访谈·中文精读

马斯克最新专访:对话大卫·法伯

Elon Musk Latest Interview with David Faber.

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

一家汽车公司的老板说,现在卖车基本不赚钱。他说这话时没有焦虑,语气像在揭开一个早就设计好的局。

2023年5月,CNBC的David Faber(大卫·法伯)走进特斯拉工厂,和马斯克做了一场长约一小时的专访。访谈从车间开始,最后聊到人类会不会被AI取代。中间经过广告、定价、中国、台湾、Twitter那场差点破产的收购,以及他和OpenAI的决裂。

开头那个场景就能说明很多。马斯克在特斯拉工厂里没有办公室,要么在车间走,要么待在那间能看见总装线末端的会议室里开会。他怎么判断工厂有没有出问题?看末端产线上的车有没有在动。车不动,说明上游堵了,他就起身去看堵在哪儿。

实时、直接、讨厌中间层、讨厌延迟。这套逻辑贯穿了整场访谈,从订单数据到利率政策,从信息纠错到AI安全。

“我二十分钟前才同意做广告,哪来的完整策略”

股东大会上有件事让马斯克自己都意外。他说特斯拉可能考虑做广告,台下掌声很热烈。

他原本没这个打算,特斯拉历史上几乎没投过广告。理由也实在:在特斯拉账号和他个人账号上发消息,本质上是对着已经信的人布道。看到的人早就被说服了,看不到的人永远不会知道特斯拉的起售价已经低于美国汽车的平均成交价。

“很多人还以为特斯拉特别贵,因为我们最早做的是昂贵的跑车,后来是稍便宜的轿车和SUV。但现在情况变了。”他在访谈里重复了股东大会上的说法,特斯拉不只是便宜,还是路上最安全的车。很多安全设计连特斯拉员工都不知道,比如座舱过热保护、持续通过OTA更新的自动紧急制动、气囊的展开方式。

Faber追问:那你打算怎么投?投在哪儿?NFL比赛中间会不会出现特斯拉广告?

马斯克回答得很干脆:“我二十分钟前才同意这件事,还没有完整的策略。”(马斯克)

他对广告只设了一个判断标准。广告得提供信息,得有美感,看完不能让人后悔。三条都过,它就开始接近内容。你希望广告尽可能接近内容,观众才不会觉得浪费时间。反过来,信息不准确、甚至误导人的广告,就是垃圾。

这套标准带来一个他不太愿意多谈的后果。Twitter的Community Notes(社区笔记)也适用于广告。有广告被标注为误导,广告商很生气,撤了投放。至今因此损失约4000万美元广告收入。

他的态度是值得。他还给那些广告商指了条路:被标注了就去Twitter补充事实,用信息反驳笔记,别撤广告。

像航空公司一样定价,只是把遮羞布扯掉了

聊到特斯拉的定价,Faber问得挺尖:你们是不是已经变成航空公司那种动态定价模式了?

马斯克说是。特斯拉有实时需求数据,每天系统自动算好,发一封邮件给相关团队,写明昨天哪个国家、哪款车、多少人下了单。他每天都看,但不看单日波动,看两周以上的趋势。

1月那波大降价,他给的解释是季节性:1月历来是汽车销售最差的月份。后来需求回暖,又涨了一轮价。

这里他讲了一个容易被忽略的事实。所有车企都在大幅调价,只是方式不同。厂商给一个MSRP(建议零售价),需求旺的时候经销商加价卖,需求弱的时候打折卖。你把这六个月的最高价和最低价拉出来看,差距非常大。特斯拉只是把这个过程变得即时、明显、透明,省掉了MSRP加价或折扣那层遮羞布。

Faber接着把话题引向利润率和那次有名的表态:技术上现在卖车不赚钱,但长期能产生巨大的经济效益。这话到底什么意思?

一辆车一周跑10小时,还是一周跑50小时

马斯克的回答从一个简单的数字开始。

普通乘用车一周的使用时间大概10到12小时。一天通勤一小时,偶尔跑个长途,差不多就这样。剩下大部分时间它停在车位上,而车位本身还要花钱,买车位、租车库、在商场被贴条。

一辆能完全自动驾驶的车,一周的使用时间可能是50小时。一周总共168小时。

车还是那辆车,制造成本一样,产出翻了四五倍。所以他判断,一辆具备完全自动驾驶能力的车,价值可能是非自动驾驶车的五倍。

这就是“卖车不赚钱”的底层逻辑。特斯拉是目前唯一一家他认为可以通过一次软件更新就实现完全自动驾驶的车企。车卖出去的时候,硬件利润可以压到很低,甚至接近于零,因为钱在后面等着。

Faber追问商业模式:车是我买的,我上班的时候它出去接客,谁分钱?

马斯克说这套条款在特斯拉的销售合同里已经写了很多年。车主拿一部分,特斯拉拿一部分,比例可能是五五,也可能是七三,还没定。真正的限制在这儿:你买的特斯拉只能在特斯拉的网络里跑,接不进别人的平台。

这意味着什么?如果一辆车能被使用五倍的时长,特斯拉从Robotaxi(自动驾驶出租车)业务里拿到的钱,大概是这辆车原售价的两到三倍。

“这就相当于用软件的利润率卖车。不是25%的毛利,可能是70%甚至更高。由此产生的自由现金流,是一个真正惊人的数字。”(马斯克)

他提到凯西·伍德(Cathie Wood)和方舟投资(ARK Invest)做过的最完整分析。当年很多人觉得她太乐观,马斯克自己也这么觉得。结果回头看,她的测算几乎精准。

“病态乐观”与那个第一次

说到完全自动驾驶的时间表,马斯克没有回避自己的黑历史。

“我确实有一点病态乐观。”(马斯克)

Faber接了一句挺妙的话:这种乐观其实有用,不然你根本不会去做这些事。做火箭、做电动车,谁会在清醒的状态下开始?

这一次他给了新证据。他最近在得州大奥斯汀地区和旧金山连续几天做同一件事:随机设一个导航目的地,让车自己开过去,全程零干预。旧金山是难开的地方,有公交专用道、单行道、复杂的路况。

“这是我第一次遇到连续几天随机目的地、零安全干预的情况。第一次。”(马斯克)

所以当Faber问“你觉得什么时候能实现”,他的措辞很谨慎:“在我看来,我们今年很可能做到。”那几个限定词他特意强调了:在我看来、很可能。

IRA到底给了特斯拉多少好处

摩根士丹利的亚当·乔纳斯(Adam Jonas)算过一笔账,认为《通胀削减法案》(IRA)给特斯拉带来的绝对金额优势,可能相当于当前每股收益的45%。

马斯克觉得没那么多。“我不确定有那么好,大概是那个数字的一半左右,但确实相当可观。”(马斯克)

他更看重战略意义。法案的写法很细,几乎堵死了所有钻空子的路径:电池必须在美国制造,正极前驱体等上游材料也必须在美国生产。电芯层面每千瓦时补贴30美元,电池包层面15美元。

“随着我们走向电动交通经济,美国在电池生产上拥有一定独立性,包括所有前驱体,这有国家战略层面的重要性。”(马斯克)

另一块是消费者税收抵免。这是特斯拉多年来第一次重新符合条件。前几年特斯拉早就超过了20万辆的补贴上限,别的车企还有额度,原因很简单,它们没造那么多电动车。

上海工厂的瓶颈在产能

谈到中国市场,Faber注意到发布会上那张图:在一堆中国车企里,只有比亚迪在赚钱。他问马斯克,低端市场的残酷价格战会不会影响特斯拉的份额。

马斯克的回答和很多人的预期相反。特斯拉在中国的限制是上海工厂的产能,需求并不缺。能造多少就能卖多少。

他确认上海也会建电池厂,主要生产Megapack,供应非美国市场。

然后Faber把话题转向地缘政治:中美之间的对抗在加剧,你担心吗?

