2011年,美国航空航天学会(AIAA)的一场问答上,有人问马斯克,可复用火箭的进展到底怎么样了。
他回答得很干脆:
到目前为止,糟透了。真的。这件事极其困难。在此之前从来没有人造出过完全可复用的火箭,是有原因的:它实在太难了。(马斯克)
那一年,猎鹰9号只飞过两次。龙飞船刚刚完成第一次轨道飞行,溅落点离靶心大约一英里。猎鹰重型还停在图纸上,三个芯级并排绑在一起的构型,连一张照片都没有。
十几年后回头读这场问答,有意思的是:他答对的部分,后来大多成了行业标准;他当时卡住的地方,也确实是后来最硬的几块骨头。
去火星,12到15吨只是起步价
问答从火星运力开场,起点是“怎么从火星回来”这个话题。
马斯克给了一个具体数字:猎鹰重型往火星表面送货,大致能到12到15公吨。他说这不算差。
紧接着补了一句:真要往那儿送人和设备,飞行器的运力得在50公吨这个量级,而且整个过程必须完全可复用。做到这一步,整个方程式才算成立。
12吨为什么不够,50吨才算数。这是火箭工程里最古老的算术。运力每往上抬一档,箭体规模涨得比运力还快。瓶颈永远是钱:能不能便宜地把东西推上去。一次性火箭的每一公斤运力都要连箭带壳一起付钱,50吨载荷意味着一支几百吨的箭,用完就扔,谁也付不起。
所以可复用在他这里不是锦上添花的功能,是这张算式里唯一能让分母变小的变量。2011年他就把它说成了前提,而不是远景。至于具体怎么做,他留了一句:剥猫皮的方法不止一种。
一年两三百次发射,靠什么需求撑起来
下一位提问者显然做过功课。他说自己翻过很多可复用飞行器的研究,结论差不多一致:要撑住成本,得做到一年两三百次发射。他问,什么商业需求能撑起这个量级。
马斯克先承认这问题难答,然后给了一个历史类比:
莱特兄弟那个年代,没人能想到后来会有这么多趟航班。(马斯克)
类比有用,但不能全信。航空业的需求是长出来的,火箭不是。所以他很快自己把几个常见的答案排除掉了。
卫星不需要那么多。月球上的氦-3开采,他认为找不到理性依据。他把话说得更绝:把任何东西从太空挖出来运回地球,他都想不出商业逻辑,因为地球本身就什么都有,地壳里几乎凑齐了元素周期表上所有稳定的元素,而且地球很大。
这段判断在2011年显得有点扫兴,那阵子小行星采矿正热,一家又一家公司成立起来,PPT 上画着铂金矿脉。他的反驳很平实:运输成本再低,也低不过“地球上本来就有矿”这件事。
他唯一认可的驱动力是:有人愿意搬到月球或者火星上去住。这个需求能撑起一年几千次航班。
几千次。这个数字是理解后面所有设计取舍的钥匙。如果客户是要搬过去住的人,飞船就得按民航的可靠性和周转率来设计,而不是按一次性科学仪器的标准来设计。这两个标准之间隔着一个数量级。
龙飞船缺的那一样东西
话题转到龙飞船和载人。
马斯克说,猎鹰系列和龙飞船从画第一根线开始,就是照着 NASA 公开的载人设计准则做的。他报了一串具体指标:
- 安全系数按1.4设计,行业惯例是1.25。
- 多重故障容错。龙飞船在任何时刻丢掉任意两台发动机,依然安全,依然能相对空间站做平移和转动。
- 主防热大底后面还有一层备份防热结构。
- 航电系统双余度起步,关键部分三余度。
- 有舷窗。
安全系数这一条值得展开。1.4意味着结构在极限载荷的1.4倍时才开始破坏,1.25是传统载人标准的常见取值。多出来的0.15不会凭空消失,它全部变成结构重量,直接从运力指标里扣掉。这是用性能换安全,账面上很清楚。
然后他自问自答:那它到底还缺什么?
