访谈·中文精读

马斯克 ONS 2022 挪威访谈

Elon Musk ONS 2022 Norway Interview

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2022 年,挪威斯塔万格(Stavanger),ONS 能源大会。主持人用一长串头衔介绍台上的人:SpaceX 创始人、CEO 兼首席工程师,特斯拉 CEO 兼产品架构师,天使投资人,颠覆者。介绍完毕,主持人补了一句:这位先生对“信任”这个主题说过一些很有意思的话,他形容自己痴迷于真相,相信阳光是最好的消毒剂。

马斯克接过话筒,第一句是“我爱挪威”。第二句是感谢挪威人对电动车和可持续能源的长期支持,他说“你们真的做出了改变”。

全场等着他谈信任。主持人没有客气,直接把问题抛回来:你怎么理解信任?

先说清一件事:算法不该是黑盒

马斯克先绕了一下。他说这个问题很哲学,可以聊很久。然后他透露了一件小事:有人告诉他,今天唯一不能谈的话题是推特,所以我避开它。全场笑。

玩笑之后他给出答案。信息这件事,人们想知道自己收到的内容是准确的、反映全貌的,读完之后能相信,而不是总觉得哪里被带偏了,或者至少能明白偏见在哪一边。所以信任的核心之一是透明。

他把透明落到一个很具体的做法上:一家社交媒体公司应该把算法开源,让人能看、能批评,而不是一个黑盒。如果公司里的人对算法做了什么改动,也要说明白,不要藏着。

自由的思想流动,在法律边界内,尽量偏向言论自由。主持人追问:法律的边界是个好的起点吧?马斯克说:越过那条线,你就会被抓。

这一节结束得很快。信任、透明、开源算法、法律边界,四个词概括了他对公共平台的全部主张。台下的人可能以为他接下来会继续谈平台治理,他把话题转到了能源。

在讲信任的场合,他说此刻需要更多的油和天然气

主持人问,下一个有待颠覆的领域是什么?

马斯克先否掉了“为了颠覆而颠覆”。他说自己没这个动机。他想的是一件更朴素的事:哪一组行动最有可能通向更好的未来。

对这个问题的回答,绕不开能源。文明要有前途,必须有一条清晰的通往可持续能源的路。他认为这一点大概所有人都同意。

接下来这句是整场最反常识的一段。他先澄清,自己不会把石油和天然气妖魔化。此刻文明离开它就无法运转,这是事实。然后他补了一句:这个时刻,我们需要更多的石油和天然气,不是更少。

这句话和“加速可持续能源”并列说出来,很多人第一反应会觉得矛盾。他的解释是这两件事同时进行,并不冲突。油气支撑当下的运转,可持续能源决定长远的方向;在替代能源还没铺开到足够的规模之前,减油气等于让文明踩刹车。

他特别提到挪威首相的发言,说“讲得非常准”。他还嫌首相说得不够。海上风电:如果搞一个 100×100 的阵列,每台机组 10 兆瓦,合计就是 100 吉瓦的装机能力。

海上风电有个天然问题:有时候刮风,有时候不刮,刮起来又刮得很猛。所以要和固定式储能电池组搭配,把能量缓冲起来。特斯拉在做这件事,其他公司也在做。

这就是他提出的可持续能源未来三大支柱:

  • 可持续的能源生产:水电、地热、风电、光伏,加上核能
  • 固定式储能电池组缓冲风电和光伏的间歇性
  • 电动车:轿车、卡车、飞机、船只

关于核能,他先打预防针:我知道这在某些圈子里是不受欢迎的观点。他的立场是:一座设计得好的核电站,不该关掉,尤其是现在。他还加了一句:我尽量说我认为在科学上站得住脚的话,哪怕它不受欢迎。

三大支柱讲完,主持人问火箭怎么办。马斯克承认火箭是那个“讽刺的例外”,但也不是没有方案。

火箭推进剂里大约 80% 是液氧,直接从大气里取。剩下 20% 是甲烷。长期看,甲烷可以用二氧化碳和水合成,产物就是甲烷加氧气(CO₂ + H₂O → CH₄ + O₂)。这套路径在火星上必须成立,因为火星上没有加油站。特斯拉现在已经在用可持续电力生产一部分推进剂,比例还小,但他预期以后会占大头。

2030 年一半新车是电动,2035 年八成

主持人把时间轴拉长到五到十五年,问能源行业的颠覆会是什么样。

马斯克给的是一组具体数字:

  • 2030 年,全球新车中大约一半会是电动车
  • 2035 年,这个比例可能达到 80%
  • 他个人认为实际数字可能更高

这不是他一个人的判断。加州已经通过法规,2035 年起在该州销售的新车必须零排放。英国也定了类似目标。挪威走得更早,新车销量里电动车已经是多数。

他说,地球人已经决定了这条路。各国、各州一个接一个地立法,方向不会退。

主持人问,如果把时间倒推,供应链会变成什么样,你最担心什么?

