2012 年的一场对谈上,will.i.am 忽然说了一句话。
我七岁的侄女,二十年后长大,会比我的手机还笨。
现场有人笑了一声。他停了一下,接着说,我没在开玩笑。
那场活动的阵容搁今天看仍然有点奇怪。埃隆·马斯克(Elon Musk)坐在一边,他的火箭公司在洛杉矶,电动车公司却在硅谷,一周里一半时间在南加州,一半时间在北加州。will.i.am 坐在另一边,黑眼豆豆的成员,同时也是科技圈里少见的真爱好者。中间坐着福克斯影业的吉姆·吉安诺普洛斯(Jim Giannoulos),以及《富足》(Abundance)的作者彼得·戴曼迪斯(Peter Diamandis)。
主持人一开始想问的是个老题目:好莱坞和硅谷,到底谁启发了谁。
聊出来的东西比这个题目大得多。技术、艺术、教育、立法、火星,全都在里面。十四年之后重读,很多话听起来像一份提前写好的说明书。
技术只是那盏小红灯,亮着不代表有内容
主持人把第一个问题抛给吉姆:硅谷的创新,跟好莱坞到底什么关系?
吉姆的回答没绕弯子。技术是让好莱坞得以存在的工具,工具本身什么都不是,除非你往里面加创造力。
他打了个很好懂的比方。你打开电视,面板上一盏小红灯亮起来,屏幕上什么都没有。灯亮着,说明通上电了,说明设备正常,可它不代表任何内容。
他说这两件事是共生的。技术把艺术家的想象力推到他们能达到的极限,而且这个上限还在往上走。摄影机让格里菲斯能剪出交叉叙事,录音技术让爵士乐能灌进唱片,色彩让《绿野仙踪》从那扇门走出去变成彩色世界,数字特效让卡梅隆能造出一整颗潘多拉。每一次技术跃迁,艺术的表现半径就扩大一圈。
主持人追问得更具体:好莱坞到底做了什么,能激励创业者、发明家、科学家?他自己先提了《星际迷航》(Star Trek)。
吉姆说,那些孩子是看着电影长大的。看完就说,我要造那台机器,我要飞到那颗星球上去,我要那把射线枪。就是这些东西,让一大批人后来去做了科学家、工程师、探险者。
他提醒在场的人,那天会上被反复提到的复制机、通讯器,最初都只是好莱坞编剧脑子里的想法。编剧写下这些东西的时候,根本没考虑工程可行性,他们只是需要一个让剧情往前走的道具。几十年后,工程师把这些道具变成了产品说明书。
反过来也成立。那些写故事的人,不少是从真实世界出来的。詹姆斯·卡梅隆(James Cameron)出道时学的是物理,他后来拍《终结者》《异形 2》《阿凡达》,脑子里装的是真实的物理规则和工程逻辑。写作者把现实里的东西拿来,加上想象,编成故事,拍成电影,然后电影里的东西又变回现实。这个循环,就是那场活动名字里讲的“奇点”在文化层面的版本。
特斯拉那座塔本来想无线输电,副产品才是无线电
主持人跟 will.i.am 开了个不太礼貌的玩笑,说一提到娱乐圈的人,你不会觉得他们聪明。话一出口他自己也觉得不对,连着说了几声“等等”“打住”。
will.i.am 没生气,接过来讲了一段更有意思的。
他说,好莱坞和硅谷的区别,得先把“好莱坞”这个词的范围放大。好莱坞不只是电影,也是音乐。电影靠艺术和科学联姻:摄影机要能转起来,靠的是一堆物理和工程;剧本、导演、演员,靠的是艺术。两边缺一边,这东西就立不住。
然后他讲了尼古拉·特斯拉(Nikola Tesla)的沃登克里弗塔(Wardenclyffe Tower)。那座塔的本意是无线输电,让电能不通过电线就能传到远处,副产品才是无线电。特斯拉本人根本不在乎无线电,那对他来说是个意外。
可正是无线电,长出了音乐产业这个艺术形式。在有电台之前,人们也做音乐,只是目的不一样,场景不一样,传播范围也小得多。他提到早期广播电台的商业模式:它不靠卖硬件赚钱,它卖的是啤酒和酒吧的生意,那还是禁酒令和地下酒馆(speakeasy)的年代。电台把耳朵聚起来,然后把酒卖出去。
他把话头收回到硅谷:硅谷缺的,正是好莱坞已经完成的那场联姻。硅谷有技术,有算力,有工具,还没有跟艺术正式结婚。这场婚礼没办,所以没人知道会生出什么行业。
音乐是第一个社交网络。如果说你是我的缪斯,你就会启发我去创造。音乐就是会旅行的灵感。(will.i.am)
这个说法挺妙。社交网络的定义是让人和人连起来、让信息流动,音乐在无线电波里干的正是这件事,只是早了八十年。而且它比今天的社交网络更纯粹,它不收集数据,不推送广告,它只是把一个人的情绪送到另一个人的耳朵里,然后那个人自己做点什么。
手机已经比《星际迷航》某一集里的设备更强了
主持人问马斯克怎么看这个世界。他的身份确实特殊:一周大概一半时间在硅谷,一半时间在洛杉矶,火箭公司在南边,特斯拉在北边。主持人还加了一句,你还在太空里。
马斯克说,他主要在技术领域,但他毫不怀疑好莱坞和硅谷之间存在共生关系。科幻电影给人想法,让人知道未来可以造什么,也激励孩子走进科学。
主持人问他,你自己是被科幻激励的吗?
