大会演讲·中文精读

Tesla收购SolarCity电话会议完整版(马斯克参与)

Tesla's Solar City acquisition conference call w/ Elon Musk [Full]

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2016年6月22日上午的电话会议,开场十分钟都在解释一件事:为什么这次的收购公告长得不像收购公告。

前一天,特斯拉向SolarCity(美国最大的屋顶光伏安装商)发出全股票收购要约,按当时股价算大约26亿美元。常规的并购新闻是这样的:两家公司谈妥最终协议,一起发布协议文本、合并后公司的财务预测、协同效应测算。这次什么都没有,只有一份要约。

特斯拉总法律顾问Todd Maron说,原因不复杂。马斯克是SolarCity的重要股东,按证券法规定,持股超过5%就要用Schedule 13D文件向市场说明自己的计划。特斯拉决定发出要约,马斯克支持这个决定,他就必须更新13D。

换句话说,市场是在谈判开始之前,被迫提前看到了牌。

这其实是一个更透明的过程。你实际上提前看到了幕后的东西,在要约阶段就拿到了通常要到协议阶段才有的战略讨论。(Todd Maron)

Maron补了一句:我们希望在SolarCity开启尽职调查,最终达成协议,到那时候该给的信息一样不少。

三块拼图:太阳能、电池、电动车

马斯克接过话,先重申了一年前Powerwall发布会上的框架。

解决可持续能源问题需要三样东西:可持续的能源生产,他认为绝大部分会来自太阳能;固定储能,用来缓冲太阳能的间歇性;电动车。三样凑齐,才是一套完整方案。这三样,特斯拉都应该做。

他给出的理由很具体。Powerwall正在集成越来越多的逆变器电子和智能控制,设计这些东西的时候,必须把屋顶上的太阳能板和整套系统一起考虑。分开做,硬件会重复,接口对不上,成本更高。

安装环节的问题更直观。一个装了太阳能、又买了Powerwall、还开电动车的用户,家里要来人几趟?太阳能一趟,Powerwall一趟,壁挂充电器一趟。至少两趟,可能三趟。

销售环节同样割裂。特斯拉门店卖Powerwall,客户往往会问:你们能顺便把太阳能装了吗?不能。SolarCity是另一家公司。马斯克说这种体验相当低效。

他算了一笔账。Model 3是一辆3.5万美元的车。同一位客户,在同一个时刻,还可以买走价值差不多的太阳能板加Powerwall。一笔交易变成两笔,销售额几乎翻倍,安装一次做完。

协同在商业话语里基本是个脏词,马斯克自己也知道。他的辩护是:这里的协同就是常识。

然后是整场会议里最重要的一段逻辑。

如果SolarCity不是特斯拉的一部分,特斯拉凭什么给它特殊待遇?统一的接口、优先的排产、联合设计的产品、共享的门店和安装队,这些都不可能给一家独立公司。给了,就是对其他太阳能公司的歧视,股东会问,监管会问,马斯克自己作为两家公司的大股东更说不清。

两家公司合在一起,这个问题消失了。用马斯克的话说,利益冲突在一家公司内部不存在,在两家独立公司之间反而存在。

所以他给出了一句很重的判断:不做这笔交易,特斯拉的执行会变得更难、更糟。

为什么不能只做合作伙伴

问答环节第一个问题就问到了这个。Robert W. Baird的分析师问:既然要一起干活,搞个合资公司或者长期供货协议不行吗,为什么非要买下来?

马斯克的回答绕回了利益冲突。他说,我们没有一个好的依据去跟SolarCity做一笔特殊交易,因为我同时拥有这两家公司。合并成一家,冲突消失;保持两家,冲突一直在。道德上和法律上,都很难为这种安排在法庭上辩护。

Todd Maron补充了程序细节。马斯克和Antonio Gracias同时在两家董事会任职,两人都回避了董事会的投票。他们还承诺,最终交易要由无利害关系的股东投票,并且是多数决。

有分析师追问,回避投票是不是也意味着回避讨论、不在会议室里。Maron纠正:回避的是投票。

上门三次和上门一次,差的是多少钱

Dougherty的分析师Charlie Anderson要一个协同效应的数字。

马斯克先说这是早期估算,然后给了量级。同一家门店、同一个销售、同一笔交易里卖出两倍金额,销售成本大致减半。他说可能不完全是减半,30%到40%是有的。这个降幅对SolarCity尤其关键,因为SolarCity第一季度单位瓦成本上升的最大因素就是销售成本。

安装侧的逻辑更简单。一次上门干完三件事,运输、人工、物流成本可能直接砍半。

硬件层面,不用重复做功。逆变器、控制器、通信模块,一套就够。

售后只剩一个联系人,不用在太阳能公司和电池公司之间互相推诿。

马斯克说,具体是20%、30%还是40%可以争论,但两家公司合起来的成本会明显低于各自为战,这一点没什么可争的。

他还提到一个更根本的理由:异构系统的集成问题,最终都发生在接口上。接口一出问题,就开始甩锅。太阳能说是电池的问题,电池说是逆变器的问题,用户夹在中间。一套系统,没人可以甩锅,bug只能自己修。

债务的真相:看追索,不看总数

市场对这笔交易最大的疑虑是SolarCity的资产负债表。这家公司长期靠融资租赁和税收权益结构扩张,负债表看起来很吓人。

马斯克的拆解是:重要的是追索债务(recourse debt),无追索债务不是重点。无追索债务背后对应着产生现金流的资产,那些现金流足以覆盖追索债务。

他说SolarCity正在走向现金流为正,时间窗口是三到六个月。公司主动降低了增长速度来达到这个位置,做得很安静。

合并之后,他预计SolarCity会变成净现金的贡献者,不再是消耗者,尤其是算上销售成本的大幅下降。

特斯拉CFO Jason Wheeler被问到合并后公司的现金需求和再融资计划。他的回答很谨慎:特斯拉这边,维持之前财报电话会上的说法;SolarCity这边,尽职调查刚开始,他手上只有公开信息,没法给备考数据。

后来UBS的分析师Colin Langan直接问:很多覆盖SolarCity的分析师都在说流动性有大问题,你怎么看?

马斯克说,交易完成之后现金消耗会减少,因为销售成本降了,运营效率提上来了,重复的东西砍掉了。他给了个时间表:交割后第二个完整季度,效果会很明显,他对此高度自信。

一块屋顶值多少钱:房子估值的五个点

Oppenheimer的Colin Rusch问的是Silevo。SolarCity在2014年收购了这家高效光伏电池公司,外界一直好奇它能不能打。

马斯克先讲了一个更大的判断:特斯拉要做世界上最好的制造商,而且不是小幅领先,是领先到别人认为不可能的程度。他说SpaceX做到了最好的火箭,特斯拉做到了最好的车,制造也一样。

Silevo的技术优势有两条。第一是效率,同样面积的屋顶,发电量比低成本的中国组件多出三分之一。第二是外观。

第二条他讲得特别细。一栋40万美元的房子,屋顶装了难看的太阳能板,房子可能贬值5%;装了好看的太阳能板,房子可能升值5%。一來一回,是4万美元的价值差。就算只按2%到3%算,也是两万美元。

屋顶上装太阳能板让房子变好看,和让房子变难看,这是天壤之别。(Elon Musk)

Rusch追问的是工艺成本:亚洲厂商成本降得比预期快,还在绕关税,Silevo工厂投产时可能面临每瓦15美分的成本劣势。

马斯克没有正面回答具体工艺路线,只说自己去过湾区Silevo的试验线,看到的是相对直接的制造流程,没有什么物理限制阻止它做到全球最低成本。

Rusch接着问,SolarCity本质上是特种施工加特种金融公司,特斯拉是技术制造公司,除了销售侧,还有什么协同?

马斯克的答案出乎意料:最大的资产是安装队。

一大批受过训练的人,懂全国各市政厅的许可流程和文书,懂37种不同的屋顶怎么处理,有一套高效的上门物流体系。这些东西建起来很慢,买下来很快。

为什么是2016年,不是2014或2018

Charlie Anderson问时机。

马斯克的回答分两头。特斯拉这边,Powerwall和PowerPack正在放量,第二代在开发,第三代第四代的产品路线图已经有了。SolarCity那边,Silevo收购案筹备了两年的组件即将推出,效率和外观都有大幅改善。

两个产品周期在这个时间点交汇。

他还说了一句略带遗憾的话:也许我们应该更早做这件事。但绝不认为现在做太早。

后面回答另一个问题时,他把这句话说得更重:长期看,特斯拉和SolarCity的融合没有任何疑问,唯一的问题是时机。两家公司的产品路线图都指向同一个方向,那些路线图大部分是公开信息,真正关键的部分他不能讲。

10%的溢价和万亿美元市值

Albert Fried的分析师Steve把估值问题摆上桌:市场对换股比例有意见,SolarCity的资产负债表让人不安,这个价格会不会损害特斯拉股东的利益?

