2015 年 12 月,旧金山,美国地球物理联合会(AGU)秋季会议。台下坐着几千名研究地球、海洋、大气的科学家。马斯克上台,主持人先抛了一个方法论问题:面对一个别人都没解决过的问题,你从哪儿下手?
马斯克的回答,基本浓缩了他后来十年被引用最多的那套思维工具。
他说,人类日常活着靠的是类比。看别人怎么做,稍微改一改,照搬过来。这是大脑在算力有限时的抄近道方式。可如果你要做的事情是全新的,尤其反直觉,类比就不管用了,还可能把方向带偏。这时候只能用第一性原理(first principles):把问题拆到最基本、看起来最简单的事实,再从那里往上推。
他补了一句:这很费脑子,你不可能对每件事都这么干。但要解决新问题,这基本是唯一的路。
后面一整场对话,他都在用这个方法拆东西。拆碳税、拆教育、拆火箭、拆能源。拆出来的结论常常让人不舒服,又很难反驳。
把碳排放想成不交垃圾费
主持人在巴黎气候大会(COP21)结束不久后见到马斯克,提起他在索邦大学对学生讲的那个比喻。
马斯克说,碳循环的问题,本质上跟不交垃圾费一个道理。
垃圾处理这件事,没人会说要建一个零垃圾社会。那太难了。真正重要的是大家都付垃圾费。可现在碳排放这摊事,等于全球每年在偷偷给化石燃料发一笔巨额补贴,却没有人为这笔外部性买单。他给的数字是 5.3 万亿美元一年(原话被语音识别成 5.3 million trillion,按语境应为 5.3 万亿)。
我们要从一个未被课税的负外部性,转成对碳征税。(马斯克)
他接着讲价格是什么。价格并不只是屏幕上的数字,它本身就是信息。它告诉劳动力、资本、资源往哪儿流。价格错了,经济就会做错事,而且是系统性、大规模地做错事。
他用了不太像能源专家会用的类比:现在的能源价格体系,相当于对水果蔬菜征重税,对烟酒几乎免税。谁都知道这不合理,可背后有强大的力量在维持这个结构。
他还提醒一件事。一般认为政府干预经济会扭曲价格、制造更多错误,但碳税属于例外。它纠正的是一个已经存在、规模巨大的价格错误。任何形式的碳税,都比当下这套错得离谱的价格体系更接近真相。
教育该教什么:批判性思维几乎没人认真教
主持人念了一条来自中学 STEM 老师的推特提问:学生该学什么,才能应对未来的就业市场?
马斯克先给了最实用的答案:软件工程。他认为这是单一价值最高的领域。然后是物理、经济学基础,以及批判性思维。
批判性思维这件事,他讲得有点激动。他说这听起来像常识,可学校几乎不教。你应该直接告诉学生:这是判断一件事该不该信的方法,这是常见的逻辑谬误,这是别人通常怎么骗你,以及你怎么不被骗。
台下笑了,他说:我知道我是在对一群本来就信这套的人讲道。
紧接着有人追问:你刚才列的清单里怎么没提地球科学?
马斯克承认地球科学很重要。他真正的抱怨在别处:普通人对地球科学的了解少得惊人,连碳循环这种基础概念都不清楚。
他举了自己的经历。他跟一些非常聪明、受过良好教育的人聊天,对方不知道地表有一个碳循环,也不知道从地下深处把碳挖出来加到地表,会从根本上改变地球表面的化学。他还提到,质量守恒对很多人来说并不显然,碳不会凭空产生,也不会凭空消失。
他们听完的反应是:哇,真的吗?(马斯克)
这段听起来像吐槽,可它连着前面碳税那条线。公众不理解碳循环,就不会支持碳税;不理解质量守恒,就会觉得碳排放是个抽象的道德问题,跟物理无关。
公共部门和私营部门的边界
主持人问了一个很实际的问题:科学研究和创新,政府和私营企业该怎么分工?
马斯克给了一个清晰到可以直接当判据用的标准。
当一件事对所有人都有好处,但好处很小,又很难挨个收钱,就该公共部门做。他打了个比方:如果有个项目要 30 亿美元,你不可能跑到美国每个人面前收 10 块钱。这种时候政府做更高效。哈勃望远镜、火星探测任务,都归这一类。
当一件事能闭合经济循环,就该私营部门做。SpaceX 发射通信和广播卫星,客户付钱,公司活下来,循环闭合。同时 SpaceX 也给 NASA 做国际空间站补给任务,这部分是公共部门出钱、私营部门执行,因为它的目的是让人类多懂一点太空,本身不产生商业回报。
他顺带说了个遗憾。欧洲的大型强子对撞机(LHC)做成了,美国超导超级对撞机(SSC)在 1993 年被取消。他说那是个让人难过的决定,科学经费应该增加。
讲这话的时候,美国国家科学基金会主任正坐在第一排。
为什么非要去火星
主持人提到马斯克在别处说过火星是个“需要装修的星球”,然后问:去火星到底难在哪?
