类做过的最了不起的事情是什么,登月一定在答案里。这种事会让人觉得未来值得期待。
这段话放在一场科技大会的开场,其实很关键。后面所有的商业决策,几乎都能从这里找到根。
12 岁那年,他读到一本伪装成笑话的哲学书
主持人问他,这些想法是小时候就有,还是后来才有的?
马斯克说,小时候没想过自己会做这些事。他只是对科技感兴趣,读很多书,读科幻,这没什么稀奇。他还顺手补了一句:我妈就在台下坐着,如果我说得不准,她可以当场纠正我。
真正重要的是 12 岁或 13 岁那年的一次存在主义危机。他突然开始追问:生命的意义是什么?如果生命没有意义呢?我们为什么在这里?这一切到底意味着什么?
他读了一堆宗教和哲学的书,最后读到《银河系漫游指南》(The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy)。
他对这本书的评价很特别:一本伪装成幽默读物的哲学书。
作者道格拉斯·亚当斯(Douglas Adams)在书里设置了一个著名的桥段,超级计算机算了几百万年,算出终极答案是 42,但没人知道问题是什么。马斯克说,亚当斯真正想讲的是,困难的部分从来不在答案这一侧,难在搞清楚该问什么问题。
这套思路被他总结成一种“好奇心的哲学”:我们能做什么,去更多地了解宇宙的本质,去搞清楚生命的意义。
顺着这个逻辑往下推,结论就出来了。想弄明白生命的意义,就得扩大意识的规模和范围。得走出去,得探索恒星,才知道该向宇宙问什么问题。
所以需要两件事。第一,保证地球是好的,所以要可持续能源。第二,要有离开地球的技术。
这些公司,大部分都从这个核心哲学里长出来。
主持人插了一句:那 Twitter 怎么帮上忙?
马斯克笑了:那先回到地球。
PayPal 卖掉是好事,因为人才散了
主持人问,卖掉 PayPal 后不后悔?
马斯克的回答有点出人意料:不后悔,被 eBay 收购是好事。
理由是人才。PayPal 聚集了一批极其聪明的人,公司卖掉之后,这批人散到各处,创办了一堆公司。YouTube 是两位 PayPal 员工做的,LinkedIn 出自 PayPal 系,Yelp 也是,还能数出很多。
他自己的话是:如果当时还在继续做 PayPal,就不会有今天这个形态的 Tesla,SpaceX 也不会存在。
但故事没有结束。
他说现在有机会做一件比 PayPal 更大的事,也就是 X,那个“万能应用”(everything app)。他用了一个很有画面感的说法:有点像回头去完成 24 年前开了头、却没收尾的任务。
X.com 创立于 1999 年,被合并成 PayPal,再卖给 eBay。二十多年后,他花 440 亿美元买下 Twitter,改名叫 X,想接着往下做。他说这件事会很有用,希望它能成为文明的正面力量。
通用汽车压碎了 EV1,车主在废车场点蜡烛守夜
主持人提到自己 90 年代末给通用汽车的电动车做过第一个广告宣传,然后把问题抛给马斯克:为什么通用和其他大车厂没做出 Tesla?差别在哪?
马斯克的回答是一段很少有人完整讲过的历史。
通用汽车 1997 年推出了电动车 EV1。马斯克当时以为,接下来会有 EV2、EV3,一代代做下去。如果真是那样,根本不需要 Tesla。
但通用把所有 EV1 都召回了。有些客户非常想留下车,车还是被收走,拉到废车场压碎。
接下来这个细节他讲了两遍,显然印象很深。那些 EV1 的车主太爱这辆车了,他们在压碎车辆的废车场外面办了烛光守夜,像葬礼上的守夜。
如果有这么多人心疼你的产品被销毁,甚至点蜡烛守夜,你也许该多造一些。为产品办守夜仪式,这种事真的很少见。(马斯克)
他说自己到今天也想不通通用为什么这么做。如果通用继续做下去,今天电动车行业的领导者就是通用。
Tesla 成立的时候,市面上一辆在产的电动车都没有,大车厂不做,也没听说有创业公司在做。所以只能自己上。
他补了一句很重要的背景:Tesla 和 SpaceX,他当时估计的成功率都是 10% 左右。他当时的判断是大概率会失败。
2001 年去俄罗斯买导弹,最后决定自己造火箭
主持人问他,一个从小想当宇航员的孩子,怎么变成了造可回收火箭的人?
马斯克说这个故事很长,他尽量压缩。
最开始他没想造火箭。他想做一个叫“火星绿洲”(Mars Oasis)的慈善项目,往火星送一个小温室,用来激发公众对太空的兴趣。
在研究怎么把温室送上去的时候,他发现症结落在发射成本上,公众的热情从来不缺。为了搞到便宜的运载工具,他在 2001 年跑了几趟俄罗斯,想买他们的洲际导弹,去掉核弹头的那种,核弹头另算钱。
2001 年在俄罗斯谈买两枚他们最大的导弹,那场面相当疯狂。(马斯克)
谈下来他意识到,除非火箭本身有根本性的改变,否则进入太空的成本降不下来。公众对太空探索的渴望一直很高,缺的是手段,缺的是把单位成本砍掉一个量级的技术。
于是他决定自己开一家火箭公司试试。
当时他跟人讲过一个行业笑话:怎么在火箭行业赚到一笔小钱?答案是先带一大笔钱进去。
SpaceX 前三次发射全部失败。第四次成功了。他说得很直白:如果第四次也失败,SpaceX 就不存在了。那次过关非常惊险。
AI 需要裁判,这是他支持监管的真实理由
话题转到 OpenAI。ChatGPT 成了史上增长最快的产品,而马斯克是 OpenAI 的联合创始人之一,后来却签了那封呼吁暂停训练更强大 AI 的公开信。
有人质疑,这是不是因为他在竞赛里落后了。
他的回应是:他并不认为有人真的会同意暂停,但他还是想公开表个态,把话说在明处。
理由讲得很清楚:数字超级智能有造成负面后果的真实危险。如果在造通用人工智能(AGI)的时候不小心,可能出现灾难性的结果。
他把可能性分成几种。最可能的结果是积极的,但并非所有可能的结果都积极。所以要做的,是把出错概率压到最低。
主持人追问,为什么主张暂停?
他的答案落在监管上。他支持对 AI 进行监管,因为先进 AI 对公众构成风险。任何对公众有风险的东西,都需要一个裁判,这个裁判就是监管者。这是他的强烈建议。
主持人顺势调侃:这也是你希望 Twitter 得到的待遇吗?
