访谈·中文精读

马斯克谈 Falcon Heavy 2011

Elon Musk talks Falcon Heavy 2011

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2011年4月5日,华盛顿下着雨。马斯克坐在Stimson Center的讲台上,主持人刚介绍完他一小时前做的发布。

他宣布的东西叫Falcon Heavy(猎鹰重型)。当时它只存在于图纸上,首飞时间定在2013年。

台下的听众是政策圈的人。他们平时讨论预算、法案、部门权限、拨款周期。马斯克给他们讲的是四十亿年的进化史。

他说,看历史有个技巧,镜头拉得越远,留下来的东西越少。真正的大事件是这些:单细胞生命出现、多细胞生命出现、动植物分化、生命从海洋爬上陆地、哺乳动物、意识。让生命成为多行星物种,在他的排序里至少和“从海洋到陆地”同一个级别。

然后他给这个级别配了一笔预算:应该比医疗支出少,比口红支出多。

一笔比口红多、比医疗少的钱

原话是这样的:

“也许我们可以很容易地划出边界:它应该远远少于我们在医疗上的花费,但多于我们在口红上的花费。我喜欢口红,它有非常重要的好处。也许是GDP的0.2%到0.3%,差不多就该是这个数。”(马斯克)

现场笑了。但这个句子的结构其实相当严谨。前半段用进化尺度给“多行星”定位,后半段用口红和医疗给这个位置定价。两个参照物都是日常词汇,听众立刻能算出量级。

0.2%到0.3%的GDP,美国2011年GDP约15万亿美元,折算下来是300亿到450亿美元。当年NASA的预算约185亿美元。也就是说,他张口要的钱比NASA现有预算还多出一倍多,可他选的参照系让这个数字听起来微不足道。这是很典型的马斯克式表达:把一个巨大的数字装进一个让人无法反驳的刻度里。

他紧接着讲了窗口期。

地球四十亿年历史里,让生命扩展到地球之外这件事,第一次在技术上可行。勉强可行。要在火星上建立一个能自我维持的文明,极其困难,但办得到。

这个窗口能开多久,他不知道。可能很久,也可能不长。他的结论只有一句:别赌它会一直开着,能干的时候干。

整场访谈里,这是最不像商人的一段话。它不讲市场份额,不讲增长曲线,讲的是物种级别的机会成本。

为什么选火星,不选月球

现场有人问了这个经典问题。马斯克的回答里没有一句浪漫话,全是工程参数。

月球太小,不是行星。自然资源弱,重力低,人类更难适应。昼夜周期28天,意味着真正宜居的区域只剩两极附近,而那里水冰非常稀少。

“我会把月球看成一个类似北极的地方。北极离欧洲很近,但它很糟糕,所以没人去那儿定居,大家去的是西伯利亚。”(马斯克)

火星不一样。它是一颗真正的行星,具备承载行星级文明的条件。

还有一层考虑:如果地球出了大事,火星足够远,大概率不受影响。月球离得太近,可能一起遭殃。这个论点是风险分散,跟保险精算的逻辑一样,只不过标的物是整个物种。

这段话在2011年听起来像科幻。马斯克当时没说出口的是,他已经在盘算怎么把人送过去,以及怎么让那趟旅程便宜到有人买得起。

政府该干的活,和它干不了的活

主持人问他,一个年轻人如果也想搞航天,是不是该去NASA或者空军。

马斯克的回答把政府和市场的边界画得很清楚:政府负责那些“收益分散给所有人、但没有直接经济回报”的事。

他举了哈勃望远镜。它大幅提升了人类对宇宙的理解,可这些知识落不到任何一家公司的财报上。没有企业会为这种收益买单。所以由纳税人出钱是合理的。

“顺便说一句,政府没有钱,它只是把钱从人民那里拿走。有时候人们会忘记这一点。”(马斯克)

这句话在华盛顿说出来,效果不会太好,他还是说了。逻辑是:钱来自全体人民,收益也归全体人民,收支两端对齐,这笔账才算正当。

接着他讲另一半:政府天生低效,所以要尽量少让它干。

证据是两个德国。同样的民族,两套制度,西德的人均产出至少是东德的五倍。而且西德当时并不算特别资本主义,比美国社会主义得多。南北韩的例子更极端,一边在挨饿,一边极度繁荣。

这段论述里有个细节值得留意。他没有论证市场一定比政府聪明。他强调的是,效率差异来自制度,不来自人。同一批人换个制度,产出差五倍。这是他对“把资源分配旋钮拧到哪儿”这个问题的全部答案。

美国是怎么把商业发射市场弄丢的

主持人问,美国的航天工业基础是不是在萎缩。

马斯克的回答很直接:领先地位在20年前就丢了。

八十年代,美国做了全世界几乎所有的商业发射。然后苏联解体,俄罗斯人变得比美国人还资本主义。接着欧洲、中国、印度一起挤进来,几乎吃光了整个商业发射市场。

有个数字对比很扎眼:每年发射的商业卫星数量,是美国政府卫星的两到三倍。而美国在这块市场里的份额,一度小到可以忽略。

转折发生在2010年。美国赢得的商业发射合同数量超过了任何其他国家,全部来自SpaceX。

但他提醒台下别高兴太早。从签下合同到真正发射,中间有2到4年的滞后。合同上的领先,要过几年才会变成发射台上的领先。

他把这件事归因于一个东西:美国自由企业的竞争力。SpaceX的运作方式更接近硅谷,而不是传统政府承包商。

“在硅谷,你不快速创新就会死。”(马斯克)

然后他补了一串名字:Google、Facebook、Intel、Cisco、Apple。这些公司的国际竞争对手,你几乎叫不出名字。而在华盛顿的语言里,情况正好相反,那里习惯的是“我们正在被追赶”。

猎鹰重型:2013年才飞,为什么现在就宣布

参数先摆出来。

  • 入轨载荷能力超过航天飞机的两倍
  • 推力是俄罗斯质子号和波音洛克希德Delta IV Heavy的两倍
  • 仅次于土星五号,人类历史上第二强的火箭
  • 2012年到Vandenberg空军基地的发射台,2013年首飞

有个细节挺有意思。主持人问,能不能一次发两颗最大的卫星上去。马斯克说:

“当然,完全没问题。”(马斯克)

现场已经签下的合同是下一代铱星(Iridium)星座,一个航班带8到9颗卫星。

他给猎鹰重型列的用途清单更长:最大的政府和商业卫星、外行星探测器、火星采样返回。这些东西当时世界上没有任何一款火箭能干。上一次具备这种量级的能力,要追溯到1970年代中期的土星五号。

他在2011年宣布的,是美国已经将近四十年没有过的能力。宣布它的当天,它还没造出来。

这也能解释他为什么要提前两年公布。运载火箭这门生意里,客户要提前两三年做决定,卫星的设计、预算、发射窗口全都要跟着火箭走。你不先把能力摆到桌面上,合同不会来找你。

俄罗斯人没什么可偷的

主持人有出口管制的背景,问了一个很具体的问题:把卫星装到火箭上,工程师需要知道多少卫星的细节?这些信息敏感吗?

