主持人问马斯克想活多久。这位把“让人类成为多行星物种”当作毕生使命的人,回答得很干脆:一百个好年头就差不多了,也许稍微长一点也行。他补了一句,自己并不是长寿的狂热信徒。拉里·佩奇(Larry Page)在资助研究如何终结死亡的生意,马斯克对此态度很淡。他承认,让人在更长时间里保持好的生活质量有意义,比如解决老年痴呆这类问题,但他不打算把精力砸在“永生”上。
这场对话发生在 2015 年,由 Vanity Fair 组织,对谈的另一位是 Y Combinator 总裁山姆·奥特曼(Sam Altman)。那时候奥特曼还没有创立 OpenAI,YC 已经投过一千多家公司,Airbnb、Dropbox、Stripe、Instacart 都在名单上,每年新投 250 家,加起来估值 650 亿美元。台上这两个人,一个在造火箭和电动车,一个在批量制造创业公司,聊的话题从火星一直铺到模拟宇宙。
先别急着往天上走。主持人给马斯克出了道难题:假设把特斯拉、SolarCity、SpaceX 都从你名下拿走,明天你可以从零开始,你会选哪个方向?
如果明天重新创业,他会去造电动飞机
马斯克的回答分两层。第一层很具体:电动飞机有一个相当明显的窗口。他的判断是,除了火箭,所有交通工具最终都会电动化。这个“除了火箭”是他自己加的笑点,因为火箭恰恰是他正在做的事。
第二层就没那么轻松了。他说有两个领域充满麻烦,但如果不做,后果可能更糟:人工智能和基因工程。这两个方向能最大程度改变人类的命运走向,同时也“相当棘手”(really dodgy)。他用了一个词,fraught with issues,意思是麻烦缠身。如果要重新选,他大概会在这两个里面挑一个下手。
奥特曼的答案和马斯克高度重合。YC 已经投了一家电动飞机公司,也投了一批 AI 公司。奥特曼说,如果能挑两件自己还没在拼命做的事,一个是让 AI 往正面方向走,他相信这可以做到,另一个就是基因技术。
主持人追问,那我们聊聊能源,这才是你真正在做的。马斯克的回答没有任何犹豫:可持续能源是我们这个世纪最重要的难题。他的论据很直接:如果继续烧碳氢化合物,未来会很难看,绝大多数科学界的共识指向这一点,任何有科学背景的人在这件事上都没有含糊的余地。
他特别推崇太阳能,理由带着马斯克式的直白:天上挂着一个巨大的聚变球,每天准时升起。太阳能加电池,就能构成一套完整的可持续能源方案。发出来的电还需要用可持续的方式消费掉,那就是电动交通要解决的问题。
奥特曼在这个话题上补了一刀,说得很实在。他说,把可持续能源的成本压到极低,可能是除了 AI 之外,对全球最贫穷那一半人口生活质量最重要的事。他每次去看数据都会被震撼:能源成本和人们的生活质量,相关性强得惊人。
核聚变、核裂变,和天上那个免费的反应堆
主持人问核能。马斯克说,世界的终局大概是核能和太阳能的组合,比例可能是 80 比 20,谁多谁少还不好说。他看好聚变在未来几十年内取得突破,但他现在的倾向变了:以前他是聚变作为长期能源的忠实拥护者,现在他认为来自太阳的“间接聚变”会成为主要来源,聚变反应堆只是在某些场景下补充,比如你住得特别靠北或者特别靠南。
主持人顺势问核能的风险。马斯克先纠正了一个常识:裂变和聚变的风险方向完全相反。
裂变的麻烦是熔毁,尽管新技术已经把熔毁风险压得很低。聚变真正的难点在于火苗会灭。太阳靠引力约束让聚变持续进行,地球上没有这个条件,你只能用电磁约束,或者用动能约束,也就是把东西高速撞在一起。让反应炸开从来都不难,难的是让它别那么快熄灭。
他顺便把两个概念给听众重新讲了一遍。聚变,是把两个氢原子、严格说是两个氢同位素撞到一起,生成氦。裂变,是一个重原子以可观测的速率衰变,分裂成更小的原子,铀和钚都是这个路子。主持人当场承认自己科学没学好,这段对话就这么带过去了。
“核平火星”到底是什么意思
接着话题跳到火星。马斯克之前在深夜脱口秀上说想用核弹轰炸火星,被不少人当成段子。他在台上承认,那句话说出口的时候是有点轻率,但这个想法本身是认真的。
问题在于,30 秒的电视节目没法把逻辑讲清楚。他的原意是:太阳本身就是一场持续的聚变爆炸,宇宙里几乎所有能量的源头都是聚变,连裂变能量往前追溯,也是更早的聚变留下的产物。如果想让火星变暖,你实际上是想给火星加能量。
具体方案是在火星的南北极上空各造一个“小太阳”,两个脉动的热源,把极区的温度升上去。冻住的二氧化碳会气化,大气密度随之上升。一部分水也会升温,变成水蒸气。二氧化碳和水蒸气都是温室气体,会进一步给火星加温,形成一个正反馈循环。火星需要被加热,地球不需要,这两件事的方向完全相反。
为什么非要去火星?马斯克给的理由有两条,他讲得很清楚。一条是防御性的:意识之光不能只在一颗行星上燃烧。火星表面没有探测到生命,地下也许有细菌,但至少表面是空的,人类过去就相当于把生命扩展到第二颗行星。这相当于给“我们已知的生命”买了一份集体保险。
另一条是进攻性的,或者说精神层面的:你想活在哪种未来里?永远困在一颗行星上,等着某次灭绝事件降临,还是走出去,在群星之间分布开来?马斯克说后者更让人兴奋。灭绝事件也许在很远的未来,也许不那么远,这本身就构成了理由。
奥特曼在这个问题上补了一个冷峻的注脚。他说自己担心 AI 的问题会比火星殖民地更早变得紧迫,可能等不到人类在火星站稳脚跟,AI 的事就得先处理。马斯克同意。奥特曼接着开了个玩笑:就算人类还没去,AI 也可以搭激光束过去。马斯克说,以光速传输信息到火星大概 20 分钟,AI 过去很容易,难的是送实体穿越太空。
费米悖论和那个让人摘下头盔后愣住十秒的体验
主持人把话题引向宇宙中的其他生命。马斯克认为微生物生命存在的概率相当高,但越往“复杂生命”走,概率越低。
他引出了费米悖论(Fermi Paradox)。宇宙有近 140 亿年历史,行星数量巨大,如果生命普遍存在,为什么我们看不到任何迹象?他给了一个尺度感极强的说法:以自行车的速度,几十万年也能骑到半人马座阿尔法星。以这种慢速,一亿年足以把整个银河系铺满。那他们为什么不在?
