2008年圣诞节前的那个周日,马斯克早上醒来,脑子里冒出一个他从未有过的念头。他一直以为自己不是那种会精神崩溃的人,可那一刻,他离崩溃只差一步。
六年多以后,2015年1月,他站在底特律文艺复兴中心万豪酒店的台上,把这段经历讲给汽车新闻世界大会(Automotive News World Congress)的听众。台下坐着的是美国汽车工业的中坚,很多人前一天还在讨论产能、经销商库存和燃油经济性法规。
他来这里的目的说得很直白:回答一些问题,顺便解释为什么他认为电动车的窗口大得惊人。
他的判断放在今天看依然锋利。除了火箭这个带点讽刺意味的例外,所有交通都会走向全电动。剩下的问题只是时间。这件事早一点发生,对世界就更好一点。
石油变便宜了,电动车反而更急
让这个时间表变得紧迫的,是一项技术:水力压裂(fracking)。
他给的估算很粗,但量级吓人。压裂技术大概把全球可开采的石油和天然气放大了十倍。具体倍数没人说得清,但大致是这个数量级。这件事带来两个后果。
第一个后果,化石燃料对气候的潜在伤害比过去大得多。
第二个后果更微妙,也更致命:石油的稀缺性再也无法把价格顶到足够高的位置,再从外部逼着整个行业转向电动。
过去二十年,电动车推广的底层逻辑其实很简单。油会越来越少,越来越贵,贵到某一天电动车自然就划算了。这个"逼迫函数"(forcing function)是很多政策制定者和车厂高管的心理依靠。
压裂把这个依靠抽走了。马斯克的原话是,我们不能指望稀缺性把油气价格推高,让它成为足够强的逼迫函数,来推动电动化。
所以电动车得自己变得有说服力,不能等油价来救。
他讲话的时候,油价已经从2014年夏天的一百多美元一桶跌破五十美元;接下来一年,它还会继续跌到三十美元附近。底特律那些人很快就明白了他在讲什么。
两份最不可能成功的创业清单
主持人开场就调侃,说这是两个加拿大男孩在聊快车和火箭。接着抛出一个问题:如果要把创业方向按成功概率排个序,汽车和火箭大概都在清单最底下。
马斯克没否认,反而把话说得更绝。
如果你把所有能创办的公司排个序,看哪个最可能成功、哪个风险调整后的回报最好,创办一家汽车公司和一家火箭公司,大概率排在最后。(马斯克)
那为什么还做?
汽车这边,他的答案跟商业逻辑关系不大。市场上需要出现一个"好的电动车"的样本,而当时一个都没有。
这个理由听起来单薄,放在2003年却极重。那时电动车在公众认知里是一种残缺的产品,谁来买它,都像在给自己找麻烦。要做的事情只有一件,先造出一辆让人无话可说的车。
火箭那边他没展开,但两边用的是同一套思路。先把"这事不可能"的判断推翻一次,剩下的才有得谈。
公众脑子里的电动车,是一辆高尔夫球车
马斯克描述当时的心智画面:电动车等于高尔夫球车。慢,操控差,续航短,难看,功能少。
这幅画牢牢钉在所有人脑子里,包括投资人、经销商和普通买家。产品竞争的第一关往往在人脑子里,参数表排在后面。这一关过不去,后面的成本、渠道、补贴都无从谈起。
Roadster 的任务就是撞碎这个模具。它得证明电动车可以快,可以性感,可以操控好,可以续航长,可以是一辆真正的好车。
车造出来之后,第二层怀疑马上来了。人们说,好吧,你造了一辆电动跑车,但没人会买。于是 Model S 要回答的是需求问题,证明真的有人愿意掏钱。
第三层是 Model 3。它要证明长续航的大众市场电动车在成本和体验上同时成立。
他说这三步在他写的第一篇特斯拉博客里就画出来了,那已经是将近十年前的事。回头看,产品路线图这种东西,写下的时候像宣言,执行起来像苦役。
顺便对齐一下时间。Roadster 在2008年开始交付,Model S 在2012年上市,Model 3 在2015年这次讲话时还没发布,要等到2016年才亮相。也就是说,他站在台上说"我们下一步要做 Model 3"的时候,前两步刚刚走完,钱还没挣回来。
2008年圣诞节前的那个周日
2008年,两家公司同时站在悬崖边。
SpaceX 的猎鹰一号(Falcon 1)前三次发射全部失败。他当时并没有为三次发射准备足够的钱,所以第三次失败之后,第四次发射的资金是硬凑出来的。一家火箭公司连续失败三次,第四次还没钱,这个故事在任何行业都接近终点。
特斯拉那边,2008年夏天正在做一轮融资。整个金融市场正在崩盘,银行接连倒闭,没人愿意掏钱。为一个做电动车的初创汽车公司融资,用他的话说,听起来像"愚蠢的平方"(stupidity squared)。
主持人问他当时是不是在谷底。他说是,而且强调这一点值得说清楚。
因为今天看特斯拉和 SpaceX,人们容易以为它们一直处在健康状态。真实情况是,没人把这两家公司当回事。火箭公司和汽车公司都一样。大家的判断是:一个古怪的有钱人在把钱扔进水里。
这个判断他听过好几次,有的是当着他的面说的。
他还听过一个流传很广的笑话。
怎么在汽车生意里赚一笔小钱?先带一大笔钱进去。(马斯克转述的行业笑话)
这个笑话他听得太多,后来干脆抢在对方之前把包袱抖出来。
那轮融资里,投资人被问得发火
2008年圣诞节前的周日早晨,他意识到自己快要撑不住了。他从来没想过自己会是那种会精神崩溃的人,但那是他离崩溃最近的一次。
融资的过程很难看。投资人甚至生气,气的是你居然开口问他们要钱。为一个烧钱的电动车创业公司融资,在2008年秋天的华尔街,是一件让人尴尬的事。
最后凑出钱的方式很朴素。大多数老股东同意继续出资,他把手里剩下的钱全部投进特斯拉。总额大约四千万美元,其中两千万来自他自己。
投完之后他没钱了,房租是借的。
这四千万撑了大约六个月,到2009年5月,戴姆勒(Daimler)投资特斯拉。
同年12月,NASA 给了 SpaceX 一份15亿美元的合同。主持人用的词是"瞬间",两家公司几乎同时从悬崖边被拉了回来。
戴姆勒那笔钱,救了特斯拉
他专门纠正了一个流传很广的说法。
很多人以为特斯拉是靠政府资金活下来的。他说这和事实不符。2009年5月戴姆勒的投资,才是特斯拉活下来的原因。那笔钱对特斯拉的生存是根本性的。
联邦政府的第一笔钱要到2010年3月才到账,那时候金融危机已经过去。2010年6月特斯拉完成 IPO,也在这之后。
这个细节值得较真,因为它决定你怎么理解特斯拉的早期历史。一家公司在最危险的六个月里,靠的是产业资本和老股东的钱。补贴进来的时候,生死已经分出来了。
这个顺序后来被反复讲错,讲成一个"政府扶持出来的公司"的故事。故事听着顺,事实对不上。
10%的成功概率,和"幅度"的问题
主持人问他,当初有没有想过这家公司会成功。
他的回答是,最开始只有他和几个人的时候,他觉得成功的概率大概是10%。
主持人追问现在怎么看。他说,某种程度的成功现在已经有保障了,问题变成了成功的幅度有多大。
这句话里藏着一个创业者很少说出口的转变。从"能不能活"到"能长多大",中间隔着一整套完全不同的能力。前者的核心是现金流和融资节奏,后者的核心是制造、供应链和组织。
特斯拉后来十几年遇到的麻烦,基本都落在后一半。
0.1%的市场份额,就是利基的定义
主持人给了一个很具体的分岔:特斯拉会不会就停在年产十万辆这个量级,做一家小而美的车厂。
马斯克用算术回答。全球汽车市场一年大约九千万到一亿辆,十万辆的份额差不多是0.1%。0.1%就是利基(niche)的定义。要想不算利基,至少要越过小数点。
他自己给的路线是2020年前后做到50万辆,然后继续往上。主持人追问时间表,他说2025年前后能做到一年几百万辆。
他还补了一句更有意思的话:会尽量把产量往上推,因为使命是把世界转向电动车。如果特斯拉不造很多电动车,就没有尽到全力。
