访谈·中文精读

马斯克在 AIAA 谈火箭科学 2011

Elon Musk talks rocket science at the AIAA 2011

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

猎鹰9号发射一次,推进剂成本大约占整个任务成本的0.3%。

这个数字是马斯克2011年在美国航空航天学会(AIAA)联合推进会议(Joint Propulsion Conference)上给出的。台下坐的全是搞推进的工程师,没人比他更清楚煤油和液氧有多便宜。

火箭发射的钱,几乎不花在燃料上。客户付的那几千万美元,买的是那枚用完就扔的箭体、九台发动机、航电、整流罩、还有几百号人的工时。

顺着这个0.3%往下推,SpaceX的商业逻辑就出来了。马斯克那天下午讲的所有东西,从猎鹰1号的失败到火星基地的成本目标,都挂在这个小数点上。

一条正在往下走的曲线

马斯克开场先解释自己为什么办这家公司。动机跟商业机会没什么关系,他看到的是历史上的一条曲线。

1969年,美国能把人送上月球。到了1980年代,能力缩水成只能把人送进低地球轨道。2011年,美国连低地球轨道都上不去了,航天飞机准备退役,只能买俄罗斯联盟号的座位。

如果你看我们在不同时间点的能力,然后做外推,方向并不好看。必须做点什么把这条轨迹掰回来,否则太空的未来极其黯淡。(马斯克)

他给的判断很直白:一个不再往前走的太空项目,会慢慢退化成历史课本里的插图。他要做的是让人类变成多行星物种,让文明有第二个落脚点。

这话在2011年说出来,台下不少人的反应大概是礼貌性点头。那年SpaceX才成立九年,飞成功过的只有一枚小火箭。

他先得把固体燃料自己配出来

主持人Mark Lewis是马里兰大学航空航天系主任、前AIAA主席,他上来先读了段简历,读得挺有意思。

马斯克在南非出生长大,父亲是南非的工程师,母亲是加拿大人。17岁那年他认定美国是机会之地,自己先去了加拿大,跟亲戚住,打各种零工,在麦田里干过活,清理过谷仓。1992年进宾夕法尼亚大学沃顿商学院,同时修物理。毕业去斯坦福读研究生,按他自己的说法,研究生只当了两天,然后觉得人生还有更重要的事。

接着是Zip2,做给新闻机构用的在线内容发布软件,卖掉。然后是PayPal,做得更大,也卖掉。大多数人到这一步就退休了,他2002年6月创办了SpaceX,同时还在搞特斯拉和SolarCity。

Lewis列了几个荣誉:2011年2月入选美国40岁以下最有影响力的20位CEO,2010年入选《时代》百大影响力人物,2007年拿过AIAA的George Low航天奖。他个人觉得最有意思的一个是,2010年太空基金会(Space Foundation)的调查里,马斯克在“太空英雄”排行榜上排第十,跟冯·布劳恩并列。还有,《钢铁侠2》里托尼·斯塔克的原型是他。

马斯克上台后自己补了一段更实在的:在SpaceX之前,他从没造过任何物理的东西,一直在写软件。

硬要说有,那就是小时候在南非造过火箭,成败参半。当年南非买不到现成的固体火箭发动机,想造就得自己配推进剂、凑原料。他的原话是,把固体推进剂配好、配对,其实挺难的。

猎鹰1号用了六年,龙飞船一年就回来了

2002年到2008年,猎鹰1号花了差不多六年才第一次成功入轨。前面三次全失败,第四次成功,第五次成功。马斯克自己承认,把发动机、结构、航电、制导控制这些环节一个个摸清楚,花了不少时间。

过了这个坎之后,节奏快起来了。

2010年,猎鹰1号再次入轨,龙飞船(Dragon)被送入轨道,再安全带回。2011年的头号任务是12月跟国际空间站对接,虽然这个计划后来拖到了2012年5月才实现。第二号任务,是拿下空军的EELV(渐进一次性运载火箭)资质,让空军和国家侦察局(NRO)相信猎鹰9号是一枚可靠的运载工具。

他把这两件事的顺序讲得很清楚:商业合同是收入流,收入流是未来研制的资金来源。没有军方和NASA的钱,火星方案只能停在PPT上。

梅林1D,和一台还没公布的发动机

产品线上,猎鹰9号和猎鹰重型已经铺开,发动机是梅林(Merlin),当时即将进入第四次迭代,梅林1D。马斯克的评价是:这是美国飞行过的效率最高的碳氢发动机。

他透露的下一步更具体。今年底或明年初会公布一台新发动机,走分级燃烧(staged combustion)路线,效率极高。但他补了一句很马斯克的话:要先把很多鸭子排成一行,才会宣布这件事。

这台发动机的目标用户不是卫星。他明说,这是为“把大量货物和人员送上火星”准备的。台上没人追问参数,但这个技术路线指向很清楚:只有高压补燃循环才能把比冲和推重比同时推上去。

可重复使用,“快速”和“完全”两个词都不能少

整场演讲的核心论点在这。马斯克说,要在火星上建立自给自足的文明,需要运送几十万人,可能是几百万人,还要几百万吨货物。现有的火箭做不到,所以必须有根本性突破,而最根本的那个突破是快速且完全可重复使用的火箭。