这个问题被他接到了另一个思路上:模拟假说。马斯克说这是概率问题,看电子游戏的四十年就够了。从 Pong 里两个方块互相弹,到今天几百万人同时在线的照片级 3D 世界,再到戴上就觉得自己在现场的虚拟现实头盔,加上能让你“摸到东西”的力反馈手套。他做了一个极端的保守假设:就算技术进步的速度从现在起放慢 100 倍,游戏和现实难以区分的时刻,也只会从 20 年推迟到 200 年。
主持人问他,你觉得我们现在就在游戏里吗?马斯克说,自己并不觉得有个手柄握在别人手里,但他补了一句更扎心的:游戏里的人通常也不这么觉得。
他举了一个真实的观察。有人第一次用最新的 VR 设备,在一个大空间里体验,虚拟空间里的长椅和现实中的长椅位置一一对应。摘下头盔之后,这些人会愣住十秒钟,然后你跟他聊天,会发现他对“什么是真实”的信念被撬动了。因为他们刚才在虚拟世界里太确信那就是现实。如果我能摘下这个头盔,那上面为什么不能还有别的层?
奥特曼把这条线和费米悖论接了起来:如果真的是一场模拟,那恰好能解释为什么宇宙里看不到外星人。
VR 离普通人还有多远?马斯克说,Oculus 和 Valve 的第一批消费级头盔大概在 2016 年初上市,也就是几个月之后。他看过的演示非常有说服力:你在一个毫无特征的普通房间里戴上头盔,瞬间就身处别处。有一个演示会在你靠近悬崖边缘时朝你吹风,在你走近火堆时打开加热器,而你全程看不见这些装置,因为你戴着头盔。
Model X 的 13.2 万美元、被删掉的那条推文和 Model Y
话题落回地面。主持人提到 Model X 13.2 万美元的定价,问这车到底能卖多少台。马斯克解释了定价结构:13.2 万美元对应的是首批量产车的满配版本,起步价没有这么高。第二年会有便宜一些的版本,不含补贴大约 7.5 万美元,算上各种激励大概 6.5 万。再往后几年是 Model 3,起步价 3.5 万美元,车更小,但普通人够得着。
然后主持人抓住一条推文。上周有人在推特上问 Model X,马斯克回了一条提到 Model 3 和 Model Y 的推文,随后删掉了。整个特斯拉粉丝圈都在猜这条推文说了什么,为什么要删。
马斯克的回答很平淡。那条推文大概是说会有 Model 3 和 Model Y,其中一款会有鹰翼门,猜也猜得到是 Model Y。他删掉的理由是,自己回头看了一眼推特历史,觉得太啰嗦,顺手删了十几条。他强调删除没有任何深意,也不觉得删一条推文就能让它从互联网上消失。
主持人追问,你投了推特,也拥有特斯拉,给个理由说服大家。马斯克的答案很产品经理:特斯拉本质上是一家带轮子的软件公司。他开过早期的 Roadster,那车不算最好,但 Model S 是市面上最好的车。你指哪,按下去,车就到了,没有噪音,可靠性高,软件真的能用,是唯一一款软件做得好的车。价格仍然贵,但他对大众市场的特斯拉有信心。他还顺口说了一句:自己开过的其他电动车,感觉落后好几年。
主持人追问,你自己怎么看特斯拉?马斯克说,是软件公司加硬件公司,但软件占比会越来越大,尤其是往自动驾驶走的时候,两部分都得做对,因为用户感受到的是一个整体产品。
自动驾驶:技术两三年,监管再加一到五年
主持人抛出一个流传甚广的猜测:特斯拉是不是偷偷把自动驾驶功能装进车里,某天突然一按开关,车就自己开了。
马斯克说,没这么戏剧化,但方向差不多。特斯拉即将推送 7.0 版本软件,开启高速公路自动驾驶:车能在高速上自己转向,也能应付没有特别急的弯道的普通道路,在拥堵路况下转向表现也不错。这套软件当时正在公测,大约六七百位车主在试。
奥特曼的判断比大多数人激进。他说,完全自动驾驶汽车到来的速度会比人们以为的快得多。你去问普通人,十有八九会说还要 10 到 20 年,他认为两到三年内就能做到“完整版”的自动驾驶。
马斯克同意这个时间表,但加了一个关键区分。技术可行性和法规批准是两件事。他说的两到三年,是指车能在几乎任何地方完成点对点驾驶,不用靠 Mountain View 或者帕洛阿尔托那种高精地图覆盖的特定区域。技术做到之后,监管审批还要再加一到五年,看地区而定。监管机构会要求看到证据,证明自动驾驶比人类驾驶显著更安全,才会放行。
关于 30 岁创业这件事,两个人都不认同彼得·蒂尔
主持人搬出彼得·蒂尔(Peter Thiel)那句著名的话:他不会投 30 岁以上的人。马斯克今年 44 岁,蒂尔投过他,所以要么蒂尔破了例,要么马斯克就是那个例外。
奥特曼先给了数据。YC 投资的创业者平均年龄在 29 到 30 岁左右,30 岁以上的创业者他们投了很多,其中一些做成了几十亿美元的公司。说 30 岁以上不能创业是荒谬的。他们观察到的相关性是:在那些最成功的、几十亿美元级别的公司里,创始人的平均年龄确实明显偏年轻。但看单个公司的成功率,也就是成或不成这个二元结果,和年龄没有明显关系。年轻创业者倾向于冒更大的险,愿意做长周期的项目,仅此而已。
马斯克说,“我永远不投 30 岁以上的人”是个疯狂策略,他也不认为蒂尔真是这个意思。任何时候开始创业都可能成功,真正重要的是:你有没有好点子,你是不是拼命干,你能不能吸引到一支好团队并且让他们保持动力。
主持人又抛出另一个流行观点:一个人一辈子只能有一个好点子。马斯克说,那句老话怎么讲的,百分之一的灵感,百分之九十九的汗水,大体属实。他补了一句更有价值的观察:很多公司起步时的那个点子其实是错的,只是他们调整得够快,最后撞上了对的东西。
特斯拉起步于两个愚蠢的假设
马斯克主动交代了特斯拉的黑历史。公司创立时建立在两个错误前提上,事后看非常蠢。
第一个前提:可以从南加州一家叫 AC Propulsion 的公司授权到电驱系统技术,拿来就能用。结果完全不行。那套技术只够做原型车,撑不起一款成本可控、可靠性过关的量产车。
第二个前提:可以低成本改造莲花 Elise 的底盘,把电驱装进去,快速造出来卖掉。结果比从零设计还糟。他们最后换掉了整辆车 96% 的零部件,原有的碰撞测试结果全部作废,车重了 30%,还得加长。马斯克打了个比方:你心里想好了一栋房子,本来应该从地基开始盖,结果你买了栋现成的,把除了地下室一面墙之外的东西全拆了。那还不如一开始就按你想要的样子盖。
