凌晨三点,屏幕那头的人穿着一件黑T恤,背景是模糊的房间。
多哈的会场坐满了人。2022年6月的卡塔尔经济论坛(Qatar Economic Forum),主持人对着镜头抛出第一个问题:那笔440亿美元的推特交易,现在是什么状态?
马斯克先道谢,说很荣幸能虚拟参会,希望有一天能到现场。然后话锋一转:这件事有点敏感,能公开说的有限,措辞得谨慎,免得凭空多出几场官司。
主持人接得很快:这个风险,你好像总能克服。
马斯克笑了:减少被传唤作证的次数,很重要。
这场对话的节奏从这里定下来。一个问题接着一个问题,马斯克用玩笑挡掉一部分,用条件清单回答另一部分。访谈结束时,主持人看了一眼时间:你那边应该是凌晨三点,这是一场相当拼的表现。
他当时的处境不算轻松。推特交易悬而未决,特斯拉股价从2021年11月的高点跌去一半,6月初那封说对经济有“超级糟糕的感觉”的内部邮件刚被曝光。坐在凌晨三点的镜头前,他需要同时回答三个方向的追问。
三个马斯克,一场凌晨三点的连线
主持人的开场白值得记下来。他说,媒体现在至少要面对三个马斯克:推特的拟议买家,特斯拉和SpaceX的CEO,还有一个正在成形的政治力量。这还没算上那些推文和公开挑衅。
这个拆法很准。同一个人,三个战场,三套追问逻辑。谈推特,问的是法律、资金和言论边界;谈特斯拉,问的是产能、对手和裁员;谈政治,问的是钱要投给谁。
马斯克对三个身份的态度也不一样。推特那段,他小心,每句话都留了退路。特斯拉那段,他放松,数字张口就来。政治那段,他绕,两次强调“还没决定”。
现场还有个细节。主持人提到卡塔尔人就在台下,而卡塔尔是这笔交易背后的支持者之一。这个提问把商业、外交和舆论放在同一张桌子上,马斯克没有接这个角度,直接进入了条件清单。
他回答问题的结构也很稳定。先给条件,再给数字,最后补一句玩笑。条件是给自己留余地,数字是让人记住重点,玩笑是把尖锐的部分磨圆。这套组合拳在那天用了几十次。
440亿美元的交易,卡在三个条件上
主持人先给了一个现场观察:看现在的交易价差,投资者似乎在押注这笔交易不会成。
马斯克的回答没有绕:还有几件事没解决。
第一件,虚假账号和垃圾账号到底占多少。推特公开的说法是低于5%,马斯克说,这大概不符合大多数人使用推特的实际体验。他用了“非常重要”来形容这件事,并说还在等结果。
第二件,交易的债务融资部分能不能凑齐。
第三件,股东会不会投票赞成。
他把这三件事并列摆出来,等于告诉所有人:交易成不成,取决于三个可以验证的条件,不取决于他发不发推。
这个回答方式很典型。面对一个充满情绪的问题,他给出一张检查表。检查表上没有情绪项。
“衰退不可避免,只是不知道多近”
主持人转了个方向,问他怎么看经济。
铺垫是拜登刚说的话:美国衰退并非不可避免。马斯克没有顺着这个说,他给了两层判断。
第一层,衰退在某个时点不可避免。第二层,如果问的是近期会不会来,他的答案是“更有可能,而不是不太可能”。他还补了一句,不是确定的事,但概率上偏向发生。
然后他反问主持人:你怎么看?
主持人说,我同意你。
这个反问不是客套。一个月前,他给特斯拉管理层发过一封邮件,说对经济有“超级糟糕的感觉”,要求暂停全球招聘、削减10%的员工。消息泄露之后,特斯拉股价当天大跌。所以主持人问的其实是邮件背后那套判断,到底有多硬。
马斯克的回答把“衰退”变成了一个概率陈述。“必然发生”和“近期发生”是两件事,“可能”和“确定”也是两件事,他把这四层拆开,分别给了答案。
有意思的是,他对宏观的判断没有落在数据上,落在感受上。这跟他后面谈推特虚假账号的逻辑一样:官方数字5%,和用户的真实体验,是两回事。
推特不在中国运营,所以这不是一个问题
主持人抛出了全场最尖锐的一个问题。
它的结构是这样的:你是中国最大、增长最快的外资投资者之一,你说过未来特斯拉三分之一的销售来自中国;你现在要买推特,那个“言论自由的公共论坛”。中国人对言论自由历来不太热情。你担不担心这两件事没法同时跑?买推特会不会给你在中国的生意惹麻烦?