“我认为所有人都应该担心。”(马斯克)

Faber追问,中国会不会对台湾采取行动。马斯克的回答几乎没有留余地:

中国的官方政策就是台湾应该统一。你不需要读字里行间,你可以直接读字面。我认为这个局势有某种必然性。(马斯克)

他接着用了一个很重的比喻。中国经济和全球其他经济体像连体婴儿。强行分离,后果的严重程度可以想象。而且对很多公司的打击比特斯拉更大:iPhone去哪儿造?先进制程芯片怎么办?台积电在台湾。

“你应该把他们的表态当真,他们是认真的。”(马斯克)

被传送到一架引擎着火、操纵杆失灵的飞机上

话题转到Twitter。Faber提到,特斯拉投资者对Twitter换CEO这件事挺高兴,因为觉得马斯克终于能把时间还给特斯拉了。

马斯克先回顾了收购交割时的处境。每年15亿美元的债务利息,同时年现金流是负30亿美元,账上只有10亿美元。按这个速度,四个月就破产。

他用的比喻是:被传送到一架正在俯冲的飞机上,引擎着火,操纵杆还不灵。

Faber问得直接:这飞机是你自己选择登上去的。

“我确实试图退出交易,但他们不让。”(马斯克)

他讲了那段过程。最初他提出收购,董事会说绝对不行,还搞了毒丸计划,态度基本是宁死也不卖。几个月后情况反过来,对方几乎是拿枪指着头说,你必须收购我们。

他一路觉得自己能找办法脱身,最后律师告诉他,法律上这个官司赢不了。

新任CEO是琳达·亚卡里诺(Linda Yaccarino),广告行业出身。马斯克说她极其擅长这一块,而且是个出色的高管。分工很清楚:琳达运营公司,他做产品和技术。

他把这套模式和SpaceX做类比。格温·肖特维尔(Gwynne Shotwell)运营公司,他负责推进技术,设计新火箭。每个人都应该做自己最擅长的事。

那时间怎么重新分配?

“我会把更多时间投入到特斯拉,尤其是AI开发和新产品开发,另外会多花一些时间把星舰送进轨道。”(马斯克)

他还提到一个操作细节:星链项目推进到一定阶段后,他把星链团队里最好的一批工程师调去了星舰项目,时间点刚好对上。

360万人申请,12万个岗位

访谈里插了一个数字,很能说明当下的就业市场。

特斯拉有大约12万名员工,而申请工作的人有360万。每年新增岗位也就两三万个。

马斯克说,进特斯拉或SpaceX的录取率,比进哈佛还低。

然后话题转向Twitter的裁员。收购时7800人,现在1500人,走了6300人。

Faber问,这些人都多余吗?

马斯克的回答比外界想象的坦诚:

不全是。有些人本不该被裁,因为我们根本没时间去一个一个判断。绝望的时刻需要绝望的手段,必须快速把人员开支和非人员开支压到至少打平的水平。这个过程里难免把洗澡水和孩子一起倒掉。(马斯克)

他说现在公司接近打平,还没到。接下来肯定要招人,如果那些人没那么生气,欢迎回来。但有一个前提:必须到办公室上班。

这就引出了他对远程办公最激烈的一段表态。

“你可以坐在家里工作,但给你造车的人不能,给你修房子的人不能,给你送餐的人不能,来你家修水管的人不能。他们必须出门,你凭什么可以?这公平吗?”(马斯克)

他不把这件事看作单纯的生产率问题。在他看来,这里面关乎公平。生产率当然受影响,人在面对面的时候效率更高,学东西也更快,可更根本的是那道落差:有些人能远程,有些人不能,而后者服务的正是前者。

他用了“笔记本电脑阶级活在拉拉乐园里”这样的说法。这批人默认自己可以享受远程的便利,同时要求其他人照常出门服务他们,这件事本身说不过去。

他自己的节奏:一周工作七天,一年里真正不工作的日子大概两三天。睡眠六小时。他试过睡更少,结果是醒着的时间变长,产出反而下降,脑子还疼。

他也补了一句:他不要求别人也这样。四十小时就够,周一到周四也行,该休假就休假。

Community Notes是个威慑装置

Faber请他解释“言论自由绝对主义者”这个自我定位,以及怎么处理平台上的谎言。

马斯克给了一个很大的框架。他对X(原Twitter)的设想是:成为人类的人造集体心智(cybernetic collective mind for humanity)。要让信息流动得快、准确、并且能自我纠错。

Community Notes就是他说的纠错机制。它的实际效果远大于笔记数量本身,因为一个人知道自己会被标注,就不太敢说假话,被公开纠错是件丢人的事。这个威慑对广告商一样有效,前面提到的那4000万美元就是这么没的。

Faber把话题引向2020年大选。特朗普的账号已经恢复,虽然人还没回来。如果有人说那场选举被操纵,平台怎么处理?

马斯克先说结论:拜登赢了,他自己也投了拜登。然后他补了一句:“我后悔了。”(马斯克)

他的解释是,他希望总统是个正常人、一个能干的执行者。总统本质上是这个国家的CEO,执行力被严重低估。很多日常决策跟意识形态无关,就看你有没有能力把事情办成。他引用了一句不知道出处的老话:从电话簿里随机抽人管理,可能都比哈佛的教职员工强。

至于选举舞弊,他的立场比较微妙。1亿人投票,舞弊概率为零这件事本身就是零,任何一场选举都会有一些。但这次选举被反复审计、打了无数官司,没有任何证据显示舞弊的规模足以改变结果。而且舞弊可能两边都有。

他愿意让人在平台上说这些,然后靠Community Notes去纠正。他说会被纠正的,百分之百。

“给我钱,给我权力,我不在乎”

Faber提到了那些让马斯克成为争议中心的推文。先是亨特·拜登的笔记本。“那件事是真的,而Twitter和其他平台当时主动压制了对公众有价值的信息,这很糟糕。”(马斯克)

然后是当天早些时候他发的关于乔治·索罗斯的推文,说索罗斯想侵蚀文明的根基、憎恨人类。

Faber问得很直接:如果这是你的看法,为什么一定要公开发出来?买特斯拉的人可能不同意,Twitter的广告商可能不同意。为什么要让全世界都看见?

马斯克先说了句“这是我的观点”,然后面对“这会让你成为靶子”的追问,他引用了电影《公主新娘》(The Princess Bride)里的一段台词:

给我钱,给我权力,我不在乎。(马斯克,引用电影台词)

他的意思很清楚:我要说我想说的话,代价是损失钱,那就损失吧。

Faber追问那条推文是否带有反犹意味,马斯克说自己是“亲犹的”。这场交锋没有继续深入,但它把一个问题摊在了桌面上:一个公司的CEO,个人表达和公司利益之间的边界在哪儿。

后来他们聊到艾伦市商场枪击案。马斯克转发的帖子暗示那可能是一场“心理战”(psyop)。他的解释是,那起事件被错误地归因为白人至上主义行动,而证据来自一个没人听说过的俄罗斯小网站,被Bellingcat(贝林猫)翻了出来,这家机构本身就做信息战。

“没有证据证明他不是,也没有证据证明他是。”(马斯克)

Faber问他是不是想在Twitter上辩论这个。他说是,因为不该在证据不足的情况下把事件归给白人至上主义。

AI伪造的时代,验证就是一切

Faber提到萨姆·奥尔特曼(Sam Altman)当天在国会的发言:AI操纵互动式虚假信息的能力是重大隐患。

马斯克完全同意,而且认为已经在发生。

这就是他推动Twitter付费验证的原因。蓝标意味着什么?一个来自正规运营商的手机号,一张信用卡,每月付一点钱。这三件事意味着你已经通过了运营商和银行的安全审查。

