2012 年,阿什利·万斯(Ashlee Vance)在旧金山一家餐厅等埃隆·马斯克(Elon Musk)。他点了一杯金汤力压惊,因为接下来这几个小时可能决定他未来两年的生活。
马斯克坐下,屁股还没沾到椅子,万斯问了句"最近怎么样"。
马斯克的回答是:我最近一直被一种恐惧占据,我觉得 Google 会毁灭人类。
那年是 2012 年。马斯克和拉里·佩奇(Larry Page)是很好的朋友,他每次来硅谷没房子住,就睡在包括佩奇在内的四个朋友家里。他一边在佩奇家借宿,一边在饭桌上说佩奇的公司可能终结人类。
万斯当时就懵了:你不是觉得拉里是个坏人吧?马斯克说,不,恰恰相反,他是那种天真地善良的人。马斯克自己对 AI 的走向持悲观态度,他认为佩奇太乐观了。
万斯为写《埃隆·马斯克》这本书,和马斯克吃的第一顿晚饭,就是这么开场的。后来这样的晚饭吃了八个月,每个月一次,每次三到五小时。
一本他本来拒绝配合的书
万斯原来是哲学专业,毕业赶上互联网泡沫,为了养活自己去当记者,先跑半导体和网络设备,一跑就跑进了科技报道这一行。他说自己一直偏爱那种真的造东西、有工厂的公司,这也是他后来盯上马斯克的原因。
2012 年他给《商业周刊》做了一期马斯克封面报道。那次接触让他改变了看法:他原以为马斯克是个单线程的技术乌托邦主义者,结果发现这人极其能聊,身边没有公关拦着,问什么都答。
报道做完,他动了写书的念头。他给马斯克发邮件说明来意,马斯克的回复很干脆:以前很多人找过我,我不做,我也不会帮你。
万斯转头飞去纽约,把书卖给了出版社。
然后他约马斯克再见一面,那是个周六,在特斯拉。他说,书我已经卖了。马斯克说,我还是不会配合你。
于是万斯开始自己干。他花了 18 个月,采访了几百人:大部分已经离职的 SpaceX 和特斯拉员工、Zip2 和 PayPal 时期的老同事、前女友、童年玩伴。这些人中的很多会回头打电话问马斯克:我该不该跟他聊?马斯克没禁止过任何一个人。
18 个月后的某个工作日晚上六点半,万斯在家,来电显示是埃隆·马斯克。他接起来,马斯克说了一句话:这事有两条路,我可以让所有来问我的人闭嘴,也可以配合你这本书。
万斯说,显然你该选 B。
马斯克提了两个条件:出版前要看书稿,还要在书里加脚注。万斯说,如果你了解马斯克写东西的风格,就会知道脚注会比正文长,这书大概永远出版不了。他准备了长篇大论去反驳,讲了五分钟,马斯克说,行吧。
之后马斯克给了万斯所有他想要的采访权限,还答应每个月见一次,一直到写完为止。最后是八个月。
吃饭对这个人只是加油
跟马斯克吃饭是件很怪的事。
万斯说他从没见过谁吃得那么快。第一次晚饭他不知道能占用马斯克多久,录音笔开着,电脑也开着记笔记,结果菜一上来就消失。他低头看一眼电脑,一整盘就没了。
马斯克点菜也费劲。在办公室里,助理直接把饭端来,他埋头吃完,好像根本不在意吃的是什么。到了餐厅问他想吃什么,他说不知道,最后都是万斯替他决定。
那天他们点了六道前菜。万斯一边问问题一边看着盘子一个个空掉,心想这样下去不行,得让这顿饭拖得越长越好。主菜上来,马斯克点的是墨鱼汁炸龙虾,万斯点的是牛排。马斯克已经吃完了,万斯才问了两个问题。
他把自己的牛排切了一半放到马斯克盘子里,想拖住他。两口,没了。
书里还写了一个更早的细节。90 年代在加拿大,马斯克在一个生日聚会上跟一个女孩坐在沙发上,说的第一句话是:如果不用吃饭,我就不会吃。要是能省掉吃饭这件事,把所有时间用来工作,我一定这么干。
那时候还没有 Soylent。
“你觉得我疯了吗”
第一顿饭吃到尾声,马斯克站起来准备走,然后又折回来,双手撑在桌上,盯着万斯的眼睛问了一句:你觉得我疯了吗?
万斯脑子里瞬间炸了:这是最后一道题吗?我该怎么答?答错了他是不是就不配合了?他后来回忆说自己当时含含糊糊地说了些"不,我不觉得你疯,你做的某些事在外人看来可能像那样,但我至少对你的公司有兴趣,不然我不会坐在这"。
事后他想明白了:自己说了什么其实不重要。马斯克只是在做最后一次直觉检查,看这个人能不能勉强被信任。
前面八个月的过程也不是一路顺风。万斯说前四次见面他很沮丧,能拿到有用的东西,但明显感觉对方有所保留,讲的都是公开演讲里听过的老段子。他也一直担心马斯克哪天就烦了,一刀切断,所以每一次见面都像捡来的。
大概在第四次之后,情况变了。他们总是在晚上八九点吃,吃到餐厅里几乎没人。那天马斯克像换了个开关,整个人松下来,话也多了。
万斯说,那八个月是他每个月最期待的事。毕竟你想想,你对面坐的这个人有可能是第一个登上火星的人,而你可以问他任何问题。
外公开着单引擎飞机,把全家搬去了南非
书的前两章讲家族。万斯说,马斯克母亲那边的外公乔舒亚·哈尔德曼(Joshua Halderman)本身就该单独写一本书,因为这人疯得离谱。
他是加拿大人,某天忽然收拾行李带着全家搬到南非。他自己开一架单引擎小飞机,五十年代带着妻子从南非沿着非洲海岸一路往北,横穿亚洲,最后飞到澳大利亚。光是办这趟飞行的审批手续就花了一年。
后来他又决定参加一场从南非开到北非的汽车拉力赛,开一台旅行车,拿了第二名。
再后来,每隔一周的周末,他会带上马斯克的妈妈和另外四个孩子,飞去丛林里找传说中的"卡哈拉哈里失落之城"。飞机降落,营地里就有狮子。
这位外公的本职是脊椎按摩师。
马斯克后来试图把那架飞机买回来。万斯说,家族里那些故事反复被讲,核心就一句话:你想做什么就去做,看起来多离谱都无所谓。
但童年还有另一半。
马斯克是个书呆子,不爱运动,话不多,没什么朋友。南非的文化极度崇尚男性气概和运动能力,他在学校里要么被无视,要么被欺负,而且欺负得很凶。有一次他被人从楼梯上推下去,那帮人还按住他继续打,他在医院躺了一两周。类似的事发生过好几次。
万斯找到了他小学同学,有两三个人说:他是我们当年觉得最不可能做出什么非凡成就的人。他们并没有觉得他哪门功课差,只是根本没人想起过他。
跟父亲的关系更糟。书里马斯克说自己的童年"很惨",但他从没讲清楚父亲到底对他做了什么。采访中有四五次,他讲到一半眼眶湿了,然后就关掉了。
马斯克的原话是:
我没有一个快乐的童年。那就是 misery。(马斯克,转引自万斯书中访谈)
万斯说,你尽可以坐在扶手椅上做心理分析:一个人的童年是这样,长大后拼命向世界证明自己特殊、能做成很多事、值得被看见,逻辑上说得通。他跟几任妻子聊,跟前女友聊,跟至交好友聊,所有人提到他的童年都用同一个词。
17 岁那年,马斯克带着 100 美元离开家,落到加拿大,背包旅行了一年。
14 岁前,他可能读完了人类所有科幻小说
万斯在书接近结尾的地方提了一个概念,他承认这听起来很虚:心理学家有个说法叫"极度天赋"(profoundly gifted),指的是一小群智商远超量表的人,他们往往表现出相似的特质。其中一条是,他们会有一种强烈的感觉,觉得世界上有某个东西是坏的、必须被修好,而且这种冲动近乎强迫。
万斯说他完全确信马斯克属于这一类。
