2015年6月28日,猎鹰9号(Falcon 9)从佛罗里达升空,执行国际空间站货运任务。飞行两分十九秒后,火箭解体。龙飞船(Dragon)连同带去的物资一起没了。
那天是马斯克44岁生日。
几周之后,他在波士顿的一场公开对话里提到这件事。没有铺垫,也没绕弯子。
那次发射本来是我们最有机会把助推器落到大西洋驳船上的一次。结果在生日当天,事情完全往反方向走了。算是个低谷。(马斯克)
台下笑了。他也笑了,然后接着讲调查。
能确定的只有一件事:二级液氧箱过压了
事故调查进行到那个阶段,能确认的只有一个现象:二级火箭的液氧箱发生了某种过压事件。
至于过压的原因,以及事情发生的先后顺序,没有任何一套理论能把所有数据解释通。
现在唯一清楚的是二级液氧箱出现了某种过压,但确切的原因和事件顺序,还没有一个理论能跟全部数据对上。(马斯克)
麻烦的地方在于数据本身互相矛盾。要么其中一部分是测量误差,某个传感器给出了错误读数;要么理论还没找对,还有一套能同时解释所有看似冲突的数据点的解释。
这两种可能必须先分清楚,否则后面的推论全建在沙子上。
调查组当时的做法是双线并行:一条线追最可能的原因,另一条线把所有"差一点也可能是它"的候选原因列出来,逐一处理。目的是把未来任务的成功率最大化,不是只找到那个最像答案的答案。
他反复强调的一点是,在结论足够确定之前不公开发言。
我不太想现在就说什么,因为我不想说一件后来被证明是误解的事情。(马斯克)
提问的 NASA 官员当场表示了不同看法。他说马斯克平时发的推特非常有价值,尤其在事故期间,很多人在引用他的话,那种"出了事就第一时间站出来说两句"的姿态本身就让人安心。
这两种态度并不冲突。一个是消息源的可信度,一个是消息源的存在感。
把遥测数据和地面视频对齐到毫秒,是件很痛苦的事
调查中最耗人力的活儿,是把所有数据拼成一条精确到毫秒的时间线:每一个传感器在每一毫秒读到了什么,和地面摄像机拍到的画面对应起来。
听起来只是整理表格。做起来要处理一堆琐碎的物理问题。
传感器什么时候采集的,数据什么时候被打包,包什么时候发到地面站,地面站收到时又延迟了多少。这些环节在秒的量级上可以忽略不计,一旦较真到毫秒,每一个都要算清楚。
当你把精度压到毫秒,这些东西全都造成相当大的差别。(马斯克)
有人问他,NASA 从三个不同的项目派人过来,FAA 也在场,靶场的人也在,这么多政府机构同时介入,是不是在拖后腿,需不需要他们改点什么。
他的回答有点出人意料。
NASA 那边配合得挺好。最大的麻烦是所有问询同时涌进来,很难每个人都立刻回复。整体进展其实相当顺利。
他还提了一句往事:之前发动机出问题那次,双方有过一次很有产出的讨论,那次的经验这次也用上了。
SpaceX 成立的原因,是想让 NASA 的预算变多
话题转到最初。他为什么进这一行。
答案比大多数人想的曲折:他一开始根本没打算造火箭。
2001年前后,他的想法是往火星表面送一个小温室。直径一米左右,里面装营养凝胶,着陆之后加水,让植物长出来。
目的很功利。公众对"第一"和"最"这类字眼有反应。第一株在火星上生长的生命,人类生命抵达过的最远距离,这类标题能把人点燃。人一兴奋就会追问下一句:植物都送上去了,什么时候送人上去。
他当时的算盘是,公众情绪能转化成国会对 NASA 预算的支持。预算涨了,火星探索就能往前走。整个计划的落点是政治,不是科学。
他甚至算过失败的代价:这个项目没什么商业成功的可能,最坏的结果是损失一点钱。可以接受。
然后他跑去俄罗斯买运载火箭,用的是退役洲际导弹改的型号。价格谈不下来。来回几趟之后他算了一笔账,买火箭的钱加上各种折腾,还不如自己造。
SpaceX 就这么成立了。
他给这家公司的成功概率估了个数:10%。
我当时觉得成功的可能性很低,大概率会失败。但我觉得还是值得试一下。(马斯克)
他还补了一句对照:火星温室那件事,失败了大不了损失一点钱,几乎没有商业回报。相比之下,一个 10% 成功率的机会已经算是进步了。
通灵板比水晶球靠谱
有人用开玩笑的方式问他:判断该不该进入一个新行业,你用的是水晶球还是通灵板?
