股东会·中文精读

马斯克参与特斯拉 Q3 2011 财报电话会(音频)

Elon Musk participates in Tesla Q3 2011 Earnings call 2011 (AUDIO)

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2011年10月,特斯拉开了一场财报电话会。那时候 Model S 还没交付一辆,公司靠美国能源部的贷款过日子,Roadster 一年卖不了几千台。华尔街分析师打电话进来,问的问题都很实在:车到底能不能造出来,供应商靠不靠谱,钱还够不够烧。

马斯克开场只说了一句话:财报你们都看过了,我就不念了,直接提问吧。

这场会里最有分量的一句话出现在中段。有分析师问 Model S 发布前还有什么没做完,马斯克说,工厂设备九成到位,没觉得有哪个单点特别危险。然后他补了一句:如果我们的标准低一点,其实可以比 7 月更早交车。但我们想让客户从拿到车的第一刻起就有好印象,所以不想赶。

2011 年的特斯拉没有资格谈"完美"。但它偏偏在最缺钱的时候选择了慢。这个选择背后的逻辑,比后来那些漂亮的销量数字更值得看。

九成设备到位,剩下的一成才是麻烦

分析师 Dan Galves 问得很直接:Model S 发布前还剩什么,供应商表现怎么样,有没有担心工具到不了位。

马斯克的回答有个很有意思的开场白。他说,我们喜欢说"进展非常顺利",因为万一出了岔子,这句话就显得很尴尬。这种自我拆台的幽默在财报会上不常见,但接下来他说的话很实在。

弗里蒙特工厂的工装设备,九成已经就位。他找不出任何一个可以点名的高风险项。真正让他警惕的是一堆琐碎的小事,没有哪一件能单独拎出来当靶子。

他的应对方式是准备一支机动队,而非逐项排查。

我们在工程和制造端有一支特种部队,任何具体问题一冒出来,他们就扑上去解决。问题是我们现在还不知道那个问题是什么。(马斯克)

这个思路值得琢磨。传统制造业的做法是把风险清单列全,逐条打勾。马斯克承认清单列不全,所以把资源押在"响应速度"上。你没法预测哪块会坏,但你可以保证坏了之后有人能立刻修。

后面有位分析师追问,那剩下的 10% 到底是什么。马斯克说,是车门、引擎盖、后备箱这些闭合件的装配设备,正在到货,一两个月内齐。再往后是车身面板的冲压模具,由富士的合作伙伴在做。

COO 帕卡补充了一个容易被忽略的细节:大量设备其实还在供应商的厂房里调试。供应商把整条闭合件生产线搭好、跑通、验收合格,才发到特斯拉。这样到了弗里蒙特,理论上只需要调"模块和模块之间的衔接",不用从零调整条线。

这是把风险前移的做法。在别人家的厂房里犯错,比在自己的总装线上犯错便宜得多。

跟松下的合同,藏着一个退出的口子

摩根士丹利的 Adam Jonas 问的是电池。特斯拉跟松下签了长期供应协议,价格锁定了,但分析师想知道两件事:成本是不是比预想的好,以及万一有更便宜的供应商,能不能跑。

马斯克的回答分两层。

第一层是好消息。松下给了四年固定价格,可预测性很强。而且特斯拉没有义务买满协议里的全部电芯。协议规模大约 8 万块电池,而特斯拉预计未来四年的产量会远超这个数字。

第二层是那个"口子"。如果松下变得没有竞争力,特斯拉可以退出,罚款"相当小"。

但马斯克紧接着补了一句,说他们确信松下在电芯制造上会领先很久,特斯拉对其它厂商的进展也看得清楚,"我们找到了世界上最好的电芯伙伴"。

这里有个商业上的微妙平衡。签长约锁价格,是为了给资本市场一个确定性;留退出条款,是为了不把自己焊死在一个供应商身上。8 万块的采购量相对四年产能来说是保守的,等于主动给第二供应商留了位置。马斯克自己也承认,这个协议"肯定给第二来源留了空间"。

后来有人问,这个合同只覆盖 Model S 吗。马斯克说,特斯拉计划用通用的电池单元,所以凡是使用这种电芯的车型都适用,不止 Model S,但也不是全部车型。

先卖贵的,像新 CPU 上市那样

Dan Galves 还问了一个很实际的问题:什么时候让预订用户开始选配置,产能能不能应付各种配置组合。

马斯克的回答透露了特斯拉早期的定价哲学。他们正在琢磨怎么给各种选装定价,要在"客户觉得值"和"毛利率"之间找一个舒服的中间点。方案预计当年 12 月公布。

更要紧的是产能策略。投产的前几个月,特斯拉会刻意限制配置组合。

具体做法是:前五个月左右,不提供 160 英里续航版本,只卖 300 英里和 230 英里两个版本。另外还有几项选装是强制的。

马斯克给了一个类比,很马斯克风格:

就像一款新 CPU 刚上市,初期很贵,随着产量上来价格再往下走。所以我们一开始坚持让客户买高配车。(马斯克)

这个逻辑说得通。总装线上同时跑的变体越少,出错概率越低,节拍越快。用高配筛选出愿意付溢价的早期用户,既提高单车毛利,又减少生产变量。等产线跑顺了,再放开低配。

他后面那句话需要单独拎出来看:"我们会根据早期需求来调整,但前几个月就是这么定的。"这是一段有明确期限的过渡安排,不会永久执行。

1150 台预订,一分钱广告没花

JP 摩根的分析师问 Model S 的预订节奏,说看起来每月 300 到 350 台,会不会非线性增长。

马斯克先纠正了数字。Q3 的 Model S 预订是 1150 台,折算下来每月 350 到 400 台,Q2 是 1000 台出头。增长是实打实的。

然后他说了一句在当时应该挺扎人的话:我们没花一分钱广告。

增长来自三处:媒体报道、门店、以及销售团队的转向。北美销售团队原本卖 Roadster,这时候已经把重心完全挪到 Model S 上。

他还专门提醒了一件事,语气挺认真。如果预订继续加速,想买车的人最好早点交定金,否则可能要到 2014 年才能提车。

有些人以为 Model S 跟别的车一样,停车场里停一堆,走进去就能开走。不是这样的,早就排满了。(马斯克)

这话听着像营销话术,但放在 2011 年的语境里,它其实是在管理预期。特斯拉当时最大的风险之一是:客户下了单,等太久,退款走人。提前说清楚排期,反而能筛掉一批不坚定的订单。

