2015年1月,德州论坛报(The Texas Tribune)办了一场交通论坛,把马斯克请到了台上。主持人本来准备的话题是特斯拉在德州能不能直接卖车、SpaceX的火箭为什么又炸了、州政府给的招商补贴到底管不管用。结果访谈快结束时,马斯克自己扔了一颗炸弹:特斯拉要建一条Hyperloop测试轨道,德州是领先候选地。
他讲这句话的口气像是在聊周末去哪钓鱼。"我们打算搞一个五英里左右的环路,德州是首要候选。"台下愣了几秒,他才补了一句,项目全部私人出资,不找州政府要钱。
整场对话信息量很大。从AI的文明级风险,到德州一条一百多年前写进法律、如今只剩汽车和酒精还在遵守的销售限制,再到火箭回收失败为什么被他叫作"快速计划外解体"。以下按话题整理。
先给AI安全掏1000万美元,而且这只是开头
主持人开场先绕到安全议题上,说马斯克做特斯拉、提Hyperloop方案,安全一直是设计里的底层原则。马斯克顺着这个话头,把话题拉到了AI。
他的判断很直接:AI的风险落在文明层面,个体层面的风险反倒是次要的。
AI是文明级别的风险,不只是个人级别的风险。这就是为什么它需要大量安全研究。(马斯克)
他已经承诺投入1000万美元用于AI安全研究,并在访谈里明确说,这只是一个开始,后面还会追加。一个造车、造火箭的人,把相当一部分注意力放到"如何不让AI失控"上,在2015年这个时间点,这个动作并不常见。
有意思的是,他谈AI风险时用了"大规模毁灭"这种词,语气却平得像工程师在描述一个需要处理的工况,一点末日预言家的腔调都没有。
德州这条法律,全美只剩汽车和酒还在遵守
话题很快转到德州。主持人提醒马斯克,2013年立法会期,特斯拉派了一支人数众多的游说团队驻扎在议会大厦,想争取直接卖车的许可,结果失败了。当时马斯克说过一句话:政治现实有时候要试三次才成。
"我希望只用两次。"马斯克在台上接话。
问题的核心是一条老法律:在德州卖车,必须通过加盟经销商(franchise dealer)。特斯拉想绕过经销商,直接把车卖给消费者,这在现行法律下不合法。
马斯克的措辞不留余地:
限制消费者直接购买,这极其不德州。这条法律居然存在,本身就很奇怪。(马斯克)
他举了一个德州人一听就懂的例子。戴尔(Dell)就是在德州起家的,靠直销电脑做到全球。如果当年电脑行业也有和汽车一样的限制,戴尔根本不会存在,或者会搬去别的州。
更荒诞的是适用范围。马斯克说,全美范围内还保留这种强制加盟限制的行业,只剩下汽车和酒精。"也许你们下次可以把酒那条也改了。"主持人笑着说。
数据摆在这里:特斯拉在全球所有其他国家都能直销,在美国50个州里有40多个能直销,只剩五六个州还堵着。德州是其中之一。
经销商真正怕的,是自己的账本
主持人问得很尖锐:是不是因为竞争?经销商怕特斯拉抢走生意?
马斯克先泼了冷水。特斯拉在德州的销量只占全州汽车总销量的0.1%。就算放开直销,撑死也就涨到1%到2%。从体量上看,特斯拉根本威胁不到传统经销商。
真正的矛盾在利益结构上。传统经销商赚的钱,绝大部分来自燃油车。让他们去跟客户推销电动车的优势,等于让他们拆自己的台。
他们大部分收入来自汽油车。你让他们去宣传电动车的好处,这是在砍自己的生意。这是利益冲突,他们不会这么干。(马斯克)
所以如果特斯拉走经销商渠道,结果只会是失败。渠道能力在这里无关紧要,真正错位的是激励机制。
主持人追问,那传统车企自己也做电动车啊。马斯克承认这一点,但指出他们卖得"非常非常少"。美国的电动车整体销量仍然很低。
他也留了余地。特斯拉在别的州做过妥协,比如纽约州,允许开最多5家直营店。按德州的人口比例折算,大概7家店。开到7家之后,可以再走加盟路线。
主持人问,那未来是否考虑传统加盟结构。马斯克说会考虑,但加了一个前提:
那些到目前为止把我们往死里揍的人,不会在考虑范围内。揍过我们的,别指望我们把他当朋友。(马斯克)
中国销量"不及预期",是统计口径的锅
主持人提到一个具体的误会。马斯克在底特律车展上透露,特斯拉2014年第四季度在中国的销量没达到预期。当时有一种说法,认为中国方面觉得充电设施不足,所以卖不动。
马斯克的解释指向一个更基础的问题:特斯拉的"销量"和"需求"是两个不同的东西。
传统车企先造车、再压库、再卖,车停在停车场里,销量和需求基本是一回事。特斯拉按订单生产,车还没造出来就已经被订走了。所以财报上统计的"销量",严格来说是"交付量"(deliveries),需求是另一码事。
真正的需求指标,是没被满足的订单积压有多少。这一点更像航空业,看的是订单储备(order backlog),当月交付说明不了什么。
现在我们的订单远远超过交付能力。我们正在解决这个问题,办法是提升产能。(马斯克)
2014年全年交付3.3万辆,低于此前的预测,被外界解读为"卖不动"。马斯克的意思是,这个数字反映的是产能瓶颈,市场冷淡解释不了它。他不太愿意公布月度销量数据,理由也是这个:口径会被误读。
当时订一台特斯拉要等3到5个月。他理想中的等待时间是1个月以内,最好是"个位数周"。这个目标能不能达到,取决于产能爬坡的速度。
电动车主不交汽油税,这笔账怎么算
主持人抛出一个德州本地非常现实的问题。德州正在为交通基建找钱,燃油税是重要来源。特斯拉的车主不加油,也就不交燃油税,那他们怎么为州财政、教育、道路出力?