马斯克的回答很具体,没有泛泛而谈。他喜欢阿西莫夫(Isaac Asimov)的《基地》(Foundation)系列,喜欢海因莱因(Robert Heinlein)的《严厉的月亮》(The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress),当然还有《星际迷航》,那部剧大概所有人都看过。
这些东西给人的是一种“可能性”的感觉。你会想把那个可能性变成现实,而变成现实的过程极其艰难,中间会失败很多次,但时间长了,有些真的做成了。
他举了个所有人都能验证的例子:今天人手一部的手机,其实比《星际迷航》某一集里出现的设备还要先进。你口袋里装着一台超级计算机,它同时是通讯器、导航仪、摄像机、图书馆。当年编剧要靠想象力才能写出来的东西,现在被装在一个玻璃和金属的薄片里,卖几百美元。
紧接着他话锋一转:通信和计算的进步跑得飞快,太空旅行的进步没跟上。这两条曲线差得太远。五十年前人类登上月球,五十年后人类还得买俄罗斯的飞船票才能上国际空间站。这个反差本身就说明问题,而这是必须补上的一块。
主持人顺着问:那你会去做吗?
马斯克说,希望如此。SpaceX 的目标是把航天技术推进到某个点,让人类能在火星上建立自给自足的文明,让生命成为多行星的存在。
我认为这可能是人类有史以来能 undertaking 的最伟大的冒险。(埃隆·马斯克)
这里值得补一句背景。那场对谈发生在 2012 年,SpaceX 的龙飞船刚在那年五月完成了对接国际空间站的任务,成为第一家做到这件事的商业公司。同一时期,特斯拉的 Model S 刚开始交付。马斯克说“希望如此”的时候,他手上那两件事都还处在非常脆弱的阶段,任何一家公司出问题,这些话就只是空话。
技术刚满十二岁,正在进青春期
主持人让马斯克拿出水晶球,看看十年、二十年之后会发生什么。
will.i.am 抢了话头,先开玩笑说音乐要彻底完了,然后自己否认,说我没在开玩笑,又补了一句我确实在开玩笑。抖完这个包袱,他认真起来。
他的判断是:技术刚过十二岁,正进入青春期。它可以往任何一边走。它可能成为人类给自己造出来的奖品,让人看了说一句“哇,你看看这个”;它也可能成为毁灭。
而且它跑得太快,快到没有任何刹车机制。它是一个十亿美元级别的产业,不会慢下来,因为没有国会能拦住它。没有红州和蓝州在辩论要不要让芯片更快,他们不用操心这个问题,芯片就是会更快。它就这么一直往前走,一直往前走。
问题在于,他七岁的侄女没有跟着一起往前走。
他说,二十年后她长大,会比我的手机还笨。
这句话在会场里显得很刺,他讲得很平静。他说的是一种相对关系:机器的能力在指数上升,人的基础能力在原地,甚至因为外包给机器而在下降。两者之间的距离越拉越大,个人面对系统时的谈判位置就越来越弱。
他接着讲机场。所有人都飞过,所有人都经历过在安检口脱鞋、脱外套、解腰带,理由是国土安全。而运输安全管理局(TSA)并不具备识别真实威胁的能力,这一点圈内人心里有数,红队测试的通过率低得离谱。税照交,安全照买,队伍照排。
可我们的年轻人一点都不安全。因为他们要在明天的世界里长大,而他们竞争不过你们正在造的东西。(will.i.am)
他还提了一个很少有人问的问题。《星际迷航》里,进取号飞向星辰大海,但剧里从来不拍那些被留在地球上的人过得怎么样。那个戴 Visor 的角色乔迪·拉福吉(Geordi La Forge),他的妈妈可能还留在某个贫民区,镜头从来没给过她。
科技的叙事总是关于出发的人,不关于留下的人。所有关于未来的故事都在讲飞船、讲引擎、讲第一次接触,很少有故事讲那些买不起船票的人在原地怎么生活。
这也是他来这场活动的原因。他说得很直白:我在这儿,是为了回去告诉贫民区的那些孩子,这边在发生什么,让他们对科学、技术、工程、数学产生兴趣。如果没有人回去讲,这些孩子就不会知道有这个选项,他们会去做别的。
电影本身就是技术,好莱坞从来没怕过硅谷
主持人提到了特洛伊·卡特(Troy Carter)。卡特是音乐经纪人,捧出过 Lady Gaga,在圈子里分量很重。他说过一句评价马斯克的话,大意是他没见过这个级别的人能这么懂技术,还有这么清晰的愿景。
主持人把这话转述出来,说一个好莱坞的重量级人物在夸你,然后请马斯克谈谈他的技术愿景。
马斯克先没讲愿景,先把一个误解拆了。人们总觉得硅谷和好莱坞对立,偶尔确实有摩擦,但前提搞错了:电影本身就是技术。
他举了《雨果》(Hugo)这部电影。那部片子讲的就是电影最早期的技术史,一个钟表匠的孩子修好了一个机器人,背后是梅里爱(Georges Méliès)那个年代的拍摄技术。没有技术就没有电影。声音、色彩、特效、剪辑、洗印、发行,今天人们消费电影的所有方式,尤其是数字化之后,全都建立在技术之上。
每一次电影技术的进步,每一次人们能在新设备上以新方式看电影,背后都是硅谷在推。好莱坞对这件事是欢迎的。吉姆接过话,说得更狠:谁不欢迎,谁就是尼安德特人。
然后他主动提起了 SOPA,因为那被当成“摩擦”的典型样本。
SOPA 是《禁止网络盗版法案》(Stop Online Piracy Act)的缩写,2011 年底提出,2012 年初引发了互联网史上最大规模的一次抗议,维基百科黑屏一天,谷歌首页挂了黑条。
吉姆解释说,这个法案最初版本非常基础,目的是阻止坏人卖假货给不想买假货的人。
他举了两个例子。你以为自己买的是 Timberland 的鞋,结果买到的是鞋底会掉的那种。你以为买的是降压药,结果是安慰剂,而且卖你原价的八折,因为打四折的时候人会起疑。这些细节是他从提案的参议员那里亲耳听到的。法案一开始管的是互联网上有人被坑。
