2015年,特斯拉在很多人眼里已经站稳了脚跟。Model S卖了三年,公司市值一路上涨,马斯克本人身家超过150亿美元。可就在澳大利亚电视台的镜头前,主持人问他当年被人说“这事疯了”时怎么想,马斯克的回答让现场安静了几秒:他一开始就认为特斯拉会失败。
“我不想给人留下一种印象,好像我从一开始就觉得特斯拉会成功。我其实以为我们会失败。当时我觉得成功的几率也许只有10%到20%。”(马斯克)
这个细节值得停下来琢磨。一家后来被奉为电动车代名词的公司,创始人自己给的胜率不到两成。
这场访谈发生在2015年,马斯克带着他的火箭和跑车出现在澳洲电视上。主持人一开场就把他比作托尼·斯塔克(Tony Stark),那个好莱坞电影里的钢铁侠。这个比喻并不随意,《钢铁侠》的角色原型正是马斯克本人。节目组显然想拍一个“现实版超级英雄”的故事,结果马斯克在镜头前讲的全是失败、烧钱和差点破产。
150亿美元身家背后,是两次差点归零
马斯克在南非长大,去加拿大读书,最后落脚加州,成了硅谷的明星。他最早做的生意是PayPal,一个在互联网上买卖东西的支付工具。几年后PayPal被卖掉,他拿到一笔钱,然后做了个让所有人都看不懂的决定:把大部分身家投进特斯拉,一家想用电动车打败燃油车的创业公司。
主持人用了个很直白的说法:如果有办法能一下子烧掉10亿美元,那就是特斯拉。早期这辆车贵到可以叫“5000万美元的车”,意思是公司为了把它造出来,累计烧掉的钱摊到每一辆车上,数字荒唐得离谱。
马斯克没有反驳这个说法。他只说了一句:“这真的只是开始的开始。”
真正难的地方在于,特斯拉在早期是个巨大的烧钱无底洞。马斯克在访谈里回忆,公司每个月都要花掉数千万美元,一天一天地往下消耗现金。他当时的预测是公司会失败,甚至他自己会破产,而这个预测差一点就成真了。
“说实话,那段时间挺惨的。我们几乎把钱花光了。2008年底,我不得不把自己最后一点钱投进公司。”(马斯克)
2008年是全球金融危机的年份,融资环境冷到冰点。马斯克说,如果特斯拉那年破产,他个人也会背上债务。他把自己和公司绑在了同一根绳子上。融资轮在最后一刻才谈成。
“我们在最后一天最后一个小时才完成这轮融资。那是2008年平安夜,下午6点。”(马斯克)
平安夜下午6点,这个时间点本身就说明了一切。再晚几个小时,特斯拉就不存在了。
传统车企把他当笑话,客户也跟着失去信心
钱的问题之外,还有面子的问题。马斯克说,传统汽车行业当时根本没把特斯拉当回事。
“当时我们面临的问题是客户信心危机。他们基本上在说,你看,这恰恰证明了一切。这个从硅谷来的毛头小子,以为自己能造车,他注定要失败。”(马斯克)
这种嘲笑有它的道理。造车是资本密集、供应链复杂、容错率极低的行业,底特律花了一百年才建立起整套体系。一个做支付软件出身的人跑来说要造电动车,听起来确实像笑话。
但马斯克的应对方式很特别。他没有装作自己一直很有信心,反而承认当时的状态很糟。
“那段日子挺难受的,说实话。看上去我们真的快要失败了。”(马斯克)
承认脆弱,然后继续干。这个模式在马斯克身上反复出现,后面讲火箭、讲火星的时候还会再看到。
澳洲汽车工业的衰落,成了特斯拉的收获
访谈里有个容易被忽略的段落。节目组带马斯克见了几位在特斯拉工作的澳洲工程师,其中一位曾经在墨尔本的霍顿(Holden)工作,另一位在福特干过。
主持人点出了一个残酷的现实:澳大利亚汽车制造业的衰落,正好是马斯克的收获。这些工程师在本国失业,然后被特斯拉招走,去设计新一代电动车的车身和底盘。
“能从头设计一辆电动车,这里面有巨大的吸引力。这允许我们重新思考车该怎么设计、怎么制造。我们挑战每一个环节,然后做出改变。”(特斯拉澳洲工程师)
这段话背后的逻辑值得多想一层。传统车企改一款车,是在既有平台上做局部调整,动一处牵全身。特斯拉从零开始,没有历史包袱,反而可以把电池、电机、车身结构一起重新排布。这种“没有存量”的劣势,在特定阶段变成了优势。
主持人接着抛出一个更尖锐的问题。他说澳大利亚是“油头”的国度,人们爱大卡车、大排量、爱轰隆隆的V8发动机,爱汽油,看不到他们短期内放弃石油的理由,特斯拉凭什么在这个市场卖得动?
