2010年4月15日,奥巴马在佛罗里达肯尼迪航天中心发表了一场关于 NASA 未来的演讲。演讲里有一句话,把登月派彻底惹毛了。
我们以前去过那儿了。去过,也做过了。(巴拉克·奥巴马)
说的是月球。在奥巴马看来那属于重复劳动,钱该投到更远的地方去。
第一个踏上月球的人不买账。Neil Armstrong 公开把这个方案称作"毁灭性"的。Buzz Aldrin 倒是站在总统一边。
演讲第二天,NPR 的 Science Friday 把三位嘉宾请进了直播间:SpaceX 创始人马斯克、美利坚大学公共事务教授 Howard McCurdy、前众议院太空与航空小组委员会幕僚长 Bill Adkins。主持人 Ira Flatow 还接了一串听众来电。
马斯克在这场节目里给出的评价,和 Armstrong 完全相反。他说,这是自阿波罗计划以来美国最好的太空政策,也是他见过的唯一一个有重大成功可能性的政策。
一个竞选时提议从 NASA 预算里砍掉50亿美元、转手投给教育的人,成了马斯克口中最好的太空政策制定者。这个反差需要说清楚。
总统来参观,马斯克是前一天才知道的
节目开场,主持人问马斯克:总统到你们发射场参观,意外吗?
马斯克说意外,他们提前一天才接到通知。"这当然是极大的荣誉。"
主持人追问,这算不算总统在用行动表明,这就是他要走的方向。
马斯克的回答很克制。他说自己没法替总统解释动机,不清楚背后的推理,但他认为这至少代表某种程度的支持和背书。
主持人接着把问题转给 Howard McCurdy,问他怎么看总统演讲里释放的信号:近地轨道交给私营公司,政府不再自己造火箭把人送上去。
McCurdy 把时间线拉回了两年前。
两年前那份泄密的预算提案
McCurdy 提醒听众,奥巴马竞选总统期间,有一份提案被泄露出来。提案建议从 NASA 预算里砍掉50亿美元,改投教育。
这份提案引发了很多人的警惕,包括 Neil Armstrong。他们担心的是"披着羊皮的狼":嘴上说改革,实际是终结载人航天计划。
所以奥巴马这次演讲的撰稿人花了很大力气去否认这件事。他们要传递的信息是:不,总统完全致力于太空计划,而且他采用的策略,激烈程度和1961年肯尼迪决定登月时一样。
主持人放了一段演讲录音。谈到火星时,奥巴马用了几乎和肯尼迪一模一样的句式:
到2030年代中期,我相信我们能把人送入火星轨道,并让他们安全返回地球。登陆火星会在这之后。我期望能活着看到那一天。(巴拉克·奥巴马)
"安全返回地球"这几个字,是从肯尼迪的演讲稿里直接搬过来的。
肯尼迪的备忘录,和奥巴马的三分球
McCurdy 讲了1961年4月的一段往事。
肯尼迪给当时的副总统林登·约翰逊写了一份备忘录,请约翰逊调研太空计划,核心问题是:怎么才能赢苏联?
能不能在载人上天这件事上抢先?不行,加加林已经上去了。
能不能抢先建空间站?约翰逊咨询了太空圈的人,答案还是不行。
能不能绕月飞行赢一把?还是不行。
约翰逊的结论是:唯一能赢的办法就是登月。跳过前面所有可以做的事,一步跨到更远的地方。
McCurdy 把这个策略比作篮球里的三分球。奥巴马干的是同一件事:跳过月球和其他一堆建议,直接奔向更深的太空。这也正是 Augustine 报告里"灵活路径"(flexible path)那一套思路。
主持人问马斯克认不认同这个判断。
马斯克说,总统必须回应批评者。几个月前他提出的新方向,被批评缺乏总体目标、缺乏目的地、缺乏时间表。所以这次演讲的核心任务,就是把这些目标、目的地和时间表摆出来。他认为总统确实回应了这些批评。
他补了一句:短期目标和长期愿景得平衡。这套方案一边投资长期技术,一边通过商业部门完成近期目标,属于折中的解法。
为什么先去小行星,而不是回月球
演讲里有个安排,很多人没想到:2025年,送宇航员去一颗小行星。这是人类历史上第一次载人深空任务。
到2025年,我们期望有专为长途航行设计的新飞船,届时将开启史上第一次飞出月球轨道的载人任务。(巴拉克·奥巴马)
主持人问,为什么要去小行星?
Bill Adkins 的解释是,这是一套复杂度递增的目标序列。登陆小行星比登月容易得多,因为月球的引力井太深。引力井这个词听着抽象,说白了就是从月球表面起飞得先挣脱月球引力,这段路本身就要烧掉大量燃料和推力;小行星的引力几乎可以忽略,靠上去和离开都省事。
小行星本身也很有意思,它们是太阳系的活化石,藏着太阳系起源的线索。
Adkins 强调了另一点:把目标定在可实现的范围里,是这个计划的关键部分。目标定得太高,实现不了,期望值被拉爆,整个项目就会崩。
他背后的意思是,不能一上来就宣布一个连技术路线都看不清的目标,然后指望国会年年批钱。
NASA 变成客户,SpaceX 变成航空公司
主持人问马斯克:你和你的公司,在这个计划里处在什么位置?
马斯克的回答很直接:
我们实际上相当核心。(埃隆·马斯克)
他说的"我们"不只指 SpaceX,而是整个私营商业太空运输行业。
他解释了这套逻辑的起点:NASA 不会再有阿波罗时代那种预算暴涨。既然没有额外的钱,又想在太空上取得重大进展,那就只剩一条路,用负担得起的方式做,也就是借助自由企业的力量,就像人类在所有其他交通方式上做的那样。
主持人追问,那 NASA 就成了客户,雇你们这样的公司上去跑近地轨道任务?
马斯克打了个比方:可以把它想成一架太空飞机,或者一家航空公司。SpaceX 负责运营这次任务,NASA 买票登机。
他还顺手戳破了一个当时流传很广的误解:很多人以为军方还在自己造火箭发卫星。事实是,军方的卫星早就在买商业发射服务了。
军方早就在买商业火箭了
主持人说,总统演讲里没提军方。军方要发射那些巨型卫星,他们会继续用自己的火箭,还是也开始买商业运载?