后来事情变味了。人们开始紧张:真的要开始监管互联网了吗?管的人会不会是一群根本不懂自己在干什么的糊涂人?这种担心被放大,一批本来不了解法案内容的人被点燃,形成了一场政治抗议的海啸,把准备投票的人吓住了。
吉姆提醒在场的人一个事实:这个法案在参议院司法委员会是全票通过的。全票通过意味着,那些议员不是一群想杀死互联网的恶人。
他还讲了个技术常识。互联网当初就是为了承受核打击而设计的,原始架构里没有中心节点,天生去中心化。好莱坞怎么可能摧毁一个为核战争准备的网络?这在技术上说不通。
在误解、措辞不当的过程中,事情失控了。现在它需要改革,需要找到合适的平衡。就这么简单。摩擦和战争是两回事,谁把它看成战争,谁就没看懂。(吉姆·吉安诺普洛斯)
这套解释今天听仍然有用。一个初衷不坏的基础法案,被误读,被放大,被政治化,最后谁都不满意。互联网立法几乎每次都走这个剧本,因为技术细节太复杂,公众只能用情绪判断,而情绪最容易被组织起来的一方引导。
只有几个人登上了月球,但全世界都去了
主持人抛了个玩笑式的问题:假设特斯拉成功了,SpaceX 也成功了,然后你收购了通用、克莱斯勒、福特,还接管了 NASA,下一步是什么?
马斯克很干脆:我们大概不会去买那些公司。
然后他讲了特斯拉在做的事。核心目标是加速交通向可持续能源的转型,这件事在多个层面上对世界都很重要。特斯拉要扮演催化剂的角色,一边造自己的车,一边把动力总成卖给别的厂商,奔驰和丰田都用过他们的系统。他的逻辑是:如果只靠一家公司慢慢替换全世界的车队,那要几十年;如果能逼着整个行业一起转,时间会缩短很多。
SpaceX 的目标更大也更远:火星定居,让生命成为多行星的。
但要实现这个,得先有运输工具。得有一艘能做行星际旅行的飞船。主持人开玩笑说,像企业号那样的?马斯克说,可能长得不完全一样,但功能上差不多。是时候了。
他讲了阿波罗登月为什么值得反复提。真正踏上月球表面的只有那么几个人,但实际上是全世界都去了。它激励的不只是美国人,是整颗行星上的孩子和成年人。那几年所有人都在看直播,所有人都在讨论同一件事。
那是那种让你庆幸自己身为人类的时刻。我觉得我们需要更多这样的事。(埃隆·马斯克)
这句话把太空探索的意义讲清楚了。它的回报从来不只包含技术副产品,也不只包含科学数据,它提供的是一个共同叙事。人类需要一个足够大的目标,才能暂时忘掉彼此的分歧,一起抬头看同一个方向。
三岁小孩摸着电视说,妈妈这个不管用
到了收尾环节,主持人让三个人各说一段。
吉姆讲的是创作者。技术让真正有想法的创作者能完整实现自己的构想,也让全世界的人用以前没有过的方式体验它。盗版是个必须解决的严重问题,围绕它的政治争议也得解决。这些之外,技术打开了很宽的地平线:一台十美元、一百美元的相机,就能让世界上任何一个人拍东西、做东西、把作品放到网上。
will.i.am 讲的那段,是整场对谈里最有画面感的。
他说,你想想创新是怎么发生的。有人想到把马尾巴绑在木棍上,蘸上颜料,就能画画了。颜料要能保存很久,这背后是化学和工艺。于是一幅画能留下来,成为经典。
然后是印刷术和乐谱。在印刷术之前,一个指挥家得有特权才能拿到乐谱,写出来给整个乐团演奏,他站在前面指挥。印刷机出现之后,出版业诞生了,乐谱可以复制,音乐可以流传到没有乐团的地方。
艺术和科学的每一次联姻,都锻造出一个新产业:绘画、出版、电影,还有为放电影而建的剧院和影院建筑。每次都是两拨本来不来往的人撞在一起,然后冒出一个之前不存在的东西。
但有一场联姻还没发生:写代码的人和搞艺术的梦想家。
App 才出现几年?时间短得不像话,可它已经是现象级的了。硅谷那些天才做的事情,还没有跟艺术正式结合。没人知道那会锻造出什么行业,也没人知道那会从哪些人的脑子里长出来。
你想想三岁小孩,他摸着电视屏幕,说妈妈这个不管用。他以为所有屏幕都能摸。iPad 才出来几天?想想它已经把人的心智改成了什么样。我们三岁的时候,不会去摸杂志然后希望图片动起来。(will.i.am)
他说,等他六十岁,他会跟孙子讲:我记得窗户就只是窗户,我们以前是从窗户往外看的。
窗户以后会是什么,取决于这个时代的艺术和科学怎么结婚。它可能是一整面能对话的墙,可能是一层能叠加信息的玻璃,可能是某种还没有名字的东西。这取决于谁先想到,谁先做出来。
最后他把话题绕回贫民区。他说自己之所以对梦想家这么执着,是因为所有的梦想都来自贫民区。那是逃离噩梦的唯一办法。
你没法从噩梦里醒来,你只会睡进下一个噩梦。你得靠做梦逃出去。(will.i.am)
这段话讲的是心理机制。人在资源极度匮乏的环境里,唯一能自由支配的是想象力。先想到一个不在这里的地方,才可能真的走过去。如果连想都不敢想,那就真的没有出口。
他有一个梦想,然后梦想怎么实现,然后梦想出障碍,再解决障碍
主持人念了一句书里的观点,来自彼得·戴曼迪斯的《富足》。will.i.am 接过去说,迪恩·卡门(Dean Kamen)、马斯克,是这个时代的英雄。
他马上补了一句:如果你读了《富足》,你会明白你也能成为这个时代的英雄。以前只有政府和富人能做那样的项目,现在一个小团队、一台电脑、一个开源社区,就能做出十年前需要国家级资源才能做的事。
主持人笑着打断,说别把他当成一个富人看。
他是个梦想家。他有一个梦想,然后他梦想怎么把这个梦想变成现实,然后他梦想出障碍,再把障碍解决掉。你不能只有一个梦想,你得有四个梦想。(will.i.am)