当然是通灵板,比水晶球可靠多了。(马斯克)
玩笑之后是正题。
他不喜欢为了冒险而冒险。真正值得做的事情,往往只有很低的成功率,因为但凡有实质创新的东西,都自带相当高的失败风险。
想拿到大的正面结果,就得承担大的机会成本。如果结果足够让人兴奋,冒一次大险就值。(马斯克)
但决定下注之后,做法完全反过来。
上路之后他的全部精力放在降低风险上,用另一种说法,是提高成功率。走一条很陡的路,就得一路想办法把坡度削平。这两件事看起来矛盾,实际是一件事的两半:先用"值不值得"决定要不要下注,再用"能不能活得久"决定怎么走。
一级火箭吃掉七八成成本
2015年上半年,猎鹰9号的一级火箭开始装着陆腿。目标是把一级火箭垂直降回来,先在海上驳船,再回陆地。
经济账很清楚。一级火箭占一次发射成本的 70% 到 80%。回收一级,等于回收了大头。上面级怎么复用是另一道题,当时没有答案。
SpaceX 此前已经做过多次垂直起降试验,用的硬件基本就是飞行状态的配置。终端下降那一段,只要条件对,起飞降落本身没有问题。剩下的工作是把所有环节凑齐。
如果一切顺利,我们能在终端阶段把它稳稳落下来。问题只是把所有拼图拼完。(马斯克)
他也承认这只是通往低成本的一步。一级复用解决了大头,但离"太空运输便宜到普通人能想象"还差很远。他把 SpaceX 截至当时的成本改进称为"进化式,不是革命式",真正的数量级变化要等完全可复用实现之后。
推进式逃逸:逃逸发动机用完不扔
龙飞船2(Dragon 2)拿下商业载人(Commercial Crew)合同之后,设计上最大的变化是推进着陆。
传统方案是逃逸塔。联盟号(Soyuz)那种,逃逸发动机装在飞船顶部,正常飞行时必须抛掉。抛掉意味着它只用一次,而且每次飞行都多一次分离动作,多一个可靠性隐患,还多一批死重。
SpaceX 选的是推进式逃逸。逃逸发动机装在飞船侧面,用的就是本来就要装的那几台 SuperDraco。逃逸时不用抛,用完还能留下来干活,最后用来做推进着陆。
同样的推进器既能逃逸又能着陆,可以做精确的推进式着陆,落陆地或者落水面都行。这算是相当大的改进。(马斯克)
他把这套能力看得很远。带推进着陆的飞船不止能往返空间站,还能当科学载荷投送平台,往月球、火星或者太阳系别的地方送仪器。
理由很实在。科学仪器最贵的部分往往不是仪器本身,是"把它准确放到某个具体地点"这件事。推进着陆把这个环节的成本压下来,等于给整个行星科学松了绑。他说当时正在和 NASA 的几个部门讨论这些想法。
同一套逻辑还有个小分支,叫龙实验室(DragonLab):把东西送上去,在低轨待几周做实验,再原样带回来。他承认这不是 SpaceX 的重点方向,主优化目标还是空间站运输,但可能会做几次这样的任务。
商业载人项目里他唯一公开吐槽的细节,是给排泄物预留的质量和体积好像太多了。
有些地方我们确实有小分歧,比如给粪便留的质量和体积看起来太大了。真有那么多吗?占的体积相当大。(马斯克)
全场笑。他补了一句,这类分歧都很小,整体方案是合理的。
可复用的坎:先有鸡还是先有蛋
可复用听起来像纯赚,实际有个绕不过去的循环。
不管一年发多少次,固定成本都摆在那儿。每次发射的边际成本可以降得很低,前提是发射频率足够高。频率上不去,分摊到每次的固定成本就下不来,票价也就降不下来。
而票价降不下来,愿意包下整枚复用火箭做一堆飞行任务的客户就不会出现。客户不出现,频率上不去。
边际成本可以随发射频率大幅下降,但发射频率本身又带来新的挑战。(马斯克)
这种结构性问题没有巧办法。只能先把能力做出来,再用价格去撬动需求,一环一环往前推。
下一代火箭:把甲烷冷到接近凝固点
SpaceX 的下一代火箭用深冷甲烷氧(deep cryo methalox)。甲烷和液氧被冷却到接近凝固点,比常规的接近沸点温度低得多。温度越低,密度越高,同样体积的贮箱能装更多推进剂。
他的判断是,这一代能做到完全可复用,成本有希望降两个数量级。
就现有的物理学,我认为我们能实现完全可复用,那意味着大约两个数量级的成本下降空间。(马斯克)
有人问他在工程改进和突破性物理之间怎么分配投入,提到了反重力和新型推进原理。
他的回答很干脆:不在这上面花时间。
以今天的物理学,太空飞行的改进空间大得惊人,没必要押注一个连它长什么样都说不清楚的突破。
研发投入的瓶颈也不在钱。他招工程师的原则是"以能找到的最快速度招":合适的人不难找,但不容易找,找到就是资产,速度能多快就多快,没有名额上限。
3D 打印的真正价值,是缩短迭代周期
SuperDraco 发动机是打印出来的。钛合金,一次成型。
传统造法的麻烦在冷却通道。推力室壁上要布满冷却通道,相当于做一件内壁和外壁之间夹着复杂流道的双层衣服:内壁机加工,套上外壁,整体钎焊。零件多,接头多,每一处接缝都是潜在的失效点。
打印能做出别的工艺做不出来的形状,整个室壁就是冷却通道本身。结果更轻,也更便宜。
打印能做到其他任何方法都做不出来的东西,最后反而更轻、更便宜。(马斯克)
下一代猛禽发动机(Raptor)也尽可能打印。当时的限制是打印机的尺寸包络,大件打不了。但涡轮泵部件和喷注器的很多关键零件可以打。
好处主要不在省钱,在速度。铸件开发要几个月,铸件做错了重开模具又是几个月,每轮迭代都以季度计。打印能把迭代压缩到几周。
铸件每错一次就要重来几个月,打印能把这种迭代缩短到几周,对研制速度帮助很大。(马斯克)
这一点容易被忽略。制造业里最贵的从来不是材料费和加工费,是"想错了要多久才能知道"。
超级高铁:SpaceX 只修一条一英里的管子
他明确表态:自己和 SpaceX 都不会去商业化超级高铁(Hyperloop)。市面上已经有两三家完全独立的公司在推进这件事,和他没有关系。
SpaceX 只做一件事:办学生比赛。
参照 Formula SAE 的形式,让学生设计车厢(pod)互相竞速。公司负责在自己地盘上修一条一英里左右的低压管道,接近真空,让学生的车厢在里面跑。
目的就是让学生对工程产生兴趣。这是 SpaceX 和我目前在超级高铁上唯一的参与。(马斯克)
国际空间站:大气层之外唯一一间微重力实验室
一位社会学家问他怎么评价国际空间站的科学价值,以及太空探索里"奢华"和"需求"的分界线在哪。
他很老实:自己绝大多数时间都在想怎么把东西送上去,直到看了新拍的 IMAX 空间站电影预告片,才对站内长什么样有完整印象。他包了 SpaceX 全体团队去看那场预告。
他给国际空间站的定义是:地球大气层之外唯一一处微重力实验室。人体生理学实验只能在那儿做,脑科学实验也只能在那儿做,这种独特性没法替代。
除了那里,你没法在别的地方做那些实验。那个实验室是独一无二的。(马斯克)
然后是"酷"这个因素。他承认专业人士经常觉得这不严肃,但他的判断是,公众对太空的兴趣有相当一部分就建立在这上面,而这份兴趣会转化成预算、支持和人才。
他讲得很直白:SpaceX 一直在想办法让人意识到低轨上有一个平台,这个平台上的事情对一辈子不会上天的人也有好处。而吸引注意力的入口,恰恰是"酷"。
宇航服:先让人想穿,再谈别的
商业载人的宇航服,他个人参与得不少。目标是同时满足功能和好看。
他讲了一个矛盾:只优化功能是一回事,只优化美观是另一回事,两头都要就很麻烦,很容易做成既不好看也不好用。
我们的一个核心目标是,人们看到这身宇航服时会想,我有一天也想穿上它。它看起来很酷。(马斯克)
这话听着像营销,实际牵涉到一件更硬的事:航天人才的供给。一个行业如果让人向往,招人就容易;一个行业如果只让人敬畏,招人就难。
卫星互联网:光子在真空里比在光纤里快一半
低轨通信星座的计划当时已经放慢节奏。他说明年先发一颗测试卫星,长期潜力不错,但不想把话说太满。
然后他讲了一个很少被提到的物理事实。
光子在真空里的传播速度比在光纤里快 40% 到 50%。光纤的路线又沿着大陆轮廓走,中间穿过无数中继器和路由器。从加州的服务器到南非的服务器,光纤绕了很远的路。
如果通信走太空,跨洲传输会快相当多。路径更直,光速更快。(马斯克)
这套系统因此有两个用途:给没有网络覆盖的地方提供带宽,以及承担一部分长距离互联网骨干的功能。卫星之间有交叉链路,数据可以在天上接力。
和历史上的失败案例比,差别在电子技术。Teledesic 那一代卫星的电子设备带宽极低,基本是模拟或者勉强数字,根本没法跟地面网络竞争。新系统也不打算抢蜂窝网络的生意,铱星(Iridium)那种直连手机的模式不是它的路线。
用户端是一个披萨盒大小的平板天线,相控阵,自动追踪卫星。可以装在窗边,也可以装在户外任何能看见天空的地方,只要能看见卫星就能用。
他也没有回避风险。
很多公司试过这件事,都在上面折了。我们得非常小心地推进,别把自己摊得太薄。(马斯克)
怎么在航天业赚小钱:从一笔大钱开始
一位来自俄罗斯联合火箭航天公司的女士提问,问他成为航天业成功商人的秘诀是什么,好带回去讲给俄罗斯企业家听。
这是全场最实在的一段回答。
如果你让人给各个行业的投资回报率排个序,航天肯定排在很后面。我很支持航天,但这是事实。开个对冲基金,或者做很多别的行业,都比航天容易赚钱。(马斯克)
接着他讲了一个在航天圈流传很久的笑话:怎么在航天业赚到一笔小钱?答案是从一笔大钱开始。
他说这笑话听过太多遍,后来干脆抢在别人前面把包袱抖出来:我的目标是研究怎么把一笔大钱变成一笔小钱。台下笑完,他话锋一转。
机会确实存在,但在目的地,不在发射场。
他拿联合太平洋铁路打比方。铁路修通之前,美国东西海岸之间的贸易只能靠马车,或者绕很远的帆船,成本高得离谱。铁路一通,才有了后来加州和华盛顿州的那些产业,才有了硅谷和好莱坞。
你得先把基础运输这一段建起来,没有它,后面的事都很难谈。(马斯克)
火星同理。如果去火星的票价降到可承受的范围,那儿的创业机会会多得惊人。第一家披萨店,第一座铁矿厂,无数等着被人做出来的生意。
他还补了一句:火星上有些生意会跟地球完全不同,是现在根本想不到的。
火星的风吹不倒人
有人问他读没读安迪·威尔(Andy Weir)的《火星救援》。读了,评价很高,说是他读过的最写实的火星题材小说之一。
然后挑了个刺:火星上的风没那么大,吹不倒人。风速确实高,但大气密度只有地球的百分之一左右,动压很低。风能吹起沙尘,推不动人。
他更在意的是这本书改编成电影之后的效果。
我有点担心这部电影会让人不想去火星。看起来太难了。(马斯克)
他半开玩笑地说,可能需要再拍一部,把火星拍成西部片,有枪手,有牛仔,那样人才会想去。
这段玩笑背后藏着一个他反复提到的判断:公众叙事决定预算,预算决定进度。火星温室计划是这么想的,宇航服设计是这么想的,电影他也这么看。
VR:沉浸感强到让人不想摘
最后一位提问者带着 VR 摄像机,来自旧金山一家叫 SpaceVR 的创业公司。他们的理念是用虚拟现实把普通人放到每一次探索任务的最前排。
马斯克说他在 Oculus 和 Valve 都体验过 demo,印象很深。如果这项技术按现在的曲线外推,未来的沉浸感会强到有人不愿意摘下来。
那东西挺迷人的。我觉得用在太空上也会相当令人兴奋。(马斯克)
然后他当场问对方公司在不在加州。在。他说今天可能安排不开,但接下来几周也许可以约一次。
整场对话就是这样结束的。一个刚炸了火箭的人,在台上花了一个多小时解释毫秒级的数据对齐、3D 打印的冷却通道、逃逸发动机为什么不扔、光子在真空里快多少,最后答应跟一个学生创业团队再聊一次。
这套思路里能拿走的东西
这场对话发生在 2015 年,那时候可复用火箭一次都没成功过,龙飞船2还在图纸和试验台上。回头看,最有价值的部分不是他预测对了什么,是他处理问题的方式。
先分清楚哪些是事实,哪些是解释。事实只有一条:液氧箱过压了。解释一个都没有。在这种状态下不急着给答案,是一种纪律。
承认失败的概率,然后照样下注。10% 的成功率不是劝退理由,是定价依据。知道自己在赌什么,才知道该往里投多少。
决定之后把全部精力转到提高成功率上。这两件事不矛盾,是一件事的两个阶段。
找那个吃掉七八成成本的环节。哪儿贵,哪儿就是杠杆点。
技术的第一价值经常是缩短反馈周期,不是省钱。铸件几个月,打印几周,省下的是"想错了要多久才知道"。
- 评估一个新方向,先算最坏情况下损失多少,能不能承受。数字能承受就下注,承受不了就换一个,别用热情替代这道算术。
- 下注之后立刻切换心态:从"赌赢了会怎样"转到"怎么把失败概率再压低一点"。前者给你动力,后者给你结果。
- 拆成本结构,找那个占比最高的环节。一级火箭占七八成,所以回收它;你的业务里也一定有一个吃掉大半成本的环节,先动它,别在边角料上优化。
- 引入新工具时,优先看它能不能缩短迭代周期,而不是能不能直接省钱。几周对几个月,长期复利远大于单件成本差。
- 面对一次公开的失败,只讲已经确定的那一条事实,其余留白。急着给完整解释,往往要给第二次道歉。
- 别把"很多公司都试过并失败了"当成劝退理由,也别当成没事。把它当成一条定价信息:这条路很贵,进场要慢,别一次把资源全押上。
- 如果你的工作成果需要外人支持,认真对待"酷"这件事。让人想穿上那身衣服,比让人理解那身衣服的技术参数更有用。
0:00the recent loss of the Dragon and in the Falcon 9 here on SpaceX 7 sure well I think it's it's obvious it's a huge load to to SpaceX and and/or which we take these missions incredibly seriously the investigate everyone that can engage in the investigation of SpaceX is very very focused on that and in this case the the
0:33data does seem to be quite difficult to interpret like whatever happened is is clearly not not a sort of simple straightforward thing so we want to spend as much time as possible just reviewing the data obviously going over it with with NASA and with the FAA and with the number of other customers and just sort of seeing what feedback everyone has based on their prior experience to see if we can get to what the most likely root cause is look at
1:07look at both what we think most likely happened and then anything that's a close call and try to address all of those things and maximize the probability of success for future missions any hints on where you think the problem lies you well I know them this is this media in the audience so though yes you have to be fair you're right I never really learned that but that is a lot working on so it's yeah I mean I you know the I think I think I
