访谈·中文精读

马斯克专访|2011 年 9 月 29 日

Interview with Elon Musk - 29 September 2011

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2008年12月,马斯克在几天里经历了两个极端。

先是最低点。他后来说,那大概是12月21日或22日,猎鹰1号第四次发射虽然成功了,但SpaceX手上合同寥寥,钱不够撑下去,必须拿下一个大单才能活。特斯拉的融资轮已经散架,SolarCity跟摩根士丹利的租赁融资交易对方自己都无法履约,他还在办离婚。

然后是12月23日,NASA打来电话,把航天飞机货运功能的替代合同给了SpaceX,金额16亿美元。

我说,我爱你们。我不知道这话是不是该说出口。(马斯克)

主持人在旁边提醒他,是billion,带b的那个。马斯克说,对,带b的,我完全失态了。

这是2011年9月29日,The Motley Fool 在华盛顿的一次访谈。马斯克穿着西装,因为下一站是五角大楼。他在开场就说,自己平时不穿西装,这次是因为在DC,入乡随俗。整场对话从2008年的绝境一路聊到火星、电动车、太阳能和管理哲学,中间还顺带骂了一个记者。

大学时他认定三个领域会改变世界

主持人一开始问他,沃顿的同学几乎全去了华尔街,他为什么多留一年读了个物理学位。

马斯克的回答很直接:大学时他觉得有三件事最可能影响世界,互联网、可持续能源、太空探索。他没指望三件都干,结果互联网那波赚到钱之后,资本密集的火箭和汽车也都能碰了。

他原本的路径是去斯坦福读材料科学和应用物理的研究生,研究方向是电动车用的高能量密度电容。学位挂在那里没读完,他跑去创业, technically 算辍学。斯坦福的教务长跟他说随时可以回来,马斯克说,可能性不大。

这段经历解释了他后来的公司组合为什么看起来那么散。PayPal、特斯拉、SolarCity、SpaceX,表面上是四个不相关的生意,在他脑子里是同一张图的四个角。

2008年,四条线同时断掉

主持人问他2008年是什么感觉。马斯克用了两个词:超级不愉快,每个层面都是彻底的悲惨。

他原本的设想是,特斯拉他只需要投入足够时间做产品开发,不用真的管公司。这个假设被证明是错的。2008年他面临的选择是:要么自己接手运营、多干几倍的活,要么公司死掉。

那一年同时出问题的有四件事。

猎鹰1号第三次发射失败。特斯拉的融资轮崩了,投资人反复告诉他们条款清单就在路上,只是想先看看市场怎么走。SolarCity跟摩根士丹利的太阳能租赁融资交易,摩根士丹利自己拿不出钱来履行。他本人还在打离婚官司。

特斯拉当时最难。通用和克莱斯勒正在破产,整个汽车业在求救。主持人插了一句,说你能想象2008年底为一家汽车公司融资吗,通用克莱斯勒正在崩,投资人问你要成功汽车公司的先例,上一个案例还是很久以前的事,而且那些公司也没在交付车。马斯克接话说,他们想到的是塔克(Tucker)和德罗宁(DeLorean)。

他说,每有人提一次德罗宁,他就该收一美元,那样他都不用做IPO了。

最后能拿到的钱只能来自内部,来自现有股东。马斯克把自己所有可动用的资本全押进特斯拉,才换来其他投资人跟进这一轮的另一半。这笔钱刚好够特斯拉撑过那个节点。

戴姆勒的5000万美元比DOE的钱更早到

外界长期流传一个说法:美国能源部(DOE)救了特斯拉。马斯克在访谈里专门纠正了这个。

真正关键的是戴姆勒。2009年初,戴姆勒向特斯拉投资5000万美元,这笔钱在当时极其重要。特斯拉拿到DOE的钱是2010年的事,而且结构不是给一笔现金,是报销制。

具体怎么运作:特斯拉先发生费用,这些费用由普华永道审计,其中跟Model S相关的部分、跟向其他公司供应动力总成相关的部分(包括给丰田的动力总成供应合同),经过核算后,一两个月后报销回来。

所以DOE的钱不可能用于Roadster,从时间上和结构上都不成立。

有媒体写错了这件事。马斯克说他犯了个错误,给纽约时报一个记者打了电话,对方明知是假的还是报道了。

如果有人明知是假还把它当真相报道出来,那他不就是个混蛋吗?(马斯克)

全场笑。主持人说,好,我们从暗走到明,继续。

火箭炸了三次,他没开除任何人

主持人问了一个他自己都说没想到会问出口的问题:火箭发射失败是什么感觉。

马斯克的回答有点出人意料。他说很糟,非常糟,但看起来还挺酷的,私下说,确实挺酷。

严肃的部分在后面。SpaceX成立之初,他估计公司成功的概率不到50%。火箭有太多环节可能出错,前三次失败涉及的具体责任人,他一个都没开。

他的理由是,那些人本可以做出更好的判断,但他们聪明、勤奋,在那个情境下开除他们不公平。只有几种情况他会动手:一个人无法围绕核心使命激励自己,或者明显没有全力以赴,或者这个人不适合某个岗位,或者招聘环节本身就出了错。除此之外,他相当宽容。

