2012年,埃隆·马斯克(Elon Musk)站在加州大学圣迭戈分校的讲台上,对着一屋子听众说了几个数字。当时听着像疯话,现在回头看,准得吓人。
他说,太阳能到本世纪中叶会成为美国最大的电力来源。当时太阳能发电占全美比例不到百分之一。
他说,纯电动车大约20年后会占所有新造车的大多数,再过20年,路上跑的车绝大多数都是电动的。当时特斯拉刚交付Roadster没几年,Model S还没下线,底特律的主流论调是电动车永远成不了气候。
他说,SpaceX最快10年、最晚20年能把人送上火星。
这场访谈的信息密度相当高,马斯克把自己从大学时代到2012年的思路完整讲了一遍,包括他怎么赚钱、怎么花钱、怎么想问题、怎么判断一个行业值不值得进。下面把里面真正有价值的部分拆开讲。
钱是一步步变成火箭的,没有一跳到位
很多人以为马斯克一开始就奔着造火箭去的。他在访谈里纠正了这个印象,整个过程更像一条接力赛,每一棒用上一棒的钱跑下一棒。
第一家公司叫Zip2,做的是帮报纸上网的生意,客户包括《纽约时报》和《费城询问报》。这家公司大多数人没听过,但它是一切的原点。卖掉Zip2之后,他用这笔钱做了X.com,也就是后来的PayPal。PayPal卖给eBay之后,这笔钱成了SpaceX、特斯拉和Solar City的启动资金。
有意思的地方在于他对自己当CEO这件事的描述。他说自己本来没打算亲自管SpaceX和特斯拉,是被局势逼上去的:
我当时的处境是要么让特斯拉死掉,要么我自己上。我不想让它死,所以就自己上了。我得说同时管两家公司真的非常难,我不想让它听起来像件容易的事,它真的很难。(马斯克)
这段话的分量落在后半句。他讲的是被动接手,但背后有个前提:他早就把资金押进了这些公司,押的时候就知道大概率会失败。SpaceX前三次发射全炸了,特斯拉2008年差点破产。他后来的说法是,那段时间他把最后一点钱都投了进去,做好了全赔光的准备。
运气的成分在这里很小。他主动选了失败率极高的赛道,在失败真的发生时也没有退出。这两件事同时做到的人,本来就不多。
大学时锁定的三个方向,几十年没变过
主持人问他,涉足这么多领域是计划好的还是机会主义的产物。马斯克的回答是,他在大学时就认定三个领域会最大程度影响人类的未来:互联网、可持续能源、多行星生存。
我当时是从抽象层面想的,没觉得自己真能参与进去。第三个领域我真的没想过自己会做,但它确实是一件应该发生的事,如果我们想要一个让人兴奋、让人受到鼓舞的未来。(马斯克)
互联网对应Zip2和PayPal,可持续能源的生产对应Solar City,可持续能源的消费对应特斯拉,多行星生存对应SpaceX。三家公司,三个方向,一条主线。站在2012年回头看,这个布局已经闭环了。
主持人追问他,为什么大学时会有这种为人类做点事的念头。他的回答不太像一个企业家该说的话:
大概是一种存在主义危机吧,就是这一切到底有什么意义,生命的意义是什么。这事可能是凌晨三点喝着啤酒想出来的,也可能更严肃一点,得追溯到高中。我有个挺阴暗的童年,过得不好,部分原因是读了太多哲学,你要是14岁,千万别读叔本华。(马斯克)
他提到《银河系漫游指南》(The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy)对自己的影响,说这本书点出了一件事:很多时候真正难的是搞清楚该问什么问题,问题问对了,答案反而是容易的部分。
于是他给自己定了一个判断标准,看一件事值不值得做,就看它能不能扩大人类意识的规模和范围,能不能帮人类问出更好的问题。这个标准听起来很虚,但它解释了他后来所有的选择。互联网相当于给世界装了一套神经系统,任何人只要有网络就能接触到人类积累的全部知识。可持续能源绕不过去,因为不可持续的东西迟早撞墙。多行星生存是给生命本身买保险。
第一性原理:多数人想问题的方式错在哪
这段是整场访谈里方法论含量最高的部分。
马斯克说他习惯用物理学的方式分析问题,核心是从第一性原理出发推理。这个词后来被用滥了,他2012年的原话解释得更清楚:
从第一性原理推理,意思是你要先搞清楚什么是基本原理,什么是那些你相当确定是真理的东西,然后从这些原理往上推导出结论。如果你得出的某个想法违背了某条基本原理,那你大概率是错的。当然也可能是你拿了个大奖。(马斯克)
他紧接着指出了一个关键区别,多数人的思维方式是类比推理。
类比推理有用,因为它是个捷径,而且大部分时候是对的。但恰恰在你面对真正新的事物时,它最容易出错,因为你很难拿一个真正新的东西去类比。(马斯克)
这句话能解释很多事。传统车企为什么断定电动车不行?他们拿燃油车的成本结构去类比。航天业为什么觉得火箭回收不可能?所有人看到的都是一次性火箭,类比来类比去就得出不可能。类比推理在稳定行业里好用,等到行业规则要被推翻的时候,它成了最大的认知障碍。
特斯拉早期有个例子很典型。Roadster最初的变速箱设计做不到既满足加速又满足续航,变速箱老出问题。后来他们的解法是把变速箱整个去掉,提高电机功率,重新设计散热。结果车身更轻、续航更长、噪音更小、维护更少、制造成本更低,几乎所有指标一起变好。传统车企的工程师很难想到这条路,因为在他们的类比库里,车必须有变速箱。
太阳能:一条被低估的复合增长曲线
主持人问马斯克怎么看太阳能的潜力。他的回答是,太阳能到本世纪中叶会成为美国最大的单一电力来源。说这话的时候,太阳能发电占比不到百分之一。
