访谈·中文精读

Gript 专访马斯克:谈爱尔兰仇恨言论法案

Gript interviews Elon Musk on Irish hate speech bill

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

爱尔兰正在推一部法案,法案里给"仇恨"下了这样一个定义:仇恨,指基于若干特定特征而产生的仇恨。

用被定义的词,去定义它自己。

马斯克(Elon Musk)在 Gript Media 的这次专访里,把这条定义拎出来讲了两遍。他的意思很直接:定义是循环的,边界就是空的;边界空了,执法的裁量空间就无限大。

这次访谈发生在 2024 年 1 月。话题从爱尔兰的《仇恨言论法案》起步,一路聊到欧洲版"推特文件"、虚假信息监管、气候与农民、出生率崩塌,最后收在荷马史诗上。信息量很密,值得慢慢拆。

一部法案,可以让你手机里的表情包变成罪证

先把法案本身的机制讲清楚,否则后面所有的争论都落不了地。

爱尔兰政府正在推动的这项立法,核心是刑事化"煽动仇恨"或者"可能煽动仇恨的表达"。听起来是常识性的东西,没人会公开说"我支持煽动仇恨"。

问题出在文本上。法案写的是:仇恨,指基于 X、Y、Z 等特征产生的仇恨。

马斯克对这条定义的评价是:

你谈的是一份连"仇恨"这个词都没有定义的法案。法案的文本说,仇恨指的是基于某些特征而产生的仇恨,这显然是循环定义。它含糊到了几乎可以套用到任何人可能表达的任何观点上。(马斯克)

批评者的担忧在这里:一旦定义是开放的,裁量权就交给了执法者和官僚系统,理论上,你因为表达几乎任何观点而被追诉,都不再是不可能的事。

马斯克把后果说得更极端:

它极端到,你可能因为手机里存了一个不合时宜的表情包而被送进监狱。这太荒谬了。(马斯克)

这句话在传播中被当成夸张修辞。把它放回法案文本里看,它描述的是一条可以走通的逻辑路径。定义有多宽,追诉的可能性就有多宽。

为什么一个美国人要管爱尔兰的事

主持人问了一个很实在的问题:你关注的通常是大科技、是美国这样的超级大国层面的审查问题,为什么会盯上一个人口五百万的国家的地方立法?

马斯克的回答来自阅读经验:

一般来说,任何可能出现在乔治·奥威尔(George Orwell)小说里的术语,你都该警惕。这类法案的命名方式通常听起来无害,听起来像"当然啦,谁会不支持这个"。但你一看细节,往往和法案标题说的正好相反。(马斯克)

接着是他真正的论点,也是整场访谈里最锋利的一段:

如果政府被赋予宽泛的权力去定义什么是仇恨言论,他们很容易把支持执政党的东西定义为没问题,把不支持执政党的东西定义为仇恨言论。所以这实际上是当权者巩固权力的一种方式。(马斯克)

这段话的真正分量在制度设计层面。任何一条边界模糊的禁令,落到执行层面都会面临同一个问题:谁来判断?答案永远是当时在位的人。换一届政府,判断标准就换一套。规则看起来是中立的,执行起来跟着权力走。

他反复强调"看细节不看标题",原因也在这里。标题是给公众看的,细节是给执行者用的。

瓦尔卡德说他作秀,他回了一句关于办公室地址的话

几个月前马斯克在 X 上提到,公司可能会在法庭上挑战这项立法。

爱尔兰总理(Taoiseach)利奥·瓦拉德卡(Leo Varadkar)的回应相当不客气。原话是:

我怀疑他根本不知道自己说的是什么意思,只是在作秀。(利奥·瓦拉德卡)

主持人把这句话原封不动搬到了马斯克面前,问他:总理说对了吗,你是在作秀,还是真的打算挑战?

马斯克的回答从公司架构讲起:

我们的默认做法是,任何侵犯人们表达权利的立法,我们都会去挑战。就诉讼资格(standing)而言,我们的欧洲总部就在爱尔兰,都柏林有一个很大的办公室,在爱尔兰有相当规模的存在。所以我们显然有资格。我们还会为想要挑战这项法案的爱尔兰公民支付律师费。如果有人认为可以压制爱尔兰人民的声音,我们会尽最大努力去捍卫爱尔兰人民表达自己的权利。(马斯克)

这段回应里有两层信息。

第一层是法律技术层面的:X 的欧洲总部设在都柏林,这在欧盟监管框架下是常识。总部在爱尔兰,意味着它在爱尔兰有法人实体、有资产、有业务,诉讼资格这件事不需要绕弯子。

