访谈·中文精读

拯救Tesla与SpaceX后,马斯克2013年受访

Elon Musk Interview in 2013 after Saving Tesla & SpaceX

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2008 年的某个晚上,马斯克要靠借钱才能付房租。

他刚把 PayPal 税后拿到的 1.8 亿美元几乎全部投进三家看起来都要死的公司:SpaceX 拿 1 亿,Tesla 拿 7000 万,SolarCity 拿 1000 万。猎鹰一号(Falcon 1)连续三次发射失败,Tesla 的融资轮在雷曼倒下的那周崩盘,SolarCity 和摩根士丹利的交易被对方撤回。同一时间他还在办离婚,科技博客每天换着花样骂他。

五年后,他坐在洛杉矶的台上,回忆那段时间只说了一句:超级糟。

这场 2013 年的访谈信息量很大。他讲了迈凯伦 F1 怎么撞毁、为什么三次飞去俄罗斯谈买洲际导弹、2008 年怎么在两个“孩子”之间分配最后一笔钱、为什么拒绝 Kleiner 的 5000 万估值、太阳能板的成本真相,还有他第一次公开描述那个叫 Hyperloop 的东西。

四家十亿美元公司,他拒绝了一个头衔

主持人开场摆了一组对照。硅谷历史上只有一个人创建过三家十亿美元公司,吉姆·克拉克(Jim Clark),做了硅谷图形(Silicon Graphics)、网景(Netscape)和 Healthcon。Healthcon 那家如果没有泡沫根本到不了十亿,而且三家都挤在同一个行业里。

马斯克做的是支付、汽车、航天,三个互不搭界的领域。算上 SpaceX 这个没上市但私募估值几十亿的,他至少是四家。

主持人问他,还有一家公司他算不算联合创始人。

他们提出把我列为联合创始人,但我觉得,虽然最初的想法是我提的,我投入的汗水和股权都不够,不足以被称为联合创始人。他们有这个提议,我拒绝了。(马斯克)

主持人在旁边调侃:你本来可以成为第一个拥有四家十亿美元公司的人。马斯克说,联合创始人这个身份有个门槛,想法贡献和早期投入都得够,这个标准主观,但他认为自己没做到。

一句“看好了”,撞毁一台迈凯伦

主持人提起一个流传很久的故事,用来解释“马斯克是不是有点疯”。

2000 年,卖完 PayPal 之后,马斯克买了一台迈凯伦 F1(McLaren F1)。那台车他开了好几年,跑了 11000 英里,从洛杉矶开到旧金山,当日常代步车用,其中还包括在 405 号高速上通勤。主持人说,拿这种车当买菜车,本身就够离谱。

撞车那天,他载着 Peter Thiel 沿沙丘路(Sand Hill Road)去见红杉资本的 Mike Moritz。路上 Peter 问,这车能干什么?

我大概排在“名人遗言”榜单第一位,我说:看好了。(马斯克)

然后他一脚地板油,在沙丘路上变道。迈凯伦没有牵引力控制系统,640 制动马力,整车只有一吨重,动力重量比大到 80 英里时速还能让后轮打滑。后轮失去抓地,车开始原地打转。

他记得自己本来是直着开,然后打了方向,接着是倒着看见对面的车朝自己开过来。车撞上沙丘路旁一个 45 度的斜坡,像掷铁饼一样被抛到空中,目击者说离地大约三英尺,还在继续旋转,最后朝着原来的方向砸回地面。

悬挂爆了。玻璃、轮子全碎,车身前后严重损毁。底盘和发动机居然没事。Peter Thiel 拦了辆车先去 Mike 那里,马斯克等消防车和救护车处理完现场,再搭车过去,会议照开。

主持人讲了一个更戏剧化的版本:撞车之后马斯克弯腰大笑,同伴问都撞成这样了你笑什么,他说,你不知道好笑的地方,这车没保险。

马斯克确认了笑点。

笑点是对的。但我不记得自己笑了,我可能是在震惊中笑。(马斯克)

主持人追问,这段经历跟你后来做公司的方式有没有相似之处?马斯克说希望没有。“看好了”这句话放在火箭发射上确实要命,一吨重的车和一百万磅 TNT 当量的火箭,完全不是一个量级。

他不做互联网公司的理由

PayPal 那批人拿钱之后,大多转头去做 Web 2.0,投社交、投内容、投各种线上生意。马斯克搬到洛杉矶,开始搞太阳能、火箭和电动车。

主持人问他,是不是觉得互联网没意思了。

他说没有。他自认还算懂互联网,也不想变成那种连电子邮件都不用的老头子。真正的原因在资本流向。

我想把精力分配到我认为最能正面影响人类未来的地方。互联网有大量的创业能量和资金涌进去,而汽车、太阳能、航天这些领域,你看不到新进入者,没有多少资本流向创业公司,也没有多少创业者愿意去。(马斯克)

他的判断是,一个行业如果没有新进入者,就缺少推动创新的力量。搅动一个行业的,从来都是那些从外面闯进来的人。

这几个行业还有个共同点:启动资本门槛极高。马斯克自己就是例子,PayPal 的钱几乎全填进去,还得算上后面几轮追加。

1.8 亿怎么分掉的

马斯克把账算得很清楚。PayPal 税后他拿到大约 1.8 亿美元,1 亿投 SpaceX,7000 万投 Tesla,1000 万投 SolarCity。剩下的钱不够生活,他得借钱付房租。

主持人问,这是原计划吗?

他原本估计 SpaceX 花 5000 万就够,Tesla 大概 2500 万到 3000 万。结果大多数项目实际成本是估算的两倍。

SolarCity 是唯一一个超预期顺利的。他顺便自嘲:SolarCity 是唯一一家他不是联合创始人的公司,看来我应该少当联合创始人。

SpaceX 前三轮,他没找 VC

主持人问,为什么后面要追加那么多钱,是投资人放鸽子了吗?

马斯克说,SpaceX 前三轮融资他根本没去找风投。原因很直接:投资人第一个问题一定是“这个领域你之前有什么成功经验”,第二个问题是“有什么可以类比的公司”。

他在航天领域的成功记录是零,行业里躺着一片墓碑。火箭又远在大多数风投的舒适区之外。

我们在成功这一栏基本是空白,在失败那一栏是一整片墓地,他们不会太感兴趣。(马斯克)

直到 SpaceX 做出进展、几乎要入轨的时候,才拿到第一笔机构投资。领投的是 Founders Fund,Peter Thiel、Luke Nosek、Ken Howery 这批 PayPal 老同事,他们在入轨之前就下注了。马斯克特意把这份信任归给他们。

他也承认,在 SpaceX 之前,他从没亲手造过物理世界的东西,更别说火箭。

三次飞俄罗斯,为了买两枚洲际导弹

SpaceX 的起点跟造火箭没什么关系,是一个温室。

2001 年前后,他跟大学室友 Adeo Ressi 聊天,说自己对太空一直有兴趣,但作为个人好像什么都做不了。他最初的想法是往火星送一个很小的温室,里面放种子和脱水营养凝胶,着陆之后加水,让植物长出来。红色背景上的一片绿色,就是他要的那张“金钱镜头”。

人们会对第一次和最高级产生反应。这将是生命走到过的最远的地方,据我们所知也是火星上的第一个生命。我觉得这会让人兴奋,会推动 NASA 的预算增加,然后我们就能送人上火星。(马斯克)

他想要的未来是“预期事情会变好”的那种,不是“预期事情会变糟”的那一种。这句话他说得很轻,但整场访谈里,它解释了他后来做的几乎所有选择。

查资料的过程中他发现,航天技术的巅峰停在 1969 到 1970 年的登月。之后航天飞机只能把人送到近地轨道,航天飞机退役之后连这个都没有了。整条曲线往下走,终点是零。

他以为会有人拿方案送人上火星,等了很多年没等到。于是他决定自己去买火箭。

接下来是三次俄罗斯之行,谈判买两枚俄军现役最大的洲际弹道导弹。

怎么搭上线的?认识认识人的人,很快就能和俄罗斯火箭部队对上话。他的评价是,俄罗斯社会相当资本主义。

会谈现场的画风很怪。他形容那些地方看起来像疗养院,墙上有软垫。一个缺了门牙的俄罗斯人冲他吼,口水喷到他脸上。

在一个墙上有软垫的房间里,口水喷到我脸上,我心想,我的人生到底发生了什么。(马斯克)

第三次回来之后他想明白了一件事:人类在航天上停滞,根子在运输成本。上太空越来越贵,能做的事情越来越少。真正要解决的是运输技术本身。

这就是 SpaceX 的由来。

他也承认,带着“大概率失败”的预期去创业听起来很怪。但最初那个温室计划从财务回报看成功概率是零,本质上是一笔捐赠。任何比捐款更好的结果,都是赚的。

2008 年,三家公司同时走到悬崖边

主持人提到,外界看到的是成功,但 SpaceX 在第一次成功发射之前失败了好几次。押上几乎全部身家、借钱付房租、发射一次次炸掉,是什么感觉?

