大会演讲·中文精读

2015年AGU旧金山大会马斯克访谈(音频)

Elon Musk interview AGU 2015 Conference San Francisco (Audio only)

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

地球的重力如果再强一点,化学火箭根本飞不起来。

马斯克在2015年旧金山AGU(美国地球物理联合会)大会的访谈里提到这个判断。重力稍微轻一点,上天会容易很多;稍微重一点,用化学火箭基本就不可能。地球刚好卡在一个让人难受的刻度上。

他给了一个对比。土星五号从地球起飞,整枚火箭有办公楼那么大。从月球起飞,只需要鹰号着陆器最上面那一半。差别就这么悬殊。

所以火箭上每一个零件都得推到极限。不能留太多余量,否则根本离不开地面。这也是他反复讲的那套方法论的缩影:把问题拆到最基本的物理事实,再从那里往上推。

那场访谈里他聊了很多。第一性原理、碳税、火星、可复用火箭、核能、太阳能、电池,还有学校该教孩子什么。把这些回答按逻辑串起来,能看出一套相当完整的世界观。

日常靠类比,新问题只能拆到最基本的地方

主持人问马斯克,很多人一想到可能性就被障碍挡住了,他怎么绕过这些障碍。

他的回答是,自己相信物理学那套分析框架,尤其面对新问题的时候。

原因在于类比会失效。人每天过日子,大部分时间靠类比,或者把旧东西稍作改动复制过来。这条路省脑子,是一种计算上的捷径。

但要做真正新的、尤其反直觉的事情,类比就不管用了。只能做第一性原理分析,把事物还原到看起来最基本、最简单的真理,再往上推理。

这需要多得多的思考。你不可能对每件事都这么干,但如果你想搞清楚一件新事,我觉得这是唯一的路。(马斯克)

这段话是他后面所有回答的底色。碳税、火星、电池、火箭复用,全都按这个路子拆。

价格是信息,现在的价格全错了

主持人在巴黎气候大会(COP21)刚结束后问碳税。马斯克先讲价格是什么。

价格就是信息本身。它告诉人们该把劳动力往哪儿放,什么该优先,什么该让路。价格错了,经济里就会做错事。

海洋和大气吸收二氧化碳的能力,是一个典型的公地悲剧。它没有定价,或者定得太低。于是错误的行为发生了。用他的话说,等于在补贴错误的行为。

他给了一个生活化的类比。假如对水果蔬菜征高税,对香烟和烈酒征低税,那显然荒唐。可现在的能源体系差不多就是这个样子。

每年有大约5.3万亿美元的隐性碳补贴。这个数字大到难以想象,等于把最糟糕的选择变得最便宜。

他也承认,政府干预经济通常会制造价格扭曲。但碳税是例外。任何一种碳税,都会减少价格体系里的错误。

一般来说政府插手经济,往往让价格更失真。但这次不一样,任何形式的碳税都会降低系统里的定价错误。(马斯克)

对巴黎气候谈判,他的评价是方向正确。会有一些进展,不会像应该的那么多,但令人鼓舞。

学校该教什么:软件、物理、批判性思维,还有地球科学

有个中学STEM老师通过推特提问,学生该学什么才能应对未来的工作。

马斯克说,软件工程大概是最大的单一领域。此外他一贯推崇物理、基础经济学和批判性思维。

批判性思维他特别强调。这听起来简单,其实学校教得太少。应该直接告诉学生,怎么判断一件事该不该相信。

就是教人认识常见的谬误类型,知道别人一般会怎么骗你,怎么避免被骗。这种事情真的应该多做。(马斯克)

他说完现场一片掌声。他自己接了一句,说台下都是已经相信这套的人。

主持人追问,你刚才没提地球科学。

马斯克马上补上。地球科学很重要。人们应该知道文明的行为会怎么影响未来,怎么把未来导向好结果。

他觉得意外的是,很多人对地球科学了解得少得可怜,连碳循环这种直白的东西都不清楚。他跟一些非常聪明、受过良好教育的人聊过,对方不知道地表有一个碳循环。把地下深处的碳挖出来,加到地表碳循环里,会从根本上改变地表的化学平衡。对方听完的反应是,真的吗。

他顺带讲了质量守恒。碳不会凭空出现,也不会凭空消失。这个道理对很多人并不显然。

公共部门做"对所有人一点点好"的事,私营部门做能收钱闭环的事

主持人问公共部门和私营部门在科研创新里各站什么位置。

马斯克的分法是看能不能收上钱。

公共部门适合那种对全体人口有一点点好处、但很难向每个人收10美元的事。比如想更了解地球、太阳系、宇宙,你没办挨家挨户收10美元。一个30亿美元的项目,向全美每个人收10美元,行政成本就不划算。这种事交给公共部门更合理。哈勃望远镜、火星任务,都是这类。

