2016年4月,奥斯陆。马斯克上台后的第一件事是道谢,第二件事还是道谢。
他说这趟欧洲之行只来了挪威,就是为了这场活动。台下的人原本以为会听到一场关于电动车的宣讲,结果接下来一个多小时里,他从峡湾里的水电站讲到了每年6万亿美元的化石燃料补贴,从氢燃料电池的能耗链条讲到了一座钻石形状、对齐正北的工厂。
中间还夹了一句:如果一定要死在某个地方,死在火星是个不错的结局。
挪威人均电动车保有量全球第一,他专程来说明这件事
马斯克开场没绕弯子。按人均算,挪威是全球电动车普及率最高的国家。他说每个挪威人都该为此骄傲。
这话不是客套。特斯拉在做产品验证时,把挪威当寒冷气候的试验场。一辆车在零下二十度能不能启动、续航掉多少、门把手会不会冻住,这些问题在加州测不出来。
所以他说,在特斯拉内部,挪威被当作先锋市场对待。
他还专门感谢了一批人:在挪威为可持续交通和可持续能源奔走了三十多年的那些人。
如果没有他们的支持,特斯拉在挪威不会是今天这个样子。(马斯克)
这句话在2016年有具体分量。那时候电动车在全球大多数市场还是小众选择,挪威用免税、免过路费、可以走公交道这几条政策,硬生生把电动车推成了主流选项之一。马斯克清楚这些政策值多少钱。
一个住在北极圈里的客户,买了一堆特斯拉让全镇人开
演讲里最像段子的部分,是他提到特斯拉全球最大的个人客户。
这个人住在纳尔维克(Narvik),在北极圈以内。他买了好几辆特斯拉,然后让镇上的人随便开,谁想用就用。
马斯克说,这人真是个了不起的家伙。
这个故事放在整场演讲里不是闲笔。它说明了一件事:在挪威,电动车是普通人日常在用的东西,跟环保主义者的身份标签没什么关系。一个北极圈里的小镇,冬天极夜,路面积雪,电动车能跑,这种说服力比任何广告都强。
峡湾就是挪威的油田,只是这口井不会枯竭
话题转到能源,马斯克的表述变得像个做长期投资的人。
他把能源问题拆成两端:可持续的能源生产,可持续的能源消费。挪威在前一端有天然的结构性优势,峡湾地形带来的水电潜力极大。
他特意强调了一点:开发水电能做到和当地环境在审美上和谐,不破坏生态。
怎么做?他提到小坝和微水电,绕开那种巨型水电站的路子。一座大坝拦住整条河,不如一系列小型水电站分散布局。他说这种做法对环境影响可以做到很小。
挪威在水电上有巨大的增长潜力,配合长距离、高效率的输电线,完全可以供应北欧相当大一部分的电力需求。(马斯克)
这个判断放在2016年看是超前的。挪威的电力结构里水电占了绝大部分,往外送电的能力一直受限于跨国输电线。马斯克看到的是:当世界从碳氢化合物转向可持续能源,挪威手里的资源会从“国内的清洁电力”变成“欧洲的战略资产”。
他补了一句让挪威人更安心的话:水电是长期产业,收入来源也是长期的。
油田会枯竭,水年年都会流下来。
马斯克说,世界正在逐步摆脱碳氢化合物,挪威在这件事上可能处在全球最好的位置。一个国家能同时做到引领可持续发电和引领可持续交通,挺值得高兴。
40万辆订单,一周多,史上最大的产品预售
讲到车,他提到了刚发布几周的 Model 3。
这款车的定位从一开始就明确:让普通人买得起的电动车。挪威的预订量在特斯拉门店里排得很靠前,这让团队看到了这个市场的热度。
然后是那组数字。
我们现在有接近40万辆 Model 3 的订单。按金额算,一周多的时间里拿到了40亿到140亿美元的汽车订单。就预订单而言,这是历史上任何品类产品里规模最大的一次发布。(马斯克)
这个数字连特斯拉自己都没预料到。他说预订的热度让团队都感到意外。
他紧接着解释了这款车的设计目标:让大约一半的人负担得起。往后再走一代,做更小的车型,目标是让几乎所有人都买得起。
Model 3 在挪威的交付还要等很久。马斯克说,他迫不及待想把这款车带到挪威。
特斯拉的三步走,是被资源逼出来的
台下有人可能会问:既然一开始就想造人人买得起的电动车,为什么不第一天就造?