两个限定词他都咬得很死。

部分可重复不行。慢慢可重复也不行。他举的例子是日常交通工具:自行车、汽车、飞机、船,全都是快速、完全可重复使用的,除了偶尔保养。反过来说,如果你有辆车,每趟都得换轮胎,或者一周只能开一次,那不是一辆好车,那是个麻烦。

他还提了一句莱特兄弟。在马斯克看来,莱特兄弟的贡献在于做出了受控的动力飞行,让一个东西飞起来本身没那么重要,后者才让飞机变得有用。

回到那个0.3%。猎鹰9号上推进剂的成本只占任务成本的0.3%,也就是说,如果箭体能完整复用,光是这一项就能带来至少一个数量级的成本效率提升。

他换了个说法让台下听懂这件事的量级:要求一个国家拿出GDP的0.3%去另一个星球建立生命,是一回事;要求100%的GDP,是另一回事。后者不会发生,因为人得吃饭,得先顾基本的东西。

至于复用方式,他明确倾向垂直起降(VTVL)。原因很朴素:去月球没有大气,去火星大气稀薄,哪儿都没有跑道,机翼在那些地方派不上用场。

火星要的不是几百人,是几百万人

有观众问火星任务架构。马斯克的回答分两层:知道要素,还没细化。

要素是,得有一个能把相当质量送到火星表面、还能返回地球的飞行器。猎鹰重型大概能把12到15吨送到火星表面,他说“不算差”。但他真正想要的是50吨级的运力,而且必须完全可重复使用,那时候整个成本方程才成立。他也承认,达成这个目标的路不止一条。

接着有人追问一个更尖锐的问题:这类飞行器要每年200到300次任务才能把成本压下来,商业驱动力从哪来?

马斯克先承认这问题难答。他说早期飞机时代,没人想象过今天会有这么多航班。

然后给出他的答案:最大的需求来源是火星基地,或者月球基地。

他不认为卫星发射能撑起这个量级。他也不看好月球采矿,尤其是采氦-3运回地球那套说法。他的理由是地球本身很大,什么都有,“我很难想象在任何地方采矿然后运回地球”。但他认为确实存在想搬到月球或火星去住的人,这个需求能支撑每年数千次飞行。

龙飞船离载人只差一个逃逸系统

有人问龙飞船载人的准备情况。马斯克的回答是,猎鹰9号和龙飞船一开始就是按NASA公开的载人设计指南设计的,具体到几个指标:

  • 安全系数取1.4,NASA的最低要求是1.25
  • 多重故障容错,龙飞船在任何时刻失去任意两台发动机仍能保证安全
  • 可以倾斜、旋转,完成跟空间站的对接
  • 主隔热罩背后还有一层次级隔热罩
  • 航电系统有故障容错
  • 有窗户

缺的只有发射逃逸系统。而这套系统的做法跟传统路线不一样。

传统做法是在顶上装一个逃逸塔,发射初期一旦出事就点火把座舱拽走,入轨前抛弃。SpaceX的方案是让船上的推进剂兼职做逃逸推进剂,逻辑是:在轨机动和紧急逃逸不会同时发生,同一套推进剂可以干两件事。这样一来质量效率高得多,而且能把高速逃逸能力一直保留到入轨,不用早早把逃逸塔扔掉。

顺带的好处是,同一批发动机还能用来做推进着陆。

他还提到,降落伞的冗余保留着。所以整套系统差不多是四重冗余:着陆发动机本身有冗余,主降落伞有冗余,得四个东西同时失效才会出人命。这套组合还能让龙飞船在火星或月球做推进着陆,变成一个通用的科学载荷投送平台。

每年两三百次发射,谁来买单

可重复使用绕不开经济性问题,台下问得很直接:一套完全复用的系统,周转和检修成本怎么控制?

马斯克的回答散在几处,拼起来大概是这样:复用的意义在于把“造一枚火箭”变成“维护一枚火箭”。0.3%的推进剂占比意味着,只要箭体本身能反复用,成本结构就完全变了。他自己也承认,这个转变需要很多年,“很多年”在他的定义里是“好几年”。

他还提到复用对载荷的侵蚀。让一级复用,就要给它加结构余量、加隔热罩、留推进剂用于减速,这些重量都得从载荷里扣。这笔账很难算,推进剂和干重之间的权衡很折磨人。他的说法是,纸面上已经有一个能闭合的方案,实际飞起来是不是真的闭合,还得看。

一级再入,几乎是在大气层上打水漂

谈到具体进展,马斯克没给任何乐观数字。他说这件事极其困难,没人发明出完全可重复使用的火箭是有原因的,“超级难”。

已经做到的部分是龙飞船的回收。如果把龙飞船看成第三级,它回收之后的状态几乎可以直接再飞,只要重新打包降落伞就行。

问题在于,不能给助推器龙飞船级别的保护。龙飞船有隔热罩、有结构余量,因为它是从轨道速度再入的。一级助推器的处境不同,如果照龙飞船的标准加固,载荷就归零了。

真正的难点,他打了个比方:要造一副盔甲,恰好抵挡它需要抵挡的那些力,多一分浪费,少一分烧穿。而一级再入的受力比他们预想的高,因为弹道很陡,几乎是贴着大气层打水漂。

