2010年秋天,耶鲁大学工程学院的报告厅里坐满了人。讲台上站着39岁的埃隆·马斯克,他刚被《时代》杂志选进当年的百大人物,头衔一长串:PayPal联合创始人、特斯拉CEO、SpaceX创始人。台下的人想听的,大概是他怎么连赢三次。
结果他开口讲的第一句话,是一个听起来像科幻小说的题目:让生命成为多行星物种。
那时候SpaceX还没把人送进过太空。猎鹰9号刚首飞成功没几个月,龙飞船还活在图纸和模拟视频里。特斯拉Roadster卖了两千多辆,公司账上紧巴巴。但马斯克站在那儿,一本正经地算一笔账:把人类送上火星,大概要花掉全球GDP的0.25%到0.5%。
他说,这个数比大家想的便宜得多。
怎么判断一件事值不值得干,用历史的望远镜看
马斯克开场先不谈火箭,谈方法论。他抛出一个问题:你凭什么说一件事重要?
他的答案是,把时间轴拉长。当下觉得天大的事,过些年回头看就淡了。真正重要的东西,放在几十亿年的尺度上依然站得住。
沿着这条线,他给生命演化史列了一份清单。单细胞生命出现,多细胞生命出现,细胞开始分化,植物和动物分家,生命从海洋爬上陆地,哺乳动物登场,意识诞生。这些是演化史上真正的大事件。
然后他把「从一颗行星到多颗行星」放进了这份清单。
我认为从一颗行星走向多颗行星,至少可以和从海洋走向陆地相提并论。(马斯克)
这个类比有具体的支撑。马斯克给了一个理由:跨行星这件事,几乎不可能靠自然演化完成。让一个物种横跨数亿英里的辐射空间,落在一个环境完全不同的星球上还能活下来,靠随机突变和自然选择,概率低到可以忽略。
唯一的路径是意识。得有智慧生命主动设计出一套运载机制,把生命打包送过去。这就意味着,跨行星化不会自己发生,它是一次需要被主动抓住的窗口。
生命大概率能延续很久,但「大概率」不等于「一定」
马斯克在这里的态度很微妙,值得细看。
他说自己对生命的未来其实挺乐观,大概率会延续很长时间。但他紧接着补了一句:生命有可能因为自然灾难被抹掉,也可能因为人为灾难被抹掉。概率不大,但不是零。
他关心的是机会成本,末日叙事只是背景板。这是人类历史上第一次,技术上具备让生命多行星化的可能。这个窗口既然打开了,那就该拿出一点资源去用。
拿出多少?他给了一个让人愣一下的区间:
我觉得这远远不到我们花在医疗上的钱,但可能比我们花在口红上的钱多一点。大概在GDP的0.25%到0.5%这个量级。(马斯克)
他赶紧补了一句,自己对化妆品没意见,觉得挺好的,只是拿它当个尺子,让人对量级有个感觉。
这个类比的妙处在于,它把「拯救人类文明」这种宏大叙事,翻译成了一个财政问题。核心分歧落在花多少钱上,而不是要不要做。而答案听起来并不吓人。
去太空和去轨道,是两码事
讲完为什么,马斯克开始讲怎么做。他先泼了一盆冷水。
很多人以为,火箭飞到一定高度就算成功了。维珍银河那种亚轨道飞行,飞到大气层边缘,让乘客体验几分钟失重,确实已经做到了。但那和进入轨道,完全不是一个难度。
他给了一组数字对比:到达太空边缘,终端速度大约3马赫;进入地球轨道,终端速度要25马赫。能量和速度的平方成正比,25的平方除以3的平方,差了将近70倍。
换算下来,飞到太空边缘所消耗的能量,只有进入轨道的2%左右。
这就是为什么亚轨道旅游看起来热闹,但和真正把货物、把人送上空间站,中间隔着一道鸿沟。马斯克讲这段时特别强调,很多人对轨道的理解是错的:
大家会以为飞到几百英里的高度,重力就消失了。其实在那个高度,重力强度几乎和地面一样。你能飘起来,是因为你必须以极快的速度绕着地球转,向外的加速度刚好抵消了向内的重力。(马斯克)
换句话说,轨道讲的是「飞得快」,跟「飞得高」关系不大。这个物理常识,是理解后面所有成本问题的前提。
猎鹰1号的前三次失败,每一次都死得不一样
马斯克把失败也讲了。他复盘SpaceX早期历史,语气平淡,像在讲别人的项目。
猎鹰1号是一枚小火箭,他打了个比方,如果它是飞机,大概相当于湾流G5那种公务机的尺寸。小,便宜,但要从零验证一整套流程。
第一次发射,升空大约60秒,发动机起火,飞行终止。
第二次,飞得挺远,几乎摸到轨道,但二级出了控制问题。马斯克解释,二级是最难的部分,因为它要在真空、高速、剧烈抖动的环境里点火,地面上没法有效模拟,而他们的仿真当时过于乐观,把问题掩盖了。
第三次,他们换了个大设计,把主发动机从烧蚀冷却改成再生冷却。简单说,原来靠材料自身慢慢烧掉来散热,现在改成让燃料流经腔壁把热量带走,理论上不会烧穿。结果推力瞬变时间过长,导致级间分离失败。