他给的理由只有一条:复合增长的力量被严重低估了。
如果你看太阳能的增长率,它就是往那个方向走的。复合增长极其强大。(马斯克)
他补了一个成本数据,很能说明问题。太阳能电池板的成本5年前大约是每瓦4美元,2012年已经降到每瓦1.2美元。太阳能发电成本低于常规电力的那一刻,整个行业的拐点就到了。美国各地电价不一样,所以这个拐点会从少数地区先开始,然后扩展到中等地区,最后覆盖大部分地区。
他还讲了一个更本质的角度。地球今天几乎完全靠太阳能驱动,太阳是唯一让地球不至于冻成零下几百度冰球的热源,所有降水、所有天气系统、整个生态系统都靠太阳运转。人类要做的只是把其中很小一部分转成电。
关于Solar City这家公司具体做什么,他澄清了一个常见误解:
Solar City大部分精力其实在系统集成上,它不生产电池板。这有点像苹果或者戴尔,针对特定的房子或办公楼设计合适的系统,做安装、布线、逆变器、审批和售后服务,这部分占了大约70%的成本。(马斯克)
Solyndra这件事,被媒体放大了
2012年正是Solyndra(一家拿了美国政府贷款担保后破产的太阳能公司)事件发酵的时候,主持人专门问了政府该不该补贴太阳能。
马斯克的回答很直接,这件事被过度政治化了,变成了政治足球。他给了一个很少有人提的角度:
Solyndra那件事里,私人投资者损失的钱是政府的两倍。参与投资的那些风投是市面上最聪明的一批人,他们不是傻子。如果最好的风投都在里面投了钱,你就很难说政府是个傻瓜。创业本来就是概率游戏,硅谷的风投投20家公司,可能一两家成为大赢家,三四家还行,剩下的全死。这就是游戏规则。(马斯克)
他顺带批评了一句媒体,如此盯着Solyndra没有意义,以后还会有别的失败案例。
关于政府对他自己公司的帮助,他分得很清楚。SpaceX很大程度上要感谢NASA,没有NASA的支持,SpaceX根本起不来,也走不到今天,双方是合作关系。Solar City拿到的联邦和州级补贴实际上相对不大,而且每年在减少。特斯拉拿了政府贷款,但特斯拉从私人部门融到的钱是政府的两倍。
他还提了一个竞争公平性的问题:特斯拉要跟通用、福特、克莱斯勒这些公司竞争,而这些公司从政府拿到的钱是海量的,资本成本接近零,特斯拉并不参与这个游戏。这让本来就很难的事变得更难。
电动车:20年成为主流,一条明确的时间线
主持人问电动车技术的改进会带来什么影响。马斯克给了两个时间点:
纯电动车大概20年后会占所有新造车的大多数。再过20年,路上跑的绝大多数车都会是纯电动的。替换现有车队至少需要15年左右。(马斯克)
他讲的日常体验改善很具体,就是不用去加油站了。他还专门跟雪佛龙(Chevron)道了个歉,因为前面主持人提醒他雪佛龙是这场活动的赞助商之一。
然后他讲了Model S,这款车2012年7月上市。他给出的参数在当年听起来很夸张:
- 外形尺寸跟奔驰E级或宝马5系差不多,行李空间是它们的两倍
- 可以坐5个成年人加2个小孩,小孩坐在朝后的后排座椅上,像老式旅行车那样
- 续航超过300英里
- 充电大约45分钟
- 换电池比加满一箱油还快
- 按2012年的标准,是全世界唯一一款在每个安全类别都拿到五星评级的车
价格上,起步价大约5万美元,高性能版本配满选装大约10万美元,跟其他豪华轿车落在同一区间。他补了一个算账角度,汽油每英里成本大约是电的10倍,把这些省下的钱算进去,相当于车价打了1万到2万美元的折扣。
关于电动车剩下的是工程问题还是科学问题,他的判断是主要落在工程一侧。科学上的挑战可能在超高能量密度电容上。他提到自己当年从宾州搬到加州,本来是要去斯坦福读博士,研究的就是高能量密度电容,用作电动车的储能装置。当时他并不确定这条路能走通,2012年的时候他越来越相信它能成。
这段细节说明了时间的作用。他中途退学创业,但退学前研究的那个方向,十几年后他还在惦记,而且判断发生了反转。一个人对某个技术问题持续追踪十几年,这本身就构成了他判断力的来源。
为什么太空值得去:一份关于无聊与灭绝的论证
主持人问了一个很尖锐的问题:在他小时候,太空是浪漫的,登月是人类的伟大时刻,现在的小孩好像对太空没什么兴趣了,为什么?
马斯克把因果倒过来了,他判断人们的兴趣没消失,真正停住的是前沿的推进:
同一部电影你只能看那么多次,看多了就无聊了。60年代和70年代初我们真的在推进载人航天的前沿。登月被看作是人类最伟大的成就之一,甚至可以说是生命本身的伟大成就之一。虽然只有少数人真的去了月球,但我们所有人都跟着去了一趟。(马斯克)
他把这件事的意义落在一个很朴素的层面,那是让人高兴自己是人类的事情之一。人类既有坏事也有好事,登月属于好事那一栏。
然后他给出了自己的大目标:
我认为我们应该追求的伟大目标是让生命成为多行星的,在另一颗行星上建立一个自给自足、持续增长的文明。火星是唯一现实的选择。生命在地球上存在了40亿年,也被困在地球上40亿年。大多数人想要一个走向太空文明的未来,走出去探索恒星,想要一条让科幻小说和电影里的东西变成现实的路。那个未来让人兴奋。而一个永远被困在地球上、直到某次灭绝事件的未来,没那么鼓舞人心。(马斯克)
这个论证的分量落在时间尺度上。40亿年这个数字承担的是一次概率判断,时间足够长,灭绝事件几乎必然发生。多行星生存更像一份保险单,代价有限,赔付场景极端。
火星船票的目标价:50万美元
主持人问得具体,未来50年、100年,你觉得什么可行?