马斯克的回答务实:只需要知道怎么把卫星集成上去,不需要知道里面是什么。这不会泄露什么专有技术。

但他补了一句:某些国家有侵占知识产权的记录,所以别让它们离美国先进航天技术太近。人员国籍、区域访问权限、监控,这套制度是必要的。

然后是全场最好笑的一段。有人担心卫星送到国外发射会被偷技术,马斯克摆了摆手:不用太担心俄罗斯。

“直到SpaceX出现之前,他们的火箭技术一直比我们好。我不太确定他们有什么可偷的。”(马斯克)

他还举了个例子。波音和洛克希德的Atlas 5火箭,主发动机是俄罗斯造的RD-180。美国人到现在也没搞定怎么自己造这款发动机。

接着他把话拉回自己:猎鹰系列是很长时间以来第一款比俄罗斯更好的美国火箭。所以对俄罗斯保持谨慎是应该的,虽然被偷的风险不大。

这段话的潜台词挺有意思。技术保护的焦虑,很多时候来自技术落后的位置。真领先的时候,你担心的是别人学得快,不是别人偷得走。

一千三百人,只招行业前3%

2011年,SpaceX不到1300人。

为什么把公司放在南加州?因为那是全世界航天工程师密度最高的地方。航天飞机退役、项目裁撤、公司重组,大量工程师在那里流动。

招聘标准是行业前2%到3%。

主持人开了个玩笑,说普通航天是常规军,SpaceX像特种部队。马斯克接了句“我明白”。这个比喻大概没错。

关于风险,主持人问得很直接:火箭公司是不是高风险生意?会不会故意炸火箭来测试?

马斯克说,从来没有故意炸过。目标是成功。

成绩单是:最近四次任务连续成功。最近一次特别复杂,猎鹰9号加Dragon飞船,绕地球两圈,溅落加州海岸外。这是私人公司第一次从轨道上把东西带回来。全世界能做到的国家,当时只有五六个。

他把这件事说得很平,但你把这个成绩放到当时的时间线上看:航天飞机那年就要退役,美国有几年时间将失去把人送上太空的能力。一家成立九年的私人公司,刚刚完成了轨道返回。

卫星得学会躲导弹

主持人把话题转到军事太空。五角大楼的说法是:太空是一个有安全利益的领域,经济、军事行动都绑在太空上,所以太空要防御。

马斯克说,发射空军和国家侦察局(NRO)的卫星,会是SpaceX未来业务的重要部分。当时还没拿到合同,他很乐观。原因很实在:空军是个非常保守的组织,而SpaceX已经有过两次猎鹰9号成功,又拿出了猎鹰重型。猎鹰重型的推力大约是空军现有一切手段的两倍,能一次带更多卫星,或者一次带好几颗。

然后他自己把话题推到了反卫星。

他的判断是:地面发射的反卫星导弹,造起来比卫星快得多。所以“被打掉就快速补发”这套思路行不通,补发的速度追不上打掉的速度。真正管用的是让卫星自己能躲导弹。

还有激光。激光可以在很短的通知时间内开机照射。

解法和再入大气层是同一个:给卫星配强力热盾。Dragon飞船本来就有,为了再入时抵抗高温不被烧掉。他向国防部建议过,这套技术可以用来防定向能武器。

与其指望对方不打,不如让自己扛得住。这个思路听上去有点土,其实是航天工程的常态:所有安全设计最后都落到材料和结构上。

动能拦截弹相对容易做,激光难一些。马斯克判断其他国家当时可能还没有成熟的定向能武器,但迟早会有。

有人顺着这个话题问,能不能把Dragon的技术用到卫星制造上。他提到了Dragon Lab项目:把执行空间站货运任务的Dragon改装,用于商业和其他政府应用。

他的说法是,Dragon本质上是一颗很复杂的卫星,比大多数卫星都复杂。多套冗余系统,能对接,能再入,还能复用。2010年12月回收的那一艘,热盾能扛住多次再入,理论上可以飞很多次。这是通往可复用的第一步。

电动车的理由,和环保关系不大

访谈进行了快一半,话题转到能源。

马斯克把大学时代那三件事又讲了一遍:互联网、可持续能源、太空。Tesla负责的是能源消费这一块。

他给的论证绕开了环保:

“即使使用化石燃料没有任何负面环境影响,即使没有任何国家安全后果,假设我们拥有所有的石油,它仍然是有限的。我们仍然必须找到解决办法,否则当资源变得稀缺时,我们将面临经济崩溃。”(马斯克)

这个逻辑链条很短:有限的东西早晚会用完,用完之前必须换掉,否则经济会崩。环保和地缘政治都是附加理由,不是根本理由。

这个说法的妙处在于,它不需要对方先认同你的价值观。你跟一个不在乎气候变化的人讲石油有限,他还是会点头。

那为什么是电动车?因为电可以从很多种能源里来。煤、天然气、核、水、风、光都行。汽油只能从石油来。

“电力有点像现金。你可以用多种方式产生它,也可以用多种方式花掉它。”(马斯克)

接下来是一组数据,讲Roadster。

  • 加速快过几乎所有跑车
  • 每英里能耗比Prius还低
  • 电池包的能量相当于两加仑汽油
  • 即使电来自燃煤电厂,算上输电损耗,每英里碳排放仍低于Prius

最后一条最反直觉。原因在于集中式发电厂的效率远高于汽车内燃机,规模把损失摊薄了。燃煤发电听起来很脏,可把煤变成电、再把电送进电池,整条链条的效率仍然好过在发动机里烧汽油。

然后他讲了Tesla真正的产品定位。Roadster起的作用,是一次认知手术。

在此之前,公众对电动车的印象是高尔夫球车:丑、慢、续航短。要做的是造一辆好看、快、操控好、续航够的车,把这个印象砸碎。

效果比预想的好。通用汽车的Bob Lutz看到Roadster的新闻稿,拿着它走进开发团队,说:一家加州小公司能做,我们也能。这件事推动了GM Volt,接着是Nissan Leaf,然后是戴姆勒的电动化项目。当时通用是全球最大的车企,最大的那家宣布做电动车,其他家会跟。

他把Tesla的路线拆成三步:

  1. 高价、低产量(Roadster)
  2. 中价、中产量(Model S)
  3. 低价、高产量(第三代车型)

