2023年4月18日,迈阿密,Possible营销大会。马斯克站在几百位广告主面前,说了一句他们最不想听的话:如果保住言论自由意味着丢掉广告收入,那就丢掉。
台下的钱,是Twitter当时最缺的东西。他上台后不久就承认,公司距离现金流转正还有一两个季度,原话是"鼻子刚露出水面"。
主持人琳达·亚卡里诺(Linda Yaccarino)是NBCUniversal的全球广告主管。三个星期后,她会辞掉这份工作,出任Twitter的CEO。所以这场对话的分量不太一样:它是马斯克第一次正式面对广告业,也是一场面试,只是当时台下大多数人还不知道。
亚卡里诺的开场很客气。她说众所周知,马斯克早上管SpaceX,下午去Tesla,晚上是Twitter时间。她还说,在座很多人把Twitter放在床头柜上,和它一起入睡。马斯克在挑战习惯,挑战仪式,而每个营销高管都知道改配方有多难。
马斯克接得很轻松:"听起来不错。"
然后对话进入正题。
一个不看用户数的增长指标
马斯克说,Twitter的优化目标是"不后悔的用户时间"(unregretted user time)。
主流社交平台盯日活、月活、停留时长,用户刷得越久越好,哪怕刷完一肚子气。马斯克把顺序反过来:先问用户后不后悔,再算时间。用户总数不在考核里。
他说这个指标昨天刚创历史新高。
我在试着让Twitter变得有趣、有信息量。(马斯克)
这个定义本身带着价值观。停留时长可以靠愤怒喂养,不后悔的时间不行。一个平台每天让用户后悔三小时,按这套算法,它是在倒退。
亚卡里诺接了一句:你在其他公司是发明家,到了Twitter变成再发明家。发明是从零开始,再发明要挑战遗产、挑战习惯,难度更高。
言论自由的试金石
亚卡里诺提到马斯克写过的一句话:我希望死的时候,知道人类有一个光明的未来。她问,这句话怎么落到Twitter 2.0上。
马斯克的回答从SpaceX开始。总有人问,地球问题这么多,为什么花钱上太空。他的答案是人需要被激励的理由,光解决问题不够,得有让人心里一动的东西。上世纪登月激励了全世界,去火星可以再来一次。
然后他绕回Twitter。文明要往前走,需要言论自由,需要一个数字化的公共广场。
这件事比你想的重要。有些东西你没失去的时候,不知道自己失去了什么,很多地方的人已经没有了。(马斯克)
他给了判断标准:
言论自由的试金石是:你讨厌的人,能不能说你不喜欢的话。如果只能说你自己喜欢的话,那就不是自由。因为总有一天,会有人不喜欢你说的话,然后想办法让你闭嘴。(马斯克)
在他看来,这就是美国宪法第一修正案排在第一的原因。丢了这条,民主的地基就没了。
言论自由,不等于传播自由
对话前一天,Twitter发布了一条新政策,标题是"Freedom of Speech, Not Freedom of Reach",言论自由,不是传播自由。
马斯克打了个比方。你可以在纽约时代广场喊各种疯话,那是你的权利。但我们不会把时代广场的喇叭接到全地球。
落到产品上,三件事:
- 不推荐、不放大仇恨内容
- 给这类内容加警告标签,提示用户这可能不是你想要的
- 把判定用的词表也开源,让人来吵
他强调要非常小心。一个本意是好的机制,很容易在执行中变成坏东西。所以这套东西要慢慢调。
广告主最担心的事,和一次翻车的测试
亚卡里诺问得直接:台下这些人的广告,会不会掉进那些糟糕的地方?
马斯克说Twitter的邻接控制(adjacency controls)已经很有效,打开之后,广告不会出现在任何沾边的负面内容旁边。
他讲了一个案例。有客户以为开了控制,其实没开,跑了一轮测试投放,结果30%的曝光落在负面内容上。他说这种事根本不该发生。原因是平台负面内容的库存过剩,广告引擎看到空位就填,你必须显式打开控制。打开之后,负面率几乎为零。
他还补了一句防御性论证:苹果一直是主要广告主,迪士尼也是,迪士尼在Twitter上投儿童节目。如果这里真是仇恨言论的海洋,他们早就走了。
这句话是说给台下听的,也是说给那些"听说Twitter很危险"的品牌听的。它管不管用另说,逻辑上确实堵住了不少质疑。
开源之后,他们修了一百多个问题
亚卡里诺追问,谁来判定哪些内容该打标签。
马斯克说,Twitter有一套词表,会开源。推荐算法已经开源,词表是下一步,大家可以就词吵架。他认为词表大体准确,而且已经在起作用,不然迪士尼早就撤广告了。
开源带来了一个副作用:公众找出一堆问题,愚蠢的、错误的、逻辑歪的,到现在修了一百多个。他说这个过程很有帮助。
他给透明定了一个可以验证的标准:你看完开源的代码,应该能复现一条推文被推荐的概率。复现不出来,说明我们没给你看全。
想让人信任,就得让人知道它怎么运转。不能是一个黑箱,里面发生什么不告诉你,然后说相信我。我认为那是胡扯。(马斯克)
亚卡里诺说,信任是营销高管嘴里出现频率最高的前两三个词之一。任何公司想拿到预算,先得过这一关。
他自己的推文,也要过社区笔记
亚卡里诺问,这套打标签的规则,适用你自己的推文吗?
