2002 年之后,马斯克就不再参与 PayPal 的任何事务。可这场采访的第一个问题,还是关于 PayPal:偷账号、隐藏收费、转账不可靠,这些指责你怎么回应?
他没辩解。系统里还留着当年他亲手写下的结构错误,那些错误没有任何存在的理由,只是当时没时间改。手续费太高,该加的功能一大堆,而他已经没有权限去改。一个卖掉公司十年的人,被追着问公司的毛病,回答的第一句是"该修的地方确实很多"。
接着他给出了一个和直觉相反的判断:PayPal 如果把手续费降下来,收入反而会更高。
理由不复杂。手续费高,用户就会把钱从 PayPal 账户里挪走,只剩小额转账时用一下。手续费低,账户就变成主账户,钱留在里面,交易频次上来,规模把费率补回去。他自己把这件事说成一条通路:先消掉人们"要把钱取出来"的所有理由,接下来那个问题自然就变成"那为什么不干脆什么都用它"。
顺着他这条思路往下推,PayPal 有机会变成一家覆盖一个人全部金融需求的金融服务公司,甚至能相当快地成为全球最大的消费银行。这句话听着夸张,但它是这场访谈里马斯克唯一一次主动给出一家公司的天花板,而且是他自己做过的那家。
他读的书:一个警示,一个榜样
主持人介绍他时用了"先驱"这个词,说他把 PayPal、特斯拉、SpaceX 一样样推到了边界之外,所以爱读传记也不奇怪。这一周的"周末阅读",他讲的是一本 Howard Hughes(霍华德·休斯)的传记。
他先有点犹豫要不要说。"我读的这本书,我一直在想要不要讲。"
那是一本关于霍华德·休斯的书,也许可以算一个警示故事。他这个人挺有意思,但我得确保自己别把指甲留太长,也别开始把尿装在罐子里。(马斯克)
这句玩笑有出处。休斯晚年被强迫症吞掉,指甲长到卷曲,把尿液存在一排罐子里。马斯克拿它当自我提醒,一个飞机制造者、好莱坞大亨、当时世界上最有钱的人,最后是被自己的脑子关进一间黑屋子的。
他说自己早就想读这本传记,一直没读,只大致知道休斯做过哪些事,看过电影《飞行家》(The Aviator)。他读传记的口味挺稳定:Isaacson 写的《乔布斯传》,他觉得有意思;同一作者写的《富兰克林传》,他很喜欢,而且富兰克林是他心目中的英雄之一。
主持人追问:传记里的东西能转化成你自己的商业策略和行事方式吗?
他的回答只挑了富兰克林一个人。富兰克林身上他学到的是做当下必须做的那件事。这个人一生横跨印刷、科学、政治、外交,每个阶段干的事都不一样,问的问题始终是同一个:现在最重要、必须完成的是什么?然后埋头去做。马斯克后来二十年的路径,从支付到电动车到火箭再到太阳能,明面上像四处乱跳,底下这条线倒是很清楚。
他在 iPhone 上读休斯传记
主持人问得很具体:你在线看,用平板,Kindle,还是翻纸?
他说传统书当然有某种浪漫,但他常年出差,大部分阅读最后落在 iPhone 上。"听起来像是天啊,这么小一个东西。"可它永远在身上。主持人不信,追问了一句:你不是在用 iPhone 读那本休斯传记吧?