拿后来的数据对照一下会更清楚。2020年特斯拉交付约50万辆,正好落在当年说的那个数上。到2025年,年交付量在一百多万到两百万辆之间,"一年几百万辆"没有按期实现。制造规模的爬坡,比他2015年的预估慢了一截。
这条曲线本身说明了当年那个判断的分量。能被准确预测的是需求,被低估的永远是产能。
真正的贡献,是在丛林里开出一条路
他在这段话里给了一个比喻,比任何销量数字都更能解释特斯拉的意义。
我认为特斯拉将来做成的最大的好事,是在丛林里开出一条路,展示出汽车能做到什么地步。(马斯克)
这句话在2015年听起来像谦虚,事后看是准确的判断。
Roadster 证明电动车可以快,Model S 证明电动车可以豪华而且有人买,Model 3 证明电动车可以进入大众价格带。每撞开一道门,后面车厂的跟进成本就低一截。开路的人承担了试错的账,跟随的人只需要抄作业。
主持人最后问,整个行业会不会跟着转向。他的回答很干脆:会。
2015年之后发生的事情,基本沿着这条线走。几乎所有主流车厂都在接下来几年公布了电动化时间表,大众、通用、福特、奔驰、宝马,一个接一个。其中不少计划后来又被推迟或缩减,方向没有变回去。
把这次讲话拆开看,最有价值的地方不在那些具体数字,而在他怎么判断一件事能不能成。
他不相信"等外部条件变好"这种策略。油价不会来救电动车,补贴不会永远在,投资人的耐心有限。能依靠的只有两样东西:产品本身的说服力,和在最糟糕的时刻还能拿到钱的能力。
2008年那个周日早晨,他离崩溃一步之遥。让他走过来的,是老股东的四千万美元、戴姆勒的一笔投资,和一份15亿美元的 NASA 合同。三样东西都和产品好坏没有直接关系,和现金流有直接关系。
至于方向,他从来没改过。剩下的是时间问题,而时间从来不听人安排。
- 评估一家公司在危机中的生死,先看那六个月里谁的钱进来了。产业资本和老股东追加的钱,比后来到账的补贴和授信更能说明问题。
- 判断一个新品类能否起量,先去找公众脑子里的那幅画。电动车的画是高尔夫球车,这幅画不擦掉,参数再漂亮也卖不动。
- 做替代品生意,别把商业模型建立在被替代品涨价上。压裂把油价打下来,电动车反而被迫提前长大。
- 看创业者的早期判断,把"成功概率10%"这种数字记下来。愿意承认低概率还继续做的人,通常对失败有预案,对成功没有幻觉。
- 把"活得下来"和"长得多大"当成两件事看。前者靠融资和现金流,后者靠制造、供应链和组织,两套能力几乎不重叠。
- 评估一个行业的变革进度,别只盯领跑者的销量,看它有没有把后来者的跟进成本降下来。开路的价值通常体现在别人的时间表上。
0:00Jason ridlo reporting for americ jr.com see Jason ridlo reporting from the Detroit Marriott at the Renaissance Center for the 2015 Automotive news World Congress stay tuned for remarks from Mr Elon Musk CEO and co-founder of Tesla Motors and so I think I'm hopeful that you know by coming here maybe answering some questions I can explain why I think the opportunity for electric cars is tremendous and why I think think that all transport with the ironic exception of rockets will go fully electric and and so it's really just a question of when it goes fully electric and if we can make it go electric sooner then that will be much better for the world and and we do have significant
0:51danger with fracking technology which is I think really still at at a an early stage because I I think fracking probably increases the accessible oil and gas in the world by perhaps a factor of 10 we don't really know what what the full extent of it is but it's probably something like Northern magnitude which which means the potential harm to the to the climate is is really much much greater than it was before and and we can't rely on scarcity to drive the price of oil and gas high and and have that be an adequate forcing function to move electric so we have to figure out how to make electric cars themselves compelling without without that economic forcing function of high
1:43gas prices thank you we against a couple of Canadian boys talking fast cars and Rockets could be better if you were going to launch two businesses I'm guessing the natural place to start would probably not be rockets and cars yeah I think for sure if you were to rank order companies to start and say what is the what is likely to succeed
2:12and what you know what what has the best risk adjusted return pretty sure starting a car company a rocket company will be at the bottom of the list so so why cars in why space well because in the case of cars it was very important for there to be an example of an electric car that