马斯克的回答很短,几乎是逐条否定提问的前提。
第一,推特不在中国运营。
第二,据他所知,中国并没有试图干预美国媒体的言论自由。
第三,他反过来问主持人:我猜你在彭博社,没有受到来自中国的压力吧?
结论:这不会是个问题。
主持人接了一句“你真是个勇敢的人”,语气里有话。
这个回合值得细看,因为它展示了一种应对方式:不辩论价值,直接拆前提。提问预设了“两边都要顾”,他否定了“两边有冲突”这个前提,问题就消失了。
至于这个否定站不站得住,听众自己判断。他后来买下推特,在中国的业务照旧,也没见因为这个出什么事,至少公开层面没有。
言论自由不等于传播自由,这是他关于推特最完整的一段论述
主持人接着问:你说过要让推特更自由、让更多人进来。那到底有没有界限?谁不该被允许进来?
马斯克的回答里有个区分,是他一整套推特构想的地基。
他先讲目标:希望这个“数字城市广场”尽可能包容,成为一个人们愿意用的系统。理想情况下,北美80%的人、全世界一半的人,最终都以某种形式用上推特。
然后是这个区分。言论自由(freedom of speech)和传播自由(freedom of reach)是两回事。
他举的例子很具体。在美国,你可以站在时代广场中间,想喊什么喊什么。你会惹恼周围的人,但你被允许在拥挤的公共场所大声说话,除了喊“这是抢劫”之类的。你说的话再有争议,也不需要被广播到全国。
推特的正确做法应该是:让人们在不违法的范围内想说什么说什么,但谁能看到这些内容,由每个用户自己的偏好决定。
把这段话翻成产品语言:发言几乎不设门槛,分发设置门槛,而且这个门槛由用户自己调。你不喜欢某类内容,把它设成不看,它就沉下去;你想看全部,那就全部推给你。
为什么要有这个设计?因为他算了一笔账。一个让人不舒服、被骚扰的地方,人们会直接不用。他用“必须是一个有吸引力的地方”来描述这个约束。
这是他给出的唯一一条硬约束,而且不是道德约束,是增长约束。想覆盖一半人类,就不能让用户觉得自己会被欺负。
至于这套机制在工程上怎么实现,他没说。谁来判断什么算“不想看的内容”,他也没说。这大概是这场访谈里最需要听众自己打问号的地方。
“我想驱动产品,叫不叫CEO不重要”
主持人问:听起来你想深度参与,你打算当推特CEO吗?如果当了,特斯拉和SpaceX的CEO还当吗?
