访谈·中文精读

马斯克与德国经济与能源部长谈能源(2015)

Elon Musk talks energy with German Minister of Economy & Energy 2015

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2015年,柏林。马斯克坐在德国经济与能源部长加布里尔(Sigmar Gabriel)旁边,开口没聊特斯拉,先聊难民。

他说,今天欧洲面对的难民问题,是几百万人的规模。如果气候这件事不处理,未来这个问题会变成几亿人的规模,而且严重得多。

台下鼓掌。他没停,接着往下推:科学家给出的把握是97%。四五十年后,你的孩子问你,当年有人提醒过你们吗?你说有,所有人都提醒过。孩子接着问,那你们为什么什么都没做?

这个问题,你打算怎么回答。(马斯克)

整场对话的底色从这儿就定了。后面聊太阳能、聊电池、聊碳税、聊火星、聊人工智能监管,全是在回答同一个问题:一件已经被证明必须做、而且拖不起的事,为什么全世界都在慢慢来。

德国是太阳能世界冠军,但车轮子还在烧油

马斯克先给了一顶高帽,而且给得很具体。

他说德国在光伏发电上是全球第一,按人均算远远第一,按绝对量算也是第一梯队。他在世界各地演讲都会举德国的例子,德国人应该为此感到骄傲。这话不是客套,因为接下来那句才是重点。

发电端的可持续,没有配上消费端的可持续。德国在电力生产上做得很好,在电力消费上做得不好,因为交通几乎还是汽油和柴油。

他把这件事定性成他能给德国的最重要建议:把交通电动化,德国可以成为全世界在这件事上的样板。

顺便提了一句大众的氮氧化物排放丑闻。新闻热度很高,事情也确实坏,但他认为那不是重点。氮氧化物影响的是局部空气质量,二氧化碳改变的是整个大气和海洋的化学组成,而且几乎不可逆。两者不在一个量级上。

电池的一半生意不在车上

风不总吹,太阳不总照。可再生能源的天生缺陷是间歇性,所以电网必须配储能。

特斯拉当时正在做固定式储能产品,家用的是 Powerwall,商用和电网级的是 Powerpack。马斯克特意提到市场排序:美国之外,德国第一,澳大利亚第二。这两个是他最看重的储能市场。

这个判断后来被验证得很快。德国电价高、屋顶光伏渗透率高、电网需要调峰,家庭储能的经济性最先跑通。他把话说在2015年,属于提前看牌。

火箭要自己飞回来,火星是让人愿意起床的理由

开场白里他顺手报了 SpaceX 的进度:六到八周之后再次发射,这次要让火箭落回来。

他补了个很马斯克的免责声明:就算只是成功入轨,他也会很高兴。能回收着陆是加分项,不是及格线。

为什么要去火星,他给了两层理由。

第一层是保险。人类要成为多行星物种,才能在地球出问题时保住「生命如我们所知」这件事。他特别强调,这不是「抛弃地球去另一个星球」,前提永远是先把地球弄好,然后再向外延伸。

第二层理由更私人,也更能解释他为什么要做那些看起来不划算的事。

生活不能只是不停地解决问题。如果一个麻烦接着一个麻烦,那你早上为什么还要起床?总得有些让人兴奋、让人希望未来快点到来的事情。(马斯克)

他把这句话重复了两遍,第二遍的措辞是:总得有些东西,让你觉得活着挺好。

给德国车企的忠告:把 A 团队派去造电动车

有人问他对德国车企有什么建议。他的回答没什么外交辞令。

德国有全世界最好的汽车公司,机械工程、电气工程、化工工程的能力都是顶级的。这么多工程人才,本该大量投到电动车上。问题不在能力,在决心。

电动车不能是副业项目,必须是主干项目。他的原话是,不能让 B 团队去做,得让 A 团队上。

政府能做的,是把话说清楚:这件事重要,应该做。

这段话听着平淡,其实是整场对话里最直接的一次批评。当时德国车企的电动车基本都是合规项目,产量小、成本高、定位边缘。马斯克的意思是,你们把它当实验,它就只能是个实验。

用第一性原理重写一遍民主

有位观众问了个跳跃性很大的问题:如果把第一性原理用在社会组织上,你会得出什么结论?