买车不该像去看牙医

Robert W. Baird 的分析师问零售策略,年底大概 20 到 25 家门店,预订是从门店来的还是网上来的,每家店的考核指标是什么。

马斯克的回答是,大部分预订来自门店,尤其是客流量大的那些。早期数据还不足以定出单店指标,但进店人数"多得惊人"。哪怕当场不买,也是在客户心里种了颗种子,可能几年后买 Model S、Model X,或者第三代车型。

接着他讲了一段关于汽车零售的观察,这场电话会里最像"人话"的部分。

大多数人买车的体验都不太好,有些人把它当成去看牙医。我们想走到完全相反的那一面,让你被磁力吸进特斯拉门店,觉得那地方待着舒服。(马斯克)

他特意强调,店里的人头衔是产品专家,不设销售岗。他们的工作是解释 Model S 和电动车的一切,不是逼单。

然后他顺口提了一句:我们还卖衣服,特斯拉服装生意相当不错,是个意外的收入来源。

这句看似闲笔,其实说明门店的定位不在传统 4S 店的框架里,它是品牌空间。服装能卖动,说明进店的人愿意停留,愿意认同这个牌子。对一家还没交车的公司,这种认同比订单更稀缺。

后面有人追问,什么时候每家店能摆上 Model S 实车。马斯克承认未来几个月有个矛盾:测试需要 beta 车,展示也需要 beta 车,两边抢。第一季度开始会往所有门店铺车。

安全测试:跳进奥运泳池,不是儿童池

高盛的分析师问安全测试进展。马斯克说目标定得极高:每一个碰撞类别都要拿五星。按 2012 年的标准,如果做到,Model S 会是唯一一辆全类别五星的车。

他解释说,Model S 有个结构性优势。前面没有大发动机块,取而代之的是一个前备箱。这让车头溃缩区比任何同级豪华轿车都长。

然后是他那套招牌类比:

你从五楼跳下来,肯定想跳进奥运会标准泳池,而不是儿童戏水池。溃缩区长,意味着可以把减速过程摊在更长的距离上。(马斯克)

他补了一句更狠的:汽油车做不到这一点,因为发动机会被直接推进驾驶舱。

这个论点在工程上站得住。电动车的电池包在底盘,前舱空出来,确实能做更长的吸能区。马斯克把它讲成了一个消费者一听就懂的比喻,这是他的本事。

后面有分析师追问碰撞测试的进度,马斯克说已经撞掉了"接近一打"的 Model S,还有一打要撞。流程是先做仿真,再用实车碰撞校准仿真模型,反复迭代。现在接近尾声,最后几轮是确认性的,验证之前的改动是对的。

90 千瓦充电桩,像外星飞船降落在停车场

Capstone 的分析师问充电基础设施的布局,问得挺远,说这不只关系到特斯拉,也关系到所有竞争对手的电动车。

马斯克在这里提前泄露了一个还没发布的东西:特斯拉超级充电站,90 千瓦。

第一座计划装在旧金山和洛杉矶之间,时间是 1 月或 2 月。之后有一整套铺设计划。他说会在第一座装好时搞一轮媒体活动,因为那东西长得太特别了。

你看到它立在高速路旁的停车场里,那简直是最酷的东西。像一个高级的外星飞船降落在原本很无聊的地方。(马斯克)

性能指标是:30 分钟充 150 英里。他描述的使用场景很具体,插上电,去吃点东西,回来继续上路。

这段回答的信息量在于,它把"续航焦虑"从电池问题转换成了基础设施问题。车能跑 300 英里,加上沿途 30 分钟补 150 英里,长途出行的可行性就成立了。2011 年说这话的时候,全美几乎还没有像样的快充网络。

Model X 要抢的,是那些讨厌 minivan 的人

有人问 12 月要揭幕的 Model X,能不能透露点细节,跟 Model S 怎么区分。

马斯克先卖了个关子,说不能讲太多,不然揭幕就没意思了。然后给了定位:Model S 打的是豪华轿车市场,顺带覆盖一部分豪华 SUV;Model X 主要打 SUV,同时桥接 minivan 市场。

核心卖点是功能性强过 minivan:上下车更容易,装人同时能装更多货。

很多人被迫买 minivan,他们其实很讨厌这车,但需要那个功能。我们想给他们更强的功能,而且长得好看。(马斯克)

分析师接着问定价,说 minivan 市场对价格更敏感。马斯克的回应有点出人意料:他认识很多买得起更贵 minivan 的人,但市面上根本没有豪华 minivan 可买。

然后他顺手批评了保时捷卡宴:空间比轿车还小,本质就是升高底盘的轿车,样子也不怎么样。

分析师笑着回了一句"这个批评公平",马斯克也接了:"这个批评公平。"

这段对话很短,但透露了 Model X 的产品假设:有钱、要空间、要面子的人,当时根本没有合适的选项,价格并不是主要障碍。这个判断后来被 Model X 的订单验证了一部分,也被它的产能地狱验证了另一部分。

2013 年盈利,靠的是选装组合

有人问 2013 年实现净利润的路径,具体到选装和续航版本的销售结构,怎么撑起 25% 的毛利率目标。

马斯克说他只能给最好的猜测。大部分人应该会选 230 英里版本,第二多的是 300 英里以上版本,最后是 160 英里。

300 英里版本实际能跑 310 到 320 英里。它还有别的优势:更长的电池保修,以及跟长途城际快充绑定的一些功能。

然后他开始推销几个选装件,语气像个产品经理:

  • 全景天窗,他声称是所有轿车和 SUV 里开口最大的,是"你能买到的最接近敞篷的东西"
  • 空气悬架,能根据载重动态调整车身高度,高速时降低车身减小风阻,过积雪路段时抬高

他特意说,希望很多人选空气悬架,但担心大家根本不知道这选项有多好用。"这取决于我们能把它的价值讲多清楚。"

这句话其实点出了特斯拉当时的一个短板:产品力强,但解释成本高。传统车厂的选装包是消费者熟悉的东西,空气悬架、全景天窗这些,需要教育。

钱怎么花:制造费用先记在 Opex 里

德意志银行的分析师问资本开支的轨迹,还有经营现金流的负值会不会收窄。

CFO 的回答比较技术性,但有个会计处理值得记下来。在 Model S 正式投产之前,所有制造相关的费用,加上研发,全部记在运营费用里。一旦进入量产模式,制造费用会从研发转到销货成本。

这意味着两件事。短期内,随着招工和培训生产队伍,Opex 会继续涨。同时 Model S 的开发费用会因为测试和供应商工程收尾而下降,一涨一降部分抵消。等真正进入量产,Opex 会明显下降。