马斯克的回答绕开了职位,落在动词上。他说,在SpaceX和特斯拉,他做的事情是驱动产品,产品和技术是他的主战场。至于外界叫他CEO还是别的什么,远不如他能不能把产品带向正确方向重要。
这个回答没有承诺,也没有否认。但从他的表述里能看出来,他把自己在推特的位置定义成一个产品负责人,而不是一个运营管理者。
这也解释了他后来在推特的很多动作。改认证、改推荐算法、把这些东西公开讨论,都是产品层面的动作。裁掉一半人之后公司还能跑,说明他判断这家公司的问题不在人数,在产品。
特斯拉真正的对手不是别的车企,是矿山和产线
话题转到电动车,主持人问了一个很直接的问题:你的竞争对手从哪里来?传统车企反扑,还是中国的新公司?他还提到一个预测,说几年后大众在电动车上的规模会超过特斯拉。
马斯克先说,那个预测是你们彭博做的吧。主持人承认。马斯克说,我不同意。
然后他给了一句在造车行业里很少听到的话:特斯拉其实不怎么考虑竞争对手。
为什么?他把限制条件列清楚了。约束来自原材料,来自产能爬坡,来自供应链的现实,来自自己建厂的速度。谁想订一辆特斯拉都知道等车要等很久,需求极高,他明确说这不是故意的,产能在以人类可能的最快速度扩张。
再往下是一串非常具体的瓶颈清单:从锂矿开采、精炼,到正极、负极材料生产,再到电芯成型。他要往前看,看整条锂离子电池供应链上哪里会卡住。
这段话的信息价值在于,它解释了电动车行业的竞争到底是什么形态。多数人以为这是车企之间的设计和品牌较量,马斯克给的是另一张图:谁抢到锂,谁建得起厂,谁就能交付。
说到中国车企,他用词很高。他说对中国车企整体印象极深,极其有竞争力、极其勤奋、极其聪明。他预测会有一波中国产品涌向全世界,而且已经在发生。他举的例子是iPhone:几乎所有iPhone都由中国代工厂制造。他认为很多行业都会出现类似的产品出口潮。
他没有正面回答“中国车企有没有优势”,但他关于供应链的那段话,实际上是在说:这个行业的胜负手在制造和资源,不在品牌故事。而制造和资源,恰好是中国公司的强项。
裁员10%还是3.5%,取决于分母是哪个
主持人抓了一个具体问题:裁员。他复述了一串前后变化的说法:先说要砍10%的员工,然后说砍10%的领薪员工,然后说领薪人数不变、总人数上升。到底是多少?已经有人就那个10%提起诉讼了。
马斯克的回答把一个容易吵起来的数字拆成了结构。
特斯拉的用工结构是三分之二的小时工、三分之一的领薪员工。
接下来三个月左右,他要削减的是领薪部分的10%。小时工不裁,还要增加。理由也说得很直白:领薪这一侧扩张太快,有些部门招人招得过猛,需要收缩。
算总账:领薪的三分之一乘以10%,对总人数的削减大约是3%到3.5%。
他还给了一个时间点:一年后,他的判断是领薪和小时工的人数都会比现在更高。短期是收缩,长期是扩张。
关于那场诉讼,他的态度很干脆。公司做了公告,那起官司没有法律基础,成本很小。他说了一句很实在的话:任何跟特斯拉相关的事都会上头条,不管是自行车事故还是严重得多的事,都能带来点击。他把这场诉讼归到“琐碎”那一类。
这段话其实在做两件事。一是把“10%”这个被反复引用的数字放回它的分母里;二是提醒听众,特斯拉这家公司的新闻流量跟事件的严重程度不成比例。
“可能支持德桑蒂斯”,但钱投给谁还没定
主持人换了第三个马斯克:政治。
问题分两半。你有没有可能支持佛罗里达州州长罗恩·德桑蒂斯(Ron DeSantis)竞选总统,现在还这么想吗?如果特朗普出来选,你会支持吗?
马斯克先把话说清楚:有人问他下次大选支持谁,他说还没决定。对方追问“你倾向谁”,他说“可能是德桑蒂斯”。
主持人直接问特朗普。马斯克的回答是:这场选举,他现在还没决定。
主持人又提了他之前的表态,说要给一个“超级温和”的政治行动委员会(super PAC)投钱,问投多少。
马斯克说还没定具体数目,但不会是小数。主持人追问,他说或许2000万到2500万美元。
主持人显然对这个“不算小”的量级有兴趣,插了一句玩笑:对你来说,不算小数可能是很大一笔。
然后是最后一个钉子。主持人问:德桑蒂斯也好,特朗普也好,这些政治家都在对中国大声喊话,这对你在中国的生意是不是问题?
马斯克只有五个字:我不这么认为。
主持人又是那句“你是个勇敢的人”。
这场关于政治的对话里,马斯克没给任何立场细节,只给了两条信息:钱会投,数目量级在千万美元级;人还没选。对于一个习惯在推特上表态的人来说,这种保留反而说明他知道哪些话在2022年中期说出去代价最大。
关于加密货币:他否认了一件事,重复承认了另一件事
主持人提到他周末发推支持某一种加密货币,又提到整个加密市场的暴跌。他问得很直接:你怎么看,还认为人们应该投资吗?还是说要更有选择地看?
