2012 年初,特斯拉开了一场财报电话会。会上马斯克说了一句话:特斯拉再也不需要融资了。
原话是 "Tesla does not need to ever raise another financing"。他紧接着补了一句,可能会想要融,但不需要。
这句话放在当时听着很狂。2011 年全年,特斯拉经营性现金流是负的 2.9 亿美元上下。Model S 还没交付,工厂刚从丰田手里接下弗里蒙特的旧厂房,第一款真正面向大众市场的车还停在样车阶段。华尔街那阵子天天在算它能撑几个月。
后面一个多小时,分析师轮番追问现金、产能、认证、竞争、电池成本,马斯克的回答基本围绕一个判断:特斯拉已经过了那个最容易死的坎。这场电话会的信息密度很高,很多当年听起来像吹牛的话,后来都被验证了。
Model X 的预订量,超过了 Model S
马斯克开场没聊财报,先聊 Model X。
他的原话是,Model X 是特斯拉历史上卖得最好的产品,而且领先幅度很大。这话有意思的地方在于,Model X 当时只是一台刚发布的概念车,价格没定,配置没定,交付时间也没定,客户只看到几张图和一个轮廓,就掏钱下了订。
我们从客户的角度想不清楚他们会怎么反应,结果 Model X 明显是个全垒打,客户用钱包投了票。(马斯克)
他甚至在电话会上直接做起了销售:如果你对 Model X 感兴趣,建议现在就交定金。
这件事对理解特斯拉的产品节奏很关键。传统车企的逻辑是先做市场调研,再做产品定义,最后定价开卖。特斯拉反过来,先扔一个足够激进的产品出去,看市场反应,反应好就加速,反应一般就调整。Model X 的预订数据,本质上是一次低成本的市场验证。
更反常识的是,Model X 开放预订之后,Model S 的预订量没有下降,反而上升了。分析师专门问了蚕食问题,马斯克的回答是,人们看到你有不止一款产品,会觉得这个品牌更靠谱,就像一家店多摆几个招牌,进店的人反而更多。
从卖电池包,到卖整套动力总成
电话会里最实质的业务进展,是戴姆勒的合作升级了。
此前特斯拉给戴姆勒供的是电池包和充电器。这次马斯克确认,开始为戴姆勒提供整套动力总成,包括电机、电控、电池在内的完整系统。
这个变化的分量比听起来大。卖电池包,你只是供应链上的一个零件商,议价能力有限,客户随时可以换人。卖整套动力总成,你进入了对方的整车开发流程,切换成本高得多,单价也完全不是一个量级。
分析师追问戴姆勒这块业务 2012 年能做多大。马斯克的回答很直接:今年戴姆勒这块的收入,可能超过过去所有交易的总和。
他还确认,除了戴姆勒和丰田,还有别的厂商在谈,但不肯说具体是谁。
这里有个容易被忽略的细节。特斯拉当时对外的定位一直是一家整车厂,但它同时在闷声做供应商生意。整车业务烧钱,供应商业务收钱,两条腿走路。这个结构在 2012 年那会儿救了特斯拉的现金流。
Model S 先交贵的,收入全压在下半年
2012 年的收入指引是 5000 台 Model S,加上 Roadster 在欧洲和亚洲的销售,加上丰田的零部件业务,再加上一些 OEM 的开发服务收入。四块拼起来,构成全年的营收盘子。
交付顺序直接改写收入曲线。
第一批是 Signature 系列,1000 台,几乎把所有选装件都装上了,是最贵的那批车。之后是 300 英里续航版本,再往下是 230 英里版本,最后才是 160 英里的入门版。
这个顺序直接决定了收入曲线。分析师问收入会不会后置,马斯克说会,而且很明显。上半年交的是高配,下半年才放量,全年收入严重偏向后半年。
他还提到一个时间点:配置器(configurator)上线之后,才能真正看清客户到底选了什么。在那之前,所有的订单结构都是估算。
这段对话里藏着一个做硬件的人都该记住的判断方法。看一家硬件公司的收入指引,不能只看台数,要看交付顺序和配置结构。同样是 5000 台,先交顶配和先交入门版,营收能差出几千万美元,毛利率也完全不同。
为什么不怕合作伙伴抢生意
有分析师问了个很尖锐的问题:特斯拉给梅赛德斯做动力总成,梅赛德斯品牌会不会反过来蚕食特斯拉?
马斯克的回答用了两组数字。
第一组是市场规模。全球汽车市场一年大概 8000 万辆,Model S 满产是 2 万辆,占比不到千分之三。特斯拉和合作伙伴加起来在这个市场里都是零头,谁抢谁的生意,这个担心太早了。
第二组是竞争坐标系。他强调,判断 Model S 跟谁竞争,不能把它跟所有电动车放在一起比,那个池子里从高尔夫球车到日产 Leaf 什么都有,没有意义。该比的是豪华中大型轿车和豪华 SUV:奥迪 A6、A8,保时捷 Panamera,宝马 5 系、7 系。
这个坐标系的选择很讲究。把自己放进"电动车"这个类目,你就永远是个小众选项,客户拿你和 Leaf 比价格。把自己放进"豪华轿车"这个类目,客户拿你和 A6 比性能、比配置、比体验,价格敏感度完全不同。
他还提了一个更深的判断标准:如果特斯拉的整车工程跟不上,只剩下动力总成能打,那特斯拉就会退化成一家动力总成公司。这句话说得很清醒,一家公司的身份由它最强的那块能力决定,不是由它自己怎么介绍决定。
研发费用降了,但成本没消失
这场电话会里有一段会计细节,很多听的人会滑过去,但对看懂财报很关键。
2011 年全年研发费用 2.08 亿美元。管理层说,2012 年第二季度开始,每季度会有 1500 万到 2000 万美元的制造相关费用从研发科目转到销货成本(COGS)。
有分析师追问:这算是成本下降吗?