马斯克主动回答了。他说,如果特斯拉一开始就有能力造出一款好的、可负担的电动车,那绝对会那么干。一家资源有限的小公司,只有一条路能走通。
第一步,小批量、高价格的跑车。Roadster。
第二步,中等价格、中等批量的车。Model S 和 Model X。
第三步,可负担、大批量的车。Model 3。
这条路走了十几年。他自己形容,过程非常艰难。
他讲了一个更本质的判断:要让一款产品真正进入大众市场,需要两样东西同时到位,多轮的设计迭代,加上规模经济。缺一个都不行。
Roadster 解决的问题是认知。在它之前,公众对电动车的印象是慢、丑、续航短,像高尔夫球车。Roadster 证明电动车可以快、操控可以好、续航可以长,代价是贵。
Model S 解决的问题是日常性。它要能和最好的汽油或柴油豪华车正面竞争,做一辆每天都能开的车。
Model 3 面对的才是真正的难题:便宜,还得大量生产。
这里出现了一个很多人当时没看懂的时间差。Model 3 的产品定义早就有了,为什么拖到2016年才发布?因为电池产能跟不上。没有 Gigafactory,就没有足够的电芯,价格也压不下来。所以特斯拉先做 Model X,把工厂和供应链的摊子铺开,再回头做 Model 3。
顺序被物理条件锁死了,跟营销节奏没什么关系。
部长说对了一件事:不靠禁令,靠产品
对话环节,挪威交通部长接过话筒。
他先肯定了挪威政策对电动车市场的推动作用,然后讲了一段很有意思的观察。他说自己去年11月去旧金山参观特斯拉工厂,印象最深的不是“我们要造更好的车”这个说法,是“我们要改变世界”这个想法。
他强调,改变的方式不是政治上禁止燃油车。
燃油车今天满足了人们对出行的需求。但我们要造的是更好的产品,好到即使燃油车还摆在店里,人们也不想买它。(挪威交通部长)
马斯克接过话头,说他完全同意。
他澄清了一个经常被误读的立场:特斯拉从来没有主张过禁止燃油车。出发点一直很简单,把电动车设计好,让它真的比内燃机车更好。
这个立场在2016年并不流行。当时不少环保组织的主张是限制、禁售、罚款。马斯克选的是另一条路,用产品把对手比下去,让消费者自己投票。
他在别的场合说过类似的话:如果电动车需要靠禁令才能卖出去,那说明产品本身还不够好。
每辆燃油车头上都顶着一个隐形的克朗符号
部长问了那个所有人都在等的问题:什么时候特斯拉可以完全不依赖补贴,和燃油车正面打?
马斯克的回答没有从特斯拉讲起,从一件大多数人不知道的事讲起。
他说,每一辆化石燃料车其实都在享受高额补贴,只是这笔钱不在加油小票上,所以没人注意。
国际货币基金组织做过一项研究。他们不造电动车,也不属于石油天然气行业,纯粹是科学分析。结论是,对石油和天然气的补贴每年至少6万亿美元。这个数字大到难以理解。(马斯克)
他把这笔账拆成两部分。一部分是给油气公司的直接补贴,数额巨大。另一部分是环境负面影响没有被计入价格,经济学里说的外部性。
他的解释很朴素:一种产品的使用会造成长期的环境损害,这个损害是真实成本。如果这个成本没有被算进油价里,那它在效果上就等于一笔补贴。
所以他给了一个画面感很强的说法。你看到一辆汽油车开过去,可以在它头顶上画一个大大的克朗符号,因为那辆车被重度补贴了。
顺着这个逻辑,电动车补贴的意义就变了。它起的作用是把被扭曲的价格先拉平一点,让两种技术能在同一个平面上竞争,跟给新兴产业喂奶没关系。
马斯克说他真正想做的事,是消除化石燃料那笔巨大的隐形补贴,不是给电动车加一笔新的。
补贴真正该做的,是拉平竞争的场地。(马斯克)
这话在2016年说出来是要担风险的。挪威本身就是石油天然气的出口国,国家福利很大一部分来自油气收入。马斯克在别人的地盘上讲这番话,语气却很克制,他没有指责,只是说账要算清楚。
把污染从排气管挪到烟囱,这个质疑站不住
部长提出了一个经典的质疑:电动车的污染只是从排气管转移到了发电厂的烟囱,尤其在有大量煤电的地方。
他先替挪威答了:挪威没有这个问题,电力几乎全部来自水电。
但放到欧洲尺度上,问题就成立了。一个国家的电网以煤电为主,电动车跑起来确实不那么干净。
马斯克的回答绕回了演讲开头。他说这就是他为什么要在挪威花那么多篇幅讲水电。可持续交通的前提是可持续发电,两者必须一起走。
他又一次强调微水电的路径:小坝、分散布局、不干扰当地渔业和野生动物。这套方案在挪威可行,在有水电资源的其他地区同样可行。
这个回答其实回避了一部分问题。煤电地区的电动车到底比燃油车干净多少,取决于电网的碳强度,这是一道需要具体数据的题。马斯克给出的解法是“把电变干净”,他并没有说“电动车在煤电区也一定更环保”。
挪威想让特斯拉建厂,他说招人都难
部长半开玩笑地问:你是不是考虑把特斯拉的生产搬到挪威来,用我们的清洁电力?我们这儿有地方。
马斯克的回答很实在:光是在挪威招销售和售后的人就已经很难了。
但他接着说了一件很多人不知道的事。特斯拉的寒冷天气工程就在挪威做。任何时候,挪威都有一批测试工程师在跑冬季验证,确保车能扛住挪威的冬天。
他还提了一组数字:美国以外,特斯拉在挪威的人均投资是最高的。充电基础设施投了很多钱。
充电网络,他讲了一个态度问题。特斯拉愿意让其他厂商使用自己的充电系统,不打算建围墙花园。2014年特斯拉开放了全部专利,还跟奔驰、丰田做过电动车方面的试点项目。
我们尽力做一个好的参与者,推动可持续交通往前走。(马斯克)
这段话在2016年听起来还挺理想主义。几年之后,特斯拉的超级充电网络在欧洲确实向其他品牌开放了一部分,只是节奏比这里说的要慢得多。
城市拥堵:他藏了一个新车型没说细
部长把话题拉回城市规划。挪威想让城市之间、城乡之间保持流动,又不想让私家车把市中心堵死。他问,特斯拉能不能在公共交通上也带来革命,比如巴士?