所以特斯拉起步于两个蠢主意,团队花了很大力气才爬出来。马斯克说,真正重要的是先动手开始干,然后随时准备质疑自己的假设,改掉做错的地方,向现实靠拢。第一版方案永远不值得当成信仰。
一天里 70% 的时间在做工程和设计
主持人问,同时运营两家公司是什么体验。杰克·多西(Jack Dorsey)当时也正准备同时管两家。马斯克说,不推荐,这会大幅压缩你的自由度。
然后他纠正了一个外界的想象。他的日常和大多数人以为的不一样:大约 70% 的时间花在工程和设计上。像这种媒体活动只占 2% 到 3%,他打算继续压缩到 1% 左右。
这个比例说明了很多事。外界看到的是一个人在推特上发言、上节目、被讨论,实际的时间分配里,绝大部分在做具体的工程决策。
手机投票、特朗普,和腐败与关注度的关系
主持人问了两个政治问题。第一个是,什么时候能在手机上投票。奥特曼说,会的,而且影响会很大,因为这会真正改变投票人群的构成。他估计这件事要花些时间,因为很多人不希望选民结构发生变化。他习惯用 10 年、20 年的尺度看问题,人们总被这个月或下个月发生了什么、是不是泡沫、买在高点还是低点牵着走,但长期看,事情终将发生。
第二个问题问马斯克怎么看唐纳德·特朗普。马斯克的回答很谨慎:自己没有强烈感受,只是希望特朗普不要拿到共和党提名,那会不太好。主持人提到巴里·迪勒(Barry Diller)说特朗普若当选就搬出国,问马斯克会不会。马斯克说自己不会走,最多是特朗普拿到提名,那也有点尴尬,但不排除会发生,他也不会感到意外。
主持人问他参与政治的程度。马斯克说,尽可能少,但有些时候不得不参与,主要是 SpaceX 要和波音、洛克希德竞争国家安全和民用航天发射合同,不争就会丢。
主持人顺势问,这个体系有多腐败。马斯克的回答角度很特别。他说总体上不算太腐败,理由很反直觉:如果这个体系真的烂透了,SpaceX 根本没有任何机会。当年拿第一份政府合同时,公司还很小。真要是深度腐败,他们一单都拿不到。
他由此提出一个规律:政治关注度越高,腐败越少。总统层面的腐败大概最少,参议院、众议院会多一些,州一级可能更多。逻辑是,有多少双眼睛在盯着,决定了有多少暗箱操作的空间。
补贴这件事,他打了个“工薪族不是百万富翁”的比方
主持人抛出针对马斯克旗下公司最常见的批评:这些生意在某种程度上靠政府补贴。如果不靠补贴,它们能成吗?
马斯克说,绝对能。他还说自己早该写篇文章反驳,因为很多说法源自《洛杉矶时报》一篇不通的文章。那篇文章的做法是,把特斯拉已经拿到和未来会拿到的所有激励加总到一个 30 年的跨度里,造出一个吓人的大数字。马斯克打了个比方:一个人年薪 5 万美元,你不能因为他在未来 20 年会累计赚到 100 万美元,就管他叫百万富翁。
他说,给特斯拉和 SolarCity 的激励,本质上是在对冲化石能源行业实际享有的隐性补贴,而且还没对冲平。他举了两个对照数字:枯竭油井有 20% 的税收优惠,太阳能当时的优惠是 30%,两年后要降到 10%。也就是说,两年后太阳能的政策优惠只有枯竭油井的一半。
SpaceX 的情况更极端。波音和洛克希德在发射业务上拿到的补贴超过 10 亿美元,SpaceX 是在这种情况下赢的。SpaceX 属于“尽管有补贴”还成功的案例,特斯拉和 SolarCity 则是补贴起了催化剂作用,让事情比原本快了一些,但没到决定成败的地步。他举了电动车的 7500 美元税收抵免,落到消费者身上大概是 10% 的折扣,算不上天翻地覆的区别。
AI 的正面版本:人类早就已经是半机械生物
台下第一位提问者来自多伦多,他说,如果马斯克对下次大选不满意,欢迎回加拿大。他的问题关于 AI:任何新技术都会引发恐惧,想请两位谈谈 AI 影响人类生活的正面愿景。
主持人这时才发现,整场对话居然还没聊到 AI。
奥特曼先答。他说科幻片给了两个版本,要么人类奴役 AI,要么 AI 奴役人类,但还有第三个版本:幸福的共生关系。他不认为这是默认结局,但这是应该努力的方向。而且这种共生已经在发生,只是没人注意到。
他举的例子很有意思。今天没有一个人能完整解释谷歌搜索结果第一页是怎么排出来的,那背后是机器学习算法。你在谷歌搜索,是一个 AI 在决定你该看到什么。婚恋网站把两个人匹配到一起,背后是一个没人能完全理解其运作方式的机器学习算法,这些人后来生了孩子。某种意义上,是机器学习算法在给人类配对繁衍,而这些孩子长大后又去改进算法。
所以奥特曼心中的正面图景是分布式 AI:把能力分散地交到大量个体手里,而不是出现一个比任何其他实体聪明一百万倍的单一 AI,统治所有人的一切。
马斯克同意,并且说得更彻底。他说人类实际上已经是一个人与机器的共生体,整个社会就是一个巨大的赛博格。他承认自己对其中“人”的那部分有偏爱。他也强调,AI 的发展需要谨慎,要确保它最终对人类有益,确保未来是好的。
超回路列车,和加州高铁那笔账
有人问超回路列车(Hyperloop)的由来。马斯克说,起因是他看到加州高铁的计划。他的判断是:花很多钱,做出来的东西相对汽车和飞机并没有明显优势,旅程时间上也没强到哪去,而加州纳税人要为此背上沉重的账单。付高价就该有高回报,这个道理很朴素,但他看到的不是这样。
于是他开始想,从洛杉矶到旧金山,以及中间的城市,最快的走法是什么。他先有一个想法,自己发现行不通,不断迭代,和一群人一起改,最后形成了技术上成立的超回路方案。现在有几家公司在推进,他希望能看到它真正建成。
SpaceX 在办一场学生竞赛,各队比拼谁能做出最好的胶囊舱。他们在洛杉矶 SpaceX 附近,准确说是洛杉矶县境内,修了一条大约一英里长的测试轨道。比赛规则是看谁的舱在赛道内跑得最快,终点设了一大片撞击区,舱要是来不及减速,就冲进去。马斯克说这会是一场刺激的比赛。
“只有软件在创新”是个错觉,因为媒体只写软件
一位斯坦福计算机系学生问了个尖锐的问题:今天听到的创业公司,大多是技术支撑的商业模式创新,真正基于硬技术创新的公司很有限,为什么?