马斯克回了一句:不确定,监管者已经够多了。
Twitter 到底哪里坏了
主持人给了三个问题:为什么收购?Twitter 当时哪里有问题?凭什么相信你能做成?
第一个问题的答案,落在他自己的使用经验上。收购完成之前,他的账号就是全世界互动量最高的账号。他对这个平台的体感非常直接,能感觉到它在往哪个方向偏。
他的判断是:Twitter 当时对文明产生了腐蚀作用,而且在往负面方向越走越远。回到他开场那套逻辑,任何削弱文明的东西都算坏消息,所以他想把它掰回正面。
主持人不客气地指出:公众的感知跟这个说法差得很远。
马斯克没有回避,直接摆动作。已经清掉了 90% 的机器人和诈骗账号。儿童剥削内容的清除率到了 95%,他提到这部分内容的存在本身让他震惊,有些内容已经挂了十年,一直没人处理。
还有一个动作是开源推荐算法。Twitter 成了唯一一家能让你看到算法真实代码的社交平台,不再是黑箱。
他对信任这件事的说法值得记下来:
想建立信任,光听我说没用,得把东西摊开给你看,完全透明。(马斯克)
他还提到接下来会做账号层面的透明化:如果你的账号被系统做了某种处理,你能清楚看到。
至于效果,他给的证据是使用量。全平台使用量创历史新高,周环比增长显著。用他的话说,公众在用时间投票,时间花在哪里,就是最真实的信号。
广告主那头,他说除了极少数例外,几乎所有的广告主都已经回来,或者明确表示会回来。他没有听说有谁彻底走了。
保言论自由,不保传播自由
Orange 的 CEO 克里斯泰勒·海德曼(Christel Heydemann)接着提问。她的问题很直接:欧盟提出了针对虚假信息的行为准则,Twitter 最近退出了。这是否意味着 Twitter 不打算对信息做审核?
马斯克的回答可以拆成三层。
第一层,言论自由的边界是法律。每个国家允许什么,平台就允许什么。法国法律允许的,Twitter 就允许。如果公众觉得法律不对,那就去改法律,改完 Twitter 遵守。让平台去执行超出法律范围的标准,他觉得不合适。
第二层,言论自由只在让人不舒服的时候才有意义。如果只能说大家都爱听的话,那就不叫言论自由。
第三层,审查会反噬。他的原话大意是,一旦走上审查这条路,早晚会轮到你被审查。这也是他反复引用美国第一修正案的原因:立国者的初衷,是他们在原来的国家没法说自己想说的话,所以要在新国家把这件事写进宪法。
他给了一个判断标准,很值得琢磨:如果你不喜欢的人能说出你不喜欢的话,这其实是健康的信号。因为这意味着你也能说话,对方不爱听,但你仍然可以说。
至于平台该做什么,他区分了两个概念:
我们保的是言论自由,不保传播自由。你可以说冒犯性的话,但你的内容会被降权。(马斯克)
换句话说,你要是混蛋,触达就会掉。不删你,但不推你。海德曼追问网络霸凌和骚扰,尤其是对年轻人的影响。马斯克说 Twitter 愿意跟其他平台合作,最终目标还是让平台成为文明的正面力量。被人骚扰当然是很糟的体验,所以才有了上面那套降权逻辑。
8393 年历史,对上一个 19 岁的公司
LVMH 的安托万·阿尔诺(Antoine Arnault)上来先铺了一段:集团旗下最老的酒庄有 650 年历史,Louis Vuitton 创立于 1854 年,Tiffany 创立于 1837 年,所有品牌的历史加起来是 8393 年。
然后他说,Tesla 才 19 岁,市值已经超过 LVMH。你还要打我们的脸多久?
马斯克先讲了估值的荒诞。他以前说过 Tesla 股价太高,结果股价接着涨。他也没办法,股价不由他定。
接着他解释了市值高的真实原因:Tesla 的价值主要建立在自动驾驶上。
今年 Tesla 的产量接近 200 万辆,但放到全球汽车总产量里只占 2% 左右。2% 的份额撑不起那样的市值,撑得起的是自动驾驶的潜在价值。
他算了一笔账。一辆普通乘用车,每周平均只用 10 个小时,也就是一天一个半小时左右。剩下 158 个小时停在车位上贬值。
如果这辆车能自动驾驶、能当 Robotaxi 用,每周的使用时长可能到 50 到 60 个小时。成本一样,效用翻五倍以上。
他说这个变化大到足以解释一切。即使给自动驾驶的成功概率打上很大的折扣,剩下的价值依然惊人。
至于时间表,他的说法是:他认为自动驾驶很快会解决。
阿尔诺又追问了一句,你当年预料到 Tesla 会到这个市值吗?
马斯克说没有,完全没预料到。
AI 是史上最具颠覆性的技术,也是富足时代的入口
阿尔诺讲了个细节:他用 Midjourney,只输入两个词,就生成了一版 Louis Vuitton 的广告。他问马斯克,广告制作行业会不会被 AI 干掉。
马斯克先开玩笑:完全安全,一点事没有。然后正色:
AI 肯定会是一股巨大的颠覆力量。它可能是史上最具颠覆性的技术。(马斯克)
他给了一个类比。人类相对于其他生物的优势是聪明。真跟大猩猩打一架,大猩猩稳赢,但人类靠脑子赢。现在第一次出现了一种东西,比最聪明的人类还聪明,而且高出很多。
Midjourney 几秒钟生成的画面让他惊叹,而这才刚开始。每过一年,AI 能做的事都会多一大截。
他提了那句著名的“愿你生活在有趣的时代”。这句话常被当成诅咒,他自己也说,有时候确实算不上好事。但他还是认为,我们正活在历史上最有趣的时代。
他甚至说,假设真发生某种 AI 末日,他仍然愿意活在这个时代,亲眼看到它发生。当然,希望不是自己造成的。
接下来这段是他对经济最直白的推演。
经济是什么?人均 GDP 乘以人口。如果人口没有上限呢?如果把机器人也算进去,人口实际上没有上限,那经济的意义就变得模糊了,因为那是一套没有上限的经济。
好的那一面是,他认为人类正在走向一个富足时代(age of abundance)。你想要什么商品和服务,直接就能有。
中间他还顺带提了两个正在发生的事:汽车会开得比任何人都好;Tesla 在做的人形机器人 Optimus,他开玩笑叫它 T800,终结者的梗,现场有人听懂了。
广告主只认一件事:内容邻接
欧莱雅的首席数字官阿斯米塔·杜贝(Asmita Dubey)把话题拉回广告。她问得很实在:Twitter 很贵,又要做言论自由,2023 年的预期收入还低于 2022 年,新 CEO 琳达·亚卡里诺(Linda Yaccarino)能搞定广告主的信任吗?