马斯克的回答里藏了一个后来才揭晓的东西。
他说特斯拉有一个想法,严格来说不算巴士,但能解决市中心的密度问题。他认为公共交通的整个概念需要重新思考,要造出人们真的喜欢用的东西。
然后他开始打太极。
我不想讲太多细节,因为我这些天说话得小心。我可能在这个场合随口说一句,到了挪威报纸上变成第三版的小豆腐块,然后国际媒体抓住它做成大标题。(马斯克)
台下笑了。他承认自己有“把脚放进嘴里”的坏习惯,还是忍不住透露了一点:这个新车型会把人送到最终目的地,不只送到公交站。
他顺手澄清了一句:跟 Hyperloop 无关。Hyperloop 解决的是城市之间的长途,他要解决的是城市内部的密度问题。
这段话在当时的听众耳朵里可能只是一笔带过。三年后,特斯拉发布了那款造型激进的车型,把它叫做“无聊公司”的地下隧道方案的一部分。2016年4月的奥斯陆,这个想法还只存在于一句“我不想讲太多”里。
Autopilot 开着的时候,事故率低一半
自动驾驶是另一个被追问的话题。部长关心的是信任问题:人们什么时候才会相信机器开车?
马斯克的判断是,信任会来得比想象中快。
他给了一组数据。当时特斯拉车上装的是第一代 Autopilot,功能还很基础。把开启和未开启两种状态的事故率放在一起比,差距很明显。
如果 Autopilot 打开,发生事故的概率大约低50%。事故的判定标准是安全气囊弹出。即便是这个早期版本,它已经差不多是人类司机的两倍好。(马斯克)
这个数据在2016年引起的争议不小。有人质疑统计口径,有人担心它会让人放松警惕。从工程角度看,马斯克想说明的是趋势:机器开车的安全水平会持续往上走,人类司机的水平基本是条水平的线。
部长还问了另一个问题:不同大陆、不同厂商的自动驾驶系统,要不要合作建一套统一的体系?
马斯克认为更可能是各干各的。理由很实际:早期阶段,路上的自动驾驶车占比极低,可能连百分之一都不到。所以一辆自动驾驶车真正要面对的,是身边那一大片还在由人驾驶的车。它必须能应对这种混合环境,安全水平还要明显高于人类司机。
他提到了通过监管审查的方式:用数十亿公里的真实行驶数据,向监管者和公众统计证明,自动驾驶的事故率显著低于人类驾驶。
唯一能说服人的方式,是数据量足够大,结论足够清楚。(马斯克)
为什么不是氢:一次物理学家的算账
有人问了一个根源性的问题:为什么选电池电动,不选氢燃料电池或者生物燃料?
马斯克先讲了自己的思维习惯。他的专业训练是物理学,习惯把所有技术拉回到最基本的层面去评估。
他说自己读大学时就已经看清楚了这件事。太阳能加上电,是一个在物理层面无法被击败的组合。挪威的水电本质上也是间接太阳能,太阳把水蒸发,变成雨落下来。
然后他开始算氢的账。
氢在自然界不以游离状态存在,它要么绑在水里,要么绑在碳氢化合物里。要拿到纯氢,只能电解水,把氢和氧分开,这个过程本身就很耗能。
拿到氢之后,还得压缩或者液化才能装进车里,这又是一大笔能耗。
装进车里还没完,氢要通过燃料电池转化成电能,才能驱动电机。
每一步都有损耗,而且是乘法关系。
如果看整个循环效率,燃料电池系统的理论最好情况,也比纯电差两倍。技术从来不会完美,实际做下来大概差200%到300%。(马斯克)
他把纯电的路径也摆出来对照:从太阳或者水里拿到电,充进电池包,电池包驱动电机。中间几乎没有转换环节,能量损失非常小。
这套算法在2016年并不被所有人接受。支持氢能的人会说,氢适合重卡、适合长途、适合能量密度要求高的场景,还能消化弃风弃光的电。马斯克的判断是,从全链条效率角度看,这条路在乘用车上没有胜算。
他补了一句前提:如果地球上存在某种现成的、不用从水里或碳氢化合物里提取的氢,那燃料电池车就有可能。现实里没有这种东西。
电池每年只进步5%,他打算把这5%放大到30%
一位来自机场运营方的听众提了个很实际的问题。他说特斯拉从85度电做到90、95,也许能到100,什么时候能有翻倍、翻三倍的突破?