马斯克的第一个回答是一句纠偏:他从来没有说过人们应该投资加密货币。
然后他讲了事实。特斯拉、SpaceX和他本人确实都买了一些比特币,但那是总现金和准现金资产里很小的一个比例。他自己也买了一些狗狗币(Dogecoin),特斯拉接受狗狗币买部分周边商品,SpaceX也会这么做。
他为什么要支持狗狗币?给出的理由很朴素。他认识很多不算富裕的人,这些人鼓励他买、鼓励他支持。他在工厂里走动的时候,SpaceX和特斯拉的员工都跟他提过这件事。“我在回应这些人。”
主持人提醒他,狗狗币跌了很多,大概跌了80%到90%,所以你那句支持,是在跌完之后说的。
马斯克的回答没有辩解:我说我支持狗狗币,我在这么做。
这里有个结构值得注意。他把自己和“建议别人投资”切割开,但保留了“我个人持有并支持某个币”的立场,理由是具体的人的请求。这个切割很干净,法律上也安全。
至于那场暴跌的原因、行业里谁该负责,他一句没说。主持人给了机会,他没接。
9月30日,人形机器人,还有一句关于AI的监管建议
最后一个问题,关于9月30日要亮相的人形机器人。
马斯克说,希望到时候能展示一个有意思的原型。特斯拉有一支很有天赋的团队在跟他紧密配合,目标是9月底拿出原型,目前进度对得上。特斯拉AI日上还会有几件别的事要讲。
他顺手定义了AI日的意义:强调特斯拉远不只是一家汽车公司,在他看来,特斯拉是当今世界领先的现实世界人工智能(real-world AI)公司。
主持人把握住了这句话,把它引到了另一件事上:谷歌那边有个工程师认为他们的AI系统已经接近人的思维,甚至有人格。你怎么看,会不会担心?
马斯克的回答没有任何迟疑。我们应当对AI感到担忧。他说这话已经说了很久,主张应该有一个AI监管机构,为公共利益监管人工智能。
他把类比铺开:任何涉及公众风险或公共利益的东西,都有对应的政府裁判和监管机构,食品有食品药品监督管理局(FDA),飞机有联邦航空管理局(FAA),通信有联邦通信委员会(FCC)。AI目前没有。他的建议就是补上这一块。
这段回答短、硬、没有玩笑。整场访谈里,只有谈到AI监管这一处,他没有给自己留缓冲。
然后主持人的总结:你那边应该是凌晨三点,这是一场相当拼的表现。谢谢你来到卡塔尔经济论坛,谢谢你和彭博对话。
马斯克说,非常欢迎,谢谢邀请。再见。
一场访谈结束。推特那部分他留了三个待解条件,经济那部分他给了概率,中国那部分他拆了前提,裁员那部分他换了分母,政治那部分他只给量级不给名字。真正没有保留的,只有AI。
这次访谈之后,事情一件件落地。7月,他宣布放弃收购推特,推特起诉他,10月他完成收购,随后裁掉大约一半员工。9月30日的特斯拉AI日,Optimus人形机器人原型被推上台,走得很慢,还需要一个支架。2022年全年,特斯拉交付了超过130万辆,增速高于他当时点的那些对手。
回头看这场凌晨三点的连线,最值得学的不是他给了什么答案,是他回答的方式:给条件清单,换分母,拆前提,把情绪问题改写成可验证的问题。这套方法在他那里反复出现,在这份文字稿里能看到完整的版本。
如果你只想从这场访谈里拿走能用的东西,下面几条比结论更值得记。
- 遇到一个数字,先问分母。“裁员10%”和“总人数减少3.5%”是同一件事的两种说法。你听到任何百分比,第一反应应该是搞清楚基数是什么。
- 区分“发言”和“分发”。这套框架不只用于社交平台。任何让内容流到别人眼前的产品,都可以把这两件事分开设计:允许发,但让看的人自己决定看什么。
- 把竞争问题翻译成约束问题。问“谁是我的对手”往往没有答案,问“我卡在哪一环”才有。特斯拉的答案不是大众或比亚迪,是锂矿、精炼和电芯产线。你所在行业的那一环是什么,值得单独列一张纸。
- 用概率说话,不用态度说话。“衰退必然发生”加上“近期发生更可能而非更不可能”,比“我看空经济”信息量大得多,也更难被断章取义。
- 面对预设冲突的提问,先拆前提。问句里藏着两个必须同时成立的前提时,否定那个不成立的前提,比在两个错误选项里选一个更有效。
- 留意他没有回答的问题。中国、加密暴跌的成因、推特改造的具体机制,这三个问题他都绕过去了。一个人的回避清单,往往比他的答案清单更能说明他当时在权衡什么。
0:13Thank you very much. We have been discussing capitalism. We now have a man who by many measures, at least is the world's greatest capitalist at the moment, Elon Musk, thank you very much for coming and talking to us. You could argue at the moment that, us in the media, we have at least three Elon Musk's to deal with.