三次失败,三种死法。第四次,成了。
马斯克讲这段时提了一句当时的处境:如果第四次也失败,SpaceX大概率就关门了。结果第四次成功,紧接着拿到NASA的商业货运合同,成为航天飞机退役后国际空间站补给的主力。
再往后是猎鹰9号。更大的火箭,更大的运力,2010年6月首飞。马斯克说,这次算是把该学的教训学到了,首飞成功。
真正的瓶颈:火箭用完就扔
讲到这里,马斯克把话题收到全场最核心的一点上。
他说,让生命多行星化,需要的根本性突破只有一个:完全可重复使用的、达到轨道级别的火箭系统。这件事极难,但绕不过去。
他拿航天飞机举例。航天飞机是唯一投入运营过的、具备部分可重复使用能力的系统。但它的外储箱每次都要扔掉,剩下那些号称可复用的部件,回收和翻修的成本高到离谱。算下来,航天飞机每次飞行的成本,是同等一次性火箭的四倍。
他补了一句带刺的话:历史上有很多次尝试造可重复使用火箭,但每次都是等到发现「成功不在可能结果之列」之后,项目就被取消了。
为什么可重复使用这么关键?他给了一道小学算术题。
如果一枚火箭造价1亿美元,你只用一次,那每次飞行的成本就是1亿美元。如果你能用1000次,每次飞行成本就变成10万美元。这个差别是巨大的。(马斯克)
然后他搬出了最生活化的类比,也是整场讲座里最好懂的一段:
波音747的造价大概3亿美元,一个往返需要两架。但乘客可以花不到1000美元从纽约飞到伦敦。原因很简单,那3亿美元的资本成本,被摊到了一万到两万次飞行上。
马斯克说,任何交通工具都能套这个逻辑。自行车、马、汽车、飞机,没有一样是靠「用一次就扔」运转的。唯独火箭,几十年来一直是这个模式。
所以SpaceX的路线图很清楚:先把一级收回来,再解决二级,最后把整套回收流程做到足够便宜。他承认这很难,也承认不一定成,但必须试。
猎鹰9号的运力,和它为什么便宜
问答环节第一个问题问的是运力。
马斯克给的数据是:猎鹰9号能把大约12吨载荷送入轨道。这个量级和波音、洛克希德马丁的德尔塔IV、宇宙神V的单个助推器差不多,也接近阿丽亚娜5的两个助推器之一。区别在于,阿丽亚娜5一次可以挂两个助推器,猎鹰9号是单芯级。
成本上,他的说法是:每公斤成本大约是德尔塔IV的三分之一到四分之一,大约是俄罗斯或中国火箭的一半。
为什么能便宜这么多?马斯克给了两个原因。
第一个是设计。系统设计决定了成本的下限,如果设计得聪明,就能抵消其他国家的人力成本优势。
第二个是组织方式,这一点他觉得被严重低估了:把工程和生产放在同一个地方。设计和制造挨着,迭代和优化才能快速发生。工程师改完图纸,走几步就能看到产线上的反馈,而不用隔着一个大洲来回扯皮。
特斯拉的续航焦虑,答案藏在平方里
话题转到特斯拉。有人问续航问题怎么解决。
马斯克说,Model S会提供最高300英里的续航,支持快速充电,大约45分钟能充满,另外还有换电池方案。他补了一句,今天的电池包能量密度已经超过汽油油箱了。
接着他讲了一个反直觉的结论:如果续航做到300英里,其实不需要多少充电站。日常通勤在家里充就够了,跨城出行才需要在州际公路沿线布点,大概每150到200英里一个。
更妙的是后面这句:充电站和换电站的需求,随续航里程的平方下降。
因为续航决定了能覆盖的面积,而面积随半径平方增长。续航翻倍,覆盖面积翻四倍,需要的补能站点数量就掉一大截。
如果续航做到500英里左右,你基本上不需要充电站了,除了酒店门口那一个。因为几乎没有人一天开超过500英里。(马斯克)
这个思路和很多人对电动车的直觉相反。大家觉得续航短才需要密集布桩,马斯克的算法是,把续航做长,桩的问题自己就消解了。
同时管两家公司,那段时间他一周干100小时
有人问,同时运营SpaceX和特斯拉是什么体验。
马斯克的回答很直白:这本来不在他的计划里。他起初只想管SpaceX,特斯拉交给别人。但金融危机来了,汽车行业受冲击最重,特斯拉眼看要死。
他面临的选择是:要么少睡点觉,把剩下的钱全砸进特斯拉;要么看着它关门。他选了前者。
那段时间确实不好玩。有很长一阵子,我每周工作100小时。现在好多了,两家公司的管理团队都强了很多,我能睡个正常觉了。(马斯克)
这段没什么豪言壮语,就是一个创始人在讲他怎么扛过现金流断裂的年份。
大学时想清楚的三件事,串起了他所有公司
有人问,SpaceX、特斯拉、SolarCity、PayPal,这些公司之间到底有什么共同线索。
马斯克说,线索要回到大学时代。他当时想的问题是:哪些事对人类未来的影响最大?