马斯克的回答没有回避。他承认电动车主应该承担相应的份额,未来可能需要对电动车征收某种补充税费,来对齐燃油车的税负水平。
电动车并没有享受完全免税的待遇。电费里含着税,注册费照交,只是燃油税这一块缺口需要单独设计。真正需要重新想的,是税基结构本身。
谈到油价时他还顺手调侃了一下。"德州的油价太低了,燃油税本身也高不到哪去。"主持人接了一句"别扫兴,油价会涨回来的",马斯克回:"现在是真的便宜。"
电池工厂为什么去了内华达,不是惩罚
电池工厂选址那段最微妙。
特斯拉的超级电池工厂(Gigafactory)最终落在内华达,不在德州。外界有一种解读:德州不修改直销法律,马斯克就用脚投票,把项目带走,这是一种报复。
主持人直接把这个问题摆上台面:这是不是惩罚?
马斯克的回答很克制:
这不是惩罚。但它确实没什么帮助。(马斯克)
"没什么帮助"这四个字,比"惩罚"更值得琢磨。他没有把商业决策包装成情绪反应,但也没有假装法律环境对选址毫无影响。
他接着透露,长期来看,未来的整车工厂和电池工厂仍在规划中,德州会是强有力的候选地。他甚至半开玩笑地请求主持人:"希望这段话别变成一篇大新闻。"
事实上,马斯克在德州做生意已经13年。SpaceX的火箭研发设施在McGregor,靠近Waco,他称其为"目前全球最先进的火箭研发设施"。Boca Chica(博卡奇卡),靠近Brownsville,正在建设全球第一个商业轨道发射场。
"我爱德州,经常来。"这句话他说得很自然,不像客套。
火箭炸了,但任务成功了
话题转到Boca Chica。不久前SpaceX做了一次发射,火箭最后着陆时炸了,媒体普遍报道为"失败"。
马斯克纠正了这个说法。那次任务的主目标是给国际空间站送货,这部分完全成功。着陆是附加实验,一个此前从没有人做成过的事情。
他描述了一下其他火箭的结局作为对照:全世界的火箭级段,最后基本都是砸进大气层、爆炸,再砸到海里或者哈萨克斯坦的草原上再炸一次。欧洲的火箭、波音和洛克希德的火箭,全都一样。哈萨克斯坦甚至有一条产业链,专门捡火箭残骸。
SpaceX想做的,是把级段完整落回来。难度在于,这个玩意儿以高超音速再入,主发动机要多次重新点火,要有姿控推力器,要有挡板,还要有高超音速栅格舵。马斯克的原话是"极其困难"。
结果呢?火箭确实命中了无人回收船,只是落地速度太高、姿态太猛。
我们管这个叫RUD,快速计划外解体(rapid unscheduled disassembly)。(马斯克)
主持人笑了,说这个缩写听起来还挺好听。马斯克说,这是技术术语。
他事前对这个结果的预期是"最多50%的成功率",而且承认这个数字是"拍脑袋估的"。所以火箭炸了,他没有表现出任何沮丧。
三四週后还有一次发射。这一次再入条件更苛刻,温度更高、速度更快。他透露上次失败的直接原因是液压油用光了,这次多带了50%的液压油。"这次可能还会失败,但希望是因为别的原因。"
招商补贴:不给,我们就不来
主持人问到了德州的政治敏感话题。Boca Chica设施拿到了州政府超过1500万美元的补贴,另有500万美元来自Brownsville方面的机构(马斯克纠正说这笔钱实际还没到账)。而即将上任的副州长Dan Patrick在竞选时主张彻底取消所有企业补贴,不是改革,是终止。
马斯克的回答很坦率,甚至有点太坦率。
他先讲了一套"房东找租户"的逻辑。州政府像房东,企业像锚定租户(anchor tenant)。补贴的设计原则应该是:无论如何,州政府都要稳赚。Boca Chica的补贴就带有对赌条款,如果达不到就业和经济效益的基准,SpaceX要把钱还回去。
然后主持人问了一句关键的话:如果没有补贴,你们还会来吗?