只缺一样,逃逸系统。
逃逸燃料装在飞船肚子里
传统做法是飞船顶上立一座逃逸塔,里面装满固体火箭。发射台上或者上升段出事,点火,把乘员舱整个拽走。
逃逸塔的毛病很清楚。它只在头几分钟有用,一旦抛掉,剩下的飞行过程就没有退路了。而且那座塔本身是纯死重,从点火那一刻起就在吃运力。
马斯克他们走了另一条路:烧飞船上自带的推进剂。
他的理由是能量账。飞船要么需要在轨机动,要么需要逃逸,不需要同时做这两件事。同一套推进剂、同一批发动机干两件事,质量效率最高。
这个设计带来一个不太显眼但很实在的好处:逃逸能力可以一路带到入轨。整个上升段都有退路,不用在某个时间点把保险扔掉。
还有一个赠品:同一批发动机可以用来做反推着陆。
降落伞没扔。反推发动机本身有冗余,主伞也有冗余,加起来差不多四层防护。要出人命,得连续四道全部失效。他补了一句:同样的反推着陆能力可以搬到火星、月球或者太阳系里别的什么地方去,龙飞船能当通用的科学载荷投送平台。
这段回答里藏着一个很少被讨论的判断:逃逸和在轨机动在物理上是互斥的两种需求,一个要求大推力短时间,一个要求小推力长时间。把它们塞进同一套硬件,等于承认飞船的生命周期里,最危险的那几十秒和最平常的那几天可以共用一套系统。
电推进:别让能源在旅途上闲着
有人问电推进的看法。
马斯克的回答绕了一下,先讲能量从哪来:
你一旦到了火星表面,就需要大量能源。那还不如在去程的路上把这些能源用掉,用来缩短旅途时间。(马斯克)
逻辑很朴素。反正要带能源过去,不管是核电源还是大面积太阳能阵列,在轨漂几个月让它闲着就是浪费。拿去驱动电推进,能把旅程时间砍掉一截。
他点了两个工程门槛:推力得大到有意义的程度,能量效率得够高,也就是每牛顿推力要花掉多少焦耳。
这两条今天依然成立。电推进的比冲高得离谱,推力小得可怜,能不能“有意义”完全取决于任务的时间预算。同样的功率,推一颗探测器去木星和推一艘载人飞船去火星,结论完全相反。
升阻比0.3,够用而且摔不死
又有人问气动外形,具体是升阻比。
升阻比是飞行器在再入时能获得多少横向机动能力的度量。数字越高,能滑得越远,落点选择越自由。航天飞机在再入段的升阻比大约在1上下,能横向机动上千公里。
龙飞船可以靠调整横向质心位置来改变升阻比,最高能到0.3。马斯克说,2010年12月那次飞行,纯靠气动减速,落点离目标大约一英里。他不觉得有理由做得更高。
0.3是个很低的数字,基本相当于一块带一点点升力的石头。为什么不做得更高?他的回答分两层。
第一层是通用性。再入外形是分星球设计的。火星大气密度低得多,尤其是低层大气,地球上好用的升力体到了火星未必好用,到了月球则毫无用处。0.2到0.3的升阻比在这三个地方都能凑合,一套外形包打三个星球。
第二层是鲁棒性。低升阻比意味着不需要维持特定攻角。就算龙飞船的控制系统彻底死机,飞船仍然会自然地把主防热大底转向来流方向,稳稳地落下来。代价只是过载从4到5个G涨到8到9个G。降落伞可以手动拉。
他连用了三个“非常”来形容这套设计的稳健程度。
这一段能看到他的工程哲学。多出来的性能要拿鲁棒性去换,他选了鲁棒性。载人飞行里,一个不会失效的姿态系统,比多出两百公里的横向机动值钱得多。
猎鹰重型的交叉输送,只在真需要时打开
问题转到猎鹰重型。三个芯级并联,外侧两个助推器给中间芯级做推进剂交叉输送(crossfeed),运力能多出20%到30%。
能这么干,靠的是发动机数量。中间芯级的九台发动机里,靠近两侧助推器的那几台直接从侧芯抽燃料,抽到某个时点关掉阀门,不让中间芯级继续从侧芯往下吸。一台发动机的火箭做不了这个动作,九台就可以,流量可以按台分配。
交叉输送是选装项。不需要大运力的客户,这个功能根本不打开。它针对两类任务:特别重的载荷,和飞往太阳系外缘的任务。他提到正在和 NASA 谈一些可能飞到150到200天文单位的任务,那个距离远远超过冥王星和柯伊伯带。
150个天文单位是什么概念。旅行者一号飞了四十多年,现在离地球大约160多个天文单位。2011年谈这个数字,等于在说猎鹰重型要接的是深空科学探测器的活儿,这跟当时 SpaceX 给近地轨道送货的形象差得很远。
给助推器穿一副刚好合身的盔甲
最后回到可复用这个总账。
马斯克第二次给出同样的评价:到目前为止,糟透了。
他承认团队学了很多。龙飞船收回来了。把龙飞船当成第三级看,返回后的状态,重新叠好降落伞,几乎什么都不用改就能再飞一次。
但助推器不行。你没法给助推器也穿上龙飞船那身衣服,穿了,助推器就一点运力都不剩。
真正的难处在于造一副刚好合身的盔甲,厚度精确对应它再入时必须承受的力。这些力比他们预想的大。一级回来时的弹道很陡,基本上是用肚子拍在稠密大气上。
要减速度,摆在面前的是两条路。
一条是重启发动机反推减速,把再入变得温和一点,让结构少受点罪。这条路烧推进剂,等于从运力里再割一块。
另一条是加厚结构余量、换更好的防热层,硬扛再入的热流和过载。这条路加干重,也等于从运力里再割一块。
两条路往同一个钱包里伸手。选哪条,取决于哪一边的边际成本更低,而这两个数字都得靠真飞才能测出来。
他说,纸面上他们已经算通了,接下来看现实认不认。
这场问答真正能抄走的东西
2011年的马斯克还没有任何一次成功回收记录。三年后猎鹰9号才开始做着陆试验,再过两年才第一次把助推器落到地面。当时听他讲这些,很容易当成吹牛。
但真正能抄走的是他说话的方式,而不是他的乐观。
被问进展,他说“糟透了”,没有用“在稳步推进”这类词。被问运力,他给数字:12到15吨,不够,得50吨。被问升阻比,他给0.3,还附一句想不出更高的理由。被问逃逸方案,他讲能量账,讲为什么这两件事不需要同时做。被问可复用的难点,他给了一个权衡:推进剂对干重。
一位工程师在2011年听完这场问答,能拿走的不是“马斯克很乐观”,是一张写满数字和取舍的表。这张表上的每一项,后来都被现实检验过,有的成立,有的被推翻。但每一项都可以被检验,这本身就是它有价值的原因。
反过来看,判断一段技术访谈值不值得读,标准很简单:里面有几个可以被证伪的数字。数字越具体,说话的人越可能是真在干活。
- 评估任何“可复用”方案,先问年周转次数。一年飞不了几十次的可复用系统,成本一定高于一次性火箭,复用次数是分子,检修工时是分母。
- 看运力指标时追问三个条件:哪个轨道、什么状态、是否复用。同一枚火箭,一次性和复用状态的运力能差出三成以上。
- 做系统设计时先问一句“这两件事需不需要同时做”。龙飞船逃逸方案省下的质量,全部来自这个提问。
- 把鲁棒性当成性能指标来打分。低升阻比换来的是控制失效也能落地,这类“坏情况下的表现”在载人系统里的权重高于标称性能。
- 跨环境的产品要留通用性。在地球大气里调优出来的气动外形,搬到火星就失效,设计文档里必须写清楚适用边界。
- 读技术访谈时盯住数字和条件句。数字能验证,条件句里藏着边界,形容词基本不携带信息。
0:00and and then returning to Earth as well and but I think we'll take this in steps certainly something like Falcon heavy could deliver you know decent payload to the surface of Mars it's sort of on the order of 12 to 15 metric tons so that that's not bad I I think you probably want a vehicle that can deliver something in the orderer of 50 metric tons you know and be able to do that in a fully reusable manner then then the whole equation Works and there's more than one way to skin that cat but yeah yeah that that's that's what I think yes I have a question on the reusable vehicle that you talked about I I've seen a lot of studies of these vehicles and the key to to making it
0:54work seems to be to get on the order of two or 300 missions a year keep the cost down what do you see as the the Commercial Drive that will will result in the need for two or 300 launches a year yeah I mean it that's always a tough question to answer and and I suspect in the early days of of airplanes people didn't imagine that there would be this many airplane trips but I I think the biggest driver for that is is really a base on mars or you know potentially base on the moon I don't think there's really a need for that many satellites for example and I I I also don't think it's that there's a rational basis for like you know doing things like mining helium 3