第四次发射成功那天,他的感受不是兴奋。

更多是解脱。我没有感到喜悦,只是觉得极度的压力被卸掉了。我其实有点失望,因为我没能更开心一点,只是觉得压力稍微小了一点,然后就去忙下一件事了。(马斯克)

第四次成功只意味着公司不会马上死掉。真正的转机是那通NASA的电话。

成功概率从不到50%变成90%

主持人问他现在怎么看SpaceX的成功概率。马斯克说,大概90%。

支撑这个数字的是几件事。SpaceX已经连续四年盈利,2011年也会盈利。手上有30亿美元的合同金额,就算从此不再签任何新发射订单,未来几年也能保持盈利。合同里有30多次发射,13次来自NASA,NASA大约占业务的40%。

主持人问,NASA是不是最大的客户。马斯克说是,然后给了一个类比:美国政府支出大约占整个经济的40%,所以哪怕你卖的是铅笔,也会有40%的生意来自政府。

主持人提到一个流传很广的说法,SpaceX的发射成本大约是竞争对手的三分之一。马斯克没有正面接这个数字,转而谈政府效率。

政府该做什么,不该做什么

马斯克的立场是古典的自由市场派,但他把边界画得很具体。

他说,总体而言政府做事的效率天然偏低,所以应该尽量压缩政府在经济中的参与范围。这不等于取消政府,而是在政府动手之前要想得非常清楚,因为自由企业体系永远更有效率。

哪些事该政府做?他列了几项:基础物理研究;军队应该是国家的而不是私人的;司法系统也该是公立的;还有哈勃望远镜、火星车这类项目。

哈勃这个例子他讲得比较细。哈勃带来的好处是给所有人的,人类因此多知道了一些宇宙的事,还得到了几张很酷的照片,这份价值属于整个美国和整个人类。但这种项目很难找到谁来付费,靠私人募资不是完全不可能,只是很难。

这套逻辑跟SpaceX的商业模式是自洽的。NASA做的是"给所有人一点点好处"的事,具体的运载能力可以外包给市场。

为什么丰田和戴姆勒要买一家小公司的动力总成

主持人说,车企把动力总成这种核心部件外包出去,他想不到第二个例子。这不只是特斯拉的机会,是整个行业的转折。

马斯克同意这很不寻常,然后把原因归到丰田章男(Akio Toyoda)身上。他说丰田章男在努力让公司重新变得有创业精神,他记得祖父那一代丰田的样子。丰田在1930年代做缝纫机,后来某天决定造车,所有人都觉得他们不可能造出有人愿意买的车,结果他们造出来了。

丰田章男担心的是,公司变得太固化,太相信自己一贯正确,这正是他上任要修的问题。马斯克对他的评价很高,说丰田有他在掌舵是运气。

关键的细节在这里:丰田章男问团队,电动车怎么样。团队回答,做不了。于是他去找特斯拉试试,看看这家小公司能不能做。

马斯克顺手补了一刀:那就试试吧,结果我们做出来了,看来确实"做不了"。

戴姆勒那边更讽刺。发明内燃机的公司,让特斯拉供应电动部件。

马斯克的判断是,这件事本身就说明了难度。如果电动动力总成那么容易,丰田和戴姆勒没有必要找一家小公司。特斯拉是一家硬核的技术和设计公司,这是它估值的来源。他顺带评价了同行 Fisker,说那家公司跟他们不一样,Fisker 不是一家硬核工程公司。

他还提到一个细节:戴姆勒、丰田、松下这些战略投资人一股都没卖。2011年初特斯拉做二次发行时,戴姆勒还优先参与了。

他说,很难找到比这更好的背书了。

大公司做不了激进创新,因为失败的代价太高

主持人追问,丰田投入了那么多钱和时间,为什么他们自己做不出来。

马斯克说,假以时日他们能做成,只是速度不够快。问题不在能力,在心态。尝试全新且激进的东西,这种思维方式在当时的丰田不存在。

他提到两本书,《跨越鸿沟》(Crossing the Chasm)和《创新者的窘境》(The Innovator's Dilemma),讲的就是同一件事:大公司做激进创新很难,因为一旦失败,惩罚极重。如果你手上还有东西要保护,难度会更高。

要做成这件事,公司必须接受自我蚕食,接受把现有业务的一部分干掉,接受新技术推进过程中必然出现的各种麻烦,还要保证自己在这个过程中不被解雇。马斯克说,这挺难的。

这套逻辑他后来反复用。技术发生不连续变化的时候,机会才会出现。IBM在大型机上绝对主导,所有人都以为他们会主导PC,结果没有。渐进式变化大公司能应付,剧烈变化往往应付不了。微软没能在搜索上赢谷歌,谷歌没能在社交上赢Facebook,原因都一样。

他给汽车业的判断是:这是自流水线发明以来最大的一次技术变化,整个动力总成都在换。

Solyndra不是被宠坏的孩子

话题转到清洁能源。主持人问中国和印度这样的市场会怎么发展。

马斯克先纠正了一个前提:中国已经在非常激进地转向清洁能源。

然后他主动谈起Solyndra。这家公司拿了DOE 4亿美元贷款后破产,成了当时华盛顿的笑柄。马斯克说,值得指出的是,Solyndra同时从私人投资人那里拿了大约8亿美元,主要是硅谷的风投,里面有不少大名鼎鼎的名字,这些人不是傻子。

