访谈·中文精读

比尔·马赫专访

Interview with Bill Maher

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

比尔·马赫(Bill Maher)一口气报完那串头衔:让电动车成为现实的人,正在完善可回收火箭,搞太空旅行,把人类大脑直接连到电脑,用电磁子弹列车连接城市,那个对乌克兰战争至关重要的星链(Starlink)卫星系统,然后周二还要去挖隧道解决交通。最后补一句,他还发很多推。

然后他问:你一天做所有这些事吗?

马斯克说:不。停了一下,补了半句,但我工作时间很长。

这个开场把两个人的位置摆得很清楚。马赫做的是谈话节目,天天讨论世界发生了什么变化,可他自己说得很实在:我们只是聊。真正让变化发生的人很少,马斯克算一个。

接下来那段评价值得留意。马赫说你是个讨人喜欢的人,他们攻击你很多次,你却一笑而过,这很棒。一个人像你这么重要、真能推动改变,完全可以把能力用在坏的地方。

我当然永远不会把它们用在坏的地方。(马斯克)

马赫判断的依据是幽默感。他的逻辑很朴素:一个爱笑、爱讲笑话的人,不太可能是纯粹的恶人。马斯克顺着聊了一句,很多年前他就在这个节目的观众席里坐着看录制,那时候他还是个普通观众。

发牌的是技术圈那批人,总统只是牌桌上的玩家

马赫是历史专业出身。他说学历史会碰到「伟人理论」,课本里讲国王、王子、女王、总统,仿佛世界是这些人推动的。但他读完之后得到的结论正相反:真正改变世界的是技术圈那批人。

他们发牌。火、电、轧棉机、iPhone、原子弹,一张张发到桌面上,剩下的人只能照着打。

马斯克同意这个框架,还给出了更长的因果链。

古腾堡印刷机(Gutenberg press)出现之前,书是稀罕物。哪怕你对知识有强烈的渴求,也几乎无计可施,因为根本没有书可读。印刷机把这个约束拆掉了,识字率、宗教改革、科学革命都跟着走。互联网比印刷机还要再进一步。

这里能看出马斯克判断技术价值的一把尺子:一项技术有多重要,取决于它把多少人的能力上限抬高了。印刷机抬高了能读书的人,互联网抬高的是所有人。

互联网让人类整体长出了神经系统

马斯克描述他第一次看到互联网向公众开放时的感受:人类作为一个整体,正在发育出一套神经系统。

以前信息怎么走?靠口耳相传,一个人传给另一个人,或者一个人打电话给另一个人。能触达的范围极其有限,速度取决于人的脚和嘴。

有了互联网,人类任何一部分都能接触到几乎全部人类的信息存量。

你可以在亚马逊丛林深处,拿着一个星链终端,能拿到的信息比 1980 年的美国总统还多。(马斯克)

马赫补了一句:其实你手机里就有。马斯克说,对,全都在里面。

这段话解释了马斯克后来所有动作的共同底色。他做的事情看上去很散:车、火箭、卫星、脑机接口、隧道、社交平台。用「连接」这个词一串,就通了。他反复在做同一件事,降低信息、能量、人和货物流动的阻力。

阻力降下来一个量级,人的行为模式就换一套。马车时代的人不会为了吃顿饭跑一百公里,高速公路修好之后,这件事变得平常。星链的逻辑也一样,把上网这件事从「有没有基础设施」变成「有没有电」。

买下推特,是因为数字城镇广场坏了

马赫问了一个当时很多人心里的疑问:你买推特,感觉像个异类,跟造车造火箭完全不搭。

马斯克不这么看。他把它归到文明级别的问题里。

收购之后有一段时间,他搬回旧金山,一度就睡在推特的图书馆里。马赫拿这个开玩笑,说这是你的固定模式,当年接手特斯拉就住在工厂,现在接手推特就住进图书馆。

马斯克的解释是节奏问题。

这家公司当时正快速走向破产,我必须采取激烈手段,没有别的选择。现在情况基本稳定下来了。(马斯克)