超级糟。2008 年尤其糟糕。(马斯克)

那一年同时发生的事:猎鹰一号第三次发射失败,连续第三次;Tesla 正在融的那一轮因为经济要崩而瓦解,2008 年底通用和克莱斯勒正在破产,没人愿意给一家创业车企投钱;SolarCity 和摩根士丹利的交易,因为摩根士丹利自己缺钱而撤回。

三家公司看起来都要死。他还在打离婚官司。媒体上全是唱衰。

主持人问他,第三次发射之前你觉得会成功吗?

他说当时认为成功概率高于 50%。失败的原因很细:他们对发动机做了改动,从烧蚀冷却改成再生冷却,导致推力瞬变过程中压力衰减掉到了临界压力以下。这个问题在海平面的试车台上看不出来,因为大气压把它盖住了。

结果是一级火箭撞上了二级,二级发动机在级间段内部点火,等离子回火把二级烧穿。

就像在一个很吵的房间里听不见一根针掉地上,到了真空里那根针变成了爆炸。(马斯克)

他说自己没预料到这个。一个几乎看不见的推力瞬变,把一次本该成功的发射变成了第三次连续失败。这段技术细节很枯燥,但它说明了一件事:火箭这行的失败常常藏在千分之一秒的曲线里,跟勇气和决心没什么关系。

两个孩子,只能救一个

2008 年底是最难的决策点。他手里的剩余资金只够保住一家公司。

SolarCity 需要的钱不多,还算安全。真正的选择在 SpaceX 和 Tesla 之间。

就像你有两个孩子,你是把钱全押在一个身上最大化它的成功概率,还是尽量两个都保住?(马斯克)

他选了两个都保。

关于 Tesla,他说自己从来没想过当 CEO。对电动车的兴趣可以追溯到大学时代,他当年约会的时候会跟对方聊电动车,这显然不是最好的策略,后来他学会了闭嘴。

因为已经在做 SpaceX,他知道同时管两家公司会极其痛苦,所以极力避免出任 Tesla CEO。从第一天起他就有公司的多数控制权,随时可以当,但他一直没当。直到 2008 年底,他把所有没分配给 SpaceX 的储备资金全部投进 Tesla,觉得自己必须亲自掌舵。

我接手那个位置,跟好不好玩没有关系。那段时间超级不好玩。(马斯克)

从 100% 到 90%

主持人提起前一年见面时马斯克说过的话:同时管两家公司根本不在“有趣”的水平线上。

2013 年的回答不一样了。SpaceX 连续五次发射成功,已经能和空间站对接;Tesla 融到了足够的钱投产 Model S,完成了 IPO。两家公司的团队厚度都不一样了。

我可以从几乎每一分钟醒着的时间都花在公司上,降到 90%,这个差别其实很大。(马斯克)

主持人问,有没有可能再找 CEO 接手其中一家?

他说可预见的未来会继续管两家,因为对两边的人都做过承诺。永远管下去不太可能。

哪家更让他牵挂?两家都是。但他给出了一个判断 Tesla 何时可以放手的标准:

Tesla 真正要完成的好事,是充当可持续交通加速的催化剂。当大多数在造的车都是电动车的时候,这件事就完成了,催化价值就实现得差不多了,边际收益递减。到那个点,我就不需要再管这家公司了。(马斯克)

这段话值得多看一眼。他给一家公司设定的退出条件,跟财务指标、市值、市场份额都没关系,只跟“这件事是不是已经被别人接手”有关。公司变成了工具,工具用完就可以放下。

5000 万和 7000 万之间,他选了前者

主持人问,跟 VC 打交道的经验跨度很大,有什么建议给创业者。

马斯克的建议很具体:如果能在“估值低但你很喜欢的人”和“估值高但你心里有问号的人”之间选,选前者。

找一个你认为是高质量、你愿意共事的投资人,比拿一个更高估值但对方有问号要好。这有点像结婚,要一起待十年。(马斯克)

他自己在 Tesla C 轮上没这么做。

当时有两家竞标,Kleiner Perkins 出 5000 万美元的 pre-money 估值,基准资本(Benchmark)出 7000 万。马斯克跟 John Doerr 说,如果 John 本人进董事会,他就接受 5000 万那档。John Doerr 觉得自己义务太多,Kleiner 内部还有另一个合伙人也想要这个案子,他没法顶掉那个人。

马斯克说,如果 John 不进董事会,只是别人来,那就不行。

那大概是个错误。(马斯克)

后来 Kleiner 投了 Fisker,马斯克的评价是:那是他们的错误。

这段对话里有 2000 万美元的差价。他愿意为了一个对的人放弃这笔钱,最后又因为没能得到那个对的人而放弃整笔交易。听起来任性,但放在十年周期的合伙关系里,账其实算得过来。

设计师和工程师的区别

主持人问,Tesla 凭什么没掉进 Fisker 和 A123 那个坑?

马斯克的回答把两家公司的底层逻辑拆开了。

Tesla 是一家硬核技术公司,做严肃的工程,也做真正的制造。Model S 是把铝材和塑料颗粒送进去,整车开出来。高度垂直整合,整车工程、动力总成工程、软件、造型设计全部自己做。

Fisker 由 Henrik Fisker 主导,他是设计师,擅长造型,但他认为一切都在造型上。

我们造不出电动车,缺的东西跟造型无关。(马斯克)

Tesla 解决的是硬工程问题。证据是丰田、戴姆勒、奔驰都来买 Tesla 的动力总成。如果这件事容易,他们自己就做了。

清洁技术为什么在硅谷没成

主持人提到,几年前硅谷想把方向拨回科学和拯救世界,Kleiner、Coastal Ventures 这些大机构在清洁技术上很激进,说这是下一个互联网。结果没成。

马斯克的第一个修正是措辞:

“清洁技术”这个说法不如“可持续能源”准确,虽然更拗口。(马斯克)

他不认为清洁技术已经判了死刑,Tesla 和 SolarCity 就是反例。至于别人为什么没成,他没给宏大解释,只说任何行业里能长到很大的公司都只有那么几家。

真正有价值的部分是他对太阳能产业链的拆解。

很多人说清洁技术依赖补贴就活不了。马斯克没否认补贴存在,他把问题转向成本结构。

标准效率的太阳能板,制造难度大概相当于造石膏板。这意味着中国、日本、德国的硅片厂之间会打一场像 DRAM 市场那样的血腥价格战,成本会一路压到接近原材料。

这件事确实发生了。板子价格掉到每瓦 90 美分左右。

那太阳能真正的成本在哪?

真正的成本叫系统平衡,除了板子之外的一切:每家的屋顶都不一样,要单独设计、安装、布线、逆变器、售后服务、融资安排。(马斯克)

一套住宅系统每瓦装下来大概 4 美元,几年前是 7 到 8 美元。4 美元里 3 美元是系统平衡,板子只占 1 美元。

他拿戴尔做类比。戴尔不造 CPU、不造硬盘、不造内存,但它设计整个系统、管理客户体验。SolarCity 干的是同一件事。

他还特意说明,SolarCity 90% 到 95% 的功劳属于 Lyndon Rive、Peter Rive 和团队,不是他。

PayPal 值 5 亿的时候,纳斯达克正在见顶

聊回 PayPal。主持人说,PayPal 起步的时候有钱、有时代红利,但相比其他互联网公司,它是一家很难建的公司,也是一家很难活下来的公司。

马斯克补充了时间线:1998 年底到 1999 年初起步,是他做的 X.com 和 Max Levchin、Peter Thiel 做的 Confinity 合并,然后两家把资源并到一起打同一个问题。

从成立到估值 5 亿美元,中间不到 18 个月,也许是 14 个月。

放到今天看,跟 Facebook 最近那些收购比,5 亿好像也没什么。但在当时,这完全是荒谬的。(马斯克)

主持人说,公司内部有人觉得“我们为什么只值 5 亿”。马斯克说他当时就觉得这个数字荒谬。

纳斯达克 2000 年 3 月见顶,正好是他们做完 5 亿估值的时候。接下来两年真正的挑战是让公司活下去,直到卖给 eBay。

和 Peter Thiel 的 95% 与 5%

主持人问两人关系,说有很多关于合并期间不合的传闻。

我们有过分歧,但我们是朋友。认识这么多年,95% 的时间是朋友。(马斯克)

