大会演讲·中文精读

马斯克 DealBook 大会访谈(2013)

Elon Musk DealBook Conference Interview 2013

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2013年,三辆特斯拉在几周内接连起火。华尔街在讨论召回,监管机构在等说法,媒体头条几乎一边倒地暗示电动车不安全。

马斯克坐在 DealBook 大会的台上,穿着那件被主持人调侃像托尼·斯塔克的外套,一开口就把话题接了过去。他先把两组数字摆在桌上,让在场的人自己做除法。

三起火灾、两万五千辆车,和一条被忽略的除法

他先给的是汽油车的基准线:在美国,大约每1300辆汽油车会发生一起火灾。全美每年有20万起汽车火灾,250到300人死于汽车火灾,1200到1500人因火灾受重伤。

然后他讲特斯拉自己的账:当时路上跑着接近2.5万辆 Model S,累计发生3起火灾。除下来大约是每8.8万辆一起。

“我们发生火灾的概率,大约是普通汽油车的五分之一。这不代表我们的概率是零,大数定律和统计学上它总会发生,但媒体的标题有极强的误导性。”(马斯克)

他补了一句让台上安静下来的话:如果火灾风险是你最在意的事,你很难在这个世界上找到一辆比 Model S 更安全的车。要想比它更安全,风险得做到零以下才行。

更有分量的是另一组数字:特斯拉历史上从没有出现过一起严重伤害或死亡事故。三起火灾里的三位车主,事后都告诉马斯克,如果当时开的换一辆车,他们大概率会受重伤;第二起事故的车主说得更直接,换一辆车他大概已经死了。

那辆从墨西哥一路滑出去的车

马斯克详细讲了第二起事故。地点在墨西哥,他不愿公开具体时速,但给了一个换算:那辆车当时的动能,大约是一辆车在设计上被认为“可存活”上限的四倍。

事故是分好几段发生的。车先撞上一个混凝土环岛,把一段15英尺长、18英寸厚的混凝土墙整体削掉,弹出来又冲向一堵7英尺高的混凝土墙,把那堵墙也撞穿了。到这一步车轮已经被撕掉,车贴着地面滑行,底盘直接摩擦电池包,最后撞上一棵树才停下来。

驾驶员和乘客从车里走出来,自己走开的。

“这有点像泰坦尼克号。假设它撞上第一座冰山没有沉,撞穿第二座,撞上第三座才停下来,所有乘客都安全下船,然后又买了一张泰坦尼克号的票。结果报纸标题写的是:泰坦尼克号上发生厨房火灾。”(马斯克)

这个类比不算精确,但它点出一个真实的传播问题:事故的严重程度和报道的角度,经常是脱钩的。三起火灾里,有一起是底盘受撞击后电池包受损,火势被电池包的结构限制在前部,没有蔓延进乘员舱;另外两起的撞击能量都远超常规测试标准。最后流传出去的版本只剩下一个词:特斯拉起火了。

“不会有召回”

主持人问得很直接:有传言说要召回,到底怎么回事。

马斯克的回答没有留余地:不会有召回,也没有任何理由召回。他说得很清楚,如果真存在影响安全的问题,特斯拉会立刻召回。当年早些时候就干过一次,后排一个安全带支架发现了轻微问题,没有人受伤,连险情都没有出现,特斯拉还是召回了全部车辆,把支架全部换掉。

然后他把话题拉回设计逻辑。他承认自己造这辆车时有点完美主义,安全是头号优先级,理由很朴素:他自己开这辆车,他的孩子坐在里面,他的朋友也坐在里面。

他给出的是第三方验证:Model S 在《消费者报告》的测试里被评为路上最安全的车,领先幅度相当大;在联邦政府的碰撞测试里,它拿到了有史以来所有被测试车型中最低的乘员受伤概率。换句话说,从数据上看,找不到一辆比它更安全的车。