第二层是策略层面的:公司自己去告,同时出钱帮本地公民去告。 这个做法绕开了"外国公司干涉内政"的指责框架,把诉讼主体换成了爱尔兰人自己。

补一句背景。爱尔兰长期是谷歌、Meta、苹果、X 等公司的欧洲总部所在地,都柏林码头区因此得了个外号叫"硅谷码头"(Silicon Docks)。这个身份在这次访谈里反复出现,它同时是商业理由,也是法律理由。

美国有第一修正案,爱尔兰没有

主持人顺势提了一个更有攻击性的方向:既然总部在爱尔兰,那要不要做一次"X 文件"(X Files)?把 Twitter 时期和欧洲、爱尔兰政府官员之间的往来邮件翻出来,尤其是疫情期间关于"虚假信息与误导信息标签"的那些。

他提到很多人的猜测:这些标签系统在被当局使用的时候,未必总是达到了公众期待的标准。

马斯克的回答很干脆:

当然可以。但我可以很有把握地说,我们在美国文件里发现的东西,在欧洲是一样的。美国政府曾大规模干预言论。(马斯克)

接着他讲了一个关键的法律差异,这个差异决定了同样的事情在两地会有完全不同的性质:

美国有宪法修正案禁止政府侵犯言论自由。第一修正案就是言论自由修正案。所以在美国,政府压制人民言论是完全违法的。而爱尔兰和少数其他国家没有这样的修正案。所以在爱尔兰做过的事情,可能实际上并不违法。但疫情期间是否存在压制言论的企图?你几乎可以百分之百地假定存在。我严重怀疑爱尔兰和美国会有什么不同。(马斯克)

这段话里有一层区分容易被忽略:"合法"和"正当"是两件事。

在美国,政府施压平台删帖是违法的,所以有宪法层面的刹车。在爱尔兰,因为缺少同等的宪法条款,同样的施压行为可能完全不触犯法律。

他也解释了为什么不愿意一直翻旧账:

我们确实想往前走,不想一直挖旧 Twitter 的东西。打今天和明天的仗,不打昨天的仗。但你提到的那件事值得担心:如果爱尔兰议会通过一部法案,把仇恨言论定义为他们认为是仇恨言论的东西,人们应该高度警惕。因为那就等于把自己交到执政党和他们安排的那些官僚手里,任其摆布。(马斯克)

你想让骗子来定义什么叫撒谎吗

访谈在这里拐进了一个更普遍的概念:虚假信息。

主持人列举了爱尔兰的具体机构。在欧盟《数字服务法案》(Digital Services Act)框架下,爱尔兰设立了媒体委员会(Coimisiún na Meán),另外还有选举委员会。这类机构在欧洲、北美、澳大利亚越来越多,共同特征是拥有法定权力,可以在特定时刻,比如选举期间,下架它们认定为虚假的信息。

他还提到一位最高法院法官的说法:言论自由的权利,需要和"不被错误信息误导的权利"相平衡。

马斯克的回应从词义切入,整场访谈里最漂亮的一次拆解就出现在这里:

你去看"虚假信息"(disinformation)这个词的定义,它和"谎言"是同义词。所以当政客说他们要监管虚假信息时,说的其实是让政客来监管撒谎。如果他们真的这么表述,我认为人们的反应会完全不同。(马斯克)

主持人接了一句,马斯克顺势推到底:

你想让骗子来定义什么叫撒谎吗?这看起来不像是个明智的做法。很多时候大家都知道某些人在刻意欺骗。让众所周知的骗子来定义什么是撒谎,这很荒谬。(马斯克)

关于"不被错误信息误导的权利",他的回答回到了程序层面:

这话表面上听起来很好。但谁来决定什么是错误信息、什么是虚假信息?重点是要有一场开放、清晰的辩论。如果某个东西是错误信息,那就提供反驳,这是最好的方式,公开辩论。(马斯克)

这里藏着一条很少被讲清楚的判断标准:面对错误信息,有两种处理方式。一种是让它消失,一种是让反驳出现。

前一种做法预设有人有资格判定真假,后一种做法预设公众有能力自己判断。选哪一种,本质上是在选你相信谁。

社区笔记的机制:先让吵架的人达成一致

马斯克把 X 的社区笔记(Community Notes)当成前一种思路的替代品,并且花了不少篇幅解释它的运作原理,因为这套机制的细节确实反直觉。

社区笔记的运作方式是,历史上持不同意见的人必须对一条笔记达成一致,这条笔记才会被显示出来。这条原则非常重要,我认为它非常强大。如果历史上意见相左的人都同意这条笔记是对的,它才会出现。所以我认为这是真相的一股极其强大的力量,比任何报纸或传统媒体都准确得多。(马斯克)

把机制拆开看,它做了一件很巧妙的事:判定真假的权力,从任何单一方手里被拿走,换成了跨立场共识。

普通的事实核查是:我认定你说的不对,然后打上标签。社区笔记是:要让一群平时互相看不顺眼的人都点头,这条笔记才能上线。后者的成本高得多,可被操纵的空间也小得多。

接下来他谈传统媒体,用的词比较重:

媒体最大的谎言是叙事的选择。因为他们可以简单地忽略任何他们不喜欢的东西,也可以过度聚焦他们想谈的东西。而我认为,谈什么、聚焦什么,这个选择权应该属于人民,少数几个编辑不该握着它。(马斯克)

这句话点出了一个很少被讨论的层面。假新闻是可验证的,一条具体的错误报道可以被指出、被更正。选择不报道是无法被证伪的,你没法证明一条没写出来的报道本来应该写。

所以他的判断是:真正影响公众认知的,往往落在"决定不写什么"上,写错一条反倒排在后面。

主持人顺着这个逻辑追问战争中的信息问题:以色列、巴勒斯坦、乌克兰,propaganda 在各方之间全方位流动,普通人几乎不可能搞清楚发生了什么。X 上流传的虚假信息,你怎么回应?

马斯克的回答是速度和可反驳性:

首先我认为 X 上的信息是迄今为止最新的。就像我说的,任何人在平台上发布任何说法,你都可以立刻回复反驳。如果有人发了一个帖子,你可以即时回复进行驳斥。还有社区笔记,机制非常严格。(马斯克)

然后是那句最不留余地的话:

如果有人说虚假信息多得多,每次我向他们要例子,他们从来举不出来。所以我会说他们在撒谎。他们要么在撒谎,要么根本不知道自己在说什么。(马斯克)

主持人追问了一句:"是蠢,还是坏?"(Fools or liars?)这个二选一的问法,倒是把整段对话的棱角保留了下来。

气候问题只剩下一个变量

话题转到能源。主持人提到爱尔兰的电网运营商 Eirgrid 已经预警,未来若干年每年冬天都会出现电力短缺。而爱尔兰同时是大量数据中心和科技公司的所在地,用电需求还在涨。

马斯克先给自己的立场做了个铺垫:

我肯定自认为是一个环保主义者。很难说还有谁比我为可持续能源和环境做得更多。所以我在这个领域说话是有些权威的。(马斯克)

然后他给出了一套极简的判断框架,这套框架和主流气候话语的重心明显不一样:

对环境来说,真正重要的只有一件事:我们从地下取出多少亿吨二氧化碳,排放到大气中。把深埋地下的碳取出来放到大气里,最终一定会造成大气的变化。所以我们确实要走向可持续能源经济,限制从地下取碳。但只有这一件事重要。甲烷不重要,甲烷很快降解成二氧化碳,最终都会变成二氧化碳。本质上就是我们往地表循环里加了多少碳。(马斯克)

这套框架把气候问题压缩成一个单一的度量:碳的净搬家量。

在他看来,其他所有议题,甲烷也好,畜牧业也好,农业方式也好,都是这个主变量下面的噪音。他给出的结论很直接:

完全没必要对农业做任何改变。改变农业对环境没有任何影响。这完全没问题。停止攻击农民。他们可以继续做他们正在做的事。(马斯克)

关于时间尺度,他也给了自己的判断,这一点常被忽略:

在我看来,二氧化碳和全球变暖的风险,从长期看,比如五十年或更长时间,是有意义的。我不认为短期内是风险。但把仍然主要基于碳氢化合物的经济,转型成以风能、太阳能、核能为主的可持续能源,需要很长时间。我实际上是核能的坚定支持者。核裂变是好的,水电、地热也一样。这些都是可持续的。事情没那么复杂,我们总体上应该朝可持续能源经济的方向走。(马斯克)

注意这里的顺序:长期有意义,短期不是风险,转型需要时间。这三个判断连起来,指向一种务实的时间表。他反对的是在这条转型路径上,附加那些对结果毫无贡献、却要农民承担成本的措施。

十亿美元的赌注:少养 20 万头牛,你测不出来

主持人接了一个非常具体的本地议题:爱尔兰有提案要削减牲畜数量,大约减少 20 万头牛。

马斯克的回答只有一个词:

零。(马斯克)

然后他把它展开:

从字面意义上说,你甚至测不出来。如果有人说他们能测出来,那我想听听那个测量数字是多少。我赌十亿美元,你根本测不出来。十亿美元,赌你测不出来。影响就是小到这个程度。(马斯克)

这个赌约是修辞手法,作用很实在:它把争论从"你支持不支持环保"拉回到"你怎么测量"。

前者是立场之争,吵不出结果。后者是技术问题,有明确答案。

他的逻辑链在前面已经铺好了:如果气候问题的唯一主变量是全球碳的净搬家量,那么一个国家的 20 万头牛在这个总量里的占比小到无法在测量精度内被识别。为一个这样的数量级去牺牲一整个农业部门的生计,投入产出比不成立。

这套论证里有一个隐含前提,值得读者自己判断:他把全球总量当作分母。如果用国家排放清单作为分母,20 万头牛的占比会大一些。分母怎么选,结论就怎么变。这一点他没在访谈里展开。

世界人口没有爆炸,正在暴跌

主持人提到爱尔兰负责养老金的部长希瑟·汉弗莱斯(Heather Humphreys)。他问过她政府打算怎么应对人口结构问题,对方的反应是:确认政府没有在做任何事,而且似乎觉得这个问题本身很奇怪,没意识到它对未来社会服务的影响。

主持人问马斯克:如果面对这样的立法者,你会怎么解释这件事的重要性?

