访谈·中文精读

马斯克接受《纽约时报》完整专访,对话安德鲁·索尔金

Elon Musk Full New York Times Interview with Andrew Sorkin

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

马斯克在那场访谈里给自己的定性很干脆:在他发过的三万条帖子里,那条关于"实际真相"的回复,"可能是我做过的最糟糕、最愚蠢的一条"。

说这话的时候他坐在《纽约时报》DealBook 峰会的台上,对面是认识十六年的老友安德鲁·索尔金(Andrew Sorkin)。台下坐着广告商、记者、投资人,还有刚被他隔空点名的迪士尼 CEO 鲍勃·艾格(Bob Iger)。

这场对话从那条推文开始,一路聊到星链的开关、中国的工厂、OpenAI 的宫斗、AI 的时间表、他十二岁那年的存在主义危机、Neuralink 的猴子,以及自动驾驶会死多少人。两个多小时里,他道歉了,也骂人了;承认自己蠢,也坚持自己没错。

他自己承认:三万条帖子里最蠢的一条

事情的起点众所周知。他在 X 上回复了一条声称"犹太人正在推动对白人的仇恨"的帖子,说"你说出了实际真相"。

索尔金念了这条推文,然后问他:你知道外面是怎么说的吗?白宫、犹太团体、反诽谤联盟,所有人都说马斯克是反犹分子。

马斯克的回答里有一个很实在的句子。他说,如果重来一次,他不该回复那个特定的人,而且应该把话说得更长、更清楚。他后来确实在回复里做了澄清,但那些澄清被媒体忽略了。用他自己的话说:

我等于给那些恨我的人递了一把上了膛的枪,或许也递给了那些真正反犹的人。那不是我本意。(马斯克)

索尔金追问了一个细节,很尖锐。他说自己也是美国犹太人,真正让他后背发凉的,是那些反犹分子在网上欢呼:"太好了,埃隆真棒。"

马斯克没有回避这一点。他说自己很快就在主时间线上发帖,明确表示他不反犹,甚至是"亲犹"的。去以色列的行程在那之前就定好了,跟这场风波无关。

他脖子上挂着一块狗牌,上面写着"带人质回家"。那是一位人质父母给他的,他说只要还有人质被扣押,他就一直戴着。

索尔金还问了一个所有人都好奇的问题:他发帖的时候,会不会有意去激怒某一群人,或者反过来去安抚某一群人?马斯克的回答很平淡,他说自己确实发过一条原话是"我谴责一切形式的反犹主义"的帖子,那条就是字面意思。他还半开玩笑地补了一句:如果大家需要,他可以翻同义词词典再写一遍。

广告商的钱和"让地球来评判"

访谈里最出圈的一段,是他对广告商的回应。

索尔金提到,很多广告商正在撤离 X,包括迪士尼。马斯克直接说:

如果谁想用广告来勒索我,用钱来勒索我,去你妈的。说得够清楚吗?嘿,鲍勃,你就在台下。(马斯克)

这里有个容易被剪掉的细节。索尔金先问他:你希望他们停止投放吗?马斯克说希望。索尔金愣了一下,追问:你是说你不希望他们投广告?马斯克才把上面那句话甩出来。

坐在台下第一排的是 X 的 CEO 琳达·亚卡里诺(Linda Yaccarino),她的工作就是卖广告。马斯克自己也承认了这一点,然后补了一句:这场广告抵制会杀死这家公司。

索尔金换了个角度继续问:如果 X 的商业模式必须摆脱对广告的依赖呢?

马斯克的回答是,如果公司因为广告商抵制而垮掉,那它就是因为广告商抵制而垮掉的,全世界都会知道是谁干的,而且"我们会把细节记录得非常详细"。

索尔金提醒他:广告商会说,不是我们杀的,是你说错话杀的,我们只是不想待在一个让人不舒服的平台上。

马斯克的回答是:"去跟法官说。"然后自己补了一句:"法官就是公众。"

这段对话里有个关键转折。索尔金指出,他做 Tesla 和 SpaceX 时极其专注产品和工程,从不会说"让子弹飞"(let the chips fall where they may)这种话。为什么到了 X 就变成这样?

马斯克的回答把他的价值观摊开了:他在意的是"好"本身,并不在意"看起来好"。原话是,他到处看到有人一边在乎形象,一边干着邪恶的事。

索尔金还问了一个很多人想问的问题:你后悔买下 X 吗?要不要考虑卖掉它,或者干脆送人?马斯克的回答绕开了这道题,他说自己时不时会说些蠢话,三十多年积累下来大概有三万条帖子,那条"实际真相"的回复可以排进最蠢的前几名。

火箭炸了你立刻知道错,舆论不会

这场访谈里最有价值的一段,是他解释自己为什么能在骂声中保持自信。

索尔金问他:你被无数人说过错,Tesla 要完、SpaceX 要完,结果你都做成了。现在别人再说你错的时候,你会不会因为过去赢太多次,反而听不进去?

马斯克先把这个问题的逻辑复述了一遍,确认自己没听错,然后给出判断标准:

物理是法律,其他一切都只是建议。你可以违反任何人类制定的法律,但你试试违反物理定律。如果你错了还坚持错下去,火箭就会爆炸,车就会散架。(马斯克)

这句话解释了他前半生的所有成功。造火箭和造车有一个残酷的好处:现实会立刻给你打分。一千种可能里只有一种能让火箭入轨,错了就是错了,没有辩论空间,也没有公关团队能救。

但他也提到一个很有意思的比喻。他说找出哪条物理定律错了,有点像找出哪种冰淇淋口味最好。这个类比的意思大概是,在物理世界里试错的反馈非常明确,你能很快知道哪一步走歪了。

索尔金马上把话题推到了更麻烦的地方:你现在做的很多决定跟物理无关,全是人的决定。星链给谁用、不给谁用,这些没有物理定律给你判卷。

白宫那场没请他的电动车峰会

谈到政治立场为什么右转,马斯克给了一个很具体的起点。

拜登政府上台六个月内办了一场白宫电动车峰会,邀请了福特、通用、克莱斯勒,唯独没请 Tesla。马斯克说他们去问了原因,得到的答复是"就是不让你们来"。他补充了一句:我们没做任何挑衅他们的事。

更让他咽不下去的是,拜登随后公开说通用在"引领电动车革命"。马斯克把数字摆了出来:同一个季度,Tesla 造了 30 万辆电动车,通用造了 2600 辆。

他在这里罕见地露出了很个人化的情绪。他说 Tesla 有 14 万员工,一半在美国,创造的制造业岗位比所有其他公司加起来都多。他还提到自己当年为了见奥巴马排了六个小时的队。这句话他说得很轻,但意思很清楚:他跟民主党没有旧怨。

索尔金顺势问出那个所有人都想问的:你花了二十年推动电动化和气候议题,可你支持的维韦克·拉马斯瓦米(Vivek Ramaswamy)公开说气候问题是个骗局。这怎么自洽?

马斯克的回答很干脆:"我在气候问题上不同意他。"接着补了一句:我还没有为任何人背书总统竞选。

至于 2024 年那一票,他说得很明确:不会投给拜登。索尔金追问会不会投特朗普,他的回答是"我也没说会投特朗普,这确实是个艰难的选择"。而谈到尼基·黑利(Nikki Haley)主张社交媒体实名制,他的态度立刻硬了起来:这太过分了,他不会投给一个支持审查的候选人。

一个城市广场配了七十亿个扩音器

关于 X 的定位,马斯克用了一个他重复过很多次的比喻,但这次讲得最完整。

他说,你去时代广场走一圈,偶尔会听到有人在那里胡说八道。可那个人只能对着周围五十到一百个人喊,他没有扩音器。

X 的问题在于,它给了每个人一个扩音器。

他承认其中有个难题(conundrum)。但他同时给出了一个数据判断:在 X 上,仇恨内容被推荐的概率其实很低,而且今天比一年前好得多。他建议用户自己去看看自己的信息流,判断仇恨内容变多了还是变少了。

索尔金作为重度用户提出了一个更真实的抱怨:我是记者,我去找东西,算法就一直喂我更多同类的东西,包括我讨厌的人。

马斯克的回答有点像产品说明,也有点像吐槽:系统会问,你是不是经常跟这个人互动?是。那它就认为你想跟这个你讨厌的人多互动。这个逻辑说得通。

然后是 X 最有意思的产品:社区笔记(Community Notes)。

马斯克强调,X 的原则是只加语境,不删内容。谁都不豁免,广告商也不豁免。他举了个公开的例子:Uber 投过一条广告,写着"像老板一样赚钱",社区笔记在下面加了一句:"如果你说的老板是指时薪 12.47 美元。"这条笔记让 Uber 暂停了一阵子投放。

《纽约时报》也问到了。索尔金说今年夏天《纽约时报》的链接似乎被限流了。马斯克的回答很简单:X 要求所有机构都买订阅,没有例外。他自己要看《纽约时报》也得付钱,所以他不会白送。《纽约时报》每月一千美元就能恢复。索尔金追问这算不算压制言论,马斯克的回答是那句玩笑:"自由不是免费的,伙计。"

星链的开关握在谁手里

索尔金把话题引向了一个越来越难回避的问题:你手里握着星链,乌克兰战争在用,台湾在观望,这种权力该怎么处理?

马斯克先做了一个澄清。他强调自己的权力不来自任何反竞争行为,只来自执行得好。Tesla 把专利开源了,任何人都能免费用;超充网络向其他厂商开放了,充电技术白送给同行;SpaceX 基本不申请专利,偶尔申请只是防专利流氓。他提了一个反问:"你能举出另一家这么做的公司吗?"