马斯克给的时间表是,SpaceX有可能最快10年送人上火星,如果超过20年他会失望。紧接着他把重点从任务本身挪开了,一次插旗子、留脚印的行动意义有限:
重要的是开发出那些能让人们想搬去火星就搬去的技术。我认为自持反应的门槛数字大约在50万美元。所以真正要回答的问题是,你能不能把搬去火星的成本,加上到那儿之后启动生活的钱,压到相当于加州一套中产阶级房子的价格。(马斯克)
主持人的回应很到位,那样人们就可以卖掉自己的东西搬过去。马斯克说,当年人们来美国开创新生活就是这么干的。
50万美元这个数字是整场访谈里最容易被忽略、信息量最大的一个。它把一个听起来像科幻的宏大目标,拆成了一道成本题。要让火星移民变成自持反应,造出一艘能飞的飞船只是第一层,真正的功课是把单位成本压到普通中产家庭能承受的区间。成本是唯一的变量,其他都跟着它走。
他还说了一句对创业者有用的定位:SpaceX只做别人不愿意做的事,第一步是能到那儿,如果到不了,其他一切都不重要。他拿跨大西洋航线打比方,如果当年人们过不了大西洋,就不会有美国。
这个世界其实变好了,只是新闻不报
主持人问了一个转折性的问题:你讲了这么多让人鼓舞的事,但美国当下的整体情绪并不乐观,你怎么看美国作为创新土壤的位置?
马斯克先幽默了一下,说他的祖父是美国人,他的名字来自明尼苏达州的曾祖父,所以他其实是回到了祖传的家乡。
然后他讲了一段对媒体的批评:
日常新闻媒体倾向于聚焦当下世界上发生的最糟糕的事情。地球上大概有70亿人,你想想70亿人里能出多少糟糕的事,真的很多。所以你打开谷歌新闻,看到的就是地球上最糟糕的事被打了聚光灯。(马斯克)
他分析了两层原因,一层在媒体,另一层在人类心理:
人类心理本身就倾向于给负面信息更高的权重。你得对要吃掉你的狮子反应快一点,而不是对桌上的晚餐反应快一点。成为晚餐比吃掉晚餐糟糕得多。所以哪怕你读到的新闻跟你没有直接关系、发生在世界另一个角落,它还是会引发那种负面的本能反应。(马斯克)
他承认自己也不知道这个问题怎么解决。他认为整体情绪应该改善,因为它跟现实脱节了,生活其实相当不错。
有听众当场提出反驳:世界上还有几十亿人吃不饱、没有像样的住所、没有衣服穿、没有受教育的权利,我们却在这里轻描淡写地讨论去火星,为什么不能把这些精力先用来解决地球上的问题?
马斯克的回答分两块。关于该花多少钱在太空上,他给了一个很具体的量级:
应该比我们在医疗上花的少得多,但比我们花在口红上的多。大概GDP的0.25%是个不错的数字。(马斯克)
关于世界是不是在变好,他引了一篇文章,讲的是人类暴力史:
我们正处在一个暴力程度低得离谱的时期。一个人死于战争或暴力事件的概率是历史最低的,这是乐观的理由。印度、中国这些我们曾经认为是穷国的国家,取得了巨大的进步。中国现在上路的新车数量已经超过美国。(马斯克)
他承认进步的速度可能不够快,方向是对的。少数还在恶化的地方,主要原因是腐败政府或内战,这些属于政治问题,技术插不上手,他也说不清自己能做什么。
主持人补了一句很关键的澄清,你的意思并非你的生活很顺,重点落在世界上绝大多数人的生活都在变好。马斯克确认了这一点。
火星改造:先建穹顶,再放微生物
有位听众问到火星地球化(terraforming)的可能。马斯克的回答是,长期来看可以把火星改造成类似地球的样子,那是几百年的项目。在那之前,需要在火星上建立基地,需要穹顶之类的设施。
他提到专门设计的微生物在改造过程中可能有用,但眼下火星的条件对微生物太苛刻:火星上温度高于冰点的时刻并不常见,也没有地球那样的紫外线防护和宇宙射线防护,得先把这些条件改善了,微生物才有可能在户外存活。
他还回应了那位听众的玩笑,火星就是一堆红色的石头,看着没什么意思。马斯克承认,火星确实是个需要大修的星球(fixer upper)。
另一位听众问得更远,如果真把人送上火星了,他会不会当第一个房地产开发商。马斯克的回答很克制,SpaceX会专注于解决大规模人员和货物运输的问题,把成本压到最低,把可靠性做上去,像当年的联合太平洋铁路公司那样。之后的机会,留给火星上的企业家。
如果能在那上面催生出各种各样的机会,我就认为那非常成功了。我们只做别人不想做的事。(马斯克)
一个关于铝车身的细节
有个听众提到参观工厂时注意到Model S整个车架是铝的,问为什么这么选。马斯克的回答很典型:
铝是最好的材料选择。Model S要达到极高的安全评级,但不能让车太重。如果用钢,你要么做得又重又安全,要么又轻又不安全。铝加工起来确实更难,连接工艺更复杂,但航空航天业不会用钢造飞机,那太蠢了,飞不起来。早期Atlas火箭的燃料箱倒是用钢做的,但那是特例。(马斯克)
这个回答里藏着一套找参照物的办法。他没拿另一个车厂的方案当基准,他去参照的是飞机制造业,因为飞机的核心约束跟车一样:既要轻,又要结实。从第一性原理出发,参照物该按物理约束来选,同行的做法排在了后面。
给技术从业者的几条可操作建议
这场访谈是2012年的,里面有几条东西到今天还能用,而且可以直接拿去用:
- 用复合增长率做长期判断。太阳能当年占比不到1%,马斯克敢说本世纪中叶成为最大电力来源,靠的是对一条增长曲线外推的判断,对某家公司或某项技术的判断反而退到了次要位置。评估一个技术方向时,先看它的成本下降曲线和渗透率曲线,再看具体玩家。
- 在你判断一个行业要被重写的时候,把类比推理收起来。类比推理在稳定行业里是捷径,在规则被推翻的地方成了最大的认知障碍。换成这个问题:这件事按基本原理推,该长什么样?