马斯克没直接回答技术难题,他先讲为什么这件事值得做。这段回答是他所有火星论述里哲学底子最清楚的一次。
他说,人类对宇宙的理解,大致跟文明的规模和范围成正比。文明越大、走得越远,能搞明白的东西就越多。
然后是概率。人类文明作为单一星球物种,最终一定会遇到一次灭绝事件。可能来自人类自己,也可能来自自然。变成多星球物种,这个概率就大幅下降。这跟浪漫主义无关,纯粹是一道概率题。
他还讲了一个时间窗口。地球诞生 15 亿年以来,这是第一次出现一个窗口,让生命有可能延伸到另一颗行星。这个窗口可能开很久,也可能开得很短。理性的做法是趁它开着的时候赶紧做。
我认为明智的举动是,趁我们还能做到的时候,让生命变成多行星的。(马斯克)
最后他补了一条不那么“理性”的理由:这也是一场伟大的冒险。人早上醒来需要有期待的东西,需要被激励。
主持人接话说,他年纪够大,记得登月那天全家早起看电视的心情。马斯克说,对,就是那个感觉。
他也承认现实:这件事会非常难,会花很长时间,他自己大概率活不到看见火星城市自我维持的那天。
让火箭便宜的三个前提
马斯克把去火星拆成几个必要技术步骤。
第一个是可重复使用火箭。现在火箭用一次就扔进海里。如果火箭能复用,进入太空的成本能降大约两个数量级。
他给了一个具体对比。猎鹰 9 号(Falcon 9)整枚火箭大约 6000 万美元,里面装的推进剂成本只有大约 20 万美元。燃料钱只占价格的三百分之一。这就像一架 747 飞完一趟航班,燃油只花了机票收入的零头,剩下的钱全花在把飞机扔掉这件事上。
第二个是规模。需要非常大的火箭。
第三个是在火星本地生产推进剂。不然从地球运返程燃料,成本根本算不过来。
主持人问,三天后(2015 年 12 月那次)要发射的猎鹰 9 号有什么不一样。马斯克列了几项改进:推进剂深度过冷,尤其把液氧冷却到接近凝固点,密度显著提高,推力更大;级间分离系统改进;上面级加长,装更多推进剂;电子设备也有一批升级。
他说了一句关于失败的实话。上一枚火箭在他生日那天炸了。原话是“情感上相当有创伤”。火箭很难,难到如果地球重力稍微大一点,化学火箭基本就玩不转了。
他拿土星五号和登月舱做对比。土星五号从地球起飞,体积相当于一栋办公楼;从月球起飞,只需要鹰号登月舱的上半截。重力差这么一点,工程难度差出一个数量级。
所以在地球上做火箭,所有东西都得推到极限。材料要最先进,设计要极度优化,几乎不能留大余量,否则根本飞不上去。地面测试也没法完全模拟真实飞行条件,没有哪个试验台能还原那种环境。
子弹的四倍:一个让人立刻有概念的类比
主持人对马斯克的一段技术描述反应特别大,专门夸了一句:你把一个普通人完全没概念的东西,比成了能立刻感受到的东西。
那段话是讲复用的一级火箭。马斯克说,衡量一级火箭性能的核心指标,是它传给二级火箭的转移能量,具体说就是转移速度对应的质量。
猎鹰 9 号的一级能把二级加速到每小时 8000 公里。一支突击步枪的子弹速度大约每小时 2000 公里。换个说法:一级火箭相当于把大约 120 吨的东西,加速到子弹速度的四倍。
它是在把 120 吨的载荷,加速到子弹速度的四倍。(马斯克)
这个类比之所以有效,是它把“运载能力”这个抽象词换成了一个身体能感受的画面。观众脑子里出现的画面,是 120 吨钢铁以四倍子弹速度飞出去,而这句话原本的表述是“转移速度 8000 公里每小时”。
核裂变、核聚变,和那个天上的聚变反应堆
观众席第一个提问来自一位风险投资人背景的听众。他提到《洛杉矶时报》头版报道过一批投资人追捧某种新型核能技术,问马斯克会怎么用批判性思维判断这类项目,以及核能在修复地球这件事上有什么前景。
马斯克的回答分三层。
第一,核裂变本身没问题。设计良好的裂变电站是可以的,尤其是在不处于自然灾害带的地区。他举了法国的例子,法国大量用核电压根不算问题。加州和日本这种地震带,就要打问号。
第二,核聚变是可以解决的工程问题。他没做,是因为算了另一笔账:天上那个巨大的聚变反应堆,也就是太阳,配合可携带的电池,在大多数场景下经济性更好。
第三,高纬度地区还有水电。北半球高纬度有大量水电资源,正好补上太阳能“天黑没电、冬天没电”的短板。
他不否认聚变值得研究,只是判断在压倒性比例的场合,间接聚变(太阳能加电池)加高压东西向输电线路会赢。
他给了一个让人印象深刻的土地面积对比。满足全美国的电力需求,只需要犹他州和内华达州交界处一小块地方铺满太阳能板。全球范围内也是类似量级,一个不算大的地表比例就够。
太阳能每两年翻一倍,但要配电池
主持人追问:太阳能装机大约每两年翻一倍,指数增长很猛,离“全部太阳能供电”只差七次翻倍,这个速度能保持吗?