马斯克说,这里有个普遍的误会。
波音和洛克希德各自经营着 Atlas 和 Delta 两个火箭家族,后来把这块业务合并,成立了一家叫联合发射联盟(United Launch Alliance,ULA)的公司。所有国防部的卫星、NASA 的星际探测器、太空望远镜,都是 ULA 送上去的。
所以这次的政策转向,没有人们想的那么激进。NASA 采购卫星发射服务,早就是买商业服务,现在只是把这个做法延伸到载人航天上。
McCurdy 补充说,这套模式同样适用于军用和民用太空。发生的事情本质上是发射产业的全球化。这个行业成熟到一定程度,NASA 就可以退出"经营一家航空公司"的业务。
1925年,骑兵不再送邮件
McCurdy 用了一个历史类比。
1925年,美国骑兵部队不再负责送邮件,这项业务交给了航空业。政府退出,市场接手,航空工业就这么发展起来了。
NASA 现在要做的,是同一件事。
但风险也摆在那儿:竞争激励下的私营企业,能不能用30亿到60亿美元,干成 NASA 原计划要花300亿到350亿美元才能干成的事,也就是开发下一代把人送上低地球轨道、再安全送回来的运载火箭。
McCurdy 说得很直白:这是一场巨大的赌注。差了一个数量级的钱,一边是效率革命,一边是灾难。
魔鬼在细节里
主持人把这个问题转到马斯克那儿,问他同不同意这是高风险赌注。
马斯克的回答有点出人意料。他说,这场政策辩论有个麻烦的地方:很大一部分争论是关于标签的,吵的是"什么才算商业"。
他有个习惯:每次有人问他这个问题,他就反问对方,"政府"又是什么意思?他认为这种讨论没什么意义。
真正该问的是:NASA 打算怎么执行这项政策?魔鬼在细节里。
他点出一个具体的担心。NASA 提议让产业界来竞标固定价格合同,可这个项目还在起步阶段,没人真正搞清楚需求和技术复杂度。对一个复杂的开发项目定死价格,非常难。国防部在复杂固定价格合同上有很长的问题史,超支、延期、返工,几乎是常态。
他还批评了辩论本身的框架:把"政府主导、政府当主承包商"和"全部外包"对立起来,属于虚假的二分法。中间有大量可行的空间,比如政府承担前期研发风险、企业承担量产和运营效率。
主持人说,那大家都在等细节。马斯克说,总统这次把批评者关于总体目标的关切回应得不错,下周参议员 Mikulski 会跟 NASA 局长 Bolden 开听证会,更多细节会在那儿出来。NASA 把细节铺开、国会议员消化接受,都需要时间。
重型运载火箭到底砍没砍
听众 Ron 从新罕布什尔州曼彻斯特打来电话。他的问题很具体。
奥巴马保留了星座计划(Constellation)里的指令舱,砍掉了原定把它送上近地轨道的助推器。用商业飞船跑近地轨道,Ron 能理解。但重型运载火箭项目也被砍了,而星座计划本来是要把人送去火星的。
Ron 的逻辑是:把月球从行程里划掉可以理解,但一边取消重型运载火箭,一边说火星是目标,这说不通。而且总统演讲里说,要投30多亿美元研究先进重型运载火箭,那又是什么意思?
Adkins 接过这个问题。他说总统演讲里提出,2015到2016年锁定重型运载火箭的设计方案,近期先投研发。美国确实需要在某个技术上持续投资,那就是推进系统,特别是大推力推进。他不认为总统放弃了重型运载。
这段交锋值钱的地方在于,它暴露了政策沟通的困境:演讲里一句话,听众听到的是两个相反的意思。
一万个岗位,和一条没有无痛选项的路
主持人问:那些担心航天业丢工作的人,总统回应了吗?
Adkins 说,总统提出了一个在全国创造1万个岗位的计划。
他也很坦白:太空计划走到今天这一步,没有一条无痛的路。资源就是不够。
他的判断是,一个可实现、可持续的项目,长期看会创造更多就业。载人太空探索如果有什么属性,那就是它是长期的。用短期的岗位数字去衡量一个五十年的项目,本身就错位了。
一位失败者的证词
听众 Chuck 从密歇根州兰辛打进来。他有个身份:他自己的公司 Rocketplane Kistler 是 COTS 项目第一轮的两个中标者之一,另一家就是 SpaceX。
COTS 全称商业轨道运输服务(Commercial Orbital Transportation Services),是 NASA 用来扶持私营公司往空间站送货的项目。
Chuck 想说的是:商业系统在奥巴马和 Bolden 上任之前就已经跑通过。
他讲了自家公司的遭遇。Rocketplane Kistler 中标后,要完成一系列很重的财务里程碑。2007年中期,他们要去市场上融5亿美元,正好撞上全球金融危机开始冲击华尔街,而且当时大多数人还没意识到这场金融风暴有多严重。
他们赢了合同,通过了所有初始技术里程碑和第一个财务里程碑。然后要拿出5亿美元私营配套资金时,华尔街没人愿意把交易做完。他们已经融到了5亿里的3.5亿,但协议条款是全有或全无(all or nothing)。NASA 有权取消合同,就取消了。
Chuck 的结论是:商业确实行得通。当时华尔街对"为私营企业服务政府需求"这类融资反应不错,而且那还是个比现在薄得多的市场。
他举了几个当时的数字:Bigelow Aerospace 在盘算每年15到20次私人载人和货运发射,服务私营商业空间站。NASA 已经向 SpaceX 和 Orbital Sciences 发出了30亿美元的商业货运发射服务合同。
他说,如果当年他们手里有其中一份合同,剩下那点钱根本不是问题。问题出在 COTS 最初的结构:第二阶段的常规发射服务协议要到后面才发。2007年的华尔街很保守,说你得有完整的订单簿才行,而他们没有。
最后他说,所以系统本身是行的,坏的是时序。
马斯克:这算是健康的政府采购
主持人问马斯克同不同意"系统行得通"这个判断。
马斯克说,他倾向于认为这属于健康政府采购的一个样本,至少部分是这样。
他复盘了过程。NASA 的商业货运任务,本质上是搞了一场竞争:谁能证明自己有能力把货送到空间站再送回来。NASA 发出竞争,两家公司赢得初始投标,Rocketplane Kistler 和 SpaceX。两家都跟 NASA 一起制定了双方认可的里程碑。
SpaceX 完成了那些里程碑,过程非常艰难,但完成了。Rocketplane Kistler 没完成。NASA 的处理是:你完不成里程碑,那就把你从合同里拿掉,资金重新竞标,给第二家公司。最后给了 Orbital Sciences。
马斯克认同 Chuck 说的一点:项目结构应该改。如果一家公司成功完成所有里程碑走到最后,这份业务本质上应该由政府保证。他认为以后的合同应该这么设计,否则敢冒前期风险的公司会越来越少。
但他对整体流程的评价是正面的。他给了一个很尖锐的观察:通常政府采购项目会把一种状态拖得特别久,那种状态里,"成功"根本不在可能的结果清单上。
韦伯望远镜,和总统没提的那件事
节目快结束时,主持人带听众过了一遍演讲里其他几个点。
总统提到"后哈勃望远镜"(post-Hubble telescope)。主持人问,这说的是詹姆斯·韦伯太空望远镜(James Webb Space Telescope)吗,还是别的什么?