他真正在意的东西是信任。

推特在某种程度上是数字城镇广场(digital town square)。这个广场要让各种不同观点的人都愿意待着,既要有实际的安全感,也要有被感知到的公平。而当时平台上存在大量审查。

「推特文件」(Twitter Files)披露出来的内容里,有相当一部分是政府驱动的审查。马斯克认为那已经构成违宪。

他自己是重度用户,所以能感觉到「有些地方不对劲」。这是他动手的原因。他特意强调,这条路跟轻松赚钱没有关系。当「推文镇」的镇长,每天有无数支箭朝你飞过来。

马赫的玩笑更毒一点,他说你上任之后塔克·卡尔森(Tucker Carlson)被炒了,希望这不是什么荣誉勋章。马斯克自嘲他不是脱口秀界的伤寒玛丽。

什么是「觉醒心智病毒」

马赫说,你谈这个东西的时候用的词很末日,说它把文明推向自杀。你得解释一下,为什么这不算夸张。

马斯克给了两条判断标准,任何东西只要踩中其中一条,就该极度警惕。

第一条是反精英主义(anti-meritocratic)。你连质疑都不允许,质疑这个动作本身就是错的。

第二条是压制言论自由。

这两条合起来,另一个名字就叫取消文化(cancel culture)。

马赫问他被取消过多少次。马斯克的回答是每周都有,左右两边都来。

这里有个细节蛮有意思。马赫说,你和我都被归到「保守派」那一小撮人里,可我们其实什么都没变,是世界挪了位置。他不觉得马斯克是保守派。

马斯克说自己至少认为自己是温和派。他给出的证据很实在:大半辈子精力都投在可持续能源上,电动车、电池、太阳能,这些东西跟极右翼扯不上关系。

马赫说得更直接。今天的「觉醒」是自由主义的反面。言论自由曾经是左派的核心价值,现在挂着左派招牌的人却在推动审查。这个转向在他看来很荒唐。

言论自由只在你说错话的时候才成立

马斯克把第一修正案(First Amendment)的来历讲了一遍。写进去有原因:那批人来自说错话就会被扔进监狱的国家,他们不想在新大陆重演这一幕。

他还提醒,世界上很多地方的言论法相当严苛,包括一些人们以为跟美国差不多的国家。

英国就是例子。在英国证明诽谤很容易,比在美国容易得多。马赫顺着开了句玩笑,说我们这儿几乎就是英国。

法国也有类似的法律。否认大屠杀在法国可以判刑入狱。马斯克的表态很干脆。

我认为否认大屠杀是可恶的,但我也认为那应该属于言论自由的范围。(马斯克)

他反复强调的那个点,值得单独拎出来:

言论自由只有在你不喜欢的人说了你不喜欢的话时才真正有意义。说你喜欢的话,那太容易了。推动审查的人最好记住,这套机制总有一天会反过来用在你自己身上。(马斯克)

这段话其实是全场密度最高的一句。它把言论自由从一种道德姿态,还原成一套制度设计。制度的价值在于它在你不想用的时候仍然约束你。

学校里的灌输,家长大多不知道

马赫问,这个病毒从哪来的?是蝙蝠,还是实验室泄漏?

马斯克没有指向某个具体源头,他给的是一个长期过程。这件事酝酿很久了。学校和大学里正在发生的灌输,程度远远超出家长的想象。

他自己也是比较晚才意识到的。他读书时的高中、大学体验,跟现在的孩子完全不是一回事。这个变化大概已经持续了十年,也可能二十年。

马赫追问,家长自己是不是也有责任。马斯克的看法是,个别情况确实有,但总体上是家长根本不知道孩子被教了什么,也不知道孩子没被教什么。

他举了个朋友的真实例子。这位朋友的孩子在湾区上学,高中和大学都有。他问女儿们,美国最早的几任总统是谁。

她们能说出华盛顿。

再问,你知道他什么?