每一代的产量提升一个数量级。他说,一家小公司能以这个速度增长,已经相当惊人。

主持人提到,有华尔街大银行预测Tesla会成为美国第四大车企,排在通用、福特、克莱斯勒之后。这个预测在2011年听起来相当大胆,现场还有人专门提了一句。

电池的数据能说明进步速度。Roadster的电池包56千瓦时,Model S是90千瓦时,体积差不多,每千瓦时成本大幅下降。Model S是5系宝马尺寸的轿车,续航300英里;Roadster是245英里。车大50%,重一些,续航多20%以上,价格低得多。

日本地震对电池供应有影响吗?有,大约一周的供应中断。库存够,生产没受影响。这个回答很短,但它其实是供应链管理的一条基本功:缓冲库存的价值,只在出事那天才显出来。

五月花号如果不返航

问答环节里,有人问SpaceX下一步的创新方向。马斯克的回答只有一个词:可复用。

他给了一组成本数据。猎鹰9号一次加注的推进剂大约15万到20万美元。整枚火箭5000万美元。推进剂成本占一次发射的0.3%。

剩下99.7%的钱,都花在了那枚用一次就扔的金属筒上。

他用了飞机做类比。一架波音747要2.5亿美元,飞一趟需要两架,那机票该卖多少钱?现实中的机票便宜,因为同一架飞机能飞几千次。

然后他讲了五月花号。

“如果当年那些船不能重复使用,美国就不会存在。没有人付得起那趟旅程。”(马斯克)

他的推演是:如果船是一次性的,想去新大陆就得一次造两艘,一艘去,一艘回。地图上标着“那边有块大陆”,可没人去得起。所以人类所有的交通工具,飞机、火车、汽车、自行车,都是可复用的。不可复用的运输方式,根本不会被采用。

关于火星的成本,他给了两个数:建立自给自足的火星文明,大约需要GDP的0.3%。但没有人愿意为这件事花100%的GDP。

可复用与不可复用的差别,就是这个差别。2011年他说这话的时候,全世界没有一家公司成功回收过轨道级火箭。SpaceX自己第一次做到,还要再等四年。

公司变大之后

有人问,SpaceX和Tesla越来越大,会不会像大公司一样失去创新能力。

马斯克说这叫“高级问题”,类比高胆固醇。他觉得当时创新速度还在加快,做的项目更多,节奏更快。

但他承认一件事:人均生产力会随规模下降。原因是沟通成本。公司早期靠专业化分工提升人均产出,规模超过某个点之后,沟通问题开始吃掉这些收益。

SpaceX的对策是压缩沟通层级:任何人可以直接找任何人,不走指挥链。他的原话是,指挥链沟通“极其低效”。

这套做法在很多公司被写进文化手册,但真正落实的很少。它的前提是信息足够透明,每个人都大致知道别人在干什么。做不到这一点,扁平化就变成了混乱。

上市和去火星的矛盾

记者问,听说SpaceX打算2012年底上市,但你想保留控股权,为什么?

马斯克的回答把话说得很白。他要SpaceX继续做的事,是开发让火星文明自给自足所需的技术。这件事可能带来经济回报,但需要长期思考。

长期思考和华尔街的季度周期会打架。

“有些人、有些华尔街的人会认为这很疯狂。他们大概认为正确的做法是,从政府和各家商业客户身上尽可能榨取最高的价格。我们不会这么干。”(马斯克)

保留控股权,是为了能对股东说“不”。

这段话放到今天回头看,格外有意思。他后来确实没有让SpaceX上市,一直拖到现在。

在华盛顿说的几句实话

最后一个问题来自主持人,问得很现实:华盛顿现在气氛很糟,赤字、持续决议、一周接一周的临时拨款,所有人都在讨论债务轨迹。你常年按另一种时间尺度做事,你会对国会和行政部门说什么?

马斯克先给了个提醒:

“首先,人们应该有点大局观。事情其实好得不得了。美国过得相当不错,我们在这里的生活真的很好,不该忘记这一点。”(马斯克)

他列了几条:美国仍是世界最大制造国,从英国手里接过这个位置已经一百多年。失业率在下降。

然后他转了。政府支出必须减下来,而且不能只在边缘小打小闹。万亿美元级别的赤字显然不可持续。

他讲了个心理学实验。桌上一块纸杯蛋糕,现在吃,只有这一块;等十分钟,能拿三块。有些孩子忍不住,当场就吃了。这种延迟满足的能力,后来被证明能预测一个人的长期成就。

“这就像幼儿面对纸杯蛋糕。国会的行为方式常常就是这样。”(马斯克)

他还说了一句不太好听的:这件事上,美国民众也有责任,因为会投票把做这种事的人选下去。

方案上他不含糊。减支和增税都得做,只做一边解决不了问题。他举了英国,当时正在削减25%的支出,他认为方向是对的。

最后一句是警告:拖得越久越难。利息负担会越来越大,把未来的紧缩空间一点点吃掉。

一个造火箭的人在华盛顿讲财政纪律,这两件事看起来不搭。但如果你把整场访谈听完,会发现它们共用同一套推理:先算清楚成本结构,再判断哪些开支通向未来、哪些只是今天吃掉明天的蛋糕。

这场访谈留下的几条可操作的东西

2011年的很多判断后来被验证了,也有没兑现的。猎鹰重型2018年才首飞,比承诺晚了五年;Tesla成了美国市值最高的车企,但也远不是“第四大”。真正值得拿走的,是他做判断的方式。

  • 给“长期重要但回报分散”的事找一个价格锚点。马斯克的做法是挑两个日常参照物,把量级钉死。做技术选型、立项汇报时,这招比讲愿景管用得多,因为听众不需要先相信你的愿景就能算出数。
  • 判断一件事该由谁做,看收益分布。收益集中在少数人、有直接经济回路,交给市场;收益分散、没有回路,才轮到公共资金。这个标准能砍掉很多无效争论。
  • 评估一家公司的技术领先能维持多久,别听发布会,看它签的合同和交付之间的时间差。航天是2到4年,各行业有自己的滞后。合同领先不等于产品领先。
  • 分析一门硬件生意,先找出成本结构里最大的一块。猎鹰9号99.7%的成本在硬件,不在燃料,所以可复用是唯一有意义的方向。同样的推理能用在很多制造和物流场景上。
  • 公司变大后人均产出下降,通常来自沟通路径变长。压缩层级、允许任何人直接找任何人,比加KPI有效,前提是信息足够透明。
  • 如果你打算做一件需要十年的事,股权结构和治理机制要在第一天想清楚。季度财报和十年计划天然冲突,这个矛盾拖到融资那天再解决就晚了。
  • 说服别人时,优先用不依赖对方价值观的论据。马斯克讲电动车先讲石油有限,这个理由对任何人都成立。讲环保只能说服本来就在乎环保的人。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:30t minus 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 we have liftoff of the Falcon I'll stay you mystic thought the 9 has cleared the tower