他说是。屏幕小,能读。
这段几十秒的对话,放在整场访谈里几乎是最不起眼的部分,但它把马斯克的一种习惯说清楚了:形式让位于可得性。一个天天在路上的人,读书这件事只能发生在口袋里。顺手,胜过一切仪式感。
特斯拉的三步走,从第一天就没改过
聊到特斯拉,他把策略摊得很平:起始是一辆贵而量小的车,然后是中等价格、中等销量的车,最后是低价、大销量的车。
第一步是 Roadster 跑车。他的说法很实在:那是当时唯一可能造出来的车。第二步是 Model S,Model X 也算在这一档。第三步才是第三代车,低价、走量。
为什么要这么走?因为任何技术要走进大众市场都需要时间,需要跨过几次大的设计迭代。他举了手机的例子:最早那批手机就是一块砖,电影《华尔街》里那个人在海滩上举着砖头一样的大哥大走来走去,贵,功能少得可怜。现在几乎任何人都买得起一部性能抵得上一台超级计算机的手机。中间隔着几十年的迭代。
特斯拉想在三次大的迭代里跑完这条路,尽可能快。
还有两笔账没法省。一是规模经济,得有大得多的工厂才撑得起低价格,而建大工厂要融一大笔钱;二是融资的次序,人们只在你已经展示过某种前期成功之后才愿意给钱,否则他们根本不信你。所以先造贵的车不只是产品节奏,也是融资节奏。没有那台跑车,就没有后面的工厂。
怎么衡量特斯拉算不算成功
他把这件事讲得很干脆:重要的是加速可持续交通的到来,让电动车比原本更早发生。
衡量的标准也就跟着这句话出来了:特斯拉的根本价值,取决于人类把电动车的到来提前了多少年。
他希望最后人们会给出一个数字,比如提前了十年,那算巨大的成功;至少提前五年,也算。
这个衡量方法有意思的地方在于,它把公司的成败和行业的成败绑在了一起。一家公司就算自己卖得再多,如果只是抢了别人本来就打算造的车,按这个标准也等于零。
联邦贷款 4.65 亿美元,和自由意志主义的冲突
主持人念了一位密歇根州安娜堡读者的提问:特斯拉最近从联邦政府拿到 4.65 亿美元贷款,SpaceX 也在争取联邦资金,这不违背你的自由意志主义观点吗?
他回答不违背,理由是时代不同。现在资本极度稀缺,连私募市场都很弱,这是大萧条以来最糟的金融时期。
特殊时期要按特殊办法处理。造一家汽车公司需要的资本量极其庞大,这种量级的钱私人市场当时凑不出来,接受能源部的贷款是合理的。
这套说法在逻辑上是有缝的:如果他坚持的是"政府不该干预市场",那么"市场太差"恰恰是干预最不该拿来当理由的时刻之一。他没有绕这个缝,他给的是现实主义的答案:原则要认,但现实里的时间窗口是硬的,造不出车,原则也没地方放。
二十年,一半以上的新车是纯电
纽约的读者问:你真的认为电动车能取代内燃机?
他给的数字很具体。二十年内,新造汽车里的大多数将是纯电,可能更早。存量车队要变成以电动为主,还要再花十到十五年,因为换掉一辆已经在路上的车需要的时间比换掉生产线上的一台模具久得多。
然后是飞机。主持人问:飞机呢,有时间表吗?
他承认这个话题目前还挺假设性。但他接着说自己相当有信心,理由是把两套知识拼起来:SpaceX 让他懂航空航天,特斯拉让他懂电机和电池,这两套东西合在一起,正好是造一架超音速电动飞机需要的东西。"配料我大概是齐的。"
差的是什么?他说是自己的带宽。一个人的注意力是有限的,那个项目排不进去。他还补了一句,没看见有谁在追着他做这件事。
这段听着像玩笑,但它是马斯克解释自己"不做什么"时最常用的一套逻辑:能力不是瓶颈,带宽才是。他手上的清单是按重要性排的,排在后面的东西不是不想要,是没空要。
猎鹰 9 号成功那天,赌的不只是 SpaceX
澳大利亚珀斯的读者问:猎鹰 9 号成功发射并进入轨道时,你什么感觉?
他说是狂喜,特别特别兴奋。然后解释为什么那天不只是 SpaceX 一家公司的事。
当时正处在向商业航天转型的历史拐点上,猎鹰 9 号的成败在那个时间点上真的可能改变整场辩论的走向。
NASA 正在向商业化走,总统在推,可国会阻力很大。他点出一个他觉得荒诞的地方:很多反对声音来自众议院的共和党一侧,而这些人平时最反对政府扩张。
他们认为公共选项很糟糕,除非它适用于太空。这说不通。(马斯克)
这句话是这场访谈里他少有的带锋芒的时刻。他平时说话绕,习惯加"可能"、"我认为"这类缓冲词,这一段没有。
可复用做不成,市场份额再高也不算成功
爱沙尼亚塔尔图的读者问:SpaceX 的长期目标是让人类成为太空文明,你希望在有生之年看到吗?