他列出了三个方向:互联网、可持续能源的生产与消费、太空探索(让生命多行星化)。就这三件。他后来做的所有公司,基本都能塞进这三个格子里。
至于造火箭的本事,他说纯粹是边干边学。一开始他打算招一个首席设计师,结果发现找不到合适的人。能来的不够强,够强的不肯来。最后他自己成了首席设计师。
如果我当时懂得更多,可能会更早成功。但事情就是这么发生的。(马斯克)
NASA该干什么,不该干什么
谈到NASA,马斯克先给足了肯定。NASA是SpaceX最大的客户,一半的发射订单来自它,技术上也给了不少指导。SpaceX是站在早期航天计划积累的知识上往前走的。
但他话锋一转,讲了一个更根本的分工问题。
NASA本质上是政府机构,而政府在创新和成本优化上通常不太擅长。更好的方式是,NASA把目标定清楚,说我们需要做到这个,然后让私营部门去找解法。(马斯克)
他拿商业货运合同举例:12次补给任务给了SpaceX,8次给了轨道科学公司。这种竞争性采购,比过去政府自己包办要有效得多。
但他也强调,NASA的角色不可替代。有些事没有直接商业价值,比如送火星车上去、维护哈勃望远镜,对人类整体有价值,但对某家公司没价值。这种时候就得靠公共资金来当那个「太空资本家」。
他做事的排序标准:影响力优先
有人问了个尖锐的问题:做这些,到底是为了经济回报,还是别的什么?
马斯克的回答干脆:都不是。他的排序标准是影响力优化,也就是哪件事对人类未来的改变最大。经济回报只是必要条件,因为一个持续亏钱的公司活不下去。
如果按投资回报率排序,太空和汽车会排在很后面。在太空领域赚钱极其困难,经营汽车公司也很难,只是有可能。如果我当年再做一个互联网公司,回报会容易得多。(马斯克)
这段话解释了他为什么不去做看起来更赚钱的事。他会算账,只是算的是另一本账。
控制权:特斯拉可能被收购,SpaceX 不会失控
有人问公司控制权的问题。
马斯克说,他持有特斯拉大约三分之一的股份。理论上有人可以发起恶意收购,但难度很大,除非对方做出极其愚蠢的举动,否则拿不下。SpaceX未来可能会上市,但即便上市,他大概也会保留多数股权,因为上市是为了融资,不是为了交出控制权。
至于特斯拉,他表态说,短期到中期不会卖。只有一种情况他会同意:特斯拉推动可持续交通转型的使命已经基本完成。
回头看特斯拉,我希望能达到的最好结果是,它的存在把电动车转型提前了五到十年。(马斯克)
为什么这五到十年重要?他给了一个经济学解释:二氧化碳是典型的公地悲剧。所有人都在往大气和海洋里排碳,消耗它们的容量,但在加油站没人为此付费。这个市场失灵,只能靠创新去填。
给年轻创业者的建议:别一上来就碰重资产
有学生问,如果想像他一样创业,该从哪儿开始。
马斯克的建议很实在:先挑资本需求低的事做。互联网就是好选择,几乎不需要厂房和设备。如果能发明一种更高效的风能或太阳能技术,也有可能拿到风投。
但太空和汽车,他打了个比方,相当于「研究生级别的创业」。资本门槛太高,一上来就进这个赛道不明智。
可重复使用的死结:2%到3%的干质量
有人追问技术细节:造完全可重复使用的火箭,难点到底在哪。
马斯克给了一个非常具体的数字。即便用最好的材料、最好的设计,一次性火箭送入轨道的干质量,大概只占起飞质量的2%到3%。
这已经是个很薄的余量了。再加回收系统、隔热罩、着陆腿、返程燃料,全是从这2%到3%里扣。扣完经常发现,运力归零。
历史上那些可重复使用项目,大多死在这一步。
所以真正的挑战是三件事叠加:提高发动机效率、提高结构质量效率、把回收系统做到极轻。最后必须保证,扣掉所有回收装置之后,还有至少2%的干质量能留在轨道上。
SpaceX的方案是:一级助推器通过推进式着陆返回发射场,二级用翼伞减速,最后软着陆。按设计,这套组合理论上能守住2%这条线。
猎鹰9号的下一代型号,目标是把这个运力再提升大约10倍。马斯克说这很难,需要在整个系统层面做优化,发动机、主结构、电子设备、回收系统,一个都不能少。
SolarCity 只做那60%的成本
最后有人问到SolarCity。
马斯克先纠正了一个常见误解。SolarCity是当时美国最大的太阳能光伏供应商,但它自己不生产电池板。它的角色更像戴尔:不造CPU和硬盘,但设计整机、做集成、管安装。
他给了一个成本结构:在屋顶太阳能的总成本里,电池板只占40%,剩下60%是其他所有东西。布线、逆变器、许可申请、人工安装,这些加起来才是大头。
所以SolarCity的价值在于优化这60%,也就是行业里说的「系统平衡」部分。
他还特意夸了美国本土的电池板制造商,比如SolarWorld和SunPower。SunPower的电池板转换效率是当时最高的。大部分太阳能领域的技术创新,其实是由美国公司推动的。
这场2010年的讲座,今天看什么
回看这场讲座,最有意思的地方在于他当时把问题拆解的方式。
他谈的是一道道算术题,情怀留给了别人。跨行星化需要多少钱?GDP的0.25%到0.5%。可重复使用能省多少?从1亿美元一次降到10万美元一次。续航多长才不需要充电站?500英里。可重复使用的物理死结在哪?2%到3%的干质量。
这种把宏大目标翻译成具体数字的能力,比任何愿景宣言都更有说服力。十年后猎鹰9号真的实现了一级回收复用,Model S真的卖到了300英里续航,这些当年听起来像吹牛的数字,一个个落地了。
当然也有没落地的。完全可重复使用的二级,到今天还在攻关。火星时间表一再推迟。但那是另一个故事了。
这场讲座真正值得带走的,是那套思考框架:
- 用历史的尺度筛问题。当下让你焦虑的事,放进几十亿年的演化史里还重不重要?如果重要,就值得投入。
- 把宏大目标换算成具体成本。别停在「这件事很重要」,往下算一步:要花多少钱,占多大比例,能不能承受。
- 找那个卡住所有人的物理瓶颈。航天领域的死结是「用完就扔」,你的行业里可能卡在别的地方。找到它,整个成本结构才有解。
- 用平方关系思考基础设施。续航翻倍,补能站点需求掉四倍。很多看起来无解的网络效应问题,换个参数就解开了。
- 工程和生产放在一起。设计和制造隔得越远,迭代越慢,成本越高。这一条对所有硬件创业都成立。
- 创业先挑资本门槛低的赛道。互联网是本科水平,太空和汽车是研究生水平。别一上来就挑战最高难度。
- 想清楚自己在优化什么。如果优化的是影响力而不是回报率,很多决策会变得简单,虽然路会更难走。
马斯克在那场讲座里说了一句话,可能是整场最实在的:这件事很难,他不确定能成,但必须试。十年过去,他把「必须试」的部分做成了一半。剩下那一半,还在路上。
0:01welcome everyone to the victor Tyler Distinguished Lecture ship and engineering I'm Kyle van der like the Dean of the School of Engineering and Applied Science this is truly a wonderful moment for Yale engineering as we today inaugurate this new lectureship made possible with a generous gift of the Honorable Guido Calabresi United States Circuit Judge and former dean of our law school and his wife Anne this lecture series is designed to bring to campus leaders whose contributions and insights not only reflect the broad mission of engineering but also shed light on some of the most important technological problems of our time the Calabrese who inspired to create this
0:47lectureship by its name namesake victor tyler a Yale graduate who received a BS in physics in 1953 and a master's in electrical engineering in 1958 for 15 years Vic served as an electrical engineer with the national defense contractor EG&G in the mid 60s he was charged with identifying new business ventures for the company one of which was the new era of electronic credit authorization systems when eng opted out he left the company to file concord computed corporation it was Vic's entrepreneurial acumen which provided financial institutions nationwide with ATM processing debit card processing access to a national debit network and deposit risk management in fact the
1:35company was the United States largest ATM processor bank his wife Mary the Calabrese and members of their families are here today to join us in welcoming our inaugural lecturer someone who so perfectly embodies the spirit of this lectureship and that being Elon Musk at age 39 eon has already helped create some of the most widely recognized and transformative companies on the planet including PayPal Tesla Motors and space X at hustla he is working to transition to a sustainable energy economy with all the electric tesla roadster and Model S sedan and at SpaceX he is not just preparing to send cargo to the International Space Station but working
2:20to extend life beyond Earth he has a bachelor's degree in physics and economics from the University of Pennsylvania and yon has received countless awards for his work in 2007 he was named rd's magazine and magazines inventor of the year he received the aviation week 2008 laureate for the most significant advancement worldwide in the space industry and the american institute of aeronautics and astronautics award for the greatest contribution to the field of space transportation the list goes on in 2010
2:54he received the auto executive of the year innovator award and is the youngest recipient ever Esquire magazine named him as one of the 75 most influential people of the 21st century in 2008 and most recently he was named to the time magazine 100 for 2010 and it it is with terrific pleasure that I welcome and present to you as our 2010 inaugural Victor Tyler distinguished lecturer Elon Musk
