访谈·中文精读

马斯克在 UCLA 问答 2011

Elon Musk Q&A at UCLA 2011

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2011年,SpaceX一枚火箭上,70%到80%的部件是公司从原材料开始自己造的。特斯拉Model S还没量产,工程完成度大约90%。马斯克坐在UCLA的讲台上,被一群学生和创业者追问。

有人问他为什么什么都自己做。他讲了一个故事。

签供应合同的时候,对方是你能找到的最好的供应商。等他们发现你没有别的退路,就开始重新谈判。谈判的第一步是三倍要价,理由后补。

“这事发生过好几次。从那以后,我们再也没跟那家供应商合作过。”(埃隆·马斯克)

他说的不是气话。火箭行业的供应链非常浅,很多部件只有一个供应商,价格很贵,而且这些供应商的设计从来没考虑过可重复使用。你不自己做,火箭的成本和迭代速度就永远被捏在别人手里。

用他的话说,你继承了多少传统部件,就继承了多少传统的成本结构和限制。SpaceX的内包比例因此一路上升,活下来是主要动力,对自制本身没有什么宗教式的信仰。

这场问答发生在2011年。SpaceX还没有稳稳跑通商业发射,特斯拉还在为Model S的量产焦头烂额。但马斯克在UCLA讲的那些判断,后来大多兑现了。这篇精读把整场问答里最有信息量的部分整理出来:电池、充电、铝车身、火箭回收、火星架构、超级重型火箭、政府贷款、太阳能、加州税负,以及他怎么看维珍银河。

多带一块电池不实用,换电只是保留一个选项

第一个问题关于换电池。马斯克的回答很直接:在电动车上额外带一块电池不实用。如果要换电,就得建换电站。

但他马上算了一笔账。如果你开的是一辆续航30英里(约48公里)的车,你确实需要很多换电站。可如果你的续航够长,比如特斯拉Roadster,从洛杉矶到旧金山400英里(约640公里),中间只需要一个充电站。

他的判断是,大多数人并不想换电池。他们更愿意把车停在高速休息区,吃顿饭,拿杯咖啡,上趟厕所,回来20到30分钟,电已经充够跑完剩下的路。

换电只是保留一个选项,给赶时间的人。

至于Better Place,那家做换电的以色列公司,马斯克说他们的想法其实来自特斯拉。对方来参观,特斯拉告诉他们自己会把换电纳入设计。但特斯拉没有跟Better Place合作。他明确说跟喜不喜欢对方无关,问题是看不到技术上的优势,也想不出怎么让消费者体验更好。

这段回答里藏着一个产品逻辑:充电站的数量不是一个固定值,它跟续航里程强相关。后面他专门解释了这一点。

龙飞船返航,3000磅推进剂够用

有人问龙飞船(Dragon)的推进剂够不够。马斯克给了一个很细的拆解。

火箭助推器把飞船送到停泊轨道,然后用一点推进剂机动到空间站。对接、离开空间站、制动离轨、下降、着陆,整个过程大约需要3000磅推进剂。其中大约1000磅用于接近和离开空间站,1000磅用于离轨,1000磅用于着陆。飞船上会剩下大约40000磅的余量。

如果出现异常,比如需要在空间站附近临时悬停,可能多用500磅,仍然绰绰有余。

龙飞船还保留降落伞作为应急。飞船会在离地面几英里的地方测试发动机,如果发动机不正常,就打开降落伞。马斯克把它比作飞机上的备用系统。

Model S:北美第一辆全铝车身乘用车

2011年,Model S还没量产,但工程完成度大约90%。特斯拉买下了加州弗里蒙特的NUMMI工厂,这家工厂之前由丰田和通用合资,生产卡罗拉和Tacoma皮卡。

买现成工厂的好处是省掉了大量增量模具成本。油漆车间只需要改造,不用从零建。冲压机和其他设备也都在。特斯拉用一个很好的价格买下了一座很好的工厂。

马斯克说,当年有两个最大的生产里程碑。第一个是冲压线投产,用来冲压铝制车身面板。Model S会是北美唯一一辆全铝车身的乘用车。奥迪A8和几款德国车用过铝,但美国市场上没有铝制乘用车。飞机基本都是铝的,因为重量重要的时候,铝是更好的金属。

铝的缺点是难加工。焊接和连接都比钢难,成本也更高。但马斯克认为,在重量敏感的场景里,这个代价值得。钢太重,不是好选择。

第二个里程碑是油漆车间。马斯克说,给车喷漆其实非常难,如果目标是出色的漆面。他们内部的目标叫“钢琴漆面”,就是你在12万美元的钢琴上看到的那种质感。要做到明显好于其他车,还不能大幅增加成本。他的原话是,目标是走到全程,但至少要走完大部分。

安全方面,Model S的设计目标是满足2012年的五星碰撞标准。马斯克提醒,2010年的五星标准到2012年只相当于三星,所以门槛高了很多。他说自己会开这辆车,朋友会开,股东会开,所以安全极其重要。他相信这会是路上最安全的车之一。

