2023 年,全人类送进地球轨道的载荷,有 80% 来自同一家公司。这家公司叫 SpaceX。
马斯克把这张图投在屏幕上的时候,专门解释了一下分母:全世界其他所有人,欧洲、印度、中国、日本,全都算进去。他说很少有哪个行业,一家公司能占到 80% 的份额。更离谱的是今年这个数字还要再涨 50%,大概会到 90%,而且这还没算星舰。
发布会现场的反应是鼓掌。马斯克自己补了一句:反正我从来不发虚假的赞美,2023 年是这家公司历史上最好的一年。
96 次发射,把苏联保持了四十年的纪录翻过去一半
猎鹰 9 号(Falcon 9)去年飞了 96 次。此前单一年度发射次数的纪录由苏联的联盟号(Soyuz)保持,一年 60 多次。马斯克说,没有其他任何一个轨道级火箭家族,一年超过 63 次。SpaceX 比这个数字多出 50%。
猎鹰重型(Falcon Heavy)去年飞了 5 次,在重型运载这个类别上超过了土星五号(Saturn 5)的历史记录。土星五号是阿波罗登月用的那枚火箭,人类历史上推力最大的火箭之一,它退役时留下的记录被一枚靠三根猎鹰 9 号芯级拼起来的火箭刷掉了。
更让马斯克自己觉得不真实的是当时的节奏。他说有一阵子他发推特,发完自己都恍惚,这是刚刚发射的那次,还是正在发射的那次?因为几天之内连着飞了三次。
这 96 次任务里,三分之二是星链,三分之一是其他客户。他特意强调了一半以上的非星链任务:NASA 的灵神星探测器(Psyche)、欧空局的欧几里得望远镜(Euclid)、美国空军的 X-37B 太空飞机、多次 Transporter 拼车任务、OneWeb、Viasat,以及跟亚马逊的柯伊伯(Kuiper)星座签下的发射合同。
跟亚马逊签合同这件事值得单独说一下。星链和柯伊伯是直接竞争对手,马斯克说我们一视同仁,该发射就发射。这句话背后的意思是:猎鹰 9 号的产能和价格,已经强到竞争对手也不得不用。
一枚助推器飞 19 次,回收这件事从笑话变成常识
有一枚猎鹰 9 号助推器在三年半时间里飞了 19 次,送了 860 颗卫星上天,累计把 260 吨载荷送进轨道。
距离人类第一次成功回收轨道级火箭助推器,已经过去八年。2015 年 12 月的那次着陆之后,SpaceX 累计完成了 260 次着陆。
马斯克提到了当年的舆论:很多人说做不到;还有很多人说,就算做得到,这主意也很蠢,不划算,没有商业意义。他的结论是,重复使用被证明完全正确,而且它是太空未来的门票。他举的类比很朴素:汽车能重复用,飞机能重复用,自行车能重复用,连马都能重复骑,火箭凭什么一次性扔掉。
他把这件事上升到文明级别:人类要变成多行星物种,必须先有一枚完全、快速可复用的可靠火箭。这是他理解的“根本性发明”。
整流罩、无人船和 24 小时周转
很多人不知道整流罩也是回收的。马斯克说这件事其实极其困难,花的力气非常大,但现在常态化回收,整流罩已经复用了 300 次。
还有一件事更少人知道:SpaceX 运营着一支小型船队。无人回收船加各类支援船,被他称为“一支小海军”。屏幕上的照片里,一个人走在甲板上,用来做尺寸参照。船身涂成黑色,马斯克自己的形容是有点达斯·维达(Darth Vader)的审美,但他喜欢。
发射台周转时间做到了 3 天,目标是在今年内压到 24 小时以内。今年计划飞 150 次左右。
15 年前,猎鹰 1 号(Falcon 1)第四次发射才第一次把东西送进轨道。马斯克现在回头看那枚小火箭,说自己大概能把它夹在胳膊底下带回家,在自家后院发射。可当年它看起来巨大无比,难到让人绝望。
真正衡量成就的数字是质量,不是次数
发射次数是表象。马斯克认为最能说明问题的是“入轨质量”这个指标。
2021 年,SpaceX 的入轨质量略低于世界其他地区的总和。2022 年,大概是其他人的两倍。2023 年,占了全球的 80%,总量 1200 吨。
他给了一个未来尺度:要在火星上建城市,需要的入轨质量是百万吨级。每 100 万吨送到地球轨道,大约有 20 万吨能落到火星表面。要让火星自持,落到火星表面的有效载荷至少得是百万吨级。
对比一下就很清楚,去年的 1200 吨,在这个目标面前等于零头。马斯克自己说,这些数字将来回头看会显得非常小。
龙飞船的在轨时间,超过了整个航天飞机机队
截至去年,龙飞船(Dragon)船队的累计在轨时间超过 1300 天,超过了美国航天飞机机队的总和。访问国际空间站的次数也超过了航天飞机。
去年所有龙飞船任务,用的都是飞过的飞船,没有一艘是全新的。今年计划飞 7 到 8 次载人任务。
SpaceX 累计把 42 个人送进轨道并接回来。马斯克在这里停顿了一下,说如果只能许一个愿望,他希望是把所有宇航员都安全带回来。
佛罗里达的第二个乘员登船臂也完工了。现在有两个发射台都能送宇航员上天,40 号台和 39A 台之间可以互相调配任务。对载人航天来说,这意味着一个台出问题不至于让整个计划停摆。
一件能在真空里走路的宇航服
发布会上放了一段新一代舱外宇航服的画面。马斯克说,这件衣服最难的地方在于它必须在充压之后还能动。
他的形容是:如果只是把衣服充上气,人就会变成派对上那种圆滚滚的气球,胳膊腿都弯不了。所以关节、活动范围、灵活性全部要重新设计。
更狠的是任务设计。执行首次商业太空行走时,整艘飞船会泄压,连不出舱的人也要待在真空里。马斯克说,衣服上不能有任何一个小孔,否则人在里面会翻着跟头失控。
他接着讲了一段听起来有点残酷的物理常识。飞机在高空漏气还能靠增压泵从大气里补,太空里没有地方可以取氧。龙飞船一旦出现严重的氧气泄漏,没有任何补救手段,人就会死。所以这套系统的要求是“绝对完美”,没有容错空间。
我们显然不是为在太空生活而进化出来的物种。(马斯克)
他的长期目标是让宇航服便宜、舒适、能大规模生产。理由很直接:如果真要送一百万人去火星,就需要一百万套火星服。
星链:把互联网在太空里重铺一遍
马斯克反复强调一件事,而且要求在演示文稿里写清楚:星链(Starlink)是对地面互联网的补充,不会取代它。
他知道外界有一种担心,觉得星链要吃掉所有地面运营商。他的回答是绝对不会,星链真正解决的是三种情况:没有网络的地区、网络贵得离谱的地区、网络烂得没法用的地区。