他把自己代入攻击者的位置算过账:如果我想操纵舆论,造一百万个账号让某个话题看起来在流行,我需要一百万个手机号、一百万张信用卡,每月付800万美元,还得保证这些信息不可追踪、不能被聚类分析。

“我认为这不可能做到。”(马斯克)

更棘手的是,最新的AI已经能绕过几乎所有“你是不是人类”的验证。老一套的图灵测试彻底失效,平台能做的只剩一件事:把造假的成本抬到经济上不可行。

钱就是信息

沃尔特·艾萨克森(Walter Isaacson)在传记里说,马斯克对Twitter的大目标是颠覆银行业。Faber拿这个问他。

马斯克先纠正了措辞。他不想为了颠覆而颠覆,如果有一个更好的产品,那很好,颠覆本身当不了目的。

他觉得PayPal只是个半成品,是一个本来可以做得更好的东西的中间版本。现在的金融系统是一堆异构数据库跑在大型机上,还在用批处理,很多环节不是实时的。

“钱本质上就是信息。”(马斯克)

完全可以有一套更高效、同质、实时的数据系统。他也承认这个说法听起来很玄,快掉进信息论里了。但这件事对他还有另一层意义:兑现他23年前对X的构想。

特斯拉会有一个“ChatGPT时刻”

访谈进入AI部分,Faber问他怎么看通用人工智能(AGI)的风险,会不会毁灭人类。

马斯克的回答分两层。AGI被称为奇点,就是因为之后的事很难预测。他觉得大概率是好事,人类会进入一个富足时代。但也有一定概率出问题,甚至毁灭人类。这个概率他希望很小,可它不是零。

所以他之前联署了那封呼吁暂停的公开信。他知道这封信号召不住任何人,还是签了,该说的要说。

关于外界传闻的xAI,他不肯展开,只说之后会有发布活动专门谈。

但他主动提了一件事:特斯拉在真实世界AI上的能力被严重低估了,远远领先于任何人,他甚至不确定第二名是谁。

Faber追问,为什么大家谈生成式AI只谈OpenAI、微软、谷歌,不谈特斯拉?

“特斯拉会有一个属于自己的ChatGPT时刻,可能今年,最晚明年。”(马斯克)

那个时刻是什么样?突然之间,三百万辆车能自己开了,然后五百万辆,一千万辆。

他顺手拆了Waymo。谷歌的Waymo能在很小的地理范围内、依靠高精度地图跑起来。一旦出现事故、游行、道路施工,它就不工作了。谷歌做了很多年,一直拿不出通用方案。特斯拉有。

他甚至给了一个思想实验:把任务对调,让特斯拉去做大语言模型,让微软和OpenAI去做自动驾驶,特斯拉照样会赢。

“我承认我在这里是个大傻瓜”

聊到OpenAI,马斯克明显带了情绪。他当年投了大约5000万美元,用他的话说,没有这笔钱,OpenAI根本不会存在。

故事要从拉里·佩奇(Larry Page)家的深夜长谈讲起。马斯克反复劝佩奇警惕AI的危险,佩奇完全不以为然,态度相当轻慢。当时谷歌收购DeepMind之后,手握全球四分之三的AI人才,加上算力和资金,AI世界是单极的。控制这个单极世界的人,对AI安全毫不在意。这在马斯克看来是个真问题。

最后一根稻草是佩奇说他是“物种主义者”(speciesist),因为他站在人类意识这一边,而不是机器意识那一边。

“对,我确实是物种主义者。”(马斯克)

OpenAI这个名字是他起的,Open指的是开源。它要做谷歌的反面:谷歌闭源、盈利,OpenAI就开源、非营利。他觉得盈利动机在AI这件事上可能带来危险。

Faber问他,回头看,当初出钱的时候有没有要治理权或者控制权?

“我在这里完全承认,我是个巨大的傻瓜。”(马斯克)

他解释当时的判断:这事大概率做不成,一只蚂蚁怎么跟谷歌DeepMind这头大象竞争。他在招募关键科学家上起了决定性作用,最核心的是伊利亚·苏茨克维(Ilya Sutskever)。伊利亚来回摇摆了好几次,戴密斯·哈萨比斯(Demis Hassabis)劝他别去,马斯克劝他去,反复拉锯,最后伊利亚加入了。

“伊利亚是OpenAI最终成功的那个关键支点。”(马斯克)

所以他对OpenAI现在的样子很不满。一个非营利、开源的机构,变成了盈利、闭源的公司。

这就像你出钱资助一个组织去保护亚马逊雨林,结果他们变成了一家伐木公司,把森林砍了卖钱。然后你说,等一下,这跟我给钱的目的是完全相反的。(马斯克)

他追问了一句:这合法吗?如果合法,那所有公司是不是都该先注册成非营利,再把知识产权转给一家盈利公司去赚大钱?

还有一个他更担心的问题:真到了那一天,谁说了算?OpenAI和微软到底是什么关系?微软作为投资方,拥有全部软件、全部模型权重,以及运行推理系统所需的一切。这意味着微软随时可以切断OpenAI。

“我确实担心,微软实际掌握的控制权,比OpenAI管理层意识到的要多。”(马斯克)

如果AI能比你更好地做你的工作

最后一个问题来自Faber自己。他有个即将进入职场的孩子,他不知道该怎么给建议。

马斯克的回答先很常规:追随内心,做你觉得有趣、有成就感的事,尽量对社会有贡献。

然后他往深里走了一层。假设我们真的到了那个“魔法精灵”的场景,你向AI要什么它都能给你,而且是良性的那种,人类怎么找到意义?

“我在这几家公司里投入了大量的血汗和眼泪,然后我会想,我该做这些吗?如果我为此牺牲了陪伴家人朋友的时间,而最终AI能把这一切都做得更好,那这些牺牲还有意义吗?”(马斯克)

他说这个问题不能想太深,想清楚了他会泄气。

“某种程度上,我必须刻意地悬置怀疑,才能保持动力。”(马斯克)

整场访谈里最诚实的一句,大概是这句。一个造火箭、造电动车、买下社交平台、又冲进AI的人,靠的是主动维持的、不被追问的信念。真把意义问题算到底,多数创造性的活儿都开不了头。

可以立刻用起来的几件事

  • 把决策依据换成实时数据。团队还在等月度报表的话,试试把关键指标做成每日自动推送,但只看两周以上的趋势,别对单日波动做过度反应。
  • 缩短“发现需求到调整价格”的链路。动态定价不是航空公司的专利,任何有库存和产能约束的生意,都可以把中间那层不透明的加价折扣换成公开的实时调整。
  • 评估任何自动化项目时,先算使用时长。同样一份资产,闲置时间和运转时间的比值,往往比采购成本更能决定回报。
  • 做内容或广告时,用“看完不后悔”当最低标准。提供信息、有美感、不误导,三条都过不了就别投。
  • 裁员要快,但要公开承认误伤。马斯克自己承认“把洗澡水和孩子一起倒掉”,并且明确说欢迎被误伤的人回来。这句话不说,组织信任恢复不了。
  • 制定远程办公政策前,先把一线员工的工作性质列出来。不能远程的岗位占多大比例,直接决定这个政策能不能站住。
  • 给任何AI生成的内容加一道验证成本。手机号、支付方式、实名信息,每加一层,大规模操纵的门槛就高一个量级。
  • 关注AI安全的同时,别只看发布会。真实世界AI的进展藏在车队规模、干预里程、事故率这些枯燥数字里,不在演示视频里。
  • 给自己留一个“刻意悬置怀疑”的空间。把长期意义想得太透,多数创造性的工作都做不下去。先做,再想。
  • 给年轻人的职业建议,与其押注某个岗位不被取代,不如押注“做有趣且对别人有用的事”这个能力本身。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00thank you for allowing us to to be here yeah you're welcome it's quite something to just sit and watch for quite some time yeah this is actually where I don't actually have an office here I either walk the floor or I hold meetings in this room okay and this room allows me to see what's going on with the production while I'm holding meetings is there one particular production that you focus on when you're here or that you sort of your eyes always go to or you you actually walk over to well this is the end of line that we're seeing here so if if cars aren't moving that means this there's some blockage upstream and then I can go and see what that blockage is