奥特曼反驳得很干脆。他说总有人讲现在没人做有意思的事了,大家都在写软件,世界在变糟,进步已经结束,他从来不同意。我们正处在一个创新速度惊人的时期。历史上发生的事是,哪里有巨大的机会,人才就往哪里涌。过去几十年软件的巨大进步吸引了大量聪明人,这并不说明其他领域停滞,只说明这一个领域在极快地改造世界。
他点出了关键错位:媒体爱写软件公司,对别的领域兴趣寥寥。所以外部的人会觉得世界上只有软件。YC 投的公司做各种事情,他们喜欢投长周期的硬科技创新,媒体不喜欢报道这些。他补了一句:写软件本身也没什么错。
马斯克接过第二个问题:如果特斯拉和 SpaceX 是你的第一次创业,你还能做成吗?他的回答是,大概不适合当第一家公司,因为资本密集型的生意极难起步。主持人追问,你是不是真的把钱全砸进去了?马斯克说,是。
他讲了当年的想法。他并不算投资人,基本只投自己参与创办的公司。从 PayPal 出来之后,他计划把一半的钱分投 SpaceX、特斯拉和 SolarCity,另一半留着。结果 2008 到 2009 年的金融危机来了,选择变成:要么把所有钱都投进去,公司可能活;要么不投,公司必死。他投了全部,非常紧张。
他记得特别清楚的一笔,是 2008 年底特斯拉的那轮融资,在最后一个可能的日子的最后一个小时关闭:2008 年 12 月 24 日圣诞节前夜下午 6 点。如果那轮没关掉,公司会在圣诞节后两天破产。
钱最后会去哪里
最后一个问题,主持人提到拉里·佩奇说过,与其把钱捐给慈善机构,不如全给马斯克。他问两个人,你们的钱会给谁,或者给什么。
马斯克的清单很短:继续推进火星上的自给自足城市,这是必须发生的事;可持续能源和可持续交通;教育;儿科医疗。他说自己的钱基本都流向这些地方。奥特曼的答案更贴合他的身份:通过 YC,把钱持续投回他相信的技术里。
整场对话里,马斯克被问到的最尖锐的问题,其实是那个斯坦福学生问的:如果你的第一次创业就是特斯拉,你还能成吗?他的回答不带任何浪漫色彩。资本密集型创业极难起步,他当年是靠卖 PayPal 的钱和自己全部身家顶住的,而且在圣诞前夜的最后一小时才勉强活下来。
把这场对话里的判断抽出来,能落成几条可以用的东西:
- 选方向时先看物理约束。马斯克判断电动飞机的依据来自“除了火箭,所有交通工具终将电动化”这条物理层面的必然,跟市场热度无关。找那种不需要赌运气的顺势方向,比追风口可靠。
- 把长周期和短周期分开算。奥特曼反复强调用 10 年、20 年的尺度看问题,因为每个月的波动会吃掉判断力。自动驾驶的时间表也是这么拆的:技术 2 到 3 年,监管再加 1 到 5 年。两件事混在一起估,必然估错。
- 假设自己起步时的判断是错的。特斯拉建立在两个愚蠢前提上,最后换掉 96% 的零部件才活下来。马斯克给的方法论是:先动手,然后随时准备推翻自己的假设,向现实靠拢。别把第一版方案当成信仰。
- 警惕被加总出来的数字。《洛杉矶时报》把 30 年的补贴加总成一个吓人的数字,就像把年薪 5 万的人说成百万富翁。看到跨期加总的数字,先问它的时间跨度是多少。
- 判断一个领域有没有创新,别只看媒体报道密度。媒体偏爱软件公司,不代表硬科技停滞。想知道某个领域在发生什么,去看这个领域的人在做什么,而不是看新闻在写什么。
- 时间分配是最诚实的自我暴露。马斯克说 70% 的时间在工程和设计上,媒体活动压到 1%。如果你想知道一个人真正在意什么,看他日历怎么分,别听他怎么说。
0:00thank you all for sticking around this afternoon we had some great conversations and we're hoping to have another great one I it is my pleasure an honor or privilege really to have this conversation about the future with two gentlemen who know probably more about it than most the fellow all the way to my right to your left does not need any introduction Elon Musk you all know from Tesla and SpaceX of course from Solar City Sam Alman I would say you don't need too much introduction either but I'm going to give it to you just in case you don't he runs ycombinator ycombinator has investments in over a thousand companies at this point they're investing in about
0:36250 companies every single year those companies collectively are worth about $65 billion dollar in total that's with a b and to give you just a a sort of a sense of the the kind of names we're talking about we're talking about Airbnb Dropbox stripe zenitz instacart Etc so both both folks with an amazing pedigree and an amazing sense of what's going on here's where I want to start the conversation with both of you and I think we're going to probably go to outer space very quickly but we're going to try to keep it on Earth at least for the moment when you think about Innovation and you think about where we are going to be 10 15 20 years and what
1:16to invest in and what to make I'm going to make it hard for you Elon if you took Tesla out of it took Solar City out of it took SpaceX out of it and you said I could go start a new company tomorrow it would be what it would be in what area where would you start thinking about well I think I think there's some
1:40fairly like there's a fairly obvious opportunity in electric aircraft because all transport will Electrify over time with the exception of rockets ironically and you know but but I there's I mean there's I think there there's two areas which I mean they're fraught with issues but you know it's one of those things where if you if you don't do something maybe not doing something is worse like on the AI front or on
2:19genetics you know so like the like the the those are the two things I think besides sustainable transport the internet and making life multiplanetary rewriting genetics and AI the latter two are the ones that can most change Destiny of humanity but but they're they're really dodgy so I mean maybe I'd try to do something in one of those two areas but they're yeah fro with difficulty Elizabeth Holmes was here earlier spoke during the lunch hour do you think about genetics and Longevity and trying to sort of avoid your friend Larry pagee is investing in a business hoping to end death I I don't I mean the
3:10the I mean I'm not actually a huge proponent of longevity I mean I do think that having a good life for longer is better like you you'd want to address the you know the things that that happen to you when when you're older like dementia and so forth th those are pretty important
3:33but I'm not I'm not sure it's sort of actually you know want to do that want to get into the genetics thing but it is something that's going to fundamentally change humanity and along with AI so you don't want to live forever so that you can actually get to Mars I definitely don't want to live forever how how many years do you want to live I don't know 100 good ones 100 good ones or 100 more good ones you're 44 I mean 100 good ones in total I think is probably fine and maybe a bit longer
4:14Sam what where where would you put your money you're you're the investor here well I mean we we try to invest in a very broad range of technology so we funded an electric airplane or funding electric airplane company we've done AI companies we've done how we the electric airplane by the way I think it should work I think it like it makes it it makes sense the math should work I think I I actually I I no huge surprise but I'll I'll agree with Elon on those two areas I think if you could pick two things that I'm not already working really hard on AI having ai go in the positive direction which I really think it can and I I think thinking about sort of genetic technology genetic
4:58technology I I made it unfair for you because I I said we had to take Solar City out and we had to take the cars out so we didn't get to really talk about energy but I imagine how big how big how big a thing do you think energy all in and when you think about both your Investments and what you're doing is something that is one of the things that you need to tackle well I think sustainable energy is the most important problem that we face this Century that's like a known
5:30difficult thing that we have to solve like if if we if we continue to rely on burning hydrocarbons it the future is going to be quite bad and the vast majority of the scientific establishment believes that and the evidence I think is well I mean anyone with a scientific background is you know unequivocal so
5:53so so we got to solve sustainable energy I'm a big fan of solar because we got this big Fusion ball in the sky called the Sun and TOS up every day so if we can you know use solar energy plus batteries we can actually have a complete solution for sustainable energy gener generation and then we need to use in a sustainable way which is you know where where you need the electric transport yeah so the thing I would add I I think getting the cost of sustainable energy Down super low is probably you know short of AI like the most important thing we can do for sort of quality of life of the poorest half of the world I think that you know every time I I look into this it's
6:37it's really amazing how much the cost of energy and the quality of life correlate what about nuclear energy you have you have some investments in nuclear energy yeah I mean what I've always said is I think the end state of the world is a combination of nuclear and solar probably 8020 one way or the other sort of terrestrial based nuclear I I think Fusion is likely to work at some point in the next couple of decades and and that's a really big deal I think that it's good to have a backup option it's good to have two sources but you know like it's all sort of fusion when you think about it yeah I I I mean I'm big I mean I think Fusion I think it's definitely
7:10possible to make fusion work the but I think the and I used to be a big fan of of like having of that as the long-term energy source but I'm inclined to think like indirect Fusion from the Sun essentially is going to be the primary source and then to some degree there will be Fusion reactors for you know maybe whatever yeah if you're really far north or really far south or something what about the risks of of nuclear energy a fusion a fusion yeah I assume there's some risk there's no risk not really zero I'm an idiot I don't no no mean with Fusion the difficulty is keeping it going not you know with with with fision you you have some meltdown risk although there's you know
7:57there's new technology on the fion front that makes meltdown risk extremely low but but with Fusion the great difficulty is is keeping the reaction from is keeping it the fire from going out it it's quite hard to sustain a fusion reaction unless you have something very big like the sun and you have the sun has gravitational confinement of the fusion reaction so since you you can't do gravitational confinement on Earth you have to do some sort of electromagnetic confinement one form or another or or a kinetic confinement by slamming things into each other so it's it's quite tricky to prevent a fusion explosion from not immediately extinguishing got it so Fusion is like
