大会演讲·中文精读

马斯克在宾州办市政厅:谈言论自由与持枪权,此前送出100万美元

Elon Musk holds Pa. town hall, talks free speech and right to bear arms after awarding $1M

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

宾夕法尼亚州的一场市政厅活动上,马斯克站上台,没有提词器,没有演讲稿。他先说了一句让全场安静两秒的话:从今晚开始到选举日,每天晚上抽一个人,给 100 万美元。

条件只有一个:你得签过那份支持第一修正案和第二修正案的请愿书。

现场炸了。第一个获奖者叫约翰·德雷尔(John Dreer),被叫上台时整个人是懵的,他说自己十年前买过马斯克的传记,一直关注他到现在,完全不知道今晚会有这一出。马斯克笑着说,我们事先没告诉他。

这事看起来像一场营销。但马斯克给出的理由很直白:传统媒体不会报道这份请愿书,也不是所有人都用 X,那怎么让消息传出去?每天发 100 万美元,新闻自己会长腿跑。

他的目标是在摇摆州拿到 100 万到 200 万选民的签名。这个数字放在全美不算多,放在几个胜负只差几千票的州,就是另一回事。

第二修正案为什么是给第一修正案上的保险

马斯克把话说得很重。他认为今年针对宪法的攻击在明显升级,具体到两条:言论自由,和持枪权。

他解释这两条为什么排在最前面。人们的祖先来自那些"说错话就可能坐牢、可能丢命"的国家,所以立国者第一件事是把言论自由写死。写完之后还得想,怎么保证这条不被推翻?答案就是让民众手里有枪。

没有持枪权,第一修正案就保不住。第二修正案放在那里,作用就是保护第一修正案。制宪者当时大概在想,这个国家将来一定会很热闹。(马斯克)

这套逻辑在美国政治里不算新鲜,由一个做火箭和电动车的人讲出来,现场的反应明显不一样。他反复强调一个词:宪法是有原因的,那份文件里藏着极大的智慧,它是把我们从暴政里捞出来的东西。

420 亿美元,惠及公民人数为零

谈到政府开支,马斯克拿出了他最有资格谈的角度:SpaceX 和特斯拉都是政府采购体系里的乙方,他见过里面长什么样。

他说自己经常跟政府里的人聊,对方也承认浪费严重、效率低下。他问那为什么不改?答案是改不动,除非总统层面下死命令。

他举了一个数字。联邦政府搞了一个 420 亿美元的乡村宽带计划,SpaceX 参与竞标并且赢了,本来可以给受飓风影响的州送去大量星链终端。结果奖项被撤销。到今天,这个 420 亿美元的项目,拿到宽带的公民人数是零。

420 亿美元换零个用户,我管这叫浪费。钱压根没花到人身上。(马斯克)

还有一笔。联邦政府拨了大约 70 亿美元,要在全国建超级充电网络。马斯克说,据他所知建成的数量在 10 个左右。钱流向了官僚和咨询公司,事情一件没办成。

他讲这些时的语气更接近困惑,愤怒的成分很少:这笔钱是纳税人的钱,为什么没人当回事。

鲨鱼、鲸鱼,还有 14 万美元的饮用水

真正让全场笑出声的,是马斯克讲的两个监管故事。

第一个。SpaceX 在得州的星舰基地用饮用水冷却发射台,因为在热带雷雨区,那地方下雨能把路淹了。结果收到环保署(EPA)14 万美元的罚单,理由是往地上倒水。马斯克说,我们不知道这需要许可证。水从天上来,天天下,为什么地上落一点水要罚款?EPA 的回复是:不交钱,以后所有发射申请都不受理。

第二个。监管部门要求 SpaceX 做一项研究,评估星舰返回时砸到鲨鱼的概率。马斯克说,海洋很大,不能说完全不可能,概率极低。他们说必须做。那就做吧,请提供鲨鱼分布数据。对方回答:不能给。马斯克说那我们怎么做这个计算?对方说,可以给我们西部分部,但我们不信任他们。

我当时在想,我是不是误入了某个喜剧小品现场。他们担心的是鲨鱼数据泄露,怕捕鲨取鳍的人拿到这些数据。(马斯克)

好不容易把鲨鱼的事解决了,对方又开口:那鲸鱼呢?马斯克反问,你看一眼太平洋的照片,你觉得其中多大比例的面积是鲸鱼?

这段话说完全场在笑,马斯克要说明的问题很严肃:那枚火箭在发射台上等了两个月,就为了走完纸质审批。SpaceX 团队造一枚巨型火箭的速度,比政府把一份文件从一个办公桌挪到另一个办公桌还快。

428 个联邦机构,平均每年新增近两个

他把这套东西叫"过度监管造成的窒息"。美国建国至今,联邦机构累计 428 个,算下来平均每年新增近两个,而且还在继续增加。

更麻烦的是叠加效应。马斯克说,办事的难度大致是参与机构数量的平方。一个机构参与,难度是 1;三个机构参与,难度是 9,因为他们彼此之间还要开会协调。

这条趋势如果继续下去,他说,很多东西将来会办不下来。规则上也许还允许,现实里没人办得成。不是被明文禁止,是流程本身把人耗死。

他为什么站到特朗普这边

马斯克把支持理由压缩成几条最普通的东西:安全的城市、稳固的边境、对宪法的支持、更小的政府、把自由还给个人。

他说这些要求听起来像右翼价值观,可他不这么看,他觉得这些只是常识。奇怪的是,这些常识今天居然需要被讨论。

关于政府部门改革,他确认自己跟特朗普有过多次对话,双方在"政府需要大改"这件事上高度一致。他提到一个设想中的"政府效率部"(Department of Government Efficiency),并且说那里的削减空间属于"目标密集区",因为浪费实在太多,改起来反而容易。

他也提前打了预防针。真要动这个系统,反弹会非常剧烈,他用的词是"抗体反应"。这件事必须从总统层面下授权令,否则推不动。

关于孩子:成年之前不做不可逆的决定

有个叫乔什的年轻人讲了自己的经历。他在怀俄明县的小镇长大,家里开小生意,本来准备接手,上了宾州州立大学读经济学,毕业后回来干了一年,生意垮了,跟父亲大吵一架,然后去了加州。他提到自己在那段时间探索过性取向,也考虑过变性。

他问马斯克,除了动教育部,还有什么办法能帮到那些搞不清自己是谁的孩子。

马斯克的回答几乎没谈政策,全部指向时间。

任何人经历青春期,都会遇到身份认同危机。这是正常的,是长大的过程。我们应该告诉孩子:你困惑,没关系,这很正常,它会随着时间稳定下来。(马斯克)