1:44think we'll be able to say something more definitive towards the end of the week at this point really the only thing that's really clear is that there was some kind of overpressure event in the up the stage liquid oxygen tank but the the exact cause and the sequence of events there's there's still no clear
2:07theory that fits with all the data so we have to determine if some of the data is a measurement error of some kind or whether there is actually a theory that matches that the sort of what would appear to be conflicting data points very good I'll just make a comment the tweets you put out regularly particularly when events like this happen are really useful to everybody we really do appreciate it you'd be amazed at how many folks quote what you said and and and how how glad they are that you just step right out and at least give some sign about what's going on and that you know we'll get through it things are going well so we appreciate that absolutely and for sure as soon as
2:50we think we've got a clear line on on what what happened and we've sort of cross-checked it with as many experts as we can and I certainly appreciate the feedback from from NASA on those fronts remember very much appreciated the will certainly put a put out that story my only reticence about saying something quite yet is I don't want to say something that subsequently turns out to be a Mis misunderstanding of the situation oh yeah absolutely understand so one of the questions that I asked
3:21myself regularly is at what point does all this government help hurt so this have been occurred and we have you have NASA folks there from from about three different programs that intend to use your services ISS being one of them you have the FAA that's that's involved the range folks are there without feeling
3:54like you're giving your customers a hard time or how is that interaction and what what should we consider doing differently so that we in those areas where we can help we are helpful and in those those areas where we're really keeping you from getting your job done we can modify ourselves yeah actually I think the interaction with NASA has been great thus far the the biggest challenges there there are a lot of enquiries coming in simultaneously so it's it's hard to sort
4:30of keep you know respond to respond to everyone right away but actually it seems to have gone fairly well the biggest thing that's needed in the in me sort of short time is the ability to sort of gather all the data create a very precise timeline so you know by the millisecond we know what each sensor was reading and we can correlate that with ground video and actually like one of the biggest challenges is mashing but these things to the exact time you know because when you're talking about you know a matter of milliseconds you know being able to say what is the ground track video compared to the data as received by the you know by the ground
5:12station from the rocket and then taking into account for exactly the the actual time taken to generate a packet of information when was that sensor read when was it encoded into a packet and when was that packet sent to the ground when when you're drilling in in milliseconds that all that stuff actually makes quite a big difference yeah so that's thought the biggest sort of effort we've been engaged in those far is just putting together a super detailed timeline and then just making sure that they have a sequence of events down as precise as possible that's what we're working on and but but actually certainly with with the interaction we've had with with NASA and with us
5:57it's actually been quite good thus far and we've explained that this is what we're doing and and then we very much welcome any feedback or input or a few of the data that would lead us to a better understanding of the circumstances I thought we had a very productive discussion back when we had the engine one anomaly and so I found it to be very useful but that's a perspective from from a NASA perspective so it's always interesting to know your perspective of that yeah it to be quite quite good actually right now so you're building the last
6:33couple launches had landing legs and you've been working on landing the first stage back eventually to shore and you talked a little bit about that what your vision is for that and for a SpaceX in general as you go forward sure well the the overarching goal of SpaceX is to try to advance the state of space transport advanced space transport technology to the point where well it get as far along the path as we can to to where space travel is a hopefully common place at some point in the future and and where we can send large numbers of people and cargo to other planets and you know they it's like that's the sort of thing that that needs to happen for
7:17Humanity have a great future in space so we want to keep pushing that I think like a key to to that future is reusability so that's why we've worked quite hard and reusability unfortunately we haven't succeeded yet and in fact the last launch ironically was we we actually had the best chance of landing the pickle on the drone the just sort of drone ship that's keeping station in the Atlantic so we're actually quite sort of geared up for for hopefully this would be a really great launch and unfortunately in anything the the opposite on my birthday of all things
7:56the real downer you'll remember it though yeah it was definitely at low point but but but I do think in the in the future launches that that we've got a decent chance of landing one on the ship and then bringing the boost age back to land and then the next challenge of course is trying to figure out how to efficiently effectively reuse it and it
8:26is designed for easy reuse in theory but we've got to see what the stage looks looks like when it comes back in one piece mm-hm we've we have been able to over the last few years to a number of vertical takeoff and landing tests of hardware that's essentially in the flight configuration so we know we can we can the terminal phase if you know if things
8:51go right we can take it off land no problem so it's just a question of completing all of the pieces and hopefully later this year we'll be able to do that but that that that's key so but of course that doesn't address upper stage reuse but it addresses boo stage reuse which is sort of 70% to 80% of the cost and and it but I think would be a