剩下的 5% 不太好过。他说自己对风险的容忍度比 Peter 高,他是那种油门踩到底的人,Peter 会说我们稍微谨慎一点。

他可能是对的。(马斯克)

主持人调侃:这挺讽刺的,毕竟是他鼓励你踩那脚油门的。马斯克说那大概不是 Peter 的本意。

四个还没做的想法

主持人翻出 2008 年的一次对话,当时马斯克提到过一个能垂直起降的电动飞机。问他现在还想不想做。

他说不想马上开新公司,但手上有四个想法,成功率大概能超过五成。

第一个是电动超音速飞机。起点是他读到协和式客机退役的新闻,觉得难过。

很多技术上的念头都来自这种“看不下去”的瞬间。他读到一个让人觉得可惜的进展停摆,接着就开始问,这事能不能换个做法。协和退役那一次,他顺手翻了几十年前的设计资料,发现协和是 60 年代的产物,气动、计算流体力学、发动机效率这几十年进步巨大,光换发动机就能让航程翻倍。

算下去他发现,电动飞机越高越好。大气密度随高度指数衰减,高度越高阻力越小,同样的推力就能飞得更快。内燃机飞机到 3.5 万到 5.5 万英尺就到顶了,再高没有氧气可以烧。电动飞机不受这个限制,可以往 8 万英尺去。高空还有一点离心方向的加速度帮忙,像卫星一样。

结论是电动加超音速加垂直起降这三个特性可以组合,做出比现有飞机领先几代的产品。

有可能我未来某个时候会做,因为 SpaceX 和 Tesla 让我有了做这件事的要素。(马斯克)

第二个是高速公路。他刚从洛杉矶市区堵了三英里花了一个小时。方案是在中央隔离带上架预制钢结构箱梁,内侧一条车道、顶上一条车道,全部预制、像乐高一样吊装到位,不动现有车流。两条车道可以都改成单向,通行能力翻倍。

我不知道 405 高速的施工是谁负责的,那是个白痴,我恨他们。那是我这辈子见过最糟糕的工程。(马斯克)

他说如果真有人做这个箱梁项目,他愿意出钱,虽然监管上会有挑战。他觉得公投通过只需要三秒钟。

第三个是磁约束聚变。他用“相对标准的聚变路线”来描述,语气轻得像在说一件周末能搞定的事。

第四个他没细说,只说是“第五种交通方式”,正在考虑开源还是先申请专利再授权给能证明自己做得出来的人。

Hyperloop:比飞机快一倍,不会撞车

这就是 Hyperloop 第一次被公开描述。

现在的交通方式有四种:汽车、火车、飞机、船。他想要第五种。

起因是加州高铁。他说这条线有一个尴尬的双料纪录:最慢的子弹头列车,每英里造价最贵。旧金山到洛杉矶的预算是 600 亿美元,说 600 亿的时候,实际一定会更高。

作为对照,1 亿美元就把我送上了太空。SpaceX 总共花了两三亿美元,包括外部投资人,而且已经盈利几年了。(马斯克)

他觉得可以做出成本只有高铁 10% 的方案。

他先问的是:从洛杉矶到旧金山,理论最快的交通方式是什么?

他列出的特性清单:永远不会撞车、不受天气影响、平均速度是飞机的两倍、从洛杉矶市中心到旧金山市中心不到 30 分钟、票价远低于机票、基础能源成本极低,因为管道内部接近真空,几乎没有空气阻力。

能源上可以自给。管道外壳铺太阳能板,发的电比系统消耗的多,用非电池的方式储能把余电存下来,全天候运行。

主持人问,这东西真的可行吗?

绝对可行。(马斯克)

火星,12 到 15 年

最后一个提问的人做航天,提到马斯克前一天发推说 40 年内会上火星,但人类已经 40 年没登月了。

马斯克纠正:他说的是 12 到 15 年。

SpaceX 在猎鹰 9 和猎鹰重型之外继续研发。他说纸面上,已经有一套能实现火星殖民的系统。

从“纸面上有”到“真的造出来”还有很长的路。但大概一年半以前我才确信,在火星上建立自给自足的文明是可能的。(马斯克)

之前他说过火星是“不可能的边缘”,现在他的说法是:可能,只是极其困难。这个转变发生在一年半之前,也正是他决定把 SpaceX 的方向从“接商业订单”转向“为殖民做技术储备”的时间点附近。

他不介意当上市公司

有人问资本效率,提到一个 700 个合伙人、管理 14 万亿美元的流动性平台。

马斯克的回答很干脆:公开市场就是很有效的资金来源。Tesla 走得不错,SolarCity 那年晚些时候会上市,SpaceX 随时可以上市但没必要,已经现金流为正几年了。

就我而言,现在我不觉得自己受资本约束。(马斯克)

主持人问他,上市之后股价每天波动、信息披露,不烦吗?

他说他管私营公司的方式跟管上市公司一样,该有的治理机制都有。只要你不去在意每天的股价,就没什么问题。

关于双层股权,他的看法是有价值但别走极端。Tesla 是单一股权。双层股权的一个问题是传承:如果继任者是子女,很难保证是对的人。福特是反例,福特家族在公司里起了稳定作用,看得更长远,福特也是那轮唯一没破产的美国车企。

氢燃料电池:数学上就输了

有人问,本田和奔驰都说氢燃料电池是未来,为什么他们还这么坚持?

马斯克的回答不留余地。

数学上明显站在电池这边。你把燃料电池最好情况全优化一遍,从物理上限去算,再跟现在量产的锂离子电池比,它还是输。成功不在它可能的结果里。(马斯克)

他解释车企为什么还做:燃料电池永远是“十年之后”,所以永远可以说我们在做燃料电池,这就够交差了,不需要交付。

Tesla 内部管这个叫 fool cells。

这段对话发生在 2013 年。到今天,氢燃料电池乘用车全球销量仍然是小数点后面的数字,而当年被他判定“没戏”的锂电池路线,把整车成本压掉了七成以上。

几个快问快答

教育怎么颠覆?他提了 Sebastian Thrun 和可汗学院(Khan Academy)的在线学习,核心是把学习游戏化。如果人们像被电子游戏吸引一样被学习吸引,事情就成了。

大学要不要上?他说完全可选。有好想法就退学试试,大学永远在那里,随时可以回去。

为什么搬到洛杉矶?南加州有全世界最密集的航空航天工程师。他之前在帕洛阿尔托住了十年,家在 Forest 街,离 University 大道的 PayPal 办公室三个街区。做火箭的成功率本来就不高,如果还要求有经验的航天工程师从南加搬到湾区、辞职、在贵得离谱的地方买房,成功率会再降一截。所以他搬过去。

洛杉矶的创业生态怎么改善?他先说了一句“更好的高速公路会带来巨大改变”,然后认真补了一句:我找不到该向谁投诉高速公路。

什么时候退休?他不想退休,但想多陪五个孩子。目标是“在痴呆之前退休”。

判断力开始退化的时候,你意识不到自己的决策变差了,就像缺氧一样,在你死之前你都不会发现。所以大概 80 岁吧。(马斯克)

生在地球,死在火星。他强调过,这句话的前提是“如果真要退休”,退休本身不在他的计划里。

关于 Stripe,他说自己是个很小的投资人,完全不知道他们在干什么。

关于 PayPal,他说得很直接:

PayPal 本该站在所有钱流过的地方,但它没有。我 2000 年写的产品计划,跟今天的产品比,几乎没差别,甚至更差。(马斯克)

最后一个问题,你的平庸超能力是什么?