他的核心主张是:不要在年轻时做无法回头的决定。18 岁之前不给纹身,21 岁之前不能喝酒,这些年龄门槛社会早就接受了,理由就是未成年人做的决定,可能让成年后的自己不快乐。他说应该优化的指标是"人一生的长期幸福",当下的即时感受排不到第一位。

他也点名批评学校:某些观念被系统性地推给孩子,推的方向,恰恰是孩子自己不会走的方向。

买下推特,是为了让声音回到人手里

一位从捷克来的合法移民问,哈里斯治下的媒体会是什么样,传统媒体还能不能赢回信任。

马斯克的判断是,如果那台"机器"赢了,审查会变得非常严厉。他提到一个词:以打击"虚假信息"为名义的审查。他的反问是,谁来定义什么是虚假信息?政府吗?这本身就荒谬。

他说信息该从下往上冒,源头是民众的声音;一小撮报纸主编替所有人决定什么重要,这件事不该发生。

他进一步指出,媒体最厉害的操纵手法常常藏在选题里:说哪件事,不说哪件事。同一件事,聚焦它或者忽略它,公众接收到的世界就完全不同。他认为正确的做法是,什么议题重要,交由全体民众判断,媒体寡头的名单没有优先权。

这也解释了他当初为什么买推特。原话很短:

收购推特的全部目的,就是把民众的声音还回来。(马斯克)

他还补了一个对比。过去推特被极左活动人士掌控时,对右派的审查是极端的,连在任总统都被封号。而现在平台上没有对左派的审查、封号或限流。他说这叫"水平场地",双方站在同一条线上。

至于左派为什么希望所有平台口径统一,他的解释带着一点冷意:那些观点经不起阳光。所有人一旦能自由说话,那些想法自己就会输。

"机器"换了一张脸

谈到哈里斯,马斯克的措辞不留余地。他说她是个傀儡,提词器一坏就不知道该说什么。他把整个民主党体系称作"机器",大政府的机器,拜登是这台机器的旧面孔,不好用了,就换一张新的,机器本身没变。

他认为拜登被撤下候选人的过程本身极不民主。所以当同一批人声称特朗普是对民主的威胁时,逻辑上站不住。

他还讲了一个引起现场反应的说法:没人费劲去暗杀哈里斯,因为没意义,换一个傀儡还是傀儡。他强调这句话属于观察,别当成建议。

国债是一张看不见的税单

有观众问,政府效率部加上特朗普的政策,能不能把接近 36 万亿美元的国债降下来。

马斯克的回答从一条会计恒等式开始。很多人以为政府开支和税收是两件事,其实是同一件:所有政府开支都是税,因为赤字会变成通胀,而通胀是一种事实上的税。

他说通胀之所以被政客偏爱,是因为它隔了一层。物价上涨的痛苦是弥散的,没人能一眼看出源头,政客就可以把责任推给别人。根子在开支上。

按他的说法,如果开支不收,这个国家会像一个人一样破产,没有第二种结局。而且钱还不是花在有价值的地方,是花在莫名其妙的项目上。

大学为什么这么贵

一个观众提到德国大学免费,问美国能不能做得更好。

马斯克没有直接回答"能不能免费",先解释贵在哪:大学的行政部分涨得远远超过教学部分。真正花在教学生上的钱,占比很小。行政人员和官僚机构的数量,已经远超教授。

所以他认为大学本可以便宜得多,是官僚膨胀把它推到了今天这个价格。如果直接搞免费,等于给这套浪费体系开一张无限额支票,只会更糟。

他的解法是引入竞争:需要新的大学去跟老大学抢学生。衡量一所学校,该看教育质量,行政开销堆出来的排名说明不了什么。

他还说了一件更根本的事:四年大学的价值被高估了。太多人花四年时间、背一身债,学到的技能用不上。他明确表示对动手工作的人有很高的敬意,电工、水管工、木工,比多培养一个政治学专业的学生重要得多。"想成功就必须读四年大学"这个观念,站不住脚。

他不觉得加沙问题有现成答案

有人提出一个大胆设想:Boring Company 能不能在以色列近海造一座人工岛,叫巴勒斯坦,像塞浦路斯那样,让人有个真正的民族国家,用加沙的废墟当材料,终结无休止的战争。

马斯克的回答很克制。他说中东这块地方争了几千年,他不知道这个具体问题该怎么解,也不确定存在一个好的解。

但他借这个问题讲了一件他更确定的事:美国对外干预太多了。他数了一遍政权更迭的账:古巴失败,伊朗失败,朝鲜失败,俄罗斯失败。他反问,成功的在哪?代价是大量人命和巨额资金,收益接近于零。结论是,少管别国的事。

他说自己本来准备好失败

有人问他人生的最大障碍是什么,怎么把障碍变成机会。

马斯克的回答出人意料地朴素。他说自己没预料到能做成这些事,坦白讲,他预期的是失败。他说自己的动机很简单:做点尽可能有用的事。

他提到当年从宾大毕业后想去网景找工作,简历寄出去了,没人回。马克·安德森是他的朋友,但还是没回音。没别的办法,只好自己写软件。95 年他写出来了互联网上最早的地图、导航和黄页白页。

如果当时有人录用我,我大概就在网景上班了。(马斯克)

他给的建议也很朴素:认真干一天的活,尽量对别人有用,给出去的比拿进来的多。他说自己非常尊敬那些踏实干活的人,这才是真正重要的东西。

关于火箭,他说差 1 万倍

一位观众提到自己在办公室看完了星舰的发射和助推器回收,看得直欢呼。

马斯克借这个话题讲了一个常被低估的经济学常识。一次性火箭和可重复使用火箭的成本差距在 1 万倍这个量级,跟百分之几十完全不在一个尺度。他打了个比方:这就像买车和每次出门都买一辆新车的区别。如果每飞一次都要造一枚新的,航天注定昂贵且低频;如果能像飞机一样加注燃料再飞,成本结构彻底改写。

正是这个差别,决定人类能不能在月球建基地、在火星建城市,能不能成为一个跨行星的文明。

还有几天,先把名报上

整场活动里,马斯克反复回到同一个动作上:登记,然后投票。

他说宾州的选民登记截止时间是周一午夜,可以在线完成,非常快。过了这个点就作废了。他还提到一个让他着急的数据:已经申请缺席选票的共和党选民里,有相当一批人还没把票寄出去。他的原话是,票就在你家,现在寄出去是个好时机,担心邮寄就亲自送过去。