8:43I mean probably what you do is just repeat it every second or whatever so I mean just just a sort of you know I Fusion is like when you when you take say two hydrogen atoms or or two hydrogen Isotopes technically and slam them together and form helium that's that's fusion and then vision is like when you've got like a heavy atom that is decaying at a at a
9:10you know relatively like a noticeable rate like uranium or plutonium and decays into smaller atoms then that that's that's Vision okay I didn't do so well in science so we're going to try to move along but you recently said that you wanted to Nuke Mars I I didn't really understand then you guys in the back were doing some science talk about how nuking Mars would work yeah yeah
9:42so so nuking Mars I I I sort of was a little flippant about that I think it's a really decent idea thank you thank you so yeah the what is really getting at but it's hard to you know convey that in like 30 seconds you know on on The Late Show with s was was that the the sun is a a nuclear explosion a fusion explosion that's what the sun is it's an ongoing Fusion explosion so if you wanted to add energy to Mars like warm up Mars the really the source of almost all energy in the universe is fusion you know even fision is
10:21originally there was fusion and then that that that then later resulted in fishion but what I was really talking about is creating two little Suns two pulsing Suns above the North and South Pole of Mars that would warm the the poles up enough so that the Frozen CO2 would would gasify and densify the atmosphere some of the water would also heat up and and you'd have sort of water more water vapor and CO2 in the in the Martian atmosphere which in that case is good because the the CO2 ends up warming warming Mars up and so you get a positive sort of reaction like it's a positive cycle of of warming on Mars like you want to warm Mars up but you don't want to warm Earth up you know so
11:06why would you ever want to live on Mars it looks like a great adventure to me Beyond The Adventure do you actually both of you you you're investing in stuff that hopefully one day will go to Mars nothing for Mars but excuse me I nothing for Mars but I but I hope El Longos I think that would be cool but is that just for one person tell what what's going to happen no really I want to yeah well I mean the the Mars thing is is really like if you say what is going to be really important to the preservation of of civilization or Life as we know it more than just you know Humanity because of course we bring Life as we know it to Mars and that there's no life that we can detect on
11:43the surface of Mars there may be some Subterranean bacterial life but there's it's on on the surface there there isn't anything so this would be the extension of life to another planet or Life as we know it to another planet and I think would be make a huge difference to the prob lifespan of human civilization and and Life as we know it so it's sort of like an insurance policy a life insurance policy for Life collectively and you know so it's yeah probable
12:16because you because you think global warming what do you what do you think is going to happen here that's I don't want to be clear this is this is a I mean I I think it's important that we become a multiplet species not a single planet species but on another planet so this is if if we it's like really it's like what kind of future do you want to have do you want to have a future Where We Are Forever confined to one planet or one where we are out there exploring the stars and and on on many planets and I think the the latter one is far more exciting and inspiring because the former is basically waiting around until some some Extinction event so because
12:50eventually there will be one and it might be quite far in the future but it also might not be far in the future so there's so there's the there's really two main reasons I think to make life multiplanetary and to establish a self-sustaining civilization on Mars one is the defensive reason to to ensure that the light of Consciousness as we know it is not extinguished or or lasts much longer and the second is that it would be an an amazing adventure that that we could all enjoy vicariously if not personally I
13:26think it's really important to establish multiplanetary life I agree with with that I think my concern is that the I think the AI question is likely to become pressing and important to deal with before we can establish a full Colony on Mars that's true you guys and I think even if not then the AI can like go to Mars on a laser beam the AI goes does that mean it's like justs itself there yeah I mean it's very hard to send through space but the AI is going to go like 20 minutes you know on a laser beam it's easy do you guys believe in life forms outside of Earth you think there are I I mean I think there's there's quite a high chance of microbial life that's
14:09there's a much that then as you get more advanced in life that there's less and less likelihood of of like sophisticated life but you don't think do you think there's sophist you think there aliens out there that we can talk to you mean as opposed to like bacteria yeah yeah there's a great onion article recently about like you know like like NASA should only hold a press conference if they find aliens that we can talk [Laughter] to but but I I think so I mean it's it's an interesting Confluence of events like it's not just that there has to be life intelligent life that evolves somewhere but that that life has to last for a long time for us to be Co
14:50for us to exist at the same time as that so what it suggests is there's this great questions called the like sort of the firmy Paradox like where are the aliens like if there are so many planets out there and the universe is almost 14 billion years old why why aren't the aliens everywhere and this is a one of the most perplexing questions because you know you could basically bicycle to Alpa centor in a few hundred thousand years like meaning at that's at bicycle speed so it's sort of like you know in 100 million years like even at a
15:40very slow speed you could completely blanket the Galaxy so why why not where are they it's very hard for me to get now well we were we were talking in the back and we've had this conversation before you please weigh in on this and I think it's a thought experiment that you have suggested that we are all collectively right now living in a simulation what does that mean yeah it's it's a probabilistic thing so they really if you look at at say the advancement of video games from say 40 years ago when we started out with pong and you had like you know rectangles Bing a rectangle to each other and and now we've got photorealistic 3D simulations with
16:32millions of people playing simultaneously or 3D games with millions of people playing simultaneously that are just getting better now we've got virtual reality headsets so you can just put it on and it feels like you're right there you'll have haptic feedback meaning force feedback sticks so you can actually pick up something and feel like you're picking up something like you know have haptic gloves and if if you extrapolate that advancement at at any rate at all like if you say okay let's say it's it slows down by a factor of 100 starting right now okay so then then then I mean the video games will be distinguishable from reality in let's say you know 200 years instead of 20
17:17years or something like that but you don't think that we're in a game right now okay well that's this is this like we all somebody has a joystick somewhere else in some other you know where I'm going with it certainly doesn't feel like that I mean I don't I don't I don't think I'm being played by somebody in a video game but then people in video games don't generally think that I I certainly think if you talk to people who use the latest virtual reality equipment in sort of a big space where they sort of map like benches in the space to benches in the game and the environment you know they have this experience when they do that for the first time and they take it off and then
17:58they just fre freeze for 10 seconds and and you can and then you talk to them and it's clear that like they their belief that this is actual reality has been shaken because they were so convinced in virtual reality that that was real and so if I can take this off like why aren't there other layers I also think it ties interestingly back to to the fmy Paradox yeah exactly you know if if it is a simulation sort of that would be a pretty good answer for why there are no aliens how far are we away from sort of virtual reality being a thing all of us sort of live in to some degree we would go to this conference we would go to this conference from