2:36that was great like there were no great electric cars so people thought electric cars were like a golf cart so they were slow and didn't maneuver well and had low range or ugly didn't have as much functionality and that's that's the picture that people had in their minds and we had to show people that an electric car could be fast sexy handle well long range and be a great car and that's what we do with Tesla Roadster so it's really important to sort of just break the mold to break the m to address that misperception that one couldn't make a great electric car and and then and then to show that if you made electric car with all those attributes
3:13that lots of people would buy it because even after we made the car you know a lot of people said well yeah you've made this electric sports car but nobody's going to buy it then so we had to show yes there is demand for it and the same for the model S and then with our model three down the road showing that it's possible to compelling long range Mass Market electric car that's I think that's that's the the third
3:38part of the strategy that I outlined with my first blog post about Tesla now almost 10 years ago so that that's you had a few people doubting you I mean when when you go back to a few just a few just a few people right every you know here and there if we go back to 2008 you've had a couple of failed rocket launches you've got a lot of Teslas sitting around in the garage it's it's there are some issues there in an instant you receive funding from NASA a huge contract from NASA for $1.5 billion and then you also get funding for the car company but you were at the bottom correct I mean you were yeah I think this is important to to to emphasize because if you look at say Tesla and
4:19SpaceX now and they think they sort of think well maybe it was always they were always in a healthy position but it wasn't no for the beginning we were in in really Dire Straits no one would take it seriously either the rocket company or the car company they they just thought well he's sort of an eccentric rich guy and he's going to lose all his money you know they told me that several times I me the most common joke I heard was you know how do you make a small fortune in in the car car business or the rocket business and the punch line is you start with a large one right so I was like I'd heard that J so many times I would just hit them with the punchline before they
4:58had a chance to say it the the yeah so and you nearly had a nervous breakdown around I mean this a personal I'm that that close to nervous breakdown but the the but I did think to myself on the Sunday before Christmas in 2008 waking up this Sunday morning thinking I never thought I would I was someone who was capable of having to a break down but this is about as close as I've ever come because things were so were really so dire as you to
5:29earlier that year after the first three rockets had failed of our Falcon one vehicle and and I don't really allowed for enough money for three flights so we had to desperately try to scrape together enough money for a fourth flight and the and then with Tesla the financing round 12 in the summer of8 because the whole financial markets were crashing and jam and tri going bankrupt and nobody wanted to give us money not an ideal time to start a car company definitely not I mean try to raise money for a startup car company that's making electric cars to boot which is like like that sounded like stupidity Square the you know investors would be angry