他把这件事的意义讲得很重。现在麻省理工学院的课程全都挂在 YouTube 上,只要你有网,几乎可以免费学到任何东西。没有网,你就只能翻手边那几本书。所以星链在他口中是“改善全球生活质量的游戏规则改变者”,长期看可能是最能提升人类生活水平的技术之一。
技术进展方面,第二代迷你星链卫星(V2 Mini)已经入轨,单星容量从去年的 88 Tbps 提升到 165 Tbps,接近翻倍。
技术上的头号目标是平均时延压到 20 毫秒以下。这个数字为什么重要,他算了一笔账:光速大约是每毫秒 300 公里,星链轨道高度 550 公里,信号上去约 2 毫秒,下来约 2 毫秒,一来一回的物理上限就是 8 毫秒。剩下的时间靠工程优化,他有信心压到 10 毫秒以内,那样在大多数场景下会比地面网络更灵敏。
他还顺带说了一句,打游戏的时候这个指标很要命,不然就输。
氩气推进器、9000 个太空激光器
星链卫星用的霍尔推进器换过工质。早期用氪(Krypton),氪不算特别稀有,但如果第二代卫星全用氪,SpaceX 会消耗掉全世界氪产量的很大一块。所以他们换成了氩(Argon)。
马斯克在这里开了个玩笑:你现在呼吸的空气里大约有 1% 是氩气,氩多到用不完。这套氩霍尔推进器被他称为第一个有实际规模的氩推进系统,也是成本和能效上最划算的。
另一项是星间激光链路。目前在轨有 9000 个活跃的太空激光器,每条链路 100 Gbps,还在往上提。马斯克说,通过太空激光链路传输的数据量,是此前任何系统的至少一千倍,很快可能是百万倍。他还拿“太空激光”这个说法自嘲,说这听起来像《王牌大贱谍》里反派博士(Dr. Evil)的台词,顺便提了一句龙飞船本身也带激光,用来跟空间站对接。
激光链路的意义在于,星链不必依赖地面站就能在卫星之间转发电波。跨洋、跨洲的流量可以走太空,时延比绕地面光纤更短。这是星链能跟地面网络比时延的技术底子。
手机直连卫星,和那声极微弱的耳语
首批手机直连(Direct to Cell)卫星已经上天,测试中手机能直接把短信发给卫星,再由卫星发回来。屏幕上那几条测试短信里有狗狗币的梗,马斯克特意说明是故意拼错的,他自己第一眼看到都怀疑是不是真的。
他觉得物理上最不可思议的地方是,卫星在几百公里外,能听见手机发出的那一点点信号。他的原话是,那声音微弱得像一声耳语,可它就是能听见。
这项业务的定位同样是补充,不跟运营商抢生意。一个波束的容量大约 7 Mbps,覆盖面积是几百平方英里。这意味着语音和短信没问题,视频基本别想,除非整个波束里只有你一个人,比如你漂在太平洋中间。
它真正救命的场景是徒步、探险、偏远地区失联。马斯克说这项技术会救很多人的命。
已经宣布合作的运营商有七家:美国的 T-Mobile、加拿大的 Rogers、澳大利亚的 Optus、新西兰的 One NZ、瑞士的 Salt、日本的 KDDI,以及智利和秘鲁的 Entel。今年还会继续签。
其他硬件进展:第四代用户终端已开始发货,成本在降;今年晚些时候会推出星链 Mini,能塞进背包;德州巴斯特罗普(Bastrop)的新工厂已经投产,距离奥斯汀大约 20 分钟车程;社区网关在持续增加,网关越多时延越低。
今年的目标是让星链服务覆盖全球超过一半的人口,能不能做到很大程度上取决于各国牌照审批。马斯克说有些国家大概不会批,但大多数国家应该能拿下。
星舰:史上最大的飞行物,和一双准备接住它的机械臂
发布会放星舰(Starship)的画面时,马斯克先讲了一段个人的事。他说自己在这个地方住了三年,这里原来是块沙洲。
现在它有一座先进火箭工厂、一个巨型发射台,外面排着一堆火箭。他说,即便他从项目第一天就深度参与,看到它真的建起来、真的飞起来,还是觉得不可思议。
尺寸和推力:星舰的推力是土星五号的两倍多,是史上最大的飞行物。后续升级后推力会超过 2000 万磅,土星五号是 750 万磅,最终会是三倍。
他预期星舰要飞得非常频繁,一天飞好几次,从全球多个地点起飞。他还认真地讲了地球点对点运输:地球上从一点到另一点最快的方式是洲际弹道导弹,你要做的就是去掉核弹头,加上着陆那一段。
关于回收,他描述了发射塔上的机械臂。有人跟他说要用巨型机械臂接住史上最大的飞行物,对方的第一反应是不可能。马斯克说,我们也可以给它装腿,让它自己走过去,那也挺酷。
第二座发射塔要建,理由很实在:一边升级塔,一边从另一座塔发射,两座塔才能把节奏提上去。
热分离、电动矢量控制和一千多项改动
第一次和第二次试飞之间,改动数量多到马斯克说要讲几个小时。他挑了最大的几项。
发射台彻底重做。加了水冷钢板,水压大到如果直着往上喷能把火箭冲毁。第一次试飞把发射台底下挖了个大坑,第二次试飞后他去检查,台面几乎没有任何损伤,理论上可以立刻再发射一次。
发动机的推力矢量控制从液压改成电动,省下大量质量和复杂度。热防护系统大幅升级,发动机本身也大改。他的估计是,两次试飞之间可能有一千多项改动。
热分离是另一个节点。此前是两级直接分离,第二次试飞改成在一级还在点火的时候点燃二级发动机,把火焰从级间排出去。马斯克说这个方案从提出到实现大概只用了三四个月,而且一次成功。
第二次试飞差一点入轨,输在多余的液氧上
第二次试飞几乎进了轨道。马斯克说了一句很有意思的话:如果那次带了载荷,它其实能入轨。
原因是液氧。没有载荷的时候,火箭会多出一些液氧需要排掉,排放过程中引发了起火和爆炸。真实任务带载荷的情况下,这些液氧本来就会被消耗掉,不需要排放。
所以那次失败算是一种“因为空载而产生的失败”,带着一种工程上的荒诞感。
第三次试飞的目标清单:入轨;用头锥贮箱做一次在轨发动机点火,验证可靠离轨;做贮箱之间的推进剂转移,这是 NASA 阿尔忒弥斯(Artemis)计划需要的能力;测试载荷舱门,也就是被马斯克称为 PEZ 糖果盒的开门机构,用来释放下一代大型星链卫星。
他给星舰定的产能目标也是百万吨级入轨,比现在的入轨总量高一千倍以上。
迭代节奏上,他讲了一段很像方法论的话:一项技术开发的进度取决于两件事,迭代次数和每次迭代之间的时间。每次发射、每次测试都学到东西,那就把节奏提上去。他还说,宁可牺牲硬件,也不要牺牲时间,时间才是唯一真正的货币。