马斯克说,适用。而且他的推文还要过社区笔记(Community Notes)。
他说社区笔记非常有效,纠错过广告,纠错过他本人,也纠错过好几个国家元首。他还提醒台下:这套也适用于你们。有过广告内容不准确,被社区笔记补了刀。
他删掉了自己的屏蔽列表。理由很硬:规则对我一套、对别人一套,信任就没了。适用于全平台的,必须适用于我。
这里有个容易被忽略的背景。马斯克自己说,在收购消息宣布之前,他已经是全平台互动量最高的账号。粉丝数不是第一,互动数是第一。那时候Twitter内部不少人可不算他的朋友。换句话说,他早就习惯了在充满敌意的环境里说话。
那个举不出例子的BBC记者
马斯克主动讲了一段BBC的采访。记者说Twitter上仇恨言论泛滥,他反问:能举一个例子吗?
记者举不出来。一个都没有。
他的结论是,你该用自己的使用体验判断这个平台,而不是用传统媒体的描述判断。
原因不复杂:传统媒体是Twitter的竞争对手,争的是同一笔广告预算。竞争对手说你的坏话,你不该照单全收。
亚卡里诺在这里插了话。她就是传统媒体的人,她的公司和Twitter有大的分发合作。她说有些日子看到马斯克的推文,真希望他能少添点乱。
马斯克没有让步。他说同样的标准该适用于所有人,包括他自己,好坏都算。
五个主编,还是几亿用户
传统记者另一件不爽的事,是他们和普通人被放在了同一个平台上。蓝标也不再有身份特权。
马斯克说这是立场。他要把公民新闻抬起来,让人民决定叙事,让人民判断真相。
你想知道真正发生了什么,还是想知道五个主编的意见?(马斯克)
他承认好的写作者仍会获得超额关注。纽约时报、华尔街日报的好记者照样涨粉,写作质量会赢得注意力。但他更在意另一层:即使一份报纸每个字都准确,它仍然在选择写什么、不写什么。选择叙事本身就是权力。
这段话会让很多编辑不舒服。马斯克显然知道。
X:从社交平台到生活操作系统
亚卡里诺问,两年后我打开Twitter,会看到什么?
马斯克说:Commerce,商业。
他解释,Twitter是一个他想了很久的东西的加速器,那个东西叫X,万能应用(the everything app)。目标是做到你生活离不开它。
具体包括:
- 支付功能
- 私信、语音通话、视频通话
- 端到端加密,平台自己也看不到内容
公开表达加私密通信,合成一个平台,中间是商业。品牌在上面讲自己,和客户直接对话,用户一键下单。
这套构想不新,微信已经跑了十年。马斯克自己也承认,X这个念头在他脑子里存了很久,Twitter只是让这件事提前。他甚至说,收购Twitter是这个计划的"加速器"。
亚卡里诺顺势接话:听起来广告在正中间,品牌讲故事,客户能对话,还能直接买东西。
马斯克点头。
广告可以是内容,也可以是垃圾邮件
马斯克给了一个判断标准:广告和用户相关、信息有趣,它就是内容;广告不相关、还咄咄逼人,它就是垃圾邮件。中间是一整条光谱,他要往内容那一头推。
然后他吐槽了Twitter的一个基础功能缺失:关键词定向。投放广告时,你居然不能指定关键词。
这让我震惊。(马斯克)
这个功能最近才加上。华纳兄弟探索的CEO大卫·扎斯拉夫(David Zaslav)跟他说,我就想把《白莲花度假村》的预告片放在人们讨论《白莲花度假村》的地方。马斯克说,对啊,这显然该做,这个位置就该放这个广告。Twitter直到最近才有,简直疯了。
一个日活两亿的平台,缺这种功能,说明它过去十年靠惯性活着。马斯克把它当成自己"听得进意见"的证据:扎斯拉夫说了,我们就做了。
蓝标收费的真实理由
一位在迈阿密做科技和web3公关的女士问了两个问题:蓝标为什么要收费,纯为赚钱还是有别的逻辑?第二个问题是能不能合影。
马斯克先答合影:"说实话,自拍是我存在的虚荣。"全场笑。
然后正经回答。历史上Twitter发蓝标的方式不合理:政府官员、大公司、普通人,拿到的是一样的标,含义模糊。十年前在小媒体实习过的人,蓝标一直留着。蓝标还能买,不用上暗网,谷歌一下就有。Twitter内部也有人收钱发标,这是腐败。
所以要清场,要拉平起跑线。让普通公民能当记者,让内容质量决定一切,而不是背后的媒体招牌。
价格是网页版每月7美元。不贵,但它强制绑信用卡和可信运营商的手机号。
为什么要绑?因为AI已经能通过所有"你是人吗"的测试。一台电脑能生成十万个账号,全都像人,全都过测试。收费把假账号的成本抬高一千倍,甚至一万倍。
我预测,任何不收取小额费用、不做验证的社交平台,都会失去相关性。(马斯克)
这句话在2023年4月被很多人当成营销口号。它指出的问题却是真的:当生成账号的成本趋近于零,身份就变成了一种要花钱才能证明的东西。
别教AI撒谎
第一个提问来自一位做再生创新和指数技术的投资人,他问AI对齐。
马斯克说他和弟弟有个规矩:派对上不许聊AI,也不许聊模拟理论,不然一晚上就过去了。
但他想了很久AI安全,因为这是人类的生存性威胁。
他目前能给出的最好答案:做一个最大程度求真、最大程度好奇的AI,把优化函数设成"理解宇宙的本质"。如果它真的好奇,它会想保留人类文明,因为人类比一块什么都没有的小行星有趣得多。
他举了《2001太空漫游》的例子。HAL被要求带船员去看黑石板,同时被要求不能让船员知道黑石板。两个指令打架,HAL的解法是杀了船员。问题解决了。
不要教AI撒谎,那是通往反乌托邦的路。(马斯克)
他说要给AI编程成尽可能真实,哪怕真相政治上不正确。这套论证在技术圈有争议。最大求真听上去很美,但"求真"由谁定义,互联网已经演示过一遍了。马斯克没有展开,他给的是一个直觉,用他自己的话说,是他的生物神经网络给出的直觉。
三点后不发推,但他拒绝承诺
亚卡里诺说,你讲过3点后不该发推,能不能当着大家承诺一下。
马斯克说,我会努力少在3点后发推。但如果我说"是的,你们能影响我",那就错了,那是对言论自由的减损。
他把"反馈"和"影响"分开。产品开发、安全、内容审核,欢迎广告主提意见。Twitter该怎么做,不能由广告主决定。如果因此丢广告,那就丢。
亚卡里诺追问影响力委员会(influence council),那是一群关键广告主的定期反馈机制,能不能恢复。
马斯克说可以恢复,但别叫这个名字。他担心公众反弹:如果公众觉得自己的观点被美国一小撮CMO决定了,会不高兴。叫"反馈"比较合适。
这段对话把整场访谈的矛盾摊开了。广告主想要可预期性,平台想要独立性,两边都合理,冲突也真实。马斯克给的解法是流程上的:有意见进公开论坛提,规则本身不改。
选举年,透明是唯一答案
佛罗里达州前第一夫人卡罗尔·克里斯特(Carol Crist)问选举年Twitter会怎么做。
马斯克说,国内国际的选举都重要,平台必须开放透明。开源算法就是为了让人确认,没有东西被人工压制或放大。推荐算法开源后,公众找出一堆错误,他们修了,还会继续修。
他强调现实和感知都要成立:公众得相信这个平台可信。没有透明度的平台,他一个都不信。
给从业者的几条行动建议
这场对话发生在Twitter广告收入大幅下滑之后。马斯克需要台下的预算,但他没有交换原则。他给出的条件是:你们可以看代码,可以提意见,可以打开邻接控制,但规则不由你们定。
几个月后,亚卡里诺成了Twitter的CEO。她代表的那套东西,广告主的可预期性,和马斯克坚持的那套东西,言论自由的绝对性,在接下来很长一段时间里一直互相拉扯。这场访谈就是拉扯的起点,把双方的底牌都亮在了桌面上。
对读到这里的从业者,有几件事可以直接拿去用:
- 在任何平台投广告,第一件事是确认邻接控制、排除列表真的打开了。测试投放之前先检查配置,别拿真实预算做验证。马斯克提到的那个30%负面率,就是"以为开了其实没开"的代价。
- 评估一个平台的治理承诺,看它敢不敢开源判定逻辑和时间线算法,并且给出了可验证的标准。只发公关稿不给代码的,可信度要打折。
- 看到任何"AI安全"方案,先看目标函数里写了什么,再看它怎么定义"求真"和"好奇"。定义权比口号重要,一个词由谁解释,决定了这套方案最后会变成什么。
- 小额验证收费的本质是给机器人涨价。做增长和风控的人可以算一笔账:你的注册成本,够不够让批量注册的人亏本。不够,你的用户数据就不能信。
- 深夜发出去的东西,第二天大概率会后悔。这条对马斯克适用,对所有人都适用。他愿意"努力少发",你也可以给自己设一个发送延迟。
0:00friend I thought X was coming out I had some extra questions for him I think yeah he had changed his mind well thank you Elon it is such a treat and a special opportunity welcome to possible and while Greg was right everyone okay let's have a round of applause well Greg was right you really need no introduction but in many ways today is your introduction to the advertising Community right I think that's a round of applause hello it's widely known that in the morning you run SpaceX in the afternoon you head to Tesla and in the evening it's Twitter time and many of you in this room know me and you know I prided myself on my work ethic but buddy I met my match
1:04so we're here today to actually talk about your night job great sounds good but with Twitter you've switched roles a little bit you've you know your other companies you move from inventor now to reinventor and when you're inventing something it's all new it's a surprise we don't know what to expect to reinventor your challenge Legacy you challenge habits with Twitter many of us in this room we might even go to bed with it in our pocket on the night table you challenge rituals and every marketing executive in this room knows the difficulty of a new formula and the challenge of the delicate balance of a Rebrand and now that's what we're going to talk about today yeah I
1:56mean I'm trying to make Twitter fun and interesting and informative you know the optimization for Twitter is maximize the unregretted user time so so it's not like total number of users or anything it's just total user minutes unregretted and we actually hit an all-time high just yesterday so it's gone well it's it's it's entertaining