0:39so I think we might be on a break right now but this if if this this is if this if vehicle end of line is not moving that means there's something Upstream that's wrong got it well it's been amazing just to walk around the facility a bit and get a sense for the size all right you just finished your annual meeting you took a lot of questions from a very eager audience I feel like most of it you've shared before but there was some news and I want to start there advertising you got a big Applause you didn't sound like you were gonna advertise that much but you did at least seem to open the way to saying okay we might consider doing some advertising

1:17why well I mean I believe in listening to listening to shareholders and I actually was surprised by the level of enthusiasm for advertising since we were not historically done that but the there perhaps there's a some good logic to it in that if we're simply sending out information by say the the Tesla Twitter account on my Twitter account we're somewhat preaching to the converted and and not reaching people that are not already convinced essentially so I think they'll probably have a good point well I mean I think it's worth a try and we'll see so we'll see how effective do you have any idea how you'd like to try it or what that would involve

1:58well I'm gonna have some general thoughts about advertising that that you know if advertising is informative and and entertaining then it is it can start to approach content so I think sometimes advertising is perhaps a non-informative or perhaps a some in some cases a bit misleading and in fact we've lost some advertisers on on Twitter because Community notes applies to advertising too and so if somebody advertises something that isn't perhaps a bit inaccurate then it gets community noted and then they they get mad and stop advertising but we're we care enough about the truth that we're willing to give out to give up advertising dollars on Twitter even

2:48if you know in order to to have the most the least inaccurate right and I want to talk about that but I want to obviously spend some time on Tesla again back to ads though I mean am I going to start to see test Labs during the NFL broadcast on a given Sunday Monday Thursday the NFL's always on well bear in mind I mean I only just agreed to it so it's not like I have a fully formal strategy okay well how much time does go into when you think about these things I mean was it something you decided to do up on stage or at least did you know coming in I may you know if this comes up that I may go there no I mean the questions are not scripted in any way right so so in that moment

3:29you just said all right yeah we'll do some ads that's right so we're only like 20 minutes later and I'm asking you detailed questions you don't have any answers I guess I'm not sure what the most effective thing is except that like I said I believe that advertising should be informative about a product it should be ideally aesthetically pleasing to be you know beautiful should have some artistic element to it and it should be something that you don't regret watching after it's done and I think if advertising fits those criteria that it starts to approach content and you want advertising that is as close to to content as possible such that you don't regret the time you spend

4:08watching it but you did say something as well which is that you know you've been preaching to the converted you mentioned a few statistics for example about safety about price during the meeting that may not be fully understood by The General auto buying public at Large yeah so a lot of people still think Teslas are super expensive because we did start out with a expensive sports car then like a slightly less expensive sedan and SUV but now we're at the point where the starting price of a Tesla is actually below the average selling price of a car in the United States so it Teslas are actually much more affordable Than People realize and so we should just make sure

4:48people at least know that right and that Tesla's also the safest cars on the road in in so many ways that people actually a lot of people at Tesla don't even know you know sort of the cabinet overheat protection for example or the fact that we continuously update the automatic emergency braking software and the the way the airbags deploy so we we look we look at an accident we say is there anything we can do from a software standpoint to improve the cars that are already on the road and then what can we update in the design to improve safety so and the I think that you know the statistics speak for themselves this is not simply a matter of opinion it's

5:29statistically it's safer than anything else you mentioned affordability it's something you discussed during your meeting you've also discussed it a bit on the call on the earnings call recently as well in relation to the Federal Reserve raising interest rates and obviously the monthly cost for a typical auto buyer you think it's going to be a tough 12 months ahead you've said that a few times yes for everyone not just Tesla understood so it's a I mean it's simply you know you can think of raising the Fred Fred rate as somewhat of a brake pedal in the economy frankly it's so it's it it makes a lot of things more expensive certainly things that are

6:07bought with credit but then it has Downstream effects on on even things that aren't on board with credit so you know if if the car payments or your home mortgage payment is absorbing more of your monthly budget then you have less to money to buy other things so actually it affects everything even those that aren't things that aren't important credit so and my concern with the with the way the Federal Reserve is making decisions is that they're just operating with too much latency basically the data is is somewhat stale so they so the Federal Reserve was was slow to raise interest rates and and now I think they'll slow they're going to be slow to lower them

6:46that's that that appears to be the case yeah that may well be we spent a lot of time talking about that as you can imagine perhaps too much but when it comes to latency that takes me to pricing because you've discussed the lack of latency in your own ability to understand exactly what's going on in the market for those cars as opposed to yeah many of the Legacy and other yes yes we have real-time information on demand so right so we we know how many people place an order for a Tesla yesterday so the computer calculates that all and and literally every day we get a you know an automated email to the exact staff that says how many people place an order in which countries

7:29for which cars you know so we know what demand we know we know what the orders were yesterday and right you don't want to overreact to these things because sometimes you get like little dips or you know reasons that are hard to explain do you look at them every day yeah yeah but like I said you don't want to overreact to to you know if like a week is slow or something you don't overreact to that but if but if

7:55you look at the trend say for over two two weeks ban or something like that you can see that okay there's this for some reason the demand is is less than it was or it's higher are you almost like an airline at this point in terms of kind of you know your Dynamic pricing model yes so we we we're basically adjust pricing to to match demand and we obviously did a big price drop in q1 but no no January is is usually a terrible type of car buying so those the seasonality to car purchases with generally generally is often the worst month so so we did we did a big price drop and then and then then recently we did we did a price increase so as I mentioned to the audience the

8:54the reality is that all companies do significant all card companies make significant adjustments to price because you've got the MSRP number and then if demand is high a dealers will charge some premium over MSRP if demand is lower they'll they'll have manufacturing setups so that you can actually see a very big difference of over the course of say six months between the peak to trough of of all cars it's just that Tesla is so immediate and obvious and transparent it's not a question of MSRP and then markups or discounts right but after your last earnings a lot of investors came away wanting to talk about your margins and wanting to talk about your pricing in particular I think

9:36you know you talked about vehicle cost reduction you sort of even said it's hard to explain the profundity of technically selling cars now for no profit and still yielding tremendous economics over time yes I'd like you to explain a little bit more of what that means he did a bit in the meeting as well you're talking about sort of the move I think from manual to autonomous and the value add that will come along with that but explain to people why that's profound and why conceivably not that you want to you could sell automobiles now for no profit and still make enormous profit in the future yeah so Tesla is the only car company selling cars that where we believe the

10:18car is capable of achieving full autonomy with a software update so the the value of a fully autonomous fully autonomous car is we think perhaps five times more valuable than a non-autonomous car why well the utility of a car typically a passenger car is going to be maybe 10 10 hours a week maybe 12. if you say like somebody's going to drive an hour and a half a day on average so maybe maybe an

10:48hour of commute per day and then an occasional long trip but figure it's like 10 12 hours a week is typical for a passenger vehicle and then you also have a lot of costs associated with parking you need a garage or you've got to buy a parking space or you've got to get a you know get a parking ticket at the mall it's there's a lot of costs associated with cars and you know if you've got a car that's autonomous that can go around and essentially be like an autonomous Uber the utility I think is is going to be so it's going to be much higher perhaps you know and this again there's so much speculative I understand we're talking about Robo taxes here at least