回答是:他是个奴隶主。

还有呢?没有了。

马斯克并没有为奴隶制辩护。奴隶制是可怕的制度,这一点没有争议。但关于乔治·华盛顿,一个人应该知道的远不止这一条。他还是美国建国过程里的关键人物,制宪会议的主持者,两任总统后主动交权,这个动作本身就是制度史上的大事。

马斯克顺手补了个历史事实:奴隶制在世界各地、从有记载以来、几乎每个种族都实行过。圣经里到处都是奴隶制的条款,圣经从来没有一句话说奴隶制是坏的。它只规定了很多细则,比如不能拿别人家的奴隶。

马赫对这段的反应是「没错,圣经里确实到处都是」。两个人在这件事上互相点头。

马斯克把这种「一个人只被记住他最糟糕的那一点」的教法,直接指认为觉醒心智病毒的典型产物。它的机制很清晰:先把历史人物简化成一个罪名,再让这个名字失去讨论价值。名字被废掉,历史就被切断。

2.5 亿人每天半小时的注意力

访谈里插了一段关于卡尔森的数据讨论。

卡尔森在推特上发的一段独白,播放量超过了任何有线电视新闻的评论节目。马斯克说,他们没做任何特殊处理,他甚至是事后才知道对方发了东西。

真正的原因是平台规模。

2.5 亿人每天在推特上平均花半小时,一天大约 1.2 亿到 1.3 亿用户小时,而且还在增长。

这个数字比很多人想象的大。半小时的平均时长意味着它已经超过「顺便刷一下」的量级,接近一种日常习惯。注意力密度高,读得多、关心时事、通常也更有影响力的人集中在这上面,于是单条内容的外溢效应被放大。

马赫提了个反面的观察:真正发推的人始终是那一小撮,大部分人只是看。

他自己不再发推的理由也很具体。那帮「mean girls」组成的暴民还在,什么都没变,太容易就被取消,而且你根本不知道什么会惹怒他们。他形容那种感觉像蒙着眼睛在屋顶上走,随时会掉下去。

马赫举的例子很荒诞:他随口说一句乔治·华盛顿是位伟大的总统,就会有人跳出来说你怎么敢。

马斯克给的建议听起来轻飘飘:如果有人在推特上攻击你,那只是互动量上升,忽略就好。

马赫当场把这个建议顶了回去:对你容易,他们拿不走你那十份工作,但能拿走我的,而且他们干过一次,我的节目被取消过。

这段对话里有个不太被注意到的分层。马斯克说的「取消」和普通人说的「取消」,成本完全不一样。前者失去的是舆论战的一场小规模交火,后者失去的是收入来源。同一个词,两种量级。

人口在往下掉,资源还算不上瓶颈

马赫提到马斯克那句口号,多生孩子,然后把他们养在火星上。他说自己没搞懂,但先放过。

马斯克顺着讲了文明衰退这条线。大多数地方的生育率在急剧下滑。

马赫接话:资源也在急剧下滑。

这里马斯克不同意。

我们并不面临资源崩溃的危险。我当然不主张躺平,我们确实应该尽快转向可持续能源的经济结构。但资源算不上那个卡点。(马斯克)

马赫举了几个例子:很多人吃不饱,水会耗尽,沙子也在短缺。

马斯克的回应很硬。地球表面七成是水。海水不能直接喝,但海水淡化的成本低到荒谬。

马赫问,那我们为什么不做?

马斯克说,我们在做,已经做了大量海水淡化。

所以他坚持那个判断:水不是问题。他特意强调了一遍,想让这句话被听清楚。

这场碰撞有意思的地方在两种思维方式的分野。一边看到的是分配和短缺,一边看到的是工程能力和成本曲线。同一组事实,落在两套框架里得出完全不同的紧迫感。

顺带说一句,马斯克在这段里其实松了一个口。他承认「我们不该自满」,也承认要尽快转向可持续能源。他反对的是「资源即将崩溃」这个判断,并不反对「我们要提高效率」这件事。很多争论错位就错在这里,一方在争时间表,另一方以为在争方向。

AI 需要一个裁判

马赫把话题拉到 AI。他说马斯克十年前就在喊这件事,当时没几个人在意。

马赫自己的理由挺朴素,他看了太多电影。电影里发生的事,现实里迟早会发生。你造出比你聪明得多的东西,它凭什么不当你的领主?