另一个证据是阅读量。马斯克大概在 14 岁前读完了能接触到的所有科幻小说,把附近书店和图书馆的书都读空了,父母还不断给他买百科全书。万斯认为那些科幻故事在他心里留下了很深的印子,所以等到他赚到够多的钱,第一件想干的事就是造火箭。
一百万人上火星,那是个备份方案
万斯把马斯克的目标分成两层。
最上面那层是火星殖民,而且规模不是"送五个人上去插个旗",是一百万人。万斯说,这个目标放在硅谷还算能理解,放到硅谷之外就很怪。但马斯克的逻辑非常自洽:他认为人类迟早会遭遇某种灾难,需要一份备份,而目前没有别人在以他这个量级推进这件事,那他就来当这个人。
有意思的是,万斯说有几位软件工程师读完书跑来跟他说:我完全理解这哥们,我也是这么想的。
下面那层是特斯拉和 SolarCity。万斯把它们看作通往火星路上的副产品:既然要折腾几十年,顺手让地球运转得好一点。
采访里有人问,马斯克做的事是不是对制度失灵的一种反应。万斯说,你这个判断很准。Hyperloop(超级高铁)就是最典型的例子:马斯克看到加州高铁项目,觉得这是个灾难性的错误,于是拿出一份方案。万斯强调,马斯克一开始压根没打算建 Hyperloop,那更接近一次思维练习,目的是让人看清楚那条铁路有多糟糕,我们应该追求点别的。
他顺手给了 SpaceX 一个数据:美国在商业发射市场的份额曾经是 100%,后来掉到 0%,在全球市场上完全没有竞争力。现在 SpaceX 是成本最低的那家,把所有东西放在美国制造,把份额重新拿了回来。而洛克希德和波音,是在买俄罗斯的发动机来发射美国的侦察卫星。
万斯说,马斯克、佩奇、贝索斯这些人手上积累了足够多的钱,开始做以前只有政府才做的事,而且证明了自己能做成。政府那边看不出有这个意愿。至于你怎么看,取决于你站在光谱的哪一端:是一群赚太多钱的《星际迷航》粉丝在瞎折腾,还是这本来就该是方向。
你说不行,他就接管你的项目
万斯说,写书之前他一直觉得"你去跟马斯克说某件事不可能,他就自己做出来"这类故事是胡扯。尤其在 SpaceX,他采访了几百人,很多人说自己亲眼见过:你对他说这件事做不到,他直接把项目接过去,然后他真的做成了。
代价是,你基本会在项目结束时被开掉,因为你说过它做不到。
万斯说这对他本人也是消耗。有时晚饭时马斯克走进来,一脸憔悴,像一个刚跑完马拉松的人,晚上八点坐在那里,而他已经干了一整天。奇怪的是他能连续好多天保持这个状态。
公司的运转方式是围绕"关键路径"(critical path)。任何时刻只有一件事是卡住整个公司的瓶颈,马斯克就把注意力全压在那件事上。万斯采访过一位叫凯文·布罗根(Kevin Brogan)的人,他某一刻正好站在关键路径上,那意味着马斯克 24 小时盯着他。
布罗根讲过一件事。有天凌晨两点,马斯克和当时的妻子塔卢拉(Talulah Riley)已经躺下,SpaceX 的团队把一个东西彻底搞砸了。马斯克不想吵醒妻子,又不打算放过这帮人,于是在床上贴着电话用气声骂人,那几个人围着免提听训。
有高管说过,他在欧洲或中国出差,凌晨两点半发邮件,五分钟后就收到回复。万斯说,能提供这种级别的支持确实难以想象,但代价也真实存在:马斯克结过两次婚,离了又复合,他自己都说过没什么正常生活可言。
书里有个场景,万斯在 SpaceX 的工位隔间采访他,那时他正好处在两段婚姻之间,他说:我又该约会了。你觉得一个女人一周需要多少小时?10 小时?10 小时差不多吧?
一周飞两座城市,五个男孩,和一个 Pepper Potts
马斯克的日程大概是这样:周一周二在 SpaceX,周二晚上飞到湾区,周三四在特斯拉,周五回洛杉矶。周末去哪家公司,取决于哪家出了最紧急的灾难。写书那段时间,他一周工作七天。
他有五个男孩,一对双胞胎加一组三胞胎。
书里有个关键人物叫玛丽·贝丝·布朗(Mary Beth Brown)。万斯说,如果马斯克是钢铁侠,她就是他的小辣椒。她从 PayPal 时期就跟着他,把生活完全交给了他:住在两个城市,万斯说没见过她有男朋友,甚至没见她好好吃过午饭。家里的私事她管,比如谁去接孩子、监护时间怎么排;公司层面最高级别的公关也归她。整台机器靠她当胶水。
带孩子的保姆团队最近"缩编"了,剩两三个。
万斯说,按所有人的说法,马斯克是个很好的爸爸,只是他的孩子过着非常奇怪的生活。有次吃饭他跟万斯说,我刚带孩子们从摩纳哥回来,跟亲王夫妇一起看的 F1。另一面是,他周末把孩子带去 SpaceX,这些孩子大概是地球上唯一会对火箭工厂感到无聊的十岁男孩。
Google 差一点买下特斯拉
书里有一段万斯独家披露的事。
2012 年 Model S 上市,评价好到超出所有人预期,底特律的汽车媒体都说这可能是史上最好的车。加州那一波早期用户买了,但那批人消耗完之后,销售开始降温。
问题出在订单转化上。特斯拉的订金是 5000 美元,很多人交了钱排队,但都在等车的小毛病修好:雨刷会乱动,门把手会失灵,内饰达不到豪华车该有的水准。工厂在运转,车卖不出去就是在烧钱。
到 2013 年第二季度,马斯克能算出来现金什么时候见底。
他找了拉里·佩奇。万斯说,马斯克觉得佩奇不只是愿意买,还会比其他人更认真地把它做下去,因为公司的使命对马斯克太重要了。但即便如此,他仍然不完全信任对方:他要求在 Google 旗下继续当五年 CEO,还要求立刻拿到大约 30 亿美元,不只是撑过这段难关,还要把工厂往前推。
然后发生了非常马斯克的一幕。
他把公司里所有人调去打电话,不管你是 HR、市场还是工程师,每个人都去联系那些交过订金的客户,劝他们把订单转成实际购买。
两周之内,车卖得足够多,那个季度成了特斯拉历史上第一个盈利季度。消息一公布股价立刻起飞,特斯拉成了 2013 年表现最好的股票。
于是这桩交易既没有必要了,也变得不可能了:特斯拉已经贵到 Google 大概买不起。
把 10 万美元的无线电换成 5000 美元的
万斯在书里想说明一个核心判断:马斯克是把原子和比特缝在一起的最好样本。
他做的事说穿了不复杂:把硅谷那一套软件业的运作方式、迭代速度和成本意识,硬塞进那些根本还没准备好按这个速度思考的行业里。
书里有个例子。你要在火箭上装一台无线电,按 NASA 的规矩得用"航天级"的,一台 10 万美元,理由是担心辐射和别的什么东西干扰电子设备。SpaceX 自己造,一台 5000 美元,然后反复发射上去,向 NASA 证明它照样能用。或者干脆一台火箭上装四台 5000 美元的,冗余堆上去。
万斯说,马斯克确实发明了很多东西,但他更大的作用是把各种技术整合起来,把整个行业往前拽一把。他提到一个感受:除了 SpaceX,航空航天业看着有点压抑。他去过阿丽亚娜太空公司的发射,那些公司做的确实是了不起的事,可设备看着还停留在 1960 年代。马斯克说过要推出新式宇航服,说那东西疯狂极了。
周五下午三点四十五分,他自己写完新闻稿
有听众问万斯:马斯克很多言行,你分得清是精明的算计还是即兴的自我表现吗?