Solyndra的根本问题是,如果太阳能价格能维持在每瓦2美元,他们本来能活。但中国把价格打了下来。

中国政府往本国太阳能产业投了400亿美元。Solyndra能调动的资源是竞争对手的百分之一。这种局面下谁能赢,不难算。

马斯克说他早就预判到了这一幕。韩国、日本、中国、德国在每瓦成本上疯狂竞争,太阳能电池板本质上是大宗商品,价格战是必然的。这种生意最好不要做。

SolarCity卖的不是电池板

所以SolarCity的重心放在系统平衡(balance of system)上。马斯克用戴尔和苹果打比方:苹果不造内存芯片,不造CPU,不造硬盘,但他们设计整个系统,做集成,管客户关系,拥有品牌。

他举了个很具体的例子。一个装了SolarCity系统的房主,根本不知道自己屋顶上是什么牌子的电池板,大概会说"板子牌的"。人们对屋顶电池板的了解,跟自己电脑里DRAM芯片是谁造的一样少。你问一个Mac用户内存是谁产的,他答不上来,反正不是苹果。

马斯克认为太阳能电池板行业的走势会跟DRAM一样,繁荣与萧条交替,利润率极薄。对SolarCity来说,电池板竞争越激烈越好,因为成本下降对它有利。

SolarCity当时的增长是每年50%到100%,现金流为正。

管理哲学:信噪比

现场提问环节,有人问马斯克创造什么样的公司文化,有没有口头禅。

他的回答是信噪比(signal to noise)。信号是把手上的事真正做成,噪音是其他一切。他希望人们把精力放在有用的事情上,不要卷进内斗。

管理者的角色,他拆成两步。第一,判断正确的战略和方向。第二,确保所有人做的事都指向那个方向,让每个人的才能和机会被最大化,然后不断迭代这个循环。

招聘和激励,他给了三条。

工作环境得让人觉得有趣,早上愿意来上班。如果一个人的心思在想着怎么逃出去,感觉像监狱,那 productivity 和专注度都上不去。

财务回报必须和投入相称。如果有人付出少却拿得多,这件事对团队的杀伤力很大,要避免制造这种局面。

第三条是意义感。如果人们相信自己做的事有更大的目的,有可能改变世界,这本身就是驱动力。马斯克承认不是每件事都能改变世界,程度也不一样,但对最有才华、最有驱动力的一批人来说,更大的目的是重要的。

顺便说一句,主持人当时问了两个问题,第一个是为什么现在的IPO数量比过去少很多。马斯克没答,直接进了第二个。这个细节挺能说明他挑问题的习惯。

做空特斯拉的人赌的是历史

特斯拉2010年上市,2011年股价在20多美元区间待了一年,市场剧烈震荡它没怎么动。马斯克提到2010年12月有过一次短暂的逼空,因为IPO六个月锁定期到期,市场以为会有大量抛售,结果没有,股价冲到36美元。他说那些引用"特斯拉股价曾高达36美元"的文章都忽略了这一点。

他当时盯着谷歌快讯,特斯拉是纳斯达克被做空第三多的股票,空头头寸2100万股。

主持人开玩笑说,那你跟做空的人说说,他错在哪。

那会很疼的,我只能这么说。(马斯克)

他的分析是,大部分空头不是因为掌握了特斯拉的什么内幕才做空,而是因为历史先例:很久没有一家成功的汽车公司了,所以特斯拉也不会成功。马斯克的回应是,那为什么不去看基本面。

三步走:从5万美元到3万美元

有人问,普通人什么时候能开上特斯拉,是十年还是一代人。

马斯克把特斯拉的总体规划(master plan)讲了一遍。从第一天起,目标就是大众市场的电动车。但一家小公司没有规模经济,技术也不够成熟,一上来就做大众市场是死路。

所以路径是:先做贵车、小批量;再做中等价格、中等批量;最后做低价格、大批量。

2011年正在进入第二步。Model S 起价5万美元,对标奔驰、宝马、雷克萨斯那个区间,2012年年中开始交付。马斯克说他高度确信能按时交付。那个周末有一场活动,是Model S beta 版本第一次让客户试驾,除了少量bug,跟量产车基本没区别。

再往后大约四年,目标是做到3万美元以下或者3万左右的车。

产能不是问题。特斯拉从通用和丰田手里买下的工厂有大约50万辆的年产能,现在只用了一小部分。其余部分的灯是关着的,主断路器都切断了,避免产生基础负荷电费。

这个资产意味着一件事:扩张的资本成本相对低。

制造业是技术问题

主持人问他是不是看好美国本土制造。

马斯克说他非常喜欢制造。制造业常被看成无聊的复制工作,好像只是把东西多做几份。但制造过程里有大量创新空间。把原材料变成想要的形状,并且尽可能高效,这本身是个很有意思的难题。