马斯克说会放缓,但仍然是高增速。真正的瓶颈在并网这一端。当太阳能占电网比例到一定程度,就必须加电池做调峰,否则电网不稳。
他还给了一个基础数据:太阳能在每平方公里地表大约能获取 1 吉瓦的功率。单看这个数字不大,乘上足够大的面积就非常可观。
有人问到电池回收和电池生产的碳足迹。马斯克说,特斯拉的电池包目前全部回收,北美、欧洲、亚洲都有回收中心。他打了个比方:电池包就是一块高品质的矿石,从电池里“开矿”比从石头里开矿划算得多。正在内华达建的超级工厂(Gigafactory)会把回收环节直接设计进去,长期看整个工厂由太阳能、风能和地热供电。
电池每年只进步 5% 到 8%,但规模能改变一切
一位观众问特斯拉在储能上的路线。马斯克的回答里有两层,一层是技术,一层是规模,他明显更看重后者。
技术层面,他的预期很保守。电池能量密度和成本,行业平均每年改进大约 5% 到 8%。这个数字听起来不起眼,可它是复利。超级工厂的思路是把规模经济做到极致,用规模把成本曲线往下压,比指望某一次技术突变更可靠。
他也承认电池是块硬骨头。太多非常聪明的人在这个问题上碰了壁。他讲这话不带客套,是在解释这个领域为什么进步这么慢。
主持人接着问,除了电池和电动车,还有哪些低碳技术方向值得投入。马斯克列了三块:交通全面电气化,包括飞机和船;供暖和制冷的电气化;以及核能,但要跟太阳能比经济性。
他给了一条判断标准:任何能源技术,如果你把它外推到很久以后,世界仍然是个好地方,那就该做。
电动车就算烧煤,也比燃油车干净
一位来自田纳西的提问者抛出一个常见质疑:电动车本身不排碳,可电从天然气电厂来,天然气电厂效率不见得比汽油车高,那电动车到底解决了什么?
马斯克的回答,是这场对话里信息密度最高的一段。
他说,即使电网 100% 由煤和天然气供电,电动车全生命周期的碳排放仍然低于燃油车,而且是把发电端的排放都算进去之后。
原因在物理约束。汽车受限于重量和体积,发动机做不大,热效率做不高。燃油车在整个驾驶循环里,能量效率通常低于 20%。电厂不受这些约束,燃气轮机可以做得很重很大,还能把余热回收去推动蒸汽轮机,联合循环效率超过 60%。
把 60% 的发电效率,乘上传输损耗和充电损耗,最后落到车轮上的能量利用率,仍然远高于燃油车那不到 20%。这个结论对煤电同样成立。
然后他补了一层:现实里电网并非 100% 化石能源。水电、核电、风电、太阳能都在,而且太阳能增长很快。等电池大规模上电网,这个比例还会加速变化。
可持续能源不是选择题,是时间题
这场对话里,马斯克重复了他在巴黎气候大会上讲过的那个逻辑,值得单独拎出来。
人类一定会走向可持续能源经济。原因跟道德无关,纯粹是算术。地下的碳基燃料有限,你把它挖光烧光,接下来要么转向可持续能源,要么整个经济因为没能源而崩掉。没有第三条路。
所以真问题从来都跟“会不会转”无关,它是“多快转”,以及“在这个过程中,有多少亿吨二氧化碳从地下被搬到了大气里”。
既然我们知道终点是可持续能源经济,那我们应该尽快结束这场实验。(马斯克)
“实验”这个词用得准。人类现在做的,是把几亿年存进地下的碳,用两百年时间全放回大气,然后看看会发生什么。这跟实验该有的谨慎态度差得很远。
信息获取的平等,被低估了
一位来自普渡大学的提问者问,马斯克的公司怎么应对全球范围内科学和能源获取的不平等。
马斯克先讲了两个具体动作。特斯拉开放了全部专利。Solar City 更进一步,把技术开放给发展中国家,还邀请这些国家的人来工厂实地看怎么做。
然后他讲了一件他觉得被低估的事:互联网是信息获取的巨大平衡器。一个 100 美元的设备,就能学到任何东西。你不需要去图书馆,不需要出生在某个城市,不需要认识某个人。
他说这段话的口气很平。放回 2015 年的语境里,这是在讲一个正在发生、却很少有人认真对待的结构性变化。
火星上如果真有生命怎么办
一位来自亚利桑那州立大学的提问者提到,另一位火星倡导者克里斯·麦凯(Chris McKay)主张,如果火星上有现存的或已灭绝的生命,人类应该撤出,让那些生命自己繁荣。
马斯克的回答很直接:火星表面看起来没有任何生命迹象。如果真发现了,那当然要认真研究,并且尽量避免把它弄灭绝,这个原则很重要。
他判断的现实情况是表面没有生命。可能存在的是深层地下的微生物,那里有岩石屏蔽辐射,也避开了极寒。如果生命在很深的地下,人类在表面活动的影响其实很有限。
这个回答体现了他一贯的处理方式:先承认原则,再用具体事实判断原则在这里适不适用。
生命、宇宙,和那个被读错的书名
主持人最后问了一个有点私人的问题:你做的很多项目,自己可能看不到结果,怎么权衡“我能参与”和“它以后才实现”?