不会。如果不给补贴,我们不会来。(马斯克)
现场有点安静。他接着解释这个逻辑:
一个州得表现出它真的想要这家公司来。SpaceX最终会在这个设施上投入数亿美元,远远超过补贴的金额。补贴在财务大盘子里其实没多大差别,但如果州里什么都不做,你会觉得自己不受欢迎。他们得有一点skin in the game(切身投入)。(马斯克)
"一点点skin in the game,一点贡献,仅此而已。"他把话说得很轻,但逻辑很硬。补贴真正买的是信号,金额本身无关紧要。
Hyperloop测试轨道,德州是领先候选
访谈接近尾声,马斯克忽然说"我有一个消息要宣布"。主持人愣了一下,说"请讲,我们挤时间"。
马斯克说,SpaceX要建一条Hyperloop测试轨道,规模大约5英里。德州是领先候选地。
Hyperloop是他在2013年发布的一份白皮书里提出的交通方案。点对点运行,比现有方式更快、更安全、更便宜,不受天气影响,抗震。加州曾有过一个提案版本,视觉上非常未来主义。
这次的测试轨道是缩比规模(subscale),不向州政府要钱,全部私人出资。"如果有人想投一点,我也不拦着。"
更具体的设想是前一晚刚和团队聊出来的,还没有完全成型:把测试轨道开放给大学团队和小公司,让他们验证自己设计的pod(胶囊舱)方案。测试轨道本身是一笔不小的资本开支,单独一家学生团队根本建不起,但如果有人先把轨道建好,生态就能长出来。
他拿Formula SAE做类比。这是全美工程专业学生的赛车设计与竞速比赛,学生组队造赛车,赛季末比赛,谁造得最好谁赢。马斯克说,SpaceX最好的工程师里,有一些就是从Formula SAE出来的,在那里学到了真正的工程能力。
可以搞一个Hyperloop版的Formula,让大家比谁的pod跑得最快,也可以比比别的维度。我觉得会挺好玩。(马斯克)
他说接下来会去和Formula SAE的组织方聊聊,看他们觉得这个想法靠不靠谱。
主持人追问时间表。马斯克说"正在研究",前一晚刚和团队讨论,大家很兴奋。主持人又追问预算,他说"我还真不知道",但重申不向州里要钱。
主持人最后确认了一遍:"德州是领先候选地。"马斯克说:"是的。"主持人说,"那我们趁他改主意之前赶紧结束。"
法案不该只给特斯拉开口子
现场提问环节,第一个问题就很尖锐。德州的这份直销法案,会不会给所有车企打开直销大门?经销商的恐惧或许就在这里:一旦口子开了,跟进直销的会是别家公司,特斯拉本身的威胁倒还在其次。
马斯克先讲了这条法律的来历。这条限制有它自己的出处,源头是当年几家大车企想把加盟权收回来,用了不少下作手段,尤其是Jack Nasser执掌时期的福特。他们对经销商施加压力,逼经销商把加盟权低价卖回给车企。
经销商当年是真金白银买下加盟权、投入时间和钱把店建起来的。他们的反抗有正当理由,于是带着这个理由去了立法机构:如果我买了加盟权、投了钱建店,车企不能靠施压逼我贱卖。这个诉求是正义的。
问题在于,这条当年为了正义立下的法律,现在被用在了一个不正义的目的上:一家从来没给过经销商加盟权的公司,被强制要求必须给。
这就像苹果来德州卖电脑,却被要求必须开苹果加盟店一样,完全说不通。(马斯克)
主持人追问:那你愿意在法案里写死"只适用于特斯拉"吗?如果经销商的恐惧就在这里,写死不就解决了?
马斯克拒绝了。
我不认为应该搞一个只给特斯拉的法案,那不公平。也许可以限定为新技术车辆,或者限定门店数量。但不该只给特斯拉。(马斯克)
但他同时划了另一条线:新法案也不能反过来侵蚀经销商已经买下、已经投入的加盟权。"那也不对。"
他的原则可以浓缩成一句:如果一家公司从没给过你加盟权,就不该被强制给你。
最后一个问题:在其他允许特斯拉直销的州,经销商到底怎么样了?那些"末日预言"应验了吗?