后续型号方面,V2 版星舰在可靠性和运力上都会更好,V3 会更高更长,最终长度可能到 140 米,甚至 150 米。
在轨加注是去月球和火星的必经关
去月球要先解决在轨加注:两艘星舰在轨道上对接,把推进剂转移过去。
马斯克对这件事信心很足,理由是龙飞船对接国际空间站比跟自家飞船对接更复杂,SpaceX 已经积累了足够的对接经验。他的目标是今年内解决,最晚明年。
在 NASA 的阿尔忒弥斯计划里,SpaceX 承担载人着陆系统(HLS)。马斯克的表态是:这个项目要成功,SpaceX 必须先成功,压力很明确。他还说想做得远超 NASA 的要求,让月球上能有足够载荷和足够频率,支撑一个长期有人驻留的月球基地。
阿波罗计划的门槛是“人上去再回来”,下一个门槛是“留下来”。他把这个基地叫作月球基地阿尔法(Moonbase Alpha),取自一部老科幻剧。他说那个剧里月球会飘离地球,现实里不会发生,但基地要真的建。
火星要自持,你得能造出芯片工厂
火星城市的画面在发布会上放了出来:星舰起降,城市铺开,文明繁荣。马斯克说,长期看火星可以被改造成类地行星,方法其实很简单,把它加热就行,然后可以把地球上的生命带过去。
但他马上回到硬指标:自持。
自持的定义很清楚:如果来自地球的补给船因为任何原因停了,火星会不会死掉。会死,就不算自持。这个门槛比大多数人想的难得多。
他举了芯片的例子。光能造芯片不够,你得能造芯片工厂。因为工厂本身会老化坏掉,如果你造不出新工厂,早晚有一天没芯片可用,然后就完了。
他给了个类比:这像大航海时代的长途航行。船上缺维生素 C,一开始没事,船照样开,几个月后牙齿掉光,人死了。火星缺的不是维生素,是整条工业链上任何一个环节。
他还提醒了一句现实:火星是个需要装修的房子。你不可能在火星上出门钓鱼,靠土地活不下去,一切都要靠带过去和造出来。
费米悖论与一根蜡烛
话题从工程转向了文明。马斯克说,他经常想的一个问题是,文明的考验是不是能不能穿过那道“大过滤器”,从单行星文明变成多行星文明。
如果穿过去了,人类可能会走到其他恒星系,看到许多早已死掉的单行星文明。他说,我们不想成为其中一员,那太逊了。
他对文明的基本判断是脆弱。读历史读多了会发现,文明从来不是永久的,一个接一个地兴起又倒下。太阳终将膨胀,煮沸海洋,抹掉地球上所有生命。那是几亿年后的事,但也就相当于地球寿命的 10% 到 20%。而聪明生命演化花了很久,如果地球再老一点,可能就没机会了。
费米悖论的部分,他讲得很坦率:我问外星人在哪,如果智慧生命很常见,为什么看不到证据。他自己没看到任何证据。
如果外星生命很常见,我们应该能看到大量证据。我没有看到任何证据。而我可以相当肯定地说,如果我看到了,我会立刻发到网上。(马斯克)
他插了个玩笑。他说经常有人问外星人的事,他一般回答“我就是”。以前他的证件上真的写着“外星人登记卡”(Alien Registration Card),因为移民身份。他说这话的时候在台上笑得很开心。
回到正题。没看到证据这件事,他觉得比看到证据更让人不安。结论是:人类更可能是一大片黑暗中一根极小的意识蜡烛,而我们要尽全力让这根蜡烛不熄灭。
他引用霍金的估算,说每个世纪文明终结的概率大约 1%。他自己的判断是这个数字可能更高。所以要走得快。
八年后
发布会里有一段回望:八年前第一次成功回收助推器。马斯克说,八年发生了这么多事,那八年之后会是什么样。
他的预期是:已经把着陆器送上火星;已经把人类送上月球;如果运气好,八年内人类会到达火星。
这些话他说得很平静,没有煽情的修饰。前面铺垫的所有数字,96 次发射、260 次着陆、1200 吨入轨、9000 个太空激光器、42 个人进轨道又回来,最后都收在这个时间表上。
值得留意的是他放在最后的那句判断:文明脆弱,时间是唯一真正的货币,宁可牺牲硬件也不要牺牲时间。这不只是火箭项目的管理风格,也是他对人类处境的理解。所有工程进度表背后,真正在跑的是那个 1% 的时钟。
给从业者的几条具体建议
- 跟踪发射节奏而不是单次成败。SpaceX 的方法论写得很清楚:进步等于迭代次数乘以迭代速度。看星舰项目,看它一年能飞几次,比看某一次炸没炸更有信息量。
- 把“入轨质量”作为衡量航天产业格局的指标。发射次数会被小火箭刷高,质量才反映真实运力。SpaceX 占全球 80% 这个数字,今年还有可能到 90%,这个趋势比任何单点新闻都重要。
- 关注在轨加注的时间点。这是月球着陆和火星任务共同的前置条件,马斯克说的目标是今年内、最晚明年。这个节点一旦跑通,后面所有时间表才有意义。
- 低轨通信领域,注意星链的时延指标而不是带宽。20 毫秒以下、物理上限 8 毫秒,这些数字决定了它能不能在实时应用上和地面网络正面竞争。带宽翻倍是常规升级,时延才是护城河。
- 手机直连业务先看运营商名单。七家合作里包含 T-Mobile、KDDI、Optus 这类主流运营商,说明这条路走的是合作而不是替代。做通信、物联网、户外设备的团队可以按这个名单判断市场开放顺序。
- 学一点在轨服务与推进剂管理的知识。在轨加注、贮箱间转移、多次点火,这些能力会从星舰专属逐渐变成行业基础设施,早一点理解原理,晚一点被动补课。
0:00[Applause] All right. it's been an incredible year. the SpaceX team, I think, is the best space team that has ever been assembled on the face of the earth by far. and the achievements of the past year demonstrate that. I think to a degree that is mind-blowing. Like what you have achieved over the past year is nothing short of incredible.