私营部门适合能闭合经济循环的事。SpaceX发射大量通信和广播卫星,人们因此能听XM电台、看DirecTV,钱能收回来。同时SpaceX也给NASA送补给,研究人在太空怎么生活,这部分是公共部门该干的。

主持人提到科学经费长期持平,其他国家在加投入。马斯克说自己支持增加科学投入,公共和私营都该加。他提到欧洲的大型强子对撞机是了不起的努力,美国当年砍掉超导超级对撞机是件让人难过的事。

火星:46亿年来第一次打开的窗口

主持人提到马斯克说过火星是个"需要翻修的行星",问他为什么坚持殖民火星。

马斯克先把哲学基础摊开。他说这是自己小时候就在想的问题:人生的意义是什么。青少年时期他为此相当苦闷。后来读到《银河系漫游指南》,书里说宇宙本身就是答案,你只需要找出问题。

他的推理是这样的。宇宙里还有太多东西要理解,而理解的程度大致和文明的规模、范围成正比。人类文明是单行星物种,寿命概率远低于多行星物种。单行星物种迟早会遇到灭绝事件,可能来自人类自己,也可能来自自然。

现在是地球46亿年历史上第一次,窗口打开了,人类有可能把生命延伸到另一颗行星。这个窗口可能开很久,也可能开得很短。明智的做法是趁能做的时候做。

我认为明智的举动是,趁我们还能做的时候,让生命成为多行星的。(马斯克)

这件事最终会带来大量新科学,也会最大化我们理解宇宙本质的概率。他还补了一句,这会是一场伟大的冒险。人早上醒来,需要有值得期待的事情,那让人兴奋,给人鼓舞。

他自己判断,大概活不到看见火星殖民地自给自足的那天。但目标定在那里,该走的技术台阶就得走。

去火星要先过三道技术关

第一道是可复用火箭。火箭能重复使用,进入太空的成本大概能降两个数量级。

他给了一个数字对比。一枚造价数千万美元的火箭,推进剂成本只有大约20万美元。这就像给一架波音747加油。如果火箭能像飞机一样反复飞,成本结构会彻底改变。

第二道是规模。需要真正巨大的火箭。

第三道是在火星本地生产推进剂。这三件事做成,自给自足的火星文明才有可能。

火箭难在重力,也难在地面测不出飞行条件

主持人提到下周要发射新火箭,这是6月失败后的第一次。那次失败让一批昂贵的科学设备掉进海里。

马斯克说,火箭真的很难。上一次失败恰好发生在他生日那天。

难度的根源还是重力。地球的重力让化学火箭必须把一切推到极限。材料要最先进,设计要极度优化,不能有大余量。而且地面上没有设施能完全复现飞行时的真实条件,你只能做到接近,做不到一模一样。

这次发射做了不少改进。第一次有人做的是深度低温推进剂。液氧占推进剂的三分之二,他们把它过冷到接近凝固点,密度显著提高,推力也跟着上去。级间分离系统改进了,上面级拉长以装更多推进剂,电子设备也有一堆改进。

他的评价是,这枚火箭比上一枚强不少。

复用的关键指标:把120吨加速到子弹的四倍

谈复用,马斯克给了一个衡量指标:传递能量。把势能和动能加起来,看助推级向上面积传递了多少,传递的质量有多大。

猎鹰9号的助推级,能把上面级加速到每小时8000公里,传递的质量约120吨。

然后他给了一个类比。步枪子弹的速度大约是每小时2000公里。所以这个助推级是在把120吨的东西,加速到子弹速度的四倍。

主持人当场说,这就是把普通人完全没有概念的东西,接到一个有概念、而且会被震到的东西上。这个沟通很厉害。

核裂变没问题,聚变他押注天上那一个

有观众问,怎么看待一群风险投资人迷上某种还没说明白的核能新技术,以及核能的未来。

马斯克说,核裂变和核聚变本身都没问题。设计良好的裂变电厂是可行的,尤其建在不受自然灾害影响的地区。法国大量用核电,对法国是合理的。加州和日本就值得商榷。

聚变他认为是可以解决的问题。但他自己没直接投聚变,理由是他判断天上有现成的聚变堆,就是太阳,加上光伏,经济上大概率会赢。

北半球高纬度地区有大量水电,正好补上冬天和天黑时没电的问题。

他的组合方案是太阳能加电池,再加东西向、南北向的高压输电线路。这样能完全解决地球的电力需求。

他给了一个面积概念。美国只需要犹他州和内华达州的一小块地方铺太阳能,就能供全美用电。每平方公里大约1吉瓦。

太阳能翻倍,电池是硬骨头

有观众提到太阳能装机大概每两年翻一倍,按指数增长,离"全部靠太阳能"只差七次翻倍。

马斯克说增速可能会放缓,但仍然是高百分比增长。太阳能占电网到一定比例后,必须加电池来调峰、存电。太阳能加电池这两样,就能把电力问题彻底解决。

电池技术对可持续能源极其关键。内华达的超级工厂,思路是把规模经济做到极限,做成他们能设想的最大工厂。

底层技术会有改进,他判断是中等程度,不算巨大,但也不小。长期看会越来越好。

他也坦白电池有多难。做一个有用的电池,约束条件太多。很多非常聪明的人在这一行折戟。平均下来,能量密度和经济性每年改进大约5%到8%。经济性这一块,靠规模经济能提升得更多。