回答是,这不是成本消失,是会计重分类。Model S 进入量产之后,原本记在研发里的试产、工装、制造准备费用,按会计准则要挪到销货成本里去。
所以看 2012 年的研发数字,不能只看绝对值的下降,要看结构。真实的研发投入确实在减少,因为 Model S 的开发进入尾声,样车和测试的支出大幅下降。但减少的幅度没有报表上看起来那么大,一部分只是换了个地方记。
2012 年研发费用大致落在 2 亿美元上下,跟 2011 年差不多。真正的下降要等到下半年 Model S 量产之后。
资本开支这边,2012 年计划 2 亿到 2.2 亿美元,而且严重偏向上半年。原因很实在:供应商的工装和设备要付尾款,验收签字就得给钱。马斯克说,这里面大部分是 Model S 的收尾支出,一部分是 Model X 的启动支出,还有门店、服务中心和超级充电桩的投入。
他还提了一个对后面几年影响很大的判断。Gen 3 的研发和资本开支,会比 Model S 低得多,因为工厂、平台、车架、零部件都能复用。有些零件在 Model S 和 Model X 上看不出区别,本来就是同一套东西。同一套平台摊到第二款、第三款车上,边际成本会掉得很快。
每千瓦时 200 美元的电池,路线图怎么走
电池成本是整场电话会里技术含量最高的一段。
分析师提到,马斯克在底特律车展上放过一张幻灯片,说电池成本降到每千瓦时 200 美元不是不可能。问题是想知道,这个数字里有多少是工程上已经跑通的,有多少是还没想清楚但相信迟早会发生的。
马斯克的回答分了两层。
第一层是电芯层面。他说未来不远的将来,电芯成本降到 200 美元以下是有可能的,这个判断比较有把握。
第二层是电池包层面。包成本要把热管理、安全系统、结构件、BMS 全算进去,这是另一个数字,也是特斯拉最核心的机密之一。他没有给出具体的包成本数字。
关于降本路径,他给了一个很实用的框架。降本有两个来源:规模效应和材料体系变化。
规模效应是连续的,产能爬坡、良率提升、采购议价,每年都能挤出一点,这是渐进式的。
材料体系变化是跳跃的,换一套正极材料或者电解液配方,成本可能一次降一大截,但周期很长。因为新化学体系要过循环寿命、日历衰减、安全性、低温性能这一整套验证,实验室里跑通了,到大规模量产还要好几年。
他给的节奏是:材料体系的迭代大概三年一次,中间靠规模效应逐年改善。这个节奏对判断整个行业的成本曲线很有参考价值,别指望电池成本每年腰斩,也别以为它不降。
三万美元的车,可能比原计划来得早
分析师问,如果不需要融资也能活,那多出来的钱会往哪投,会不会加速 Gen 3。
马斯克的回答改了一个既定计划。
原本特斯拉的路线是:Roadster 之后做 Model S,Model S 之后做下一代 Roadster,再之后才是面向大众市场的 Gen 3。
这次他说,技术可扩展性的进展比预期快,Gen 3 会提前,下一代 Roadster 往后排。
我们原本打算先做下一代 Roadster,但现在对技术能扩展到更大销量的信心足够了,所以可以更早做第三代车,一台三万美元左右的车。(马斯克)
为什么顺序会变?因为 Roadster 是低产量高价车,一台卖十万美金以上,一年卖几千台,摊不开研发成本。Gen 3 是三万美元级别,一年能卖几十万台,同样的研发投入摊到每台车上就便宜得多。技术成熟到一定程度,做便宜车比做贵车更划算。
这也解释了为什么他一直强调平台复用。Model S 和 Model X 共用平台,Gen 3 再复用一部分,每一代车的开发成本都在被前面的车摊薄。
五星安全不是门槛,是目标
关于 Model S 的认证进度,这段对话有两个技术点值得记下来。
第一个是模具。Model S 的冲压模具来自富士的冲压厂,特斯拉的做法是,在模具运到弗里蒙特之前,先在富士那边用同一套生产模具试冲,把件寄回来,跟自己冲压机上冲出来的件做比对,确认没有实质差异。这样模具一到,装上去就能直接用。马斯克说,全部模具会在第二季度初到位,留出足够的验证时间。
第二个是安全认证。美国的汽车安全认证是自我认证制,厂家自己测、自己申报,NHTSA 事后抽查。所以拿不拿五星,不构成销售的法律前提。
但马斯克把目标定得很高。他说原本预计平均四到五星,某些单项可能只有四星,现在看起来所有类别都拿五星的可能性越来越大。
最难的一项,是第五百分位女性(身材娇小的女性)在更高速度下的正面碰撞。这个场景一直是碰撞测试里最难通过的,因为假人小、坐姿靠前、气囊和约束系统的匹配难度大。他说这一项也基本拿下了,正在跟外部工程伙伴一起做最后的优化。
他还补了一句,就算法规不要求,特斯拉的目标也是造出路上最安全的车,内部甚至拿"虚拟六星"当目标。这话听着像营销,但结合他后面讲的"如果车不够完美,不会先给汽车记者试驾",逻辑是一致的。
真正的底牌,是超级充电桩
整场电话会里,马斯克唯一一次用扑克术语打比方,是说超级充电桩。
他说,技术路线图上有很多不确定的牌,但真正的河牌(river card,德州扑克里最后一张公共牌)是超级充电桩。等人们看到它有多好用,一切就不一样了。细节会在 2012 年晚些时候公布。
这个判断后来被证明是对的。Model S 最早的卖点不是加速,也不是续航,是"我能开它跑长途"。这个能力不是车本身给的,是充电网络给的。
把它放在 2012 年的语境里看,这个判断相当超前。当时全行业的共识是,电动车的短板是电池,解决办法是把电池做得更好。马斯克把短板定义成补能体验,解决办法是自建网络。同一件事,换一个角度定义问题,解决方案完全不同。
Roadster 会变成收藏品
有分析师问 Roadster 的长期计划。
马斯克的回答很坦率:第一代 Roadster 产量两千多台,是第一款真正能上路的电动车,他相信它会成为 21 世纪第一批真正的收藏车之一。
下一代 Roadster 会做,但排在 Gen 3 之后,大概要等四年左右。
这个安排背后是资源分配的逻辑。Roadster 是品牌资产,不是现金流业务。在产能和现金都紧张的阶段,先做能放量的车,再做能立品牌的车。等 Gen 3 把规模做起来,再回头做一台高价的旗舰跑车,那时候品牌溢价和资金都到位了。
不试驾,也敢交车
有个分析师问了交付流程的细节:客户提车前能不能试驾?第一批 5000 个客户里,有多少人会坚持试驾?