可能的解法有几条,都在权衡中:重启发动机减速,让再入更温和;提高结构余量;换更好的隔热罩。每一条都要用载荷换。

核热推进:马斯克当场改了口

核热推进这段问答出现了整场演讲唯一一次当场改口。

马斯克先被问到核推进,他的第一反应是泼冷水。难点不在物理,在于把反应堆和成吨的铀送上天,公众那关过不去。他说小的放射性同位素温差发电机(RTG)可以接受,大的反应堆不行。人们还常常忘记反应堆有多重,而且通常需要附近有水源来驱动蒸汽轮机。相比之下,太阳能板其实相当不错。

但他也承认,火星表面是另一回事。那里反应堆很好用,废热在火星上是宝贵资源,任何能给火星加温的东西都值得考虑。

然后台下有位观众站起来,把数据摆了出来。大意是:核热火箭相比今天最好的化学火箭能把比冲提高一倍,六个月往返的火星任务能省下几百吨推进剂。而且发射时装的是天然铀,没有裂变产物,发动机还没启动。反应堆布置在箭体顶部,不在货舱里。就算发射失败、箭体解体散开,燃料的放射性也很低。他还举了个对比:卡西尼号上那三台RTG的放射性物质,比送人上火星所需的32.5万磅核热发动机加起来还多。

马斯克的回应值得完整引用:

如果真是这么少的放射性物质,那也许上面级可行。但说实话,我怕的是公众那一关。如果我真提出发射几千枚核动力火箭,会有人想把我吊死。(马斯克)

接着他自己往下接了:圣地亚哥港里停着核动力航母和核潜艇,好像没人特别惊慌。也许公众的担忧比他以为的要小。他说自己对新的思路是开放的,这件事跟他原来想的不一样。

他还补了一句,他很喜欢聚变,聚变如果能成会非常酷,但得先在地面上实现能量净输出,那本身就是对人类的巨大贡献。

吸气式发动机,纸面上就算不过来

有人问更远期的方案:氢氧系统在穿越大气层时顺便抓取空气中的氧气,能不能省掉一部分氧化剂。

马斯克的回答是没有悬念的否定。他看过这些数字,阻力带来的损失总是超过省下的氧化剂。

原因有两个。一是空气里80%是氮气,只能取那20%的氧,等于每抓一次有用气体,要拖着四倍没用的质量走。二是获得大量空气的前提是处在稠密大气里,而稠密大气意味着高阻力,速度一快加热率就受不了,箭体自己会熔化。

他的结论是,就算看起来这枚火箭上带了一大堆氧化剂很浪费,带着走仍然是更划算的做法。他没在纸面上见过一个能算通的方案,而现实通常比纸面更糟。

把26个月的火星窗口拉宽

有人问了个架构层面的问题:火星窗口每26个月才开一次,每次有效窗口只有几周,如果要在那儿建基地,发射得挤在极短时间内完成,经济性怎么成立?

马斯克承认这是建立火星自给文明最大的挑战之一。他说必须把窗口拉宽,也许能到6个月。窗口正中间载荷最大,前后三个月逐渐衰减。

他提了两条路。一条是电推进。这个方向他看好,理由是火星表面本来就需要大量能源,与其在途中闲着,不如拿来加速,缩短航程。前提是推力要够大,能量效率要够高,得算清楚每牛顿推力要花多少瓦。

另一条更巧:提前发射,把一批飞行器送进高远地点轨道停泊,等着地球和火星对齐,到时候再踢最后一脚。相当于在空中排一个车队。

但他也老实说,从delta-v的角度看,把窗口拉到6个月以上已经很难想象了。

每磅50美元

有观众直接问成本门槛:每磅多少钱,火星才谈得上可行?

马斯克给的数字是:每磅入轨成本要远低于100美元,大概是50美元左右。

作为对照,猎鹰重型一次性使用时每磅约1000美元。也就是说,要往下砍10到20倍。他认为如果做到可重复使用,即便损失一部分载荷,也有可能触到这个数字。依据还是那0.3%,推进剂只占火箭成本的三百分之一,剩下全是硬件,硬件能反复用,成本就能塌下来。

他没给时间表,只说这需要很多年。

铁路修通之后

演讲快结束时,马斯克讲了个类比,解释SpaceX到底在做什么。

他说,联合太平洋铁路横贯大陆之前,加州没什么像样的生意。铁路修通之后,各种生意繁荣起来。但如果没有到达的手段,另一边的组织就无法生长。

所以SpaceX的定位是修那条铁路,把地球和火星之间的运输链路建起来,然后不断迭代,让它越来越好、越来越便宜。别的组织和企业在这个基础上能做什么,是下一步的事。

他反复强调这不可能是SpaceX一家的事。没有NASA就没有SpaceX的今天,NASA是关键伙伴,而且会一直是。他希望空军和NRO也成为伙伴,也希望有其他公司参与,“不该只有SpaceX一家在做运输”。

关于更远的架构,他描绘了一个画面:地球和火星轨道上各有一批小型飞行器负责接送人和货,中间是一艘大型飞船在地火之间循环。但他明确说这是几十年后的事。中期方案还是一艘船从地球飞到火星再飞回来。

他还提到一个有意思的机制:火星基地一旦存在,就成了改进运输技术的强制函数。就像美洲殖民地建立之后,跨大西洋的船只技术一年比一年好,因为有真实的需求在后面推。没有基地,技术改进就缺少动力。

至于钱从哪来,他的判断是政府和私人资本的组合,具体比例不好说,不太可能做成X Prize那种形式,但可能会有X Prize的元素。

最后有人问商业载人的乘客是谁。马斯克的回答很干脆:NASA是客户,谁上船由客户决定,就像你买机票,坐哪趟航班由你定。除此之外还会有私人宇航员,去私人空间站、绕地球飞一圈,甚至绕月球飞一圈。