马斯克先夸人,说琳达非常懂广告主的处境和顾虑,会做得很好。
然后是机制层面的解释。他用了行业术语“内容邻接”(content adjacency):广告主真正关心的是自己的广告出现在什么内容旁边。
品牌调性不同,要求就不同。迪士尼如果在推一部儿童电影,就需要全年龄的内容环境。他顺手补了一句,迪士尼是 Twitter 最大的广告主之一。
有些内容区不会有广告,因为没人愿意把广告投在那儿。那些争议最大的内容,基本就落在这一块。
杜贝追问创作者广告分成。这个政策的条件是,创作者要通过蓝标认证,广告也只投给认证用户。这会不会让公司更偏向订阅收入,而压过广告收入?
马斯克的回答绕回了真实性。
广告曝光要看一个根本问题:这些曝光是真人产生的,还是机器刷出来的。一台电脑跑十万个假账号,曝光数字很好看,但电脑不会买东西。
所以 Twitter 把认证和订阅合并成了同一件事,认证用户就是付费订阅用户。这个设计的好处是没法造假,你可以确定屏幕对面是真人。
他顺带讲了一段当下的现实。社交媒体上机器人、诈骗和垃圾信息的规模大到离谱。今天的 AI 已经能通过几乎所有“证明你是人类”的测试,而且可能比人类通过得更好。识别红绿灯这种题,Tesla 闭着眼都能做。开源模型现在也能过所有人类验证。所以平台需要比这更强的身份验证手段。
Starlink 是乌克兰军事通信的骨干
现场有人问到乌克兰。
马斯克的回答很克制,先说这件事非常复杂,然后讲事实。
当时俄罗斯摧毁了乌克兰几乎所有的卫星通信和地面通信,只剩 Starlink 还在运转。到今天,它仍然是前线唯一有效的通信手段,是乌克兰军事通信的骨干。
他说帮助乌克兰很重要。但他也说,希望尽快出现某种解决方案。乌克兰和俄罗斯的年轻人在战壕里死去,他们并不想待在那里,这件事让人难过。
给年轻人的建议:你等不及这款产品上市吗
最后的提问环节有点失控,话筒在人群里乱传。有个年轻人抛出一个很妙的观察:你所有公司做的事情,放到火星上都比在地球上更合理,火星上造真空容易得多。马斯克回了一句,我和火星该开个房间。
一位研究太空心理健康的学者问,去火星的人类心理健康重要吗?马斯克说非常重要,得确保每个人都神志清醒,不然半夜有人把气闸打开就完了。
还有人问,欧盟的 AI 监管是在大语言模型出现之前起草的,现在怎么把 LLM 纳进来?马斯克的回答是,监管应该覆盖 LLM,也应该覆盖任何形式的 AI。他不认为 LLM 是 AI 的终极形态。他还讲了个圈内笑话:你觉得 2032 年的美国总统是 diffusion 还是 transformers。
主持人最后问,给现场这些创业者和年轻人两三条建议。
马斯克的回答没有一条是关于风口的。
第一条,做你个人真正在意的东西。为一个你并不在意的产品保持长期动力,几乎不可能。
第二条,不必是高科技。任何行业都行,要紧的是你觉得这个东西必须存在,而且你自己真的喜欢它。
第三条,听直觉。你没法知道别人喜欢什么,但如果你自己喜欢,那是个好信号。
他给了一个很具体的检验标准:
一个好的测试是,你等不及这款产品上市。如果是这样,你走的方向就是对的。(马斯克)
Neuralink 的第一次人体植入
最后一个问题关于脑机接口,什么时候开始人体试验。
马斯克先安抚了一下。Neuralink 会是一个相当缓慢的过程,任何在人身上做的事都很慢。有些人以为某天所有人的脑袋会突然连上互联网,然后大家一起完蛋,不会那样。
时间表是当年晚些时候做第一次人体植入,对象是四肢瘫痪、大脑到身体的连接已经断掉的患者。他的预期是,这个人能像身体功能完整的人一样快地交流。
再往后,他们看到了一条路径:把大脑运动皮层的信号绕过脊髓的损伤点,让身体重新可用。如果成功,全身功能有可能恢复。
他补了一句:如果霍金还活着,这会是多么巨大的改变。
把这场对话拆成能用的东西
一个多小时的访谈,真正有信息量的部分集中在几个地方:他解释自己为什么做这些事,解释 Tesla 的市值逻辑,解释他对 AI 监管和言论自由的态度,以及解释他判断一件事值不值得做的标准。
把这几块挑出来,能落到具体动作上的大概有这些。
- 判断一个想法值不值得投入,用马斯克那个测试:你会不会等不及它上市。答案是“会”,再往下做;答案是“还行”,趁早换。
- 看社交平台或内容产品的数据,先问曝光是真人还是机器。10 万假账号刷出来的数字不能换算成收入,这个判断标准对投放和融资都适用。
- 做社区产品可以借鉴“言论自由但不给传播自由”的思路:内容不删,靠降权处理。既不激化对抗,又控制住扩散。
- 做 AI 产品别把身份验证当小事。今天的人机验证已经挡不住 AI,机器比人还容易被放过。需要真人验证的场景,早点上更强的方案。
- 面对监管,主动参与规则讨论比事后对抗划算。马斯克自己给的建议就是,先进 AI 有公共风险,就该有裁判。
- 做硬科技要有心理准备:他给 SpaceX 估的成功率是 10%,前三次发射全败,第四次才活下来。融资节奏和现金储备要按这个概率设计。
- 学他追问问题的方式。12 岁那次存在主义危机里,他得到的不是答案,他得到的是“先把问题问对”这个方法。这个习惯比任何具体结论都值钱。
最后回到那句自嘲。440 亿美元买 Twitter 值不值,短期看财报是笔烂账,长期看他赌的是同一件事:文明需要有人把方向掰回来,而他有这个能力也有这个意愿。这个赌注对不对,还得再看几年。
0:00You don't need any introduction. your name is a brand is already a brand. It's a brand for Yeah. For innovation, for ambition, for a perfume. Yes. Yes. This is the agreement that you made with the Arno family a few hours ago. I mean it's I mean really it brands itself. Yeah. And you are the origin of PayPal, Tesla, SpaceX to name a few, and even OpenAI.