嘉宾们的判断是韦伯。也有人提到,可能指干涉测量任务(interferometry),那类任务能把多台望远镜的信号合成,从而收集系外行星的数据。但大家的共识是韦伯。再说从零开始设计一台望远镜要花好几年,一夜之间拼不起来。
另一件被总统略过的事:有传言说他可能会给航天飞机计划延长几次飞行,国会也提出了相关立法。但他在演讲里对这件事明显保持沉默。
这事一半是科学,一半是政治
主持人问了一个尖锐的问题:这场演讲里,有多少是为了在佛罗里达拉选票?
嘉宾的回答没有回避。很大一部分是政治转变。佛罗里达的初选过程里,像 Lori Garver 这样的人终于有机会把问题讲给奥巴马听,他很认真地接受了。
主持人接着问:国会掌握钱袋子,他们会照着这个方案走吗?
回答援引了历史。从肯尼迪1961年那次著名宣告开始,国会大体上倾向于跟随总统。既然总统现在走的是前进的方向,削减的方向被抛在了一边,国会大概会去塑造细节,但总体方向会同意。
节目里还有一句观察,说得很透:每一位当过参议员或众议员、在任内谈过削减太空计划的总统,一旦真正坐进椭圆形办公室、要为关闭载人航天计划这个决定负责,就没人愿意把自己的指纹留在上面。
奥巴马身上发生的转变就是这个。责任一旦落到自己肩上,人就往前走。
火星轨道和火星着陆之间
主持人抓住了演讲里的一个措辞细节。
总统说要让人进入火星轨道。但他没说什么时候着陆,也没说什么时候把人带回来。
嘉宾指出,火星着陆是个技术难度极高的问题。进入、下降和着陆(Entry, Descent, and Landing,EDL)这一整套动作,已经有好几个机器人探测器没能活下来。火星大气稀薄,减速窗口窄,伞开早了不行,开晚了也不行,这一段被业内称作"恐怖七分钟"。
绕火星和落火星,难度差着好几个量级。
主持人还提了另一个遗憾:火星车取得了那么大的成功,声誉那么高,演讲里却没怎么提机器人任务。嘉宾说,科学和技术政策办公室的情况说明书里确实提到了机器人任务,但那不是演讲的重点。演讲的重点是给载人航天重新定调。
马斯克的结论
节目最后,主持人请马斯克做总结。
马斯克说,这场演讲真正说明的事情是,奥巴马坚持了自己的立场,坚持了他在2月提交给国会的那份预算里提出的相当激进的改动:取消星座计划,发展有竞争性的商业太空运输,开发去火星所必需的核心技术,或许有一天还能走得更远。
我认为这是自阿波罗以来我们有过的最好的太空政策。这是我的真心话。至少在我所见过的政策里,它是唯一一个有重大成功可能性的。(埃隆·马斯克)
主持人最后祝 SpaceX 下个月的发射顺利,那是猎鹰9号(Falcon 9)的首次飞行。
回头看这场2010年的电台辩论,有意思的地方在于它把一整套决策逻辑摊在了桌面上:预算不会暴涨,目标必须分级,风险必须有人承担,标签之争毫无意义。
这几条逻辑,放到今天任何一个技术行业里,都成立。
给今天做技术决策的人几条可操作的建议
- 评估任何一项政策或项目,先找它的里程碑和时间表。没有可验证节点的宏大叙事,基本等于没有计划。马斯克给奥巴马好评的具体理由,就是演讲补上了目标、目的地和时间表这三样东西。
- 遇到"商业还是政府""自研还是采购"这类路线之争,别在标签层面纠缠。直接跳到执行层问三个问题:合同怎么设计,风险怎么分配,失败由谁承担。马斯克那句反问很锋利:先定义清楚"政府"是什么意思。
- 目标要按难度递增排列。先小行星再火星,就是这个思路。一上来就定一个连技术路线都看不清的目标,期望值被拉爆的那天,项目也就完了。
- 签全有或全无(all or nothing)条款之前,先把最坏情况推演一遍。Rocketplane Kistler 融到七成资金仍然出局,输在条款和时机上,能力没有问题。
- 别用宏大目标掩盖资源不足。Adkins 那句"没有无痛的路,资源就是不够"听着不舒服,但它比任何乐观表述都诚实。承认约束,才谈得上设计一个能活五十年的项目。
- 给敢冒前期风险的执行方一个明确的终点承诺。完成所有里程碑就该拿到业务,这是一份合同最该写清楚的地方。做不到这一点,下一轮就没人愿意接盘。
0:00you just press the buggy hello and welcome back to Science Friday thanks were you surprised the president came out for a visit yeah it actually was surprising we only learnt about it the day before so it was certainly great honor and yeah was that his way of saying this is this is the direction I want to go in do you think you know I I can't speak for the president I don't know that there the underlying reasoning but I think certainly it's a it's some level of
0:33support and endorsement I think Howard mccurdy is the president basically just saying that and near Earth orbit we're gonna go to private companies anything at all design around rockets well it was quite a transformational speech when you think back to a couple of years ago to when he was running for the presidency and there was a proposal leaked that's in which he suggested cutting five billion dollars out of the NASA budget and spending it on education which is why I think a lot of people including Neil Armstrong were fearful that this is wolf in sheep's clothing that it's really the end of the human spaceflight program so the people who wrote a speech
1:10yesterday try very hard to say no no he's fully committed to the space program and has adopted as radical a strategy as President Kennedy adopted in 1961 when he decided to go to the moon and I'd be glad to explain that if you want me to well let me play a cut of that because when he talked about Mars he had almost an identical language to President Kennedy's speech by the mid 2030s I believe we can send humans to orbit Mars and return them safely to earth and landing on Mars will follow and I expect to be around to see it that returned them safely to earth is directly right out of the Kennedy speeches that's right in April of 1961 President Kennedy wrote a memo to Lyndon
1:51Johnson and asked Johnson to research the space program and said how can we beat the Russians can we beat them in putting a human in space well no Yuri Gagarin had already done that can we beat them to put up a space station Johnson said no after consulting with some people in the space community can we beat them by flying around the moon Johnson said no the only way we can beat them is by landing on the moon leapfrogging all these other things that can be done in space and going further and this is like a 3-point shot in a basketball game for Barack Obama he's leapfrogging the moon and other suggestions and going deeper into space which is what a lot of people had