马斯克的回答是,客户根本没有"提车前必须试驾"的预期。这些人等了两三年,只想尽快拿到车。
他补了一句更有意思的:就算有人提车后发现不喜欢,也可以直接卖掉,因为需求远超供给,转售价格会很漂亮。
这句话信息量很大。当一款产品的需求远大于供给时,你不需要靠试驾来降低决策门槛,因为客户知道买错了也能原价出掉,风险被市场本身消化了。这是极少数产品才有的待遇。
当然特斯拉也不是完全不给试驾。门店会放一批车专门做试驾,跟客户交付并行推进。等产能上来、车多起来,试驾自然就不是问题。
关于媒体试驾,他的态度更保守:车要调到足够完美,才会交给汽车记者。第一批评测的口碑影响太大,不能赌。
租赁可能比购买更有吸引力
有分析师问融资方案。马斯克的回答绕到了太阳能。
他说特斯拉会提供完整的租赁和融资方案,跟多家金融机构合作。然后他讲了一个类比:太阳能行业里,租赁模式比直接购买更受欢迎,因为租赁能让客户把太阳能的价格和电费直接对比,而电费是每月都在涨的。
电动车是同一个逻辑。买一台车,客户要一次性拿出一大笔钱,很难跟油费做对比。租一台车,每月付的钱可以直接跟每月省的油钱对比,电价和油价差着一个数量级,这笔账一算就清楚。
他还提到一个细节,租赁模式还能规避残值波动的风险。电动车的二手残值当时没人看得准,租赁把这个问题从客户身上转移到了金融机构身上。
这段对话在 2012 年听起来是个销售技巧,放到今天看是对整个电动车商业模式的预判。后来特斯拉自己的租赁业务、电池租赁、FSD 订阅,本质都是同一套思路:把一次性大额支出拆成月度支出,让客户能跟替代方案做直接对比。
中国是绕不开的市场
最后一个提问的分析师问了 Gen 3 的目标市场。
马斯克的回答是全球,包括中国。原话是,如今很难忽视中国这个市场。他还确认,Model S 和 Model X 都会在中国销售,而且 Model X 在中国可能会有很强的吸引力。
这段话放在 2012 年,是个相当早的判断。当时中国的新能源车市场几乎为零,充电设施基本没有,进口车关税高得吓人。但特斯拉的逻辑不是看当下的销量,是看十年后的市场容量。
关于 Model X 的产量规划,他给了一个保守数字:Model S 的一半到四分之三。
分析师追问 2014 年 15000 台的目标,他确认这是保守估计,按需求看很可能更高,但不想给太激进的指引。
这个"保守估计"的说法在整场电话会里出现了好几次。给指引时压低预期,交付时超预期,是马斯克一贯的做法。听特斯拉的财报会,得把管理层的数字和他们的表述方式分开看。
这通电话会之后发生了什么
回头看清这场电话会,几个判断后来都被验证了。
Model S 确实在下半年放量,2012 年交付约 2650 台,虽然没到 5000 台的目标,但产能爬坡的曲线是对的。超级充电桩确实成了 Model S 最核心的卖点之一,2012 年 9 月第一批站点上线。Gen 3 确实提前了,2016 年发布的 Model 3 起售价 3.5 万美元,比原计划晚了几年,但方向没变。戴姆勒和丰田的动力总成业务确实撑起了那几年的非整车收入。
"再也不需要融资"这句话,从字面上看是错的。特斯拉在 2013 年、2014 年、2017 年、2020 年多次融资。但从另一个角度看又是对的:那些融资都是"想要"而不是"需要",是为了加速,不是为了活下去。
这场电话会最值得学的地方,不是马斯克说了什么,是他怎么组织判断。市场多大、坐标系选谁、成本曲线怎么走、哪张牌最关键,每一个问题他都先给出判断框架,再填数字。框架对了,数字差一点也能修正;框架错了,数字再准也没用。
- 听财报电话会,把管理层的会计重分类和真实成本变化分开。研发费用下降,先确认是不是转进了销货成本,别把记账动作当成降本成果。
- 看硬件公司的收入指引,别只看台数,要看交付顺序和配置结构。先交顶配和先交入门版,同样台数能差出几千万营收。
- 判断一家公司怕不怕竞争,看它选什么坐标系。把自己放进"电动车"类目和放进"豪华轿车"类目,是完全不同的两门生意。
- 看技术路线图,区分规模效应和体系变化。前者连续、可预测,后者跳跃、周期长,别用前者的节奏去预期后者。
- 跟供应商或合作伙伴做联合开发,第一件事是把 IP 条款和授权模式写清楚。互信是结果,不是前提。
- 产品需求远大于供给时,试驾、试用这类降低决策门槛的动作可以往后放,先把货交出去。反之,需求不足时,这类动作要提前做。
- 做长期投入的决策,先问自己这张"河牌"是什么。哪一件事做成了,其他所有事都会顺,把资源优先压在那里。
0:00good day ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the Tesla Motors incorporated fourth quarter 2011 financial results q a conference call during today's call all lines will be in a listen-only mode later we will conduct a question-and-answer session and instructions on how to participate will be given at that time if anyone requires operator assistance during the call please press star then 0 on your touch-tone telephone as a reminder today's conference is being recorded and now I would like to turn the program over to Jeff evenson Thank You Matthew and good afternoon everyone welcome to Tesla Motors for the quarter and full year 2011 financial results Q&A session
0:40i am joined today by elon musk Tesla's chairman CEO and chief product architect and beep at abuja Tesla's chief financial officer we announced our financial results the fourth quarter and full-year shortly after one p.m. pacific time today the shareholder letter financial results and webcast of this Q&A are all available at the company's Investor Relations website at ir tesla motors com high class quarter this call
1:13will consist of some brief remarks by elan followed by time for questions and answers we will conduct the Q&A session life so if you have not already done so please log in now if you wish to ask a question during the course of this call we may discuss our business outlook and make forward-looking statements such statements are only predictions based on management's current expectations actual events or results could differ materially due to a number of risks and uncertainties including those mentioned in our most recent form 10-q filed with the SEC such forward-looking statements represent our views only as of today and should not be relied upon after today we
1:59also display menu to update these forward-looking statements and now let me pass the call to Elon I will welcome let's also playing a few few comments I'm incredibly excited by the sales and any interest in the in the Model X when we introduce the product that is really groundbreaking innovative and you don't necessarily know how
2:27customers going to react to that and the best a directed thinking clearly well from a customer standpoint so that model x was clearly a home run and they've spoken with their dollars by putting down reservations on the one leg and ineffective you know if anyone on the call is interested in a Model X i recommend putting down a deposit students because this is by far the best
2:53selling product in cuz the history and if I by significant margin so it's a get just great and so you know that main thing I want to mention and then at the male looking being lips begun work on the office full Mercedes powertrain I if we previously we've done the battery packs of charges now we're doing in a title car a Mercedes as it stable policy we you know we don't comment on the details of caltrain agreements we live up to our strategic partner so that will
3:38be better to dimerize when they event which is but we can will detail about that but with with those a directory comments let's jump these questions thank you ladies and gentlemen if you would like to give up to ask a question please press star then 1 on your touch-tone keypad our first question comes from amir razvi dowski at barclays capital your line is open thank you very much gentlemen and healing on the discussion of the the Daimler contract I realize that you folks don't provide a too much color in terms of the partnership but in the past you have highlighted that you have a number of these discussions underway are these two folks that you would suggest
4:22it could ultimately end up being a pretty significantly sized opportunity or should we assume that that is we've got with someone else at the moment tricky question lets break that question part of it is there are little bit this I do expect that this year will be significant and probably more significant than the sum of all both deals we've done with time with state and that's not what i can say on on that
5:02front and then are there are other fields of significance in discussion yes there are okay that's very helpful and then if I may you folks have provided you know some color in terms of where your revenue where you expect your revenues to be in the same 2012 and certainly has I think you've barely been consistent that it's going to be fairly back half waited to the launch of the model asked I was wondering if you could give us some color in terms of the mix of the Model S reservations that you have so far in terms of running the numbers it does seem as though you're going to be delivering on the high end versions first and I look to hear you know sort of mix potential what you guys
5:48are factoring in for a s keys for your deliveries for the year or any color along those lines I'm sure so from that I do expect that is going to be weighted towards the Harriet versions of the model for Lance and it necessarily so for a signature series which you know this because with almost all the options then it's the first thousand vehicles but then even beyond that you know where would we then deliver regular series with the trainer mile range and then we go up to the two 30-mile range and then the 160 mile range version doesn't get delivered winter such memory sometimes a little going xtr so that's necessarily going to ship the waiting's towards the
6:35various versions of the model and we'll have a much better sense and protect quite a precise sense for that in the coming months as we're hopeful you know release its like the configurator and at the exactly what options people think okay that's very helpful and lastly if I may you know there's been a lot of questions around concerns on cash