股价涨了474%,他说这价格我们配不上

话题转到公司和资本市场。2013年特斯拉股价年内最高涨幅到过474%,访谈当时已经回落,但仍然涨了37%。

主持人想知道,一家变成流行文化符号的公司,内部是什么状态。马斯克的回答有点出人意料:

“我一直以为这种过山车会慢慢平缓下来,但它好像一直在继续。我其实觉得高股价有点让人分心。我公开说过,我认为那个价格高于我们应得的。”(马斯克)

他补了一句平衡的话:长期看他相信公司的价值会远超那个水平,可按当时的估值买入,等于对公司未来的执行力押上极大的信任,他们会尽力兑现这份信任。他说自己不会刻意唱多,那次也无意唱空,只想把话说准确。

“按现在的价格,这股票算是不错的买卖。但之前那个价格,可能确实偏高了。这是我的真实想法。”

乔治·克鲁尼那辆车,是2008年的

主持人提到当天报纸上乔治·克鲁尼的评论,说他因为老被撂在路边,把那辆车处理掉了。马斯克当场纠正了事实。

克鲁尼说的是自己2008款的 Roadster,在一次慈善拍卖会上卖掉的,事情发生在2008年。马斯克的原话大意是:那是一辆五年前的车,型号也不是 Model S,时间也不是最近,这实在算不上新闻。他打了个比方,“这就像说我的第一代 iPhone 在2001年有个 bug”。

他也没有完全把责任推开。他承认那条评论出自一篇 Esquire 文章,作者是个对特斯拉没什么好感的记者,克鲁尼只是随口提了一句,被人单独拎出来放大。信息在传播链条里丢掉了时间、型号和上下文,只剩一个名人加一个负面动词。

需求没见顶,产能卡住了

有分析师猜测美国市场的需求已经见顶。马斯克直接否定:

特斯拉当时卡在产能上,需求端远没到天花板。销量在增长,只是增长速度被生产瓶颈压住了。他提到公司正在欧洲扩张,短期内美国交付占比会下降,这属于主动分配,卖不动的说法站不住脚。

这段话在2013年说出来是需要底气的。当时主流分析框架还停留在“电动车是小众玩具,需求天花板很低”。他给的是另一套解释:一家公司的股价波动,很多时候反映的是供给端的执行节奏,跟需求端的故事关系不大。

“所有交通工具最终都会是电动的,火箭除外”

主持人问十年后路上会是什么样:纯电占多少,混动占多少,会不会天然气最后赢了。

马斯克说中间过程很难预测,长期他有把握:所有交通都会变成100%电动,唯一的例外是火箭。他顺口加了一句,牛顿第三定律绕不过去。

飞机是最后一块,因为长距离航空需要电池有极高的能量密度。但他相信这件事一定会发生。他给了一个历史视角:人们回头看蒸汽机会觉得古怪,觉得那东西该放进博物馆,留几台就够了,可它绝不会是人们出行该用的方式。电动化在他眼里属于常识的回归,谈不上什么技术路线之争。

他提到了波音787。当年787出问题,核心是电池自发燃烧。主持人追问:如果机票上写着这班是787,你坐不坐。

马斯克的回答很实在:大概会坐,但不会作为首选。他接着说自己的最爱其实是747,理由是设计太漂亮,速度快,是民航客机里最快的,气动效率还高,他就是喜欢那个外形。

对787的评价就不客气了:它是777的改进版,主要卖点是每个乘客英里效率提升10%,而这10个点里有8个来自发动机,机身本身只贡献了2%。花那么多钱,机身上只换来2%的效率,他觉得这事儿有点让人失望。

他心里有一架电动超音速垂直起降飞机

主持人顺势问:你是不是想造飞机。

马斯克说,他确实觉得这里有个有意思的机会:做一架电动、超音速、垂直起降的飞机。这三件事在工程上互相加分,电动推进的响应速度和布局自由度高,垂直起降不需要长跑道,超音速解决速度问题。