1:51stage 2 em back engine chillin in first two m9 engine shutdown first age me go to prestige engine shutdown second stage has separated inertial velocity at miko was approximately em back ignition confirmed three point two columns per second nominal

4:52hi well good afternoon everybody welcome to the Chairman's form thanks for coming to Stimpson on a rainy day I'm link Bloomfield maybe somewhere in the outer galaxies there's intelligent life that knows how to come into our orbit and then safely land on the surface of the earth but in all of human history only one human being has ever done this without a government sort of leading the way and he's sitting next to me so welcome Elon Musk thank you it's an honor one of America's real pioneers and entrepreneurs here at Stimson we talk a lot about policy we talk about governments we come from some of us are old enough to come from a 20th century

5:38mentality the government seemed to set policy but in the 21st century we're realizing that non-governmental actors often are out in front changing things and as well here I'm going to give a little bit of your background before we start to talk about space you've actually changed things in the way we use the internet you're changing the game in space you're changing the way we we use energy and all of those are things that Washington people find themselves chasing the policy implications and so to have an innovator entrepreneur i think is fits right into the theme of Chairman's forum so again we're honored to have you thank you for taking the time with a place knowing me

6:16I know you made an important announcement an hour ago and I'm going to get to that but first let me just introduce our guest mr. Elon Musk was born and raised in South Africa came to Canada as a teenager and then came to the United States where he is a US citizen as a youth computer programmer at the age of 12 created and sold the software for a space game and made a little money off of it so and then just to quickly touch on the other innovations a company called zip to which created online content publishing software for news organizations you co-founded XCOM which became paypal secure ecommerce logic which of course is used everywhere now in 2002 founded

7:05Space Exploration Technologies known as SpaceX you're the not only a CEO but this chief technology officer which is so I think very interesting we'll talk about the line of Rockettes we knew about the Falcon one in the Falcon 9 we're going to hear a little bit more in a moment and then in 2004 founded tesla

7:23motors co founder chairman and CEO the electric vehicle company in California and is also chairman of SolarCity a photovoltaic products and services company started in 2006 so you see some themes here internet video games ecommerce energy efficiency technologies and space and so before we talk about the the announcement I'm curious what was it that captured your imagination as a young person about space well but what did space mean to you well when I was very young a space just seemed like it seemed really cool but but it was I didn't expect to be involved in space when I was young but when isn't in college I decided I wanted to be involved in things that but would have a

8:10significant impact in the future of humanity and the three things that I could come up with were the internet sustainable energy both production and consumption and space exploration but particularly the extension of life beyond Earth to to multiple planets and as it turns out I've been fortunate enough to to get involved in input in all three of those areas well that's quite interesting so there's a there's a geographic reach to your interest in space right now you're involved in sort of doing contract activities we can talk about that with with the space station and whatnot but but you you see a future vision do you think that the United States or even private sector entities

8:56will be accessing outer space at some point in the future and have far are we from from that vision yeah I think in order to well in order for Humanity to become a true spacefaring civilization and ultimately become a multi-planet species I think we have to harness the power of free enterprise because otherwise it will simply be unaffordable the you know that the it's important

9:29appreciate that there is a very fundamental cost barrier to life becoming multiplanetary and if I go if you don't mind me exploring that that issue a little bit because if you if you break it down and and first say well why is it important that life become multiplanetary if you if you look at the

9:57nature of importance itself and use the lens of history as a guide and and and generally the legend history the further you zoom out the more the the important milestones remain and the less important ones disappear things that may seem important in the moment you if you if you think about them are not going to be really important in the long term but it on the grandest scale on the evolution of life itself and you can look at the major milestones and say that there's the advent of single-celled life multicellular life differentiation two pints and animals life in from the oceans to land mammals consciousness

10:41those are kind of the big ones but I think also on that scale would fit life becoming multiplanetary it would be at least comparable to like going from the oceans to land and if the a something that fits that there's important up to arguably fit on the scale of evolution of life itself it's fair to say that it should be considered important and and and deserve some some

11:04small portion of our resources to accomplish and I'm not talking about a huge portion but you know perhaps we can bound bound it quite easily by saying it's should be much less than what we spent on health care but more than what we spend on lipstick and I'm you know I like lipstick I of six very important

11:29benefit you know maybe it's a sort of a point 20 point three percent of our gdp something something like that is warranted and I do think it's with that we should not delay just this this action because you know this is the first time in the four billion year history of Earth that has been possible at all for for like to extend beyond

11:55Earth and and and it's possible just barely for he for Humanity to create a self-sustaining civilization on Mars extraordinarily difficult but possible and and it is hard to say how long that window will be open that window could be open for a long time or could be open for a short time but but if I think that the wise thing to do is to not assume it will be open for a long time and to take action to to make life multiplanetary while we can well people who have had a similar aspiration and a vision an attachment to the vision of space and and the continuum of human and and planetary evolution have generally joined into sort of governmental efforts

12:41until this point because that's where the action was would you if someone were sitting in this audience a young person who's who shares a similar aspiration might my expectation is they might think well can I get a job at NASA or can I work for the Air Force you went to business your business man you've had MBA war in school actually don't have any I do a lot of graduate in physics and economic physics and economic I think you've in so many ways demonstrated the MBA capability and the question is you that wouldn't appear to have been in something you would naturally do do you do you think that private sector is on a par with the private with with the

13:28government in their capacity to to to it to aspire to these kind of accomplishments or where does the government and non-government come together which which one has the more why would you why would you invest in one more than the other well i think you know like it it's govern plays an important role in funding things that have a small about it benefit to a large portion of the population you know sort of basic science the frontiers of

13:58exploration that that kind of thing where there's not an obvious direct economic feedback loop but it's nonetheless an important thing to do that's helpful to everyone like the hubble for example you know that we gained a lot of knowledge and understanding the universe from from the Hubble it didn't necessarily translate to specific economics for one particular company so it made sense that that would be funded by by the government but under by the governess means funded by the people government by the way has has no money it only takes money from the people sometimes people forget that that

14:36that's really what occurs so so when there is a benefit that accrues to the people as a whole then then it's fair that the money should be drawn from the people as a whole to match that benefit but but but government is inherently inefficient and so it makes sense to to minimize the role of government and at such that government gum it does only what it has to do and no more I mean

15:06there's I mean you obviously very clear examples of this in comparing something like East and West Germany on Alta growth in South Korea or you know places where you have essentially the same people but but two different systems of government and in east and west germany for example the economic output per capita was was about five times higher in West Germany arguably more than five times but at least five times higher West Germany than east and that and it's not as

15:40though West Germany was particularly capitalist I mean there there's sort of a lot more socialist than we are and and yet they had that huge output difference or North and South Korea is an even more stark example where North Korea people want to grow starvation South Korea is incredibly prosperous and and and so you