6:59position do e loans among the industry at the moment it seems for me prepared comments you feel comfortable with your current cash position and liquidity I was wondering if you could give us a little bit of color in terms of how you view that progressing to the end of the year and into into the beginning of next I mean do you feel that with the trajectory of the Model S at this point you feel comfortable in terms of how that's going to sort of pan out for your cash burn situation currently well I feel confident saying that Tesla does
7:34not need to ever raise another financing my office in terms of need it's possible that we made to that we may want to do so but importantly we do not need to do so produced by our predictions so yeah we were in it it was really strong okay cash position our relationship with the via video is very good so I feel pretty secure on those for us great thank you very much good increment for color okay thank you the next
8:14question in queue comes from Jesse patchell with Jefferies your line is open yes good evening a chassis results from Jeffries congratulations on the launch last week thank you for hosting us some my question is from a branding and strategic perspective how should we think about the Mercedes brand cannibalizing Tesla products and what keeps Tesla differentiated from your customers in this particular supply arrangement yeah absolutely will let me
8:47say on a few occasions that we do the goat has with service cameras for electric vehicles so we want to do in it everything we can to advance the course electric car is where that car to make ourselves or cars that we help others make and you know in the day of if a vehicle engineering is not to par another hour powertrain is then then obviously that would let us become more of a powertrain company now I think that we do great big we sharing and recovering engineering and that apart school Pike Place Market and that's as
9:24demonstrated by the customer interest really and then you know the sort of important very minor fix the car the new car market is something like 80 million vehicles a year for the model apps at full production that's 20,000 vehicles here is a very tiny portion of the market assuming you know it we were
9:49surely not taking business away from very much business away from partners and nor they take much with a swing much so we're sold at a small portion of the market and when consider when comparing vehicles i get to is important to think about comparing six a premium sedans or premium suvs rather than thinking of save molesta model access competing takes it was so set of all electric vehicles which range from golf carts to you know Nissan lead to you know or whatever the case may be that's not really what people think is when somebody is listening at finding a Model S they're considering that again something like an audi a6 or age or against the force Panamera or you
10:41know we have every five series 7 series is that this really tips through the basis of comparison and to thank you very much yes thank you the next question in queue is from Peter Christensen with Bank of America Merrill Lynch your line is open thank you this is Peter and perceive Milanovic me when I was wondering can just give us some color on on the range the guidance range is that more of a function of model house a mom's or a Model S output or the timing of development services revenue and and and how does that tie into your ear mark gross margin outlook at least
11:2435 answer was that permanency there's a me that the volca with 2012 revenue is Model S related ridiculous yeah I mean that there are three elements to this season obviously the biggest one is a projection of 5,000 Model S's which drives it and then we have our own roadster sales that we would have in Europe and in Asia and beyond that we
11:50have developing components business with Toyota and then some bit of development services revenue is OEM great and then yeah I'm sorry I'm sorry I was wondering if you characterize a revenue opportunity you know of providing a full drivetrain solution versus some of your previous programs notwithstanding you know a different battery size
12:19or are you referring to the diner yes so that we're talking with the full of well it's not really there is more revenue buttocks in our mind it's the ability to provide two dime there a much higher performing vehicle which includes a full integration of our system so it allows us to provide a much more cost-effective and higher performing in edina rather than just over Battery Park which gets integrated into their system yeah exactly what fighting full conference was a really seamless integration that it's a better customer experience and every mystery optimize football well what's with the other elements and it
13:05was we demonstrated that full foot diameter pretty fast and it's worth listen to what is report thank you and just one last one Elon you just talked about you know the difference between needing additional financing or wanting one and and one would assume that could imply you know accelerating the gen 3 program you know if that were the case you know what would be your thought process would it be driven more by you know the momentum and the confidence that you're experiencing right now or possibly a response to some other competitive threats that you see from other OEMs well i'm not sure that
13:42competitive threats because just the market is so vague found that you know what a word what we really focused on is not what say anyone other than any other company sharing with other are we making the best possible product you know that is there anything we can do to make a park that is going to amazing light customers more and then that's that's I think the right thing to focus on you
14:10know and we are going to do as the next significant vehicle but it isn't that the other night basic physics the next major vehicle has perhaps more likes who will be aged m3 so this is amended be coming to summon media but it's perhaps worth reaffirming that previously we were going to do a next-generation roadster Absalom elects but I'm have to gained enough confidence
14:39that we fear that that the technology will be scalable to higher volumes but maybe a bit sooner and and so we'll be able to do our generation vehicle speeds and a strong vehicle with the priceless kind of thirty thousand dollars break finish and if we were to accelerate that it would fit they're here because they
15:04were being argument for the still modest capital raised that's great honor and it's a much much school thank you the next question in queue is from dan pelvis with deutsche bank your line is open good afternoon wondering if you could take us a little bit through kind of the near-term certification process or qualification process for the Model S I'm just curious you know considering that you're still we have some dyes arriving in the next couple months what are the key bottlenecks that could come up in qualification and what you know level of vehicles need to be used to qualify for / driving on us roads in