他鼓励对电池感兴趣的人去做更好的电池。这是个超级难、又必须解决的问题。

电池包是高品质矿石,回收比挖矿划算

有人问电池生产和回收的环境代价。

马斯克说,目前特斯拉的电池包都在北美、欧洲、亚洲的回收中心处理。逻辑很简单,电池包可以看成高品质矿石,回收电池包比挖原矿划算得多。经济上说得通,也明显降低了生产成本。

内华达的超级工厂会把回收内置进去,闭环。长期看,工厂会完全用太阳能、风能和地热供能。

电动车就算全烧煤也赢汽油车

有观众提出质疑。电网还在烧煤和天然气,这些电厂效率不见得比汽油车高,电动车怎么解决温室气体问题。

马斯克的回答是一个具体数字。就算电网完全由煤和天然气供电,电动车产生的二氧化碳仍然更少,一直算到电厂那一端也是如此。

原因在于发电厂不受质量和体积的约束。能量提取效率可以做得高得多。一台GE的天然气电厂效率超过60%。天然气轮机可以做得很重很大,余热还能再驱动一台蒸汽轮机,效率再往上走。

汽油车在整个驱动循环里,效率通常不到20%。

把输电损耗和充电损耗都算进去,电动车还是遥遥领先。换成任何燃料源,煤也好,结论都一样。

当然电网并不是全靠化石燃料。水电、地热、太阳能、风能都在里面。太阳能增长很猛,可持续能源占电网的比例在上升。加上电池之后,这个比例还能再推高。

火星上真有生命怎么办

有观众引用另一位火星倡导者Chris McKay的说法:如果火星上找到现存或已灭绝的生命,应该考虑撤走人类,让那种生命繁衍。

马斯克说,火星表面看起来确实没有生命,至少没看到任何迹象。如果真的找到迹象,那当然要搞清楚它是什么,并且尽力不去灭绝它。

但他判断现实是表面没有生命。可能有微生物活在很深的地下,那里能屏蔽辐射和寒冷。如果真是这样,地表上的活动对地下生命影响很小。

电气化不止是汽车

有人问,除了电池和电动车,还有哪些技术方向值得投入。

马斯克说,交通电气化整体都重要,飞机和船也算。供暖和制冷的电气化同样重要。

核能他觉得可能挺有意思,但要看它怎么和太阳能竞争。

他的判断标准很朴素:任何一种能源的产生或消耗方式,如果推到很久以后,世界仍然是好的,那就该做。

一百美元的设备能学任何东西

有观众问科学和能源获取的不平等。

马斯克提到,特斯拉刚把专利全部开放。Solar City走得更远,把技术提供给发展中国家,还邀请这些国家的人来工厂,亲眼看看怎么做。

他还讲了一个被低估的平等器:互联网。只要有一台100美元的联网设备,就能学到任何东西。这跟过去比是巨大的变化。你不需要一座图书馆,理论上可以免费学任何你想学的东西。

他觉得这是我们所处时代相当好的一部分。

可持续能源经济是必然,问题只是什么时候

访谈里马斯克重复了他在巴黎讲的一个判断。

人类一定会走向可持续能源经济。因为另一条路是:把地下所有碳基燃料挖出来烧掉,然后要么转向可持续,要么整个经济因为没有能源而崩溃。

所以终点是确定的。真正的问题只有两个:什么时候到,以及大气里和地下各留多少十亿吨二氧化碳。

既然我们知道最终会走到哪儿,那就应该尽快终止这场实验。(马斯克)

这场访谈从头到尾没有故弄玄虚。碳税为什么合理,用水果蔬菜和烟酒讲清楚。火箭复用为什么重要,用加油和子弹讲清楚。电动车为什么赢了,用60%和20%两个效率数字讲清楚。每一件事都拆到最基本的物理和经济事实,再往上推。