他说希望。如果寿命允许,四十年内有可能。
但有一个前置条件,他讲得很重:必须做出真正可复用的火箭系统,这是整件事的关键技术突破。
他把"成功"的门槛设得很高。发射一次性火箭也挺好,公司可以非常成功,甚至拿下极高的市场份额,在发射市场上占据主导地位。可如果可复用没做成,他不认为那叫成功。
这段值得多看两眼。大部分公司用收入和份额定义自己,他用"有没有把那件难的技术做成"定义自己。这也解释了 SpaceX 后来那些炸掉的火箭为什么不被他当成失败:一次性火箭炸掉是损失,可复用火箭炸掉是数据。
创业的本质,是组织一群人去做出别人觉得有用的东西
主持人把一位发展中国家年轻人的问题递过来:很想创业,但心里发虚,能给点什么建议?
他先回到最基础的定义。创业本质上就是组织一群人,去做一件有用的东西,而"有用"由消费者来判定,不由创业者自己判定。
这话听起来像废话。可他紧接着指出,很多人组织起一家公司,做出来的东西别人并不觉得有用。他们把组织这件事做成了,把有用这件事忘了。
第二层是反馈。任何正面、负面的反馈都要听,听不等于信。要看,要掂量,要想"它可能对,也可能不对"。把收到的信息放在一起反复琢磨。但如果手上真有货,别怕扣扳机。
必须转向可再生能源,问题只是多快
他的论证方式很马斯克:反对可再生能源,等于说人类终将耗尽能源然后死掉,或者文明崩溃。所以这件事没有"要不要"的选项,只有"多努力、多快"的选项。
他的答案是尽可能快。既然知道终点在那儿,早到比晚到好,在造成环境破坏之前到,而不是破坏之后再去修。
他还替反方说了一句:就算有人扮演魔鬼代言人,说环境破坏没那么严重,那又为什么要赌?他在这里用的是概率语言,不是道德语言。
一百英里见方的太阳能阵列,够全美国用电
很多人会说太阳能撑不起人类需要的能量。他先纠正一个常识:太阳能已经是地球绝大部分能源的来源。
没有太阳,地球是一颗冻住的冰球,温度在绝对零度以上三四度。煤炭、石油、风、水,追到根上都是太阳。所以太阳能发电这件事,实际要取的只是人类用电需要的那一点点,和照到地球的总量比,小到几乎可以忽略。
他给了一个具体到能画出来的例子:一块一百英里见方(约 160 公里见方)的太阳能阵列,就能发出全美国需要的电。换算一下,就是亚利桑那州的一个角落。
这个数字之所以让人听着不敢信,是因为它把两件事混在了一起:发电需要的面积小,和把电送到需要的地方、在没太阳的时候也能用,是两件完全不同的事。马斯克讲的是前者,储能和电网解决的是后者。这一段他讲得简洁,容易被误读。
电池不缺金属,缺的是时间
接着他把电池的材料账算了一遍,这一段信息密度最高。
不存在材料短缺。地壳里的金属,以人类的需求量衡量,几乎是无限的,目前只是碰到了表面一层。这和煤、石油有本质区别:金属可以回收。一旦你有足够的金属支撑起一个给定规模的产业,它就会在回收循环里一直转下去,只有很小一部分会离开这个循环。
拆开一个锂离子电池包看:正极用镍、钴、铝,是最贵的部分;负极是碳;外面一层薄钢壳。真正算得上稀缺的只有钴,而且只是轻微稀缺。这也是特斯拉从纯钴正极转向镍钴铝正极的原因,钴的用量降到原来的四分之一左右。镍、铝、钢都不缺,钴贵,但够全世界用。
电池包到了寿命终点,它不是垃圾,是一座高品位矿。回收一个电池包,里面镍、钴、铝的浓度远高于普通矿石,效率高得多。一块退役的锂电池包还保留着大约 10% 到 20% 的价值,所以回收是笔算得过来的账。
这套账他讲了很多年,后来成了特斯拉做电池回收、做材料闭环的底层理由。
人类最近拿到的两个大突破
主持人问他,这几十年里人类最大的进展是什么。
他排了两个。第一个是互联网。人类由此获得了一套神经系统,全人类的知识从任何地点都能瞬间取到。他打了个比方:过去信息从一个人传到另一个人慢得可怕,现在任何一个个体都能拿到关于整体的全部信息,就像身体里的一个细胞能读取整个身体的数据。人类事实上已经组成了一个超级有机体。
第二个是可持续能源,也就是能源生产和消费方式的转型。后面还跟着几项:把生命延伸到另一颗行星、基因编辑、AI。
关于文明的未来,他比霍金和 Martin Rees(英国皇家天文学家)更乐观。这两人都认为本世纪文明终结的概率不低,马斯克说他个人没那么悲观。
他想要的未来长这样:人类成为太空文明、成为多行星物种,走出去探索恒星。排在第二位的动机是保存意识、保存人类文明的未来。他说对某些人而言,这一条可能排在第一位。
本世纪后半段,一场超过黑死病的人口塌陷
话题转到人口,他的语气变了。
本世纪中期,尤其是后半段,人类会遇上一场前所未见的人口塌陷,规模超过黑死病。他形容那感觉像有人走了一遍,杀掉了半数人口,或者说杀掉了未来人口的一半。
按这个速度,最后剩下的只有机器人。(马斯克)
他把算术摆出来:生育率只有替代率的一半,连续三代,人口就掉到原来的 12%。而剩下这 12%,全都在照顾自己的祖父母。再往下,就没有人了。
他还提到另一项担忧,宗教极端主义,如果它继续增长。第三个他没说出口,紧接着来了一句:希望 AI 对我们友善。
这一段在整场访谈里很短,但它把马斯克后来的很多动作提前说完了。他买下推特、反复谈出生率、把 AI 安全挂在嘴边,源头都在这几句话里。
创业四条:吃玻璃、好很多、求批评、假设自己错
最后一个问题还是创业。他先说了一句限定条件:创业不适合所有人。然后给了四条。
第一条,要有很高的疼痛阈值。他有个朋友的说法,他引用过很多次。
创办一家公司,就像一边吃玻璃,一边盯着深渊。(马斯克)
他把这条曲线描述得很清楚:刚创业时乐观,事情看着都好,幸福感最高;接着各种问题冒出来,幸福感一路下滑;然后是一段漫长的、说不完的痛;如果最后成了,还要很久才回到幸福。大多数情况下你不会成功,特斯拉也差点没成,离失败非常近。