9:16great step towards lowering the cost of space transport so you know if you look at your history I guess zip to PayPal these are largely software type efforts now you've got Tesla electric cars you're building a battery plant a solar city I guess you're involved in the solar city so why space this seems space
9:48to me and just what I rate we with you seems to be more of a passion and the others are our businesses but I can't tell why space why are you why do you think it's important for us to be sure access to low-earth orbit well the I mean actually technically I mean with with Tesla and SolarCity they're about
10:09helping to solve the sustainable energy problem and so we're trying make progress in that front on the with those companies with with SpaceX it's trying to help solve the space bearing problem I mean I think that a future where we're a spacefaring civilization and a multi-planet species is very exciting inspiring awesome future and in order
10:36for that to happen we've got to dramatically improve the cost of spaceflight and and that's that's why why SpaceX exists is to try to try to lower the cost of spaceflight which we've made some progress in doing but still I would call up improvements thus far Evolutionary not revolutionary and but
11:03with with a lot of continued work I mean I think there's the potential for for order of magnitude or greater improvements reusability being key to to all of that of course and and then hopefully if at you know what we want to see if we can keep improving that the cost of space bite and eventually that trend is in the right direction it could be leading to a city on Mars and certainly along the way a lot of activity and low Earth orbit and the moon and you know what's of other exciting things so one of the things we're trying to do with the International Space Station is try to figure out which industries will prosper from the use of low Earth orbit to try
11:48to understand or or help grow the kind of and economy essentially in low Earth orbit and folks who are doing that are all taking risks today our job is to try to reduce the risk as much as we can near-term so that they can get the information they need to really have a business case for the future but everyone's trying to calculate a risk so is there an Elon Musk philosophy of
12:19risks versus benefit and when you when you think is the right time to jump in I mean what is your thought on on how to approach new industries innovative areas and when's the right time to jump in there or not or do you just is there no crystal ball or is it a crystal ball or a Ouija board I mean how do you how do you figure out what you should go after well definitely the Ouija board of course much more reliable than the crystal ball so the yeah I mean I don't
12:55really like risk for risk sake or anything it's and I do think that the only things are are very risky with a low chance of success but if you want to try to come up with an interview that's kind of that's gonna be how it is at anything which is significantly innovative is going to come with a significant risk of failure and but you
13:24know if you've got to take big chances in order for the potential for a big positive outcome and you know just if I mean if the outcome is exciting enough then then taking a big risk is worthwhile yeah it's really I approach it but with them but then once executing down a path actually do my absolute best to reduce risk you know because or to improve the put another way of saying it to improve the probability of success because when you try to do something that is very very risky that you had you have to spend a
14:04lot of effort trying to reduce that risk as you walk down that path I mean when when I saw his face X the I thought the odds of success very low I thought we've most likely fail but I thought well we should give it a try nonetheless and then I'm not sure if you know what what preceded SpaceX because people why I got into the space ride you
14:33remember you're trying to purchase a vehicle - from our Russian car yeah well actually it was that the reason I got into space was to try to increase NASA's budget [Laughter] that the and but I'll say also the roundabout way I thought we that might be accomplished was I thought well if if NASA's budget was more larger than we could do more in space exploration and I thought well what work particularly if we could get the public excited about sending people to Mars and I thought well if I could do a small greenhouse and I'd send that to the surface of Mars with seasons in nutrient gel and you hydrate the gel and landing you have a little miniature greenhouse and then
15:27you'd you'd have the public tends to get excited about precedents and superlatives so if we like the you know sort of first life on Mars the furthest life's ever traveled and get people sort of excited about well but we wish then people there like the health plants we should send people oh right right and and then I thought well that could give if I could get the public really excited about sending fuel to Mars than that were translating to congressional support for a bigger NASA budget that was the goal and then I don't have enough money to buy and I thought that the bad outcome would have a harvesting chance of noticing nope no commercial success so the harps a chance of losing
16:06little money so so compared to that SpaceX which I thought maybe had a 10% chance of success that was an improvement that makes good sense so are you still thinking about that IRA do remember that conversation this was my idea we used Martian regolith you send these self-contained habitats who did not have it it wouldn't land chamber kriti of things and grobel yeah like a meter across or something but just to prove the concept yeah just to get it I mean the real goal was to get the public excited you get some engineering data about what does it take to maintain a little habitat on Mars type of thing but the main thing would be to get the public excited and you
16:50know get people to be you know the public to being a paper of a bigger NASA budget wants to go again god bless you so worthy goal I hope this off so Commercial Crew so you've been selected as one of the providers for the Commercial Crew can you tell us a little bit about where that's headed for you as the company and perhaps maybe house affected your company if it has if it's changed d thing and how you approach space miss thing seems to be going