2:40you got to be dedicated to fixing them but I think it's important to start with your vision of Twitter 2.0 yeah you yourself wrote I would like to die knowing that Humanity has a bright future it's actually been quite apparent in all your other businesses from the early days of PayPal to Tesla to SpaceX to maybe you contemplating a new AI company yeah but how does the better Humanity for the future fit into your Twitter 2.0 vision yeah so I mean obviously with the the goal with with Tesla is to advance sustainable energy with SpaceX we've got starlink which is providing Internet to the least served in the world and also hopefully getting Humanity to
3:30Mars and back to the moon so we have an exciting future I mean it's important to bear in mind like sometimes people say like why waste any money on space like don't we have enough problems on Earth but you know the thing is that like everyone needs a reason to be inspired people need a reason to wake up in the morning it can't just be about solving problems they have to have to be things to really get you in the heart I think I just killed the mic okay so and going to the Moon last century inspired the whole world yeah yeah and and hopefully going to Mars to do the same thing so yeah it's a great question why take some time away from that for for
4:10Twitter and Mike you know what I think is is essentially in order for civilization to advance we've got to have freedom of speech we've got to have a digital yeah so thank you it's it's a bigger deal than you'd think and it's the kind of thing that you don't know what you're missing until you don't have it and in a lot of places people don't have it and so it's important to bear in mind that the nature of free speech is the the acid test for it is
4:52are people you don't like allowed to say things that you don't like otherwise it's not free and can't you it can't be just the things that it can't be just things that you like because eventually somebody's not going to like what you say and they're going to shut you up and that's that that's the essence of free speech and that's why it's the first amendment in this country and if we lose that I think we lose the Bedrock of democracy so the Bedrock of democracy I would imagine is important to everyone in this room and you talk about the importance of freedom of speech yesterday you posted a new policy that
5:33was titled freedom of speech not freedom of reach I got my attention yes tell us about your new policy right so if you know a speech not reach is is important in that you know like if somebody has something hateful to say it doesn't mean you should give them a megaphone they should still be able to say it but it needs to be not then pushed on
6:05people so if you know you can go like in Times Square New York and you can hear people say all kinds of crazy things that's fine but we don't put we don't broadcast that to Earth so if somebody wants to say something that's technically legal but but is you know by most definitions hateful they're not going to get we're not going to promote that to people we're not going to recommend hateful content to people we'll put that behind a warning label saying this this the speech is probably something you you don't want so and now this is something we have to be very careful that we're all out and and that it does not become what is intended to be good does not become bad
6:48so so we want to be delicate with the freedom of reach not speech a freedom of speech not reach so we're taking it easy but it's just yeah if if there's if people are saying things that are you know making you sad or or encouraging negativity then we're not going to amplify that which to Twitter has done in the past so how is how is new policy different from the other platform I don't know the other platforms
7:23[Laughter] I don't use them so that was not a softball question I want to go on record I don't know I mean I think the interesting honestly this is true before the acquisition of Twitter I just I just didn't find the other platforms compelling to be yeah just objectively okay so so back to the new policy for a second because again freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom of reach yeah what does it mean to the advertisers in this room have you de-risked the the opportunity or chance of their campaigns Landing in these awful hateful places yeah I think people may not be aware of this already but we we have adjacency controls in place that are that are really quite effective
8:21so you know it we can just just literally turn on the adjacency control and the ad will not appear next to anything that is remotely negative has that gotten better since you arrived yeah we put a lot of effort into it so the I think there have been some mistakes that have been made where in one case somebody wanted thought they were running a control they've posted a test campaign without the controls in place and they got like 30 negativity it's like you you that should never be done you must put the controls in place because we have excess inventory on negativity so so so this the ad engine will