16:02want to always watch that that dial that that allocation of resources dial and make sure that that that government doesn't doesn't become too large a portion of the economy well in the space sector if we look back on the last going back to the 60s if you will where NASA was in its heyday we put a man on the moon in 1969 a lot of studies in Washington have talked about how the space industrial base is shrinking in the United States how we've sort of losing our lead in space after certain events of the 90s involving US companies in China there was more restrictive export controls on satellites commercial satellites which remain I believe under

16:40review in the White House as they were under the previous administration but but restrictive and so there's a there's an international space industry do you have a view on whether the industrial base are we shrinking is America's lead shrinking in your view and where does where does your activity fit into that picture well it's something true that over the past few decades Americans lead has really well it went away like 20

17:11years ago and and returned last year thanks to SpaceX in the 80s or it the America I used to do almost all the commercial launches and then the full of Soviet Union and they actually sort of lawyers become more capitalist than we were and and then between Europe and Russia too little less agree China India

17:42they absorbed almost the entire commercial launch market there are a lot of commercial satellites launched every year more they're more commercial satellites launched every year than there are US government satellites by at least a factor of two or three and yet the United States has sure of that market has been sort of negligible 20

18:06but last year the United States one more launch contract commercial launch contracts than any other country duo is entirely to SpaceX another there's a lead time of anywhere from two to four years between when you win the contract when you do the launch so in about sort of two to four years we'll be doing more launches then we'll commercial launches than any of the country so but I think

18:32that's because its basics we're really the harnessing the power of American free enterprise which is the most competitive system in the world and applying kind of a mode of operation that is sort of closer to Silicon Valley I think then in typical government contractors so in economic terms who are the sort of bigger users looking forward a few years is it commercial use of space is it government and military use or scientific use where's the market looking forward in the near to mid-term well like I said that they're actually more commercial launches even today that then then there are US government launches so I and I expect that as we

19:16are able to lower the cost of access to space with which we're doing in it in a very significant way that there will be more commercial satellite business plans that work then then was previously the case will see some some market expansion occur so I would expect that the percentage of a SpaceX to activity that is commercial will increase over time government will still play a very important role of particular permissions likes it earlier that have a small amount of a benefit to a large number of people but where there isn't at direct economic feedback loop so governor slow play a very important role also in pushing the frontier of exploration but in terms of

19:56of market size I expect the commercial market to actually increase in on a percentage basis you've just come from an announcement we knew about the Falcon one rocket the Falcon 9 was just depicted in the film can you tell us what's coming next yes so that the big announcement I we just made today was for a falcon heavy launch vehicle which is it's going to be the most capable vehicle of any kind on earth it'll put

20:28more than twice the payload capability of the space shuttle into orbit and has twice the thrust of the biggest Russian rockets and the and the biggest US rocket so twice as big as the Russian proton oh and the Boeing Lockheed Delta for heavy so it's really quite an epic vehicle in fact it'll have more payload to orbit than any rockets apart from the Saturn five moon rocket and and what kind of a payload do you expect to be launched off of this vehicle I mean what are what are the potential uses it's a wide range of potential uses certainly Falcon Heavy can launch the the largest government commercial satellites with with ease in fact you could arguably do

21:17two or two of the largest satellites at a time it's a conceivable technologically oh yeah well we expect this to be on the launch pad I've been at a dawat at Vandenberg Air Force Base next year and then launch probably in 2013 so this is not speculative or could you deploy two satellites with one oh yeah sure sure absolutely no problem yeah we can deploy well in fact we have

21:44the launch contract to do the next generation iridium constellation in where we were doing doing eight or nine satellites per flight per flight yeah well you're the chief technology officer I'm curious because I a bit of a background in export controls and wish I had known a lot more about the fine details how sensitive is the

22:08information that your engineers have when they marry a bus to a rocket launch a payload to a launch vehicle how much do they need to know about what's on the bus in order to make sure that they don't destroy it or that they deploy it properly is it is it highly sensitive information well it's i think the the it

22:33simply providing enough information to know how to integrate the satellite onto the rocket i don't think that necessarily reveals anything particularly proprietary however certain countries have a track record of absconding with intellectual property and and and so I think it's perhaps not

22:55a good idea to put give put there in close proximity to anything that's at any advanced u.s. space technology so there needs to be I mean the export control regime looks at the nationalities of the workers their access to certain work areas right there are monitors often and so after the Space Shuttle Endeavor takes its mission at the end of this month there will be no more space shuttle your company will be the cargo delivery vehicle to the spate to the International Space Station if i'm not mistaken you'll do 12 12 resupply missions yes and so that's been somewhat privatized i mean just the u.s.

23:36from a policy standpoint need to worry a little bit about whether it has and whether it can control its technology and still get it launched reliably well I I think I think I think I wouldn't worry about your satellites being launched on on any vehicles except maybe maybe China is a bit dodgy but better

24:09but so not that does really i think that the only only meaningful concern I've not really seen the Russians tried to steal us rocket technology and actually that's because be released until SpaceX that their rock technology has been better than ours so I'm not sure exactly what they would steal in fact the the Boeing

24:36and Lockheed sir atlas 5 vehicle uses a Russian main engine and they've not yet figured out how to make that engine themselves so the Russians obviously not not too worried about that with space is with haven't of SpaceX and our Falcon family of rockets it's this is now for the first time in a long time a vehicle that is better than the Russian so we would certainly be cautious about exposing our technology to the Russians but at this little danger of that with if your engineers in California can come up with a bigger and better launch vehicle are there other entities around the world who could be doing the same thing and doing it within a cost sort of

25:23level that competes as well with SpaceX and with others is this is this a one-off or a unique situation or might there be a new baseline if you will of competitive launch technologies emerging I'm not aware of anything that has the potential to beat what beat our technology as far as I can tell we're better than anything else that's exists or anything else that's out of development by a significant margin or there could be some secret development that I'm not aware of or they could be you know there could be some organization that starts up that's new but at least I'm not aware of anything that poses a threat to to SpaceX particularly given that that our rate of

26:11evolution of our technology is it is very fast in the who you know it in Silicon Valley you're sort of very useless mentality if you innovate fast or die and if you think of the the national champions that are international champions that have grown out of Silicon Valley of the googles Google Facebook Intel Cisco Apple who are their

26:35international competitors you name one exactly unfortunately that's that's a different language them in this town it's you innovate fast and die -huh right there's a bit of a cultural difference here right you've got your operations are just outside of Los Angeles roughly I mean how big is the workforce at SpaceX we're just under 1,300 people 13 and where do you where do you find space capable engineers how do you grow a space company in America well so I was in Silicon Valley for 10 years before moving down to LA to start SpaceX the reason i did in southern california's because southern california has the biggest concentration of space engineers in the world and who have been