马斯克的回答先泼了一盆冷水。
他说电池技术是历史上最难的技术问题之一,无数聪明人试过,爱迪生试过,特斯拉本人也试过,都没成功。做电池本质上是在和热力学定律硬碰硬。
电池比较现实的进步速度,是能量密度每年提升5%到8%,成本每年下降差不多的幅度。(马斯克)
这个数字听起来让人失望。年化5%意味着要十四年才能翻一倍。
但他接着说的是特斯拉真正在做的事。
既然单体的化学体系一年只能进步5%,那就从别的地方把这5%放大。放大倍数来自规模经济。
他讲得很具体:Gigafactory 要把供应链从头到尾整合在一起,原材料用火车从矿山拉进来,另一头出来的是完整的电池包。中间环节全部自己控制,物流、加工、组装都在一个屋檐下。这样可以把5%到8%的自然进步,放大到接近30%。
30%正好是让 Model 3 达到目标售价所需要的幅度。电池工厂必须先建成,车才能发布。
他还给了一个对比:这一座工厂的电池产量,会超过全世界所有其他电池工厂加起来的总和。中国、日本、欧洲,所有现有的电池厂加起来,都不如这一个。
一座钻石形状的工厂,对齐正北
讲到工厂,马斯克的语气变得轻快。
Gigafactory 位于内华达沙漠。他要求工厂在能源上做到自给自足,靠的是太阳能、风能和地热。沙漠里没有水电,地下有地热,可以用来做厂房的温度调节。屋顶铺太阳能板,周围架风机。
还有一层考虑:这是电池工厂,本身就是一个巨大的储能装置。它可以在电力富余时充电,在需要时放电,理论上可以24小时连续运转,甚至向电网回送电力。
然后他说了一件跟工程完全无关的事。
出于一些情感上的原因,我也在意工厂好不好看。所以它是钻石形状的,而且对齐了正北。(马斯克)
施工团队当时一脸困惑,问他为什么要这么干。他的回答是:这些事里得有点浪漫和情感。
这句话在整场对话里显得很轻,但它解释了马斯克做产品的很多选择。功能之外,他总要留一个纯粹为了好看、为了意思对的位置。
油气行业不该被妖魔化,但账要算清楚
最后一位提问者把话题拉回了挪威自己身上。他说挪威的福利制度建立在油气收入上,现在还要在巴伦支海钻更多油。他想听马斯克怎么看。
马斯克先承认了一件不太符合他“电动车布道者”身份的事:中短期内,石油和天然气有存在的必要。
理由是时间。可持续发电和电动车的规模都还在早期,把产能拉起来需要很多年。在过渡期里,直接断掉化石燃料会让经济出问题。
我不倾向于妖魔化油气行业。如果没有它们,经济会崩溃,人会饿死。短期内它是非常必要的。(马斯克)
紧接着他把话锋转回那笔账。真正重要的,是给那些没有被定价的环境影响定一个正确的价格。市场价格机制在价格正确的时候运转得很好,价格错了,整个信号就错了。
他说,油价里没有包含环境成本,这就构成了一种事实上的补贴。把这件事纠正过来,市场自己会完成剩下的工作。
他给挪威的建议是加快转型速度。转型越快,长期的环境影响越小,这件事对全世界都有好处。
这个回答的立场挺微妙。他没有要求挪威立刻停掉油气,也没有为挪威的油气收入辩护。他说的是一个时间表问题:可以继续挖,转型的速度要提到最快。
死在火星,是个不错的结局
对话快结束时,主持人问起了那句著名的话:我想死在火星,只是不希望是撞上去的那种死法。
马斯克先还原了当时的语境。有人问他打算什么时候退休,他说自己没打算退休,等老到干不动了自然该退。那时候去火星退休挺酷。
如果一定要死在某个地方,死在火星是个不错的结局。(马斯克)
现场笑了。这个回答听起来像玩笑,放在整场对话的语境里,它和前面那些数字是连着的。
从挪威的水电,到6万亿美元的化石燃料补贴,到电池每年5%的进步速度,到一座钻石形状的工厂。这些东西看起来各说各的,实际上都指向同一个判断:人类需要一个更长期的坐标。
2016年的马斯克还没有把星舰拿出来。SpaceX 当时在做的还是猎鹰9号的回收试验,火星计划停留在概念阶段。但在奥斯陆这场对话里,他已经把时间尺度拉到了几十年之后。
电动车替代燃油车要几十年,全球电力结构转型要几十年,让人类成为多行星物种也要几十年。这些事在他嘴里是同一个句子的不同分句。
这场对话里藏着的几个判断
回头看2016年4月的这场对话,有几个判断后来被验证了,有几个还在路上。
被验证的部分:Model 3 的订单量证明了平价电动车的市场需求确实存在,后来的交付地狱也证明了“规模经济”这道坎有多难跨。Gigafactory 的产能确实在几年内超过了全球其他电池厂的总和。Autopilot 的数据积累路径成了行业标准做法。
还在路上的部分:挪威的水电向外输送,受限于跨国电网的建设速度,进展比想象中慢。氢燃料电池在乘用车上没成气候,在重卡和航运上找到了位置。城市内部交通的新方案,至今没有拿出一个让人信服的答案。
马斯克在对话里最坚持的一件事,是把所有问题拉回物理和经济学的基本面。电池为什么进步慢,因为热力学。氢为什么效率低,因为转换链条太长。燃油车为什么看起来便宜,因为环境成本没有计入价格。公共交通为什么不好用,因为设计的时候没有把人的体验放在第一位。
这套思维方式比任何单个结论都更有价值。它不依赖预测,只依赖算账。
- 看一项技术值不值得投,先算全链条效率。从能源源头到最终做功,每一段转换都要计入损耗。氢能的问题出在中间那几道转换上,跟氢本身无关。
- 看一个产品的价格,先问它有没有包含外部成本。油价、电价、机票价,都可能有没被计入的环境账。谁在享受隐形补贴,谁在裸奔竞争,看清楚了再下判断。
- 看一个行业的进步速度,别指望突破,先看年化。电池每年5%到8%是常态,谁能在工程和供应链上把这5%放大成30%,谁就赢。这个逻辑适用于光伏、储能、芯片封装。
- 看政策,重点不落在补多少,在补的方向有没有纠正扭曲。给电动车补贴的目的如果是拉平化石燃料的隐形优势,那它是临时工具;如果变成长期依赖,它就成了新的扭曲。
- 看一个国家的资源禀赋,别只看地底下有什么,也看地上常年有什么。油气会枯竭,水流不会。挪威真正的优势是峡湾,不是油田。
- 做长期的事,给自己留一点“不必要”的东西。一座钻石形状、对齐正北的工厂不影响产能,但它决定了团队怎么看待自己做的事。
0:10so most pleasure to be in Norway I always have a great time always look forward to to visiting and in fact I on this visit to europe I'm only in a way this is I'm just coming for you so I think I'd like to just express a word of appreciation thanks for the support of Norway for electric vehicles and being the leader in the world on a per capita basis for the adoption of electric vehicles I think everyone in Norway should be incredibly proud of that fact i think that's that's wonderful and at
0:49Tesla we actually I can sort Norway to the Pioneer particularly for cold weather activity and it remains the case that our top individual customer in the world it lives in Narvik so obviously it's above the Arctic Circle and he's a such a big fan that he bought a bunch of Tesla's and he's just letting the townspeople use them whenever they want so great guy so let's see I think for
1:31you know thinking clear both sides of the energy equation there's sustainable energy generation and the sustainable energy consumption so on the one side Norway has a tremendous structural advantage with with the fjords and being able to generate immense amounts of hydropower and that's something that I think that can be done it in a way that's aesthetically in harmony with the environment and doesn't disrupt the local ecology and I think this immense growth central a really immense growth potential in Norwegian hydropower which when combined with long-distance high efficiency power lines and actually supply a very significant portion of Northern Europe's electricity needs so I
2:26think you know as the world transitions away from hydrocarbons Norway's actually it in an excellent position maybe the best position of any country in the world to ramp up sustainable power generation and and and and then the great thing about disabled power is that it's a long term industry and long-term revenue source so I think people know we
3:03should feel very optimistic about the future as the world transitions away from away from higher hydrocarbons and yeah so I think doing great sort of leading into single power generation leading in sustainable transport noise doing an amazing job and as leader in the world so you know it's sort of like the gradual ations is an order and people should feel great really great about that let's see in the looking into
3:41the future on the transport side obviously it's incredibly important that we achieve affordable electric cars Tiesto recently announced the model 3 which is a much more affordable EV actually got charisma of interest from Norway redlines at our stores which shows the level of interest so really looking forward to producing a great affordable electric car which is which has been Tesla's mission from the beginning so if we could impact it we could have produced a great before we'll lectric are on day one that's absolutely what we would have done but but the only way to success was for small company with limited resources where's the start off with a low volume