第二条,产品或服务必须真的好。这里他补了一个区分:如果进入的是一个全新的、没人碰过的市场,标准可以放低;如果进入的是已有市场、面对根深蒂固的对手,你的东西必须比对方好很多。只好一点点不行。站在消费者的位置想一下就很清楚:我凭什么买你的?消费者永远买信得过的牌子,除非差异大到无法忽略。他说很多创业者拿出来的东西只是稍微好一点,那不够。
第三条,不断主动去找批评。
一份考虑周全的批评,价值和黄金一样贵重。(马斯克)
要跟所有人要,尤其是朋友。因为朋友通常知道你哪里错了,但他们不想伤你,所以不说。他们会说"我想鼓励我朋友,就别告诉他这东西有什么毛病了"。朋友不一定对,可常常是对的,至少要认真听。
第四条,假设自己是错的。创业者要带着这个前提去做事,目标是让自己变得不那么错。
整个访谈到这里结束。回头看,他讲的每一件事背后都是同一套动作:先把目标定在物理和数学允许的地方,再把路径拆成几段,然后接受路上会炸、会疼、会被骂,最后靠一轮一轮的反馈把错误削掉。
对读者来说,能直接拿去用的东西不多,但这几件确实可以明天就做:
- 把你手上的产品拿去问十个真实用户,只问一个问题:你为什么不买。别问"你觉得怎么样",问"你为什么不买"。
- 找三个会说实话的朋友,明确告诉他们:我现在需要批评,不需要鼓励。听完不许辩解,只许记。
- 做一次"降低门槛"的算术:如果你的价格或手续费降一半,用户会不会把这件事变成主场景?如果会,算一遍规模回来之后的收入,很多生意死在高单价低频率上。
- 把你的目标和行业绑定,而不是和公司绑定。问自己:如果我不做,这件事会晚几年发生?答案小于两年,说明你在抢生意,不在创造增量。
- 给"难但必须做"的那件事留出带宽。列一份你真正重要的清单,只留三件,其余全部标为"没空要",然后承认这就是选择。
- 重新算一遍你要进入的市场:如果里面已经有强势对手,你的产品好在 10% 还是 10 倍?10% 就别去了。
0:00What are your thoughts on PayPal being criticized for stealing account numbers, hidden fees, and not being a reliable money transfer system? Well, there's definitely lots of things that should be fixed about PayPal. but unfortunately, since I am, you know, have not been part of the company since 2002, it's difficult for me to do do things about about PayPal. I think there's like a lot of functionality that that should be added and a lot of things corrected and there's still errors in the PayPal system like m mistakes and structure that that I put there and you know I really you know there's no actual good reason for them being there. I I would we just didn't
0:48have enough time to kind of fix them. and I certainly think the fees are too high and there should be much more functionality added to the system. and and overall PayPal has the opportunity to become the financial you know the the financial services company that that addresses everything that a person needs. and
1:15it PayPal could really quite quickly become the largest consumer bank in the world. I think you just need to take away the reasons that people remove money from the PayPal account and then it's like well why not just use it for everything? So and and somewhat it's somewhat counterintuitive but I think if you reduce the fees on the PayPal system then the revenue will be greater because more people will use it. And the Tesla chief executive, Elon Musk, is without doubt a pioneer in his field.