27:19laid off or who are moving from one thing to another it's basic so it hires at the sort of the top two or three percent of the space profession so I think interesting space looks like special but like you have regular me and then there's like the special for specialized new space SpaceX is Special Forces I see so so it's possible they

27:41would retire someone who's late over there later for reasons of seniority and not merit mmm but not otherwise I mean it's curious to me it's strikes one as a high-risk profession I mean if a rocket goes awry we've seen films of sort of Chinese launches in the past and and others and while they make fascinating viewing they're probably highly expensive they make insurance companies very nervous is it high risk to have a rocket company I mean do it do you test launch things and let them blow up just to just to find things out or no we've never intentionally blow up a rugged or do you or does it all just come down to 11 vehicle and and it's supposed to work

28:21and hope it does we always aim for success and we've unfortunately that there are our last four missions have been four consecutive successes and and particularly last one was particularly complex because it was a test of our Dark Knight launch vehicle and our dragon to me crowd at which wich over the earth couple times never been touched down just up the coast of california which is the first time that a private company is board for something back from orbit and that that's tough the zone there's only sort of half a dozen in the nation's that a bit of achieved that that's right well that's where we began I want to I want to just mention the military side

29:04of space and get sort of get your review on this a lot of work is done in the Pentagon in the Congress in the executive branch and there's been doctrinal development that says space is a domain we have security interest in space our economy is tied to space our ability to conduct military operations is integrated tied to space if there's no going back and so some will say space must be defended it must be protected there's a lot of effort that is that

29:36it's not irreversible but it's to prepare for contingencies in which we are threatened in space and I guess my question is as as a private sector space player do you have a view on what's happening with the military reliance on space and sort of the the substantial effort that's put into it in Washington is that something SpaceX would potentially contribute to the Air Force effort yeah absolutely you know we

30:04certainly see a launching of air force and nro type satellites as an important part of our future business we don't have any air force and relaunch contracts yet but I'm very optimistic that we will will soon have have such contracts and they're just a very conservative organization and but now that we've had two successes with our Falcon 9 vehicle and now that we've come in with Falcon Heavy and in Falcon Heavy sense it's it's if maybe is twice as powerful as anything the Air Force currently as access to it allows them to launch a bigger satellites or potentially do multiple satellites on a single flight and then as far as civil space missions in terms of sending

30:54probes to two outer planets perhaps doing something like a Mars sample return these are really enabled by by our Falcon Heavy capability since the since it is it's a capability the world doesn't have yet and and so it hasn't had since at 75 so it's both the civil and potentially military or intelligence use yes it's it's exact civil military and commercial I think it's it's really going to open up a lot of world of possibilities and all of those arenas well one of the things that military planners talk about is sort of the worst case in which assets are either being degraded or denied or in the worst case destroyed which can obviously create

31:36debris in orbit with with very long term consequences and they talk about the ability to reconstitute a capability very quickly in these these fast-moving crises if you have a launch vehicle that could potentially put several assets up quickly I mean is that something that you would you would look at from a SpaceX perspective yeah absolutely so I

32:00mean it's basic so we're very supportive of national security goals as well as civil space and commercial goals I think in terms of sort of anti-satellite capability you know I think we really need to pay closer attention to having defense systems on on the satellite just basically basically being able to dodge missiles you know it's because I think you can always pull you can build ground ground base to anti-satellite missiles a lot faster you can launch satellites so just replacing them fast is is not going to really do the trick you will you really need to have satellites up there that can effectively dodge incoming missiles I'm a little concerned about

32:44laser beams which can be turned on I'm very short notice and yeah there's a solution to that too which is to have a powerful heat shield so that that's something that they can agree you need to deal with missiles as well as directed energy weapons it's a little harder to do the directed energy weapon at technology I'm not sure that you know that other countries have that yet they're probably will at some point in the future but it's much easier to just have an assassin yet some sort of kinetic interceptor but like I said I think you can if you have a satellite

33:26with with a powerful heat shield that that can be a good defense against you know sort of a laser or something like that in fact our dragon spacecraft has a powerful heat shield for for reentering where it's going to resist tremendous heat to prevent getting getting vaporize on re-entry so that that's something we suggested to the Defense Department that could be interesting technology in defending against anti-satellite weapons it seems like the Pentagon has because of the decline of the u.s. space sector which you sort of marked at a very low point even starting 20 years ago you know now suggests the possibility there could be more of a competitive space

34:08sector back in the United States is that do you agree with that and you do you think that competition can be increased to provide solutions like more resilient satellites or to sort of have a technological race if you will to solve problems as opposed to the sole source methodology yeah I think competition is always a good thing and now the US has actually done a relatively speaking much better in in the in the satellite competing in terms of satellite market then than in the launch market so the u.s. actually does have a dominant share or at least a secret substantial share in in the commercial satellite market with Laurel space systems in in Silicon

34:52Valley and Boeing space satellites you choose to be Hughes in Southern California Orbital Sciences here Virginia so it's the users dunk done recently well that commercial satellite front end is very well in the division defense satellite side of things but I but I think you look look at this as a constantly evolving get where European Chinese and other satellite makers certainly want to take that market share away from American companies we've been talking about what the u.s. can do and some of it on a sensitive unilateral kind of basis but do you have a view as to what the future could hold in terms of international space cooperation because certainly the

35:43National Space policy NASA's mission are very much geared to international cooperation peaceful cooperation in space how does how does a private entity that specializes in launch services what do you see is the road ahead in terms of potential involvement with with non-us players in space in civil space missions

36:08it's sort of like science missions that kind of thing or governmental even manned space missions i mean if there were a failure of a national program and they saw an opportunity they could afford to use your launch service i mean i'm just making this up but ya know III think I think SpaceX will probably in

36:29about three years and so be carrying astronauts to to the space station I mean as you mention remember to got the Space Shuttle retires this year SpaceX takes over from space shuttle as far as the cargo transport to and from the space station but on an interim basis the Russian Soyuz will carry American astronauts to the space station until until we're ready to take over but I think at that point I I think SpaceX will take both American astronauts arose from other countries and as well as

37:02private individuals to space it's very interesting I'm sure there are a lot of people who want to ask you questions but before we turn to those questions I hope you don't mind if I turn to energy efficiency because user if you've got a lot of people driving electric vehicles and more probably more to come can I ask

37:22you sort of what your what your view is on energy and is there a purpose a mission behind the Tesla Motors which which people x focus on the sports car and and what fun it is and I've driven it and I agree it's fun but but is there a larger sort of view that that you're trying to change policy and change societal behavior on energy yeah absolutely so as much earlier that there was in college I will throw three errors that were suspect a future humanity the internet sustainable energy with production consumption and then space so what would

37:59tez is about is is trying to help solve the consumption of energy problem so I mean logically we must have sustainable consumption of energy and production because if it's unsustainable well it's unsustainable in fact if even if you even if there were no negative environmental consequences to use of