这套方法不复杂,难的是愿意多花那种力气。下次遇到一个新问题,先问问自己:我现在用的是类比,还是第一性原理。

  • 遇到新问题,先别急着找类比。把问题拆到最基本的物理或经济事实上,再往上推一步。
  • 判断一项能源技术,算全生命周期效率,别只看终端。发电厂效率超60%,汽油车不到20%,差距在源头。
  • 关注碳定价的进展。理解价格是信息,价格错了,行为就会错。
  • 想押注能源方向,太阳能加储能的组合值得长期看。北半球高纬度地区再加水电,冬天也能兜底。
  • 教孩子或自己补批判性思维。常见谬误、怎么判断该不该信,这些比背知识点更有长期价值。
  • 学一点软件工程,再看点物理和基础经济学。这是马斯克列出的未来工作能力清单。
  • 对电池技术保持关注。每年5%到8%的改进听着慢,累积十年就是质变,这是硬骨头也是关键。
  • 检查自己做决策时用的到底是类比还是事实。这一步很花力气,但真正新的问题,只有这一条路能走通。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00now for the moment you've all been waiting for our presidential Forum as you know we hold this forum every year as a way for us to reflect on the broad relevance of our science in today's changing world the purpose of the event is not to tell us about science but rather to focus our attention on the challenges and opportunities facing the world and to make us think about the role of Earth and space science in those challenges and opportunities that is why I am so pleased to be able to welcome Elon Musk as the 2015 presidential Forum speaker

0:38he is the CEO and lead designer at space exploration Technologies and the CEO and product architect at Tesla Motors Incorporated as lead designer at SpaceX he oversees the development of rockets and spacecraft for Missions to Earth orbit and ultimately to other planets the SpaceX Falcon 1 was the first privately developed liquid fuel rocket to reach orbit and following that Milestone spacex's Falcon 19 rocket and dragon spacecraft won the NASA contract to provide commercial replacement for the cargo transport function of the space shovel and in 2014 SpaceX won a commercial crew contact contract from NASA to carry astronauts in 2017 at Tesla Elon serves as product architect

1:40overseeing product development engineering and design for the all electric vehical range the Tesla Roadster sports card debuted in 2008 followed by the model sedan introduced in 2012 the model S was named Consumer Reports best overall car in 2014 and 2015 and it earned the highest ever safety rating awarded by the national highway traffic safety administration and in 2014 Elon and the company open all their

2:30part of the open source movement in addition to his work at SpaceX and Tesla he is the non-executive chairman and principal shareholder of Solar City which is the leading provider of solar power Solar Power Systems in the US and he's also been known to produce a movie or two please join me in welcoming Elon Musk

3:15thanks so much for joining us today as I said in my YouTube in invitation to you we think we are your peeps in your so I'm going to ask some questions and then we will have some opportunity for questions from the audience in your Ted Talk which I really enjoyed you said that Discovery requires us to boil things down to their fundamental truths and reason up from there so that's a mindset that you live every day for a lot of us when we think about what could be we often get stopped by obstacles and what what the

3:58impediments are and and you have clearly blown through those so how do you think about that and and how do you focus on getting by those obstacles well I'm a big believer in in the sort of science or physics framework of trying to analyze problems particularly if if they're new so if if something's new then analogies don't don't work very well because it's it's it's it's new I mean the way we get through daily life is is mostly by analogy or by sort of copying things with minor variations because it's a computational shortcut but if you want to do something that's that's fundamentally new or particularly that's counterintuitive then you have to do a

4:45first principles analysis and you know take things from from the what appear to be as fundamental sort of simple fundamental truths and then reason up from there and I mean that that requires a lot more thinking and you can't you can't do that for everything but but if you're trying to figure out something new I think it's it's really the only way to go so I mentioned that that I was in Paris and I know that you were there too and as I listened to presentations first there was a real sense of optimism at this cop that I don't think was there before but there was still an overwhelming sense of of a lot of work that we have to do and I was struck by some comments that you made

5:37when you were talking to a group of students at the surbone and they were talking about sustainability and you said regarding the carbon cycle this is analogous to not paying for garbage collection it's not as though we should say in the case of garbage have a garbage free Society it's very difficult to have a garbage free Society but it's just important that people pay for the garbage collection so we need to go from having an untaxed negative externality which is effectively a hidden carbon sub subsidy of enormous size 5.3 million trillion a year and we need to move away from this and have a carbon tax so can you talk a little bit about that

6:22especially from the standpoint of being in PR Enterprise yeah I mean essentially prices are just information they they the primary information to allow for labor labor allocation and I they sort of tell people what what to do and what thing should be favored over another thing and and so when the prices are are wrong then the wrong thing happens in the economy so when you have sort of a tragedy of Commons like the CO2 capacity of the oceans and atmosphere and it's unpriced or

7:00the price is is much lower than it than it should be then the wrong Behavior happens so effectively we're we're inting that behavior and I mean I just talked about how analogies are imperfect but but you know it's kind of like if if we had high taxes on on fruits and vegetables and low taxes on on cigarettes and alcohol that would it wouldn't make sense that's sort of what we have right now with respect to energy and and and we're very

7:38powerful forces trying to keep it that way so you know if it will eventually correct but and and we are seeing some good movement in that direction with the the Paris climate talks it sounds like it's direct directionally correct and and there'll be some movement not as much as there should be but it's it's encouraging and I I think it's

8:05worth noting that like generally when when when the government interferes in the economy it's it's it's it's that usually results in a in a a pricing error increase but in this case I think it would it would be it's hard to miss like any any sort of Caron tax would reduce the effect of error in the system of prices in the economy