他也回应了 2020 年那场关于计票的质疑。他的思路是不纠缠细节,把票数拉开:只要领先幅度足够大,任何操作都追不上。同时他邀请所有人把投票现场拍到的图像、视频、证据发到 X 上,让光照进来,光越亮,动手脚越难。

如果这场对话只能留下几条能立刻执行的事,大概是这样:

  • 查一下自己所在州的选民登记截止日期,宾州是周一午夜,能在线办就今晚办,别拖到周一晚上。
  • 已经拿到缺席选票的,今天就填好寄出,或者直接送到指定投递点,不要放在家里等。
  • 给三个你确定的亲友发消息,只问一句"你登记了吗",不要去争论政治,只确认注册状态。
  • 提前投票能查状态,投完去官网确认自己的票已被接收,别默认它一定到了。
  • 如果你在摇摆州,签不签那份请愿书是个人选择,但把截止日期转给身边人这件事没有门槛。
  • 看到投票站的异常,先拍清楚时间、地点、画面,再发出去,比情绪化的转述有用得多。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00[Applause] everyone all right well I'm guessing this is a pro Elon crowd somehow thanks guys well thank thank you for coming tonight and it's an honor to be here and be able to speak to you and and I look forward to questions and comments it's it's always interesting to have that that Q&A and hear what people's concerns are and and answer questions and you know I think these These are these things are great so

1:02one of the things that has been concerning me for you know this for a while particularly it's ramped up this year is that there there's increasingly attacks on the Constitution and specifically there are attacks on your right to freedom of speech there are attacks on your right to bear arms and you know without the right to bear arms the the re the first the second amendment is there to protect the First Amendment [Applause]

1:40so and you have to say you know why are these why were these the the first and second amendments is because the countries that people came from if if you spoke your mind you could get imprisoned or you could get killed that's that's why they said we got to we got to make sure we have freedom of speech and then well how do we ensure that we have freedom of speech well right to bear arms

2:07so I mean the the the the founders of the founders of the Constitution must have been saying to themselves this country is going to be lit so and I I I believe everyone here has actually signed the petition in support of the yeah so [Applause] [Music] so one of the things what we're doing is we want to try to get over a million maybe two million of voters

2:44in the Battleground States to sign the petition and support of the first and second amendment because I think this sends a crucial message to our elected politicians to you know who care about about the outcome in Battleground States say okay wow people in these states really actually care about these things it's a big deal so

3:11and and and but but but we really want to try to get as many people as possible to to sign this petition so I have a surprise for you which is that we are going to be awarding a a million dollars to randomly to people who have signed the signed the petition every day from now until the [Applause]

3:51[Music] election so you know one of the challenges we're having is like well how do we get people to know about this petition because the Legacy Media is won't report on it you know and not everyone's on X so so I figure how do we get people to know about it well this news I think is going to really fly [Applause] [Music] [Applause] so so every day between now and the election we'll be awarding a million dollars starting [Applause]

4:36[Music] tonight all right so tonight's person is John Dreer yeah [Music] all right thank you so by the way John had no no [Laughter] idea so anyway you're welcome and yeah so so so the the the only the only the only thing we ask for the million dollars is that you be a spokesperson for for the petition and that's it really that's the whole that's it and yeah that's it so wait do do you want to say anything yeah yeah yeah go ahead thanks Elon this is great I'm really ecstatic I want to congratulate you on your rocket catch Last Week Big cball but yeah been F I've been following you for for 10 years got your biography 10 years ago and been watching ever since and big fan so thank

6:07you all right well cool so yeah so I think this is kind of fun and you know it's it seems Seems like a good use of money basically so and we you know we really need to to go all out to protect the Constitution the Constitution is there for a reason there was great wisdom in that in that document and and and if if if anything you know we I just it is it is what will save us from tyranny and yeah

6:56[Applause] [Music] well let's see so I don't actually have any like as as you can see there's no teleprompter or or anything I'm just like what should I say next I don't know but but you know the it's worth reiterating why why I'm I'm supporting Donald Trump for president and you know there's I I I think important things that that need to happen I mean I think we want we we essentially want the sensible basic things we want safe cities we want secure borders we want obviously support for the Constitution we we you know we want I think a less go

7:54government sort of overreach and you know really we I think we want to we want to restore freedom to the people you know so that your that your individual Levi are prized and and you get to do what you want to do and and you're not sort of overregulation to death which is kind of what's Happening you know it's it's sort of shocking that I think there's something like 428 federal agencies that that's almost two agencies per year since the founding of the country and more being created and so I I call this like sort of strangulation by overregulation and this is crazy so I think with with with a trump presidency we have real opportunity to reduce the size of government to

8:50have sensible regulation and and and and really free the American people to do what they want to do so [Music] [Applause] yeah I mean I I'm not sure like these are sort of rightwing values I don't they seem like sensible values I mean like in fact I find it strange that these are even question marks frankly so it's it's the it's just it's just just obvious things that that should happen

9:37so well you know what let let's let's go straight into to Q&A because I feel like you know you a lot of things you've kind of heard before or people out there have heard before you know and if if you know if I keep repeating myself it's going to be kind of boring so better to have questions and then the questions can lead to you know interesting discussions and one you know note I should make with respect to to questions or comments the the kind of questions or comments you want to have are things that that you think the public would be interested in hearing so it's sort of you know what what what would people out there be interested in in hearing

10:25hearing me answer or or hearing you say and and that that's the way to kind of think about the the framing of the questions please go ahead hey Elon BJ woren absolute honor to meet you tonight first I just want to say thank you for your leadership we all really appreciate what you're doing it's absolutely amazing that you're even here out here doing this absolutely well you know really appreciate that I mean the the reason that I'm I'm doing this is because I I really think we're at a fork in the road of Destiny and this this election is an absolutely crucial one I haven't been I have not been politically active before and I'm politically active

11:06now because every Instinct that I have tells me that this this is a folk in the road of of Destiny so so you you obviously are interested in Pennsylvania and there's even a rumor that you might want to invest in Pennsylvania that's that's that's true actually I spoke with yeah so well well my first question is would you want to go haves with me on the Pittsburgh Pirates we could really piss off Mark

11:36Cuban no now the real question you're a numbers guy you're you're looking at the numbers yeah what are you seeing here in Pennsylvania and others that's giv you encouragement and what are you concerned about well I I'm I'm very much encouraged by the enthusiasm that I see obviously in the you know the crowd tonight is incredible energy and enthusiasm it's like you know