资本开支这块,全年指引略微下调,但季度之间的分布很难预测,因为涉及跟供应商的付款时点。2012 年的指引要等到 Q4 财报会才给。

这段问答没什么戏剧性,但它是理解特斯拉 2012 年财务报表波动的钥匙。很多人在 Model S 交付后看到毛利率跳变,原因就在这里。

几张不摊开的牌

Doyle 的分析师 Andrea James 注意到股东信里一句话,说资本开支可能落在指引低端,原因是"在某些项目上控制了支出",但具体项目保密。她问,这话到底想传达什么。

马斯克的回答挺坦诚。他说上一场电话会也提过,战略上留几张牌在手里是合理的,不必把所有事都摊开。这些事对长期很重要,花的钱不算多,但足够保证时机成熟时能快速推向市场。

我以前一直非常开放,但我想说的是,往后有些事完全公开并不符合战略利益。(马斯克)

他承认这个回答很含糊,还道了个歉。

同一场会里还有两处类似的"不能说"。一处是关于跟奔驰的新合作,Smart for two 项目在收尾,有新的合作在谈。马斯克说不能评论,要尊重合作伙伴,希望年底能多说。另一处是跟丰田的关系,上一季度提过可能有一份比以往大一个数量级的合同。他的回答是"保持关注"。

这三处加在一起,能看出 2011 年特斯拉的另一条线:靠给大车厂做电动动力总成供应,换取现金流和信用背书。这条线后来慢慢淡出了公众视野,但在 Model S 量产前,它是特斯拉活下去的重要支撑。

Roadster 是侦察兵,不是主力

JP 摩根的分析师问 Roadster 的季度销量,说 Q3 比 Q2 多了 45 台,增速是 Q1 到 Q2 的三倍,是不是有什么特别的原因。

马斯克的回答很干脆:别过度解读。

Roadster 是限量生产的车,而且是敞篷跑车,天然有季节性,夏天卖得比冬天好。

然后他说了 Roadster 真正的价值所在:

Roadster 对特斯拉最大的价值是当侦察兵,帮我们搞清楚怎么造电动车,它在不同国家、不同气候、不同监管体系下怎么运作。它是个滩头阵地。(马斯克)

这个定位很准确。Roadster 卖了不到三千台,但它验证了三件事:电池管理、充电兼容性、以及各国法规的坑。后面有人问充电会不会烧变压器、会不会让家庭电费翻三倍,马斯克的回答就是:这些问题 Roadster 已经小规模踩过了,"我们是在小规模上犯错,避免在 Model S 和后续车型上大规模犯错"。

Model S 的充电算法比 Roadster 更聪明,会自动适配输入的电流和电压,避免给供电线路造成问题。

英国那档节目,和一笔法律账单

高盛的分析师问欧洲市场的成本,提到了 Top Gear。2008 年那期节目说 Roadster 跑不到 55 英里就没电了,特斯拉起诉了节目方诽谤。

马斯克说得很谨慎,因为有正在进行的诉讼。但他还是讲了立场:Roadster 在那档节目里被冤枉了,给英国市场留下了持久的负面印象,而英国是 Roadster 表现最强的市场之一。

他提到这笔成本包括法律费用、市场活动、拿工资的销售人员,还有品牌损伤。品牌损伤会随时间修复,但"它确实在那里"。

这段插曲值得放在整场会的语境里看。一家还没量产的公司,要同时应付产品、供应链、资本、以及一场跨国的舆论官司。马斯克在会上的语气一直很稳,只有聊到这件事时露出了一点疲态。

3000 人来看工厂,比任何广告都管用

Andrea James 追问了一个很聪明的对比:英国那档节目能对生意造成可量化的负面影响,那 Model S 发布会带来的正面影响,可量化吗。

马斯克说,效果很明确。大约 3000 人来到弗里蒙特工厂,很多人是从世界各地飞来的。

他说这场活动真正的对象是客户,媒体只是顺带。参加的门槛是必须是 Model S 的预订持有者。让他们试驾 beta 车,看工厂,看设备确实在那里。

他们回家跟朋友同事聊的时候,可以很确定地说,我坐过那辆车,我看过那个工厂。卖产品最好的人,就是你的现有客户。(马斯克)

他还给了一组数据:Signature 系列共 1000 台,现在只剩几百台,已经订掉 700 多台。想在今年提车,唯一的办法就是买剩下的 Signature 系列。

这段回答解释了特斯拉早期增长的一个机制:不投广告,把资源投在让已有客户成为传播节点上。3000 个飞到加州看工厂的人,回去就是 3000 个销售。

一些不那么重要的细节,和一句认真的提醒

会里还有一些零散的问答,单独看没什么,合起来能看出这家公司的性格。

有人问内饰材料,会不会用碳纤维。马斯克说会提供碳纤维和几种木饰,其中一种是落叶木,另一种是掉落的香蕉叶。他还开了个玩笑,说如果有人想站道德高地,找不到比"掉落的香蕉叶"更好的木饰选择了。

有人问会不会做越野车或者非传统品类。马斯克说短期中期必须专注 Model S 和 Model X。但他补了一句,Model X 会是不错的越野车,空气悬架能抬高车身,四驱系统"可能是所有车里最好的"。

有人问置换怎么处理。马斯克说会支持,正在跟几家大型二手车集团谈。Roadster 时期绕过了这个问题,Model S 必须解决。

有人问纯电车能不能进 HOV 车道。马斯克说可以,加州这类对纯电有倾斜的州都没问题,而且纯电车没有排放合规的麻烦。

最后有人问,电动车多起来会不会影响燃油税,国会会不会担心。马斯克的回答挺有意思:这是个"高品位的问题"。如果电动车多到能影响电网,那说明特斯拉成功了。他估计那至少是十年以后的事。Roadster 的数据显示,绝大多数充电发生在夜间的家用车库,而夜间电网容量巨大。

主持人提醒时间到了,马斯克说了句"下个季度见",会就结束了。

2011 年那场会,真正说了什么

把这场电话会放回时间线看,它的分量在于:这是特斯拉在"还没证明自己能造车"这个阶段,对外界做的最后一次系统交底。

会上给出的硬信息不多,但每条都能对上后来的事实。九成设备到位,年底全部到位;预订每月 350 到 400 台,还在加速;五星碰撞目标;90 千瓦快充;2013 年盈利目标;先高配后低配的投产策略。

更值得记的是那些判断。马斯克在最缺钱的时候,选择了不为赶时间而降标准。他说如果不追求完美,7 月前就能交车。这句话在当时听着像托词,放到 Model S 后来拿到的高评分和低故障率上看,它是一个真实的取舍。