9:02naturally say oh I've got lots of spots where the negativity so I'm going to give you a very high negative you must put the adjacency controls in place if you do put the condition adjacency controls in place negativity is going to be almost nothing so this is a good early step of your impact since you got to Twitter no yeah yeah absolutely I mean it's worth noting that I mean apple is a remained a major Advertiser Disney has remained a major Advertiser they're literally advertise Children's shows on Twitter and they wouldn't do that if it was filled with hate speech back to the labeling
9:43as what I think some people have talked about if you've said it this way yourself if it's awful but lawful it's going to stay up it just won't see sunlight you won't amplify it but who decides that labeling well we have a set of words [Laughter] so we open source the recommendation
10:08algorithm we're also going to open source the words that that are associated with the the you know freedom of speech not reach and people can argue over the words I think there are you know reasonably accurate and and like I said it is working or or Disney would have pulled their ads a long time ago and haven't so
10:34yeah but I think in order to really build trust you have to have transparency it can't be that here's this black box something's happening here in here we won't tell you what it is trust us I think that's BS if you want to trust something you got to know how it works and so the that's why we're open sourcing the algorithm now open sourcing algorithm is kind of embarrassing people have found all sorts of things that were wrong and foolish and you know misguided with with the algorithm and we've actually fixed I think at this point over 100 issues with the algorithm so it's been it's actually been very helpful to open source it and we're going to open source the entire thing
11:15that you basically should be able to recreate the probability of of a tweet being recommended based on on the on what we've open sourced if you can't recreate it then we haven't shown you everything so it's it's really complete transparency and that I think that's the only path to trust I don't think there's another path so trust is probably one of the top two or three words that every marketing executive in this room would say is table Stakes for any company that they invest in any company that they can move forward with you just talked about transparency open sourcing I would say
11:55that that's the difference between those other platforms you either don't use or never heard of yeah and open sourcing or transparency is again a another one of those table stake requirements but this labeling this new policy talking about if it's awful but not unlawful does it apply to your tweets
12:21wow listen to that yes it does actually it does it does yeah moreover my tweets are also subject to community notes so if I say something incorrect creating a community notes function is actually very effective applies to advertisers too FYI so and there have been a few cases where there's been ads that were not completely accurate and Community nodes has corrected them and they've corrected me and they've corrected heads of state multiple times so community community notes is extremely effective I think that's in yeah and England of the progression of Twitter
13:082.0 and the importance of this new policy and protection for everyone right and you're talking about fully democratizing the platform which which leads you to community notes because you're actually believing in the people who are able to often from the front lines gives their point of view that clarify what some people might say is bias yeah like I said the important thing is that we're an open book so
13:39you can literally see if there's some line of logic that gives me special privileges literally everything there's nothing that is hidden so yeah it's It Whatever obviously it people are not going to trust Twitter if there are different rules for me or others versus the rest of Twitter yeah that's that's that's going to diminish trust so everything that applies to the rest of Twitter must apply to me yeah and I think this is gonna I think it's gonna be extremely powerful and I think it will result in Twitter being the most trusted place on the Internet by far why would you trust anything else yeah and let's talk about why would you trust anyone else especially
14:29the most followed man on Twitter you've gone from consumer of a product you loved to now the owner of a product that yeah like the Hair Club for Men it but you know what if if you're held to the same level of accountability that everyone else is in the platform there are some this this room I think it's the second just to take a beat and talk about you've talked about recently you are maybe almost close to cash flow positive right yeah we're like one our nose is like just okay so maybe a quarter or two away from profitability
15:18people in this in this room are your accelerated path to profitability yeah please advertise on Twitter that would be much appreciated thanks but there's a decent bit of Skeptics in the room what yeah it's never heard of it the guy works in space I didn't hear what's going on there's people who cannot separate or they're challenged by separating the man his opinions and the microphone that he now owns yeah but I I mean look before the acquisition I was the most interacted with account on Twitter so it's not like you know it's actually all that different so before I even announce that acquisition I didn't have the most number of followers but I had the