马斯克说,全美50个州里有40多个州特斯拉能卖车,经销商活得好好的,没有任何一个州出现经销商因此陷入困境的情况。特斯拉在30多个国家销售,那些国家根本没有加盟限制,经销商也没事。
他还举了餐饮的例子。加盟店和直营店可以并存,麦当劳就是混合模式,运行得很好。
所以他觉得这个诉求很合理:特斯拉想直销,就应该有权利直销;德州消费者想怎么买车,就应该有权利怎么买车。
整场访谈里最值得拿走的几件事
这场对话发生在2015年,很多具体议题已经翻篇。但马斯克在里面展现的几种思考方式,放到今天仍然有用。
- 区分"销量"和"需求"。当一个行业的所有人都在用同一个指标说话,而你的商业模式让这个指标失真,跟着用这套口径只会误判。把口径讲清楚,才是正事。特斯拉的订单积压和交付量是两回事,混着看必然得出错误结论。
- 看利益结构,不看表态。经销商反对直销,嘴上说的是消费者保护,账本上写的是燃油车利润。判断一个对手的真实动机,去看他的收入从哪里来,不要听他怎么说。
- 补贴真正买的是信号。马斯克说得很直白:SpaceX在这个设施上要投几亿美元,补贴金额相比微不足道,但州里什么都不做,你会觉得自己不受欢迎。谈任何合作,先想清楚对方真正在买的是什么。
- 把失败拆成可归因的模块。火箭着陆失败,他第一反应是找出具体原因(液压油用光了),下一次多带50%,并且接受"可能因为别的原因再失败"。失败的事实提供不了太多信息,能归因的原因才有价值。
- 先建基础设施,再养生态。Hyperloop测试轨道是学生团队和小公司建不起的资本项,SpaceX先把轨道建好,再开放出去让大家比pod设计。想让一个领域动起来,先看卡点是不是那个谁都建不起的东西。
- 留一条不做"只给自己开的口子"的底线。法案可以限定新技术、限定门店数量,但不该只写特斯拉的名字。这条底线短期看是让利,长期看是让规则站得住。
回到那个下午最有画面感的一幕:一个刚讲完火箭炸了、补贴谈判、法律博弈的人,被问到Hyperloop测试轨道什么时候能跑起来,他的回答是"昨晚跟团队聊的,当时喝了两杯,感觉不错"。
然后他补了一句,德州是领先候选地。
0:01and the way that you've approached the design of the Tesla cars, the way you've approached the theoretical plan for a hyperloop at some point, safety has always been baked in as a core principle of what you've done. So, it's consistent. Yeah, I think certainly I think safety safety is really important, right?
0:20you know, I think it's particularly important when there's the potential for mass destruction, right? you know, it's I mean, I think AI is something that is risky at the at the civilization level, not merely at the individual risk level, right? And that's why it really demands a a
0:41lot of safety research. That that's what sove I've committed to fund $10 million worth of AI safety research. I've AI safety research. Yeah. and I'll probably do more actually. I think that's just just that's just the beginning. That's that's the beginning. Let me ask you directly about Texas. The fact that you're in Texas is no accident. You were here during the Say again.
1:09It is Texas. Yes, I can confirm that it's Texas. You were around during the 2013 legislative session. your lobby team, large in number, was around the capital attempting unsuccessfully, it turned out, last time, to try to get permission for Tesla to sell cars directly to customers in the state of Texas.
1:27You said at the time that you'd be back that in the in the the political realities are sometimes it takes three times before I hope it's only twice. You hope it's only twice, right? Well, see you next time provisionally, but let's see if you can get it done this time. Would you talk about the issue the political and policy issues at the center of this fight? It sounds that in a state like in a state that is so good with free enterprise, right?
1:53Liberty, we want to give everybody the right to do what they want without the giant boot of government coming down on their heads. Sure. That this sounds like something that ought to be a no-brainer, but the automobile dealers and their team has a different point of view about this. So, talk talk about that.
2:07Yeah, absolutely. really all we're saying at at Tesla is that we want to be able to sell our cars direct to consumers in Texas, right? and I think this is this is actually directly in line with the ethos of Texas. in fact, restricting what consumers can do in terms of buying direct is extremely untex, right?
2:32It's it's it's very weird that it's that it even exists. I mean, you think of something like Michael Dell's company, Dell Direct. Dell direct, Dell started his computer company in Texas selling direct to consumers, right? If the same laws had existed for for computers as just for cars, right?
2:52then Dell wouldn't exist, right? Or it would be in some other state. Yeah. so it really I I think there's this something on the books that most Texans aren't even aware of that is that is fundamentally untex and and needs to be changed. And and and the restriction relates to the model for selling cars that exists in Texas today. You have to go through kind of a franchise dealership model. That is the law on the books right now.
3:18Yeah. The the law currently says that in order to sell a car in Texas, you have to sell through a franchise dealer. Right. but this exists only for alcohol and cars, which is weird, right? maybe maybe you can fix that booze problem next, actually. I mean, probably that should shouldn't exist either.
3:37it's just weird that it's cars. Like, what the right, you know, and and we and we we can sell direct in every other in every other country in the world, right? And in in in all of in we can sell direct in every state in the United States except for about half a dozen. Yeah. so it it's it's just we're just asking for essentially a modification of the law to allow us to sell direct to consumers. And is it competition, Mr. Musk? Is is that what has the the the opponents of this plan tied up in knots? Competition. They don't want you in taking away some of their As I understand the numbers right now. Mhm.
4:17Don't your sales in Texas represent.1% of the total number of cars that are sold in Texas? Yeah, I don't think we're like a huge threat to the car dealers, right? but of course, if you were permitted to sell cars directly, you might you presumably would grow those numbers to some degree.
4:34Yeah, we might grow from 0.1 to 1% perhaps or 2%. Yeah. but it's it's not something that I think is fundamentally a threat to to the cloud dealers. and and and the problem is that the the the incumbent car dealers have a conflict of interest. they make all their money from selling gasoline cars, right?
4:53for them to to then tout the advantages of an electric car when most of their money is coming from gasoline cars. They're undercutting their own deal. It's a conflict of interest, right? they're not going to do that, right? so if we were to go through them, we would fail. But of course, many of the traditional automobile dealers and and auto companies are themselves getting into the business of electric vehicles.