马斯克的回答是,特斯拉拿到的是个不错的价格。要约价格是按公开市场价定的,特斯拉不决定SolarCity的股价,市场决定。收购溢价在20%多到30%之间,不高不低,比微软收购LinkedIn的50%左右低不少,基本就是公开市场并购的平均水平。

然后他给了一个很大的数字。

明年,尤其是再往后看,这些数字会显得非常小。作为一家合并后的汽车、储能和发电公司,特斯拉有潜力成为万亿美元市值的公司。(Elon Musk)

他的逻辑是:如果特斯拉在推动世界转向新的能源生产、储存和交通方式中扮演主要角色,这个市值就是结果。到那时候,收购价格上下的几亿美元,不会有人记得。

2016年的特斯拉市值大约300亿美元,万亿美元是当时的三十多倍。这句话在会议记录里显得突兀,但马斯克说得很平静。

马斯克不投票,但他劝你投赞成

Steve追问:你和你的人都回避投票,那怎么保证短期股东能投赞成票?

马斯克的回答分两层。第一层是价格有边界,超出合理范围任何一方都不会同意。第二层是他个人的态度。

我会回避股东投票,这必须由我和其他股东之外的人来决定。但我做这件事,是因为我相信它让事情变好,不是变坏。我强烈建议投赞成票,因为任何不投赞成票的人,都是在投票反对自己的最大利益。(Elon Musk)

他说自己对这笔交易零怀疑。原话是:如果你觉得有更好的做法,道德上更好的,或者执行上更好的,告诉我。我们尽量做得比法律要求的更公平。

Steve又问:所以你认为特别委员会做完尽职调查,双方董事会都会同意?

马斯克说两家董事会目前的意见是一致的,除非尽调发现了他和所有董事都不知道的东西,那种概率极低。

产品导向的人祝贺,财务导向的人担心

J.P. Morgan的分析师问,有没有跟特斯拉最大的无利害关系股东聊过,他们怎么看。

马斯克说没有,因为希望所有人同时听到消息。但过去几年,这个想法跟一些机构股东讨论过,有人觉得是顺理成章的事。

他讲了一个观察。公告发出去之后,产品导向的人发来的是祝贺,附带一句你们怎么没早点做。财务导向的人,担心明显更多。

然后他给出了自己的价值判断:长期看,公司的价值由产品和服务的价值决定。做好产品的公司迟早会有好估值,做烂产品的公司迟早会有烂估值。这是系统本来的设计。

救助的说法从哪来

Steve后来又问了一次,这次更直接:有分析师说这笔交易是对SolarCity的救助,如果股东不投票支持,SolarCity会怎样?

马斯克明显不认同这个说法。他说特斯拉不决定SolarCity的市值,股市决定。SolarCity完全可以按现在的估值增发股票,他认为没有任何问题。公司三到五个月内现金流就会转正。一家即将现金流为正、又有能力自己融资的公司,被收购怎么能叫救助。

我不知道救助这个说法是从哪来的。这显然是一个错误的描述。(Elon Musk)

他还被问到,过渡期特斯拉会不会给SolarCity提供资金。他说如果SolarCity短期受限于不能自己发股,特斯拉会提供过桥贷款,这是公平合适的做法。但他不认为真的会用到。

世界很大,夏威夷的电很贵

Goldman Sachs的Patrick Archambault搬出了落基山研究所的研究:太阳能加储能的平准化度电成本,可能还要五到十年才能低于现有电价。既然这样,为什么你们这么有信心现在就成立?

马斯克的回答是地理。世界很大,各地电价差得很远。夏威夷的电很贵,因为发电用的燃料要船运过去。岛屿国家、欧洲很多地方、美国很多地方,太阳能加电池的经济性已经压倒性合理。

然后他讲了一条技术采用的曲线。新技术扩散是S形:早期人们低估它的速度,进入指数增长,到线性增长阶段人们又开始高估,最后对数增长收尾。互联网这样,手机也这样。太阳能加储能会走同一条路。

Archambault追问,美国市场五年内经济性合理吗?

马斯克说绝对可以,只要规模大到让工厂满负荷运转。他说自己昨天的会全是关于怎么加快电芯、电池、整车的产量爬坡,把所有限制因素一个个拆掉。

0.2米/秒的汽车厂

这场电话会议里有一段跟收购没什么关系,但信息密度最高。

马斯克讲他怎么看制造。核心概念是制造机器的机器。他说第三代产线能做到数量级的改进,到时候看起来像外星无畏舰,人们会问那是什么鬼东西。

让他不理解的是,为什么大家没意识到改进空间有多大。他说这是高中物理水平的问题,不复杂。走进工厂,做一次体积密度计算:建筑内部的空间里,有多少体积在干有用的事,多少是空气或者闲置。算出来的比例会让人震惊,通常是个位数。

再算产品的出口速度。全世界最快的汽车工厂,整车离开产线的速度大约是每秒0.2米。马斯克说,这个速度相当于老奶奶推着助行器走路。跑得最快的人能到每秒10米。

为什么汽车厂的出口速度只有每秒0.2米?这太荒唐了。为什么汽车厂的体积效率只有个位数的低段?没人会设计一艘体积效率2%的船,那看起来很可笑,但工厂就是这么设计的。(Elon Musk)

他说30%到40%的体积效率完全可以做到。Model 3的目标是外星无畏舰的0.5版,最明显的改进会出现在电芯生产上。特斯拉的工程团队和松下合作,把电芯卷绕效率做到了世界最好工厂的三倍左右。他的形容是:电芯会像机关枪子弹一样飞出来,实际上比机关枪子弹还快。

为什么不让你把车当电池用

RBC的分析师Joseph Spack问了两件事,一件是净计量(net metering)政策变化对商业模式的影响,一件是车辆到电网(vehicle-to-grid)支持。

净计量这块,马斯克承认内华达、亚利桑那几个州的政策变化有影响。纽约谈出了合理的安排。储能成本每年大幅下降,两到三年内就能跑在政策变化前面。

他也承认公用事业公司有一部分道理:太阳能占比超过某个局部比例,确实会对电网造成冲击,确实需要缓冲。只是这个影响被夸大了。

车辆到电网,他的态度很明确:技术上早就做过,早期的Roadster原型车就能反向送电,但用户体验会变成灾难。什么时候允许车给房子供电,什么时候不允许,电池被抽干到什么程度,这些规则很难定。最尴尬的场景是:家里灯亮着,车却开不走,因为电都被房子用掉了。

他的方案是解耦。车是车,固定电池是固定电池,太阳能是太阳能,三者分开。电网层面的调节,靠公用事业规模的太阳能加电池电站来做,因为独栋房子的屋顶面积不够,公寓楼更不够。

他顺便提了Powerwall发布会上那张图:供整个美国用电需要的土地面积,只是德州或犹他州的一个小角落。那个角落里还有一个小方块,是支撑全美国电网所需的电池组占地面积。他说那只是图上的一个像素。

点击这里,买一个微电网

最后一位提问者问微电网和电网级市场的机会。

马斯克的回答是产品化。他希望做到点击这里,你得到一个微电网,而不是每个项目都定制。产品化之后,事情能发生得很快。

消费者喜欢简单快速,商业和公用事业客户也一样。他们不想走冗长的采购流程。按一个按钮,东西装好,能用,他们会很惊讶。

他的总结是:产品大,不意味着流程必须复杂。大和复杂不是一回事。

把视线从细节抬起来

会议结束前,马斯克说了段总结。

他说这类讨论很容易陷进细节里,但正确的做法是抬头看未来,看宏观趋势往哪走,然后问自己:这个动作是不是顺着历史潮流的方向。

他给了一个比喻。未来的人回看今天,会觉得烧汽油像我们回看蒸汽机,是一个奇怪的阶段。更奇怪的是,我们把恐龙和古植物的液态残骸从地下挖出来,装进车里烧掉,或者送进电厂烧掉。他会跟孙子说,你不敢相信我们当年干了什么。