11:32what people have called and you have called yeah autonomous Uber is what do you think about it so perhaps the utility then would be on the order of 50 hours a week this is just a gas they say there's 168 hours a week and probably as a rough guess an autonomous car is will be able to be active instead of four or ten hours a week probably you know in our view for about 50. but it's the same car so the

11:57and it costs the same to build but you're I want to understand the business model a little bit because I'm buying the car and instead of it parking at my lot while I'm working it goes off and picks people up and drops them off yes who's making the money from that I assume there that's the value ad you're talking about is it a revenue share do you have this model sort of planned out specifically is how it would look yeah it's it's been in the test of terms and conditions for for quite a long time no it has yeah so the the owner of the car would make I don't know some amount who knows what it would be but perhaps it you know could be a 50 50 split or 70

12:3930 I don't know but the the cars are are if you buy a Tesla car it can only be used in the Tesla Network it cannot be used in someone else's Network so that that means that if the car is able to be used five times as much it and and Tesla is likely to make basically two or three times the original value or sale value of the car in in Robo taxi Revenue right this this is this is gigantic as I said it'll be like selling cars for software margins because in fact it is software right so

13:21instead of effectively having say 25 margins it might be 70 or 70 or more and I mean the the free cash flow associated with that it is actually truly a staggering amount the best analysis that I've seen thus far about this is from Kathy woods from Ark invest you know Kathy well yeah she's great yeah I would assume you like her obviously she's been a huge proponent of your stock for many years was right by the way very early on she was right yeah so I I I thought she was being optimistic but I actually turned out to be in fact almost spot on yeah and I am familiar somewhere with her analysis what a lot of investors come back to or everybody is your promises of

14:12of full autonomy and you seem to be saying again it's close you said it before you know that yes no I mean you said 19 I think about 20. I've certainly been you know if I I guess I have somewhat of a pathological optimism well it works by the way because you don't end up with this unless you're optimistic but yeah exactly I mean who would try to do this and this and Rockets if they weren't pathologically no you'd have to be yeah so there's a you know there's a double-edged sword I guess but but you know do you ever say to yourself all right I'm getting a little ahead of myself here I mean when you said again we're going to have full autonomy no I didn't say very well I

14:54said I thank you in my opinion we probably will okay right there's a number of qualifiers there I think in my opinion we probably will so what do you think in your opinion you probably will when I mean it does look like it's going to happen this year why well we're not at the point where the car can drive on highways and in cities with and where a human intervention is extremely rare so I mean just I was able to drive for several days just dropping a navigation pen in random locations in the greater Wilson area with no interventions and the same in San Francisco which is a very difficult place to drive so I mean it's you've got bus lanes one-way streets

15:41this is you know so it was quite quite a challenging homeless situation you were driving recently in San Francisco where the car was I have been doing doing that quite a lot because of Twitter's headquartered course maybe less maybe a little less soon yeah we'll we'll get to that but go finish it this is why you feel more why you're optimistic I'm obviously for that reason which is that the I I've actually never this is the first time I've had a situation where there's been several days in a row going picking random destinations and having no safety related intervention right it's the first time ever I want to get to a lot of other topics but you know I am curious on

16:30Tesla in particular one thing I haven't heard you discuss is is the impact on your business of the inflation reduction Act at least I haven't heard it maybe you've discussed it you know Adam Jonas who follows your company at Morgan Stanley said we believe the IRA is so advantageous to Tesla in terms of absolute dollars versus the Legacy oams it could equal as much as 45 percent of current earnings per share is the IRA going to be usually beneficial to your company I I I'm not sure it'd be it's gonna be that beneficial there's there are there are significant advantages for having domestic production of batteries which I think is important for strategic reasons you

17:17know I think as we move to an electric transport economy I think it's important for the United States to have some independence with respect to battery production including all of the precursors necessary for a battery so the the IRA is strongly had sense that and I think that will prove to be something of important of of national strategic importance in the future so I I'm not sure I would say it's as good as say a 45 increase in earnings per share over 40 it's it's is it it's helpful yeah yeah I would say it's maybe it's have that or something okay but I mean it's quite significant have you mapped to that at all do you have a a sense I mean

18:02obviously you talk about storage for example which is so important you spend time on that as well the mega pack is it beneficial in that particular area Beyond obviously the the credits the tax credits that certain people get for buying a Tesla yeah there's two there's really two plus two the Ira there's the incentive for battery manufacturing and it's really quite a detail it's especially a very well written well in in that it's it really makes sure that you can't game it you know so you actually have to blow up the batteries in in the US and you actually have to build the precursors of the batteries but if you do it is I believe thirty dollars at the at

18:44the cell level and fifteen dollars at the Pack level I believe if I recall correctly so that that is very significant for batteries and then you've got the consumer tax credit for EVS provided they are built in the US and that the package built in the US so yeah now this this is the really the first time that we've actually had the the first time in many years that Tesla's actually had the consumer tax credit yes because we actually exceeded the limit for the consumer tax credit several years ago and so up until December or until January this year I should say there was no consumer tax incentive to buy a Tesla but there was for the other car

19:29companies because they have not reached they've not made that many electric cars right they didn't reach their limit yeah you know before I wrap on Tesla I would like to get to China which is obviously an important market for you you know I noticed that chart you put up byd is the only company that seems to be making money so far are you concerned at all about you know a ruthless pricing sort of at the low end in the Chinese market and what that will mean to your market share that well currently a limitation with it is that is the is the production rate of our Shanghai Factory it's not demand so you know so that's there's some constraints on our ability to expand in

20:17China and and so it's we're making as many points as we can it's not a demand issue and you're going to be making batteries soon as well yes yes for the mega pack for for mostly for non-us markets yeah so are you concerned at all about the growing belligerence between China and the US I think that should be a concern for everyone I think you're right I think it is shared by many people who run large organizations and smaller ones do you think for example China will will make a move to take control of Taiwan the official official the official policy of China is that

21:02Taiwan should be integrated one does not need to read between the lines one can totally read the lines do you think so I think there's a certain there's some inevitability to to the situation that would not be good for Tesla conceivably or for any any company in the world frankly yes or any company in the world I think most almost no no one really realizes that the Chinese economy and the global the rest of the global economy are like conjoined twins it would be like trying to separate conjoint twins that that's the severity of the situation and it's actually worse for for a lot of other companies than it is for for Tesla I mean I'm not sure not

21:49sure where you're going to get an iPhone for example and Apple's recently started doing some some sort of small amount of production in India but it's tiny it's tiny not to mention Advanced semiconductor chip if they take over Taiwan semi correct so you design your own chips but you manufacture them at Taiwan send me too right we do some we do we do we use Samsung and tsmc right but but you seem to think it's it's likely to happen I'm certainly saying that that is their policy and I think you should take their word seriously they mean it you know your time I think you've said in fact some of the brief conversations we've had you know is one of the most valuable things in your own

22:34control and I am curious now and Tesla investors sort of seem to Rejoice at the announcement of a new CEO at Twitter in part because they thought well he's gonna have more time for Tesla that's true is it true how do you see sort of allocating your time now that you will soon no longer be the CEO of Twitter yeah so you know it was it was really very challenging situation at the point in which the Twitter acquisition closed because you know in rough terms that there was a billion and a half dollars of debt Services added while at the same time it was a massive site exactly you said you were four months away from bankruptcy it was three billion dollars

23:17in a year conceivably negative three billion dollar cash flow and had a billion billion dollars in the bank yeah no that's not good no anybody who knows anything about Corporate Finance knows that's bad no I mean I I say like the analogy I was using was it's like being teleported into a plane that's in a nosedive headed to the ground with the engines on fire and the controls don't work right yeah you chose to get into the plane well I did try to exit the deal and they wouldn't let me know it was a funny situation where when I first first proposed the acquisition they said hell no they adopted a poison pill basically saying they'd rather die than be than be acquired like the