关于蓝色起源,他的回答出乎意料地大方。他说如果有个按钮能一键删掉蓝色起源,他不会按。他认同贝索斯的动机,觉得多一家造火箭的公司是好事,只是"建议他多花点时间在上面"。

然后是索尔金真正想问的:星链算不上垄断,可它是唯一好用的那个。这就是杠杆。你怎么看这种杠杆?

马斯克的回答把责任推回给市场:如果我们的产品不好,用户会用钱投票,换别家。他还补充说,自己的公司受几十个国家的几百个监管机构管着。

这里他讲了一个关于监管的段子,值得记住。媒体总爱统计他跟监管机构吵架的次数,听起来像个刺头。但真实比例是:他的公司遵守了大约一千万条法规,只对其中五条提出过异议。他说,反对那五条的唯一理由,是他认为那些法规名义上为公众利益服务,实际上没做到。他还打了个比方:把所有要遵守的汽车法规打印出来,能堆满整个舞台,没有这些合规文件,车根本不能上路。

中国的四分之一和"法律边界"

索尔金问得直接:你在中国的生意很大,X 又是一个言论自由平台,这算不算虚伪?中国对你有没有杠杆?

马斯克先划清界限:星链和 SpaceX 在中国没有任何业务。Tesla 在中国有四家工厂中的一家,中国约占它四分之一的市场。他强调这种情况不止 Tesla 一家,几乎所有车企在华销量都占差不多这个比例,所以这属于整个汽车行业的问题,不能只算在 Tesla 头上。

接着是他对这类问题的标准答案,也是理解他行为逻辑的一把钥匙:

我只能做法律允许范围内的事,超出这个范围我做不到。我的愿望是在合法的前提下尽可能多做好事、尽可能有产出。再多我就做不了了。(马斯克)

这句话可以拿去解释他所有的争议:X 在各个国家能做的极限,就是遵守当地法律。他自己也提醒,不要把几家公司的处境混在一起谈。

从"开放"到"超级闭源为盈利"

聊到 OpenAI,马斯克的语气变了。这场政变般的宫斗发生时,他正在处理自己那堆头条。

他先讲了 OpenAI 的起源。2015 年前后,谷歌加 DeepMind 聚拢了全球三分之二的 AI 人才,算力上几乎无限,那是一个单极世界,没有任何制衡力量。

他和拉里·佩奇(Larry Page)当时是密友,常住在佩奇家里聊 AI 安全聊到深夜。然后他意识到一件事:佩奇并不在乎 AI 安全。让他确信这一点的,是佩奇骂他"物种主义者"(speciesist),意思是,你像个种族主义者,只不过歧视的对象换成了物种。

马斯克的原话是:「等等,拉里,你站哪边的?」

这就是 OpenAI 诞生的原因。它本该是开源的,名字里的 Open 就是开源的意思。马斯克说,现在它应该改名叫「超级闭源为最大利润 AI」(Super Closed Source for Maximum Profit AI)。

他提到了一个朋友的"约拿定律":最可能发生的结果,是最讽刺的那个结果。OpenAI 从一家 2015 年成立的非营利开源机构,变成一家估值 900 亿美元的闭源营利公司,正好符合这条定律。他说自己也想不明白,从那里到这里,中间那段路是怎么走通的,甚至怀疑这整件事合不合法。

关于萨姆·奥尔特曼(Sam Altman)被解雇,他说自己有复杂感受,用《指环王》里的至尊戒打比方:权力之戒会腐蚀人。

他更在意的是伊利亚·苏茨克维(Ilya Sutskever)。伊利亚是他从谷歌挖来的,那次挖人直接导致佩奇跟他断交。马斯克说伊利亚有很强的道德指南针,会在"什么是对的"这类问题上反复煎熬。所以如果伊利亚觉得问题严重到要解雇萨姆,那这件事就值得全世界知道原因。

他联系过伊利亚,对方不想跟任何人谈。他也问过很多人,没人知道内情。他给出了两种可能:要么是件严重的事,公众应该知道;要么不是严重的事,那解雇就说不过去。

然后他说出了自己真正的担心:他怀疑 OpenAI 内部发现了某种危险的 AI 元素。

三年之内,机器会比最聪明的人聪明

索尔金问他:那个精灵(genie)出瓶子了吗?

马斯克的回答是,精灵已经把头探出来了。

他给了一个具体时间表。如果把"比最聪明的人类更聪明"定义为能在任何领域胜过任何人,比如写出 J.K. 罗琳水准的小说、发现新物理、发明新技术,他的判断是不到三年。

他顺带说了一句很有画面感的话。所有那些模型权重,本质上就是一个逗号分隔值文件(CSV)里的一堆数字。

那就是我们的数字上帝,一个 CSV 文件。听着好笑,但字面上就是这样。(马斯克)

他解释了自己为什么三十年没碰 AI。大学时代他就认为 AI 会彻底改变世界,但他一直算不清这把双刃剑哪一边更锋利。所以他先去做了那些"单刃"的事:可持续能源、让生命成为多行星物种、星链的连通性。

提到星链,他补了一个细节:乌克兰人说星链在阻止俄军推进上起了关键作用。

AI 不一样。AI 是那个"魔法精灵"问题。你可能以为自己想要一个精灵,但精灵出了瓶子之后会发生什么,谁也说不准。

他承认自己一度因为 AI 的危险失眠。后来他变成了宿命论者:就算他知道结局是毁灭,他也会选择活在这个时代,因为这是人类历史上最有趣的时刻。这个念头让他睡着了。

关于监管,他说了一句让全场安静的话:现在各国政府开始管 AI,最大的原因就是他本人在反复敲鼓。他的立场是,AI 比核弹更危险,而核弹是被监管的,你没法在自家后院造一枚核弹。他还顺带点了一句:总有人把 AI 当成天堂,所以一听监管就炸毛。

版权官司还没判完,数字上帝已经出生

索尔金问了一个很现实的问题:xAI 和其他模型的差别在哪?

马斯克的答案是数据。X 可能是地球上最好的数据源,全世界指向 X 的链接比指向任何其他平台都多,这一点谷歌一下就能验证。他说很多人以为 Facebook 或 Instagram 更大,其实链接流向完全不是那样。OpenAI 那场宫斗,全程就是在 X 上直播的。

然后是全场最锋利的一段。索尔金提到,AI 公司一直声称自己没有用版权内容训练模型。

马斯克直接打断:

这是赤裸裸的谎言。所有这些人都在版权数据上训练,显而易见。(马斯克)

索尔金追问:那创作者和版权方该怎么办?毕竟一篇文章一千字,理论上可以被拆成无数条引用发到 X 上,最后拼成一个完整的语料库。

马斯克的回答既冷酷又诚实。他说,等这些官司判下来,我们已经有数字上帝了。到那个时候,这些小小的诉讼根本不在一个相关的时间尺度上。

他没有为此辩护,也没有给出解决方案。他只是描述了正在发生的事。

十二岁那年的问题,和"42"

访谈进行到这里,索尔金问了一个更根本的问题:你做这一切,到底是被什么驱动的?

马斯克讲了一段很少完整讲过的经历。

十二岁左右,他经历了一次存在主义危机:人生的意义是什么?如果一切终归无意义,为什么不干脆自杀?为什么还要存在?

他去读宗教经典,读哲学书。他特别提到德国哲学,说那些书让他相当抑郁,还开玩笑说别在青少年时期读叔本华。

救他的是道格拉斯·亚当斯的《银河系漫游指南》。那是一本用幽默写成的哲学书。亚当斯的真正观点是:我们根本不知道该问什么问题。所以答案才是 42。地球是一台巨型计算机,算出了答案,但真正难的是搞清楚问题是什么。

他说这在物理学里也成立:一旦你能把问题正确地表述出来,答案往往是最容易的部分。

这构成了他全部事业的动机。人的一生在银河尺度上只是一闪,但如果能扩大意识的规模和范围,我们就更有能力去问出关于这个宇宙的正确问题,也许能找到生命的意义。他甚至列了几个人类还没答上来的问题:我们从哪来,往哪去,外星人在哪,暗物质和暗能量背后有没有新物理。

所以 SpaceX 的目的是让生命在可持续的基础上延伸到地球之外。他用的是费米大过滤器(Fermi great filter)的框架:如果一个文明只待在一颗行星上,它就是在等着某次灭绝事件,无论那是人造的还是自然的。成为多行星物种,才有资格谈多恒星物种。

但他强调这里头还有更重要的东西。人需要早上醒来时对活着感到高兴,需要对未来有期待。他给了一个很具体的建议:如果你不确定未来有什么可期待的,去问你的孩子。

我的脑子像一场风暴,不是愉快的那种

索尔金提到他一个月前说过的一句话:「我不认为大多数人真的想成为我。他们以为想,但他们不知道那是什么感觉。」

马斯克承认了。他说自己的心智经常像一场风暴,念头多到根本执行不完。他用一句话概括:创新不是问题,执行才是问题。他脑子里有一整套电动超音速垂直起降飞机的设计,放了十年,做不了。

索尔金问:这场风暴是愉快的风暴吗?