这段话把创业这件事讲得比大多数商学院案例都清楚。一个想法不值钱,值钱的是后面那三层:路径、障碍、解法。大部分人停在第一层,少数人走到第二层,能预判障碍并同时准备好解法的,才会真的做出东西。
我们太习惯盯着坏消息了
马斯克最后那段话,语气比前面都轻。
他说他想强调彼得一开始讲的那个点,就是《富足》这本书里的。人有时候太陷在世界的负面里了。他承认负面是真实存在的,也不认为该无视它或者因此自满,但他希望人们同时承认一件事:生活其实挺好的。
如果我们对现在拥有的东西、对事情现在的状态都没法感到高兴,那我们就永远不会高兴了。现在这样已经相当不错了。(埃隆·马斯克)
他说人应该总体上更积极一点,因为那才是底层的现实。新闻的逻辑是报道异常,正常的、顺利的、每天在运转的东西不会上头条,所以人从媒体里获得的印象会系统性地偏离实际。只按新闻判断世界,会觉得一切都在崩坏;按数据看,大部分指标在变好。
他说 21 世纪会看到很多让人兴奋的事。交通会转型,能源生产会转型。他希望看到火星上有一个基地,那是他最终的梦想。如果 SpaceX 能把运输这一段打通,就会给所有愿意过去、在另一颗行星上创造东西的人打开巨大的机会。
他拿联合太平洋铁路(Union Pacific)举例。当年铁路修到加州,人们说加州根本没人,我们去那儿干什么。现在再看。
will.i.am 在这时候插了一嘴,讲了个反面教材。洛杉矶到现在都没有像样的地铁,原因是当年有一批政治力量想卖更多的车,一辆接一辆,结果把整座城市的交通系统搞坏了。所以不能盲目乐观,不能不看清楚潜力会走向哪里,否则就会变成洛杉矶这样:开发最糟、堵车最狠。
这个提醒放在最后挺合适。技术乐观主义如果不带一点对次生后果的警觉,很容易造出一座以高速公路为中心、没有公共交通的城市。当年那些决策者大概也觉得自己在做好事,让每个家庭都开上车,多自由。
这场 2012 年的对话,今天读起来像一份迟到的说明书
十四年过去,回头看这场对谈,很多话都挺准。
will.i.am 说技术刚满十二岁正进青春期。今天它大概二十多岁,副作用全部显形了:社交媒体的成瘾设计、算法推荐的信息茧房、儿童屏幕时间、自动化对就业的挤压。他当年担心的“年轻人竞争不过机器”,在生成式 AI 出现之后变成了一个具体得多的问题,提问的人从音乐人变成了老师和家长。
马斯克说通信和计算的进步远超太空旅行。今天这个差距还在,但可回收火箭把发射成本压下来了一个数量级,星舰在做轨道测试。他当年说“希望如此”的那件事,正在被一步步逼近,虽然时间表一再推迟。
吉姆讲 SOPA 的那段,几乎可以原样套用在后来每一次互联网立法争议上。一个初衷不坏的基础法案,被误读,被放大,被政治化,最后谁都不满意。这个剧本后来重演了很多次,从版权到隐私到人工智能,结构完全一样。
will.i.am 讲的那件事,可能是最没有被解决的:搞代码的人和搞艺术的梦想家,还没正式结婚。今天的 AI 产品里能看出一点苗头,工具开始理解自然语言,开始能生成图像和音乐,离“锻造出一个新产业”还远。App 已经快二十年了,下一代范式还没定形。
这场对话真正有价值的地方,是它没有把技术和人文当成两个阵营。两个人都同意一件事:技术没有创造力,就只是那盏亮着的小红灯。
下面几条,是对读者真正有用的行动建议。
- 判断一个技术项目值不值得投入,先问一句:它有没有“艺术”那一半。工具做得再好,没有内容和使用场景,就是那盏小红灯。
- 如果你在技术行业,主动去找一个完全不同领域的人认真聊两次。will.i.am 说的那场“联姻”,历史上每一次都发生在这种跨界的偶然相遇里,不会发生在同一栋楼里。
- 把“四个梦想”当成一个自检清单:我有了想法吗?我有把它变成现实的路径吗?我预判到最大的障碍了吗?我准备好解决它的方案了吗?四个都打勾,再动手。
- 面对一项新技术,先问它会把谁留在原地。这是 will.i.am 在那场对谈里提的最尖锐的问题,也是今天做产品、做政策、做教育的人最容易跳过的一步。
- 读一读《富足》,尤其在你觉得“这事只有大公司和政府能做”的时候。2012 年那本书里的判断,在今天被 AI 和开源工具验证得比当时更彻底。
- 给自己留一点“整体上更积极”的空间。马斯克那句话可以当成一个工程判断:如果对现状永远不满意,你会在下一个项目里重复同一种不满足。承认现在还不错,是继续往前走的条件。
0:00When you think innovation, you think Silicon Valley. Tell me about it, Jim. Avatar. Well, what about Avatar? Well, that's, you know, I think when people look at innovation, I think technology is an enabling tool that has made all of Hollywood possible. But, I don't think anything of technology means anything unless you add creativity. Ultimately, it's a little red light that goes on when you turn on your TV and there's nothing on. So, unless you add the creativity of great artists, including Will, those two things are symbiotic.