“我认为澳大利亚人也欣赏先进技术和出色的工程。这辆车被世界上最挑剔的批评者认为是世界上最好的车。”(马斯克)
这个回答其实绕开了问题。他没说澳洲人会放弃大排量,而是说产品本身足够好,好到能让人改变习惯。这是马斯克一贯的推销逻辑:不跟用户争论观念,直接把东西做到让人没法忽视。
691马力,3.1秒,还有一个叫“疯狂”的按钮
三年前Model S上市,特斯拉才真正起飞。Model S是一辆四门轿车,外形跟大多数人印象里的电动车完全不一样。
“我们想造一辆漂亮的电动车,操控出色,加速惊人。Model S拥有史上所有四门车里最高的加速度。”(马斯克)
数据是硬的。高性能版本691马力,0到200公里每小时加速3.1秒。主持人坐进副驾,马斯克踩下油门,镜头里的主持人被按在座椅上,脱口而出一句“这太惊人了”。
车上有几个明显是马斯克个人趣味的细节。音响系统的音量旋钮最大档位标到了11,这是对摇滚纪录片《摇滚万万岁》(This Is Spinal Tap)的致敬,那部电影里的音箱“比别人响一格”,最高就是11。高性能版还有一个选择开关,名字直接叫“疯狂按钮”(Insane Button),按下去,691马力瞬间释放到四个轮子。
“我当时试着把车开出去,加速感觉太疯狂了。所以我想,那不如就在这里做个按钮,让人自己决定要不要疯狂加速。”(马斯克)
这个细节很小,但它解释了特斯拉为什么能吸引一批死忠用户。车可以只是交通工具,也可以带着设计者的性格,特斯拉选了后者。
续航焦虑是真的,但超级充电站把账算平了
电动车被诟病最多的两件事,价格和续航。大多数车主都体验过“续航焦虑”,担心电量撑不到下一个充电桩。
Model S一次充电大约能跑400公里。访谈里,节目组跟着一辆车从洛杉矶开往旧金山,全程约600公里,中途需要补一两次电。听起来麻烦,但马斯克布了一张网来化解这个麻烦。
“好在沿途都有超级充电站。点两下屏幕,充电口打开,插上枪,15分钟车就充满。更好的是,这是免费的。”(节目旁白)
15分钟,免费,这两个词组合在一起,把电动车的使用成本压到了极低。传统加油站要排队、要付费,超级充电站对特斯拉车主完全不收费。这套基础设施是特斯拉自己掏钱建的,短期看是巨额支出,长期看是护城河:车卖得越多,充电网络越密,用户体验越好,反过来又推动销量。
至于价格,马斯克的答案是规模。
“我们的第三代车型Model 3,会是一辆更小的车,产量大得多。我们的目标是把价格做到大约3.5万美元,而不是现在的4.75万美元。”(马斯克)
从7万多美元的第一代Roadster,到4.75万美元的Model S,再到目标3.5万美元的Model 3,这条降价曲线是特斯拉整个商业计划的骨架。马斯克2006年就公开写过这个路线图:先造少量昂贵的车给有钱人,用赚到的钱造中等价位的车,再用赚到的钱造大众买得起的车。2015年他讲的这段话,就是在执行第三步。
SpaceX的火箭刚炸过,他却已经在卖火星船票
访谈的后半段切到了太空。马斯克另一家公司SpaceX造无人火箭,给国际空间站运送补给,成本比NASA自己干要低得多。他挺得意地提到那份20亿美元的NASA合同。
节目组也没回避坏消息。就在访谈前不久,SpaceX的一次发射失败了。
“我们似乎经历了一次运载火箭的失败。”(马斯克)
他说这话的语气很平,像在报一个已知会发生的意外。火箭这行的容错率极低,一次失败就是几亿美元和几个月的进度打水漂。可马斯克把失败当成必经的台阶,访谈里他反复用同一个词:垫脚石。
真正让人停下来的,是他对火星的计划。节目组问起这个话题,马斯克的回答具体到让人怀疑自己听错了。
“要让火星计划成立,我们需要下一代火箭和飞船。我们认为我们已经有了方案,能让人搬到火星去,花费大约50万美元。”(马斯克)
主持人确认了一遍:“50万美元?”