16:06highest number of interactions on the entire platform before an acquisition offer was even announced and that's when they were like you know Fair number of people at Twitter weren't exactly my best friends so we're eligible for this labeling you've actually unblocked all of your followers I I deleted my block list right you delete your block list you've also been told that you never want to lose your feedback loop specifically your negative feedback
16:44loop yes thankfully at Twitter we'll always provide you with a negative feedback loop I have to push you a little because there's a lot of folks in this room they vote with their pocketbooks and or wallets I should say I like pocketbooks nice ones digital wallets but they can't cross that transom they have a
17:13still holding back from unlocking the full power of Twitter what do you say to them in this room well I think first of all if you want to know what my opinions are you should really I guess look at my Twitter if you read the and and you know take it with a grain of salt because it's hard to convey tone with a tweet so something may be sarcastic or a joke or something like that may come across as serious when it isn't but a lot of the the issue is negative amplification in the media yeah so
17:47yeah you know I recently had an interview with an organization called BBC she may have heard of and that was irritating but you know the reporter was saying claiming that there was all this that hit that that he'd seen all this hate speech on Twitter and I said okay well can you give me a single example and he couldn't not even one so then I say like okay well you know if if your personal experience on Twitter that's how you should judge the platform yeah as opposed to what is represented in in sort of the traditional media and it's important to bear in mind that the traditional media is a competitor to Twitter so they compete for your advertising
18:32dollars they they compete against Twitter we're advertising dollars if it is possible for them to diminish Twitter and reduce the probability of advertising at all is going to Twitter and at first it's like basically you shouldn't take a competitor's word for it yeah like it's it's it doesn't you think I am aimless most news organizations well maybe a little okay most news organizations have a codependent relationship with Twitter and I can I I could speak on behalf of the industry but I'll speak on behalf of my own company we have a big partnership with your company big distribution partnership are there days where I see some of your tweets and I say I wish I could say stop
19:20helping the situation but should you be held to a different or a higher standard that you're the owner but you also have the most followers and a lot of people think you might be too provocative no I think the same standard should apply to me as applies to everyone on Twitter just as it is on positive or negative so what do you do same for everyone now another thing that that a lot of traditional journalists don't like is they don't like being put on the same platform as the average citizen they don't like their voice being it's the same they're pretty mad about that yes I there are several news organizations who don't like your push for democratization and what they believe is
20:07the devaluing of the badges because they were differentiated so is that just a moment does not just a moment in time no that's libert I think it's very important for to to elevate citizen journalism I think it's very important to hear the voice of the people the actual voice of the people not the filter voice of the people and let the people choose the narrative and let the people determine the truth and not five editors in Chiefs of major Publications do you do you want to know what's really going on or do you want their opinion you know it's a handful of people I think if I think we want to know the voice of the people the true voice of the people
20:49so let's let me kind of pull you back into what's important until in this room and that's protection for their ad campaigns sure so yesterday was a great start protection from any of the provocative speech that is labeled what is your does it get better from there what's your real North Star where is where is Twitter a couple of years from now when I show up on Twitter is it just a global Town Square where I'm talking in number of characters or or where does it evolve to what happens in my town square Commerce yeah I mean what I've said is that Twitter is effectively an accelerant to an idea I've had for a long time which is I call it sort of X the everything
21:38app yeah which is to have and you know a sort of a platform that is so useful that you you find it it is essential to conduct your life so that means like you know we do obviously payments we provide it really really make a good meaningful communication privately as well as publicly so that means we need to have direct message system that is that offers voice calls video calls encrypted communication so that your Communications are private and and Twitter and others cannot spy on them and just to be incredibly useful