0:38Those two things really go together. And what technology has done is it's enabled the vision and the creativity of artists to reach their maximum potential and it continues to do that. But tell me what Silicon Valley sorry tell me what Hollywood has done to motivate entrepreneurs, motivate innovators, motivate scientists because we talked about Star Trek earlier. Yeah. Because I was inspired by the reason why I was so interested in science fiction was because of Star Trek. Well, they watch the movies.
1:06You know that's ultimately those are the you know those kids grew up watching those movies and saying I want to invent that machine. I want to fly to that planet. I want to kill those aliens. I want that ray gun. Ultimately, that's what inspired a lot of people to be scientists, to be engineers, to want to explore. What I was trying to bring out was that the replicators we heard about today, the communicators, you know, the you know, all these great technologies, they all started with ideas from Hollywood. You've challenged us in Silicon Valley to think bigger.
1:41Well, once again, it is symbiotic because, you know, people look at those things and they say, "I want to invent them." in the the people who create those things, writers, filmmakers, you know, Jim Cameron started out as a physicist, you know, so those things aren't created, you know, those things come from the real world and then they're embellished and they're created and they're drawn from great science fiction writers. They're drawn from the real world and then they're, you know, they're made into wonderful stories and wonderful science fiction and wonderful iterations that become movies and then they become the real world, which is a lot what Singularity
2:22is about. Well, when you think entertainers, you don't think smart. But I tell you, both times I met you, I've been blown away. Wait, whoa, whoa, whoa. Wait a minute. Okay. All right. Let's just take a beat. All right. All right. I know I was going to take a whack for that. But respond to me. what do you what do you want me to respond to? No. All right. No, no, no. Tell me what you think about u Hollywood's role in u in u innovation. Well, when you think of I was teasing about the smart thing. I mean, that's cool. That's cool.
