大会演讲·中文精读

马斯克 ISS 研发大会完整演讲:SpaceX、NASA、隧道、太阳能

Elon Musk Full Talk @ ISS R&D Conference, July 19, 2017 : SpaceX; NASA; Tunnels; Solar

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2017年7月,马斯克出现在ISS研发大会(ISS R&D Conference)的台上,跟NASA空间站项目经理Kirk Shireman聊了一个小时。开场没多久,他就给台下所有人泼了一盆冷水,说的是Falcon Heavy。

这枚火箭有相当大的概率进不了轨道。我希望它至少能飞离发射台足够远,不至于把发射台炸坏。说实话,能到这一步我就觉得算赢了。(马斯克)

他把这趟发射形容为"major pucker factor",一个不太好翻译的俚语,大意是紧张到括约肌收紧。他补充说,这个描述会劝退一部分想坐首飞的人,但人数确实在变少,还是有人愿意上。

这场对话信息密度很高。火箭复用、整流罩回收、商业载人、火星架构、人工智能监管、隧道掘进、教育方法,全在一个小时里过了一遍。下面是整理后的精读。

一托盘现金从天上掉下来

先说整流罩(fairing)。就是火箭顶上那个巨大的鼻锥,里面能塞下一整辆城市公交车。马斯克给出的价格是五六百万美元,包含声学阻尼、分离系统、全部认证在内。

他跟团队讲这个事的说法很有意思:

等于说,我们有一托盘现金,六百万美元,正从天上掉下来。我们要不要去接一下?我说要,试一把。最坏的结果是它掉进海底,但万一接住了呢,那就是六百万美元。(马斯克)

主持人接了一句,说他也想去接那托盘现金。马斯克说,它跟一托盘现金也没区别,因为成本就是六百万。

他的判断是,年底之前有不错的概率把整流罩收回来,明年底或者后年初有可能实现复飞。

这里有个成本账要说清楚。猎鹰9的上面级大约占一次任务成本的20%。如果助推器和整流罩都能重复使用,那剩下不可回收的部分就只剩20%左右,也就是80%的硬件可以反复用。对很多任务来说,他甚至认为第二级也有机会带回来,但优先级排在后面。

24小时复飞,连漆都不换

过去两年SpaceX在技术上最大的一件事,是猎鹰9(Falcon 9)一级助推器成功着陆。马斯克建议所有人都去卡纳维拉尔角或者范登堡看一眼,说那个场面"真的挺好玩"。

更要紧的是后面的目标。他说,不久的将来,很可能就是明年,猎鹰9助推器能做到24小时之内再次复飞。实现路径听起来很朴素:

你只做检查,不更换任何硬件,连漆都不换。这一点非常重要。当然前提是必须保证任务可靠性和安全。(马斯克)

这跟航天飞机时代的翻修逻辑完全不同。航天飞机每次飞完都要大拆大卸,成千上万个零件重新检测更换,成本压不下来,周转周期也压不下来。马斯克要的是飞机逻辑:落地、加油、再起飞。

他提到那年剩下的时间里还有大约12次发射。

NASA那套货运合同,他说该推广到整个政府

这场对话里有一段很少有人注意,但信息量很大。主持人问行业进展,马斯克开口先谈NASA的商业货运合同模式,技术反而放在后面讲。

他把它拆成几个要素:两家公司竞争、固定价格、按里程碑付款、里程碑主要是硬件交付。如果其中一家没走到里程碑,剩下的里程碑就重新竞标给另一家公司。

这个模式真实跑过一遍。最初是SpaceX和Kistler两家,Kistler做了一些进展但没能冲过终点线,第二名的位置重新竞标,Orbital Sciences接手并完成了。现在SpaceX和Orbital同时在给空间站运货。

马斯克对这件事的评价很高,说这是"一个执行得非常好的模型",而且他在前一周的州长会议上就拿这个当例子,说政府其他领域也该这么干。

这段话的分量在于,说话的人是一个承包商。他在夸客户设计的规则让自己不得不保持竞争力。

顺带还有个花絮。马斯克说他很长一段时间里密码是"I love NASA",然后意识到这话在全球直播,说"全世界的黑客现在都开始试了",得赶紧改。台下笑成一片。

载人比货运难在哪儿

谈到商业载人(Commercial Crew),马斯克的措辞明显变了。

它比货运难得多,这一点毫无疑问。人一进入画面,整个事情的等级就跳了一大截,必须保证一切都不能出错。(马斯克)

NASA的监管强度也完全不同。他说货运的监管已经不算松,但载人的强度是"really intense"。他承认这对SpaceX的工程师来说有时候挺难受,但他清楚这套要求的出发点是对的。

接下来他说了句挺有意思的话:明年会有一堆细节技术上的争论,有些议题非常偏门,除非你真的钻进了火箭和飞船设计的深处,否则听起来就像在讲希腊语,还是古希腊语。

但他认为这种争论本身是健康的。两家都是工程师,工程师就靠这个活着。

目标时间点他说得很清楚:按照对NASA的承诺,2018年年中把宇航员送上空间站。他提了一句这件事的公众意义,美国本土已经很久没有发射过宇航员了。

那艘复飞的龙飞船,成本几乎等于新建一艘

主持人提到最近龙飞船的复飞,马斯克当场承认,这件事SpaceX自己没宣传好。

我们真该把这件事说得更大声一点,因为这是航天飞机退役之后,第一次有轨道飞船复飞。我觉得公众根本不知道这件事。(马斯克)

然后他主动交代了不太好听的部分。SpaceX内部会计给出的数字是,这次复飞的成本几乎等于从头造一艘新的龙飞船。他自己怀疑内部会计没把某些项算进去。

这一艘确实情况特殊,溅落时进了水,返工量很大。他的预期是下一艘能把成本压到新建的一半左右。主持人当时就笑着说,自己的合同还在桌上呢,马斯克这是在跟自己谈判。

马斯克马上接话,说SpaceX希望给NASA最好的条件,只是预算总盘子要涨从来都很难。

说到这儿他补了一句判断:NASA的预算顶线如果能提高,能做成的事会多到一般人根本想象不出来。

Falcon Heavy:27台发动机同时点火

回到开头那个问题。有观众问Falcon Heavy和绕月私人飞行的风险怎么管。

马斯克的第一句话是:这需要27台轨道级发动机同时点火,能出问题的地方太多了。

难点在于很多东西没法在地面测。地面能点火试车,但模拟不了27台发动机一起工作时的耦合动力学,模拟不了跨音速阶段的气流,也模拟不了Max Q附近的载荷行为。他说这枚火箭会遭遇严重的跨音速抖振。

然后是那段最坦率的自白:有相当大的概率进不了轨道,希望大家把预期调好。

他还讲了个技术细节,说明Falcon Heavy比外界想的难得多。最初的想法很简单,把两个一级当助推器绑上去就行,能有多难。结果全变了:所有载荷工况变了,气动完全变了,振动和声学环境翻了三倍,很多硬件的认证包线直接被突破。中间芯级要同时承受两个超强助推器的推力,整个芯级机身重新设计过,跟猎鹰9完全不是一回事。分离系统也是新的。

他用了"naive"这个词形容当初的判断。

回报也摆在那儿:完全优化后,Falcon Heavy的运载能力大约是猎鹰9的2.5倍,低地球轨道(LEO)超过10万磅,差不多50吨,优化后还能再高一点。

绕月这件事的技术底子也讲了。Falcon Heavy有足够能力把龙飞船2(Dragon 2)送上绕月自由返回轨道。龙飞船2的隔热罩设计余量很大,足以应付月球再入,尤其如果先做一次掠过减速、第二次再入,更稳妥。

至于首飞上的人,他的评价是:谁上谁勇敢。

龙飞船不再推进着陆,因为火星方案变了

有观众问,听说龙飞船不打算做推进着陆了,是真的吗。

马斯克说这个决定很艰难。技术上龙飞船2仍然具备推进着陆能力,只是隔热罩上那几个伸出来的小支腿被删掉了,所以要落在相当平整柔软的着陆场上才行。

放弃的主因有两个。一是要通过载人安全认证,工作量巨大。二是更根本的:他曾经认为龙飞船那种带底部隔热罩、侧面装推进器的方案是登陆火星的正确路径,现在他确信那条路不对,下一代火箭和飞船会走另一套方案。

技术路线变了,为它做的适航认证投入就失去了意义。他没有完全关死这扇门,说以后有可能捡回来。

火星飞船缩小了一圈,因为要自己赚钱

主持人提到2016年瓜达拉哈拉国际宇航大会(IAC)上的火星演讲,问什么时候会公开更新。

马斯克说大概是当年9月阿德莱德那届IAC,架构变化挺大。

变化的核心跟钱有关。

最要紧的是我们怎么付得起去火星这件事,它非常非常贵。我的想法是把火星飞船的尺寸缩小,让它同时能承接地球轨道的业务,用地球轨道赚的钱来支付火星。(马斯克)