3:34well very glad to be here thanks for thanks for having me the the what I was going to talk about today was basically the importance of making life multiplanetary and how I think we could get there and it's a I think it's one of the most significant things that that will ever occur in the history of life itself and and this is really the first time in the Pope alenia history of life on Earth that it's been with within the realm of possibility personal I guess
4:10I'm what should to look at the nature of importance itself how do you decide that that anything is important i think that the lens of history is is a helpful guide in that that the further use the amount and the greater the span of time that you look at the things that seem important in the moment fade away and the the things that are truly significant are still there and if you
4:36look at the history of the evolution of line you could say well what are the major elements in that in that history and it obviously the advent of single-celled life multicellular life differentiation plants animals the transition from of from the oceans to land mammals and consciousness and those
4:58are the big ones but I think also on that list Woodward fit like going from one planet to multiple planets your pc at least comparable to library from the the oceans to land and and i think given the immense difficulty of that egg where you actually need consciousness to develop in order to achieve that goal because this I can't see any way that black could we just evolved in dominant fashion to
5:33go across hundreds of millions of miles of irradiated space to an environment that's completely different to it and still just a live so if you really need consciousness in order to design a mechanism of making that journey and then I don't I should actually I've all just stand talking to like on a better thing on so Mary sits I think an
6:02extremely important thing that we try to accomplish this and it's not really fun perspective of thinking that a lot but it is in imminent danger of ending I'm actually quite optimistic about like you know if I think it's likely to last for a long time this is this there's some chance of life it would be being eradicated due to some natural calamity or potentially a man-made calamity but I think most likely it will will do well for a long time nonetheless this is the first time that it's been possible to
6:45consider making life multiplanetary and so I think it's it's wise to take advantage of that opportunity and and dedicate some portion of our resources about like resources to that goal and we can debate as to what is the magnitude how much you know resources should be dedicated to it but it's you know I think not nearly as much as we get a hit to help here but maybe more than we spend on lipstick you know that's the kind of it brackets things I don't have anything against because cosmetics I think they're great but you know it just that's it gives you
7:29an approximate sense of things maybe it's the quarter of a percentage point of the gdp or half a percentage when did you hear something like that so in endurance basics what we're trying to do in space lexmark about a rocket company is to make some progress in that direction and it's a very difficult goals I think it's going to take love two companies and a lot of people to actually make this happen but at SpaceX we're going to do our best to move the ball forward as much as we can so the
8:10the way we started out boys by designing a small rocket I called the Falcon one and if that was an aircraft it would be comparable to look at the Gulf Stream five or something like that basically comparable in size to a corporate jet and it's it took us a couple pies to get to over it's quite the Pope and getting to space is actually a lot easier than getting to orbit so so that will think that physics is competing with Virgin Galactic which has been done by LJ Branson but but this is not the case really like to get just going to the edge of space which requires terminal velocity about Mach 3 but getting to orbit requires terminal velocity of Mach 25 and the energy
9:07scales with square of the velocity so the getting to space is only about two percent of the energy required to get to do a forward so the first ones that we did welcome on didn't even get to space got about 60 60 seconds up and then an engine fire terminated the well it's a complicated story but the spice to say
9:36an engine fire course tantrum to stop and and then our plight to we actually got quite close to orbit but had controls issue you are a second stage is breathable since the second stage in particular because second stage starts in vacuum at very high speed and and hide reloading so it's really difficult is that exactly on earth you can simulate it you can't really test it effectively and our simulations happen to be optimistic so we corrected that
10:15error and then on flight three we would change the main engine design from an ablative lee cooled management which means that the the chamber will burns way slowly to are generally called engine which means it's that you use the fuel to cool the chamber I think essentially run the fuel fueled through the chamber wall to cool a chamber and end and so nothing burns away but the
10:44net result was a thrust transient and extended thrust transit that caused the failure and stage separation so but fortunately fourth time was the charm as it turns out the hit on segment and an artifact for we were made it toured with Malcolm wanted and I was a very nervous side because we were if we had made her