演讲结束后,Lewis上台致谢,送了马斯克一枚AIAA的纪念币。整场问答不到一小时,但几乎把后来十几年商业航天的争论提前讲了一遍。

把这场2011年的演讲拆开看,能提炼出几条对今天仍然好用的判断方法:

  • 评估任何运载系统的成本结构,先算推进剂占比。占比极低,说明降本空间在箭体复用,不在燃料采购。
  • 听到“可重复使用”这个说法,追问两件事:复用比例是多少,周转时间是多长。部分复用和慢速复用都不改变成本方程。
  • 区分“纸面收敛”和“飞行验证”。马斯克自己说一级再入的受力比预期高,纸上算得过来不等于真能飞。
  • 面对自己反对的技术路线,把物理可行性和公众接受度分开评估。核热推进属于物理上成立、公众那关难过,这跟技术上做不到是两件事。
  • 遇到别人拿出具体数据反驳你,改口不丢人。马斯克当场就把核热推进从“不现实”改成了“也许上面级可行”。
  • 行星际运输的瓶颈常常在发射窗口和delta-v,不在发动机本身。看架构时先问窗口能不能拉宽,再问推力够不够。
  • 把成本目标换算成单一可比较的指标。“每磅入轨成本从1000美元降到50美元”比“便宜很多”有用得多,因为它能倒推出复用次数和载荷损失的容忍范围。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00good afternoon and welcome back for those that were here this morning and it looks like we have a few more to join us if you're not here this morning my name is Wayne herds from Northrop Grumman Systems Corporation here in Southern California and I am the industry general chair for this year's joint propulsion conference after this morning sessions I hope you all agreed that we're off to a good start I was happy to see full sessions papers being presented the great keynote and panel session this morning and well one of the things that

0:36made that possible was the great help from our organizing committee I want to once again thank my jpc government co-chair Jimmy Kenyon from the office of the assistant secretary of defense for research and engineering our general chair for this year's ie CEC Ted Stern from Vanguard space technologies and Ashwin Gupte from the University of Maryland our current director for AI double-a propulsion and energy group as I said this morning we got a lot of help pulling together this year's program and once again I would like to thank all the volunteers including the conference technical chairs topic area organizers and our sponsoring societies the a

1:14double-a staff and our industry sponsors as well who made this all possible so continuing our jpc theme design test fly turning propulsion ideas to reality our keynote speaker and panel this afternoon will continue today's theme of space and high speed systems tomorrow again we will turn our attention to propulsion for aviation and Wednesday we'll talk public policy and our test infrastructure in parallel sessions continuing on will be our ISE EC theme continuing to offer topics on government academia and industry working together towards clean energy so there's lots of topic areas for everyone to participate in so you don't want to hear me speak

1:56anymore so now to introduce our keynote speaker for this afternoon I invite to the podium our past Aila president and the willis young professor and chair for the department of aerospace engineering at the university of maryland dr. mark Lewis well thank you everyone and welcome to what is already turning out to be a spectacularly successful joint propulsion conference I know none of you are actually here to listen to me this this afternoon so I'm gonna make my remarks as briefly as possible those remarks will be to introduce this afternoon's guest speaker mr. Elon Musk truly an individual who requires no introduction but please indulge me because I'm gonna offer him one anyway

2:39Elon Musk is I think you know is the the CEO and the inspirational force behind the company called SpaceX which has made quite a name for itself he has a very very impressive background born and raised in South Africa he was the son of a South African engineer his mother was from Canada at the age of 17 he decided America was the land of opportunity so on his own moved to Canada in the United States lived with family did a variety of odd jobs including working on a wheat farm and cleaning grain bins was accepted in 1992 to University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School and also studied physics at the University of Pennsylvania from there he went to

3:20graduate school at Stanford where he explains that he basically spent two days as a graduate student and decided that now there are better things in life went on to and which some of us in academia would hardly agree with don't quote that in front of any of my graduate students went on to found a company called zip2 which provided online content publishing software for news organizations sold that company and whereas I think most of us in this room would have retired went on to found an even bigger and better company PayPal which I'm sure many of you familiar with Elon sold PayPal and I think he decided all he ever really wanted to do was build electric cars and build space

4:01vehicles and he's managed to be able to do both in June of 2002 he founded space explorations technology SpaceX he's currently the CEO and the CTO very impressive dual role and of course SpaceX develops and manufactures space launch vehicles perhaps their best-known products are the Falcon one rocket and most recently the Falcon 9 rocket he is also a famous for his role in leading the Tesla Motors Corporation of building electric cars perhaps the first truly operational electric cars that I think been an inspiration to the rest of the automotive industry and he is also the primary investor and chairman of the board of a solar city it's a photovoltaics products and

4:42services company that is providing electric power services throughout planning to do so throughout the United States if I went through a list of awards and recognitions it would also I think fill most of the a lot of time I'll just hit some highlights in February of 2011 Elon was listed as one of America's 20 most terrible powerful CEOs 14-under he was listed as one of Time Magazine's 100 people who will most affect the world in 20 and 10 he is a recipient of our very own a double-a George Lowe astronautics award presented for the most outstanding contributions in the field of space transportation he got that in 2007 2008 I needs on the Caltech Board of Trustees perhaps most