价格方面,Model S的定位类似宝马5系,根据配置不同,从大约5万美元到10万美元。

电池配方改了,因为钴的产地政治不稳定

有人问材料短缺。马斯克的回答分几种材料。

硅不用担心,储量充足。铜也够用,电池包里需要不少铜,但世界上铜很多。

真正的问题是钴。钴的产地很少,价格贵,最大的来源是刚果,而刚果的政治稳定性经常变化。

所以Model S换了电池化学配方,钴的用量降到大约四分之一。这样既降低了电池包成本,又提高了电池包的能量密度。

另一个潜在问题是稀土元素。中国在稀土上占绝对主导,稀土被用于永磁电机。特斯拉的电机设计不使用任何稀土元素,部分原因就是绕开这个依赖。

至于石油这类不可再生资源,马斯克说价格会涨得很高。

充电站数量随续航的平方下降

马斯克对充电基础设施不担心。电到处都是,插座的数量比任何其他能源的接入点都多好几个数量级。

Tesla Roadster和大多数新电动车把充电器装在车里,所以几乎在任何地方都能插电。要快充,找个高功率插座就行。

实际使用数据是,Roadster超过90%的充电发生在家里。

续航里程直接决定充电站需求。如果续航只有50英里(约80公里),你最多做25英里的往返,稍微开远一点就不够。续航越短,需要的充电站越多。

他给了一个几何直觉:你能开车到达的范围是一个圆,圆越大,需要的充电站越少。充电站数量大致随续航的平方下降。

具体算:400英里的路程,如果车续航400英里,中间只需要一个充电站。如果车续航50英里,同样400英里需要8到10个充电站。

所以特斯拉的充电站主要会建在州际高速上,用于长途旅行。日常通勤不需要。

火箭回收:第一级容易,第二级难

有人问可重复使用火箭。马斯克把两级分开讲。

第一级要调头,重新点火,飞回发射台,然后推进着陆。这个技术上很棘手,但可行。

第二级难得多。因为第二级每增加一磅质量,就直接从入轨载荷里减掉一磅。第一级不一样,第一级和载荷的比例大约是5比1到10比1,第一级增加10磅,载荷只减少1磅。

第二级需要更重的热防护,需要在再入时控制姿态,需要保留一些阻力来转向发射场,最后还要着陆或其它方式回收。这些都要花质量。

整个架构的难点是质量效率。一枚火箭只有大约3%到3.5%的发射质量是载荷,目标是至少做到2%的载荷比,剩下的质量要分给所有其他系统,余地很小。

马斯克说,基本架构就是这样,难的是用极高的质量效率去实现。他心里有一条清晰的路径,先做第一级回收,再做第二级。

去火星,先看美国造不造超级重型火箭

马斯克说,长期来看会看到类似的东西,甚至在初期阶段就可能用上。

这取决于美国造不造超级重型运载火箭,像土星五号那种级别。如果有75吨级的运载能力,去火星就不需要在轨组装。如果运载能力更小,就需要在轨组装。

他希望有超级重型火箭,但如果按典型的政府方式做,他预计会因为严重的进度和成本超支而无法实现。所以真正的变量是NASA是否决定用商业方式来采购超级重型运载。

如果超级重型火箭有了,在轨组装就不必要了。

再往远看,当地球和火星之间的航班足够多,会出现大型太空巡洋舰在地球和火星之间循环飞行。人们坐小型穿梭机上去,巡洋舰在地球或火星加注燃料。这是长期优化,前提是两个星球之间出现大量交通。

25亿美元造超级重型,马斯克押上整个SpaceX

有人问SpaceX会不会做超级重型。马斯克说会,而且他很想拿政府的合同。

他给了一个数字:超级重型的开发成本大约25亿美元。其他估算大约是10倍。他说的超级重型,运载能力大约160吨到近地轨道,比土星五号还多。他顺带对比了一下现役火箭:德尔塔四重型大约25吨,猎鹰9重型大约30到35吨,土星五号超过100吨,超级重型在160吨级。

他甚至说,愿意个人担保,押上SpaceX的一切,保证这件事会实现。

他的策略是消除反对者的借口。他说,有强大的政治力量不希望SpaceX做这件事。所以他提议,把超级重型预算的10%到20%拿出来,按固定里程碑付给SpaceX。达不到里程碑就不付钱。剩下的预算,传统承包商可以按原来的方式拿走。

这样是一个不会输的方案。但马斯克补了一句:逻辑不总是占上风。

他提到,一些大型国防承包商明确希望SpaceX死掉。他说,你电影里看到的那些坏公司,就是大型国防承包商的样子。

政府贷款不是救助,NASA是最大客户

有人问政府支持。马斯克先讲SpaceX。NASA是SpaceX最大的客户,大约40%的发射是为NASA做的。NASA为演示飞行付钱,但前提是满足NASA的具体需求,按里程碑付款,钱有明确用途。

特斯拉这边,2011年拿到一笔政府贷款。马斯克强调,这笔贷款跟救助无关。贷款项目2007年经济繁荣时就启动了,要求企业本身有生存能力,并且提供20%到30%的私人资本作为匹配。所以破产的通用和克莱斯勒被排除在外。