11:16fight for it's not clear whether we would wear the SpaceX work which select this day and unfortunately we did made from flagpole and an in-flight hydrogen so successful and we were awarded the contract to NASA to be the primary replacement for the space shuttle as far as cargo transport is concerned and with recent events this year looks like we will win the primary contract for astronaut transport as well and anna-marie divorced of alpha 9 which is a much larger version a much larger rocket and launch data return and
11:58actually looks like we learned our lessons because actually were successful on the first flight so I'll show you some of the videos at some point will maybe release videos of the first three flights
13:00music video version of the music for sampling is a high roller from the crystal method
13:50little island that we worked from bodily quadrant Lee natural in law quad
16:41so it's a sophomore and it's really the great difficulty was getting to orbit his really that that velocity element celeste groups who assume that if you go up to a certain altitude ulc your engineering services improve it so he will think that gravity kind of stopped if you were you got a couple hundred miles but actually the gravity strength of gravity Cutler vows about subsea is almost the same strength as at the surface of the earth it's just that in order to stay out there you have to zip around the earth really fast such that the outward acceleration and the outward to radiate alteration sequel to the inward acceleration of gravity and so
17:26there's two null out and that's what gives you the feeling of 0 ki so he'll should be milk at nine
18:08it's big buck 99 engines on the base and each of those engines is actually operating on a higher thrust of God reward you really have something here which is over a million pounds of thrust and that's about four times the maximum thrust for a 747 look go little waited de trop faible 27 for example the Lord
18:36took place in June and it's got essentially a just a structural test article a dragon spacecraft on the top there the launch that's coming up hopefully next month will carry operation virgin about Dragon spacecraft this is Cape Canaveral so welcome i will just come out a North crab you have a cape canaveral where someone will choose from
19:12you sonic there you actually is not shutting down this is the phase of life that were most concerned about is the stage separation the ignition I control of the second stage in this case the second stage engine was at two o'clock bed engine which is more complex than fresh occasion
22:30or just a rolling a little more going to the control this has been quite well
23:01that was about tonight future link to see that one gets away and they had one final video just let's see now this is obviously a simulation and this this is a simulation of the Dark Knight will a dragon spacecraft and going to the space station and basically thoughtful and rooster glimmers dragged into your parking orbit near the space station then I dragon spacecraft maneuvers over the space station ducks lovers Parker or astronauts and then I'm dr. Newton's drill in the simulation the launch escape system is shown as a kind of a tractor like that needle needle thing on the nose but the reaction going
23:54to do something that's never been done before which is called the launch escape system into the spacecraft itself so you don't have a tractor on the nose we've got that's fundamentally safer and more efficient also dragon once we were confident of our landing accuracy dragon will land on land as opposed to the water which is shown in this simulation
24:51as I mentioned next month you'll be launching the first operation from a dragon spacecraft it worked dr. a space station on the first flight it kind of just move around in orbit and then reenter tests the primary heat shield the kinds of aggregation control system full inflammatory and then the obviously the parachute recovery from from the order and in-flight to provide a product which is due to take place next year will be the first flight that actually goes to the space station soho goes well we'll be going to the space station and doing pretty much what you see here except with cargo is there are people around you or next year which is the
25:30short day option spatial retires you is the parent here is that this is actually controlled reentry so this is just great treated the drug trade craft has a look of a drag about point two five and that's due to having a offset center of mass in the castle so just by rotating a capsule with the onboard engines you can actually change that lift vector and achieve a very accurate landing location in fact even during the Palo Duro they're able to glance you might receive about one mile and that was at ggs rating so it sort of seems like this coming elastically protect you to break your toe really
26:56and then as I said this is kind of a short ending 1 2 will land on landing legs and simmer probably in lobby Desert California and so this is sort of worked
27:23with SpaceX is at this point that now the really big breakthrough that's needed the fundamental invention that is needed to make life multiplanetary is a fully reusable mobile / class rocket system this is an extremely difficult thing to achieve the space shuttle which is partly reusable and they partly because the main tank is thrown away every time and even the parts that are supposed to be reusable are so difficult to reuse or recover that the spatial costs about four times as much per flight as an equivalent expendable vehicle so special is the only operating