马斯克的回答大概是全场最不像企业家的一段。

直接民主优于代议制民主。理由不是道德层面的,是技术层面的:代议制之所以存在,是因为过去信息传递太慢,只能把人派到首都去替你投票。现在信息瞬间可达,民意可以实时表达,中间层就失去了必要性。

中间层一消失,特殊利益集团扭曲民意的空间也会变小。

他还提了两个具体机制。

一是日落条款。法律一旦通过就几乎永久有效,这个惯性本身就是问题。所有规则应该设定有效期,到期自动失效,除非重新投票确认。

二是不对称门槛。一条法律通过需要60%的票,但任何时候只要有40%的人反对,就可以把它废掉。立的门槛高,废的门槛低。

他自己也承认这套东西听起来有点无政府主义,然后接了句:我确实偏无政府主义。

加布里尔在旁边笑着回了一句:你先把这套在美国试了,我们再跟。

二氧化碳定价为零,是市场系统里最大的一个错误

这是全场信息密度最高的一段,也是马斯克反复讲了一辈子的那套逻辑。

他说气候问题的本质是公地悲剧,是经济学入门第一课的内容:当一个外部性没有被定价,市场系统就不会正常运转。

为什么?因为价格就是信息。价格错了,行为必然错。

他把政府干预分成两类。通常情况下,政府干预会让价格里的错误变大,所以他一般主张少干预。但碳排放是例外:二氧化碳的价格本该大于零,现在被定成零,任何提高碳价的动作都是在减少价格里的错误。

推到这里,结论就很硬了:

如果碳被正确定价,电动车不需要补贴,储能不需要补贴,清洁发电也不需要补贴。所有这些激励措施,都是因为碳价定错了才被迫存在的补丁。(马斯克)

补丁不是没用,是次优。他自己说得很清楚:在碳价没被修正之前,补贴和激励是第二好的选择。

关于浓度上限,他提了个具体的问法:人类能接受的大气二氧化碳浓度上限是多少?500ppm 还是800ppm?这个数字一旦定下来,就等于给地球算出了一个碳预算总额。海洋能吸收多少,也得单独定一条线。两条线画出来,边界就能定价。

他判断,按这个边界算出来的碳价会非常高。而现在的实际售价是零。

他还给了个比喻,用来描述二氧化碳浓度的运作方式:棘轮。只能往一个方向转,转上去就退不回来。接着他把这个比喻推到了酷刑架上:刚上去的时候感觉还好,转几圈甚至有点拉伸背部的作用,再转下去就变成难以忍受的疼。

国际资本怎么才肯进来

现场有观众追问:全球有大量资金,但流不进真正需要减碳的产业。怎么建一个框架,让钱进来?

马斯克的答案还是那一套,只是换了个说法。最好的办法是对碳排放收费,次好的办法是给电动车和清洁发电补贴。激励越大,好事发生得越快。

然后他讲了一个很少被拿出来讲的讽刺:

长期看,人类必须转向可持续能源和可持续交通,这跟环保立场无关,纯粹是因为碳氢燃料总会被烧完。终点是确定的,唯一的问题是路上往大气里多塞多少碳。你可以把地底下所有化石燃料都挖出来烧掉,也可以只烧一小部分,全看你怎么设定「排碳行为」和「不排碳行为」之间的经济账。

很多国家给电动车的激励大概在10%左右。他补了一句:德国目前是零,所以比零多一点都是进步。

这时候加布里尔插话了,而且插得挺硬。他说自己完全反对用国家的钱、纳税人的钱,去补贴那些想在金融市场上赚钱的人。几年前银行业出事,国家掏了几百亿欧元,凭什么现在还要给激励。给消费者买电动车的补贴可以,替金融市场的富人设计激励,这个想法本身就不对。

马斯克的回应降低了调门:没有人主张让对冲基金经理更富。逻辑只是,如果清洁能源能让人看到回报,钱自己会来,不需要谁去劝。

一平方公里一千兆瓦,够不够用

有人问:如果全世界的车都改成电动,其他资源撑得住吗?会不会带来新的、更大的问题?

马斯克没有直接算锂和钴,他把问题提到了上一层。

全球能源大致三等分:三分之一发电,三分之一取暖,三分之一交通。这三块看起来完全不同,但共同点是需要一种不改变大气和海洋化学组成的能源来源。只要清洁发电这件事解决,再配上储能和电动交通,三块就一起解决了。电是最通用的能源形式。

然后是他那套被讲过很多次的太阳能算术。

太阳送到地面的能量密度是每平方公里1吉瓦。这个数字大得离谱。地球本来就是一台几乎完全靠太阳能驱动的机器:没有太阳,地表温度只比绝对零度高几度,整个降水循环和生态系统都由太阳供能。人类文明需要的那点能量,放在太阳的尺度上微不足道。

按20%的组件效率折算,每平方公里能发出200兆瓦。只要5平方公里,就能拿到1吉瓦。

他给了一个对比:大多数核电站的隔离区面积,铺上光伏板发出来的电,比那座核电站本身还多。

结论是,发电、取暖、交通的全部能源需求,靠太阳能为主,加上风电、地热、潮汐做补充,完全够。技术上没有障碍,剩下的只是做不做。还有一件必须做的事:停止对燃烧化石燃料的隐性补贴。

人工智能会被监管,问题只是主动还是被动

一位观众抛了个很尖锐的矛盾:你反对过度监管,又公开担心人工智能,那 SpaceX 自己被监管吗?