5:24impressive at least in my mind is in 2010 a survey by the Space Foundation ranked Elon as the number tenth most popular space hero tied with dr. Verner von Braun he's also I think is very well known the inspiration for the fictional character of Tony Stark in the Iron Man 2 movie so without further ado let me

5:46ask you to join me in welcoming Elon Musk to the podium thanks very much for

6:02having me and for the kind introduction I think we've got a video that may be a good way to kick it off just to play the video if we could

7:14one liftoff so I'll just give it a little bit of background as to you know what why I'm doing this and I think I think some people maybe have heard part of the story before so I apologize if some of it seems repetitive but I started SpaceX nine years ago almost exactly nine nine years maybe two months ago and the the reason for it was was was I was really

9:45concerned that we were not on a path to become a multi-planet species and a spacefaring civilization and you know if you look at what our capability has been at various points in time and you you extrapolate that it doesn't go in a good direction I mean in 1969 we were able to go to the moon and then in the 80s we were just able to go to low-earth orbit with people and and of course now we cannot even go to low-earth orbit with people although hopefully in in a few years we'll be able to do that on on our spacecraft or maybe maybe other spacecraft other American spacecraft but clearly something needs to be done to reverse that trajectory or or the future

10:33of space is extremely dismal so that was the reason I started SpaceX with that aspiration and but it was a very difficult thing because I'd never built anything physical before I'd done a lot of software actually technically I'd built rockets when I was a kid but with myth with mixed success in in South

10:58Africa that they didn't have sd's rockets so in order to make a rocket you have to make sure in grain and and you know get get all these ingredients and and you know it's actually pretty hard to create a solid rocket propellant and get it all right so it's some of them work but apart from like stuff as a kid that's the first time I've made anything physical was with SpaceX and so I kind

11:27of figure out all the elements of of what going to a rocket you know how do you make the engines in structure and the avionics and the guidance and control and all that so took a little time to figure that out and then we reached overt with the Falcon 1 basically but you know five and a half booyaka sort of in six years after starting the company so it took took awhile but since then our momentum has increased quite a bit and then last year we got what Falcon I into orbit and and

12:02then to drag into orbit and brought it back safely and then hopefully if all goes well this year we'll be docking with the space station in December so we're focused on that that's that's our current to the top priority and and then okay our other big priority of course is making sure that we can satisfy the Air Force in our o4 for Space Launch and in

12:33fact after we get to space station that will be our top priority it's really really convincing that Air Force and NRO that we're a good vehicle and all of these things are important their revenue streams because they they're they're needed to fund future developments and you know we've got mostly Falcon 9

12:57Falcon Heavy we've got the Merlin engine which is about to go through it's the fourth iteration with the merlin 1d and it's it's the the highest efficiency hydrocarbon a u.s. hydrocarbon engine ever DC flight and then we will probably be able to be able to announce maybe late this year or early next year a new engine development that we're going to do which is we're going to be very exciting and that that'll be a super

13:28high efficiency stage combustion engine and we want to make sure we have a lot ducks in a row before announced announced that development I think that's gonna be very exciting and also it's something like that's very important for if you want to take significant amounts of cargo and people to to Mars so I think ultimately that

13:51the the thing that is super important in the grand scale of history is all we on a path to becoming a multi-planet species or not and if we're not well that's that's not a very bright future you know it will simply be hanging out on earth until some eventual climate II claims us so so that that that's really

14:16the important thing and that that's kind of you know how I'm judging SpaceX like all we are we're helping move things in that direction and in order to have a self-sustaining civilization on Mars you have to be able to transport hundreds of probably hundreds of thousands maybe millions of people and and millions of tons of cargo so so clearly very

14:42significant breakthroughs are needed and I think the most fundamental breakthrough is a rapidly and fully reusable rocket and those are important qualifiers it doesn't help if it's partially reusable and it doesn't help if it's not rapidly reusable because if you think of any other mode of transport like or the idea any mode of transport from bicycles cars planes boats they're all rapidly and completely reusable I mean apart from occasional maintenance items so and that's why they function

15:21well you know if you had a car if you had a car where you had to say you know replace the tires on every trip or could you could only use it once a week that wouldn't be a very good car or plane or anything so it's got to be fully and rapidly reusable just like weird wiener when the Wright brothers invented and created airplane actually didn't invent something that flew they an event could they demand a controlled powered flight that that was really this doesn't really what made an airplane very useful and so

15:57that that's that's something that either SpaceX or some some organization has to invent I think that's a critical elements in revolutionising space and if you look at say the so the Falcon line the cost of propellant on Falcon 9 is about 0.3% of the cost of a mission so you know the

16:21that means if we could fully reuse the vehicle I mean it's at least at order of magnitude increase in the cost efficiency of the of the flight you know or thought of another way you know it's one thing to ask for say 0.3% of of the GDP to establish life on another planet it is another thing to ask for a hundred percent of the GDP that it was simply not occur people need food and think you know basic stuff like that so that that's something that I think is also an important long-term thing that has to occur and in that regard I'm I'm a fan

17:03of vertical takeoff or landing because obviously you're gonna go to two other places in the solar system you know there's no dere on the moon and there's no runways so the wings are not a great idea and yeah so those are sort of the things that we hope we hope to do in the future and we're hiring a lot of people