- 把宏大目标翻译成一个可算的数字。火星移民听起来像科幻,拆成“50万美元一张船票”之后变成成本工程问题。任何听起来不可执行的大目标,都值得追问一句:它的成本门槛数字是多少?
- 换参照行业,别在同行里打转。车用铝,参照的是造飞机。遇到设计或成本难题时,去找那些受同类物理约束、但竞争压力不同的行业,看它们怎么解题。
- 把失败当作概率游戏的一部分。风投投20家成一两家属于正常,Solyndra倒闭推不出政府愚蠢,也推不出太阳能没前途。看一个赛道时,看样本量,别看单个案例的成败。
- 对新闻的负面偏好保持警惕。人的心理天然给负面信息更高权重,那是进化留下的机制,跟现实的准确度无关。读行业新闻时,刻意去找那些“进展顺利所以没人报道”的部分。
这些建议里最反直觉的是第二条。多数人的职业决策都是类比式的,看同行怎么做、看成功者怎么走、看现在什么最热。这条路在平稳时期有效,等到结构性变化发生,它会把所有人一起带进沟里。马斯克讲这番话的时候四十出头,靠的正是这套绕开类比的方式在三个行业同时下注,三次都下成了。
0:00the theme we're going to explore in the next two plus days involves Confluence of various kinds of Science of pure science and technology and commerce and Innovation and public policy and The Human Condition and culture and and all all the rest and we have a gentleman to to lead this off who epitomizes in the spectacular and so far brief
0:23career he's had a variety of different interests that he's been able to meld and maybe maybe we'll hear there's a unified field theory behind it but at least we'll we'll have different ones I'm going to take a minute to read a few of Elon musk's achievements just as background for the kind of variety and breadth that he brings this conversation he's now the CEO and product architect of Tesla Motors and also the CEO CTO of space exploration Technologies SpaceX which had of course its its wonderful launch a little more was that two years ago when it was a year Falcon 9 is what I'm thinking we did two launches last year yeah and it was it wasn't a
1:00recognition of the Falcon 9 that I served as Mr musk's mini biographer a year ago we had our annual Brave thinkers issue for the Atlantic so I got to do a brief q a with you about all the various things you're also the the non-executive chairman and principal shareholder of Solar City which is now the leading provider of solar power systems in the U.S and of course among other things in your spare time you were the co-founder of of PayPal there are I will just give one or two other accolades and then get onto the the convert conversation that in 2009 the National Space Society awarded Our Guest Mr musk there Von Braum trophy given for leadership of the
1:37most significant achievement in space and in 2010 he was the youngest recipient of the auto executive of the Year innovator reward for his work at Tesla Motors and so [Music] and and we'll have we'll have one more and then we'll get to to actual questions which is there are other Publications in the universe apart from the Atlantic Monthly one of them is is time it's a younger publication than we are they're about 80 years old we're 154 and counting but the the time 100 for 2010 you were a member of that so with that background we have a few minutes to explore a whole variety of topics about the business histories the various Enterprises you've been involved in
2:20about the frontiers of energy and transportation in the sky and the land about the process of innovation the U.S environment for for making these discoveries but let me just start most of us are wondering how you could possibly have been involved in so many different fields and be pushing the frontiers of all of them how did you end up being in PayPal and space exploration and solar power and all the red how did you get here sure well some of that was serial so I I did a an internet company that most people haven't heard of called zip2 which helped bring the newspapers online these newspapers weren't always online but the but my company helped bring help help with the New
3:03York Times and heard some light Road and a few other things and and then with the capital from that I started PayPal which was originally called x.com and and then from the capital of that it allowed me to start SpaceX Tesla and and SolarCity so and I didn't I didn't actually I didn't expect to be running SpaceX and Tesla but I kind of had the choice of either let Tesla die or or run it personally and so I I didn't want to let it die so I I stepped and run personally but I have to say it's quite difficult running two companies at the same time I I don't want to make it sound like this is easy it's really difficult and was it planned all along that you would get
3:56into all this whole range of fields or was that opportunistic no it was actually well planned is maybe aspirational so when I when I was in college there were three areas that I thought would would most affect the future of humanity in a positive way and a bit but I thought I thought of these in the abstract not not from the standpoint I would actually be able to be involved in those three areas but those were the the internet sustainable energy both production and consumption tells us about production sorry solar studies about production Tesla's about consumption of energy in a sustainable way and then the third is making life multi-planetary
4:37and I really didn't think I'd be involved in the third one but it but but it did seem to me that's one of the really important things that should happen if we're to have an exciting and inspiring future and let me you said something which caught my attention that that when you were in college and developing these skills you want to do some things that were of benefit to humanity why why did you think that well because not everyone does yeah no I I guess it was I'd
5:03sort of a existential crisis of like what does it all mean and what's the meaning you know what's the meaning of life and is this 3am over a beer or this one as well more seriously probably goes back to high school I guess I don't want to give a laboriously long answer but I was yeah I had