马斯克前几天在国会山跟参议院多数党领袖查克·舒默(Chuck Schumer)聊过 AI。他还在开场时被马赫调侃,说你的预测有个变种版的奥卡姆剃刀:最反讽的结果往往最可能发生。

他主张的东西不复杂:要有某种监管监督。

他拿飞机和汽车打比方。任何对公众构成危险的东西,都有一套监管机制在,像一个裁判,确保公司不会为了省成本而偷工减料。

如果承认 AI 对公众构成潜在风险,那就应该有对应的监管机构,盯着公司别抄近路。

马赫追问,如果什么都不做,未来两到五年、十年会怎样?他很清楚人类很擅长什么都不做,尤其当这件事挡在利润前面。AI 现在是个巨大的利润引擎,公司之间只会拼命竞争。

马赫提到雷·库兹韦尔(Ray Kurzweil),说他不觉得这是个问题。

马斯克补了个时间点:库兹韦尔预测人工超级智能(artificial superintelligence)到来的时间是 2029 年。这个预测离得不算远。

库兹韦尔为什么不担心?马斯克的解释带点黑色幽默。因为库兹韦尔想活得久一点,甚至不想死,而数字超级智能在他看来是唯一能解出长寿这道题的东西。所以他更愿意要通用人工智能(AGI),而不是不要。

这个观察值得多想一想。AI 讨论里最激烈的声音,往往跟说话者的处境有关。想延寿的人盼它快些来,做内容的人怕被它替代,做芯片的人希望监管晚点落地,做安全研究的人希望监管早点到位。动机决定立场,这一点在 AI 讨论里格外明显。

马斯克自己站在哪边?他既在做 AI,又在喊暂停。这种表面上的矛盾,其实是他一贯的做法:先造出来,再把风险摆到台面上,逼着行业和监管一起往前走。

幸福的两个条件

马赫翻出一篇旧采访,滚石杂志那篇,马斯克在里面说,如果不谈恋爱,他不可能快乐。

马斯克的修正版本是:可以半快乐。

他把幸福拆成两项。在爱情里幸福,加上热爱自己的工作,两项齐了,人就是完全幸福的。只有其中一项,大概就是一半。

这个说法跟前面聊的所有宏大话题放一起看,反差挺大。一个在谈文明衰退、AI 风险、火星殖民的人,被问到幸福,给出的是两个非常具体的条件:一个人,一份事。

马赫观察到一个贯穿所有项目的主线,就是「连接」。超级高铁(hyperloop)连接城市,星舰连接火星,他甚至开玩笑说连四子棋(Connect Four)也是连接。马斯克接了这个梗。

回到那个住工厂的老梗。马赫说这对他不好,一个男人住在工厂里,对感情是个障碍。马斯克承认,是有可能。

整场对话接近尾声,马赫给了段评价。天才总归有点怪癖,但你的心在正确的位置上,你在试图修好这个世界。

他还说了句挺有画面感的收尾:我很想跟你一起抽一口,我知道个好地方。

这期访谈没有发布任何新产品,也没有宣布任何计划。它值钱的地方在于,马斯克把这些年所有看似不相干的动作,当场串成了一套逻辑:技术决定文明能走多远,信息流动决定技术扩散得多快,而言论自由是信息流动的前提。他买推特、喊 AI 监管、担心生育率,都是从这套逻辑里长出来的。

放到 2023 年 5 月这个时间点看,ChatGPT 出来才半年,AI 监管在美国还只是国会山上的几场闭门会。他当时说的「应该有裁判」,两年后成了各国立法讨论的默认前提。而他关于言论自由的那句话,在今天的中文互联网上读起来,恐怕比当时更刺人。