这是新版架构里最重要的一个改动。上一版是一个专门为火星设计的巨型运载系统,除了去火星没别的用处,收入从哪里来是个死结。新版本把飞行器做小,让它能接地球轨道的商业订单,靠日常营收养活火星计划。他说尺寸比原来小,但还是很大,只是这一版"有机会成真"。

推进剂的选择也讲了。火星运输飞行器主要用甲烷,因为甲烷储箱的体积只有氢的一半左右。火星大气是二氧化碳,地下有大量水冰,这两样凑起来能合成甲烷。他提到如果往更远的地方走,氢的吸引力会上升,因为那时候只需要水。

火星大气还有个好笑的评价:刚好够到"不够用来气动减速,但足以让事情变得很麻烦"的程度。

去火星路上,最坏情况相当于一路抽烟

一位基因组学博士生问长期任务中的生物医学风险。

马斯克先给了个不加修饰的版本:去火星不适合心脏弱的人,有风险、危险、不舒服,你可能会死。然后说,很多人会回答"打死我也不去",也有一些人会回答"打死我也要去"。

辐射这块他给了个具体类比。最坏情况下,路上的辐射剂量大致相当于一路抽烟。抽烟确实很糟,但配以适度屏蔽,可以挡掉相当大比例的入射粒子,剩下的边际癌症风险不至于成为拦路虎。他强调这是截至目前的最好判断。

接着讲了个他刚学到的东西。他原先以为太阳风粒子是从太阳方向直线吹出来的,实际上粒子沿着磁力线走,所以可能从侧面打过来,跟太阳方向正交。防护不能只做迎风面,四五个方向都得考虑。

人类在太空连续驻留的最长纪录是一年多一点,而火星任务按现在的方案是三年。ISS上正在做的长期驻留研究,就是在补这块数据缺口。他补了一句,火星的相对位置每26个月才和地球对上大约6个月,如果能把这个往返压进3个月以内,同一艘飞船的复用频率能翻倍。这给了快速往返一个很强的经济理由。

火星不会有资源战争,土地多得很

一个住在卡纳维拉尔角附近的观众问,火星殖民地建成100年后,各国会不会为了最好的资源打起来。

马斯克的回答很直接:火星上地多得是,人没几个,不会出现资源稀缺导致的冲突。他还开了个玩笑,说如果火星上真有人,那他们藏得可真好,肯定比我们聪明得多。

他也承认人类文明史上战争不少,不指望上了火星就永久和平。

但他给了个更有意思的制度设想:与其让所有国家联合成一队一起去,不如让两三个国家联盟各自组队,友好竞争谁进展更快。他的类比是奥运会,如果所有人手拉手一起冲过终点线,那比赛就没意思了。

AI是双重指数,政府该先建机构再定规则

一位国会工作人员问到AI风险,以及作为政策制定者该做什么。

马斯克先解释了为什么这件事难判断:硬件能力在指数增长,投入AI的软件人才也在指数增长,两个指数叠在一起,预测会极其困难,而且几乎所有预测都偏保守,实际情况比预测来得更早。

他举了两个例子。一个是生成对抗网络(GAN),两个网络互相对抗,一个生成视频,一个找出哪里假,然后反复迭代,直到人眼分不出真假。另一个是AlphaGo,全世界都以为击败围棋还要20年甚至永远不可能,结果发生了。一年之后,同一套系统能同时击败排名前50的棋手,对手胜率为0%。

AI能施展的自由度,每年增加大约10个数量级。这非常疯狂。(马斯克)

他还提到硬件层面的变化:GPU比CPU在神经网络上强一个数量级,而为神经网络专门优化的芯片又比GPU强一个数量级,这类芯片当年底或次年会集中上市。也就是说,现在的AI进展还是跑在不那么合适的硬件上。

政策建议他讲得很具体,也很克制。他主张分两步走:先成立一个政府监管机构,初期只做一件事,就是获取洞察。大家都还在摸黑的时候仓促出手定规则,那是拍脑袋。等洞察积累起来,再开始施加规则。

我们有FAA管飞机,有机构管汽车、药品、食品,没人希望这些机构消失。(马斯克)

他要防的是"抄近路",即在AI安全上偷工减料。他的判断是这件事会像海啸一样到来。

Neuralink:打不过就加入

一位再生医学研究者问到脑机接口对太空探索的意义。

马斯克把Neuralink的动机讲得很白:它首先是对AI存在性风险的一个对冲。他的判断是人类智能不可能在通用意义上赢过AI,那就剩下"打不过就加入"这条路,让AI成为个体人类意志的延伸。

顺带的好处会先到来:中风、脑损伤、先天性缺陷、老年记忆衰退这些问题的治疗。他强调这些会远早于"人脑与AI共生"出现,而且整个过程是渐进的,不会一夜之间发生。

他还提了一句,这件事让他对载人探索的长期必要性更有信心,探索不必全部交给机器人。

教育的毛病:从来不解释"为什么"

这个问题来自一位做教育科技的人。马斯克的回答值得单独拎出来。

他说自己看到的最大问题,是老师不解释为什么要学这门课。孩子被直接丢进数学里,不知道学它干什么,只觉得这些题目莫名其妙。

"为什么"极其重要,因为大脑是进化出来会主动丢弃它认为无关的信息的。你一边要求孩子背公式,一边不告诉他公式为什么成立,就制造了认知失调:看起来没用,但被告知必须记住,否则会被惩罚,那就只好硬记。

他给了一个替代方案,用拆发动机打比方。把一台发动机拆开、再装回去,这个任务本身会逼着你去用扳手、螺丝刀、千斤顶、内六角。在解决拆装问题的过程里,你自然学会了这些工具,也理解了它们为什么重要。

反过来,如果开一门"扳手课",学生的反应只会是:这东西有什么意思。

把知识挂在要解决的问题上,相关性就建立起来了,孩子会兴奋,知识也留得住。

他顺势夸了CubeSat这类项目。做一颗立方星,你会被迫搞明白太阳能板怎么工作、轨道动力学怎么算、电池和电子系统怎么配、控制系统怎么设计。因为你要让这颗卫星真的能用,所以这些学科你都得学。

他把设计制造飞行器、Formula SAE大学生方程式赛车这类项目,都归到同一类有效的学习工具里。

隧道和火星地下城,是同一套手艺

主持人问他,Boring Company除了交通,会不会也做栖息地。

马斯克的回答是,把掘进这件事练熟,对火星确实有用。火星上需要大量冰矿开采和原材料开采,也需要挖地下空间做辐射屏蔽。理论上你可以在火星地下建一整座城市,人还是会想时不时上地面看看,但主体可以在地下。

他指出了一个现实障碍:现在的地球掘进机非常重,因为地球上没人操心重量,越重越稳。要送上火星,得重新设计成极轻的版本,还要适应火星的不同工况。这可不是小改动。

他还提到好奇号(Curiosity)的轮子被火星砂石磨坏这件事,说明那个环境跟地球的差别有多细微又多致命。

顺便,他讲了南得克萨斯的第三发射场,在布朗斯维尔附近。理由是冗余:万一卡纳维拉尔角来飓风,空间站还得有人送货,从南得克萨斯能发出去,服务不会断。

隧道这件事他自己怎么看的?