0:36We have the proposed buyer of Twitter, we have the CEO of Tesla, SpaceX, and much else and we have Musk, the emerging political force and that's before we discover or discuss all the different provocations and tweets and so on. Maybe we can run through those three and let's begin with Twitter.
0:56I suppose my question for you is what is the status of the $44 billion deal to buy the company? If you look at the deal spreads at the moment, the investors seem to be betting that it won't happen I suppose. Right here, you have the Qataris who are amongst your backers. What are you going to say to them and to us?
1:19-First of all, I'd like to say, Your Highness, Your Excellencies, and distinguished guests, thank you very much for hosting me virtually. It's an honor to be here or be there virtually. I actually wish I could be there in person. With respect to the Twitter transaction, there's a limit to what I can say
1:42publicly given that it is somewhat of a sensitive matter. [chuckles] I would like to be measured in my responses here, such as not to generate incremental lawsuits. Unfortunately-- -That seems to be a risk you sometimes manage to overcome. -Yes. Deposition minimization is I think important.
2:05[laughs] -Have Twitter given you enough information? -Well, there are still a few unresolved matters. You've probably read about the question as to whether the number of fake and spam users on the system is less than 5% as for claims, which I think is probably not most people's experience when using Twitter.
2:33We're still awaiting resolution on that matter, and that is a very significant matter. We're awaiting resolution on that. Then, of course, there is the question of, will the debt portion of the round come together, and then will the shareholders vote in favor? I think those are the three things that needs to be resolved
3:02before the transaction can complete. -What about the general state of the economy? Does that weigh on you when you think about this? You just described it, you have a super bad feeling about the economy. Are you still in that position? I just said to you earlier, Joe Biden has just come out and said that a recession in America is not inevitable.
3:23How do you feel about the economy? -I think a recession is inevitable at some point. As to whether there is a recession in the near term, I think that is more likely than not. It's not a certainty, but it appears more likely than not. What do you think? -I'm with you. I agree with you.
3:49I think it's more likely. Can I ask you one particular thing to do with the Twitter bid, which is you are one of the biggest and fastest-growing investors in China. Tesla, you've talked about it being a third of your sales going forward. You're now buying Twitter, the public forum for free speech.
4:09The Chinese historically don't tend to be very enthusiastic about free speech. Are you worried about whether you can keep those two particular horses running? Is buying Twitter going to get you in trouble with the Chinese? -Twitter does not operate in China. I think China does not attempt to interfere with the free speech
4:40of the press in the US, as far as I know. I assume you're not under pressure at Bloomberg from China. I don't think this is going to be an issue. -In terms generally of that issue of freedom of speech and Twitter, you've talked about Twitter making it even freer and letting more people onto it.