0:38So, you love taking risks and you are going always against the tide and the popular wisdom. You have been always proven right. Now there is almost not always almost. Now there is a bet of the 44 billion US question which is will you still be right with Twitter? Sure. So it was expensive. Yeah.
1:19Yeah. You agree? I don't know if you know if listen if I'm so smart why did I pay so much for Twitter then? [Laughter] So as I'm not a journalist, I'm not trying to get headlines and to have provocative response and to make a scoop. But nevertheless, if you wish to do that, it is authorized.
1:52Okay, great. So we are expecting that you will really make the show because everyone comes here to see you and to listen to you and to get some of the magic that you have. All right. Well, I'm I'm I'm honored that you all went to listen to what I have to say. It's great to to see the crowd and I don't know, you guys seem awesome. So, but you told me that you would like
2:23You said that you would like to speak in French. Oh my goodness. [Laughter] [Applause] a genius and yeah there there are some who are you would believe that you are evil so well I mean you can be both you we I mean you could be an evil genius that's not you know so you will tell us what you are or you will let the people draw their own conclusion I am definitely not evil
3:04that's it tell me what What is the thing that you have a head of your own? yes. If you if you look carefully, you can see an angel's halo on my head. And the wings, it's a subtle, but where are the wings? Yeah, they're difficult to see, but if you look carefully, you know, they're right there.
3:24Yeah, small wings. Yes. so yeah, hopefully not evil. Aspirationally not evil. so, yeah. okay, so that wasn't convincing. Elen, you you have done a lot of operation. You have created a lot of companies. The most important question for everyone is what the hell is driving you? Why are
3:54you so obsessed by new operation, new creation, new things to do? Yeah, crystal meth is the answer. if you think Red Bull gives you wings, so man, that that that's that that quote's going to probably sting. so, yeah, just kidding, for the record. so, well, I think there's, you still
4:29have a lot to do for their their core mission. the you know for electric vehicles, sustainable energy, the still less than 1% of the global fleet is electric. So you've got about 2 billion cars and trucks on the road, but still less than 20 million are electric at this point. So there's still a long way to go for sustainable energy for sustainable energy generation. So this, you know, the Tesla mission, I think we've we've made a a lot of progress, but still, it's a lot a lot more ahead. then SpaceX, the goal is
5:08it's a it's a big goal, but it's we we want to try to make life multilanetary to extend life beyond Earth. And I think this is important for a number of reasons. but you there's there's the sort of defensive reason of ensuring that the light of consciousness does not go out. and and if I may some of these questions I if I'm going on too long, you feel free to interrupt me. But the No, no, you can.
5:35Okay. You can be long. Okay. So, you know, people do ask me, you know, have I seen UFOs and aliens and that kind of thing? And I haven't. and I think I would have seen them by now. so it it appears that we might there's we might be the only consciousness at least in this galaxy. And and if so, that's kind of a scary prospect because it it means that the light of consciousness is like a like a tiny candle in a vast darkness and we should do everything we can to prevent that candle from going out.
6:16So yeah and and and so so some of the thing so that means obviously taking the actions to ensure that earth is good that earth is safe and secure for civilization. and it I think it also means ex extending life beyond earth to other planets in the solar system and ultimately to other star systems.
6:45and I think that's that's both a sort of defense of the light of consciousness and also I think a point of inspiration because the life cannot just be about solving one problem after another. We need things that inspire us. I mean, we need things that, you know, move our hearts and that when you wake up in the morning, you're excited to be alive. And being a space fairing civilization and making true the things that we see in the good science fiction movies, this is one of the things that I think can inspire all of humanity. Just like the, you know, when when the astronauts went to the moon in ' 69, it was something that then
7:34they said for all mankind, you know, and it really was something if you say to any human on Earth, what's the what what's like the most amazing thing that humanity has ever done. A lot of at least one of those things would be we went to the moon, you know, and so you want to have these inspiring things that make you excited to be alive and excited about the future.
7:56yeah and you you had those thoughts and dreams when you were a kid or this came much later on. Well, I didn't think I would be doing these things as a kid. that's for sure. I was interested in technology. I read a lot of books. so I was obviously interested in SC. I mean this this is hardly going to be surprising. I was interested in science fiction and technology.
8:26You have to tell the truth because there is someone is listening to you. Huh? Yeah, my mom's right there. She can she can call me out on this if it's not not accurate. But so I I guess the the thing that was maybe most significant from a philosophical standpoint was that when I was about maybe 12 or 13, I had somewhat of an existential crisis where I was like I was like what what is the meaning of life? Is life just meaningless? Why are we here? What does it all mean?
9:00And and I read a lot of books on religion and philosophy and and then ultimately the you know I read this book Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy which is great. and and in that book that book is really a a philosophy book that's disguised as humor. And the point that Douglas Adams makes is that the the
9:23real difficulty is understanding what questions to ask about the answer that is the universe. and that we we that that really we want to we want to have it's it's essentially a it's it's like a philosophy of curiosity of of of saying what can we do to find out more about the the nature of the universe and and the meaning of life. And so that's that's the sort of foundational element. And then from there you say okay well if we want to find out meaning of life we have to expand the scope and scale of consciousness. We have to go out there and we explore the stars to to know what questions to ask about the universe and and understand the universe. And that's that's my core
10:11philosophy. and and and so from that it was like well we have to make sure that earth is good so we have to have sustainable energy. we we want to build technology to travel beyond earth and that's it's it's from that sort of core philosophy that these companies arise in most cases. you can say how does Twitter help with that?
10:41So I would like to go back to earth. Sure. and to the various enterprises that you contributed to create or co-created or created. Let's start with PayPal. Very impressive company. Do you regret to have sold it? I I I think in in retrospect, I think it was it was good to that that the company was acquired by eBay. because there was so much talent at PayPal and that talent subsequently went on to create many other companies. so
11:20YouTube for example was created by two people that worked at at PayPal. we had there was LinkedIn was created from from PayPal. There was Yelp. There was many other companies. impressive. Yeah. Yeah. Very impressive. Yeah. So, and then and if if I'd been still working on PayPal, then I there wouldn't be, you know, Tesla would not be in its current form and and SpaceX wouldn't exist.