28:09example of something that even has partial reusability they've been many attempts to achieve to pull the reusable rocket system but they have always been cancelled once they discover that success was not one of the possible outcomes so but this is fun really something that has to be solved if if life's become multiplanetary and it is just incredibly fundamental if interrupted costs 100 million dollars to produce then if you can use one will
28:49then a customer glowing balls per flight but if you can use it a thousand times it costs a hundred thousand dollars per flight it's a pretty huge difference and it's the reason why pretend air flight okay I think of any mode of transport and imagine if we were not reusable we would see how much they use whether it's a bicycle a horse playing
29:11we just think you'd have to have two more sisters for entre and you know or air flights a good example where you know 747 costs on the order of that Turner 5,300 billion dollars and you need two of them for round trip and yet you can fly from New York to London for less than a thousand dollars if you work here too can't that so the reason is because the capital cost of that 747 is allocated over when a case of imports are in probably ten or twenty thousand trips so that that that's really the hugely fundamental thing that's needed and and SpaceX we're hoping to make some
29:52progress in that direction thus far we've recovered anything except a few bits and pieces and but hopefully on the upcoming fight a line with dragon things go really well will recover the first stage and water recover our dragon spacecraft and then long-term we'll have to work on recovering the second stage and then making that whole recovery process really cost-effective and yeah so that's
30:21just kind of lot but the long-term goal and I don't know probably successful on that but I think we have to try it yeah so that's that about SpaceX and was made tough topic of my talk but I'm happy to add taking questions from google maps basics or Tesla or or anything else
31:00we have plenty of time for questions but we don't have any mics in the audience so if you'd like to ask a question just make sure you move it out so start in the back to
31:50write those words then act very much and so well in terms of the costume tough 90 booty up 90 Klein is capable of about roughly 12 tons to orbit and that's comparable to the rocks made by a lucky even Boeing IT mystically or comparable to one of the two bays in the ariane 5 RM buy this bigger awkward but watches to sublights at a time and we actually the most cost effective in the world for about a third to a quarter the cost of boy malaki and and maybe half the cost
32:39of the Russians or the Chinese and you know I think it's just really a function of the design of the system that it's able to to be a lot more cost effective than other other designs and a big believer in having engineering and production co located so that the yet the iteration you're the optimization between engineering and production can happen quickly so i think that's often overlooked as as a way as a aware of achieving cost effective product is what
33:22I be the design of the system sets the sets that the lowest potential cost and if you're smart about the design you overcome the labor cost advantage of other countries and then with respect to the range exciting thing the way that we're addressing that with the Model S the sedan that's coming out a few years is we're offering a range of up to 300 miles an ability to charge the battery very quickly and every charger in about 45 minutes and then also fast
34:00fat so the battery pack today's walk down pass the nucleophilic gas tank and if you're going to range with 300 miles you really don't need a lot of recharge stations or battery pack swap stations in fact you don't need any within your hometown you maybe need them along the interstates and that kind of thing every 150 200 miles I'm
34:23interesting to note that the need for recharge stations and backpack swap stations drops with the square of the of the range you know that because that defines that the area you're able to cover and so as the range gets bigger bigger the need for our return stations drops quite a bit arguably if you get up to around 500 miles range you don't really need any charge stations because apart from the one at the hotel that you're saying it because almost nobody travels more than 500 miles in a day
35:11well yeah it's definitely been a difficult thing to run SpaceX and Tesla simultaneously and it was not it was not really my intent to run both companies I had hope to just run SpaceX and then Tesla would be run by by others but when the economy you know had issues that and those issues particularly affected the car business our CEO murders of high school at Bangkok it was a choice of either get a lot less sleep and and rent as low as well plus applied all my remaining capital Tesla or because it would die and so that's you know I obviously the performer and that was
36:01definitely it was actually definitely not fun drink during that period but at this point I feel a lot better about things and the management teams are both companies or a lot is this lot more bench strength there so I can get to a reasonable amount of sleep and but for a while there were six of continuous under Dara weeks which is I think that's not fun
37:02sure well the time the frustration of the thing that kind of ties together SpaceX Tesla Solar City which we haven't talked much about and and and then paypal and micros area company was that in in college I thought about what are the things that would most effective future humanity and those things need to be the internet sustainable energy both production consumption and then and then space travel typically making life multiplanetary so that's that's the only thing that really ties in together regard from from atl to SpaceX was definitely a huge learning process because I've never made anything because it go before just basically done there