5:07Is there a limit at all to who you think should be allowed onto Twitter? -My aspiration for Twitter or in general for the digital town square would be that it is as inclusive in the broader sense of the word as possible, that it is an appealing system to use. Ideally, I'd like to get like 80% of North America,
5:38and perhaps I don't know half the world or something ultimately on Twitter in one form or another. That means it must be something that is appealing to people. It obviously cannot be a place where they feel uncomfortable or harassed or they'll simply not use it. I think there's this big difference between freedom of speech and freedom of reach in that one can obviously,
6:07let's say in the United States go in the middle of Times Square and pretty much yell anything you want. You'll annoy the people around you, but you're allowed to just yell whatever you want in a crowded public place, more or less apart from, "This is a robbery." Probably that would get you in trouble but then that whatever you say,
6:34have a controversial does not need to then be broadcasted to the whole country. I think generally the approach of Twitter should be to let people say what they want to do within the bounds of the law but then limit who sees that based on any given Twitter user preferences. If your preferences are to see anything or read anything,
7:03then, you'll get that but if your preferences are you prefer not to see comments that you find offensive in one form or another, then you can have that as a setting and not see it but I think one way or another one needs to take the steps that entice most people to want to be on Twitter and enjoy it and find it informative
7:35and entertaining and funny and useful. As useful as possible. -It sounds like you want to be involved is your plan to be CEO of Twitter and if you do that, would you still keep being CEO of Tesla and SpaceX? -Well, I would drive the product which is what I do at SpaceX and Tesla.
8:02I drive the product in technology. Whether I'm called the CEO or something else is much less important than my ability to drive the product in the right direction. -Can I jump towards Tesla there. Most people it's very obvious you have changed the car industry in a dramatic way.
8:23I'm quite intrigued by one thing, which is your competitors. Where do you see competition coming from? Do you see it coming from the old car makers coming back at you? I just saw a forecast that maybe in a couple of years' time Volkswagen would be bigger than you in electric cars or do you see it coming from new place,
8:41do you believe that? -I believe that forecast was from you, -Yes, it was and do you agree with that? -I would not agree with that forecast, no. -Do you see people like Volkswagen and General Motors and people like that as the opponents or do you see people like China, the new Chinese companies?
9:03Where do you see the most vibrant competition in electric cars? -I'd say that I am very impressed with the car companies in China, just in general. With companies in China, I think they're extremely competitive, hard-working, and smart. I think there's going to be just a massive wave of Chinese products
9:29going out into the world. They already are. For example, almost all the iPhones are made in China by contract manufacturers for Apple. I think we'll see just a large wave of products being exported from China in many industries. -In electric cars, do they have an advantage at all?
9:58-I should say, from a Tesla perspective, we don't really think about other competitors. Our constraints are much more in raw materials and being able to scale up production. Our constraints are not imposed upon us by competitors but rather just imposed upon us by the realities of the supply chain
10:26and building up our manufacturing capacity. As anyone knows, who has tried to order a Tesla, the demand for our cars is extremely high, and the wait list is long. This is not intentional. We're increasing production capacity as fast as humanly possible. We really don't think about competition at all.
10:53We just think about how do we address the limiting factors in the supply chain and in our own industrial capacity. Basically, we need to build the factories faster and that we need to look ahead to whatever the choke points are in the whole lithium-ion battery, supply chain from mining and refining
11:12to cathode and anode production and cell formation. -Can you set the record straight on one thing, which is this issue about the layoffs. I think you've said initially that Tesla, 10% of the workforce will be cut, then 10% of salaried would be cut, then salaried would stay flat and overall headcount would go up.
11:35What is the number? I know there's already, I think, been a lawsuit about the 10%. Is 10% the goal to reduce the workforce? What is the number that we should think about or that you're planning? -Tesla is reducing the salaried workforce by roughly 10% over the next probably three months or so.
12:02We expect to grow our hourly workforce. I was quite clear that we expect to grow our hourly workforce but we grew very fast on the salaried side and we grew a little too fast in some areas, and so it requires a reduction in the salaried workforce. We're about two-thirds hourly and one-third salary.
12:31I guess, technically, attempts at reduction in the salaried workforce is only roughly at 3%, 3.5% reduction in total headcount. -I think that number is important legally, isn't it? Because I think people are trying to say if you're going to lay off 10% of your workforce, you have, even in America to make an announcement about that.
12:54-We did make an announcement. [chuckles] Let's not read too much into a pre-emptive lawsuit that has no standing. That is just a small lawsuit of minor cost points, that just anything that's related to Tesla gets big headlines whether it is a bicycle accident or something much more serious.