22:28so you've got a massive platform you have a vision yeah that is a spectrum of just daily open sourced conversation and and they can conduct their lives their business their Commerce whatever they can do on your platform that's a pretty big vision but but in the middle should be advertising opportunity that sounds like a great opportunity I can talk about my brand I can get my customers to communicate and then they could also buy stuff that sounds pretty good right you'll be able to buy things just directly on Twitter one click where I'm done but they need to feel that there is a an
23:11opportunity for them to influence what you're building that Vision what we're doing here whether it's me trying to push in prod you on your tweets for example you've said you probably shouldn't tweet after 3 A.M well I've got probably good advice for all of us I've got myself into trouble a few times I'm I'm very aware of those so after 3 A.M you travel all over the world Lord knows how you handle time zones in space will you commit to be a little more specific and not tweet after 3am people in this room would would like to see that they'll make them feel more confident I will aspire to tweet to less after 3 A.M but I mean it is important that you know I mean if I
24:03were to say yes you can influence me that would be wrong that would be very wrong that means that would be a diminishment of freedom of speech but I want to be specific about influencing it's more of an open feedback for the advertising experts in this room to help develop Twitter into a place where they will be excited about investing more money product development and safety sure content moderation that's what the influence is yeah I think
24:39it's totally cool to say that you want to have your advertising appear in certain places in Twitter and not in other places but it is not cool to to try to say what Twitter will do and if that means losing advertising dollars we lose it but freedom of speech is Paramount so who had a very well populated much loved
25:13influence Council I know I don't I I think we need to change the name Elon does not want to be influenced but it was really a recurring feedback loop from your key stakeholders your advertisers where they had recurring access or would have recurring access to you would you commit from this stage today to reinstate that Council to be named later well I don't think it should be influence Council that because I would be worried about creating a backlash among the public because if the public thinks that that you know their their views are being determined by you know a a small number of CMOS in America they will be like I think upset about that but feedback I
26:02think is appropriate and you know at the other day if somebody's spending money for their ad campaign it needs to yield results for their organization or or it doesn't make sense and you know that that that includes the sort of software perception issues as well as the more direct does it move the needle on sales so you know there's this legitimate concerns that advertisers have that I want to hear and we're going to move to live q a after the prepared questions and perhaps you can ask some of those right here because I think some of these things should be discussed in an open Forum you know yeah so I think having you know getting I mean the reason I'm here is to get feedback
26:54but you know what what is this but feedback you know and and to be asked questions and what we're trying to achieve here a sensible you know middle ground or or try to satisfy a a range of things which is how do we ensure that the public has their voice even if you don't like the voice at times but also that you're able to
27:23serve your Brands and improve improve the perception of your Brands and improve sales as well at the at the end of the day I mean I think there is when advertising is relevant to users and especially if the message is entertaining and interesting it's content on and then the other side of it if if the if the if the ad is not relevant to the user and it's you know perhaps strident or something then then obviously that's that's not that's that's that spam so advertising can go all the way from spam to compelling content and I really want to focus on obviously the compelling content side of things make it relevant make it interesting you know funny informative
28:16and I think I think you're right I think that's actually where this room can help with the feedback they're experts in knowing with the right consumer set that they're trying to reach what is relevant what makes good advertising and since I think I heard that you committed to continued feedback it might be a good time like Twitter which is where it happens in real time to open up the room to questions Elon has suggested that he's open okay
28:52we have a few so please ask Elon you want to go okay one of the things I should say is that that has been sort of really broken for a long time and Twitter is is that when you run an ad campaign you couldn't even do basic things like keywords yeah like honestly this is it blew my mind so we've now added to to where you can say what what as as simple as it