他先纠正了一个普遍印象:

首先,大多数人仍然误以为世界人口在快速增长。事实并非如此。在大多数国家,人口在暴跌。而且应该说,出生率每年都在暴跌。人口之所以还没有暴跌,唯一的原因是人们在活得更久。仅此而已。(马斯克)

接着他讲人口统计学为什么是一道"简单题":

用人口统计学预测世界的未来非常容易。你只要知道明年有多少婴儿出生,就立刻知道二十年后有多少成年人。所以不需要成为统计学专家才能理解二十年后的人口会是什么样。你只要把出生人数乘以预期寿命,大致就是这个人口随时间的变化。(马斯克)

这个观察的分量在于:人口是所有长期预测里最确定的一项,因为它的输入端已经发生了。 二十年后的劳动力,取决于今天的产房,不取决于今天的政策辩论。

然后是结论:

几乎每个国家,事实上我认为几乎所有发达经济体国家,出生率都低于替代率。有些情况下只有替代率的一半。如果一个国家的出生率是替代率的一半,那意味着每一代后继人口都只有上一代的一半。而且情况比这更惨,因为留下来的人会非常老。于是一个国家基本上会变成一个养老院。(马斯克)

"国家变成养老院"这个比喻在修辞上并不夸张,它描述的是一个具体的结构:劳动人口萎缩,需要照护的人口膨胀,税基缩小,支出上升。这个组合在财政上没有软着陆的路径。

成人纸尿裤与婴儿纸尿裤的比值

他给了一个让人无法忘记的指标:

衡量任何一个国家,一个很好的指标是成人纸尿裤与婴儿纸尿裤的销量比值。这个转折点很关键。在日本,成人纸尿裤的销量超过婴儿纸尿裤,我想那是十多年前的事了,而他们的出生率从那时起变得更糟。(马斯克)

这个指标之所以有效,是因为它绕开了所有话语层面的争论,直接反映人口结构。纸尿裤销量不做宣传,不说立场,只记录事实。

然后是整场访谈里语气最重的一段:

文明会以一声巨响终结,还是一声呜咽?这场争论由来已久。而现在,它 threatened to die with a whimper in adult diapers,也就是以一声呜咽、在成人纸尿裤里终结。这个场景极其惨淡。(马斯克)

主持人接了一句:我宁愿轰轰烈烈地死。

对,至少轰轰烈烈地死很酷。一场大爆炸之类的,你还能像动作英雄一样走掉。我想到的是在养老院里患着阿尔茨海默症、穿着成人纸尿裤死去,那太惨了。所以出生率真的很重要。我不是说我们应该大幅扩张人口,但我认为至少应该把数字维持在原来的水平,目标是略有增长。这看起来是个合理的目标。大多数国家在做的正相反,那是人口自由落体。(马斯克)

这里有个细节值得留意:他明确说了"我不是说应该大幅扩张人口"。这个限定很重要,因为他的观点经常被简化成"多生孩子"的口号。他真正主张的目标很温和:守住替代率,最好略有增长,避免自由落体。

回到主持人最初的问题:怎么跟一个觉得这问题很奇怪的部长解释?

访谈里没有给出逐句的话术。从他的论证结构看,说服路径大致如此:不讲价值观,讲算术。不讲"我们应该多生孩子",讲"二十年后有多少劳动人口,这是今天已经确定的事"。

他把《伊利亚特》叫作史上最好的故事

访谈最后转到一个轻松的话题。马斯克此前曾称荷马的《伊利亚特》(Iliad)是史上最好的故事,主持人问他为什么。

他的回答从类型入手:

它基本上是一个动作故事,一部动作电影,具备你想在电影里看到的所有元素。斯巴达王后坠入爱河然后离开了,整个斯巴达和希腊去把她夺回来。里面有很多英雄式的战斗。我们在电影里看到的很多东西,其实都来自《伊利亚特》。(马斯克)

接着他点了两个具体的人物设定:

有阿喀琉斯,一个不可思议的战士,但他有一个弱点,经典的阿喀琉斯之踵。而且他容易让情绪控制自己。还有一个不可思议的场景:父亲来赎回儿子的尸体,哀求阿喀琉斯。(马斯克)