马斯克的回答是"不是"。他说自己大概天生如此,然后被艰难的童年放大了。他记得即使是小时候快乐的时刻,脑子里也总有一团翻涌的力量。

这股力量大部分被导向了造东西。他举了一串例子:Tesla 如果只把超充网络拆出来,单独就是一家财富 500 强公司;他们自己造电芯、电力电子、动力总成;用了史上最大的压铸件;制造技术比干了一百年的老厂还好。

他也承认,偶尔会出岔子,那条推文就是。

他为什么现在更像右派

索尔金把话题推到政治上:过去两三年你明显右转了。

马斯克的回答绕回了第一修正案。他说,言论自由只在一种情况下有意义:当你讨厌的人可以说你讨厌的话。否则这个词毫无意义。一旦你向审查让步,早晚会有人来审查你。

他谈到了自己对两党的判断。这话他说得很谨慎,但结论明确:目前来看,民主党比共和党更倾向审查。他补了一句,这跟历史上相反,左派曾经是言论自由的旗手,美国公民自由联盟当年甚至为纳粹分子的言论权辩护过。

他顺便吐槽了加拿大:没有宪法保护的言论自由,也没有米兰达权利(你有权保持沉默这条)。他说自己算半个加拿大人,所以有资格说这话。

至于 TikTok,他说自己不用,原因很个人化:他感觉那个 AI 在探查他的大脑,让他不舒服,所以停用了。

他不认为 TikTok 是中共的阴谋,算法完全是 AI 驱动的,目标只有一个:找到最能让你黏在屏幕上的内容。但他指出了一个数量级问题:全世界有二十亿穆斯林,犹太人只有两千万左右,差了不止一个数量级。纯粹按内容生产的基数算,反犹内容自然会压倒性地多。

没有老爷和农奴的工厂

谈到 UAW(美国汽车工人联合会)在福特和通用的胜利会不会蔓延到 Tesla,马斯克的回答很坦率:他反对工会。

但他的理由跟成本无关。他说工会会在公司内部制造"老爷和农奴"的结构,而这是他最讨厌的东西,工会也容易在公司里制造对立情绪。

他举了两个对比。Tesla 里很多人从产线工人做到了高级管理层,所有人都在同一张桌子吃饭,同一个停车场停车。通用有专门给高管用的电梯。

他强调自己不是旁观者。他在产线上干过,睡过工厂,走过每一条线。他甚至提议在 Tesla 搞一次工会投票,结果被告知公司不允许组织这种投票。

他真正担心的事听起来有点反常识:Tesla 的难题在于怎么留住好工人,工人并没有被困住。造车是苦活,同一个人在外面有六份更轻松的活可以干。他还提到,很多产线工人当初连股票是什么都不知道,现在成了百万富翁。他说自己非常感激造车的人,这一点他们心里清楚。

猴子天堂、霍金和复明

Neuralink 是这场访谈里最科幻的部分,也是马斯克讲得最具体的技术部分。

他先回应了"猴子死了"的新闻。美国农业部的检查员去过 Neuralink 的设施,说在她整个职业生涯里没见过更好的动物照护条件。马斯克的说法是,这里是"猴子天堂",对老鼠也一样好,尽管老鼠传播过瘟疫。

关于死亡,他的解释是:确实有几只猴子死了,但那是在几年前,那些猴子本来就已经是绝症末期,研究团队判断可以在它们身上试装实验设备。猴子死于癌症,跟植入物无关。他还说,现在有猴子已经带着植入体生活了两三年,状态很好,设备甚至换过两次,猴子还能靠意念打游戏。

关于时间表,他说几个月内会做第一例人体植入。

他把早期应用称为"单刃剑",也就是纯粹的好事。第一批使用者是失去脑与身体连接的人,他们能用意念操作电脑或手机,速度比有手的人还快。他的比喻是:如果霍金能比健全人更快地交流,那会是怎样一件事。

下一阶段是视觉。给双眼或视神经损坏、完全没有复明可能的人做直接的视觉接口。他甚至说,到那时你可以看见任意频率,比如像《星际迷航》里的乔迪·拉福吉(Geordi La Forge)那样,直接看见雷达波。

人类是糟糕的司机

最后一段谈的是自动驾驶,以及一个很少被摆上台面的问题:公众能不能接受有人死于电脑驾驶的车。

美国每年有 3.5 万到 4 万人死于交通事故,全世界大约一百万人。马斯克说,人类是糟糕的司机:发短信、喝酒、吵架、做各种不该在开车时做的事。以这个基数看,现在每年死这么多人反而算奇迹。

他的预测是,电脑驾驶会让死亡率下降一个数量级,全球范围内降幅可能超过 90%。它不会完美,但会好十倍。

索尔金追问:公众会接受吗?政府会接受吗?

马斯克的回答是,最终这会明显到无法否认。

他也承认自己在时间表上一贯过于乐观。他说,如果不是病态乐观,他根本不会去开火箭公司和电动车公司。当年他给 SpaceX 和 Tesla 估的成功率都不到 10%,别人说这两家公司会失败的时候,他自己是点头同意的。

至于 FSD,他给的数据是:监督版的全自动驾驶目前大约比人类驾驶安全四倍,而且逐年进步明显,在多数地方可以从一个地点开到另一个地点而不需要干预。他承认"说我迟到,这个批评是公平的",但后半句是"我最终总会交付"。

这里还有个细节值得留意。索尔金说,很多投资人其实是在明知道他们不相信的情况下投的钱。马斯克的回应是,这正好说明没人是因为盲目相信他才下注的。

一天一小时,还是新手机的四分钟

访谈快结束时,索尔金玩了一个现场游戏:掏手机,看屏幕使用时间。

马斯克说,他发帖基本靠碎片时间,比如每三个小时去一次"实验室"(上厕所)的时候。索尔金让他打开设置里的屏幕使用时间,结果显示四分钟。

马斯克立刻解释:我刚换了新手机,这个数字不准。

索尔金让他看整周的数据,数字依然很低。马斯克自己的估计是每天一个多小时。他说自己同时干七份工作,发帖严格来说也算工作的一部分。

索尔金还问了一个前瞻问题:你会自己做手机吗?App Store 会不会成为下一场仗?

马斯克的回答是,没有做手机的必要,如果真有必要他会做,但他手上的事已经够多了。他倒是给了一个判断:所有手机厂商现在都卡在同一个问题上,一块黑色矩形,接下来还能怎么改进?他自己心里的答案是 Neuralink。最好的界面,就是直接接到大脑的界面。

最后两个字:放大共情

11 月 11 日,他在 X 上只发了两个词:amplify empathy,放大共情。

索尔金问他当时在想什么。马斯克的回答简单到让人意外:他在跟几个朋友聊天,大家都同意应该试着放大共情,于是他就写了这两个词。他说自己一向很字面。

整场访谈里,他一边骂广告商去你妈的,一边说自己亲犹;一边把 OpenAI 改名叫"超级闭源为最大利润 AI",一边说伊利亚有道德指南针;一边承认那条推文是这辈子最蠢的一条,一边拒绝为"让子弹飞"的姿态道歉;一边说 AI 可能比核弹更危险,一边说这是人类最有趣的时代。

索尔金最后说了一句话收尾:如果你想看一个不加修饰的马斯克内心,你刚刚看到了。

读完之后可以做的几件事

  • 把"物理是法律,其他都是建议"当成一把尺子。下次你要判断一个观点靠不靠谱,先看它有没有被现实打分的机制。有反馈闭环的判断可以信,没有的只能当假设。
  • 重新理解你和平台算法的关系。你点开的每一个你讨厌的人,都是在告诉系统"多给我一些"。想要什么样的信息流,就先去改变自己的点击行为,抱怨没有用。
  • 看到有人说"AI 没有用版权数据训练"时,记住马斯克的判断:那是谎言。如果你靠内容吃饭,现在就该想清楚自己的内容资产怎么定价、怎么授权,别等官司判完,因为官司判完时游戏规则已经改了。
  • 给自己设一个三年窗口。马斯克押的是三年内出现全面超越最聪明人类的 AI。你不必认同这个时间点,但可以拿它当压力测试:如果你的工作核心是处理和生成文本、图像、代码,三年后你还剩下什么不可替代的部分?现在开始补。
  • 对自动驾驶的公共讨论保持警惕。真实的数字是人类驾驶每年在全球杀死约一百万人。当你看到某起自动驾驶事故被放大报道时,把它放回这个基数里再判断,别被单点案例带跑。
  • 如果你管团队,学他那个"没有老爷和农奴"的原则:同一张桌子吃饭,同一个停车场停车,管理者下过一线。真正让人愿意留下的,是尊严和上升通道,薪酬表只是其中一项。
  • 最后一条,关于那句"放大共情"。在一个算法奖励愤怒的时代,这条建议有操作性:发帖前问一句,这句话是在增加理解,还是在增加对立。如果是后者,删掉重写。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00we've been friends for 16 years and I promised you I'd be here and that's why I'm here well I appreciate you being here for any other reason but let me ask you this this then go go at it just tell me what happened you you you write this tweet that says that this is the actual truth people read that tweet yes and they say Elon Musk is an anti-semite that he he he he is he is riling up this base you're hearing it from as I said the White House you're hearing it from Jewish groups all over I think Jonathan greenblat from the ADL was here there's there's a lots of people who say this and by the way it's not just that did you read the whole thing I did and

0:38that's why I want to ask responses excuse me I said more more responses I said more than what you just read yes no there was ABS there was more yes but I'll tell you the thing that struck me it wasn't and I'm an American Jew it wasn't just the people who who had the view it was actually people who H who antisites who said oh my goodness go go Elon is fabulous and that actually was the thing that really really me back and I said to myself what's going on here and I want to know how you felt about that in that moment when you when you all of this happening yeah well first of all I I did almost immediately what I meant I would say that that was you know if I could go