5:22sort of a dark childhood it wasn't good probably partially brought on by by reading some of the philosophers like don't ever read chopinar initra if you're 14. yes it's not good or iron Rand either too yeah yeah so I was just trying to find figure out what you know what this will mean and actually when I read The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy which I think is a great work philosophy that sort of highlighted the point that very often the issue is understanding what questions to ask and if you can properly frame the question then the answer is the easy part so I thought things that expand the scope and scale of human consciousness and allow us to better ask questions and
6:10you know and and Achieve greater Enlightenment those are good things and so that's sort of what what can we do that's gonna most likely lead to that outcome and so obviously we have to assist the internet is an important element to that because the internet is like it's like the world acquiring a nervous system all of a sudden you can be anywhere if you have an internet connection you you have access to the cumulative knowledge of humanity it's pretty incredible I mean you have more access more information than the Library of Congress through your iPhone I want to be part of yeah you know always put a small brick in in the construction of that
6:49that edifice and and and that's that's why the internet and then sustainable energy because well tautologically if it's not sustainable we're going to hit a wall and even if one considers the environmental issues to be non-existent in fact you could say for the sake of argument that CO2 is beneficial but let's assume it's beneficial by the way I think that would be a bad assumption or respect to Chevron the the
7:24and then even if you assume that the United States has every drop of oil in the world well we still need to get off oil eventually because what will happen is that scarcity will drive the price up leading to economic collapse and so my interest in in electric vehicles goes back to to college before global warming became a a real issue and so and but I think I think the environmental issues do add additional urgency to to the matter simply unwise to run an experiment on how much CO2 the the ocean's the atmosphere can absorb yes as yes let me ask one other question
8:07about again you and how you got to this this point in life one reason people read biographies of accomplished people is to get more clues more data points on how it happened what what the the the steps were along the road many people kind of college and can't find a job you've been invented several entire new new Industries or or companies what do you think made you the way you are and what can be extrapolated could other people learn from your example to date I you know I I think I need to sort of put some thought into that and say what what lessons can be drawn because I'm so usually in the thick of things that that it's I don't I don't I haven't really put a lot of time into
8:47abstracting what lessons can be most helpful but and the way I tend to view problems is is from a from a physics standpoint and I think I think physics is a good analytical framework and one of the key things in in physics is to reason from first principles this is contrary to the way most human reasoning takes place which is by analogy reasoning from first principles just means that you figure out what are the fundamentals what are the fundamental truths or or things that are pretty people are pretty sure are fundamental truths and and can you build up to a conclusion from from that you know from those principles and and then certainly if you come up
9:30with some idea and it appears to violate one of those fundamental truths then you're probably wrong or you should get a really big prize or something like that so this may seem like I don't know it maybe it may seem sort of obvious when it's explained but it's actually not what people do reasoning by analogies is helpful because it's a shortcut yeah and it's and it's mostly correct but but it tends to be most incorrect when you're dealing with new things because it's hard to analogize to something really new let me now shift to the areas where your businesses are now operating you have a solar solar power company obviously you have the electric cars and you have
10:12space and so let's talk about each of those areas give us if you would what you think the potential of solar power is and your general you're making your point about the importance of addressing sustainability energy what how you think people should think about energy now about solar energy and more broadly sure well I I think I think solar solar power will be this the single biggest source of electricity at least the United States by the middle point of the century and that that may seem like a bold statement given the tiny percentage that it generates right now which is from the order of sort of one percent or less less than one percent really
10:52but if you look at the growth rate of solar that that's where it's gonna it's gonna go this compound growth is incredibly powerful and but I think anything we can do to accelerate that that growth is a good thing because it means we will have power as long as the sun shines and if the sun doesn't shine we have larger issues so so I think that that's a good way to go and actually the Earth is almost entirely solar powered today the the I mean the only reason we're we're not a frozen ice ball at around four Kelvin maybe three Kelvin is is because of the sun and the so all the precipitation the weather system almost everything is so proud that the ecosystem is is solar powered
11:38and you know so so it's really just about taking a little bit of that that solar power and turning that into electricity which people could use and is there a way to explain concisely in terms I might understand the concept that solar cities is applying that will make it successful in a way that previous solar projects have not been yeah so well first of all I should say that most people don't realize how much the cost of solar panels has dropped there used to be about four dollars a white five years ago they're now about a buck 20.