他指的应该是《伊利亚特》第二十四卷,特洛伊老王普里阿摩斯(Priam)夜入希腊军营,跪在阿喀琉斯面前,亲吻那双杀了他儿子赫克托尔的手。那是西方文学里最早、也最难写的一场共情戏:一个失去儿子的父亲,和一个知道自己必死的人,在同一个帐篷里哭。

他还给了具体的阅读建议:

我推荐企鹅出版社的有声书版本,因为它本来就是口头传诵的,拿来默读就浪费了。企鹅的《伊利亚特》有声版非常出色。(马斯克)

这个建议有文本依据。《伊利亚特》成文之前是口传史诗,六音步格律本身就是为吟诵设计的。当成小说默读,会丢掉一半的信息。

主持人反手推荐了爱尔兰史诗《夺牛记》(Táin Bó Cúailnge),说类型相近。马斯克接受了这个推荐。

这段对话放在整场访谈的末尾,看起来像闲聊,其实和前面的主题是同一条线。一个社会如果只剩下对当下的争论,没有共同的故事,它也就没有延续下去的理由。 出生率讲的是一代人愿不愿意把世界交给下一代,《伊利亚特》讲的是一个文明愿意把什么交给下一代。两者说的是同一件事。

这场访谈能留下什么

把整场内容拆完,能看到一条反复出现的方法:不看标签,看定义;不看标题,看条款;不看立场,看测量。

用在他批评的法案上,就是去读"仇恨"到底怎么定义的。用在他批评的虚假信息监管上,就是去问"谁有资格判定"。用在气候政策上,就是去问"这个措施能测出多少吨碳"。用在人口问题上,就是去看出生人数,别只看总人口。

同一种方法,套在五个完全不同的议题上。

这大概也是这次访谈最值得带走的东西。它对具体议题的判断可以商榷,比如气候问题的分母怎么选、农业减排的账怎么算,都有更细的讨论空间。那套追问方式本身,倒是可以直接拿来用。

下面几条,是这场访谈里可以马上用起来的:

  • 遇到任何一部以"打击 XX"命名的法案,先去找它的定义条款。如果关键概念是循环定义,用被定义的词定义它自己,那就说明边界是开放的,裁量权在执行者手里。
  • 听到"虚假信息""错误信息"这类指控时,只问一句:请举一个具体例子。给不出例子的指控,可以直接归到"不知道自己在说什么"那一栏。
  • 判断一条信息是否可信,别只看它是否被标注,要看它是否经得起反驳。能即时回复、能公开反驳的平台,比只有单向发布的渠道更接近真相。
  • 评估任何气候政策,先锁定一个指标:它能减少多少吨从地下取出的碳。如果一个措施在这个指标上测不出变化,那它产生的是别的东西,跟气候无关。
  • 关心人口问题,看出生人数和替代率。总人口因为寿命延长还会涨一段时间,这个数字会掩盖真实的趋势。
  • 跟不关心人口问题的决策者沟通,别讲价值观,讲算术。二十年后有多少劳动人口,取决于今天有多少婴儿出生,这件事已经确定,无法通过政策追赶。
  • 给自己的信息源做一次"纸尿裤测试":找一两个不会被立场污染、也不会被宣传修饰的硬指标,用来校准你在话语层面听到的一切。
  • 找时间读一遍《伊利亚特》,或者听企鹅的有声版。一个文明愿意反复讲的故事,通常比它当下的政策辩论更能说明它相信什么。
语音识别自动转录(Whisper),含全部发言人,可能有识别错误。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。

0:00Well, welcome everybody. We are here with Mr Elon Musk of SpaceX and Tesla fame. And today he's going to be speaking with us about the Irish hate speech bill and related free speech issues. And it's very good to have you here, Elon, because I know you and I have been speaking about doing this interview for a little while now,

0:20because free speech is obviously an issue you've spoken quite a bit about in the past. So thank you so much for taking the time to discuss it. You're welcome. Yeah, I think it's pretty obvious that free speech is the bedrock of democracy. And if you lack free speech, it's impossible to have a proper democratic process because people

0:41are not aware of the fact. So well, they may be misled. So you'll have to be able to speak in mind within the context of the law. And without that, you don't have a real democracy. Yeah, so specifically then regarding the Irish context, what was it that made you sit up and take an interest in the Irish hate speech bill specifically?

1:08Because of course, you've focused on issues of censorship at a big international level when it comes to big tech and things in superpowers like America. seems unusual, but welcome that somebody of your stature, shall we say, would focus on a bill in a country like Ireland. Yeah.

1:32Well, generally, you want to be concerned about anything that, you know, any terminology that could fit in a Georgia or well novel. And they're not going to, these bills will generally be named in ways that sound innocuous and sound like, sure, why wouldn't anyone support that. But when you look at the details, it's often the opposite of what the title of the bull is.