8:31I want to shift directions while we are a research Community we're also an education community and we have crowdsourced some questions for today's event and one of them comes from the education community so this came to us on Twitter from Regina Brinker at Brinker science if you want to follow her and she says I teach Middle School stem what should students be learning to be prepared for and contribute to the Future Workforce well I think I mean software engineering is probably the single biggest area that that people should learn and and I and I think I think I'm always sort of a fan of physics and General economics and

9:25critical thinking I think those are we really should teach critical thinking a lot more I mean that may seem like a simple thing but it's it's just like you need to just tell people like this is how you know whether you should believe something or not yeah you can you can tell how much everybody resonates I think I'm preing the converted here yeah but yeah it's

10:01yeah you know just teaching people these are the general types of fallacies and this is how people will generally trick you and how to avoid being tricked and that kind of thing it' be really great it would it would let's do it at the fall meeting here we also try to stress the importance of transdisciplinary research and how science and forms other areas like policy and so forth so another question we received from Twitter came from Lori xowski she's

10:34at extra neutrons who asked so you didn't mention geoscience in that list of things that people should know about I do think JS is very important let me be clear yeah what do the engineers of the future need to know from geosciences and how can how do we influence them and work together well I mean I think in general I think that it would be good in general for people to know about G sciences and to know how our actions as a civilization will affect the future or and you how we can posibly affect it how we might be negatively affecting it you know on the assumption that we want the future to be good we want to direct our actions to you know with respect to

11:26to geosciences to to a good outcome so I you know generally it's it's sort of quite surprising how little actually people know about about geosciences I mean even like pretty straight towards like the carbon cycle you know sort of I mean I've had conversations with with with quite quite smart and well people who who who don't understand that there's like a surface Club in cycle and and then but if you dig stuff up from deep underground and add it to the surface C cycle that that that fundamentally changes the chemical equilibrium of the the surface of the Earth and they're like wow really

12:09yeah and you know like there's just conservation of mass is not totally obvious to people okay you know like you can't just create new carbon from nothing you have and you can't disappears yeah it doesn't appear yeah exactly so you know just like basic stuff like that would be like great to educate people on terrific I I we're sort of bouncing around but I have some you know I we got great input from all of you when we ask for questions and I want to make sure we try to touch on a lot of different topics so I want to talk about the roles of the private and public sector in ensuring the advancement of scientific research and Innovation and where do you see the

13:10roles of the private sector versus the public sector are there places where they overlap are they totally separate yeah I think the public sector is when when you have something that's kind of a small amount of good for the whole population U or for you know the whole country or even the whole the whole world but it would be really difficult to go and collect like $10 from everyone to understand you know more about the nature of the Earth or the solar system or the Universe so you it's it's sort of it's not efficient to go to try and you know collect sort of this if you if you got say A you know a$3 billion project to go and get $10 from everyone in the United

13:53States it's like it's it's better to do that by the public sector and then you know you have great things like like the Hubble and I think what people would say like that's that's quite a quite a good thing or or the Mars missions so I think you know where where you have these things which are a small amount of good for for a lot of people it makes sense for the public sector to to you know for government to do that where you can more

14:25concretely close the economic Loop that that's where the private sector makes sense so for example at SpaceX we do a lot of launches of communications and broadcast satellites and and that that can sort of close the economic Loop because then people can listen to XM radio or get Direct TV or something like that and and that kind of makes sense but then we'll also do missions for NASA to re resupply the space station so we can sort ofar more about living in space and that makes sense as a as a public sector thing so I think that's the basic basic difference so in that public

15:09sector not only geoscience but a lot of Sciences seeing very flat funding at a time when other nations are investing at a time when there's tremendous opportunity how do you think that the private sector can help us turn that around and focus focus on you know what the benefits will be for Society for U public sector investment and in research well I'm certainly proponent of increasing investment in in science in general U from you know both public and private sector and I'm

15:51a super pro science so I and it is it was interesting to see like the large haton fider you know that was that was really a great effort there there in Europe and you we sort of canel the superc conducting super glider here in the US I thought that was that was sort of a sort of a sad thing that we did there you know I I really think we should we should increase funding for science absolutely you know across the world really great we have the director of the National Science foundation in the front row here I'm sure she's in violent agreement yeah definitely so you mentioned Mars and in your interview with Steven coar you said that Mars is a fixer uper

16:45Planet yeah but you've also been a proponent of colonizing Mars what are some of the challenges that you think we would face in traveling Mars I know you're very interested in this how do how do you think about that sure well I think first of all I should say you know why do I think this is important and and that's if I sort of unpack the sort of

17:15philosophical basis for that as far as I'm concerned it's the reason I came to that conclusion was that you know I think that we we don't there there's so much more to understand and learn about the nature of the univers and that understanding will will grow kind of proportionate to the scope and scale of of civilization and