6:13that we even asked them like that that we that we even ask them that would be angry about that and and in fact the only way we were able to raise money to keep Tesla going was from is that that most of the existing investors agre to to fund the company and I put all of all the money that I had remaining into Tesla so it still wasn't it was it was you know amounted to about in total about $40 million 20 of which came from me and then and and I was Tapped Out head to borrow money rant after that and and that tied us over into for about about six
6:53months to May of 2009 when dler invested in in Tesla and that diam investment was really fundamental to to the survival of of Tesla in fact a lot of people think like somehow the government failed us out or anything that is actually not not true it it was the dam investment that saved Tesla not not not Government funding the first money we got from the government ever was in March of 2010 and that
7:22was after the crisis have passed and it wasn't your intention to even that this would be profitable I mean you thought it was actually going to fail at some point right well when or you weren't sure it was going to be that successful at this at the start of Tesla when it was just me and a few guys I thought I thought we maybe had a 10% chance of success okay how do you feel
7:48now well now I I think we've got now now I think this some degree of success is assured but it's a question of the magnitude so does Tesla does Tesla become sort of a a niche car maker making maybe 100,000 cars a year or something like that which is always super super tiny you know that that would be yeah I mean 0.1% of market share is I
8:23think that's the definition of a niche if you're 0.1% you have to at least get past decimal point to not be a niche so so that that's one that's one possible F 100,000 or yeah or your stated goals of 500,000 by 2020 yeah I I think we'll probably aim to do more cars than than thanat I'm not necessarily by by 2020 show 500,000 but I think we'll probably continue past that you'll continue past the 500,000 yes okay within which time within what kind of time frame let's say I don't know I think I think should we should be able to get to probably at least a few million cars in 10 years a year so by 2030 by well by 2025 Oh by 2025 okay we
9:13can probably get to a few million cars a year we just I think we're just going to keep driving our our volume as as as as high as we can because our mission is fundamentally to transition the world to electric cars so if we don't make a lot of electric cars then we're not doing as much as we can now I mean that that being said I think most of the good that Tesla will accomplish is by sort of cutting a path through the jungle to to to to show what can be done with M cars like so I think so you think that that the industry as a whole will adopt a greater yes I think
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版