马斯克把问题重新定义了一下:真正决定世界能以多快速度转向可持续能源的,是电池产能扩张的速度。

真正的卡点在加工,不在矿

电池里有什么?正极材料主要是镍、锰、铁;负极主要是碳(石墨),加一点硅提升能量密度;此外还有锂和电解液。大家容易担心这些金属是不是稀有,其实不是。

锂几乎是地球上最常见的元素之一,铁也一样常见。他猜磷酸铁锂(LFP)会成为被使用最多的电池化学体系。真正的限制不在矿藏,在加工。从矿石变成电池级材料,需要极其庞大的加工设备,因为正极和负极材料必须极纯,电池才能用得久。

他把这件事的规模对标全球油气行业。要满足转型,加工能力得扩到那个量级,处理量惊人。

他说自己正在写“特斯拉宏图第三篇章”(Master Plan Part Three),梳理的就是这件事:扩大可持续能源需要哪些步骤、限制因素在哪、怎么加速。预计一两个月内完成。

主持人追问:所以现在没有卡点?马斯克说没有卡点。事情已经在发生,只是要多少年,以及我们能做什么让它更快。

他给全场的话是一句乐观和积极的信息,但他同时强调,自己不是在建议自满。

上海、柏林、奥斯汀,还有一个待宣布的选址

主持人问中国,也问到投资机会。

马斯克的回答很直白:特斯拉正在中国投资产能。上海有一个大工厂,还在扩产,还在继续投钱。同时特斯拉在欧洲(柏林郊外)和美国(奥斯汀郊外)各建了新工厂。他预期今年晚些时候可能宣布又一座超级工厂的选址。

主持人问,特斯拉怎么衡量自己的成功?

马斯克的回答和他一贯的说法一致:特斯拉的根本价值不能用利润衡量,要看它把向可持续能源的转型加速了多少年。他相信,如果没有特斯拉,汽车行业转向电动车会晚得多。

主持人开玩笑说这是指数曲线还是直线。马斯克说指数曲线。主持人笑着回了一句:希望是对数曲线。马斯克接着解释,对数曲线开头快、后来慢;大型工业转型不会走纯指数,会走 S 曲线:先指数上升,再接近线性,最后趋缓。

这段对话很轻松,但它把马斯克对技术扩散的理解讲清楚了。所有大型工业转型都是 S 曲线,没有一条是永远指数增长的。

为什么敢赌?因为不动才是最大的风险

主持人换了个角度。他说在座都是聪明人,但马斯克承担的风险可能比这里 95% 的人都多。是什么让他敢这么做?

马斯克的回答没有戏剧性。他说自己用的就是科学方法:衡量结果的重要性,衡量为达成结果要冒什么险。如果结果足够重要,哪怕成功概率低,也必须做。

他还说了一句更重的话:最冒险的事情是不采取行动。因为如果不做,就不会有好的未来。这么算下来,那根本不是风险,也不是选择。

这个逻辑贯穿他所有的项目。SpaceX 早期连续失败三次,特斯拉 2008 年濒临破产,他都在同一套框架里做决定:先看结果重不重要,再看失败代价能不能承受。如果两个答案都指向“必须做”,那就没有退路可言。

乌克兰、星链和无人机战争

主持人提到乌克兰,说马斯克“四个小时”就把互联网接通了。

马斯克纠正:接近四天。这个细节值得记一下,因为他完全可以不纠正。

他说,当时他们预判乌克兰可能会出事,提前在那里预置了一批星链终端。入侵开始后,几天内加速交付了大量终端。乌克兰政府告诉他,这些设备非常有用。

他补了一句:我希望乌克兰和俄罗斯能实现和平。应该想一想终局是什么。终局需要双方都做出一些妥协。

主持人顺着这个话题问未来战争。马斯克说,未来的战争是无人机战争,乌克兰已经露出一个缩影。如果你的无人机比对方好,你就赢。历史上战争不总是这样,但以后会是这样。

AI 能帮气候吗?他说不需要,但得当心

主持人提到一个说法:特斯拉在解决的是 AI 问题,而不是交通问题。

马斯克马上纠正顺序。特斯拉的首要目标从成立那天起就是加速可持续性,这个目标没有变。第二目标才是解决真实世界的智能问题,应用在自动驾驶上,未来可能还有人形机器人。他说特斯拉越来越像一家 AI 公司,但根本还是一家可持续能源公司。

那么 AI 能帮气候吗?