特斯拉拿到的是一笔信贷额度,专门用于Model S的工程和生产成本。这笔钱减少了股权稀释。如果提前还款,就没有股权稀释。如果不提前还,美国政府会拿到特斯拉的认股权证。

马斯克说,在政府做过的各种交易里,这算比较小的一个。他顺带抱怨了一句,贷款消息宣布的时间刚好撞上救助新闻,所以外界都以为特斯拉也拿了救助。

太阳能会超过其他任何单一能源

有人问可持续能源。马斯克说会有很多来源:风能、地热、水电。但他个人的判断是,太阳能发电量会超过其他任何单一来源。不一定是多数,但他预期太阳能会是最大的单一来源。

形式会是组合。一种是光伏,装在住宅和商业建筑的屋顶上,好处是不需要额外的输电线路。另一种是电站级的太阳能热发电,用太阳加热工作流体,产生蒸汽,驱动涡轮。

加州和美国其他地方有一批这样的项目即将上线。

马斯克给了一个更大的视角。地球的天气系统几乎完全由太阳能驱动,降水也是。整个生态系统是太阳能驱动的。化石燃料本质上是太阳能驱动的化学反应。人类现在讨论的,只是替换其中很小一部分电力,并让这部分也变成太阳能。他说,如果不是太阳,地球就是一个4开尔文的冰球。

特斯拉的真正使命,是逼整个行业转向电动车

有人问特斯拉是不是要打败底特律。马斯克的回答是否定的。

特斯拉的目的,是把整个汽车行业拉向电动车。所以每当看到其他厂商宣布新的电动车项目,他都很高兴。

特斯拉作为公司的成功,当然取决于产品品质。他说,特斯拉必须造出比通用和克莱斯勒更好的车。他不觉得这是巨大的挑战。

他顺带讲了一段美国汽车史。上世纪60年代美国造过好车,70年代出了些问题,内饰和设计都值得商榷。

他提到一个朋友对特斯拉长期战略的总结:造不烂的车。

他举了两个背书。丰田是世界上最大的汽车公司,也是混动的领导者,是特斯拉的投资者和合作伙伴。如果这件事容易,丰田自己做就行了,没必要找特斯拉。戴姆勒发明了内燃机,是梅赛德斯和Smart的制造商,同样是特斯拉的投资者,也让特斯拉做供应商。如果复制特斯拉做的事很简单,他们不会这么做。

外包太多,工程和生产之间的迭代断了

有人问外包。马斯克说,总体来说美国外包太多了,加州外包也太多。很长一段时间里,外包是一种风潮,但很多情况下人们没有看基本面。

当技术快速演进时,工程和生产之间保持紧密的迭代回路很重要。设计完成,马上能进生产,工程师能走到车间看到自己犯的错,生产人员能告诉工程师哪里可以改进。这样能更快得到更好的设计。

这一点经常被忽略。

他举SpaceX为例。SpaceX的火箭成本比中国、印度或任何其他方都低,而且这还没算可重复使用。部分原因就是这种紧密迭代。

他又举特斯拉的弗里蒙特工厂。这家工厂直到2010年4月1日还在生产卡罗拉,一辆1.7万美元的车。如果加州制造从根本上太贵,他们怎么可能在这里造出1.7万美元的车?

所以加州需要小心,不要不断推高这里的生活成本。

他提到税负。加州的边际税率是11%,华盛顿州是0%。加州是个昂贵的地方。他喜欢住在加州,但他知道很多人因为税高、工伤赔偿和其他成本高而搬走。加州监管过多。

他的判断是,加州必须削减州政府开支,可能还要稍微减税,才能和其他州竞争,同时放松监管。这些能增加就业。但政治上很难。他不确定加州怎么走出这个困境,可能要靠公投,因为立法机构似乎无法达成任何明智的方案。

“我不是风险投资人,我是工程师”

有人把马斯克当风险投资人,想向他推销项目。他纠正了这个误解。

他说自己不是风险投资人。他投钱只投自己的公司,偶尔投密友的公司,而且零尽职调查。他的投资逻辑很简单:觉得对方人不错,大概率会成功,就投了。

所以向他 pitch 想法不是好主意。应该去找真正的风险投资人。

这段话值得单独拎出来。马斯克的身份认同是工程师,从来不是金融买家。他判断项目的方式,是从技术和产品能不能做出来出发,不是从财务模型出发。这也解释了为什么SpaceX和特斯拉都选择了重度内包,他习惯把问题拆到物理层面,再决定自己造还是买。

人类毁灭的概率不到1%,但1%也不小

有人问人类面临的风险。马斯克给了一个数字:人类被毁灭的概率不到1%。

但他马上做了区分。即使人类把大气中的二氧化碳浓度推得很高,也不太可能导致人类毁灭。它可能因为海平面上升之类的原因杀死几百人,或者几亿人,这显然不好,但不是毁灭级事件。