15:51terms of whether it's a beta or a release candidate vehicle or something full with with full dies production intent there's parts from the factory it dispense with learning that some before the dealership recruit view is a priority I supplier they actually do I stand a number of forty bucks so that we actually do get production right across before the dive ship and are making cars with those production body clocks now on the that that way when we receive the dies then we put them into our stamping presses and all we're doing is just verifying that this you know no meaningful difference between the stamping press at fuji and our stamping press but they put the dive themselves
16:37are already sorted out and as far as you know risks for production timing yeah provide a little bit of color there seriously I said well we you know we were respectively five store on average but maybe we'll be four star in some categories it's looking increasingly like we will be five star in all categories that is looking increasingly optimistic this particular challenge with the fifth percentile female in the passenger with reverent faster speeds
17:22and just kind of meaning this morning which looks like to be able to achieve much darkness in that category which is great news we're going to be we'd be doing some pretty innovative things working with ricotta so FX applies so that's that's good and I think level of homologous prime line is is on track in
17:50terms of the certification that Dan was asking since most of that certification made self certification and it's on production in 10 color box and that you mentioned that dies in 40 of producing the pods which allow us to make the bodies and get that certification none so far facts are a bit yeah this is a
18:11five digit was justing that I should return this it's looking quite cool if I saw on your pillow category I want to say for sure sure but fitted for games like that's quite likely so I just in case with any ambiguities right so I think we've answered that question okay thanks Prancer it's very clear then
18:38you know my second question have to do with your RV factory if you will you know with us with us workers probably winding down on the model s coming off and ramping up on the model acts will you have additional capacity in R&D I guess it my real question is would you have the capacity with your current R&D staff to begin work on a gen 3 vehicle let's say you know by by the Byerly 2013
19:10after the Model S is fully launched yes yes I think so that'sthat's the fight of action is that ok alright great thank you thank you very much so thank you my next question in queue is from Patrick archambault with Goldman Sachs your line is open hi good afternoon oh my i guess you know maybe my first question
19:44would be as we think about it i think reading through here it sounds like you know if you look at the rd and capex plan for 2012 it's largely a model still model s focused unless i'm mistaken right i think that the wording is that on the rd front you know by the end there is some ex spending that that you
20:11know picks up how do we think about you know what that might look like you know both on the capex basis you next year for you know where I'm presuming the rd and the capex for that program is going to be really you know at its peak you know how should we think about that you know maybe whatever you're comfortable talking about maybe you're on your comparison or you know a comparison of how it is visa vie what you spent on the ass you know presumably obviously it's a lot less that that's on the same platform so just helping to mention that the president clarifies worsening crd
20:53spending on the s should reduce in the second half ikea said in the letter not just with the end of 2012 because once we go into the production of the fs a lot of our manufacturing expenses pre production which are presently not in these will move into cost of goods sold so there should be a substantial reduction and we will be done with a lot of the sending we are presently incurring on building the prototype and testing them so yet there will be some ongoing aren't beyond that as we look to up another european version or fine-tune some other things will get a lower level and then we'll see if it up in DX spending at that point the same goes for
21:38capex a lot of our capex is in the first half its heavily rated we pay our suppliers vote for tooling and equipment the final payments once we sign off on including and the equipment and if i think about you know just how those things trend into 2013 one would say one would expect you know that perhaps you get a bigger spike in R&D then you would maybe in capex because you can leverage some of the equipment you know how do we think about that I think the leverage is there in both our Indian cafe con tell you specifically where the bigger leverages
22:27of our kids are spending on the more left is going to be very substantially lower overall nds because we're leveraging every element of the manufacturing factories the platform depowered frames so it's and there's quite a bit of harmonization of parts in areas where you can't see the visible differences in the 80s but if you
22:51probably you're probably right but it's better because it may be if they're saving a boat but but relatively speaking is probably more savings and Catholics and they are in charges okay you know taking a step back in terms of more of a product question how are you thinking about you know sort of higher mileage vehicles in your product cadence you know I think at the detroit auto show you have put up a slide suggesting it would not be inconceivable to get your cost per kilowatt hour down to i want to say something like 200 if i'm remembering correctly you know you've mentioned the next gen and and and perhaps after that maybe a new roadster but might there be an interim demand for
23:48you know an S or an X with even higher mileage capabilities just given the availability of cheaper batteries yeah well yes which is like separate and texas holdem like you know you never know what the river card is going to be well you know no could be okay and I guess last one just I know you guys have reiterated this for but before but just to remind myself what kind of you know IP protections do you have in place you know when you do these these programs with other OEMs you know what what kind of restrictions are there to prevent them from you know leveraging what they learn from from working with you and then in doing it I'm doing something
24:43independently but our relationship with Toyota and I'm though they're we have these programs has been such that they're very respectful of our IP and certainly we don't see any issues where this relationships based on their desire to do things the wrong way and we feels very comfortable and as we grow that business I know we will work as and all that we get to very high volumes we saw that licensing and other opportunities to manage that growth but this time not concerned about our IP in these relationships yeah mr. it's been really great working with fear and I'm literally status companies there's been no indication at all of you know the morning to abscond with IP and guru very
25:35clear agreements linear scale with IQs which company and we really have no son disputes at all and them so I can expect it's quite a mutual trust there we do a post out patents and we've got quite a few patents but there's never really even been 45 on extensions so insignificant so and we've actually said