如果你想从这期访谈里拿到点能用的东西,下面几条可以直接抄走。

  • 判断一个项目会不会改变世界,看它有没有把某种流动的阻力降下一个量级:信息、能量、人、货物。阻力降了,行为模式就换一套,这类机会比「更好的同类产品」大得多。
  • 评估新技术风险时,用马斯克那把尺子:它对公众构成潜在危险吗?如果是,就该有裁判,等行业自律是靠不住的。这把尺子对 AI 适用,对生物技术、社交平台、自动驾驶同样适用。
  • 看到「某个人只被记住一个污点」的叙事,先停一下。这是叙事被单点劫持的信号,无论对象是历史人物、竞争对手,还是你公司里一个犯过错的同事。
  • 做内容、做传播,看注意力密度,不要只看总量。2.5 亿人每天半小时的价值,在于这批人读得多、说得响、影响别人,人头数本身说明不了什么。
  • 遇到「资源要耗尽」的论断,先问一句成本曲线。海水淡化的成本低到荒谬,这句话背后是工程视角和分配视角的分野。分清对方在争方向还是在争时间表,能省掉很多无效争论。
  • 别人建议你「忽略攻击就好」的时候,先算一下双方的损失量级。他有十份工作,你只有一份,同一句建议对你们不是一回事。
  • 想让自己状态好一点,别只修一项。热爱的工作和一段好的关系,缺哪个都只是半格电。
语音识别自动转录(Whisper),含全部发言人,可能有识别错误。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。

0:00I don't know if I've ever been so excited to have my first guest here. My first guest is the man who made electric cars a thing and is currently working on perfecting reusable rockets, space travel, connecting the human brain directly to computers, connecting cities with electromagnetic bullet trains, the Starling Satellite System that's so important to the war in Ukraine, and then on Tuesday.

0:20It's going to work on that tunnel thing on traffic. He also tweets a lot. Elon Musk, ladies and gentlemen.

0:43Did I get the full order of things that you do in a day there? When I was reading there, I left out the tunnel thing at the end. Do you work on all these? A lot of jobs. Do you do all these things every day? Do you work on all of them in a single day? No. But I do have a long work day.

1:00Yeah, so I work a lot. Well, I'm so thrilled you're here because we do a show where we talk about what changes happen in the world. but we just talk. There's a very few people who actually make change happen. You are one of those people probably. you know, I just wanna say I love this audience.

1:28Well, you're a likable guy. I mean, they attack you a lot. They do. Yeah. And you seem to laugh it off, which I think is fantastic. I love it that you have a sense of humor, Because a guy as important as you, who makes changes, could use your powers for evil and not good. The fact that you could.

1:56Of course, I would never use them for evil. No, I know. But the way I know that is because you have a sense of humor. You really do. I swear to you. You like laughing. You like to be funny. I kill me. Right. No, I... I suppose there's somebody like Zuckerberg who I'm not even sure is a real boy.

2:17Yeah... I mean, I actually love comedy, and, I still, you know, like, many years ago, actually, was in the audience here and watched your show. Oh, really? So, it's been a long time, my record show. Oh, well, thank you. I... Let me get back to you. Let me get back to you being a genius.

2:44Okay. But that has always been my view, is that I was a history major. And when you study history, what you realize is that, you know, there's the great man theory and they talk about kings and princes and queens and presidents. It's really the people in tech who change the world.

3:00They're the people who deal the cards, whether it's fire or electricity for good or bad or or the cotton gin, or the iPhone, or the atom bomb, those are the cards and the rest of us just play it. Would you agree with that assessment? I think technology is the thing that causes these big step changes in civilization.

3:24So obviously you've got things like, say, the Gutenberg press, before which it was very difficult to get books. There was very rare. Even if you had a thirst for knowledge, you really couldn't do anything about it because there were very few books to read. So, and the internet is something beyond the good

3:42but press I think. But, you know, it's, it's, when I first saw the internet coming into being in a way that the general public could use it, it felt like the, the humanity as a whole was developing a nervous system. So previously the way the information would travel would be Vio's Moses, one person to another or one person calling another.

4:05But the access to information is very limited. Now with the internet, it's like having a nervous system. It's like any part of humanity has access to almost all the information of humanity. Like you could be in the middle of the Amazon jungle with say a startling terminal and have access to more information than the president did in 1980.