他翻出了化石记录。地球历史上发生过几次毁灭级事件,主要是各种陨石撞击,可能还有超级火山,还有一些原因不明的事件。所以人类确实面临类似的风险。

还有人造风险。超级病毒是一种。大型强子对撞机也是一种,他半开玩笑地说,你可能会看到一份新闻稿:好消息是我们发现了新的物理定律,坏消息是有一个正在迅速变大的小黑洞。他说这极不可能,但人类确实发现过新的物理定律。

这段回答的语气很马斯克。他把灭绝风险当成一个可以估算概率的工程问题,给数字,做区分,不渲染。

亚轨道和入轨,差625倍能量

最后一个问题关于理查德·布兰森和维珍银河。马斯克说布兰森是他的朋友,人很亲和,强项是品牌和营销。

但他认为进入火箭行业很棘手,因为这是很深的技术问题。布兰森会面对一些挑战。

维珍银河做的是亚轨道飞行,只需要入轨能量的约1.5%。飞船冲到大约60到70英里高,然后落下来。马斯克说,这像一次很棒的过山车,很好玩,但不是最终能把人类送出地球、送往其他星球的技术路径。

他解释了其中的区别。很多人分不清“进入太空”和“进入轨道”。太空的边界可以按大气稀薄程度来定义,60英里高空大气已经非常稀薄,但卫星不能待在那里,因为会迅速衰减然后掉下来。

要留在轨道上,靠的是横向速度,绕地球飞得够快。需要的能量主要花在加速上,不在爬升。事实上,需要高度的唯一原因是避开大气阻力。如果没有大气,你可以在离地面一英寸的地方绕地球运行。

入轨需要大约25倍音速。能量随速度的平方增长。亚轨道飞行,比如维珍银河,大约马赫3,需要90个能量单位。入轨需要625个能量单位。再入时还要把这些能量烧掉。两者的差别是量级级别的。

这段对比把航天里最容易被营销模糊的一件事说清楚了:上去和留在上面,是两个量级的问题。

  • 如果你在做硬件创业,先列出哪些关键部件只有一个供应商。单一供应商在谈判后期涨价的概率很高,能在内部做的核心部件,尽早做。SpaceX的内包比例是被供应商逼出来的,不是一开始就设计好的。
  • 产品定义阶段就把续航、充电、换电放在一张表里算。充电站数量随续航的平方下降,这个关系能帮你判断该把成本花在电池上还是基础设施上。续航翻倍,基础设施需求降到四分之一。
  • 材料选择要看地缘政治。钴、稀土这类材料的产地集中度高,价格和政治风险会传导到成本结构。能改配方就改配方,Model S把钴用量降到四分之一,成本降了,能量密度还升了。
  • 可重复使用的第一级和第二级不是同一个问题。第一级增加的质量对载荷影响小,第二级增加的质量直接扣载荷。资源有限时,先做第一级,再做第二级。
  • 跟政府或大客户谈创新项目,主动设计“达不到里程碑就不付钱”的结构。这能拆掉对方“风险太高”的借口。但别指望逻辑一定赢,政治永远在场,提前把反对者的利益算进去。
  • 外包之前问一句:工程和生产之间的迭代回路还在不在?技术变化快的行业,这个回路的价值经常被低估。马斯克用SpaceX和弗里蒙特工厂两个例子说明,成本优势来自迭代速度,不来自单纯的低价劳动力。
  • 如果你在加州或类似的高成本地区做制造,先把税负、工伤赔偿、监管成本算进单位经济模型。加州边际税率11%,华盛顿州0%,这个差距会影响公司选址和招聘。
  • 区分“进入太空”和“进入轨道”。前者是体验,后者是基础设施。投资和创业时别把两者混为一谈,能量需求差几百倍,技术路径也完全不同。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00it is not practical to carry an extra battery pack in an electric vehicle so for the battery pack swap there would be if they're happy some sort of swap station however if you have a 30 mile range car you're really not talking about a lot of swap stations you just need say one between LA and San Francisco and then there's a question as

0:21to whether people will even want to swap battery pack rather than simply park a car at a highway rest for up wrist up grab a meal or a copy and hit the restroom come back 20-30 minutes and you recharged enough to complete the journey I think most people probably do that but we wanted to preserve the optionality of fastpack swap just in case though people in a hurry

0:55right so it's better place actually got the idea of battery pack swapping from Tesla when should I guess II came and visited and we told them that we were going to incorporate battery pack swapping there's like a good idea yeah well yeah but not that I think it's a genius move I mean that you know you have cell phones and laptops that have battery packs as well but but we're not

1:21currently working with with better place yeah I yeah but not because we don't we don't like them or anything it's just we don't see any sort of technical advantage or anything to work with them that we there's no obvious to happen to us how we make the consumer experience better with better place so yeah

2:04well it's sort of on your room about a thousand pounds of a felt that you need to expand to land for possibly well the Bruce of the rocket booster is what delivers you to a parking orbit then use a little bit of propellant to maneuver over to the space station then Department space station initiate a deal with burn control your reentry at during the descent phase in total is about 3,000 pounds propellant and they use maybe a thousand in terms of getting the space station and departing in deep deorbiting about a thousand on landing and you'd have 40,000 spare roughly speaking it's not if you if there was something unusual happened like you had