有点奇怪,它其实是个压力很小的活动,因为所有人都预期它会失败。我关于隧道的一个冷笑话是,它的期望值很低。(马斯克)

主持人补了一句:只能往下走。马斯克说,我可以一直讲下去。

他还讲了自己的外号变迁史。做互联网的时候别人叫他"互联网小子",意思是这人做太空肯定要失败。后来没人这么叫了,改叫"交通小子"。

公众为什么不再抬头看

最后一位提问者来自一家做全球宇航员培训的公司,问公众参与的意义。

马斯克的回答有两层。第一层很朴素:多飞,自然就有人关注。航天飞机在飞的时候,关注度明显更高。第二层更本质:如果公众看到一条路径,哪怕很长,知道自己或者自己的孩子、朋友有可能上轨道、上月球、上火星,兴趣会大幅上升。有些人自己没打算去,可只要孩子、兄弟或朋友想去,他们就会支持。

他讲了阿波罗11号的那个细节:如果方圆50英里只有一台电视,人们会走50英里去看。

有时候人们会问,世界上还有那么多穷国,为什么要花钱搞太空。答案是,这件事同样激励着他们。(马斯克)

关于为什么要做多行星文明,他的论证是概率性的。单一星球文明的风险无法消除,全球战争、社会衰退都在历史里发生过,古埃及和古罗马都曾达到技术高峰然后衰落,原因至今说不清。成为多行星物种能显著延长人类文明的预期寿命。

他给的比例是:把1%到2%的资源用于让生命多行星化,其余绝大部分仍然留给地球。

还有一句他觉得被低估的话:未来得有让人愿意起床的东西。不能全是解决一个接一个的糟心问题,得有事让人兴奋。

他一周80%的时间在开工程会

有人问研发策略,短期问题解决和长期目标怎么分配。

马斯克的回答是,尽量把研发拉满,收入拿回来直接投研发,大部分时间花在工程上,一周大约80%是工程会议。他说工程是他觉得最有意思的事,所以尽量往那个方向走。

他还提到公司也在做火星通信相关的探索,可能跟NASA合作。

主持人问他会不会自己坐龙飞船去空间站。他说想,大概三四年后。主持人说,那我把你加进名单。

这场对话里最值得记住的,其实是几个不太起眼的细节。宏大目标听多了会麻木,这些数字不会。一艘复飞的飞船成本几乎等于新建;一枚火箭的整流罩值六百万美元,值得到天上接;一套为空间站运货设计的合同规则,被承包商本人建议推广到整个政府。

这些细节拼出来的图景,比"马斯克要上火星"这句口号具体得多。

如果你是这几类人,可以从这里下手

  • 做政策或公共管理:去读一遍NASA商业货运合同(CRS)的里程碑付款结构,两家竞争、固定价格、硬件导向、掉队者被替换。这个模板对采购效率的价值,被严重低估了。
  • 做工程或制造:把"复用"当成设计约束,从需求阶段就写进去,别等到产品定型后再优化。马斯克给的目标是24小时周转、只做检查、不换硬件、连漆都不换。拿这个标准去审自己的产品线,会看到很多从没被质疑过的翻修工序。
  • 做教育或带孩子:下次教任何东西之前,先回答"为什么学这个"。把知识点挂在一个真实任务上,拆发动机、做CubeSat、造一辆能跑的车,让工具在解决问题的过程中被自然学会。
  • 关注AI治理:马斯克的主张是先建机构获取洞察,等洞察积累起来再制定规则,参照FAA和FDA的模式。判断一个AI监管提案好坏的标准,看它急着定规则,还是先建立持续观察的能力。
  • 做传播:SpaceX自己都承认,航天飞机退役后第一次轨道飞船复飞这件事,被彻底漏掉了。好的进展如果没人讲,等于没发生。你所在的组织里,大概率也有几件这样被埋在细节里的第一。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:01When I think about innovation beyond boundaries, so I cannot think of a better representation of that concept in our generation. Please join me in welcoming Elon Musk and ISS program manager Kirk Shireman to the stage. Very good. So Elon, thanks so much for for being here today.

0:26Elon commuted from the West Coast this morning. So we appreciate you taking the time and coming out here and talking with us. Absolutely. Thanks for having me. We've had we've had a pretty good conference so far at least in my opinion. Over a thousand people signed up for the first time, so a significant increase.

0:41And lots of people interested in in in space and lower earth orbit and the International Space Station and work that's going on. So Anyway, we're very very excited about the work that's going on and excited to have you here today, too. Great. Thanks for having me. So you were here a number of years ago in July in 2015. It's not that long ago, I guess, two years ago.

1:03And had a had a discussion like this with Mike Suffredini. And a lot of things have happened since 2015 for SpaceX. So can you can you talk about how things have gone, how how they've progressed, how you're feeling about how the industry and and SpaceX in particular progressed? Sure. What I think I think we we are entering a new era of space exploration, which is extremely exciting.

1:29And it's it's not just SpaceX, but there's a number of other companies that have developed new approaches. NASA is taking new approaches things, which is really exciting in in the way that the the contracting has been done for space station resupply. I think it's a great model that frankly should be adopted throughout government.

1:53I spoke a little bit about this at the governor's conference and was actually using the NASA NASA cargo resupply contracting process as a really great model for government in general. You know, it's where you have two competitors fixed price milestone based with a hot milestones are are primarily hardware oriented.

2:20and then if one of the two companies that's that's competing does not reach their milestones, then the remainder of the milestones are are competed to another company. And that's what happened with cargo resupply. Started off with SpaceX and Kistler. Kistler made some progress, but wasn't going to get across the finishing line.

2:39And then Orbital Sciences was competed for the second slot and they did get across the finishing line and now both SpaceX and Orbital are providing NASA with cargo services to the space station. And having that competitive dynamic is is I think it's a very powerful powerful function for getting a great outcome for the NASA as the customer.

3:01and I think that that's just a great that was a great model really well executed and to the degree that's applicable in other areas of NASA or the government, I think that's there's the potential for revolutionary progress on that front. so from from a from a technical standpoint the the the biggest thing that's happened in the last couple years, which I'm really excited about and I think makes a difference for access to space is the landing of the Falcon 9 rocket booster and then the that

3:52And if you ever get a chance to go out to the the the the Cape over Vandenberg to see that, I'd really recommend it. It's really pretty fun. So And there'll be a lot of those flights in the remainder of the year. We've got about a dozen flights still to go this year. and then after landing re-flying that same booster with minimal work to the booster.

4:21and we believe we can get to the point where in the not too distant future, in fact, probably by by next year where the the the the Falcon 9 booster can be re-flown within 24 hours. so yeah. And and and and the key the key to that is that all you do is inspections and no hardware is changed not even the paint. And so this is very important.

5:03so that's our aspiration for for next year. obviously while paying very close attention to mission assurance and reliability. But we think we've got at least a technical path to to achieving that. and then the I think we're quite close to being able to recover the the fairing. so it's a huge nose cone on the front of

5:30nose cone. You can fit a basically a whole sort of city bus in there. And and and that just that that fairing alone with all of its systems and the acoustic damping and qualification all that and separation system, that's about a five or six million dollar piece of equipment and the analogy I use with my team is like, guys, imagine we had you know, six million dollars in a pallet of cash and that was you know, six million dollars is falling through the sky and would we try to catch it?

6:08I say we do. I say we give it a shot. You know, worst case it ends up at the bottom of the ocean, but maybe we do catch it and then pay six million dollars. Let me know when that pallet of cash is coming back. Yeah. I mean I'd like to give it a shot, too. You know, it might as well be a pallet of cash because it costs six million dollars. So And but I I think we we got a decent shot of recovering the fairing by the end of the year.

6:34and and possibly reflight by either late this this year or early next. and that just leaves the the upper stage of the rocket. Upper stage is about 20% of the cost of the mission. so if we get booster stage and and fairing, we're right around 80% reasonable. And then I think I think we for for a lot of missions we can even bring the second stage back.

7:02So we're going to try to do that. Although our primary focus will be on our Dragon over the next particular of the next year or so. Our Dragon 2 spacecraft, which is what will which is the crew crew Dragon next generation Dragon spacecraft, which has got all of the equals systems and the but it will allow you to do a launch aboard all the way to orbit.

7:29And and and do an automated docking maneuver. So it's not it does it doesn't need to berth with the aid of the arm. It can do a direct docking maneuver. and then that will be the what once that's operational the new method of taking both cargo and crew to the space station. so if I say what's what's our primary focus, it's making sure we stay on track for getting getting crew to station as we promised NASA around the middle of next year. That's going to be real exciting. I think it's going to be great for getting the public fired up.

8:06You know, that's really It's been a while since we launched astronauts from US soil. So we're we're all looking forward to that. Yeah. and I I I just like to to to to to thank people at NASA for giving SpaceX a chance to to do this and just want a word of appreciation for the working relationship with NASA, which is great. in fact, I told the governors last week that, you know, for a long time my password was I love NASA.

8:37That that is actually true. This is You know, you've just given you've given all the hackers around the world a chance to go work on that. I I hopefully I don't have like some old email accounts somewhere that still with that. You know, like I've got to I've got to change this. People are going to cotton on.

8:58Very good. So how you talked a little bit about commercial crew. How is that going? I know it's you know, flying flying humans is more systems involved. Of course, the risk is higher. How is that progressing? you know, it's it's been way more difficult than cargo for sure. Yeah. I mean, as soon as as soon as sort of people enter the picture, it's it's really a giant step up in

9:29making sure things go right, you know, and and for sure the the the oversight the oversight from NASA is much tougher. It was not that it wasn't tougher cargo, but it's really intense for crew. So coming from the right motivations. but yeah, it's you know, it can be a bit tough on on on my guys you know, what with the women men of SpaceX, but but I but I you know, know where it's coming from. It's the right right motivation.