11:48Yes. So, yes, I guess the short answer, yes. Short answer is that yes. Yeah. But now with you would have loved to keep it again. Well, there is I think the potential to do something that is u bigger than PayPal. this is sort of like the X the sort of everything app kind of thing. So I think it's it's
12:24somewhat poetic like we're trying to get go finish a task that was started about 24 years ago. I think it's I think we it's going to be useful. X/ Twitter is going to be just a very useful thing. and hopefully something that is a positive force for civilization. moving to Tesla.
12:53I have through one of our operation done the first advertising campaign for the electric car of GM that was at the end of the '9s. So can you explain why GM and other car manufacturers have not created Tesla and why Tesla is successful? what is the difference? you talk about the EV1 basically the EV1 car that so General Motors
13:33actually did come out with this electric vehicle one EV1 and it's Yes, you remember EV1. Yes. Yeah. and actually so I thought when that came out it was 97. Yeah, that sounds about right. Yeah. I would have I expected there would be an EV2, EV3, and so forth. And if if they had done that, actually, there would be no need for Tesla.
13:57but for reasons that that aren't clear, they GM recalled all of the EV1s, even from customers that really wanted to keep the cars. They recalled the cars and they crushed them in a junkyard. And the the it's it blows it still blows my mind that they did this because the the the people who had the EV1s, they love the car so much they held a candle lit vigil at the junkyard where the cars were crushed.
14:30Okay? like it was like like someone was getting killed, you know, like and and it's like if somebody is holding a candle at vigil for the destru because they love your product so much, maybe you should make more of it, you know? I mean, it's like pretty rare for candle individuals to be held for products. So, I I don't understand why they didn't do more. They should have and they would be the leader in electric vehicles today, but they didn't. they they didn't and so there was a need for Tesla because the you know at the time of starting Tesla there were no electric vehicles being made and there were so the big car companies were not making electric vehicles there were no startups
15:14that we were aware of making electric vehicles so it's like well we should try and I mean in the case of both Tesla and SpaceX I thought the chance of success was maybe 10%. So it's not like I thought it would be successful. I thought it would fail. Good lesson. Now moving to the kids dream which is to
15:38become an astronaut and not to build rockets. How you move from the idea that every child has I will be an astronaut to I will do reusable rockets. Yeah. you forgot. No, I I'm trying to compress the story so that they're not too long. because the story is actually quite long because I didn't start out wanting to do the rockets. I at first I was going to do this philanthropic mission to Mars called Mars Oasis. And then as I started investigating the what it would take to launch this mission to Mars, just a little greenhouse basically it was intended to inspire the public and and I I started understanding more about the the what rockets could be
16:33used. I actually went to Russia a few times to try to buy some of their nuclear missiles minus the nuclear minus the nuke. that's extra. so that was pretty wild being in in Russia in 2001, negotiating to buy two of their biggest missiles. but but but it became it became clear that the, unless there was something new with rockets, there that that that was the fundamental issue. The cost of access to space was the fundamental issue. So it wasn't a it wasn't a question of trying to increase the public's desire public's desire for space and exploration is very high but there needs to be a means there needs to be a way and there need
17:26to be a radical improvement in the cost of access to orbit. so I was like okay well I'm going to try starting a rocket company and see if it's successful. But I like I said I I told people at the time cuz cuz people would say to me this tell me this joke of like what's the fast you know what's what's the you know how how do you go from sorry
17:54sorry I'm getting a little hot under the color here. I think a lot of people are so they'll say what what's the fastest way to make a a small fortune in the rocket industry and it and the punch line is you start with a large one. So you know it was it was a tough going for a while. Our first three launches failed. Fortunately the fourth one succeeded. If the fourth one had not succeeded SpaceX would not exist. So it was a very close call.
18:25Fast forward, you created u or you co-created OpenAI. Yes. Chad GPT has been incredibly success, incredibly successful. It's the the the fastest growing ever story. And after having created Open Eye, suddenly you say, "oh, we should have a pause." Some people say, "Oh, it's because he has not done it."
19:00Well, I mean, I didn't think anyone would actually agree to the pause. but I thought just for the for the record, I just want to say I think we should pause. I didn't think that any that the Why do you want to should pause? Well, I think there's there's a real danger for digital super intelligence having negative consequences. And so if we are not careful with creating artificial general intelligence we could have potentially a catastrophic outcome. So now I think there's a range of possibilities. I think the most likely outcome is positive for AI but it but that's not every possible outcome. So we need to minimize the probability that something
19:46will go wrong with digital super intelligence. yes. so I'm in favor of AI regulation because I think advanced AI is a risk to the public and anything that's a risk to the public, there needs to be some kind of referee. That referee is the regulator. And so I think that that my strong recommendation is to have some regulation for AI.
20:13Some regulation for AI. Yes. Which is what you want also for Twitter. not sure. regulation. I guess there's plenty of plenty of regulators. Sure. Okay. so speaking about Twitter, you you have made a big bet on Twitter. You said it a few minutes ago that you paid too much. Yes. Yes. and you are now going on to
20:47Twitter 2.0. Mhm. or 3.0 which I understand it's a fullscale reinvention of the company. yeah, we're evolving the company very rapidly. Yeah, the the company is changing quite dramatically. There are a lot of controvers. So I I have in fact three very quick question. The first one is why have you decided to acquire it? The second is
21:19what was wrong at Twitter to make you acting and the last one is not the last last of the three because there are many other question is why do you believe that you would be successful and you will be huh well thanks I can imagine I can't imagine that you will not be well thanks so
21:47Well, obviously I was on Twitter as a as a major user and even before the acquisition closed, my my Twitter account was the most interacted with account in the world. So my I guess I'll be I'm pretty closely attuned to what's going on with Twitter, you know, I get a feel for how is it shifting one way or the other. And generally I was concerned that Twitter was having a negative effect on civilization, that it was having a corrosive effect on civil society. And and so that you know, anything that undermines civilization I think is not good. And you know, go back to my point of like we need to do everything possible to support civilization and
22:36move it in a positive direction. And and I felt that it would that Twitter was kept moving more and more in a negative direction and my hope and aspiration was to change that and have it be a positive force for civilization. It is not perceived like this. People are very happy to listen to that
23:01approach but it the perception is very different. Well, I think it depends on I mean I think if if somebody is a regular Twitter user, I think they most people would say that their their experience has improved. we've we've gotten rid of 90% of the bots and the scams and and and the various bad things that were happening. we've
23:28gotten rid of now at this point I think 95% of the child exploitation material that was on Twitter, which was a shock to see the the amount of that. That was really terrible. some of that had been going on for 10 years and no action. So, I think we've done a lot of good in that respect. and
23:50and then I think we you know we've also done things like we we have open sourced the algorithm. So we're trying to be as transparent as possible. So Twitter is the only social media company where you can see the actual code of the algorithm. So it's not like some secret black box. yeah,
24:12I mean the the the way to build trust is the way to build trust is not take my word for it. It's let's let's show you exactly how it works and full transparency. and and and we're also going to be showing like if your account is in any way affected by the Twitter system, you can see it clearly.