2:54to temporarily aboard on an approach of the space station that you might use another 500 pounds of propellant or something like that but we will actually have still have parachutes as an emergency on Dragon survey so you test the engines at say a couple miles valve to make sure they're working if they're not then you deploy the emergency parachute kind of like the source aircraft

3:28well it's not yet in production but Annika on a go-forward basis well most of the engineering is done real sort of the ninety percent engineering complete stage right now the the factory we were fortunate in being able to purchase the the new me factory in Northern California which was a jointly owned by Toyota and GM although it was in recent years i'll even make intuitive products where they made that the corolla and the tacoma so we were able to buy at a very good price a great factory and let's minimize the incremental tooling cost to

4:09produce the thumb of the model s so is existing paint shops you only have to modify a paint shop instead of bully one from scratch this stamping machines and all sorts of things there that are helpful the two biggest milestones this year I think are probably getting a stamping line operational but to snap the aluminum body for body panels the Model S is actually going to be the only aluminum car made in north america the

4:37the audi a8 and have been a few of the advanced german cause or aluminum but currently there are no aluminum passenger vehicles made in the United States or may vary from the sort of space arenas like obviously made from aluminum what else would you make it from here like steel is really heavy and not great so and then the second thing

4:59is the paint shop painting a car is actually really difficult if you want to go get a spectacular paint job and we're aiming for something called up which we call it a piano finish like it what kind of things you see on a 12 grand pianos Oh something that's noticeably better than any other car and so that's up

5:20that's a high bar and it to do so without adding a lot of costs to the process so we're optimistic that we'll get if you're going to all the way there but most of the way there those are two big production Muslims this year about get my hands I sorry away the back there

5:55hello oh yeah well I mean there will certainly be issues that we have to deal with but but but this sort of less than one percent chance of my listen one percent I mean less than one percent chance of annihilation of humanity and I mean even if they even if we do mess we increase the the co2 concentration in the atmosphere it is unlikely to result the annihilation of humanity it could could

6:42kill a few hundred people or a few hundred million people do to you know rising sea levels and that kind of thing which is obviously not fun good but but it's but it is not an annihilation event but if you look at the fossil history there have been several annihilation events you know mostly due to meteors

7:03one kind or another possibly some due to super volcanoes and some do to you know who knows what but so we obviously suffer from some risk of a similar annihilation event and also potentially a man-made thing like a super virus or you know you know it could be something like it with with a certain large hadron collider you know potential you could

7:38see it could see a press release where the the good news is we've discovered a new law of physics the bad news is there's a small black hole that's rapidly growing now I think that's extremely unlikely clear but you know we've we've discovered new laws of physics before

8:19you well I am not at a venture capitalist so people sometimes think I'm I magic apples but actually I'm an engineer so when I apply capital it is to my own companies and to occasion to the company's of close friends of mine where I do zero due diligence and I just basically invest in the basis that I think they're good and likely to succeed so I so I'm not the guy to pitch on on

8:57ideas to be find it because that's that's not a veggie catalyst it's better to picture venture capitalists and on that well I suppose if we were to help the space for help space program I mean you know the doubt that would be quite surprised that were case but it's possible yeah I'm here so surprised a good

9:40it would look a little bit different but not not that much different my view n reusability is you have to take the the first stage has to basically turn around relight its engines boost back to the launch pad and lamp repulsively just tricky bit effect is very doable and then the second stage six stages harder because second stage you're a pound for pound trade off on payload so any any mass that you add and it shows a heat shield or reentry systems it's directly subtracted from the amount you can put into orbit where's the first stage is anywhere from a five to one to ten to one ratio so you get 10 pounds and early takes away one pound of payload and

10:36there's also a lot more unity with the second stage you have been a much more significant heat shield gift you have it you have to deal with the stage control it during reentry it's got to have some leftover drag so you can steer it back to the launch site and then you've got to either compulsively land or perhaps these are powerful something like that all those things cost mass but that's kind of how I think it should get can and should be done that's where we get more so that basic architecture is what we're going to try to do the trick is to do it with just very mass efficiently

11:14because you've only got that three maybe three and a half percent of master play with you know you want to try to get at least say two percent a beautiful pass to orbit so that leaves like what I have to say for everything else so not much

11:41yet I think long-term you'd see that sort of thing and maybe even in the truck in the in the initial phase it kind of depends on whether the country both United States builds a super heavy lift or not like a Saturn five classic vehicle if you have 75 class people you don't need to do on-orbit assembly if you have something smaller than that then you then you do if you want to go to Mars so so it kinda depends on which

12:13how things unfold and in that direction I think it'd be great to have a super heavy lift launch vehicle if it's if it's if it's done in a typical government way I I think will will not come to fruition because of massive schedule overruns and massive cost overruns so it really depends on whether