“对。顺便说一句,这个价格还包含一张免费返程票。”(马斯克)
免费返程票这个说法很有意思。它说明马斯克设想的是一个可以往返的火星运输系统,并没有打算把人单程送过去。火箭和飞船要能重复使用,成本才能摊到这个量级。50万美元听起来仍然贵得离谱,可和动辄几十亿美元的航天项目比,这是把太空旅行往“中产买得起”的方向硬拽了一把。
他给这件事的理由也不复杂。
“想想未来,如果我们真的在外面探索宇宙,那会比我们永远被困在地球上要激动人心得多、鼓舞人心得多。”(马斯克)
那些嘲笑过他的人,现在开始害怕了
访谈里有一段话,信息量比前面所有技术细节都大。主持人说,很多人觉得马斯克的未来愿景令人叹为观止,但一路走来也有无数人唱衰。马斯克的回应是:
“最近几个月、几年我注意到一件事,很多既得利益者已经看明白了,特斯拉和SpaceX不会死。以前他们要么无视我们,要么嘲笑我们。现在我们真的开始取得实质进展,他们把我们当成真正的威胁。”(马斯克)
这段话解释了2015年这个时间点的特殊性。在那之前,特斯拉和SpaceX是媒体喜欢的故事,是硅谷的奇观,可主流产业界并不当真。到了2015年,Model S的销量、超级充电网络的规模、SpaceX的发射合同,都到了无法忽视的量级。汽柴油车厂开始认真算电动车对自己的冲击,传统航天承包商开始盯着SpaceX的报价。
被嘲笑不可怕,被当成威胁才说明你真的动到了别人的蛋糕。
他承认世界很糟,但拒绝当悲观主义者
访谈快结束时,主持人提到一个观察:当下关于世界的写作充满反乌托邦色彩,未来的图景被描绘得很灰暗。马斯克承认了这一点,然后给了一个挺有意思的解释。
“灰暗的故事确实更有戏剧性。但我是个乐观的人,我希望做的是把未来变好的概率最大化。这算是一种利他主义吧。你想想,如果你本来就会是未来的一部分,为什么不试着让它变得更好呢?”(马斯克)
这段话不太像金句,可它把马斯克的行为逻辑说清楚了。他做电动车、做火箭、做火星计划,心里清楚这些事大概率会失败。他押注的理由是,这些事一旦成了,人类整体的处境会更好。他算的是概率账,并非确定性账。
这也解释了为什么他敢在2008年平安夜把最后的钱投进特斯拉。那是一个低胜率的赌局,成功概率只有一两成。但他判断,如果不投,这个概率就是零。
这场访谈真正值得带走的东西
2015年的马斯克在澳洲电视上讲了四十多分钟,技术细节讲了不少,但真正有分量的,是他对失败的态度。
大多数人做决策,是先看成功率,再看回报,成功率太低的事不碰。马斯克的算法不太一样:他先看这件事做成了对世界意味着什么,再看自己能不能承受失败的代价。特斯拉当年成功概率10%到20%,他照样投,因为他判断就算失败,自己也能扛住,而一旦成功,整个汽车行业会被改写。
这个思路有个前提,他后来在访谈里用一句话带过:你本来就身处未来之中,所以试着让它变好,是件顺理成章的事。这句话听着像鸡汤,放在一个刚刚经历过平安夜融资、火箭爆炸、客户退单的人嘴里,分量不太一样。
顺带说一句,2015年这个时间点选得很有意思。往前推七年,特斯拉差点在平安夜死掉;往后推五年,Model 3量产地狱会再次把它推到破产边缘。这场访谈夹在两次危机之间,是这家公司少有的、可以稍微松一口气的时刻。也正因为如此,马斯克讲起当年的绝望才那么具体,讲起火星的价格才那么随意。
- 判断一件事要不要做,先算成功概率,再算失败你能不能承受。能承受的失败,加上足够大的回报,就值得下注。马斯克给特斯拉的胜率是10%到20%,他仍然投了全部身家。
- 别急着说服别人相信你的方向,先把产品做到让人没法忽视。澳洲人爱大排量、爱V8、爱汽油,马斯克没有跟他们争论,他只说这辆车是世界上最挑剔的批评者公认最好的车。
- 把基础设施当成产品的一部分来建。超级充电站免费、15分钟充满,短期是巨额成本,长期是别人绕不过去的护城河。
- 降价路线要提前想清楚,别走一步看一步。从7万美元到4.75万再到目标3.5万,这条曲线特斯拉在2006年就画好了,2015年讲的只是执行进度。
- 被嘲笑不算坏信号,被当成威胁才说明你动了别人的蛋糕。2015年马斯克说这话的时候,特斯拉已经被传统车企当成真正的对手。
- 允许自己在公开场合承认曾经很惨。马斯克在电视上直接说那段日子挺难受,承认脆弱不会削弱可信度,反而让后面的判断更有分量。
- 做长期决策时,算概率,别等确定性。火星计划、电动车普及、可重复使用火箭,这些事当年看都是低概率事件,可一旦成了,收益是数量级的。
- 给自己留一张返程票。马斯克讲火星时特意强调价格里含免费返程,这个细节值得学:激进的计划配上退路,才有人愿意上车。
0:00the story of Elon Musk is almost too incredible to believe he's an engineer and entrepreneur worth more than 15 billion dollars he backs himself on high-risk ventures which invariably lead to huge profits first there was paypal the way to buy and sell on the internet then Tesla the electric supercar he built and SpaceX the rocket company nASA uses now his sights are set even further afield colonizing Mars and if he reminds
0:35you of Tony stark/iron man you're right because he's also the inspiration behind the Hollywood superhero Iron Man Tony Stark is a brilliant relentlessly driven and more than a little eccentric billionaire who always aims high mr. musk how are you rotations the promotion thank you very much exactly like Elon Musk yeah good idea for an electric jet you do and if you
1:15spend any time with the real life Tony Stark thank you all for a connect tonight be prepared to move quickly but this is where our mission control and watch Patrol will be one moment he's a Rocket Man worked off of the SpaceX alpha-9 one proudly boasting his two billion dollar contract with NASA ferrying supplies to the International Space Station it's just a game kicking the ball some people that said we couldn't do it
1:49and you next minute he's perfecting another rocket his electric super fast super car the Tesla it is a beast a monster 691 horsepower yeah and will go to 0 200 kilometres in 3.1 seconds whatever he does and at whatever speed he's doing it there's always a legion of adoring Musketeers on hand
2:28what really strikes me about your staff is everyone is almost miss ionic with the official their true believers in elon musk's vision of the world sure well I mean generally I tried to discourage cult-like behavior by the way Elon Musk grew up in South Africa studied in Canada but then moved to California and became a Silicon Valley superstar by creating the online commerce business PayPal a few years