24:31and just you know moving in a I think a good direction. we've I think the recommendation algorithm anyway I don't want to go on too long for Twitter but I think it's I I think it's actually quite good and that those who are on who are on the Twitter system I think generally think it's good. the you know we are seeing all-time highs in in usage. So at least you know for the
24:59public out there they are using the system more. so we're seeing you know pretty significant week-over-week growth in in usage. so you know the public is speaking with their time and if they're if they're putting their time on on Twitter that's a very good signal. so that's that's that's very positive.
25:22what what would you say to advertisers who left Twitter to convince them to come back? Yeah, actually I should say that maybe with a few exceptions almost all the advertisers have said that they've either come back or they said they will come back. So actually I feel pretty pretty optimistic about the future. and yeah, so it you know
25:53we really at this point I believe actually I'm not aware of any advertiser that is either they've either come back or they said they will come back. I'm not aware of any exceptions. There probably a few exceptions but overall I think it's it's very positive. Good. So we will have now a broader conversation. We will ask Christan from Orange, the CEO of Orange to join us as well as Antoan Arno from LVMH and Asmita
26:27Jub from L'Oreal we have to move in order that they add chair. So come here. [Applause] Now while they are arranging there is Yes. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. there is one question. Yeah. That I would like to [Applause] take care. So finally we are all together again. so I had another question but I will save it for later and I will give the floor to Crystal Crystal Edman who is the CEO
27:19of Orange and she is very much excited about putting some harsh difficult question to you. Let's go. Not sure that's so difficult but so I like to talk about obviously social networks and I was not sure if I heard what you just said with Maurice but obviously social networks and Twitter has been a fantastic tool to develop free speech and open debates that maybe were not possible before that.
27:54Sure. Now there's also another side of it which is that there can be some disinformation fake news for fake news. Fake news. What? That's crazy. Fake news. Believe it or not you believe that. How do I know this is real? Now the question is and and actually I think there's a flip side in to social networks and there's a code of conduct that the EU has proposed disinformation.
28:24Okay. Recently Twitter just decided to walk away from it. So is this because Twitter doesn't I mean respect the fact that information needs to be moderated and actually you've been pretty vocal on the content moderation. So just what are your thoughts on that? Well, I'm generally a fan of that we should have free speech as much as possible as much as is allowed by the laws of any country. So you know I
28:56think that you know say for France we should allow things that are allowed by law and if the people are want the laws to be different then pass a different law and we'll adhere to that law but but for for Twitter to go beyond the law that you know that doesn't seem quite right to me. I I think we want to allow the people to express themselves.
29:22and and and really if you have to say when does free speech matter, free speech matters and it's only relevant if if people are allowed to say things that you don't like because otherwise it's not free speech. and and I would I would take that if if somebody says something, you know, potentially offensive, but that's that's actually okay. Now, now we're we're not going to promote those, you know, offensive tweets, but but I think people should be able to say things because the alternative is censorship and then and frankly, I think if you go down the censorship route that it's only a matter of time before censorship is turned upon you. and and and then there so that's why it's
30:06important you know for in the US you've got the first amendment of freedom of speech amendment and you said like why did they do that? It's why did they pass that amendment? It was because they they were not able to say what they wanted to say in the countries that they came from and they wanted to make sure that they could say what they wanted to say. So I I believe in freedom for the people to say things and that even if somebody said that it's actually in some ways a sign of health if people are able to if someone you don't like is able to say something you don't like rather than try to suppress that you say like you know what that's a good sign because that
30:47means I can say things and that person will not like what I say but I can still say it and that's a really big deal. I think especially in this country I mean freedom of speech that's something that's very I mean at the core of our values but now if we look at young people and being in the digital field and we provide digital services that people use there's also a move towards cyber bullying and harassment which I think we all it's also our role to educate young people on how to use the technology and make sure that because some behavior I mean on Twitter or other social networks can actually have devastating effects on on people. is Twitter
31:33doing something about it or would you be willing to engage with other players? Actually at Orange who do a lot in that space. True. I mean that's true. I think I think you know Twitter is for sure willing to engage with others. and as I said, the overarching goal is to have Twitter be a force, a positive force for civilization. And you know, so and and and it and if if you're on the platform and you're being harassed or bullied or whatever, obviously that's a negative experience.
32:08so so you know what we're doing is it's we we call it sort of freedom of speech but not freedom of reach. which is that if you yes you can say offensive things but then your content is going to get downrated. So if you're a jerk your your reach will drop. So yeah, I think that's the right thing.
32:34And I don't know if you will be competing with L'Oreal to launch the future fragrance for Elon Musk and the brand Musk. So you have to compete very hard. But maybe you I I know that you had already the lunch but there is now the dessert. So you can put your question. All right. first of all, in the name of Paris, thank you very much for being here. This group is a co-host of Vivette Tech and it's it's great to to have you and welcome.
33:10So, ch change of subject from Twitter. at LVMH, our oldest mison is called Clare. I saw you enjoyed good wine. Yeah. it's 650 years old. Wow. Louis Vuitton was founded in 1854. Our most ancient American mason Tiffany was founded in 1837. The sum of the years of existence of all our mison at LVMH is 8,393
33:42years old. Wow. Tesla is a teenager, right? Yes. Yes. 19 19 years old. Yeah. And its market cap is already higher than LVMH. So it's just a question of age. Yeah. So, so first question, first question. How much longer are you going to make us look so bad? Second question, more serious. Do you feel the creation of value is more challenging in traditional or innovative business?
34:14Well, first of all, it's an honor to be here and and speak with you. So, thanks for having me. you know evaluations are are a strange thing because you know sometimes I've said hey I think the stock price is too high at Tesla and then the stock price goes up I'm like okay so if you you tweet is it going up or down?