17:38the probability of the probable lifespan of human civilization is is much greater if we are a multiplan species as opposed to a single planet species if we're a single planet species then eventually there will be some Extinction event either you know either from humans or or some natural thing so so I think and and now is

18:03the first time in the history of Earth that the the windows opened where it's possible for us to extend life to another planets I mean it's been 4 and a half billion years so it's a long time and and and that that window may be open for a long time and hopefully it is but it may also be open for a short time and so I think the the wise move is to make life multiplanetary while we can and and and this ultimately is what will lead to a huge amount of of new science and ensure that that we have the highest probability of of understanding the nature of the universe so that that's actually the the reason that I think it's important and and I also think it would be a

18:52great adventure and you know there need to be things that people look forward to when you wake up in the morning like it's it's exciting and inspiring and you know we we need those things yeah I'm old enough to remember the landing on the moon and getting up that day about that and

19:18just the change yeah exactly so but but it it will be super hard to do this and it will take a long time and I I suspect I probably would live to see it become self- sustaining but if we are to aim for that objective then you know they important technological steps that are needed to to get there one of them for example being reusable Rockets if

19:54we have reusable Rockets we can reduce the the cost of of access to space by probably TS magnitude and I me it's worth noting that for the the Falcon 9 which is a about a $16 million rocket to build the the cost of equalent is only about $200,000 so you know it's much like U refueling I guess 747 or something like that so it's it's really a massive difference if we can make reusability work and then we also need scale we need to have really big Rockets and and you need to do local propelling production on Mars so if you can do those things then I think we can establish a self sustaining civilization on ours so I understand that you're going to be launching your newest rocket

20:52next week right and this is the first launch since the Falcon 9 back in June and I've lost some scientific gear that was pretty expensive in the ocean and I know what that feels like Maybe not maybe I don't know how it scales but you know if this is successful it's clearly historic and how do

21:24you think about that issue of you know failing forward failing forward well I think I think I question prefer success forward of course but but yeah it's it's I it's quite emotionally traumatic actually and yeah the the last fight which failed actually did so on my birthday which really hour yeah so yeah I mean it's it's

21:59Rockets are hard the I mean if if gravity was just a little lighter it would be much easier actually If gravity was a little little stronger on Earth it would be basically impossible to do with with chemic rockets it's amazing how much gravity affects things I mean and like small change in G and it's like wow but you can look at say the Saturn 5 which was like the size of like an basically an office building to take off from Earth and and yet to take off from the moon was just the top half of the eagle Lander so it's wow it's like a crazy

22:43difference so anyway the so for for in order to make things work on Earth for Rockets you have to really push everything to the maximum so you have to have really Advanced Materials really optimize the design everything's got to you can't have huge amounts of margin in in the rocket otherwise it just won't get to open at all and and it's really hard to test everything in the ground in the exact circumstances that you would experience a flight because there's just no there's no test facility that could do that exactly so you do you make it close but not exact but for the Post

23:26upcoming flight there are number of improvements in the rocket and one of the things we're we're doing for the first time the first time I think anyone's done it is deep deeply cryogenic propellant so we're subcooling the the propellant particular particularly the liquid oxygen because it's 2/3 liquid oxygen close to its freezing point which increases the density quite quite significantly

23:55and and then the thrust is higher we're going improved stage separation system we stretched the upha stage of the rocket to add more propell to that and there are a number of other improvements in electronics so it's I think a significantly improved rocket from the last one and then I should say like what is important about reusability as far as the Boost AG is concerned what the the key sort of figure of marit is is the transfer

24:27transfer energy so if you take the potential energy and the kinetic energy and say how much has been transferred to the the alpha stage by the Boost stage and and what's the mass that so basically yeah basically conect potential energy transfer that that's the thing that that's the figure of Merit so the the Boost AG of falcine is is capable of of

24:54transfer of a transfer velocity to the alha stage of 8,000 km an hour so it's really that's pretty fast y a bullet from an assault rifle it goes at 2,000 km hour so it's four times faster than a FL for an assault rifle that's a transfer velocity at roughly 100 kilm and the to to a mass of about 120

25:21tons so it's accelerating 120 tons to four times faster than than a bullet I love the way that you just compared something that people wouldn't have any conception of to something that they would and that they would be really impressed by I mean was that amazing communication that was terrific

25:50yeah I wanted to ask you one last question and then we're going to throw things open for the the audience when you talked about Mars you said I don't think I'll ever get there well and yeah what you can talk a little about you know a lot of us get involved in projects that we don't know if we'll see the realization and can you talk a little bit about how you think about that and and trading off you know I get to do

26:22it versus it'll come later well you know going back to the sort of underling mindl sort of philosophical rationale for doing it in the first you know doing in the first place the you know basically I sort of was thinking about this when I when I was a kid and trying to find some meaning in life like what's the meaning of life you know and I I got quite sort of sad