5:16Yeah. But but they they always sell them very very I mean the electric car sales in the United States are are very low, right? I mean and and it's but you're betting on the future, Mr. Musk. And there are obviously things that have to happen in order to enable the electric car sector to grow. There has to be adequate infrastructure which doesn't always is not always in the control of the car companies themselves. There's got to be, you know, working with government, working with local communities, being sure that we have the infrastructure that we need to to to support this this emerging sector.
5:47But the reality is if the auto companies or the auto dealers see that there is growth potential, they will get into this business in a much bigger way in the long in in the long term. Yes. and and we've actually struck compromises in a number of other states where we've we've been allowed to open, you know, let's say take the state of New York for example, we're we're allowed to have up to five stores, right, in the state of New York. So, if we were to do something like that proportion in Texas, maybe we'd have like this Texas biggest states of seven stores, right?
6:18and let's say after seven stores at that point, you know, we'd have to go to franchise or something like that. So, you'd be willing to entertain some modest Yeah. Yeah. Just to start. Yeah. Absolutely. And you indicated actually at the Detroit Auto Show this week that you would be willing at some point down the road to consider a more traditional franchise dealership structure if it came to that.
6:40yeah, we'd certainly consider that down the road, but I I can certainly say like anyone who's been a huge jerk to us thus far is not not going to be one of those. So, jerks need not apply, right? No, I mean, if they've been punching us in the face, they shouldn't expect that we're going to be their friend, right? Yeah. let let me ask you about that question of adequate infrastructure. This this came up in a weird way a misperception of the Tesla situation in China where you all reported, in fact, I think you specifically revealed at the Detroit Auto Show that fourth quarter sales of Teslas in chi in China were not where they had hoped to be, where you had
7:15hoped them to be. And there was some question about whether on the China end of this conversation they thought well you won't really don't have charging capacity that's adequate to to to make this go. Can you talk a little bit about that? And I want to understand in this country if we have a similar misperception of what's required to make this model car work.
7:34Yeah. I think I think there's a maybe a couple points that are worth clarifying. for for for for Tesla sales and and demand are are two different things because the way that sales is measured is is in terms of deliveries right whereas you know for the rest of the car industry because the cars aren't ordered in advance sales demand and and deliveries are the same thing because their cars are out on the and and that they're not they're not built to order, right?
8:12They're out in the light, right? So So very it's extremely common for people to u misunderstand demand and and sales for for Tesla for sales for us is or the the the sort of technical accounting definition of sales is how many cars did we deliver, right? But the measure of demand is how many cars have been ordered.
8:39Correct. so at we we have far more cars ordered than we can deliver right now. Now we're trying to solve that problem u by ramping up our production. So increasing production would would address that in part. Yes. It is important to note that the demand for our cars significantly exceeds our production capacity currently. So when people say, "Well, he only sold 33,000 cars in 2014, less than he predicted, or he won't reveal his monthly sales numbers because he says they'd be misleading." This is what you're talking about.
9:10Yes. I mean, maybe at some at some point this will become clear, but but but because Tesla is so is like a different different animal than the rest of the car industry, right? the the numbers mean different things. It's not apples to apples. Correct. People people look at our deliveries or sales and take that as a proxy for demand, right?
9:33whereas the actual proxy for demand is is how many unfulfilled orders do we have, right? It's it's more like the aircraft business where they'll have an order backlog. Indeed. so I mean right now the the wait time for a Tesla if you if you order one is anywhere from 3 to 5 months.
9:50Three to five months. Yes. Right. And ideally it would be with all adequate facilities in place. You'd like it to be what? A month. A month, you know, or less. Goal is to cut it down. Goal is cut down. Yeah. If we can get it down to like low single digit weeks, I think that's that's ideal, right? Let me let me ask you about one aspect of this model and the the the the cost of a car and where those dollars go that are of particular interest to Texas right now. We are engaged in an enormous conversation about funding of transportation. Well, people who buy gasoline powered cars in doing so or use gasoline powered cars indirectly contribute to the state budget in ways
10:31that we really need. And in fact, we're constantly looking for more money for transportation, more money. If if you have an electric powered as opposed to a gasoline powered car, how will your customers contribute from a revenue standpoint to the Texas budget, to education, to roads? Where are you all going to put in your table stakes to contribute to the economy of Texas?
10:53Well, I mean, there's there certainly are taxes on electricity generation. there's registration fees and that kind of thing, right? and but you're not paying gas taxes. Well, no, drivers of your cars will not pay gas taxes and therefore the revenues available to Texans through the state budget generated by gas taxes will not come from Tesla customers.
11:12I mean, gas taxes can't be very high because the price of gas in Texas is real low, right? Well, it is right now. Don't bum us out. It'll get back. It'll be okay. It'll be better. It's like super cheap, right? But the point is, you don't think that electric car customers should have to figure out a way to contribute their share as gasoline car customers do through Yeah. No, sure they should. I mean, maybe there should be at some point some some increased tax on electric cars or something like that to match that of gasoline cars, right? U but you know I mean but I mean I I I can't imagine like you said that that there's very much revenue generated from
11:52Texas on gasoline given the low price of gasoline. Now you're going to be putting a fairly heavy lobbying effort in place to get this legislation done up this session. You've got a bunch of Tesla cars now actually out by the capital today as a demonstration. Yeah. You're going to have meetings today up at the capital and you intend to really put on a fullcourt press to get this done. What's it going to take? What will be different this time than last time?