37:48it's offer so they were it was just a huge huge learning vetting process the initially I had thought that I would hire someone to be the chief designer of the rocket but I can actually find anyone who is willing to join oh I work who was good so they could look at Williams drawing food I thought what couldn't do the job and those who could do the job we're going to join so I ended up being a chief designer of the rocket and I think perhaps it if you know if I'd been more knowledgeable we were too pregnant Warwick sooner than flight full but it
38:28was yeah that's kind of how yeah well I think it necessarily observes a lot of credit for the progress that SpaceX is made in that NASA is our biggest customer you know of the launches that we've solved by half hour to NASA that half hour other organizations NASA's also served as as a advisor on some important technical issues and so they've been very helpful of course SpaceX is building upon a knowledge that was created during the early days of space of program now that
39:30being said that I mean NASA is sold at the end of a the government so the government is generally not good at generally not that great that innovation and cost optimization so it is is better if if NASA's kind of sets the goals and says okay this is this is what we need to achieve and then allows the private sector to figure out the right solution and I've gots been very effective with the transition work and spatial to
40:04SpaceX and then that's not how many opal Sciences natural order 12 12 with the resupply missions to SpaceX and 82 opal sciences so I think that's a much better solution than nordisk incorporated before but but absolutely we still need that the NASA there to serve as you know a funding source essentially kind of like a spacecraft capitalist if you will that's spending money on things that are a benefit to the whole country and arguing to humanity at home but aren't necessarily of commercial value to met that plugs directly into the economy you know it's a hard to say exactly like what is the direct commercial value of sending the Rovers to Mars it's I mean
40:55it's or the Hubble telescope you know these things are great value to humanity but they aren't specific commercial value to other companies and so that there is that important role for pronounced or play in the making and funding those important objectives and apps in working on their
41:18doing basic research on to fundamental new things that that have a very long payoff period started eating dumb of really interesting things which are poly and I wanted to ask was pretty you first look whether there's any an economic you look is something
42:06sure well I'd say it's actually it's neither of the two it's it's really kind of like a relevance optimization and it's what I think is going to make the biggest difference to the future of humanity and and then and then I see Curtis Lee if I can have the value of the output be greater than the cost of the input which is necessary for any ongoing Enterprise so but it's
42:38definitely not from respective this is the best return on investment or anything like that if one were to rank order return on investment in theme of effort required I think space and cars would be really low on the list it is extraordinarily difficult to make an economic return on you know in the space endeavor or I think it run a car company it's something possible and that's or actually it has to adapt a great economic return but could a great difficulty and if I'd done say another internet company that the return would have been it would have been easy relative to the near the return that we would have yielded so yeah so it's just
43:25from the standpoint of am i working on things that I think will have biggest impact on on the future and then economics making the economics work is necessary just because if you don't make even artwork they often have impact on future but second row
43:59well you know I'm actually look good only pick on the exit both for what my first company is up to which internet software it helped the media companies come online at you know and and paypal and I was the least interested in installing and the rest of the board was so I kind of along with that and but I had no no plans to sort of South Tesla or solar city or SpaceX but I think it's very important particularly that they switch not resolved because then it would lose the those awful goals that I
44:42had in mind well Tesla is public and I'm so in theory somebody could attempt a hostile takeover Tesla although it would be tricky so I know about a third of the company so that have to really I don't read ruin something really stupid in order to you know for somebody to do on hostile takeover and so from just doing water at least you two things I think they wouldn't be able to take it over and and then SpaceX I think we'll
45:18probably takes basic to public but I even going probably i'll probably still have a majority share of space xo going public would be you know give us access slow class capital but I wouldn't do this control of the company and I think with with Tesla it's possible some point in the future swimming out in the short to medium term at some point of future it may make sense for your shareholders language to self-test lot but I would only agree to such as well if I felt that the fundamental good that Tesla can achieve as we had largely been achieved and that fundamental good the acceleration to sustainable transport and that's which one looks back at the Tesla and says well what's