2:28suggested in what constitutes the flexible path option in the Augustine report a bill that kins do you agree I think the president had to address the the concerns of his critics that the new direction he proposed a couple months ago lacked overarching goals and destinations in a time frame and so I think a key point of the speech was to lay out those those goals the destinations and the time frames and I think he really did answer the critics well the he needs to balance a near-term
2:59goals with a vision for the long-term and I think the program that he's proposed is a balance between investment and technology for the long haul and meeting the near-term goals by engaging the commercial sector let's let's talk about some of those definite goals that he had made and and let's let's begin by talking about something that in another I don't think anybody had expected and that was going to an asteroid landing land landing an astronaut on an asteroid this is something that he laid out saying that that by 2025 we expect a new
3:37spacecraft designs along the new journey let's listen to him say it himself by 2025 we expect new spacecraft designed for long journeys to allow us to begin the first-ever crewed missions beyond the moon into deep space so we'll start we'll start by sending astronauts to an asteroid for the first time in history honey how do you why we do that bill well I think he's laying out a plan of increasingly complex goals and landing on an asteroid is a lot easier than landing on the moon because the the deep well the gravity of the moon and so it's an easier goal and asteroids themselves are interesting objects and are in fact keys to the the origin of the of the solar system and
4:22and I think laying out achievable goals is a critical part of this plan and not to to set goals so high that they're unachievable and raise expectations too high so I think that was a an appropriate balance you know on musk where do you fit in your company and private companies like yours where do you fit into the president's plan well we're actually pretty central when I say we I mean I'm private in private to the commercial space transport not just basics or or really central to the president's vision and strategy I think what what this new policy recognizes is that NASA isn't going to get some huge increase in its budget as occurred would
5:04be in the Apollo era so if we're to make great progress and make that the next giant leap for mankind then it has to be done in an affordable manner and the only way to do that is by harnessing the power of free enterprise as we use in all other modes of transport so you're gonna be like a customer then NASA will hire people like you to go up and dues near-earth orbital missions for them yeah they think of us like a space plane you know it would I guess we operate the mission as well so I guess we're coming like an aircraft company and and and Caroline well what was left unsaid in his in president speech was what about the military gentlemen I mean the
5:48military you know they're gonna fly their giant satellites on their own Rockets are they gonna use commercial vehicles well you know the funny thing is that they already do use commercial vehicles that there's a lot of confusion out there as to what's commercial and what's non-commercial but Boeing and Lockheed have brought two families or rockets called the Atlas and Delta and they merged the business there's one that operates as one company called United Launch Alliance and they they are the ones that launch all of the Defense Department satellites as well as the NASA spacecraft missions like you know going to the interplanetary mission right the Space Telescope's and that
6:29kind of thing so it's it's in one way it's that's less radical than people think because it's really taking the approach that NASA or users for their satellite missions which is to buy commercial launch services and extending that to human spaceflight but how are they going to continue to do that model and will the military still use these other rockets that were not mentioned yeah well I think I think that the model applies equally as well to the military and civil space what's happening here is a globalization of the of the launch industry it's sufficiently mature now that at least NASA can get out of the business of running an airline in the similar way that the u.s.