丰田用丰田生产系统证明了这一点,马斯克认为还能再往前走。前提是工程和生产之间要有紧密的迭代循环,这也是特斯拉把工程和生产放在硅谷同一处的物理原因。

三年后的船票和太空里的发动机

有人问商业载人飞行什么时候能实现。

马斯克的估计是,最好情况三年,最差五年,飞行是轨道的。票价取决于火箭能回收多少。如果完全一次性使用,票价大概2000万美元。

这个价格听着离谱,他给了一个类比:如果每飞一次就得把飞机扔掉,机票会贵成什么样。一架747大约3亿美元,往返需要两架,没人会为一张机票付5亿美元。747能重复使用一万次以上,所以资本成本摊到票价里只占很小一块。

最后一个问题是关于 VASIMR 火箭,一种空间电推进方案。马斯克的评价比较技术流:VASIMR 本质上是离子推进,推力很低,只能在大气层外用,所有离子推进都是这样。他存疑的地方在于运行需要多少能量,这套方案通常预设一台核反应堆,这就比较麻烦。他也不确定 VASIMR 在"每牛顿推力需要多少瓦输入"这个关键指标上是否胜出。

他说自己相信离子推进,SpaceX 大概率会走霍尔效应推进器(Hall effect thrusters)的路线,也许还会考虑激光加速粒子之类的方案。

整场访谈里,马斯克没有讲什么宏大的愿景口号。他讲的是2008年怎么凑钱、NASA的电话是12月23日来的、戴姆勒的5000万比DOE早一年、工厂的灯是关着的、屋顶上的电池板没人知道牌子。这些细节拼起来,才是他说的那句"三件事会影响世界"的实际执行版本。

对读者来说,这场14年前的对话有几条可以直接拿去用的东西。

  • 判断一个行业是否值得进入,看技术是否处在不连续变化的节点。渐进改良是大公司的地盘,剧烈变化才是新玩家的窗口。汽车的动力总成、当时的太阳能、今天的某些AI硬件,逻辑一样。
  • 看一家公司,别看历史先例,看基本面。空头做空特斯拉的理由是"很久没有成功的汽车公司了",这是用归纳法代替分析。反过来,看到"这个行业从来没有过"这种论断时,先问一句数据在哪。
  • 做资源不对等的竞争时,先算清楚对手能调动多少资源。Solyndra用竞争对手百分之一的资源去打价格战,结局在开局就写好了。选战场比努力更重要。
  • 在大宗商品化的环节里不要硬拼,往系统集成、客户关系、品牌这些不容易被价格战碾平的地方走。SolarCity不造电池板,苹果不造内存。
  • 管理上先把信噪比当指标。定期问自己:团队这周做的事里,有多少直接指向核心目标,有多少是内斗、汇报和流程。比例失衡就要动手砍。
  • 对待失败,区分"想清楚了但没成"和"没尽全力"。前一种不该罚,罚了之后就没人敢做激进决策。后一种要及时处理,否则会传染。
  • 融资时先想清楚最坏情况下的钱从哪来。马斯克2008年能活下来,靠的是现有股东和自己全部可动用资本,不是等外部条款清单。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00so we're gonna just talk for about 20 minutes and then just open it up for for for questions because i know a lot of people have have a bunch of them so i was a little bit i was interested by your background you you finished your bachelor's degree at wharton and then you stayed on an additional year and got a physics degree when i imagine almost all of your classmates went to wall street so that must have must have been a pretty tough year did you have a vision at this point for what you ultimately wanted to achieve

0:38well i yeah there were three things in college that i thought i would most affect the world and that there were internet sustainable energy and space exploration i didn't think i'd be involved in all three of those but as it turns out as a result of some success in the internet arena i was able to get involved in rockets and cars which are pretty capital intensive and but yeah after sort of finishing the wharton undergrad i i decided i didn't want to work on wall street or work for mckenzie or something like that which everybody else wouldn't talk do do and i'd taken enough sort of physics electives so that i could just spend another year in financial physics degree and then

1:22and then head to california to do grad studies at stanford and material science and applied physics working on high-energy density capacitors for electric vehicles and then i ended up putting that on hold to horse really dropping out you're going back technically dean says i can come back any time but that's unlikely so you know with that stanford degree you might really do something about your life exactly

1:53yeah so a couple internet companies and then kind of circled back to electric cars and and then rockets yeah it's a typical story right so you know it seems like a long time ago now but you know i i think probably you know your entire background is very interesting you know for us you know we're we're you know we're an internet company at our at our core as well and we came up really during the same period of time as paypal to me one of the really interesting things about you and that is very similar to some of the history of our company is that you have been very willing to put your own capital and your own money into into your business and one of the most

2:38intriguing times for me for you was 2008 with tesla and you went in and you were not originally the ceo you were the you were the funding you know you were the the funder and the chairman but then you're also just you were a developer so talk a little bit about that time and you know what it was like to have basically everything on the line yeah that was that was super unpleasant that's for sure

3:04yeah basically 2007 2008 and 2009 sucked they were really horrible it was awesome here in washington so yeah so my you know my thought with what i had originally hoped with tesla i mean was that i wouldn't that i could just dedicate enough time to do product development but then not actually run the company so that turned out to be a false assumption and i was sort of faced with the choice of in 2008 to either run the company and just work a lot more or or it would die mostly you know so