万斯说他自己也经常问这个问题,答案是两者都有。
他举了特斯拉工厂的例子。有台巨大的舒勒(Schuler)压机,为了把它运进工厂费了天大的劲,结果马斯克嫌颜色难看,让人全部拆下来重新喷成红色。万斯说,这是他身上最像乔布斯的部分:他会在意这种细节。
工厂本身也是一种内部宣传。你走进去很难不兴奋,那不是个阴暗的汽车车间,巨大的标识、灯光、颜色,全都在传递情绪。SpaceX 则是一片纯白,白得可以在地上吃饭,白色的台面、白色的兰花,一路白到底。
公关层面他也确实把同行打得没脾气。万斯说有时候他替那些同行难过:马斯克去 Reddit 做 AMA,洛克希德的 CEO 说我也去做 AMA,结果所有问题都是关于马斯克的。有一次特斯拉和福特同一天办活动,福特那边去了 50 人,特斯拉门外排了 5000 人,原因只是马斯克发了条推文说"我可能会展示点东西"。至于到底会展示什么,没人知道,也可能是六个月后的一次软件更新。
另一面就完全不精明了。SpaceX 要起诉美国空军,争取侦察卫星发射合同的竞标权。万斯说,换任何一家公司,你要起诉自己最大的客户、而且客户是政府,你会提前给《纽约时报》的记者打电话漏料,把话术喂过去,指望周一早上头版是一篇同情你的报道。而实际情况是:新闻稿是马斯克自己写的,周五下午 3 点 45 分写完,五分钟后直接发了出去。公关团队的反应是:完了,我们要起诉美国政府了,现在赶紧想想该怎么说。
演讲也一样。他不是乔布斯那种提前排练好几天的人,他上台就讲,有时候效果好,有时候不好。
万斯给了个公允的评价:能同时插手工程、营销和商业决策,并且每一块都做得像样、偶尔还非常出色,这种人极其罕见。
凌晨三点半的那封邮件
书出版前大约三周,印刷已经启动,万斯给马斯克寄了一本。他不想让马斯克只能在亚马逊上买一本匆匆翻完。
某天早上他醒来,收件箱第一封邮件的时间戳是凌晨 3:30,马斯克逐段看完了整本书,写了一大堆批注。有些挺好笑,比如"我吃饭不是那样的"。有些是认可,"这个你写对了"。他说书里有三处事实错误:其中两处其实是对他的评价,万斯解释那是观点不是事实;第三处是那趟横跨美国的公路旅行,马斯克说车是他买的,不是他弟弟金巴尔(Kimbal)。
中间还夹了几封语气不太好的邮件。过了一天,马斯克回来说:这书写得真好。然后他给了一个准确率评分:95%。万斯说,按马斯克的标准,对凡人来说这就是 100%。
书出来之后,《华盛顿邮报》挑了一批"最劲爆的引语",其中包括马斯克说自己是武士、不会失败,还有一段是特斯拉艰难时期他训斥一位员工,因为那人跑去陪孩子出生而没参加重要会议。这两件事马斯克看书时都没提,等媒体和读者开始负面反应,他的反应相当不好。万斯说那段时间关系有点僵,后来又慢慢恢复正常,他和塔卢拉复合了,塔卢拉对万斯还挺客气。
他像乔丹,但乔丹已经退役了
采访者在现场提了个类比:迈克尔·乔丹的名人堂演讲,别人上去都是谦逊感恩,乔丹上去把当年赢过的对手一个个点名,还专门把高中时顶掉自己位置的那个人请到现场指给观众看。马斯克身上有同一种东西。
万斯说他同意这个判断。他见过几乎所有大科技公司的 CEO,马斯克的强度在另一个层级上。他不接受"不",而且不接受的方式让人有点害怕。书里有个人形容他:他会在思考上压过你,在拼劲上压过你,还有第三样,但核心是拼劲。为了赢他什么都干。
万斯对同行有点同情:你只是个上班的人,想把公司管好,然后有个疯子走过来说"我要毁了你"。在他看来这是战争,在同行看来不过是一份 CEO 的工作。
但他也看到另一面。万斯说,尽管说了这么多,马斯克给人的感觉意外地接地气。他走进餐厅时不会摆出"我埃隆来了"的架势,就是一个走向自己桌子的人,不指望谁认出他,或者根本不在乎。他身边长期没有一堆助理挡驾,永远是"你直接跟我谈"。回答问题时他非常认真,至少是在真诚地努力。
至于这种强度会不会有一天反噬,万斯说他能看到身体上的损耗,那张脸上的疲惫是藏不住的。他还注意到一件奇怪的事:随着时间推移,马斯克做得越来越好、钱越来越多,这对他从来不是解脱。
他对比了贝索斯:贝索斯办蓝色起源的时候已经富得流油,从不需要把太空公司做成生意,想去火星随时可以去。马斯克从 PayPal 拿到两亿美元,够他花,但远不够建火星殖民地,所以他必须把太空公司做成一家能赚钱的企业。他必须拼。
等到事情开始成、钱开始变多,本该是喘口气的时机,结果变成:现在我要宣布 Hyperloop,现在我要宣布太空互联网。特斯拉刚造出业内最好的车、股价表现不错、偶尔开始盈利,他立刻把所有的钱加上新募的 20 亿美元,全部押在那座电池工厂上。
万斯说,这里头几乎有一种对"做事"本身的上瘾,他也确实享受扮演钢铁侠,享受被崇拜。所以他不会停下来。他不会选择让现状多维持一会儿。
采访者追问:那会不会有一天,他早已过了巅峰,却还是不肯放手?万斯说这个问题他没想过。
普通人能从这份材料里拿走什么
万斯写这本书用的方法,本身就有可复制的地方。他想采访一个明确拒绝配合的人,用的不是说服,是把事情先做成:先卖书、先采访几百个外围当事人,等马斯克发现挡不住,主动打来电话。
至于马斯克这个人,万斯给出的画像里,有几条是能落到具体行动上的:
- 先算清楚失败的时间点。2013 年特斯拉那次,马斯克没有凭感觉焦虑,他算出了现金哪天见底,然后带着确切数字去找救援方案。
- 把不可能的任务变成全公司的动作。两周卖爆订单靠的不是销售部门,是让 HR 和市场一起打电话。你手上最紧的那件事,真的只能由一个部门负责吗?
- 定期检查自己有没有在被"关键路径"盯着。如果连卡住整个项目的是哪一件事你都说不上来,那你大概不在那条路径上。
- 对成本假设保持敌意。一台 10 万美元的航天级设备,可能只是没人试过 5000 美元的版本。你行业里那些"必须这么贵"的规矩,有几条真的验证过?
- 留意那些把细节当情绪工具用的人。把压机刷成红色、把工厂刷成纯白,这些动作不产生直接产出,但它们决定了团队每天走进门时的状态。
- 如果你打算写一个人,别只采访愿意说话的人。万斯找到的大部分是已经离职的员工,正因为离职了,他们才肯开口。
- 接受一个事实:那种极端强度的人往往付掉了别的东西。婚姻、睡眠、正常的晚餐。看清楚代价,再决定要不要羡慕。
0:02MALE SPEAKER: Good afternoon to everybody here in Mountain View. Thanks for coming out. And to our Googlers tuning in at offices around the world, hello. Good day to you as well. We have a really exciting hour ahead of us. We're here with Ashlee Vance, as you guys know. So Ashlee's a featured journalist for Bloomberg "Businessweek." He's written a bunch-- I think over a dozen now-- feature and cover stories for Bloomberg.
0:24And we're here today to talk about his new book. I think it was out in May? ASHLEE VANCE: Yep. MALE SPEAKER: OK. It's "Elon Musk." And so you call yourself-- you can call yourself an Elon Musk biographer now. Very exciting stuff. And is the book-- I think I read it's a "New York Times" bestseller now?
0:38ASHLEE VANCE: It's been on the bestseller list just about since it came out, 12 weeks. MALE SPEAKER: Very cool. Congratulations. And its rightfully so. It's a fascinating read. If you haven't checked it out yet, I highly encourage you to do so. So we've got about 30 or 40 minutes of facilitated Q&A we're going to do.
0:53And then we have a mic in the back to pass around for audience question-and-answer as well. So to begin, so Ashlee, before Bloomberg, you were with "New York Times," "The Economist," a few other places. How'd you get into tech journalism? And specifically, how did you decide to write a book about Elon?
1:10ASHLEE VANCE: Well, I guess it's sorts of two different things. I mean, I kind of stumbled into tech journalism. I was a philosophy major at college. So I had to find a way to feed myself. And I had always wanted to be a writer, but I'd never really thought of being a reporter. And I had graduated during the dot-com boom.
1:28And there were tons of jobs. I wanted to live in San Francisco. And there were tons of reporter jobs open for anyone who wanted to be paid very little and work hard. So I did that. And I ended up liking it. I got thrown into covering semiconductors and networking equipment. I was working for a trade publication, basically, and knew nothing about any of the stuff.
1:49So I downloaded Unix, started learning about RISC chips, and then off I went. The Elon thing, I mean, I guess it does sort of come out from that a little bit. I was never the person that covered consumer tech stuff and was never like really into the-- I mean, I was into the web, but not-- it's just never the area that I really wrote about a lot.
2:15I always wrote about companies that actually made things and that had factories. And I don't know why. That's just kind of when I gravitated towards. And so I was not like that into Elon until about 2012 and I did a cover story on him. And when I saw Tesla's factories and SpaceX factories-- especially SpaceX-- I decided that's what I had to do.
2:36MALE SPEAKER: OK. Fair enough. So was Elon on board from the beginning? How did that go? ASHLEE VANCE: So in 2012, I did a "Businessweek" cover story on Elon. And we got along pretty well. I got to spend a bunch of time with him, going through the SpaceX factory. We went to movie premieres and all this stuff.
2:56And the companies were very interesting. And Elon was much more interesting than I'd given him credit for before the story. I'd sort of pegged him as just like a one-note techno-utopian kind of guy. And he turned out to be this great interview. He didn't have PR handlers around him.
3:16So you had access to him. And he would answer just about anything you asked him. And so I decided then, this is a guy I really want to write about. And I'd been looking for a book to do. And so after I did the story, a couple months went by. And then I started to feel Elon out about doing a book.
3:34And I think I either sent him an email or called him on the phone. And I said, this is what I want to do. And he said, look, a bunch of people have asked me in the past, and I'm not going to do it. I'm not going to help you do the book. And then I went to New York, and I sold the book anyway.