1:20back and say I should in retrospect not have replied to that particular person and I should have written in Greater length as to what I meant I did subsequently clarify in replies but those clarifications were ignored by the media and essentially I handed a loaded gun to those who hate me and arguably to those who are antisemitic for that quite sorry that that is not that was not my intention so I I did know post on my

1:54primary timeline to be absolutely clear that I'm not anti-semitic and that I in fact if any anything and philosemitic the trip to Israel was planned before any of that happened it was neither here nor there do you see you saying mhm you know what it is I do because I actually followed your entire trip to Israel right why don't you tell everybody this is this says says bring the hostages it was given to me by the parents of of one of the hostages and I said I would wear it as as long as there was a hostage store remaining and I have what was that trip like and obviously you know that there's a public perception that and this now but there's a public perception

2:37that that was of a apology tour if you will that this had been said online there was all of the criticism there was advertisers leaving we talked to Bob Iger I hope they stop you hope don't advertise you don't want them to advertise no what do you mean if somebody's going to try to Blackmail me with advertising blackmail me with money go [ __ ] yourself but go [ __ ] yourself is that clear I hope it

3:04is hey Bob you're here in the audience well well let me ask you then that's how I feel don't advertise how do you think then about the economics of of x if if if if the underlying model at least today and maybe it needs to shift maybe the answer is it needs to shift away from advertising if if you that this is the one part of your business where you will be beholden to those who have this view what do you do FY I I

3:35understand there's a reality too right yes no no Lind Yaro is right here and she's got to sell advertis absolutely so no no to tell so what no no actually what what this advertising boycott is is is is going to kill the company and do you think that the and the hold will know that those advertisers killed the company and we will document it in great detail but there are those advertisers as I imagine are going to say they're going to say we didn't kill the company oh yeah they're going to say tell it to tell it to Earth but they're going to say that they're going to say Elon that you killed the company because you said these things and that they were inappropriate things

4:13and they didn't feel comfortable on the platform right what and let's see how Earth responds to that so me okay this then this go back to we'll both our cases right and we'll see what the outcome is what are the economics of that for you I mean you you have in resources so you can actually keep this company going for a very long time would you keep it going for a long time if there was no advertising I mean if the company fails because of AD Advertiser boycott it will fail because of an Advertiser boycott and that will be what bankrupted the company and that's what all everybody on Earth will know what do you think then of the back to the idea

4:47of trust though then be gone gone because of an advertised boycott but but you recognize that some of those people are going to say that they didn't feel comfortable on the platform and I I wonder and ask you and think about that for tell it to the judge but but there's going to be the judge is the public and you think that the public is going to say that that Disney is making a mistake yes and they're going to boycott Disney they already are well there there that are for for for different reasons but you think that this is going to that you have the this goes to actually the interesting of P of of power leverage let the chips fall where they may let

5:24the chips for where they may can I ask what why that is approach I ask it because you've been what's approach well you've been very particular about the I mean the approach to Tesla when you think about the engineering involved in that the approach to SpaceX the approach to some of the stuff you're doing with with AI been very specific right there's not a let let the Chip Fall where they may approach to those businesses I don't think no we focus on making the best products and and and ta's gotten to where it's gotten with no advertising at all I understand that Tesla currently sells two twice as much in terms of electric Vehicles as the rest of electric car vehicles in United

6:03States combined Tesla has done more to help the environment than all other companies combined would be fair to say that therefore as a leader of the company I've done more for the environment than everyone any single human on earth how do you feel about that I feel about that yeah no I'm I'm asking you how you feel about that because this goes we were talking about power and influence and I'm saying I'm saying what what I care about is the the reality of goodness not the perception of it and what I see all over the place is people who care about looking good while doing evil [ __ ] them okay let me ask you this because I think part of this by the way there's

6:42some people who said look owning X to begin with has just created problems that you've created so many amazing things that are changing our world and and and I to make X this fabulous Town Square fre Free Speech platform but that unto itself s that that has created some distraction of all of these things this is the conversation we're having we're not focus or not talking at least yet and we will on Tesla you have your cyber truck deliveries tomorrow and everything else that you're doing but it would be the biggest product launch of anything by far on Earth this year is is there part of you though that just says you know what I just shouldn't have done

7:20this or maybe I should sell it or give it away or do something else W with with the X piece of it yeah given GI given the propensity for some of the things that you do and say on that platform to create these these issues yeah the post of I I've done on the platform I think there might be 30,000 or something like that right once in a while I will say something foolish and I have and I would certainly put that comment that you said the actual truth among perhaps one of the most foolish if not the foolish thing I've ever done on the platform and I my best to clarify afterwards that you know I I certainly do not mean anything anti-semitic in that the the

8:09nature of the criticism was simply that the Jewish people have been persecuted for thousands of years there is a natural Affinity therefore for persecuted groups this has led to the funding of organizations that essentially promote any persecuted group or any group with the perception of persecution this includes radical Islamic groups everyone here has seen the the massive demonstrations Hamas in

8:39every major city in the west that should be jarring well an a number of those organizations received funding from prominent people in the Jewish Community they didn't expect that to happen but but if you generically without conditions sort of fund if if if you find some of those persecuted groups unfortunately want your Annihilation and what I'm what I'm when I subsequently clarified is is that it's to to to find organizations support

9:13groups that want your Annihilation is this coming across clearly my my question to you though is I think logically this is makes a lot of sense is there any part of you I mean just tell me what happens though when once all this happens let's say you fund a group and that group supports who wants you to die perhaps you should not F them but you but you you you do appreciate that when you wait into these very delicate Waters at these very delicate times yes that it can create a real I mean as it created headlines for the past two weeks and and economic impact what what I'm just curious what H in your brain when you see all this happening are you sitting there going oh

9:57my God I stepped in it I wish I didn't do that are you saying screw them I hate these people why are they after me but all of that yeah all of that I mean I mean look I I'm sorry for that that that tweet or post it was foolish of me of the 30,000 it might be literally the worst and dumbest post that I've ever done and I try to my best to clarify six ways this Sunday but you know at least I think over time it will be obvious that in fact far from being anti-semitic I'm in fact philosemitic and my all the evidence in my track record would support that me ask do this though there are people who say crazy things on on X as you know maybe you think they're

10:42crazy maybe they're not the the the the aspiration for X is to be the global Town Square now if you were to walk down to let's say Time Square right do you occasionally hear people saying crazy things yes but they're not megaphone right and that's that's the conundrum but they can only say it to the 50 or 100 people that are that are sitting standing there in Time Square they don't have a mega I mean look the joke I used to make about old Twitter was it was like giving everyone in the py a megaphone so you know I'm I'm aware

11:14that can get promoted that are negative beyond the sort of Circle of of somebody simply crazy things in Time Square which happens all the time you know so so the it's it's it's it's pretty rare frankly that is hateful to be promoted it's not it's not it's it's fairly rare I mean I would encourage people to look at for those that use the system when you look at the the sort of the feed that how how often is it is it hateful and over time has it gotten more or less hateful and I would say that if you look at the X platform today versus a year ago I think it is actually much better I mean what what is are you surprised I'm just curious you use this I use the platform

12:04religiously I I being an addict and I use the for you and I will I will the problem is I'm a journalist I go looking for stuff well that's I'm just saying because alith for me personally because I'm looking for stuff also is feeding me other things well this this this is in that like sometimes people will say like why is it showing me post from this person that I hate and and we were like well did you interact a lot with this person that you hate well yes well therefore thinks that you want to interact more with this person that you hate that's like a reasonable let me ask this you kind of want to have an argument when you tweet yeah do you ever

12:43or post let's say post when you post listen I'm open if anyone can come up with a better word that would be great when you post though but the least bad word I can think of is post it's when you post though do you are you rile up either a base or or an audience do you do you do you wreck how you have in that and and also by the way not just rile up rile up of it but also rile down which is to say as I said there are people who are demonstratively anti-semitic on on the site who I I get boy things and all sorts of things that come my way hey for a while they thought I was Jewish so they would you know I'd get it too but but but no question is my

13:21name is super do you ever think to yourself you know what I'm going to go online and I'm going to say these people I condemn these people that are on my site saying these things because I I have said I have no you say I've condemned and I S but do you ever go yeah I said I've cond I literally I literally posted I condemn anti-Semitism in all its forms like that is a literal I believe literal post that I made I mean I'm like listen if I can get out the thesaurus if you you know and we you know let me ask you a different question you you you compose it I'll post it okay let me ask you this you you were about a month ago go and you said something that struck me and it

14:02struck me as accurate came out of your mouth so hopefully it is but it I'm hoping deep on this just because it came out of my mouth does not mean it's true but you said you said my you said is a storm I don't think most people would want to be me they may think they want to be me but they don't know they don't understand what did you mean by that what was what your mind being a storm and I think it I mean I have known you for quite some time I think it is a bit of a storm yes yeah I mean I in as much as

14:34a a weather metaphor makes sense my mind is often feels like a like a like a storm I mean I have I have of ideas I mean I have more ideas than I can possibly execute so I have no shortage of ideas Innovation is not the not the problem execution is the problem I've got a million ideas I mean I've got an entire design for an electric supersonic vertical takeoff jet but I I mean I can't do that as well I've had that for 10 years I there's a million things is your storm a Happy Storm no it's not a Happy Storm no tell us about that because I I think that that actually when people try to really understand you I think that there's a lot of this comes from some other place

15:15and I I want to talk about that what do you think that is we we need like a psychiatrist couch here or something you know I I think to some degree I was born this way but and then I was Amplified by a difficult childhood frankly but I can remember even in happy moments when I was a kid that there's just it just feels like there's just a a rage of forces in my mind constantly now this productively manifests itself in technology and Building Things for