3:46yeah in 2008 it was particularly tough on a number of a number of fronts because the the third launch of the falcon 1 rocket for spacex failed the tesla financing round fell apart because well we kept people kept telling us that the term sheet was just around the corner they just want to see what the market's going to do like it was great yeah we were doing the same thing right absolutely so so tesla desperately needed money and then solar city had a deal with morgan stanley solar lease finance deal that morgan stanley themselves could not honor because they just didn't have money and then i was also getting divorced so that was like just on every level

4:39utter misery and then fortunately things perked up towards the end of the year the fourth launch of falcon 1 did work solar city was able to get through that period by just selling solar systems instead of leasing them was very tough tesla tesla was probably the most difficult in that time because you know obviously general motors and chrysler were busy getting bankrupt and trying to raise money can you imagine trying to raise money for a car company in late 2008 while jerome was in crisis are going bankrupt and they're like asking for examples of prior successful car companies in the last you know the last examples are at least you know but they're not delivering

5:27memory you know so there's that tucker guy yeah yeah i mean they think of tucker and delorean you know it's like you've had a buck for every time somebody mentioned lauren i wouldn't need to have an ipo so yeah that was very difficult in fact the only way we could raise money was internally so from existing investors and and then i had to commit all of all of my available capital to to tesla in order to get the other investors to do the other half of the round and that was enough to get get tesla through that point and then a lot of people assume that the doe saved our butt but actually it was daimler so that in in early 2009 daimler invested 50

6:15million dollars into tesla which was extremely important tesla didn't actually get any doa money until 2010. so if that was a loan correct is that correct the structure alone and it's it's a staggered loan it's actually what it is is as we incur expenses those expenses and then audited by pwc and the portion that is applicable to the model s and to powertrain deals or powertrain supply to other companies like the powertrain supply deal we have to download toyota that that portion is then reimbursed about a month or two later because we also get got some press about like oh the deal is you know giving us money for the for the roadster and it's like no it's like literally

7:04impossible for them to do that so yeah i made the mistake of calling some the new york times reporter who falsely reported that knowingly falsely reported that a douchebag now if somebody knowingly falsely reports something like the truth are they not a douchebag [Laughter] well i'm going to ask you a i'll we'll go from dark to light here's a question i've i really never thought that i'd ask with someone what was it like to have a rocket fail i mean i mean that sucks it's really terrible it was it was but it looked kind of cool i mean it did look kind of cool just between you and me well so the first one but i mean i guess a serious question i mean

7:49you had to expect that there was a very high likelihood that that the rocket was you know that there were kind of a lot of things that could go wrong yes yes at the beginning at the start of spacex i thought the chance of success of the company was less than 50 percent how we doing now oh i'd say well 90 at this point because well spacex has been profitable for four years and will be profitable this year as three billion dollars of contracts under revenue contra three billion dollars in revenue under contract like even if we didn't sell any more launches we would be profitable for the next several years you have an existing the nasa contract correct yeah the nasa is

8:28the biggest contract but spacex has over 30 launches 13 of those are for nasa it's about 40 of our businesses with nasa but you know if you look at the government spending as a percentage of the economy it's about 40 so even if you sold pencils about 40 of your business would be with the government i've lost my and then what was like to when you when that when the when the fourth rocket went up and it was a successful launch that that had to be kind of cool too yeah that was awesome it was it was actually more just relief i didn't feel elation i just felt like extreme stress relief yeah yeah i actually was disappointed that i didn't feel happier but i just

9:11felt like slightly less stressed just on to the next thing yeah well that the fourth launch just meant that we wouldn't die quite then but well that's good news right but then we were awarded a big nasa contract at the end of literally i think it was december 23rd in fact the absolute low point was for me was i think december 22nd or 21st of 2008 because even though it had the that falcon success the i mean we we didn't we still had very few contracts and we didn't have enough money to keep the company going we really needed a a big contract win and then nasa called and said that they'd awarded us the the main contract for replacing cargo transport function of

10:08the space shuttle and it was 1.6 billion so i was like i said i love you guys i don't know if that's you're supposed to say that but yeah that was billion with a b right right right i love you yes lost all decorum yeah the i i think one of the interesting things you know taking quotes from you is that your cost is about one-third you know i believe that's right of of of the competitors for for for for rocket launches or yeah are you are there things that you think that nasa could learn from private companies that are that are coming into the market now yeah you know i think in general it's tough for government to do things

11:00you know so i mean generally i think that that government should do [Music] try to minimize the number of things that government does so i'm generally a proponent of of smaller government not bigger government just because gov government as a as a system is not an efficient system so you want to minimize the government participation in the economy that doesn't mean getting rid of it but just saying you have to think really carefully before the government does something versus free enterprise or something free enterprise is always going to be more efficient so now there are things like like basic physics research and obviously i think we'd rather have a a

11:42government army than a private army and i think probably a government justice system then a private justice system you know there's sort of things that are that the government should do and and also kind of doing things like the hubble and the mars rovers you know something like the hubble is a small amount of good for everyone like it's like oh we learned more about the universe got some really cool pictures and and and that that's that's that's a value to all of america and all of humanity really but it's hard to say like who's going to pay for it if you try to raise private funds for it but you might be able to get it but it's it's it's harder