12:38NASA decides to take a commercial approach to super heavy lift if there will be superb waved and obviate the need for on overt construction and then you know when there's a lot of traffic between Earth and Mars i would expect this probably some you know large kind of space cruiser that's circulating between Earth and Mars and then you just basically take a small shuttlecraft up to the space cruiser if you will and the space cruiser gets refueled from from Earth or on Mars but that's a long time optimization and would be driven by pile of traffic occurring between the two to two planets

13:33what is I think it's generally good well in NASA's our biggest customer force for SpaceX so they certainly are huge in the customer front that they about forty percent of our launches are for NASA they haven't I mean it did it pay for demonstration flights so there's a requires e fonder but we specifically

14:09for their needs so wasn't just sort of here some money do what you want it's like we have a specific need we'll pay you as you demonstrate milestones and in that direction in a case of Tesla we were fortunate enough to receive a government loan last year which was unrelated to the bailout unfortunately it was announced right around the time of the bailouts but it all sort of assumed it was somehow bailout but the

14:38loan that we received was actually quite a program was initiated in 2007 in boom times and one of the requirements of that loan program was that you had to be a viable in your own right and provide twenty to thirty percent of private capital as matching as a matching contribution which therefore excluded for example GM and Chrysler who were bankrupt

15:07so for nissan tesla receipted receive light essentially lines of credit that and which was specifically rated in our cases simply related to the engineering and production costs of the model s so it certainly helpful from a from a capital dilution standpoint and then if we if you repay the loan early then there's no there's no capital pollution if we if we but if we don't repay the loan early then the US government gets a bunch of stuff warrants in Tesla so I think it's a pretty sort of one I mean in the grand scheme of things are the various government deals that are done this is I think one of the smaller ones

16:10yeah I think I mean there will be many sources of electricity that are sustainable there's a wind geothermal a hydro and but but my personal view is that sole power will be we will generate more power more electricity from solar than from any other single source and it may not be a majority but I expect release morality from from solar power and that there will be a combination of photovoltaics at the point of views you know roofs of houses and businesses which is also a good from separate not requiring additional power lines and then at the power plant level I think we'll see a lot of solar thermal power generation where we essentially just

17:02using the Sun to heat a working fluid and and then generate steam and power turbine they're a bunch of those projects that are going to come online in California and few other place in the united states soon and if you think of soul power you could if you can sort of beyond beyond humanity's need for electricity the earth is in time almost entirely solar powered the whole weather system is solar powered or almost entire where the system is sold out a little but it is from earth rotation but you know all or precipitation so solar powered the only reason we're not a frozen dog ice ball at four degrees Kelvin is because of the Sun and you the

17:47whole ecosystem is so low power plants are essentially a solar-powered chemical reaction so we really were just talking about replacing this itty bitty think of electricity and having that also be so calm Oh oh thanks you bet that was the intent that was the whole lot that was my idea no I don't

18:34think so it likes to be either the whole purpose it has a whisk to to draw the rest of the car industry into electric cars so I'm the more electric our programs i see being announced that happy I am the success of Tesla as a company naturally is going to be a function of the quality of products that we produce so you know we have to make better cars than say GM and Chrysler I don't see that as a huge challenge okay

19:12no you know but the setting is that generally in the United States if people can afford an expensive car they do not buy an American car and I think it's at a year in the 60s the u.s. make great cars before that make great cars but then something happened in the seventies matter what happened was a lot of bad things octet retail fashion was questionable and I karst out of so

19:51I think it would it actually is a friend of mine now I said summarize the Tesla strategies to in long term is to make cars at that suck so so I think we'll be okay and the sub indication in that Toyota which is the largest company in the world and leader in hybrids is an investor and partner with with Tesla and if if it was easy they were simply do it themselves not bothered to to partner with us Daimler is the was the inventor of the internal combustion engine car maker of Mercedes and smart and again they would not ask us to be a supplier to them or nor would they be an investor in Tesla if they thought it was a simple matter to replicate what we're doing

20:55no no this this aluminum is great and the audi a8 for example is an aluminum car or all the airplanes that that you fly are mostly aluminum and it's it's a little it's a little hot it's luminaries law is harder to work with in terms of bonding and joining it's harder to weld and then that's deal for example so it is technologically more difficult to work with but it is superior superior metal for anything where weight is important but that's why planes that are made of steel so in fact the more or

21:39less our design target is is to meet five-star crash rating by 2012 standards which are higher than the car this 5-star in by 2010 standards is only a three star by 2012 standards so we have a very high bar there waiting for from a safety standpoint obviously you know I'll be driving a car my friends will be driving the car a bloated shareholders

22:06we're driving the car so we it safety is extremely important if that they would I don't think they'll be a safer car on the road oh sorry that's sort of the price it's it's kinda like a pie series BMW so depending upon configuration it would vary from about fifty thousand dollars to a hundred thousand dollars

22:56well I i I'd really think that there's been a bit too much outsourcing in general but outsourcing up California outsourcing on the United States business sometimes tends to be a little fatty you know it's sort of like what's the district because there was a for a very long time very strong outsourcing fad and it but I don't think people