1:46Think about it. He brought us PayPal. He also has brought us the Tesla car and SpaceX. He's constantly pushing the frontiers. So, it's not surprising perhaps that he loves to read about biographies. And in particular in this weekend's reading for leading, he's telling us about the history of the aviator and the businessman Howard Hughes. I'll I'll tell you honestly the book the book I'm reading which I was sort of thinking should I say this or not but it's it's a book on Howard Hughes which you know maybe a cautionary tale. I mean he's sort of an interesting fellow. definitely want to make sure I don't grow my fingernails too long and start peeing in Jaws. You
2:33beat me to the line. I was just about to say why, how you what is it about him that you found interesting? I I've just been meaning to read a book about him for ages and I I haven't and so I'm broadly aware of of of his sort of the things he's done and u I saw the movie The Aviator and you know and a few few other things. I like biographies in general.
2:54biographies I think are really you know really interesting read. what did you learn from them? Well, I think you learn a lot depending upon, you know, whose life you're reading about. there are lots of lessons in there. I read Isaacson's biography of Jobs, which I thought was quite interesting.
3:08And I actually really liked, his biography of Benjamin Franklin, who who I would say is certainly one of my heroes. He seemed like a really great guy. And you you actually managed to incorporate any of this into your own strategy, your own way of doing business, your own ethos and philosophy?
3:25Well, I think in the case of Franklin, he did what needed to be done at the time it needed to be done. So, you know, he was in different fields and and you sort of thought about, okay, what's the important thing that needs to be accomplished right now? And then worked on that. Are you online, on tablet, a Kindle, or
3:45a crinkle of the paper? There is something romantic about traditional books, of course. but I find since I'm traveling so much and and that that that I often find I'm reading the books on my iPhone. which may sound like wow, this is really tiny, but it's always with you. Pass me my iPhone. Pass me I mean book.
4:07You're not reading the Howard Hughes book on your iPhone? Yes, I am. Yeah. You're reading a Howard Hughes book on something the size of this? Yes. It's it's it's small but it works. The Tesla strategy has been the same from the beginning, which is to start out initially with a car that was expensive but low volume. It's it's the only car we could have really made.