38:26fossil fuels and even if there were no national security consequences let's say we owned all the oil and it had no negative impact on the environment it's still finite we must still find a solution or we will face economic collapse when the resources become scarce so obviously we must find alternatives I believe in electric

38:51transport because it allows for energy to be produced in a wide range of sustainable you know means and then and then you just charge the car you know electricity sort of like like cash I mean it's sort of you can generate in multiple ways you can spend in multiple ways so so it's electric vehicles is

39:14something like that is a long-term sustainable option and it is fundamentally very energy efficient to use electric vehicles in fact although as a roast is a fast sports car faster than almost better acceleration than almost any other sports car it uses less energy per mile than a Prius in fact the

39:34battery pack only has the equivalent of two gallons of gasoline worth of width of energy and and even if you take power from a coal power plant it's entirely cold and you take into convulsions and so forth and say how much co2 generate per mile it's still less than a Prius because the stationary power plants are actually quite energy efficient so in

40:06order so the point of Tesla was to make a viable electric car that that broke kind of broke the paradigm of what people thought of as a network off because people use think electric cause as these sort of ugly slow-moving golf carts and and so by making a sports car that I was that was aesthetically pleasing very fast great handling long

40:33range you know what ranges you get from a gas tank that that really helped break people's perception of what an electric car could be and it ended and it had a powerful catalytic effect in that when General Motors when Bob Lutz general motors saw the announcement about the tesla roadster he took the press release went down to his development team instead of a small company california can do it so can we and that's what generated the GM fault and in turn the nissan leaf and daimler's movement and electric vehicles and because at the time they were they used to be the world's largest car company so when the world's largest cog company announced

41:13they're going to go do an electric program the others tend to follow so things had to get a good effect in that in the direction of course we need to keep up the momentum and so Tesla is coming out with the sort of step 2 which is a mid-price mid volume car that's that really shows what is possible when you design the whole car is a system around electric powertrain and just how much more compelling it can be even a gasoline car I think people will be quite pleasantly surprised by the Model

41:42S that's coming out next year and there's a longer-term vision of a third vehicle yes yeah so that so the simple sort of 13 step strategy of Tesla who has come out with a high priced car low volume price card mode volume low price card high volume kind of three major technology iterations and then and stepping up production volume by order of magnitude in each case which witch is which is damn damn fast for a small company to grow at that rate I should just say I saw a news clip last week that a major Wall Street bank predicted that Tesla Motors will become the fourth American major automobile company after GM Ford and Chrysler so that's that's

42:29that's pretty amazing I do want to ask you as a technology person about battery storage because the question is batteries can do what they can do today how fast is the power density improving in whether the lithium chemistry's or alternative the military is looking at battery based energy efficiency in both the operational theater but also in facilities there a big consumer of energy as you know and lithium ion has is expensive it's lightweight but it's expensive and and so the question is how fast is this moving is and how fast can we expect leaps and bounds in battery storage well it's it's very pretty fast I mean if you look at the tesla roadster

43:14that has a 56 kilowatt hour battery pack the Model S will have a 90 kilowatt hour battery pack and about the same volume and it edit wither with a dramatically lower cost per kilowatt hour so the Model S despite being a good size sedan that's about the external dimensions roughly that a 5 Series BMW or any class mercedes can can do what will do 300

43:43miles of range on a single charge and versus the roadster which is 245 miles and a much smaller car so the model asus fifty percent bigger than the heavier than the in the Roadster and yet there's more than twenty percent greater range and costs much less than the Roadster so can I just ask whether the tragic events in Japan acted the supply of batteries from no we

44:16buy we had about a one week or so a spy interruption but we had sufficient buffer inventory on hand that it did not change our our production at all I see well with that are you ready to face the the crowd I'm sure there are a lot of questions would you please identify yourself and state your question clearly thank you here we go like to

44:42congratulate you on receiving the innovators award that this evening open till sat so I'm order to receive it thank you just two quick questions if I could one of the moon vs mars in terms of a colony and also the issue of sustainability of space and space debris what thoughts do you have about avoiding the Kessler syndrome and so on sure well I I favor Mars over the moon is

45:13that Mars has really got the potential for a true planet class civilization because it's a planet of the moon as the moon is not a planet the moon is much smaller it has its it's much weaker in terms of natural resources it's harder for us to adapt to it because it's got a much lower gravity the day/night cycle is is 28 days so you really effectively

45:38have a fairly small habitable zone near the poles of the moon and and water ice is very very rare there so i think i'd consider the moon to be kind of analogous to the Arctic so so the Arctic was very close to Europe but it sucked that's why America isn't there so that the Soviets but Mars is a real planet and we can create a become a true multi planetary civilization on Mars which I don't think is realistic on the moon and it also won one thinks of preserving the future of life as we know it the Mars is sufficiently far away that if something terrible happened to 2a it would probably be what wouldn't it would not what would not be affected the moon

46:34might still be affected and so that that's that's there's not a favor of Mars in terms of all over all debris I think there's only there's a certain zone which is quote I'd save sort of the medium Earth orbit altitudes where overall debris is a lot long term becomes a problem it's not a problem today but long-term it becomes problem in low Earth orbit the atmosphere

47:02distilled there to a certain degree and actually ends up being like a cleaning a clinic head it just it'll it'll sweep out it over Bri and eventually bring it back in and slow down and reenter and burn up so there's not really a low Earth orbit debris problem this and if you go out to geosynchronous orbit that's just so freaking far out there that it's really you know if we're about it there either so it's kind of just in that medium zone that's sort of the maybe eight hundred to a few thousand miles type a little bit that we need to be pay attention to but i but i do think it's something it's only really a very long term problem that's why we need to

47:43worry about in this short video a question sir i'm gonna wait for the mic bill sweetman defense technology international magazine you talk about needing to continue innovating fast with SpaceX beyond Vulcan line heavy which is extension of the original architecture what directions you taking going to take that in you go to go further into reusability what do you think that the space exploration needs as the next phases of innovation from say sex yeah I'm a big believer in

48:27in reusability and that remains a fundamental long-term objective of SpaceX in fact a fully reusable rocket system I think is the fund it's a pivotal fundamental invention necessary to make life multiplanetary I do not think it will occur in the absence of a fully reusable system and the reason for that is if you look at the cost of propellant on a falcon 9 it's it's maybe 150 thousand dollars maybe two hundred thousand dollars most but the cost of the vehicle is 50 million so so UV so

49:11when you've got the cost of repellent at kind of point three percent of the cost of a flight then clearly there's a lot of efficiency efficiencies to be had if you can use that rocket more than once and it really it's it's no different than air flight you know as a Boeing 747 costs make a quarter billion dollars you need two of them for a round trip so why doesn't your air ticket cost half a billion dollars it's because they can lose that plane thousands of times so it's so it's incredibly fundamental to have a reasonable system and going back