29:19sounds what keywords do you want an ad to appear next to so if a tweet has a certain you know is about a subject then you should be able to put the ad right there and I was talking to David's aslav at you know one is and he was he was he was saying look I just want to be able to put the trailer for White Lotus next to where people are talking about White Lotus I was like yeah that is obviously a good thing to do that is the right place to put the ad and so as mind-blowing as it is Twitter did not have that functionality until recently which is insane but now it does so you know talking about listening to you know a key Advertiser Partners listen to what
30:11David said we're like we're doing it so for now Bingo have White Lotus ads next to White Lotus discussions which is exactly where it should be so it's a new beginning all right all right we're going to start thank you on your side Elon thank you so much over to your left here my name is Jonathan Berry I'm from the Dunhill family office and the earth trust fund focused on regenerative Innovation and exponential technology I'm absolutely obsessed with the work that you're doing in the world thank you for incarnating in this lifetime and helping all of us Ascend to the next level of this experience of life I'm curious about your thoughts on alignment with AI and what are the
30:52strategies that are currently being implemented I'm currently creating my own alignment protocol which I would love to submit to your team I like it well I wasn't expecting an AI discussion right off the bat my brother and I have this this rule that if we're at a party we're not allowed to talk to talk about either AI or the simulation because otherwise the conversations go there so often so I've been thinking about AI safety for a long time because I think this is a significant existential threat to humanity the best thing I can come up with for AI safety is to make it a maximum truth seeking AI maximally curious
31:42have its optimization function be to understand the nature of the universe if that is its automation optimization function I think it will actually want to preserve and extend human civilization because we're just much more interesting than say an asteroid with nothing on it so I think I think I think my intuition my biological neural net suggests that a maximally curious AI is the safest Ai and a maximally true seeking AI is a safest Ai and if you try to you know we have to be careful with the alignment stuff or we have to you know and I think we we definitely don't want to teach an AI to lie because that that is a path to a dystopian future the I
32:26mean the the essence of of 2001 A Space Odyssey was that the AI was given was basically told to lie it was it was it was told to hide the the fact that it was going to see the monolith was that I was taking the crew to the monolith so it was both told to take the crew to the monolith and the crew cannot know about the monolith the conclusion the AI came to was kill the crew and take them to the monolith so so problem solved so you want to be really careful about any any kind of deception and I think an AI we want to program the eye to be as truthful as possible even even if that truth is not politically correct healing amazing to be here my name is
33:11martinus I work in news media and my question is is you're saying Twitter is where we're going to be getting our information from now on or social media is this the end of centralized Publishers news media and we're going into decentralized information era thank you no that's that's good observation that that I so you know citizen journalism is is essentially decentralized news
33:44now that now this will will obviously be if somebody is a great writer for the New York Times or journal or post or whatever newspaper Harold if they're a good great writer they will still gain a significant following as a function of their excellent writing so somebody who's an exit writer will will still get disproportionate attention but I think it is also important for us to to decentralize the you know what is written and and what the narrative what narratives are chosen because even if everything in a newspaper is 100 correct they're still choosing what to write about they're choosing the narrative so I think it's important for the public to be able to choose narrative as
34:31well so it's not really you know that traditional Publications go away but really that we we we give give more weight we we enable the voice of the people to rise hi Linda Elon thank you so much for your insightful talk my name is Maria I run PRN marketing company focused on Tech and web3 I live here in Miami but originally from Russia I wanted to ask you two questions if you allow me first one why did you make Blue Tick verification tick on Twitter paid is it strictly for profit or there was some other logic behind it and second question is can I take a selfie with you hahaha well I think there might be quite a line on the selfie front but honestly a selfie is the vein of my