2:00So if the government is given broad powers to define what hate speech is, they can easily define things that support the ruling party, define hate speech as anything that doesn't support the ruling party effectively. So it is a way for whoever is in charge to cement their power.

2:32Well, I think on that, there's probably many people from abroad who aren't aware of the situation here at Ireland, but for those who might not know, the government here is currently trying to pass a piece of legislation which would criminalize incitement to hatred or expressions that could incite hatred.

2:55But you're talking about a piece of legislation that doesn't even define the word hatred. When you look at the text of the bill, it says that hatred means hatred on the basis of X, Y, and Z characteristic, which is obviously a circular definition. So it's incredibly vague and ambiguous to the point where it could potentially be applied

3:17to almost any view that somebody could express. And this is what many critics of the bill have been saying for some time that it opens the whole of discourse up to legal scrutiny potentially where you could be prosecuted for expressing almost anything hypothetically. Yeah. I mean, I'm not.

3:37I mean, why is that? I mean, it's so extreme that you could be put in prison for having the wrong meme on your phone. And that's insane. Well, on that, when you first started tweeting about this legislation a few months ago, you seem to indicate that your company ex might challenge the billing court.

4:01And in response, our T-Shock, which is like the Irish Prime Minister, Leo Veradkar, he He dismissed your suggestion and he said that you need to have legal standing to do that. And he said, and I quote, I suspect he doesn't know what he means and is just showboating. So now that I have you here, is the Irish teacher correct?

4:19Were you just showboating or do you intend to challenge this bill if it becomes law? Well, our default approach is to challenge any legislation that infringes upon the people's ability to say what they want to say. So at Rio of C.F. standings, it's our European headquarters are in Ireland. So we have a big office in Ireland, a major president in

4:48Ireland. So we obviously have standing. And we will also fund the legal fees of the of Irish citizens that want to challenge the bull as well. So we'll make sure that if there's an attempt to suppress the voice of the Irish people that we do are absolutely best to defend the people of Ireland and their ability to speak on mind.

5:17So on that you obviously mentioned that X's headquarters in Europe is based in Ireland. And so that naturally raises the question of a kind of a, I mean, previously it would have been the Twitter files. Now it's supposed to be the X files. The potential of delving into some of the correspondence

5:38that Twitter would have had with European and Irish government officials throughout periods like the COVID pandemic, for example, because there's been many, there's been a lot of suggestion that things like so-called misinformation and disinformation labeling systems might not have always been used to the standard that one would

6:01.. hope they would be used to buy authorities in terms of.. how they choose to label certain pieces of information .. and and so many people have.. speculated that there's a lot of .. potentially shocking material in there that's just waiting to be found would you be open to doing an x-files type project that here here in arland

6:22specifically in Europe more broadly? Yeah, sure. But it's a pretty safe bet that whatever we found in the U.S. files will be the same in Europe. So there was massive government interference in the U.S. Now, the U.S. actually has a constitutional amendment that prohibits the government from

6:45attacking free speech. It's literally the first amendment is the free speech amendment to the Constitution. So it is actually fully illegal for the government to impede the free speech of the people in the US. Now Ireland and very few other countries do not have such an amendment.

7:06So it may not be illegal actually, what was done in Ireland, but was there an attempt to suppress free speech during COVID, you can pretty much assume that to be 100% likely. So I seriously doubt that is any differ from the US. So yeah, I mean, we do want to sort of move on, you know, and not be constantly dredging up things

7:35from old Twitter, you know, fight the battles of, just today and tomorrow, not the battles of yesterday. But as you mentioned, the thing we should be concerned about is if the Irish Parliament passes a bow that defines hate speech as whatever they think hate speech is, people should be

8:01extremely concerned about that. just at the mercy of the ruling party and whatever bureaucrats they put in place. And they can just define something that really is not hate speech as hate speech, just because they don't like it. On that, there's been something that has been used similarly as far as vague concepts

8:28that can sort of be applied to any context. And that's misinformation and disinformation. We hear about this a lot. And in fact, under the EU Digital Services Act here at Ireland, we have a new body, the media commission. And we've also got the electoral commission. And these bodies, I think many countries now, have them in Europe and North America and Australia and so on,

8:54where we're developing these bodies that have the legal authority to shut down that information that they deem to be false at any given moment at election time, whatever it might be. In fact, we even had one Supreme Court judge who's a member of one of these bodies who said that it's important to balance the right to free speech with the right not to be misinformed.

9:18Now, I'm not aware of any such right in the Irish Constitution, but who am I to contradict a Supreme Court judge, do you believe that there is a right to not be misinformed as that judge told us? Well, that may sound nice on the surface, but who is deciding what is missing information

9:39and disinformation? The point is to have an open and clear debate, and if something is missing with disinformation, then to provide a rebuttal, that's the best way is open debate. And obviously we've got community notes on the X-platform, which I think is very powerful for addressing inaccuracies or adding context.