0:30And one day we will indeed occupy Mars. So So let's so let's go through everything that SpaceX has achieved that you've done. and it's it's actually going to take a while by the way. This is going to take a minute. so first of all with Falcon we have achieved the most launches of any rocket in a single year ever. So the the next best is was the Soviet Soyos which I think did a little over 60 launches in a year and we did 96.
1:13So [Applause] there's this there's yeah so no other family of orbital class rockets has launched more than 63 times a year that was so and we did 50% more. Falcon Heavy also surpassed in terms of heavy lift vehicles the record for Saturn 5 which I think did yeah I think we with five launches last year we exceeded the Saturn 5 record. So that was like pretty incredible on Falcon Heavy.
1:42So, this gives you a sense in pictures of how incredible that was. you know, for a while there I was like when I was like I'd be posting something. Is this like the launch that just happened or the one that is happening or like because there were like three launches that happened in the space of a few days. So, but this is all the launches on one page and yeah, it's
2:07really really incredible. all made it to orbit, all landed. so just a huge hand for the Falcon team. That was incredible. So [Applause] and twothirds of the missions were Starlink but a third were for other customers for NASA for other communication satellites. so it was a combination of our of Starlink plus a lot lot of other missions.
2:43so so even if you just take the non-stalling portion of the flights that was more than any other vehicle last year by a long shot. we launched NASA's Psyche issa's Uklid the X 37B space plane multiple transporter missions. we launched did missions for one web viaat. and we're actually on contract to launch Amazon's Kyper constellation.
3:09and we treat everyone fairly. So you know just one so and just and and we we managed to do 19 flights on a single Falcon 9 booster which is really incredible. in three and a half years. so and and that that vehicle did that booster did 860 satellites and delivered 260 metric tonses to orbit. So it's like wow.
3:36So there's a lot of wows. and it's it's worth you know like how long ago was that we landed a a booster was actually eight years ago in in December like roughly roughly eight years ago. And since that time, we've landed 260 times. So, 260 landings. It's just like, wow. I mean, there were a lot of people that said that it couldn't be done. And then there were a lot of people that said even if it could be done, it's going to it's a dumb idea. that no that it wouldn't it wouldn't pay off, that it wouldn't, you know, wouldn't make sense.
4:15But we've shown that in fact, it is absolutely the right idea. reusability is the key to a great future in space. It's essential. We need reusability for rockets just like we have re reusability for cars, for airplanes, for bicycles, for horses. Obviously, reusability is is essential.
4:35and the the fundamental invention that is necessary for humanity to become a multilanet species is a full and rapidly basically rapidly reusable reliable rocket.
5:02down back. Hey [Music] Heat. Heat. [Music] Heat up here. [Music]
6:23down. Heat. [Music] Heat. [Music] Heat. [Music] Heat. Heat. Heat.
7:58[Music] Yeah. So, it's I mean it's incredible how much has happened in 8 years. So, you know, I wonder what what will things be like eight years from now. and hopefully we have I think we will have landed on Mars. and I think we will have sent people to the moon and and maybe if we get lucky, we will have sent people to Mars within eight years.
8:48you know the you know the the key question sort of I think about for civilization is are the key test perhaps for civilization is do we make it through this spirmy great filter of being a going from a oneplanet civilization to a multilanet civilization. and if we are if we do become multilanet civilization, we may go out there to other star systems and discover many long deadad one planet civilizations.
9:20And we don't want to be one of them. That's lame. We don't want to be one of those lame one planet civilizations. but I think we should always regard civilization as fragile, as not something that not a situation where there is an inevitable upward trajectory. I mean I read a lot about history and if you look at if you read read history you you see that civilizations are anything but permanent. That many civilizations have risen and fallen over the years over the centuries and millennia.
9:52And eventually the sun will expand, boil the oceans and destroy all life on Earth. now admittedly that's you know several hundred million years in the future but it's only about maybe 10 or 20% of the existence of earth itself. If earth is 4 and a half billion years old then another 10 10 20%
10:24longer and life would or intelligent life would not have evolved because it's taken us a long time to get to this point. So, you know, that's that's really my that's that's really the key test. Do we become a self-sustaining multilanet civilization while while civilization still exists or or or don't we? That that you know, I think that's that's really the key question.
10:55I think we've got a good chance, but it's not a sure thing. that's why time is of the time is of the essence. I think we want to make Mars self- sustaining as quickly as possible. It's not just a question of getting people to Mars, but it's getting enough tonnage and equipment to Mars to make
11:18enable Mars to be self-sustaining. The the key test being that if the resupply ships from Earth stop coming for any reason, do we does Mars die out or does it continue? That's the that's the really the fundamental threshold to pass the the Fermy paradox great filter. The Fmy paradox is where are the aliens? You know, if if if life is common, if intelligent life is common, shouldn't we see a lot of evidence of it? Now I get asked a lot about you know aliens
11:50actually and I usually say I am one. Well actually I used to be according to you know homeland security. it said alien registration card literally. I was like okay. so, but but but the truth is I actually have not seen any evidence of aliens, which I think is maybe a bit more troubling than if I had. I I have
12:17not seen any. And I'd be on it and I can pretty much guarantee that I would post about it instantly. Okay. I was like, "Yep, this is we we got one. This is a spaceship for sure." but I have not seen anything. So that leads me to think that we're more likely to be a tiny candle of consciousness in a vast emptiness, a vast darkness. you know, that the civilization that we have is really just this very very small candle in a vast darkness. And we just must do everything possible to ensure that that candle does not go out.
12:57Yeah. Anyway, I think we can do it. So, you know, but we need to move fast because you just never know. I mean, there could be, you know, at any given point there's a like Steven Hawking actually, I believe, said that he thought there was like roughly a 1% chance in any given century of civilization ending. That was his rough estimate. I think it actually might be higher than that. So, we just want to go there fast.