2:56if you think of Hollywood versus Silicon Valley, and not just Hollywood with movies, but Hollywood is music as well. What you had was a marriage of art and science. the science it took to make that camera work and the art for the scripts and the directors and the actors and actresses to play those roles or Nicola
3:26Tesla's you know his warden tower which was meant to broadcast electricity and the byproduct was you know radio. He didn't care about radio, but from radio came a wonderful art form of music. They were they were doing music before radio. It just was different, different purpose. And it didn't sell hardware. It sold beer and bars. And when when it was illegal to have alcohol and speak easys.
3:56So what you're missing in the Silicon Valley that Hollywood has, and you compare, you dare to compare them is that Silicon Valley doesn't have its art marriage yet. But music, right? Music and you could use music and epidemic because they spread. So music is a spreading of inspiration. If you were my muse, you would inspire me to create. and all the art that I make will live in a museum. And if you made me laugh, you would be a musing. It's just inspiration. And so in music is inspiration traveling. So what the Silicon Valley has done is been has been able to allow you to take your thoughts and travel them around the world to to bring people
4:42together. Music was the first social network. So that's what you're missing there. Very interesting. Very very interesting. Absolutely right. Elon, what what's your view of the world? I mean, you have a foot both in Hollywood and Silicon Valley somehow. I don't know how you do it. And in space, right?
5:00well, I I'm really I mean primarily in in in technology. I spent about half the week in Silicon Valley, about half the week in LA, but Rocket Company's down here. Tesla's primarily up there. So but you know, I think I think there's no question that there's symbiosis between Hollywood and and Silicon Valley and technology.
5:19You know, it the the things that one see season science fiction movies give you ideas for what you want to try to create in the future. and they inspire kids to to go into the Were you inspire Were you inspired by science fiction? I mean, we're looking at what you Absolutely. I I was definitely inspired by science fiction. you know, both books and and movies. I really loved Azimar's Foundation series, you know, Heinland's The Moon is the Harsh Mistress. and, and of course I I watched Star Trek, which is, I think everyone watched that. so, it it really sort of
5:53it creates this this sense of possibility that you want to make real. and that's and then making it real is you know a very difficult process but but over time we've been able to do that. If you look at the the cell phones that we take for granted today I mean they're they're actually way more advanced than what you'd see in a Star Trek episode. you basically got a super computer in your pocket.
6:18It's incredible. Yeah, absolutely. and you know we need to do a a few other things like our advancements in space travel have not matched advancements in communications and computing and that kind of thing. And so that's something that we need to do. So we need to are you going to do it? Yeah.
6:33I mean that's that the aspiration is well I hope so. I mean the aspiration of SpaceX is to drive forward space technology to the point where we can have a self-sustaining civilization on Mars to make life multilanetary. Right. which I think would be the greatest adventure that humanity could ever undertake. Absolutely. absolutely.
6:51Well, I want to before I ask Jim, I want to ask you where do you think technology is headed? Take out your crystal ball. A decade from now, two decades from now, what do you see happening? music is going to be over completely. No, no, I'm joking. no, I'm not. Yeah. So, so technology, you know, we we use the word, you know, the concept of Star Trek. but no one ever thinks about the people that Star Trek left behind in the ghettos because they never talk about those things. Like, what was it life like for the people that Star Trek left? They were off living this great space life.
7:34But the people in the ghetto, golly, they never even put a perspective on homeboy's family with a little visor. You know, his mom's in a ghetto somewhere. I'm just saying. So, so technology, we're we're we're at the we're just fresh out of 12 years old and it's in its teens right now. And it can either it could go either way, right? It can be the prize for humanity, the thing that we created, like, whoa, check this out. Or it could be the doom. and as fast as technology is growing, it's a billion dollar industry and it's not slowing down because there's no Congress to stop it. There's no red state or blue state figuring out if we're going to make the chip even
8:28faster. They don't have to worry about that. We're going to make the chip faster. It's just going and it's going and it's going. But the same isn't for my little seven-year-old niece. It's not going for her. She's going to grow up 20 years from now dumber than my phone. That's funny. It's a real concern. Real concern. But it's so scary. Meanwhile, those who fly commercial go to the airport and we take off all our clothes in the name of homeland security knowing that the TSA is not qualified for a real threat. But I'm going put my tax dollars in the concept of safety. But our youth
9:07are not safe at all because they're going to grow up in the world tomorrow and they can't compete with what you're building. It's real. Sorry. No, it's not sorry. It's just the reality that we all have. Who the developers, right? Are we just I'm excited about technology, but the reason why I'm here is so I could go back to the ghetto and tell these kids what's going on over here. So they could take an interest over here so they could want to be scientists and technicians and engineers and mathematicians. Will I tweeted earlier on that you've challenged you've challenged Singar University and challenged me to think bigger because we have to get to the
9:41ghettos. We have to help those people. So your message heard loud and clear. Now let me you know earlier today Troy Carter who something on I hold in amazingly high regard made a comment about you. He says you know the I was blown away with how much Jim Giannopoulos gets it. He says, "I haven't met someone at his level who really understands technology and his vision like you do." That was nice.