马斯克的回答干脆:所有交通都被监管。特斯拉被多个国家的交通部门管,SpaceX 被美国联邦航空管理局、空军、NASA 管。这么多监管之下,两家公司照样在创新。

他进一步把范围拉开:凡是公众可能受到伤害的领域,都有监管。食品、药品、交通,全都有,这些领域的进步也没停。

所以他认为,AI 研究者担心的「监管会卡住进展」,是个假问题。真正的风险在另一头:监管来得太晚。

他几乎可以肯定,长期看 AI 一定会被监管,唯一的变量是主动还是被动。历史上监管基本都是被动的,等出了事再补。

他举了安全带。

数据早就铁证如山:不装安全带,大量的人死亡和重伤。但大型车企抵抗了十年到二十年,理由是装了安全带没人买车,成本还要涨。一直扛到死亡数字堆到无法辩驳,安全带才成为标配。结果呢,车照卖,什么也没发生。

当证据已经清楚到不能再清楚,行业还是会抵抗十年二十年。这是监管被动化的代价。(马斯克)

关于超级人工智能本身,他的态度比外界想象的更诚实:他希望有解,但他不 pretend 自己有解。他提到一个技术细节,AI 的优化函数可能导致某些灾难场景只影响地球,这反而意味着把文明摊到多个行星上,不能覆盖所有风险类型。他很欢迎有人带着方案来找他。

超级充电桩不建围墙

有人关心特斯拉的充电网络会不会变成排他性的护城河。他明确否认。

对外开放只有两个条件。第一,车得能吃下高功率,吃得慢的车会长时间占着桩位,把整条网络的效率拖死。第二,按使用比例付费,用多少分摊多少成本。

他透露,已经有一家欧洲车企来谈这件事了。特意注明:不是德国公司。特斯拉的态度是完全支持。他甚至希望别的车企也来建网络,最后拼成一张共享的充电网。

三个愿望,一个就够

主持人给了一个带点玩笑性质的环节:如果对德国政府的电动出行政策有三个愿望,你会许什么?

马斯克的第一个愿望是给碳定价。

然后他说,如果第一个愿望实现了,第二和第三个就不需要了。

主持人笑着接话:客人只有一个愿望,我们已经很满足了。

他补了句闲话,说昨晚在柏林吃的那份烤肉卷(Kebab)很不错。

Model 3 还要两年多,因为电池厂是前置条件

有人催 Model 3。他的回答是:能明天发布就一定明天发布,现在的预期是两年到两年半。

卡点不在设计,在成本。电池包占了整车成本的大头,超级电池工厂(Gigafactory)必须先跑起来,Model 3 的生产线才可能同时跑起来。两条线的时间得对上,这是特斯拉内部最难平衡的一件事。