26:00we are open to licensing IP as well so far as though here we necessarily have to be the ones manufacturing but the powertrain of stuff partners want to do that then we can like themselves Jackie's and a testament volume you know inspected in 100,000 Venus or something that's like make love sense so it sort
26:24of it what Qualcomm model in them yes but again so i should state you know those being able to get with river cards but but i think the real river card is going to be the supercharger what people really see how awesome that is it's great killer so for will and they let you know it will fully fully elements of the supercharger later this year and that's just for it up to the stage three charger crack it's hbu of busy haha
26:59alright very good well congratulations on all the benchmarks met so far and thanks for taking my question thank you the next question in queue comes from imagica cells with JP Morgan your line is open hi good afternoon guys it C questions just I wanted to clarify on the rd you did 208 million in full year
27:262011 you're sort of indicating about a 70 million annualized reduction from you know the sort of fall off on model s and and fremont related costs kind of gets you to a run rate of 138 million and then you're kind of indicating some uptick from there related to the Model X in the second half I guess could you to simplify all of this and just give us the 2012 rd number that you're thinking and also what would any sort of dimensioning you can do one sort of there just a run rate of that number prospectively either in absolute terms or as a percentage of sales I think
28:07everyone chill would see some increase in q1 and q2 because we're just adding a lot more people in our manufacturing facility and as we educated in our letter there's about 15 to 20 million dollars of manufacturing with related expense that comes out and the second half one signal to solve and then when you add in a fit of hot legs I think we wish to perfectly
28:35not in the advisers for giving this efficient granularity incentives as I'm sure you can work it out recently as well in your models I be back I just wanted to be clear be felt like this two issues going on with the R&D costs there's a reduction happening from just an accounting reallocation from our dieter clogs and then there's another sound like another reduction they're happening from just the kind of you know turning off if you will of elevated costs related to the model last launch and the Fremont factory and cinemas my understanding was the 15 to 20 million dollar per quarter reduction which which was kind of the genesis of my 70 million
29:18annualized comment is that related to the latter or the former the former actually how much of a so that's just so those costs don't actually go away entirely they're just kind of every allocated from R&D into caustic Atoll that's right okay and is there a reduction sort of an overall you know cost reduction in the corporation regardless of where it gets pinned on the pml just related to you know the fact that the model s development is behind you you indicated that the x is going to be you know considerably lower costs presumably a lot of you know costs related to get in fremont now they have been hitting the rd line as well what is this sort of reduction associated with
30:05down regardless of where it's sort of classified on the piano there is a reduction related to that you're absolutely right send us we partially offset sighs I'm spending and eggs that we talked about you know there are different calendar ization there which is you know we have a sense of it but it depends on how everything goes by Porter so we aren't getting any success numbers but I think overall will be you know in
30:38the 200 also range for our names and now you know I think you're when you run the models you come from where there 204 hurt for this year yeah okay and then the the next question is just you know the Roadster what is but the long-term plan for that what will that be reincarnated back from stage or is this just kind of being you know going into some shot forever well yeah it would be
31:14with the roads or the first person roads that was really to create a real collector's item it's obviously that's the first viable electric cars 10 and I think I think it's likely to be one of the first true collectors cars of the 21st century for every wanted to be that this over kappa volume ettore 500 there
31:40will be at some point in your generation roadster but i'm fairly comments that's going to come after the third generation vehicles so you know that that pushes it out probably at four years or so -huh and then that you on just kind of going back to to one of the earlier questions on you know there's there's sort of this you know theoretical curve if you will on prospective cost per kilowatt-hour reduction that that I'm sure you've got you know some historic data to sort of support and then there's sort of stuff you're working on right now that may just be in validation and you know there's just a matter of time before you actually get there it can you just
32:24dimension for us you know how much of that kind of two hundred dollar per kilowatt-hour number is sort of in the bag from from you know the engineering efforts that you can see and know that the organization has pretty good visibility on right now versus you know something that you're you haven't really figured out exactly how you're doing i but you sort of know over time that will happen well I'm sure
32:51we've actually ever fitted you up it's good spirits probably about it clear to her stellar yes sir don't be so we are so I mean I wouldn't want to be able to assume that we have I do think that some Hospital what are at the cell level or the client below that you know below 200 of you know even in the not-too-distant future but but i don't it be the best
33:22that it's been this incremental cost for four pack you know good cop of the seller was looking you know the cost of a pack when all the tax safety systems are gridded so if you know say like the cost of the hospital without a battery practice which is a highly proprietary number so it's something we've got pretty closely you know there for fringe
33:49which is where it is a given clean okay then maybe just one last question what was the kind of thought process on opening up the reservation book for the X at this moment or would you would you I mean clearly there's some demand for but there are any ways that there could be some cannibalization of ass volumes yeah that's if your question actually were concerned that perhaps there would be some combination Council to conversation of the of yet and in fact the office would occur we we've seen higher model s reservations not lower I think it's just kinda like when people see that you've got you know of more than one product in the liner that they
34:34actually nice complementary can I keep it into a storm it's kind of better the store sells pens entrance you know it just seemed assured store so I mean that's that's honest with what we see in the HC igp people saw the presence and the pictures of the VX and then some of them came through the website it will Texas really cool that for a sedan in Baltimore let you know and we've
35:02actually had customers who've decided by boat and you let them it really is the objective it is that it's complimentary nuts that's nothing kind of it okay thank you thank you I'd like to remind everyone if you wish to queue up to ask a question please press star then 1 on your touch-tone keypad next question is from Andrea James with tortilla company your line is open hi there on earth it's