12:15Well, I think we're there's a lot more awareness. There actually are a lot of Tesla customers in Texas. again, 1500 cars sold in Texas last year, right? So, not all that many. Our voter turnout is bad, but it's not that bad. Yeah. Yeah. But still, it's there's a lot of supporters.
12:31and I think there's a lot more awareness in the Texas state legislature than this time than there was last time. Right. now we we are being outlied by the car dealers association by probably 10 to one. Well, that that's one another reality of life in Texas is he who has the biggest lobby team wins, right? That's Well, I certainly hope not. but but yeah, it's kind of crazy the the order
12:57Texas Auto dealers association has really pulled out all the stops, right? that they've said they'll spend whatever it takes to to win. I think they're spending us outspending us at least 10 to one, maybe more. but I mean but at the end of the day I think I think we have the people of Texas on our side.
13:15Yeah. and because all we're trying to do is give people in Texas the right to choose how they buy their car. Why should they be denied that right? Now, didn't you didn't you didn't you say to me earlier in this conversation, we don't want to do business with jerks? Who does who who does right? Well, so I'm wondering was was well in my business sadly it's occasionally necessary.
13:41Unfortunate, right? but my my my question is you made the decision to locate your battery plant in Nevada and not Texas. Some people perceive that to be you saying, "Well, if they're not going to change the laws to accommodate my direct sales model, I'm not going to do business with the jerk that is the state of Texas. I'm going to take my battery plant to Nevada." Is that what happened? Was this punishment?
14:04It wasn't punishment. It certainly wasn't helpful. but it wasn't punishment. No. Right. Yeah. we are actually still strongly considering the long term. you know, you know, and please hope this doesn't come become some big news article. but but we are we are considering in the long term you know f future vehicle and battery plants right and Texas would certainly be a strong contender for you've already got a presence in McGregor and Waco a company I guess it's more SpaceX than Tesla right but you have yeah you're already doing business in one part of the state you obviously have the book to switch over to the SpaceX stuff you've got the Bokeh Chica
14:48facility now the the the rocket facility down there in the valley. So you actually are doing business in Texas despite your issues with the legislation. Yeah. I mean I've been doing business in Texas for 13 years, right? so that's that's 13 years ago is when we established the rocket development rocket development facility in McGregor, right, near and that's worked out really well for us. It's the most advanced rocket development facility in the world at this point.
15:16so I think people in tech should be very proud of that. and then we've we're establishing the first commercial orbital launch site in the world at Bog Chica near Brownsville, right? so I think I mean I love Texas, you know, come here a lot. Yeah. and you know, so so yeah, I certainly, you know, big big fan.
15:38Can I can I ask you about the the the rocket facility in in the valley? you just actually had a launch within the last little while, right? Yeah. And it was perceived to be not successful because of the way the rocket landed. But the reality is the mission was really to deliver goods north and that actually was a success, right? You you were generally happy with the test.
15:59Yeah. I think within the space community certainly it was I think quite well understood that the mission was completely successful in delivering cargo to the space station which was the primary mission. and I would consider it partly successful in trying to do something which has never been attempted before which is to to to land a rocket stage successfully to to actually land a rocket stage successfully because every other rocket in the world the the rocket stages basically smash into the atmosphere, explode and then further explode when they hit the ocean or in you know the steps of Kazakhstan or something like that. so, that's what the Russians rockets.
16:44There's a there's a whole, right? There's a whole industry collecting rocket parts, by the way, out there in Kazak. It's always Kazakhstan, too, right? Well, yeah. No, I mean, no, they have they have a launch site in Placets as well. but you know, basically the Siberian steps collectively, right? and but but the you know all the other like the European rockets and the Boeing and Lockheed rockets they all all of their stages basically just smashed to bits and land there somewhere at the bottom of the ocean.
17:12and so what we were trying to do was to land land land our rocket stage but it's a very difficult thing because this thing's coming in from hypersonic velocity. It's got to do multiple relights of of the the main engine. It's got attitude control thrusters. It's got slash baffles. It's got you know and and it's got a and it's got these hypersonic grid fins, right?
17:36This is extremely difficult. And the point of this, you want to reuse rocket you want to reuse rockets or parts or what have you. You talked about the importance to be sustainable and to actually not have to consistently redo equipment for these launches and and I suspect that that was at least one goal you had in trying to land this thing safely, right?
17:56Yeah. Yeah. So, I mean in in in the sort of rocket industry, this is considered kind of crazy. so, and and like, you know, very unlikely to succeed, right? I certainly agree with the very unlikely to succeed, right? You know, thing, but but as it turns out, we were able to to actually hit the drone ship.
18:22you know, it was a sort of a higher velocity bumpy landing landing than Yeah. yeah, it's a what we call a a RUD as a rapid unscheduled disassembly, right? so I like your acronym. It almost sounds good actually. Right. Yeah. It's a technical term. Yeah. Right. well, you're pretty chill about it. I think that's good.