17:21it's really well on the Commercial Crew front I mean the I mean overall I mean I mean that there are small disagreements here and there but overall I think I think we very much agree with the way it's being done and yeah I think it's it's it's pretty pretty good I mean there are a few things where like it seems like the amount of lot of sort of mass and volume reserved for poop is too high but that's you know like little
17:57things like that we're like well are they really gonna do that much but it's quite it's quite large volume and really is so bit I could really they're pretty small disagreement so I think that it seems to be pretty pretty sensible and and then we did the the launch abort test earlier this year which at the Cape which actually went went pretty well and
18:26yeah so things were going going along great getting pretty exciting and yeah I think there's also some potential use for Dragon 2 as as a science delivery platform you know going to sort of delivering payloads to Mars or other places we're in discussion with other parts of NASA about some of those ideas because the propulsive landing you know it could really lower the cost of getting science instruments to various places in the solar system so it's kind of exciting so I'm going to come back to that in just a second but commercial the the crew vehicle versus the the Dragon cargo vehicle clearly there are some significant differences fairly innovative approach I think to
19:14abort testing where traditionally you've seen the the Jessen rocket on top that it's a polar versus the pusher technique where you utilize fuel that you otherwise would use for right on-orbit but of course you're not going there so very innovative approach are there other areas where you feel like you're from an
19:35innovation standpoint you're making some significant strides with the Cree vehicle yeah I think the the big items for whether the biggest item really for Dragon 2 is the ability to do a propulsive landing and it's basically you have having heavy thrusters on board so those same heavy thrusters can then do the abort but retain the the engines so instead of in a normal sort of crewed mission like safe to take the Soyuz for example they'd have a tractor motor on the nose of the vehicle that would have to be basically rocket engine on the nose that we have to be discarded in every flight which is a potential reliability issue and it and then you
20:23have obviously aren't able to reuse the the abort system and yeah and it adds your adds bunch of bunch of mass but but then in addition those same thrusters can be used for propulsive landing so you can achieve a precise propulsive landing which are on land or water which is I think a significant improvement and I mean it's sort of also
20:53it's sort of like really I think feels feels more like the future to have that capability and then as I mentioned it before it can be extended to do payload delivery to to the Moon or Mars or other places because of the the generalized capability of a propulsive landing to to land land almost anywhere very good so let's go back to dragon at one point you had a conversation talked a little bit about something I think Virtue's dragon lab where you go to low-earth orbit and do what I assumed was sortie kind of research and then and bring the vehicle back are you still pursuing that or something like that is this an area where you think that there
21:36is potential there there is some potential for to essentially just take things to go over it and then bring them bring them back you know after a few weeks or something like that it's it's not a huge area of attention that's at SpaceX but I think we might do a few missions like that but yeah I mean
21:59dragon is it's very much sort of right its primary optimization is as a transport vehicle to and from the space station and and so things like dragon lab and then the science delivery platform I think are interesting extensions of that and I think well as as dragon to first flies and then gets into regular flight I think they'll probably will be some you know more applications that that people could think of particularly since with dragon - the reusability of the vehicle should be quite high so if we have reusability of the Dragon spacecraft and reusability of the booster and somebody's willing to sort of do a bunch of flights with with
22:46the fully reused system there's the potential for for much lower cost access to space there is a bit of a chicken and egg challenge because like the there's a certain amount of fixed costs that have to be carried no matter what so the the the marginal cost of launch or the cost of each subsequent launch can drop quite significantly as long as the launch rate per year is is high and stay that yeah of course that adds other challenges to the system yeah trying to fly as often as you as you need to yep well let's see I don't want to bore everybody with all my questions and we had talked about if folks had any questions in the audience let's see this
23:29oh wow that is they're not bashful that's good so I don't know if we're gonna need microphones but but I'll start here
23:50because you are like a kind of mentor and a visionary and you give hope to a lot of people around the globe because when they see you they realize that they can realize their dreams but my question is different when you are a dreamer when you are when you are a dreamer when you are a visionary of course you have your vision but there are moments that sometimes maybe you stop believing in this vision especially in the moments of some problems or failure so could you tell me and could you tell also to thousands of people who maybe will be motivated by your answer what keeps you fighting for the division what helps you to reach your dream
24:46well I mean I I think I'm kind of constitutionally just geared to to just keep going I don't know it's a yeah I mean it just I I don't know I mean it certainly there are times when you know things don't go well and then that's quite aspirating for sure and so then it's difficult to proceed with the same level of enthusiasm but but I do think