他说最厉害的超能力是运气,主持人说你已经有了。那就退一步。

永远不堵车。(马斯克)

全场笑,散场。

这场访谈里真正有用的东西

回头看,2013 年的马斯克处在两个极端之间的位置:最坏的时候已经过去,最大的赌注还没开始。那年他描述的大部分东西,后来都发生了。

Hyperloop 在 2013 年 8 月发布了白皮书,完全开源,没有申请专利。加州高铁还在修,预算一路上涨。火星时间表从 12 到 15 年变成了 2020 年代后期。SolarCity 2012 年底上市,2016 年被 Tesla 收购。氢燃料电池乘用车到今天还是边缘产品。

但他给出的那些判断依据,比结论更值得留下来。看一个行业有没有新进入者、算一条技术路线的物理上限、把成本结构拆到最细的那一层、在低估值好伙伴和高估值陌生人之间选前者。这些东西不随时间过期。

如果你现在正在做一些决策,可以从这场访谈里拿走下面几条:

  • 选投资人时把估值往后放。签字之前问自己一句:我能不能跟这个人共事十年。答案是否定的话,多出来的那部分估值不值。
  • 选赛道时看资本流向。所有人都在往同一个方向挤的地方,不缺你一个。资本和创业者都不愿意去的领域,才是新进入者能撬动创新的地方。
  • 评估技术路线先算物理上限。把最好的情况拉满,再跟现有量产方案比。如果最好情况都输,不要指望工程优化能救回来。
  • 拆成本结构时找出那块没人注意的部分。太阳能板只占系统成本的四分之一,剩下四分之三在安装、设计、融资、售后。真正能做出差异的地方往往不在最显眼的位置。
  • 重资产、长周期的项目,先把最坏情况写下来。马斯克自己都说 SpaceX 最可能的结果是失败,他还是做了,因为下行是“捐款打水漂”,上行是一切。想清楚下行能不能承受,再决定要不要开始。
  • 需要顶尖人才的行业,公司开在人才密度最高的地方,别让人为你搬家。SpaceX 在洛杉矶,就因为南加州的航天工程师密度全球第一。
  • 做硬件公司,垂直整合不是可选项。整车工程、动力总成、软件、制造全自己做,才有资格把动力总成卖给丰田和奔驰。
  • 判断一个创始人懂不懂产品,看他把设计当全部还是把工程当全部。前者能做出好看的车,后者能做出能开的车。
  • 给自己设一个非财务的退出条件。别问“公司值多少钱我才能走”,问“这件事什么时候不再需要我”。答案清楚的那天,你才真正自由。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00is you seem to play this game differently than everybody else you know there's in the history of Silicon Valley there's only one guy who's created three companies that were worth more than a billion dollars each and that's Jim Clark and he did it with silicon Graphics legitimate company Netscape legitimate company and health on which never would have been a billion dollar company without a bubble but all sort of in the same industry you've done it if we count if we count SpaceX even though it hasn't exited but it has a multi-billion dollar contract so I think we can count it as more than a billion right yeah SpaceX is a a private

0:38yeah I mean it's it's private Market valuation sort of a couple billion dollars right so so you're the only other guy who's done it and you've done it with payments probably one of the hardest Industries to disrupt on the web cars and going to space right yeah so what do you do differ

1:00later this year by the way oh yeah but do you count as as a co-founder for that one no actually they offered to have me be listed as a co-founder but I I thought that although I suggested the initial idea I did not put enough sort of Sweat Equity into it to be considered so you should have been because you could have been the first guy with four yeah it's a I think

1:23there's sort of a certain threshold of of idea contribution and you know initial effort that that's that's required for that that's sort of you know I mean sort sort of subjective but I think I don't think I did enough right they did offer it to me but I I said no so it is part of the reason you've done this that you are sort of crazy are you lucky I you know I've been thinking about that lately and and I I sort of Wonder you know I think I probably am a bit crazy

1:58but I think but maybe that's that's sort of a healthy sign because at the point at which you conclude you're not crazy at all then you probably are so the fact that you you realize Cur thing yeah there's one story that I've heard about you do I seem crazy yes said that about you here's the story that made me think you were crazy and you can tell me if this involve the New York Times no Elon got me in so much trouble several years ago and I he called someone a douchebag and a liar and I started laughing and never to be precise douchebag and an idiot well actually said a liar we cut out the liar did I really yeah it would be liist that part we cut okay yeah well I think that that

2:43may well I guess that's probably true too but but I I think it's more more the first two yeah more the first two so no this is the story that made me think you were crazy yeah I heard right after you sold PayPal before the other two companies you went and bought a McLaren an S1 because F1 F1 sorry that that's that's the same part so because partially because you were going to race cars with Jim Clark and Larry Ellison no well not really no actually and I never did although that was one of the things that was sort of talked about at one point but I never did fact I've never raised anyone with McLaren with I had it for several years I put 11,000

3:20miles on it and I drove it from LA to San Francisco it was my daily driver which is a crazy car to have as a daily driver particularly on the 405 so but I understand when you got it yeah you're driving down 280 and you wrecked it no well and you let me just tell the story you can correct it the story is great and I yeah let's see if the story that you tell is actually how does that how that compares to the the reality cuz the reality is pretty messed up hopefully the reality is better so you wreck the car you get out of the car you're doubling over with laughter and the person with you said why are you laughing that you just wrecked this car

3:56and you said no you don't know the funny part it wasn't insured well the punch Line's correct yeah so I was actually I was driving up Sand Hill Road with with Peter teal the co-founders PayPal we actually driving to see Mike Moritz MH this is in in 2000 and so we're driving up at St I didn't really know how to drive the McLaren and Peter says so so what can this do and then like I'm probably number one on the list of famous last words I said watch this so I so I floored it I floored it and did a lane change on on Sand Hill and so the McLaren has no traction control or anything it's just it's massive power to to the wheels so 6 640 brake horsepower and it only weighs

4:54a ton so it has massive power to weight it can break Wheels free at 80 mph so broke the re the rear end free and and started spinning and I I I I sort of let's see I think it was sort of I was I was going straight and then turned and and I I remember seeing the the the cars coming towards me while I was going backwards and then we hit the hit an embankment sort of a 45 degree embankment on Sand Hill which tossed the car into the air like a discus and it kept Ro it kept rotating with about 3T of air air clearance according to Witnesses and then slammed down on on on the ground going the original Direction and and we blew the suspension out and now didn't

5:40actually wreck the car the course chassis and the engine were okay thank God but but all all the glass and the wheels and everything was was shredded and and there was massive body damage in the front and rear and yeah did you start laughing I don't recall laughing I I mean I I could have been laughing in shock but I don't recall laughing and

6:10and then and then Peter quot a hitched a ride to to Mike I I I waited while the the firet truck and the ambulance arrived then finally the did Peter teal literally hitch a ride to to like to yeah over to to sequa to yeah and then then I I once once the car was taken care of then I I I HED to ride too and so and we we we continued the meeting that's I'm picturing you and Peter teal like that scene in Tommy Boy where like the deer and you're both like ah like yeah really wow yeah is there a parallel can't be alive really I I should say so is there a parallel with how you build companies in that story I hope not let's see what this thing can do

6:55yeah watch this that that could be awkward with a rocket launch you know yeah it's it's one thing if you've got a one ton car versus a million pounds of TNT equivalent that is a little dice here yeah now what I think is so I mean one of the things I find so interesting about you the rest of the PayPal guys they get done with PayPal they start starting and investing in Web 2.0 companies at a point in time whenever and said that's insane that's insane the internet will never come back they were considered The Crazy Ones meanwhile you move to LA and start working on Solar City SpaceX Tesla's a glint in your eye why didn't you will you ever do an internet company again do

7:41you find the internet boring I think it's unlikely that I'll do an internet company again because not that I find the internet boring I mean I'm still sort of I think I'm relatively sort of net Savvy and interested in the internet and what what's going on you know I I I don't even want to be the the like like Grandpa who doesn't do email or something like that you know so I I think but I think I'm trying

8:10to allocate my efforts to that which I think would most affect the future of humanity in in a positive way and the I think there's there's lots of entrepreneural energy and F and and financing headed towards the internet whereas in certain sectors like automotive and solar and space you don't see new entrance you don't there's not there's not a lot of of capital going to startups and not a lot of entrepreneurs going to that into those Arenas and the and and the problem is that in the absence of some new entrance into an industry you you you don't you don't have that in that Force for Innovation it's really new entrance that that drive Innovation more than

8:53anything so that that's why I have devoted my efforts to to those those Industries and and there are industries that require as said you cap quite a bit of capital to get going and even with SpaceX I mean I I invest I mean I my proceeds from PayPal after tax were about $180 million 100 of that went into into SpaceX 70 into Tesla and 10 it's solo city and and I literally had to borrow money for rent so

9:25that was CL plan or no that was not the plan what was what was the plan you thought I'll just put 10 in each of these or well actually I thought the spaceex I thought it would be about well I guess I was probably about double it would cost it ended up being double in in in most cases so with SpaceX I thought it would be 50 with Tesla I thought it would be I thought it' be putting in 25 maybe 30 with solo city for well Sol City actually went really well and that's that's the one where I wasn't a co-founder so me that a good sign I mean I I should co-found less stuff so that's so what happened why did you have to put more money in the other two did investors flake did you