10:06And of course, when somebody posts something, people can reply with that it's not true for the following reasons. Whereas say something that a newspaper publishes, there's no community notes, there's no ability to robot the claims in an article in a newspaper. So the newspapers can publish, and they do publish all sorts of things that are completely untrue.

10:30as well as to avoid subjects that they decide they don't want to write about. The biggest lie in the media is the choice of narrative, because they can simply ignore anything they don't like, and they can overly focus on things that they do want to talk about. Whereas I think that the choice of what to talk about, the choice of narrative, should

10:55be up to the people, not up to a handful of editors? How do you respond to critics who say that X has helped to spread misinformation about controversial situations like, for example, the current war in Israel, Palestine, or the Ukraine situation? Because obviously, I mean, the old quote is the first casualty of war's truth and propaganda

11:25is always omnidirectional on every side. And it's almost impossible, it seems, as an ordinary person, to figure out what's going on. How do you respond to people who would criticize your platform or social media platforms in general on that basis? Well, first of all, I think actually X has the most up-to-date information by far.

11:53As I said earlier, you can rebut anything that's set on any claims. So if so, it makes a post, you can reply to that post with a rebuttal instantly. There's community notes, which is very rigorous. And the way that community notes works is that people who historically have had different

12:13opinions must agree on a note in order for that note to be shown. That's a very important and I think very powerful principle. If people who have historically disagreed do both or agree that this note that I given community note is correct, that's what's required for it to show up. So that's I think it's an incredibly powerful force for truth. And I

12:42I think it's by far more accurate than any newspaper or traditional media. If somebody is saying that there's much more disinformation, whenever I ask them for examples that can never produce any. So I would say that they're lying when they say that. They're either lying or they don't know what they're talking about.

13:02Fools or liars? Well, it's interesting that when you actually look at the definition of a word like disinformation, It is synonymous with a lie. So really when politicians say they want to regulate disinformation, we're talking about allowing politicians to regulate lying, which is if they were to phrase it that way, I think

13:28people would have a very different reaction to it as far as policies go. Yes. Do you want liars defining what lying is? It doesn't seem like the wise is the approach. A lot of the time, everyone knows that. So they're costly being deceptive. So it would be absurd for known liars

13:52to define what lying is. On that, because you are somebody who obviously is, you're known for, I suppose, environmentalism in terms of electric cars and this sort of space. So when it comes to Ireland's green policies, you've criticized the energy policies of other European countries like Germany previously.

14:20And now Ireland has gone a very similar route to the point where our national grid operator, air grid says that we're gonna have electricity shortages every winter for years into the future. And this seems like a big deal, But considering the fact that Ireland is home to so many data centers and tech companies and so on, you would think that as sort of the Silicon Valley of Europe, you would want

14:43to have a secure energy grid. So as somebody with a tech company based in Ireland, we yourself and all the European countries, are you worried about the direction of the Irish energy sector and the European energy sector more broadly? Well, I think we've gone, you know, I certainly consider myself an environmentalist and I think

15:05It's hard to say that there's any single person who's done more to help sustainable energy and the environment than I have. So I speak with some authority and an analogy in this area. There's absolutely no need to do anything to forming. Changing farming will have no effect on the environment.

15:30It's totally fine. Stop attacking the farmers. They can just keep doing what they're doing. There's only one thing that really matters with respect to the environment, and that is how many billions of tons of CO2 do we take out of the ground and put into the atmosphere? So it's a reason that if you take enough tonnage

15:54of CO2 from hydroclobbins, that's buried deep underground, and you take it from deep underground put it in the atmosphere that eventually you're going to have some change in the atmosphere. So I do think that we want to move towards a sustainable energy economy where we limit how

16:17much carbon we take from deep underground and move to the atmosphere, but that's the only thing that matters. Methane doesn't matter. Methane decays to CO2 very quickly, so it all ends up being CO2 anyway. It's fundamentally how much carbon do we take from deep underground and add to

16:37the surface cycle. That's the only thing that matters and you can leave farmers alone. And the risk in my view for CO2 and global warming is it is meaningful in the long term if you say 50 years or more. I don't think it is a risk in the short term. But it was It will take a long time to transition the economy that is still mostly based on hydrocarbons

17:10and transition that to sustainable energy where it's mostly wind, solar, nuclear. I'm actually a big part of nuclear. I think nuclear actually, nuclear vision is fine or hydro, geothermal. These are all sustainable. That's it, really. Some were complicated than that is that we should just generally lean in the direction

17:33of a sustainable energy economy. But for sure, we can leave the farmers learn that these actions that hurt farmers' ability to do farming, and have a lot of respect for the hard work associated with farming, are completely unnecessary and will achieve nothing with respect to global warming.