10:03And and there'll be some debates, you know, going into next year about some of the detailed technical de- de- de- But I think we really want to do everything humanly possible to make sure it goes well. And you know, triple check everything. and O- overall, I think it's going you know, really well.

10:32you know, there's getting like these little small technical bones of contention, which you know, but we're working through those. We're engineers. We live We live for that. Exactly. Yeah. it And and some of these things are really like esoteric. I mean, unless somebody's really in the weeds on the rocket and spacecraft design, it will just sound like we're talking Greek, but ancient Greek, you know, but Yeah, but there's you know, I think it's good to have these debates. and overall, I'm confident that it's going to be a system that that NASA feels good about and that SpaceX feels good about and we're looking forward to continuing the partnership into next year and

11:25doing a great job for NASA. Excellent. Thank you. and of course we're looking forward to. We're excited about it and and as you mentioned, we're NASA's working hard with you Yep. on on Oh, yeah. and and yeah, and we're also all down in the weeds on those technical details. I'm sure you are down.

11:43Yep. Let's see. You see down to the little bolt to the little thing and all that. Where's Gerst? Gerst is here somewhere. That's Gerst's gravy, too. Gerst, if you can't have a If you can't have a dry lube bolt pitch discussion with Gerst, you know, it's not a good day. We We I guess I have a many many just many sort of in the weeds technical discussions. I actually love I love talking to Gerst. one of my favorite people in the world, actually. So.

12:12Yeah. There you go. Mine, too, but but he's my boss. I I have to say that. Let's see. So, you you talked We talked a little bit about commercial crew. We have cargo supply resupply one, which you have the Dragon, which of course Dragon one, which is birthed. And and in fact, you've done a reflight recently with with the Dragon.

12:36You know, thanks for bringing that up. You know, cuz that's kind of important. Yes, it is. And again, thanks for the NASA support on that. God, we we really should you know, we should have made a slightly bigger deal out of it because it was the first reflight of a spacecraft since the shuttle.

12:55Mhm. and we kind of forgot to make, you know, let people know to I mean, I guess it was there in the details, but we forgot to you know, let I don't think the public even realizes that it's the first reflight of a spacecraft orbital spacecraft since the shuttle. Which performed very well, too. Very good good clean mission. Yeah, solid.

13:16I mean, that that now that was a case case where I should in full disclosure say that it cost us almost as much to in fact, probably about as much, maybe more to re- re- negotiating contract here. No, I know. I know. I'm just I'm just being totally honest here. I I Our the SpaceX internal accounting said that it cost us almost as much as building a a Dragon one from scratch. I suspect our internal accounting was probably being wasn't counting certain things.

13:49There were some circumstances unusual about this one, right? This one had some water incursions and things like that. Yeah, yeah. The amount of rework on this particular This had a lot of rework, yeah. But the next one, we think there's a decent shot of of being maybe sort of 50% the cost of a new one.

14:06and Keep going. My contract is here. Yeah, I'm negotiating against myself here. Yes. and but yeah, no, I I mean, we want to offer the, you know, best possible deal deal for NASA and it's always tough to get that top line budget to increase. Hope it does. man, I think so much could be could could be accomplished if the NASA top line budget was increased. I think people have no idea, you know.

14:38So, it's there. So, talk a little bit So, we talked about CRS one and and birthing and CRS two. Are we talking about commercial crew? CRS two, the Dragon is going to its cargo Dragon It's It's the similar Adam old line of It's It's It's It's Dragon two, it's yeah. But it's going to dock. And so, talk about the it could then we'll have good commonality between the two.

15:00and and things like that. Yeah. so, the I mean, the only thing cargo Dragon won't have is the launch escape system. although it'll still have the logic associated with separating from the vehicle. So, I I think most likely even even cargo Dragon two would be able to survive booster anomaly.

15:20Like like that word anomaly. The the We don't like that word. Yeah, well, I got I guess I don't like it. Yeah, right. The the one of the the launch It have everything else on the Dragon crew Dragon two has except the the thrusters, but I think in most cases actually it would still be able to survive re-entry and and keep the cargo safe.

15:44But but having that commonality is great. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, going forward, it seems like, you know, docking itself and if, you know, even beyond testing of systems and evolutions and things that might be beneficial to test on on the cargo version Yeah, totally. Absolutely. And I know you've already done some things on on CRS one to prepare for CRS two and you're testing some TPS repair capability and things like that.

16:10So, exactly. actually I really, you know, just like to you know, express some appreciation for the the whole CRS team because they they've really allowed us to update the rocket and you know, add crazy things like landing legs. and and been really fair, I think, in allowing us to iterate with the booster for for the CRS contract.

16:41And then and and then as you're pointing out, Dragon two being used for both cargo and crew allows us to iterate with a just a slight less little more risk on the cargo version and prove it out for the screw on board. Yeah, it's really helpful. Excellent. So, let's let's talk about I I I know we got a few more minutes here and then we'll open it up to questions. But you know, the the theme here is for the conference is innovation. And and of course we talked already about some innovations in the launch business, but what what do you think needs to be Where are the areas or the thrusts for innovation that we really need both you know, not not excluding the launch,

17:23but but also looking at lower earth orbit. What's in lower earth orbit? Where do we Where do you think we as a as a you know, space industry need to go and look for our innovation? Yeah. Well, you know, I I I think for long I I I I still believe in I think many people do that the the real the key to opening up space space or orbit, you know, Leo and beyond is rapid and complete reusability.

17:57near complete reusability. Like we have with aircraft. or cars or you know, almost any form of transport. Now, it's it's super hard with space cuz this is you know, we live on a planet with pretty high gravity. so, so, it'd be pretty easy if we're on Mars or something like that.

18:19But but the earth's gravity is is really pretty pretty high and we've got a thick atmosphere and so, reus- reus- reusability is tough when you're going through, you know, high sort of you you're going to operate in a vacuum, hypersonic, supersonic, transonic, subsonic. That's just a lot of regimes for any sort of flying object to go through.

18:47but but reusability I think is absolutely fundamental to a breakthrough in access to orbit and beyond. the Leo Leo and beyond. Anything that can be done in that direction, I think is is is good. Mhm. Surely change the economics of transportation to lower earth orbit, right? Really fundamental.

19:08You get quick reusability, the economic equation it becomes easier to get to lower earth orbit and do more things. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, it's kind of like, you know, just any mode of transport. Like it's And before there was the Union Pacific going across the US to California, and there was like hardly any people in California. People thought building the Union Pacific was just crazy cuz you got like nobody there. So, why are we building a railroad to nowhere? Now, you know, California's most populous state in the country.

19:36Some people stopped in Texas along the way. Yeah, yeah. Few of us did. I love Texas. By the way, by the way. Texas. you know, we we do a huge part of our R&D in Texas, in Central Texas. A lot of people don't know about that. near Waco. We have so Central Central Texas, we do You did Boca Chica down in the south there.

20:02That's right. Yeah, yeah, exactly. So, we've got a lot of activity throughout Texas. we're building yet third launch site in South Texas near Brownsville. I think that'll that'll give us good you know, contingency capability if there's a say a hurricane coming through the cape and we still need to get to the station, we could, you know, launch out of South Texas and that that'll ensure continuity of service.

20:30and yeah. I really I spend a lot of time in Texas. Yeah, it's great. Excellent. All right. traffic's not as bad as in Southern California. Oh man, traffic. So, that's the biggest issue with Southern California, traffic hell. I mean It's like It's like which level of hell are you in?

20:49You're in hell. Yeah, Washington's trying to catch up. But you know you know what we're I I mean this is I mean we're digging a tunnel. Have you heard about that? Yeah. Yeah. So so it's like the the and the tunnel starts right across from SpaceX HQ. So, if you're ever out and want to see our tunnel Yeah, as long as you promise not to close it in after That's not a problem.

21:21it would Yeah, we're digging a tunnel. and I it's kind of like a So, actually maybe I don't know. Sort of It It's like a little Actually, oddly enough, it's like a little low-stress activity cuz like everyone expects it to fail and I mean the sort of grown-worthy joke that I make about tunnels is that they have low expectations.

21:52There's nowhere to go but down. Yes. I could keep going. Wow. That makes sense. You you're involved in space, you're involved in tunnels, you kind of kind of cover the gamut. They used to call me internet guy when I was in startup open space. hey, this is internet guy. he's in space. He's obviously going to fail.

22:15So, then they stopped saying internet guy. I think they call me transport guy. He's a transport guy. So, talk Speaking of transports, you know, so today ISS is up there and and really the conference is focused a lot on on some of the research and development that's going on there.

22:31But and and commercialization, too, by the way. But what and commercialization, at least NASA's strategy is commercialization will will be fostered on ISS and then at some point in the future ISS will go away and and we are we we expect we hope for a vibrant lower earth orbit economy at that point in time.