10:11have well I didn't actually seek investor funding for the first three rounds of of SpaceX because I mean the first thing that investors want to ask you is sort of well what's tell us about prior successes in this field and and you know what could we compare this to and and there's you know when when you've got kind of the donut in the success category and a lot of you know a cemetery full of failures then they they're not that Keen and I Rockets are just pretty far out of the comfort zone of most vure capitalists and and now we were able to to get

10:51Venture finding after we've made some progress and demonstrated that we were able to almost get to orbit and you credit goes to sort of to Founders fund and which is obviously some of my compatriots from from PayPal Peter and Peter teal and Luke NOK and and Ken Harry and the other guys so and they they invested before we got to Orit so so credit to them for that but but I did have to show that I could actually make stuff like I I never actually made physical stuff before you know before SpaceX so let alone Rockets so you started with a rocket yeah I mean it's that's a that's a hard one and it's the probability of success was low in fact when I started

11:35SpaceX I thought that the most likely outcome was failure but and and I think to have any other expectation would have been irrational so so why did you want to do it I know for Tesla it seems more obvious like oh Save the Planet big automakers aren't doing this I mean I think it's sort fairly obvious it's good for Humanity why did you feel like SpaceX needed to be done well

12:00I I I I I guess the if you if you look at the trajectory of space technology and and progress the the Pinnacle of of that progress was was around maybe 1969 1970 you know with with the with the moon missions and so we we made incredible incredible progress in the' 60s and and then we were able to land on the moon and then with the space shuttle It could only get people to low orbit now the space shuttle is retired and that's just a there there's no trajectory of improvement it's a trajectory to nothing so and I kept thinking that there would be some plan to send people to Mars because that's the obvious next step and the actual origin of SpaceX

12:48is is is when I was I think it was around 2001 or so and I was visiting a friend of mine ad RI who actually you met but he lives in palta now we were College housemates and he asked me what I was going to do after PayPal and I said well I've always been interested in space and but I didn't think there's anything I could do in space as an individual so my initial plan in space was actually to send to do a small

13:17Mission to Mars with u with a greenhouse essentially seeds and dehydrated nutrient gel in a little Greenhouse that would land and you'd hydrate the gel and then you'd grow the plants and you'd have this great shot of green plants and a red background and that would be the money shot essentially and and and the people

13:38tend to respond to precedents and superlatives and this would be the furthest that life's ever traveled the the first life on MAR as far as we know and and that that would get people excited I thought well that would result in an increased NASA budget and then we could send people to Mars because that's you know I think you want to have a future where you're expecting things to be better not one where you're expecting things to be worse M so that was how things started out and then as I learned more and I I went to U speaking of crazy things went went to Russia three times to negotiate a deal to buy a couple of of the largest icbms in the Russian

14:11Fleet a strange experience how do you even get into that negotiation well you talk to people who know people and and pretty soon you're talking to the Russian rocket forces and you know they it turns out Russia is quite quite a capitalist Society and and so but but it definitely has had some some weird meetings in in in places that that I swear they looked like a San sanitarium or something I don't know it was very odd we keep poting back to the theme of crazy yeah seriously this place had padded wolves you're like why do you have ped

14:58wolves it was weird and yeah and then I had some some sort of Russian guy who was missing a front two started yelling at me because his friend one of his friend teeth singly was like spit flying at me in a place with padded wols I'm like this is really bizarre what's happened to my life right and that was the moment when you thought I'm going to build my own rocket yeah that was probably when I got back from that third trip I was like well I realized that the real issue the reason we haven't Advanced in space is because the the cost of of space transportation is is be become unaffordable you know it's got It's become more and more expensive to do to

15:36do less and less in space and we really need to improve the technology of space Transportation so that's why I started SpaceX but it it it may seem odd that I would saw SpaceX with with an expectation of failure but bear in mind that my initial thing was to do essentially a philanthropic Mission with a 0% chance of success from a financial standpoint so it would have effectively been a donation to the cause and so anything better than that is a win right right so you know I know people think of you as someone who's had a lot of success but you had several failures within SpaceX before the recent launch can you can you tell us a little bit about what it's like to put that

16:19much work into something and and and be doing something that really no one else is doing yeah and at least trying something and putting that much of your own money in it that you're having to borrow money from friends to pay your rent and there are launches and it's failing yeah that that well it super sucks I tell you yeah that that

16:40that that was I 2008 in particular was was was was awful because we had the third launch failure in a row of of our Falcon one vehicle at SpaceX and we the Tesla financing round that we were raising fell apart because the economy was going to Tail Spin and it's pretty hard to raise money for a startup car company you know late 2008 when JM and Chrysler busy going bankrupt MH that that was that was tough and then Solar City had to deal with Morgan Stanley and Morgan Stanley had to reeg on the deal because they themselves were running out of money so all looked like all three companies were going to die and was also going through divorce so that was

17:25definitely a low Point and but fortunately the fourth launch worked and and then did you think the third launch was going to work was it a shock that it didn't well I I I thought it would most like I think I thought the odds of it working were were better than 50% but yeah there was just a little little change in the thrust transient of the first St engine that resulted in that we didn't we couldn't see it on the ground because the thrust Transit well to get slightly technical for a second the the pressure Decay on the thrust transient dropped below C Level pressure so when you when you look at it on the test stand at with you know at sea level you don't see it it doesn't it

18:12doesn't look like there's a Thrust transient and because we changed the architecture of the engine to one that was regeneratively cooled instead of atively cooled it had this little tiny transient which caused the first stage to Ram the upper stage and and the upper stage engine started started inside the interstage section like it's like sort of firing up this giant this engine indoors with with with a big plasma blowback that fried the fried the up the stage wow yeah I wasn't expecting that so so it's 2008 you're going through a divorce which like some toar your word douchebag bloggers are writing about to make even worse right yes that's true in addition to to all

18:53that stuff happening I was getting dumped on massively in the Press right yeah you're you know it looks like all three companies are going to get faile I mean why do you keep going with all three like I feel like even a lot of great entrepreneurs in that situation would have been like I I've already sunk everything I have in these companies and I got to pick one but you didn't I mean you kept doing all three why yeah that was that was a very tough c at at the end of 2008 that was that was probably the tough you know one of the toughest goals I've had to make because I could either Reserve capital for one company or the other I mean fortunately Solar City didn't need

19:33a ton of capital so they were okay but between SpaceX and and and Tesla you know it's sort of like like if you got two kids and what do you do do you spend all your money to to maximize probility success of one or do you do you try to keep both Al fortunately it work you also had to step back in as the CEO of Tesla yeah my goal was never to be the CEO of Tesla from the beginning u i mean I've had interest in electric cars that goes back 20 years to you know when I in college in fact I used to talk to my dates about electric cars it's probably not the best strategy closest dates no no I usually

20:18have to stop talking about that but yeah so I I've had a long long-standing interest in electric cars but since I was doing SpaceX I knew that if if if I did try to start an electric car company and run it that it would be extremely painful to run two companies so I didn't I I really tried my hardest not to be the CEO of Tesla I mean I could any at any point from day one I could have been the CEO because I had majority control of the company but I really tried

20:50not to and in the end it was at the end of 2008 it's I commit all of my Reserve Capital to to Tesla all that that wasn't allocated to SpaceX and so I I I felt I had to sort of steer the ship directly but it was it was not it was not out of it was most it was really not fun like super not fun yeah I remember when we talked I guess maybe the next year after that you said you know this is not at the fun level running these two companies no I mean it's definitely gotten a lot better with with SpaceX you know we so since we've now had five successful launches in a row and we're able to talk with the space station and with Tesla were able to raise enough Capital to get the

21:39company to be able to produce the model S and and do the IPO and you know so I've got a much strong I've got much strong a much stronger team lot of bench strength at both companies so you know I can go from essentially almost every waking being being spent on the companies to 90% which is big difference actually is the ambition still to find another CEO for one or the other well I

22:13I I expect to run both companies for the foreseeable future because I've I've made a commitment to people at both companies to do that will I be running both companies forever I think that's that's unlikely but but certainly for the foreseeable future I will be is there one that has your heart more than the other one well you know they they both they both do have my heart but I think that there may come a point you know several years in the future where the the fundamental good that Tesla is trying to accomplish which is to serve as a catalyst for the acceleration of sustainable transport has been accomplished in other words I mean that's really what what what the

22:57if look at from an historical standpoint what what's important here in affecting the world it's it's to what degree is Tesla serving as a catalyst for the Advent of electric vehicles and at some point you know when when say most cars being manufactured are electric then that will have been