马斯克的回答有点出人意料:解决可持续性不需要 AI。这件事已经在发生,AI 可能让它更快一点。比起指望 AI 拯救气候,他更担心 AI 本身。

我认为我们对 AI 安全的担忧还不够。要确保 AI 不会失控,确保它让人类的未来更好。(马斯克)

这个立场他讲过很多次,这次讲得很短。

让他睡不着觉的两件事

主持人最后问:什么让你睡不着?或者你每天都睡得很好?

马斯克先给自己定位。他说自己本质上是工程师、技术专家,有时候被人叫做商人,但他必须带一群人一起干,因为这些事没法一个人在车库里完成。

他眼下最专注的两项技术,都希望在年底前完成:

  • 让星舰(Starship)进入轨道,把意识和生命扩展到地球之外
  • 让特斯拉汽车实现自动驾驶,至少在美国广泛发布,欧洲看监管审批

这两个目标,一个指向星际,一个指向地面。前者关乎人类作为物种的长期存续,后者关乎每天开车的人能不能少操一点心。他把它们并列说出来,没有分轻重。

整场访谈里,他给信任下的定义和给能源下的定义其实是同构的:都讲透明、都讲长期、都讲不要拿眼前的数据当全部真相。信用不是靠承诺堆起来的,是靠把黑盒打开、把算法开源、把油气的必要性说清楚、把电池加工这条最难的路指出来,一点一点积累的。

访谈结束前,主持人感谢他,马斯克回了一句“非常荣幸”。全场掌声。

这场访谈里能拿走的行动清单

  • 把 2030 和 2035 两个年份记下来,当参照点。看电动车行业进展时,不必被单一季度销量带跑,看新车电动化比例是否还在往这两个数字靠。
  • 追电池新闻时,先看加工产能,再看矿价。锂、铁、磷都不缺,缺的是把矿石提纯成电池级材料的产线。判断一家电池公司行不行,看它上游加工布局,比看它签了多少矿权更有效。
  • 看社交平台,拿“算法是否公开”当尺子。公开算法、改动留痕、内容推荐理由可追溯,这三件事是判断平台是否愿意被信任的最快切口。
  • 听到“指数级增长”,心里先画一条 S 曲线。任何大型工业转型都会从指数变线性再变缓。中途出现减速,不一定是失败,可能是走到中段。
  • 评估风险时,把“不动”也算进去。很多决策不是“做还是不做”,是“做有代价,不做也有代价”。把不动的那条成本列出来,判断会清楚很多。
  • 关注星舰入轨和特斯拉 FSD 的发布节点。这两个项目一旦真正落地,一个改写人类作为物种的存在边界,一个改写日常出行的定义。它们离我们不远,值得放进日历。
  • 把 AI 安全当一个正在发生的问题看。不必等到出大事再关注。现在就跟进模型可解释性、对齐研究、监管讨论,判断力会比事后追新闻的人领先一截。
  • 下次听到“某年全面禁油车”,先问一句:电网和储能配好了吗?发电、储能、终端电气化是三条腿,缺一条就站不稳。判断一个地区的电动化路线是否靠谱,看这三条腿进展是否匹配。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00a man whose business achievements need no introduction the founder the ceo and the chief engineer at spacex yes i am talking about you the ceo and the product architect of tesla angel investor a disruptor he's also a man who's had some very interesting things to say on the theme of this conference on trust he's described himself as being obsessed with truth he believes in sunlight being the great disinfectant elon musk please do join me

0:54let me start tell us how you think about trust well i i believe in trust and transparency and the pursuit of truth in general but i mean first let me just take a moment to say thank you for inviting me and it's an incredible honor to be here so i love norway so and and and i just wanted to to thank the leaders and the the people of norway for their long-standing support of electric vehicles and sustainable energy and i just want you know the people of norway to know that hey you really made a difference and you know so i thank you