22:49That's cool. And I'm kind of curious what what you see in terms of SpaceX and your transportation relative to that that economy. What's next for commercial crew after after ISS? Sure. Well, first of all, I don't think the public realizes how cool ISS is. you know, that is an awesome thing that's up there.

23:10you know, I I I talked to a lot of people that First of all, some people don't realize we have a space station. Like you can't can't be serious. like we have a gigantic space station. It's huge. Yeah, it's really gigantic. I mean it's a pretty incredible structure that we have orbiting orbiting the earth and I think just I I I'd recommend like man, we've got to do something to educate the public about the awesomeness of of of the space station cuz it is pretty amazing.

23:41and and and big. Like people just lose sight of like they think oh, it's like a little thing. You know, it's big. It's real big. and yeah, so and and I was finally getting it to sort of real operational use and that was great. So, again, amazing technological achievement. So, but then yeah, I I I think the the in terms of lower earth orbit stuff on the commercial side, I think there's a lot of opportunities in you know, kind of a global internet capability to providing internet to parts of the world that either don't have it or where it's very expensive and not very good.

24:28Yeah, so like the the space is really good for providing internet connectivity for sparsely populated or or low populated regions. So, it's not it's not really a threat to telcos. It actually can make make telcos' lives easier because there are a lot of customers that are very hard to serve where like you're digging a fiber cable for 2 miles, they'll never pay off the investment to you know, to get to one house type of thing. Mhm. But but for space, you can really serve serve those customers at at at so at economically sensible rates.

25:04There's earth observation you're getting better understanding of of natural sort of nat- any natural disaster you know, information. and You know, but I think the If you want to get the the public real fired up, I think we got to we got to have a base on the moon. You know? I don't It's like that'd be pretty cool.

25:38and then going beyond that, getting people to Mars. Yeah. Certainly sending people further we've ever sent them before, I think it's captivating for the people, so. Yeah, exactly. It's captivating for me, I know that. Yeah, exactly. So, yeah, just you know, having some permanent presence on another heavenly body should be the the kind of moon base and then the you know, getting getting people to to Mars and beyond.

26:04and you know, it's sort of the That's the that's the continuance of the dream of Apollo that I think people are really looking for. Yeah. Excellent. You know, this might be a good time to to go ahead and open it up for a few questions from the audience. we're where the where they're on the side. I think microphones on the side.

26:26I can't tell if people are I don't know where they are. lights are so bright, it's hard to tell. I know this is a risk asking people to ask questions, but any any questions? Looks like there's a few people signed up lined up over here, so. Go ahead. hi Elon, over here from the UK.

26:43Pleasure to ask a question to you. my question is how are you managing the risks associated with the Falcon Heavy and particularly the recently announced private launch around the moon. Thank you for your time. Sure. so the But first of all, I should say Falcon Heavy that requires the simultaneous ignition of 27 orbit class engines.

27:16It's like, you know, a lot that could go wrong there. and I I encourage people to come down to the cape and see the first Falcon Heavy mission. it's guaranteed to be exciting. But it But it's you know, this is one of those things that's really difficult to test on the ground. I mean we can fire the engines on the ground, but and we try to simulate the the the dynamic the dynamics of having 27 instead of nine booster engines and the you know, the airflow as it goes through transonic. it's like it's going to see heavy transonic buffet.

27:57the max Q or has behavior on a max Q. There's a lot of risk associated with Falcon Heavy. Real good chance that that vehicle does not make it to orbit. want to make sure set expectations accordingly. I hope I hope it makes it past you know, far enough away from the pad that it does not cause cause pad damage. I would consider even that a win, to be honest.

28:26and yeah. Very exciting. Major pucker factor, really. It's like another way to describe it. You know, that dwindles that that dwindles the amount of people who want to ride on that the first time. Yeah. Well, It gets smaller cap There are still people And full disclosure here, man. Full disclosure.

28:51I you know, I think Falcon Heavy is going to be a great vehicle. just just like so much that's really impossible to test on the ground. and we'll do our best. and it it actually ended up being way way harder to do Falcon Heavy than we thought. cuz it's at At first, it sounds real easy. Just stick two first stages on as strap-on boosters. Yeah, how how hard can that be?

29:15But then everything changes. All the loads change. Aerodynamics totally change. you've tripled the vibration and acoustics. so, if you sort of break the the qual levels on so much of the hardware the amount of load you're putting through that center core is ins- is crazy cuz you've got two super powerful boosters also shoving that center core.

29:41And it's like So, we had to redesign the the whole center core airframe. it's not like the Falcon 9 cuz it's got to take so much load. then you got the separation systems. and, yeah, it just ended up being really way, way more difficult than we originally thought. we were pretty naive about that.

30:04but I I but it the nice thing is it's it's, yeah, when it on fully optimized, it's about 2 and 1/2 times the payload capability of a Falcon 9. So, you know, it's well over 100,000 lbs to to Leo payload capability, yeah, about 50 tons, could even get up to a little higher than that if, you know, if optimized.

30:29and, and then the the nice thing is that does have the throw capability to toss a Dragon 2 in a loop around the moon. and, and then Dragon 2 itself, the heat shield is, designed with a huge amount of margin. So, it's got enough margin to handle, lunar re-entry. and, particularly if we do initial velocity scrub, do sort of at least one pass to scrub velocity, then come in on the second pass.

31:03yeah, but, no question, whoever's on the first flight, you know, brave. Yes. Let's see, let's go over here to this side. Here's a question from over here. hey Elon. Ted Tagami with, educational company called magnitude.io. I had the good fortune of meeting you, back in September watching your five sons launch their own rockets Black Rock Desert. Oh, yeah, cool. Yeah. That was fun.

31:32And since then, we've actually been able had the great fortune of sending students payloads up to the International Space Station. And we're now working with CASIS to extend that. We'd like 50 million students to get on the International Space Station, their experiments on the Space Station by 2014. so my question to you is more about the innovations in education and your thoughts. That same year that I met you and your sons, you announced Ad Astra.

31:56Oh, yeah. and and before the, advent of Neuralink gets fully implemented, what what are your thoughts on the innovations in education today? Thank you. just the thoughts on education. well, I I think there's maybe a there's definitely some good schools out there, but I think the some of the the mistakes, at least in my opinion, that I see being made in education is, that people teachers do not explain why kids are being taught a subject.

32:33you know, you just sort of get dumped into math and like, well, why are you learning math? What's the point of this? It seems like some, you know, for some people like maybe it's a I don't know why I'm being asked to do these strange problems. but you know, the why of things is extremely important.

32:50because, you know, our brain has evolved to not to discard information that it thinks is has no relevance. So, then if on the one hand you, you're being asked to memorize or learn, say formulas, but you do not know why this is the case, then you have this cognitive dissonance of it seems irrelevant, but I'm being told to remember it, so I'll be punished.

33:17So, so I better remember it, but so the why of things is very important, and then, being able to and and then pi- picking kind of a a problem, and then, using various educational tools to solve that problem, like using math or physics or economics to to solve that problem is far more engaging, than teaching the tools.

33:42you know, it's different between if you say, well, we're going to take apart this, this engine, and and see how it works and put it back together again. and then in order to take the engine apart, we need, you know, wrenches and screwdrivers and a winch, and Allen keys and and whatnot, and and and it's a and then in the course of solving the problem of taking the engine apart and putting it back together, you learn about wrenches and screwdrivers and all the tools that you need. and then now you understand the relevance. Ah, this is why wrenches are important. I you know, whereas if you had a a class on wrenches, you'd be like, why is this this not seem that

34:27great, you know? so ti- tying it to solving a problem is I think very powerful for, establishing relevance and getting, kids excited about what they're working on. and then and and and having the knowledge stick. Yeah. And so to some extent, fly, you know, building a a a CubeSat or flying an experiment on on ISS is like that, right? You you've got the you've got the why or the relevance and the curiosity and in terms of building that, that device or that experiment. I I think there's some really cool and it ties to the, it gives you a really a concrete example of what, what you're learning and why. Yeah, exactly. I think like things like CubeSats,

35:10exactly. We're we're because say like, okay, w- like what is a solar panel? How does orbital dynamics work? How do we, you know, how do we power this thing? You know, how do batteries work? Electronics, co- control systems, and you you need to then then you're like, oh, we want to make our satellite work. That's why we need to understand all these disciplines. so I think it's like like CubeSats students CubeSats are great. like things like design build fly for model airplanes or Formula SAE. we've got a design and build a, kind of a a race car and and then you know, race that against other people. That I think those things are very powerful for

35:51learning as learning tools. Yeah, very cool. All right, thank you. I see over here another question. hi, my name is, Jacob and I actually live near the Cape. So, my question is not much of a tech question, but more of what your prediction is. So, about maybe 100 years after we develop sustainable colonies on Mars, do you think, and of course many other countries will also try to get to Mars, that there would be like a conflict for the best resources on Mars?