这场电话会议的名字叫收购说明会,实际讲的是一个能源公司的自我定义。太阳能负责生产,电池负责缓冲,电动车负责消耗,三样东西在同一家公司里设计、销售、安装、维护。

至于26亿美元贵不贵,换股比例合不合理,Silevo的产线什么时候能跑通,SolarCity的债什么时候能转正,这些问题在会议里都没有完整答案。Todd Maron一开始就说了,这是过程的开头,不是结尾。

市场后来给出了自己的答案。交易在2016年11月获得双方股东批准,特斯拉股东以85%的比例赞成。SolarCity股价在公告后跌了不少,特斯拉股价也跌了大约10%。

七年后再看,这笔交易的价值判断变得更复杂。特斯拉能源业务在2023年做到60亿美元营收,增速跑赢汽车。SolarCity这个品牌消失了,安装业务被整合进特斯拉能源,屋顶光伏产品变成了Solar Roof。Silevo的技术路线几经调整,没有变成马斯克描述的那种颠覆。

但马斯克在电话会议里讲的那套框架,太阳能加储能加电动车,确实成了特斯拉后来的主线。Megapack现在是特斯拉增长最快的业务之一,储能部署量在2023年翻了一倍多。

回到那场电话会议,最有价值的部分可能是那几个跟收购无关的段落:0.2米/秒的汽车厂,个位数的体积效率,机关枪一样的电芯。这些是马斯克判断制造业的方式,也是他敢用26亿美元买一家亏损公司的底气。

如果你在自己的行业里也遇到过接口对不上就互相甩锅的问题,这场会议提供了一个思路:与其在两家公司之间修接口,不如把它们放进同一个容器里。代价是你要处理估值、董事会、股东投票这些麻烦事。收益是你可以设计一个完整的系统,而不是两个勉强拼在一起的半成品。

这个判断不总是对的。SolarCity的整合花了几年,屋顶业务的转型也不顺利,2019年特斯拉能源的营收还出现过下滑。但马斯克在会议里说的那句话值得记住:公司存在的意义,是创造更有说服力的产品和服务。如果两家公司合起来能做出更好的东西,那就应该合。

下面几条是可以直接拿走的判断标准:

  • 看一笔并购,先分清它解决的是产品问题还是财务问题。产品问题有长期价值,财务问题通常只是把麻烦推后。
  • 判断协同效应,别听形容词,算上门次数、销售成本、硬件重复率这些具体数字。马斯克给的30%到40%,是拿一次上门对比两三次上门算出来的。
  • 遇到利益冲突,合并成一家公司是干净的解法,做特殊交易是最脏的解法。这条在任何一个有多方股东的结构里都成立。
  • 看制造业的潜力,先算体积密度和出口速度。这两个数字低得离谱的行业,改进空间通常也大得离谱。0.2米/秒和个位数百分比,就是马斯克眼里的机会。
  • 技术采用是S形曲线,早期低估和中期高估都会发生。用线性外推做五年以上的决策,大概率会错。
  • 产品导向的人和财务导向的人对同一笔交易的反应经常相反。两边的意见都要听,但拉长到五年,产品决定估值。
  • 看一家公司的收购,别只看它买了什么,要看它买完之后能不能把接口拆掉。接口越少,甩锅越少,bug 修得越快。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00good day ladies and gentlemen welcome to the Tesla Motors conference call at this time all participants on the listen only mode later we will conduct the question and answer session and instructions will follow at that time if anyone should require assistance during the call please press star then zero on your touchone telephone as a reminder this conference may be recorded I would like to introduce your host for today's conference Mr Jeff Evanson investor relations Tesla Motors sir you may begin thank you teria and good morning everyone welcome to Tesla's call to discuss the rationale for our offer to acquire Solar City I'm joined today by Elon Musk Tesla chairman and CEO Todd

0:41Marin Tesla general counsel JB strable our CTO and CFO Jason Wheeler yesterday we announced our offer to acquire Solar City in filings with the SEC and through a blog post available at www.tesla.com during our call this morning we'll discuss our our some of our business Outlook and make other forward-looking statements these are based on our predictions and expectations as of today actual events or results could differ materially due to a risk a number of risks and uncertainties including those mentioned in our most recent form 10q filed with the SEC we're going to start today's call with some comments by Todd and then Elon followed by Q&A so go

1:34ahead and press star one now to get into the que to ask a question and with that I'll pass it over to you Todd good morning everyone thanks Jeff so I just wanted to briefly touch on some of the process points and why yesterday's announcement might have looked somewhat different to people who normally see these kinds of announcements it's actually somewhat of a easy explanation but it's it is somewhat of a unique situation so usually I know that everyone is is used to seeing an announcement when there's actually a definitive agreement that's reached and not just simply an offer and obviously in our situation we were only announcing an offer and

2:14then as a result you didn't receive the same kind of information that you would receive when an agreement is reached such as the agreement itself and detailed financial information about the combined company the reason for that is that Elon is a 5% stockholder in Solar City and he's required by the Securities laws to keep the market informed through a schedule 13d filing about his plans with respect to those Holdings and because of Tesla's decision to make an offer to Solar City and Elon support for that decision it was appropriate to amend his schedule 13d to update the market even though no definitive agreement had yet been reached it's obviously Our Hope

2:53to engage in a due diligence process with Solar City and ultimately reach that agreement and all that information that you would customarily see at that time including the agreement itself and detailed financial information about the combined companies would be provided then but the result of this is that this is actually a more transparent process because you're essentially seeing behind the curtains more than you would ordinarily see in a transaction because you're actually getting additional information upfront at the offer stage and getting an advanced look at the Strategic business rationale for the deal and so with that I'll actually pass pass it over to

3:30Elon so that he can speak more about the Strategic rationale for the deal and why we do think that combining the two companies makes sense here sure I I did touch on most of this yesterday but I think what this call is mostly going to be about is getting into maybe some of the detailed questions that people have the

3:54you as I said yesterday there's there's kind of three parts to and and as I said the at the actually power wall presentation last year so is part of why I think this is really quite quite an obviously correct move is that in order to solve the sustainable energy question we need a sustainable energy production which is going to come

4:19primarily in the form of solar overwhelmingly in the form of solar in my view then with combine that with stationary storage and and electric vehicle and you have a complete solution to sustainable energy future and those are the three parts that that are needed and and that's those are the three things that I think Tesla should be providing and it just became increasingly obvious that as we're developing the power wall and new versions of the power wall is we integrate more of

4:56the Inver verter electronics and the intell in the power wall it it really you really need to take the solar panels and solar system into account when doing that otherwise you duplicate a lot of Hardware that doesn't work together as well it's more expensive the installation cost is substantially higher since you've got to put the Sol power wall inst the solar panels if you got an electric car you got install the the W connector and a

5:30home charging system there's potentially three three visits there's at least two visits and then in terms of the the sales process itself when we're selling somebody the power wall very often if not almost always they're curious about solar and want to do the same thing so then not being able to sell them solar directly at Solar City oh sorry the Tesla through our stores is is pretty inefficient but you as you look ahead to say model 3 at a $355,000

6:10car well that same person in that same at the same moment we could sell them roughly an equivalent amount value of solar panels and and a power wall effectively doubling almost doubling the sale at that time and then and then putting it all in at the same time so that I mean I think the the word Synergy is B it's like sort of a dirty word but I I think it's I think the these synergies are really just common sense like obviously it's more efficient to do this as an integrated system at the sale and at the installation and and in terms of just general maintenance and and managing the customer relationship and yeah

7:04and I think I think that that makes it kind of a pretty obvious thing to do and it's it's quite difficult to create an integrated product if you're forced to be at an arms length and be two different companies so you know because if we give a special deal to Solar City and Solar City is not part of Tesla then why

7:35are we doing that so we can do that if Sol city is part of Tesla we can't do it if Sol city is a separate company so it just it just just makes things the the execution I think a lot easier and cleaner and more effective so you know that's why I said yesterday I think it's really It's Kind it's kind of an no-brainer like if we didn't do this it would make Tesla's execution harder and worse and you know and I think the the tide of History very strongly supports it will will be a sustainable energy future primarily solar and you know virtually entirely electric vehicles and May that temporarily interrupt that side of History but in

8:35long term it will overwhelm everything and our goal is to accelerate the event of that future as fast as possible and this helps us accelerate it so that that's the reason and yeah so yeah and I think there been some some questions about like does this sort of really increase our our debt position or