4:30high priced car go to a mid-price mid volume car and ultimately to an affordable high volume car and that's what we're sort of getting to step three which is obviously vital to have a real effect on the world so the the model 3 the affordability car is has really been the dream of Tesla from the front beginning and we had the product launch
4:56a few days ago a few weeks ago I mean and the interest level actually its prized even us we had we're now almost 400,000 orders for the model 3 which actually makes it the in terms of pre-orders the highest the space the biggest product launch of of any of any kind of car or otherwise in history
5:27because it's sort of on the order of 4 to 14 billion dollars worth of car orders in a little over a week so I think that that that's great and it shows that people have a lot of faith that we can going to produce a great affordable electric car and I think they're right I think this car is going to be great for middle-class families and so I can't wait to bring that to Norway so I'd like to give a word of
6:00thanks also to the the people in Norway who have for a long time fought for sustainable transport and sustainable energy I know that people that have been fighting for over 30 years to support electric vehicles and sustainable energy and satellite say thank you to those people and we wouldn't be where we are in no way today without their support and just the general thank you to the Norwegian people and the New Eden Norwegian government for their support of electric vehicles at up yeah so I've
6:44phrase frequently say which is I love Norway and so yeah so thank you for your support and like I said my message is very simple which is no year Norway has a training opportunity probably the best opportunity of any country in the world for sustainable energy production it needs to be done in a thoughtful way such that it's just it's aesthetically appealing blends into the local environment it doesn't disrupt the local fisheries and wildlife which i think is very doable and i think that's that's a
7:25very exciting future for the country see but i think that's that's mostly what i wanted to say and i think we're going to go into a QA and so will do sort of a back-and-forth conversation and then if there's anyone in the audience who wants to ask questions of any kind then i'd love to hear your questions I think it's always good to get it back and forth going with with the audience all right thank you we do prefer small questions
8:03from the audience now or should we sit down with a minister and yeah I think listen Sarah with the minister have that discussion and then turn it to audience questions thank you all right okay hey that's me mr. muskie
8:42well mr. Minister let me ask by asking you he's saying thank you to Norway and that we are in such a special global position to to be the sort of for running country what's your initial reaction to that well I'm glad if with Norwegian Policy Center weeding consumers police have aided the development of the new products electric cars I'm also glad to see though that many of the big car producers are looking at what you're doing and are trying to compete nothing is crappy and battery however what impressed me when I visited your factory in san francisco in november last year was not the idea would with the people saying that we're going to produce a better car but it's
9:28also the idea that by doing this we're going to change the world we're going to change the way business works we're going to change the way the market works by producing not not by trying you know they don't complete with me you have to ban the electrical know that the fossil fuel car the idea was that well the fossil fuel card that's meeting the demands today the necessity for mobility however we're going to produce the next product the better product which means that even with the fossil fuel cars being available people are not going to want to buy them yeah and that's where i think you know she's shown that you how are we getting a little bit of
10:04government aid from around the world you're going to beat the competitors in the marketplace not by having politicians band the computer competition I agree it totally agree a phosphate Tesla from the beginning has been to show that an electric car if it's designed well can actually be better than internal Russian car and you know for a long time
10:29people one of the impression that electric cars had to be slow not good looking low range kind of like a golf cart and so it was extremely important to to break that misperception to change that misperception and I think with the sports car roaster we're able to show you can actually have a fast electric off good handling long range that looks good even though it was very expensive and then with the Model S queer showing you can actually have an electric car as a daily driver and has and it can compete against the best of the the gasoline or diesel premium TVs and now
11:11with the model 3 we're a third generation with much higher state economies of scale we've got the gigafactory and we've got the much high-volume production line and there's really two things that are necessary to achieve a compelling mass-market product you need to have multiple design iterations and you need economies of scale so I think we're finally taking a long time and it's been a difficult journey very difficult journey but I'm