12:22so you got your money back from the last thing right so the which one you got your money back from you know having invested in tesla and you just got the contract from nasa so yeah actually as it turns out tesla and spacex and solar city are doing really well in you know at the you know the i think it's if you look at say the tesla stock price it's actually been remarkably stable it's been sort of in the 20s for a year despite massive gyrations in the market and there was a there was a momentary short squeeze in december of last year which there's a bunch of articles that reference oh tesla had this high of like 36 dollars that's only because there was

13:08a short squeeze at the end of december it was because at the end of the that was when the six-month lock-up period for the ipo expired and i think people in the market expected that there would be a lot of people selling stock at that point and actually they weren't just didn't happen right so this big short squeeze took place i think there's probably going to be another short squeeze on tesla because like i apparently get these google alerts that were like the third most shorted stock on the nasdaq 21 million shares short now i mean somebody's got a lot of bulls yeah well so what all right what do they have wrong what okay so that guy he's short your shares

13:47so talk to dave meyer you tell him why he's wrong dude it's going to sting that's all i can tell you it's like yeah i think well i i mean i don't know if you're actually awesome okay but but i think generally when i talk to people who showed the shows that they're not shorting it because of anything they know about tesla they're just shorting it because of historical precedent it's like oh there's never there hasn't been a successful car company in ages so tesla is going to be is not going to succeed like how about looking at the fundamentals you know so the the the thing is that whenever there's a big change in technology whenever there's a big technology

14:37discontinuity that's when opportunity arises in in industry and if you look at say like the computer industry we had ibm was extremely dominant in mainframes and everyone thought oh you know they'll just be extremely dominant in pcs and everything and they they weren't they just they have a hard time with the technology you know when there's a sharp change in technology gradual changes they can deal with but but sharp changes that they tend to not do well with and and you can look at the internet and say well why wasn't microsoft the leader in in search why didn't they beat google why didn't google beat facebook and you know it's just tough to deal

15:19with big technology change and what we're seeing in the automotive industry is the biggest technology change since the moving production line the entire powertrain is changing so and and that and and then people say well how could you possibly compete with like the big car companies like toyota oh like you i mean our partner the one that we're providing electric power trains to that would that be the toyota you're referring to

15:48you know it it you know you have to say well why why is toyota having tesla supply electric powertrains it can't be that easy if if if we're doing that why is daimler the company that invented internal combustion engines having a supply components to them and it's because it's it's it's really hard technology taylor is really a it's a we're a hardcore technology and design company you know there's i think there's other companies out there like that that are not that are sort of different and you know like i think fiscal is pretty different from us like they're not a hardcore engineering company but but but we are and so i think come what made this this this huge value

16:31and tesla in terms of the intellectual property that that we've developed and if you look at you know some of our strategic investors like daimler and and like toyota and like panasonic who have not sold a share in fact daimler at the last time we did a secondary earlier this year daimler participated for priority in that secondary you know it's difficult to ask for a better endorsement than that yeah i think that the the the powertrain contract that you all signed with with toyota was very interesting for for one reason it's it seems to me i couldn't think of another another instance where a company a car company had outsourced such a central

17:14component like usually they do a lot of manufacturing but that's a central component so that feels like not just a game changer for you but a game changer for the industry yeah yeah you're right it is unusual for that to occur and we are part of what akio toyota is trying to do with his his company is is try to push it to be more entrepreneurial he remembers the days of his grandfather when it was very entrepreneurial you know toyota would made sewing machines in the in the 30s and and then they just decided one day they're going to make cars and people like ha they can possibly make a car that anyone would want to buy and they then they made a

17:52great car but they were very entrepreneurial and akioto is concerned that they're they've become too set in their ways they've become too convinced in their own rightness yeah and and that's part of what led to some of the issues that that that he came in to to fix and aikido isn't a really great guy by the way toyota is really fortunate to have him at the helm there but but but he you know he he he wants to push push his team to to try new things because when he went to his team and said hey what about electric vehicles they said it couldn't be done right and so it's like okay so let's see if this little company toyota tesla can can do it and so and we're

18:36doing it and i'm like oh okay i guess it can't be done why don't you think they could do it i mean they tried for they tried on a number for a long time they put millions of dollars into into developing the technology what's what's different well no i i think they will be able to do it over time but it just it's just not very quick and you know they they didn't

19:07the the mindset of trying something new and radical was just not there that there it's you know if there's people have written books about this like crossing the chasm and you know innovators dilemma and all that about how it's difficult to do radical innovation at a big company because if you try to do radical innovation and you fail you get a huge ding yeah and and then and especially if you have something to protect to start with yeah right exactly you've got to decide that you're trying to you decide that you're going to cannibalize your existing business and take a big risk and deal with all the issues that inevitably arise when you're trying to push a new

19:45technology and and and then and not get fired along the way it's pretty hard yeah one of your one of your passions has been been clean energy and you know this is you know this has been something that that you've done i guess on the side of the other you know these other very small projects do you believe that the developing markets like india and china how are they going to develop in a way that sustainable and clean energy is possible well china is actually already moving to

20:20towards clean energy very aggressively you know people there's a lot of press about solyndra and you know the doe giving flundrek 400 million dollars and and slyndra failed and should should the government really have given them 400 million dollars and well it's worth pointing out that they got about 800 million dollars from from private investors primarily silicon valley venture capitalists including some very big names so they weren't suckers who got that money and the fundamental issue with solyndra was they would have been okay at about two dollars a watt for for solar but it the chinese pushed it down to a right so what yeah the price is