17:28last year we grew by 50% in personnel we're continuing to grow rapidly this year so we're now about 1,500 people and yet and significant operations in Florida Texas and California Angele in the DC Virginia area so Roy's looking for great talent so if anyone's interested in joining SpaceX please send us your resume and they say I think I

18:00think with that I'd be happy to open the floor to any questions you have sure

18:17aye sir question is do we have an architecture planned out for Moyes trips aye we do I wouldn't say it is fleshed out to a detailed level but we know what the ingredients are you know which is a vehicle that's capable of delivering substantial mass to the surface of Mars and and then returning to Earth as well

18:49and but I think we'll take those some steps certainly something like Falcon Heavy could deliver you know decent Paylor to the surface of Mars can it's sort of on the order of 12 to 15 metric tons so that that's not bad I think you probably want to be a co I can deliver something an order of 50 metric tons you know and be able to do that in a fully reusable manner then the whole equation

19:18works and there's more than one way to skin that cat but yeah you know that that's that's what I think I have a question reusable about I've seen a lot of studies of these vehicles and the key to making it work seems to be to get on the order of two or three hundred missions a year to keep the cost down what do you see as the commercial drive yeah I mean it's

19:58always a tough question to answer and I suspect in the early days of airplanes people didn't imagine that there would be this many airplane trips but I think the biggest driver for that is is really a base on Mars or you know potentially based on the moon matter I don't think there's really need for that many satellites for example and I also don't

20:23think it's that this a rational basis for like you know think things like mining helium-3 on the moon and really I have a hard time imagining mining anything anywhere and bring it to earth because earth has got a lot of stuff but this quest has got almost every I mean earth is big so but I do think there is

20:46a market for people who want to move to the moon or move to Mars and and and that that I think is is is interesting and could support a huge number of flights that thousands of flights a year

21:14I sure question just about our Dragon spacecraft and what we're gonna do with respect to carrying transporting astronauts in work or not so the we actually designed the Falcon 9 and dragon to meet the published NASA human rating design guidelines so you know things like so designing 21.4 factor of safety instead of a 1.25 having multi being multi failure tolerant tolerance the dragon dragon for example can lose any two engines at any at any time and still be safe with respect to the space station the slope translate and rotate as needed and we

22:01actually have sort of a secondary heat shield behind the primary heat shield the the avionics all to fail eternal life so stuff it's got windows so the question is well what doesn't it have really the main thing is just the escape system so that so in terms of upgrading it we need to add a launch escape and in this we're taking a sort of a different path than has been done before which is to tap the onboard propellant which is an TRMM age as escape propellant and because you either

22:38need to maneuver on orbit all you need you to escape you don't need to do both and if this makes for a very efficient mass efficient design it also means that you can carry high velocity escape capability all the way to orbit as opposed to having to dump the launch Tower kind of early on and and then a

23:03sort of optional bonus is we can use those same engines to land repulsively now we're still going to retain redundant parachutes on dragons so you still have redundant you know parachutes so effectively you would have almost four levels of redundancy because the the landing engines are themselves redundant and then you've got redundant main parachutes so like four things would have to fail before actually it only on the yeah the yeah what four things are oh it had to fail before loss of life but then the neat thing about that is you could use it to propulsively land in other places like Mars or moon or somewhere so I think it's it's got potential as a generalized science

23:49delivery platform of for other you know missions in the solar system so questions where do I see electric propulsion I think that's actually let's if for sure a good idea for interplanetary travel particularly since you know you're gonna need a lot of energy once you're on the surface of Mars so you may as well use that energy while you're in transit to to speed up the journey and yeah so I think electric

24:26propulsion definitely is a good idea and it would be kind of a waste not not to do electric repulsion on the way there the you know the the trick is you want you want to obviously have electro propulsion with enough for us to matter you know that that's that's pretty important so yeah I think that's that's

24:49and it needs to be fairly efficient in terms of the energy but you know per Newton like yes what what's of energy to Newton's of force

25:20so I mean the capsule is that does have an LED you know that it has a depending upon where we put the the the lateral center of mass we can adjust the LED to as high as 0.3 so that that gives us a pretty good accuracy effect dragon landed to within about a mile of its target on the flight in December and

25:51yeah but there's there's not an obvious reason I think to have more elevate even that yeah nothing that I can think of and then you know the poem with with having more complex lifting bodies is that then it gets kind of weird if you're gonna if you wanna go to Mars you know and you see if you Mars has a much lower and atmospheric density particularly in the lower atmosphere so you know something that worked well on earth would necessarily work well on Mars it obviously would be completely useless on the moon so I think you know something with a you know point 2 to point 3 LOD is as I think good enough and it's very robust as well you don't have to worry about maintaining a

26:43specific angle of attack or something going wrong with your control systems or anything because even if the dragon control systems totally malfunctioned and we're just dead you'd still you still survive because it's going to naturally orange what the main heat shield down Yorgi you'll experience higher G's you know you like to see eight or nine G's instead of four to five but that's the only downside and you can literally you can manually pull the shoots so so it's very very robust in that sense

27:23sure yeah so the four falcon heavy to to the cross speed between the the outer course to the center is pretty helpful you know it gives roughly twenty to thirty percent more payload and we have an advantage here in that because there are nine engines we can control flow to those engines engines individually so the way we do cross speed is is to