1:42well thank you for joining us but i'm still going to come back to the question tell me tell me how do you think about trust well i think there's i mean that's that's that's really quite a philosophical question it is and one could wax on at length about that i guess you know we talk about twitter i was told that's the one topic i'm not to talk about so i'm going to avoid it they must start with the t i suppose well i mean i do think that with respect to information you know generally people want to know the information that they're receiving is accurate that it is a representative of the full picture and they want to be able to believe what they read and not feel that it's

2:37overly biased or at least understand the nature of the bias so i think one of the key things to trust is transparency and for people to really know you know if there's like a social media company or something to understand what the algorithm is so to open source the algorithm so people can look at it and critique it and it's not a black box and then if there are any modifications done by people at that social media company that they're clear and again transparent and so it's not hidden and and i you know believe in the the sort of free flow of ideas and and just generally erring on the side of free speech within the boundaries of the law within the boundaries of the law it's a

3:25great place to start isn't it yeah well you can't go sort of beyond that without being arrested i think let's move on shall we you've been a great disrupter of technology technological models in energy and space where is the unexplored area for disruption well you know i like the word disruption i mean i don't aim to disrupt for the sake of disrupting you know it's more like there's thinking about what set of actions what set of actions are most likely to lead to a better future and so

4:11you know in order one of the things obviously in order to for humanity to have a compelling future for civilization is that we must have a clear path to a sustainable energy future that's one of the things that i think everyone i think would agree with now i actually i'm not someone who who would tend to sort of demonize oil and gas to be clear this is necessary right now or civilization could not function so i do think we actually need and actually at this time i think we actually need more oil and gas not less but but simultaneously moving as fast as we can to a sustainable energy economy i thought the words the prime minister were just spot on you know it's

4:57and i'm glad to hear that there's a large effort for oh so ocean wind because that's that that's a i think a massive untapped potential i would say go even more than what the prime minister said frankly it's like that's you know i mean if you did 100 by 100 array of 10 megawatt systems you'd have 100 gigawatt capability so and then you do need to combine that with stationary storage battery packs to buffer the energy because sometimes the wind blows and sometimes it doesn't blow it just blows hard and so so you need you need to buffer it with with battery packs stationary battery packs and tesla and other companies are also making that so that the sort of the

5:46three pillars of a sustainable energy future are sustainable energy generation which is hydro geothermal wind solar i'm also pro-nuclear i mean i think we should really keep going with the nuclear plants i know this may be an unpopular view in some quarters but i think if you have a well-designed nuclear power plant you should not shut it down especially right now so but i try to say what i what i think is you know scientifically cogent even if it is not popular so

6:24and anyway so the pillars are sustainable energy generation but then must also store the energy because many of the the two main sources of of sustainable energy wind and solar are intermittent the wind doesn't always blow the sun doesn't always shine so you must buffer the energy in stationary battery packs and then the third element obviously is electric vehicles so electric cars trucks aircraft boats with the ironic exception of rockets

6:56but but we do have a plan for sustainably producing the rocket repellent which is actually almost 80 liquid oxygen so liquid oxygen you can get from obviously from the atmosphere and then we're going with methane fuel which is 20 percent of the propellant but that you can make also sustainably long term from co2 and water h2o which produces ch4

7:26and o2 so that's the sort of sustainable long-term path for rocket propellant generation and that's how it would have to be done on mars for example so not electrifying quite yet we are we do actually have sustainable power generation for some of our propellant generation already but it's it's a small percentage now but will be a big percentage in the future okay yeah so what do you you know you've got i was about to say the energy in industry here but that's probably an exaggeration you've got a you know pretty pretty significant

8:01set of the energy industry here if you were to look ahead five ten fifteen years what is the disruption going to look like in the energy industry well i think we'll see tremendous change over the next five 10 or 15 years i'd say like if you sailed by by by 2030 i would say probably half of all new cars made will be electric 2030 half of all new cars that's my guess yeah by 2035 it might be 80 or something like that i think it could be even higher than those numbers but the the the car industry is moving rapidly towards electric and you know one country after another and one state after another is making zero emission mandates california recently passed

9:01zero emission mandate for new cars sold in california i think 2035 can only be zero emission so the uk is as well yeah yeah exactly so it's it's clearly the people of the earth people of earth have decided this is the way to go and so i think this is so we'll see quite a tremendous change in in that regard and if you look at the streets of norway you actually see an advanced version of that because norway has it some of the highest i believe gone to majority electric vehicles of new cars sold which is which is great again thank you so yeah so it's pretty cool so if i if i pick up on that idea so the future the biggest change you see for the energy