3:54And I thought I would sort of force his hand a little bit. And then I arranged another meeting with him. And I'll never forget. It was on a Saturday at Tesla. And I came in. I was like, look, I've sold the book. And he said, I'm still not going to cooperate with you. And so I spent 18 months interviewing hundreds of people.
4:13I found all these SpaceX and Tesla employees, most of whom had left. All the Zip2, Paypal people that he'd worked with, his ex-girlfriends, his childhood friends, and all that stuff. And then a lot of those people would call back to Elon and say, should I speak to him or not? And he was a pretty good sport about it.
4:32There's nobody that he told not to. And so I think that happened enough times that after about 18 months of doing it, I was at home. It was like 6:30 at night on a weekday, and up on my caller ID, it was Elon Musk. And I picked up the phone. And he said, look, I can basically-- this is going to go one of two ways.
4:54I can shut down all these people that call me and ask whether I should let them talk to you, or I could cooperate with the book. I was like, obviously, you should choose option b. And then we set up a meeting to talk about it. He wanted to be able to-- he wanted to have some control over it initially.
5:17He wanted to be able to read the book before it came out. And then he wanted to put footnotes in the book. And if you know anything about Elon, that would mean the footnotes would be longer than the book and that the book would probably never be published. And so I kind of pushed back on him on that.
5:34I had this huge speech prepared. And I got five minutes into it, and he just said, OK. Yeah, to his credit, after that, he gave me access to everybody I wanted. And then he agreed to have a meeting with me once a month, he said, for as long as it took. It ended up being about eight months.
5:52And we would have three-, four-, five-hour dinners. MALE SPEAKER: Wow. So the book, I have to say, especially the beginning, it reads like a suspense thriller, even though it's nonfiction because-- I don't want to give too much away, but it opens with you kind of showing up a little early for this meeting, sitting down with a drink, waiting for Elon to show up, knowing full well that this is kind of a make-or-break moment.
6:12And it goes well, like you said. I can't believe you didn't agree to his two demands, by the way. They seemed reasonable, but-- ASHLEE VANCE: There was part of me that-- so Elon's got this very unique writing style. I mean, part of me, I thought it would be like a novelty to actually see his thinking of some
6:31of this stuff. And there was like a moment in time where if he had really, really pushed on that, maybe. But honestly, I could see stuff in the book where it's like, oh, he had a turkey sandwich on this day. And then it would be five pages about why he could not have had a turkey sandwich.
6:49And it had to be a ham sandwich because he-- And it was just going to be a mess. MALE SPEAKER: Fair enough. So how does this conversation end? You get what you want. How does it end? ASHLEE VANCE: Well, it was weird. I mean, the dinner went on. I feel like that first one was like two or three hours.
7:03And it was all over the place. We walked about Larry Page a bit and AI. And then we had these other things. It was very Elon. He's kind of like, I'm looking for a PR person. And they'd say, who's the best PR person in the world? And the conversation went all these different ways.
7:21And then, I'd thought he agreed to participate in the book. And then right at the end, he's kind of getting up. And he stood up from the table first. And then he came back and he put both his hands on the table. And he looked at me in the eye. And then he said, do you think I'm insane?
7:39I'd already been through this whole huge test. My brain is going, is this the last sort of riddle? What does that mean? How am I supposed to answer this question? Is this the final test to see if he'll cooperate? And I remember all this stuff was going through my brain so fast while he's still looking at you in the eyes.
7:57And I think I just mumbled out something about-- it was like, no, I mean, I don't think you're crazy. I think some of the stuff you do could be perceived that way. But no, I mean, I'm like at least into the companies or I wouldn't be doing this. But ultimately I came to just think-- I don't think anything I said would have mattered.
8:18I think he was having this one last gut check of whether I could be at least quasi trusted. MALE SPEAKER: Trusted, OK. So if you said yes, I think you're crazy, you think he still would have-- ASHLEE VANCE: Yeah, I don't know. I think it was a looking into my eye to sort of see what happened.
8:35Or maybe, I also thought he'd already made up his mind and he was just asking himself a little bit. MALE SPEAKER: I see. I understand. So what was the process like? You mentioned about eight months, once a month, you get together. What is it like to spend a few hours a month interviewing Elon Musk?
8:52ASHLEE VANCE: It was really fun. At the beginning, it was nerve-wracking because I never knew how many of these interviews I would actually get. Even though he had agreed to it, I always figured that he might do one and they he'd be like, OK, that's enough. And then I thought he might get sick of it after a while and just cut me off.
9:11So each one felt like an accomplishment. But then it was frustrating because the first four, I really didn't-- I was getting lots of useful stuff, but nothing that was-- I could tell he was still holding back a bit. And he was repeating a lot of stories, if you watch Elon's speeches and other talks, that you would have heard before.
9:34And so that was frustrating. And then I'm still not sure exactly what happened, but around the fourth meeting-- we used to always do the same thing. We would get there. He eats really late. So it'd be like 8:30, 9 o'clock at night. And we would go a few times 'til just everybody had left.
9:50And it was kind of one of those things. There was like hardly anybody there. And he just-- it was like a flip-- the switch flipped. I think he had really committed to doing it. And he became much more relaxed and easygoing. But on the whole, it's like what I looked forward to every month.
10:09It was really fun. I mean, if you consider the idea that he might actually be the first guy on Mars, it was weird to be having dinner with this guy over and over again, and getting to ask him whatever you wanted. MALE SPEAKER: Very interesting. So we'll talk a little bit about his childhood upbringing in a moment.
10:26But something that stuck out for me when I was reading the beginning, you mentioned something from his youth. I think he's in Canada at this point. He's not even in college yet. I'm not sure if he is. And he's having a birthday party. And it's the first time where romance appears in the book.
10:42And he's sitting on this couch with a young woman. And one of the first things he says to her is, if I didn't have to eat, I wouldn't. If I could just get rid of eating and just work all the time, I would just do that. And I'm thinking, this is the '90s. This is way before Soylent or anything.
11:01So what is it like to eat with Elon Musk at 8:30? ASHLEE VANCE: Dinner with Elon is an experience. It's-- MALE SPEAKER: Really? ASHLEE VANCE: Yeah. I've never been-- the actual act of eating. MALE SPEAKER: I get it. OK, how so? ASHLEE VANCE: I've never seen anyone who eats as fast as Elon does.
11:23In that first meeting, I didn't know how long I would have him there. And so I have my tape recorder on. And I have my computer on the side as well. I always take notes even though I'm recording. It helps me to remember stuff and things. And we're going along. We ordered appetizer.
11:41First of all, Elon has to-- it takes him a while to figure out what he wants to eat. I think he's used to having a lot of this stuff taken care of for him. His assistant, when I would be at the office, she would just bring him food. And he would just scarf it down. And didn't even seem like he was paying attention to what he was eating at all.
12:03And when we'd go to these restaurants, it was like, what do you want to eat? I don't know. And we would never get anywhere. So I would make all these decisions. And we ordered a ton of appetizers. Instead of just getting one or two, then he would be like, let's just order like six things.
12:19And then I'm asking questions. And he's talking. So he's doing most of talking, and he's still-- they're just like all disappearing, one after the other. And I'm like, this is going way too'fast. I have to have this dinner last as long as possible. And they're all just-- I would look down at my computer for a second and entire things would just vanish with the plate.
12:42And then the main courses came. And the same thing was happening again. And I knew I was really on the clock. And so he had gotten some sort of seafood. I think it was octopus or squid in black ink. And then I-- Oh, no, it was lobster, fried, with black squid ink. And then I got a steak.
13:00And he'd already finished his dinner. And I was only two questions. And so I cut off half my steak and put it on his plate. And I thought, this will hold him. It was like two bites. And that was gone. And then this repeated itself over and over. I mean, I think for him food really is just fuel.
13:17MALE SPEAKER: I see that. OK. I promise we're going to leave this dinner after this question. But one more thing came up. You mentioned, I think, when we were talking before, that a few of these dinners, rambling, all sorts of subjects, but one thing that comes up occasionally is Elon's greatest mortal fear in the world.
13:33And I wonder if you'd share that with us. ASHLEE VANCE: These days, it's AI and you guys, I think. I mean, it's funny because he's friends with Larry. But OK, so at this first dinner, there's also like no small talk with Elon. So I'm coming into this thing, it's like my whole life feels like it's on the line.
13:53I've made this huge gamble on this book. And I have to convince him to participate. So I had to have a gin and tonic to try to settle my nerves before he got there. And then he's sitting down and you just say, hey, how's it going? And before his butt even hit the seat, he's like-- How's it going?