13:26So, this is the getting back to Falcon 9, back to reality. this is these are all the launches we've done and you can see how the cadence of launches has rapidly increased over time. I think people online have actually assembled videos showing every every launch. and it just gets like crazy fast as you get to 2023.
13:56so yeah, so we've and we've we've done a 193 flight. We're now qualifying Falcon 9 to be able to do 40 flights. and we're aiming for maybe as much as 150 flights this year. So, and then let's not forget fairing fairing recovery because actually a lot of people don't realize we recover the fairing as well. This was actually very difficult to recover the fairing. So, it cost a an immense amount of effort.
14:25but we now quite regularly recover the fairing and we've refflown fairings 300 times. So, congrats to the the fairing recovery team. That was actually pretty damn hard. So, oh, and then of course, we do operate basically a small navy. I think people don't don't always know that. but we have you know drone ships and support ships of various kinds. So we've got a small fleet of
15:00ships. and we operate them very efficiently. I think people also sometimes don't know the size like you can see the size of the ship by the person walking around on it. It's not small. So it looks cool. black sort of it's kind of a doth Darth Vader aesthetic, but it's I like it.
15:25So, and and we're also getting much better with the pad turnaround. we achieved a 3-day pad turnaround and I think we're aiming to hopefully I think get under 24 hours pad turnaround by the end of this year. So in terms of yeah launch rate yeah so it's been 15 years since flight one of Falcon 1. Oh sorry flight four of Falcon 1 the first one to reach orbit. so 15 years since we we got anything at all to to orbit.
16:01yeah and now we're aiming to have 150 flights or thereabouts this year. So, and these are big rockets at this point. Falcon 1 is little rocket. In fact, when I see Falcon 1 right now, I was like, man, I think I'll probably tuck that under my arm and just take it home with me, you know, it's like launch it in the backyard or something. it looks so cute. but at the time, Falcon 1 did seem like extreme, it was extremely difficult. It took us four flights to reach orbit and, it did seem kind of big at the time, but now now it's like your little adorable thing. so yeah
16:40so the the most I think the most profound metric or the the metric that really describes the magnitude of what SpaceX achieved in 2023 is the mass to orbit number. So and you can see the the incredible change just year-over-year. so 2021 we're slightly below rest of world. 22 we I think roughly doubled what the rest of the world did and last year we were 80% of all mass to orbit. So
17:14when rest of the world we mean like the rest of us industry you know Europe, India, China, Japan, everyone. So there's there's not a lot of industries where a company is doing like 80% of everything and and then what's really mindboggling is that that that number should increase by 50% this year. So I guess on
17:40the order of like 90% of all mass orbit not count not counting Starship. So if we start as we start launching Starship, Starship is like you know roughly 100 tons to orbit with every flight. There's a path to getting Starship to do over 200 tons with full reusability. so 200 tons to useful orbit with full reusability and yeah it's really an incredible amount. 1,200 tons of useful load to orbit last year.
18:11yeah, that's that's just astounding. So, I I think that that really deserves a round of applause. Like, wow. I mean, that's just that's the most mind-blowing and the rate of increase is just astonishing. now these numbers will actually look very small in the future. In order to build a city on Mars, we
18:38we'll need to be kind of in the million ton to orbit range. So maybe a little higher, ideally a little higher, but it's sort of if you just try to get things to the right order of magnitude, like not trying to get to exact number, but try to get the order of magnitude right. I think it's it's on it's roughly a million tons to to Earth orbit. that'll that'll get you roughly 200,000 tons to the surface of Mars. So roughly what you know approximately 20% of whatever you get to Earth orbit you can get to the surface of Mars.
19:15so and figure like maybe we need at least a million tons of useful load to the surface of Mars for this for it to become self- sustaining. that self-sustaining threshold is is actually a very tough threshold to meet because even if you're missing a tiny thing, then eventually that Mars will die out. So, you got to be able to not just build, for example, computer chips, but you need to be able to build computer chip factories because if you can't
19:47build computer chip factories, the factory that you do build will eventually break down and then you'll have no chips and then you're that that's it. So, it's kind of like a long sea voyage where if you're just missing vitamin C, yeah, you'll cruise on for a while, but then you know, your teeth will fall out and you'll die.
20:06So that was a real problem in the old days. so anyway it's it's quite a a high threshold is and and like Mars is Mars is a fixer upper of a planet. you know it needs some work but so it's not like you can just like run around outdoors and like you know fish or live off the land you know you can live can't live off the land on Mars.
20:36so it's it's really quite a lot of work that's required to make that work. so Dragon an amazing amount of progress with Dragon and an incredible track record of success. so by as of last year the Dragon's fleet time on orbit exceeded the space shuttle fleet. So we had a cumulative 1300 over 1300 days of time on orbit last as of last year. So it's that's pretty mindboggling that Dragon has now had more days in orbit than the entire space shuttle fleet. It's like wow. So
21:19yeah and we've we've had now Dragon has visited the space station more times than the space shuttle as well. This is an incredible incredible achievement by the Dragon team. So once again, as I was saying, this really has been an incredible 2023 was like maybe the best year in company's history. I mean, it was the best year in the company's history, actually. So there's a lot of great things to go through.
21:49so and I'm I'm not one who gives out false praise. So it's really mind-boggling what what you've achieved. so all of the missions last year used a a flight proven Dragon. so the these were all these are all these dragons all flown before and and this year we're looking to fly maybe seven or eight Dragon missions. So it's really been yeah a fantastic success by the Dragon team.
22:25This doesn't have audio. There's no sound in space. Yeah, it's a great that's a great looking space suit and dragon interior. So yeah, so we've we've now sent 42 humans to orbit to be precise. Space is space is relatively easy, but orbit is very difficult. so we've now taken 42 humans to orbit and back. and I have to say like,
23:16yeah, if there's one thing I I I wish for it is that we bring them all back safely. That's like some some people like say, what is the one thing you wish for? I said, I wish we bring this astronauts back safely. That is one thing. If I had one wish, that's what it would be. So, and we also have now completed a second crew arm in in Florida. So, we've got two towers that are capable of two launch pads that are capable of sending astronauts to to orbit.