11:59it's it's it's it's heartening it's really heartening it's it encourages me because sometimes sometimes I wonder is is you know is there enthusiasm is there energy to make things happen because sometimes you know like our biggest issue is often apathy you know is that is if if the people that if if the people that could vote just actually voted then Trump would win for

12:22sure you know so so so a lot of it is is I think convincing people who sometimes feel like the vote doesn't matter or it's all rigged or or whatever that that actually your the vote does matter and if if there's any election in their lifetime that they're going to vote they should vote in this one this one really is a big deal

12:48so you know I I I really want to encourage people out there to to you know this this is this is a one-time ask just go out there and talk to your friends and family and acquaintances and people you meet on the street and and and convince them to vote make obviously you got to get registered make sure they're registered and then and make sure they vote this this this one this is a big one this this is a really big one and I've never said that before so I I this this one you got to go all out you know all out [Applause] [Music] yeah youon I'm senator Greg rothen welcome to central Pennsylvania we're so glad you're [Applause] here so so you've been in Pennsylvania

13:37at least the last week or so anything surprises you about this state our Commonwealth what have you noticed what have you seen that that's have been a surprise to you well you know I I I I did live here for three years so I'm not like a total stranger I went to college in Pennsylvania so you know I'm not like some you know guy just like what is the state what's it like I I lived here for three years so no it's it's a you know it's a great state I really enjoyed my time here and it's and and and I think actually

14:14Pennsylvania is it really it's the lynchpin in this election you know and it's a so it's how Pennsylvania goes I think is how the election goes and yeah yeah Elon my name is chandi I'm one of the pastors here thank you for hosting your town hall here at Life Center in Pennsylvania my question for you is would you hold an official position in the Trump Administration if so what would it be would you create a new role for you to help save our nation well

14:54yes so I and and I've had many conversations with president Trump who is very much aligned in in thinking that we need significant government reform we we need to get get the government out of people's lives really and and and and have America be the land of liberty which is that that's that is what has made America great is is the land of liberty and opportunity you know so you you maximize people's personal freedom and and and and we make sure that getting ahead is a function of of of hard work and talent and you know in honest days work that's really what should get people ahead and that's the only thing you know [Applause]

15:47so hello Elon Jerel with genuine assets I'm welcome to Pennsylvania again my my question for you Elon is the biggest obstacle that you've had in life and how you turn that obstacle into an opportunity well I guess I've I've had a lot of obstacles I I certainly didn't expect to you know be get get the things done that I that I have gotten done I I quite frankly I I expected failure so

16:22it was really just that I wanted to be to do something that was as useful as possible I wanted to be as useful ful as possible and that that that was it really so I I didn't even really actually originally intend to even start a company I try to get a job at Netscape after graduating from pen and I know Mark Andre's a friend of mine and but they didn't they didn't respond to my my resume that I mailed in so I was like okay well I guess I'll try writing software I I've been writing software since I was a kid so I I'll write some internet software and and see if I can do some useful you know applications on the internet and I ended up sort of writing the first maps and

17:09directions and yellow pages and white pages on the internet back in '95 and and that it was just really because nobody would give me a job on the internet so that that was it if they given me a job I I guess I would have just worked at Escape or something but I I my my best advice really is just like you know try to do an honest day's work and try to be as useful as possible to your fellow human beings you know try to give more than you take and I just have a lot of respect for people who do an honest day work you know that that's what really matters [Applause]

17:53so how's it going Elon good to see you my name is Josh I'm worried about kids in a big way I grew up in Wyoming County up north small town area real conservative got a education at Penn State economics and it really turned me away from my father and our small business that we had I was basically raised to take it over and I did once

18:27I graduated but it kind of imploded afterwards about a year and I I moved to California and I I didn't know what really happened we got in a big argument and I just I had to go you know was freeze so flight happened next ex explored homosexuality considered transitioning to a female and wow this is quite the journey yeah and I think that there's there's a big problem with education that is having people I guess my question is what are other things we can do besides the impact that we can have on the Department of Education to help confused children that are trying to know who they are and how they can fit into their community and be productive

19:27sure yeah well I I think I think there's there's there's well what I think I mean what I see is that there's there's like a tremendous amount of propaganda being pushed on kids in schools and it's it's it's I think it's just messing with with with kids heads you know I mean anyone that goes through puberty it's it's a it's going to be an identity crisis you know going through puberty like it's normal kind of to have an identity crisis really and I think we should tell you know tell kids like yeah you know if if it's if you're confused that's that's okay it's like it's it's coming of age you know we we shouldn't like steer them in a particular direction or convince them of

20:12something that's that they're not it's it's just it's okay to go through an identity crisis everyone does and but I think what I see in in schools is that that they tend to send kids down paths that they that that you know they wouldn't actually go down because that they're being pushed down that by that way by the teachers you know and by the propaganda that's pushing the schools [Music]

20:45so I I think it's we need to tell kids it's okay to to live with uncertainty that it's that it's normal to have uncertainty and it'll it'll settle it'll settle down over time and you know and and don't make any permanent decisions you know like decisions that can't be reversed can't be reversed so you know I I think we we definitely should not have any any sort of sterilization of kids you know below 18 that's no good

21:23that that there's an age of consent for a reason and you know we don't let kids get tattoos until they're 18 and we don't you know alcohol is technically illegal until 21 although that's often you know observed in the breach so but but we just want people to not make decisions when they're young that make them unhappy as an adult that's really what it comes down to and I think you want to say we want to optimize for people's long-term happiness and and that but that means like making sure like I said that that there are no irreversible changes during a kid when a

22:07kid has an identity crisis which every kid has and that's totally cool and so my yeah my opinion is we should just tell kids if when they're going through puberty and an identity crisis that's totally normal and don't get too stressed about it and things will settle out how they settle out and you know that's the right thing to [Applause]

22:35do hello thank you very much Mr elen musk my name is Linka white I'm a legal immigrant from the Czech Republic we are all very grateful for X I think it's the only platform where we can find the truth and not only here in the United States but in places like Europe my question is what is your vision on the future of the media under Harris versus Under Trump how it would look like and can the Legacy Media still earn the trust back and what would happen to X of course thank you so much sure well no it's a it's a great question because I there's a there's a I mean there's I think what we'll see is a lot of censorship under sort of

23:28the a CALA regime you know Kamala is really just she's just a puppet frankly I mean you know if the teleprompter breaks doesn't know what to say so I it's you know I I just call it the the the machine you know the the kind of big government machine essentially and you sort of have a face on the big government machine and and and when when when the when the Biden puppet had you know was not working out they they sort of got a new puppet but it's still the same machine obviously and it's extremely undemocratic what was done you know