10:03Yeah. And I I was blown away. This this is a Hollywood, you know, player basically talking so highly about you. Tell me, what's your vision of technology? Where do you see things headed in the next 10 years? Well, you know, to start with, I think go back to your earlier comment about, you know, the Silicon Valley and Hollywood. I think people assume antagonism where there is occasionally friction because film is technology. You know, if you saw Hugo from its earliest days, film is technology. Film wouldn't exist without technology. The advances in film, sound, color, every special effects, every aspect of film, the distribution of film, all the ways we enjoy film today
10:42and especially in digital form couldn't exist without technology and every advance in technology in film. and the ability for people to enjoy it on various devices in various ways couldn't exist without the advances in technology and most of those are coming from Silicon Valley and Hollywood embraces and implauds them and anybody who doesn't is a Neanderthal so I I you know I don't get this idea that Hollywood is afraid of Silicon Valley company soap so we'll get to silic to soapa because that was an example of friction and the friction came from a real misunderstanding of intentions and and meaning. You know, SOAPA started out as a very basic bill which was intended to
11:26stop bad guys from selling things to people that they didn't intend to buy. That's really what it was. It included things like you thought you were buying Timberland shoes and you were buying things where the soul would fall off. you thought you were buying blood pressure medicine and you were buying, you know, a placebo that they sold you at 80% of the cost because when they sold it at 40% of the cost, people got suspicious. This I heard from the the the the senator who who sponsored the bill. So, you know, it wasn't just about Hollywood, it was about people being cheated on the internet. And then what happened was people got a little nervous
12:04about oh wait people are actually going to regulate the internet and maybe the people regulating it will be dopey people who are not sure about what they're doing and that's bad. So they lit up a lot of people who weren't sure about the meaning of the bill and that caused a tsunami of concern that turned into a political protest that scared the heck out of a lot of people who were about to vote for it. That's a good perspective. That's what happened. It's really simple because it doesn't come out of the Senate Judiciary Committee unanimously because they are a bunch of evil people trying to kill everybody on the internet. And the people who said
12:47here's Hollywood, this is going to destroy the internet. The internet, as most of these people here will tell you, was created to withstand nuclear attack. So how Hollywood was going to destroy the internet was, you know, was beyond my understanding. I hope I hope that our friends will report on it. So, but but in the process of misconception and perhaps badly wording or whatever, things got out of hand and now it has to be reformed and now it has to find its proper balance. It's that simple. That's friction. That's not a war of Hollywood and Silicon Valley. And anyone who sees it that way doesn't understand it. Absolutely. Elon, let's say you succeed with Tesla, which I hope
13:30you do, and with SpaceX. Now, you bought General Motors, you bought Chrysler, you bought Ford, and you've taken over NASA. What's next? I'm looking a decade forward. I'm I'm pretty sure we won't be we won't be buying those companies. well, maybe I just say a little bit about, you know, technology and why why I think it's cool. you know, the why I got into it is because, I want to know what's next. I don't want to look back. I want to look back. Okay. I mean, yeah, but Well, I You think you
14:05think bigger than anyone else does? Okay. I mean, I think there's Well, the thing that we're most focused on at at Tesla is accelerating the transition to sustainable transport, which I think is extremely important for the world on many levels, right? and serving as a catalyst both in the cars that we make ourselves as well as the cars we help others make. So we you know we do power trains for Mercedes and and Toyota and that kind of thing. So and then at SpaceX the the overarching goal of SpaceX is the settlement of Mars to make life multilanetary which I think is you know will be one of the I think probably the greatest adventure that humanity
14:36ever undertakes and and create a an enormous opportunity on the surface of Mars. But we need to be have a transport mechanism that's capable of getting there. The SSS Enterprise well something like that. I mean, might not look quite like that, but it's it's, you know, we need a we need a spaceship that can can do interplan interplanetary travel. It's about time, right? and and I think that's something that that would actually inspire people all around the world because if you think of say the the Apollo moon landings, I mean, it was only a handful of people that went to the surface of the moon, but but actually we we all went there. I mean, the whole world went there. I
15:09mean, that inspired kids, people, the whole planet, right? and you know, it it's one of those things that made you glad to be a human being. Absolutely. So, we I think we want more of that stuff, right? Rob, are we out of time or do we have Tell you what, let's do concluding thoughts. Whatever you want to say to the audience about the future of technology or Hollywood, go for it, James. You start. Well, I guess I think the future of technology reflected here is that technology enables really great creators to truly realize their vision and for people all over the world to experience it in ways that they haven't before. And that's just looking at it from the Hollywood
15:54perspective and the incidental as I call it friction that's that exists today whether it's piracy which is a real serious issue and has to be resolved or the the political issues that that that are attended to it need to be resolved but it really does provide a great horizon for not just Hollywood but anyone holding a $10 $100
16:21$ whatever camera to be able to capture and create and I think that's a wonderful opportunity for for people all over the world. Well, you've inspired us. What more do you want to say? Well, if you think of the the innovation when they thought to put a horse's tail on a wooded stick and make paint that inspired painters to paint and the technology it took for paint to last a long time and you have a a classic painting for time and then from that point on, you know, the technology of print and sheet music because If you were a an a conductor, you were privileged to have sheet music to write it out for a whole orchestra to play and you as you conduct it. But then
17:12when the the printing press came along, it created our publishing industry. So it was the marriage of art and science and the you know the marriage of art and science that created the m movie industry and the architects that made the theaters and the basilas. So, we haven't seen the marriage of code writers and dreamers in the arts because it's a it's it's an art of its own applications. Look at what apps did in the past. How many years? It ain't even been that long. Apps, it's absolutely phenomenal.