23:23accomplished and or the catalytic value of test will will have been realized and the diminishing returns that regard and I think at that point I I would not need to run the company yeah can we talk a little bit about across the companies your experience with Venture capitalists because it's been pretty varied right yes so you've had good experiences and you've had not so good experiences is that fair had a wide wide range yes what have you what what would you advise entrepreneurs watching this or in the audience to make sure they don't they don't live through what you did in the bad experiences and can you tell us about the bad experience well I think I think one

24:11thing that's important is if if you have a choice of a lower valuation with with someone you really like or a higher valuation with someone you have a question mark about take the lower valuation it's it's better to have a a higher quality bench capitalist who you think is would be great to work with than to you know get a get a higher valuation with someone where there's even a question mark really you know I think that's that's important it's sort of like getting married you know I don't know well maybe I haven't been that good at that but probably Lear 10 years is okay I mean it's not too bad did you do that wrong did you maximize for valuation

24:59the I suppose in in the case of the Tesla Series c I don't I mean at some point I think I'll I'll tell the the full story but not tonight but not tonight the they did wait an hour right no I know well I'll tell part I'll tell I'll tell part of the story so the there there was there there were two there were multiple competing bids but there were two competing bids one was from

25:37Kleiner Pok the other one was from vanish Point Kleiner offered 50 a $50 million pre-money Bish Point offered 70 I actually said to John dur that if if John joins the board we'll do it at 50 but John felt that there was that that he had too many obligations and that there was another partner at cler who who really wanted the deal and so he could not supplant that person and I I I I thought well we could do I would I would be okay if if John der would joined I I I I mean there's a 40% different that difference that's pretty significant I thought if John would be willing to join the vard then we could do that but not if it was somebody else MH

26:24yeah that that was probably a mistake mhm and so then they did Fisker instead which and that was their mistake yeah yeah yes that's I I I hope they live past the election Fisker and A123 are both having a lot of issues yeah what has Tesla done that it hasn't fallen in that bucket what was I mean looking back was there a Crossroads where you made a right choice that has put you guys so far I mean you're not profitable yet yet but in a different category well the Tesla is a a really different company to to Fisker I mean we're Tesla is a hardcore technology company and and we we do really serious engineering and and I think you only build value in a company if you

27:14if you're doing hard work to solve tough problems that that's that's why companies are valuable or it's why they should be valuable and and largely is why they're viable so and and and we do we do our we do real manufacturing as well I mean the model S coils of aluminum and plastic pellets come in and Cars come out I mean we're we do real hardcore manufacturing quite vertically integrated and we did all the vehicle engineering all the powertrain engineering all the software and whereas and we also we also

27:50of course do the the The Styling and design of the car we've got a great Design Studio our head of design France from Hol hous is awesome in the case of Fisker it's it's headed by or was headed by you know Henrik Fisker and and he's he's a designer so he's he's good at sort of the styling of the cars but he thinks it's all about styling and it and and it's not you know it's really this is

28:19you know the the reason we don't have electric cars is not for lack of styling [Laughter] right at the the time when you were getting started with Tesla the valley was trying to take a turn back towards science and towards saving the world you had Kleiner Perkins Coastal Ventures a lot of these big firms really getting aggressive about clean tech and saying that was going to be the next internet that has not been the case right why did clean tech not work for the valley well I think the jury's out on clean tech I think as far as Tesla and Tesla and solo city certainly clean tech or I'd say I I think of more like sustainable energy stuff I think

29:04sustainable energy is a better it's a little bit more of a mouthful but it's more accurate than than than than clean tech and I mean I think the I think I think Tesla is going to be an extremely valuable company in the long term and what have you done differently because a lot of ECS have said well the problem with clean tech is you have to rely on subsidies and if you have to rely on subsidies it's never going to work I mean people buying a Tesla in park get a subsidy it takes down the price I assume with Solar City so it's like like that hasn't been a knock against you guys like why have these two companies worked when when so many other ones haven't

29:43I I think it's you know in any industry there are only a few companies that that kind of get big and and succeed and I I don't know I think I it just seems that in in the case of of Tesla we were focused on making great products and and doing solving hard engineering problems I mean it's evidence in Tesla for the fact that we solve hydrog engenering problems is the fact that Toyota and Daimler and Mercedes you know bu electric power trains from us I mean they if this was easy they would just do it right so so we focused on solving really hard engineering problems at at Tesla know

30:27like I said that contract with Fisker some degree and and then at at Solar City the Solar City does everything except the panel so what a lot of people don't realize is that the solar panel if it's a standard efficiency solar panel the difficulty of manufacturing that is about as hard as manufacturing drywall it's really easy uhhuh and so I mean it seemed to me pretty obvious that in the long term we'd see Cutthroat competition between silicon PB manufacturers

31:02in China Japan Germany and other places much as you see this competition in the dam Market I think the PB market and the dam Market are very similar and so you that that cost will be driven down to to very low number approaching the raw material cost really and that that's that's pretty much what happened and and so the real the real cost of solar and and real challenge to Sola is what's called balance of system it's everything except the the panel and and so the the the

31:32cost per installed what for a residential system might be around $4 now which is a big drop from where it was a few years ago it used to be sort of $7 $8 now it's it's sort of kind of half that but the optimization really has to be at the at everything except the panel cuz the panels are dropping now to like 90 cents a watt MH so you know over three you know $3 of the $4 is balance the system which you know which includes the you know it includes the the custom ownership experience designing the system particular to particular rooftop installing it the wiring the inverter after sales Service figuring out the financing found financing of it all

32:12you know it's in the same way that say say Dell Dell doesn't make the CPU or the hard drive or the the Ram or anything but they kind of design the system and they manage the customer experience and that's that's kind of how Solar City is so when I looked at the problem of solar power that that that's what it looked like to me mhm so that's why Solar City is

32:36working on the problems that it's working on and it's doing super well with you know 90% of the credit 95% of the credit due to Lyndon Peter R and the rest of the team at Solar City you've said I think this is the first time I've interviewed you and you haven't said it that being an entrepreneur is like standing on the edge of an AB looking into abyss and chewing broken glass yeah actually that's a a phrase from a friend of mine bully who who's early internet entrepreneur done done a number of things since and and he the the

33:14phrase that he uses is like starting a company is like it's like chewing glass and staring into the abyss right so I flipped it yeah just so it's it's I mean there's a point which obviously it's not that not that way do you still feel like that or easy now I I you know the string the best part is just you are you are you facing imminent death and we certainly were at SpaceX and Tesla and Solar City for a long time I think I we're no longer staring into the ABS which is great there's always going to be some amount of GL glass that's got to be chewed it's never zero but it's less and less as as time goes by so less glass and more Abyss no yeah the abyss is kind

34:00of there in the distance but I'm not staring right at it a peripheral vision yeah I mean you know you guys did PayPal which was you know obviously started at a time when the there was a lot of money and there were advantages but you know compared to other.com was a very hard company to build and then you go on hard company to keep alive yeah as as you point out I mean p PayPal got started in like late 99 late 98 to early 99 and yeah it was a sort of a merger of two companies x x.com that I started and confinity that Max and Peter started and and we startd to sort of pull our resources and Tackle problem together and but but we went from

34:44starting the company to less than 18 months later maybe it was 14 months later or something having a valuation of $500 million and you know those these days you know after you see some of the you know things like the recent acquisition by Facebook think oh well maybe that's not that great but but at the time it was certainly was like this is this is completely ridiculous that did you feel that way though cuz I know there were some people inside the company who thought why do we why are we only worth 500 million I thought it was completely ridiculous but I mean the NASDAQ peaked I think in March or there abouts of 2000 right and that's around when we when we

35:33did the valuation for $500 million the the challenge was really keeping the company alive for the next two years roughly until well until it was sold to eBay what what is you and Peter's relationship like and what was it like then there's there's a lot of stories that the two of you guys did not get along in that mercher you know we've had our disagreements but we are friends and I would say for 95% of our the

36:02time we've known each other we've been friends I bet that 5% was rough though knowing both you it was a little it was a little rough yeah things got a little bumpy at at one point and I think I'm I'm not I have more tolerance for risk than Peter does so I I was sort of maybe more kind of pedal to the metal and Peter was like well let's a little let's be a little cautious here he may have been right actually so mm which is ironic since he encouraged you to gun your car that made you guys I think that was what he had in mind but yeah he

36:39I'm I'm probably slightly more risk tolerant than Peter is but I think it what between all of us we managed to make Paypal work which is was that was the important thing but back to the back to the abyss and the the broken glass I mean do you only enjoy this if you're just the odds are failure