17:54So that would include things like cutting down on the number of livestock we have a proposal here to cut the number of livestock in the country cows I believe by about 200,000. You don't think that would have any positive impact on the environment? Zero. And okay then. Like literally you wouldn't even measure it.

18:15And if somebody says they would be able to measure it, I think then I want to hear what that measurement number is. I will bet a billion dollars you won't even be able to measure it a billion dollars. That's a bold. Unmeasurable. That's how little the impact is. On a related note, and I know you don't have much more time, and I really appreciate you taking the time to do this, on a related note, how would you explain the importance of birth

18:44rates to politicians who aren't even thinking about that as an issue when it comes to demographics and so on because you've spoken about this many times before and the demographic crisis that's brewing for humanity. And when I asked our minister who's responsible for pensions, Heather Humphreys about this

19:04issue and what our government is doing to address it, she not only did she confirm that they're not doing anything to address it, she almost seemed to act like it was an odd question. She didn't seem to understand the significance of it and how it might impact on things like social services going into the future and a whole range of other issues. So if you were

19:24speaking to lawmakers like her in the West, how would you explain why that issue is so critical? Well, first of all, I think most people are still under the wrong impression that the world population is growing rapidly. It is in fact not growing rapidly. In most countries, it is plummeting. So, and with each passing year, I should say the birth rate is plummeting.

19:52And the only reason the population isn't plummeting is because people are living longer. That's it. But it's very easy to predict with demographics what the future of the world will look like because you can say how many babies were born next year and then you immediately know how

20:07many will be adults in 20 years. So, one doesn't need to be some expert in statistics to understand what the world population will be like in 20 years. You can just look at the number of babies born, multiply that by life expectancy, and that's gonna be the population over time.

20:26And what we're seeing in basically almost every country, in fact, I think almost every country with an advanced economy, which is most countries basically, is that the birth rate is below replacement rate. So, and in some cases, it's half replacement rate. So, if somebody's half replacement rate, that just means that there will be half as many people who are generation, with each successor generation will be in half.

20:57And it's bleaker than that, because the people that remain will be very old. And so, essentially, a country will just turn into an old age home. And a good ratio to look at, for any given country is the ratio of adult diapers to baby diapers. Okay, this is a, that's the key turning point.

21:22You know, in Japan, there were more adult diapers sold than baby diapers, I think over 10 years ago, and their birth rate has gotten worse since then. And, and civilization, you know, there was a longstanding debate of, Well, civilization die with a bang or a whimper. Well, right now it's threatening to die with a whimper in adult diapers.

21:45And that is an incredibly bleak scenario. Now, how sad? I'd rather die with a bang. Yeah. At least a bang would be cool. With a whimper in adult diapers. Yeah, at least a bang would be cool. You know, big explosion or something. You can walk away from it and look like an action hero as you go out.

22:07I just think of dying with Alzheimer's and C-Rile and adult diet because that's miserable. So the birthright really matters. And I'm not saying we should just expand massively, but I think we should at least keep the numbers where there are an aim for a slight amount of population growth, but that seems like a reasonable objective as opposed to doing a population free fall, which is most countries.

22:44Well, I know you after Ron, and I don't want to take up any more of your time. I really appreciate all the time you've taken here. I wanted to end on a question about the Iliad because I know you're a big fan of Homer's Iliad. recently called it the best story ever. What about that story specifically? Do you like

23:08so much? Because I remember studying at school and it's a beautiful tale, but I'm wondering what about it? Did you find so intriguing? Well, I think it's basically an action story, an action movie, and it's got all the elements that you want to see in a movie, which is, you know, like, you know, the Spartan Queen,

23:44falls in love, falls in love and leaves, and then all of, you know, Sparta and Greece goes to get her back. There are many heroic battles. It illustrates, I mean, there's so many things that we see in Ruby City really come from the Allead. You know, there's Achilles, who's this incredible warrior, but he's got a vulnerability with

24:16Classic Achilles heel. And he's prone to letting his emotions get the best of him. There's this incredible scene where the father comes to get his son's body back and begs

24:45bigs Achilles to get his son's body back. It's a great story. And I've recommended, I recommend the Penguin audio version because it's actually meant to be spoken not read. And Penguin's audio version of the Iliad is excellent. Well, I would strongly recommend to you, if you like the Iliad, any of the Irish epics like the Catal rate of Cooley, it's a similar genre and they're excellent.

25:22If you like the Greek myths, you'll certainly like that as well. So that's a recommendation I can make to you. But anyway, I want to be conscious of your time. And I know you say you have to run around half five. So I don't want to keep you any longer. But thank you so much, Mr. Mosk for your time and for all of your thought provoking contributions.

25:40All right. Welcome. Thank you. Thanks so much. Talk soon.

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份