23:49and this is going to be great for being able to shift missions between pad 40 and pad 39A. we've got this here our first spacew walk. and so we've got to redesign the the suit so that you can actually move around in it and you don't just like you know pop out like cuz if you just inflate the suit, you know, you just basically, you know, you're kind of like one of those like balloons at a party or something, you know. so it's it's quite hard to make the to still be mobile in an inflated suit. and have the joints move and stuff and and then we we will actually evacuate the whole spacecraft. So everyone even those that don't go on the spacew walk will still be in vacuum. So
24:42obviously very important that it work. you know we don't have like a little hole in the suit or something go flipping around. so but I think you know obviously we're going to put a lot of testing into this and but this there's going to be another significant milestone which is to have a suit where you can be in like the the vacuum of space with just nothing nothing at all and just be out there.
25:10It's hard to con it's actually hard to conceive the concept of nothingness and it's not technically nothing like there's a small number of particles per per cubic meter but it's pretty damn close to nothing. you know if you if you lose too much too much air too too much oxygen that's it. There's no place to get oxygen from. So like an airplane even at
25:37high altitude can increase it the the the pressurization pumps and get more more atmosphere from because it's in the atmosphere. Dragon springs an oxygen leak and that oxygen leak is too significant. There is no place to get oxygen. You're just going to die. So the requirements for
25:58getting everything perfect are insane. It's everything's got to be absolutely perfect to work. I mean we did not you know evolve to live in space obviously. so it's a tough one. but this is this is really going to be another great milestone is to actually be have be able to have someone floating out there, you know, in the vacuum of space and come back.
26:33and we do want to actually have we want to have a space suit that you can walk around in because if you're on the moon, you're on you want to be able to walk around the moon, walk around on Mars. So, having a high mobility space suit that actually isn't crazy expensive ideally and that you can walk around in comfortably is is a big deal. It's actually an important thing that needs to be developed and ultimately made in large numbers because if we send say a million people to Mars then that's a million space suits or a million Mars suits that you need. So we'll have to make a lot of these things and we're also going to launch Starlink on that flight. So then coming to
27:13Starlink this is this is normally a whole separate company but we we're basically building rebuilding the internet in space which is pretty wild. and now it is I I want to emphasize supplemental to the terrestrial internet. Sometimes people think well is Starlink just going to take over and destroy all the terrestrial internet like I it definitely will not. but what it will do is Starlink will give access to the internet to to people that either don't have access or where their access is extremely expensive or or very very bad access. So this is a massive enabler for
27:53improving enabling you know people in remote locations to learn anything like you can basically learn almost anything for free on the internet right now. Like for example MIT has all of its lessons on YouTube. You can you can learn almost anything if you've got an internet connection but if you don't have an internet connection you're limited to I guess book you know what maybe you got some books or something but not it's it's a basically Starlink is a gamecher for improving people's quality of life around the world like it's this might be the single well certainly one of the I think it might be the number one might o over time technology that improves people's
28:31standard of living around the world it's certainly a candidate for potentially being the most profound thing that actually improves quality of life for people around the world which would be really something to be proud of obviously. so see and we're we're now introducing the the V2 minis. so this next generation
28:55satellites that we've introduced into the constellation and yeah these are twice twice the capacity of last year. So from 88 terabits per second to 165. and our goal the the the the biggest single goal for installing from a technical standpoint is to get the mean latency below 20 milliseconds.
29:20So that would that actually makes it's for immediiacy of for actually the quality of internet experience. This is actually a really big deal. Also if you play video games like I sometimes do this is also important. otherwise you lose. So so this is anyway so but that's actually a very very hard problem but because we're a low earth orbit constellation the speed of light it is is what do you think the speed of light is 300 kilometers per millisecond. So if we're at 550 kilometers think of it like roughly 2 milliseconds up 2 milliseconds down. So if you go up down up down so 8 milliseconds speed of light limitation and then almost everything else we
30:06can actually address it like we can't go faster than speed of light yet you know but yeah probably ever but we can we can we can get the rest of the the time I think below below 10 milliseconds and so then it basically it'll be it'll be more respons expensive than ground internet in most cases which is really what we're after here. so yeah this is really amazing work. We also have now launched the Agon whole thrusters which are very low cost
30:46and use argon which is plentiful. So we've gone from using krypton which is not that rare. I mean, if Superman did come here, I'd be like, you can get some krypton, you know, and squirt gun or something like that. And okay, now what? so, krypton is a noble gas that is it's moderately rare.
31:07but we would actually be using a huge percentage of the world's krypton if we were launching that with the the Gen 2 satellites. And so, we moved to argon. And argon is is actually extremely plentiful. In fact, right now you are breathing approximately 1% argon. So argon is there's a lot of of
31:26argon. and but this is really the I think the first significant argon whole thruster and certainly by far the most costefficient and the most power efficient and it was really great job by the Starling team to create this thruster. and many other upgrades to the then there's the inspace laser stuff. I mean so this is by far I I think we're now sent at least a thousand times more data maybe 10,000 times more data over laser links in space than any other system before.
32:07and I think we we'll soon be like a million times more data transferred, maybe more than that, through this the the Starlink laser interconnects between the satellites. so we now have n 9,000 active space lasers. So, sort of vaguely reminds me of Dr. Evil, you know, lasers from space.
32:31Actually, well, I guess I made that joke a long time ago. It's like Dragon does have LAR. It has like a laser for you know docking with the space station. So it's like like dragons with lasers. I mean like be better than shocks with lasers. so and each link each laser link is capable of 100 gigabits per second and we're looking to increase that.
32:58so let's see this is an animation of all the places where Starlink is active. So obviously a lot of the stallink activations depend on country approvals. So as we are able to get a country approval then you see rapid adoption within a country. and hopefully we'll get to most countries most the rest of the countries will get the approval hopefully this year. and we'll be able to go almost worldwide.
33:32Some countries are probably unlikely to approve our system. but most most countries we we think we should be able to get to. So and our goal this year is to activate service in more than half of the world's population. So that would be that would be fantastic. but I do want to emphasize because we are going to put this this presentation on online that Stalink is supplemental to terrestrial internet. it is not
34:03does not replace it. It is stalling does not it does really well for like low population density areas. but it is it is really not going to be competitive in high density cities or it's it's really low low density situations which is really where the need is. so anyway works well
34:27with works well with other internet providers is what I'm saying. then we got community gateways. I'm told this is a town called an Alaska in Alaska. So, it's a real place. so we're we're putting a lot more gateways down. as we increase the number of gateways, that improves latency.