马斯克把话题拉回少年时代。他说十几岁时在找生命的意义,一度相当沮丧。后来读到《银河系漫游指南》(The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy),书里的梗是:一台超级计算机算了几百万年,最后给出的宇宙终极答案是 42,但没人知道问题是什么。
马斯克从这个梗里读出的道理是:给出答案很难,提出正确的问题更难。宇宙就在那儿,关键是问对问题。如果他能帮着把问题问得更清楚一点,他就觉得这件事值得做。
这段听起来像闲笔,其实是他整套方法论的闭环。第一性原理是拆解问题的方法,而“问对问题”决定了你先拆哪一个。他做电动车、做火箭、做太阳能,跟赚钱的关系不大,是他把“人类未来怎么才能不崩”这个问题拆开之后,这几件事排在了最前面。
这场对话里,最该拿走的是什么
回看整场访谈,马斯克没讲太多新技术细节。他讲得最多的是判断方法:怎么定价、怎么分工、怎么判断一项技术值不值得投、怎么在一个自己看不到终点的项目上撑下去。
这些东西比任何一条具体结论都更耐用。太阳能的翻倍速度会变,电池的改进曲线会变,火星时间表会变,“把问题拆到基本事实再往上推”这件事不会过时。
对读者来说,这场十年前的对话有几条可以直接拿走用的东西:
- 遇到新问题,先问自己是否在用类比。如果这件事此前没人做成过,类比大概率会把你带偏,逼自己拆到基本事实。
- 看任何价格,问它是否在传递正确的信息。价格错了,行为就会错,而且是系统性地错。
- 判断一个项目该谁做:好处小而分散、难以收费的,交给公共部门;能闭合商业循环的,交给市场。混着来,两边都做不好。
- 评估一项能源或减碳技术,把它外推到很久以后,看世界是否仍然是个好地方。如果是,就值得投。
- 算能效时把整条链路算完。发电端的约束和汽车端的约束完全不同,只盯着末端那一段,结论常常跟直觉相反。
- 做长期项目时,先想清楚你要回答哪个问题,再去想答案。答案会过时,问题不会。
0:00have clearly blown through those so how do you think about that and and how do you focus on getting by those obstacles well I'm a big believer in in the sort of science or physics framework of trying to analyze problem particularly if if they're new so if something's new then analogies don't don't work very well because it's it's it's it's new I mean the way we get through daily life is most by analogy or by sort of copying things with minor variations because it's a computational shortcut but if you want to do something that's that's fundamentally new or particularly it's counterintuitive then you have to do a first principles analysis and
0:48you know take things from from the what appear to be as fundamental sort of simple fundamental truths and then reason up from there and I mean that that requires a lot more thinking and you can't you can't do that for everything but but if you trying to figure out something new I think it's it's really the only way to go so I mentioned that that I was in Paris and I know that you were there too and as I listened to presentations first there was a real sense of optimism at this cop that I don't think was there before but there was still an overwhelming sense of a lot of of work that we have to do and I was struck by some comments that you made
1:36when you were talking to a group of students at the surbone and they were talking about sustainability and you said regarding the carbon cycle this is analogous to not paying for garbage collection it's not as though we should say in the case of garbage have a garbage free Society it's very difficult to have a garbage free Society but it's it's just important that people pay for the garbage collection so we need to go from having an untaxed negative externality which is effectively a hidden carbon sub subsidy of enormous size 5.3 million trillion a year and we
2:17need to move away from this and have a carbon tax so can you talk a little bit about that especially from the standpoint of being in price yeah I mean essentially price are just information they they the primary information to allow for labor labor allocation and they sort of tell people what what to do and what thing should be favored or another thing and and so when the prices are wrong then the wrong thing happens in the economy so when you have a sort of a tragedy of Commons like the CO2 capacity of the oceans in atmosphere and it's it's un price or the price is is much lower than it than it should be then the wrong Behavior happens so effectively we're we're incenting bad
3:09behavior and I mean I just talked about how analogies are imperfect but but you know it's kind of like if if we had high taxes on on fruits and vegetables and low taxes on on cigarettes and alcohol that would that wouldn't make sense that that's sort of what we have right now with respect to energy and and and we're very powerful forces trying to keep it that way so now it will
3:44eventually correct but and we are seeing some good movement in that direction with the Paris climate talks it sounds like it's direct directionally correct and and there will be some movement not as much as there should be but it's it's encouraging and I think that it's worth noting that like generally when when when the government interferes in the economy it's it's it's it's that usually results in a in a a pricing error increase but in this case I
4:18think it would it would be it's hard to miss like any any sort of C text would reduce the effect of error in the system of prices in the economy i' like to shift directions while we are a research Community we're also an education community and we have crowdsourced and questions for today's event and one of them comes from the education community so this came to us on Twitter from Regina Brinker at
4:53Brinker science if you want to follow her and she says I teach Middle School stem what should students be learning to be prepared for and contribute to the Future Workforce well I think I mean software engineering is probably the single biggest area that that people should learn and and and I think I think I'm always sort of a fan of physics and General economics and
5:24critical thinking I think those are we really should teach critical thinking a lot more me seem like a simple thing but it's it's just like you need to just tell people like this is how you know whether you should believe something or [Laughter] not yeah you you can tell how much everybody resat I think I'm preaching to the convered here yeah but yeah it's yeah you know just teaching people these are the general types of fallacies and this is how people will generally trick you and how to avoid being trick and I think it be really great let's do it at the fall meeting here we also try to stress the importance of transdisciplinary research and how
6:22science informs other areas like policy and so forth so another question we received from Twitter came from Lori xowski she's at extra neutrons who asked so you didn't mention geoscience in that list of things that people should know about I do think J is very important yeah what do the engineers of the future need to know from geosciences and how can how do we influence that and work together well I mean I think in general I think that it would be good in general for people to know about geosciences and to know how our