他判断这件事不太可能从波音或空客出来,因为这两家把精力放在非常渐进的改进上,对激进重构没兴趣。所以它更可能来自一家创业公司。他说如果未来再办一家公司(他强调短期内不会),那大概率就是电动飞机。

这个想法的源头他讲得很清楚:协和式客机停飞的那一天。当时他想,超音速民航没有了,未来是不是在变糟。他说自己有个特点,一旦觉得未来在变糟就会不舒服,然后开始琢磨有没有办法修。

飞行汽车和自动驾驶,他都不太乐观

主持人提到塞巴斯蒂安·特龙(Sebastian Thrun)的预测,说到2050年会像喷气机一样普及,飞行汽车满天飞。

马斯克的反应是有保留的。他承认飞行汽车这个概念有吸引力,同时提了两个现实问题:

  • 机械故障。当路上有数百万辆车同时在天上飞,故障率再低,也意味着会有东西从天上掉下来,人们会开始担心它落在自己头上或者自家房顶。
  • 噪音和天际线。满天嗡嗡作响的飞行器,对城市空间的侵占是实实在在的,代价得有人承担。

自动驾驶这块,他给了一条很特斯拉的路径:先把主动安全做到极致,再慢慢过渡到自动驾驶。主动巡航、车道保持、自动变道,这些功能一步步做,能力一点点叠加,最终车能自己在几乎所有场景里开。

他把门槛讲得很明确。真正意义上的自动驾驶,必须比人开车安全得多,因为它会被用更高的标准审视。他拿电动车做类比:Model S 已经比汽油车安全五倍,外界照样拿放大镜看它的每一起事故。

难度曲线他也讲了:做到90%是一回事,从90%到99%要难十倍,从99%到99.9%再难十倍,越往后越是在清除长尾里的边角案例,难度指数级上升。

主持人问那个具体时间点:什么时候你能放心让孩子坐在后座,车自己开。马斯克说,那还要很久,至少十年以上,可能二十年。

点子是怎么来的:先觉得未来不对劲

主持人转述了一位创业者朋友的邮件,问马斯克一周到底能产生多少个想法。马斯克没回答数量,他讲了机制。

“通常是有某件事让我不喜欢那个未来,或者不喜欢未来的某个部分,然后我就会去想有没有办法修好它。”(马斯克)

Hyperloop 就是这么来的。加州在建高铁,他看着觉得贵,也不够快,还不如中国和日本已经做出来的东西。这件事让他沮丧,于是他开始问:在两个城市之间做大规模运输,除了瞬移之外,最好的办法是什么。

瞬移他做不到,那么在已知物理定律范围内,他想到的下一个最优解就是 Hyperloop。他说自己相当确信它能跑通,后来其他人做了仿真,结论也是可行。

电动超音速飞机的起点则是协和停飞。这两件事的共同点是情绪的触发方式:他看到未来在退步,就坐不住了。这个描述挺关键,说明他的创意起点跟“这个市场有多大”关系不大,真正的起点是“这个未来我不接受”。

“创业就像吃玻璃,同时凝视深渊”

主持人抛出彼得·蒂尔那一派的观点:伟大的创业者一辈子只有一个伟大的想法,成功后动力就消失了。

马斯克不同意。他认为一个人可以有好几个伟大的想法,真正的原因在于过程太痛苦,多数人不想再来一次,想法用光了这种解释站不住脚。

他引用一位朋友的说法:创办公司就像吃玻璃,同时凝视深渊。你要做大量自己不喜欢的事,会遇到一堆看起来无解的问题,要投入巨大精力,承受巨大压力,比外人想象的痛苦得多。而且大多数公司会死。

他给了一个神经科学层面的解释,这段是整场访谈里少见的自我剖析:人类的大脑没有为公司这种东西进化过。我们进化出来是为了应对真实的死亡威胁,一家公司的死亡在物理层面算不上死亡,没有人在生理上死掉,可大脑的边缘系统分不清这件事。它会真的当成生死来处理,那种压力是生理性的。