18:36our VR sets I mean I do think there there's still something to actually really being there in person that that we probably won't lose for for a long time hopefully never but I mean with with what Oculus and valve are coming out with and I believe some of that that like the first VR headsets are doe out early next year yeah like in the next several months and and the demos that that I've seen and I think Sam's probably seen too are incredibly compelling and there is that strange feeling because you you you put the headset on in like a very nondescript Bland room and and you you put the headset on and suddenly you're in anywhere like you could be yeah you
19:20know I got this demo where they would like blow air on you when you like got near a cliff Edge and when you walk near a fire they would turn on a heater and you don't see any of this cuz you're just wearing it and then and it's it's really quite quite compelling I want to talk about something else that's compelling which is Tesla it's really nice talk about the X it's an SUV it's an SUV but here's what I was going to say $132,000 how many people really going to buy this thing yeah so the the the F
19:48the first cars that are produced are fully the sort of fully optioned version so it's not like a base price of you know 132,000 it's and we'll have a version that's still expensive on the expensive side but before any incentives would be about 75k next year and you know with incentives and whatnot it's you know maybe 65 so it's it's it's still expensive but it's not as crazy as 132 the and and then in in a couple
20:21years we should have the model 3 and that'll be starting price of $35,000 so it's a smaller car but it's you know a lot more affordable okay so for the Tesla sort of real efficient AOS who follow you on Twitter you need to you need to answer one thing which is last week somebody tweeted at you I think about the X and then you put out a tweet that mentioned the Y and the three and then you deleted the Tweet yes this and everybody wants to know why you deleted the tweet and what the Tweet actually said I no I think I think it was it just said something like the there'll be the model 3 and the model y and that one of them will have like a faling door which is like pretty
21:07obviously the model y so the but I I I deleted that and like I don't know a dozen other tweets because I S it had like kind of a rambling Twitter history but it was had no significance the delete has no significance like I don't think deleting a tweet like makes it go away from the Internet or something so why why delete the tweet I just didn't like what the way my Twitter history looked it was it was like too
21:33rambling you've invested in Twitter I'm I'm in Twitter in Tesla yeah you own a Tesla yeah make the case for those who are out there you I make it harder because he has to do it now why what what is this going to become in your mind you sure you don't want him to answer yeah we know what he's going to say look I mean I think as most people who own one think it's the best car like out there I had a roadster before a Tesla Roadster which was not the best car but the model S really is like it's just it's the best car on the market and I think that people think of this like existing car companies but actually this is like a software company with a car attached to it and
22:17it's you know you just like you sort of point and click you like point the wheel somewhere you push the thing down and it just kind of gets there it doesn't make noise it like it's very reliable the software actually works it's the only car with good software so I think people really like it now yeah it's like really expensive still but I think well I'm
22:36confident that a mass Market Tesla will do very well and I also think the other electric cars I've driven feel like many years behind right you talked about this being a software company do you think of yourself as a software company I think we're software and a hardware company but but the software component does become increasingly important so you got to get both right because it's you know it's a holistic product experience but it it softwares increasingly the you know an increasing proportion of the problem particularly as you get to autonomy and yeah so so there is a view I don't know if it's a conspiracy theory that you are building autonomous functionality and
23:20other driverless like functionality into the car without advertising that it's in there and that one day you going to flip a switch and the car is going to start just driving well no not quite like that but we are going to upload new software soon and and we this is not actually a secret or anything we we have version seven of our software which turns on Highway autopilot so the car will be able to steer by itself on on highways or or any kind of any kind
23:56of road that doesn't have really steep sharp curve curves on it and and then also it'll steer quite well in in traffic so those are the two scenarios where it'll it's think going to be quite good at steering and and and we'll that that's in public beta right now so we have I don't know 600 or 700
24:17Tesla drivers owners that are testing the aut steer software and and yeah go ahead I think full self-driving cars and not Tesla specifically just in general are are likely to get here much more quickly than people realize yeah I absolutely you ask most people they'd still say it's 10 to 20 years away and I actually think we'll have sort of like full point too autonomous driving in a in a few years it won't be uncomon few years like two or three years three or four maybe know better I agree I think that's something on the on the two to three year time frame is likely for for it to be technologically I mean you you'll be able to demonstrate it but it you won't be able to go to
24:59fully autonomous until you get reg regulatory approval so there's there's a there's a time difference between when it is technologically possible in a general sense you know so that you know not not just like in a very tightly mapped situation like say Mountain View or paloalto right but in the general sense of like you know can it can it do point to point virtually anywhere right I think that's that's only you know two to three years away but but then approval of from Regulators of of having it be autonomous is anywhere from I don't know one to 5 years after that depending upon the location because The regul Regulators have to be convinced that it is substantial I think they'll
25:44they'll want to see that it's significantly more sign significantly safer than than cars that are driven by people I want to open it up in about 5 minutes so I just have a couple more questions to get to you and so if you guys have a question in the audience get your shot on goal in just a second I want to talk about entrepreneurship because both of you are entrepreneurs you invest in them you are one and you think about this a lot your old pal Peter teal likes to say that he would not invest in
26:14somebody who's over the age of 30 years old that that it should be the cut off you're 44 now he's invested in you yeah I guess make some exception but you may be the exception to the rule as some as somebody who invests in companies every day do you think there's a cut off there's a lot of people out here who are over the age of 30 are we done I mean we've said this before but when we've looked at our data the the mean age of entrepreneurs we fund is just around 29 or 30 so there's obviously lots of over 30 entrepreneurs that we fund some of which have gone on to create multi-billion dollar companies so I think certainly you can't say it's impossible for people over 30
26:55to create companies that's that's ridiculous and we plan to continue to invest in people of all ages the correlation that we've noticed is that if you look at the really successful companies we've had the multi-billion dollar companies the the average for those average age for those Founders does skew significantly younger but the success rate of founders of you know this binary is the company a success or not excuse older than 30 so you know younger entrepreneurs I think tend to take bigger risks maybe they're willing to work on these very longtime Horizon projects but that's the only correlation we see I think it would be a crazy strategy to
27:31say I'm never going to invest in anyone over 30 yeah no I mean I think I think it's I don't think Peter meant that either yeah I mean you you can definitely start a company at any age and be successful I mean it's really just question of like do you you know do you have a good idea are you working really hard are you able to attract a great team and motivate the team and that I mean that that's sort of really what what matters but you've had multiple ideas and there's there's another view by the way which is that you can only really have one great idea right that everybody sort of has maybe maybe one great idea it's not really the idea you know I mean like