24:04[Music] it's it's it's bizarre and hypocritical to claim that Trump is somehow a danger to democracy when what happened with Biden being removed as the candidate was incredibly undemocratic yeah so it doesn't make sense but there's there's there's clearly a strong a strong push for censorship under the guid of fighting disinformation and but but really disinformation is a propaganda word it it's it's not a it's well who's who's going to decide what's disinformation the government that's crazy you know so

24:46that that's you know yeah so I I I think we'll see it this is like a very this is why we have this petition in support of freedom of speech and right to bear arms is that it's it's under siege it's being attacked but really we should we should have the free Marketplace of ideas people can propose an idea they can you know the people can discuss an idea and and they can make make a statement people can reut that they can you can have you know the sort of the the people can decide and you know I

25:23think it's it's far better for information to sort of Bubble Up from the the voice of the people than to be decided by a handful of editors and Chiefs of of newspapers you know that's [Applause] yeah I mean the the the sort of the biggest point of manipulation that occurs in the media is is not when the media says something that's false or or misleading but because when they do that but but their choice of narrative what are they going to talk about is that

26:06that's by by choosing to focus on one thing and not focus on another thing that they're sort of steering what what information the public receives whereas I think the right thing is that the the narratives that are important should be the narratives that the people as a whole think are important not what a you know a a few media ologs think is

26:34important so yeah but they they they sure like controlling information so I I I think we're if if if if if if the Kamala machine wins then we'll we'll see I think sever censorship is what's going to happen and that's why I think this is the last election yeah thanks to you Cala is not going to win I'm [Applause] [Music] Chad my name is Chad berer I'm from right here in central Pennsylvania and I I don't think that was an overstatement thanks to you Camala will not win I have two questions regarding the election itself and what you believe can be done to create not only a victory but a a strong Victory yes I'm now convinced that again thanks to you we're going to

27:37sweep the seven states that we must win but I also hope we could pick up New Hampshire New Jersey and Virginia so I wonder what your thoughts are as to how decisive the victory could be and then number two as was referenced earlier we and all of America is very enthused about you working with Donald Trump to make our government appropriately smaller and more effective

28:09so because that message is so compelling I wonder if your Super PAC could be a little more clear about that point as it relates to you affecting that upgrade to this great country certainly I'm I'm happy to clarify that you know I I you know I think I'm a lot of the things I say I feel like I'm just stating the obvious but but sometimes the obvious isn't what happens or is that if if America is

28:43not strong if the West is not strong then nothing else matters like you know the companies that I run that they don't matter like basically if like America is the Central poll holding up the tent that is worse than civilization and if that if that poll fails Nothing Else Matters nothing else

29:10matters so you know I I've and I'm trying to encourage a lot of people in you know business and technology to say like hey don't you just got to think long term you don't you don't even need to be alistic you just got to think long term and say if America fails what good is your business it do do matter so America must be strong the and and the the central pole that holds up the T of Western Civilization must be f as no

29:43so hi Elon my name is Josel and thank you for saving Free Speech M my question is what would you expect to see when you had the government efficiency Department what are your strategies and priorities to curb government spending well I've had some exposure to government spending because you know SpaceX has does have a lot of government contracts you know does a lot of work for NASA and for DOD Intel and whatnot and so I I've I've actually seen just the level of waste that that happens and and if you talk to people the government they they actually agree yes this is very wasteful and inefficient and I'm like well why don't we do something about it and but but

30:34really in order to do something about it it has to be a mandate from the top and if if if the president is you know if we have a great president like like Donald Trump who who's willing to make major changes and and difficult because the system will fight you you know the system is not going to be like oh yeah no totally we're we're totally happy being smaller that that will not be like the sort of antibody reaction of the system will be quite severe you know that I don't think it's going to be they're not going to you know like it basically so but you have to have that mandate from from the president and we need a real president not a puppet

31:15you [Applause] know you know the the thing that the thing that that that scares the system that scares the machine is that Donald Trump is not a puppet he's a real person you know and he's not behold to anyone and and that's why you see sort of you know that they're trying to kill him you know and you know I I

31:44mentioned as a as a joke I meant it as a joke that that no one's even bothering to try to kill Camala U you know because there's no point there's no point is what I just get another puppet you know so I I'm I'm not suggesting someone should try to kill her it's pointless but I'm just saying I'm just making an observation nobody's bothered why is that because it doesn't

32:11matter yeah assassinating a pop out is pointless so yeah [Applause] [Music] hi youan I'm Chad Wick from Westchester Pennsylvania and I think more more people are voting for Trump than ever before it's historically been Democratic I wear my trump hat and walking around people come up to me all the time all Races all Sexes and they're like cheers let's go I just like let's go yeah Mega exactly all right so Mega loud and proud let's go yeah I I I encourage people to put Trump Vance signs on their loan and we mag much because a lot of it is like people you know a lot of people like they will like they they actually would like to support Donald Trump

33:05but they they they aren't sure if anyone around them does too and and a lot of people so you got to sort of you know if you sort of kind of plant the flag then then people like yeah you know I see other people are doing it then maybe I will too so yeah thank you for doing what you're doing 100% thank you for what you're doing thank you for standing up for Trump and putting your voice out there because it's really important seeing your face the richest person in the world that's you so thank you for that yeah I mean

33:33I just I I I built some companies that are do a lot of useful things and as a result the Stock's worth a lot so that's what that's kind of what happens it's like you know but in terms of personal expenditures I I I do not live a particularly you know I don't have like a Yachts or or Islands or anything like that I just work you know so [Music]

34:03good evening Elon my name is Jared it's a pleasure and honor to meet you here in Pennsylvania and it's honor and pleasure to meet all you guys you guys [Applause] rock I mean this is this is fire I mean seeing the level of enthusiasm is just I mean it's it's this is firing me up big time this is awesome yeah me too

34:30USA USA absolutely I have a two-part question part A I admire your authenticity as well as Donald Trump and truly wanting to make America great again giving up whatever you need to just do the right thing even if it's unpopular yeah with all the government spending that you keep talking about on X do you believe that in combination with the Department of government efficiency with Donald Trump's policies do you think we can reduce the US national debt that's currently at under $36 trillion and Part B is that after you do it we have to like if we if we don't do something about the debt it's going to like this is like for some reason you know just