这也解释了他为什么说“人们大概不想经历超过一次”。想法也许够用,身体先不干了。

他欣赏谁,以及微软那个问题

主持人最后问:下一个乔布斯在哪里,你欣赏谁。

马斯克点了几个名字:拉里·佩奇(Larry Page),他的好朋友,做了很了不起的事;杰夫·贝索斯(Jeff Bezos),亚马逊在做的事情令人印象深刻;还有 Dropbox、Uber 这一类公司,他觉得有意思的事情正在发生。

关于乔布斯,他的评价很干脆:乔布斯是非常独特的个体,很长一段时间内不会有人像他。

主持人补了一个没写在流程上的问题:微软,你想不想当CEO。

马斯克的回答只有一个词:不想。

追问:如果换对人,微软还有救吗。他说大概可以,那里还有很多有才华的人,对的人有可能把船带向一个好的方向。

回到2013年那个房间

这场访谈最值得看的地方,跟他后来预测对了什么关系不大,真正值得琢磨的是他面对质疑时的处理方式。

三起火灾,媒体给的是情绪,他给的是除法。他把分子分母都摆出来:汽油车每1300辆一起,特斯拉每8.8万辆一起。他没有否认火灾会发生,只要求用同一把尺子量。

股价涨到他自己都说配不上,他也没顺着资本市场的情绪往上吹。产能受限、需求未受限,这句话在2013年是逆着当时的分析共识说的,后来成了特斯拉十年里反复出现的主题。

对未来交通的判断,他给的是长期确定加短期不确定:长期100%电动,中间怎么走不知道。这种表达方式在科技领袖里不多见,多数人愿意把短期也说得很有把握,因为那样更好卖。

至于电动超音速垂直起降飞机,他在2013年就说了这是他会做的下一家公司。到2025年回看,这个判断还挂在空中,方向一直没变过。

最后那段关于创业痛苦的描述,可能是整场访谈里最不像“马斯克式叙事”的部分。没有火星,没有颠覆,只有一句话:大脑分不清公司死亡和真实死亡,所以它用最原始的方式让人紧张。

这大概能解释,为什么他一周能冒出十个想法,却还是说这活儿没人想干第二次。

如果要把这场访谈用起来,可以怎么做

  • 下次看到“某类产品起火或爆炸”的新闻,先找分母。问一句这个品类总共有多少台在跑,事故率是多少,替代方案的基准率又是多少。分子容易被放大,分母从来不会自己出现。
  • 评估一个新产品是否安全,优先看第三方测试里的极端指标,少看个案报道。Model S 当年拿到的是联邦测试史上最低受伤概率,这类数据比三起事故的叙事更能说明整体分布。
  • 听一家公司的增长故事时,把“需求受限”和“产能受限”分开看。这两种状态对应完全不同的估值逻辑,也对应完全不同的风险点。马斯克2013年的表述可以直接当成一个判断模板。
  • 做长期判断时,把终局和中间过程拆开下注。终局可以有高置信度(交通全面电动化),中间路径保持谦逊(混动、天然气、氢能都可能阶段性胜出)。两者混在一起谈,结论一定会失真。
  • 遇到自己不满意的现状,先问“在已知物理定律内,最好的解法是什么”,再问“这能不能做成生意”。Hyperloop 和电动超音速飞机的起点都不在市场规模上,它们的起点是“这个未来我不接受”。
  • 如果你正在考虑创业,认真对待“吃玻璃加凝视深渊”这个描述。它的作用在于让你提前知道压力来自哪里:大脑会把公司危机当生理危机处理,这属于硬件层面的设定,靠调整心态解决不了。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00the one and only Elon Musk is here I could have introduced him as Tony Stark and with that jacket on you look like Tony Stark we have a lot to get to about Tesla about SpaceX about entrepreneurism and about everything however you are in the news for some reasons that you may not wish to be which is that there have been now Three Fires in these Tesla vehicles with the most recent one in the past week and there are question questions lots of questions in the Wall Street Community among the regulatory community that wants to understand all this and so I want to I I want to do this I want to understand what you understand about this there are rumors that there's going