11:42super excited about being able to reduce a car that that most people can afford and they'll be future cars that that you know even more affordable down the road but with something like the model 3 it's it's designed to be able to achieve it's designed such that hat off Lee half of people can afford the car and then with 4th generation and smaller cars and whatnot will ultimately be in the position where I think almost everyone can afford the car but if I may when you look in the future how long until you really don't care about government policies when it comes to subsidies or tax deductions where where the project is affordable enough that you compete
12:29head-to-head with a few cars yeah I think that's an excellent question but the thing that I think people don't totally appreciate is that every fossil fuel car is quite heavily subsidized it may not seem like that bit but it is so if you if you see if you look at like the IMF study the IMF you know which doesn't have any actually grind one or the other don't
12:56make electric cars and they're not part of the oil and gas industry is just a scientific analysis they concluded that the subsidies to oil and gas are at least at least six trillion dollars per year I think most people don't don't realize that and so every time you see a gasoline car going down the road you imagine a big kronor sign on on top of
13:23that car in front of it it'll be exactly if it's heavily subsidized because of the the both the direct subsidies that the oil and gas companies get which are enormous and the subsidy on the negative effect of the environment so what we effectively have this is economics 101 you know like basically every every
13:49economist we you know would agree with us is that whenever you have an unprofessional T essentially in where the use of the product causes long-term damage to the environment that that's that that is a true cost and if that cost is not incorporated into the price of petroleum then effectively it's a
14:15subsidy so just so it's real important to to appreciate this because I think a lot of people just don't even know the the level of subsidies that oil and gas and it gets a guest in the world it's really a figure that is so large that it's difficult to even comprehend so the the what what the sub seasons
14:38so really intended to do is to even the playing field to even the playing field between the tremendous subsidies and incentives that oil and gas gets compared to getting electric car so so that that really the thing to do is to try to eliminate the gigantic incentives for for for gasoline or for oil and gas
15:05in order to get that that in order just to compete on a level plane thank you are you happy with the level of subsidies right now mr. Minister I think the a level of subsidies will be different from country to country when you look at some of the countries where you really subsidize fossil fuel gasoline diesel course that's not that's not the direction we want to go into you yeah however what I want to do you expand a little bit on this one when skeptics talk about the electric car they say well you remove the pollution from the car but you move it into the cow coal power plant instead so don't know we have a lot of coal power plants Norway does not -huh but from a
15:46European scale you know because if we're going to change the world and not just Norway you have also you know how do you make the energy production greener and get it not just the car which is exactly why I emphasized in my talk no way has a tremendous geographic advantage with hydro power like said it should the hydropower always be done in a way that fits that fits in aesthetically with the local environment and that doesn't doesn't disrupt local fisheries and that kind of thing which it can be done particularly if you go with sort of micro dams or small small downs you know so it's not like a giant hydroelectric plant but it's sort of sort of a small
16:29it's a series of sort of micro hydro plants those those can be done with no disruption to the to the environment mr. musk are are you implying here that you might consider moving the production of of Tesla to Norway or using our clean power we do have space available well I have to say even just
17:02hiring people for sales and service in Norway has been hard the yeah we'll talk in the day but you know what the information may be filled I know this but we do our our cold weather engineering in in Norway I don't know if you know that but so there's actually at any given point there's a lot of test engineers in Norway doing cold weather engineering and testing and validation and making sure that the car works well for Norwegian winter and so we actually do have a lot of activities in Norway and also we've invested a lot in EV
17:51charging infrastructure and we've also said that we're happy to have other manufacturers use our charging systems so we're not trying to create a walled garden I we really tried doing our best to help other manufacturers as much as possible last year we made our patents freely available to other car companies and we've done pilot programs with Mercedes and Toyota for EVs to sort of get them educated on on electric vehicles so we're doing our best to be a good sportsman and to facilitate the
18:25advancement of sustainable transport and but yeah I really wanna emphasize like outside of the US the Tesla's investment per capita is actually the highest in Norway yeah but you're doing it from tremendous job in showing industry that you can make greener cars however when we look at developing our country we want mobility between the cities in the countryside however we also want to avoid overcrowding the cities with personal cars you've done a tremendous job to to kind of remove pollution from the cars driving in the city spot which makes a big difference on health it does however can we expect test also to help revolutionize mass transit when it comes