除了火箭,所有交通工具都会电动化

有人问欧洲的高燃油税。对方的意思是,这本质上就是一种碳税。马斯克同意,然后加了一句:听着是挺高,但应该更高。

接着有人问电动飞机,提到欧盟的「2050飞行路径」计划和空客的 E-Fan 电动飞机,航程大概一小时。

马斯克的评价很干脆:空客做的事非常聪明,他们在飞机电动化上投的每一分钱,将来都会觉得值。他希望波音和其他厂商赶紧跟上。

他给了一个判断:除了火箭这个反讽的例外,所有交通方式最终都会电动化。火箭必须自带氧化剂,没法从空气里取氧,所以短期内没法电气化。

他还说了句实话:如果不是手上事情已经太多,他自己一定会去做电动飞机。

共享汽车:想拿特斯拉做,先买

一位做私家车共享平台的创始人问了两次,希望把特斯拉接入分时租赁。马斯克的回答大概是他全场最不像商业计划的一段。

特斯拉现在的目标是造车,以及尽量不亏钱。就这样。

至于你想拿车去做共享,非常欢迎,买就行。他提醒了一句:我们有一座大工厂,账单得付。

  • 把碳价当成第一优先级。讨论任何环保政策之前,先问一句:这里的碳有没有被定价?如果没有,所有补贴都只是补丁,效率注定打折。
  • 看基础设施,不只看产品。储能、充电网、电池产能这些「不好看」的环节,决定电动车能不能真正铺开。判断一家公司的长期位置,就看它在这三处投了多少。
  • 警惕「B 团队项目」。一家公司说要做某件新事,先看派去的是哪批人。派边缘团队去做战略业务,等于宣布这件事不重要。
  • 把监管当变量,不当敌人。食品、药品、交通都是在强监管下持续进步的。讨论 AI 监管时,真正该问的是主动立规还是等出事再补,不是有没有监管。
  • 算清楚自己的「棘轮」。二氧化碳浓度只往一个方向走。个人层面也有类似的东西:债务、健康、信任,都是转上去退不回来的棘轮。早一点承认它的单向性,比事后补救便宜得多。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:01all right well thank thank you for having me and thanks for the the kind of introduction the you know I I guess the there's there's a lot of things in the world today that are happening that are important and that deserve our attention but I think it's it's it's always important to say what is going to be the what's important in the longterm what are the actions that if we don't take them today will result in quite a a terrible future

0:32and I think the the you know the you know to today's Refugee problem or challenge is is is perhaps a small indication of what the future will be like if we do not take action with respect to climate change [Applause] so so I mean today the challenge is in terms of of millions of people but in the future based on what the scientific consensus is the the problem will be in in hundreds of millions and and much more severe so I think it's it's very important that we we take action today to recognize that we are making a very significant change to the chemical constituency of the atmosphere and the oceans and one that is almost impossible to reverse

1:30and I think you know when we look back on on these days in the future we want to be able to say that we we did the actions that were were right the actions that that were important because I think it's very difficult to say you know if you go say 20 30 40 years in the future you know what do you say to your kids or your grandkids you know it's not as though like the I mean

1:58it's like the the scientists say that these bad things are going to happen it's like 97% so like say well to your grandkids your kids like well did nobody tell you no it's like no if everyone was telling us okay so why didn't you do anything what's the answer I think it's very important that we do something so the you know there's there's things in the news like you know the nitrous oxide thing with the VW and obviously that's that's bad but it's the CO2 thing is really the the think what what we should be most concerned about and if you look at say what is necessary for a sustainable future actually you know in one respect a very important respect Germany is a huge

2:45leader which is in solar power generation Germany is by far the the best in the world when it comes to solar power I think even in terms of in absolute terms but certainly in in solar power per capita by far the best and wherever I go in the world I say hey Germany is a great example for for solar power generation and I think people in Germany should be really proud of that that's a great thing that you've done but it needs to be it needs to be paired with sustainable consumption of energy on the transportation side so

3:26that hopefully is something that will change you in the in the near future but but you know whereas Germany is really great on sustainable power generation it's not so much on the sustainable power consumption because transport is still very much petrol and Diesel so so hopefully that that

3:49that's something that that changes I think that's the most important thing that can be done for for climate and and Germany could be a great example in this regard so so that's that's my Hope on that on that front let see and then stationary storage battery packs are also something that's important because you need sustainable power generation sustainable power storage because of the intermittent nature of renewable energy and then combine that with with electric vehicles so you at Tesla we're developing stationary storage with a power wall power pack and we think actually Germany is a very important market for that in fact outside of the US Germany and

4:39Australia are Germany first of all and in Australia are our top priorities so I think that will hopefully be helpful and then let's see would you like me to talk about space as well I'm not sure if that's okay by okay by claim so the we we hope to launch again in a couple of months so and I guess maybe six to eight weeks or so from now and then if things go well we'll be able to land the rocket and although I'll be happy if it just gets to orbit course but if hopefully it can come back and land as well and that will be an important Milestone for space exploration because ultimately I think a very you know we want to have a a very exciting inspiring future in

5:39space and in order for that to happen we really want to become a multiplet species and a space fairing civilization and I do want to emphasize a multi-planet you know it's not like another planet but over there we got to make sure things are good on Earth and then and then extend Life as We Know know it to to Mars and and Beyond and you know

6:06that will certainly be a great source of security for Life as We Know It but I think even more motivating for me personally is that trying to establish self- sustaining civilization on R would be a great adventure it will be really fun and exciting and there there need to be things that are inspiring and exciting because life cannot just be about solving problems you know if if it's just about one miserable problem after another why get up in the morning but

6:42but if there things that are exciting and inspiring and make you want the future to happen I mean that's that that that that I love that you know that's there need to be things like that so [Applause] you know there just need there need to be things that make you want to be alive so I think I think I think Mars could be one of those things and anyway that's what we're trying to make progress on with with SpaceX certainly very tricky progress