36:22like in I guess you could say in sort of like a interplanetary warfare, if you know what I'm trying to get This sounds like a video game, doesn't it? it's an idea. Mars Attacks or, the you know, I think it's some pretty open territory on Mars. so there's I don't think we're going to be there's going to be any kind of scarcity.

36:50there's like a lot of land on Mars. Not many people. so Unless they're hiding on the backside. Yeah, no, I mean, they're they're pretty clever. If there are people on Mars, man, they are way cleverer than us cuz they're hiding well. so, yeah, I know, there's plenty of land on Mars. It's I mean, you know, the history of human civilization does contain a lot of war, so I I don't think we you know, we go to Mars and that you you know, be war free forever.

37:26But, but I think there's certainly not going to be a resource-based conflict due to scarcity of resource on Mars. I think we're going to go to to the Mars as a multinational effort, too, right? So, it's not it's not one country going and another country going and then they're fighting over wars. I think it's countries going together and and so I think we're we're more likely to be peaceful in that in that scenario as well. Yeah, but you know, I I actually advocate for I think it's fine if if if countries get together to form teams, but I think it's actually probably better if there are at least, you know, at least two or three, country coalitions going going to

38:02Mars, in a friendly way, and and competing to see who can make the most progress. and if you look at like say the Olympics, it would be pretty boring if everyone just linked arms and crossed the finish line at the same time. we're friendly, but it would you know, not be More like the opening ceremonies, I guess. Yeah, yeah, exactly. so we I think friendly competition is a good thing.

38:30Yeah. Very good. Well, I I think, you know, NASA wants to be part of one of those kind of coalitions with the United States and and so we're I know we're actually trying to build such a coalition now. Let's see, from over here, another question. Hi, I'm, Yotam Ariel, founder and CEO of Bluefield. We're deploying methane tracking microsatellites. And my question to you, I hope to learn your thoughts on advancing remote sensing capabilities of critical gases on Earth and on Mars.

38:59Thank you. Well, that's a pretty esoteric question. remote sensing of of gases, yeah, I think, that that's something that's going to be important. Mar- Mars has a number of trace gases that are pretty helpful. it's very helpful that that Mars has CO2 and nitrogen and argon. Those are those are like really helpful gases to have in the atmosphere. it's mostly CO2, but that little bit of nitrogen and argon is really can be pretty helpful.

39:32Yeah. And other and whatever other trace gases we can get out of there. know. We we always say Mars has just enough atmosphere to, it's not enough to be really helpful in terms of, aerobraking, but it sure makes it a lot harder. So, it's just enough to be to be difficult. Yeah. of in situ resource utilization, you know, when we get there to be able to build to to to get your oxygen and That's super helpful.

39:54have a water and can build a build a hot get hydrogen manufacture hydrogen on on on the planet. So, Yeah. Hopefully there's enough resources that we'll we don't have to carry everything with us. Well, the nice thing having if you got H2O and and CO2, you can build hydro carbons of of any kind. you can certainly build plastics.

40:14you can build well, you know, short chain long chain hydrocarbons. you know, the the current SpaceX thought for kind of a Mars transport vehicle is a primarily methane based system. cuz you get to have a kind of a smaller I mean, the tanks are half the size with if with methane.

40:34so and and and yeah, but and and Mars with with a CO2 atmosphere and a lot of water ice is is great for for that. going beyond Mars, I think there's a lot of merit for hydrogen cuz then you only need water. But that's that's also our current thinking on that front. So, we we speaking of that, last last year at Guadalajara at the IAC conference, you talked about plans to go to the Mars and and and I know you guys have been working on that since then. Yep. You do you so you plan at some point to talk about that work publicly?

41:09Yeah, thinking probably the upcoming IAC in Adelaide might be a good opportunity to do the updated version of the Mars architecture cuz it's it's evolved quite a bit since that last talk. Yeah, I'm I'm going to ask for questions to be collected at time and and for that I assume Good strategy. There was some very enthusiastic people to the mic at the IAC last time.

41:39I mean, but but the You know, the the the key thing that that we figured out is like how do you pay for this whole, you know, something to go to Mars? That's very super expensive. Mhm. and I kind of think by kind of you know, if we downsize the the the Mars vehicle, you know, make it capable of doing Earth orbit activity as well as you know, Mars activity, then you know, maybe we could pay for it with by using it for Earth orbit activity.

42:17that's that's one of that's one of the key elements in the new architecture. It's it's it's similar it's similar to what was at IAC, but it's it's it's it's a bit a little bit smaller, still big, but but but but I think it's I think this one's got a shot at being real. And and on on the on the economic front, you know, that's the trick.

42:43All right, let's see. I think another question from over here. Hi Elon, Eugene Mark. I have mostly one important question and one little aside. I Can you talk a little bit about your R&D strategy for your companies and is it all focused on short-term problem solution or how much and in what fashion do you allocate time and money towards R&D spending on some of the long-term goals you're working at? And then just as a little aside for the Boring Company, are you looking at that only as a habit as a transportation, but potentially as a habitat company for not just tunnels, but habitats on Mars or the moon?

43:23Yeah, actually so I do think like getting good at digging tunnels could be really helpful for Mars. Mhm. cuz like once you've got a a kind of a it would be a different optimization for, you know, a Mars boring machine versus a Earth boring machine, but for sure there's going to be need to be a lot of of ice mining on Mars and mining in general to get raw materials.

43:48and then along the way building underground habitats where, you know, you get good radiation shielding and you kind of have you know, as much you can you can build a really an entire city underground if you wanted to. I think people are still going to want to go to the surface, you know, from time to time, but you you you can build trans mount underground with the with the right boring technology on Mars. So, I do think that there's some overlap in that technology development arena.

44:24And then R&D you know, I I try to spend as much on R&D as we can at my companies. So, we really max out R&D. I mean, I spend most of my time on engineering. that's probably 80% of my week is engineering meetings. and so as you know, any money that we get in revenue, we we we would put that right back into R&D.

44:55And some of it is longer term. yeah. You know, like for example, the you know, Mars vehicle look at some doing some Mars communication stuff potentially with with with the NASA or in part and yeah, but one super priority is like engineering's my most fun thing. So, try to follow that to the max.

45:26Over here. Hi, my name is Chris LeFlore. I work for Congress for Representative John Conyers. A couple days ago I read about you talking about artificial intelligence and the dangers of it and how as a as a businessman, you are totally against regulation and stuff like that, but as a you know, a human being, you think it's critical that we get ahead of this issue. Yeah. can you please elaborate on like why what are you seeing that we don't get to see and what as a policy maker I should be looking to do to sort of I guess protect us all?

46:04Sure. Well, I think it it it is difficult to appreciate just how far artificial intelligence has advanced and how far it is advancing because we have a double exponential at work. we have an exponential increase in hardware capability and we have an exponential increase in software talent that is going into AI.

46:32so whenever you have a double exponential, it's very difficult to predict. real predictions almost always going to be too conservative in terms of thinking it'll be further out than it is. you know, you start to see things like I don't know if you've seen like the the videos where you can sort of really quite accurately video simulate someone and put words in their mouth that they never spoke.

46:59you just Google it. It's really pretty amazing. and then they they had something called a generative adversarial network. it had had two of them. compete with one another to make the most convincing video. So, one would generate the video and then the other one would identify where it it it looked fake and and then that would the other one would fix that.

47:23And then and they'd go back and forth to the point where you couldn't tell which one is the real real video, which one is the fake one. and you you actually there've been some very public things like the defeat of AlphaGo or defeat of Go by AlphaGo of the world's best Go champion. People thought defeating Go was either never or 20 years away.

47:48That was world's best Go player was defeated. and now that same AlphaGo system can defeat the top 50 players simultaneously with 0% of chance of them winning. Yeah. And that's 1 year later. so the degrees of freedom to which artificial intelligence is able to apply itself are in really increasing

48:13I think by 10 orders of magnitude a year. It's that's really crazy. So, I think and and we're starting and this is on hardware that is really not well suited for neural nets. you know, like a GPU is maybe an order of magnitude better than a CPU, but something but a a chip that is designed optimally for neural nets is an order of magnitude better than a GPU.

48:46and that is there are a whole bunch of neural net optimized chips coming out either late this year or next year. so, I think we should I think you know, the part of the role of government is to make sure the public is safe, like to take care of public safety issues. And I think so, I think the right move is to establish some government regulatory agency, which at first is just there to gain insight. So, it's not about like shooting from the hip and just putting in rules before anyone knows anything, but you got to set up agency. It's got to gain insight.