还有一个细节容易被忽略。他反复说"我不知道那个问题是什么","我们准备了特种部队去应对还不知道的问题"。公开承认不确定性,这种姿态在 CEO 里很少见。大部分人在这种场合会选择展示掌控感,他选择展示准备度。

今天做硬件、做产品的人,可以从这场十四年前的电话会里直接拿走几处做法。

  • 把风险预算押在响应速度上,而不是风险清单的完整性上。你列不全所有会坏的东西,但可以保证坏了之后有人能立刻修。先建机动队,再谈流程。
  • 签长约时留一个便宜的退出条款。锁价格是为了给外界确定性,留口子是为了不把自己焊死。采购量故意定得比预测低,就是在给第二供应商留位置。
  • 新产品爬坡期,主动限制配置组合。用高配筛选早期用户,既提高毛利又减少产线变量。但要给出明确的期限,别让限制变成永久策略。
  • 让供应商在自己的厂房里把模块跑通再发货。在别人家犯错比在总装线上犯错便宜。你只需要调模块之间的衔接,不用从零调整条线。
  • 把营销预算换成客户到场。3000 个飞来看工厂的预订用户,回去就是 3000 个销售。前提是产品真的能让他们有底气开口。
  • 给产品找一个一句话能讲完的物理类比。溃缩区是奥运泳池,快充桩是降落的外星飞船。工程师听得懂不够,得让掏钱的人一秒听懂。
  • 提前把排期说难听。告诉客户可能要等到 2014 年,短期看是劝退,长期看是筛掉了会在等待中退款的订单。
  • 允许自己有几张不摊开的牌。但要在会上说清楚"我有牌但不能讲",而非假装没有。前者建立信任,后者消耗信任。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00good day ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the Tesla Motors Incorporated third quarter 2011 Financial results and Q&A conference call at this time all participants are in a listen only mode to queue up to ask a question at any time during the call please press star and then one on your touchtone keypad as a reminder today's conference call is being recorded and if you require operator assistance during the presentation please press star and then zero now I would like to turn the conference over to your host Jeff Evanson thank you Matthew and good afternoon everyone welcome to the Tesa Motors thirdd quarter 2011 Financial results Q&A session I'm joined today by

0:44Elon Musk Tesla's chairman CEO and chief product architect and deep pakaha Tesla's Chief Operating Officer we announced our financial results for the third quarter shortly after 1: p.m. Pacific time today the shareholder letter Financial results and webcast of this Q&A session are all available at the company's investor relations website at ir. teslamotors.com

1:12like last quarter this call will consist of some brief remarks by Elon followed by time for questions and answers we will conduct the Q&A session live so if you have not already done so please log in now if you wish to ask a question during the course of this call we may discuss our business Outlook and make forward-looking statements such statements are only predictions based on Management's current expectations actual events or results could differ materially due to a number of risks and uncertainties including those mentioned in our most recent form 10q filed with the SEC such forward-looking statements represent our views only as of today and

1:58should not be relied upon after today we also disclaim any obligation to update these forward-looking statements and now let me pass the call to Elon hi thanks for joining us so I think we can proceed directly to questions and since there's no point me reading something that that you already have so Jeff let's just go directly to question thank you and again ladies and gentlemen if you'd like to ask a question please press star then one our first question comes from Adam Jonas of Morgan Stanley your line is open hi thanks everybody

2:45Elon first question the long-term Supply contract with Panasonic you said it gives you increased visibility on on variable cost for Sals but do you also have increased confidence in the cost I.E based on what you've seen so far is it is it better than you thought and the second part to that question is if over time you you have a a competing supplier that offers a lower cost solution do you have any opt out from Panasonic and and if so what are some of the costs or types of cost for that for that opt out thanks sure I so we we do have a firm

3:22pricing from Panasonic so we have very good predictability as to what what the price will be over the next course four years we are not obligated to purchase all of those cells so it is possible for us to if Panasonic becomes uncompetitive to to to to exit the deal with with with

3:51relatively small there's some penalty but it's quite small now now that being said I we feel pretty confident that panan is going to be in in the lead position for from a sales manufacturing standpoint for quite some time and we have pretty good visibility into what others are doing so I think we've got the best salale partner in the world and someone who's going to remain the vest for for quite a while now we do

4:21expect over that period of time let say the next four years to to make a lot more cars than we' currently talked about you know the Panasonic deal you know which is on the order of 80,000 so that that definitely leaves room for a a Second Source if if that if that's supp makes sense thanks can can I ask a question about leasing any progress on making or establishing any leasing partner as you get closer to the commercial launch of of Model S yeah I've actually we we've

5:00had a number of conversations but I've just decided to deprioritize that initially because there there really doesn't seem to be a need to have leasing take place in the probably in the first certainly the first six months but but I think maybe even in the first 12 months and you know so so

5:20better for us to focus on more important things we we could certainly get a leasing deal done you know so so but it's just it just doesn't seem to be necessary to achieve our volume targets you in the first qu 6 to 12 months yeah okay that's all I have thanks very much okay thank you our next question comes from Dan galves with Deutsche Bank your line is open good afternoon thanks for taking my questions I just wanted to ask you know can you just give us an update on kind of what what's left to be done before launch of the model S you know are your how do you feel like your suppliers are performing are there is there anything you're worried about in

6:07terms of suppliers on time or tooling getting to you guys on time well going going very well and we sort of like to say things are going very well because you know in case that jinkx his things but but things all going very well we have overnight 90% of the the the factory tooling equipment in place I I don't

6:36really know of any one thing that I would call out as being particularly risky but there there's a lot of little things and you know that that that could potentially go AR but what I'm trying to make sure of is that is that we have the the agility to respond to any one of those things you know so we have sort of

7:05a special forces team you know that that's in the engineering and Manufacturing side that can go and Tackle any specific problem once it arises but but that that we don't know what it is yet if that makes any sense so yeah things things look great I mean I I don't really have any anything to to complain about right now we do want to make sure this car is as close to perfect as possible and you

7:37know think we could ship cars sooner than July if if we had lower standards in that regard but but but we want to really create a good impression with customers from the moment they received the car so okay we don't we don't want to rush the market okay yeah that sounds good and then you know my next question is related to the the mix of vehicles when do you expect to kind of let the reservation holders start specifying or specking the cars and I guess you know more longer term do you feel like you have the flexibility to kind of meet whatever mix of vehicles comes at you in terms of options battery sizes and that type of thing yeah in fact the we're we're