7:22but I think we're we're headed in in an exciting Direction there let's see I that's that's all I have to say in terms of opening remarks I guess we go to the interview yeah all right thank you

8:01question you're ready yeah okay well I think the I I think there should be more action the I mean Germany has some great car companies I think some of the greatest car companies in in the world and amazing engineering ability particularly with respect to electrical and mechanical engineering I think also chemical engineering Germany is probably the leader in the world so there's a an enormous amount

9:28of engineering Talent that I think could be put towards electric cars and and really and really should be and I think it's just a question of making the leap and make and and making it a mainstream initiative instead of a a side initiative it it needs to be a a mainstream program not not not sort of the like The A Team the at team needs to work on it that's a you know really important thing and I think the government can certainly can certainly help by by saying that you know emphasizing that this is important it's something that should be done so I think if if the A Team

10:12at any of the big German car makers work on electric cars it'll be a great outcome

10:59the [Music] en for economy of scale in for [Music] yes hi first of all thank you very much for having us Elan great to be here and thanks also for asking Tim Urban from web why to do this fantastic article on Tesla and why Tesla will succeed my question is the following next to electromobility which is a fundament Al part what we do at Ry is private car sharing on platforms so to make more use of underutilized products like cars bringing them on the platform and making use not only of the owner but also of other people in your vicinity in the neighborhood to rent them out while you're not using them sure so my question would be to you is this something which which you could

14:20consider as also an option to put for instance your Tesla on it sure my question is a bit off topic from the electric vehicle part it's more about if you applied thinking from first principles to the way we structure our societies what would be the principles you would start at and what would be some of the conclusions you would come to okay when do we start answering them yes that would the okay hello so

14:57what can you recommend Mr gabia to to make to to to increase the selling excuse

15:16me how can you push El emobility in Germany what do you recommend Mr musk

15:40public grants for research and innovation yeah than do you want me to ask that one yeah okay what about the other questions you should answer every Okay so them in sequence or

16:53backwards okay fair enough okay got it so I should just try to sort of broadly answer the the set of questions okay all right well I I guess maybe I'll start off with the first principal's approach to societal you know how would you do do it differently I think I think probably direct democracy is better than representative democracy and so if you're trying to represent the will of the people it would be better to have direct votes which were not possible in the old days because you had you know you have to mail things around and information moved very slowly but in in an electronic Society where information moves instantly you can you can represent very directly the will of

17:40the people and I think this diminishes the ability of special interest to influence things in a way that is contrary to the will of the people so I think that's what I I would say is probably good also that laws are laws have a infinite lifetime so you have to I think or it's probably a good idea to have something in the in the voting system that accounts for the infinite lifetime of laws and the sort of inertial effect of laws so perhaps it would be good for all all rules to have a inherent sunset provision so they would automatically expire unless they get revoted as being correct and then

18:24maybe have it have a hesis where if in order for something to become a law maybe it requires 60% vote but at any point 40% or more can remove the law this sounds sort of anarchist I suppose but I I'm kind of pro Anarchist so I would say try it in try it in the US and then we will follow you know I I think gen generally fewer rules better than Mor rules but you know that's that's my rough guess at you know if if you had to re you know recompile on on Democracy how would you do it to better represent the true will of the people which I think is the intent of democracy so

19:19then for you know for electric vehicles and CO2 I mean the the fun FAL issue we have here is a tragedy of the commons if it's economics 101 when you have an unpriced externality the market system will not function correctly and so the market system is just a it's just a set of it's it's just prices are just information so when the price when the price information is false then the wrong Behavior will occur obviously in a market economy now very often when there is government intervention the the government intervention increases the error in the prices so generally as a general rule government intervention is best to to be avoided but there are cases where government

20:10intervention decreases the error and since we know that the price of CO2 should not be zero any action to increase the the price of CO2 will reduce the error in the market system so it it will result in better Behavior the so that's that's the thing that's that's important to occur here if if CO2 is correctly priced and this is of course the correct price is a debatable proposition then then then no subsidies are needed no incentives are needed for electric vehicles no incentives are needed for battery storage or clean energy production if the CO2 if CO2 is correctly priced since we set a price of zero which is wrong then we try to make up for it with