7:10actions as a civilization will affect the future or and how we can possibly affect it how we might be negatively affecting it you know on the assumption that we want the future to be good we want to direct our actions to you know with respect to to geosciences to to a good outcome so
7:30so I generally it's it's it's sort of quite surprising how little actually people know about about geosciences I mean even like pretty straightforward stuff like the carbon cycle you know sort of I mean I've had conversations with with quite quite smart and well people who who who don't understand that there's like a surface carbon cycle and and then but if you did Stu up from deep underground and add it to the surface carbon that that that fundamentally changes the chemical like liing of the of the surface of the Earth and they're like wow really [Music] yeah and you know like there's just conservation of mass is not totally obvious to people you know like you can't just
8:21create new carbon from nothing you have and you can't just disappear yeah it doesn't disappear yeah exactly so you know just like basic stuff like that be like wa to keep people on ter I we s bouncing around but I have some you know I we got great input from all of you when we ask for questions and I want to make sure we try to touch on a lot of different topics so I want to talk about the gools of the private and public sector in ensuring the advancement of scientific research and Innovation and where do you see
9:10the roles of the private sector versus the public sector are there places where they overlap are they totally separate yeah I think the public sector is when when you have something that's kind of a small amount of good for the whole population U or for you know the whole country or even the whole the whole world but it would be really difficult to go and collect like $10 from everyone to understand you know more about the nature of the Earth or the solar system the Universe so you it's it's sort of it's not efficient to go to try and sort of you know collect service if if you got say A you
9:50know a$3 billion project to go and get $10 from everyone in the United States it's like it's it's better to do that by the public sector and and then you know you have great things like like the Hubble and I think what people would say like that's that's quite a quite a good thing or the Mars missions so
10:12I think you know where where you have these things which are a small amount of good for for a lot of people it makes sense for public sector to to you know for government to do that where you can more concretely close the economic Loop that that's where the private sector makes sense so for example at SpaceX we do a lot of launches of communications and broadcast satellites and and that that can sort of close the economic Loop because then people can listen to X and radio or get Direct TV or something like that and and that kind of makes sense but then we'll also do missions for NASA to re resupply the space station so we can sort of learn more about space
11:00that makes sense as a as a public sector thing so I think that's the basic basic difference so in that public sector not only geoscience but a lot of Sciences seen very flat funding at a time when other nations are investing at a time when there's a tremendous opportunity how do you think that the private sector can help us turn that around and focus on you know what the benefits will be for Society for
11:35public sector investment in research well I'm certainly a proponent of increasing investment in in science in general from you know both the public and private sector and I'm a super pro science so I and it is interesting to see like the lar collider you know that was that was really a great effort there there in Europe and you know we sort of canel the superc conducting to glider here in the US I thought that was that was sort of a sort of a sad thing that we did there you know I I really think we should we should increase funding for science absolutely you across the world really great we have the director of the National Science Foundation in the
12:29front row here I'm sure she's yeah in violent yeah definitely so you mentioned Mars and in your interview with stepen coar you said that Mars is a fixer uper Planet yeah but you've also been a proponent of colonizing U Mars what are some of the challenges that you think we would face in traveling to Mars I know you're very interested in this how do how do you think about that sure well I think first of all I should say you know why do I think this is important and and that's if I sort of unpack the sort of
13:14philosophical basis for that as far as I'm concerned it's the reason I came to that conclusion was that you know I think that we don't there there's so much more to understand and learn about the nature of the universe and that understanding will will grow kind of proportion to the scope and scale of of human civilization and the probability of the probable lifespan of human civilization is is much greater if we are a multipl species as opposed to a single plan species if we're a single plan species then eventually there will be some Extinction event either you know either from humans or or some natural so so I
14:01think and now it's the first time in the history of Earth that the the window is opened where it's possible for us to extend life to another planets I mean it's been one and a half billion years so it's a long time and and that that window may be open for a long time and hopefully it is but it may also be open for a short time and so I think the the wise move is to make life multiplanetary while we can and and and and this ultimately is what will lead to a huge amount of of new science and in sure that that we have the highest probability of of understanding the nature of the universe so that that's actually the the reason that I think it's important
14:48and and I also think it would be a great adventure and you know there need to be things that people look forward to very in the morning like it's it's exciting inspiring and you know we we need those things yeah I'm old enough to remember the landing on the moon and getting up that day and about that and just the change yeah
15:22exactly point so but but it it will be super hard to do this and it will take a long time and I I suspect I probably would't live to see it become self-sustaining but if we had to aim for that objective then you know they important technological steps that are needed to to get there one of them for example being reusable Rockets if