25:19like I do think the things that we're doing are you know pretty important to the future and if we don't succeed then you know there's well this there's not it's not clear what other things would succeed and if if we don't succeed then we will be certainly pointed to as a reason why people shouldn't even try for these things so I think it's important that we do whatever is necessary to keep going okay and last question last question so in 2004 when you are going to body man with your cousin you were thinking there is a Sam and let's make energy out of this yeah and I would like to ask you why do you believe so in solar energy and in clean tech energies and also in
26:10sustainable energy and the last question I will not ask any more questions what will be the role of solar in the exploration of Mars sure I think the solar energy is probably fairly significant for Mars and what's gonna be quite important is having a very lightweight solar system
26:32that would both volumetrically and gravimetric lee dance so actually you were sort of playing with the different concepts like you know that like thing that party thing will you be able played it and it rolls out the thing I think what one of the solar concepts is is to have like a big role that you just basically inflate and it rolls out with with with like really thin solar
27:03panels on it but but it's it's gonna be pretty important because really either got to do that or nuclear and you know nuclear has it has its challenges but put for solar it's pretty straightforward so I think I think so is very important to the future exploration of Mars for sure so thank you and I wish you that your next birthday is very successful thank you so much okay let's go let's go okay el-tee my name is valentina verifying from the United rocket and space cooperation which shortly will become a part of state separation Roscosmos so I made this one quest to
27:49the west because I'd like to ask one question of human masks what is his secret to become a successful businessman in space industry and then coming back to Russia to tell Russian businessmen there as way to become a tycoon a space industry yeah so serious seriously speaking I'd like
28:13to ask you when you started your business was the government your partner was it useful in what areas and so there are always two sides of the coin sure as there there were times when you had to fight the bureaucracy thank you sure well I should say with respect to starting a space business it's definitely not the easiest environment to start a business and I think if most people were to rank order what's the highest return on investment I hate I mean space would not be very good I mean it's I I'm very Pro space so it's like I you know but it's I mean it's just true that like if you you know start a hedge fund or if you're like many other industries then it's much easier to make
29:10money than the space industry this is not the easiest one to make money and it's yeah car industry also quite difficult so the if I I mean when starting SpaceX the the joke I heard the jokes this joke so often it was ridiculous the jerk was how do you make a small portion in the space industry and the punchline of course being start with a large one yeah I got
29:53a point out of heard the joke so many times that I would just get to the punchline and say like well I wanted to figure out how to turn a large fortune in just one that was my goal and they're like well how did you know that so yeah the I mean I do think there's that there is opportunity in space but but it is it's it's it's it's tough going I think if but I think if if if
30:17SpaceX and other companies can can lower the cost of transport to to orbit and perhaps beyond then there's a lot of potential for Entrepreneurship at the destination I mean you can think of it like the like the Union Pacific Railway you know before there was a universal railway it was real hard to have commerce between the west coast and the East Coast it would go by wagon or a really long sailing journey but once there was the transport then they were opportunities and now look at sort of you know the California and Washington State and and all the industries that have been created in Silicon Valley in Hollywood but you've got to have that fundamental transport element otherwise
31:00there's just it's really tricky so we're trying to establish that transport element and make it easier to get to low-earth orbit and hopefully in the future make it easier to get to the Moon or Mars and I do this long term vision of like if there was affordable transport to to a place like Mars I think the entrepreneurial opportunities would be phenomenal you know because there'd be people that would want to create everything from the first pizza joint to the first iron ore Factory to be like just a enormous amount of opportunity for people to create things on Mars and then it'd be different things on my as some of the things would be different that we don't
31:40even imagine on earth be very exciting so I think that's that's really key to making things happen in space is you've got to have your someplace you gotta have someplace to go in someplace in some way to get there yeah so so along those lines did you read Andy where's book the Martian yeah yeah it's good what do you think I thought it was it was pretty excellent certainly one of the most realistic books on Mars that that I've read I mean I'd like there were a few things like the wind force on Mars is not really that high I was it's
32:18not gonna knock you over or anything it's hi Roxy hi blasted a with low force but overall I thought it was pretty cool and apparently it's being made into a movie and everything you don't you don't have a cameo on that one - I don't have a count me on that one I'm a little worried that it might not make people too keen on going to Mars like this is
32:41looks really hard I think we need a show about a Hamas is also now it's like the Wild West and you got the gunslingers and like the cool Cowboys and that kind of thing maybe you got to write a book - let's see there's a question over here right hi there my name is Anita Goyal I'm here at out of Harvard and MIT run a company called nano bio sim so in your vision and dream to achieve low-cost space travel how do you allocate your investments between engineering and essentially driving down the cost of existing technology versus investing in new breakthrough physics things like breakthrough propulsion physics anti-gravity what's your vision in the
33:27bifurcation of those two kinds of portfolios well we don't spend a ton of time on you physics I mean the I think with get with current physics this there's huge potential so rather than rely on a breakthrough which we you know really it's difficult to envision what that breakthrough would exactly be already even in exactly be