7:14cavalry got out of the business of delivering the mail in 1925 and spurred the development of the aviation industry the big risk in all of this is whether or not private industry with the incentives that competition provides can do for say three to six billion dollars what NASA was planning on doing for about thirty to thirty-five billion dollars developing the next generation of launch vehicles to get humans to and from low-earth orbit that's a big risk hell do you agree yeah well I I think there's a part of the problem in having a debate about this policy is it's a lot of it's a debate about labels about what is commercial and I like whenever
7:53anybody asks that to ask them what does it mean to be government because I'm not sure that that that debate really serves a purpose I think the real question is is how will NASA implement this policy and the Devils in the details and there are lots of nuances a one area of concern is if NASA as they've proposed
8:13is to put industry up to bid on fixed price contracts in this program is still at a beginning stages and and no one truly understands the requirements and the technical complexity of it and it's very difficult to put a fixed price on a complex development there's a long history of problems in the Defense Department with fixed price complex contracts and I think the debate about commercial versus government is really the way to look at it and they really need to look beyond that and exactly how does NASA plan to implement that program and does it balance the risk so you're waiting for the details to come out that Devils in the details the devil is
8:52always in the details and we don't have those details yet when would we start to see them well I think the president did a good job of addressing the critics concerns about the overall goals of the program next week Senator Mikulski's going to have a hearing with administrator Bolden who I think will follow up with additional details and it'll take some time for NASA to lay roll out those details and
9:17for members of the Congress to become comfortable with the plan but I think one of the problems again is it's it's a false dichotomy between programs that are driven by the government in a government as the prime contractor role versus we're just gonna outsource everything there's a lot of ground in the middle that that could work for the program all right we'll take a short break come back talk more with howard mccurdy bill Adkins Elon Musk and your calls one 899 eight two five five stay with us we'll be right back [Music]
9:56I'm Ira Flatow this is science Friday from NPR listening to Science Friday from NPR I am Ira Flatow we're talking this hour about President Obama's speech to NASA downtown the air in Florida one eight hundred nine eight nine eight two five five let's get some calls and Ron in Manchester New Hampshire I Ron thanks for taking my call something that's been bothering me about this whole thing Obama retained the command module from
10:27the constellation program he told the booster that was supposed to take it into low-earth orbit I understand the whole thing using commercial vehicles to take into low-earth orbit but he also killed the program for getting heavy lift for getting us to Mars constellation was supposed to get us to Mars in everywhere else in hooding the moon I can understand taking moon off of constellations itinerary but to cancel
10:54the heavy lift vehicle that's supposed to get us to Mars at the same time talking about that tally his goal let's see if I get an answer because the President did say in his speech that he's going to invest more than three billion dollars to conduct research on an advanced heavy lift rocket bill what did that mean to you can you answer Ron's question well I think the President's speech I don't have in front of me but laid out to lock in a design I think in a 2015-2016 range for a heavy lift vehicle in the near term he intends to invest in R&D and frankly in one of the areas that the United States needs to invest in technology is in propulsion
11:34and large propulsion so I think there's a lot of benefit to that and I don't think he walked away from heavy lift did the president answer his critics who were worried about all the jobs that would be lost in the aerospace industry well he identified a program to create 10,000 jobs across the country and I don't think the stage where the space program is today I don't think there's a painless way out of the current dilemma there just simply aren't enough resources but I think having a program that is achievable and sustainable will create more jobs over the long run the space program if there ever was a program that's long term it's human space exploration Chuck flower in
12:14Lansing Michigan hi welcome to science Friday yeah hi first of all I'd like to point out that the commercial system even as it was before Obama and general Bolden took over the reins actually worked my company Rocketplane Kistler was the other cots one winner and in our case we had some pretty heavy-duty financial milestones that we had to meet and unfortunately we were going out into the marketplace in the middle of 2007 to go raise 500 million dollars essentially when the global financial meltdown was just starting to hit Wall Street and long before it was generally recognized how bad the the firestorm of financial hemorrhaging was so in our case we want
13:02a contract we got through all of our initial technical milestones and our first financial milestone and then when we had to go show the five hundred billion dollar private-sector matching check and nobody from Wall Street was willing to complete the deal we actually had 350 of the 500 million raised but it was an all-or-nothing proposition under the terms of our agreement NASA had the right to cancel the contract and they did so what's your point well the point is that commercial does work and in when we had a good reception to Wall Street for raising money for private sector servicing the government needs and that was on a much thinner market than is out
13:42there now you now have Bigelow Aerospace looking at 15 or 20 private launches per year for humans and cargo for private commercial space stations you have crew plus cargo and you have NASA having demonstrated that they dished out three billion dollars of commercial cargo launch services to SpaceX and to orbital sciences if we had had one of those contracts we wouldn't have any had any trouble raising the rest of our money but the way the cots program was originally structured they were not dishing out the Phase two routine launch services agreements until later and Wall Street in 2007 was conservative and they said well if you all right order book you'd be okay but
14:24we didn't so the system works let me ask you line Muscovy agrees the system working you on yeah I actually think this is like this is a sort of an example of of healthy government contracting it or mean or aspects of it at least in that for the net for the NASA cards cargo missions which has been worse basically a competition demonstrate the ability to take cargo to the space station and back NASA put out a competition there were two companies that won the initial bid Rocketplane Kistler and SpaceX and we've we both worked with NASA to come up with mutually agreed-upon milestones we were able to to meet those milestones it was very difficult but we're able to meet
15:06them a rockland Kista was not and that nasa then said okay if if oakland just kissed i can't make milestones then we need to cut them from the contract recompete the funds and awarded to a second company which is what they did and awarded the funds to orbital sciences I do agree that this there should have been a change to the way the program was structured in that it should have been if you succeed in completing these milestones and get to the end this should be essentially guaranteed business from the government so I think that that is something that should be changed in the future for how these contracts are done but overall I think it was an example of a fairly healthy
15:49process where it because usually what happens in these in these government procurements is that they really get they prolong a situation where success it's not one of the possible outcomes for far too long one eight hundred ninety nine eight to five five is our number we have just a few more minutes and I want to go through another few points of the president's speech he talked about a post Hubble telescope telescope is the Webb telescope what he's talking about her we're mentioning something else here anybody wanna chime you down there I think my story Webb I think he's talking about the web don't
16:28we have the web lined up that coming or is he got something else well he could be referring to interferon three missions which would give capability for gathering data from extrasolar planets but I assumed he was talking about the web yeah so I mean I that take a few years to design from scratch if he was talking about it's not something you can just put together overnight anything else surprising to gentlemen that the president left out or included well there was a rumor that he