17:47But when it comes to the Silicon Valley and these geniuses that you know that are doing incredible things, that marriage is the one we haven't seen yet. We don't know what industry it's going to forge. We don't know the minds and of from these 5-year-olds, these three-year-olds that are touching televisions like this doesn't work, mommy. They're touching a television like it's an iPad. An iPad's not even old. Just think of how it's changed the human mind from when we were three. We didn't touch a magazine and want the pictures to move. So that simple thing of what it's done to the human mind of how you see a window. I'm we're going to say when I'm
18:2960 years old, I'm going to tell my little grandson, I remember what window was just a window. We used to look out the window. You never know what a window is going to be until you marry art and science for this era. And that's the reason why I'm so passionate about the dreamers. All the dreams came from the people in the ghetto because that's the only reason that's the only way to escape a nightmare is to dream out of it. You don't wake up from a nightmare.
18:54You're just going to go back to sleep in another nightmare. We hit him on our faculty. You dream out of it. Can you make it happen? Elon, your thoughts. Well, that was just very touching. Amazing. I mean, I'm blown away. But it's going to happen regardless, you know. Maybe it's maybe it's, you know, Singularity University.
19:15Maybe it's NASA. Maybe it's it's probably going to be Elon Musk cuz people like me, I waited in line for my Tesla. I I got the new one coming. It can get you bumped up. Thank you. No, no. Honestly, by the way, these these guys, the Dean Cayman's, the Elon Musk, these are the heroes of of this era. But if you read abundance, no, no, no. If you read abundance, you realize that you can be the hero of this era as well.
19:39this anyone can now do what previously only governments and and rich people like him could do. No, no, no. You can't you can't look at it that we can't. Hey, I'm supposed to be the shallow one. You can't look at him as a rich person. He's a dreamer that's a that was able to have four dreams. He had one dream, then he dreamt how to turn that dream into reality, and he dreamt around his and he dreamt up his own obstacle to fix the obstacle. You can't just have one dream. You have to have four dreams.
20:07And he did it. And that's the reason why I'm sitting here talking with a guy from Tesla. All right, you get the last word, my friend. I love you, Will. Final words. well, I you know, I think I' I'd really just like to emphasize what what Peter was saying at at the beginning, which is, you know, on his book Abundance. And, you know, I think we get sometimes too wrapped up in the negativity of the world. And it's not like we should ignore the negativity or or get complacent or anything, but I think we should also recognize that life is pretty good, you know, and if if we can't be pretty happy with the way things with what we have and and and where things are, well, I mean, then
20:49we'll never be happy, you know. This this is pretty great. so, I think people should just, you know, generally have a a more positive attitude because that's the underlying reality. yeah and and and I think I think in in the 21st century we'll see lots of lots of exciting things happen. and you know I think we'll see the transformation of transportation and energy production. we'll hopefully see a base on Mars. I mean that's that's a sort of I guess my ultimate dream. and you know if if if if
21:26SpaceX can help help make that transportation happen then I think we would enable enormous opportunities for anyone who who is able to go over there and create things on another planet just like you know when you had the Union Pacific come to California and people initially said well there's no one in California what are we going to do and now look you know we got we're on this movie studio lot you have to be very careful there was a lot of politics that involved the reason why we still don't have a freaking subway is because they wanted to have more cars and cars and cars and cars and messed up our whole transportation in a way. So, you have to
21:57have some type of like you can't be too gleely like you ain't really paying attention to what the potential is going to be cuz you could be like Cal LA which is like the worst developed city where the traffic is horrible. I want to thank three amazing people for their time. This was just an amazing I wish we could talk for two more hours but but we can't. Thank you.
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版