49:29Once that insight is gained, then start applying rules and regulations. we have that for the you know, for aircraft, the FAA, we've got that for cars, we've got that for you know, drugs, for food. and I don't think anyone wants the FAA to go away or the FDA to go away or, you know, any of those regulatory agencies.

49:54I think we would just need to make sure people do not cut corners on AI safety. It's going to be a big deal. It's going to be a real big deal. and it's going to come on like a like a tidal wave. All right, thanks. Let's see you. Over here, question. Good afternoon. my name is Anna and I'm a film director and VR producer. And

50:19I'm currently working on a on a film, on a documentary film about future scenarios for humanity, which actually brought me to this amazing conference where I can learn and complete my research on the space exploration area. And in the previous few days, there was a lot of talks, which is, I think, an extremely beautiful phenomenon, about this kind of dual philosophy behind space exploration and space solutions, about solutions that are coming back to Earth that can benefit humankind in very, very wide area. And today we've been talking about the commercialization of the of the space area, and it brings a lot of questions to me about social responsibility behind gigantic

51:04companies that would actually probably take over how the space industry would develop in the nearest future. So, I'm very curious how you see in long term, these kind of benefits for people or social goals for for SpaceX, and especially in the context that you are an entrepreneur that invests in infrastructure and transport, hard solution that would probably change the way most of us live, and the way we communicate with each other. So, I'm very, very curious how you see that in terms of long-term mission, long-term philosophy, and what would be your advice or maybe it's kind of security signal for other of your colleagues and for all of us.

51:56Phew. I I I'm you know, I'm not sure I I fully understood the question. the yeah, or the answer. but Yes, I I I think mainly about long-term benefits from the R&D endeavors that your companies would conduct that could actually be also not only serving building a service that can be useful for business or for people, but also benefit the societies in a wider context. And also knowing that it would probably the interest the commercial industry in space would probably develop very quickly and it it will grow. How do you see the social responsibility of the companies who actually do that and where are the limits of what can be done, what should be done? The same way

52:53as you think about, for example, open AI mission in the area of of of AI development. So, can you try could be translated into space industry endeavors? Well, I think there's a a pretty big social benefit or civilizational benefit to being a multi-planet civilization. you know, that dramatically increases the probable lifespan of human civilization if we are a multi-planet species versus a single-planet species.

53:22but sometimes that is misinterpreted as, well, shouldn't we just focus everything on Earth? It's like, well, you know, but we should focus almost everything on Earth, but I think that should be maybe 1% or 2% of our resources that are applied to making life multi-planetary because there are certain irreducible irreducible risks for you know, for on Earth. it's it's you know, it's possible in the future that there there's some global war that knocks us back many levels of technology, you know, certainly if it was a major nuclear war it would.

53:58and the there's just so the general decay of societies over time, we see this through history, you know, if you look at ancient Egypt or ancient Rome, you know, they had reached peak peak technology levels and then for reasons that aren't obvious, just declined. and you know, so so I think just having being a multi-planet civilization, you you know, having human bases throughout the solar system, I think First of all, I think it's very exciting and inspiring and there needs to be things that are exciting and inspiring and and make you look forward to waking up in the morning. Like, it's like, hey, future's exciting.

54:47This is underappreciated. You know, like tunnels. Sorry. I was just saying. All right. and you know, but there's got to be things that make you excited about life. like, you know, it can't just be problem solving, you know, one one sort of miserable problem after another. It's got to be like, I'm fired up about the future because and here's why, you know?

55:13And and space is one of those things that that does that for people all around the world. you know, when when Apollo 11, you know, when when they landed on the moon, I mean, it was that was something for all of humanity. It really was, you know? And people would you know, if there's like one TV for 50 miles around, people would walk you know, they'd walk 50 miles just to go find that one TV to to watch it happen.

55:40so it you know, sometimes people think, what about what about poor nations of the world? Like, you know what? It inspires them, too. and you know, we need things like that. We don't have we don't have enough of them. All right, thank you. Over here? Hi Elon, quick question. I heard that Dragon is no longer planned to land propulsively. Is that true?

56:06Yeah, that was a tough decision. It Dragon is capable of landing propulsively Dragon 2 is capable of landing propulsively. and it technically it still it still is. although you'd have to land it on some pretty soft landing pad because we we've deleted the little legs that pop out of the heat shield.

56:31but it's technically still capable of doing it. the the reason we decided not to pursue that heavily is it would have taken a a tremendous amount of effort to qualify that for for safety, particularly for crew transport, and then there was a time when I thought that the Dragon approach to landing on Mars, with a base heat shield and side-mounted thrusters would be the right way to land on Mars, but now I've I'm pretty confident that is not the right way. and that there's a there's a there's a far better approach.

57:13and and that that's what the next generation of SpaceX rockets and spacecraft is just going to do. so yeah, so just the difficulty of of of safely qualifying Dragon for propulsive landing and the fact that from a technology evolution standpoint, it it was no longer in line with what we were confident was the the optimal way to land on Mars. that's why we are not pursuing it. It could be something that we bring back later, but it's it it doesn't seem like the right way to apply resources right now.

58:00Over here. Hi Elon. my name is Elia Overby. I'm a PhD student studying genomics. We've all made we've all together made a lot of technological progress on space systems. My question isn't about the technology, it's about the biology. what are the principal biological concerns you have about human health on long duration missions, such as a mission to Mars? And have you identified any solutions to these problems?

58:26well, I'd say going to Mars is not for the faint of heart. and it's it's risky, dangerous, uncomfortable, and you might die. Now, do you want to go? Yeah. you know, and for a lot of people the answer's going to be hell no, and for some it's going to be hell yes. so there will you know, there will be issues. I don't think it's like it's it's going to be a case of like you get irradiated to death along the way. I don't think that's the case at all.

59:05you you know, the the radiation levels sort of roughly you you know, in worst case scenario really kind of about equivalent to smoking on the way there. now smoking's pretty bad. but but I think with with some moderate shielding, we we can cut down on a large percentage of the incoming radiation. and that should be enough that that the the sort of marginal risk of cancer is not something that is going to be a showstopper.

59:41that's that's my best assessment to date. something learning a lot about solar winds and you know, fast particles and what not. And you know, one of the things that I learned recently that I wasn't didn't didn't quite understand is that the I I always thought of the particles from the sun the sort of solar wind is going kind of straight up from the sun, but they they follow the magnetic field lines.

1:00:11so, you you actually can get the particles coming at you from the side even though you know, it's kind of at a direction orthogonal to the sun. So, you do need some some amount of protection at least on yeah, on on on kind of four four or five sides. Anyway, but I don't think it's it's it's not a showstopper, but it's it's it's definitely, you know, if if safety is your top goal, I wouldn't go to Mars.

1:00:43Yeah. You know, there's a there's a bunch of work going on ISS right now to understand the risk to the humans for long duration. Certainly we're in we're in the Van Allen belts, so the radiation environment's different. But and all part of it is understanding what happens to the humans the longer you stay. So, so far we've had humans stay a little bit longer than a year, and that's it. So, in the history of the species they've we've had someone off the planet for a little more than a year, and we're talking 3 years to go to Mars. Well, you know, I think you can get the Perhaps perhaps shorter, but it's in the years.

1:01:12it's you know, it's so there there potential for for things out there that we haven't found yet. Yeah. And so, we'll we'll learn more as we go along. Hopefully learn more before ISS is done. Yeah, it's interesting that actually the you know, you know, Mars is only in the same sort of rough quadrant of the of of Earth six roughly 6 months every 2 years.

1:01:38By same, I mean it's sort of trans slightly offset cuz it's like a transfer quadrant, but but if you can get the ship to and from Mars in inside that 6-month window, then you get to reuse it twice as often. So, there's actually a lot of merit to being able to get to Mars in under 3 months.

1:01:59If you can get there quick and back, of course it means a bigger bigger vehicle and and resupply. So, anyway, we'll interesting problem that will I'm sure we'll work on here as we go forward. Lot lot lot of lot of Earth orbit refueling or it's not really mostly oxygen, but it's propellant reload. There's no good word for for propellant for fuel plus oxygen.

1:02:23prop, I guess. Prop prop load. We'll have to We'll have to invent a new word, right? So, that's I guess that's it. Okay, question over here? Demetrios Tseriotis from Los Angeles. First, thank you very much for digging those tunnels. They will be really handy during Olympics. my question is like with Tesla cars, will we see you riding the crew module to ISS and back? Thank you.