19:13to buses if we can have more people drive their Tesla or electric car to help outside the cities but still go mass transit into the cities we will do something with the pleasantness of the city with we have an idea for something which is not exactly a bus but would solve the density problem for inner-city
19:35situations I think we need to actually rethink the whole concept of public transport and create something that that is that people actually going to like a lot more I don't want to talk too much about it because sorry are you talking about the Hyperloop no no no the Hyperloop is great for going between cities but I'd be careful what I say
20:02these days you're among friends personally I you know what'll happen is I'll I'll I'll make an offhand comment in you know with a group like this and then it'll be like a small you know maybe it like page 3 of an article in the Norwegian newspaper then international press will seize on that and turn it into a big headline so for my foot in my I mean unfortunately you're thinking about my bad habit of putting my foot in my mouth unfortunately but but but I don't think your bank dantdm I might but I very much agree with solving the high-density urban transport problem and I think this this is a new type of car or vehicle
20:51that I think would be really great for that and actually take people to their final destination not just to the bus stop which i think is great and then someone so where do you see autonomous vehicles in this autonomous vehicles are key it's Kiki and will people trust it or how long till people will trust it I think people will trust it surprisingly quickly the feedback we've gotten from our autonomous version 1 which is in
21:20Tesla's today has been extremely positive and when we look at the data I mean this is a real interesting fact of cars that with if the autopilot is turned on or off you're probably it take the probably of having an accident is fifty percent lower if you have autopilot on even with our first version so we can see basically the how many kilometers what's the average number of kilometers to in it to an accident accident defined by airbag deployment and it's and even with this early version it's it's almost twice as good
22:02as a person but to have this work in a society where you have a lot of different automakers from different continents how important will it be for them to cooperate to make kind of a hub modernized system or or it's really every car going to be independent so it doesn't matter what kind of system you have in the other car it's more like I think it's more likely to be the latter because in the beginning the percentage of autonomous cars will be very low so it's it's critical for the autonomous car to be able to handle a large number of non autonomous cars as good at really with a safety level higher than a human driver that's the threshold and I think
22:44it's going to be important in terms of satisfying regulators in the public to show statistically with a large amount of data with billions of kilometers of driving to say that the safety level is definitively better by a meaningful meaningful majin if its autonomous versus non autonomous I think that's the really the thing that will convincing when if I may if when he's decided to kind of start to try to change things why did you choose battery-electric as your source of drivetrain why not hydrogen or why not just go with biofuels well my main
23:22training and mindset is that of a physicist so I tend to think of things in a very sort of kind of physics framework because I think that's like the best framework for critical thinking and for evaluating technologies at a fundamental level and I mean even when I was in college it was very obvious to me that electric was the right path because the fundamental efficiency of em in solar being the isola in the case of norway hydro which is effectively indirect solar you know the sun is really vibrating water raining and so that's it sort of in a form of indirect solar but Isola is a sole solar plus
24:06electric is an unbeatable combination for at a first-principles physics level for having the most efficient sustainable system and I mean to me this is as obvious as day and night and the now if there was a readily available source of hydrogen that wasn't bound up in water or bound up in hydrocarbons then there would be the possibility of a fuel cell vehicle but if your cell vehicle relies on hydrogen so the only way to get the hydrogen is to electrolyze water and split the hydrogen and oxygen apart which is a very energy intensive and inefficient process and then once you've split the hydrogen off you've then got to compress it or render it to liquid form which also takes a
25:03tremendous amount of energy then you go to store it and and then once even once it gets in the car it then has to go through a fuel cell power plant to get turned into energy and only then can the other energy be applied to the electric motor so if you look at the total cycle efficiency of a fuel cell system it is
25:29at least twice as bad well it's theoretical best case is twice as bad as electric in terms of the the energy cycle that's if the technology is perfect then the technology is not perfect so it ends up being maybe 200 to 300 percent worse than solar solar electric alternative because the solar electric alternative use it's dead simple and the energy transfers are very high efficiency essentially collect power from the Sun or from you know hydro or the and then you charge a battery pack which with almost no energy losses and that's it you're done perhaps we should open for some questions from the audience now time flies really quickly so please keep your questions