8:30just deciding that that right now which is to to figure out what what is the best way to to price the the various options such that it you know it it strikes a good a good happy medium between customer value perception and gross margin you know accumulative gross Maring to to Tesla and we really want to put a lot of thought into that into that but we may need to adapt obviously after if our assumptions are wrong after we put out the option mix but we we do expect to have that out before the end of this year so i' say December the lat okay and Y and is there is there any

9:20I mean and you feel like you've got the flexibility to kind of meet whatever whatever mix of vehicles people people end up ordering yeah I I think so well and now for the first several months of production we're going to constrain the the option mix to to to a pretty high you you have to basically you you have to order stuff that's got a pretty pretty high option mix initially so you know for example and we said this several months ago for the f for the first five months or so we won't be offering the 160 mile range vehicle it'll just be the the 300 mile and 230 mile range and you know there'll be probably a few there will be a couple other options that kind of mandatory in

10:17the initial period so that that makes it easier for us to constrain the number of variables in the a start of production so so we don't have too many variations of vehicles coming out the Factory and U you know and and I think that's sort of the best way to take advantage of of of early demand you know it's kind of like you know when when they bring out a new CPU or something like that it would initially be expensive and then go down later you know as as production increased so we're kind of insisting that people buy the the heavily optioned car initially for the first several months okay makes sense one more if I could you know based on the

11:04capex guidance it looks like that capex is is going up a little bit slightly next quarter will will that represent the peak of the capex spend for the next several quarters and and any indication you can give us on kind of the the trajectory of well you're not really burning cash cuz you're you're drawing the loan but in terms of you know operating cash flow and capex the trajectory of of the negatives over the next several quarters will will it be moderating would you like to Pi that sure Dan

11:43you know it's you know from on a full year basis as you can see we've taken down the gapex guidance slightly although in the in the big scheme of things that timing difference really doesn't change things and doesn't matter much it's difficult for us to predict exactly what the quarterly capex is given some of the timing issues and how we pay suppliers so I think as we pull together our 2012

12:17guidance and share that with you at the end of the during the Q4 earnings call we can give you a better sense at that point of how capex will be spread through the year okay thanks very much okay thanks Dan thank you our next question comes from Andrea James of doy and Company your line is open hello good afternoon okay so in the quarter letter it says something about cacks may come in at the lowend of guidance and then you go on to say in spite of controlled expenditures on certain products projects and you want to keep that confidential and I guess any type of context would be helpful you know what are you trying to convey by sharing that sort of mysterious detail and then what

13:03are what are investors supposed to take away from it well I guess I mentioned this on the last call which is we we I think it makes sense strategically to keep a few cards close to our v and and not not Prevail you know sort of everything and that that's essentially you know that's part of what what I'm trying to H that there and but I think I think I I think

13:37those are sort of smart decisions that that that that should I mean the things that we're doing that they're they're very important for long term and you when we do unveil them I think people will Le most people will agree that that they were sensible things to do but I mean but but we're not spending a ton on that but we're spending enough to make sure that when the timing is right we're we're

14:06we can be quick to Market with with a few things that that I think people aren't expecting sorry to be so obuse but you know previously would would been very we've always been extremely open about things and I just wanted to make the point that that strategically going forward there's a few things that it doesn't make sense to be completely open about for you know competitive strategically okay and one more and then I'll hop back in the queue so we see the smart for 2 program winding down and now it looks like you might have something new and Mercedes related I guess how do we think about that the size relative to the smart for 2 program in in Defence to to Diel I I can't

14:59make any specific comments about this deal and I I we we'll really wait until they're ready to talk about it some more I'd love to talk about it but but I I do need to be respectful of our key you know what of about key strer Partners when do you think you'll be able to speak more about it well hopefully around the end of this year but that that's really going to be upon the mutual consent of D and and us I mean so it's it's when when when they're ready to talk about it then then that's when we talk about it okay thank

15:45you thank you our next question comes from imanu Patel of JP Morgan your line is open hi good afternoon guys couple questions Elon on the last call you you had made a vague reference to some additional strategic opportunities was that the the diimler Lo Loi was that what that was in reference to no no no that's I was referring to something different okay number two can you yeah yeah could you guys talk a little bit to just just Roadster volume you know the quarterly Cadence really kind of picked up it looks like you sold three times as many I guess the growth rate you know is 45 units more than and Q2 which seemed like goes three times as fast as

16:40what you saw q1 to Q2 what what what kind of happen in the third quarter and is there any way for us to think about kind of the quarterly Cadence of of Roadster volumes and is there any seasonal seasonal Trends here that we should be thinking about either yeah I mean Ro the of course there's always intend to be kind of a limited production vehicle and and there

17:04certainly is some seasonality given that it is a convertible sports car so it will tend to sell a little bit better in in summer than in Winter but but I mean I wouldn't read too much into roads to sales one way or the other they the biggest value the Roadster has to to test was really as kind of an advanced Scout to help us understand

17:36how to make an electric vehicle how it operates in all sorts of different countries and different climates and Regulatory regimes and it's kind of a beach head you know so and and it's it's really Serv it's purpose very well and but but we're really not moving away from that to to the next major phas of things with the model S so you I think that's what

18:04really matters in the long term so yeah okay and then I I guess if you guys could speak a little bit to the kind of pace of reservation book building on the model S it looks like you're doing about 300 350 you know reservations a month here is that is is there something to the the pace of that that we should be thinking about Pro respectively does it ever become nonlinear at one stage is there I mean it sounds like you're starting to be a lot more aggressive on the marketing but I'm just wondering if you guys had a view on on how we should think about that well it the rate of model reservations does appear to be accelerating and you know I should point out we're

18:51not paying for any advertising so as long as the we actually advertise the models we we we get a lot of press and obviously we have our Stores and our sales team particularly in North America is starting to shift its focus from the road to has has shifted its focus at this point at least from the roads to the model S but but it is noteworthy that

19:21that without advertising that you're seeing this grow I think that probably a lot of people don't realize that this is just wor them out and and sales team but I think I think something that cons that that that people who are interested in buying the modelist should should appreciate is that if the modelist reservations continue to appreciate you know continue to accelerate that it's very important for them to put down a deposit soon or you know that they'll be getting a car in 2014 you know it's it's I think sometimes people under the impression that the model S is kind of like how other cars are where there's a ton of them on the lot and you can just go to

20:11the lot and buy one but that's not the case they're all sold out way in a account okay and then I I guess one last question I think at the press release you guys make a reference to you know Opex you know Rising slightly as you kind of prep for the the factory launch debach I'm wonder if you can talk a little bit about it you know the $74 million non-gaap Opex number this quarter how does that sort of move over the next two three quarters does it does it I guess you know I'm trying to understand is that a linear sort of mild rise or does it sort of have a big spike in q1 or Q2 sure and before that let me just add that our reservations in Q3 for