9:06whatever the bank balance sheet it really doesn't I think really encourage people to take a Clos look at Solar City the you what really matters is the the the recour debt obviously the non- recour debt is is not not what matters and the the cash flows generating that that that's supposed to be will generate you it covers all the you know what's

9:41required with the recourse dat so U they are headed to cash flow positive situation over the next 3 to six months the outside and that that's where the company's been steering itself reducing their growth rate some degree to achieve that cash flow positive position but they're very quietly on their way to getting there short order so it it actually we expect it

10:22to be a net cash generator not not a user of cash particularly when taking into account the dramatic reduction in the cost of sales of Sol systems sold through our store or through our Stores the biggest factor in Sol cities increasing cost per wat in q1 was their sales cost so as soon as you that quite quite increase in sales cost that that'll go radically another Direction with s s through through Tesla

11:05and then I'd love to talk more about what's going to happen on the product side obviously that would be I think shed that would shed a lot of light on this deal and why I think it it makes total sense and really is a no-brainer but I can't talk about you know teral non public plans you know except that I'm

11:37very optimistic about those plans and that that while to date Solar City has not been significantly differentiated on the product side you know terms of the Sol Palace themselves they certainly will be in The Fairly near future and actually if you just listen carefully what Sol has been saying in the in its earnings calls and its announcements that I think should be also pretty clear like that you that so he saying that there's going to be significant part differentiation there's the SLO acquisition which we think is the the best technology out there for high efficiency low class solar panels and

12:35at the same time very significantly improving the Aesthetics of the solar panels like I think there's quite a radical difference between having solar panels on your roof that actually make your house look better versus ones that do not I think this is I is going to be a night and day difference and the SLO development allows for that

13:06so any the we can't go into the details of those because making kind of future product announcements that are really exciting obviously affect future product sales and yeah it's the full extent of that is is not is not yet publication but but I do believe it it fits together very well with Tesla's plans on the power wall and power pack side

13:43yeah so we can turn it over to questions at this point all right thanks Elon teria why don't we go to the first question please certainly our first question comes from the line of Brian Johnson of Barkley please your line is now open yes thank you I have about three questions for one for Elon one for we start with the general counsel and Jason for Todd you know you you talked in the letter about two of the directors not voting can you give us a sense because this will come out in the proxy eventually of the discussions between the two companies is there actually a committee of independent directors how independent do you consider the remaining directors do they have any

14:31personal ownership of Solar City and the other things that are likely to relate to the board issues so this is Todd you know when this is a little bit tracks back to what I was saying earlier about the stage of the process that we're in but when a deal is announced if that happens all this stuff will come out in terms of exactly what the process was at every point the key points now are that Elon and Antonio since they're on both Boards of exuse themselves from the board process of of voting on the transaction and they've also committed to if there's a deal that the disinterested shareholders would vote on that deal with a majority of those disinterested

15:13shares determining the outcome of the vote but beyond that it's really too early in the process to get through to get into all the different details but rest assured that will all come out once there's actually a definitive agreement that's reached at this point it's probably more appropriate to just focus on the business rationale for why this deal makes sense which and just when you say recruit from voting does that also mean recused from discussion and not present in the room when this was brought up no no it was recused from voting okay for Jason you know given your talk earlier in the year about kind of focusing on cash and even you know stipulating perhaps that Solar

15:55City could reach some sort of cash break even by 4 quarter you know how does this change your view of the proformer companies in terms of their cash usage and their need to potentially go back to the capital arets either debt or Equity to finance the ongoing business yeah sure on the on the Tesla side I I stick with the statements that we made on previous earnings calls on the Solar City side you know as Todd has laid out we're just at the beginning of the process now and the only information you know I've had access to is what's publicly available so I don't have anything to say about the performer combined entity at this point and you know we'll we'll start

16:41to look at that as we get into the full due diligence now and I guess I guess a due diligence question at least probably scoped out before you did the deal you know when you survey Tesla owners you know what percent have solar already what percent are in states where solar would make sense you know how and sort of just what are some of the basic kind of merger synergies in terms of customer overlap and customer potential that you guys looked at well I mean the

17:18the I think the way to think about this is not not to kind of look in the review miror but look through the wind windshield like only about 1% of us homes have solar so you have a massive addressable Market that that's unserved it was at least 40 to 60 million households that were were solar where they they could do solar if they wanted to so if the economics were right and they liked the Aesthetics and it was easy to do then they would do it so the

18:02the future Market there is really gigantic and yeah I mean on on the cash cash front like we we don't expect Solar City to have a material impact on future cash needs yeah I mean it's don't think it's going to make make much of a difference really the yeah positive Cash Flow by the end of the year and just final you know you talked a little bit yesterday but how does this affect the how do you make sure that your personal time between this and of course a rocket business given the m&a NE that synergies that you're trying to get given the sales the service overlap that's kind of a whole separate line of processes and you know te kind of grunt work on the ground from

18:57launching a new model car how do you actually get both the integration of a sales and service system for solar and cars and batteries done at the same time you've got a you know by your own admission aggressive launch schedule for the model three well I mean my intuition about this could be wrong but I mean from my standpoint this makes Tesla's future execution easier not harder you know because I it's just get increasingly unwi be to work with Solar City at on an arms length basis we really need to have an integrated product the power wall and the

19:40Power Pack need to be designed together with the solar system so it's it's it's a one piece thing and we we we really can't do that if we're two separate companies we've got to you know we've got to treat solo city like there like there any other company which is extremely unwieldy so from my standpoint this makes the execution easier not harder and I think Sol City's got a got a great future independent of Tesla but

20:25and and obviously Tesla is but I but but being able to integrate things at the product level at at the you know at the consumer experience level the utility level the commercial level it just it actually it makes it easier not harder you that's that's why we're doing this I mean it's like why why should companies exist at all like what what's the point of having companies the point is to that that that a given company is going to create a more compelling good or service

21:10for for the customer and and then so should the companies be two separate containers or one container and if they're one container we can make AAL compiling product and work together easier so that's the reason for it so I think I think that that it speaks to the sort of fundamental economic goodness of the transaction and it would be harder if we if we if we remain two different companies okay thank you thank you and our next question comes from Charlie Anderson of do and Company your line is now open

21:58okay and our next question comes from line of Brian Johnson of Barclays your line is now open well I already asked a question yeah Tria why don't we go to the next caller please let's try Charly again okay our next question comes from the line of Charlie Anderson of darly and Company your line is now open yeah good morning thanks for taking my questions so I I wondered if shareholders of Tesla will have a synergies number in mind when they vote and if you guys have any early look at what synergies could be and you know are you expecting much in the way of cost and you know just thinking about the incremental cost of combining the products you know what will that be

22:48it sounds like some of the work has already been done to combine the products but just any thoughts on that would be helpful sure I mean give estimates because obviously this is still the early stages and I mean their estimates based on kind of what stands to reason but you know you look

23:07looking ahead particularly to next year selling model 3 kind of something on the order of a $35,000 car if we're selling Power walls and and solar systems of comparable value then and doing so in the same sales footprint with the same person the first over approximation our cost of sales should drop in half as as would solar cities correspondingly maybe it's not entirely in half maybe it's you know 30 to 40% but it's a pretty I think a very substantial drop on SOL City side and also a drop of a material drop on Tesla side U because

23:56you're basically selling let's say almost twice as much in a single transaction as you otherwise would and and then on the installation setup side it's one crew instead of and one visit instead of two to three visits the ongoing maintenance is kind of one point of contact and not sort of two or three points contacts and

24:29the the the cost of the system itself is lower because we're not duplicating Hardware the hardware level so I think that that all makes makes a lot of sense yeah so the fundamental cost for both companies would go down materially and yeah it's I I think it's we can argue about like is it sort of 20% reduction 30% reduction 40% reduction but it's pretty significant and and for sure better than if the companies were were

25:14separate great and then just another quick one from from me I wondered why now versus two years ago versus two years from now yeah the the reason now is because we've got we're really ramping up Power wall and power pack and we're developing version two and then we have kind of our plans for version three version four and so forth Solar City also is preparing you to come out with the solar panels that as consequence of the civo transaction a couple years ago that significantly improved

26:01the efficiency and the Aesthetics of the roof and I think the Aesthetics matter a lot as you know Tesla were super sensitive to Aesthetics and I think soci cities you know I think they're they're going to get there on their own but I think that that Journey will will be accelerated

26:31as part of Tesla as well you know just sort of makes sense that like if you had our solar system that made your house look better lowered your cost of electricity and and then gave you security with against the power outage with the the power pack and and and allowed you go potentially completely off grid then