1:44on the moon and or really I have a hard time imagining mining anything anywhere and bringing it to Earth because Earth has got a lot of stuff Earth's crust has got almost every I mean Earth is Big but I do think there is a market for people who would want to move to the moon or move to Mars and and and that
2:08that I think is is is interesting and it could support a huge number of flights thousands of flights a year can you tell us your plans for theing capsule and sure question just about our Dragon spacecraft and what we're going to do with respect to carrying transporting astronauts and whatnot so the we actually designed the Falcon line and dragon to meet the
2:48published NASA human rating design guidelines so you know things like subd designing to a 1.4 factor of safety instead of a 1.25 having a multi being multi faure to tolerant so Dr a Dragon for example can lose any two engines at any at any time and still be safe with respect to the space station can still translate and rotate as needed and we actually have a sort of a secondary heat shield behind the primary heat shield the the
3:23avionics all two fairly tent all that sort of stuff it's it's got Windows so the question is what doesn't it have really the main thing is just the Escape system so that so in terms of upgrading it we need to add a launch Escape and in this we're taking a a sort of a different path than has been done before which is to tap the onboard propellant which is ANH as Escape propellant and because you either need to maneuver on orbit or you need to escape you don't need to do both and this this makes for a very efficient Mass efficient design and it also means that you can carry High Velocity Escape capability all the way to orbit as opposed to having to dump a launch Tower kind of
4:12early on and and then a sort of optional bonus is we can use those same engines to land propulsively now we're still going to retain redundant parachutes on dragons so you still have redundant redundant you know parachutes so effectively you'd have almost four levels of redundancy because the The Landing engines
4:41are themselves redundant and then you've got redundant main parachutes so like four things would have to fail before actually only on yeah the yeah four things in a row would have to fail in for loss of life but then the neat thing about that is you could use it to propulsively land in other places like Mars or Moon or somewhere so I think it's it's got potential as a generalized science delivery platform for for other you know missions in the solar
5:16system so question is where do I see electric propulsion I I think that's actually for sure a good idea for interplanetary travel particularly since you know you're going to need a lot of energy once you're on the surface of Mars so you may as well use that energy while you're in transit to to speed up the journey and yeah so I think electric propulsion definitely is a good idea and it would be kind
5:47of a waste not not to do electrical propulsion on the way there the you know the the trick is you you want to obviously have electric propulsion with enough thrust to matter you know that that that's that's pretty important so yeah I think that's that's and and needs to be fairly efficient in terms of the energy per you know per per Newton like guess
6:14what whats of energy to to Newton of force so so I mean the capsule is does have an lvd you know that it has a depending upon where we put the the the lateral Center Mass we can adjust the LV to as High as3 so that that gives us a pretty good accuracy in fact drag landed to within about a mile of its Target on on the flight in December and