4:30Right, well anything on your phone? Everything. Yeah. Okay, so you are one of these dealers, these people who deal the cards and send me. I feel some names too. Yes, you do. So,.. No. No. No. No. No. No. So, I think a lot of people thought, when you bought Twitter, that this is kind of an outlier, like, how does this, what doesn't fit with these other things you're doing?

5:00I never thought that. Because I think you're dealing with big civilizational issues and problems, And I was right on your page. I think Twitter is one of them. I mean, you have talked about this woke mind virus. Yes. And really apocalyptic terms. I don't, you should explain why you don't think it's hyperbole to say things like it's pushing civilization towards suicide.

5:23First of all, what is the woke mind virus? And if we don't deal with this, nothing else can get done. Tell me why you think that. Yeah, so I think we need to be very cautious about anything that is anti-meritocratic and anything that results in the suppression of free speech. So those are two of the aspects of the work mind-birus that I think are very dangerous,

5:50is that it's often anti-meritocratic. You can't question things. Even the questioning is bad. So another way that almost anonymous would be cancel culture. And obviously, people try to cancel you many times. Many times. I mean, every week. Yeah. Yeah. From left and right, I've had it from both sides.

6:14And people, you and I, are both in that little group of people. Maybe it's a bigger group now. Who are called conservative, who haven't really changed. I don't see you think of you as a conservative. Definitely, yeah, like, I at least think of myself as a moderate, you know. So, I mean, at least, like, I spent a massive amount of my life energy building sustainable

6:38energy, you know, electric vehicles and batteries and solar and stuff to help save the environment. That's not a, you know. It's not exactly far right. You drew that diagram once where you're here. I related to that. And like, the world has changed. I feel the same way. I feel like very often, wokeness, is not building on liberalism.

7:05It's the opposite of liberalism. I can mention this. Exactly. Many examples where it's the including free speech. Free speech is actually extremely important. And it's bizarre that we've come to this point where, free speech used to be a left or a liberal value. And yet, we see from the in quotes left a desire to actually censor.

7:29And that seems crazy. I mean, I think we should be extremely concerned about anything that undermines the First Amendment. There's a reason for the First Amendment. The First Amendment is because people came from countries where they could not speak freely and where saying certain things would get you thrown into prison.

7:51And they were like, well, we don't want that here. And by the way, in many parts of the world, including parts of the world that people might think are relatively similar to the United States, the speech laws are draconian. England is quite different. I won't name any country, but.

8:09England, why are we protecting them? They have no first and end. It's very easy to prove libel in England. We're here at almost England. Yeah, you do. But I wouldn't want to say the wrong thing. Yes, you could be sued easier. I mean, there are law in France. I think if you deny the Holocaust, which I think is abhorrent, but I also think it should be part of free speech, you can be thrown into jail.

8:34OK, so this might really can't emphasize this enough. We must protect free speech. And free speech only matters. It's only relevant when it's someone you don't like saying something you don't like, because obviously, The speech that you like is easy. So it's, and it's, the thing about TensorShow is that,

8:56for those who are advocated, just remember, at some point, that will return on you. So this woke mind virus, how did it start? Was it bats? Was it a escape from a lab? I mean, what is your assessment of why? Because it's fairly recent. Why did it start and why? I was trying to figure out where it's coming from.

9:27I think it's actually been a long time brewing, in that it's been going on for a while. The amount of indoctrination that's happening in schools and universities is far beyond what parents realize. And I only sort of came to realize this somewhat late. The experience that we had in high school and college is not the experience that kids

9:57that they are having. And hasn't been for, I don't know, 10 years, maybe 20 years. So... What parents themselves also have been part of the problem? Well, I suppose in some cases that parents, but I think like the parents are just generally not aware of what their kids have been taught or what they're not being taught.

10:20They're letting the kids think that they're equal. Yeah, let me give you an example that a fair amount told me, which his daughter's go to college and so go to high school in the Bay Area. And he was asking them, well, so who are the first few presidents of the United States? They could name Washington.