20:54Model S were 1150 so they were closer to between 350 and 400 a month and as compared to a th000 in Q2 so there was clearly an increase in Q3 that we saw and then in in terms of Opex as you know all our manufacturing related expense in addition to R&D is being booked as Opex until we are

21:25in the launch mode for the model S at at that point our manufacturing expenses will move out of R&D into cost of good sold as a result as we continue to hire more people and we'll hire more more of the production Workforce in the next few quarters and start training them and getting ready clearly our manufacturing related expenses will continue to increase and that's going to drive our Opex primarily at the same time we'll see some decline in Model S development expenses as some of the testing and supplier Ed andt work gets done so there's a bit of in andout happening but it's really once we are in the production mode of modes and Manufacturing expenses are in cost of

22:16with sold then we'll see an appreciable drop in Opex thank you thank you our next question in Q comes from from Carter Driscoll of Capstone Investments your line is open thank you good afternoon want to ask the first question if I may about maybe you could add some additional color about the model X what you're hoping to unveil in December do you think you will be able to have an alpha model in prod you know produced by then could you could you maybe compare and contrast the model X with the model S in a little bit more detail if I understand correctly you are going to be using the same Powertrain chassis would you maybe just drill down a little bit without you know

23:02revealing anything you don't want to compare why the model S would be in one segment versus the model X being targeted at another type of customer segment sure I don't want to give away too much because obviously there wouldn't be much of an unveiling but whereas the the model S our goal was to address the premium sedan and

23:28to some degree premium SUV market with the model X we're also trying to bridge a market but we're we're trying to address P primarily the SUV Market bridging to the minivan Market so what what what what we're trying to achieve with the model X is to have more functionality than a Minyan meaning it's easier to get in and out of you can pack more cargo along with people

23:57and that that's I I think that's that's really that's really missing you know it's right now if if you for a lot of people I know that that they're forced to buy a minivan and they they kind of hate it but they need the functionality so we want to give them that functional in fact we want to give them more more than that functionality in something that looks really cool so betters a little bit

24:27more functionality do do anticipate that you'll be able to price segment I imagine the minivan segment is a tad more price sensitive than the premium sedan group well you know there's premium SUV I mean I I know a lot of people who can afford to pay a lot more for a many band but there's just nothing that that's out there to buy there isn't really a premium any and there

24:57there's certainly premium SUV like you know Porsche cion and whatnot but I mean it's like some Porsche cionne it's got like less room than some sedan it's like a sedan with a more ride height it doesn't look that great sorry that's fair criticism all right thank you for that for that elaboration could you also maybe just talk you you may I guess public statement you you expect to reach net profitability in 2013 could you talk about what you're EXP ing obviously the first 6 months you're trying to limit the option range to reduce the level of potential production defects and and and tightly control that initially could you talk about in 2013 where you think the

25:41mix of options and and range you know whether you're talking the 160 the the 230 the 300 where do you think that mix will be to get you to that 25% targeted gross margin line and what the variables might be that would increase it above or below well I can give you my obviously just just just my best guesses I think most people are going to probably want the the 230 mile range car I think a

26:14lot of people are going to want the the 300 plus mile car U especially I we think it'll probably do 310 to 320 miles a range and there are some other advantages to to that car in that we're going to be offering that much longer battery warranty it's there's some cool things that that we're going to tie into long distance inter city fast charging any so I think I think I think we'll see probably most people 230 then next largest being the 300 and then then the 160

27:01and and then there's a number of other options that that are pretty cool I mean the the roof we have the the biggest roof opening of any car I believe that any San or SUV or anything in fact I think the model S panoramic group is closest thing you can get to having a convertible without it being a convertible I think you a lot of people want to pick that option the air suspension which is able to dynamically adjust the right height according to the load of the car and it also improves efficiency on the the highway because it can hunker down you can raise the the car going through heavy snow and snow ice I I think a lot of people I hope a lot of people pick

27:43that option because but I think a lot of people don't even realize you can like how cool an option that is so it kind of depends on on how well we can convey the the value of of having that and that's very helpful maybe just switch gears quickly and then I'll flip back into Q is could you give me a view of you know where the charging infrastructure is nationally regionally and where you expect it to be over the next 12 to say 24 months and what do you think that does support a higher production level that you're hoping to achieve in 2013 and then obviously a lot of competitor vehicles that will also need that infrastructure yeah that's a good

28:25question I think we're going to have a very exciting announcement about inter city charging or inter city supercharging if you will so we developed this what we call the Tesla Supercharger which is the 90 kilowatt charger and I think we're hoping to have the first one installed between sancisco and N La

28:56probably in the Jan or February time frame and then there's a a whole roll out schedule for that and we're planning on on on doing doing a fair bit of press around the I'm bailing with the first one because I mean when when you see what this looks like in in a Highway W up parking lot it's it's like the coolest thing it's like it looks like it looks like an ad Advanced alien fact landed in the middle of the of this High otherwise Dr well they're not that Dr think they're okay but it's it just looks looks amazing and will allow

29:41people to charge their their cars that to charge 150 miles in 30 minutes so that you can you can park plug your car in grab a bike to eat the out come back and continue your journey but I'm prob getting ahead myself on on that that's very helpful do you have you obviously you guys stay on top of legislative developments that affect electric vehicles could you talk about you know some of the noise that perhaps there might be a searge in terms of you know Congress worried about losing the gas tax as EVS proliferate and you know how that may impact you know sales

30:26well I I think that's the high class problem because I mean if if there that many EVS it it pretty much means we wanton so I I yeah mean we're selling so many cars that it actually matters for the grid I mean I think we're probably more than a decade away from from that what we've seen from the roosta is the vast majority of charging occurs at night in somebody's garage which I guess one would intuitively expect so and and and the the grid capacity at night is huge mass of capacity so it seems to fit well with

31:06with the existing infrastructure appreciate you taking my questions I'll jump back into kuna thank you our next question comes from Steve milanovich from Bank of America maril Lynch your line is open thank you very much could you comment a bit about how you take back customer feedback and and any changes that you're looking to make post the reveal on October 1st obviously you've generally had very good reviews but there's been some concerns about seed comfort and you know a few other things do you have the ability or interest in taking that in and potentially making any changes for the production model oh yeah absolutely that's we emphasized it was it was really a beta