37:05no no I'm I'm I'm liking life more and more actually as as there's less staring into the abis and less glass chewing I'm finding that to be a good thing so I I hope never to return to the experiences I had in 2008 and 2009 so I know back in I think it was 2008 you talked about if if you were to start other companies one that you had an idea for was a electric plane that could take off and land vertically yeah does that see are are you now like [ __ ] no I am not starting another company or are you still thinking that yes that's how I feel that is yeah I've actually I mean there are three things that that I think U well arguably four that I think could be

37:53done I think it could probably do it maybe you know have a better than the even chance of success one is the an electric jet sort of it's this would be kind of something cool because one of the things that I guess where theide where these things tend to come from is like I'll read something that seems like like a sad thing in technology and they're like well how could we make it not a sad thing so when I read about the Concord being retired and I was like oh geez you know we don't even have supersonic transport that's terrible M and I actually didn't have a chance to to fly in the Concord so you know that just seemed like a terrible thing so initially I thought

38:35well I started reading up about it and I read that that the Concords was really designed in the 60s and and so aerodynamics have have improved a great deal with computational fluid dynamics engine efficiencies improved massively and even if you just change the engines on the Concord you could double the range mhm or or their Valance and so I thought well okay what if what if you we to figure out a really efficient design that could make it economically competitive to have a supersonic aircraft and and and

39:09then I started looking at it more and more and then as started doing the math on on all of it it seemed like well you just really want to go higher and higher you know the lower you are in the atmosphere the more drag you have atmospheric density decays exponentially so as as you go up you your air density just drops drops dramatically and it's it's really easy to go fast and I mean and your speed is just a force balance it's whatever your the output thrust of the engine is you know balanced against the the drag that you're experiencing so as you go higher you just go faster for the same Force mhm and and then there's a slight

39:52outward acceleration you experience which is also slightly helpful like like a satellite you know when satellite is going March 25 it it just goes on forever once it's out the atmosphere so anyway this is may be slightly little wor but the an an electric fan gets better the electric aircraft gets better the higher you go whereas a combustion aircraft does not you have you you start starving it starving it from from oxygen and and only but

40:25the eror is mostly nitrogen m so when you as you're going through the air you're sort of sucking in all this all this nitrogen which is kind of slowing you down and and you're trying to combust oxygen anyway so with with aircraft with combustion aircraft you hit a an optimal altitude that's in the sort of 35 to maybe 55 Max altitude and

40:50whereas an electric aircraft you could you you'd want to go like maybe 80,000 ft and anyway it's long long way of saying you can get super efficient and super fast with electric aircraft and and vertical takeoff Landing works well with being Supersonic and anyway so I think I think you could you can make a really breakthrough aircraft that's several Generations beyond what currently exists but are you going to do that not anytime soon it's possible that I may do it at some point in the future because between SpaceX and Tesla I kind of have the ingredients so it's very tempting easy after those yeah but I the the the I think maybe it's

41:36worth something worth considering in a few years that so that's one idea then there's I think we could really improve transport by having a pre-fabricated kind of double deck or actually what what would really make sense is a steel box beam over the center divider with a lane on the inside Lane on top M that's made in pre-fabricated sections and stalled down the center divider and you can get two lanes and you can have the the traffic be you know all oneway all the other and massively improve life in places like Los Angeles where I was just stuck in traffic going right took me an hour to go 3 miles so I don't know who's in charge of the damn 405 construction

42:18but they're a bloody idiot and I hate them is it is the worst construction project I ever witnessed in my life going curse them daily okay so that's two what are the other two you would do well the other one well one of the third one would be I think you could make fusion work and and I mean and I mean by that I mean magnetic confinement fusion you know relatively standard Fusion if you will and and then the four one photo

42:58sharing app right subscription Commerce in a box absolutely the fourth one I'm considering just open sourcing you know basically just describing the idea saying this is what would be done and and if somebody wants to do it then then they can do it but I'm thinking like maybe I should patent it and then offer to open source the patent to anyone that can make a credible case that they could actually do it so I'm sort of debating it but it would be for for a fifth mode of Transport so right now we've got of terrestrial transport we've got planes trains Automobiles and boats for getting around Earth and

43:38what if there was a fifth mode mhm and I I've have a name for it name for it which is called the hyperloop the hyperloop hyperloop yeah is it like a Jetson's tunnel it's sling like that yeah like you just get in it whisks you yeah well and I'll tell you the characteristics so this is partly prompted by the California train thing like we know we've got like a bullet train that that's like it's the has the dubious distinction of being the slowest bullet train and the most expensive per mile go California we

44:16got some superlatives there so we setting records at both you know both ends of the the wrong the wrong ends of the of the spectrum and you know apparently it's going to be like $60 billion or something to go from San Francisco to LA and if it's if they're saying 60 now it's going to be more later and as course it's really slow train put this in perspective 100 million got you into space well it got be start I mean it got it got me to yeah it sly got me to space didn't quite me get me into orbit very close yes yeah something like that yeah in terms of cap of of cap venture capital investment it's been a couple hundred million total including outside investors so

44:57and basic has been profitable for the last few years so I think we can do do something that's probably 10% of the cost and and and I I try to think of what are the attributes that you'd want in a new mode of Transport in fact what is the theoretically fastest way that you could get from LA to San Francisco and and so so the system

45:21I have in mind which is you you're sort of you're guessing in the right direction sort of how would you like something that can never crash it is immune to weather it goes three or four times faster than the the the sort of bullet train that's jet well it it goes about let's say an average speed of twice What what an aircraft

45:48would would do so you go from downtown LA to downtown San Francisco in under 30 minutes and it would cost you much less than than an air ticket or cart much less than any other mod transport because the fundamental energy cost is is so much lower and I think we could actually make it self power self-powering if you just U if you put solar panels on it you generate my back the envelope is you generate more power than you than you would consume in the system and there's a way to store the power so that it would run 247 without using batteries so you there different you can you know different ways to store energy anyway so that's do you think this is

46:42possible this is not just yes absolutely absolutely yeah wow is there ever a time you retire you have five children right you ever just want to hang out with the kids yes I do I do want to hang out with the kids I don't want to retire but I do want to hang out with the kids my goal is to retire right before senility it's a tough you know tough you know like your Jud start to Beed yeah it's like getting hypoxia you don't like you don't realize your your decisions suck until you're dead so so I don't tend to retire

47:21maybe like at 80 or something and it would be cool to be born on Earth and die on Mars you know yeah You' said before you want to retire on Mars is this more or less feasible well actually it was asked do I it's more like if I were to retire it's not like I want to retire but if I were to retire on the virility I'd like it to be on Mars that would be cool it's funny because you were saying earlier that you're slightly more risk-taking than Peter Peter wants to be on a boat that's like an island out somewhere that has no laws you want to be on Mars it is the slightly riskier crazy version yeah I think Peter entertains a lot of interesting ideas

48:04not sure he necessarily wants to be on an island offshore I mean last time I saw him he was in San Francisco so but but I think he likes to he sort of entertains interesting ideas and he's not bound by convention certainly that's for sure all right we want to get some questions from the audience so we've got a couple microphones if anyone wants to line up while we're waiting on people you're an investor in stripe and very tiny investor very tiny investor and I have no idea what they're doing wow I know this is the only subject where I know more than you I talked to them the other day but which leads me to the question do you think PayPal is finally

48:43screwed well if if PayPal doesn't do something it will be screwed yes there has not been a lot of innovation no in fact if if you look at the product plan that I wrote in 2000 there's hardly any difference in fact it's it's slightly worse than that theyve gone backwards yeah I mean PayPal should be where all the money is yeah and it's not it's definitely not all right go ahead there I first want to thank you Sarah for believing in La I was actually up at one of the events in San Francisco and I think we have two to three times as many people here so thank

49:23you it is it is the same it's actually 100 people people fewer than we fit in our in our San Francisco venue but it sold out the fastest so Ben hor sold out in about 4 hours and you sold out in three all right and you have a a writer here Michael so thank you for believing in La I think we are the only blog with a full-time writer here way to go my question is for you Alan first of all thank you for doing these big things so you know improve Humanity I work for Space Adventures when I was in college and I really believe in the space Frontier the abyss so to speak the good Abyss yeah but indeed but just thinking about La for a moment what do you think we can do to improve

50:02this the ecosystem here in La well I think better freeways would be huge honestly I I don't I I I wish there was like who do I complain to about the the freeways yeah yeah some somebody's got to be responsible for it May yeah don't do that I'd rather you build Jets and Hyper Loops than be the mayor of La but I I I think if if somebody could seriously it's like if improving the transport system it that's got to be for anyone that lives in La what's going to be the number one gripe it's it's the damn highways I tried to run a startup to do that but no one would fund me yeah any gridlock org I'm open to funing someone if they if they want to do the box beam thing over the center