28:06there's that old saying it's 1% inspiration I I think and 99% postp spiration I think it's generally true I mean a lot of times like companies start out with with with an idea that's actually wrong but they they adapt quickly enough to get it to something that that's right right and I can say like at the beginning of Tesla we started out with we started the company with two false premises like that would turn out to be like really dumb one was that we'd be able
28:36to license the drivetrain technology from a company called AC propulsion in Southern California and that it would just work that didn't that totally didn't work and then we also thought we'd be able to adapt the Lotus Elise chassis at low cost and be able to essentially put the AC propulsion drivetrain technology in a Lotus at leas chassis and then just build that quickly and and sell it and that it would that that would be okay but but like I said the AC propulsion technology did not lend itself to any any kind of
29:14cost-effective reliable car it was okay for like a small prototype but not not for a commercial product and and the and then the Lotus Elise that that ended up worse than if we had designed a car from from the beginning because we ended up changing like 96% of the components in the car and invalidating all of the crash results and all the safety stuff the car ended up being 30% heavier had to be longer
29:45and it ended up being like like if you if you want if you had a house in mind and instead of actually building that house from scratch you got some existing house and ended up knocking everything except one wall in the basement out and and it would have been better to just build the house from the beginning the the house you wanted so so so basically Tesla was started on the basis of two dumb ideas and but we managed to you know it was a tough one to overcome those two two issues but we we managed to get get past them that's so that's I think the more important thing is like start somewhere and then you know really be prepared to question your assumptions fix what you did wrong
30:23and adapt to reality how did you run two companies at the same time Jack dorsy is about to take this on in a meaningful way what is what does a day in the life of Elon Musk actually look like yeah I wouldn't recommend running two companies this is it really it decreases your freedom quite a lot
30:45so and and I'll tell you what so my day is probably a bit different than people think it is I me most of my time is actually spent on engineering and design so that's probably I don't know like 70% of my time like press stuff like this is maybe two or 3% of my time it's really really tiny and I'm going to reduce it even further it's probably like 1% of my time so real quick and then we'll go to the audience politics I want to ask you two political questions one is innovation in politics when when do you think there'll ever be a day where we actually vote on our phone we stupidly seem to still go and vote you know in our local District often times at a local school and I also
31:38wanted to get your sense of who out there you may or may not like right now in terms of what you guys do and who who you think might do the best all right I'll take the first question Elon can answer the second Trump's amazing I I think that yes we will someday vote on our phones I think it it like and it will have a significant impact because it'll really change people who vote so I think that may take a while because there are a lot of people who don't want to see the electorate change but you know over a 20year time frame I always try to think about things over these sort of you know 10 or 20 year time frames I think you can get so caught up
32:10in the what's happening this month or next year are we in a bubble are we buying at a low tick or a high tick but but eventually it's going to happen and I take soless in that anyway Elon on Donald Trump yeah he asked you I mean and I don't really have strong feelings except that I you know hopefully Trump doesn't foret the nomination of you know the Republican party that's because I think that's yeah that wouldn't be good so but I mean bar Diller said he would move out of the country what about you really no I would move I mean I think like at most he would get the Republican nomination but I think that was still be a bit embarrassing so I
32:56think that could happen yeah you think it will happen it could it won't surprise me if it does yeah I honestly don't have strong feelings about the do you get involved in politics I get involved in politics to the as little as possible yeah there sometime I have there's some amount that I have to get involved in mostly because SpaceX has to battle Boeing and locked you know for National Security and and civil space launch contra s so if we don't if we don't battle them then you know then they will we'll lose how corrupt is that whole thing yeah well I mean the the I mean
33:41actually would say that on on balance I guess it's it's not that corrupt because if if it was corrupt then SpaceX would have no chance because SpaceX I mean it's got it's gotten a bit bigger these days but it was very tiny when when we won our first govern contract and if if it had been like deeply corrupt then we would not have won anything so you know I think you
34:09know I think actually at the the the greater the level of visibility politically the the the less corruption occurs so I think there's actually probably like the least corruption at the presidential level than at the Senate level in the house and then that there can be a bit more corruption at the state level U it's like basically how much attention are people paying that that that defines how much corruption occurs right yeah you know perhaps and we'll open up to but it got me thinking the only real big critique of some of your businesses is that they are subsidized to some degree by the government could these businesses succeed without government
34:49help yeah absolutely the the the and I should at some point I should probably write a rebuttal because there was like nonsensical LA Times article from which a lot of this stems because what what the LA Times article did was add up all incentives that Tesla has received and all inent incentives that Tesla will receive so like over a 30-year period and made it made it sound like a big number but it's you know like if somebody's
35:20earning $50,000 a year you don't say you don't call them a millionaire because over the next 20 years they will cumulatively earn a million do but that's effectively what that article did the incentives I think for for Tesla and Solar City what they really do is balance out the the the the actual
35:42and de facto incentives that carbon producing activities have so and I don't think they actually balance it out so the carbon producing activities still sort of overwhelm the incentives that electric cars and solar receivers I mean for example there's a 20% tax incentive for stripper oil well like and the the incentive for
36:07solar is currently 30% but dropping to 10% in two years right so the you know two years the incentive for solar power will be half that of a stripper oil well right so you know and and SpaceX made it in in in spite of boing lock receiving a billion dollar plus subsidy for the launch activities so I think in the case of SpaceX it was sort of success in spite of incentives and in the case of Solar City and Tesla it was the incentives were you know moderately helpful but not not the deciding factor they they're they're Catalyst they made things happen a little FAS than they would otherwise happen but you know you look at something like the like the there's a
36:52$7,500 tax credit for EVS Okay so that ends up being a 10% discount that the consumer receives for buying the car it's it's not like night and day difference okay we got a lot of people who are standing and we want to get to all the questions we're going to sort of try to do this rapid fire so I'd ask you to keep your question short and these guys are going to keep their answers short as well at least we're going to Hope goad hi my name is Bruce Gman I'm a private investor in Toronto Canada and Elon if you're not happy with the next election you're more than welcome to come back to Canada question is about artificial intelligence like any good good new
37:27technology people always fear the change and things that can go wrong I was wondering if Sam and Elon could share with us their positive vision of ai's impact on our coming life right we didn't even get to AI in this whole conversation yeah I I think look there is a really positive Vision here right I think there are the science fiction version is either that we enslave it or it enslaves us but there's this Happy symbiotic Vision which I don't think is the default case but what we should work towards I think already humans and AI are Co evolving and no one's paid attention to this yet but I don't think there's any human left that understands