14:15My greatest-- He's like, well, I'm just consumed by this fear that Google is going to destroy mankind. That's like what he says as he's like he's getting into the chair. And he's friends with Larry. Elon doesn't have-- he splits his time between LA and Silicon Valley, but he doesn't have a house in Silicon Valley.
14:33And so he either stays at a hotel or he couch surfs-- or villa surfs-- at this group of four people. And Larry's one of those four people. So he's like a really close friend. And so that, yeah, it sort of threw me. I'm like, but you don't like sort of fundamentally think Larry's evil.
14:52He's like, no, no. It's kind of the opposite. He's kind of naively nice. And I think he felt like Larry had a-- where Elon has a cynical take on where AI's heading, he feels like Larry's too optimistic about where it's heading. And it was funny because this was 2012. And it felt like it was like the early days of Elon starting just to really become top of mind for him.
15:18And ever since then, now he's writing papers about it. He's calling out Google and stuff. So I don't know what it's like when they're at the house together. MALE SPEAKER: Fair enough. Fair enough. I understand. So for somebody who's involved with so many potentially world- and humanity-changing endeavors, does Elon have a world view or does he have a sole focus or goal or mission?
15:39And maybe if you could talk about where that might come from, if he has one. ASHLEE VANCE: I guess there's a couple levels. His driving purpose these days is to have a colony on Mars-- and not like five people, like a million people. And I think it comes with his very logical-- he's hyper
16:01rational. And it probably makes more sense, I think, maybe to a lot of people in Silicon Valley. I think to people outside of the Valley, it's a weird life's goal. But I think he thinks that something horrible could happen to the human race. And we kind of need a backup plan. And nobody else is really actively working on that.
16:22I mean, some people are, but not at the scale he is. And that he's going to be the guy that makes this backup plan. I've had a couple software developers who read the book and they're like, yes, I totally identify with the dude for this. And so that is like absolutely what he wakes up
16:41in the morning wanting to do. And I think stuff like Tesla and SolarCity, it's kind of on the way to this journey. And setting up this thing, let's try to make Earth sort of function a little bit better along the way. MALE SPEAKER: OK, I see that. In the book, you mention-- I think it's a quote from Elon when he says that he read too many comic books as a kid.
17:04Do you feel like he has that "the Earth needs to be saved" mentality? ASHLEE VANCE: Yeah, absolutely. I mean, there's a couple of bits and pieces to it. Near the end of the book, I put forward a theory that I think he is-- there's a clinical term that psychologists use called profoundly gifted.
17:23And it sounds abstract and fluffy and vague. But it's like a specific group of people who are obviously very, very intelligent, off the chart IQ scale. And they tend to exhibit similar traits. And one of them is a-- it's like this feeling that something is wrong in the world that needs to be fixed.
17:46And it's like a compulsion to want to fix it. And I think-- I'm totally convinced Elon fits into this category of people. And I also am convinced that he read probably-- I mean, he may have read every science fiction book known to man before he was about 14. At least he was probably getting close.
18:07MALE SPEAKER: I see. ASHLEE VANCE: And I think-- MALE SPEAKER: A few encyclopedias, too, it seemed like. ASHLEE VANCE: Right. I mean, he read out every bookstore in his neighborhood and every library. MALE SPEAKER: Wow. ASHLEE VANCE: And then his parents were-- he would just get encyclopedias and he would pour through those.
18:22And I think he took that stuff-- I think he took the sci-fi stuff really-- I mean, I think it resonated with him. And once he made enough money to go pursue something like building a rocket ship, that was right up his alley. MALE SPEAKER: I see. Very cool. So one thing that I also enjoyed about the book is the first chapter or two, you give this nice background on his heritage, his family.
18:45And it's nice because it's not this arduous, every relative in the family tree. But there are people there flying in very primitive planes around the world doing things that I knew a few people did back then, but I didn't realize that Elon's family-- so he's definitely got some interesting folks.
19:04Would you mind, I guess, talking a little bit about how his childhood may have shaped the person he is today? ASHLEE VANCE: Yeah, sure. Yeah, well, so, just real quick his grandfather on his mother's side, Joshua Halderman, he probably deserves a book in and of his own right because he was insane.
19:20MALE SPEAKER: Absolutely. ASHLEE VANCE: He was Canadian. And just picked up his family and moved to South Africa one day. And he used to fly his own single-engine plane. And with his wife, they flew-- this would have been-- I don't know-- must have been in the '50s, I want to say.
19:39They flew from South Africa all the way up the African coast, all the way across Asia, down to Australia. I mean, it took them-- it was like it took them a year just to get the paperwork done to do this flight. MALE SPEAKER: Wow. ASHLEE VANCE: And then one day, they decided to enter this car race from South Africa to Northern Africa in a station wagon.
20:01And they got second place, I think, in this car race. And then every weekend, or every other weekend, his grandfather would take Elon's mom and her four siblings, and they would go look for a lost city of the Kalahari out in the bush. And they would land their planes, and there would be lions in the camp and everything.
20:19So he was a chiropractor. MALE SPEAKER: There's a nice picture, I think, in the book, as well, that shows them with the plane. ASHLEE VANCE: With them with the plane. Elon tried to go-- he tried to buy the plane later in life. I mean, so I think he was definitely like a little bit of that spirit.
20:35And Elon knew his grandfather. And then they would always talk about these stories and, I think, this idea that if you want to do something, just go do it, no matter how audacious it seems. But, I mean, on the other side, Elon was-- he was a big reader and everything. He was also kind of a know-it-all.
20:58He didn't have a lot of friends growing up. Sort of his family seemed like the only ones that really would tolerate him. And at school, I mean, he was basically either kind of ignored by a lot of people or bullied, and really badly. There's one incident that he talks about where he got kicked down a flight of stairs, and then the guys stuck in-- got lit into them even more after that.
21:24He was in the hospital for about a week or two. And there were a few times like that. It was South Africa at that time-- even still today-- it's a very masculine, macho, sort of athletic culture. And Elon didn't play any sports. And he was like the bookish guy off in the corner.
21:40And then it was really funny. I mean, I went back and I interviewed-- I found all these kids that he went to grade school with. And I was really surprised. I mean, two or three of them said he was the least likely guy that we thought would do anything exceptional. It wasn't that they thought he was bad at anything or anything.
21:57It was just that he was so-- nobody thought about him. He just stayed to himself. And then he had a really horrendous relationship with his father, which, like in the book, he talks about having this horrible childhood. He never-- it's kind of unfulfilling. He never tells us exactly what is dad did to him.
22:19And in my interviews with him, there were times when he'd start to well up with tears. And he would start to talk about it. And then he would shut off. And that happened four or five times. But I think the sum total of all this stuff was, I mean, you can just play armchair psychologist,
22:36and it's like a guy who's out to kind of prove to the world he's special and can get a lot of things done and deserves our attention. MALE SPEAKER: I see. I appreciate that. I had one quote I wrote down. He says, I did not have a good childhood. It was like misery. And going off what you just said, would you say that the chip on his shoulder, do you think it formed during that time?
23:01Does he still have it? ASHLEE VANCE: Yeah. I definitely think so. There's sort of two things going on with him. He's always this independent spirit. He used to always want to get to America, to Silicon Valley, in particular. He'd read about this is where technology is happening.
23:19He got a computer at a young age and was really into it. And the second he's 17, he runs away from home with $100 in his pocket and lands in Canada. And he's backpacking around for a year. And so he had sort of an independent streak. But I do think any time you tell him no, he's going to try to prove you wrong, that he can do something.
23:50It's so funny because that quote you read, not only does any time I ask him sort of how he got through really tough times with the companies or in his life-- I mean, he always talks about his childhood. His wives always talk about his childhood being horrible, all his close friends.
24:07So this is clearly something that left this scar and this sort of need to get past it. MALE SPEAKER: I see. ASHLEE VANCE: And I do think he has a chip on his shoulder. We talked a little bit sort of like Michael Jordan kind of type figure. I mean, I do think Elon's cut using that mold.
24:26He's just relentless and takes everything as a sleight. MALE SPEAKER: I see. Thank you. To move on to maybe a little happier things, what I was struck by is, just as a lay person [INAUDIBLE] of reading the book, you know Elon is the guy, the Tesla guy, SolarCity, SpaceX. And you just think, how does one man lead all these companies?
24:48And that's cool enough. But then I'm reading about him picking up a 350-pound sumo wrestler off the ground. I'm reading about him at his birthday parties volunteering to have balloons placed all over his body, especially in between his legs, and have knife-throwers throwing knives at him.
25:06ASHLEE VANCE: These investors were not happy with that. MALE SPEAKER: Not happy with that, right? And the one that I love most is this anecdote that somebody says no to him at his company. Like, I can't do this. And you're fired on the spot. I'm going to take-- I don't know if he fires him, but he says, I'm going be CEO of my two companies, and I'm going to be CEO of your job.