7:08you there's there's not an obvious reason I think to to have more elev than that yeah nothing that I can think of and then you know the problem with with having more complex lifting bodies is that then it it gets kind of weird if you going if you want to go to Mars you know and you see if you Mars has a you know much lower en atmospheric density particularly in the lower atmosphere so you know something that worked well on Earth would necessarily work well on Mars it obviously would be completely useless on the moon so so I think you know something with a you know 02 to3 LOD is is is is I
7:52think good enough and it's very robust as well you don't have to worry about maintaining a specific angle of attack or something going wrong with your control systems or anything even if the if Dragon Control Systems totally malale functioned and then were just dead you you'd still you still survive because it's going to naturally Orient with the main heat shill down your G you'll experience higher G's you know you might see eight or nine G's instead of four to five but that's the only downside U and you can literally you can manually pull the shoots so so it's very very very robust in that
8:38sense sure yeah so the for Falcon heavy to to the cross feed between the the outer cores to the center is is pretty helpful you know it gives roughly 20 to 30% more payload and we have an advantage here in that because there are nine engines we can control flow to those engin engines
9:12individually so so the way we we do cross feed is is to basically draw propellant for for the engines that are adjacent to the core from from the you know so the engines that so the center core engine is is pulling from from its side core on either side and and then we we can shut prev valves to those engines so that it's not sucking it down from the side course you can't do this you've got one engine or or if if you know but you can do it if you have if you have mult you know nine engines it's a lot easier but but the the the cross speed is is is is really an option for a really big payload so for customers that that don't need the cross feed we would we would not
10:05enable cross feed yeah it's just it's just but it's helpful for Missions to they out that either big missions toor or missions to the outer solar system you so we're talking with tenas about some potential missions that that go out you know to 150 or 200 Au so you're sort of way out past past Pluto and stu
10:48yeah well his question was just generally how's it gone with reusability well so far it has sucked really I mean it extremely difficult and there's a reason that nobody has invented a fully reusable rocket before it's super damn hard [Music] but we have learned a lot and we did recover Dragon so if you sort of think of dragon as a third stage we have recovered dragon and we recovered in a condition that you could easily refly it with with changing nothing you know repack the shoots and you can fly it again but but but but the thing is we can't afford to give a dragon level of protection to the booster or the booster would get no payad orbit so the real
11:37tricky thing here is essentially you know constructing a suit of armor that is just exactly tailored to the forces it's going to need to resist on re-entry and then so and those forces are higher than we anticipated it's even for the first stage because of the trajectory the first stage it comes in at a pretty steep angle so the force is is is very high it's basically belly flopping on the atmosphere and so something has to be done to to shed velocity so you we're looking at you know potentially restarting the engines to do U to sh shed some velocity and and give it a a more benign re-entry weight against increased structure you know margins and and increased
12:33the and a better thermal Shield it's a tough trade on propellant versus dry mass and I I think you know we've got something that on paper closes and we'll see if that if that turns out to be reality as well
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版