9:52industry is electrification electric car vehicles light transport maybe heavy transport what does that mean about supply chains so if you kind of roll that backwards what is the supply chain going to be what are you worried about if we're going to meet that rise yeah so the interesting thing is that you say like what what is the what are the limiting factors governing the rate at which the world can transition to sustainable energy and i think it's the rate at which one can grow battery production okay so then if you say well what are the constituents in the battery in lithium-ion batteries it's you've obviously got lithium you've got a cathode which is the the main cathode

10:37materials are going to be a metal and that's nickel manganese and iron and on the anode side is primarily carbon graphite and so in essential sequester sequestering a little bit of carbon in the battery and and with some silicon added for energy density on the anode side and then there's the electrolytes and whatnot so it's it's it's it's and and the main limitation is actually not that these metals are exceptionally rare but that there's a tremendous amount of processing equipment to take the ore and turn it into battery grade materials because the battery grade android and cathode have to be extremely pure in order for the battery to last for a long time

11:27and so it's it's sort of processing of those elements and i'm sort of writing this sort of master plan part three which is what are the steps needed to scale a sustainable energy and again what are the limiting factors and how can we potentially accelerate these so hopefully finish that in a month or two so do you want to give us a preview what you know what are the what are the you know what are the gating functions if you will that we need to get over what are the what are the big steps well the materials that i mentioned are are really essential it's generation it's processing yes there's actually there's not a raw material constraint so there's actually

12:11a tremendous amount of lithium it lithium is almost everywhere it's it's one of the most common elements on earth so is iron and so it's carbon and then on the iron you should usually combine phosphorus so it's iron phosphate so that'll probably be the the biggest chemistry that's used so it's not so much the raw materials as it is converting raw materials into the highly purified form that can be used in batteries and so that's a tremendous amount of of processing needs to happen for that at a really at the sort of scale that is currently you know comparable to the world oil and gas industry so it's a the scale is just tremendous so so this is all happening

12:56and it's happening fast it's just a question of how can we what can we do to potentially accelerate that and make it go even faster so it's all happening it's just a question of when and are you going to give us the answer to that what can we do to accelerate it to make it happen even faster if we're going to be new electric vehicles sold in what eight years you said i think i think that's actually where we're trending okay even if we we if even if we just keep doing the things we're currently doing okay yeah so it's not so pretty you don't say you don't see a limiting function at the moment no i don't i don't see a limiting function it's really just

13:34how many years will it take us and all that actions we can what actions can we take to have it be faster and it's going to be increasing the rate at which we can convert the or into battery grade materials that will set the rate at which we can weld electric vehicles and stationary battery packs to capture solar and wind okay so this is all you know basically what i'm saying is is this is a an optimistic and positive message and i'm not suggesting at all complacency but just saying that things are moving in a good direction and but obviously if we can make them go even faster that's better and a lot of this happens in china right at the moment today

14:21so yes so you said last year that you thought trust in china would improve prove post covet so do you think that's happened do you see china as an investment opportunity today well tesla is actually investing in production in china so we have a large factory in shanghai and we are continuing to expand output and invest in that factory but we're also investing in europe with our factory just outside of berlin and in the u.s with our new factory just outside of austin so and we hope to announce a location for another gigafactory perhaps later this year so we're going as fast as we can and i've always said that the i would say like when you look at tesla

15:12the fundamental good that tesla does i think it's not measured by profit but rather by how many years will tesla have accelerated the transition to sustainable energy this is how i think it's a measure of success yes yes i think we have accelerated it to some degree already you know i think it wasn't for tesla the the car industry would have transitioned to evs much later so exponential curve or straight line it is somewhat it is an exponential curve yes okay you know you're making me use my chemistry in my maths which i haven't done in yeah i i just few decades most people don't know what a next dimensional curve means but it's a i think most people in this room meet in

15:55this room yes yes this room they know yeah yes yes yeah i thought so i've had a logarithmic curve [Laughter] now that's optimistic can you do it no i think i think the the things are improving exponentially with respect to sustainable energy so okay but if we can make it go faster all the better so how do we go from exponential to l logarithmic well i no i think we'll look you've thought about this i know you've thought about this logarithmic is is actually fast in the beginning but slow at the end so i think we we actually it what will actually happen is is is a transition from it'll follow it's following an s curve so you have an exponential