1:03:03I would like to at some point. I would like to. Yeah, I would I think assuming things work out, you know, I I you know, I'd like to yeah, maybe three three or four years, something. yeah, be great. All right, we'll put you on the manifest. Okay. Next question over here? Hello, I'm Anna Sophia Bagirayev, and I have kind of a follow-up on the biology question from before.

1:03:40It is one thing to say obviously it's not going to be a safe experience to go to Mars, but there are some technologies essential especially if we're looking to putting humans there permanently that are going to be have that are going to have to be developed with biological capabilities. Speaking of like flight suits, habitats, eventual artificial biospheres for people to live in. Do you see your company playing a part in the development of those technologies? Do you see biology having a place in SpaceX's work, or will that be outsourced to other unrelated companies?

1:04:11Hey, and before you answer, you should know that Anna Sophia over here won a Genes in Space competition and flew on a SpaceX Dragon. Anna Sophia was at was at SpaceX 10? When was that? Eight. SpaceX eight. So, as a yeah, and a very smart young lady. I think in fact, I think she's smarter than me in high school than than than I am now. So, anyway, so good luck with your answer. Sure.

1:04:44biology absolutely has a significant role to play in any kind of permanent Mars base or city. I mean, if if for SpaceX, you know, we're we're we're trying to make sure we can get people there reliably at a at a cost they can afford. and get cargo there at at a at a at the right cost number. You know, cuz there's there's there's kind of a threshold cost per ticket or cost per ton to the surface of Mars below which a self-sustaining city can develop and above which it cannot.

1:05:20that that sort of critical sort of economic and tech technical threshold is is is what we're is what we're focused on at SpaceX. And then we'll we'll probably also have to do a fair bit of work on propellant depot, basically propellant plant on Mars. but then our our intent is to

1:05:43you know, we we we don't want to get in the way of of what others are doing. Like we want to make sure that let's say if somebody makes an investment or wants to do something on Mars, create a you know, a business or do some scientific endeavor, that SpaceX does not compete with them, you know, cuz they need to feel like okay, they're we're not going to just go in and compete with them arbitrarily.

1:06:06We we we want to make sure that they they they they feel it's going to be a fruitful environment to be that you know, to go there and and and and do something special. So, our focus is going to be on transport, kind of fundamental utilities, survivability, and you know, we'll we'll and we'll do more if we need to do more, but we want to make sure that that lots of people can go and do all sorts of things on Mars or the moon, and not feel like SpaceX is going to do anything but try to help them. We don't want We don't want to interfere or compete.

1:06:42you know, they got to feel like the opportunity is there. Next question over here? Hi Elon. my name is Tracy, and I'm not here for any reason related to my career or to my area of study. I'm actually here as a very cool and only slightly overbearing mother Okay. to my 10-year-old daughter Harper and a sister to my 14-year-old brother Ben, who are both in the audience today, and who think of you the way that I guess I thought of Madonna at the same age.

1:07:20Wow. Yeah. That's that's that's some That's some high praise there. Thank you. In this spirit of that, I wanted to get your advice for two kids who are All right. very interested in space and engineering and entrepreneurism. Thank you. I'm sorry. Space, engineering, and entrepreneurialism.

1:07:45What's your advice? What's your advice? Yeah, well, you know, there's a lot of technical problems to solve. so, I guess it would be sort of, you know, start studying kind of engineering and physics and biosciences and that kind of thing would be the way to go. yeah. lot of going to be a lot of problems to solve to to make a city work on Mars.

1:08:11You know, we're we're thinking of just as a well, sort of a semi-joke putting a job description on our website for urban planner in brackets Mars. but you know, there's there's there's going to be a tremendous amount of problems to solve. There will be There's a lot of building, building and problem solving. So, those are like the right you know, skills to work on if if if someone's interested in going beyond Earth or, you know, space in general.

1:08:42Thank you. We're glad you're We're glad you're here. Glad your kids are here, too. They're they're the future for all of us. So, thanks for coming. See you over here? Hi. My name is Gerard Valle, NASA Johnson Space Center, and my question is in your quest to colonize Mars, do you foresee utilizing expandable spacecraft modules as a stepping stone or or even a final final utilization?

1:09:13Well, I think there's definitely going to be inflatable things on on Mars itself. you know, in the journey there, there might be some amount of inflatable, but we're not currently baselining that. Otherwise itself I think there'd be quite a lot. Yeah. Okay, thank you. Inflatable and and perhaps just building it with the materials that's already present that exactly. Local materials are key. You don't have to carry it with you. Yeah, tunnels.

1:09:48Tunnels. You got to get that tunnel that boring machine there though. That's going to be a It's Well, right now the earth ones are really heavy. Like really heavy. Right. Well, they're not built by aerospace engineers there. You're not worried about weight for earth tunneling machine. You like actually want one that's nice and heavy.

1:10:08but for a Mars one you'd have to redesign it to be super light. That's a tricky one. And then just taking into account the different conditions on Mars and everything. So yeah. It's interesting the you know, the Curiosity rover and the tires being chewed up by the the sharpness of the of just of the dirt of the gravel there. It's a you know, a very foreign environment to us and even in very subtle ways. So Let's see. A next question over here? Hi Alan. My name is Praful Chandra. I'm a regenerate medicine scientist from Wake Forest University. My question is regarding your company Neuralink that makes a brain machine interfaces.

1:10:47So what do you think this technology, how is it useful for humans when they you know, go into low earth orbits or even deep space exploration? And do you have any plans in that direction? Well, the the reason for the reason I wanted to create Neuralink was primarily as an offset to the existential risk associated with artificial intelligence.

1:11:13I think we will human intelligence will be not I mean we will not be able to beat AI. So then if you know, as the saying goes if you can't beat them, join them kind of thing. So I think having some some basically way to to link you know, human will on mass to the outcome of of AI.

1:11:39Having AI be an extension of individual human will. That's really the point of Neuralink. Now along the way I think there'll be some a lot of good that's achieved in addressing any any brain damage that's you know, as a result of a stroke or lesion or something congenital. or just you know, loss of memory when you get old that kind of thing.

1:12:05and you know, that will that will happen well before it it becomes a sort of you know, brain AI symbiote situation. So if we plan it you'll see it coming. It'll be it won't it won't happen all of a sudden. Very I I I do think it it it increases the long-term relevance of human exploration.

1:12:33and yeah and I don't think I think it's for for me it increased my motivation long-term that that it doesn't just need to be done by robots. You know, yeah. I don't know if that answers your question but Does that answer your question? Oh, yes. Okay, okay. All right, let's see. Maybe we're one more question here and we'll we'll wrap it up on the left here.

1:13:04Okay. Hi. Call it from Space Nation. As we are building the first global astronaut training program for everyone. My question relates what you earlier said to the about International Space Station and how it's a shame that it's not better known around the world as probably compared for example the shuttle program. So and thinking that in

1:13:26the future we need thousands and more space pioneers. So how do you see the significance of this public engagement and especially in the time where we have more and more tools to do that and and do you have specific plans on that and how you see that affecting accelerating or does it have in that kind of effect for the whole humanity's transition to space and and the new space era?

1:13:53Sure. Well, I think just getting more more human space flight is going to automatically engage the public. I just pointed out that space shuttle there was a lot more engagement when the space shuttle was launching. I think if if the public public sees some some path even if it's long-term where they themselves may be able to go to orbit or beyond or to to the moon or Mars, I think their interest level increases dramatically and it may not be even that that they want to go but they have a son or a daughter brother or a friend that really wants to do it and and and so they want to support this their you know, friends and family in in that in that ambition.

1:14:41but it really needs to be something ultimately that looks like it's going to be accessible to a large number of people. and then I think we'll get a large number of people engaged. Yeah, one of the things about engagement too I think for the for the US anyway will be we have had people launch from the United States. So I can't tell you how many people around the world have said you know, oh you guys are still flying? Well, absolutely we never stopped flying. We've had people living on board ISS you know, for almost 17 years.

1:15:11And but they don't see the smoke and the fire, right? They see that they see they knew they turn on the TV and there's a shuttle going and it's got seven people on board and they see it and nowadays at least in the US it's half a world away. So here in in a week a week from Friday we'll be launching three people. Yeah. But it doesn't feel the same as if it was happening in in our backyard in in Florida. Absolutely.

1:15:35So so we're looking forward to to that happening very soon here in in the US and we wish you the best of luck. Thanks very much for being here today. Thanks for for joining the conference.

1:16:00You're a big part of ISS and a big part of of the research and development that goes on on ISS. So so thanks very much. I'm glad we've been able to help be helpful and thanks for having me. I'd like to to extend my thanks also for a incredibly insightful and frank discussion that you guys have had with the group. So we really truly appreciate it. And tunnels are cool, too.

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份