34:52So, we've now shipped our nextG hardware. that's a version four of the user terminal. So that's it allows us to lower the cost of Starlink. And we'll be introducing the Starlink Mini later this year, which can fit in a backpack. So that'll be pretty cool for anyone who wants a very portable Starlink.
35:16And then we just opened our Starlink factory in Basher of Texas. So that's just a little you know about 20 minutes away from Austin. And this is this is gonna be Yeah, I guess I guess some of you guys are part of that. [Applause] Yeah. in general, we're g we're gonna have like a massive round of applause for Starlink. That is for sure.
35:40because it's like the achievement level there is is amazing. Actually, let's let's just have a massive round of applause. It's like god damn. Yeah. Sorry. It's hard to clap with this thing. yeah, this the Starling achievements are really mind-blowing. so it's like the Starling system is an anomaly in the matrix.
36:08and then we we also just recently launched our our first direct to cell satellites and we were able to to send text messages directly from a phone to the satellite and then back down again. So, we did intentionally, misspell these things, by the way. so, although actually when I first saw it, I was like, is this real? it turns out it is in fact real. this is, yeah,
36:37some Dogecoin jokes basically. so yeah, and anyway, so it's it's it's kind of amazing that you can actually close the link between a phone in your hand and a satellite that's hundreds of miles away. and the the satellite can hear the tiny signal that your phone is outputting, which is like such a faint whisper, it's ridiculous. but it can actually somehow hear that faint whisper and be able to communicate with a phone is is I think it's one of those things like I was sure is that actually physically possible, but it is.
37:18now I do want to emphasize this is also a not a competitor to to phone companies. this is something that will be supplemental. So it's it's going to be very helpful for remote areas where there's no cell connectivity or once in a while within a city if there is a place that has no connectivity within a city then stallink will be able to communicate with with phones but it's I think
37:46it's some something on the order of seven megabits per second within a within a cell and the cells are sort of hundreds of square miles of kilometers in size. So, it's really it's good for you know, text messages. you could technically do video if you're the only one or if there's only a few people in that cell like if you're in the middle of the Pacific or something like that then but but it is something that is going to be very helpful and will I think save lives of people you know if somebody's sort of hiking in a remote region and they get lost well now their phone could actually work and it could I think it will actually save a lot of lives which is cool so
38:35And then we we have se seven announced partnerships. So we've got T-Mobile in the US, Rogers in Canada, Optus in Australia, One New Zealand, Salt in in Switzerland, KDDDI in Japan, and Intel in Chile and Peru. So, and we expect to announce a number of other telco partnerships this year. So, this is definitely something where we're again in partnership with Telos. I just basically don't want the Telos to get really mad at us. that's what that's what I'm saying. you know, we want to we want to be support the Telos.
39:09And then of course, this is slowed down a little. So, but that first launch did did take a take a while to get off the pad. better there for a second.
39:54I mean, when that took off, I was like, "Wow, I can't believe it took off." How's my reaction?
40:38So, I think I think it's incredible that it we we took off twice last year. I mean, even though I've been very, you know, closely, you know, involved with the Starship program from the beginning. and actually like I lived out here. This is my my primary residence for three years. this used to be a sandbar, basically what we're looking at here. and now it's got a an advanced rocket factory and and a gigantic launchpad and got a whole bunch of rockets out there.
41:18but I still amazed that it actually got put together and it took off. I'm like, wow. I mean the Starship is more than twice the thrust of a Saturn 5. It is by far the biggest flying object ever made. and for, you know, with with some upgrades down the road, it'll it'll actually be, I think, probably over 20 million pounds of thrust. and Saturn 5 is 7 and a half, so it'll it'll end up being three times the thrust of Saturn 5.
41:56and it's going to fly a lot. It has to fly a lot. So, it's it's going to end up flying several times a day. from many different locations in the world. And I think there's a pretty good chance that it does Earth to Earth transport as well because the fastest way to get from one place to another on Earth is, you know, to get from here to the other side of Earth is an intercontinental ballistic missile. But just make sure you delete the nuke and add the landing part basically.
42:27it's the fastest way to get somewhere. Yeah. Wow. And then between flight one and two, we made a number of massive upgrades. So the there was obviously a massive upgrade to the launchpad. so we've got like many Niagara Falls here. I mean the water pressure is so much that if it went straight up it would actually destroy the rocket. That's how much water pressure it is.
43:01So it's like wow. and it worked. Like I actually went and looked at one of the first things I went looked at after the second launch was to check out the launchpad because obviously after the first launch we dug a pretty big hole. and and honestly it looked like you could just it looked like there was no damage at all like the you could just launch again basically for the pad itself. so it's great work by the team to radically improve the launchpad overnight. Yeah,
43:42people always like want to use the Statue of Liberty for stuff. Statue of Liberty is not that big. I was like I was like been there. I actually climbed up the Statue of Liberty in the tiny staircase a long time ago. but anyway, this this is a big rocket. and it will get bigger over time. So,
44:03yeah. So, that's I don't know if you guys watched Kong versus Godzilla. it's like the one of the most insane movies I've ever seen, but it's like kind of entertaining and it's sheer madness. and the crazy thing is that that our launch tower is bigger than Mechazilla and it's going to do basically like the same thing but with the arms, you know, like catch the rocket. And I tell people like, "Yeah, we're going to catch the largest flying object ever with giant mechanical arms." They're like, "There's no way that's real." I mean, we could give it legs, too.
44:46Just Just give it legs and have it trump around. That'd be pretty cool. so and then we're also going to build a second tower. yeah. [Applause] So, we're this is this is we're going to really be launching a lot and up and we're going to be upgrading one tower while we launch from another tower. So, two towers is important.
45:15there was there actually so many upgrades between flight one and two that it would actually take it like hours to go through them all. but one of the biggest upgrades was going from hydraulic to electric actuation of the engines. So that actually saved a lot of mass and complexity.
45:34so yeah the electric TVC I mean it it it was just this is one of the biggest upgrades. We also massively upgraded the heat shield. The engines themselves were massively upgraded. L literally everything on the rocket was like there might have been thousands of upgrades between flight one and two.
45:53so really gigantic improvement between flight one and two and also obviously many improvements between flight two and three. And then we've got we've got a whole development plan to like I said ultimately get to a fully reusable rocket that does over 200 tons to orbit on a regular basis. full reusability.