12:13so that that's a huge drop and and there's obviously this sort of threshold where when when solar power is cheaper than conventional electricity that that's a massive inflection point and and electricity costs vary across the country so you'll see it's it's it starts to be better in some places than a small number of places than a medium then eventually most most places right which I think is what what will occur and I'm not saying solar power will be everything but it'll just I think it'll probably be at least a plurality maybe a majority by the midpoint of the century and most of what Solar City specifically is focused on is actually balance of systems so the solicit does
12:52not make the panel so I'll say it's it's kind of like say apple or Dell where they they design the system appropriate to a particular house or or office and they'll do the installation wiring the inverter permitting and after sales service which is about 70 of the cost and and since I've come from DC only today where any discussion of solar involves solyndra Scandal government policy et cetera et cetera what what should the government be doing if anything about solar now yeah well I I think the Slender thing is somewhat overblown it's obviously become political football but not not a very good one I think I think Republicans should pick up and
13:35I'm sort of moderate sort of half half of all they can have Democrat if you will but I'm somewhere in the middle I guess I'm sort of socially liberal and physically conservative presenting a lot of the country is actually but you know so but but the thing is that if you look at Slender it's Pacific private investors lost twice as much as the government and and the the investors The Venture capitalists that were involved in solyndra are some of the smartest Venture capitalists out there they're not they're not Bulls so it's difficult to say the government was a fool if if you've got some of the best Venture capitalists in there investing at all it's just
14:13startups are it's a bit of a numbers game you know typically in in Silicon Valley venture capitalist if they invest in 20 companies one or two will be a big hit Maybe 304 will be okay and the rest will not make it but but that's the way it works it's it's so it's it's I don't think it makes sense to to for the media to be so focused on solyndra there will be other failures too by the way it's not right yeah and and is there anything briefly that the government is doing right now that is either helping or hindering your work at SolarCity well probably both I suppose but but I think probably on balance more helpful than hurtful and certainly you know the case of SpaceX a lot of
15:01credit goes to NASA where I mean SpaceX would have been able to get started and and nor would it have gotten to where it is today without the help of NASA right so this is very much a sort of a partnership on that on that front and then with with solar SolarCity the associate actually doesn't get it gets gets a little bit on the federal side a little bit on on the in certain States in terms of the subsidies for for solar but those subsidies are actually actually relatively small these days they're not very big they used to be big but then they've been declining every year and then the big challenge for Solar City is of course to provide unsubsidized power at better than grid
15:45costs that's that's sort of the Holy Grail there and then of course sorry Tesla has received a loan from from the government which is part of why I get these slender questions but actually it's so City ever sorry Tesla has also raised about twice as much from the private sectors from the government and you know if Tesla is to compete effectively against GM Ford Chrysler and and others and those guys are getting massive amounts of money from the government and and at near zero cost to Capital and and we don't participate in that game it makes a very difficult job even harder and so it just wouldn't it would be sort of brilliant wise if we didn't do that
16:30and let's talk now about the electric car business itself what should people expect in terms of the technological improvements that are ahead of how much of a difference this will make in energy consumption and environmental impact in patterns of Life how should we think about this well actually on electric cars I actually think that that's electric vehicles will be a majority of all new cars manufactured in about 20 years will be pure electric and 20 years after that I expect the vast majority of cars in the road to Pure electric it takes sort of at least sort of 15 years-ish to replace the existing Fleet and so that's another prediction I hopefully I live to see the truth or or
17:16you know pulses of that and but in terms of how I think it'll affect things I I think I think that the transportation experience will become better and and most people haven't driven an electric car or used one day to day but but it's actually really nice not having to go to a gas station sorry sorry Chevron sorry I I don't mean to
17:42they are diversifying too absolutely I know chevron's doing doing a lot of good things so I I I don't mean to be negative on that front so so I think with the model S in particular that's coming out in July of next year the that's where we hope to show that an electric car can actually be Superior to a gasoline car in terms of of how how much usable space you get in the car so the model S is about the same external Dimensions as say Mercedes E-Class or BMW 5 series but it has twice the luggage capacity and it can actually seat up to up to five adults plus two two kids in a rear-facing seat kind of like the old station wagons and it it'll have a range of over 300
18:33miles you can charge charge in about 45 minutes you can swap the battery pack out faster than you can fill a gas tank and it will have the highest safety rating of of any car in the world every five star in every category and in fact it'll be the only car that's five star in every category by 2012 standards so it'll be the safest car you could buy and its cost would be order of magnitude what well it's one to two million dollars that's a great deal good for you no no it's it's it's it's it's it's actually priced at the it's at the same same price as as other premium sedans so it's about 50 50 000 starting price and then goes up to about a hundred thousand dollars for the high
19:17performance version with all the options and and and actually when you factor in the the that gasoline is much more expensive than electricity per mile it's about 10 times more expensive when you factor in those cost savings it's it's almost like a anywhere from a ten to twenty thousand dollar discount of the price okay and so one other question on electric cars is the challenge between now and the future describing mainly an engineering challenge or is there a science challenge that's still left I think it's mostly an engineering challenge there's some there there is a science challenge potentially in the high energy density capacitors and in effect
19:58what originally brought me out to California was I was going to do progressives at Stanford to try to develop a high energy density capacity that could serve as an electric an energy storage mechanism electric vehicles I think I know I wasn't sure that success was one of the possible outcomes but but now I'm I'm increasingly convinced that that it could work and and there's definitely some interesting science there yeah yeah so so I'm going to ask you a question about space and then a question about American policy before I invite a few questions from from the crowd question on space for Americans of my vintage which is tragically older than your vintage space was very
20:43romantic in the time when I was a kid we were having you know the race to the moon and it's become routine and you don't find that children seemingly excited in space why are you fascinated with space why should people care about it right well I think part of the problem the reason people aren't as excited about space is that we haven't been pushing the frontier as much and so you can only you can only watch the same movie so many times and before it gets a little boring and you know in in this in the 60s and early 70s we're really pushing the frontier of human space flight and and obviously those landing on the moon is regarded as one of the
21:22greatest achievements of humanity of arguably of life itself and and even though only a handful of people went to the moon vicariously we all went there well at least I wasn't alive at the time so but retrospectively you know and it was it was just one of those really inspiring things that I think made everyone glad to be a you know human you know it's like the things that we were we don't they're bad things humanity is and they're good things and and this is one of the good things and I I do think it's important that that we have these inspiring things that make you glad to get up in the morning and and that that's and glad to be a member of the human race