17:01may try to extend the space shuttle program by a few flights there's been legislation introduced to try to do that but he was noticeably silent on that issue and how much of this do you think politically was was to try to help him sure above voters in Florida this speech I think a lot of it a lot of it is a political transformation that he's just seen the light and become interested in space exploration as part of a political process in Florida and this went back to the primary campaigns when he was responsive and people were finally getting to him and explaining what the issues were people like lori Garver and I think he was very receptive to that
17:39and how much will Congress try to shape this policy now because they control the purse strings are they gonna go along with this or we have a history we have a history of Congress following the president ever since John F Kennedy made his great pronouncement in 1961 that Congress tends to acquiesce and what the president says and since the president's now moving in a in a forward direction instead of a cutting direction they will probably shape the details but go along generally with the idea none of you look at this as a really radical departure it's a change but not but not a rat I think it's I think it's a radical change yeah I think it's a radical change from
18:18the constellation program yeah but frankly I think it's a retort returning to the core principles of the vision laid out in 2004 if you go back and read that document I think it right it shares a lot of that so it's a change from constellation but it's and their prayer and well the president said he wanted to get to Mars orbit I love the language I'm parsing the little words in the speech you wanted to get to Mars orbit but in his lifetime he didn't talk about when he wanted to land and bring people back landing on Mars is a very very technical problem to do a entry descent and landing in fact we've had several robotic probes that have not survived
18:56that for various reasons so the level of difficulty the problem of orbiting Mars as compared to landing on it is significant well I find that with the tremendous success and and reputation of all those Mars rovers that we didn't hear more about those kinds of robotic trips that might be in store and for singing i'm sending back wonderful pictures from other world there were few notations about robotic missions and then there is money in the program for expansion of those capabilities if you loo look at the Office of Science Technology Policy fact sheet which you can google it refers to the robotic missions but that was not the point of his speech yesterday his speech was was
19:35was a was cheerleading I think no it's more than cheerleading I think he laid out some sort of goals that were lacking in the original rollout of the budget you know what's amazing is that is that every president who was a senator or a congressman who has talked about cutting the space program when they get into office do not want to put their finger prints on the decision to close down the human spaceflight program and I think that's the transformation you saw with President Obama that once he's got the responsibility for the decision he moves in the forward direction so he saw he saw the light as you say before yeah I
20:09think what we really saw with the speech there was that Obama is sticking to his guns and he's taking to the fairly radical changes that he initiated in the budget that were submitted to Congress in February which was to actually cancel the constellation program to develop competitive commercial space transport and to develop the core technologies that are necessary to go to Mars and and and maybe even beyond one day I think it's I think it's by far the best space policy that that we've had since Apollo I mean that's that's my honest opinion at least as far as you know he was placed by this concerned it's the only one that I've seen that has a
20:53possibility of significant success alright gentlemen that's a good place to leave it I want to thank you all for taking time to be with us Neal on musk is the CEO of space explore raishin technologies corporation that's the SpaceX good luck eyes on your launch next month is it yep good luck bill Adkins is the president of the global think tank Adkins strategies in Washington former staff director of the House space and Aeronautics subcommittee thank you Bill Howard mccurdy professor of American University at Washington and a visiting professor of the Evans School of Public Affairs at the University of Washington in Seattle thank you all for taking time to be with us Thank You IRA
21:28thank you [Music] ergo and you have NASA having demonstrated that they dished out three billion dollars of commercial cargo launch services to SpaceX and to orbital sciences if we had had one of those contracts we wouldn't have any had any trouble raising the rest of our money but the way the cots program was originally structured they were not dishing out the Phase two routine launch services agreements until later and Wall Street in 2007 was conservative and they said well if you had all right an order book you'd be ok but we didn't so the system works let me ask you on Muscovy agree is the system working you on yeah actually this is like this is a sort of
22:15an example of of healthy government contracting it or mean aspects of it at least in that for the net for the NASA cots cargo missions which has been worse basically competition demonstrate the ability to take cargo to the space station and back net NASA put out a competition there were two companies that won the initial bid Rocketplane Kistler and SpaceX and we've we both worked with NASA to come up with mutually agreed upon milestones we were able to to meet those milestones it was very difficult but we were able to meet them a rockland Kista was not and at that NASA then said okay if if Oakland
22:57just kissed I can't make milestones then we need to cut them from the contract recompete the funds and awarded to a second company which is what they did and awarded the funds to overall Sciences I do agree that this there should have been a change to the way the program was structured in that it should have been if you succeed in completing these milestones and get to the end this should be essentially guaranteed business from the government so I think that that is something that should be changed in the future for how these contracts are done but overall I think it was an example of a fairly healthy process where it because usually what happens in these in these government
23:35procurements is that they really get they prolong a situation where success is not one of the possible outcomes for far too long one eight hundred ninety ninety two five five is our number we have just a few more minutes and I want to go through another few points of the President's speech he talked about a post Hubble telescope telescope is the Webb telescope what he's talking about her we're mentioning something else here anybody want to chime in on there I think my star lab I think he's talking about the web don't
24:11we have the web lined up and then that coming or is he got something else well he could be referring to interferometry missions which would give capability for gathering data from extrasolar planets but I assumed he was talking about the web yeah so I mean I that take a few years to design from scratch if he was talking about it's not something you can just put together overnight anything else surprising to you gentleman that the president left out or included well there was a rumor that he
24:44may try to extend the space shuttle program by a few flights there's been legislation introduced to try to do that but he was noticeably silent on that issue and how much of this do you think politically was was to try to help him sure above voters in Florida the speech I think a lot of it a lot of it is a political transformation that he's just seen the light and become interested in space exploration as part of a political process in Florida and this went back to the primary campaigns when he was responsive and people were finally getting to him and explaining what the issues were people like lori Garver and I think he was very receptive to that
25:22and how much will Congress try to shape this policy now because they control the purse strings are they gonna go along with this or we have a history we have a history of Congress following the president ever since John F Kennedy made his great pronouncement in 1961 that Congress tends to acquiesce and what the president's it's a science Friday from NPR I am Ira Flatow I am 100% committed to the mission of NASA and its future that was President Obama speaking yesterday at the Kennedy Space Center in Florida but we not sure exactly what is the future of NASA that's what we're gonna be talking about today President Obama laid out his plans for the agency yeah
26:02today and in a nutshell I guess you could say he's counting on private companies for short trips into low-earth orbit and is charging NASA with developing the technologies to go into deeper space like like Mars and beyond president also questioned why anybody would want to go back to the moon I understand the Sun believe that we should attempt a return to the surface of the Moon first as previously planned