35:09the Legacy mainstream media just ignores the fact that America is going bankrupt like crazy it's like at a rate that is unprecedented and the the the reality is that all government spending is is is taxation so even so people like think well this there's government spending and Taxation somehow separate but they're not all government spending is taxation because the deficit is what results in inflation and and so and inflation is a de facto tax because it it it causes you know old prices to rise and makes you know people trying to just live their lives have a lot of difficulty but inflation throughout history has been used as a pernicious tax because because because it's like

35:52it's one degree removed so people don't feel it directly they sort of and and then the politicians will try to blame it on something else but it's all about government spending if it government spending is what drives inflation so if the key is we've got to reduce the government spending and if we don't we're going to go bankrupt as a country end of story just like a person you know if a if a person spends beyond their means they go bankrupt and and we're spending beyond our means and and we're spending on like silly stuff that doesn't actually benefit the public correct yeah two to that I believe you're going to do that with Donald Trump I'm just telling you that it's not

36:31if it's when cuz I am confident you and Donald Trump are going to truly make America great again well thank you but I I I I do want to I do want to caution against against complacency is the only thing so it's like we just need to be super hardcore right about getting every possible vote confidency have not complacency yes exactly we want to be confident but not not complacent corre and so that's why it's like we got to just be total evangelists about the voting and and and really every vote counts and just make sure everyone you know is registered the deadline for registration in in Pennsylvania is Monday yeah midnight Monday like you can register

37:06online it's super easy but like Hound everyone you know to get registered because after after M midnight on Monday it can't it's it's no good and this is a silly question but when you cut the government spending and all you have a stack of all these deregulations can you live stream on X and use not a flame thrower and burn that to the ground yeah great idea yeah I I I think I think a a a a bond a bonfire of nonsense regulations would be epic yeah and you know sometimes people sometimes people look concerned like well what if there's some regulation that's actually really important and and we get rid of that and say well you know what we'll put it right back

37:58problem solved so all right Mr mosa thank you for speaking directly with the voters of the United States it's a pretty great VI yeah absolutely removing yourself from the equation what does it say about the Biden Harris Administration and the wouldbe Harris Administration that she had that they haven't worked with such great American companies such as SpaceX TW Tesla and then even speak out against X yeah I mean it's it's it's pretty weird you know

38:38yeah because it's it's it was kind of kind of a surprise because it's like you know Biden you know for for example had that like electric vehicle Summit at the White House 6 months after getting inaugrated and specifically excluded Tesla even though Tesla makes more electric cars than yeah it was it was not cool cool and and and then credited GM with driving the electric vehicle Revolution and in the same that was a second event and then in that quarter GM shipped 26 electric cars and Tesla shipped 300,000 so I'm [Applause] like and and you know Tesla's at this point about 140,000 people it's it's really it's like there's a lot of Blood Sweat and Tears from 140,000 people

39:26working hard to to make great great electric cars and you know to be sort of cold shouldered like that for no reason it's like what's the deal you know that was wrong so yeah and and then there was like that crazy thing where SpaceX competed for the rural Broadband initiative which and and and by the way I'm actually generally against subsidies and incentives you know like we should let tax taxpayers keep their money as is my opinion but but they had this like $42 billion thing and we competed and and we won and and we we would have actually been able to supply a lot of U stalling terminals to the states that were affected by the Hurricanes and

40:14they they they revoked the award it's messed up like why and then and then to dat that 42 billion program total number of of of citizens that have received Broadband from that $42 billion allocation is zero now that's if if you want to the $42 billion for zero I would call that waste yeah that's waste that is not a good use of money

40:48you know so there was also a big government initiative I think $7 billion something like that for Nationwide network of electric super Chargers and I think they they got made like 10 I'm like this is the most egregious waste of money and there's so many situations like that so you know it just goes like bureaucrats and consultants and nothing gets done and and it's it's wasting your money which is crazy so I one I'm

41:22saying like there's there's the opportunity to reduce government waste is is actually actually I think easy because there's so much of it you know it's it's it's not like it's they just don't care about your money which is messed up and so so I think the department of government efficiency is going to face a Target Rich environment for reducing [Applause] [Music] cost hi Elon I've been waiting years for you to join the Maga movement so we're so glad you did yeah I guess my question is you keep repeating that most of these things we believe in are common sense and I really feel like they are yeah do you have any woke friends and how do you deal with

42:16them well I I I mean I I have been red pilling my friends like crazy lately so I fewer and fewer work friends at least they're still friends but they're not woke so you know they I I think where you know where the sort of you know the sort of good interpretation of the the W movement is is that we want to have empathy for our fellow human beings and of course we want to have empathy for our fellow humans I I strong strongly believe we should care about humanity and we we should care about the future but but the but but we we need to have empathy that is deep not shallow you know shallow empathy is caring about criminals but but deep empathy is

43:05caring about the victims of the criminals you know and so you know why why do we have you know violent off repeat violent offenders released on the streets often with no bail it's crazy and they pray upon people innocent people you know and and then our streets are not safe and and how can America be the greatest country in the world and we don't even have Safe Streets you know this is so crazy you know I was talking to my mom and and she was saying like just this year like three three of our friends have been assaulted in New York you know and and it's and I said well was anyone arrested no they don't even try this

43:53is we can't have this you know people deserve to to you know have safe cities and and secure borders and basic stuff like that you know yeah so I think I think it's I I do feel that there there's there's a shifting of of of you know shifting of perception and I think we I I think I hope I'm not being too optimistic but a nationally optimistic person obviously but I I do feel as though that there's a shift in National mindset and a shift to to

44:37more to to just common sense and and and not believing everything the the media tells you and and I I think actually in in the US people are starting to realize that you know the Legacy Media is just a propaganda machine and and in in Europe they still believe they still believe the news so we got to work we got to work on Europe they they still they still think the news is real but you know here you know

45:10thanks to X and and and and just you know people being I think maybe a bit more aware and having and having an actual Free Speech Constitutional Amendment is is has helped Americans you know understand what is what is actually real and I mean I do find it remarkable like the just just how

45:32sort of coordinated the Legacy Media is in in in their talking points it's absurd and and I kudos to to those who who put together the compilations of of you know where where all of the talking heads will say the same thing word for word yeah and they they'll say the exact same thing and and you know but I mean I think the propaganda is not even good frankly it's not even entertaining and and you know so you know what the week before the Biden Trump debate you know every media organization was saying that Biden sh is attack you know the exact same words sh is Attack sh's Attack over and over again then it became obvious to the public that he was

46:23indeed not a sh as attack and and but then immediately the Legacy Media pivoted to knifing knifing Biden and anointing a successor so we see this over and over again and yeah so anyway but that's why we need to have the voice of the people and and and that's that's that's you know why I felt it was necessary to acquire Twitter and and and you know [Applause] thank you the like the the the whole the whole point of acquiring Twitter was to restore the voice of the people [Applause]