28:03basically draw propellant for the engines that are adjacent to the core from from the you know the engines that so the center core engine is pulling from from its side core on either side and then and then we can shut pre valves to those engines so that's not sucking it down from the side course you can do

28:29this you've got one engine or if you know that you can do it if you have if you have multiple you know nine engines it's a lot easier but the the the cross p it is is is it's really an option for a really big payloads so for customers that don't need the cross p agree what we would not enable cross speed yeah

28:53it's just it's just it's helpful for missions to out of that either big missions to Mars or missions to the outer solar system yes we're talking with ten ass about some potential missions that they go out you know to 150 or 200 a you so your way out past past Pluto and stuff

29:33well his question was just generally has it gone with reusability well so far I decide really I mean is extremely difficult and there's a reason that nobody has invented a fully reusable rocket before it's super damn hard but we have learned a lot and we did recover dragon so if you sort of think of dragon as a third stage we have recovered dragon and we recovered in a condition that you could easily reef lie it with with changing nothing you know repack the chutes and you can fly it again but

30:13but but the thing is we can't afford to give dragon level of protection to the booster well the booster would get no payload orbit so the real tricky thing here is essentially you know constructing a suit of armor that is just exactly tailored to the forces it's gonna need to resist on reentry and then

30:33so and those forces are higher than we anticipated it's even for the first stage because of the trajectory of the first stage it comes in at a pretty steep angle so the force is is is very high it's basically barely flopping on the atmosphere and so something has to be done to to shared velocity so we're looking at you know

31:02potentially restarting the engines to do to shed some velocity and and give it a more benign reentry weighed against increased structural you know margins and and increased and a better thermal shield it's it's a tough trade on propellant versus dry mass and I think we've got something that on paper closes and what we'll see affect that turns out to be reality as well

31:45you spoke about the need for hundreds of thousands of lunches per year to the village anomic to serve this and the moonbase of Mars base but you justify that and what I'm wondering for a Mars mission you don't want that surged in two weeks every twenty six months or the economics breakdown you talked a little bit about electric propulsion for non minimum energy transfers but how do you see this architecture working so that it can support Mars base with the missions spread over right that

32:24certainly is one of the biggest challenges with establishing a self-sustaining civilization on Mars is that planetary alignment so clearly we need to widen that window I think maybe if we can get it to you know maybe six months and obviously you're going to put more payload to Mars if you're at the center of the six months then if you're you know three months on either side and that's so that's something where electric propulsion could be pretty helpful another thing you can do is you can actually launch ahead of time into high Apogee orbits so that there's a whole series of craft kind of in you know high Apogee parking orbits waiting for the alignment to occur and then and

33:10then you kick it over to you you know you get that final kick once so Mars is close enough but certainly it is a tricky thing and it's it's it's it's hard to imagine how its opening that window more than about six months and even that is pretty tricky from a delta-v standpoint would you

33:43nuclear propulsion well you know the tricky thing with nuclear propulsion is getting that reactor up there with a ton of uranium that the many people I think it's gonna be hard to convince the public that we should launch large reactors into space because of the potential for a failure spreading uranium on earth you know it's one thing to do sort of a small RTG but another thing to have a big reactor I think at some point you could probably construct a reactor or maybe on the moon or mars and and and you know and then then have

34:24that power but but also I think when people sort of think about nuclear reactors they they kind of forget how how heavy they are and also the fact that you know they usually have a source of water close by to drive a steam turbine so it's you know when you factor all the like a really useful reactor in space and and see how much it weighs and compare that to say solar panels solar panels are pretty good that's it's a different story for for for Mars itself that think Mars on the surface in lies you reactor would be great because generating all that waste heat would be if you want waste heat on Mars that's great stuff also on any anything that's

35:11gonna anything is going to cost level warming on Mars that can be shipped

35:44I so the question is what do I think about kind of grabbing the oxidizer on the way through the atmosphere so like if you have a hydrogen oxygen system and then and then and having it to grab the oxygen on the way you know when I've looked at the numbers it always seems as though the the drag was was so significant that it outweighed the benefit of of grabbing oxygen it might be a different thing if I mean if air wasn't a sort of 80% nitrogen but when

36:18you're when you're grabbing stuff you're actually grabbing 80% stuff you can't use in 20% stuff you can and and then of course but you're sort of stuck in the situation that you can only get a lot of air when there's a lot of drag and so if you can't really do the high acceleration and you go past a certain velocity and the heating rate is is too extreme so you just Mel Borden you'll just melt yourself so I think I think carrying oxidizer is is probably even though it seems like Wow gotta lotta oxidizer on this rocket is probably the way to go I mean certainly somebody could prove me wrong but it's so far I've not seen anything even on paper that would work

37:00so if it doesn't work at least on paper then well reality is usually worse than paper in fact you get a hundred percent

37:24increase in ISP with best chemical rockets that we have today you wind up saving hundreds hundreds of metrics of metric tonnes of propellant on these you know six months round you have transits back and forth so you know when you think about even you have to think not just of an engine the engine is only one piece of the overall stage and the system so it's one thing I didn't want the audience to kind of think that nuclear rockets are somehow just too heavy and if they have radioactivity in them when you launch them they're relatively clean and there is more radioactivity in the three RTGS that were on Cassini on Cassini's three RPGs then there are in 325 thousand

38:04pounds for us nuclear rocket engines to send humans to Mars okay that seems surprising but okay well in might if it's really such as such a small amount of radioactive material then then maybe that that could work for an upper stage of a rocket I you know it's just I think it's it's a it's a tough thing to do for