0:41to be a recall what is going on with these fires sure well there there's definitely not going to be a recall there's there's no there's no reason for a recall I believe in fact I think the the the the I mean the perception is if you read the headlines it it sounds like Teslas have a greater propensity to catch fire than other cars and in act in reality nothing can be further from the truth the the the

1:11rate of fires for the average rate of fires for cars for gasoline cars is about 1,000 one one fire for every 1300 cars at Tesla we now have almost 25,000 cars on the road we've had Three Fires so it's sort of roughly one for every 88,000 cars so we're about five times less likely to have a a fire than the average gasing car that doesn't mean we have zero likelihood it's you know sort of law of large numbers and statistics suggest that they would but but the the headlines are extremely misleading in fact if if fire risk is your concern you would have a great deal of difficulty being an any better car than the model S as I said it's it's it's it's five times less fire risk

2:02than a gasoline than the average gasoline car moreover in in the the history of Tesla we've never had a serious injury or death in any of our cars so the this is I mean so maybe there is a car that is as safe as the model S but there is certainly not a c that is safer because it would have to have less than zero let me ask you this well when you walked in and I was thrilled to see you I've compared this gentleman to the next Steve Jobs but when you walked in I said how are you and you said you know it's been a tough week when you hear

2:46about a fire like this what happens tell tell us just bring us inside the room for a moment what happens at Tesla because I imagine everybody says oh my goodness there is clearly issues and and concerns in the market place about batteries and fires period I mean that's that's where this all begins and then what do you do well I guess we we you know we kind of see what the the reaction is and and and then you know in this case the reaction is extremely inaccurate and unreasonable you know the fact that there are 200,000 200,000 gasoline fires car fires per year in the United States 200,000 there are on average 250

3:35to 300 fire Automotive fire deaths in the US there are about 1,200 to 1500 serious fire injuries per year how many times have you read about that can you recall right no one instance in complete fairness in complete fairness exactly so I mean so it's like wow this is extremely unreasonable and wrong the the the

3:59the expert press you know in the sort of automotive industry so like take the the automotive news editor at Automotive news actually wrote a great article kind of debunking the fire risk of the model S because they they they know that that the propensity of fire is vastly greater than a gasoline car but in the popular press unfortunately it's easier to report on sensation even though that even though that is demonstrably false with a simple Google such so just just to explain everybody explain to everybody what's happened in these Three Fires because there's a sense that these cars got in got into accidents from what I understand by the way every driver who of the cars is then

4:40asked to get a new car yes exactly but that there's something going on where something underneath the car ask for replacement model S as soon as possible have you had conversations by the way with any of the people who have been in ACD yes what do they tell you it's the best car they've ever driven and all three cases they think they were saved from serious harm by the models and if they had been in a different car they would have been seriously injured and in the case of the second fire probably dead in the case of the second fire that was in Mexico there was I won't

5:18comment publicly on the exact speed but it's sort of four times the maximum kinetic energy that a car is supposed to be survivable at and and the the accident was in multiple Parts the it the first impact was a concrete roundabout where 15 ft of concrete wall was sheared off mm of 18 in thck concrete wall it was a curb wall so you know like a foot high type of thing then the car bounced into a 7ot tall concrete wall smashed through that by this time the wheels had been torn off so it was just skating Along on its belly basically on the battery pack and and then finally came to arrest against the tree the driver and passengers got out and walked