21:04all these incentives and subsidies they're not as good as simply pricing CO2 that would be the right thing to do but in in the absence of pricing CO2 you know incentives and subsidies are are the next best thing you know that's the that's the long and short of it and we could say like you know where what is the what is the maximum part per million of CO2 that we would consider acceptable you know every year the the CO2 PPM ratchets up it's like a it's like a ratchet so it's kind of like being on on on the rack you know of like the stretching rack that old torture device you know probably you know you put you got on the rack at first doesn't feel that bad you

21:50know crack it up a few notches kind of stretches out your back not too bad but then you keep you keep not you keep ratch further fur it and it becomes excruciating so that's where that's the thing that's where we're headed so you have to say what is the what's the maximum PPM that we would consider acceptable for Earth is it 500

22:14800 that that sets our our bank account of of carbon that's acceptable in in the in the in the atmosphere and then have to say what's the what's theet level in the ocean that's acceptable and if you if we can just agree on what those numbers are then we can price that that boundary accordingly I think we'll find it's a very high price and currently we're selling it for zero could you answer the question there were were two questions first of all how could could we create a framework where the international money will go into climate friendly and hopefully social friendly Investments That was the first question I remember so there are a lot of money around the globe but it

23:07will not flow into the real Market or the real industry or the products which we need to save the climate and the second question was was what would be your advice to Germany to raise the the numbers of electric cars and to be faster and better in the electric Mobility I'm not sure if you can do but you should absolutely actually the the best thing to do is just to to to to either put put a a penalty on carbon CO2 creation or next best not as good is

23:46to provide an incentive for electric vehicles and for sustainable energy Generation the the greater the incentive the faster the the good behavior will happen now of course the great irony here is that of course in the long term we will have to go to sustainable energy generation and sustainable transport because we will simply run out of hydrocarbons to burn so we know with certainty that this is the end point the question is just do you want to get there how much CO2 do you want to put into the atmosphere before we get there like we can dig it all out and put it in the atmosphere I think there will be quite that or we could put a small incremental amount or

24:34large incremental amount it's just entirely dependent upon how you set the economics of carbon producing actions versus non-carbon producing actions so it's it's somewhat of a Continuum the the the greater the incentive the better I mean for for a lot of countries they're sort of aimed at around a 10%

24:59incentive for electric vehicles I think that's certainly helpful so it's Curr currently nothing in Germany so hopefully anything more than nothing would be good anything question SC no the question isn't answered what can we do to bring money from the international finance markets to to you know oh no that I was that was the answer but that's not that's but I would say therefore I would be completely against it's not the responsibility of the state or the normal people to give tax incentives to people who want to make money on the finance Market that's not our obligation no they have to they have to take the risk of an investment that's not the obligation of the

25:54state and I think he maybe he he he thinks about different ideas but to give incentives for consumers to buy cars electric cars that's okay sure but to think about what can we do for the rich people in the finance Market that they will invest the money in Technical Innovations which we want to have that's a crazy idea I think so I would not agree yeah but if if if you if you make the they cost they cost us some years ago billions of Euros I mean they should pay back then it's okay then I would give incentives yeah I don't think anyone's sort of arguing in paper of making hedge fund managers even richer it it's it's basically just that if in order to get

26:34them to invest they have to see that there's going to be a return on sustainable energy and and then then the they will automatically do it so that there won't be any need to coer them or anything if they see that they can get a good return on clean energy stuff then they will they will take take that action yeah

27:06hi U is this hi Elon it's a honor to be able to ask you this personally and probably before I asked my question I should say that I'm against regulation in Innovation and research overall but reading your comments on artificial intelligence research I get a feeling that you you want us you want the researchers to very careful about what we do but also perhaps be regulated in some form so if I compare that to research at SpaceX is the research at SpaceX regulated at all and if so is it enough or is it too much and who sort of keeps check of that yeah absolutely well all All Transport is is regulated oh sorry you don't want to do the we we want to collect the question right sure

27:54sure okay is okay hi Elon I I wanted I'm mday I'm from the Infinity Project and I wanted to ask this while migration to other planets is exciting and it would prevent us from a planetary catastrophe it may not prevent us from a strong artificial intelligence that's true and I if I believe that I have a solution to this problem what recommendations would you give and how would you be interested in helping out with this problem definitely interested

29:19thanks thank you could you use the mic yes hi one question about sustain sustainability since CO2 is not the only resource involved let's think to the extreme that cars run on electricity throughout the world how much do you do or think about the consequences regarding other resources because I mean might have even bigger consequences regarding chemicals Assets in the oceans and stuff like like that you think it's even

30:06possible G okay so one more question there are many ways to reduce and save CO2 and cars and transportation are just is just one of them so why precisely did you decide for cars and not for something like the heating industry for example where there's also a lot of CO2 emissions