38:02all of how Google search results are ranked on that first page it really is machine learning algorithm so when we search on Google it's an AI deciding what we should see when a dating site matches two people together there's a machine learning algorithm that no human understands how it works that is getting people together that then have babies and so in in effect you know you have this like machine learning algorithm breeding humans and so really I mean you do and so there's this and then you know those people like work on the algorithms later and so I think the happy vision of the future is sort of humans in Ai and a symbiotic relationship distributed AI where it
38:38sort of empowers a lot of different individuals not this single AI that kind of governs everything that we all do that's you know a million times smarter a million times smarter than any other entity so I think that's what we should work towards I agree with what Sam said I mean we are effectively already a human machine Collective symbiote like there's like we're like a like a giant cyborg that that's actually what Society is today you know but but I'm going to sort of obviously I mean have an affinity for the human portion of that cyborg Collective and I think I do think we need to be careful about the development of AI and make sure it is
39:24ultimately beneficial to humanity that it's that that the future is good question over here okay so not too long ago oh my name is Jessica sing by the way but not too long ago on the nightly show with Larry Wilmore they had Bill n the Science Guy on there discussing the new Mars Discovery and the other P panelists basically said that our society doesn't care about the scientific discoveries of NASA and how does Innovation what does that mean in a society that only values the results like the final products like a car or like finally going to space and not really valuing the process proc of getting there well I mean I do I do think that there is I'm not sure I agree with that
40:04I me I think we do value Discovery and and new things and and learning about the Universe I mean there was quite a bit of attention paid to the discovery of of water flowing on Mars I mean I'd certainly say that it should be more but I think it's okay I think it's not bad I think we're I think we're better off than than that the show would suggest okay yeah okay we're going to try to get everybody up there if we can so go ahead question for Elon I I understand that the hyperloop was inspired by your opinions about California's High-Speed Rail and could you share those opinions as well as a bit about the hyperloop yeah just if if if we're
40:51to have a some new form of Transport in California which I think is would be good to have then we want to we want to Aspire to have something that is Cutting Edge technology and when when I was reading about the highspeed rail plan it's it's a lot of money for something which isn't obviously compelling relative to a car or a plane
41:17in terms of the time it would take to complete the journey and and it will will settle California taxpayers with a pretty significant amount of money that they got to pay so so it's like if you pay if you pay a high price you should have a a great outcome like that should be the sensible thing and that that doesn't seem to be what what is happening from what I can tell and so I was trying to think well what what would be the the fastest way you could get from say LA to San Francisco or cities in between and
41:53ended up mentioning that I had the an idea actually had a toour not unlike this and then and then discovered my initial idea didn't work and then kept iterating with a with a bunch of other people and came up with a hyperloop so that's sort of where where it actually it finally did work from a technical standpoint and now there are some companies pursuing that which is awesome and I hope we see some I hope we see it come to fruition SpaceX is is doing a a hyperloop student comp ition that where where teams will compete to see who can make the best pod and and so we're doing a sort of a mile long hyperloop section in La just right near SpaceX really
42:44whone technically but LA County and and so I think that's going to be pretty exciting to see what the students can come up with and here can come up with the most advanced pod design and I I think we're going to set it so that like like like the winner would be who can get their pod to go the fastest within a on M section and like then have like a big crash area at the end like so if the pod doesn't slow down in time can sort of get into the crash area you know I think that'll be quite an exciting competition we had a couple more seconds we'll grab it thank you hello my name is Bish I'm a computer science student at Stanford and so far west majority of startups we heard here
43:25today or the ones we hear on the news are brilliant Innovations on business models that are supported by technology but on the other hand the ones that are based on true Technical Innovations are kind of limited that we have a few examples here I want to ask Sam why do you think that might be the case and as a followup to that to Elon do you think you'll be able to successfully build Tesla or SpaceX if there if they were your first Ventures and if you were looking funding for them out there so I I I think that a lot of people talk about how you know no one's working on anything interesting we're all just doing software the world is like really shitty it's getting worse
44:03it's the end of progress and I've never agreed with this I think so two-part answer one I I actually think we're on an incredible pace of innovation what's happening as what happens historically is that when there's a great opportunity sort of talent sashes around and finds that and there's been incredible progress in software in the last couple of decades there will be more and so a lot of talented people are choosing to work on it but that doesn't mean we're not making press it just means this one area is like transforming the world incredibly quickly people are doing other things as well as you mentioned and you know at y combinator we fund
44:35companies doing a lot of things here's the issue the Press loves to write about the software companies and they have very little interest in writing about the other stuff and so as an outsider you would say well there's only software but that just doesn't reflect reality you know we fund companies doing all sorts of things and I think we love funding Tech we love funding technological innovation on a long time scale the Press does not love covering it and also I think there's nothing wrong with working on software yeah I think for SpaceX and Tesla are probably not the the ideal companies to have as the first thing
45:13I mean generally because like if something is capital intensive it's really hard to get going because is it true that you totally ran out of money supporting those two companies yeah wow so I guess that would not have been a good first no I mean the the thought I had in the beginning was I'm like I'm not really an investor I just like basically invest in the companies that I help create and I thought you know coming out of PayPal I sort of I said I thought I'd invest like half the money in SpaceX and Tesla and Solar City and and then I still have the other half left over except that doesn't really work out cuz then the recession of 2008 and 2009 came
45:56along and it was a choice of either invest everything or the companies would definitely die so it's like if I invest everything then they might live and if I don't invest everything then they're definitely going to die so ended up investing any investing everything and it was real tight actually in fact like the the Tesla financing round at the end of 2008 I remember quite well because that we we closed that financing round on the last hour of the last day that was possible it was 6:00 p.m. Christmas Eve 2008 and we would have gone bankrupt like 2 days after Christmas if we hadn't closed that round yeah that was hard okay we got to wrap up final
46:37question for both of you but I'm going to start with Elon with this your pal Larry Page once said that rather than give all of his money to charity he would prefer to give all of his money to you he might have changed his mind so my question for both of you is where do you want to where who would you give all of your money to or what would you give all of your money
47:02to well I mean my expectation is I mean I I want to sort of continue the the path of establishing a self-sustaining City on Mars I think that's an important thing that needs to happen and and then also sustainable energy sustainable transport and then education and Pediatric Healthcare those are like the areas that I mean that's essentially where all all my money is going sort of the good thing about why combinator is I get to pour all of my money back into the Technologies I believe in so I I would keep doing that and Larry Page will give your money to you Elon Musk Sam Sam Alman thank you guys
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版