23:23really looked at the fundamentals in a lot of cases when they when they out sourced and particularly when the technology is evolving rapidly I think it's important to have a tight iteration link between engineering and production so if you so what as soon as you've designed something you can bring it to production right away and you can get the engineers can go on the on the floor and see the mistakes that they've made the production people can talk to the engineers and say here's some good ideas and so you can you can involve the product and achieved it gets a better design solution faster I think this is an important thing that's often overlooked you know its face x our

24:07Rockets lower costs than the Chinese Indians or anyone or anyone else and that's before we use abilities taken into account and i think i think it's like it's because that tight iteration with and in the case of tesla you know the fremont plant the nummi plant that they until april first of last year they made the corolla there which is seventeen thousand dollar car so if it was fundamentally an expense it was fundamentally too expensive driver in California how could they make a 70 desk to a car so I you know we in Californy I

24:42think we do need to cautious about adding more and more costs to to living here you know the I do you think we're close to sort of we're in a cuspid to a tipping point if you if the taxes arcade you have much higher than they are you know it to California marginal tax rate is eleven percent you could go to state of Washington and pay zero percent so there's an expensive place to live I like living in California it's on here but I know many people who moved out because the texts are too high or the

25:21where's the workman's comp and other costs are too high California's I think tend to over-regulate a little bit so so I think generally California's going to have a really tough thing to do which is it's gotta cut cut cut the cost of what it spends at the state level and and and

25:50maybe even reduce the taxes a little bit to be competitive with other states and deregulate those are the things that can be done to increase employment in California and politically these are difficult things to do and I'm not entirely sure how Calif like a California gets out of the spine it might have to be a proposition or something because the legislature seems unable to arrive at anything sensible

26:23sure sir no no no no pills limitations in space so silicon it we don't worry about silicon from a limitations that where there's lots of silicon copper is probably okay to this quite a lot of copper in the world for battery packs one of the challenges we had was cobalt actually couples coke is only available in a few places in the world but it's quite expensive and the biggest source is the Congo which tends to vary as political stability so that that's why

27:17I'm going to go to the Model S we change the chemistry to require only about a quarter as much cobalt and let's reduce the cost of battery pack an actual increase that the energy of the pack if you're going to worry about any material sort of shortages maybe some rare earth elements are maybe a concern China has a huge concentration of rare earth elements which are used in permanent magnet motors to avoid that issue well

27:47actually there are other reasons for it as well but the Tesla that uses a has a electric motor design that doesn't use any rare earth elements I think we're generally ok on the other commodities fine don't worry too much about it again except for that the non-reusable commodities like oil and that kind of thing well the old price is going to go way way way up in case I always wondering yeah I'm sure some really okay

28:20with the back you know I'm not too worried about recharging stations the great thing about electricity is it really ubiquitous I mean they're more power outlets that ad is the more partners than access to any other kind of energy by orders 92 in the indicate in case Tesla and and most of the new electric cars are coming out the charger is built into the car so you can plug it in almost anywhere if you want to charge fast you can eat a high power outlet but what we're seeing with the use of the tesla roadster is almost all charging occurs at home it's like ninety percent plus now it is important that you have a range that is reasonable if you've got

29:18sort of a really low range like say 50 miles 50 miles range then well you can't you can't do a lot of round trips I mean really you know 25 miles is you're Max and you're being pretty sporting if you do that so so as you reduce the range you start to require a lot of charging stations but as you increase the range the number of charging stations you need tends to drop with the square of the range okay so you've got sort of us you know a circle that you can travel in and so the big that circle is the fewer recharging stations you need and you know so so for something like the Tesla road so you only need one charging station between LA and San Francisco

29:59it's a 400-mile trip till you could turn it back to 50 miles of range there's the one translation but if you had a 50 mile range you need probably 10 charging stations yeah eight to ten charging station so i i i i i think you'll really only see a lot of use of charging stations place as far as Tesla cars are concerned on the interstates so when

30:29you're making really long distance trips that kind of thing but otherwise not enough

30:52yes sure so in the case of SpaceX unfortunately the supply chain in the rocket business is very shallow very often there is only one supplier and it's a very expensive supplier and they're really not designed for your usability so do screwed if you don't buy get yourself basically but for the most part yeah and so let's led to SpaceX

31:32being sort of maybe seventy to eighty percent of the rocket being Fulton house from from literally for a little raw material and I guess so another way to look at it is to the degree that you you you inherit the legacy components you're gonna get inherit the legacy cost structure and limitations so it is up

31:54from any sort of religious bias towards the insourcing but rather because on the fundamentals we were driven to do that in Tesla the haze Tesla the automotive supply chain is much better much more competitive there are many suppliers for any given component and so you know maybe forty to fifty percent of the

32:17Tesla Model S is in sourced you mean you use use parts that are our rocket in something else at their day not yet then there's a bit of your queries about using our engines in some other programs which we've responded to and it could it could happen that our engines are are used in some other government programs we do yeah well this