34:37No the crazy thing I mean when I've tweeted I think the stock price is too high almost always it goes up. So I don't know it's it's strange thing. So I I I guess in the in the case of Tesla if if the the the really the the value of the company is primarily on the basis of autonomy. So in my
35:00opinion because if you look at our total vehicle output it's you it'll be almost 2 million vehicles this this year something like that. but that's that's still only 2% of total vehicle production. So then why is our market cap so high? And it's because the potential for autonomy is that the
35:21value of autonomy is so high that even even if you have a discounted percentage probability of autonomy happening that is still incredibly valuable. so the average passenger car is used only about 10 hours a week. So an average of about one and a half hours a day. But if you have an autonomous robo taxi, the utility is might be 50 or 60 hours a week out of 168 hours. So now you've got a vehicle that costs the same but has five times the utility.
35:54So it's so gigantic a change that that's really I think the main driver of our value. and although I've said this before, I think we will solve autonomy soon. Did you expect that Tesla will be at this level of market cap? no. I did not expect Tesla would be at this level. Yeah. Because it's just extraordinary.
36:19unfair by the way. I mean, I don't set the price. So, yeah, you don't set. Maybe just another quick question. I tried MidJourney the other day. Yeah, Mjourney MJurnney is amazing, right? and and I asked the the software to make a Louis Vuitton advertising campaign with only two words. So here it's a bad question for you, Maurice, right?
36:43If if you if you want to put me out of a job, that was my question. Do you feel this advertising production industry is going to be threatened by AI? Be careful. Not at all. It's totally safe. I mean, AI is definitely going to be a massive disruptive force. I mean, it AI is probably the the most disruptive technology ever.
37:14I mean, the crazy thing is that, you know, the the advantage that humans have is that we're smarter than other creatures. Like, if we got into a fight with a gorilla, the gorilla would definitely win. but we're smart. So, but now for the first time there's going to be something that is smarter than the smartest human like way smarter than the smartest human. And as you can see from the journey the art that AI can create is incredible. It's so beautiful and it does it you know within seconds.
37:45So we're at I mean I I think you know there's that sort of saying may you live in interesting times which I think is like not exactly a good thing sometimes but but would we actually live I think we live in the most interesting of times the advent of AI and I actually thought to myself at one point like should you know do I would I really want to be alive at this point like let's say that there is some AI I Armageddon that happened some sort of AI apocalypse.
38:20I think I would still be want to be alive at this time to see it. Hope, you know, hopefully not not create cause it. but it's it's just a I think we live in an an extremely interesting time, you know, because the things that you see AI being able to do now, it's going to do much more with each passing year.
38:45cars will absolutely drive themselves better than any person could drive. we'll have humanoid robots. like so Tesla's developing a humanoid robot. they call it the T800. It's a Yeah, some people get that joke. it's a Terminator. so we can tweet that. Yeah. but but if if you like to say what is an what is an economy? An economy is GDP per capita times capita.
39:21Now what happens if you don't actually have a limit on capita? If you if you have an unlimited number of sort of people or robots. it's not it's not clear what meaning an economy has at that point because you you have an unlimited economy effectively. so so like on the good side the plus side of AI is that I think we are heading for an age of abundance.
39:46where any goods and services that you want you can just have. so that's that's the that's the the positive side of of of AI future is an age of abundance. From the advertising side, I must say that we are using AI since many years and it is helping us a great deal and this tool that we are already using and I think it will be helping us to do even faster some very good ad it will be
40:19probably long time before they replace the creative minds. Asmita maybe you have an opinion on that and maybe you can Asmita is the CDO of L'Oreal and she she knows a lot about digital so maybe you can tell us a little bit about advertising and AI and put your question to Elon yeah so I'll pick up from advertising and from what you said before about Twitter so now we know that Twitter is expensive and we know that it aims to have free speech The question I have is about winning the advertisers's trust to be a preferred social media platform in the current context where the expected revenue you know in 2023 is lower than 2022. You have brought in new leadership
41:12Linda. So I wanted to know that how time the support the freedom because she's an advertising expert. Yeah. so so will she be able to manage the situation and how? Yeah, I I I think I think I think Linda's great. so I think Linda's going to do amazing things for for Twitter. and obviously understands where advertisers are coming from very deeply. understands the concerns that advertisers have and I think we'll do a great job in addressing those concerns.
41:49you know a key part is you know say like if you're an advertiser what content do you want to appear next to and depending upon what advertiser you know the sensitivity of the brand if you're for example say Disney and you're advertising a children's movie then you want to have you know all ages content you know and by the way Disney is one of our biggest advertisers so so So we so it's really just making sure that the content adjacency matches what a brand is comfortable with. and and then there's some cases where the the content is like you know there's not going to be any advertising because nobody wants to advertise next to it and that's going to be some of the more
42:35controversial stuff. yeah I have a followup on that. You know because we were talking about content you have just made the announcement that there will be ad revenue sharing for creators. Yes. Yeah. And that has a condition it will be done when they are verified blue tick creators and the advertising is to verified blue tick users.
42:57Yes. Now if with that how how does that impact your focus on subscription revenues because to be blue tick you know there's a subscription versus advertising revenues focus. Yeah. So a big part of like when you say like say how many impressions does something get you say like well were those impressions real or not real you know was it you know a computer just running 100,000 fake accounts cuz that obviously doesn't count because the computer's not going to buy anything.
43:32so that's why our focus is on on verified users because and we are admittedly conflating verification and subscription at Twitter. So you could say like verified subscriber or something like that. That's not it's not possible to game that. So you know it's real, you know it's solid and you know it's not a computer. so that's why it's that that's why we're focused on that. is is to ensure the authenticity of the views and that it really that real people are seeing what's going on. I mean the sheer amount of of bot and scam and spam activity in social media is insane. and we're talking about AI, it's very obvious that especially with today's AI, the
44:18computers can pass every like are you a human test. In fact, I think they can pass are you a human test better than a human. you know, sort of you say like identify a traffic light or something like that. Okay, let me tell you, Tesla can identify a traffic light. So, if we're, you know, and and but even like open- source AI stuff right now can pass all of the the human tests. So, you have to have something that there's better authentication than than that. Yeah.
44:46Thank you. Yeah, I think that confidence and trust is something which we lose fast and that we regain slowly. I have no doubt personally that Twitter will gain back the trust provided that you do the right thing and I'm sure that you will do the right thing. So it is something which
45:12is probably just a hiccup in the time but you need to do the right thing and I'm sure that you you will do it. I have two small questions. One which is regarding Ukraine you have helped enormously Ukraine. Yeah. at the beginning with Stallings and I think we owe you a lot because without access
45:46access to internet and without access to communication the war would have been finished. what is your take on that experience? Yeah, that that was a I mean that whole situation is very complex. no kidding. Yeah, it's really really complex. as as you point out Starlink did play play a priv pivotal role because Russia had actually taken out all of the satellite communications and all of the ground communications except for Starlink. was the only one that was still operating. and and even today it is still the only one that is effective at the front lines and stalling today is the backbone of the Ukrainian military communications.