27:03that's kind of a no-brainer like why wouldn't you do that thanks so much thank you our next question comes from station cha of Albert freed your line is now open hi good morning congratulations on the offer couple questions I think that people are kind of trying to digest I think strategically Elon that you've made

27:33your points clear but I think the valuation is what the market is having issues with you know there are some questions about solar solar cities balance sheet and you mentioned about the debt so how do you put that into context with the you know exchange ratio that you've offered you know kind of not jeopardizing kind of the future of you know Tesla while you make this

28:06offer well I think Tesla is getting a pretty good you know at current share price I mean the tend doesn't decide what you know company's share price on public market should be the public market does so we're just obviously keying off of what the you know public market price is which is decided by people yeah like other than ourselves and and then as you know I think

28:36a quite quite you know a reasonable neither High nor low acquisition premium that is you being put forward subject to further diligence and I think it's I mean I think you know every elevance of it is is very reasonable like something that's out of whack about the proposal it's sort of you know extremely normal to have a acquisition premium of that that size it's certainly you quite a bit lower than for example say linkedin's LinkedIn I think had a% premium you here we're talking about a sort of you know low low 20s to maybe maybe 30% premium so it's seem it's more or less in line with the the average acquisition premium for any given Public Market

29:42company so it's like if extremely normal and and and then just over all these you know I think when people when we're down the road not even far down the road like you know next year but particularly as you go further into the future these numbers are going to seem like very small very small numbers you know and

30:12I think as a combined automotive and Power storage and power generation company I mean the potential is there for Tesla to be a trillion dollar company like Market cap company yeah so we you know if if we play a major role in transitioning the world to a new form of energy generation and storage and transport you that's what kind of it's kind of what happens so that's yeah I think I think the one

30:52isn't going to be worried about whether it's a you a few hundred million dolls one way the other here down the road it's not you know really going to make a difference okay I I appreciate your your your your cander about the the trillion dollar market cap I think that leads to you know the future

31:15value of of Solar City but I guess the near term because you're not voting your shares both on Tesla and and Solar City from from my understanding of the how do you expect the the near-term kind of shareholders or near-term Focus shareholders to kind of vote this in vote in favor of this I'm assuming it's a simple majority and so it it's kind of a chicken and egg thing where your your your your future your your expectation of the future is is is probably correct

31:55strategically but near term people are having more time to digest this not enough time to digest this and and kind of looking more near term and and that's what the concern is is getting to the finish line so how do you see this getting to the Finish Line where you see shareholders on the Solar City side being receptive to the exchange ratio you reach a merger agreement and then further along you know Tesla shareholders being receptive to you know voting in favor of this because ultimately it's these two or three Ducks you know valuation of the exchange ratio and then understanding the future opportunity that will get this to the finish line on the shareholder side

32:41shareholder vote yeah I mean the exchange ratio obviously I mean there's there's some bounds on the exchange ratio that that you know if if we exceed the bounds of reasonableness for for any party obviously it it wouldn't happen so you know said the obviously the the market cap of so cities decide about the market so that's what it it is what investors think it is and then the the premium you know you you don't get to acquire companies for zero premium that's just not how it works

33:20and so some reasonable premium obiously is appropriate in a situation like this as it always is and you know we're kind of right where premiums normally are and and actually lower than some recent prominent premiums paid like the the LinkedIn one which said I believe was on the order of 50% so I think that you know we're it's a reasonable market cap with a reasonable premium and what can maybe equival

33:57around the edges a little bit but it's I don't think this anything's like out of whack there and but at the end this will definitely be up to the you know you guys who own shares like I said I'll recuse myself from the shareholder vote it'll has it has to be a you know majority of nonme shareholders and

34:28but but like I said I I'm doing this because I think it makes things better and in the future not not worse for everyone and so I'd really recommend voting a favor of this because I think anyone who doesn't vote in favor of this is going to be voting against their best interests but we will certainly abide by the shareholder vote so if there's a great deal of unhappy this we we want to move forward but I just really want to emphasize that I I have zero doubt about this zero

35:09you know arguably we should have done it sooner but I think doing it now is it gives us enough time to create a compelling integrated product assuming it doesn't take forever to close gives us time to create a a very compelling integrated product and bring that to significant scale next year okay so when you say you have no doubt so you believe the special committee independent board when they do their due diligence you know and reverse due diligence on both companies that they'll reach you'll be able to reach your agreement that's that seems very likely at the board level yeah I mean like the board the V the V opinion is unanimous in both companies so

36:03so I mean they're they're I mean unless there's something discovered that like that I have no idea about or you know it's just what that no nobody on the board has any idea about which is extremely unlikely then you know that the board would the impend board members would recommend in favor of completing a transaction somewhere in the price Str range that was mentioned most likely and then

36:34it would be up to sharehold a vote to say excluding me to say yes or no and yeah so it's I think that's about as Fair as one could make it great thank you very much congratulations again yeah oh thanks yeah I mean if anybody here thinks like hey the there's some you know better way to do this you

37:02know like morally better way to do this or better way to do this from an ex execution standpoint like let me know but and we've tried to do this in the way that's in a way that's as Fair as possible and really going Beyond what's legally required and and to make it as as you know

37:28you know not just legally correct but morally correct thank you and our next question comes from the line of Colin Ro of Oppenheimer inco your line is now open thanks so much you know at what point are we going to get financial details here clearly there's been an awful lot of cross-pollination with the boards former CFO of Solar City is on the board of Tesla JV is is on the board of Solar City there's been a lot of sharing you know to to have a price here without some sort of scope of return on Capital you know I think would be incredibly important for us and so when are we going to get that information and you know you know without you you're

38:10begging off the the the detailing on synergies but I I think you know getting specific about return on capital for Tesla shareholders will be essential to to getting this done you know when are we going to get that information yeah I agree I I agree I mean as Todd was saying like we kind of have to do this in a bit of an unwieldy way because I'm largest shareholder of both companies if that wasn't the case we could you know we could do a lot of this and then and kind of present you with like the like the the full full

38:47and final details of the proposed merger and what the you know but but but before we since since I'm like large in both companies we have to tell you at the beginning of the process not the end so we'll certainly have all that that done for you but the reason it's not just all you know in a neat package is because this is a sort of an odd case

39:25where we have to we have to tell you at the start of the process before we have all the answers rather than at the end of the process get definitely get all that information but I'm confident it will be extremely galing okay and then the second question is around civo so there's actually a lot going on in terms of manufacturing for solar at this point with Asian manufacturers reducing cost well in excess of what expectations have been and certainly there's folks that are getting around the import duties you know even with the the potential savings on on installation costs with the the extra efficiency at civo you know it looks like you know there

40:09there isn't going to be that much of a cost Advantage just from a raw cost perspective when you look at a price point for solar panels coming into the US that Solar City would buy you know can you talk a little bit about you know your begging off some of the the product details here but you know what you're expecting Tesla to be able to bring to that Engineering Process to improve that cost trajectory Because by the time you get that civo factory up and running you know there's going to be you know I think at least a 15 cent cost disadvantage for their their target cost at this point and I think there's something that needs to get done there

40:41to to make that a compelling compelling offering sure so so Tesla we're putting a lot of effort into becoming world's best manufacturer and and I really mean that that's like I'm highly confident we will be the world's best manufacturer just as we you know I said we would build the world's best car we did that you know SpaceX I said we build the world's best rocket we did that we're going to be the world's best manufacturer not by a small margin but by a margin that people don't even think is possible you know I I I believe taking a first principles physics based approach to analysis and and my analysis of the situation is that dramatic improvements

41:36are possible on the automotive side and on the ptic side the an an important advantage of the the SLO technology is that it has significantly higher efficiency than the the very lowc cost chin panels so on the same surface area of roof you can get you know as much as a third more power and then aesthetically speaking

42:13the S panels look better they look a lot better and if it's done right we can make your roof look better with solar panels than without this is a night and day difference and if you've got a let's say somebody's got a you know a $400,000 house if you make the roof look ugly then arguably you've made that house worth 5% less or some some non z% less valuable on the other hand if you make the roof look beautiful you've made it the house more valuable and maybe that's plus 5% or some non zero plus percent in the value of the house if it is something on the order of 5% then the value Delta there is called $440,000 or maybe it's