25:22And I'm going to accomplish this. And he has a streak of doing it. And it always works out. Is this the profoundly gifted? Is he just like a super human, I guess, is what I'm getting at. Is he really Tony Stark? ASHLEE VANCE: Yeah, I mean, I don't-- It's kind of weird because it sounds like such a fan boy kind of thing.
25:38I mean, and I tried to have the book be really balanced. But it definitely seems like he has-- He's got a stamina and a resolve that other people, just in my experience, do not seem to have. And it's an intensity of will. And I thought this was total BS. Because I'd heard these stories about you go to him and you say this thing's impossible, and then he does it.
26:07I mean, it just sounds like total BS. Especially at SpaceX, I interviewed hundreds of people that worked at SpaceX. And many people said they saw this exact thing happen. It was like you tell him this thing can't be done and he takes over the project. And he does it. And then if he does it, you're pretty much fired at the end of that because you said it couldn't be done.
26:30And I think it takes a toll on him. When we would be at dinner, he would sometimes come in and just have this really haggard look, like somebody at the end of the marathon. And he's just sitting there at 8 o'clock at night and has been at the office all day. But he seems to be able to do that for days on end.
26:51It's really strange. MALE SPEAKER: Actually to bring up an interesting thing. I decided not to read a passage from the book, it's a couple pages long, where you talk about a typical week for Elon. And there's also a nice-- somebody put together an image of all the flights that he takes in a year, he took in one year.
27:07So how does a man run multiple companies like this? He has five kids? ASHLEE VANCE: You know, five boys, twins and triplets. MALE SPEAKER: Right. How is it possible? We struggle with the 24 hours we're given in a day. ASHLEE VANCE: There's all the stuff we talked about. And then he has a lot of help as well.
27:24But I mean, isn't it strange? It's a totally abnormal existence. So more or less, it fluctuates a little bit, but it's kind of Monday, Tuesday at SpaceX, coming in up here sort of Tuesday night. And then Wednesday, Thursday at Tesla. And then Friday back to LA. And then typically it seemed like the weekends would be whichever company was having the most immediate disaster.
27:49And the entire time I was doing the book, he worked like seven days a week. And then there's a woman in the book, Mary Beth Brown. If Elon is kind of like Tony Stark, she would be his Pepper Potts. She was with him from Paypal on. She devoted her life to him. She lived in two cities just like he did, had no boyfriend
28:18that I could discern. She didn't ever even have lunch or anything like that. And she handled his personal affairs, like scheduling custody with the kids, who was going to pick them up, like basic things like that. And then business affairs, she handled Elon's PR, more or less, for the really top-level stuff.
28:36So she was this glue that made everything work. And then he used to have a team of nannies. They've done a little nanny reduction lately. So/ they're down to two or three. And then when he's up here, he's got his staying at the friends and all that. Yeah, it's a totally crazy existences.
28:58His kids-- by all accounts, he's a very good dad. It's just that his kids live a very strange life. There's one time we're at a dinner. And he said, I just got back from Monaco with the boys. We were watching the F1 races with the prince and princess. And then his people would tell me--
29:20because he brings the kids to SpaceX on the weekends. So it's like they're so bored of going to the rocket factory. And they're like the only 10-year-old boys on the planet that are bored of going to the rocket factory. MALE SPEAKER: That's great. That's fantastic. Kind of on this thread, I remember one of his employees-- I think it's a director of one of the companies, somebody pretty high up-- said, I would be in Europe or China and send an email at 2:30 in the morning his time.
29:46Five minutes later, I'd get an answer back. It's unbelievable to have support on that level. So what toll does it take on his health and his family if he's up that late working seven days a week? ASHLEE VANCE: Well, you can see he's been married and divorced. To the second wife.
30:01He's married, divorced, married, divorced, and then gotten back together with again. MALE SPEAKER: I didn't realize that. OK. ASHLEE VANCE: I think it takes a-- I don't think he has anything resembling a normal life. There's another quote in the book where he's between wives at the moment and he says-- I was interviewing him at his cubicle in SpaceX
30:23and he's like, I need a date again. He goes, how long do you think a woman needs a week? 10 hours? Is like 10 about right? MALE SPEAKER: About the minimum would be great? ASHLEE VANCE: Yeah. And then there's another. You remind me of another thing. The guy who was talking about when he would answer emails at any time.
30:42I mean, there's one time when Elon's in bed with Tallulah his second wife. And the team at SpaceX has totally screwed something up. And it's 2:00 in the morning. And he doesn't want to wake Tallulah up. And Elon really lays into people. So he's like whisper yelling at these guys from bed.
31:04They're all huddled around the speaker phone taking this verbal lashing from him. MALE SPEAKER: That's fantastic. Did you get that story from Tallulah, or-- ASHLEE VANCE: That one-- MALE SPEAKER: --from one of the people [INAUDIBLE]. ASHLEE VANCE: That was from this guy, Kevin Brogan, who-- yeah, he was on-- So there's also this-- I don't know if this is common to every tech company, but at Elon's company, they always talk about the critical path.
31:27And so it's the one thing that's blocking the companies at any point in time. And so that's where Elon puts his focus. And so I remember Kevin was on-- he was the guy on the critical path at that moment. And so that meant that Elon's watching you 24 hours a day. MALE SPEAKER: I see.
31:40ASHLEE VANCE: Yeah. MALE SPEAKER: I think that's a good segue into just what is he like with employees? It seemed like there was a general sense of admiration, but very varied stories on either side of that line. ASHLEE VANCE: Yeah, I mean, I think Google has some of this going for it as well and is probably among the few companies that do.
31:59But I think there's like this mission that Tesla and SpaceX have that the employees fully buy into. And it's a little bit different than working at another company. If you want to go to Mars, and that's been your dream since you were a kid, SpaceX is the place you go to work. If you are into electric cars or you really care about changing the global warming situation,
32:25you buy into that. And so there is a sense of mission. And there's this faith in Elon. Especially now, I think. Pre-2012, he was struggling in a lot of ways. He has hit his stride more. And so now I think there's this real faith that if you-- you may have to work hard. You may suffer a bit.
32:46But there's nobody else is going to get it done the way he is, and that these companies are the place to do the most exciting work in those fields. It's kind of weird. The one thing that I was struck by the most is that-- at both Tesla and SpaceX, there's among the EVPs, there's a group of people that have been there really since both companies have been founded.
33:12So they've worked alongside Elon through thick and thin for 10 or 12 years and pretty much on a daily basis. And I don't think he would consider them friends. And I don't think they would consider him friends. I think it's still there's always this line drawn for him. And I don't know.
33:36I found that a little bit weird just because they have been through-- both companies have almost gone bust so many times and pulled off pretty incredible feats. So it feels like this amazing bonding exercise. MALE SPEAKER: Wow. ASHLEE VANCE: So yeah, he's always the boss. MALE SPEAKER: I understand that.
33:56OK, cool. I want to turn it over the audience in a moment here. A couple of quick last ones. Can you tell us about the time that Google almost acquired Tesla? ASHLEE VANCE: Yeah. The Model S had come out in 2012. And it had received way better reviews than, I think, anyone, even Elon, would have expected.
34:20Even the Detroit automotive press was saying this may be the best car ever built. And you had this whole first adopter wave of a lot of people in California who bought the car. We're used the early adopters, but early adopter for something that cost $100,000 and its door handles may or may not work is a leap of faith.
34:42And people bought in. Their sales were fantastic. And then things started to cool off. After you had that first wave, there were on the Tesla forums, there were glitches with the car, like the windshield wipers would go weird. The door handles would go weird. The interior was not really where a luxury car should be.
35:01And so I think a lot of people-- you have to place orders to get in line for the car. And so people would put down $5,000 to get line, but they were all waiting to actually convert that to a purchase until everything got worked out. And this was a huge problem for Tesla. Because you're running a factory, it's burning through tons of money if it's not being filled.
35:25And so it was basically, I think it was the second quarter of 2013, Elon could plot out that they're just going to run out of money. And he was good friends with Larry. And I think he felt like Larry would sort of-- because the mission of the company's important to Elon, I think, he felt like Larry not only would be sort of like into buying the company, but would see it through more than maybe some other guys.
35:54And so he turned to him for this emergency bailout. But Elon still didn't trust him enough. He wanted to remain CEO for, I think, it was five years of time within the auspices of Google. And he wanted an immediate guarantee for-- it's in the book, but it's like $3 billion, I think, of money to sort of not only see this tough time through, but advance the factory and everything.
36:23And then this very Elon thing happened. He basically took everybody in the company, whether you were in HR or marketing or whatever you did-- an engineer-- and he had everybody call every single customer who had placed a reservation and try to talk them into converting it into a sale.