24:00rather chew on Cyanide and then a few months later that they're like basically have a gun to my head saying no you must acquire us I mean that's quite a change it is quite a change but you seem to think I I can figure out a way out of this until finally I guess you realized I can't it was made clear to me that the decision would not come down in my favor legally yeah all right well now you have a new CEO

24:26yeah that's good Linda your career is going to be great why well Twitter is is very much an advertising independent business Linda is obviously incredible at that and she's just a great executive in general so the and you know my my skills and interests are in technology so you know I'll continue to to play a role advancing the software and you know you know getting the Futures product stuff basically so I mean the general idea is Linda Linda will operate the company and and I will build products yeah and that's I think that's that's a good that's a good and that will take less of your time yeah and I have I have that situation at SpaceX yeah well who's amazing you

25:20know operates the company and I and I I've broken the sort of advanced technology right both sort of Designing the new rockets and that kind of thing and and that's you know everyone should play to those strengths and that's that's mine that's true although I wonder you I mean in 2021 you said you spent most of your time on the development of Starship I think you've also been quoted I've read or I think I heard you say actually most of your mental energy at certain points has been on Starship yes so I wonder have you been diverted from Starship a little bit and we'll return to it as the main focus or is it Tesla you know again your time I know having tried to schedule this

25:55interview with you time time triage is a real thing yeah in fact I I I I the the the the I'd say that the only real currency is time time is the only true card so where are you going to spend the currency now that you don't have to spend as much at Twitter well I'm gonna be devoting a lot more time to to Tesla and especially on on the AI development and new product development the and and then there's and I'll also I'll be allocating some more time to getting Starship to orbit the in the case of SpaceX what I was able to do there was to take as as the starlink constellation I

26:42started working I was able to move some of the the best people from the stalling program to the Starship program so they were you know the timing kind of worked out well that that I mean we have really some of the world's best engineers at SpaceX and Tesla really some incredible human beings there was some statistic you shared I think 3.6 million people applied for a job at Tesla I think I did I wrote it down I didn't write it down here so it's remember but that was that the number yeah it's crazy there's a lot of demand we have 127

27:17almost 120 000 employees but 3.6 million people applying for a job yes and I mean there's you know we would only add like say 20 or 30 000 jobs so it's it's sort of the the acceptance rate for for Tesla is is it's much more difficult to get into Tesla or SpaceX than Harvard right the acceptance rate is is even lower one for two well yeah it's it's it's it's the acceptance rate is lower than the most demanding universities in the world it's insane speaking of employment though you had 7 800 people at Twitter when the plane was nose diving I think you're at 1500 now so roughly 6 300 people were they all Superfluous no not all do you figure out which ones aren't or

28:08is it a little late you know sometimes it gets a little late I mean look desperate times call for desperate measures so there's no question that some of the people who were let go probably shouldn't have been let go because we we simply did not have the time to figure out we had to be you know make make widespread Cuts to get the Run rate under control so you know and so so this is not to say that hey everyone who is like go from Twitter is like somehow terrible or something it's just we we have to with very little information get get the the the head count expenses and the the non-personnel expenses down to where at least break even and we're not quite a break even

28:54yet but we're close we need to do it fast and if you if you do it fast unfortunately they're going to be some babies thrown out without water so so I definitely I definitely would not want to say you know disparage you know anything but it's funny you know I hear from other I've heard from other Tech CEOs quietly they look at what you did at Twitter and they sort of they won't admit it publicly but you know they say wow that was something I mean to cut that deeply and still be able to run the company people will argue about how well or things are running have you heard from any of these CEOs who said thank you for doing that giving us sort of Runway or leeway to at least

29:36make some cuts of our own I I have I've heard that from a few people and and I heard that through the grapevine yeah but like I said I I if desperate times call for desperate measures and unfortunately those were desperate times so do you see starting to I mean will lend hire people do you think or are you ready for people to be hired at Twitter you know I think we absolutely need to need to hire people and and if they're not too mad at us probably rehire some of the people that they were let go and they're gonna have to come into the office look I I I'm a big believer that that that people need to are more productive when they're in person and

30:19and and and and really man I and the whole sort of work from home thing it's like I I I think it's like there are some exceptions but I kind of think that that the whole notion of work from home is is a bit like the you know the the fake Marie Antoinette quote like the meat cake it's like it's like it's like really you're gonna work from home and you're gonna make everyone else who made your car come work to the fact work in the factory you're gonna make the people who make your food that gets delivered that they can't work from home the you know the the people that come fix your house they they can't work from home but you can does that seem morally right

30:59that's messed up you see it as a moral issue yes I mean I see it more it's a productivity issue but it's also a moral issue you also get off they go on a moral high horse with the work from home because they're asking everyone else to not work from home well they do and yes there's still pushback by the way it's still going on this battle is still happening I mean leaders of organizations and I speak to plenty of them I want people back I want people back three days a week they're still battling it's not clear that it's ever going to change to people are not coming back the the the the laptop class is living in la la land okay as I said the you you

31:38can't but look at the cars oh people working from from home here of course not so the so the people were you know building cars servicing the cars building houses fixing houses making the food making all the things that that people consume it's it's messed up to assume that that this they have to go to work but you don't how is that that is it's not just a productivity thing I think it's Marley Marley wrong although productivity is definitely impacted too and the ability people learn and I mean on and on listen I I so I mean look you know people will disagree with me about this but I you know it's like so if you want to work at Tesla you want to work at SpaceX you want to work

32:25at Twitter you got to come into the office every day yes I mean you know like I'm not saying I'm I'm saying like look we put 40 hours in you know and frankly it doesn't even need to be like you know Monday through Friday you know you could work Monday through Thursday and also not saying no one should take I mean I think people should take vacations like I work seven days a week but but I'm not expecting others to do that how much sleep do you get by the way about six hours you do six hours typically yes oh that's not bad I thought it would be less I've tried less but I my productivity my even though I'm awake more hours I get less done okay and the Brain pain level is

33:06bad if I get less than six hours but you work seven days a week yes yeah I I actually only in terms of actually if you say like how how many days in a year do I not put in some meaningful amount of work it's probably about two or three right two or three days a year yeah a year yeah yeah yes I want to get to some more specific questions about Twitter that sort of have a more Global aspect and I still want to get to AI you're going to give us some time here can we still yeah I think we've got a board meeting coming up but I'm happy to give as much time as reasonably possible I think it's maybe at six or something okay well let's what time is it now it's 5 45. all right I love

33:47another 20. all right at least 20. great let's talk about Free Speech a bit you know you call yourself a free speech absolutist you want Twitter and this is aspirationally aspirationally you want Twitter to be as truthful as possible most accurate source of information about the world so what does that mean for how you police lies on the platform you mentioned Community notes is that I think Community yeah I mean I'd say so my overall kind of vision for Acts or Twitter is to be a cybernetic Collective mind for Humanity this is going to sound quite esoteric in sci-fi but so the if if you know in pursuit of

34:33that objective you want to have information move quickly have that information be accurate and you want to have error correction on that information so you can think of community notes as like an error correction on information in the network and the effect of community notes is actually bigger than it would seem it's bigger than the number of notes because if somebody knows that they're going to get noted they are less likely to say something that is false because it's embarrassing to get community noted okay and that applies even to advertisers by the way right we've lost that's so far 40 million dollars in advertising because it was misleading or because

35:12of the community with the community you know it's two two pretty big advertisers got community noted and I I I yes I think on balance security notes were correct and and I did I did say to those advertisers look provide just go on Twitter and provide some facts that contradict the community note that's the way to deal with the community note is to say is you is that the community note is saying that the ad is misleading for the following reasons if you've got information that robots that note then just add that to the ad okay well we're coming up on an election I mean it's a ways away but it's going to all start yeah president Trump is allowed back