13:18It seems like anything which is related to Tesla gets a lot of clicks whether it is trivial or significant. I would put that lawsuit you're referring to in the trivial category. A year from now, I think our headcount will be higher in both salaried and obviously in hourly, but in the short-term
13:42of the next few months, we expect to see, like I said, roughly a 10% reduction in salaried workforce which is actually just really only 3%, 3.5% reduction in total headcount and not super material. -Shall we jump to that third, Elon Musk, the uncontroversial one in politics. You've indicated that the Florida Governor Ron DeSantis is someone you could get behind if he ran for president?
14:12I wonder if you're still in that position and whether you would, for instance, think about supporting Donald Trump if he were to run? -Well, I was recently asked if I had decided on who I would be supporting in the next presidential race and I said I had not decided who I would support.
14:34Then I was asked, "Well, who might you be leaning towards?" I said, "Possibly, DeSantis." -Now I'm asking you about Trump, whether you would consider him? -I think I'm undecided at this point on that election. -I wondered, you talked about putting money behind a super moderate super pack in the US.
14:58-Yes. -I wondered how much money do you think you are going to push into that? What support would you push? -I have not decided on an amount, but it would be some nontrivial figure I think. At least on the order-- -Nontrivial could mean a lot with you. -Sorry. -Nontrivial could mean a lot of money with you, I was guessing.
15:22-I don't know, I've not decided on the exact amount, but perhaps it'd be $20 or $25 million. -Just on that issue. Again, you look at what DeSantis says, you look at what Trump says, and those politicians, they, again, are people who make a large noise about China. I wondered whether you thought that was also an issue for you in terms of business in China.
15:56-Well, no, I don't think so. -You are a brave man. Can I ask you over the weekend, you tweeted your support of one cryptocurrency. You've seen the carnage that has been happening in cryptocurrencies at the moment. What is happening and do you still think people should invest, or is it a more selective approach?
16:22-I have never said that people should invest in crypto. In the case of Tesla, SpaceX, and myself all did buy some Bitcoin
16:40but it's a small percentage of our total cash or near cash assets, not less significant. I also bought some dogecoin and Tesla accepts dogecoin for some merchandise and SpaceX will the same. I intend to personally support a dogecoin because I just know a lot of people who are not that wealthy, who have encouraged me to buy and support dogecoin.
17:19I'm responding to those people. Just people that when I've walked around the factory it's SpaceX or Tesla, they've asked me to support dogecoin so I'm doing so. -Dogecoin, I think has come down a lot. It's down about 80, 90% or it's down a lot. That's the reason why you came out and said that you still thought there was value there.
17:43-I said I support dogecoin and I am doing that. -Can I ask you one last question, I notice that you are going to unleash a humanoid robot to be unveiled on September the 30th. I wonder if there's any more you could tell us about that? -Well, I hope that we will have an interesting prototype to show people.
18:07We have a very talented team at Tesla that I'm working with closely to have a prototype humanoid robot ready by the end of September. I think we are tracking to that point and there'll be a few other exciting things that we talk about at the Tesla AI day. We have these AI day events to just emphasize that Tesla
18:35is a lot more than a car company and that we are in my view, the leading real-world AI company that exists. -Did you see at all the drama at Google where people at least one engineer thought that what was happening in terms of their AI machinery was closer to human thought than had been
19:01seen before and had a personality? Is that something that you think about at all or you worry about? -I think we should be concerned about AI and I said for a long time there I think there ought to be an AI regulatory agency that oversees artificial intelligence for the public good.
19:27For anything whether is a risk to the public, whether that's food and drug administration or federal aviation administration, federal communications commission, whether it's a public risk or public good at stake, it is good to have a government referee and a regulatory body. I think we should have that for AI, we don't currently and that would be my recommendation.
19:54-Elon Musk, you've been incredibly kind with your time, not least, because I think it's 3:00 AM in the morning. It's been a heroic performance. Thank you very much for talking to the QATAR Economic Forum and talking to Bloomberg. Thank you. -You're most welcome. Thanks for having me. Bye. [music]
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版