15:49the most part so and I think on balance the output has been very productive I think the results as we you know know discussed earlier with SpaceX Tesla PayPal which is you know still going today the first internet company that I started in fact the first internet company I started zip two was funded by New York Times company Hurst night rer and in fact we wrote some of the software for the the New York Times website and we helped bring online several hundred newspapers that previously were only in print now this is in the '90s which at this point is like like a grandpa PL basically you know the '90s and internet feels like a pre-cambrian era when there were only

16:39sponges so anyway you know I feel like a lot of productive things have been done and you can also look at Tesla as being s many companies in one like our supercharging network is if it were if if the TLA supercharging Network were its own company it would be a Fortune 500 company by itself just just just the supercharging system we also make the cells we we we Power Electronics and the power train from scratch we have the most Innovative structural design the larest castings ever used we have the best manufacturing technology at Tesla better technology than companies that have been doing it for 100 years so so these these of the mind you know are for

17:23the most part harnessed to productive ends let me ask you that doesn't mean that once in a while they you know go wrong but but this is a question I think a lot of people you know are always trying to figure out about not just you but sometimes themselves meaning what is driving all this you're doing all of these things do you think it's it do you think that you would be as successful whatever success is if it wasn't being driven by some I think that there's something you're trying to prove either to yourself or to to somebody I don't know we're all trying to prove s I'm trying to prove to my mother I don't know no if I were to describe my my as a

18:05philosophy of curiosity I mean I I have this existential crisis when I was around 12 about what's the meaning of life isn't it all pointless why not just commit suicide why exist I read the religious texts I read the philosophy books that well especially the German philosophy books made me quite depressed frankly want you not read shophow n as a teenager but then I read Douglas Adams hit's Guide to the Galaxy which is a book on philosophy in the form of humor and the point that Adams was making there was that we don't know what questions to ask that's why he said that you know the answer is 42 like basically Earth's a giant computer and and it came up with the answer 42 but

18:53then to actually figure out what the question is that's the actual hard part I think this is generally true also in physics at the point in which you can properly frame the question the answer is is that easy part my motivation then was that well my life is finite really a flash in the pan in on a galactic time scale but if we can expand the scope and scale of Consciousness then we are better able to figure out what questions to ask about the answer that is the universe and maybe we can find out the meaning of life or even what question to what what the right question to ask is you know where did we come from where are we going where are the aliens and

19:41you know these these questions you know and is there new physics to discover is this because be some real questions about dark matter and dark energy and so the purpose of space Act is to extend life beyond Earth on a sustain basis so that we can at least pass one of the firmy great filters which is being a single planet civilization if we are a single planet civilization then we are simply waiting around for some Extinction event whether that is man-made or natural but if you're a single planet civilization eventually you will something will happen to that planet and you will die if you're a multiplet civilization you will live much longer also a multiplet

20:27civilization is that's the natural stepping stone to being a multi- stellar civilization and being out there Among the Stars so now this I has two this this is not simply a defensive motivation but it is also one with that you know that gives meaning man search for meaning ask let me finish this philosophy Point even though it may seem rather esoteric it may resonate with a few people we must get past this firmy filter of being a a filter of being a single planet civilization and if we do that we're more likely to understand the nature of the universe and what questions to ask if you're believer in the philosophy of curiosity then then I think you should support this

21:18ambition and there's being a multiplan species is more than than simply you know life in life insurance for Life collectively that's a defensive reason but but I think also that that that has to be more than simply solving one sad problem after another you know there have to be there have to be reasons where you wake up in the morning and you're happy to be alive there have to be reasons that you you have say why are you excited about the future like what gives you hope and and and if you if you if you aren't sure ask your kids and and and I think the idea of us being a space fairing civilization and being out there Among the Stars is incredibly

22:05inspiring and exciting and something to look forward to and there need to be such things in the world let me ask you a different question about confidence we were having a conversation here earlier but people U and where you get their Confidence from some people have great insecurity other people have great confidence and I was thinking about you because you have a very interesting history where people have told you over and over again that you're wrong well sometimes they're right well sometimes they are but I would say that when it comes to Tesla when it came to SpaceX people told you that you were crazy you were out of your mind this was never

22:43going to happen this never going to work and so ask you this though is now when people say you're wrong this isn't right do you look at that and say you know what that's like a red flag for me because because you know I've been told so often that I'm wrong that I know that I and I know I'm right CU I've had that experience or are there people in your life when they say you know what Elon this is not this is not right do you know what I'm saying I mean I think what you're I'm trying to say is that do I at this point think because I've been right so many times when others have said I'm wrong that now I F believe I'm right when in fact I'm wrong you did

23:21very well what do you think no I'm right so yeah no look here's the thing physics is UN I mean I have you know these various little saying that I've come up with that physics is the law and everything else is a recommendation right in the sense that you can break any law made by humans but try breaking a law made by physics that's much more difficult so if you are wrong and persist in being wrong the Rockets will blow up and the cars will faade so this is just figure out what what of ice cream is the best flavor of ice cream like if there's a thousand things that can happen on in a rocket flight and only one of them gets the rocket to orbit and

24:11so being wrong results in Failure when dealing with physical objects but that's the interesting part so now you've built this these companies that physically of them are enormously successful so successful arguably that you have lever over everybody else right there's nobody else can do starlink nobody else can get nobody else can get the rockets in in space yet Amazon and Jeff basist are trying but they haven't yet I hope he does you hope he does yeah yeah I think you know I I actually agree with with withot Jeff's motivations I mean I think you know he's you know and I so let me put let me put this way if if there was a button I could press that

24:53would delete blue arigon I wouldn't press it so I think it's good that he's spending money on on making Rockets too you know I suggest perhaps he spend more time on it but you know it's up to him the but make a point here so nothing nothing of my companies have done has been to stifle competition in fact we've done the opposite so at Tesla we have open- sourced our patents anyone can use our patents for free how many companies do you know who've done that can you name one I can't at SpaceX we don't use

25:33patents so I mean said once in a while we'll we'll F patent just so some patent trol doesn't cause trouble but we're not stuffing any we've done nothing anti-competitive we've done nothing to stop our you at all I I just want to clarify for the audience because some companies have done done an competitive things the strange thing or the unusual thing about SpaceX and Tesla is that we've done things that have helped our competition so at Tesla we have made our

26:02supercharger system Open Access we we've we we we made our charger technology available for free to the other manufacturers the re no world Garden we could have put a wall up but instead we invited them in the reason I mentioned this though is because you've had the success in the physical physics world you now have these very difficult decisions that have huge impacts on the world that are not physical decisions at all they're they're just of the mind they're decisions that you and others have to make and there's a question whether you should be making these decisions at all and I I that in the context of starlink obviously there was the report about how it's being used in

26:42Ukraine and and the russal war there's questions about what you know Taiwan whether Taiwan should use it or will use it I believe they're not right now because they're worried that some point maybe the Chinese will tell you that you have to they have leverage over you and you're going to have to turn that off right I mean these are very difficult decisions and I'm so curious how you think about that and not just the decisions the fact that you have that power I I just I think it's important for the ordinance to understand that the reason I have these power is not because of some anti-competitive actions it's simply because we've executed very well

27:13oh I'm not dismissing that I think there are so many people by the way who are huge supporters of what you cre satellites out there you know but but they're and but not as good as yours and the same and we can say that maybe make the same argument out of cars and everything else but as a result that gives you enormous leverage right with the exception of the by way these advertisers who aren't on X in every other instance everybody needs you I mean nobody's they use our product if it's better than use somebody else's product if it's their other product better and I accept that and maybe one day somebody else cre better products is it like you know how is it a bad thing

27:47to make better products than other companies well and I I want to go back to this to the starlink piece of it though because it that has sort of a Geo geopolitical ramification in terms of your power and how you think about that specific power and then the power that the US government might have either over you or Not Over You the power the Chinese government might have over you or not over you and how those things get used I mean what are you suggesting I I'm I'm asking the question around this this idea of how these satellites are going to be used whether you think that you should have control of them whether the government should have control of

28:26them the government well that's there's a lot of people who don't trust the government no exactly but then this goes back to the trust of you right I mean like I said we're not the only company who has communication satellites our satellites are just much better than theirs so it's not like we have a monopoly do you feel like anybody product it's not like do you feel anybody has leverage over you I mean I think at the end of the day if we make bad products that people don't want to use then the users will vote with their

29:00resources and use something else let me pivot the conversation for a second I mean certainly I mean my company's overseen by regulators and and you know once since SpaceX starlink Tesla are overseen by you know cumulatively over 100 Regulators in in more than that a few hundred Regulators because you got 55 countries if if you sum up

29:27all the times that I had an argument with Regulators of hundreds of regulators over decades it it sound really terrible except but they forgot to mention that there were 10 million regulations we complied with and only five that I disagreed with but at list all the five and it sounds like wow this guy's a real Maverick I'm like yeah but what about the 10 million we complied with do you let me let me related thing on The Leverage of countries and things over you and regulators X is this free speech platform you do business in China lots of business in China that's an important part of your your business I imag well not facex how do you think about the leverage that the Chinese have

30:10over you and do they have leverage over you and how do you feel about some people would say is it hypocritical for you to be doing business in China or frankly in other countries as it relates to X and other things that don't follow this free speech path that you have espoused the best that the xplatform can do is adhere to the laws of Any Given country do you think there's something more we could do than that I think it would be very hard but I just wonder given the sort of strong philosophical approach that you've you've you've you've been vocal about whether you say to yourself you know maybe I shouldn't be doing business in that country well