26:53about it actually when I was a teenager and and then I read the Hedgehog Sky the Galaxy which basically said like the the real the real you basically universe is the answer you just need to figure out the questions so I think you know that that's if I can help kind of figure out the questions then that I consider that to be meaningful absolutely and maybe we can all use a Babel Fish as well right

27:32exactly okay now it's time for you and I'm going to go we're going to alternate between questions from the audience and questions from the the no Joan we're not we we won't okay just the audience okay so it's your turn questions for youone please come to the microphones that are in the in the aisles and there's somebody at this microphone go ahead thank you very much for appearing today two weeks ago the Los Angeles Times featured prominently on its front page a story in which it described many self-described Venture capitalists from this area who were enamored by a new and as yet unspecified technique of nuclear power generation it did not it was

28:25promised in the article that I think was different than those demonstrated at three m Island Chernobyl and Fukushima the I'd like to ask if you had what your critical thinking skills would be when approached by people offering you to invest or become involved in new and undefined nuclear power techniques do you know what they're talking about and two what you see as a future for nuclear power in our efforts to restore the Earth to the conditions that it might have existed more closely at the start of the anend proy sure well I I actually am

29:05I I I mean I think there's nothing wrong with nuclear power whether Vision or Fusion I think if you get a properly designed Vision power system is is actually fine particularly if it's in an area that's not subject to natural disasters so you know for example France has a lot of vision power and that can that I think makes lot of sense for them but but for California it's more questionable or Japan so then then then then fusion I I definitely think Fusion is a solvable problem the the reason I sort of haven't done

29:50anything in direct Fusion is that I I currently think and I may be wrong about this that that indirect fusion from the the the big Fusion explosion in the sky called the sun is you know and you having pable takes is is probably going to make the most things economically and in the in the Norther in the high high latitudes of northern hemisphere you tend to have a lot of Hydro power so that that that

30:26really helps solve the you know how do you make power when it's dark a problem or or in the middle of winter type thing so I don't want to discourage people from pursuing Fusion but personally I think the economics are going to favor indirect Fusion of vol vable takes at least to an overwhelming degree particularly when combined with batteries and high voltage lines running East West and north south I mean you can completely solve Earth's all the power needed on Earth with a with a fairly small percentage of the surface area I mean for the United States you could take basically little a corner of Utah Nevada and power the entire United States with solar

31:19power so I I think that's that's mostly how it will get solved the next so this is a bit of a followup on that solar power has been doubling U basically every two years and we all know that exponential growth is a powerful thing so we're only what seven doublings away from everything being powered by solar power and do you think that that doubling rate will will keep Pace I mean I I think it'll probably slow down but but it's still going to be a high percentage growth rate every year once you reach a certain percentage of solar into the grid you really need to add batteries in order to load level and and kind of cach power but but solar combined with

32:11with batter is really I me you kind of like I said you can completely solve all of power with just those those two things great that Victor you know it's worth it's worth noting I think probably people aware of this but you know you get it's there one Gatt per sare of solar energy solar power right I'm Victor zos this your massive fop work particularly fighting the carbon pollution and actually full up on this battery question we tend to start understanding how powerful the carbon pollution is but battery related technology and F Tes has its own production side I was wondering if you could maybe share your thoughts on what the consequences and maybe a remediation

33:03reyment if that would be yeah well all of the battery packs for Tesla are currently recycled the recycling centers in North America and Europe and and Asia and it kind of makes sense because you can just think of the battery packs as really high quality or it's way better to mine a battery pack than rocks so so it kind of

33:27makes to to recycle them economically yeah and that obviously reduces the the cost of production quite a bit for the gigafactory that that we're building in Nevada that will have recycling built in so that you know it'll be completely sort of you know close that cycle and it will be in the long

33:53term fully sustainably powered so solar wind and geothermal yeah and the the far microphone hi I'm Jim croll from Arizona State University I was listening to Dr Chris McKay another advocate of hum to Mars and he was talking about when we do go to Mars if we find life either currently there or extinct we should re consider removing human presence so we can allow that life to thrive I was I was wondering what your thoughts on that were well I it really doesn't seem like there's any life on on Mars I mean if they're on the surface at least we're not seeing any sign of that I think if we do find some sign of it then for sure we need to understand you know

34:47what it is and and try to I try to ensure that we we don't extinguish it I mean that's that's important but I think I think the reality is that there isn't any life on the surface of Mars there may be microbial life deep underground where it's sort of shielded from radiation and from

35:13the cold and yeah so that that's that's a possibility but in in that case I think anything we do on the surface is really not going to have a big impact on the Subterranean life yeah okay thank you here again hi with a decision coming out of cop 21 just a few days ago with the world now appearing to be on track to decarbonize the Energy System renewable energy and of course storage is going to become increasingly important and likely the development will accelerate I'm really interested in what Tesla's doing on batteries that will help smooth the intermittency of the renewable generation and would really like to hear your discussion of where you see Tesla