4:29and that was the the Roadster Sports car. And then step two was a car that was sort of mid-pric, midvol, and that's the Model S. And Model X also fits into that category. and then our third generation car would be low price, high volume. and the reason for that strategy is that in order to make any technology mass market, it takes time. You've got to go through major design iterations. And you think of like the first cell phones that existed like the one in in the first Wall Street movie where the guy's walking down the beach with a giant brick on his, you know, of of a cell phone. And those things were really expensive and had, you know, didn't have much
5:03functionality. But but now we now anyone can afford a cell phone that's basically a supercomput. so, you've got to go through major design iterations to achieve that. And that's what we're trying to get there as quickly as possible with three major iterations. you also need economies of scale. So, you've got to, have much bigger factories in order to afford those bigger factories. you've got to raise a ton of money and you've got and and people will only give you money if they've if you've shown some prior success. Otherwise, they like they don't believe you. Well, I just think that that it's important that we accelerate the advent of sustainable transport.
5:39that we, you know, that electric cars happen sooner than they would otherwise occur. And and and and I think the fundamental good of Tesla will will be measured by to what degree did we accelerate the advent of electric vehicles. and I'm hopeful that in the end people might say, well, probably by 10 years. You know, that would be a really great success, but maybe at least by five. Hi, I'm Brian Alexander with Time and I'm here with Elon Musk who has been dubbed the real life Tony Stark and who is also the founder of PayPal, the founder of Tesla Motors and the current head of this company SpaceX. Right.
6:16Thank you so much for joining us. Thanks for having me. Kevin Lyn in Ann Harour, Michigan asks, "Tesla Motors was recently awarded $465 million in a loan from the federal government, and I believe SpaceX seeks money from the federal government as well. Doesn't this contradict your libertarian views?" And no, I don't think it it it does contradict those views. because we're just living in very unusual times.
6:40we're living in times where capital availability is extremely difficult. and even the the the private markets are somewhat weak right now. this is the worst periods financial period since the great depression. so I think you know special times call for special circumstances and I think in the in this time particularly when you're dealing with something that requires an enormous amount of capital to to get done which is to to build a car company I think it does make sense to accept a loan from the department of energy.
7:15Tom Hail in New York City asks do you really think the electric car can replace the combustion engine? I think probably within 20 years, a majority of new cars manufactured will be pure electric. it'll take another 10 or 15 years beyond that for the the fleet of existing cars to be primarily electric cuz it takes a while to sort of switch out things. But I I feel confident in saying that within 20 years, probably sooner, a majority of new cars manufactured will be pure electric. And what about planes? I mean, do you have any kind of timetable for that? you've talked about yeah you know it seems pretty hypothetical at this point and when when does a concrete work begin
7:58with that I I I do feel pretty confident that with what I know what what I've learned from doing SpaceX which is an aerospace company and what I learned from doing Tesla obviously has a lot of experience with electric motors and batteries that kind of thing if I combine the the knowledge sets of those two then it's really ideal for creating a supersonic electric plane, right?
8:22You're the guy. It kind of makes sense. so, I don't see anybody behind you, right? I don't know who, you know, who's who's chased me on that one, but, so I I do think I've got the necessary ingredients, to to design the plane and make it work. I just need enough bandwidth, a personal bandwidth to be able to to get it done.
8:40Andrew Colgree from Perth, Western Australia, asks, "How did you feel when the Falcon 9 successfully launched and achieved orbit?" I was definitely elation in that case. I was super super excited and glad and it it was you know there there was a lot riding on that rocket beyond just SpaceX because we're really at this historic inflection point for a transition to commercial space. and the success or or failure of Falcon 9 was at at that point in history really could have shifted that whole debate.
9:14NASA is right now moving towards commercial. the president is is moving things towards commercial, but there's a lot of opposition in Congress. Ironically, a lot of that opposition is coming from Republican the Republican side of the House. I think it's somewhat not well reasoned. It's it's sort of strange that you'd have some Republican senators and congressmen opposed to commercialization.