30:47first of all starlink and SpaceX do are no business in China whatsoever has one of four factories four vehicle and China is you know I don't know a quarter of our Market or something like that so it's a quarter of the market of one company the same is true by the way of of all the car companies they also have something on that order of quarter of their sales in in China so if you if that's a for Tesla it's a problem for every car company I mean I think one has to be careful about not conflating the various companies because I can only do things that are within the bounds of the law I cannot do beyond that my aspiration is to do as much good as possible and to be as

31:29productive as possible within the bounds of what is legal more than that I cannot do I want to Pivot and talk about AI for a moment we had Jensen Wong here who's a big fan of yours as you know yeah Jensen's awesome talk about talked about the first box by the way with Ilia interestingly enough yes back in 2016 I think there's a video of Jensen and me unpacking the first AI computer at open

31:56AI so so I'm so curious what you think of what's just happened over the past two weeks while you were dealing with this other headline series of headlines there's a whole other series of headlines so at open AI what did you think well you founded it co-founded well well the the Open Eye frankly is a little troubling because the the reason for starting openi was to create a counter counterweight to Google Google and deep mind which at the time had 2third of all AI talent and basically infinite money in compute and there was no there was no counterweight it was unipolar world and Larry and Paige and I used to be very close friends and I would stay

32:42at his house and I would talk to Larry until late hours of the night about AI safety and it became apparent to me that Larry did not care about AI safety I think perhaps the thing that gave it away was when he called me a speciest for being pro Humanity as in you know like a racist but for species so I'm

33:05like wait a second what side are you on Larry and then I'm like okay listen this guy's calling me aist he doesn't care about AI safety we've got to have some Counterpoint here because this seems like we could be this is so open AI was actually started and it was meant to be open source I named it openi after

33:29open source it is in fact closed Source super CL it should be it should be name renamed super closed source for maximum profit AI so because this is what it actually is I mean fate loves irony I mean in fact A friend of mine has this says like the way to predict outcomes is the most ironic outcome is the most it's like this aams Razer like the simplest sort of explanation is most likely and my friend Jonah's view is that the most ironic out is the most likely and that's what happened with open AI it's it's gone from open source Foundation a 513 to Suddenly It's

34:06like A90 billion for-profit Corporation with closed source so I don't know how you go from here to there but that seems like a I don't know how you get I don't know if is this legal like so as you saw Sam Alman get ousted Yeah by somebody you know Ilia and Ilia was somebody was a friend of yours yes you brought him there relationship with Larry Page effectively broke down over you recruiting him away I think that's correct that was the fight that was the Larry refused to be friends with me after I recruited Ilia and so here's Ilia apparently saying something is very wrong I think we should be concerned about this because I think Ilia actually

34:43has a strong moral compass he thinks about he you know he he really sweats at questions of what is right and if Ilia felt strongly enough to want to you know fire Sam well I think the world should know what was that reason have you talked to him I've reached out but he he doesn't want to talk to anyone have you talked to other people behind the scenes is this all happening I've talked to a lot of people as nobody I've not found anyone

35:16who knows why have have you I think we are all still trying to find out I mean look one of two things is is either it was a serious thing and we should know what it is or it was not a serious thing and and then the bo what do you think of Sam Alman I have mixed feelings about Sam I I do you know the ring of power

35:37you know can corrupt and is is the ring of power so you know I don't know I think I want to know why Ilia felt so strongly as to fire Sam this sounds like a serious thing I I don't think and I'm quite concerned that this that there's some you know Danger ous element of AI that they've they've cre discovered yes you think they've discovered something that would be my guess where are you with your own AI efforts relative to where you think open AI is where you think Google is where you think the others are I mean on the AI front I'm in somewhat of a quandry here because I've thought AI could be something that would change the world in a significant way since I was in college

36:22I mean like 30 years ago the reason I didn't go bu AI right from the get-go was because I was uncertain about which which edge of the D edge sword would would be sharper the good Edge or the bad Edge so I held off on doing anything on AI I could have created I think leading AI company kind of open AI actually kind of is that because I was just uncertain if you make this magic Genie what will happen you know whereas I think building sustainable energy technology is much more of a single-edged sword that is single-edged good making life multiplanetary I think single-edged good you know starlink mostly single-edged good I mean giving people better connectivity to people that you

37:08know don't don't have connectivity or offensive I think is very you know very much a good thing Sonic was instrumental by the way in halting the Russian Advance the ukrainians said so so you know I think there but with AI you you've got the magic Genie problem you may think you want a magic Genie but that but once that Genie is out of the bottle it's hard to say what happens how far are we away from that Genie being out of the bottle you think we think it's already out me the genie is suddenly poking its head out AGI the idea of artificial general intelligence given what you now are working on yourself and you know how easy or hard it is to train to create

37:55the inferences to create the weight I hope I'm not getting too far in the weeds of just how this works but those are the basics behind the software end of this it's funny you know all these weights they're just basically numbers in a comma separated value file and that's our digital God a CSV file found that funny but that's kind of literally what it is so I I think it's pretty fast you know there that I mean you you you you famously have admitted to overstating how quickly things will happen but how quickly do you think this will happen if you say smarter than the smartest human at anything yep it may not be then quite

38:39smarter than all humans all machine augmented humans you know because people got computers and stuff there a higher bar but you say smarter than any you know can write as good a novel as say JK rling or discover new physics or invent new technology I would say that we are less than 3 years from that point let me ask you a question about xai and what you're doing and because there's an interesting thing that's different I think about what you have relative others which is you have data you have information you have all of the stuff that everybody in here has put on the platform to sort through and I don't know if everybody realized that initially what is the value of that yeah

39:23I mean data is very important you could say data is probably more valuable than gold but then maybe you have actually maybe you have more maybe you have the gold in X in a different way in a way again that I I that I don't know if the public appreciates what that means yes X is the might be the single best source of data I mean it is there are more people

39:47links that go to people click on more links to X than anything else on Earth sometimes people think Facebook or Instagram is a bigger thing but actually there are more link to X than anything you can this is public information you can Google it let me ask you a so it is where you would find what is happening right now on Earth at any given point in time the whole open AI drama played out in fact on the xplatform so it is one of the it's not there Google certainly has a massive amount of data so does Microsoft so it's not like but but it is one of the best sources of data can I ask you an interesting IP issue which I think is actually something I

40:28can say as somebody who's in the Creator business and journalistic business and and whatnot where care about copyright so one of the things about training on data has been this idea that you're not going to train or or these things are not being trained on people's copyrighted information historically that's been the concept yeah that's a huge lie say that again yes these AI these AI are all trained on copyrighted data obviously so you think it's a lie when when open AI says that this is not none of these guys say they're training on copyrighted dat that's a lie it's a lie straight up a straight up lie okay so obviously it's been trained on Prop data okay so let me

41:08ask a second question which is all of the people who have been uploading all of the people whove been uploading articles the best quotes from different articles videos 2x all of that can be trained on and it's interesting because people put of that there and those quotes have historically been considered fair use right people are putting those quotes up there and individually on a fair use basis you'd say okay that makes sense but now there are people who do threads and by the way there may be multiple people who've done an article could has a thousand words technically all thousand words could have made it on to X somehow and effectively now you have

41:49this remarkable repository and I wonder what you how you think about that again and how you think the creative community and those who were the original Ip owners should think about that I don't know except to say that by the time these lawsuits are decided we'll have digital God so as as digital God at that point these little suits won't be decided before on a time frame that is relevant but is that a good thing or a bad thing we live you know there's that

42:17I don't know if it's actually a real Chinese thinging or not but may you live in interesting time is apparently not a good thing but I I I would prefer to personally I would prefer to live in interesting times and and we live in the most interesting of times I think for a while I was like really getting demotivated and losing sleep over sort of the threat of AI danger and then I sort of became fatalistic about it and said well even if I knew it was nihilation was certain would I choose to be alive at that time or not and I said I probably would choose to be alive at that time because it's the most interesting thing even if there's nothing I could do about it so then you

43:02know then basically sort of a fatalistic resignation helped me sleep at night because I was having trouble sleeping at night because of AI danger now what to do about it I've been the biggest the one banging the drum the hardest by far the longest at least one of the longest on for AI danger and and these regulatory things that are happening the single biggest reason they're happening is because of me you think they're ever going to get their arms around it we talked to the vice president this afternoon she said she wants to regulate it people have been trying to regulate social media for years and have done nothing effectively well there's there's

43:38regulation around anything which is a a physical danger or a danger to the public so cars are heavily regulated Communications are heavily regulated rockets and aircraft are heavily regulated the the general philosophy about regulation is that when something is a danger to the public that there needs to be some government oversight so I think in my view AI is

44:03more dangerous than nuclear bombs and we regulate nuclear bombs you can't just go make a nuclear bomb in your backyard I think we should have some kind of Regulation with AI now this tends to cause the accelerationists to get up in arms because they think AI is sort of Heaven basically but you

44:24typically don't like regulation you've pushed back on Regulators for the most part in the world of Tesla and the so many so many instances where we read articles about you pushing back on The Regulators I'm so curious why in this instance now you own one of these businesses as I said a moment ago one should not take what is viewed in the media as being the whole picture there are literally hundreds this is prob not an exaggeration so there are probably a 100 million regulations that that my companies comply with and there are probably five that we don't and if there we disagree with some of those regulations it's because we think the regulation that is