47:13so and and it's important to note that the while while the the far-left activist that used to control Twitter obviously did extreme censorship of voices on the right there has been no censorship of voice is on the left that you know they they suspended a sitting president you know s have suspended a sitting president which is insane and but there's been no suspension or censorship or Shadow Banning or anything of anyone on the left so you know it's a Level Playing Field but but I I I think the the the re the reason that you that the sort of far-left activists want you unanimity in in all social media platforms and in all Legacy Media is that their ideas do

48:04not stand the light of day that is the reason they they don't they they don't they actually don't stand up and so inless everyone is parting the same thing their ideas will fail so hello Mr musk my name is Zeon Thomas and you know I was going to ask for Millions but my parents told me to keep it professional so well it's it's actually still possible that you may win that in the so but yeah so you taking over Twitter was awesome I want to know what other radical ideas you have to save our nation while working with Trump yeah well I I I try to be as literal literal as possible so you know the the the you stated on the at America you know the America pack U website

49:02and X account I try to be just as straightforward and literal as possible you know so that's why it's sort of safe cities secure borders sensible spending you know protect the Constitution especially the right to free speech and these are all like I said things that seem very obvious and frankly normal U and but they're not being done and and they're in in severe danger if the Kamala machine

49:36wins hi I'm Mickey and I've been working with voter registration and a lot of people are concerned about the escalation in the US military in Israel because there's over a hundred troops there on land now what do you think of this idea a boring company offering to build an island off the coast of Israel and call it pal Palestine they can finally have their nation state like Cyprus it's been done in China Dubai and the Philippines and we can finally end these endless Wars could there be enough Rubble in Gaza to do it thank you well that I mean the Gaza is a thorny problem indeed you know the M Middle East has been an area of contention well for

50:19thousands of years I I I would I would say that I I do not know the solution to that difficult situation there so I'm not sure there there is I'm not sure there is a good solution there may be but the the but I I I think we we need to make sure that America is is solid like so I I'm I'm like let's just make sure America is is is strong and you know there's I I mean I I I do think we we interfered too much in in what other countries do and and and and and a lot of our

51:05attempts at regime change in fact our the success of this of you know the state department in achieving regime change is terrible I mean you know so this all this effort spent like all this money spent trying to affect regime change in various countries but failed in Cuba failed in Iran failed in North Korea failed in Russia was what wait where were the successes but we but we we a lot of people died and a lot of money was spent and and but no what good has come of it so I think we should interfere with other countries a lot

51:50less hi Elon my name's Luke I'm a local Liberty Liberty lover who lives just across the river actually I find the idea that basically everything that we care about is dependent on a single federal election to for lack of a better word be unacceptable so what I've U what I and some colleagues of mine have t have talked about is decentralization and localism specifically nullification at the state and local level of the federal Leviathan yeah

52:24at the state level the 10th Amendment Center has done great work the basis of nullification is the 10th Amendment the idea that no powers I mean I I agree the federal government should get off people's backs yeah absolutely and do you believe that nullification is a viable path forward to getting that done well I can't speak to whether that is legally would legally stand up or not I mean but I I think if there's an executive branch and we also need to you know try to win the Senate and the house but if there's if there's you know a cons consensus that that the federal government should do less and restore power to the states and to the communities which I think should be

53:12the case then then I think we can make that happen yeah hi Elon my name is Edward and one of the really great things about going into these rallies are the people that you meet Tuesday of the JD Vance rally I spoke to some young students and they wanted to be Health Care Professionals and the hardest thing for them to deal with was the financial obligations of doing it trying to get an apartment and everything else and I mean I went to Germany and college is free over there so there's no one in the world that can tell me that America can't do it better well can can you help those rilees of the World out please well I I think there are a lot of

54:01issues with with college education it's gotten very expensive because the administrative portion of of colleges and universities has grown dramatically compared to the educational portion so you say like how much is actually spent on teaching people very little so so the you know and so I think that you've got these these these sort of administ rid of groups that are the far outnumber the actual number of professors and and like there isn't actually a need for college to be so expensive it it it it should be far less expensive but the sort of bureaucratic creep and the administrative burden have grown dramatically over time and that is what has caused college to be so

54:47expensive it's it doesn't make any sense so yeah but but but there there is I mean if if we if we do sort of make college free we have to be careful about that because it then it's open season for wasteful spending at universities and like then how bad it is now is going to be even worse in the future I I think I think we need new universities to compete with the existing ones because what actually matters is how good is your education not how much was spent on administrative BS you know

55:31I I I also think that like the the the value of a college education is is somewhat overweighted you know and I I I think it's to too too many people actually spend spend four years accumulate a ton of debt and then don't often don't have useful skills that they can apply afterwards and I think I have a lot of respect for people who work with their hands and we we need electricians and plumers and carpenters and you know that's that's a lot more important than having incremental Pol political science Majors I think you know so

56:12it I I think we should not have this idea that that to be successful you need to have a four-year of college that that is simply not true hello Elon my name is beam it's a pleasure to meet you my question is as we near the election I know you're covering a lot of ground going to Battleground States how important do things do you think adbis will be this election because in 2020 Mike Bloomberg we know spent a vast amount of money trying to get Biden into the White House so are you looking into that and yeah that's my question well actually I'm I'm not sure I mean the amount of money spent on advertising in the Battleground States is truly staggering and and in

56:54fact the the Democrats are outspending Republicans dramatically depending on how you count it I think it's like two or three times more money is being spent by Democrats and Republicans U and in addition they have the Legacy Media on this side and they have a whole bunch of Hollywood celebrities on this side so it's remarkable that this election is in contention at all given that they have really you know all all that on their on their side so but but I guess

57:24you got to you got to reach people with message somehow so I think probably you know we do need to do more advertising just so that people will hear the message but in in my opinion the thing that's actually most important is is is is getting friends family acquaintances anyone you run into to register to vote and then to actually vote so it's and and this this this election could be decided by you know a thousand people 100 people it could be a very tiny margin so every incremental person makes a difference and and I've seen some some pretty wild numbers where there's I think even right now there's a there's a a lot of people that have requested a

58:14lot of Republicans that have requested absentee ballots but they have not mailed them in I'm like guys mail it in come on just mail in your ballot you can do it you have it in your house mail it in now would be a good time and if you're worried about the mail you can bring it in person so I I