36:01going on battery storage for Renewables and generally the whole issue of storage for Renewables yeah well definitely this batter technology is super important to sustainable energy what what we're doing with the the the big Factory and that we're bulling in Nevada is is really trying to take economies of scale to the Limit so it's like the biggest Factory we could conceive of in order to to maximize economies of scale and then

36:37obviously there's the underlying technology itself which there there will be I would say moderate improvements in the underlying technology not giant but not not small but kind of medium but then over time I would expect those those technology improvements to get better and better and from Tesla standpoint we're always interested in trying to figure out how to how to make it better I I do think that batteries are one of the hottest technology problems out there because there's so many constraints on creating a useful battery it's it's really I mean so many super smart people have broken a pick on improving batteries so so it usually ends up being on average like about a 5

37:25to 8% Improvement per year in energy density and economics although I think we'll be able to improve the economic element a lot more just by the economies of scale but I anyone who's interested in in doing batteries I'd certainly encourage them to to research better batteries it's

37:47it's a super hard problem and a critical one to solve what do you think are the main steps in a low carbon energy transition and in that vein what technologies out there What technological developments do you find very interesting that you're not already working on things that aren't batteries or electric vehicles but that you think are cool areas for people to go into well I think electrification of Transport in general is important so aircraft and and boats that that that's Prett important and and then Heating and Cooling electrification of that

38:37yeah I me I think I mean the nuclear stuff could be could be quite interesting but it would just have to sort of see how it competes against solar but yeah and any anything which any form of energy generation or consumption which if you extract into the future goes on for a very long time and still has the world being good I think we should just do

39:09that over here good morning fisha Hoover from Pur University my question pertains to science access and energy within the global context and I was wondering how you see any or all of your your companies and ventur is trying to address the the inequity of science access or access to energy or or what

39:37types of things that you're hoping to do within that context to try and really expand those resources and make it accessible to everyone sure well I mean as was mentioned earlier Tesla has just made all the patents open and Solar City is actually going even a step further than that which is they're making the technology

40:10available to developing countries and and they're offering to have people come from those countries and actually sit in the factory and see how it's done so I think you know trying to be helpful in that respect and but but I I do think that you know the internet is a great equalizer of access to information the you

40:41know this is this is maybe not talked about as much as it should be but you can learn anything if you have a $100 internet device you can just learn anything it's which is amazing compared to the Past you don't need you don't need access to a library principle you could just you could learn whatever you want for free really think that's that's a pretty great part of the future that we're in right now inde in the end hi kho Park from siia National La Tesla has done a great job creating an infrastructure for electric cars in the country so far but I don't think electric cars themselves solve Greenhouse greenhouse gas problems because we're still generating GRE

41:26greenhouse gases from coal and natural power plant natural gas power plants which are not as efficient as gasoline cars so how did you originally Envision the future source of electricity and how do you envision it now yeah actually it's it's worth noting that even if the grid was completely powered by coal and natural gas electric cars would still generate less less CO2 even when you extract when you take it all the way to the power plant level the the reason for that is that when you're not constrained by mass and volume you can make the the efficiency of energy extraction much better in a power plant than you can in a car so if you take say like

42:21natural gas power plant from from GE it's it's over 60% efficient so take the Source energy 60% efficient in generating electricity so it's really good whereas typically a gasoline powered car over the drive cycle will be less than 20% efficient and and that's because you know the the big natural gas turbine is it it can be really heavy it can be really bulky and you can take the the waste heat and then run a steam turbine and you know get even more energy out so your efficiency is just fundamentally much better and so even when you take into account the transmission losses and the charging losses you're still way far ahead with electric cars than you are with

43:10gasoline cars so even you can take this do this with any Source fuel coal anything you're just you're just always going to win even if everything's powered by by CO2 sources then then of course everything isn't powered by CO2 sources you have Hydro geothermal solar wind and as was pointed out by one of the earlier questioners the growth of solar is

43:44very dramatic so the you know the percentage of the grid that is sustainable energy is increasing over time and then particularly when we add batteries to the mix that will that will further increase the range so I think I think we're we're on a we're headed in a positive direction which just the question of how long it will take to get there in fact like one of the things I really emphasized in the Paris talk was that it is a certainty

44:17that we will move to a sustainable energy economy because the alternative would be would be to mine all of the carbon based fuel from the ground burn them and then you either move to a sustainable economy or the entire economy collapses because then it doesn't have any energy so we know for sure that we'll move to a sustainable energy economy the question is just when and and H how many you know billions of tons of of CO2 are in the atmosphere

44:48versus in the ground that that's really the only question is is what what what PPM number will we you know stabiliz yeah exactly so you know so given that we know where will end up which is a sustainable energy economy it seems like we should we should terminate this experiment as soon as

45:23possible I'm sorry but we don't have time for any more question questions when I was walking in one of my friends was telling me how excited he was to be here and I wrote down what he said U because I think it's something we all share he said it's such a rare thing to see a person devote themselves to coming up with real solutions to the biggest problems and then doing it thank you so much thanks for

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份