31:52that that people were getting a test ride in because there's there's a thousand little details that that we want to improve from the beta I mean my goal for the car is to be as as close to perfect as possible and I certainly think I mean the seat needs to be extremely comfortable I mean just everything needs to be as close to perfect as possible you obviously can't be there in a beta so we try to set people's expectations appropriately but I think almost well all of the concern that I've heard people Express about the beta of concerns that we already planning to address okay and then as I recall last quarter you had discussed potentially a large contract I thought that was with

32:40Toyota and you had suggest that it could be an order of magnitude larger than what you've done before would you like to Pro provide any update on that thinking you know I think I think we remain quite quite optimistic about the a future relationship with Clara along with B they're they're a key strategic partner and things seem to be going very well so you know as with with with I'm like I

33:14always prefer to take take my queue from the a strategic partner before making too much of a of a before talking about something too much so you know so I think St stay tuned on that FR okay thank you it was worth a worth a shot then finally as you pointed out you haven't had to advertise yet when you begin to ship the car you obviously have enough demand for some period of time so you won't necessarily need to advertise then but when do you plan on advertising and when you do start to ship I would think it might be worth from branding standpoint beginning to get get out there in any case yeah definitely at at some point we'll we'll do advertising and

34:05but but I think it'll be a few years before we do advertising I mean there just you know this if we're production limited then then there's not much point in spending money on advertising and but we want to get to a point where we're not production limited and and then advertising going make sense so I guess we probably start some advertising in in 2013 yeah that's just a guess but we may not need to in 2013 but but I wouldn't say wouldn't be any sooner than 2013 great thank you thank you our next question is froma oberoy with Goldman Sachs your line is open great thanks a lot can you provide some color around the costs you are incurring in Europe related to the

34:53Roadster issue oh H you mean with respect to the tough gear onell trashing us yes well I have to be a little bit careful because we do have an ongoing legal action there and you know we're just trying to write or wrong essentially T tedler was was was really wronged by by that show and it's left the negative lasting impression on in the UK particularly CU that's what what top is strongest and so we just got to we got to change that bad data point that that's been conveyed and and I think we're making some progress in that direction and if we'll have to I I don't

35:45want to say anything that would that would negatively affect our legal case there so so I'll have to probably not say anymore my put my now or maybe I can ask it in another way that you guys mentioned that you guys are incurring additional costs to correct consumer misperception so are these costs related to advertising or are they more of just legal costs yes it's not not advertising but but certainly legal cost Market would you would do execute marketing events we have sales people on salary and and of course then there there's a little bit of brand damage but I mean we'll correct that brand damage over time but it's still it's still there

36:38got it and can you talk a little bit about what is those what are those 10% of things that are left at the Fremont facility as you guys mentioned that you almost 90% there yeah it it's less with each passing week I mean so the the doors and closures you know basic closures which is sort of doors Bonnet and trunk the the assembly equipent for

37:08that is arriving but not but hasn't completely arrived that's that's like one example and but I think we expect to have that in the next month or two and then the next big thing after that will be the the stamping dies for the body panels so those are being made by a Fuji partner that front

37:38so yeah we should have all of the equipment in place by the end of this year and then it's going to be working you we have to work really hard to iron out any the bugs in the overall manufacturing line yeah and to add to elon's information here a lot of this equipment is at our suppliers and it's being tested including the body enclosures line and when the trials are completed and they're fully acceptable to us they get shipped to us so a lot of progress happening at our suppliers at the same time yeah that's a good point I should have mentioned that the ping his our supplier for for that for those assemblies is they

38:36built it up at their facility and they're debugging it at their facility and then once it's debugged they sh it to us so in principle at least at the manufacturing module level stuff has been debugged and then we're just kind of the what what we have to do just pront is debugging the module to module interactions you as stuff moves from one pod line to the next so that that should minimize over manufacturing line risk that's and while we're doing this you know we are continuing to do the beta builds in our Freemont Factory so even though we may not have the full Automation in some cases our suppliers can provide us those parts based on the Automation in their facility and

39:25that's allowing us to then continue doing the buildout and just refining and learning our own manufacturing processes and interacting with our suppliers as well right exactly like that when when Fuji makes the stamping guide and they first stamp a bunch of panels in in Japan or Taiwan whatever the case may be and then they they send us those parts and the stamping D that's very helpful and one last one if I may ask the contract you guys signed with Panasonic was it is it just for Model S or all the all the vehicles that will be on the models architecture we plan on using a common battery cell so it would apply to all vehicles that use it would apply to

40:09more than just the model S not necessarily to all vehicles but but to more than just a mod got great thank you thanks a lot guys thanks thank you our next question comes from Ben callow of Robert W be and your line is open all right thanks for taking my question I want to focus on the retail strategy it looks like you're going to end the year with about 20 25 stores I think is the number can you kind of talk about how reservations have changed for the model S if you're seeing reservations actually come from the stores or from surrounding areas whether it's on the internet and then also can you talk about what metrics each of those locations are going to be judged on as

40:53you go forward is there actual targets for reservations at each store yeah we we we see most of our reservations coming from the stores particularly the ones that have high foot traffic I mean we're still at the early stages so it's difficult to to to say what what should a store do but I

41:17mean early indications are very very promising we're just seeing an incredible number of people come through our Stores in the high traffic Mall shopping malls and even if they don't they don't buy a car now they we kind of planted the seed for them to buy a car in the future whether it's the model S model X or you know a future sort of third generation vehicle so

41:43we think our our store strategy is is showing itself be to be very powerful and and fundamentally different from how things have historically been in the auto business you know most people don't have a positive experience buing car and and for some they sort of look at it like it's a dental appointment you we wanted we want to go to the complete opposite side of things where you're you're magnetically drawn into the Tesla store it's just a really appealing place to be and you know we don't we we

42:20actually don't don't have they're not really sales people they're product Specialists but they're just there to sort of explain anything you want to know about about the model S or or or electric vehicles in general and it seems it seems to be really going well and we sell clothing as well we actually quite quite a good business in Tesla clothing is unexpected Revenue source and so along those lines what's the strategy and then the roll out of actually having Model S vehicles at each Loc a because I guess seeing is believing in some ways sure absolutely and certainly it has a big impact if we've got a modeless beta there or not you know for the next few months we

43:10we have a a dichotomy which is we need we need beta vehicles for testing and we need we we need beta Vehicles so that customers can see them so we we we have to make a a tough trade between those two competing priorities but but that's not going to be an issue you know a few months from now so we'll start deploying the the cars to all of the stores in in in the first quarter okay then my last question is on on the testing front any update on where you are as far as safety testing goes yeah the safety testing is looking really good I've set an extremely high bar which is to be a five star Crush rated in every category and from what I'm told if we achieve that we will be the