58:36yeah I I I think it's very important to encourage people to to to vote like like said I'm I'm really emphasizing this registration point because it's we've only got a couple days left for registration so that that's why it's the to the top priority is is is get get people registered before Monday night and and then make sure that they vote and and I would recommend voting early and then you can check to see if your your vote's been received you know it's it's that's you you I think there's there should be a lot more Republicans voting early

59:16yeah hi Miss hi Mr mus it's a pleasure to be able to speak to you thank you so much for pushing the world forward in every industry and I'm sure you'll be doing the same now in politics so my question is given the recent hacking of Donald Trump how important do you think it is for the tech industry and government to back platforms that prioritize privacy and secure Communications such as signal and do you see an opportunity for your companies to partner with this platform or to better protect user data or even Safeguard government Communications yeah I mean there there's always this debate between you know privacy and security but I think the bias should be towards

59:55privacy you know I I I think we should not trust the government really and we just shouldn't so and and I'd say even if even if I'm in the government don't trust the government like that's it's just you know we we've we've got to protect the privacy of of citizens and and you know and make sure that

1:00:23people really have their Liberty and they're not not being spied on or you know manipulated so you know yeah so I I I I think we we need to make sure that there are not like back doors and and and and weird things and that that where where the government can you know spy on and potentially you know take action against people yeah hey Elon my name is Ron Blau I'm from Harrisburg before I ask my election question I just have to tell you that I accidentally caught the launch and catch of both sections of Starship on live and it was breathtaking which I know everyone in here knows but I want you to ack or be acknowledged for the level of inspiration that you're

1:01:11creating worldwide I was cheering in my office like watching this thing go down and so thank you for that no you're most welcome I mean I think it's it was a yeah I mean it certainly inspired me and and that's it's a that's a Testament to the the incredible work by the SpaceX team very talented super hardworking team and you know the

1:01:37the making Rockets fully and rapidly reusable is really what's going to open up a space for Humanity and enable us to have a base on the moon and build a city on Mars and be a space bearing civilization so the a lot of people don't realize like the difference between like an expandable rocket and a reusable rocket is like 10,000% it's literally at least you can think of it just the difference between you know what is the cost to you know fill up you know fill up a car versus buy a car that it's the same difference for Rockets you know do you do you if you have to if a new rocket is needed every flight that's super expensive and difficult but if you only

1:02:19have to refill the rocket it's dramatically cheaper just like it is for a car or an airplane understood pulling that off and doing the catch and The Landing in the ocean was just so Stellar yeah all right so my my question is on U election night 2020 I sat down to watch the returns and I watched them steal the election all right I saw it live watched it all night okay if you were watching it then you knew at nine o'clock when Fox declared Arizona that it was going down and that was the moment okay but even worse than that was over the next months watching the courts and the shenanigans in the courts and the lack of good representation that Trump had and just

1:03:04nothing happening because there was obviously a problem nothing would seem to be happening in the courts at all and between that day and now it doesn't look like anything has changed and so we're about to to I think the votes matter but the count is what matters and if the courts are corrupted we're not going to get anywhere and so do you have are you participating in that it seems as though you're aware of that how can you help solve that issue so that we don't have that problem again yeah [Music] [Applause] well I mean the if if the margin of

1:03:41Victory is high enough then I think any it can exceed any any sort of cheating that may take place so we got to aim for just a massive margin that's the key it's it's really aim for a margin that it is impossible to have any Shenanigans but but on the xplatform we'll I certainly would invite people to you know if there's any voting

1:04:08issues you know if if they people think there fraud then they then post the images post the videos post the evidence and and let's shine a bright light on on and the brighter the light the harder it will be to cheat [Applause] hi Elon it's a pleasure to make your acquaintance thank you for the work you're doing for Humanity there are a lot of changes happening in our world right now a lot of changes happening in our own country and these changes are being perceived as chaos but I always say that if it wasn't for chaos we wouldn't be able to experience peace if it wasn't for chaos we wouldn't be able to experience growth and evolution and with AI being the new

1:04:55K on the Block and advancing at an incredible Pace I guess my question is how do you foresee the election of President Donald Trump influencing technological advancements and societal transformation well I I think the H reducing this sort of you know strangulation by overregulation is a super big deal you know the our the the rocket that we're just talking about it was sitting on the on the launch pad for two months waiting for paperwork to be processed and it's just insane that that the SpaceX team can build a giant rocket faster than the government can move paperwork from one desk to another like that's just crazy and and and the problem is that's

1:05:48that's getting worse and worse every year so if that Trend continues it's just going to be illegal you know we just won't be able to get anything done so the this that's why I I call it like this this this extreme overregulation where there's just new agencies being created every year and and the difficulty of getting anything done is like the square of the number of agencies involved so if there's one agency it's like one but if there's like three agencies it's like nine times harder because they all have to meet with each other and you know we get crazy things like SpaceX got fined $140,000 for dumping portable

1:06:28drinking water on the ground at at at at Starbase where where we launch the rocket because we you know we cool we cool the launch pad with with water and in an excess of caution we said you know we're going to bring in drinking water just to be sure and and and we're going to cool the pad with that we didn't know there was a like a permit needed for that I like water falls from the sky all the time you know it it it start is in a tropical thunderstorm area it rains so much that the roads get flooded why are we getting fined for a tiny amount of water on the ground but EPA said they're not going to process any future applications for launch unless we pay this F so we just got you

1:07:12know held for ransom basically and that's tip of the iceberg I mean I got I got a bunch of sort of nutty stories you know some of them are I guess kind of funny there you know we had to do this SpaceX had to do the study to see if if Starship would would hit a shark and I'm like it's a big ocean you

1:07:38know there's a lot of sharks it's not impossible but it's very unlikely and and said well you have you know this is I think from from National marine fisheries one of the you know nymph it's called and you know they were like well you have to do the study on whether you're going to hit a shark we're like what and then like then I we said okay fine we we we'll do the analysis and then well can you give us the Shar data they're like no we can't give you the Shar data well like okay well then we're a bit of a quandry how do we solve this difficult this this shock probability issue and and they they said well well we could give it to our Western

1:08:21Division but we don't trust them and I'm like am I in a comedy sketch here and like they're worried about the shock density data like the people who hunt shocks for shock fins somehow getting their hands on this shock D the shock data and and So eventually I think we we we we got the data and and we could you know run the analysis to fig say like yeah the shocks are going to be fine but but they wouldn't let us proceed with launch until we did this crazy Shar data and and then we thought okay now we're done they said but water about whales I'm like when you look at a picture of the Pacific what percentage of the sofs area of the Pacific do you see as whale

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份