18:45Yeah. But but I think we've got a decent chance of of landing it intact on one of the the later missions this year. So, and you're going to try again soon, right? Yeah. in a in about three or four weeks we've got another flight. Yeah. so so now this is actually it's a tougher re-entry condition. Like it's coming in hotter and hotter and faster than the last flight. So so that does throw a little bit more of a it's a little makes a little trickier.
19:12but we've got 50% more hydraulic fluid which was the we ran out of hydraulic fluid last time. So, I think we we shouldn't if if we we may fail the landing again, but hopefully for a different reason. and but the point is you're trying again. You're not you're not particularly put off by the first result and we'll see what happens.
19:34I expected it to fail. You did. You expected it to fail. You went into it thinking it might fail. Yeah. No, I said I said I think we've got it best of 50% chance. Wow. And even that I said, I'm kind of making that up, you know. I was like, I don't really know. Yeah. Pretty good. Yeah. Good. Good guess.
19:48we're going to have to go to questions, Mr. Mus, because we we start a little late. and I've got some Twitter questions here that I'll be asking from the stage, but I want to ask you something as it relates to the book at Chica facility. We are at the beginning of a legislative session, and there are many issues before people in this room.
20:03And one of them relates to business incentives, economic incentives offered to businesses to locate in Texas. This has been a hallmark of the Perry era, now about to end as governor. He's been very successful in growing the economy in part by luring businesses here and there have been economic incentive funds that have done so. You received more than $15 million from the state and another $5 million from the city or Brownsville or from a city organization.
20:28We haven't actually received that money. Well, but it's was offered to you, but but the point is it was offered to you and there was a lot of discussion that incentives were offered to get you to come here at at the time. How important were those incentives for you to come to Texas? The incoming Lieutenant Governor, Dan Patrick, said during his campaign that he thought we ought to get rid of all incentives, not mend them, end them.
20:51So, what is your message to the Texas legislature as it relates to business incentives used to lure companies like SpaceX here? Well, I mean, I think the the the way to look at look at it is like more like like you're you're like a landlord, you know, or or you're like a and and you're looking for anchor tenants and you're making decisions.
21:14You're trying you're trying to make a decision of like if if we bring this company or this facility to Texas, is it going to be a net gain for the state or is it not? sometimes you'll be right about that, sometimes wrong, right? it's important to structure any incentives such that it's a guaranteed win for the state. and in the case of the incentives for the the Bohica facility, we have to repay those that that money if you don't meet certain state benchmarks.
21:43Yes. Related to job creation. Yes. Economic impact and all that. And a lot of them are directly tried directly tied like so we create the job that then we get on a per job basis. Would you would you have come in the absence of incentives? there are a lot the reason I asked Mr. Musk No, I think we would not have come.
22:05There are a lot of people who view those kinds of incentives. The the popular phrase these days is corporate welfare. There are a lot of people who say that we shouldn't be offering incentives to multi-billion dollar companies to come to a place like Texas. That money could be better spent on people who need it.
22:19No, we wouldn't have come because it would have been quite rude if to not have offered incentives. Okay, very good. I appreciate I appreciate your cander. That's good. Okay. There you go. All right. Can I ask the questions? Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Good. It's more like it's what I mean is that it's it's like like a state has to show that it really wants a company to to be there, right?
22:43ultimately SpaceX will spend hundreds of millions of dollars on that facility vastly in excess of what the of what the incentives would be of what the incentives would be, right? so how much do the antennas really make a difference in actually in the monetary in the grand scheme of things?
22:57Not that big of a difference, but but it's it's sort of like it's it's it you don't feel welcome like like it doesn't feel like the state really cares unless it does something, right? They've got to have a little skin in the game. There's got to be a little bit of skin in the game. there's got to be some contribution.
23:14Yep. You know, got it. That's that's really all it is. Okay, let's use the time we have left to ask some questions. And I know that the people who are keeping time for this will tell me to shut up when the time comes. First question, could the proposed Tesla bill in the legislature open up all direct car sales in Texas?
23:29In other words, would the bill apply to companies other than Tesla? And might this not be what the auto dealers fear, not so much your direct car sales, but direct car sales that would not run through them by other companies? Sure. Well, I think first of all, it's like I think when when thinking thinking about these things, you have to say
23:53what is right like what is the origin of of this bill? Like why why is there this this restriction at all? and the restriction actually originates from when a bunch of the car the big car companies tried to get back their franchises and and engaged in nefarious behavior to do that particularly Ford under Jack Nasser. So they put all these pressure tactics on the on the car dealer on on the on on the franchises to sell the franchises back to the the car company. and then the reaction of from the franchises who who had bought and paid for their franchises and who had invested all this money they their cause was just and they went with their just cause to the legislature and
24:36said look if we have bought our franchise and we've invested our time and and and money to build this franchise it is not right for the franchiseor to then engage in pressure tactics to to force us to sell it back to them at at a fire sale price, right? Obviously, that would be, you know, so the cause was just. But now they take they're taking legislation that was meant for a just cause and applying it to an unjust cause, which is to say that a company that has never granted them a franchise must be forced to grant them a franchise. This is not right. So would you be willing to stipulate, if this is what was driving the auto dealers crazy, the prospect that other companies would
25:17be selling direct, would you be willing to stipulate in your legislation that this was a Teslaon bill? If that were even possible? No, I don't think it should be a Tesla only bill. That wouldn't be that wouldn't be fair. it should it should be perhaps limited to new technology vehicles or limited to to to a certain number of stores or something like that, right? I don't think it should be just for Tesla.