3:03later musk sold paypal for a packet he then bravely or stupidly called his great fortune into Tesla an electric car start up company that aimed to beat petrol powered vehicles well so far this is a very expensive car call this the 50 million dollar car if ever there was a way to blow a billion bucks this was it you know this is really just the beginning of the beginning alright so when people were telling you this is insane what do you say well I don't want to give the impression that I thought Tesla would be successful from the beginning I actually thought we would fail you did really i thought would maybe have a 110 twenty percent chance of success I mean sort of sin general
3:48fail and order startups especially factorable in the early days Tesla was a hugely expensive money pit and his prediction of failure and personal bankruptcy came perilously close to true you know each month that passes is literally cost us tens of millions of dollars I mean read to appreciate that it didn't help that
4:15the traditional car industry treated Elon Musk as a joke right now we're facing issue which is that it's sort of a crisis of confidence among our customers they were basically saying our all this proves it you know here's this cheeky bloke from Silicon Valley who thinks he can make a car he's gonna fail right sure how do you feel at that stage well pretty miserable honestly if they'd honestly look like we were going to fail almost ran out of money in fact at the end of two thousand eight so I had to invest up the last money that I had in the company you staked your fortune and everything yeah I would have ended up owing money if Tesla's gone bankrupt
4:54and we managed to close the financing round on the last hour of the last day that was possible so it was Christmas Eve to 2008 6pm there's the electric car maker tesla motors are at the eleventh hour musk convinced investors to get him a second chance and set out to build a completely new type of illiterate car yeah this is a
5:24full-size model can your shoulders which part and all of it the whole thing I think we can show you the whole thing the death of Australia's car manufacturing industry was Elon Musk's gains so you've been here from the very beginning on the very beginning Australian been burn it that's him on the right used to work for Holden in Melbourne he no managers play modeling of new Tesla cars I should be doing it in our own country fellow was Iran polanski used to work at Ford I can imagine there's a huge attraction in designing an electric vehicle from the ground up and that that allows us to to kind of rethink how the cars designed and manufactured we challenge everything
6:13and then we change can I be the Australian data for a moment this country is a nation of petrol heads they love their big trucks their big cars their throbbing v8's they love their gasoline I don't see them getting rid of oil anytime soon why wouldn't I trick car work in that market well I mean I think Australians also appreciate advanced technology and great engineering and that this car is regarded by why the most difficult critics in the world as the best car
6:54three years ago Tesla really took off with the launch of the Model S it's a four-door sedan that looks nothing like what most people would assume an electric vehicle to be we wanted to create electric car that it was beautiful at incredible handling great acceleration back the Model S has got the highest acceleration of any four-door car ever
7:27it's a beautiful car to drive as if playing up to his credentials as an automotive renegade musk ensured there were plenty of idiosyncratic quirks in his new car the stereo does go up to 11 thanks spinal tap and in the performance Tesla there's a curious selector appropriately called the insane button it immediately unleashes an eye-watering