35:36all it needs to happen before you can offer a test drive on the model s to a customer and I guess what seems to be the position of those first five thousand customers well we all need to test drive or will some be happy to take delivery without that I think the assumption of customers is that they just going to take delivery the visited there's no there's no presumption of a test drive before delivery so if they make that there may be a few that want to do that but my settings within took
36:06me to those customers really is that they they just want the cars as possible so and now in until the test drives we have to wait until cars believe mala gated and so that's really effective we're going to be appointed that we're delivering the first production cars so thats a little this year is when you will be able to take a test ride and over time we'll have a lot more cars out there and we're so give me any customer who won so a test drive before three now that should not be a problem thought yes we interact immediately given the fact that that there is excess man for the model apps and the idiom is somebody didn't like the model in space they
36:51probably should appoint a livery and then can they sell it because i expect that the cars for sell for for them phenomenal price ok so sound like from your review given the choice of delivering a car to a customer or sending that car aside for test drives you would just do the delivery yeah we're going to do a little bit of votes so there will be cars that are walking cause no delivered through the stores for test drives that's to be having a parallel with liver servers customers okay and then moving on to just Toyota
37:27how has your communication bond with them as far as them saying this is what we need and when and do they give you hard targets or moving targets and also just you know you said you're going to do a shipment and q2 is that in line with the red wreck on that contract thank you 30 times you can imagine has
37:47very established processes and systems so they and they have an oil suppliers nobody's but they have a fairly stable production plan which they share with us in advance so we have little clarity and visibility or what they need and clearly the components that we will suffice with them and not you to savor the revenue on
38:12doors will be recognize when because there were those components like any other supplier okay anything you'll be kind of lumpy there then no I don't think so i think there's going to be a ramp up as we take up the production rate but it won't be lumpy okay thank you that's all for me thanks so much thank you so the next question in queue comes from Adam Jonas with Morgan Stanley your line is open thanks matthew good evening guys oh just a Halon just to follow up on the test drive question would the magazine's first chance to drive the model s also coincide with deliveries to customers in middle of the year or would there be an opportunity before it probably codes
38:58idea we definitely don't want to sort of it I mean really really what the club is putting perfect as possible before we give it to any automotive journalist to adjust right understood Deepak in 2011 looks like your cash flow is you know rent just under negative 300 million or 290 million can you at this point confirm given you know the assumption of 5,000 units deliveries of the other model s that cash burn in 2012 should be you know significantly less than this amount I'll still negative but the less negative it will be you know our cash
39:38flow from operations here clearly determined you know we have reservations in play as well as working capital needs and in our cases we ramp up we can have some benefits and working capital given the differences in payments to our suppliers vs pain Lisa people x from our customers so yes it will be less than that great just a fall on the capex outlook
40:06that 200 to 220 any rough split of how much of that is related to final spending on the model s vs early spending on the Model X or the other the other buckets which wait on a good retail or development work or early gen3 any idea of a rough split what we have at utility said we have the buckets of spending on outputting you source of their service centers we are also going to do some supercharging installations of eli mentioned and then spend on the eggs it's going to be you know the
40:46majority is i would say it I'd leave it at that and I think that gives you enough for an analogy I appreciate that and just just finally on the Model X reservations be nice if we could continue that a daily daily amount but looking at the split from relay know it's early data but how does the reservation amount compared to the you
41:16know roughly eleven thousand dollar for reservation that you're getting on average to the model ass I guess we may be getting to that average because we collect forty thousand dollars on the signature series and five runs an instruction we have a combination of signature and German production reservations on DX I don't have that
41:41number off and what that based on this will be getting substantial signature reservations no doubt about that for the ax but yes yes -huh yeah it should be busy in the order and Brazil with the order of magnitude difference on the upfront reservation for four signature X would be comparable to a signature s versus the higher battery non signature ass sorry well image for the mullet there's kind of regular series which is a five-thousand-dollar reservation in his fingers from series which is 40 the same for the male and that the 55 thousand dollars number is imperative the configuration of the model s understand okay thank you very much right thank you
42:33next question in queue is from Ben chalo with Robert W Baird your line is open figured out there guys but the long attention being paid unguents number of eyes as you have in fremont second is it plausible bit you don't have all guides there at my best friend you're still stamping some sub parts with your partner yet still delivering vehicles I know that's not your best case scenario but exactly an option you have to suppose to meet your delivery come one I think we have enough gap in between that we don't see that at the possibility we expect just one all the guys on all of
43:17them to be here by early q2 which gives it enough time to find through them and use them for the production part okay but would that be a possibility so we came up with your guitars if there's always a possibility yes we would always have a lot of products produced as fujian have been shipped one that I was coming but clearly that's not part of the plan okay oh because you talk about how you get to pretend to 15,000 of deliberate number for outlook for 2014
43:56for the Model X you have all right I yeah we're just sort of scaling that has roughly a half to three quarters of a mullet and it could be higher than that I mean I Connecticut based on the demand with CMS bar probably will be higher than that but you know we don't know how I think I probably owe behind master the cook expect greatness to the exact number of a reversal put it up as a good conservative projections okay conservative projections yes okay great actually finally you just talked about your your spot star rating in economy