33:55the I'm quite confident that with what we know of current physics sort of just going with kind of you know where the standard model of physics is today that there are dramatic improvements possible in space flight and I think with the you know certainly with Falcon 9 I think would make improvements and then with our next generation rocket system which is still you know many years away that'll be a deep cryo methyl ox system
34:26I think I think we can achieve full reusability and that that's really that's that that's a huge potential for you know like maybe the two order of magnitude reduction in the cost of spaceflight so as far as R&D is concerned that we we we hire great engineers as fast as we can find them so it's like the it's not that easy to find but I should say great issues with the sort of like the right mindset and everything we hire at the at
35:03the at the maximum rate that we can find people that we think what would really be an asset to the team so there's no limitation on that hey over here hi my name is Zachary multum a student from Babson College I just want to say it's an honor to be here I read a Schliemann C's biography about you but one thing that really was intriguing to me was the super Draco engine for the dragon v2 that was unused printed out of a three day technology division using that technology more in the future and when he first splashed exploration and you think though how about affect the costs in terms of getting to Mars like that yeah absolutely so as really - we
35:42we we actually print the super Draco engines so they're printed out of titanium in a canal and and that actually allows us to reduce the cost of those engines quite a bit in particular because we can get a print integral cooling channels so when you've got it an hourglass chamber and you've got cooling channels in in the wall of the chamber where the whole wall consists of cooling channels it's only quite difficult to create that a thrust chamber or nozzle because you've got to create an inner jacket outer jacket kind of machined the inner jacket it's and then braise the whole thing together it's real pain and you've got a bunch of joints in there to make it all work
36:29so with printing you can print something that you can't make by any other means so it actually ends up being lighter and cheaper then if we built it by traditional methods for our next generation engine which we call the the Raptor with transmission is sort of a it's a it's a deep-fryer methyl ox so what I mean by that is that the methane and oxygen are cooled to close they're freezing points so not not far from the freezing point as opposed to close to their boiling point which is more witches than only the case the you
37:06know what would look for that engine we're trying to print as much as possible it's a bit the biggest limitation on 3d printing right now is the theater size envelope so with there's a limit on how big we can print something but we're able to print the turbopump components and much of the injected not the whole thing but but many of the critical parts we can print so that actually helps us in speeding up the development so instead of waiting for castings to be developed which can take several months and then if the casting is wrong you've got to iterate in the casting and each iteration can take several months with printing we can have those iterations can be reduced to
37:48a matter of weeks or months so that that actually helps up with these disputed developments as well see over here hi i'm ross Buntrock with a company called high orbit I wondered if you'd give it could give us a little bit of an update on what's going on with the Hyperloop and is there any overlap between the worker doom of SpaceX and Hyperloop technology yeah SpaceX is not neither I nor SpaceX are doing anything to try to commercialize the Hyperloop there are I think at least two maybe more than two companies that have formed that are completely independent of me or SpaceX that are working towards commercializing the Hyperloop technologies idea or design
38:36what's basics is doing is we're we're gonna just create a little student competition for for Hyperloop ideas so it can like around the way that Formula SAE works where students can come up with a design and compete against each other to design the best pod so what we're SpaceX will do is just construct about a mile long
39:03low-pressure tube near nearly vacuum tube basically in which students can kind of race their pods so what it's just basically to support get get students excited about engineering that's the that's the only involvement to SpaceX myself with the Hyperloop at this point okay well I'm Paula castaigne I'm a sociologist and I'm writing a book about the International Space Station how do you describe the scientific value of the International Space Station and where would you draw the line between luxury and need when it comes to space exploration well I mean I would for
39:50space that I mean I really spend all of my time thinking about just how to get to the space station be honest I've I I actually hadn't even really seen a proper movie of the inside of the space station until I went to see the I a preview of the new IMAX thing that's coming out we're and it's amazing yeah like when that I Space Station IMAX movie comes out people looking at blown away it's awesome I actually bought my
40:17whole team at at SpaceX to go go see the preview of the a of the IMAX movie and I mean I'm it's like it is a very unique laboratory because this is the only thing that's in sort of microgravity that's above the Earth's atmosphere and you can learn a lot about basically human physiology and do experiments that you can't really do any other any other laughs and you know and you can have
40:53brain scientists up and they can actually work in this incredibly unique lab so I think that there's a lot to be gained there and and I think it just you can't sort of you know ignore the coolness factor of it like that's like people think it's pretty cool so I think it's pretty cool and you know the public
41:19one I have something going on in space event that involves people and yeah and it's it's just I don't know it's the coolest thing going on in space so like there's a lot of value to that you know we we've tried to - sells the wrong word it's the word we use but sells really the wrong word we're trying to get people to recognize that there's a platform in low-earth orbit and that this is important what's done in low-earth orbit has benefit to to those of us on earth that will never actually go to space but in doing that you're trying to get their interest level and part of their interest level is the cool factor that she talked about and and I've always kind of struggled with that