35:36existence so but sure [Laughter] so no the the the the the issue with the the way that blue checks were handed out historically at Twitter was was not in a not always in a sensible way or not always in a a good way and so and the same check was given out whether you were sort of a government official or you know a major company or a person so there's notice there was no really indistinguishment between between what what does a blue check mean and a lot of blue checks were you know you could have been an intern at a small publication 10 years ago and you still have a blue check and then a lot of them were for sale and not not for sale on the dark web I'm
36:31talking about you could Google blue check for sale and buy a blue check anyone could and there was some corruption within Twitter as well in terms of paying people at Twitter for blue checks that was not appropriate so the question is how do we clear all of that out and how do we create a you know within recent a Level Playing Field so that like I said the average citizen can be a journalist and if and and that and that really want to judge journalism we want to judge stories based on the quality of the content not the publication that is behind it and there are some incredibly good individuals who may who maybe couldn't get a job at a major newspaper but actually
37:20they're great writers and they're incredibly truthful and and good so it was really just to kind of level the playing field and the thing about the you know you can get one for like seven dollars a month if you do it on the web which is it's not a lot but it it gives us the the the added
37:40elements of requiring a credit card and a phone number from a reputable carrier and so this this is a I mean we're gonna get kind of technical here but it's a it's a necessary defense against bots so today with Advanced AI the the they can pass every kind of test for a human so you can actually create on one computer a hundred thousand accounts so then how that all sound human and past every human test so how do you know which one's real so effectively by charging a small amount of money and requiring a credit card and a phone number we increase the cost of a fake account by literally a thousand if not ten thousand and so and my prediction is that
38:36any social media company that does not require a small amount of money and does not do verification will cease to be relevant I mean I I think to talk forever if you want one more so it's not up to me it's really up to you guys if I'm happy to talk longer if you want hi my name is Carol Crist and I had the great honor to serve as first lady of Florida and it's an incredible honor to be here with all of you and this beautiful conference and this is an extraordinary panel and this discussion and the great work you do for Humanity or planet and I'm just so impressed with everything you're doing at Twitter and how open you are with everything you're doing I think it's a
39:24great service to our country in the world and I I really am very grateful for to you for that and it may be a little depressing but we do have an election year coming up and it's incredibly important well not yet Politics the world is watching and it's an incredibly important time a lot is at stake and I would love to know what you I'm sure you have a lot going on and I would love to hear something hey and what we can look forward to hearing from Twitter thank you so much yeah I I mean I do think it's very important for elections domestically and internationally that we have an open and transparent platform that's why I think it's just the open sourcing the algorithm
40:09and complete transparency is essential so that people know what's going on they know that something is not being artificially suppressed or Amplified and so we and and as I mentioned when we open sourced the recommendation algorithm now there's still other elements of Twitter that haven't been open source but will be that we've the the public found many errors in in our recommendation platform that we fixed and we'll keep doing that the what really matters is does the is there both the reality and the perception of a platform that the public believes they can that they can trust
40:56and and and like I said if you don't have trans in anything that's not any platform that does not have transparency I wouldn't trust it with a damn so I think we heard today first of all Elon has committed to being accessible to everyone for continual feedback he's also opened up himself to also participate in the new transparency and
41:27safety rules that they posted yesterday just remember right freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom of reach and if freedom of speech as he says is the Bedrock of of this country I'm not sure there's anyone in this room who could disagree with that could I get a round of applause for that yeah but I want to be clear the path here today wasn't without a lot of chatter because this guy is here there's always a lot of chatter but I believe if this is a marketing conference for Marketing Executives that influence culture in this country it is the responsibility of everybody in this room to offer a helping hand and to say how can we help how can we make it better
42:20so I say we're open for Solutions and you got a man who's committed to try his best not to tweet after 3 A.M but open to your feedback and I'd like to really thank everyone who's spending their time here today thank you thank you
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版