36:45And within two weeks, they sold so many cars, that it ended up being Tesla's first profitable quarter. And then the stock price immediately, once they announced that, it shot up. And then it became the best performing stock of 2013. And so there was never-- not only did they have enough money to see through the quarter, then Tesla became so expensive that it was like-- I don't even think Google would've bought it anyway.
37:10MALE SPEAKER: Understandably so. Tesla almost an Alphabet company. ASHLEE VANCE: Yeah. I mean, it's a little tricky because some of the stuff was sourced in the book, so there's only so much I can say, but this was very close to happening. MALE SPEAKER: Wow. Fair enough. Very interesting.
37:28At this time, I'd love to have folks in the audience also chime in with questions as well, I think Jeremy has a mic in the back. AUDIENCE: Yeah I want to go back to your mentioning how much of an influence comic books and reading science fiction was for Musk. One of the things I'm really curious about is, looking at the industries that he's taken on, it's very sort of like Modernist perspective of transportation
37:52and energy. Even the way he's thinking about AI, I'm curious if it's reflecting this '50s, '60s view from science fiction. And meanwhile, when you think about like Philip K. Dick, you think about Cyberpunk, a lot more sort of engaging with identity, how a human identity involved, how our composition evolves through genetic engineering.
38:12Do you see him engaging in some of these more recent preoccupations of science fiction? ASHLEE VANCE: I mean, first of all, I think your point is exactly right. I mean, that's the way I sort of came-- your first point is the way I came to view the companies. I mean, like the aerospace stuff in particular is sort of depressing outside of SpaceX.
38:32I would go to launches of Arianespace and-- I mean, these companies do amazing things. But the equipment looks like it's from 1960s still. And you expect there to be these kind of modern-- you just expect it to be advanced. And it just hasn't been. And SpaceX definitely has put pressure on everybody to up their game on software, all the electronics inside of the rockets, and then more recently just with the way a capsule should look.
39:00And Elon's going to come out with new spacesuits soon that he says are crazy. And so, he's into all that stuff. And then I think that modernization of Tesla's pretty obvious, like beyond the electric car stuff, the software in the car. It's funny because people ask the second part of the question to me.
39:18Other times it's like, what? When's Elon going to cure cancer or something like that. I don't he-- I just never heard him really get into the biotech sort of-- I've never heard him even address that stuff outside of industry. It's really funny. I mean, I think that's kind of where he's locked in.
39:42Craig Venter and Elon are pretty close. And they talk about these biological 3D printers on Mars and where they want to go with that. But that was the only time I've ever heard him sort of even begin to sort of veer in that direction. One of the central arguments I try to make in the book is that Elon's-- I give you guys credit, too, but Elon is one of our best examples-- I think the best-- of combining atoms and bits.
40:09And this is obviously going to be this huge trend that we see in the next couple decades of-- essentially what he's done is take Silicon Valley, just the way you run your business, more like the way companies are run here, and then the software ethos and sort of push that into these industries that were not prepared yet to move at that speed or think that way.
40:34There's examples in the book where if you want to put a radio on a rocket, NASA would make you put this $100,000 space grade radio on the rocket. And I'm sure that was because they used to worry about the radiation and all these things messing with the electronics. And then SpaceX was building their own for $5,000.
40:56And they would have to fly it up like a bunch of times and prove to them that it still worked. Or that they could put four of the $5,000 radios on. And so, to me, Elon invents a lot of stuff, but he's this great integrator of technologies and pushing these industries forward. AUDIENCE: Thanks for talking to us.
41:15The book is great. ASHLEE VANCE: Oh, thank you. AUDIENCE: Now that the book has been published, what is Elon's response? Did he get a chance to read it before? And have you guys-- are you guys still on communication? ASHLEE VANCE: Yeah, it's complicated. Even though he didn't get to make any changes, I didn't want him to have to buy it on Amazon and speed read through it before anything happens.
41:43So I think it was about three weeks before the book came out. The presses had started and all that stuff. So I sent him a copy. And then he did this very Elon thing. I woke up one morning, and the first email, the timestamp was like 3:30 AM. And he had been going through the book paragraph by paragraph.
42:02And it was sort of like-- I mean, it was all-- it was a mix of stuff. Kind of silly things like, I don't really eat like that. And then other things, like, yeah, you got this right. And it was all over the place. It was actually kind of cool. He's like there's three factually wrong things.
42:21And two of them were opinions of him, which I was trying to explain were not facts. And then the third one, he said that Kimbal, his brother, had bought this car. They had a cross-country road trip. And he's like, I bought the car, not Kimbal. I was like, OK, I'm sure we can get to the bottom of that before the paperback comes out.
42:40And then there were a couple nastier emails. And then a day went by. And then he came back, and he said, you know, this is really well done. And he gave me an accuracy rating of 95%. Which like in Elon terms, I take that as 100% for mortals. And then basically those three weeks passed and the book came out, and then some of the press started grabbing-- like "The Washington Post" did this list of the juiciest quotes or whatever from the book.
43:13And there were a couple there, like one he said he was a samurai and he would not fail. And then the other one was about during Tesla's rougher times, him giving this employee a hard time for going to see the birth of his child when he was supposed to be at a big meeting. And that was weird, when people reacted to that in a negative way, then he reacted in a pretty negative way.
43:40It was weird because he'd never even commented on either of those things when he read the book. And so then he got [INAUDIBLE] for a little bit. And then things have been pretty normal since then. I sort of covered some Tesla stuff. He's back together with Tallulha. And she's been quite nice to me.
43:59So I don't know. Things are still a little tense, but not horrible. AUDIENCE: To what extent do you think a lot of what Musk is doing is a reaction to a failure of our institutions? The hyper loop was, essentially, his version of a back-of-the-envelope drawing. I mean, gigantic white paper, but it's a back-of-the-envelope drawing.
44:21And you see a lot of people comparing that. And I think his idea was to compare it against California high speed rail, which is this gigantic thing which used to be emblematic of our inability as a civilization to really accomplish big things. And his shtick is trying to accomplish big things.
44:37To what extent do you do you think that he's responding to that, or that that's why he seems to be so important, that sort of thing? ASHLEE VANCE: Yeah, I think you're spot on. I mean, I broke the story on the hyper loop. And I sat Elon the first time he ever talked about it. And it was exactly what you said.
44:52I mean, it was basically a brainstorm-- He saw the California high speed rail coming and thought it was so disastrous and such a horrible mistake that he had to come up with some other proposal. I don't think-- I know for a fact, he had no intention of building the hyper loop initially at all, and sort of-- well, it was more like a thought exercise and just to make people
45:20see how bad the train was and that we should be striving for something else. I think Elon, Larry, Jeff Bezos-- they're all sort of examples of people who have amassed enough wealth now to do things that governments used to do and that are proving that they can accomplish stuff on that scale.
45:50And there doesn't seem to be a willingness on the government side to tackle a lot of these things. And so I guess it depends where you are on the spectrum. If you think this is a bunch of "Star Trek" fans who have made too much and are charging around, going after these wild dreams, or if you buy into the idea that this is the direction we should head in.
46:13I mean, I think, if nothing else, Elon's set a good example for believing in the spirit. Even if you just take SpaceX, you drop the Mars thing and all that, the US used to have like 100% of the launch market. Then we went down to 0%. And we're completely uncompetitive on the worldwide stage.
46:36And now SpaceX is easily the low-cost leader that has brought us back. It's manufacturing everything in the United States. Lockheed and Boeing buy Russian engines to send up our spy satellites, which obviously the government gave up if we're doing that. So, yeah, I mean I completely agree.
46:55I think it's a really interesting time to be alive when people can go do these government-scale type things. AUDIENCE: Thanks. Love the books. And actually, I felt like I've been following Elon and Tesla and SpaceX pretty well for the last several years. And I was amazed how much I learned and how much I enjoyed hearing this sort of oral integrated way you've talked about how the stories went on.
47:15ASHLEE VANCE: Oh, thank you. AUDIENCE: That's unusual for books about Silicon Valley because normally you feel like I'm just reading what I've read before. This is for the people who live outside there. But this-- anyway-- this really broke through. ASHLEE VANCE: Thank you. AUDIENCE: My question was-- and this is more just your own gut opinion-- a lot of the stuff that Elon says and does, it's hard for me to tell if he's being really savvy and cynical, like some of the PR stuff.
47:34Or if it's just kind of vanity, and he's off the cuff and whatever. A lot of the PR feels very spontaneous, but you're not clear if he's trying to sound that way, or-- I remember when I first saw the Tesla factory, there's this giant Schuler press. And there was this crazy story to get in the factory.
47:50And then he made them take it all down and paint it red because he didn't like the way it looked. Is it crazy? Or is it brilliant? Or is it both? I'm just kind of curious how you break down those kind of decisions he makes. ASHLEE VANCE: It's funny that you ask that. There were times when I would ask myself the exact same question.