43:16maybe it's only like 2 or 3% and it's and it's it's 20,000 you know it's like there's it's it's you have quite a big value Delta so being able to have higher power that looks great and I think at costs that are at least as good if not better than what's coming from anywhere else in the world that's obviously a winning outcome and that's the outcome that we will pursue and I think we'll I conf we'll get there okay I I'll follow up on that I think my question was more around the process technology it's leave than than the ultimate fundamentals of the yeah

44:02the the fundamentals of the the the process technology you know and we're going to get the cost out I think there are a variety of detailed questions I can come back with you with but the my follow-up question on that is just you know fundamentally Solar City is a specialty construction and specialty Finance entity at its heart and and so as you look at Tesla being you know a value added manufacturer of variety of products and a technology company moving into what we see as as a fundamentally different business you know where are you seeing the synergies come back to Tesla other than the sales side is there something to do on that specialty Finance expertise that you

44:41would be bringing in house and you know the the actual boots on the ground you know the footprint of Solar City is incredibly important to actually en closing sales and and delivering things versus the footprint of of Tesla's customer base which is very different than than the concentrated footprint on at Solar City how are you seeing the value come back to Tesla other than just in in the the cost of customer acquisition yeah I mean I think the the biggest asset that we' be acquiring is the are the installers the the installation team of Solar City and and allot of people trained in doing the permitting and the paperwork and all the complexities that exist

45:29in municipalities throughout the country and understanding how to deal with you know 37 different roof types and having an efficient Logistics infrastructure for doing the installations and then I think this this some strengths in the C City sales side that we can take advantage of and yeah so but but I really don't I do

46:07want to emphasize like I think the SLO technology is going to make quite a big difference and and I I don't I don't see any fundamental cost issues that prevented from being at or lower cost per whatt than any other panel in the world okay thanks me I spent time in the you know in the Sol City SLO pilot plant in the Bay Area and you know so I'm not not UNF familiar with this and in my observation is there are traumatic improvements where like there's not some physical thing that's preventing it from being s super competitive right it's

46:59it's yeah actually relatively straightforward manufacturing process okay thanks a lot all right Elon and Todd I've it's Jeff I've had a a number of people emailing in questions about process here possible timeline Todd or Elon if you want to speak to kind of a recap of who who needs to vote who's recused and and how how and when diligence disclosure and the shareholder votes might might happen that might be helpful sure I can I can take that if you want so on the Tesa side the board has approved going forward with the offer which is why we made the announcement that an offer was made Elon and Antonio being Direct dors on both boards recuse themselves

47:58from the vote on that we're now in a in a stage where we've delivered the offer to Solar City Solar City will set up their board process on their end and decide how to do this so that it's done as as he La set not only legally but morally correctly I'm sure and then we'll move into a diligence phase very quickly hopefully diligence can can take place you know promptly so in the next two three weeks and we can get to a place where everything makes sense that there's a assign merger agreement and at that point everyone would receive the the merger agreement as well as the typical disclosures that would be provided at that time combined substantials proxy statements and

48:38everything and we'd move to a shareholder vote we're now getting a little bit further out so it's harder to predict with with certainty but the hope would be that there would be a shareholder vote on each side in the next few months thank you and our next question comes from the line of Joseph Spock of RBC Capital markets your line is now open thanks so I guess I just wanted to get your your sense on how much of a play you think the solar

49:12City bet is on on Lower storage costs meaning you know we've seen some proposed changes to net metering laws and and if that sort of continues or or or there's more of that does how long does the business model work like do you need do you need to see the falling storage cost for it to work and and are and is your confidence in that the reason to go forward with the deal yeah the storage cost is going to drop really dramatically with each passing year and and I think

49:51the you know I mean depending with exclusion of certain situations like Nevada maybe Arizona which you know what we're working to mitigate the it's it'll be ahead of the net metering situation as like in New York a reasonable deal has been arranged and you know basically this this gets ahead of the net metering situation you call it roughly the two to threee time frame so so it's it's definitely important for long term and although you know some of the utilities will exaggerate the impact of solar on the the grid ultimately the impact of solar on the grid Beyond a certain localized percentage does have an impact and you do need to to buffer the power so

50:40so they have a value argument it's just exaggerated so it's obviously very important for for the long term and yeah it's it's going to work together well I mean this is what the world needs you know this is the ultimate solution for Earth is what we're talking about here solar power stationary storage electric cars this is Earth's solution and we're going to try to make that happen as fast as possible and the fundamental good of Solar City and Tes will be measured by the read of which we accelerate that transition so we're going try to make it happen as fast as possible and you know I think we'll have a meaningful impact on that time frame and then maybe just two real quick

51:26on if the deal is consummated do do you have you given any thought or plan to provide segmented balance sheet or cash flow just to to to provide a little bit more transparency on each line and then and then on a technical point so you will do that yeah I mean I do think it's it's valuable to have transparency

51:50so you we want to we we will want to show show that transparency as much as we can you some for some cases kind be like where exactly should the cost be allocated but I do think it's it's it wouldn't be great if it's like a black box that people can't figure out and then have to like somehow parse out what what pieces are what so we don't want

52:18to have an information discount to the stock because people are uncertain so I think that's having clearer information gives people a better understanding of the value of a company the various pieces it will inevitably you know lead some people to reach conclusions they maybe shouldn't reach or they're premature but I do believe in transparency and and then from a technical standpoint you talked about some greater seamlessness between the entities would would you also consider allowing vehicle to grid

52:53support I think we've deated this since the early days of the Roadster I mean even like the very Proto early Proto roadsters that we had would do vehicle vehicle deg grd but you do get a lot of complications with that if you backflow power through the through through the car into the wall like when is the car allowed to do that when is it not and and mean how

53:25much do you not the car battery to be drawn down and then you know people I think were pretty upset if they if the lights are on in the house but they can't drive their car because otherwise all the power in the house shuts down so I think the right solution is to decouple it and and into the vehicle stationary battery and

53:48solar and then OB we some need to supplement that power at the grid level by having you know utility scale solar battery installations because you you don't always have enough surface area on a house or certainly for an apartment building you don't have enough surface area so you got to kind of ground Mount the utility scale solar battery system and feed that to the grid but if if anyone that's you know seen my power wall presentation it's remarkable how little land you need to power the entire United States it's crazy like a little corner of Texas or Utah that's all United States is power and then then like there's like one pixel inside that box that I showed

54:42which is the box of how much land area you need to power the United States that was like a little box like I said fits into it like the little Texas pan little corner Utah and inside that box is one pixel that's the size that that that's the surface area the battery packs needed to support the entire United States one pixel so anyway we're going to try to

55:06build that as fast as we can and the us but throughout the world thanks and that that video by the way is available on our website of of Von's presentation on the Tesla Energy Products Elon we we are at the at the the half hour mark here we have nine more questioners in Q so I'll defer to you as as to determine how far long you want to go but let's try to try to yeah let's try try to answer everyone's questions and you know like I really would

55:51encourage like think about the longterm you know where's this all headed and I think if you think about like the longterm there's there's really no question about the convergence of Tesla and solo city it's really just a question of what timing is appropriate for that convergence and the you know it's it's basically solar City's product Lo map and Tesla's product Lo map which obviously you know very significant

56:22public information which I wish I could tell you about can't the timing is if anything we you know maybe we should have done this sooner but I I certainly don't think we're doing it too early and and then what you know what's the long-term picture long-term picture is a world with sustainable power generation with stationary storage to buffer that power and and electric cars and T is going to be lead be the leader in all three so if if you believe that that's the future we're headed towards which everything points that being true and really like gasoline caus we going to look back on gasoline cause like we look back on Steam Engines it was like a

57:19phase but weird like yeah and we're going to look back on fossil fuel power generation the same way it was a weird phase now we want to get out of that weird phase as soon as we can and this is all about accelerating us getting out of this idiosyncratic you know moment in in history when we were digging up sort of

57:49Cambrian level fossils and burning them and I you be telling your grandchildren like yeah you won't believe in what we used to do it's like we used to dig up you know the liquidized remains of of dinosaurs and old plants and put them in cars and and burn them to move and did the same thing to put the power plants and like that sounds crazy that's that's what it's going to be in the future obviously so anyway we're trying to have the the non-weird future get here as fast as possible all right terel let's go to the next question please certainly our next question comes from Tyler Frank of Robert Barrett your line is now open hey guys it's actually Ben kayb

58:41from Barrett Elon I was just wondering you know I understand you know working together and being cumbersome by separate entities but you know could you just talk us through what the difference is of actually owning Solar City versus maybe doing some kind of you know JV or some other kind of entity like that to help you guys you know work through some of the issues yeah I mean the problem is I think we we just we hit the you know it's like why we we don't have a a good basis for