22:04and and we need to we need to push that that front here so and and I think I think the great goal we should be trying to pursue is trying to make life human make life multi-planetary so to establish a self-sustaining and growing civilization on another planet Mars being the only realistic possibility and and I think that would just be one of the greatest things Humanity could ever try to do you know in a life's been on Earth for four billion years and it's been confined to Earth for four billion years and and so I think I I think most people want a future where we're headed towards being a space-bearing civilization we're going out there exploring the stars and and
22:48and and and we want to be on a path to making true the things that we read in in science fiction books and see in in the movies and that that's a that's that's an exciting future but a future Where We Are Forever confined to Earth until some eventual Extinction event is less inspiring to be a journalist how all our stories turn out and how much of this if if the space part of your visions and Collective Visions goes as well as you expect how much do you expect actually to see yourself setting aside any life extension experiments you may come up with but right what what do you think is feasible in the next half century in The Next Century well I think I actually think it's I
23:31think well I don't want to get too too far ahead of ourselves with SpaceX but but I I think we could potentially send someone to Mars as soon as 10 years and I'd be disappointed if it took us longer than 20. but then then going beyond that what's important is not to to sort of have a flags and Footprints Mission but to develop the technologies that that could allow people to move to Mars if they wanted to and I think that that threshold number for where people where you think it would become kind of a self-sustaining reaction is around half a million dollars so that's the really the key question can you get it down to where the cost of moving to Mars plus enough
24:18to get going is equivalent to middle class house in California yeah because then you can like sell your stuff and move right and then okay that's how people came here to start right yeah right that's true how my parents came here I think that's possible I wasn't sure it was possible I wouldn't in fact I'm still not 100 sure as possible but I I I but I now think I think it is possible basic architecture and design in mind that I think could accomplish that yeah in that time frame I have one more question to ask you then I'll turn it over for questions from the crowd you've given us now almost half an hour of really inspiring and encouraging things to think about that most of our
25:04power will come in these from these solar installations that most of the cars will be running for a tenth a mile cost per mile they'll be going to Mars in 10 or 20 years you must have have noted that the prevailing mood in the U.S right now is not quite that that's not too negative really you know and it's like people like to lighten up a little I think honestly and and so I mean one
25:30but but it's my it's my duty of course to press on the scab of of of optimism or the pessimism which is that that that for example if options about the the festering sore of pessimism I can say that that many of the fundamentals that have made Americans successful in research over the years seem to be less invested in now than in the future we still have people coming from around the world like you to make this the arena for their their talents which is America's greatest asset in my view but universities are having troubles et cetera et cetera you think on the objective merits how do you think about America's position right now as an arena for the kind of innovation you're
26:11discussing sure well actually you know she mentioned my my grandfather was American and I was named after my great grandfather who's from Minnesota that's where my name comes was not at all exotic so I'm really returning to my ancestral Homeland if I were coming back to the U.S yeah I mean I I I think that I think there are actually lots of reasons to to be optimistic and and that life is actually pretty good you know but and if I'm if I may criticize the media a little bit here and actually not not so much the Magazine Media magazine is actually pretty pretty good choice but yeah the the the daily news media tends to focus on the worst thing
26:55occurring in the world at any given point it is like if if you know you know the world this this almost seven billion people or something like that on Earth you can imagine that the seven billion thing is pretty awful okay it's really bad and and if you but if you look at your Google news page or whatever it is you'll see a spotlight on the worst thing on earth it's so it should be cool what is the worst thing on Earth today that's it is it's terrible no I think it's it's I mean daily news media is probably blame but I think also there's something in the psyche of the human psyche which tends to place a weight on negative stuff more than positive I mean you want to react faster
27:40to the lion that's going to eat you rather than dinners on the table yeah you know being dinner is what is going to get a worse than having dinner so yeah so even though that the the news that you're reading is you know probably doesn't affect you directly and it's somewhere else in the world it's it's still it still has that sort of negative visceral reaction I know I'm not quite sure how that problem gets solved but I I do think the mood ought to improve because it's it's not it's out of sync with with reality life life is really pretty good you you've made a good case for that now we have time for a couple questions I'm going to turn to to Mary for the responsibility to
28:22choose questioners yeah yeah you got to choose yes among your your friends and colleagues here Elon if I might ask you you guys are talking pretty light-heartedly about things are actually pretty good but I think it's fair to say everyone in the room is aware that a lot of people
28:40many of those billions of people they don't have proper food they don't have proper shelter they don't have proper clothing they don't get educated around the world and you know we're talking rather glibly about perhaps making interplanetary Journeys to the moon or the Mars I'm just wondering well how about taking some of this you know effort and really trying to devote it to solving these very intractable problems here on Earth before we worry about going to the moon or going to Mars well I don't think it's neither old thing and I should maybe clarify that in terms of making life multi-planetary which you can sort of view as as kind of life
29:20insurance for Life collectively I I think you know we should spend a lot say much less than we would spend on health care but more than we spend on lipstick you know that's kind of like maybe a good way to bracket it and so maybe and I'm not I like lipstick you know but but but maybe a quarter of a
29:42percent of the GDP so it's not you know it's it's I think this may be a good number now I mean as far as the the rest of the world is concerned I think I mean in fact there was a good if I think fire fire well actually I I I read an article recently I remember who wrote it but it was called A History of Violence and and that you know we're actually at this incredibly non-violent period in history so if one of the metrics you'll use is like how much violence is there in the world we're at this ridiculously low violence period the probability of someone in the world dying for dying from war or or some violent event is extremely low at the lowest
30:24it's ever been in history that's that's a reason to be positive and if you look at most countries in the world that that we used to consider to be I guess poor I mean like say in India or or China they've made massive strides that this was good and a bad thing it's it's it's good obviously primarily good but it also means that there are a lot of more resources that that get used you know China is now putting more new cars on the road than than the US is but still it's it's a good thing overall so I I I wouldn't think of the rest of the world is not improving I think I think it actually it is improving when maybe I'm happy with the rate of improvement but it certainly is it is