15:54we reusable Rockets we can reduce the the cost of of of access to space by probably two magnitude and worting that for the the Falcon n which is a about a $6 million rocket to B the the cost of the propellent is only about $200,000 so you know it's much like U refilling think it's 747 something like that so it's it's really a massive difference if we can make rity work and then we also need scale
16:32need to have really big Rockets and and you need to do local propelling production on Mars so if we can do those things then I think we can establish a self sustaining civilization on R so I understand that you're going to be launching your newest rocket next week and this is the first launch since the Falcon 9 back in June and I've lost some scientific year that was pretty expensive in the ocean and I know what that feels like Maybe not maybe I don't know how it
17:13scales but you know if this is successful it's it's clearly historic and how do you think about that issue of you know failing forward well I think I think I success forward but yeah it's it's it's quite emotionally traumatic actually and yeah the the last fight which failed actually did so on my birthday which of a doubt yeah so yeah I me it's it's Rockets are
18:02hard the I mean if if gravity was just a little lighter much easier actually If gravity was a little little stronger on Earth it would be basically impossible to do with chemical Rockets it's amazing how much gravity effects things like this small change in G and it's like wow you look at say the Saturn 5 which was like the size of like an basically an office building to take off from Earth and and yet to take off from the moon was just the top half of the eagle Lander so it's wow it's like a crazy
18:43difference so anyway the so for for in order to make things work on Earth for Rockets you have to really push everything to the maximum so you have to have really Advanced Materials really optimize the design everything's got to you can't have huge amounts of margin in in the rocket otherwise it just won't get to open at all and and it's really hard to test everything in the ground in the exact circumstances that you're would experiencing life because there's just no there's no test facility that can do that exactly so you do you make it close but not exact but for for this
19:25upcoming flight there are number of improvements in the rocket and one of the things we're doing for the first time the first time I think anyone's done it is deep deeply cryogenic propellant so we're subcooling the propellant particularly particularly the liquid oxygen because it's 23 liquid oxygen close to its freezing point which increases the density quite quite significantly and and then the thrust is higher we're going to improve stage separation system we stretched the upper stage of the rocket to add more propellent to that and there are a number of other improvements in electronics so it's I think a significantly improved rocket from the
20:13last one and then I should say what is important about reusability as far as the Boost stage is concerned what the key sort of figure of marit is is the transfer transfer energy so if you take the potential energy and the kinetic energy and say how much has been transferred to the the alha stage by the Boost stage and and and what's the mass that so basically yeah basically connecting to potential energy transport that that's the thing that that's the figure of marit so the the boo stage of falcine is is capable of of
20:54transfer of a transfer velocity to the opp stage of 8,000 km an hour so it's really that's pretty fast a bullet from an assault rifle it goes at 2,000 km hour so it's four times fast than a bull from an assault rifle that's a transfer velocity of roughly 100 kilomet and to to a mass of about 120 tons
21:21so it's accelerating 120 tons to four times FAS than than a bullet I loved the way that you just compared something that people wouldn't have any conception of to something that they would and that they would be really impressed by I mean was that amazing communication that was terrific
21:50I wanted to ask you one last question and then we're going to throw things open for the the audience when you talked about Mars you said I don't think I'll ever get there well and yeah you talk a little about you know a lot of us get involved in projects that we don't know if we'll see the realization and can you talk a little bit about how you think about that and and trading off you know I get to do
22:22it versus it'll come later well you know going back to the sort of UNL mindl sort of philosophical rationale for doing the first you know doing in the first place the you know basically I sort of was thinking about this when I when I was a kid and trying to find some meaning in life like what's the meaning of life and I quite sort of sad about it
22:53actually when I was a teenager and and then I read the HED guide thexy which basically said like the real the you know basically universe is the answer and you need figure out the questions so I think you know that that's if I can help kind of figure out the questions then that I consider that to be very absolutely maybe we can 's a b fish right exactly okay now it's time for you
23:36and I'm going to go we're going to alternate between questions from the audience and questions from the the U no Joan we're not we we won't okay just the audience okay so it's your turn questions for youone please come to the microphones that are in the in the aisles and there's somebody at this microphone go ahead thank you very much for appearing today two weeks ago the Los Angeles Times featured prominently on its front page a story in which it described many self-described Venture capitalists from this area who were enamored by a new and as yet unspecified technique of power generation it did not it was promised in the article I think was different