59:16doing some special deal with Solar City because there effectively a conflict of interest I like ironically conflict of interest goes away for one company but it doesn't go away for two separate companies so like there's not really a good rationale for just offering a special deal and only working with one company that I I also happen to own

59:44you know just it's it's it's I don't think we have you know good moral legal basis for behaving in a special way to so City unless we're it's actually one company got it and then one more if I can could you just you know could you just rank some of the things that that you talked about in kind of the in the order you look at you know as far as you know Revenue synergies U from you know cross- selling the the technical synergies of you know being able to work with on both the manufacturing the the panel side as well as the battery side and then maybe the third one at being cost synergies and then if I forgot any out there maybe maybe list those as well in kind of the order that

1:00:33you're thinking of them thanks yeah I mean I think we'll have a a more definitive answer for you once this process wraps up so I mean i' regard what I'm saying here is anecdotal but it it it's kind of the way I think about it from a gut Point is like first and foremost do we offer what allows us to offer the most compelling product to Consumers and

1:01:08businesses and and and it seamlessly integrated product that all just works together that's that's better like you don't want to have to have a heterogeneous you know systems integration problem like that's you know that that that's just basically where the interfaces break down and then people they're sort of pointing fingers like this didn't work no yours thing didn't work it's like if it's just one integrated system there's no finger pointing there you know you can iron out all the bugs and it just works and you're not wondering whe should I blame the solar compy or the battery company or the who knows you know it's just like pay it's a sort of pay the

1:02:00butt to try to figure that out if you're the End customer and you know I think we can guide the integrator product to be the the right to just be right to be better that's so that's that kind out from that standpoint more than anything else and then in addition you know there's just obvious cost savings to be had if

1:02:30in the same store we can sell twice as much dollar volume like well it's the same store not selling twice as more stuff and if with the installation crew if they're now able to knock out three things in a single visit rather than schedule two or three separate visits that's also way better

1:03:02you know what can this sort of like how much better is it it's definitely some percentage better that's material you which is kind of but I mean that's kind of like the threshold for making a decision it's it's obviously going to be a lot better like if if there just if you just cut the visits down to you know from 203 to one okay you've probably cut your

1:03:31transport labor and Logistics cost maybe in half something like that and if you have a seamless integrated product you're going to have less servicing costs and things are going to break down less it's just it's just the thing you'd want to buy if you're the End customer or would you want to buy anything else

1:04:01thank you and our next question comes Brian Brinkman of JP Morgan your line is now open hi this is samic on behalf of Ryan just a quick one from us have you had conversations about this offer already with the largest disinterested shareholders of Tesla and what's your sense in terms of do they see the same value in the com combining the two businesses as you do and what's your sense about how they'll vote on this well everybody we wanted to make sure everyone heard about it at the same time so we've not discussed it with anyone

1:04:45because we wanted you know invest with SW and large to hear about it at the same time now s I've popped in that over the years have there been has this idea been banded about with some of our largest shareholders institutional shareholders yeah I mean there have been discussions and I think I think you know some of them see it as like a natural thing to do and but I mean it's interesting to sort of look at the feedback that I've received since we made the announcement yesterday anyone who's product focused sent me sort of a congratulatory note and like why didn't you do it sooner sort of message and and then people that sort of more Finance folks focused they were like a

1:05:51lot more worried about it but know in in you know in the long run the value of a company is defined by the value of its products and services that's like real important to bear in mind like it's why companies exist they shouldn't exist otherwise and you know the the value of the

1:06:10company will will follow the value of the product you know a company that's starts making lousy products is pretty soon going to have a lousy valuation company that makes great products is pretty soon going to have a great valuation because that's how the system is set up and it's how it should be set

1:06:32up oh great thank you thanks thanks thank you and our next question comes from Patrick archol of Goldman sax your line is now open great yeah thanks a lot for taking my question so so look I think a lot has been laid out about the Strategic vision for this you know longer term but I wanted to piggyback on on one of the earlier questions and and just get a sense of you know the possible Financial sense

1:07:07it makes kind of in the shorter term you know and correct me if I'm wrong I don't cover Solar City but my understanding is is is the storage plus you know solar piece of that business is actually quite small you know you've had places like the you rock Mountain Institute put out you know fairly detailed studies on you know combining solar Plus Storage you know that suggest the levelized cost of energy won't be lower than the current available you know price for you know maybe call it five to 10 years but you guys sound very confident that this makes sense sooner so I I I just wanted to get yeah definitely your view on that yeah I think the important thing is bear in mind like

1:07:59it's a big world out there and there are places where the cost of energy is much higher than other places like for for example in Hawaii energy costs are are very high because they have to ship in all of the fuel for their power plants so it's it's very expensive and so the economics of solar Plus Battery make overwhelming sense for places like why a lot of actually island nations out there U and and really any place that's got expensive energy costs or even moderately expensive energy costs and it's going to make sense for many parts of Europe many parts of the United States and yeah so it and and and then over

1:08:52time it's going to make sense for everywhere like everywhere is going to be solar battery I mean there'll be some wind of course some geothermal Hydro and and there'll be some long tail of you know before the final coal plant finally stops operating and the final natural gas plant stops operating I mean that those might last you know that'll be some long tail it's going to look like an S curve as is typical for new technology adoption so you know it's

1:09:31like in the beginning of the es curve people tend to underpredict what's going to happen and then it goes through an exponential growth phase then an approximately linear growth phase usually people overpredict what's going to happen in the Steep linear portion of the growth phase and then it goes back into a logarithmic sort to complete the s shape you know that's what happened with the internet for example cell phones same thing will happen here

1:10:06yeah and I guess like within the United States do you think like five years is a reasonable time frame for the economics to start to work oh yeah absolutely on a m question that okay Hest I mean it just needs to be on a scale that it's like that as allows our Factory to operate at maximum capacity so we yeah we think the factories can to be operating at maximum capacity as far into the future as we can see like it's this is all about production you my meetings yesterday all about guys we need to figure out how to rate ramp out our production of of cells batteries obiously cars faster and addressing every limiting factor that we can you know I know I mentioned like

1:11:12this whole thing about like manufacturing the machine that builds a machine it's like let me tell you like it's order of magnitude improvements are are are what I think can be achieved won't get there right away but by version three of the machine that builds the machine order magnitude that that

1:11:35that's the sort of you know compared to car manufacturing you look at that and you're like it'll seem like an alien dreadn like what the fu you like what the hell is that and it's just like it blows my mind that people don't realize just how much improvement potential is is possible and I mean this is B we're

1:12:04doing High School level physics necessary to figure this out it's like not Mega complicated just go to the factory and say do a volumetric density calculation say what percentage of the volume of the the inside of this building is doing useful stuff versus is either air or not doing useful stuff you'll be shocked at how tiny that percentage is like single digits then

1:12:28what is the velocity what is the exit velocity of the product how fast will things moving out the exit you know what's the sort of mass flow with the m dot of the of the factory it's like whoa It's really low like the F the fastest car Appliance in the world the car exit velocity is basically grandma with a walker that that it's real slow you know 02 meters per second that's you know really really slow so I could do way better than that like the fastest person can run 10 meters per second faster than 10 meters per second so why why is car exit velocity only 02 meters per second that's ridiculous and then you know

1:13:27why is the volumetric efficiency of a car factory in the usually it's in the mid to low single digits I mean that's very low why shouldn't be at least volumetric density of 30 or 40% maybe 30% seems very very achievable like no nobody would design a ship that had volumetric efficiency of 2%

1:14:00would look ridiculous and yet they designed factories that way are are these efficiencies that you are looking to put in place for your next Tesla plant or are these things we can see in Fremont at some stage in the near future you'll see things moving in that direction I mean with model 3 I think we're you know we're aspiring to get to version 0.5 of alien dreadn level of where

1:14:35alien dread level is like version three so so you'll certainly see that directionally where it's most obvious is in the cell production so I mean our engineering team has worked very closely with Panasonic to make dramatic improvements to the cell r ing efficiency we think we're probably approaching 3x the efficiency of the best plant in the world so that's that's pretty good A

1:15:08lot room for improvement I mean sells sells be going through that thing like bullets from a machine gun in fact the exit rate of s will be faster than bullets from machine gun well we look forward to the next time you you take us around yeah comes the gigafactory party the eye opener thank you our next question comes from Colin langland of UBS your line is now open oh great thanks for taking my question a lot of analysts that cover Solar City are highlighting you know major liquidity concerns with the company you sounded pretty confident that that was going to turn cash flow positive what do you think they're seeing differently and are you concerned