46:15Yeah, hot staging. I mean, hot staging was was a change that was basically I don't know just really within a space of like three or four months, maybe less. going from or roughly that going from previously just kind of like separating the rocket without anything and to to actually lighting the upper stage engines while the first stage engines are still thrusting and not blowing up the ship which is that is an amazing achievement. So I was like wow that's and it worked. so I was like
47:03wow. So so then look let's look at flight two. Attention all operators on countdown one. This is the final go now go for flight two of starship z at 7 a.m. central. Raptor one go. Raptor 2 go. Stage one go. Stage two go. Copy. Go for flight. Clock is rolling. 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1. We have liftoff.
47:59[Music] We stretch it. Cut off. [Music] Stage separation. [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music]
49:00So yeah, big round of applause, guys. Wow. So flight 2 actually almost made it to orbit. so in fact ironically if if it had had a payload it would have made it to orbit. because the reason that it actually didn't quite make it to orbit was we vented the liquid oxygen and the liquid oxygen ultimately led to fire and an and an explosion because we wanted to vent the liquid oxygen because we normally wouldn't have that liquid oxygen if we had a payload.
49:37So, ironically, if it had a payload, it would have reached orbit. and so I think we've got a really good shot of reaching over it with flight three and then a rapid cadence to achieve full and rapid reusability. And I mean the kind of the mind-blowing thing is like there is an actual path that we are on to make life multilanetary.
50:01Can you freaking believe that? Like what I Yeah, we just got to get it done before civilization ends. But but like I think we I think it's going to happen. yeah, right here. So anyway, so in terms of getting there, we want obviously want to accelerate the production and testing get to a high cadence. you know, for for any given technology development there it is
50:40you know how many iterations do you have and what is the amount of time between each iteration. So every time we launch we learn every time we launch or do a test we we learn something more. So increasing that cadence of launching and testing. and it's always better to sacrifice hardware rather than sacrifice time. Like time is the true the one true currency. so it's
51:04the sort of the fastest path to as I saying earlier rapidly re rapidly reusable reliable rocket. yeah. So, and we've got, yeah, a block sort of a version two ship, that will be more reliable, better performance, endurance. We've got a version three ship, design that will stretch the the and be even taller, probably end up being, I don't know, 140 m before it's all said and done, maybe 150 in the end in ter in length.
51:42so, yeah. So, it'll be even taller than it currently is. yeah. And so, with with flight with flight one, the goal was not to blow the the pad up and ideally get get some distance, which we did. With flight two, it was to get past staging. So, we achieved the goal of getting past staging and almost to orbit. And then flight flight three, we've got well, we want to get to orbit and we want to do an an inspace engine burn from the header tank and and prove the that we can reliably de-orbit.
52:25we want to do a tipping point header domain propellant transfer. this is important for the NASA Artemis program. And we want to also demonstrate the the payload door for the sort of PEZ dispenser for delivering the stalling the the V2 non- mini the actually probably V I guess V3 technically. but really the really giant satellites to orbit.
52:56yeah, so like I said the the master orbit ultimately of Starship will be you know over time I think millions of tons of of payload to orbit. so it's it I mean compared to present day master orbit it'll be more than more than a thousand times I mean you know more than a thousand times greater than master orbit currently that's what it will be eventually or needs to be.
53:36so we also want to demonstrate on orbit refilling. This is very important for the NASA Artemis program. so we're very proud to be part of the NASA Artemis program. I'm always incredibly grateful to NASA for their support. and for trusting us to do to take take astronauts to orbit to trans take cargo to the space station and to be an integral part of of getting astronauts back to the moon.
54:05one of the other questions I get a lot is, did we really go to the moon? I've gotten that from from a lot of people and I'm like, "Yes, we went to the moon." more than once, in fact. but the crazy thing is that it's been over half a century since we last went to the moon. So, you know, that's I think what maybe that's what causes people to be skeptical like how come we we can't go to the moon now?
54:34it was 66 years from the first controlled powered flight of the Wright brothers in 1903 to landing on the moon in ' 69. So only 66 years but you know like 50 years have passed since we last went to the moon. but now we're going to give go back there and we're going to go back there soon. and we're not going to go just I think like we want the next step I think is to build a a moon base like moon base alpha make sci-fi real
55:08not remove the fire part of sci-fi. So but now one but in order to go and land on the moon one of the technical challenges we have to solve is orbital refilling where we dock the starships dock on orbit and transfer propellant. now we've gotten very good at docking because we've we dock with Dragon to the space station which is actually more complicated than docking with our own spacecraft. So we have a lot of expertise in docking. So I'm I'm confident we will solve this and we just ideally want to solve it hopefully by the end of this year but certainly by by next year. and that that's a big deal. This is one of the fundamental technologies that's
55:53necessary to to build a city on Mars and to have a Mars a moon base. and then yeah, we'll also be launching some very big satellites. world's biggest peasants is better and we do hope to do this by the end of this year. and then yeah, more about the NASA human landing system. So, as I said, we're extremely grateful to NASA for entrusting us with a fundamental part of the OTMUS program. we want to make sure we do a great job for NASA. and and really the we like we are a very fundamental part of the the Otmus program. So if we do not succeed, which we will but but we in order for the Omus program to succeed, we must succeed with with with Starship. and
56:57like I said, we actually want to far far ex far exceed what NASA's asked us to do. So, so the we want to go far beyond the NASA requirements and actually be able to put enough payload on the moon with enough frequency that you could actually have a permanently occupied moon base. That's that's the next really big threshold from Apollo is have a have an actual moon base. I remember seeing this like I guess kind of cheesy sci-fi show long time ago called Moonbase Alpha. I don't know if anybody seen that, but like the moon actually drifts away from Earth. Now, this is not going to happen, but but it was a cool show. Moon base alpha.
57:41but we need a real moon base alpha and we're going to do it. So, then yeah, as I saying, the this is the long-term goal. This is what we want Mars to look like is Starships coming and going. an incredible beautiful Mars city and a flourishing civilization on Mars. and you know ultimately we can transform Mars into an earthlike planet with terraforming.
58:16just needs to be warmed up really. And then you could it could be ultimately an Earthlike planet and we could bring the life from Earth. we could extend life from Earth to Mars. and really it has to be, you know, has to be humans, you know, because it's not going to be the dolphins.
58:37so but we can bring we can bring all the creatures with us and we can ensure that life on Earth continues on Mars even after Earth becomes unlivable in the in the distant future. So anyway, I'll go into questions.
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 视频在 B 站收看UP 主「睿瑞兰徳」搬运
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版