6:11away afterwards there was a small fire in the front Okay final fire so I mean it's sort of like okay let's say that that you know which this is probably the wrong analogy but let's let's say the Titanic okay instead of the Titanic sinking if it smashed through the first Iceberg smashed through the second Iceberg came to arrest on the third Iceberg all the passengers disembarked safely and bought another ticket on the Titanic and and then the the newspaper report was kitchen fire on the Titanic okay it's not the point final question on this topic and we're going to move on which is this has any regulator contacted you about this and what is the threshold for deciding that

6:59you need to look at these types of issues more meaningfully in terms of either thinking about either recalls or changes in the production of these vehicles and I know that you consider this vehicle to be safe yeah I mean I so I'm somewhat of a perfectionist and safety is like as a

7:20number one priority it was always a number one priority in designing car because I drive it my kids are in it my friends are in it it is the absolute number one priority and in fact when our car was tested by Consumer Report safest car on the road yeah by long shot yeah it has the model S when it was tested by by the federal government as well the it got the lowest probability of injury of any car ever tested in history in other words you could not drive a safer car right and

7:51if there was something that we thought would negatively affect the safety we would immediately do a recall and in fact there was something earlier this year which was basically a bracket there were no injuries there were no even there were no near injuries but we discovered a slight issue maybe with one of the the rear seat belt brackets we recalled all the cars and replaced the bracket got it let me ask you a different question I think of you as an entrepreneur someone who likes to operate your business and think about the future and what the future should be like what is it like though at the same time running a company that has become not only a sort of Pop Culture

8:33sensation but this Market sensation where you have a stock that has run up for those of you you know who've been counting at one point it was up 474 per this year it's come down a little bit but you're still up 37% this year in terms of how much you think about that issue how much your employees think about that issue what it does to the culture I mean this is sort of a bit of a wild ride that you're on yes I keep thinking it'll get less less of a wild ride but that seems to keep going I I actually think the the high stock price was somewhat distracting and in fact I I I went on record as saying that I thought the price was higher than we had any right to deserve

9:21now I mean that said I do think long term that the price will be or the value of the company will be well excess of that but to give us that valuation now is to have a lot of faith in our future execution which we'll do our best we'll do our best to meet that Faith and U but I mean I don't believe in sort of talking up a stock or you know I certainly wasn't trying to talk it down but I was trying to be accurate I I think the Stock's pretty good deal where it is right now but it's it was probably a bit high before that's my honest opinion how do you feel about running a comp that is clearly in the public eye we were talking in the back there's a piece in in a newspaper

10:05today George Clooney is commenting we we now now quoted George Clooney twice today because we had we were talking about Dan lobe earlier today and I quoted something to him but George Clooney was commenting that that he got stuck on the side of the road too many times with his car and he's he's gotten rid of it how do you run a company I this this that's not quite accurate so what I said or Clooney what you said and I I think so the clly comment was like it's it was a needless comment needlessly reported because he he he made an offhand comment in an Esquire article by Tom janard who who for some reason doesn't love love Tesla that it clearly said that his 2008

10:47roader broke down and so he he sold it at a charity auction that was in 2008 so it's kind of like you know that was 5 years ago that that this happened it's not a model as it's not even recent it's not really news I'm not sure why it was even reported I mean it like saying you know my iPhone

11:091 in 2001 had a bug right okay let's let's talk a little bit about you talked about the valuation of the company you've started to sell more vehicles in Europe now yeah less vehicles in the US or or because of this it'll be less vehicles in the US there have been some analysts and folks who have speculated that maybe the demand in the United States right now has already reached some kind of peak peak level do you buy that no I I don't think so I mean the the main reason I think we got dinged on the the the valuation of stock price was that we are at least in the short

11:51term constrained on production so it's not we don't have a we're not demand constrained we're production constrained and it's going to take a bit of time to work out the production constraints right I mean our volume is increasing it's just not increasing as fast as if we didn't have that production constraint so yeah okay