7:57691 horsepower to the cars four wheels and if you push it and put your foot on the accelerator it does amazing things Wow go that's amazing it just pushes you back into the back of your seat when I was trying to car out it the acceleration felt insane so it's like well we should probably of a button there so that people would decide if they want to have insane acceleration or not so it has the
8:36speed the looks and the gadget REE but the issues that have always held the lit the cars back have been price and range most owners talk about range anxiety but this car can travel around 400 kilometers before it needs recharging so here we are enroute from LA to San Francisco and this being an electric car on that sort of journey you've got to top it up probably a couple of times to be safe the nice thing about this though is they've got these supercharging stations all along the way a couple of clicks on that it opens it up plugs it in in 15 minutes the cars energies all topped up and better still it's free
9:30which helps ease the pain of the cars high costs although the boss and chief salesman says like all evolving technology it will get cheaper our third generation cars model 3 which is it'll be a smaller car and at much higher volume we're aiming to approximately have the price of the car and be able to produce something for thirty five thousand dollars instead of four seventy-five thousand dollars are you talking yeah
10:03having Tesla's fortunes improving gives Elon Musk the chance to pursue his other greater vision space his company SpaceX builds unmanned rocket switch resupply the International Space Station more economically and efficiently than NASA looked off of the spacex falcon 9 rocket it's a risky business as musk discovered last month
10:34and we peer to have had a launch vehicle failure but even this is just a stepping stone to his most ambitious dream of all standing by for some information SpaceX is an astonishing achievement but you've also got your plans for Mars think about the future is just if we're out there exploring sighs it's so much more exciting and inspiring than one where we are forever can find to earth and a Mars mission yeah so in order to make Mars work we we need kind of the next generation of rockets and spacecraft we think we've got something that will enable people to move to Mars for approximately half a million dollars half a million dollars yeah you can get
11:20a free return to take it with that by the way so the thing that most people say about you is the vision of the future that you have is quite breathtaking and so many times along the way people have nay Sade haven't they I guess there's certainly been a lot of attacks one thing I've have noticed in recent months and years is that it's become obvious to a lot of the entrenched interests that that Tesla and SpaceX are not going to die previously they thought well they're just basically ignored us or laughed at us now we're actually starting to make real inroads and they're treating us as a real threat and so the it is it is quite daunting is
12:01actually within the power of humanity to do and I think it's something that that it's we must do Elon Musk strives for what others might think impossible thinking ahead of the curve he wants technology to improve the way we live for generations to come get the feeling that's a lot of dystopian writing about the world at the moment the future it's very bleak the way that which is cast isn't it yeah I guess bleak stories make for better drama but you're an optimist statue you're hopeful I'm hopeful I want to try to do is maximize probability that the future will be better so it's sort of altruistic but I think why wouldn't you try to make the future
12:45better if you're gonna be part of it
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版