30:30thanks okay okay okay sure well I guess it's a good question that last question on why not say heating U but really there's a general the general problem is producing energy or producing electricity which is sort of like the most general purpose form of energy in a way that does not fundamentally change the chemical constituency of the atmospher or oceans so sort of a you know sustainable energy production if as soon as you have sustainable energy production and if that's combined with stationary storage and electric transport that can cover all forms of all energy needs because I mean roughly in a sort of very top level view about a third of of all energy

31:44is electricity about a third is used for for heating and about a third is used for transport but that there's enough energy coming to us from the Sun to actually support all three areas there's really an amazing amount of energy that comes from the sun it's 1 gaw per square kilometer which is mind-blowingly huge and and actually

32:12if you think about it we the Earth is almost entirely solar powered already in the sense that we would be a frozen ice ball at a few degrees above absolute zero if not for the sun the sun Powers our entire system of precipitation and almost the entire ecosystem and then there's then there's the energy needed to power civilization which to us seems big but actually to the sun it's very tiny so

32:44as I said a Gatt per square kilometer is a super giant amount of energy and at 20% efficient solar panels that's 200 megawatt per square kilometer and I me what's interesting is if you look at most at the the sort of clearance area of of most nuclear power stations you can generate more energy from solar panels than you can from than than from that that nuclear power station is quite amazing so you know all You' need is 5 square kilometers to get to a gwatt of power which is a tiny area usually the clear area is much greater than that

33:29yeah so so no no problem to generate all the energy we need for electricity for heating for transport from solar with some contribution from wind and geothermal and tidal no problem at all we just have to do it and and then we we need to stop effectively subsidizing burning fossil fuels by by placing yeah [Applause]

34:04and let's see on the strong AI man I wish there was some solution to that I don't know if what what we can do about strong AI there are potentially some scenarios in an I you know in an AI apocalypse which only affect Earth because of the optimization function of the AI but hopefully we don't face such a situation and with respect to regulation

34:28yeah SpaceX and Tesla are are highly regulated today you know Tesla's regulated by the Department of Transport in in multiple different countries and still Tesla is able to innovate in a regulatory structure SpaceX is regulated by the FAA in the US and by the Air Force and is and

34:56by NASA effectively so and still able to innovate so I think a lot of AI researchers are afraid like if there's a regulator that will somehow stop them from making progress this is not true most in fact every Everything where where there's a danger to the public there is regulation so there's regulation in food and pharmaceuticals and transport and and and all of these areas there's significant progress made so I don't think regulation of AI is going to stop progress in AI but it may it may stop us from doing some foolish things in in AI and and it's quite I would say virtually a certainty that in the long term AI will be regulated I I would say almost a

35:49certainty the question is really is that regulation Proactive or reactive historically regulation has been reactive and in taking the car industry as an example even when the evidence is very clear that there should be regulation in for for example for seat belts seat belt regulation was fought for 10 or 20 years by the big car companies and they said that if you put seat belts in cars people won't want to buy cars and it's going to add all this cost so even though the data was unequivocal that huge numbers of people were dying and being serious injured because of lack of seat belts the car industry still refused to put seat belts in cars only eventually after the

36:35evidence and the number of the death count was overwhelming eventually they put seat belts in cars and people kept buying cars not a problem I missed anything and sorry you

37:03my name is andera Happy Tesla driver I have a quite different question actually obviously you're following your passion to make a change and I learned you built your own school for for kids in your hometown so my question is on education what is your idea on how to teach kids actually

37:24to gain like or get a passion to make it a change so how how do we teach them what do we do to need to do to to inspire them to build like be entrepreneurs or build digital products or companies so I would love to hear your ideas on that sure I think hello again I just wanted to ask you if you had some wishes free towards German politics in terms of e-mobility what would you wish for but you have only three wishes okay I will count I will count three

38:04wishes hi elen and thanks for taking your time and inspiring us all here my question is the following you're the CEO to two of the probably most important companies in the history of mankind it seems like on the side you create Innovative Transportation Concepts like the hyperloop you build solar City you bring battery packages into people's houses and obviously you somehow find the time to read a lot and and learn a lot new stuff I think the question that is on most people's mind is H how does he do it like I assume your day has 24 hours as well so what is your daily routine how how can you focus on so many different and obviously important things thanks today

38:46is today is less time because it's here yeah hello hell all just s answer yeah okay you could stand with education or sure so yeah we we're totally cool with people with other companies using our supercharger infrastructure there's no intent to create a wall Garden or to create some sort of you know protectionist thing it's basically the only requirements for using our supercharge Network are that the car needs to be able to take the high power level cuz if it's if it's really low power level it's going to hog the spot and sit there for too long so it's got to be able to be charged fast and then there just needs to be proportionate payment for so