12:15take take us to the Future what what are the roads going to look like 10 years from now I right now you're build You're Building charging stations all across the east coast and across the country if you go on their site you can see this map and see where how how it's all all going to roll out what percentage of cars will be fully battery operated what percentage will be hybrids in terms of new vehicles that other audio manufacturers are producing and I ask it be in part because I remember talking to some Executives at Toyota recently and they said look we can't make a bet on one thing or the other we because it could be natural gas that could be the

12:52the big winner in this it could be batteries it could be a combination could be some other thing that we haven't thought of yet well it's difficult to predict the intermediate but I I I feel confident in predicting the longterm that all transport will be 100% electric with the ironic exception of rockets the and unfortunately there's no way around Newton's third law so the you know aircraft will be the the last because of the you need a very high energy density in the the battery pack to have longdistance aircraft for air travel but everything's going to go fully electric it's kind of weird that we're not I mean it's I mean I think people will look back on this era like

13:34we look back on the sort of steam engine you know it's quaint and you know we should have a few of those around in a museum but but it's not how people would drive how how far batteries though generally from being widely adopted safe I mean you got you guys may be doing it better than anybody else I remember when this when the 787 came out originally you had some comments about how they had produced them yeah I mean the 787 the issue was spontaneous combustion I mean I think it's understandable if the 787 had well if it crashed and and the B there have been a battery fire again that would be battery fire would be not the point but the you know the the the issue on 787 was the

14:14spontaneous combustion yeah if you if you got a ticket by the way an airplane ticket I know you probably fly musk air but when you fly commercial air if it said that it was a 780 787 plane would you fly on it today I I guess so I mean it wouldn't be my first choice as an aircraft but it's because of the safety or because you'd prefer to fly privately no I mean relative to other airliners my favorite airliner is actually the the 747 I think that's just an awesome design it's a fast airliner it's the fastest of the airliners actually and quite quite aerody nomically efficient and I like this I like the look of it honestly so that that was a ring I mean that's

14:57sort of Hall of Famer right there the the 787 is kind of an improved version of the Triple 7 and I just think it's a bit it's a bit disappointing because it's its main attribute is being 10% more efficient per passenger mile than the seven the TR than the Triple 7 and eight of those 10 points come from the engine so seems like a lot of money to spend to get 2% more efficient on the air frame side it sounds like you've thought about this a lot do you want to make a airplanes too I I I do think that there's there's an interesting opportunity to create a supersonic electric vertical takeoff Landing jet and I think that would be really great how far are we from

15:44that well it seems unlikely to come from boing or Airbus given that they seem to be focused on very incremental improvements to the planes as opposed to radical improvements but it could come from a startup I mean if if I were to have another company in the future which I would not be anytime soon the I think that

16:09would be the thing to do is to do do an electric aircraft you want to do an electric aircraft yeah and Supersonic and vertical takeoff Landing actually work well with electric yeah so you a Believer Sebastian thern believes that we will it'll be like the jet by 2050 this is one of the guys who started Google Glass flying cars flying cars flying cars everywhere is that is that directionally how this all goes for you I'm not I mean I kind of like the idea of flying cars on one hand but you know it may not be what people want because if you have a huge number of cars and you have mechanical failures then you're you know I think we sort of vaguely be wondering where the

16:57car is going to land on your head or you know house or whatever so I think that's a concern and then maybe there's also question of noise pollution and to what degree does it affect the skyline you know is it just buzzing thing of cars how about driverless cars so so Google is out there with its Google car how far we from driverless cars and driverless Tesla cars well so the approach that Tesla is taking in this regard is to develop active safety and do active safety in the limit you know things like active cruise control keeping in the lane doing automatic passing passing and that kind of thing and and then gradually improving Act of safety until

17:46ultimately the car is able to drive itself in long term in in virtually every scenario maybe every scenario I mean the threshold I think for something to be autonomous is it's got to be much safer than a person driving a car because it'll just be held to a higher standard it's kind of like like as an electric car even though like we're much safer than a than a gasoline car we're we're held to a much higher standard and and I think it's going to be the same thing for autonomous cause I do think it'll happen but for for to be truly autonomous you have to take care of these Corner cases and so getting from getting to 90 % is one thing but then it's going to be