24:27than those demonstrated at three m Island chyl and Fukushima the I'd like to ask if you had what your critical thinking skills would be when approached by people offering you to invest or become involved in new and undefined nuclear power techniques you know what they're talking about and two what you see as a future for nuclear power in our efforts to restore the Earth to the conditions that it might have existed more closely at the start of the you had to proceed sure well I I actually am
25:04I I I mean I think there's nothing wrong with nuclear power whether Vision or Fusion I think if a properly designed Vision power system is actually fine particularly if it's in an area that's not subject to natural disasters so you know for example France has a lot of fion power and that can that I think makes lot of s for but but for California it's more questionable or Japan so then then then then fusion I I definitely think Fusion is a solvable problem the the reason I sort of haven't done
25:50anything in direct Fusion is that I I currently think and I may be wrong about this that that indirect fusion from the big Fusion explosion in the sky called the sun is you know and having portable takes is is probably going to make the most things economically and in the in the Norther in the high high latitudes in nor Northern Hemisphere you tend to have a lot of Hydro power so that that
26:24that really helps solve the you know how do you make power when it's dark problem or or in the middle of winter type thing so I don't want to discarge people from pursuing Fusion but person thing I think the economics are going to favor indirect Fusion of multiple pable Tes at least to an overwhelming degree particularly when combined with batteries and high voltage lines running East West and L South I mean you can completely solve Earth's all the power need on Earth with a with a fairly small percentage of the surface area I mean for the United States you could take basically little a corner of Utah Nevada and power the entire United States with solar
27:19power so I I think that's that's mostly how it will get solved the next so this is a bit of a followup on that solar power has been doubling basically every 2 years and we all know that exponential growth is a powerful thing so we're only what seven doublings away from everything being powered by solar power and do you think that that doubling rate will will keep Pace I mean I I think it'll probably slow down but but it's still going to be a high percentage growth rate every year once you reach a certain percentage of solar into the grid you really need to add batteries in order to load level and kind of cash power but but solar combined with
28:11with batter is really you kind of like I said you can completely solve all of this power with just those those two things great that Victor yeah it's it's worth noting I think probably people aware of this but you get it's there's one Gatt per square km of solar energy solar power I'm Victor massive F ofio work particularly fighting the carbon pollution and actually full up on this battery question we tend to start understanding how powerful the carbon pollution is but the battery related technology and F takes has its own production c i was Wonder you could maybe share your thoughts on what the consequences and maybe a radiation recyle if that would be yeah well all
29:06of the battery packs for Tesla are currently recycled so the recycling centers in North America and Europe and and Asia and it kind of makes sense because you can just think of the battery packs as really high quality ore it's way better to mine a battery pack than rocks so so it kind of
29:27makes sense to to recycle them economically yeah and that obviously reduces the the cost of production quite a bit for the G Factory that that we're building in Nevada that will have recycling built in so they we completely sort of you know close that cycle and it will be in the long term fully sustainably powered so solar wind and geothermal
30:00yeah and microphone hi I'm Jim croll from Arizona State University I was listening to Dr Chris McKay another advocate of humans to Mars and he was talking about when we do go to Mars if we find life either currently there or extinct we should consider removing human presence so we can allow that life to thrive I was wondering what thoughts on that were well I it really doesn't seem like there's any life on on Mars I mean if they're on the surface at least we're not seeing any sign of that I think if we do find some sign of it then we sure we need to understand you know what it is and and try I try to Ure that
30:51we we don't extinguish it I mean that's that's important but I think I think the reality is that there isn't any life on the surface of Mars there may be microbial life deep underground where it's sort of shielded from radiation and from the cold and yeah so that that's that's a possibility but in in that case I think anything we do on the surfice is really not going to have a big impact on the sub tring life yeah thank you here again hi with a
31:34decision coming out of cop 21 just a few days ago with the world now appearing to be on track to decarbonize the Energy System renewable energy and of course storage is going to become increasingly important and likely the development will accelerate I'm really interested in what Tesla's doing on batteries that will help smooth the intermittent of the renewable generation and would really like to hear your discussion of where you see Tesla going on battery storage for Renewables and generally the whole issue of storage for Renewables yeah well definitely this B technology is super important to sustainable energy what what we're doing with the
32:19the the big Factory and that we're buling in Nevada is is really trying to take economies of scale to the liit so it's like the biggest Factory we could conceive of in order to to maximize economies of scale and then obviously there's the underlying technology itself which there there will be I would say moderate improvements in the underlying technology not giant but not not small but kind of medium but then over time I would expect those those technology improvements to get better and better from Tesla standpoint we're always interested in trying to figure out how to how to make it better I I do think that batteries are one of the hottest technology