25:40Shouldn't only be for Tesla. A car for Tesla. It shouldn't be only for Tesla and but but nor should it erode the franchise that they've that they've bought and paid for and have put a lot of time into. Got it. you know, that that wouldn't be right either. So, it's it's it should just be that if somebody hasn't granted them a franchise, they shouldn't be forced to grant them a franchise. It would be like like if Apple came here and wanted to sell computers in the same legislation that they'd have to like give out Apple franchise stores or something, right?
26:09That wouldn't be wouldn't make any sense. Well, the the last question we're going to have time for is actually related to this and that is to ask what has happened in fact in other states where Tesla has been allowed to sell directly. What has happened to the dealerships? Are the predictions of are the predictions of doom here have they been manifested in other places? No, I mean in in basically in in
26:31more than 40 out of 50 states, we sell cars. The the dealers are doing fine. Nobody's, you know, in in trouble or I mean this no no terrible thing has happened to the dealers in in any of the other states and like said in we currently sell in over 30 countries, right? And and and these franchise restrictions don't exist in any of those countries and the dealers are fine there. And the dealers are actually fine.
26:54Yeah. Absolutely. And there's plenty of examples where the there are franchise restaurants and company owned restaurants or a mixture of franchise and company owned like McDonald's has a mixture of company owned and they have mixture and and franchise stores. Yeah, it works fine. So I I think I think it's a pretty reasonable thing to ask that you know if we want to sell direct that we we have the right to do so and that and that you know like I said that consumers in Texas have the right to to choose how they want to buy their car, right? and and I know we're running short on time, but there's there is one sort of announcement that that I'd like to make.
27:31Oh, please news. Go ahead. We'll make time. Since this is the this is this is the trans transportation forum. Yes. so we're going to create a Hyperloop test facility. so I don't know if people have read about this sort of it's kind of a a new mode of transport. it's something that you rolled out as a as a on a white paper in 2013, right?
28:00Yeah. And it's a it's a futuristic that sometimes is negative. I don't mean it in that case. A futuristic way of going from point to point faster, safer, cheaper, immune to weather, earthquake resistant in the case of the California plan that was proposed. But it looks it looks like a very futuristic way of doing this kind of travel.
28:20Yeah. So So in order to kind of help things along, we're going to create a hyperloop test track. You are? Yeah. So something that's maybe on the order of a kind of five mile a five mile loop. Please say it's going to be here. Texas is the leading candidate. It is. Yes. Is that right?
28:46I'm I'm liking you better already. and and so does the state have to promise not to be a jerk in order to get this business? There's there's no quid proquo here. but certainly it would be nice. It would be appreciated. It would be nice. I bet. I bet. Okay. But but there's no When and when will all this go into production? The the the test facility will be begun production on that or up and running? When? What's the time table?
29:12Yeah, we're we're just figuring that out. so I just actually discussing it with some members of my team last night who were pretty excited about doing this. How big a project is this? How much money are we talking about going into something like this? I actually don't know, but we're not asking for any money from the state.
29:26so it would be it would be entirely funded. It would be entirely funded by you all. yeah, private not private public not all private funds. yeah. I mean, somebody wants to chip in, I won't stop them, right? But this is not a stock offering right up here on this, right? So, but but no, it's it's this would be kind of a a subscale track. and the the thing we were talking about last night, it's not fully formed. We're just sort of figuring it out is to to have have a test facility where different teams from you know university or
30:01or even you know little companies that people form could use this test track to kind of validate their ideas on on designing the the pod system within the in for the hyperloop. But the but the test track is quite a sort of expensive capital item. it is. so if we can build a test track and then offer that to for use by by
30:25by companies, teams of students to try out their their pod design. And something that we we we might end up doing or at least it sounded good last night after, you know, a couple of drinks. was was your your management style was okay with me. Shoot from the hip. Yeah. Right. so but but there's this really awesome competition called Formula SAE.
30:56Okay. where where students engineering students work together to design and build a race car and then they they race it at the end of the season and and then whoever builds the best race car kind of wins, right? It's like an adult soapbox derby. Yeah. But it's pretty sophisticated.
31:14and some of our best engineers have come from that program and and really really learned how to do great engineering as a result of that. And so I think it could be kind of fun to to have some sort of formula thing for for the hyperloops. Yeah. Where people could compete say okay who who could make the pod go the fastest and you know maybe compete on other dimensions and I think that could be pretty fun.
31:41Yeah. and so we're going to talk to the formula organizers and see if they if they think this would be this would be good. And Okay. Well, and and I'm just going to repeat what you said. Texas is the leading candidate to get this facility. Yeah. Okay. All right. Well, that's a good place to let's get out of here before he changes his mind. Right. Okay. Elon Musk, thank you very much. Thank you all very much.
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版