36:03on the platform he hasn't actually come back right but one would imagine if and when he does or there are others who will say 2020 election was rigged is that something I assume that's not something you believe I well I think the the answer the answer is is nuanced it's like do I believe Biden won yes I believe he won and you voted for it I did actually do you regret that I mean man I I wish we could have just a normal human being as president that's what I want I think if if we could you know there's that old saying of like we're better we're better off being run by by people picked at random from the phone book than the faculty of Harvard yeah I don't know who said that

36:53but if someone were very wise and and I I I I would I would say if we could do that for the president that that would be great obviously you're not happy with buying don't we all just want a normal human being whatever I'm not even sure anymore what normal means no but I mean like you know just I don't know so you want somebody's competent that's helpful yes I think definitely somebody's executive ability is underrated since the president is effectively the chief executive officer of the country it actually matters if they are a good executive officer yeah it's not simply a matter of do they share your beliefs and that you know but but are they good at getting

37:35things done there's a lot of decisions that need to be made every day many of them are unrelated to what moral beliefs you know right and and you just want a good executive who said their CEO of America they are they are we want a good CEO of America who's going to do Be an Effective unfortunately we live in highly partisan times where there is war about everything yeah including ideas including the truth which gets back to it's not true that the election in 2020 was rigged it wasn't stolen and I wonder on the platform when you see that does that end up in a community note or is that something you take more action on and obviously I mean to be clear I I I I

38:18I don't think it was it was a stolen election but by the same token if somebody's going to say that there's there's never any election fraud anywhere this is obviously also false yeah if 100 million people vote the probability that the fraud is zero is zero this election was audited it was so many judges I mean it went on and on and on and there was no nothing whatsoever that I don't want to debate this with you my question is more about I think it's important to say like that in any given election even if you try your hardest if you've got 100 million votes there's gonna be some some amount of fraud that is not zero and that that it's important

39:03to acknowledge that without saying that that the fraud was of sufficient magnitude to change the outcome so so my opinion would be that there was some there was some small amount of fraud but it was not enough to change that and by the way it might have been either way I mean I you know yeah this is probably a little bit but again it's going to be you're going to let people say that though on the on Twitter and then you're going to hope that they're corrected they will be corrected they will be oh yeah 100 let's talk a bit about your tweets because it comes up a lot even today it came up in you know anticipation of this I mean you know you do some tweets that seem

39:40to be or at least give support to some who would call others conspiracy theories well yes but I mean honestly you know some of these conspiracy theories have turned out to be true which ones well like the the hunter Biden laptop that's true yeah yeah so you know that that that was a pretty big deal there was Twitter and and and others engaged in active suppression of information that was relevant to the public that's that's a that's a terrible thing that happened that's like an interference but how do you make a choice you don't see I mean in terms of when you're going to engage I mean for example even today Elon you you tweeted this thing about George Soros

40:27what I'm looking for because I want to make sure I quote it properly but I mean you know what you wrote but you basically reminds me of my vetoes is like you know calm down people this is not like medical case out of it you said he wants to erode the very fabric of civilization and Soros hates Humanity like when you do something like that yeah I think that's true that's my opinion okay but why share it why share it especially I mean my share it when people who buy Teslas may not agree with you advertisers on Twitter may not agree with you why not just say hey I think this you can tell me we can talk about it over there you can tell your friends but why

41:03share it widely I mean I this is freedom of speech I'm allowed to say whatever you absolutely are but I'm trying to understand why you do because you have to know it's got a there it puts you in a in the middle of a the partisan divide in the country it makes you a lightning rod for criticism I mean do you like that I you know people today saying he's an anti-semite I don't think you are no I'm definitely I'm like I'm like a pro Semite if anything I I believe that probably is the case why would you even introduce the idea of it that that would be the case I I mean it looks we don't want to make this a George Source interview no God no I don't want him at all but I'm what I'm

41:43trying even came up though in the annual meeting I mean you know do your tweets hurt the company are there Tesla owners to say I don't agree with his political position because and I know it because he shares so much of it or their advertises on Twitter that Linda Ocarina will come and say you gotta stop man or you know I can't get these ads because of some of the things you tweet

42:14you know I'm reminded of the there's a seat in The Princess Bride great movie great where he confronts the person who killed his father he says I offer me money offer me power I don't care see you just don't care [Music] you want to share what you have to say I'll say what I want to say and if if if the consequence of that is losing money so be it okay but I mean when you when you link to somebody who's talking about the guy who killed children in a mall in in Allen Texas you say something like it might be a bad psyop I'm not quite sure what you meant but oh in that particular case there was a a so somehow that that's not not that the the the that the artistic people were

43:34killed but the it was I think incorrectly ascribed to be a white supremacist action and the evidence for that was some obscure Russian website that no one's ever heard of that had no followers and the the company that came that found this is bellingcat right and you know what Bella cat does psyops right I couldn't really even follow exactly what it was you were trying to express there so that's part why I was curious but I'm saying that I thought the the the ascribing it to white supremacy was okay and and and and that the information for that came from an obscure Russian website and was somehow magically found by ballingcat which is a company that does psyops

44:22and there's no proof by the way that he was not there's no I would say that there's no proof that he is and that's a debate you want to get into on Twitter yes because we should not be ascribing things to white supremacy if they're if it's false okay can we talk about AI now actually I want to talk about AI well let me end with Twitter in the sense of Sam Altman was on the hill today and he said ai's ability to manipulate interactive disinformation is a significant area of concern it's moving so quick it is a significant and how you know I yeah I'm curious as to whether you agree with that how you see that even playing out on Twitter with people who

45:05yeah no somebody could you know look like you and and or me and use our voice I don't know what it could be oh that that that that that is happening big time so the the the the the so the the reason that I'm asking people to be verified on on Twitter and and and and that we're saying okay verification means you've got a phone number from a reputable carrier which means that you've at least passed through whatever their security mechanisms are that you have a a credit card which so you now have

45:41passed through whatever security mechanisms the credit card company has and that there's some small amount of money paid per month that that set of actions significantly increases the cost of of a fake accounts and the with with moderate with with the latest AI it can bypass basically every test for are you a human right so so then how do you know that a million accounts were created how do you know that those are people I don't know how do you exactly you have to do you have to do account verification and the thing that makes like I sort of put myself in a position of like if it was my goal to manipulate public opinion and create millions of

46:29accounts and make it seem as though a topic was trending and and that and that this is actually what the public believes but in order to do so I I had to get a million phone numbers a million credit card numbers and pay you know eight bucks a month right and and have that all not be traceable and clustered I would say it's impossible impossible so the the goal of the of

46:58the sort of Twitter verification is fundamentally to prevent AI manipulation of the system got it final question on Twitter Walter Isaacson your biographer he said your big goal for Twitter is disrupting the banking industry well is that accurate I I'd say that's that's that's a that's a I look first of all I don't disrupt something with the same sake of disrupting it it's more like if there is a better product that's great but I'm not output disruption for the sake of disruption I'm like if we can make a product that improves a quality of life for people that they find more useful that that's great and what what people see in PayPal is sort of like a sort of a halfway it's

47:45sort of a sort of a it's frankly sort of a half-baked version of what it could be and and so I think there's potential to create a more efficient Financial system and here we can get again quite quite esoteric and sort of into sort of information Theory but the the actual Financial system today is a heterogeneous set of databases running on mainframes and Koval that still engage in batch processing it's really quite very inefficient so things are still not real time and and so it's possible to have a much more efficient homogenous real-time data system money is just information and and so the so but that's not like the only reason it's just a thing that that would be I