9:38you know, they they think the public option is, you know, public option is terrible unless it applies to space. doesn't make any sense. Eric Kulu from Tartu, Estonia asks, "Wow, from Australia to Estonia." Yes, we give you the world here that time. SpaceX was founded with the long-term goal of enabling humanity to become a space fairing civilization. Are you hoping to see that in your lifetime? yes, I really am. And now, of course, it depends on how long I live. I within 40 years, we could be a space fairing civilization. the critical breakthrough technological breakthrough that's necessary for that is to create a a truly reusable rocket system. I
10:22mean it's you know launching expandable rockets is nice and yes we can be a very successful rocket company and and and we could we could even be the you know the overwhelmingly successful rocket company. I think there's a good chance we could be the the the main you know have very high market share and and really be be the you know quite quite dominant in in the aerospace launch but nonetheless if we do not make reusability work I I would not consider it to be a success. What advice would you give to young persons of developing countries who are seriously considering to be an entrepreneur but still feeling a bit wobbly? You really when you're
11:00trying to create a company, what you're really trying to do is organize a group of people to do something useful and something useful is as measured by by other people who are the consumers of your products and services. but this seem may seem like an obvious thing, but but often people will organize groups into a company that doesn't produce something useful or that other people consider useful. So you definitely want to listen to any positive and negative feedback that you get, which is not to say that you believe it, but you you need to look at it, any positive, negative feedback, and say maybe it's correct, maybe it's not. Weigh it up. and just just sort
11:38of carefully reflect on on all the information you receive. But don't be afraid to pull the trigger even in this if you got if you got the goods. Yeah, exactly. By definition, we must move to renewable energy. I think people sometimes, you know, I mean, how can one argue against that? Because to argue for it is to say that we will eventually run out of energy and die. I mean and or or civilization will collapse. So obviously we must find ways to produce energy in a renewable manner. the question is just how hard we should try, what pace we should go at it. And I I think logically we should go as fast as we can. because since we know we have
12:15to get there eventually, it's better to to get to a renewable future, a sustainable future sooner rather than later, you know, get there before we do the environmental damage, not after. and even if one could say that that well maybe there isn't that much environmental damage to play the devil's advocate may maybe the environmental damage maybe it won't be that bad. Why take the chance? Now a lot of people would say well well solar cannot really provide the energy that we need. A lot of people don't perhaps appreciate that solar energy is already the source of the vast majority of Earth's energy.
12:54without the solar power we would be a frozen ice ball at about 3 or 4° above absolute zero. So really all we're talking about for solar electricity is is taking the tiny tiny bit of energy that humanity needs for electricity which which is I emphasize is super tiny compared to the amount of solar energy that hits the earth. you could generate all the electricity that the United States needs with about a 100 mile by
13:27100 mile grid of of solar power. So you just take like a corner of Arizona and that would be all the energy that the United States needs. I think the important thing to bear in mind with with batteries is there really is no material shortage. The Earth crust has essentially an infinite amount of metal as far as humanity is concerned. we have barely scratched the surface of the the res of the metal resource availability of the earth's crust. and and this is a very fundamentally different thing from mining mining coal or oil or or you know because metal is recycled. so once you have enough metal to support a given size of industry then it just keeps it
14:10just keeps going in in a recycling process. I mean there may be a small amount that exits the recycling process but it's quite a small amount. and so for for lithiumion battery packs in in the case of Tesla the the the the cathode which is made of nickel, cobalt and aluminum is the most expensive part in the of the cell.
14:33the anode is made of of carbon and and then there's a a thin steel shell around the cell. So the the really the only part of that that is remotely scarce and and I and only slightly so is cobalt. and that's why we moved from a pure cobalt cathode to nickel cobalt aluminum cathode which uses only about a quarter as much cobalt.
14:57but there's there's as much nickel as you could possibly want. Certainly as much as aluminum as as you you'd need. no shortage of steel. and and the cobalt is it's expensive but there's certainly plenty available to support all the world's needs. So there really is not some fundamental metals shortage with respect to battery packs then and then as I mentioned at end of life you recycle them. so and you can you can think of a battery pack as basically really highgrade ore.