31:07improving and you know this there's still issues in in less parts of the world but but they're going in the right direction they're not getting worse except in a few exceptional cases and and where those are exceptional cases they tend to be more driven by corrupt government or Civil War that then technology problems so but you know it's sort of unfashionable these days to sort of go and take out some well I guess maybe it's not that unofficial to take out dictators of other countries and so I'm not sure what I could do you know in that in that thing it's like I don't think these are technology problems for them you know and to clarify one thing you said that I I
31:53think should be clarified you're a person with great success in life and you're not saying oh life is good for me you're arguing that life is better for most people than what we usually appreciate but better for the vast majority of people in the world I mean it's difficult about a thousand on on you know everywhere all the time but but the vast majority of people in the world of life life is is good exactly life is great for me Mary yes yes hi Yvonne so I had the opportunity to your factory which is brand new and and amazing and I noticed that while your cars are battery driven and that's great it's also that the entire frame of the car is made of aluminum correct I and I
32:35was wondering how you made that choice and maybe we should should rebuild all cards with an aluminum frame yeah I mean I think aluminum is the best choice of material because with a Model S we wanted to achieve an extremely high safety rating but not make the car super heavy because then if it's so so the problem with with if you use steel is is that it ends up being you either you can either make it heavy and safe or light and unsafe like either of those Alternatives and and so enhance the use of aluminum it is it is a little harder to work with aluminum it's harder to join and so forth but since in the Aerospace industry like you know people would would not make a plane
33:20out of steel I mean that that would you know be a bit but it's a bit silly I got a plan it would fly right and and steel would also not be the first choice for for a rocket although I should point out the early Atlas tanks were steel balloons but but but for the most part you would not make a rock out of out of us out of steel so I do think moving to aluminum would be generally be a good idea yeah I was actually presenting some work I did at a conference at Stanford and NASA actually saw what I was doing they asked me to come over to the aim Center they brought me over there and they tasked me on a project to build a genome synthesizer for Mars which is
34:04kind of a crazy crazy story so I just moved here to La Jolla and actually started a company called Cambrian genomics okay where actually a couple days ago I met with Craig Venter and the entire team there originally they were they contacted me in Korea and it's part of why I dropped out of school to come come here and start this company and work with Craig all right right so Craig you know he started he made the first synthetic cell right from completely synthetic DNA right so the the company I started is called Cambrian was started with George charge at Harvard both of us came up with these light based devices to get DNA off the next-gen sequencer right
34:46so the synthesis that we do is is massively parallel the sequencing we do is massively parallel and then we use laser as a serial capture process we can capture about 100 base pairs every second two seconds can you steer this towards a question towards them yeah anyway so my my thinking was basically that people weren't very interested in going to Mars for the simple reason that it's a bunch of Red Rocks it doesn't look very interesting and they've seen lots of pictures of it on the television well it's definitely a fixer upper of a planet I agree absolutely right so if we could if we could go there potentially do something interesting and have people do you know
35:24make interesting things on for the planet and terrible maybe small parts of it we could we could do something maybe a little bit more interesting have you have do you have any plans I know your original plans were to do the greenhouses but maybe we could do without the greenhouses right well I think I think long term it's possible to terraform Mars and make it much like Earth but but that's sort of a long-term project that that may take a few centuries but in the meantime we need to to have established studies on Mars and I think that would require sort of Domes and and and that kind of thing but that's the only way to I only way to go I I think
36:02and then and then over time you you know we can terraform it and and then I think they could there could be a role for specially designed microbes in that scenario it it's tough right now for Mars because it's it's quite cold and you know well it's sort of it's not super common that there are times at Mars where it gets above freezing but but you know you don't have the same UV protection that you have on Earth or the same cosmic ray protection so you kind of need to fix a few things about the planet I think before it's really going to be feasible to have microbes that that could you know live outdoors in Mars so the kindly Mary has said that
36:43we should have a few more questions from yes so if you are willing sure yeah absolutely [Music] and Amory Lovins right up here in the front I'm just curious if either of them wants to enter into this conversation I want to pay tribute to something that has a Tesla that I think has some important implications your chief engineer JB Strobel is an old dear friend of mine yeah and the original Roadster had a problem that the gearbox blew up when it tried to meet the acceleration and and speed specs simultaneously so JB had the neat idea of getting rid of the gearbox getting more power out of the motor and his colleagues said well then the motor will
37:29overheat will have to Band-Aid on this Baroque cooling system so he said no we'll figure out what's getting hot and we'll give it a bigger cross-section or a higher conductivity it will tweak the software and Power Electronics to match and correct me on this but I think the result was something like no gearbox 10 miles longer Range 14 pounds lighter weight less noise less maintenance much lower manufacturing cost everything got better so the moral of that story was that there's a lot more flexibility in the software and Power Electronics design space than in the Baroque Victorian mechanical arts and that the ability to exploit that flexibility probably goes more to the
38:15small agile company than the Big Rich company now you may like to know that when I told this story to the chief engineer of one of the big automakers who had been saying electric traction will never make it in the market internal combustion engines will rule for another half century within a few weeks he gave an interview in the trade press saying he changed his mind and now he thought the future of traction was electric okay great and I I think this is a very interesting example of the kind of mind bending that that goes on in the
38:49kinds of small entrepreneurial outfits that that you have started and you know the the search for intelligent life on Earth continues but some really promising specimens are turning up just when and where we need them thank you so I think we have a microphone way in the back yeah so you've had a remarkable entrepreneurial journey and my question is just where do you draw the bounds on your entrepreneurial Vision do you for instance see yourself as if you get someone to Mars are you going to be its first real estate developer for instance well I think you SpaceX is going to be focused on Trans on the problem of being able to transport large numbers of people and
39:38cargo to Mars at at an affordable you know at local at low cost very reliably kind of like the you know the Union Pacific sort of you know but but then I think that will enable a lot of opportunities for entrepreneurs on Mars you know if we can enable all sorts of opportunities there then I would count that very successful so we'll just do the things that other people don't don't want to do but
40:10but I think you know step one is getting there and if you can't get there then it doesn't matter and I mean if if people couldn't get across the Atlantic there would be no United States so yeah before we thank Elon Musk which we all will do enthusiastically we'll have have a minute of stages we want to thank Merrill Lynch we want to thank Chevron also for its patience and big-heartedness in this session and in particular we want to thank we want to thank UCSD we want to thank the Atlantic event staff so now please join me in thanking everyone [Applause]
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版