1:15:58at all that the cash burn may increase after the deal well I I think once the deal is done the cash burn is likely to reduce because of reduced cost of sales and general operational efficiencies like there's a lot of things that's duplicated that they're duplicated so would expect costs to to decrease

1:16:25and to increase the positive cash flow you from the Sol City acquisition yeah I mean might take like a few months for those to come into effect but pretty short order let's say six months after the acquisition is complete I would expect those efficiencies to become to be there and be significant kind of actually was that's my second question so in terms of the time Horizon in terms of delivering on you know goals and promises you know particularly around this acquisition you actually think the synergies would be achieved within six months of post closing that it' be that quick yeah I think from the point of which it is the deal is done yes it should be meaningful in no

1:17:20school by this you know the second full quarter after the acquisition is completed I'm highly confident that that would be the case yeah okay well thank you for taking my question right thank you our next question comes from Patrick doin of PR the Line is now open hi thanks for taking the questions here I guess a question for Elon or Todd why not pursue a less Capital intensive model at least in the near term and proceed with more of a a marketing or sales relationship between the entities you know I guess for the cross cell opportunity and installation efficiencies of the Integrated Systems it seems like I think you use the term special deals but those seem

1:18:09to be the norm between between entities if they're beneficial for both I guess are there any legal impediments to to having approached some of these synergies in that fashion I I think I think we would certainly face them if we if we if we did that I I think yeah I mean I I I just don't think I think morally and legally we find it very difficult to defend a unique

1:18:43relationship that just favored Solar City if we're separate companies if if for one company then OB see that's fine but separate companies we can't do that so yeah okay my second question you know everyone's focused on Capital and cash flow here I guess Elon from your perspective would Tesla be receptive or would there be any plans to provide Capital to Solar City in the interim during the kind of pending acquisition you know obviously I'm thinking about it more from the Solar City side but you know given what we saw with Fant and SE Edison you know the pending acquisition disrupted some access to the capital markets in the interm I'm just trying to understand you know

1:19:35solar City's near-term path and and what you'd be willing to do from a Tesla standpoint thank you yeah I mean since Sol city is constrained in the short term from just going out and raising Equity itself Tesla would provide you know bridge loan if needed I actually don't think it's going to be needed to be clear because I mean that's that's something that's something fair and appropriate to do so we will be there if needed but I I don't think what we need okay thank

1:20:16you we have three other callers with questions so let's try to wrap them up quick so if everybody could be brief that would be great we're coming up on 90 minutes here thank you our next question comes from Dana Hall of Bloomberg News your line is now open yes good morning could you talk a little bit about how you envision this impacting Tesla's retail footprint going forward and if the Tesla stores are now selling solar panels and power walls is this sort of an effective Enron around your dealership battles

1:20:57oh that's interesting question yeah we're not limited in stores you know in terms of selling solar and and seing storage we yeah we could do that and then you know potentially offer just have the car there in a gallery format something like that so yeah it did open up additional options on the retail front actually no you mention

1:21:27it I'm just wondering whether you know a car dealer Association can can say that it's a dealership if it's not if it's selling more than cars if it's also selling solar panels and power walls and if it's going to change the look of the stores significantly enough that that helps you guys out with that yeah it I think we'll still be prevented from actually including a car transaction even if it's part of a Brer store but but but usually there's not a limit on having galleries where you simply display the car and have information about it and then you we get look conclud transactions for solar and batteries yeah so I mean some that it does open up additional possibilities

1:22:18now mention thanks thank you our next question comes from St Sha of Albert freed your line is now open hi I just had follow up so you mentioned the positives of of rolling up Solar City and you know I think somebody earlier mentioned in so many words that you know the analysts have been saying that this is a bailout of Solar City so you know

1:22:50can you just mention if if if shareholders don't vote for this what happens you mentioned that solo city in the next 3 to 6 months should be net net cash generator so it's not as Bleak as some of these analysts have been saying Solar City would be in a position if they don't vote for the potential transaction with Tesla and then secondly what does this you know what does this deal mean for your gigafactory does it have any change timeline has changed because you're going to have more of U capacity or not thank you sure I

1:23:29don't know where this bailout stuff comes from because I mean Tesla is not the one deciding what the market value of social city is it's you know the stock market is so Sol City could certainly raise Capital you know equity on its current valuation and I think with without without any problem so and solo City's headed

1:24:01to like a very very healthy place from a Cas standpoint in short order so you know like next sort of three to five months getting to cashlo positive so you know if a company's you know around the corner from being cash positive and has the ability to raise Equity capital on its own I don't see how an acquisition is in any way bailout that's obviously a false

1:24:35description and then the gigafactory kind of proceeds independently of Solar City except that obviously we gear the product of you know the the storage product would be geared towards a solid City type system and we wouldn't be this wouldn't be something that would be explicitly exclusionary to other solar companies by the way it would just be that other solar companies would have to match the Solar City product and in order to use our battery battery product most effectively so it's not about sort of trying to shut out other solar companies it's just about being able to guide the product to where it needs to go and then you know we'll do the right

1:25:31thing with other solell companies if if they're also guiding their products to match so we're not going to basically be a j or other solell companies this is this is really you know about being laser focused on on having the most compelling consumer solution yeah that's you know I think the right thing to do okay thank you very much congratulations again all right thanks thank you and our next question comes from Hank Elder of Goldman Sachs the Line is now open hey guys this is actually Brian Lee on for Hank I have just three housekeeping questions more along the the deal itself and in the interest of time I'll just run through these quickly

1:26:28first is given solar City's relationships with various lenders and and tax Equity Fund structures was hoping you could talk to any visibility into potential change in control provisions and or exposure to clawback provisions on solar tax credits that might exist second question would be as part of the due diligence will the board consider other alternatives to Solar City and then third one and I'll pass it on is are there any collar or caps on the stock exchange ratio being proposed and if not what's what's the rationale for that thanks yeah as the beginning like like really this is kind of the beginning of the analysis not the end and normally would be a lot closer to

1:27:11the end because large shareholder in both companies it's you know it's something we have to talk about at the beginning where we don't have all the answers but then we will compile those and present those to shareholders for their decision in the in the months to come so obviously part of that diligence process would be talking to the lenders making sure they're comfortable and think it's a good idea pretty sure they will but we going to talk to them and yeah and then in terms of other companies you know we did did consider that and it's part of the initial D diligence process but you we think Solar City

1:28:06is the best company out there and it's it's got it's sort of the leader in the field it has the the SLO technology the product Direction yeah we believe is correct you know in terms of making rapid progress towards a highly differentiated product and just no there's just no other company out there that's like that at

1:28:46all thank you and our next question comes from Tri Chari of global equities research Aline is now open thank you I have a quick question for Elan I was just wondering like how does this acquisition plays out with the opportunities that Tesla may find in micro grids and grid space yeah I mean I think there we want to have I think it's always good to like productize things you so it's like kind of like you can click here and buy your micro grid like you versus like

1:29:34having a tailored situation for for all over the place like if if you can productize it it can just happen real fast and so I think like productizing micro grid say click here and you get a micro grid it just works that's I got it's a good way to go you know I think consumers obviously appreciate things that are easy simple and fast

1:30:06but actually Cate customers utilities they appreciate that too because they don't have to go through big laborious process and paining the buff for them it blows their mind when they they can just sort of click a button and then we installed everything and it worked you just because just because the product's big doesn't need mean that the whole process needs to be complex

1:30:38bigness and complexity are about the same thing so I think some Val utility customers have been quite positively surprised by just how easy it is to impl it and it's going to get a lot easier in the future all right I think that's the end of the questions thank you Todd Elon and the rest of the team thank you teria and thank you investors for all the interest if you have any closing remarks Elon otherwise we can end it there no I think those are a lot of great questions and then obviously we'll have a lot more information as Ence process concludes

1:31:28hopefully Reas near future but but I think it's easy you seem to get sort of mired in in in the details but if I think the the right thing is to sort of kind of look kind of look up into the future and say where is this headed what are the macro Trends does this action match what the where where the tides of History are going and that's really that's really what's what's going to make the difference in the long term so I just encourage people to to think in that way all right thank you everybody have a great day all right ladies and gentlemen thank you for your participation on today's conference this concludes your program you may now disconnect everyone have a great day e for

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份