20:56collapsed right yeah and the chinese government invested 40 billion in their solar industry and so we were like like slender you suck for failing like i'm like yeah they they had literally one percent the resources of of their competitors who would win in that situation it's pretty hard you did well okay yeah yeah but you know in the case of solar city so i mean i did i i i thought this would occur i you know i thought there would be a rabbit competition in the cost per watt of solar they're somewhat inevitable with you know korea japan china germany or competing like mad on on cost per watt and it's a very much a commodity that you do not want to be in that in in that

21:47business and then so solar city's focus is on balance of system they're kind of like dell or apple you know the dollar apple they don't make the the memory chips or the cpu or the hard drive but they design the overall system they put it together they handle the customer relationship they own the customer brand they're in the relationship i mean if you've got solar city installation of your house you have no idea what panels you got i mean it's like panel panel something it's all the city panels you might as well know like people know about as much about what panels are on the roof as they know about what dram chips are in their computer like who made your dram chips on your

22:21mac apple no it wasn't apple so in fact i think i think that the there's a lot of parallels between the the dram business and and the solar panel business i think it's going to go through the same sort of boom bust microscopic margin situation but the more competition there is in panel cost for what the better solar city it is so they're kicking butt i mean they're growing at 50 100 a year and positive cash flow you have a you have a pretty tight time frame so i want to make sure that we open it up to to questions from from the audit sure if that's if that's okay so alan thank you very much for visiting us today just a couple questions the first is

23:07why are there so many fewer ipos now than have been the case in years past and the second question is having never had the pleasure of working with you or for you this might actually be a better question for your associates but you know i always think of ceos and leaders as creating cultures around them bill's interview very much was focused on exploits achievements and forward looking things for your businesses what's it like to work with you on a daily basis what kind of a culture do you typically create around yourself are there catch phrases you use or express how do you roll well i don't normally wear a suit the reason i'm wearing a suit is because i'm

23:46in dc and you know when in rome although you guys aren't wearing suits but we roll a little differently right you're not normal for dc yeah welcome to virginia right i just gave a talk at the national press club and i'm headed to the pentagon right after this that's why i need to leave on time because they're quite functional over there so i you know i don't know i'm not sure exactly how to describe the culture of of spacex or tesla but

24:22i i do try to think of it in kind of like signal to noise you know where signal is getting useful things done noise is everything else and so we want to get have people do you know be focused on doing useful things and not involved in sort of internecine politics and you know i i think yeah the role of the manager is like basically to make sure people are well you need to be able to decide what is the right strategy what's the direction to go and then and then make sure people are are doing things that are pointed in that direction and that that that the their talents their other opportunities are maximized and just sort of like iterate on that

25:07loop that that's that's kind of how i think and then i think in terms of of recruiting and motivating the the best people having you got to make sure it's a reasonably fun work environment so if you were looking forward to coming in the work to work in the morning it's a lot easier to be productive and and focused about if you if you're interested in what you're doing and and and you're looking forward to it then if your mind's trying to escape and and it feels like prison where you leave at 5 p.m or something like that and then the others that is financial reward needs to be commensurate with the effort expended so if they work really hard they're gonna

25:46think okay that that will the reward will be proportionate to my effort you know obviously if you have a situation where where you see somebody is highly rewarded for doing much less effort than you then that's demotivating so you want to avoid situations like that and then the third thing is i think if people think that what they're working at on it there's a greater cause you know that there's something that could change the world then i think that that's also a motivating factor now not everything changes the world i mean or changes to various degrees but but i think for the most talented and driven people it's very it's important that there be a larger purpose how do

26:26you view well-conceived failures in your company well i think it's important like nobody bats a thousand obviously and no matter how smart you are you'll make some number of mistakes everyone makes mistakes it's just a question of how many and how often and do you have a good whether a rocket blows up right i didn't fire anyone responsible for the particular failures associated with the first three three flights actually and because they i mean they could have made better decisions but they're they're smart hard-working and it's sort of like you know it just wouldn't be fair in that situation so it's all it's only if somebody is either like they can't that they're

27:18like they can't get themselves motivated around the core mission or they're really not giving it everything they can in some cases they may be not the right fit for a particular role or there was an error in the hiring process but other than that it's it's pretty forgiving i think who's next okay so hi i've got a question it's a nice segue to your next appointment at the pentagon so i'm interested in what the us military is doing with green energy how they're going to use it in the future for them it's probably a matter of national security i'm that's very important but i also care a lot about our planet and i know you do too so any comments on upcoming opportunity for

28:04either solar or electronic vehicles or anything green with the military yeah absolutely well you know the military does does so military does have a mandate to move towards sustainable energy and it does have the dual advantage of being good for the environment and good for national security i think certainly solar is is very important because a lot of the military bases out there they operate on generators and and so it's they're pretty inefficient from an electricity generation standpoint they're just importing a lot of oil and it actually takes a lot of oil oil to get the oil there so it's really inefficient so going big on solar is pretty important