26:27but I just have to say pretty bluntly here we've been there before been there done that the president seems to be saying so his vision calls for the cancellation of the Ares Rockets and the constellation program say goodbye to that return trip to the moon and while the president said he's 100% committed to the agency and calls it a transformative agency for NASA not everyone has characterized the president's plane that way Neil Armstrong the first person on the moon and some other astronauts have decried the plan as devastating Buzz Aldrin who followed Neil was not among them he backed the president's plan so what's your take what's in the stars for NASA
27:09is it the end of the glory days or is it a much-needed rebirth give us a call our number is 1-888-936-3264
27:56of space exploration technology Corp that space X a private commercial rocket company in Hawthorne California and the president toured space access launch complex and viewed the Falcon 9 rocket scheduled for its major as maiden voyage next month hello and welcome back to Science Friday we'll use prai's the president came out for a visit yeah it actually was surprising we only learnt about it the day before so it was certainly a great honor and yeah was that his way of saying this is this is the direction I want to go in do you think you know I can't speak for the president I don't know that the underlying reasoning but I think certainly it's a it's some level of
28:41support and endorsement I think Howard mccurdy is the president basically just saying that and near Earth orbit we're gonna go to private companies anything at all design around rockets well it was quite a transformational speech when you think back to a couple of years ago to when he was running for the presidency and there was a proposal leaked that's in which he suggested cutting five billion dollars out of the NASA budget and spending it on education which is why I think a lot of people including Neil Armstrong are fearful that this is wolf in sheep's clothing that it's really the end of the human spaceflight program so the people who wrote a speech
29:18yesterday try very hard to say no you know he's fully committed to the space program and has adopted as radical a strategy as President Kennedy adopted in 1961 when he decided to go to the moon and I'd be glad to explain that if you want me to well let me play a cut of that because when he talked about Mars he had almost an identical language to President Kennedy's speech by the mid 2030s I believe we can send humans to orbit Mars and return them safely what was left unsaid in his in President's speech was what about the military gentlemen I mean the military you know they're gonna fly their giant satellites on their own rockets are they gonna use
29:55commercial vehicles well you know the funny thing is they already do use commercial vehicles that there's a lot of confusion out there as to what's commercial and what's not commercial but Boeing and Lockheed have brought two families or rockets called the Atlas and Delta and they merged the business there's one that operates as one company called United Launch Alliance and they they are the ones that launch all of the Defense Department satellites as well as the NASA spacecraft missions like you know going to the interplanetary but Space Telescope's and the kind of thing so it it's in in one way it's
30:36that's less radical than people think because it's really taking the approach that NASA already uses for their satellite missions which is to buy commercial launch services and extending that to human spaceflight but Howard is are they going to continue to do that model and will the military still use these other rockets that were not mentioned yeah well I think I think that the model applies equally as well to the military and civil space what's happening here is a globalization of the of the launch industry it's sufficiently mature now that at least NASA can get out of the business of running an airline in the similar way that the u.s.
31:17cavalry got out of the business of delivering the mail in 1925 and spurred the development of the aviation industry the big risk in all of this is whether or not private industry with the incentives that competition provides can do for say three to six billion dollars what NASA was planning on doing for about thirty to thirty-five billion dollars developing the next generation of launch vehicles to get humans to and from low-earth orbit that's a big risk Cal do you agree yeah well I think there's a part of the problem and having a debate about this policy is it's a lot of it's a debate about labels about what is commercial and I like whenever
31:56anybody asked that to us so what does it mean to be government because I'm not sure that that that debate really serves a purpose I think the real question is is how will NASA implement this policy and the Devils in the details and there are lots of nuance so it's a one area of concern is if NASA as they've proposed
32:15is to put industry up to bid on fixed price contracts in this program is still at a beginning stages and and no one truly understands the requirements and the technical complexity of it and it's very difficult to put a fixed price on a complex development and there's a long history of problems in the Defense Department with fixed price complex contracts and I think the debate about commercial versus government is really the way to look at it and they really need look beyond that and exactly how does NASA plan to implement that program and does it balance the risks absolutely so you're waiting for the details to come out but Devils in the details the devil
32:54is always in the details and we don't have those details yet when we start to see them well I think the president the president did a good job of addressing the critics concerns about the overall goals of the program next week senator Mikulski's gonna have a hearing with administrator Bolden who I think will follow up with additional details and it will take some time for NASA to lay roll
33:18out those details and for members of the Congress to become comfortable with the plan but I think one of the problems again is it's it's a false dichotomy between programs that are driven by the government in a government is the prime contractor role versus we're just gonna outsource everything there's a lot of ground in the middle that that could work for the program all right we'll take a short break come back talk more with howard mccurdy bill Adkins Elon Musk and your calls one 899 8 to 5 5 hit Earth and landing on Mars we'll follow and I expect to be around to see it that returned them safely to earth is directly right out of the Kennedy
33:59speeches that's right in in April of 1961 President Kennedy wrote a memo to Lyndon Johnson and asked Johnson to research the space program and said how can we beat the Russians can we beat them in putting a human in space well no Yuri Gagarin had already done that can we beat them to put up a space station Johnson said no after consulting with some people in the space community can we beat them by flying around the moon Johnson said no the only way we can beat them is by landing on the moon by leapfrogging all these other things that can be done in space and going further and this is like a 3-point shot in a basketball game for Barack Obama he's
34:34leapfrogging the moon and other suggestions and going deeper into space which is what a lot of people had suggested in what constitutes the flexible path option in the Augustine report a bill that Ginn's do you agree I think the President had to address the the concerns of his critics that the new direction he proposed a couple months ago lacked overarching goals and destinations timeframe and so I think a key point of the speech was to lay out those those goals the destinations and the timeframes and I think he really did answer the critics well the he needs to
35:10balance the near term goals with a vision for the long-term and I think the program that he's proposed is a balance between investment and technology for the long haul and meeting the near term goals by engaging the commercial sector let's let's talk about some of those definite goals that he had made and and let's let's begin by talking about something that in another I don't think anybody had expected and that was going to an asteroid landing land landing an astronaut on an asteroid this is
35:43something that he laid out saying that that by 2025 we expect a new spacecraft designs along the new journey let's listen to him say it himself by 2025 we expect new spacecraft designed for long journeys to allow us to begin the first-ever crewed missions beyond the moon into deep space so we'll start we'll start by sending astronauts to an asteroid for the first time in history honey how do you why we do that bill well I think he's laying out a plan of increasingly complex goals and landing on an asteroid is a lot easier than landing on the moon because the the deep well the gravity of the moon and so it's an easier goal and asteroids themselves are interesting