42:08being sort of a black and white I understand the purpose in my head that's why I joined NASA right but over the years this is one of the things that I've started to recognize as important so my question to you is did we I've heard a rumor that for the suits for Commercial Crew that you wanted to play in a role in that and so it's that true and and is there some reason behind the design of the suit that you want to personally be involved in other than crew safety yeah I think you've actually
42:41spent a lot of effort on the spacesuit design on the both functionality and the aesthetics but I think just just getting it's actually really hard because if you're just sort of optimized functionality it's one thing if you optimize for aesthetics it doesn't work you know that's that series they don't work so so it's like okay how do we make
43:12something that looks cool aunt works and with with a key goal here of being being that you know when people see that space who think they want them to think yeah I want to wear that thing one day yeah that looks awesome so that that's that's the reason for it very good let's see we'll do a couple more questions and then let's let's can we get back in the back here do we have somebody else here already with the microphone all right go ahead thank you we don't want to it I'm Alex Pearlman I'm with Boston Magazine and I'm writing for advice today I was hoping that you could give us a little bit of an update on the most recent news with the idea of putting
43:57satellites to provide Internet to developing countries and unconnected people sure so we slowed the early stages of it's a sort of a big Leo constellation communication idea and we're hopeful hopefully going to launch I get a test satellite next year and a bit but IIIi think the long term
44:24potential of it is is pretty pretty great but I don't want to overplay or overstate you know things quite you know that this you know or any stage of the game really but the the the long-term goal is to create a comprehensive global communication system that's that provides high-bandwidth low-latency connectivity anywhere in the world and provides cross links through the satellites so that you can have improved
44:55long-distance internet there's one things that sort of your eyes when you look at this is that you can actually have a more direct path through space and you can and photons move faster depending upon what fiber-optic material they're running through photons actually move about as 40 to 50 percent faster in in vacuum than they do in fiber-optic cables and if you look at the way that
45:28the fiber-optic cables go if they trace the outlines of the continents and they go through many repeaters and routers and everything so if you want to say communicate from a server in California to one in South Africa it's a very very long route and so very roundabout path and it's high latency low photonic speed
45:49and you could actually have that communication would be quite a bit faster if it's in space so I think there's there's the potential for doing a fair bit of long-distance internet activity as well as providing bandwidth portly but it's also worth saying that a lot of companies have tried this and kind of broken their pick on it and I think we we want to be really careful about how we deliberate about it trying to make this thing work and not not overextend ourselves so we're being you know fairly careful about it but I I'm I do think this is something that should be built and would be quite good to have well in our case the the
46:42communications technology would be substantially more advanced in the past would say Tim's like Teledesic that the electronics of the day were very low bandwidth I mean really analog or barely digital and they weren't very high bandwidth CCG so it really didn't compete with sage' with terrestrial phones in the case of tells you that they were looking to compete with or or to address the cellular needs that the system we're talking about would not attempt to compete with cellular needs so for example it wouldn't compete directly with say iridium which is which which can talk directly to a handset our system would seem to would safe to talk to a small user terminal that's about
47:31the size of a pizza box or more much like you know current dishes that are those satellite dishes but but it will be flat because we have phased array antenna that's tracking those satellites but you could mount it in a window or just anywhere outside as long as you can see this guy it would work see back here
47:54we'll take our last question back here hey Ilan thanks for coming out I would like to show you we brought a virtual reality camera here it's a record for the first time we have a small start-up in San Francisco called space VR and we believe that virtual reality is the future of space exploration because you can put people on the very cutting the very front of every every exploration mission is that something that you've given much thought or have any opinions on well I've gone I've perceived the virtual reality demos at oculus and at valve and
48:32it's pretty impressive you can start of imagine if that's extrapolated into the future it's really gonna super feel like you're there and I wonder if some people are never gonna want to take that off honestly you know it's like it's pretty I mean it's pretty entrancing but I do think it'd be quite exciting through that for space as well yeah but do you have a setup here okay it's right there Wow yeah cool okay are you based in are
49:18you based okay I think maybe today's gonna be tricky but but but maybe if since you're based in California we could arrange something and you know in the coming weeks all right let's see Elon we'll we'll call it a a conference I wanted to first thank you very much you've been very generous with their time and we you know for the moment I called you you were all in and it's really this open
49:54conversation and your your thoughts on on the on what's in front of us that really excites us all in this room so thank you very much for your time we really appreciate it yeah thank you [Applause]
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版