10:43And I said, what do you know about him? Well, he was a slave owner. What else? Right. Exactly. Nothing. Right. Like, OK, that's maybe you should know more than that. You know? Yeah. Yeah. And that is the woke mind virus, exactly. Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. It's like, you know, the slavery is obviously a horrific institution, but we should still

11:09know more about George Washington than that. And by the way, one that was practiced all over the world forever since the beginning of time by every race, including people of color. I'm sorry to tell you that. It's huge in the Bible. Absolutely. So Bible loves it. Really? Yes. They're quite strict about like, you know, don't take someone else's slave and that kind of

11:29thing. Right, but no one ever says just don't do it. They don't. They don't. They don't. They don't. They don't. At no point does it say slavery is bad in the Bible. No. No. They do not condemn it at all. But Twitter is not doing bad, right? I mean, I saw today that Tucker Carlson recently fired.

11:47You were just on his show and he lost his job, so I hope this isn't an honor. Yeah. Yeah. Hopefully, yeah. Will you be the angel of Jeff? Yeah, no, exactly. I'm not the typhoid Mary of talk shows. But for some reason, people just get fired after. His rant yesterday or today on Twitter.

12:07Do you have a yesterday or something like that? It did more than every cable news monologue or something like that, is that right? Well, Twitter has a tremendous audience. So there's 250 million people that spend an average of half an hour a day on Twitter. So it's about 120 to 130 million user hours per day and it's been increasing.

12:24So we didn't do anything too clear. We did nothing special whatsoever. I learned about it afterwards that he had posted something on Twitter. So it's just that Twitter has a lot of people's attention. And it tends to be the people that read a lot or are interested in card events and generally

12:48are pretty influential. But most of the people who tweet are the same people, right? I mean, the people who actually tweet it's supposed to just reading it. I feel like that's, I've read this many times, it's a very small percentage of the people on Twitter. And it seems like, see, here's why I don't tweet anymore.

13:05because you may be the mayor of Tweet Town now. Yeah, and a mayor of Tweet Town. And getting a cap with that. And I'm glad, and I like it that the mayor likes my jokes. But the reason I don't do it anymore is because the mob of mean girls is still there. And that has not changed.

13:22I know. It's too easy to get canceled. Yeah. And I don't even know what pisses them off. They're so nuts, these kids. I feel like I'm walking on a roof with a blindfold. I could fall off anytime. That was the most innocuous thing, but it's like, you know, I said George Washington was a great president.

13:40Well, how dare you? Yeah, yeah, exactly. It hit some flows, but I will. So how do you fix that? It's instrumental in the creation of the United States. Yeah. Well, you have to say like, what does canceled mean? You know, I mean, yes, if people attack on Twitter, that's one thing, but frankly, that's just an increased engagement.

13:58So I would just ignore it. Well, that's easy for you, because they kind of take your job away. or any of your main 10 jobs, but they could take mine, and they did once, by the way. Yeah, okay, well fair. You know, I was like literally canceled. Thank you. Yeah, I mean like the show is canceled.

14:16So, but okay, so you were in Congress, at Congress the other day talking with Chuck Schumer about AI, I'm very interested in this because you've been on this for years, I've always thought you were right about this. I think you're right about almost everything. I mean, let's have more babies and raise them on Mars.

14:31I don't get that, but okay. Well, I think we should be cautious about civil civilizational decline and we have plummeting growth rates most places here. Right, and also plummeting resources. No, no, we have resources that will be fine. But they're not fine now. And I know a lot about it.

14:48They're not fine now. Look, I'm not suggesting complacency. We do want to move to a sustainable energy economy as quickly as possible, but we were not in any danger of resource collapse. But lots of people don't have enough food or water. Water, we will run out of water. They're running out of sand.

15:07No, Earth is 70% water by sofceria. But you can't drink that. De-salination is absurdly cheap. Why don't we do it then? We do it? It is done. You have a lot of free time. It is done. There is a lot of de-salination done. OK, but there's plenty of water. This is not an issue. I want to be clear.