36:29objects and are are in fact keys to the the origin of the of the solar system and and I think laying out achievable goals is a critical part of this plan and not to to set goals so high that they're unachievable and raised expectations too high so I think that was a an appropriate balance now you know on musk where do you fit in your company and private companies like yours we do you fit into the president's plan well we're actually pretty central when I say we I mean I'm private and private to the commercial space transport not just space X are are really central to the president's vision and strategy I think what what this new policy recognizes is that NASA isn't going to
37:13get some huge increase in its budget as occurred would be in the Apollo era so if we were to make great progress and make the next giant leap for mankind then it has to be done in an affordable manner and the only way to do that is by harnessing the power of free enterprise as we use in all other modes of transport so you're gonna be like a customer then NASA will hire people like you to go up and deuce near-earth orbital missions for them yeah they think of us like a space plane you know but I guess we upgrade the mission as well so I guess we're coming like an aircraft company and and there and an airline might well stay with us
37:57[Music] I'm Ira Flatow this is science Friday from NPR listening to Science Friday from NPR I am Ira Flatow we're talking this hour about President Obama's speech to NASA downtown the air in Florida one eight hundred nine eight nine eight two five five let's a get some calls and Ron in Manchester New Hampshire I run thanks for taking my call something that's been bothering me about this whole thing Obama retained the command module from
38:34the constellation program he told the booster that was supposed to take it into low-earth orbit I understand the whole thing using commercial vehicles to take into low-earth orbit but he also killed the program for getting heavy lift for getting us to Mars constellation was supposed to get us to Mars in everywhere else in putting a moon I can understand taking moon off of constellations itinerary but to cancel
39:01the heavy lift vehicle that's supposed to get us to Mars at the same time talking about that tally his goal let's see if I can get an answer because the President did say in his speech that he's going to invest more than three billion dollars to conduct research on an advanced heavy lift rocket bill what did that mean to you can you answer Ron's question well I think the President's speech I don't have in front of me but laid out to lock in a design I think in a 2015-2016 range for a heavy lift vehicle in the near term he intends to invest in R&D and frankly in one of the areas that the United States needs to invest in technology is in propulsion
39:41and large propulsion so I think there's a lot of benefit to that and I don't think he walked away from heavy lift did the president answer his critics who were worried about all the jobs that would be lost in the aerospace industry well he identified a program to create 10,000 jobs across the country and I don't think the stage where the
40:02space program is today I don't think there's a painless way out of the current dilemma there just simply aren't enough resources but I think having a program that is achievable and sustainable will create more jobs over the long run the space program if there ever was a program that's long term it's human space exploration Chuck flower in Lansing Michigan hi welcome to science Friday yeah hi first of all I'd like to point out that the commercial system even as it was before Obama and general Bolden took over the reins actually worked my company Rocketplane Kistler was the other cots one winner and in our case we had some pretty heavy-duty financial
40:46milestones that we had to meet and unfortunately we were going out into the marketplace in the middle of 2007 to go raise 500 million dollars essentially when the global financial meltdown was just starting to hit Wall Street and long before it was generally recognized how bad the the firestorm of financial hemorrhaging was so in our case we won a contract we got through all of our initial technical milestones and our first financial milestone and then when we had to go show the five hundred billion dollar private-sector matching check and nobody from Wall Street was willing to complete the deal we actually had 350 of the 500 million raised but it
41:28was an all-or-nothing proposition under the terms of our agreement NASA had the right to cancel the contract and they did so what's your point well the point is that commercial does work and in when we had a good reception to Wall Street for raising money for private sector servicing the government needs and that was on a much thinner market than is out there now you now have Bigelow Aerospace looking at 15 or 20 private launches per year for humans and cargo for private commercial space stations you have crew plus they could bind to that return trip to the moon and while the president said he's 100% committed to the agency and calls it a transformative agency for
42:08NASA not everyone has characterized the president's plan that way Neil Armstrong the first person on the moon and some other astronauts have decried the plan as devastating Buzz Aldrin who followed Neil was not among them he backed the president's plan so what's your take what's in the stars for NASA is it the end of the glory days or is it a much needed give us a call our number is
43:181-888-936-3264 when he talked about Mars he had almost an identical language to President Kennedy's speech by the mid 2030s I believe we can send humans to orbit Mars and return them safely to earth and landing on Mars will follow and I expect to be around to see it that returned them safely to earth is directly right out of the Kennedy speeches and that's what's right in in April tank Adkins strategies in Washington and former staff director of the House space and Aeronautics subcommittee welcome to Science Friday thank you I welcome you know a musk is the CEO of space exploration technology Corp that SpaceX a private commercial rocket company in
44:23Hawthorne California and the president toured SpaceX has launched complex and viewed the Falcon 9 rocket scheduled for its major as maiden voyage next month hello and welcome back to Science Friday were you surprised the president came out for a visit yeah it actually was surprising we only learnt about it the day before so it was certainly great honor yeah was that his way of saying this is this is the direction I want to go in do you think you know I can't speak for the president I don't know that the underlying reasoning but I think certainly it's a it's some level of
45:00support and endorsement I think Howard mccurdy is the president basically just saying that and near Earth orbit we're gonna go to private companies anything at all it's a science Friday from NPR I am Ira Flatow I am 100% committed to the mission of NASA and its future that was President Obama speaking yesterday at the Kennedy Space Center in Florida but we're not sure exactly what is the future of NASA that's what we're gonna be talking about today President Obama laid out his plans for the agency yesterday and in a nutshell I guess you could say he's counting on private companies for short trips into low-earth orbit and is charging NASA with
45:42developing the technologies to go into deeper space like like Mars and beyond president also questioned why anybody would want to go back to the moon I understand that some believe that we should attempt a return to the surface of the Moon first as previously planned but I just have to say pretty bluntly
46:04here we've been there before been there done that the president seems to be saying so his vision calls for the cancellation of the Ares Rockets and the constellation program 1961 President Kennedy wrote a memo to Lyndon Johnson and asked Johnson to research the space program and said how can we beat the Russians can we beat them in putting a human in space well no Yuri Gagarin had already done that can we beat them to put up a Space Station Johnson said no after consulting with some people in the space community can we beat them by flying around the moon Johnson said no the only way we can beat them is by landing on the moon by leapfrogging all these other things that
46:42can be done in space and going further and this is like a 3-point shot in a basketball game for Barack Obama he's leapfrogging the moon and other suggestions and going deeper into space which is what a lot of people had suggested in what constitutes the flexible path option in the Augustine report a bill that gains do you agree I think the president had to address the the concerns of his critics that the new direction he proposed a couple months ago lacked overarching goals and destinations in a time frame and so I think a key point of the speech was to lay out those those goals the destinations and the time frames the nations and the time frames the nations
47:22and the time frames the nation
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版