45:03meant to do good doesn't actually do good but that's an defying regulations for question if there are laws and rules whether the idea is that you're making the decision that the law and the rule shouldn't be the law and the rule and then right isn't no I'm saying you're fundamentally mistaken and and and it should be obvious that you're mistaken my company's Automotive is heavily regulated we would not be allowed to put cars on the road if we did not comply with this vast body of Regulation now you could you could fill up this stage with literally you know 6' High the the the regulations that you have to comply with to make a car make you could have a room

45:41full of phone books that's how many that's how big the regulations are and if you don't comply with all of those you can't sell the car and if we don't comply with all the regulations for Rockets or for Starling they shut us down so in fact I am incred ibly compliant with regulations now once in a while there'll be something that I disagree with the reason I would disagree with it is because I think the regulation in that particular case in that rare case does not serve the public good and therefore I think it is my obligation to object to a regulation that is meant to serve the public good but doesn't that's the only time I object not because I seek to object in

46:18fact I'm incredibly rule following let me ask you a separate question social media related question we've been talking about Tik Tok today head of the election Tik Tok is what do you think of Tik Tok do you think it's a national security threat I don't use Tik Tok it again you personally use it U but for people that for for teenagers and people in their 20s they seem almost religiously addicted to Tik Tok some people watch

46:46Tik Tok for like two hours a day I stopped using Tik Tok when I felt the AI probing my mind and I don't it made me uncomfortable so I stopped using it and in terms of anti-Semitic content I mean Tik Tok is r with that it has has the most viral anti-semitic content by far but do you think the Chinese government is using it to manipulate the minds of Americans no is that something that you think we should worry about I mean you have you have different states that are trying to ban it I don't think this is a SES government plot but it it it it

47:22is the Tik Tok algorithm is entirely AI powered so it is really just trying to find the most viral thing possible it's it's what is going to keep you glued to the screen right that's it now the sheer numbers there are on the order of two billion Muslims in the world and I think a you know much smaller number of

47:47Jewish people 20 million something many orders magnitude fure so if you just look at at content production just on sheer numbers bases is going to be overwhelmingly anti-semitic let me ask let me ask you a political question and I've been trying to square this one in my head for a long time yeah in the last two or three years you have moved decidedly to the right I think have I well we can discuss this I think that you have been espousing and promoting a number of of of and and others and very frustrated with the Biden Administration over I think unions and feeling they

48:30did not respect what you've created well I mean without any doing nothing to provoke the vit Administration they held an electric vehicle Summit at the White House and specifically refused to let Tesla attend this was in the first 6 months of the administration we inquired we're like we literally make more electric cars than everyone else combined why are we not allowed why are you only letting U Ford GM Chrysler and

48:55u and you're specifically disallowing us from the EV Summit at the White House we' done nothing to provoke them then Biden went on to add insult injury and publicly said that GM was leading the electric car Revolution this was in the same quarter that Tesla made 300,000 electric cars and GM made 26 does that seem fair to you so but but tell me this then doesn't seem fair and and I've asked it repeatedly probably seen and by way I had a great relationship with Obama so there's not a so but but but I

49:27stood stood in hours for six I stood in line for six hours to sh Obama's head okay so but okay so let me just ask on a personal level this I can see it in your this this hurt you personally and it hurt the company too and it was an insult to you know Tesla has 140,000 employees okay of the half of them are in the United States Tesla has created more manufacturing drops than everyone else combined so let me ask this then you you've devoted at least the last close to 20 years of your life if not more to the climate climate change trying to get Tesla off the ground in part to improve climate you talked about that yeah a real right-wing motive is

50:08repeatedly got far right if anything no I understand that and then so it's Go reverse psychology but so here's then the question which is how do you square the support that you have given I believe you were at a fundraiser for Viva gramas Swami for example who says that the climate climate issue is a hoax right I disagree with him on that I but I would think that that would be such a singular issue for you I would think that that the climate issue would be such a singular issue for you that actually it would disqualify almost anybody who who didn't take that issue seriously well I haven't endorsed anyone for for president I mean I wanted to hear what P had to say because I think

50:52some of his things are some of the things he says I think are pretty solid you know he's concerned about government overreach about government control of information I mean the degree to which old basically a sock puppet of the government was ridiculous so you know it seems to me that there there there's a very severe violation of in terms of how much government control how much control quter and it no longer does so you

51:22know there's a reason for the First Amendment the reason for the First Amendment for freedom of speech is because the people that immigrated this country places where there was not freedom of speech and and they were like you know what we we we got to make sure that that's constitutional because where they came from if they said something they' be put in prison or there'd be you know something bad would happen to him so and freedom of speech you have to say when is it relevant it's only relevant when when someone you don't like can say you don't like or it it has no meaning and and as soon as you sort of you know throw in the towel and concede

52:03to censorship it is only a matter of time before someone censors you and that is why we have the First Amendment could you see yourself voting for President Biden if if it's if a Biden Trump election for example I think I would not vote for Biden you'd vote for Trump I'm not saying I'd vote for Trump but I mean this is this is definitely a difficult Choice here you know would you would you vote for Nikki Haley by the way wants all social media names to be exposed as you know no I think that's outrageous yeah no I'm not going to vote for some Pro censorship candidate like I said I mean I think these you have to you have to you know because a lot of wisdom in

52:47these amendments you know and in the Constitution and and you know a lot of these a lot of things granted here in the the United States that don't even exist in Canada there's not no constitutional right to freedom of speech in Canada so you know not and there's no Miranda think like you know you have the right to remain silent you don't actually in Canada so you know I'm half Canadian I can say these things as but you know so so like you just got you the freom of speech is incredibly important even

53:25when people and like it's actually especially important in fact relevant when people you don't like can say things you don't like and do you think right now that you think right now the Republican candidates or the Democrats are more inclined I mean this is where you go to I assume to to to woke and anti-woke and the issue that you've talked about which party do you think is is is more Pro freedom of speech given things you've seen because we also see you know santis of you know preventing people from Reading certain things maybe you maybe you think that's that's that's correct no look we are in an odd situation here on

54:08balance the Democrats appear to be more Pro censorship than the Republicans I mean that used to be the opposite it used to be you know the left position was freedom of speech I believe at one point the ACL you even def defended the right of someone to claim that they were Nazi or something like that you know so like they W there really were like the left of speech is is is fundamental and I mean my at least perception is inaccurate is that the

54:43pro censorship is more on the left than than the right we certainly get more complaints from the left and the right let me put it that way so but my aspiration for the xplatform is that it is the best source of Truth or the least inaccurate source of Truth and well you know I don't know you will believe me or not but I think Honesty is the best policy and I I think that the truth will win over time and the you know we've got this this great system and it's getting better called which is fantastic I think at correcting or or adding context in fact we we make a point of of not removing anything but only adding context that context could could include that this is completely

55:29false and why and and and no one is immune to this immune to it advertisers not immune to it in fact we've had Community notes which has caused us some loss in advertising speaking of loss advertising Revenue when if a community note if an if there's false advertising the community note will say this is false and here is why I mean like there's one specific example that is public knowledge so I'll mention it which is at one point Uber had this ad which said earn like a boss and it was Community noted if by boss you mean $12.47 an hour this this did cause at least a temporary suspension of advertising from uba I got to ask you a question that might make everybody in

56:13the room uncomfortable or not uncomfortable but it it goes to the Free Speech issue the New York Times company and the New York Times newspaper it appeared over the summer to be throttled what what did the New York Times well we we do require that that everyone has to buy a subscription and we don't exceptions for anyone and and I think if I want the New York Times I have to pay for a subscription and they don't give me a free subscription so I'm not going to give them a free subscription but were you but were you throttling the New York Times relative to other news organizations relative to everybody else was it was it was it specific to the to the times they didn't

56:50buy a subscription by the way like $1,000 a month so if they just do that then then they they're back in back in the saddle but but but you are saying it was throttled no I'm saying I mean was there a conversation that you had with somebody you said look I'm unhappy with the times they should either be buying the subscription or I don't like their content or whatever whatever any organization that refuses to buy a subscription is is is not going to be recommended but then what does that say speech and what does that say about amplifying C it costs a little bit right but that's but that's an interesting yeah know it's like it's like an South Park you know Freedom isn't free

57:34bucko 5 or whatever so but it's pretty cheap okay it's lowcost lowc cost freedom I got a couple more questions for you you're head to Texas after this to launch the Cyber truck yeah it's going to be a big launch but I wanted to ask you right now more broadly just about the the the car business and what you see actually happening and specifically the government in place lots of policies as you know to try to encourage more EVs and one of the things that's happened uniquely is you have now a lot of car companies saying actually this is too ambitious for us these plans are too ambitious 4,000 dealers I don't know if you saw just yesterday sent a letter to

58:15the White House saying this has gone too far you're going too far you had this anti EV it was an it it was a this is going too fast too far and that there's not enough demand our underneath all this is this idea that maybe there's not enough demand for EVS that the American public has not bought into the I mean they bought into with with with your company but they haven't bought into it broadly enough well I think if you make compelling electric car people will buy it no question about it I mean electric car sales in China are gigantic that's by far the biggest category right and I think that would be the ca you know I mean it's worth noting

58:55okay so the probably the best reputation of that is that the Tesla Model y will be the best car of any kind on Earth this year of any kind gasoline or otherwise is there another car company that you think is doing a good job with EV I mean I think the Chinese car companies are extremely competitive by far our toughest competition is in China so I mean there's there's a lot of