44:42around that we don't need that five star rating before the cars can actually sold is that correct does that help search down like that to come after you are you certain more predisposed yeah i mean the is you do everything that necessary to achieve the past five star rating and then it and then it is officially awarded at some point access to other production yeah but but you mean you pretty much know in advance what it's going to be yeah thank you on your right we don't have a five star rating to get the fine for not to miss our goal to get it yeah there's no regulatory requirement so no absolutely no but really I go with the model s was to
45:21create the safest car on the road you said Conrad you really know the only possible inspired at five star in your category and actually there is mythic star but figured if you know the rooms aim for kind of a virtual six are to achieve that the highest possible victory a great thing
45:49thank you the next question in queue comes from Carter Driscoll with capstone your line is open good afternoon gentlemen first questions around no potential financing options obviously maybe not quite as relevant for the ass of the axe but maybe you could talk about what you're attempting to line up for you know more of a mass-market gentry vehicle oh sure we would expect
46:15to have the full range of leasing and financing options that people are used to sing for for cars and yep probably working with a number of blood vessels to shun students make that happen so that's a very promising tools but yes we don't want to make sure that the cars are as the affordable as possible and I
46:43think there's an argument actually that the appeal of electric cars on the leasing side is going to be greater than on the purchase I which I certainly see that in solar it's worth hoping to have a solar system anneliese basis because people can then compare that correctly with the trust of the pain there from the utility can sense the concept of
47:10electricity is so much less than the cost of gasoline in the choices which was met you know an order of magnitude difference did I live by by leasing out of the car and you know in 10 10 can carry in your hand that crossword crispy which was a very least cost of gasoline car and the Christ ghastly which selectively increasingly expensive the value proposition to customers are purely economic level it's going to be that much more compelling but that's all blessed I was kind of driving at is in terms of the volatility of the residual value and using a much more constant the Whopper our price nationally then certainly differences regionally in gasoline prices my next
47:54question is maybe you can in your own opinion Iran or Deepak talk about the different model options you expect people to take in the different models or maybe even compare them entrap the model s versus the axe and so we can kind of drill down into what you think an ASP might look like a finalist he might look like and not necessary just the base price at least your best caps
48:19but I thought I think evening on sort of answer if there's a high level in one of your questions that you know initially we would have the signature series which is 300 or the unified for what our battery park and then we'll have the base in fact a lot of battery pack in addition we even offer the performance version which we expect to have a very fairly significant a trace given these specs on that so between that and the options I know which we wouldn't be surprised if that is on average of ten to fifteen thousand dollars pick up above the base price which is very normal in the premium fitness and then
49:04in 2012 it becomes the mix of sales 2013 rather becomes a mix of sales in asia and europe where pricing structures are different than the content what standard versus option is different says we thought that out for 2013 in a wood flight more granularity but i think 2012 is fairly clear given our plants of a
49:27lot of launching a different theories for four times okay just keeping an eye on the time here we probably have time for questions from maybe one more analyst so operator just one more please next question then comes from Michael Liu with Needham your line is open art be one moment please
50:13oh thank you and I'm sorry Michael your line is open now okay thank you an afternoon in California you had mentioned other potential supply agreements and partnerships in the pipeline and I realized almond tart or solid partners but could you give us a sense of how many other ongoing powertrain development discussions are going on with other automakers and are they for more mainstream vehicles or luxury type of offerings I'm sorry but i
50:40tend to congenital on it okay and also to slip approve it but wanted to follow up on your comment regarding a gen 3 mainstream model with this be any be targeted more at the emerging markets like outside china or a broader base type of offering it would be targeted I think worldwide monsters building so many please go to China well I mean I would seriously every country in the world but it certainly is in China it's pretty hard to ignore China as a market these days and get us I think I think
51:16we're in fact we expect to be selling the model s from the Model X in China okay and yeah we were but we think that there could be a lot of Appeal interesting Lee for the model for the male in China okay okay also regarding on your prior comments on self cost reductions from the colorant I told what our pricing how much would it be such a scale driven versus and material change driven like what would be the split on that be anonymity a good question well
51:53given without any material changes this is done officially at scale you can get a current chemistry below turtles make sure what our but you know that that I think we will see material changes over time that septum simplify that self should be yes and how long would it take to let they qualify and enhance your material driven change if you wanted to let the implemented on let's say the Model S or an existing model at that time well I think you kind
52:32of see most experience is coming because you know because you have to implement them at large scale so this is one of the class something that just like working in a lab and then very rapid you know directly bring that to full-scale production not less you have just as things like a calendar-like degradation and particularly insightful satellite
52:55recreation so you tend to see self chemistry changes coming from a few years away and we've got a roadmap of changes that said look pretty interesting and you know results the steady improvement Europe year-over-year but a feckless day we would go and implement the new chemistry every year i think would probably look to include your chemistry probably every three years something like that got it thank you
53:29thank you i'll turn the call back to our presenters for any concluding remarks okay thank you everyone for joining us we look forward to seeing many of you over the coming weeks as we attend conferences in particular we will be at the Jefferies growth conference next week in New York City and the week after that we will be at the Morgan Stanley technology media and telecom conference in San Francisco so we look forward to seeing many of you that's those events thank you goodbye thank you ladies and
54:03gentlemen thank you for your participation on today's call this does conclude the program and you may now just kidding
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版