15:29that's it's it's much more efficient to recycle a battery pack which has essentially very high concentrations of nickel, cobalt, aluminum than it is to mine rock which has a very low concentration. So you know it's at at end of life a lithium battery pack has still about 10 to 20% of its value in in as as a recycling item. So you would definitely pay it pays to recycle probably for apart from the the internet where humanity essentially acquired a nervous system and all of humanity's knowledge was instantly accessible from anywhere the sustainable energy. So, the transition to sustainable production and consumption of energy, hopefully the extension of
16:13life to another planet writing genetics and AI. I'm I'm more optimistic than Steven Hawking or Martin Ree who's that royally. He thinks it's quite likely that civilization will end the century. but I'm I'm personally more optimistic about civilization and and I did say multilaner. You say what what's the future you want? What's the future that seems oh that that'll be a good one. then I think you want to have a future where we're space fairing civilization a multilanet species are out there exploring the stars. It's going to be I think that'd be great.
16:47but I mean a strong second and and I think for some people maybe it will be the first motivation is the preservation of the future of consciousness and and and human civilization as we know it. I mean we I think we have effectively created a kind of a super organism before the internet particularly before advanced telecommunications communication was incredibly slow. It would basically it would have to go from one person literally you know to another suddenly all the world's information all of humanity's knowledge is instantly available to to any any person that's just like one cell in your body having access to all the information about the
17:26rest of your body. We are going to face in the mid part of the century a and particularly the latter part of the century a demographic implosion the likes of which we haven't seen including the black plague. It's as though someone went through and and killed half the population or at least of the future population. There's something better happen to turn this around. At this rate the only thing that'll be left will be robots. you know, three generations of 50% birth rate of, you know, 50% replacement rate gets you to 12% of where you were. And those those poor 12% all they're going to be doing is taking care of their grandparents. I mean, eventually there just won't be people at
18:10that rate. the other I mean I think religious extremism is obviously a concern, you know, if that if that grows over time. Yeah, I won't mention the third one. But we like I hope the AI is nice to us. And first of all, I'd say starting a business is not for everyone, you know. So, generally starting a business, I'd say number one is have a high pain threshold. That's there's a friend of mine who's got a good saying, which is that starting a company is like eating glass and staring into the abyss. Okay, that's that's generally what happens because when you first start a company, there's lots of optimism and things are great and then so happiness
19:03at first is high. Then you encounter all sorts of issues and happiness will steadily decline and then you'll go through a whole world of hurt. That's and then eventually you if you succeed and in most cases you will not succeed. and and Tesla almost didn't succeed came very close to failure. then if if you succeed then after a long time you will finally get back to happiness. I think two is you got to make sure that that you that whatever you're doing is a great product or service. It it has to be really great.
19:40And I go back to what I was saying earlier where if you're a new company, I mean unless it's like some new industry or or new market that if it's an untapped market or then then you have more ability to there's there's the standard is lower for your product or service. But if you're entering anything where there's an existing marketplace against large entrenched competitors, then your product or service needs to be much better than theirs. It can't be a little bit better because then you put yourself in the shoes of the consumer and they say why would you buy it as a consumer?
20:18You're always going to buy the trusted brand unless there's a big difference. So a lot of times you know entrepreneur will come up with something which is only slightly better. M and it's it's not it can't just be slightly better. It's got to be a lot better. number three I'd say is constantly seek criticism. Yeah.
20:43a a well a wellought out critique of whatever you're doing is as valuable as gold. and you should seek that from everyone you can but particularly your friends. usually your friends know what's wrong, but they don't want to tell you because they don't want to hurt you. so lift you up. So you're
21:09Yeah. So they, you know, they say, "Oh, I want to encourage my friends, so I'm going to I'm not going to tell him what I think is wrong with this product." It doesn't mean your friends are right. but very often they are right. and you at least want to listen very carefully to what they say and to everyone. If you're looking for basically you you should take the approach that that you're wrong. you know that
21:36that you the entrepreneur are wrong. Your goal is to be less
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版