46:38so you know, I thought it was important to help out. and but I but I I do I do hope for some kind of resolution soon because I I think it's it's it's terribly sad that that's the flower of the youth of Ukraine and Russia u who don't want to be there that they're dying in trenches right now. And I I sure hope we can figure out some means to peace soon.
47:10[Applause] The last question is going back to this crowd. You have a lot of startupers. You have a lot of young people who want to be successful. Sure. What are the two or three pieces of advice that you would give them? Well, you have a question over there. Yes. do we have a microphone? Because Alen has accepted to take question from the floor.
47:52Shout out a microphone. Go. You have the mic. You go. Yes. Okay. Hello. I don't know why you got the mic, but please go. All right. so I had a question about about all of your different companies and projects in the past 10 years. there's a pattern that I've seem to have identified.
48:30Short question. Every single one of your companies would work a lot better on Mars than on Earth. Sure. It's really hard to make a big vacuum in on Earth, but on Mars, it's a lot easier. Same for Tesla. Electric cars obviously the only can Yeah. And I mean, space station is Okay.
48:56Yeah. Give the mic back. Yeah. Me. Yeah. I mean me and Mar should get a room basically. I I love Mars. Okay. No, no, no, no. Now I want that you give the mic. Sorry, guys. Question. oh. I was there. Okay sir. What's the question? What is the question? My name is Na co-ounder and CEO at clickout. We make AI tiny. So Tesla is one of our target. We'd love to work with you Ellen. and my husband is actually ex Moiline who hard like the infrastructure on MLOps.
49:41Okay. Okay. Sure. Oh, okay. One last question. Yes, sir. Guys, whatever. Yeah, I'm fine with it. However long you want to do it. No, no. Totally crazy. Ali. Yeah. Hi, thank you for being here. Dr. researcher nurse space psychology lab we are working on the mental health to have a human to go to Mars actually sure that's great okay so the question is how do you think it's relevant the mental health for human well I think I think you'd want to have a very good mental health on a trip to Mars and make sure everyone's sane because you don't want someone opening at the airlock in the middle of tonight.
50:46so I think sanity is very important if you're going to Mars, please. We're just going to descend into chaos. Just a second. What do you want? I'm here. Okay. You wouldn't get Okay, thank you. So, I'm Nathaniel Akaman from Okay, I I I think we're going to just It's going to be chaos.
51:20can you hear me? Hey, great t-shirt. Okay. So you talked about the European regulation Elen and you know that there have been many amendments due to LLM deployment. Do you think how can we integrate the use and actual use of this LLM in a non-controlled way in the the the current discussion legislation?
52:00Thank you. You're asking about safe LLM use. Okay, just a second. No, please. It he will answer the question. Was it about safe safety in LLMs or Sorry, I didn't hear the whole question is like safe application of LLMs or or what is it? The the regulation at the European level was conceived when we talk about LMS.
52:31So what would you integrate in the current negotiation at the European level to integrate the the and protect from the Jews? No. Okay. It's sure. Okay. When the regulation has been created, LLM didn't exist. So what would be your suggestion regarding regulating LLMs? Well, I I think more broadly there should be regulatory insight
53:07into LLM and and really any other form of AI. I mean there's I'm not sure L I I don't think LLMs are are the ultimate form of AI. I mean there's sort of an inside joke on AI of like who do you think will be the the American president in 2032? diffusion or transformers. There's an inside joke, but yeah, it's like what does that mean?
53:35but that like might be a real it might be real. so yeah, so we will have the just the two latest question one here and one that in that region. So go ahead. [Music] I mean no if we don't listen to the question we will not be able to continue. Well okay thank you. I'm really confirmed and we have every every year we have a palm which is 13 under 13. My question is what business young people should focus on?
54:18sure. [Applause] well I think generally I think it's important to focus on something I don't go ahead. Sorry. I I think you want to focus on something that you are personally passionate about that you personally care about. it's very hard to be motivated for a product that you don't really feel strongly about.
54:45and it doesn't have to be high-tech. It could be in any in any field. It's just it's got to be a product that you feel is is really needs to be there that that and and something that you personally love. and I would listen to your instincts on on, you know, do do you love this product or service? because it's it's kind of impossible to know what do other people love, but if you love it, that's a good sign. and
55:13and that could that could be small to large, any kind of any field, it's it does not doesn't be have to be high-tech. But if if you don't love if you if you don't really love the product that you're making, if you can't like a good test would be that you can't wait for this product to be on the market that and if that's the case, you are you're going in the right direction.
55:35Great. no. No. The last question. We have Wow. uhoh. We have a French. We have a French saying which is [Applause] wait. No. No. You you not the kid. I know. Okay. Okay. [Applause]
56:36He's asking for narrow link and about the human testing and he's very excited when we will when do you think that we will be able to start testing in our virtual world Victoria we are sure well so so Neurlink is first of all I I want to assure everyone who may be worried about neural link that you will see neural link is going to be a fairly slow process because anything that's done in humans it's very slow. So sometimes people think that this suddenly we're going to be tripping everyone's head and then before they know it everyone's connected to the internet and then we're in trouble with your brain. so it's going to happen very slowly. Hopefully later this
57:20year we'll do our first human u device implantation and this will be for someone that has sort of tetroplegic quadriplegic does not have has lost the connection from their their brain to their body. and we we think we should be able to that person will be able to communicate as fast as someone who has a fully functional body. so that's going to be a big deal and we and we see a path beyond that to actually transfer the signals from the motor cortex of the brain to past the injury in the spinal cord and actually enable someone's body to be used again.
57:58So essentially shunting the signals past the broken point and and restore potentially full full body use to someone that has completely lost the connection. And I mean you can imagine like if say Steven Hawking were alive today what a profound change that would be. and so that's our first application and if it's looking like that the first case will be later this year. So yeah, fantastic.
58:36No, I would like a very very warm rose of applause to Alon M. Sounds good. Okay. Okay. No, no. Thanks, guys. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Uhoh. Thank you. I just want to say you guys are great. You guys are all I mean it's it's so inspiring to see so much energy and so much positive energy in the room. So this is very inspiring for the future.
59:21Merci Abu, thank you. Great. Thank you. No, no, no. Okay, thank you. Guys, if I go down there, it's going to be crazy.
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版