26:15brief and precise there's a there's a microphone somewhere it's over that please introduce yourself and Bob oh sorry talk for Peterson of annoyed airport operator but this is all about airport is about batteries what we see all I mean talk about Tesla and SpaceX impressive but what about the battery technology we see that Tesla is moving incremental from 85 to 90 and 95 maybe 100 but when will you see a giant leap in this double or triple the capacity of the batteries that you already have is that coming soon on I have to say that battery technology is one of the most difficult technological problems in history I mean so many smart people in
27:15the course of history I have tried so hard to improve batteries and you're really just fighting the laws of thermodynamics very very hard in creating a battery you know I mean Edison it was a great inventor tried super hard and he didn't succeed and many many very you know Tesla try himself tried and didn't succeed some of the smartest people in history have tried very hard what what actually tends to happen with batteries is that the improvements tend to be maybe five to
27:56eight percent per year in energy density and then an approximately that improvement in cost now with the gigafactory where we're trying to take economies of scale to the maximum limit in order to reduce the costs even further just just by having economies of scale and a look and and having a
28:18tightly integrated supply chain that goes from raw materials coming in from on rail cars from from mines and out comes a completed battery pack that this is the most efficient that we're taking that like the look that the fundamental economic efficiencies to the maximum which is why I think that in addition to the natural progression of batteries and energy density and cost of five to eight percent with the gigafactory we can actually amplify that to as much as thirty percent which is very important for achieving the affordable car and that's what's the reason why we did the Model X before during the model 3 is because creating the gigafactory which
29:06does have a lot of advanced technology in it because it's going to be making the more batteries of the gigafactory than the rest within the rest of all world combined so get up every battery factory in China Japan Europe anywhere combine this one factory that we're building will produce more battery output then all of them together and i want to emphasize it's designed to be energy neutral in its energy usage so we're using a combination of solar wind and geothermal and where we are in the
29:44Nevada desert there's not a lot of hydro that there is in Vegas because you have to give a damn but not not where we are but using geothermal for temperature conditioning of the factory particularly and then wind and solar for the rest of the factory and of course it's a battery factory so we can buffer the energy so we can go 24 7 with a factory that generates its own energy and might actually end up generating additional energy to give back to the grid and I
30:17mean for sentimental reasons I also care about the aesthetics of the the battery factory so it's it's a it's shaped like it shaped like it like a diamond and aligned on True North and my construction guys like what are you why were doing thats like gonna have some romance and sentimentality in these things one more question where's the way
30:43and we love hearing that but norway is based on them our income from oil and gas now we'll be drilling for more oil and gas in the barents sea to to preserve their welfare state i would like to hear what is your point of view on this sure well i agree with the minister in that there is actually a
31:08necessary short to medium-term role for oil and gas because the sustainable power generation and electric vehicles are still at the early stage and it takes time to scale up and get to high volumes so the the real thing that really that that's that's important is for for hydrocarbons is to correctly
31:39price the the unpriced externality of the impact on the environment so market mechanisms work very well when the pricing is correct but if the pricing does not of oil and gas does not include the environment environmental impact that that is a de facto subsidy and so I mean I'm sort of just inclined to vilify the
32:06oil and gas industry because if we didn't have them then we would have economic collapse and people were starving to death I mean it's it's it is very necessary in the short term and it's just it's just that we need to be taking the steps to accelerate the transition to a sustainable energy economy in Norway and throughout the world as quickly as possible and the faster we do that the better of the world will be and the lower will be the long-term environmental impact we're running out of time I'm afraid if I can just ask you towards the end that you famously said that I'd like to die on Mars just not on impact how far are you away from that from impacting yeah sure
32:55so I mean that was actually prefaced by it somebody asked me when I was going to retire and I said like well I don't really plan to retire I mean hopefully at some point when I'm you know too old to do a good job then obviously I should retire and then it would be kind of cool to retire Mars and visit Mars but you
33:19know not if you're going to die somewhere you know it would be cool to die Mars that's a nice ending you actually mr. musk thank you so much for coming mr. Minister thank you for joining us here on stage thank you
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版