18:31another factor of 10 harder to get to 99% another factor of 10 to get to 99.9 then it you know becomes exponentially more difficult to get rid of the corner cases so how far out is that the the to get to the 99.99 like 69 or something like that something that you let your kids in the back seat I think that'll be a while I would say it's probably at least well more than 10 years maybe 20 years right I have a friend who's an entrepreneur who sent me an email last night knowing that I was going to see you and said the question you need to ask Elon is how many ideas does he literally have a week and by the way we were in the back and just Elon and I and I felt

19:12he had 10 new ideas how do you sort through them how do you decide which ones are are good and bad and for example you came out with this hyperloop idea which you went public with something you you're not going to do on your own but how do you even decide to do that I mean what's going on inside your brain if you could try to unpack it for us well usually it's there's something that that makes me not like the future you know or or not like some element of the future and then wonder whether there's some way to fix that so you know in the case of the hyperloop it was like you know we're building this train in California and it it's it seemed very expensive and not

19:56that fast and it it seemed to be not as good as what they've done in China or Japan and so I was like wow that that's kind of depressing in fact like the electric supersonic plane that I've got a I've got a design for that in mind and that that came from when when the Concord was canell so when the Concord was cancelled right I you know I was like well that's that's sad now there's no supersonic transport and you know is the future getting worse and I it bothers me when the it seems like the future is getting worse so that's where the supersonic electric plane thing came from and and then the hyper was well is is there a what's the best way to do

20:42mass transit between two cities like La in San Francisco you're short of teleportation what would you do that would be really great I don't know how to do that so so the next best thing within the known laws of physics that I could think of was the hyperloop and I I'm I'm pretty sure it would work and other people have you know redone the they've done sort of simulations and and and they've they've said it right it would work so two more questions because we're going to run out of time you are a Serial entrepreneur and a successful serial entrepreneur most entrepreneurs have one great idea in them do you believe that do you believe what that there's another view there

21:29there's another view that and I've heard it from Peter teal and others that a great entrepreneur has that one great idea and that success takes them away and then the motive to to keep coming up with the next idea doesn't happen what's your take I think it's more that I think I think people can come up with more than one great idea so I think it's more like I mean creating a company is a very difficult thing a friend of mine's go saying that like you know creating a company is it's like eating glass and staring into the abyss I mean it's just you have to do lots of things you don't like and and there are lots of seemingly intractable problems that come along and

22:10you know you so you have to put in incredible amounts of effort and huge amount of stress and it's it's much more painful than it would maybe people let people realize and most companies die and and on a certain level in your brain it your your brain you we didn't Evol we didn't evolve like with companies right so we evolve to respond to real death and even though this a company's death is not real it's not like somebody's physically dying your brain doesn't quite understand that you know at the lyic system level so it's really sort painfully stressful and I don't people probably don't want to go through that more than once yeah okay final question for you I have

22:54compared you as others have to Steve Jobs who do do you think the next Steve Jobs is out there who who do you admire and go you know what there's something going on over there well you know I mean I a big fan of Larry Page he a good friend of mine like he's he does great things obviously Jeff Bezos is doing some impressive stuff with with Amazon and yeah there's

23:25companies like Dropbox and there's bunch of uber you know this this cool things are happening Steve Steve Jobs was a very unique individual I'm make sure this anyone was going to be like him for for a long time before I forget I know I supposed to ask you one more question Microsoft you want to be the CEO no no is it fixable if the right person was there I'm sure it I mean it could probably be turned around with the right person there I mean there's a lot of talented people still add Microsoft not so the right person could probably steal the ship in in a good direction okay Elon Musk everybody unbelievable thank you for this conversation and for being so

24:08forthright and taking on these issues really appreciate it thank you very very much

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份