38:34from I I I'm scared of doing that with with the public basically if people may be braver than I am but I I think if I were to raise the idea of of marching thousands of you know nuclear-powered rockets there would be people trying to lynch me we're not watching I mean when you launch them they're natural uranium

39:01there's no radioactive fission products because the engine hasn't been turned on yet so it's only once they're up in space in a stable orbit that you can unlock the interlock control drums and and start bringing the power okay but what if it what if it crashes the but what if there's a launch failure well there could be a monitor with the stages located way up on the top it's not in a cargo bay like on the show they're worried about explosions or collapses sometimes in itself and again like I said even if it were dispersed and break open the decor the the fuel is the little virtual little radioactivity in an office it's never been operated okay

39:40that that sounds like it could be a better option than I thought okay all right yeah I'm certainly open to to if new different ideas and that that's certainly different than I thought it was

40:15yeah no it's actually surprising I mean this is obviously this nuclear powered craft right here insane you know San Diego so and nobody seems to get too alarmed about that new cloud submarines and stuff so yeah I mean perhaps perhaps that the public concern is is less than I think it is people people do seem to get alarmed about establishing a nuclear reactor for two reason you know on the ground and in the past they've been upset about nuclear launches but maybe there's if a clear case can be made that it's safe then maybe it's a good way to go you know I love the idea of fusion I

41:04think fusion is is is awesome and I mean if somebody were to do that that would be very cool yeah I mean we need to make fusion work on the ground you know in an energy positive way first but which in and of itself would be a huge boon for Humanity and yeah so yeah be tremendous

41:31if somebody sorted that out well our main goal is to to establish a means of getting to and from Mars and and then I think if if that if there's that ability then that will open up opportunities for you know many organizations and many many many facets so it's it's kind of like you know you can get if you can get the Union Pacific Railroad across the country then think of all the businesses that prosper in California but but in the absence of a means of getting there then there's no opportunity for businesses to for organizations to flourish on the other side so so that's our focus is really just a camera can we establish that transit transportation link and and then

42:50keep iterating and innovating to make it better and better that's that's our sole focus really well I think it's

43:09definitely gonna be a joint effort and you know even as it is in terms of the progress that SpaceX has made thus far I mean we would not be where we are today without NASA I mean NASA has been a key part of our success and and will continue to be and obviously we're hopeful that the Air Force and in a row will you know become a partner as well so it is very much a joint joint effort

43:39and hopefully other companies - I mean it's if it's not as though I think it should just be SpaceX I think they need to be you know multiple entities that are that are doing that transport

44:04so the question was what what cost per pound per gram do we need to get below in order to make Mars viable I mean is it so I think in order to make a self-sustaining civilization possible on Mars we have to get the cost per pound well and well under $100 per cost per pound to orbit well under $100 probably closer to $50 now the thing is that

44:37Falcon Heavy the cost per pound to orbit on an expendable basis is about $1000 so if we can make Belkin heavy reusable depending upon how much payload we lose in the process of making it reusable that that could make that could get to that number so we'd have to basically improve it by about a tenth the back factor of 10 maybe 12 20 to get down to the $50 point and when you consider that the cost of the propellant is you know about 0.3 percent of the cost of the rocket or one three hundredth then it's you know as long as it should be it should be possible to do that even with with a falcon heavy but but this will

45:30take this will take a lot a long time to get it's a little long time by in fine definition meaning like several years are you considering architectures where you have interplanetary vehicle once always stays between Earth and Mars and then on each end you have decent asset vehicles which are like taxis or rental cars to the

46:04major yeah I think I think long-term there probably is some architecture where there are a smaller craft that take you to earth orbit get back people from Earth orbit and Mars orbit and then there's some sort of much larger strip that's been circulating or ships that are circulating between Earth and Mars I think that's by longer - I mean like that so that's you know in several

46:30decades from now I think that's probably the right thing but in the interim I think it's probably gonna be a more like it's one one ship that takes you to Mars and back I think that's kind of a short-term medium-term solution and another nice thing is that as soon as you have a base on Mars you've got a forcing function for improving the the transportation technology just like when before the the United States colonies were established there was no forcing function for improving trips across the Atlantic but but when they were then suddenly there was a need to have those trip ships be better and better every year you know and so ship technology improved

47:12dramatically because of that forcing function I think the same will occur if there is a base on Mars

47:32be a hell of an X PRIZE I think it's by think it's some combination of government and private and yeah it's hard to say exactly what percentage but I think it's a pretty sure bet that it'll be a combination of government and private enterprise unlikely to be an X Prize but there may be elements of it that are XPrize ish so once you begin

47:58sending people up to the space station do you have well I mean NASA would be

48:23our customer as far as transporting people to the space station is concerned so it really every decision of NASA as to who goes on and I mean I think it's gonna be nasty NASA astronauts that that goat that fly on on those trips will be whoever our customer decides it's sort of you know it's just like my like but buying a flight of an airplane or something it's up to the customer to decide I think we will also have a private astronauts that want to fly either to a private space station or maybe on trips around the earth or conceivably a loop around the moon

49:06all right thank thank you very much let me let me thank you on for a very stimulating presentation and question and answer and of course the thank you for your time and also your service in support of this conference we have the coveted edible a coin

49:34and that concludes his keynote thank you all very much

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份