28:46for the military and solar city is actually trying to do that with it with a a big solar installation at military bases it was announced recently it was actually going to be funded by in part by the doe but then the solyndra thing kind of threw everything for a loop and so it doesn't look like that's going to happen unfortunately but on the on the positive news side the solar city thinks they could they might be they can probably get done without the doe so i think i'm going to jump the gun here but but i think it i think they'll be able to move forward even without the doe the cost is going to be a little higher because the cost of solar is so dependent on the

29:30capital cost of the thing because it doesn't cost anything to run it really it's just capital cost so so yeah i think things are moving in a good direction there and then and then over time i think we'll see military vehicles going increasingly electric but you know the military can be relatively slow adopter you know unless there's like a pressing need it it can be a pretty slow adopter of technology i mean some of the planes that are up there flying pretty ancient so i think it'll probably take a while for the the military will not be the probably not be the first here yeah

30:15more of a whimsical question and a dream of mine chances of passenger flights how soon sure well i think we could do passenger flights i think maybe best case three three years but probably worst case five years and these will be orbital flights and depending upon what level of reusability we're able to achieve with the vehicle that that will that will drive the cost on on a completely expendable basis i think that the cost proceed would be on the order of 20 million dollars which is obviously pretty expensive but but that's because you're throwing the rocket away you know it's sort of like you know imagine how much an air ticket would cost if you had to throw

30:59the plane away every time you're really expensive you know 747 is about 300 million dollars you need two for a round trip but nobody's playing half a billion dollars for a plane ticket or even you know whatever it is 400 passengers times that so like one and a half billion dollars a ticket so they do it if they could get away with it well that's beauty of competition and everything but you can use that 747 over and over again like 10 000 times or more so the capital cost of the you know in your ticket price the capital cost has to be counted somehow but it's a pretty small portion so we have time i think for maybe two more questions oh right here

31:39in in keeping with the what do you see in the future discussion we've got going with tesla it seems like the odd industry is you know right for a disruption as well how how long do you think it'll be until we're we're all driving tesla's to work you know will be a generation what would be ten years when do you think the technology will really be commercially viable for the everyday consumer well so we're trying to get to mass market electric cars as fast as possible and if that's really been my goal with tesla from the beginning is to make mass market electric cars but but as a small company we didn't have economies of scale and the technology wasn't refined

32:15enough to to go to mass market right away so the master plan has always been to start with expensive vehicles in low volume go to mid price mid volume and then low price high volume and so we're about to do step two in that strategy which is mid price mood volume with the model s which i'm highly confident will will hit the market and get delivered to customers middle of next year in fact we've got a big event this weekend which is the the first customer drive or the first first time anyone will will drive the model s beta which is essentially indistinguishable from the production car except for but you know slight bugs and things and that's a car that starts at 50 000

32:57so it's comparable to your mercedes bmw lexus type of thing and then hopefully in about four years or so we can get to the kind of the sub 30 000 or maybe around 30 000 car and and we have the factory to do it the great thing about the factory that we acquired from gm and toyota is that it has about a half million vehicle your capacity we're just using a little tiny portion of it in fact we've literally turned the lights out and cut off the the main breakers in the rest of the building so not to use base load but we have this huge asset which is the that this factory that that we can leverage and scale up at a relatively low capital cost and

33:44you're you're a bull on manufacturing domestically i i really like manufacturing and i think sometimes manufacturing is looked at as kind of a boring like you're just making copies or something like that but there's a huge amount of innovation that occurs in manufacturing and i think it's it's actually a really interesting problem so i i'm i'm very pro manufacturing and a very very much in favor of thinking manufacturing like a technology problem and not just like you're just going to make copies bending iron and yeah you this you're thinking about like this if you're trying to take raw materials and get them into the desired shape if if as efficiently as possible and it's a

34:26really interesting puzzle as to how you do that and there's a huge amount of innovation that can be applied there toyota showed this with the toyota production system and i think i think there's actually there's more even more that can be done in that in that regard and but i think you have to have a tight iteration loop between engineering and production in order to to experience that in order to apply that innovation that's why we've got engineering and production closely physically located in silicon valley i think jeff yeah jlo hey actually i was curious what you thought of the future of the vasimir rocket and does spacex have any plans on working

35:05with that astro at all so the the vashmir is it's basically an in-space propulsion and it's basically a an ion drive and it's it you can't use it to depart from earth you can only use it in space because the actual thrust is quite low that is true for all ion drives and i think it's okay as far as ion drives go i mean it's it's i think there's some question marks around how much energy is required to operate the the vasmir and i think they generally pre sort of presupposes a nuclear reactor and and all that sort of stuff so i i think that's that's a bit tricky and it's not clear to me that the vasamira wins when when you're looking at you know basically watts of input

36:00energy per newton of thrust which is sort of a key figure of merit i do i do believe in ion drives i'm saying it's that something spacex will get into but but i think we'll probably be more in the in favor of sort of things like hall effect thrusters and and and you know maybe maybe maybe laser accelerated particles or something like that so elon i think you can get a sense from you know from our audience that we are enormous fans of purpose-driven entrepreneurship and you know you're one of the embodiments of of that and we you know we really appreciate that you took the time to come and speak with us today all right thank you thank you [Applause]

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份