48:40think poetic to fulfill ultimately the vision that I had for x over 23 years ago and and actually see that County fruition would would be nice but but there are many other things for for Twitter it's not just financials well you talk about enhancing Humanity you know I'm curious then about AI which many people say will lead to Great productivity gains you showed those robots I mean I can imagine what they conceivably could do when powered by AI but I am also curious because you've certainly been concerned what percentage do you give the chance that it will destroy Humanity

49:22well the the Advent of artificial general intelligence is called a singularity because it is so hard to predict what will happen after that I think it's it's very much a double double-edged sword I think and it's there's a there's a strong probability that it will make life much better and that will have an age of abundance and and there's some chance that it goes wrong and destroys Humanity hopefully that chance is swole but it's not zero and so I think we want to take whatever actions we can think of to minimize the probability that AI goes wrong you've called for a pause along with the number of other people yes I look when I called for a friend of mine Max tegmark is a

50:05physicist at MIT you know I wanted you to sign on to the letter and it's it's like I I knew it would be futile it is I knew it'd be true I just want to call it like it's one of those things well for the record I recommend it that we pause did I think we would there would be of course absolutely not you're starting xai I I think that's

50:30what you're calling it or some new AI effort how is it going to be different than open AI or alphabet this is this is not the time to to this it's not I I we don't have enough time and and nor is this the moment to really talk about it we will have a launch event and we'll explore the the issues in more detail but I I should say that that and I mentioned this at the shareholder meeting that Tesla has actually tremendous capability in real world AI yes in fact it is very far ahead of of anyone I know people actually on Twitter prior to our interview were saying you know he never gets asked about how advanced his AI is at Tesla you always talk about

51:22the other names like I said by it's like if there's not I'm not even sure who's second frankly why is that why then what what are people not understanding about what you have and why are we talking so much about chat GPT and generative AI at open Ai and what Microsoft's going to be able to do with it and not about Tesla I don't know I mean people do talk about it online I think I think Tesla will have sort of a chat GPT moment maybe if not this year I'd say no later than next year wait say that again I'm sorry you're gonna have a sort of chat GPT moment oh you will in terms of suddenly it will yeah suddenly three million calls will be able to drive themselves with no one

52:04right it goes back to that right yeah and then five million cars and then 10 million cars so the the and and and and I would I would also say that if if positions were reversed and say well in fact the positions are are reverse for example Google has waymo which is a you know sort of attempting self-driving and they are able to make self-driving work in a very limited geography with with very tightly mapped streets but as soon as any as soon as anything goes wrong with those tweets like if there's an accident or a parade or road construction it stops working it basically Google is unable to to produce a generalized solution to self-driving that works anywhere they've

52:51been trying to do that for a long time they've been unsuccessful Tesla basically has that and and and is is far more advanced than Google yeah and so if the positions were reversed and you said Okay Tesla's got to produce a large language model that has output equal to a greater than EVT or Microsoft open AI has to do self-driving and we just we flip the tasks Tesla would win you'd win yes you have the computing power and everything else you need to do it absolutely I'm being told we don't have that much time do you can you give me another five minutes or yeah yeah I think so I do have a board meeting I know but five minutes is probably fine sure okay

53:34thank you open AI I mean you seem somewhat frustrated with them you were one of the big contributors early on the reason I am the recent open AI exists how much money did you give them so I I I'm not sure the exact number but it's some some number on the order of 50 million dollars so so the man fate loves irony next level

54:06so I used to be close friends with Larry Page and I would say at his house and we'd have these conversations long into long into the evening about Ai and I would I would be constantly urging him to be careful about the danger of AI and and and and he he just he was really not concerned about the danger of AI and was quite Cavalier about it and and and at the time Google especially after their acquisition of deepmind had three quarters of the world's AI Talent they had obviously a lot of computers and a lot of money so it was a unipolar world 4 Ai and and to go to unipolar world but but the the person who who controls that does not or at least did not seem to be

54:52concerned about AI safety that that's not that sounded like a real problem so and then the final straw was Larry calling me a speciesist for being pro-human Consciousness instead of machine Consciousness and I'm like well yes I guess I am I I am a speciesist and and so right so you helped to the creation of open AI you put as much as 50 million dollars more than helps it wouldn't exist with that it wouldn't exist without you I came up with a name the name open AI refers to open source so it's the intent was what's the Opera okay so what was the opposite what's the opposite of of Google which would be a an open source non-profit because Google is

55:34closed so it's full profit and that profit motivation can be financially dangerous so should you have gotten governance for that money should you have gotten some level of control perhaps in retrospect yeah I I I fully admit to being a huge idiot here so anyway so so open AI was like meant to be openly open as an open source it was created as a buy one T3 and but but so so part of it is also in the beginning I thought look this is this is probably a hopeless Endeavor how could we possibly compete with how could open AI possibly compete with with Google deepmind I mean this this seemed like an ant against an elephant you know not a contest

56:26and and I was also I mean I I I I was instrumental in recruiting the the key scientists and Engineers most specifically most notably ilyascar in fact Ellie went back and forth several times because that he would say he's going to join open AI then Demis would convince him not to then I I would convince him to do so and then and this went back and forth several times and ultimately he decided to join open Ai and really Ilia Jordan was the what was the linchpin full opening eye being ultimately successful so you're very disappointed in what's happened there in terms of it becoming a for-profit in some way I I do think that there's some look it does seem weird that something

57:23can be a non-profit open source and somehow transform itself into a for-profit closed Source I mean this would be like like let's say you funded an organization to save the Amazon rainforest instead they became a lumber company and chopped down the forest and sold it for money and you'd be therefore like well wait a second that's the exact opposite of what I gave the money for yeah is that legal that doesn't seem legal and if it is and and in general if it is legal to start a company as a non-profit and then take the IP and transfer it to a for-profit that then makes tons of money shouldn't everyone start shouldn't that be the default and and then I also think it's important

58:16to understand the the like like when push comes to shove let's say they do create some some digital super intelligence almost Godlike intelligence well who's in control yeah and and what is exactly is the relationship between open Ai and Microsoft and I do worry that Microsoft actually may be more in control than say the leadership team at open AI realizes I mean Microsoft as part of the Microsoft's investment they have rights to all of the software all of the model weights and everything necessary to run the inference system so they essentially have a great deal of control at any point Microsoft could cut off open AI Elon I'm being told we have to wrap

59:00up your board has been very patient I want to end on one AI question you have a lot of kids I have some kids I have one who's actually soon to go into the workforce I struggle with how to advise him about a career when this technology exists and will only improve I'm just curious when you think about advising your children on a career with so much that is changing what do you tell them there's going to be a value

59:30[Applause] [Music] well that is a tough question to answer I guess I would just say you know to to sort of follow their heart in terms of what they find interesting to do or fulfilling to do and you know try to be as useful as possible to the rest of society you know if we do get to the sort of like magic Genie situation where you can ask the ad for for anything

1:00:16and let's say it's even the benign scenario let's say it's a benign scenario how do we actually find fulfillment you know it's how do we find meaning in life if the AI could do your job better than you can I mean if I think about it too hard correctly it can be just dispiriting and demotivating because I mean I I go through I I've put a lot of Blood Sweat and Tears into building the companies and then it and then I'm like well should I be doing this because if I'm sacrificing time with friends and family that I would prefer to to but but then ultimately the AI can do all these things does that make sense I I don't know to some extent I have to have

1:01:09deliberate suspension of disbelief in order to remain motivated so I I guess I would say just you know work on things that you find interesting fulfilling and and and that contributes some good to the rest of society well that's a great place to end there's so much we didn't get to I hope you'll give me another chance to sit down with you but Elon thank you for being so generous with your time thanks to your board for waiting as well and thanks for having us here at this incredible facility appreciate it thank you you're welcome all right pleasure

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份