49:48to the sort of create your founding of America if if ships had not been reusable in the days the Mayflower the United States would not exist nobody could afford the journey and you know they might have seen a few people as an exploratory thing and of course since ships were expendable you need to tow your turn ship behind you and and you know so so the map said oh

50:15yes it turns out there is a continent out there but of course we can't afford to go there because it costs to ships every time we make the return journey but it been effective ships going to use repeatedly airplane Swedish repeatedly in fact every mode of transport can be used repeatedly and if that were not the case we would not use that motor transport whether it's plane train automobile bicycle or whatever and you

50:43know if I think we think we can establish a self-sustaining civilization on Mars poor probably something like point three percent of our gdp but I don't think we're willing to spend 100 percent by GDP on it that's the difference between reusability and no reusability so it remains a fundamental

51:02goal of SpaceX am in the front row and rima later with future on you made some really interesting comments about some of the protective systems you talk about the heat shields on the dragon and so on can we see the possibility that you would take some of that technology in some of those innovations to apply to the spacecraft manufacturing world where there's a lot of interest both in terms of military satellites and commercial satellites in having awareness and protection on that is that can we see moving in that area yeah well I think with a sort of dragon lab program which we're sorry a fair bit of interest in which is to take the dragon spacecraft

51:46that will be used for Space Station servicing and adapting that to commercial and other government applications I I think you'll start to see if my favorite of that happening so certainly that that's on an area of interest to us well dragon is kind of like dragon is basically a sophisticated satellite there's actually more sophisticated than most more satellites I'd say you know because it's got multiple redundant systems it's got the ability to dock with with another you know with dock with the space station or with anything and reenter and and

52:25actually dragon can can be reused we were when we recovered dragon and we're actually able to fire dragons engines and have no problem the heat shield could take several reentry events so even the first dragon that we were covered in December from orbit could be flown many times so that's a step in the direction of reusability questions sir I

52:53just made it with sojitz corporation I was just wondering if you're worried as the SpaceX and Tesla grow you talk about innovation all the time Google's now some people say having trouble innovating I want to stay young have that startup feel do you are you running into that problem or do you think you will as you as you grow that's what we call a high-class problem forehead is the high cholesterol I actually think our rate of innovation is increasing we're doing more things faster i also have a lot more employees so there's another question as to where that productivity of a person is increasing and i do think it gets difficult for

53:32companies to maintain a high productivity per person as they grow because companies initially improved productivity per person due to specialization of Labor and then productivity per person has decline as companies get beyond a certain scale due to communication issues so it would you know we do our best at SpaceX to minimize communication issues and have fun and anyone to anyone communication instead of say chain of command communication which is extremely inefficient so I think I think we're

54:06sort of we're a little lower on productivity per person although like said what we're trying to fix that but but at but since we have a lot more people at total productivity and a pace of innovation is faster than it has ever been sir Frank morning with aviation look I know you mentioned this morning that you're thinking about taking SpaceX SpaceX public toward the end of next year possibly but that you'd like to retain a personal patrolling interest in it because of some things that you want to do I wonder if you could elaborate a little bit about those personal objectives that would entice you to keeping the controlling interest yeah absolutely well it's really what I want

55:00SpaceX to to keep doing is working on the technology in this nest technologies necessary to create a self-sustaining civilization on Mars and what I do think there's this there's likely to be some economic pay off by transporting large numbers of people and cargo to Mars it requires a bit of long-term thinking so that maybe goes beyond the the quarterly cycle aboard the wall street that's for sure so you know some people and Wall Street will think that's just crazy and what I should actually just do is milk the government and various commercial companies and tried charged in the highest price as possible which which we will not do so you know I I want to make

55:53sure that I could ignore you know there's such things and which I can only do if I'm because I can call a shareholder look can I just piggyback on on that with a Washington question I mean the mood in Washington is a bit grim we've got a lot on our plate where the there's a lot of discussion of unaffordability we're going week to week with your continuing resolutions and and the the long-term discussion is about what's going to happen to this country if we can't change the trajectory of debt right no one's talking about new things to spend a lot of money on right what advice for what message would you give to the Congress and the executive branch in this sort of tough time that

56:32everyone's slogging through with a very short-term focus what would you say to them as someone who is really operating against a different vision and a different sort of time cycle well I think first of all people have some some sense of perspective and realize that things were actually really freaking great you know it's like the

56:56United States is actually doing doing doing quite well and and we all live really great lives here here here in the US and its shouldn't lose sight of that and the u.s. is still the world's largest manufacturer and has been since it took over from from England I don't know 100 and some odd years ago you know

57:17that the unemployment rate is decreasing I think there's lots of reasons to be positive actually without being complacent the the we certainly need to decrease the amount of government spending I think that that that's really important that this needs to be some movement afoot to rein in government spending and it can't be like a little bit here around the edges so that doesn't count it's there needs to be a meaningful decrease in income and spending such that we do not have trillion-dollar deficits because that's obviously unsustainable I mean it and that's the twenty dollar deficit thing I liken to this sort of it's like toddlers with a cupcake you know if you've seen

58:01these sort of delayed gratification tests where where you can prepare you can predict somebody's future success by the greeter which they can engage in delayed gratification where if you say here's this cupcake it's on a table if you eat it now you that's all you get but if you wait 10 minutes you can have three cupcakes and some totals they just go when they eat that cupcake and that they've basically sacrificed tomorrow for today effectively that's kind of like what you know Congress often

58:35behaves like the and and to some degree the American people are responsible for this because we will work to vote people out who engage in such behavior so I you know running trillion-dollar place deficits well that chicken is going to I mean that is going to come back to haunt us like there's no tomorrow you do not want to be Greece or Portugal or any such country so so we we must make the hard decisions of rainy and government spending and probably increasing the tax burden as well but we need to do both we can't solve it either bite something for some taxes all by just just cutting deficit I mean it's at the all having that's like saying you know the sky is

59:16blue I'm so freakin obvious and and and so I think hopefully we can Congress can can can display sufficient maturity and fortitude to to make the right decision in this regard and applauded for example the UK is is taking the appropriate austerity measures and you're cutting 25% of spending and I think it's we've got we have to do that here and it's just going to get harder and harder if we don't do it do it soon because our interest burden is going to eat the amount of money we spent on interest is going to start getting bigger and bigger and bigger and it's going to make that as austerity even worse down the road well I must say that you know for all of

1:00:02the debate about how to spend less in Washington we now know after an hour of conversation that there are people out there who are are pursuing a long-range vision that points to a lot of interesting and more sustainable and brighter vistas and so I on behalf of the Stimson Center I'd like to thank you very much for being my guest on Chairman's forum it's been wonderful to have you Thank You mr. Moscow

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份