33:14just a strange 20 heavy liftin super heavy left because there are rockets that like if L can dine heavy and there's the Delta for heavy and then these these were on the order of indicates tell four hits but maybe 25 tons to orbit in case of Falcon 9 heavy it's maybe 30 35 tons to orbit but

33:36compared to the Saturn five which was over 100 tons tool but it's this preparatory difference there so I general McCulloch sort of super heavy in 110 plus class and yeah SpaceX would really like to vote was super heavy and and I think we could do it for a small fraction of what now you know people what they think people think it would cost actually my name when I'm going to record to say I think we could go super heavy for development for on the order of two and a half million you know prior other estimates sort of are about 10 times that and and the super-heavy that

34:18i'm alluding to would have about 160 tonto over capability so way more than or Saturn 5 in fact I've even gone as far as to say that I will guarantee that personally and stake everything on SpaceX that it will happen so I mean we'll see there are strong political forces that that don't was that that don't want us to do that so I'm trying to eliminate any argument that they could have for not for not not at least allocating a

34:58small portion of the super habit of funding to give us a shot of making it work you know they can take all the rest of the Super very funny and apply it in it to the traditional way we will take these sort of ten ten to twenty percent of that number on a fixed milestone basis so if we don't achieve the milestones we don't get paid and and and

35:26I will personally guarantee it so you know like if we don't achieve the milestones then that then that money can then be applied to the other programs so it is a no lose proposition but logic does not always prevail right

36:15so Oh yeah I think I think tears will be okay yeah I actually I'm bounce that the program has been helpful to Tesla and yeah so I ok in a space arena you know well man there's a complicated situation but but the out of necessity NASA as has you've brought about a bunch of necessity anna has gone commercial as far as cargo transports concerned and and then last year President Obama said

37:40well we should also outsource national transport to commercial entities if we can fly in boring airliners and Airbus airliners and forget about that then why can't on spacecraft people by commercial entities to and but there was a battle royale last year against that which won by a three percent margin in the House of Representative that was Harry battle

38:11but but it is moving that direction it's somewhat unavoidable I i mean it's it's gonna be that or nothing so so i think it's going to be that episode i'm feeling pretty optimistic about it I probably worried slightly more about in the space arena about some of the big government contractors they would

38:41definitely like to see SpaceX die I'm quite confirming tortured an effigy right now you know how you see a movie and like this look the bad corporation of the movie that's like the big defense contractor so that does that those are a competition in a lot of cases so yeah okay I'll take a couple more questions and good great I'm a huge fan of NASA

39:30yep yeah that's happened many times actually you know we didn't start out in sourcing you know seventy eighty percent of our of our hardware initially we thought we'll what tried to do as little as possible but then over time we just had insolence more and more out of necessity and we found many times that we were to sign a deal for supply have a component for and then the best supplier would

40:24find a reason to triple the price and so basically soon as they thought we didn't have any way out then they would start with the conclusion which is tripled price and insert reasoning that that's happened several times and and then and then we never again supposed to Pont to this price so often with a lot of letter

40:53grief so yeah I Burt pleased with how things are now but it was very very hairy for a couple years there and two late two thousand seven through say for first half of 2009 okay we came close to not making it all right last last question he said somebody who have been ignoring for a long time okay all right go ahead you up

41:34Richard who yeah actually I'm afraid I mean refer a friend is a friend of mine I mean so I mean he's a very affable guy he's a he's a lot of technologists so he's sort of I mean see his strength is brand and marketing and that kind of thing is very good at that you know I think going into the rocket game is tricky because it is a very much technology problem and so I think he's

42:11going to he's going to counter some challenges there also what Virgin Galactic is doing is a suborbital flight which is only about one and a half percent of the energy that you need to get to over it so it is a much simpler problem it's basically you shoot up to about sort of 60 60 60 or 70 miles and

42:34then you fall down but that's that's a social bittering but it's just like the Wolves best roller coaster ride so it's like a really fun trip but it's it's not it's not a technology path that would ultimately take us off of 22 other planets and that kind of thing but I think it a lot of people it's there's this is not it's not a clear distinction between getting to space and getting to orbit and space with some of the loose definition it's kind of where does the atmosphere get thin and and you can sort of define how thin is then I mean it's

43:09pretty darn thin at 60 miles altitude but you can't have a satellite up there because if satellite would order to K very quickly in a degree in her butt and then going up and staying up is actually about how fast you're zooming around the earth but it's it's a takes much more energy to to do that sort of zooming

43:33around the earth but then it is to get the altitude in fact the only reason need altitude at all is to get out of atmospheric drag if it worth had to atmosphere you could be orbiting Earth like an inch above the ground so yeah it's a so to get to / can you at least to go about 25 times the speed of sound on it for 4th and the energy required scales with the square of the velocity so let's say 625 units of energy to do a suborbital flight such as what Virgin Galactic sorta let need maybe about Mach 3 which is 90 units of energy so it's a pretty huge difference and then if you want to re-enter you have to burn off 625 units of energy or bergdorf 19 strategy so it's just a

44:20giant difference so all right well thankee

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份