15:25All right, so let's talk about AI. Because you were on this tip 10 years ago when nobody else was. And I always thought, he's right. Why? Because I've seen too many movies. Everything that happens in movies, that happens in real life. And, you know, if you make things that are way smarter than you, why wouldn't they become your overlords? So what did you say to Chuck Schumer and what are we doing about this? I know you want to pause in the eye because it in the last six months with chat GPT, which came from a company you started. Yes.

15:56I mean, a fair amount has a sort of modification of Occam's razor, you know, instead of the simplest thing being the most likely, that the most ironic outcome is most likely? Right, yes. So with respect to AI, I just think we should have some sort of regulatory oversight. So, you know, for anything that is a danger to the public, if it's sort of aircraft, cars,

16:23We've got some regulatory oversight, like a referee, essentially, and making sure that companies don't cut corners. So I think that since, if one agrees that AI is a potentialist to the public, then there should be some regulatory body that oversees what companies are doing so that they don't

16:43cut corners and potentially do something very dangerous. That's... And if we don't do something, lay out a scenario for me in the next two, five, ten years. If nothing is done because we're very good at doing nothing, especially when it comes in the way of profit, and this is a big profit engine now for companies, they're going to

17:04want to just compete with each other. I mean, there are people like Ray Kurzweil who doesn't think it's a problem at all. Actually, Ray Kurzweil's prediction for artificial superintelligence is 2029. He's not far wrong. Right. But he doesn't think it's a problem, whereas people like you and Bill Gates and Stephen Hawking

17:22thought it's a problem. Yeah, it depends. If some people want to live forever or for a much longer period of time and they see AI as the only way, digital super intelligence is the only thing that can figure out how to get them to live forever, I think, as well as in that category.

17:39So he would prefer to have AI, artificial general intelligence than not because he can figure out longevity. So are you optimistic? I read in your Rolling Stone article back in the day that you said you could never be happy unless you're in love. Well, you can be half happy, I suppose.

17:57I mean, there's two things. I think to be most happy, if you're happy in love and you love your work, then you'll be, I think, fully happy. If you lack either of those two, if you have one of those two things, be half happy, you know, roughly. I feel like the theme in a lot of your works that connects all these different things is connecting.

18:20Like you wanna connect things. You know, you wanna connect on the hyperloop and you wanna connect this to Mars and even- Or connect four. You want, you wanna love that game. What? Connect four, yeah, wake up. Yeah, yeah. Okay. Okay. Okay. But, sorry, this is a comedy, right? You know?

18:44but it's hard for you because I've, when you bought Twitter, you kind of doing what you did when you took over, when you started Tesla, you lived at the factory, right? I feel like that's your pattern. You get into this thing and then you gotta live at the factory to make it work.

19:06You've been back and you moved to Texas, then you went back up to San Francisco because of Twitter. I was living in the library of Twitter for a while. Yes. But I think things are reasonably stabilized right now. It was just on the fast track to bankruptcy after that position. So I had to take a drastic action.

19:25There wasn't any choice. I'm just saying it's hard for a woman. So when the guy lives at the factory. Yes. LAUGHTER That could be a stumbling block. Yes. But overall, my concern with Twitter was that it is somewhat of the digital town square. And it's important that there be both the reality and perception of trust for a wide range of viewpoints.

19:56And there was a lot of censorship going on. And we uncovered a lot of that with the Twitter files, including a lot of government-driven censorship, which, you know, it seems that that's got to be a constitutional violation of what was going on there. But so, since I'm like an avid Twitter user, I could detect that like something's not right

20:21here. And so that's really why I had the deposition. It wasn't because I thought this was an easy way to make money or something like that. And this is being mayor of Twitter town, Tweet town or whatever, it's definitely like there's a lot of arrows pointing at you, like flying at you.

20:38Of course. But you seem to handle that OK. I hope you do, because look, I mean, geniuses are going to be a little quirky sometimes. But your heart is always in the right place. You are trying to fix this world. And look, I could talk to you forever we can today. I'd love to get high with you.

20:56I know a great place to do it. But I can't tell you how much I appreciate you. I know you have a lot of choices and places you can go. Thank you. Elon Musk, ladies and gentlemen. All right, I'll see you soon, Elon.

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份