46:02the best outcome I can help for Tesla the best outcome I hope is that the presence of Tesla accelerated the transition to electric cars by five to ten years and and and the reason it's important to have that acceleration is that we have a tragedy of the Commons problem in blood of co2 or universal consuming some co2 capacity the oceans and atmosphere but we're not paying for that at the gas pump and so we have to
46:34be you have to bridge that that issue with innovation and that search that's the funnel growth of Tesla and solar city yeah you wouldn't have a question
46:55other questions ah yeah i think if so many systems are starting out as kind of an engineer or partner have a role then you need to pick something where which is which requires low capital that's why the internet is to be a good choice well terribly if you in a few committee if you can invent something associated with making it a more efficient form of wind
47:44energy or so of power or something like that then I think you may be able to crank venture capital for full end of that investment but I think certainly space and cars and would be an equivalent of like graduate entrepreneurship thank you but probably not wise to start to start out in that arena just because of the capital requirements are pretty pretty high two more question
48:42yeah so the base we did I mean the final issue with making an overt class system reusable is that typically up the even for expendable system after you use the best materials and bad stuff design techniques that kind of thing you maybe get two to three percent rulers of master orbit so if you then start adding in recovery systems and heat shields and all sorts of things then you're subtracting from that to three percent and and then historically wonder when
49:17they've been they've been many attempts to create a reasonable overall system that found that after editing reusability elements they gets irritable or almost nothing fold it so the real challenge is improving the engine efficiency the mass efficiency and then just having very lightweight recovery systems so that you can actually end up with that say at least two percent of
49:47your left foot mass coming back or a period and these two your percent of your book book match being a paler to orbit after subtracting all of the recovery systems and that kind of thing so you do have a design in mind for full Vulcan my version to that in principle does achieve that and that's consists of
50:08the first age boosting back through a propulsive landing at more site and the second stage having a parafoil to 22 a and landing on either one head back or kind of like a said something soft soft landing and in principle that got achieves the two percent okay little bit see if someone have roughly 10 times Tulio capability
50:41lowered over capability so that's what we're going to try to do with version two fell for nine but it's a very tough thing and Alexis requires optimization across the whole system you know engines primary structure in ronix recovery system the whole shooting match it's it is no one syllable it's a it's an overall system optimization
51:37right right right well as you clarify with with SolarCity supposed to skate the city's largest provider of solar power or photovoltaic solar on the ISIS right now but it's kind of like analogous to tell computer so so much time does not make the solar panels itself but it designs the overall system for a particular rooftop Disney installation the wiring Souls the inverter does the permitting lights and stuff so just like dell computer doesn't make the hard drive of the cpu or that kind of thing and that actually is majority of the cost so if you hear wanted to go so power on your normal business about forty percent of the caucus is the panel and sixty percent is
52:24everything else and so that's why I what it was important to have company like SolarCity to optimize the all the sort of bony bits of their their of the what's called the balance of system for installing solar power so so so city will buy a house from a wide variety of manufacturers but but I should say that
52:51the US companies are actually very strong in the end up in the panel manufacturer business corsola for example it is the US company is phenomenal job on cost of solar power SunPower provided PA which is basic social value has the highest energy efficiency panels so this is a huge
53:14amount of innovation taking place and most that innovation is driven from the US let me take this opportunity to thank you on must for an absolutely inspirational and wonderful lectures the police
53:40I would also like to thank the caladrius and the Tyler's for making this event possible one of the most significant comments to me today was your answer to the question why do you do what you do and of course the answer was not because of the economics or because of the fun of it because of a passion to impact the future of humanity and I've never heard a better description of the essence of engineering than that and that is what this lecture series is all about so I thank you for this opportunity to have this lecture series and I welcome everyone to a reception in the becton
54:20student area in the back the tropical island drive the back of the building for a reception with our distinguished speaker lastly I'd like to offer you just a very small token of our gratitude these are Yale cufflinks now I see you're not the complete white they come in however on the very first multiplanetary black-tie event we hope you will consider wearing them thank you very much you
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版