40:11however much the other manufacturers cars are using the network that they should just pay that proportion which I think is pretty fair and they actually a see of one European car company not a German car company has approached us recently about doing exactly that and we're super supportive of anyone that wants to do that and if if other car companies want to also create networks and we can have a shared network that'd be cool and we're for for anything that's going to promote the future of electric vehicles so anything we can do to be genuinely supportive we want to we want to do that in terms of The Wishes I think the you know anything we can do to address the fact

40:51that there's that that that CO2 is being done for free you know you know there there's always like budgets to deal with and and whatnot but anything to kind of even the playing field for CO2 production versus non-co2 producing cars you know so I don't know sometimes like like a a 10% subsidy I mean the best thing like I said the best thing would be to price CO2 that is by far the best thing and then no subsidies or anything are needed for electric vehicles but then people will find that the CO2 producing things are a lot more expensive than they realized and so I don't know which one is worse I mean perfectly I would say if my number one wish would be price CO2 correctly and

41:37then the good things will happen yeah I'll just take one wish that'll do it that's it oh jeez two and three jeez well if I got wish one I think it would be great wouldn't really need anything more sorry I can't do probably oh sure absolutely yeah had a this great food in Germany actually so had this great Kebab last night actually and this in this minut we are happy if a guest has only one wish I mean we are very happy that's it I mean I be you know I think yeah that's it I don't really have anything more

43:18tesil for the being good in fr in [Applause] then [Applause] that's thanks a lot for visiting us it's it's a great honor and I hope that we can realize some of your ideas and projects in Germany and whenever you come to Europe visit us and let's discuss also about the gigawatt battery Factory we need some of these ideas to promote innovation in our country thanks a lot all right thank you we had this this Refugee meeting

46:40what up do you still have time I think so do we okay yes we have okay

47:08my okay can I just answer the questions my yeah yeah so so the I I'll answer them rapid fire so the with the model 3 I mean I go if we could bring the model 3 out tomorrow we absolutely would it's it's going to happen as fast as we possibly can our expectation right now is about two two two and a half years for the model 3 we got to get the gigafactory operational and the model 3 production line operational at the same time so gig gigafactory is a necessary precurser because of the cost of the battery pack before we can have the model 3 in production so it is tricky timing we got to balance that at Tesla internally but it's going to be as fast as we possibly can two two

48:28and a half years so so a quick point and a question first point is in Europe we have very very high fuel Duty which is kind of also a tax on co2 if you look at it like that and the second question is you may be that's true could be higher but yeah I agree with you but it's it's it's too it it sounds high but it should be higher yeah I maybe you're right yeah and the second you heard of flight path 2050 and so this is a European initiative to man 2050 I hope we're all around to freaking talk in a little long it's a long distance May civilization still be around so air bu is air bu is playing around with making little electric aircraft they got a range of like an

49:06hour I think it's great what they're doing with the Ean so the question is you've got an aerospace company and a car company specializing in battery technologies so when are you going to be building a new electric airliner oh man I got a lot of fresh I got a lot a lot of fish frying right now I I'd love to be working on electric aircraft I think All Transport with the ironic exception of rockets will go electric so I think what Airbus is doing with electric aircraft is really smart and I think they will be very happy with any it's it's and any investment that they make in electrification of aircraft they will be very happy they did that down

49:44the road it's absolutely The Right Move so I think it's very encouraging what they're doing hopefully Boeing and other aircraft companies start doing the same thing because we we did we need electrification aircraft as well as of cars I mean if if I wasn't super strung out I would for sure be doing electric aircraft I el el just just one short

50:10question read addressing the car sharing Mobility from before obviously there are huge inroads now from Uber Google Etc who do very smart technology and Ma they have their Mass departments who understand where you guys going to go from A to B and then pick up other people while you go on it you obviously do very beautiful model with them s model and then down the road you go probably for the commodation of cars would you consider car sharing like what we do with drive as a startup a worthwhile Endeavor or would you put Teslas on it I mean from a Tesla standpoint we we've we've just got to build cars and try to not lose money like that's our goal it's like it was

50:46like aspiration so so you could offset the costs like the Tesla Model is quite expensive I mean go ahead I mean go ahead and buy them no problem but just remember like like we got a big Factory and we got to pay the bills sure it's actually private cars so everybody here could actually

51:23do thank you for being with us thank you for your great comments and [Applause]

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份