50:48divider which be I mean a regulatory challenge but I I mean I think people you can get people to vote for it i' vote for it in like 3 seconds and it's just you got to do it in a way that it doesn't impede the existing traffic flow and so it's got to be pre-fabricated sections that just get dropped in place like Lego mhm why did you move to LA because the Southern California has the biggest concentration of aerospace engineers in the world oh and it was a choice my I mean I lived in in the bay for 10 years and lived in paloalto I lived like three three blocks away from the PayPal office that's why I paypals on University Avenue cuz I lived on Forest which is

51:25really convenient so so I moved down to La just because the the odds of success with a rocket company were pretty low to begin with and if I insisted that experienced aerospace engineers move from Southern California to the Bay Area and kind of leave their job and buy buy a house in the area which is really expensive then then the odds of success would would go would be decreased even further so that that that's why I moved to to La is is all right yeah I want to try to get through as many of the questions as possible but because we do not have Elon for much longer so let's ask him real quick and answer real quick okay all right okay hey Elon huge fan of yours so thank you

52:05so much for inspiring young entrepreneurs all over the world quick question one of the area of Innovation is in area of Education right so I love to hear your thoughts on what are some of the ways that we can disrupt or to you in the area of Education right well what Sebastian thr is doing

52:26and somean I mean I think that's real that stuff is really disruptive sorry and so so what Sebastian thron and and and and Conor doing is that that's great stuff sort of online learning and I think there's a to to the degree that you can gamify learning I think that's really helpful most

52:51you want to make learning not a chore if if people are drawn to it like they're drawn to video games then then I think that would really help what do you think about Peter's whole getting people to drop out of college thing yeah I think I think going to college is you know entirely optional I mean it's if you got a if you got a good idea I I'd say drop out and try it out you know you can always go back to college it's always there yeah all right Honda Mercedes have both sort of said to me very clearly they feel hydrogen fuel cells are the future but I believe strongly in batteries I know why do you think they're so behind why do you think they're so committed to hydrogen as like

53:34the next step whereas batteries I really feel like we can make this happen I don't really know because the the math is so super obviously in favor of batteries that it's like it's like staring facts in the face and saying they're not true if you take the best case scenario for a fuel cell and you say you know forget about like assume it's fully optimized so you're you're you can you you're can envelope it from a physics standpoint and say and give it the best case situation how does that compare to state-ofthe-art lithium ion or current current lithium ion in production and it loses so so it's like success is not one of the possible outcomes why why Amar upon that

54:13it's crazy I I think part of it is like there there's they felt for a long time that there was this need to be doing something and since fuel cells were 10 years in the future and always would be then they could always say they're working on fuel cells and and that would satisfy people you don't have to deliver yeah Tesla called it full cells all right great go ahead hey there my name is Richard Cooper I was an early executive at Facebook where I headed up all the international business development corporate development and strategy and so you know thinking big was something that you know has been a part of my DNA from those days and before and so as I look at all the

54:52things that you've been building obviously it resonates very much so in order to build the things that you're building obviously you need sources of capital and you have you know a sort of network of people around you I recently partnered with a group called liquid net and they think about providing liquidity on a nine figure and up kind of basis and they've created this really Dynamic platform where they have 700 Partners who all have an average of20 billion under management which equals about $14 trillion and what they're trying to do is identify really tremendous technology companies biotech farm and that kind of thing and space being sort of the next Frontier my

55:30question to you is where do you think you know the next big buckets of efficiency are for you in your Capital formation efforts Visa you know really finding that way to Mars and finding that way to kind of create the next the next wave of humanity out in the in the in the wider universe and you know we have a platform that provides for that my question is is where do you find you know efficient sources of capital or is a platform like what we have something that would serve your needs well in my case I I I find the public markets to be a pretty effective source of capital it's it's worked out well for for Tesla and Solar City will probably go public later this year

56:09and so generally you know so so all and and and SpaceX could go public at any point it's it doesn't need SpaceX has been cash flow positive for a few years so it doesn't really need doesn't really need additional Capital so actually as far as I'm concerned I at this point I do not feel myself to be Capital constrained but going public is is more efficient for you than than sort of staying private you know thinking about what's been happening in the in the public markets and sort of the the gyration and the need for public disclosure and all that kind of stuff you think that's more efficient yeah I actually don't find it to be too much of a problem to be to be a public

56:49company and I mean I kind of run the private companies like their public companies in terms of you know having the you know the appropriate controls in place and and mechanisms for Effective governance I don't I I don't think it's actually that bad to be a public company unless if if unless you're going to sort of get really concerned about the day-to-day fluctuations in the stock price that so as long as you just say look is the stock pric is going to fluctuate day to day and I don't care then you know that that's the only time it's an issue just you just shouldn't worry about the day-to-day fluctuations too much what do you think about the trend of the Dual

57:31class shares and this whole idea like being pushed byre and horwood and others of basically you need a fortress to go public I think there can be some Merit to a dual class I mean Tesla has a single class and and there's there's some Merit to a dual class I think it can be taken to a bit of an extreme in some cases where it's a dual class or one class basically doesn't count I think that's that's probably a bit unreasonable we we we you know you need there needs to be some path towards ultimately I think having a single class because you you you just get the succession problem right and it's just it's just rare that say somebody's successor particularly if that's so

58:16their kid is is is the right person it is it does happen but it's unusual and so but I mean there are cases where it's been well managed say like with the with Ford like Ford was the only company not to go not to go bankrupt and one could argue that the Ford family was a stabilizing influence on the company and had more long-term thinking and and so like I said I think there's merits to to having a dual class of ownership as long as it's not taken to an extreme right I'm I'm getting a sign that we can only take one more question yeah I apologize I'm actually supposed to be at a at a at a screening for a film at about Haiti and that's actually where I inadvertently went

59:01first and why I was so late so but I I absolutely have to show up there because so I apologize you guys but you're getting the last one all right so I I work in the space industry out here as well so I appreciate the things you're doing with SpaceX you tweeted yesterday that you thought we're going to be in at Mars in 40 years and we haven't been to the Moon in 40 years so I was wondering what space ACC plan is for that yeah actually I was I was saying that I thought we we could conceivably be at M around 12 to 15 years from now and SpaceX is is

59:38continuing to develop the technology Beyond Falcon 9 Falcon heavy and on you know on paper at least I think we've got a system that could achieve MOS colonization there's a long way from having such a system on paper or electronically really I really have it on paper and and actually making it real but it was only maybe a year

1:00:09or two ago that less than two years ago that that I concluded that it was possible to to to create a a self-sustaining civilization on Ms that's a yeah so I I read earlier a quote from you that said that that Mars was just this side of impossible or is it further than this side of impossible I believe it's possible just extremely difficult okay yeah I I wasn't sure it was possible until about a year and a half ago uhhuh so last thing we we always ask everybody a series of questions and the the crowd favorite as always what would be your mediocre superpower now this is absurd to ask you because Tony Stark is partially modeled after you so you actually are sort of

1:00:54have real so we actually technically have a superpower he I guess except like inventing technology or something right so we're sort of asking you to downgrade from that EV it so an example of a med mediocre superpower would be one of the best ones we've ever gotten is this guy who wished to temporarily detach his arm while spooning with a girl sometimes it say it's sometimes it's stay that's what he wants to do with a girl that's awesome sometimes it's like staying perfectly caffinated that's some people's the other day my nanny had a great one which was to inflict menstrual cramps on her enemies wow okay so what what would yours be a mediocre

1:01:37superpower MH so it can't be CU I think the most awesome superpower would just be to be lucky and one would say you have been yeah so if you could dial that back slightly what what would be a good mediocre superpower I think you're talking mediocre superpowers here I think to just to always beat the traffic I think that's an appropriate way to end tonight so just a couple housekeeping things we're we're not going to do la monthly but we are going to do it regularly so we'll do two or three more of these before the end of the year and we will try to have as impressive guest to zon we have a couple in mind already that I think will be surprising if anyone would like to

1:02:31sponsor these events we are a for-profit company and we're trying to make money you can email me at Sarah panda.com and I will get you to the right people as you can see it's an amazing event you should absolutely give us money so we can keep doing it and pay people like Michael who cover La companies next week if you're in San Francisco we have Mark Pinkus we would love to see you there and other than that let's just give a huge round of Applause to Elon

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份