16:39increase then linear and then logarithmic and that's that's basically how any transition large industrial transition happens i think i'm going to get off math now because i could get into trouble what's your approach to risk how would you talk about that i'm back to philosophy i'm safer in philosophy well i think because i don't sort of like you know just arbitrarily seek risk i think there's you know some things are risky but if this you know if the stakes are important enough then you take the risk because

17:25and today the stakes are important enough yes i mean the stakes are very extremely important very fundamental to the future yes because you take i'm guessing i'm just you know i don't know everybody in this room but my guess is is that you take significantly more risk than possibly anybody in this room but certainly more than 95 of the people in this room what what allows you to take those risks are you faster are you smarter do you think differently what do you do differently that allows you to do something that most people here smart as they are can't do well i think there's probably a lot of people in this room that do take a lot of risks but

18:11we've got to volunteer but but before you really like no no i want to hear what elon has to say about how he takes risks anyway i literally just tried to use the scientific method frankly and you know consider the you know what what is the importance of the outcome and what what what is one risking in order to achieve that outcome and but like i said if the outcome is important enough even if the probability of success is low one must i think still still do it in my view you know some things are very important and if in order to have a good future and if we don't do them well they're in big trouble and so i and then then how much of a risk really is

18:58it because if we don't take those actions we won't have a good future and i think the riskiest thing would be no action so it's almost as though it's really not a risk it's not a choice at all not really yeah okay i think it's wonderful that you can change the world because you really can change the world and you have you have the ability to do what in many cases not even governments can do i mean i i as i was doing a little bit of research for this panel one of the data points that i saw is you were able to turn on if you will the internet in ukraine in just four hours

19:40what what kind of responsibility do you feel as a corporate leader you have when you have that kind of power how do you think well i think it was a bit bit longer than four days but it was it was about oh sorry for four hours about four days i think but but we did we did well we we did have some guess that maybe there would be something happening in ukraine and and so we did pre-position some starling terminals there just in case

20:15so [Music] that was helpful for the initial part of the invasion and then we accelerated delivery of a lot of terminals within a few days of the invasion taking place and the ukrainian government tells me it's been very helpful so yeah forethought is the answer perhaps i mean forethought and and just moving quickly decisively yeah so i do hope a piece on peace can be achieved in ukraine and russia you know that's you know i do seem think some short some thought should be given to you know what's the end game there and i think the end game will require some compromise on the part of both parties

21:16you've said that what you're solving at tesla is an a.i problem not a transportation problem and you talk about the next big disruption being ai what can a.i do to help combat climate change particularly in this period the short term period as we're transitioning well tesla's goal from from when we started it has always been to accelerate sustainability so that is still our primary goal by far we have a secondary goal which is to solve at least real-world intelligence as it applies to self-driving cars and and then potentially you know with with humanoid robots but you know it's and so tesla is in part an ai company and increasingly an ai company but is

22:12still primarily a sustainable energy company i think ai what will i do i i don't think we need ai to solve sustainability that is that is happening it might help us accelerate it but i think we should also be cautious about ai and just make sure that as we develop ai that it is you know doesn't get out of control and and that that the ai helps make the future better for humanity and that's something i know you're working quite a lot on i think we should be more worried about ai safety than we currently are yeah especially you know the future wars are really going to be and we're seeing a taste of that within in ukraine very much drone wars so

23:06if your drones are better than their drones then you won't basically it's what will happen thus has has it always been no that's going to be it hasn't been that but will it final question you just got a minute what keeps you up at night and what are you doing about it or do you sleep soundly every night well there's the the the two main technical i mean i'm fundamentally a technologist it's like a kind of important engineer to so you know sometimes people call me like a businessman i guess i have to do business you have to have a group of people because i can't just do this in a garage by myself but i'm fundamentally an engineer or technologist and so

23:52the two the two technologies i'm focused on trying to ideally get done before the end of the year are getting our starship to orbit which i think is important for expanding consciousness beyond earth and life beyond earth and and then having the tesla cars be able to do self-driving so have self-driving and wide release at least in the us and hopefully potentially in europe depending on regulatory approval this is two great great goals to have and i wish you luck thank you so much for joining us thank you from the audience thank you please ladies and gentlemen elon musk thank you so much real pleasure

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份