44:05only car that is five star Crush rated in every category by 2012 standards so that's looking extremely good now we have a fundamental Advantage here with the model S which is that because we do not have a large engine block in in the front in fact we've got a front trunk that gives us a much longer crumple Zone than is possible in other premium sedans

44:35you I'm not sure the right analogy is here but you think of it like if you jump out of a you know five story window you probably want to jump into an Olympic side swimming pool other than a kitty pool and having a long that long crumple Zone means that you can do the you can spread out the deceleration of the car over much longer distance whereas otherwise you know other a gas mov then can't can't do that because it would just shove the engine right through a chest and and that's that's part of why we we can you know that fundamentally that Superior architecture is why we think we've got a shot at making this the sa this C in the world great thank you very

45:25much welcome thank you our next question is a followup from Andrea James of dhy and Company your line is open hi thanks for letting me lob in one more so I thought this was interesting you know you saw in the UK that a TV show can affect the business in a negative and and also in a quantifiable way and I so so The Logical followup to me would be you know did you see a quantifiable effect from the model S event and the subsequent positive media and then if so like you know how did it track with what your expectations were after the event thanks U sure it we definitely had a positive impact from the the model S beta event and with you roughly

46:103,000 people came to visit our Factory in Fremont many many of them coming from countries all around the world and a goal there was was actually it was actually not media it was really to to to to let our customers know that that their faith was not misplaced that that was the most important thing so in order to come to the event you have to be a model as reservation holder and yeah so we want to show this this

46:47is what the car is at least in beta form with the test drivve and then this is our Factory and and it's real and the equipment's there and it's so so when they go home and they talk to their friends and colleagues they they can speak with confidence that they've been in the car and they've seen the factory and they're they're really the best people to sell a product are are your existing customers you know don't really have any incentives that was the that was the main goal and and I think that's it's been effective and will continue to be effective and the media was was was was also very positive and helpful as well did you see reservations increase or

47:33did you see some of the $5,000 convert over to the 40 we we we did so there's a a thousand calls in the signature series and there's only a few hundred left actually so we're now 700 and something of the signature series have been reserved and in fact the only only way to get a car next year is if you buy one of the couple hundred remaining Signature Series cars so yeah we a

48:07number of people compared to that yeah it was just it was an awesome event so thank you thank you our next question comes from Ben Rose of battle Road research your line is open good afternoon based upon the feedback from the datas with regard to the use of materials in the model S are you thinking any differently about possibly using carbon fiber or other Advanced Materials in the model X and other forthcoming Vehicles yeah we'll be offering carbon fiber as well as a couple of wood trim options one being a lace wood which is kind of a cool kind of black wood and then the other being Banana Leaf it's actually it's it's Fallen Banana Leaf so if somebody's looking for the

49:09model High Ground I don't think we could find better oral High Ground than than Fallen ban banana leaf as the you know choice of wood trim and and we'll continue to try to add some interesting options over time so and there will be some things very unique to the to the model X certainly yeah we really want to drive drive Innovation on on almost every fund here with with cars and whatever we can think of that has the potential to amaze and like our customers we want to do that okay and then just one final question with regards to your plans for future Vehicles sort of broadly defined is it possible that you would look at some other kinds of off-road categories and maybe sort of

50:10non-traditional Automotive categories where you could parlay your electric expertise well I think we need to be to to stay focused on the model S and then like that's really sort of the best of our focus and then the model X which the model X by going to be a pretty great offroading vehicle because it also have that air suspension that so you can raise the the r height and it's going to have a particularly killer four-wheel drive system we think probably the best four-wheel drive system of of any car period so that should cover us re

50:53well on the nor roing PL you know long term it's possible we could go into a wide range of of areas but but I think in the short Medi term we it's very important to stay focused okay thank you thank you our next question comes from Jesse pel of Jeff your line is open hi this is Ela Quay for Jesse thanks for taking our question just to follow up on Ben Call's earlier question what exactly is left in terms of the federal and state crash testing and other requirements needed to get a new car on the road and to qualify for the different incentives out there such as HOV lanes have a couple of Model S's already been sacrificed or will they be soon actually we we've now

51:43sacrificed quite a few modeles to crash testing I think probably approaching a dozen and there's another dozen that's there's another dozen to come as we iterate through the the you know we do as much as you can with simulations and you do the crash test to calibrate and validate the simulation and you go through the series of iteration Cycles we're very close to to the end of that I think the the final Crush set are really confirmatory of I thought that we've made the correct changes so that's well looking really

52:20good and and as far as HRV well because the model S is pure electric any state that that has H preference for Pure electric such as California you you'll be to drive in AC C Lane without a problem as you can right now with roader great and being p Electric we also we don't have you know we don't have sort of EPA issues to deal with because we don't have any any direct emission so great and now that we're talking about a car that could potentially be adopted in much greater numbers and some of the prior maybe perhaps more Niche EVS are you engaging with any local utilities or anything like that and discussions about potential customer issues with charging will there be

53:18smart charging apps built in I I guess it's kind of an idiot proofing question so you know there's in case of any issues of crashing Transformers or people tripling their pg& bills so we've got a fair better of experience with that with the Roadster not with tripping not with tripling PJ evil not with the bad stuff you mentioned but in terms of working out the bugs with with charging and and knowing what what's going to be an issue with some with houses out there and what won you know that's where the the road has been really really valuable you know so we where we did make the faal roads we made them at a small scale in order to avoid making them at a large

54:02scale with with the model apps and and subsequent vehicles so I think we've got a pretty good handle on things and there's a lot of intelligence in the charge algorithms of of the model S even more so than than the road store and yeah I mean so the vehicle automatically that to the input charging current and voltage so as not to create problems with whatever whatever circuit's feeding it so it's got a really intelligent feedback

54:44with hey Matthew we want to keep the call to an hour so let's if there are any more call questions Let's go to the last caller please okay our final question will come from Brian Russell of Russell group your line is open thank you good evening real quick on the stores as you ramp up to a higher volume and get past the initial reservations what are the plans for tradein is that how's that going to be

55:12handled we we definitely want to enable tradein and and we're talking to a couple of large youth car groups in the country to be able to handle that in a seamless manner for customers so we will have that ability to to deal with trade ends for for the model but for the Roadster we we we kind of sidestep that issue and it wasn't really all that important for for the Roadster but for the model S certainly is thank

55:46you all right well thanks everyone and yeah look look forward to the next quarter thank you do everybody ladies and gentlemen thank you for your participation on today's conference this does conclude the program and you may now disconnect

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份