59:21people who out there who think like the top 10 car companies is going to be slow followed by nine Chinese car companies I think they might not be wrong so China is super good at manufacturing and the work ethic is incredible so you know like if we consider different leagues of competitiveness at Tesla we consider the Chinese League to be the most competitive and by the way we do very well in China because our CH China team is the best trying how worried are you that that the union unionization effort that just took place at well not I should say effort but the the the new the new wages and the like at GM and and Ford are that they're coming for you and they are coming for

1:00:02you what is that going to mean to you in your business well I I mean I I think it's generally not good to have an adversarial relationship between people on the line one group at the company and another group in fact I mean I I disagree with the idea of unions but perhaps for a reason that is that people may expect which is I I just don't like anything which creates kind of a Lords and P sort of thing and and I think the unions naturally try to create negativity in a company and and create a sort of Lords and peasants situation there there are many people at Tesla who have come gone from working on the line to being Senior Management there is no

1:00:43Lords and peasants everyone eats at the same table everyone parks in the same parking lot you know at GM there's a special elevator for only for senior Executives we have no such thing at Tesla you know and the thing is that I actually know the people on the line because I worked on the line and I walked the line and I slept in the factory and I and I worked beside them so I'm no stranger to them and then actually I've said well

1:01:11can't we just hold a union vote but apparently a company is not allowed to hold a union vote so it has to be somehow cold for but the unions can't do it so I said we'll just hold a vote and see what happens the actual problem is is is the opposite it's not that people are trapped at Tesla building cars the the the the challeng is is how do we retain great people to do the hard work of building cars when they have like six other opportunities that they can do that are easier that's the actual difficulty is is that building cars is hard work and and and there are much easier jobs I just want to say that I'm incredibly appreciative of those who

1:01:53build cars and they know it you know so there's there I don't know maybe there will be unionized if if I say like unionized will be because we deserve it in some way but we we certainly try hard to you know ensure the prosperity of everyone we give everyone stock UPS we've we've made many people who are just working the line who didn't even know what stocks were we've made the millionaires so we're going to run out of time a couple quick questions when do you have the time to tweet or to post I actually think about it all the time as I said I use go the bathroom sometimes I use it all the time meaning if if we were to if we were to open up our phones and look

1:02:38at the screen time what does yours look like well about every 3 hours I make a trip to the laboratory that's the only time you do this seems like you're on there a lot no I mean I there'll be like brief moments between meetings I mean it's not obviously I've I like seven jobs so you know and no no I guess technically it's work it is but but I'm thinking in terms of your mind share I mean by the way lot of people who should be working who are on who are on this technically posting on Twitter is or or X is is work is work so that's you know there's that but no I mean I I think I'm on well I us probably I'm on for longer than I found I know but do you

1:03:22think that's 5 hours a day the screen time of like number hours per week sometimes that's a scary number it's probably I don't know it's a little over an hour a day or something like that just an hour a day if we really looked at this together do you have your phone with you yeah you want to look okay okay here we go you ready screen time hit General screen time sometimes this is a scary number but I know that's why I I thought I just got a new phone so I think this is not accurate cuz it says I'm it's 1 minute pretty sure it's more than that wait it's over the week there we go yeah go go to the week okay so it's it's still wrong it's it's more than four

1:04:08minutes I I just got a new phone so this is not accurate literally says four minutes new phone Tim Cook said do that phone new new phone who does you know I should ask by the way because I just mened Tim Cook do you feel like you're going to have to have a battle with him eventually is that the next fight over the App Store the idea of making a oh phone you mean like no of the App Store you ever make a phone Sam alman's apparently thinking about making a phone with Johnny I I mean I don't think there's a real need to make a phone I mean if there's a essential need to make a phone I'll make a phone but I got a lot of FR to fry so I do think there's a

1:04:45there's there's a fundamental challenge that phone makers have at this point because you've got a basically a black rectangle you know how do you make that better so you want to do that what does that what does that look like in elon's head no that's literally yeah good good phrase in the head a neural link well there we go that we need to touch that before it's over the best interface would be a neural interface directly to your brain that over how far we do you think from that and how how excited or scary does that seem to be and we read these headlines obviously about monkeys who died as you know what should we think about that yeah actually the the the

1:05:24is the the USDA inspector who who came by neuralink facilities literally said in her entire career she has never seen a better Animal Care Facility it is we are the nicest to animals that you could possibly be even to the rats and mice even though they did the plague and everything so it is it is like monkey Paradise

1:05:50so the thing that gets complated is that there were some terminal monkeys where this is actually several years ago where the monkeys were about to die and we're like okay we've got an experimental device it's the kind of thing which only put on a monkey that's about to die and then you know now the monkey died but it didn't die because of the new link it died because it was you know had a terminal case of cancer or something like that so neur link has has never caused the death death of a monkey unless they're hiding something from me is is never caused death of monkey and in fact we now had monkeys with the neuralink implants for 2 3 years and they're doing

1:06:28great and we've even replaced the neuralink twice and it's and and we're getting ready to do the to do the first implants in hopefully in a few months the early implementations of neuralink I think are unequivocally good speaking of the double-edged sword I think these early implementations are single-edged swords because the first implementations will be to enable people who are have lost the brain Body Connection to be able to to operate a computer or a phone faster than someone who has hands that that work so you can imagine if stepen Hawking could communicate faster than someone who had full full body functionality how incredible that would be well that's

1:07:06what this device will do and we should have proof of that in a human hopefully in a few months already works you in monkeys and works quite well with monkeys that can play video games just using just by thinking so and the next application after sort of those dealing with cetopic and quad quadriplegics is going to be Vision vision is the the next thing so it's like if somebody has has lost both

1:07:38eyes or the optic nerve has failed basically where's they have no possibility of having sort of some ocular correction that would be the next thing for neuralink is a direct Vision interface and in fact then you could be like Jord Le Forge from start TR you could see in like any frequency actually you could see in radar if you want two final questions and then we're going to do end this conversation which I think has taken everybody Inside the Mind of Elon Musk today not as well as NE link will it actually goes to self-driving cars and vision and everything else and I asked this question of Pete Buddha judge Transportation secretary it's actually something you retweeted so I

1:08:19wanted to ask you the same question there's a big question about autonomous vehicles and the safety of them but there's also a question about when it will be politically palatable in this country for people to die in cars that are controlled by computers which is say we have 35 40,000 deaths every year in this in this country yeah if you could bring that number down to 10,000 5,000 that might be a great thing but do we think that the country will accept the idea that 5,000 people that your family might have have have perished in a in a a vehicle as a result not of a human making a mistake but of a computer so well first of all humans are terrible drivers

1:09:11people text and drive they drink and drive they get into arguments they you know they do all sorts of things and cars that they should not do so it's actually remarkable that there are not more deaths than there are what we'll find with computer driving is I think probably an order of magnitude reduction in deaths I think now and the US has

1:09:34actually far fewer deaths per capita than the rest of the world if you go worldwide I think there's something close to a million deaths per year due to Automotive accidents so I think computer driving will probably drop that by 90% or more it won't be perfect but it'll be 10 times do you think that the public will will accept that do you think the government will accept that well at the it simply be so obviously true that it it cannot be denied and what do you think I know we've talked about the timeline before and I know people have criticized you for putting out timelines that may not have come true just yet but what do you think it really is and and by the way do

1:10:17you feel that do you ever said to yourself oh I shouldn't have said that sure of course wait I shouldn't have said that so yeah I I mean I'm optimistic about I mean I'm I'm like naturally optimistic about time scales and if I was not naturally optimistic I wouldn't be doing the things that I'm doing I mean I certainly wouldn't have S A Rocket company or electric car company if I didn't have some sort of pathological optimism frankly so as you pointed out many people said they would fail and in fact I actually I agreed with them I said yes it probably will fail and they're like okay but I I thought spasic and Tesla had less than 10% chance of success when

1:10:54we started them any but but the self-driving thing is is I've been optimistic about it we certainly made a lot of progress if anybody has tried the very has been using the sort of full soft driving beta the progress is you know every year has been substantial it's really now at the point where in most places it'll take you from one place to another with no interventions and the data is unequivocal that that supervised full

1:11:25self-driving is somewhere around four times safer maybe more than than just human driving by by themselves so I'm I'm I I really see it coming really do you think it's another five or 10 years I mean people no and do you feel like investors have invested in something that that happened yet is that fair to them and that's the other question that people have about that well I mean I think the they've they've all with rare exception thought it wasn't happening so they were investing in despite thinking they're very clear that they don't think it's real so they're not saying oh we we believe everything y says hook and sinker and but is that I mean I would be a fair

1:12:11criticism of me to say that I am late but it is but I always deliv her in the end let me ask you a final question I took note of this it was November 11th and you took to Twitter and you wrote only two words you said amplify empathy right I was taken back by that given all the things that have been going on in the world do you remember what you were thinking well I think it's quite literally amp I understand it but what was what was on why why did you right then well I was encouraging people to amplify empathy literally I tend to be quite literal but was there something that had happened I me that you had seen that you said to yourself I need to say

1:12:50that I think I talking to some friends and we all agreed that we should try to amplify empathy and so I wrot amplify empathy if you wanted an unvarnished look inside the mind of Elon Musk I think you just saw it look sometimes it's pretty simple you know Elon Musk thank you very very much for the conversation thank you appreciate it very very much thank you thank you so much take that with you for a second I'm just going to say a thank you to everybody who stuck around for what has been a remarkable day we are so appreciative of everybody who has been with us for so many years coming back to this every year so thank you thank you thank you I hope you had a

1:13:28great day and I hope we have an opportunity to do this again Elon Musk everybody thank you for more videos like this please smash the Subscribe button and don't forget to like the video we really appreciate it thanks for watching the America truth Channel

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份