48:04It's definitely-- I think it's a mix of both. There are these almost like propaganda sort of things that he does internally, but they actually do seem to work really well. Like when you into the Tesla factor, I mean, it's hard not to be enthusiastic. And this is not some dingy car factory.
48:22This is like an exciting place making exciting cars with all this huge massive logos and the color. And at SpaceX, everything is this pristine white. You could eat off the floor. And it's like the white counter, the white orchids, the white everything all the way through. And so he has this sort of-- that, to me, was the most
48:46sort of Steve Jobs-ian part about him, is he pays attention to things like that. The other-- and then, you know, he's also very good at-- he's definitely outclassing in PR terms his peers at the aerospace companies and the automotive companies. I feel bad for them sometimes. Elon will do a Reddit AMA.
49:10And then Lockheed CEO's like, I'm going to do a Reddit AMA. And then every question is about Elon. And then I remember Tesla was having an event the same day Ford was having an event. And there were like 50 people at the Ford thing, and there were 5,000 people lined up outside of the Tesla thing all just because Elon tweeted about I may show something.
49:32And with Elon, you never know. Is it actually going to be a thing? Or is it just going to be some sort of software update that we're getting in six months or-- you don't know. Other stuff, he's just totally off the cuff and I think not very good at what he's doing. But they have to sue the Air Force to try and get
49:54the rights to bid on the launch contracts for spy satellites. It was a Friday afternoon when they announced that lately. So any other company, if you're going to sue potentially your largest customer, and it's the government, you would like do this strategically. And what you do is call up a reporter at "The New York Times" ahead of time and be like, look, I'm going to give you this-- I'm going to leak you this story.
50:18And you would sort of feed them your spin and hope the reporter does a sympathetic SpaceX story. And you have that on the front page on Monday morning. I'm pretty sure what happened was that Elon who wrote the press release himself and finished it at 3:45 on a Friday. And then five minutes later, issued the press release.
50:39And then all his PR people were like, oh, crap. We're going to sue the US government. Now let's sort of figure out what we're going to say about this. And that's, I think, probably how that kind of thing goes. And he talks about it in the book a little bit, like the speeches and stuff like that.
50:55He definitely does not do the Steve Jobs, I'm rehearsing for days beforehand. I mean, he just gets up there and wings it. And sometimes it works, and sometimes it doesn't. You definitely have to give him credit for being the five-tooled player. I mean, to be able to do some of the engineering, marketing,
51:17business decisions, the fact that he actually has a hand in all that stuff and can do it competently if not sort of excel at it at times is like completely unusual. AUDIENCE: Hi. What was the thing that surprised you about him the most? ASHLEE VANCE: I think just the once he agreed to cooperate with the book, and then we-- it's probably about like 18 months.
51:45I mean, we had this weird relationship. We were not friends. It was like a business relationship of some sort of where I was obviously on the begging end. And so he could be this wonderful guy to deal with. And then he can be a very hard guy to deal with. And the ups and downs and the intensity of that and being--
52:10I definitely am in a weird space. I have spent way more time with them than probably like a pretty select group of people, especially for a journalist, way more time. And so you would start to hear these stories and then to get like that up close and personal, to see the intensity of how it operates first it was like oh OK all this stuff makes a lot of the cell and I like I've just never met anyone who is just all in about
52:42every single thing he does. And it just felt when everything was finally all said and done and the book came out, it just felt such a relief because it had just been this crazy process. And I mean, I feel in retrospect, I really feel blessed to have sort of gotten to know kind of what it's like.
53:07And then, I don't know. And then you hear all these stories along that way. And you're like, there's no way this could be true. And then it turns out, I mean, most of them seem like they are kind of true. Just sort of the larger-than-life kind of thing. MALE SPEAKER: I've actually got one more question.
53:24We'll stop after that. And then, I think, you'll stick around for a bit for some more. Forgive me, it's kind of a rambling question. But I've been thinking about this since we spoke maybe a couple hours ago. And we compared Elon in some ways to Michael Jordan. And just a quick side thing for anybody who's listening now or watching later, highly recommend going on YouTube and looking up the Hall of Fame enshrinement speech that Michael Jordan gave a few years ago.
53:47I forget. It was about a 20-minute long speech. He gets up there. And he gets the longest speech at the end. And he's going after guys like John Stockton who he beat, defeated for years. And John Stockton goes up there as humble, grateful. He's there with his family. He's at peace.
54:03Jordan's still taking shots. He flies in the guy who was picked over him for the high school team just to point him out in the audience. I think he threw a coach out, too. So we're making some comparisons about this chip on the shoulder that Elon may or may not still have. But it's a two-part question.
54:20You've met with a lot of these other CEOs. You met with Larry for this book. Part one is how does Elon compare to these other titans in a way? And part two, I'd love to also ask you is, around time that speech Jordan gave, ESPN, I think, did a cover story about how Jordan can't sleep at night.
54:42He has cowboy Westerns on his TV that remind him of his father. And he needs them on all night to be able to sleep. Do you worry or do you think even his friends might worry that Elon someday might be past is prime and still not letting go, I guess? ASHLEE VANCE: I never thought about that one.
55:00MALE SPEAKER: It's tough. For such a-- I never would've thought about it either until we spoke ASHLEE VANCE: Yeah. So remind me exactly what the-- MALE SPEAKER: OK, first question, how does he compare to his contemporaries, his peers? They all are leaders just filled with that drive?
55:12ASHLEE VANCE: Yeah. Say Elon is unique in a couple ways. I mean, one, he is-- to his credit, I mean, despite all this stuff I've said, I mean, he's surprisingly down to earth in many, many ways. I talk about it in the book. When he comes into the restaurant, he's not I'm Elon coming in the restaurant.
55:33It's just kind of like, I'm walking to my table. He doesn't really expect anyone to kind of notice him. Or he just doesn't care. And he never had lots of handlers or it was always just-- Elon was just, deal with me. Let's just do this. And he was very earnest and authentic when he was answering questions, or at least putting a good effort forward.
55:59And then sort of the 180 part of that, though, is that intensity thing we were talking about before. I mean, he is on a-- I think I've met most of the major tech CEOs. And he's just like-- he's just on a level of intensity beyond them, you know? I would say like the Michael Jordan thing
56:22where we talked about it before. I mean, definitely does not take no for an answer on a level that's kind of frightening. And then is just relentless. There's a guy in the book who says something about Elon will out-think you, out-hustle, and there's one other part. But it's always the hustle part.
56:41He will do anything to win. When we were talking about Lockheed and the other CEOs, that's the other part where I feel sorry for them. You're just a guy who's in a job. And you're trying to run this company well. And there's this maniac who's like, I'm going to destroy you. For him, it's war, right?
57:01And for these other guys, you're a CEO running a major company. That's perfectly acceptable. And so, yeah, I think for him, it's like everything is a bit of a battle. MALE SPEAKER: I see. And the last part, though, is do you ever think it might have a toll some day? ASHLEE VANCE: Yeah, I think what I talked about, too, when you could see it on his face, that he's clearly already has like a physical toll.
57:30There's a weird thing that I've noticed, which is that as time has gone on and he's done better and better and made more money, you know the funny thing, like SpaceX, Jeff Bezos had the luxury of being filthy, filthy rich by the time he started Blue Origin. He never had to turn his space company into a for-profit enterprise.
57:51If he wants to go to Mars, he can just go to Mars. Elon had made a lot of money-- like $200 million-- from Paypal, but not enough to make a colony on Mars. So he had to make a for-profit space company. MALE SPEAKER: He had to hustle. ASHLEE VANCE: Yeah, he had to hustle. And so I think as the stuff has started to pan out for him
58:17and he's made more money, it's not like it's a relief for him. It's like now I'm going to announce the hyper loop. Now I'm going to announce the space internet. It's like it's always growing and growing and growing. I think there's almost like an addiction to doing. And I think he does enjoy the Tony Stark sort of thing.
58:38I think he enjoys the adoration of people. And so instead of it being a moment to pause and just be the status quo for a little bit, then use the money to just advance the businesses, it's like, no, now we're going to do the next crazy thing. And you see it with Tesla, too. I mean, he sort of has to build the giga factory to get the batteries down where he wants to get the price of the car down.
59:01But it's like Tesla had just hit this point. You made the best car the automotive industry has ever seen. And the stock price is doing well. You're turning a profit sometimes. And it's like, OK, now we're just going to take all the money. And then we're going to raise $2 billion more and bet the company on this battery factory the minute that happened.
59:20And so he's just relentless. MALE SPEAKER: Very cool. It's a fascinating read. That was fascinating conversation. Thanks so much for being here, Ashlee. ASHLEE VANCE: Thanks for having me. [APPLAUSE]
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版