33:06problems out there because there's so many constraints on creating a useful batter it's it's really I mean so many super smart people have broken their pick on improving batteries so so usually ends up being on average like about a 5 to 8% Improvement per year in energy density and economics although I think we'll be able to improve the economic element a lot more just by the economies of scale but I anyone who's
33:40interested in in doing batteries I'd certainly encourage them to to research better batteries it's it's a super hard problem and a critical one to solve what do you think are the main steps in a low carbon energy transition and in that vein what technologies out there What technological developments do you find very interesting that you're not already working on things that aren't batteries or electric vehicles but that you think are cool areas for people to go into well I think electrification of Transport in general is important so aircraft and boats that that's very
34:26important and and then Heating and Cooling electrification of that yeah I me I think I mean the nucleus stuff could be could be quite interesting but it would just have to sort of see how it competes against solar but yeah and any anything which any form of energy generation or consumption which if you extrapolate into future goes on for a very long time and still has the world being good I think we should just do
35:09that over here good morning Pisha Hoover from Purdue University my question pertains to science access and energy within the global context and I was wondering how you see any or all of your your companies and Ventures trying to address the the inequity of science access or access to energy or or what
35:37types of things that you're hoping to do within that context to try and really expand those resources and make it accessible to everyone sure well I mean as was mentioned earlier Tesla just made all the patents open and Solar City is actually going even a step further than that which is they're making the technology
36:10available to developing countries and and they're offering to have people come from those countries and actually sit in the factory and see how it's done so I think you know trying to be helpful in that respect and but but I I do think that you know the internet is a great equalizer of access to information the you
36:41know this is this is maybe not talk about as much as it should be but you can learn anything if you have a $100 internet device you can just learn anything which is amazing compared to the Past you don't need you don't need to access to a library in just you can learn whatever you want for free
37:01really that's that's a pretty great part of the future that we're in right now on the end hi ke Park from T national Tesla has done a great job creating an infrastructure for electric cars in the country so far but I don't think electric cars themselves solve green greenhouse gas problems because we're still generating greenhouse gases from and natural power plant natural gas power plants which are not as efficient as U gasoline cars so how did you originally Envision the future source of electricity and how do you envision it now yeah actually it's it's worth noting that even if the grid was completely powered by coal and natural gas electric cars would
37:55still generate less CO2 even when you extra when you take it all the way to the power plant level the the reason for that is that when you're not constrained by mass and volume you can make the the efficiency of energy extraction much better in a power plant than you can in a car so if you take say like natural gas power plant
38:22from from G it's it's over 60% efficient so take the s 60% efficient in generating electricity so it's really good whereas typically a gasoline powered car over the drive cycle will be less than 20% efficient and and that's because you know the the big natural gas turbine is it it can be really heavy it can be really bulky and you can take the the waste heat and then run a steam turbine and you know get even more energy out so your efficiency is just fundamentally much better and so even when you take into account the transmission losses and the charging losses you're still way far ahead with electric cars than you are with gasline cars so even you can take this
39:11do this with any Source fuel coal anything you're you're just always going to win even if everything's powered by by CO2 sources then then of course everything isn't powered by two sources you have hydro ummal solar wind and as was pointed out by one of the earlier question is the growth of solar is
39:44very dramatic so the you know the percentage of the grid that is sustainable energy is increasing over time and when we add batteries to the mix that will that will further increase the rate so I think I think we're we're on a we're headed in a positive direction it's just a question of how long it will take to get there in fact like one of the things I really emphasized in the par tool was that
40:16it it is a certainty that we will move to a sustainable energy economy because the alternative would be would be able to mine all of the carbon based fuels from the ground burn them and then you either move to a sustainable economy or the entire economy collapses because then it doesn't have any energy so we know for sure that we will move to a sustainable energy economy the question is just when and and how many you know billions of tons of of CO2 are in the atmosphere versus in the ground that that's really the only question is is what what what PPM number will we you know yeah
41:00exctly so you know so given that we know we will end up which is the sustainable energy economy it seems like we should we should terminate this experiment as soon as possible why not I'm sorry but we don't have time for any more questions when I was walking in one of my friends was telling me how excited he was to be here and I wrote down what he said because I think it's something we all share he said it's such a rare thing to see a person devote themselves to coming up with real solutions to the biggest problems and then doing it thank you so much thanks time
42:07thank all of you for joining us today please come back later on in in about an hour to hear from France Cordova the the head of the National Science Foundation
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版